FoE 2012 the Rise of the Bio-based Economy Report WEB

7/29/2019 FoE 2012 the Rise of the Bio-based Economy Report WEB

1/40

Media Partner

GreeninG europe Forum (GeF) roundtable

The rise of

The bio-based economy

su 2012


2/40

CleanStar Mozambique Fact Sheet

The Problem

Every day, hundreds of millions of women in the developing world are forced to feed their familiesusing charcoal-burning cookstoves. The noxious combination of carcinogens and pollutants in cookingsmoke lingers in poorly ventilated living quarters, leading to underweight births, cancer, respiratory

diseases, and increased rates of infant mortality. Household indoor air pollution causes an estimatedtwo million deaths per year and sickens millions more mostly infants and small children.i Theequivalent of smoking two packs of cigarettes daily, this health threat is as critical as poor sanitationand AIDS, and greater than malaria.ii In addition to the impact on global health, nearly a third of

Africas seven million square kilometers of forest has already been burned for charcoal,iii stripping thecontinent of vital biodiversity and greatly contributing to the projected 6.7 billion tons of greenhouse

gasses that household energy use in Africa is expected to emit into the atmosphere by 2050. iv

The Solution

CleanStar Mozambique (CSM) is pioneering a new, sustainable business model that will drasticallyimprove both the environment and human lives. Thousands of smallholder farmers in Sofala province

will transition from charcoal production and slash-and-burn agriculture to cultivating a diverse range ofcrops and trees, which will significantly improve their income and nutrition levels while rehabilitatingdegraded soils and enhancing biodiversity. Whatever the families do not consume themselves, theycan sell to CSM. The company will operate a local food and ethanol cooking fuel production facility and

produce a range of food products as well as an ethanol-based cooking fuel made from cassava. Theseproducts, as well as clean-burning ethanol cook stoves, will be sold into urban markets.

The Benefits

CSM is a highly integrated business that will create economic, social and environmental value at every

point along its value chain. Rural smallholders in Sofala province will experience improved nutrition andincome increases of at least 300% while planting millions of trees and enhancing biodiversity. Urban

households in Maputo will experience cleaner air, a reduced disease burden and lower energy costswhile reversing deforestation by transitioning from charcoal to ethanol. By 2014 the venture willinvolve 2,000 smallholders over 10,000 acres (4,000 hectares), supply 20% of Maputo households witha clean and cheaper alternative to charcoal and thus protect 9,000 acres of indigenous forests per

year. The company will also employ approximately 1,000 people in Mozambique. From a commercialstandpoint, CSM is replicable and scalable across large parts of the developing world, offering thepromise of widespread development impacts and significant reductions in global greenhouse gas

emissions. By helping establish proof-of-concept in Mozambique, Novozymes intends to catalyze thedevelopment of agriculture, food and ethanol industries in developing countries, creating new,sustainable, bio-based markets.

The Partners

Novozymes and CleanStar Ventures have jointly founded CSM. As the world leader in industrialbiotechnology, Novozymes provides enzymatic and microbial solutions to many industries, including

food, agriculture and biofuel. CleanStar Ventures is an environmental venture development group withparticular expertise in agroforestry and biofuels. Novozymes and CleanStar Ventures have joined also

forces with ICM (US-based world leader in ethanol production plants), Dometic (Sweden-basedbusiness that produces the worlds leading ethanol cookstove), and Bank of America Merrill Lynch

(world leader in carbon finance). The day-to-day management team leading CSM has decades ofexperience in agriculture, bio-processing and business development, including many previous projectsin sub-Saharan Africa.

www.cleanstarmozambique.com

i Biomass Fuels and Respiratory Diseases: A Review of the Evidence (http://pats.atsjournals.org/cgi/content/full/5/5/577 )ii On Cookstoves, Research Paves Way to Action (http://rael.berkeley.edu/node/716)iii Africa's burning charcoal problem (http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8272603.stm )iv Impacts of Biomass and Petroleum Energy Futures in Africa (http://www.caei.com.ar/es/programas/africa/05.pdf)


3/40

The rise of

The bio-based economy

rpt t Gg ep f (Gef) tl

-g Friends of Europe nz

wt pt Europes World

s 2012

bl


4/40

T w p t pt t pt w

l t l t w tgt t pt, Friends of Europe,

t b Tt, pt.

rpt wl pt ptt, p

tt ll t g t Friends of Europe, p

tt pt, wt wl pt,

t l l pt t wk.

