Upload
vuongkhanh
View
225
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
11
Hydrological processes and drainage basins:
Case study of the River Souteyran
Discover Ltd.
“Timbers”,
Oxted Road,
Godstone,
Surrey. RH9 8AD
www.discover.ltd.uk
©Discover Ltd 2009
22
Hydrological Processes and Drainage Basins: A Case Study Of The Souteyran River
Teachers’ notes Channel processes and landforms come under close scrutiny in this unit, as does river morphology. River
morphology can usually be considered in three dimensions; long profile, cross-sectional shape and plan-
form. This unit concentrates on the changes which the Souteyran exhibits on its journey along the southern
flank of Mont Lozere to its junction with the Tarn at Pont de Montvert.
The work for this unit is carried out from the Eagle's Nest without the need for transport except for the return
journey from Le Pont de Montvert. Students walk the entire length of the River Souteyran (approx. 10km)
over rough ground and along the Stevenson’s Trail. Most groups measure between 4 and 10 sites at a
variety of locations. Liaise with your group leader before you set out on the number of sites and the
locations that you wish to study.
This study gives many opportunities for students to produce coursework based upon the data collected. A
list of possible project titles is included with this unit.
Many groups spend a good deal of time in the evening drawing out cross-sectional areas. We have
software that processes the student’s data quickly and efficiently, producing a cross-sectional diagram and
calculating discharge. This leaves groups with time for discussion and more sophisticated of the results that
they have collected. If you would like to use the software, please ask your group leader.
Some groups may choose to study variations in water quality. Because of the organic nature of the farming
in the valley, there is very little nitrate pollution and the acidic nature of the granite bedrock eliminates most
meaningful variations in pH. The most successful way of testing for changes in water quality is to look for
biological indicator species. However the ‘clean’ nature of the river means that little variation is apparent
between sites. For a more detailed investigation the Freshwater Pollution unit based upon the River Lot
should be considered.
On the walk down it is easy to see evidence of rejuvenation in the valley. This may be a useful teaching
point.
Key Specification Areas:
• The drainage basin, hydrological cycle: the water balance;
• Factors affecting river discharge: the storm hydrograph;
• The long profile – changing processes: types of erosion, transportation and deposition, types of load,
the Hjulstrom curve;
• Valley profiles – long profile and changing cross-profile downstream, graded profile, potential and
kinetic energy;
• Changing channel characteristics – cross-profile, wetted perimeter, hydraulic radius, roughness,
efficiency, and links to velocity and discharge;
33
• Landforms of fluvial erosion and deposition – potholes, rapids, waterfalls, meanders, braiding, flood
plains;
• Process and impact of rejuvenation – knick-points, waterfalls, river terraces;
• Physical and human causes of flooding – location of areas of high risk in an MEDC;
• Impact of flooding – case study of the river Souteyran;
• Flood management strategies – to include hard engineering and soft engineering.
Reference Texts
Barker, A., Redfern, D and Skinner, M. (2008) AQA AS Geography. Phillip Allen Updates.
Knighton D (1984) “Fluvial Forms and Processes”
Knill, R. and Smith, J. (2008) AQA AS Geography.
Lenon & Cleves (1994) “Fieldwork Techniques and Projects in Geography” Collins
Miller (2000) “Fieldwork Ideas in Action” Hodder & Stoughton
44
Introduction
General Information The Massif Central, a roughly triangular upland area covering one-sixth of France, contains a landscape of
enormous variety characterised by a number of distinctive landforms. Water is an important and dynamic
component of this landscape system. The striking gorges of the limestone Causses reflect the erosive power
of the Massif's principal rivers. Today these waters have become a major recreational attraction and have
brought an important source of revenue into the region.
Elsewhere, water plays a vital role in agricultural activity and many rural valley communities rely upon the
flow of rivers for their continued prosperity. The dynamic nature of the river system has a direct impact on
man. Heavy rain in October 1987 and September 1994 brought severe flooding to many areas; the droughts
of 1989 and 1990 have reduced river flow and this, together with increased deposition, has made it almost
impossible for some of the canoeing and rafting businesses to operate profitably.
People also have an impact on rivers: pollution is becoming a major problem as more farmers turn to
chemicals to increase yields and as domestic waste tips build up outside the major settlements. River
channels have been straightened and banks protected in urban areas and in the rural sector channelisation
has been used to re-direct flow onto agricultural land.
The physical geography of the Massif Central means that the region forms a vast watershed from which
rivers flow to the Mediterranean, and the Atlantic coasts. These rivers are not important for navigation but
their valleys provide route-ways for road and rail transport away from the mountain mass to other parts of
France. The water input into these river systems comes principally from the Atlantic depressions.
The Massif is well watered. Lozère has more than 2700 km of water courses and 230,000 hectares of forest
land – it constitutes “Water Tower” and green lungs of Languedoc-Rousillion to which it belongs.
Precipitation is high with more than 1,200 mm per annum being recorded in the highest areas. The whole of
the Massif has more than 75 days of frost each year and large areas of ground are snow covered for more
than two months of the year, rising to six months in the high mountains. The prevailing soil and geological
conditions favour rapid run-off and overland flow tends to be the dominant process during periods of heavy
rain (See Figure 1). This is accentuated where deforestation has occurred on a large scale. There are
many natural and artificial water stores that may help to regulate river-flow, such as Lac Villefort at Villefort
and the Reservoir de Cambous between Florac and Alès. These are used for the supply of water to
surrounding towns and for recreational purposes.
River management is an important aspect of water control and conservation in the Massif. Much of the
management in the Cévennes is entrusted to the National Park which is primarily responsible for maintaining
the landscape. Elsewhere Regional River Authorities have implemented various river management
schemes. Good management can only be achieved by gaining a full understanding of the physical
processes acting within river channels - the processes at work today, the erosional history, and the physical
controls of the environment (See Figure 2).
