31
From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results Lessons Learned About Change, Culture and People- Focused Process Improvement Vickie Kennedy, Assistant Director for Insurance Services Shelli Lackey, Operational Change Manager Amy Nagley, PhD, Organizational Culture Change Architect

From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

From Quick Fixes to

Sustained Results

Lessons Learned About

Change, Culture and People-

Focused Process Improvement

Vickie Kennedy, Assistant Director for Insurance Services

Shelli Lackey, Operational Change Manager

Amy Nagley, PhD, Organizational Culture Change Architect

Page 2: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

2Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Page 3: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

3Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Five key agency goals

Page 4: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

4Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Lessons learned

Quick fixes are easy. Sustaining results can be

much harder.

Page 5: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

5Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Lessons learned

Effective long-term improvement efforts often

combine:

Cultural strategies

Focus on effects on people

Change management

Page 6: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

6Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

The challenge (and opportunity)

Page 7: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

7Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

The challenge (and opportunity)

Page 8: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

8Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational

rehabilitation

Page 9: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

9Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 10: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

10Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 11: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

11Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 12: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

12Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 13: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

13Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Barriers to change

Without strong communication –

and explaining why – policies have

a way of living on even after they’re

changed

With a lack of clear direction,

people will hesitate to adopt a

change

People need context to embrace

change

Page 14: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

14Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 15: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

15Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

A holistic approach

Mapped out the process and its pain points

Training for confident conversations

Eliminated ambiguity with reminders

Mentoring of new staff

Visual management

Gemba walks, talking about barriers

Page 16: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

16Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Involving external

partners

Eliminating barriers/frustrations for the

vocational rehabilitation counselors

Vocational Recovery Project: identify

worker-centric best practices, show what

works

Working closer – and earlier – with

employers and medical providers to

remove return-to-work barriers

Page 17: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

17Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Vocational rehabilitation

63

0

50

100

150

200

250

300

Tim

e-l

oss

day

s p

aid

Median time-loss days paid at first AWA referral

The goal is to

decrease

this number

Page 18: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

18Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Results: Better outcomes

New Process

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

Perc

ent o

f all

outc

omes

Outcome distribution, first AWA referrals, select outcomes (12-month rolling average)

Able to work job of injury Return to work

Eligible for Retraining Able to work transferable skills

Page 19: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

19Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

BACKGROUND

Page 20: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

20Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

“Autopsy of Success”

Change Management

(Operational Needs)

Organizational Development

(Culture Needs

Enterprise Needs

Page 21: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

21Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Change management: Key principles In Action

• Insurance Services leadership provided autonomy along with strong support to the people doing the work.

• Leaders remained focused to provide sustained support to team members.

Active and Visible Sponsorship

• L&I engaged Voc Rehab stakeholders much earlier in the process.

• Team members were empowered to design new process.

• Claim Managers met regularly with leaders to ensure continued alignment.

Engage Key Stakeholders

• Staff were trained on how to engage injured workers and employers more effectively, including role-playing that first call to the injured worker.

• New staff were paired with mentors.Training

• A system was set up to automatically prompt claim managers to refer certain cases to voc rehab counselors.

• Vocational counselors are having different conversations with medical providers – referring to the worker’s vocational recovery plan (similar to their medical recovery plan), rather than assessing employability

Reinforcement

Page 22: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

22Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Change management: Key Take-aways

What Are You Doing?

(Be crystal clear as to what the change is, and what it’s

not)

Who Does It Touch?

(Ensure impacted stakeholder voices are

heard and included)

You Can’t Overcommunicate

(Simple key messages; multiple mediums; multiple

iterations)

Reinforcement For the Win

(Create an environment to sustain your change in the

long term)

OCM

Take-aways

Page 23: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

23Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Change management: Where to learn more

Questions about what L&I is doing to make change management

a core capability? Email [email protected]

Prosci.com

Popular Change Management Books:

– Our Iceberg Is Melting : Changing and Succeeding under Any

Conditions - by John P. Kotter and Holger, Mueller, Peter Rathgeber

– Switch: How to Change Things When Change Is Hard – by Chip Heath

and Dan Heath

Page 24: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

24Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Developing

Page 25: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

25Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Developing Culture

“Culture is the work

environment in which we all

grow, learn, and serve. Its

elements include our

individual and shared vision,

values, structures, systems,

mindsets, norms, beliefs,

traditions, and physical

space.” L&I’s Definition

Operational Change & Success

Structures & Systems

Normative Behaviors

Values & Mindsets:

Positive Core

Page 26: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

26Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Values & Mindsets– The

Positive Core

Respect for People “Doing

the Work”

Safe Space to Speak Up

Learning & Innovation

Inclusion and Empowerment

of staff

Page 27: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

27Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Normative Behaviors–

Living from the Core

• Leaders and decision-makers regularly spent time with staff, and understood their work and daily experiences. Understood and spoke to their experiences and “pain points.”

Respect for People Doing Work

• Energized staff by meeting regularly and discussing the stats. Showed how their work was moving the dial on the bigger picture.

• Collected thoughts, feedback, and questions continuously.

Inclusion & Empowerment of

Staff

• Regular and structured conversations around failures and learning.

• “Blame” was a no-no. Collaborative effort of support, questioning, and reflection together for the sake of innovation and the customer.

Safe Space to Speak Up

• Had a “license” to “make things up” daily, figure out what works.

• Support and autonomy from the top allowed people doing the work to figure out the best way to go about the changes. Sponsored and supported when needed.

Learning & Innovation

Page 28: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

28Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Shifting Structures &

Systems

Before• Injured workers saw

Voc Rehab as a burden.

• Voc Rehab Counselors (VRCs) experienced low engagement and success.

• Claims Managers (CMs) and VRCs didn’t have a collaborative and meaningful relationship.

During• Dialogue was

occurring between CMs and VRCs

• Listening to concerns, questions, and feedback from VRCs

• Sharing data with CMs and VRCs

After•Injured workers are happy to receive Vocational Rehab counseling•Meaningful and collaborative relationship between CMs and VRCs•VRCs feel that their work is more meaningful and productive

Page 29: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

29Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Key Cultural Takeaways

Core Values

(Identify the core values that enable us to best serve our

customer)

People Make the Place

(Invest in talent that embodies those values– hire, promote, train, and evaluate based on

values)

Pilot Projects are Our Friends!

(When someone sees something that can be made better, try a pilot. Because… Why Not?”

Sponsor & Let Go

(Trust our people to do the work and ask what support we can

provide)

Cultural Take-aways

Page 30: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

30Washington State Department of Labor & Industries

Developing Culture: Where to learn more…

Stay tuned for a comprehensive white paper discussing how

L&I is taking a leap of faith in investing in a values-driven

culture. Email [email protected] for more info.

Popular Books

– The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By

Daniel Coyle

– Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

Books). –By Margaret Heffernan

Other Resources

– The Leadership Challenge Workshop. -- By Kouzes & Posner

(Values Cards to help you get started. Type title into search engine

and have fun!)

Page 31: From Quick Fixes to Sustained Results...–The Culture Code: The Secrets of Highly Successful Groups. –By Daniel Coyle –Beyond Measure: The Big Impact of Making Small Changes (Ted

31Washington State Department of Labor & Industries