Rapporteur: d KzjPublisher: Gt c

Project Director: ntl f

Project Manager: L dg

Photographer: Plpp mlt

Cover Photograph: nz

Design & Laout:dl Tt

T pt pt tl p pp


5/40

Tl tt

execuTive summary 5

recommendaTions 7

Benets of the bio-based economy 10

Dening a clear direction for the- 13

Wt l l? 16

fg t gt l 20

a l lk t t- l 22

Wt t eu ? 24

fg t - 26

cl 29

annex i Lt dt 30

annex ii Pg 32

annex iii Lt o 34


6/40

4 Friends of Europe | Gg ep f


7/40

5T t - | s 2012

execuTive summary

f wt t ez, t ep u (eu) t tk t pltl t tt t ep . a pt t Gg

ep f, Friends of Europe brought together experts from multiple elds

t t t tp tw tg ll, ll

tll l - .

T t t tl gll llg ep

wll t pt. hw, t ppl lp t, ep -

k llg t gll pt ptt lt

gt wk pl. oll, tgt pp t t - , w l gt, t, l t t,

, , .

Though there are many potential benets of the bio-based economy, future

sustainability is at risk if it is not carefully dened and suitable policies are not crafted.

i t t w pt tll tl w t,

t t pt pl wt pt w kt, t

certications.

Wl t - p w t, j tl

tlt, t tl t ll w t tl t t t

t wl tg l tw , tk, g tl .

ft, g t plt lt t , - g

tlg l tllgtl t wt t wl g

.

a t - tk p, t wll tl t ll lg t glll t w t t t gg lg

to increase resource efciency and reduce and recycle waste. European capacity for

t t w tt t g pl t t pt t -

t t tl t t t t gll - .

Finding sufcient nancing is going to be an enormous challenge, with some

tt llg pw tl $4t p t t t

-. Tg t t tl w t g ,

t g t tl t ep g t tg pl-pt ptp -tl llt

g .


8/40



9/40

7T t - | s 2012

recommendaTions

The rise of the bio-based economy roundtable made specic recommendations

t plk w t tlt t lpt t - .

T t gp t :

1) ct g w

T pt jt t - l ll

t t eu plk pl w

pg l t t ep pl t wt t -

based economy entails and its benets for European and global society.

2) eg tlt

The EU should produce a scientically-assessed land use strategy that

clearly identies the sectors and resources most relevant to the bio-

, lg t pt. Gt

p pl l pl tlg

t tlt t wt pt t ,

llt l-l l - pt.

3) spptg t - l-

T t l t - l

tl t t ep t. clg t gp tw

lt - pt p wll

ttg t l jt t t l.

The EU must seek to comprehend the most efcient and effective uses of

pt t tg t pl t tg

a level playing eld for all biomass applications based on greenhouse gas

emissions and resource efciency. Dedicated efforts must be made to

ptt ep t g

t lpt t tlg t t

tg tl w.


10/40


) eg t ppl tk tt lpt

ctl, t l g pl ppt t

- g tw l g t.

T llt t - l

tt l tw , tk, g w tl

tl wg glt wk t. i

t, t q gtl tt

t lpt w l t - ,

wll tlgl .

rg eu ppt tw l tl pt

wll t -g wll p

tl t t -

t t t eu pl t gt tt

associated with rst generation biofuels.