55
Although total yearly precipitation is high in the region, it is as always distribution that is the problem. During
the long, dry summer, water supply may be barely sufficient to meet demand. With an ever-increasing
number of tourists in the region, the problem is becoming more acute. The Departement of Lozère has
become sufficiently concerned to fund research by the University of Alès into the hydrology of the region. It is
hoped that a more efficient way of managing the available water will be found.
Specific Information The Souteyran Valley lies along the southern slopes of Mont Lozère. It contains two rivers, the Souteyran
and Rieumalet, which is a tributary of the former. Both these flow into The Tarn at Le Pont de Montvert. The
rivers are characteristic of upland streams which drain a granite and peat area. The soils are generally
acidic and very thin on the slopes, but are deeper in the valley bottoms where periodic flooding has provided
some input of alluvium. Both rivers are important to the valley communities: The Eagle's Nest relies upon
them for its water supply as do Finiels and Prat Souteyran. In the latter two villages the water from these
rivers has been carefully diverted along small drainage ditches or 'beals' which sometimes appear to be
flowing uphill! Some farmers feed the water into ponds where trout are bred for sale in local markets and to
the restaurant in Le Pont de Montvert. Both rivers flow continuously and much of this flow can be attributed
to a slow release from stores held high up on Mont Lozère. These are peat bogs that play an important role
in the basin hydrological cycle.
Discharge, precipitation and temperature data have been collected daily, from a site close to the Eagles
Nest, since December 1997. This data is available at the Centre or from our Web pages.
River Souteyran Storm Hydrographs In early October 2001, there was a short violent storm around the Eagles Nest. The following data was
collected and may be used to produce a storm hydrograph. The rainfall information was collected by the
centre’s automatic station and the river was measured at centre’s water intake.
Time Rainfall (mm) River Height (m) Discharge (m3/s)
09-00 (03-10-01) 0 0.34 0.041
19-00 (03-10-01) 0 0.34 0.041
20-00 (03-10-01) 0.5 0.38 0.051
21-00 (03-10-01) 6.5 0.39 0.058
22-00 (03-10-01) 1.5 0.43 0.206
23-00 (03-10-01) 0 0.41 0.131
24-00 (03-10-01) 0 0.40 0.068
09-00 (04-10-01) 1 (over 24 hrs) 0.38 0.053
09-00 (05-10-01) 0 0.38 0.051
09-00 (06-10-01) 0 0.35 0.045
66
Later in the month a more prolonged rainfall event occurred, although of similar intensity at times and the
following results were recorded. This provides a useful contrast to the previous shorter event. Photographs
of the River Tarn in Pont de Montvert were taken during this event and are quite dramatic.
Time Rainfall (mm) River Height (m) Discharge (m3/s)
17-10-01 1 0.35 0.045
18-10-01 30 0.37 0.048
19-10-01 19 0.37 0.049
20-10-01 79 0.52 0.687
21-10-01 3 0.55 0.886
22-10-01 0 0.55 0.759
23-10-01 0 0.55 0.734
24-10-01 0 0.54 0.531
25-10-01 0 0.53 0.466
26-10-01 0 0.52 0.437
27-10-01 0 0.51 0.428
28-10-01 0 0.51 0.428
29-10-01 0 0.50 0.361
30-10-01 0 0.48 0.307
01-11-01 1 0.44 0.176
FIGURE 1: The Drainage Basin System
TThhrroouugghhffaallll
IInntteerrcceeppttiioonn
TTrraannssppiirraattiioonn
PPeerrccoollaattiioonn
EEvvaappoorraattiioonn
GGrroouunnddwwaatteerr SSttoorraaggee
IInnffiillttrraattiioonn
VVeeggeettaattiioonn SSttoorraaggee
SSuurrffaaccee SSttoorraaggee
SSooiill wwaatteerr ssttoorraaggee
PPrreecciippiittaattiioonn
SSuurrffaaccee RRuunnooffff
TThhrroouugghhffllooww
BBaasseeffllooww
CChhaannnneell FFllooww
77
FIGURE 2: Schematic Diagram of the Relative Rates of Downstream Change in Channel Form
Discharge
Sediment Load
Bed Material Size
Average Size
Valley Slope angle
Width
Depth
Channel Slope gradient
Velocity
Hydraulic radius
88
Aims
• To investigate downstream changes within the river channel and to account for the changes which
take place.
• To Investigate if the River Souteyran is a ‘model’ river
• To investigate the potential for flooding in the Souteyran valley and identify flood risk in le Pont de
Montvert.
Hypotheses
• The cross-sectional area increases downstream.
• Bed-load size decreases downstream.
• Bed material will become more rounded downstream.
• Channel efficiency will increase downstream.
• The channel is more efficient at bank-full levels.
• Mean velocity and discharge increase downstream.
• Channel gradient will decrease downstream.
• The Souteyran valley has a low flood risk, but contributes to a high potential flood risk in the river
Tarn, further down the valley, due to a range of factors (vegetation, geology, relief, etc.)
99
Data Collection Sites
Most groups measure between 5 and 10 sites at a variety of locations over a 10km stretch. Please liase with
your group leader over the number and location of the sites that you wish to study. If a large number of sites
are to be visited then considerable planning is necessary. This may involve the splitting of groups to visit
different sites or the allocation of tasks.
Under high flow conditions it may be impossible to sample at some of the more downstream sites.
Equipment Ranging Poles
Tape Measure
Chain
Metre Rules
Callipers
Flow Metres
Stopwatches
Clinometers
pH meter
Conductivity meter
Power’s scale of roundness
1100
Method and Organisation of Study
Task One – Cross Sectional Area and Bedload (Hypotheses 1, 2 and 3)
Channel form is more a measurement of bank-full discharge than any other factor. Discharges lower than
bank-full are likely to have a smaller proportion of excess energy to mould the channel, and although flood
discharges may cause damage and channel change, their effects will be neutralised by the next bank-full
state (once every 1-3 years).
i) Most natural channels are irregular. Where is the 'bank-full' cross section to be measured from?
ii) Climatic conditions have changed dramatically over the last 10,000 years. Is the present river
responsible for the channel erosion?