) sppt -

T ptpt ppt t lpt tt

tl plt - t pt, ptl

bio-reneries. Funding for pilot projects in this area requires the

tgt , lg t c agltl

Pl, t c f Pl, t c Pl, t

rwl eg Pl, hz 2020, lt eu it

Ptp, wll pl-pt ptp.

it w t tt pl g tt t -

l gtl .

) Ptg - pt

T ptpt g tt t eu l t pltt

t L mkt itt (Lmi) - pt. T

tt t Lmi l gg g pl pt

and the promotion of certication schemes for these products. The

current policy decit in this area should be examined and the creation


11/40

9T t - | s 2012

l pl pl wk l lt

t t t ptt tg t tl- . T tg kt -

pt, gg pt l, tg pg lgtl

ppt, g pl tl , ptg

tl p.

4) ipltg p epb- sttg

T ep c t g t ttg t t

itg stl Gwt: a b- ep, pt

13 f 2012, lp l p t

pltt t - .

T ep c, wt pt t tt, t

l, g ep l t ptt,

l plt t t p

t pl t - . a gt ,

t c l t t pt pltl

-tl lt w t -

pl.


12/40


Benets of the bio-based economy

ag t blg nw eg f, t lpt ep

l t l:

ct p t ll j tw 2010 2020 t tl l

;

Gt p t 31 tll t eu27 p 2020;

r GhG gl lt tpt 50%;

i g t tttg t l ll gl

49 l pt. T ptll lt wt l wll

100$ l t wt iea tg tt eu l p

wll 95% 2035;

d gt l t.

T - l-g w, t tt t

Stephan Singer, dt Gll eg Pl, Wl Wll f (WWf)

European Policy Ofce. It can provide innovation and jobs while reducing emissions

T - l-g w.

Stephan Singer, Director for Global Energy Policy, World Wildlife Fund (WWF) European Policy Ofce


13/40

11T t - | s 2012

t t t t, w t tt w l plt t

g p t t gwg . a t wl pplt gw,so too does the demand for the efcient use of bio-based resources, he added.

Tg tll l tg lpt, t Maive Rute, dt

btlg, aglt f, ep c dtt

Gl r it, t pptt t -

ep .

rgt w t eu, g Lars Christian Hansen, Pt rg ep,

nz, w tl gltl t, wt t ll t . W l t pl l wt

tt tl . T ll tl tt

w t tg g-l pt.

o t pptt t plt g l pt ttlindustries, continued Rute. For example, clothing bres made out of forest residues

t p t-t t ttl pt t plp pp

t. i ep, l, t .

i t t ep, t tll pg 40% t gw

t ll l tl pt l.

i t t tg l pt, t t -

lt pt wt w qlt, t pl

gl plt g gltl w p

T y pptt t -y ep y.

Maive Rute, dt btlg, aglt f,ep c dtt Gl

r it


14/40


pg plt t lgt lg pjt

t eu st fwk Pg (fP7) tt.

The nal example Rute offered was that of a Coca-Cola bottle made of plant

tl, wg tt wl pt t t j t

- . hw, t, t pt t

as this, new markets, standards and certications must be created in order to

t w pt tll tl w t.

a t eu wt gl t t, t t

eu pt t t gwt t j. yt, w lttl t tl t pl g t pt. T -

t tt tl tt t t jt wl g

t tl llg t t t, h . nz t

ep p wkg t l t l gl

t kg w lll tl t t ll

ptt pplt . nw tt t gl ,

- lt l pl g l t

lt, t.

At the heart of this reality is the bio-renery utilising renewable inputs to create

or replace many of the products traditionally provided by reneries using fossil

inputs. These bio-reneries are appearing in greater numbers around the world,

l, g t tl t lg t

pl wt g t t t pt.

T t eu pty t tgwt t j. T -

y t tt tlytt t v t jtv

wl g t tl

llg t t t.Lars Christian Hansen,

Pt rg ep, nz


15/40

13T t - | s 2012

Dening a clear direction for the-

a t - t l plt w

it comes to dening what the bio-based economy actually is and should be,

-t Giles Merritt, st Gl Friends of Europe.