Method 1. Present flow Cross-section
Measure water surface width and divide into 10 equal intervals – i.e. divide the width by 10. This will mean
that you take 11 depth readings. Your first measurement should be taken directly against one bank and your
last measurement should be taken against the other bank.
At each of the 11 sites measure stream.
Calculate the mean depth.
Cross-sectional area is calculated by multiplying the width by the mean depth.
2. Bank-full Cross-section
Measure the width of the channel.
Measure the distance from the tape to the water surface. This value is added onto the present flow depth
reading (normally once the mean has been calculated). The tape must be held taut and horizontally at bank-
full level.
Cross-sectional area is calculated by multiplying the width by the mean depth.
3. Bedload
At 11 equally spaced points across the stream (ideally the same points that you took your depth readings
from) measure the ‘b axis’ of the FIRST PEBBLE that your finger touches. The ‘b axis’ or width is used as
this is considered to be the most representative axis of most clasts in relation to their size.
Calculate the average size of sediment for the station.
The shape (roundness) of the clast is compared to a Power’s roundness scale.
Task Two – Channel Efficiency (Hypotheses 4 and 5)
Hydraulic Radius
The efficiency of a channel is controlled amount of contact between the bed and banks and the flowing
water. High degrees of contact give high levels of friction and thus make an inefficient channel. The most
1111
commonly used method for expressing channel efficiency is through the hydraulic radius. This is the ratio of
cross-sectional area (CSA) to wetted perimeter (wp).
Hydraulic radius = CSA/wp
Hydraulic radius is not expressed in any unit, but the higher the figure then the more efficient the channel.
Method In the same location as the cross-section, run the chain along the bank and bed of the stream following all
the contours of the channel. This gives the wetted perimeter at present flow levels. Measure the length
using the tape measure. Note that the wetted perimeter is always greater than the width!
To find the bank-full simply measure the two sections of bank from the surface to the bank-full level and add
this onto the previous reading. The hydraulic radius can now be calculated.
Task Three – Gradient and Average Velocity (Hypotheses 6 and 7)
Method 1. Gradient
Place the ranging poles at either end of a measured 10m stretch of stream.
Using the clinometer, measure and record the gradient of the stream.
2. Using a Flow Metre/Impellor assembly
Measure the width of the stream and divide into 4 equal intervals (this will provide 3 measuring points – ¼,
½, & ¾ across the channel).
At each of these 3 points measure the velocity –set the impellor at ½ of the water depth and ensure that it is
pointing upstream. Make sure that you stand downstream of the impellor when taking readings!
Record the time taken for the impeller to move from start position to finish position.
Calculate the velocity using the formula or chart.
Calculate the mean velocity for the station.
(For hydroprop flow meter chart, see appendix 2.)
1122
Analysis
Cross Sectional Area (Hypothesis 1)
Using the Centre’s Software:
Use the computer program to plot the cross-sections of the river sites. The program will automatically
calculate wetted perimeter, wetted area, hydraulic radius, mean velocity and discharge (cumecs) once all the
relevant data has been inputted. Ask your group leader if you require assistance.
By Hand:
Draw a cross-section of the stream at each survey point. A cross-section is drawn using the width and depth
measurements. Draw a straight line in proportion to the width of the stream channel. Work out a vertical
scale for the depth measurements, this should include the bank-full depth. Calculate the difference in depth
between bank-full and current stream level. At this calculated distance below the bank-full level, draw a
straight line to represent the water surface. This line should be in proportion to the water surface width.
Below the line representing the water surface, mark the 10 depth measurements across the stream. Join up
the points representing the depth of the stream. Mark on the extent of the floodplain on each side of the
channel. Try to use the same scale for all survey points as this will make it easier to compare the differences
downstream.
Ensure the cross-section is fully labelled. Describe any changes in cross-sectional shape and area
downstream. Is there any pattern? Try to give reasons for any trends shown. Does on or more of the sites
not fit the pattern? Use your site descriptions to explain why this might be so.
Bedload Size and Shape (Hypothesis 2 and 3)
Tabulate the results that you obtained for each site. Calculate a mean bedload size for each site.
Refer to your site cross-sections and try to explain the changes in bedload across the stream channel.
Calculate the standard deviation and interquartile range of bedload sizes at each site. Remember this is a
mountain stream prone to flooding. Why might the standard deviation and interquartile range be quite large?
Draw a scatter graph to show changes in bedload downstream. Do you notice a trend? Why?
Channel Efficiency (Hypothesis 4 and 5)
Calculate the hydraulic radius for each site at both present flow and bank-full levels.
How do these change downstream and relate to each other?
How does hydraulic radius relate to other factors measured, especially discharge and velocity?
Mean Velocity and Discharge (Hypothesis 6)
Tabulate your velocity readings and calculate a mean velocity for each site. Describe any patterns in
changes in velocity across the stream channel. Can you account for these patterns? Draw a scatter graph
1133
to show how average velocity varies downstream? Does this show the result that you expected? If not, why
might this be so?
The discharge is the cross-sectional area (m2) multiplied by the average velocity (m/s) and is measured in
cubic metres per second (cumecs). If you have used the Centre’s software, you can tabulate you discharge
directly from your printouts. If not, first calculate the cross-sectional area as described above.
A third method of obtaining discharge measurements for each site is to use Manning’s ‘n’. This can be
calculated using the following formula:
Q=A x
Where Q = Discharge
A = Cross Sectional Area
R = Hydraulic Radius (Area x Wetted Perimeter)
S = Channel Gradient (This must be a tangent, so convert from degree)
n = Manning’s ‘n’. (This is a constant – you will need to select the appropriate constant from
the table below.)
Channel Type Manning’s n
Earth canal, straight
Artificial channel – shuttered concrete
Winding natural river
Natural channel <30m wide, sluggish weedy pools
Mountain rivers, cobbles and boulders
Major rivers >30m wide, clean regular
0.020
0.014
0.035
0.070
0.050
0.025
This method is particularly useful for calculating discharge at bank-full levels since it is not usually possible
to measure velocity under these conditions. By removing the area from the formula it is possible to estimate
a bank-full velocity.