W l l t t , g David Baldock, et dt

t ittt ep etl Pl (ieeP). T -

t llg t pptt. it t

t gl t.

i t ppl plt t gwg pttl t - ,

plk t tkl t pp tgl t tt tl, pltl - plt t pg t.

a t - t l plt w t t g wt t - tll l .

Giles Merritt, st Gl Friends of Europe

T - t

llg tpptt. it t t gl t.

David Baldock, et dt t ittt ep etl Pl (ieeP)


16/40


W t g t lt tl, l. m wt w t

l t t tg - pl kwlg pl

.

T lltt t pt, t pjt tk t ieeP

tw. Tg tw , t pg w lttl

p t ll t t . dlpg llwg tg

on small and specic projects of this type is the foundation of the bio-economy.

Lt t kp t wk p, l. i w t t wk, w

wll gt t - wg kl, w t t wk.

Though there are certainly some very benecial applications for biotechnology in

t, t plk t k pl t gwg -

t ll ptt plt gt

tl wt t ep pl. T - t

lt ppt t lk pl w, blk t.

W l l t wt t wt t t t,

t pl. rgt w, t t l t wll t pg t .

Wt tt t, t wll pl t t

t t t t t l g

(iLuc) pt l g g .

m, t t a sk, ct t fl, ntwk

G stl e, t pt

tw t t, ep plk t k tg qtand dene the needs and purposes of the new paradigm.

W t ep c t t l. a lg t tt gt tl pltt, w t wktgt t pl t t tptw t - .

Markus Holzer, h ut, bg & b,

ep c dtt Gl aglt rl dlpt


17/40

15T t - | s 2012

One of these questions is whether the bio-based economy should be dened

pt tt wll t kp tg tt g w

way to dene functions and the manner in which Europeans consume and live.f pl, T ep c tl wkg pjt t

ttt ll- plt g wt gl . T

pl lt t t wt gt plt g tt t

pllt t t g t qt t lg pt tt

ppl l t g.

W t t q t, tJudith Merkies MEP,

m t ep Plt ctt it, r eg.

W t k l w wt t t t t pt ll,

with the addition of a certied bio label on our products or if we want to redene

w l tl .

Another area that needs to be dened is innovation. Should EU policy focus

tl t pg pt p? o l t ll tl l t t t t

-pt ? W pl t, mk , t

i tk tt t t t wl t tl. W

t ll tlg w wt w t g

t pt pg.

Pt t t pt ptt l l w w lpg

t - , Markus Holzer, h ut,

bg & b, ep c dtt Gl aglt rl dlpt. W t ppl tt t l

W pl t, t i tk ttt t t wl t

tl.

Judith Merkies MEP, m t epPlt ctt ity, r egy


18/40


g t t, t. W t t lt w t

lpg lt l l. T t l l lfor policymakers, for example when it comes to the promotion of certication of

- pt t pl pt l l t -

pt.

Wt l l?

el ppt tpt l oecd w tk t

t pt l ppl wl ltt w t

land for highly efcient biomass for other purposes where there is no alternative

t l l ptl t ppg t sg. bl

l t tpt, t q t l t p.

Instead, we should focus efforts on other areas of innovation. The electrication

, pl, l tl t t t eu 20-20-20

gl1, wll t llt l t t t tt wll

difcult to de-carbonise such as aviation and shipping, he concluded.

Wl t pplt g t t ppg t t

t lt, tt t Xavier Beulin, Pt t

ft ntl st epltt agl (fnsea), l

tt t eu jt 10% wl tpt 2020 l

l wt l, tg t eu t wt t

2 3 gt l.

W g vy t gllptt ty. ep vlp

w vlpt plt t wl vy t t t pl w t vt

y -ep t.

Xavier Beulin, Pt t ft ntl st epltt agl (fnsea)

1The EUs 20-20-20 goals call for a 20% increase in energy efciency, 20% reduction of CO2

, 20% wl, lg 10% lq l tpt 2020.


19/40

17T t - | s 2012

Tg ttk g gt t - gltl

l, t, ep tlz gt t gltlp t t t g, t t zt p.

ft, l, ep tl g l 2.5% t l

l tl pt, p w l

p klg t pt lt l p,

t g t ptt g ep p pt

l pt.

rt t g t . l t, t gl

pl t t tw, t Marcel Wubbolts, Chief Technology Ofcer,

dsm, t ntl. i tk w gltl l t

l, . at g gltl wt tl, w tt 25%

t l t pp wtt

tg l qlt.


20/40



21/40

19T t - | s 2012


22/40


T - t t jt l, t

ptpt g. ctl, t Michael Carus, mgg dt t

n-ittt, G, t t ppt t - g

tw l g t. T tg pl t -

based economy, we need a level-playing eld for all bio-based products.

fg t gt l

T t t -: , , g l,

w tl tl , t lk, t l. Wt t pl p, w, t l l

wt t wk - , c l.

T t wk l t ql llt tt,

t t t, wt g g t l

p t eu, t ggp, w t p

t pltl wk g pt nt a a.

o plt w lt , t, w t l t wt w t t . h ggt t t ppl

t t t w t pt .

Willem Sederel, s it Plt, t ntl Jean Sentenac, a, f

Lkg t l wll q w ptp t tt gl. Wt w l t lt pp.

Marcel Wubbolts, Chief Technology Ofcer, DSM, the Netherlands


23/40

21T t - | s 2012

Firstly, sectors with the highest resource efciency should be given precedence.

fllwg t, k l k t gt g g

reductions possible. Thirdly, it should be considered which sector will benett t - pt plt, t

l. fll, l l w t l pt

t wl g, l w.

cg t t, l, t t t t

is industry. EU policy, however, has set aside the lions share of nancial support

t g t, wl tl pt, pt t

, lttl.

T tt ppt - tt qt

t, t G, w t t l g

t t tw 25% 80% t (2012), t. T

g pk w 2009. Wt gl g t, tl

p t lt l t l pt l .

Wt t g t t tl t l t t

t pt t -, t t tp t t w pl

tt tt wll llw t t - t lp ll

playing eld for all biomass applications. The region of the world that is most

ready to create and implement a level playing eld for the bio-based economy

will prot the most from its development, he concluded.

o t t t wl g w tl

t t - pt, t bl. at t t, t ptl tl wk. W , tl

l p glt tg eu t ttl gt.

T g t wl tt t t t plt

ll plg l t- wll pt t

t t lpt.

Michael Carus, mgg dt t n-ittt, G


24/40


a l lk t t

- l T ep p wt -tl t t l t t

pt tg w gll l wll t t -

. o w t w t gll ppl pt, w

can determine where to nd added value and where mistakes are being made,

t blk t ittt ep etl Pl (ieeP).

Wl t eu lg t wl t tlg, t

tlgl t g pt, t t tt t ep - , t h nz. i t, , ep

ll t lt t l t - . e

tg t eu t , tlg, t , tl

base, and workforce, these elements are not sufcient without the correct

tt l tl- t -.

W g t gll ptt t, g bl. ep

lp w lpt pl t t wl

t t t pl w t t -ep t.

T l g wt gltl , h t, g tt

glt, t plt t eu pl t,

tll ptt pptt, t eu pl wk twk t

W k l g t

w tt wt g t lt.

Roel Bol, Pg dt t b-e, dt mt e a,

aglt it


25/40

23T t - | s 2012

t t t - . T pt

and land use strategies must be reected in the Common Agricultural Policy

(caP), wt tg g g t ll t t tw l t w pp t pt t , t

tl g.

i t t ptt, ep t t -

w p ltpl t tt ll t ppt, K

mtzl, et dt, ep Plt s ogt (ePso). i

t, -tl llt t g ltt

t t p llt ll lg t l .