Plot a scatter graph to show how discharge varies downstream. Does it show the pattern you expected? If
not, why might this be so?
Discharge is very closely linked with hydraulic radius. This is the cross-sectional area (m2) divided by the
wetted perimeter (m). The hydraulic radius for each site is given on your computer print out, or can be
calculated by hand. It is an efficiency ratio. The higher the number, the greater the efficiency of the stream
channel. What might the relationship be between discharge and hydraulic radius? You could test for a
relationship by using Spearman’s Rank or Pearson’s Product.
Channel Gradient (Hypotheses 7)
Compare the gradient readings at each of the sites. How do these change downstream?
Most theories relating to the long profile of a stream suggest that gradient should decrease. Why may this
not have happened on the Souteyran?
Is there any relationship between gradient and velocity?
R 0.67S 0.5 n
1144
Points For Discussion
Comment on trends and anomalies of graphs and calculations. Particular points to consider might be:
Problems encountered by the group in carrying out the planned investigations.
Limitations of the study – length of river, number of samples, methods of sampling etc.
Ways of improving the accuracy of the study. Which methods are the liable to contain the most errors and
can they be improved upon?
What else may affect the results, for example how do humans impact on the river?
How would different weather conditions change the results?
What changes have taken place in pH and dissolved materials (if measured)? How do these relate to other
factors?
Is the Souteyran a typical river? Can it be related to river models?
1155
Appendix 1: Site Of Study Stations
Site
No.
Distance
Downstream
(km)
Altitude
(m)
1 0 1440
2 0.8 1340
3 1.05 1310
4 1.95 1220
5 2.2 1200
6 3.75 1060
7 3.8 1050
8 4.45 1020
9 5.75 960
10 6.95 880
Scale 0 1000m
NN KKeeyy:: -- SSttuuddyy
SSiittee -- RRiivveerr
1166
Downstream Rivers Recording Sheet
Station Station Station
Present Flow Bank full Present flow Bank full Present Flow Bank full
Width (w)
Wetted
Perimeter(w)
Depth (m)
Mean:
Measure from
tape to water
surface
……….
Add to present
flow mean
depth
Measure from
tape to water
surface
……….
Add to present
flow mean
depth
Measure from
tape to water
surface
……….
Add to present
flow mean
depth
Size Shape Size Shape Size Shape
Sediment:
Mean Size &
Shape
Time Taken
Mean Time
Velocity(m/s)
Gradient
pH
Conductivity
1177
RIVER INVESTIGATION RESULTS SHEET
It is recommended that this sheet be filled in with pencil so that any errors can be easily changed.
Station Station Station
Present flow Bank full Present flow Bank full Present flow Bank full
W (w)
m
m
m
m
m
m
Depth (d)
m
m
m
m
m
m
Area (A)
(w x d)
m2
m2
m2
m2
m2
m2
Wetted
Perimeter (P)
m
m
m
m
m
Hydraulic
Radius(A/P)
Present flow only Present flow only Present flow only
Velocity (v)
m/s
m/s
m/s
Discharge (Q)
m3/s
m3/s
m3/s
Conductivity
ppm
ppm
ppm
pH
Gradient (S)
Sediment
Shape
Sediment Size
cm
cm
cm
1188
Possible Project Titles
The following are some possible ideas for projects which students can undertake for coursework using data
collected in this unit.
• The Souteyran River exhibits the classical model of development forwarded by W.M. Davis.
• How do channel variables change downstream?
• To examine the relationships between width and depth, and velocity and discharge along a river
channel.
• Do streams of different orders exhibit different characteristics?
• The Souteyran River becomes more efficient downstream.
• Velocity is related more to channel efficiency than to gradient.
• Sediment size and shape are related to velocity.
• Sediment size and shape will change downstream.
• Channels with small, rounded bed-load are more efficient than those characterised by large, coarse
poorly sorted materials.
• Does velocity change with water depth?
• Abstraction of water has an impact on channel variables within the River Souteyran.
• A comparison of a river channel at bank-full and normal flow conditions.
• Dissolved load and pH are related to geology and land-use.
• Stream channel size and discharge is related to the size of basin area drained.
• Rejuvenation along the Souteyran has directly affected channel variables.
The following titles require more data to be collected on the Souteyran or elsewhere.
• Do streams of the same order exhibit similar characteristics?
• How does discharge relate to rainfall in the Souteyran basin? (Secondary data available in this unit
and at The Eagles Nest).
• Comparison of an upland stream with a lowland stream.
• Comparison of a stream on granite with a different rock type.
• The River Souteyran can be considered to be clean and unpolluted along its course.
1199
Investigating Flood potential in the souteyran Valley.
AAiimmss
TToo iinnvveessttiiggaattee tthhee mmaaiinn ffaaccttoorrss tthhaatt iinnfflluueennccee fflloooodd rreessppoonnssee iinn aa ssmmaallll ccaattcchhmmeenntt..
TToo ssttuuddyy iissssuueess ooff fflloooodd rriisskk iinn aa ccaattcchhmmeenntt sseettttlleemmeenntt
HHyyppootthheesseess
DDiiffffeerreenntt llaanndd uusseess wwiillll hhaavvee ddiiffffeerreenntt iinnffiillttrraattiioonn rraatteess..
RReelliieeff hhaass aann iinnfflluueennccee oonn iinnffiillttrraattiioonn rraattee..
AAnntteecceeddeenntt ssooiill mmooiissttuurree wwiillll iinnfflluueennccee iinnffiillttrraattiioonn rraattee..
DDaattaa CCoolllleeccttiioonn SSiitteess
VViissiitt RRoocc DDuu CCoouuiilllloouu ffoorr aann oovveerrvviieeww ooff tthhee SSoouutteeyyrraann ccaattcchhmmeenntt.. UUssee tthhiiss llooccaattiioonn aass tthhee bbaassee ffoorr tthhee llaanndd
uussee ccaattcchhmmeenntt mmaappppiinngg wwhhiicchh mmaayy ddeeppeenndd oonn wweeaatthheerr ccoonnddiittiioonnss.. VVaarriioouuss ssiitteess aalloonngg tthhee ccoouurrssee ooff tthhee
rriivveerr ccaann bbee uusseedd ffoorr ssiittee ssppeecciiffiicc eevvaalluuaattiioonnss wwiitthh ddiiffffeerreenntt llaanndd uusseess..
EEqquuiippmmeenntt
CCaattcchhmmeenntt mmaapp ((AAppppeennddiixx 11))
BBllaannkk ccaattcchhmmeenntt mmaappppiinngg sshheeeettss ((AAppppeennddiixx 22 && 33))..
PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt fflloooodd rriisskk aasssseessssmmeenntt wwoorrkksshheeeett ((AAppppeennddiixx 55 && 66))..
RReessuullttss rreeccoorrddiinngg sshheeeett ((AAppppeennddiixx 44))..
PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt bbaassee mmaapp((AAppppeennddiixx 77))..
PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt fflloooodd rriisskk aasssseessssmmeenntt mmaapp ((AAppppeennddiixx 88))..
CClliinnoommeetteerrss
RRaannggiinngg ppoolleess..
IInnffiillttrraattiioonn rriinngg
MMaalllleett
MMeettrree rruulleerr..
TTaappee mmeeaassuurree..
SSooiill tteexxttuurree kkeeyy
SSooiill MMooiissttuurree ssaammppllee bbaaggss ((MMiiccrroowwaavvee aanndd ccrruucciibblleess iinn llaabb))
CCoommppaassss..
2200
MMeetthhoodd aanndd OOrrggaanniissaattiioonn ooff SSttuuddyy
TThhee ddaayy wwiillll ssttaarrtt wwiitthh ssoommee llaanndd uussee mmaappppiinngg ffrroomm oonnee ooff tthhee mmaannyy vvaannttaaggee ppooiinnttss cclloossee ttoo tthhee EEaagglleess
NNeesstt.. TThhee ccllaassss wwiillll tthheenn ffoollllooww tthhee ccoouurrssee ooff tthhee rriivveerr ddoowwnnssttrreeaamm ssttooppppiinngg aatt ssppeecciiffiicc ssiitteess ffoorr tthheeiirr
iinnffiillttrraattiioonn eexxppeerriimmeennttss oonn ddiiffffeerreenntt llaanndd uusseess.. TThhee ccllaassss wwiillll ffiinniisshh iinn PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt ffoorr tthhee ffiinnaall mmaappppiinngg
eexxeerrcciissee
11.. CCaattcchhmmeenntt MMaappppiinngg
FFrroomm RRoocc DDuu CCoouuiilllloouu llooookk oouutt oovveerr tthhee SSoouutteeyyrraann vvaalllleeyy aanndd rreeccoorrdd oonn tthhee bbllaannkk bbaassee mmaappss ((AAppppeennddiixx 22 &&
33)) wwhhaatt tthhee ¼¼kkmm22 ssqquuaarreess aarree ddoommiinnaatteedd bbyy,, iinn tteerrmmss ooff::
LLaanndd UUssee::
((11)) DDeecciidduuoouuss wwooooddllaanndd ((DDaarrkk ggrreeeenn))
((22)) CCoonniiffeerroouuss wwooooddllaanndd ((LLiigghhtt ggrreeeenn))
((33)) PPaassttuurree//MMeeaaddooww ((YYeellllooww))
((44)) BBrroooomm ssccrruubb ((OOrraannggee))
((55)) BBaarree ssooiill ((BBrroowwnn))
((66)) BBaarree rroocckk//SSccrreeee ((GGrreeyy))
((77)) PPaavveedd//UUrrbbaann ((BBllaacckk))
aanndd RReelliieeff::
((11)) FFllaatt
((22)) GGeennttllee
((33)) IInntteerrmmeeddiiaattee
((44)) SStteeeepp
((55)) VVeerryy sstteeeepp
((UUssee oonnee mmaapp ffoorr llaanndd uussee aanndd aa sseeccoonndd mmaapp ffoorr rreelliieeff.. TThhee ccoolloouurr ddeessiiggnnaattiioonnss aarree ffoorr tthhee ffoollllooww uupp wwhheenn
pprroodduucciinngg nneeaatt llaanndd uussee mmaappss))
22.. SSiittee eevvaalluuaattiioonn aatt vvaarriioouuss llaanndd uussee ssiitteess::
PPlleeaassee nnoottee tthhaatt tthheerree mmaayy nnoott bbee eennoouugghh ttiimmee ttoo ssttuuddyy aallll llaanndd uusseess iinn ddeettaaiill,, iitt iiss bbeesstt ttoo ccoonncceennttrraattee oonn 33
iinn ppaarrttiiccuullaarr.. OOnn aarrrriivvaall aatt tthhee cceennttrree ddiissccuussss wwiitthh tthhee ccoouurrssee lleeaaddeerr wwhhaatt tthheeyy wwoouulldd rreeccoommmmeenndd.. FFoorr eeaacchh
llaanndd uussee ttyyppee mmaakkee ssuurree yyoouu hhaavvee ssiixx ppiieecceess ooff ddaattaa ((eennoouugghh ffoorr aa MMaannnn WWhhiittnneeyy UU ssiiggnniiffiiccaannccee tteesstt)),,
ddeeppeennddiinngg oonn hhooww mmaannyy ssttuuddeenntt ggrroouuppss tthheerree aarree ssoommee rreeppeeaattss mmaayy nneeeedd ttoo bbee ddoonnee.. AAtt eeaacchh ssiittee ccoonndduucctt
tthhee ffoolllloowwiinngg.. SSeeee rreeccoorrddiinngg sshheeeett ((AAppppeennddiixx 44))::
IInnffiillttrraattiioonn rraattee
CCaarreeffuullllyy wwiitthh tthhee aaiidd ooff tthhee mmaalllleett,, hhaammmmeerr tthhee iinnffiillttrraattiioonn ccaann iinnttoo tthhee ggrroouunndd bbyy aapppprrooxxiimmaatteellyy 33--55ccmm.. WWiitthh
hheeaalltthh && ssaaffeettyy iinn mmiinndd,, iitt iiss bbeetttteerr ffoorr aa mmeemmbbeerr ooff ssttaaffff oorr tthhee ccoouurrssee lleeaaddeerr ttoo ppeerrffoorrmm tthhiiss ooppeerraattiioonn.. OOnnccee
2211
tthhee iinnffiillttrraattiioonn ccaann iiss ffiirrmmllyy iinn tthhee ggrroouunndd,, ppoouurr wwaatteerr iinnttoo tthhee ccaann ttoo aa lleevveell ooff 1100ccmm.. WWiitthh tthhee aaiidd ooff aa mmeettrree
rruulleerr ppllaacceedd iinnssiiddee tthhee ccaann,, rreeccoorrdd tthhee lleevveell ooff tthhee ssuurrffaaccee ooff tthhee wwaatteerr lleevveell aatt 11 mmiinnuuttee iinntteerrvvaallss oovveerr aa ttoottaall
ppeerriioodd ooff 55 mmiinnuutteess ((NNoottee tthhaatt iiff aallll wwaatteerr iinnffiillttrraatteedd bbeeffoorree 55 mmiinnuutteess,, rreeccoorrdd tthhee eexxaacctt ttiimmee ttaakkeenn))..
AAnnggllee ooff ssllooppee..
UUssiinngg aa cclliinnoommeetteerr aanndd rraannggiinngg ppoolleess,, aasssseessss tthhee aannggllee ooff ssllooppee oovveerr aa ssttaannddaarrddiisseedd ddiissttaannccee,, ssuucchh aass 1100mm
mmeeaassuurreedd wwiitthh aa ttaappee mmeeaassuurree..
SSooiill ccoommppaaccttiioonn
UUssee aa sskkeewweerr ttoo ppuusshh ddoowwnn iinnttoo tthhee ggrroouunndd.. RReemmoovvee tthhee ssppiikkee ffrroomm tthhee ggrroouunndd aanndd mmeeaassuurree tthhee ddeepptthh ooff
ppeenneettrraattiioonn ((ii..ee.. hhooww mmuucchh ooff tthhee ssppiikkee ssttuucckk iinn tthhee ggrroouunndd)) wwiitthh tthhee aaiidd ooff tthhee mmeetteerr rruulleerr..
SSooiill tteexxttuurree tteesstt
WWiitthh aa ssooiill ssaammppllee,, ffoollllooww tthhee iinnssttrruuccttiioonnss oonn tthhee ssooiill tteexxttuurree kkeeyy ttoo iiddeennttiiffyy iittss tteexxttuurree..
SSooiill MMooiissttuurree
CCoolllleecctt ssooiill ssaammpplleess ffrroomm tthhee ffiieelldd aanndd ppllaaccee iinn aa sseeaalleedd ccoonnttaaiinneerr.. WWhheenn bbaacckk iinn tthhee llaabb,, wwiitthh tthhee aaiidd ooff
ssccaalleess tthhaatt ccaann mmeeaassuurree ttoo wwiitthhiinn 00..0011gg.. MMeeaassuurree aanndd rreeccoorrdd tthhee mmaassss ooff aann eemmppttyy ccrruucciibbllee.. PPllaaccee aa
ssaammppllee ooff tthhee ssooiill iinn tthhee eemmppttyy ccrruucciibbllee,, mmaakkiinngg ssuurree nnoott ttoo oovveerr ffiillll tthhee ccrruucciibbllee ssoo tthheerree iiss ddaannggeerr ooff ssppiillllaaggee
tthhrroouugghhoouutt tthhee eexxppeerriimmeenntt,, oorr ttoo pprreessss tthhee ssooiill ddoowwnn aanndd ccoommppaacctt iitt wwhhiicchh ccaann iimmppeeddee tthhee eessccaappee ooff
mmooiissttuurree bbyy eevvaappoorraattiioonn tthhrroouugghh tthhee ssooiill ppoorreess.. WWeeiigghh tthhee ccrruucciibbllee wwiitthh tthhee ssooiill ssaammppllee aanndd rreeccoorrdd tthhee
rreessuulltt,, tthheenn ppllaaccee iinn aann oovveenn oorr mmiiccrroowwaavvee ttoo ddrryy tthhee ssooiill ((IIff uussiinngg aann oovveenn ddoo nnoott hhaavvee tthhee tthheerrmmoossttaatt sseett ttoo
hhiigghh ssiinnccee tthheerree iiss aa ddaannggeerr ooff bbuurrnniinngg ooffff tthhee oorrggaanniicc mmaatteerriiaall wwhhiicchh wwoouulldd aaffffeecctt tthhee rreessuulltt.. HHaavvee iitt sseett ttoo
112200°°CC wwhhiicchh iiss ssuuffffiicciieenntt.. IIff uussiinngg aa mmiiccrroowwaavvee,, mmaakkee ssuurree yyoouu aallssoo ppuutt aa sseeppaarraattee vveesssseell ooff wwaatteerr iinn tthhee
mmiiccrroowwaavvee aass wweellll,, bbeeccaauussee iiff tthheerree iiss nnoo mmooiissttuurree iinn tthhee oorriiggiinnaall ssooiill ssaammppllee,, tthhee mmiiccrroowwaavvee ccoouulldd bbee
ddaammaaggeedd ssiinnccee iitt wwoorrkkss bbyy hheeaattiinngg wwaatteerr mmoolleeccuulleess)).. AAfftteerr ttaakkiinngg tthhee ssaammppllee oouutt ooff tthhee oovveenn//mmiiccrroowwaavvee,,
wweeiigghh tthhee ssaammppllee iinn tthhee ccrruucciibbllee tthheenn ppllaaccee bbaacckk iinn tthhee oovveenn//mmiiccrroowwaavvee.. RReeppeeaatt tthhiiss pprroocceessss ttiillll yyoouu rreeaacchh aa
ccoonnssttaanntt mmaassss ttoo bbee ssuurree tthhaatt aallll mmooiissttuurree hhaass eevvaappoorraatteedd..
33.. SSeettttlleemmeenntt
IInn PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt,, SSttuuddeennttss wwiillll ccaarrrryy oouutt aa ccoorrrriiddoorr ssuurrvveeyy aalloonngg tthhee TTaarrnn wwiitthh tthhee aaiidd ooff tthhee bbaassee mmaapp
rreeccoorrddiinngg tthheeiirr oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss wwiitthh rreessppeecctt ttoo fflloooodd rriisskk aasssseessssmmeenntt aatt tthhee sseelleecctteedd ssiitteess ((AAppppeennddiixx 55 oorr 66))..
2222
AAnnaallyyssiiss
11.. CCaattcchhmmeenntt MMaappppiinngg
PPrroocceessss tthhee ddaattaa bbyy pprroodduucciinngg aa nneeaatt llaanndd uussee mmaapp ((wwiitthh tthhee ccoolloouurr kkeeyy mmeennttiioonneedd iinn tthhee mmeetthhooddoollooggyy)) iinn
tthhee ccllaassss rroooomm,, ssttuuddeennttss wwiillll bbee aabbllee ttoo aasssseessss wwhhaatt tthhee ccaattcchhmmeenntt aarreeaa iiss ddoommiinnaatteedd bbyy oorr iiff tthheerree aarree
ddiissttiinnccttiivvee sseeccttoorrss.. IItt iiss ppoossssiibbllee ttoo wwoorrkk oouutt aa ppeerrcceennttaaggee bbrreeaakkddoowwnn ooff tthhee ddiiffffeerreenntt ccaatteeggoorriieess.. AAllssoo
pprroodduuccee aa nneeaatt mmaapp bbaasseedd oonn tthhee rreelliieeff ddaattaa,, uussee ddiiffffeerreenntt iinntteennssiittiieess ooff oonnee ccoolloouurr ((ssuucchh aass ppuurrppllee)) ttoo
rreepprreesseenntt tthhee ddiiffffeerreenntt ggrraaddeess ooff rreelliieeff wwiitthh tthhee ddaarrkkeesstt bbeeiinngg tthhee sstteeeeppeesstt..
FFlloooodd RRiisskk SSccoorree
FFoorr eeaacchh ooff tthhee ssqquuaarreess ccaallccuullaattee tthhee fflloooodd rriisskk ssccoorree,, wwhhiicchh iiss tthhee LLaanndd uussee ssccoorree ((11--77)) mmuullttiipplliieedd bbyy tthhee
RReelliieeff ssccoorree ((11--55)).. TThhee fflloooodd rriisskk ssccoorree wwiillll vvaarryy ffrroomm 11 ((ffllaatt ddeecciidduuoouuss wwooooddllaanndd;; llooww rriisskk)) ttoo 3355 ((vveerryy sstteeeepp
ppaavveedd//uurrbbaann ssuurrffaacceess;; hhiigghh rriisskk)).. PPrroodduuccee aa nneeww mmaapp wwiitthh tthheessee ssccoorreess ttoo hhiigghhlliigghhtt hhiigghheerr fflloooodd rriisskk aarreeaass..
PPoossssiibbllee eexxtteennssiioonn;; CCaallccuullaattee aann oovveerraallll aavveerraaggee ooff aallll tthhee fflloooodd rriisskk ssccoorreess ttoo ggiivvee aa CCaattcchhmmeenntt fflloooodd rriisskk
ssccoorree.. TThhiiss ccoouulldd bbee uusseedd aass aa mmeeaassuurree ooff ccoommppaarriissoonnss wwiitthh ootthheerr ccaattcchhmmeennttss..
22.. LLaanndd uussee eevvaalluuaattiioonnss
FFoorr eeaacchh ooff tthhee llaanndd uusseess ccaallccuullaattee tthhee::
IInnffiillttrraattiioonn RRaattee
DDiivviiddee tthhee ttoottaall ddrroopp ooff wwaatteerr iinn tthhee iinnffiillttrraattiioonn ccaann ((ccoonnvveerrtt ttoo mmmm)) bbyy tthhee ttiimmee ttaakkeenn ((iinn mmiinnuutteess)).. TThhiiss wwiillll
ggiivvee yyoouu aa rreessuulltt ooff iinnffiillttrraattiioonn iinn mmmm//mmiinnuuttee.. MMuullttiippllyy tthhee rreessuulltt bbyy 6600 ssoo iitt iiss eexxpprreesssseedd iinn mmmm//hhrr.. TThhiiss iiss
tthheenn ccoommppaarraabbllee ttoo rraaiinn ffaallll rraatteess..
SSooiill mmooiissttuurree
UUssee tthhee ffoolllloowwiinngg eeqquuaattiioonn ttoo wwoorrkk oouutt %% ssooiill mmooiissttuurree
((MMaassss ooff oorriiggiinnaall ssooiill ssaammppllee iinn ccrruucciibbllee)) –– ((MMaassss ooff ddrriieedd ssooiill iinn ccrruucciibbllee))
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ xx 110000
((MMaassss ooff oorriiggiinnaall ssooiill ssaammppllee iinn CCrruucciibbllee)) –– ((MMaassss ooff ccrruucciibbllee))
ii..ee.. ((MMaassss lloosstt dduuee ttoo eevvaappoorraattiioonn))
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------- xx 110000 == %% SSooiill MMooiissttuurree
((MMaassss ooff oorriiggiinnaall ssooiill ssaammppllee))
PPoossssiibbllee ttaasskkss;;
MMaannnn WWhhiittnneeyy UU tteesstt ttoo sseeee iiff tthheerree iiss aa ssiiggnniiffiiccaanntt ddiiffffeerreennccee iinn iinnffiillttrraattiioonn bbeettwweeeenn llaanndd uusseess ((HHyyppootthheessiiss 11))..
SSppeeaarrmmaannss RRaannkk CCoorrrreellaattiioonn CCooeeffffiicciieenntt bbeettwweeeenn ssllooppee aannggllee aanndd iinnffiillttrraattiioonn ((HHyyppootthheessiiss 22))
SSppeeaarrmmaannss RRaannkk CCoorrrreellaattiioonn ccooeeffffiicciieenntt oonn ssooiill mmooiissttuurree vveerrsseess iinnffiillttrraattiioonn rraattee ((HHyyppootthheessiiss 33))..
2233
CCoonnssiiddeerraattiioonnss oonn ssttaattss tteessttss;;
NNuummbbeerr 11 ddooeess nnoott ttaakkee iinnttoo aaccccoouunntt tthhee iinnfflluueennccee ooff tthhee ssllooppee ooff tthhee llaanndd,, ssooiill tteexxttuurree oorr tthhee aanntteecceeddeenntt
mmooiissttuurree..
NNuummbbeerr 22 ddooeess nnoott ttaakkee iinnttoo aaccccoouunntt tthhee llaanndd uussee,, ssooiill tteexxttuurree oorr aanntteecceeddeenntt mmooiissttuurree..
NNuummbbeerr 33 ddooeess nnoott ttaakkee iinnttoo aaccccoouunntt tthhee llaanndd uussee,, ssooiill tteexxttuurree oorr aannggllee ooff ssllooppee
33.. SSeettttlleemmeenntt EEvvaalluuaattiioonn
LLooookkiinngg aatt tthhee ccoorrrriiddoorr mmaappppiinngg ffrroomm PPoonntt ddee MMoonnvveerrtt wwiitthh tthhee ssttuuddeennttss’’ oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss.. DDiissccuussss hhooww aatt rriisskk
tthhee sseettttlleemmeenntt iiss ffrroomm ffllooooddiinngg aass aa rreessuulltt ffrroomm eexxttrreemmee wweeaatthheerr aanndd wwhhaatt iiss pprreesseenntt ttoo lliimmiitt tthhee ddaammaaggee ooff
ffllooooddiinngg ((SSuucchh aass cchhaannnneell mmooddiiffiiccaattiioonnss,, hhiigghh bbrriiddggee aanndd wwaallll bbyy rrooaadd,, bboottttoomm fflloooorr uusseedd aass cceelllleerr)).. PPrroodduuccee
aa nneeaatt fflloooodd aasssseessssmmeenntt mmaapp uussiinngg IIGGNN PPoonntt ddee MMoonnttvveerrtt bbaassee mmaapp ((AAppppeennddiixx 77)) bbaasseedd ffrroomm oobbsseerrvvaattiioonnss
aanndd ccoommppaarree ttoo aaccttuuaall fflloooodd aasssseessssmmeenntt mmaapp ((AAppppeennddiixx 88)).. WWoorrkk oouutt wwhhaatt tthhee iimmppaaccttss ooff ppootteennttiiaall ffllooooddiinngg
wwoouulldd bbee.. DDiissccuussss tthhee aaddvvaannttaaggeess aanndd ddiissaaddvvaannttaaggeess ooff ppoossssiibbllee fflloooodd mmaannaaggeemmeenntt tteecchhnniiqquueess,, wwiitthh
rreeffeerreennccee ttoo ccoosstt bbeenneeffiitt aannaallyysseess..
PPoossssiibbllee mmeetthhooddss ooff fflloooodd ddeeffeennccee//fflloooodd rriisskk rreedduuccttiioonn..
CChhaannnneell mmooddiiffiiccaattiioonn..
DDaamm..
AAffffoorreessttaattiioonn..
DDiiffffeerreenntt ffaarrmmiinngg tteecchhnniiqquueess,, ccoonnttoouurr pplloouugghhiinngg..
PPooiinnttss FFoorr DDiissccuussssiioonn
BBrriinngg aallll tthhrreeee eelleemmeennttss ttooggeetthheerr iinn aa ccllaassss ddiissccuussssiioonn..
WWhhiicchh ppaarrttss ooff tthhee ccaattcchhmmeenntt ccoonnttrriibbuuttee mmoosstt ttoo fflloooodd rriisskk??
DDooeess pprreecciippiittaattiioonn eexxcceeeedd iinnffiillttrraattiioonn lleeaaddiinngg ttoo ssuurrffaaccee rruunn ooffff wwhhiicchh iinnccrreeaassee fflloooodd rriisskk??
WWhhaatt tteecchhnniiqquueess ffuurrtthheerr mmaannaaggeemmeenntt ppllaannss ccoouulldd bbee uuttiilliisseedd ttoo ffuurrtthheerr lleesssseenn tthheessee ppootteennttiiaall fflloooodd rriisskkss??
AArree tthheessee mmeeaassuurreess ccoosstt eeffffeeccttiivvee??
HHooww ddoo yyoouu tthhiinnkk tthhiiss ccaattcchhmmeenntt ccoommppaarreess ttoo aa llooccaall eexxaammppllee nneeaarr yyoouu??
2244
AAppppeennddiixx 11::
2255
AAppppeennddiixx 22::
2266
AAppppeennddiixx 33::
2277
AAppppeennddiixx 44:: SSiittee eevvaalluuaattiioonn rreeccoorrddiinngg sshheeeett
LLaanndd uussee
AAnnggllee ooff ssllooppee
SSooiill ccoommppaaccttiioonn
SSooiill TTeexxttuurree
SSttaarrtt
11 mmiinn
22 mmiinn
33 mmiinn
44 mmiinn
II nnff ii ll
tt rr aatt ii oo
nn rr aa
tt ee,, hh
ee iigg hh
tt ooff ww
aa ttee rr
55 mmiinn
TTiimmee iiff aallll wwaatteerr
iinnffiillttrraatteedd iinn lleessss tthhaann 55
mmiinn
AAppppeennddiixx 55::
2299
AAppppeennddiixx 66::
3300
AAppppeennddiixx 11.. HHyyddrroopprroopp FFllooww MMeetteerr CChhaarrtt..