T t - p tt l pl: p,

kwlg p, nGo, gt l . Lkg t l

wll q w ptp t tt gl,

Wlt t. Wt w l t lt pp.

a w l w l twk, w t t

gtl t, t Roel Bol, Pg dt t b-

e, dt mt e a, aglt it. W

lkg t tt w t l t t wt t

gltl t, wt t pp t. T ll t lgg

t t t l t t t.

a w gtl tt , t t - wll t

t tl ll, blk . W t t t gt

ll t tkl t t t l t t ,

. i t w, lk g gg t t

gt l tt ptg wt g w t l implemented in more efcient ways.

mk hlz t ep c dtt Gl aglt

rl dlpt t tt t eu gt pl

pltt t t t -

t lt. Wl g t, t llt

tw t eu ttt tt gt, wll tw

t dtt-Gl t ep c t

t w wt t - ttg.


26/40


2 f t t hz 2020 fwk Pg r it:ttp://.p.//z2020

W t ep c t t l, l. a lg

t tt gt tl pltt, w twk tgt t pl t t tp tw t - .

W k l g t w tt wt g

t lt, g bl. T t g, eu plk t g

t pl t tl eu ll t w tg

pl wt g pl, t caP, t hz 2020, t l

ttg pt t gt.

Wt t eu ?

Faced with stiff competition from abroad and a fragmented and loose-tting policy

wk t , t t eu t tp p pl tg g

to reap the benets of the bio-based economy, the roundtable agreed, highlighting

l w t eu l pt tg pp

t t -. it ltl tl tt ep g

p, bl l. T l pt t eu.

i t t p, rt, t ep c

ppg t p p tlgl lpt t tl

wt tg t hz 2020 fwk Pg

r it, w lt t pl t st fwk

Pg (fP7) 2014.2

dt Olivier Dubois, f aglt ogzt t ut nt(coPa-coGeca), Nikolaus Tacke, T c-cl cpy, James Philp,ep Plt s ogt (ePso)
http://ec.europa.eu/research/horizon2020http://ec.europa.eu/research/horizon2020http://ec.europa.eu/research/horizon2020


27/40

25T t - | s 2012

i t t t t hz 2020, t, lt

eu it Ptp wkg t lk t t l t- dG r wt t ptt

t lp pl-pt ptp t g t t.

W t t ptl , bl, w l tlt

ppt ll tp (sme) t t tt

pl lt t w tq .

f pl ppt, h t, t eu t tt

t tg t t t l , t t

t t: t t caP t t ppl pg gltl wt; hz 2020 t ppt lg l -

reneries through public private partnerships; renewable energy policy to provide

tl lg-t pl wk l; tl pl

t l g kt ppt p t; ttl

t t l g tt t.

Pt t pl wk t tkl t kt t

tl pt, t m rt.

f t ppt, g Wlt, tlt g

lp p t . dsm, gll p

t t pt 2 gt l, pt ppll

t atlt t eu ll t us t kt t

tt t - .

ao), Nella Mikkola, Gl ctt agltl cpt t eugt e c-pt dvlpt (oecd) Karin Metzlaf,


28/40


Wl t tlk t eu - g, w ep

t tlt t, g w lpt. T wll tk t t w pg. W t t tt t

t ep, l.

sg t t tt t t eu t

l tt t - . r lpt

gt ep lg l , , g

tt t t lt t gt.

Singer also recommended that more specic guidelines should be given by the

ep c t w t t - l tk.

m t t l-l l - pt

and standards creation before we can move condently forward with the bio-

, m rt.

fg t - T tl, ttg l llg tt t

lg-l lzt . T t

pg llg ll - t t p t

pt tg plg tlt.

T t wllg t t l g t t t t

signicantly or rapidly without conducive policies and government support given

t ttl k t tt t lt pg l l tt t - pt.

i t t Pwtcp (Pwc), t w tt tt,

in order to nance the development of the bio-based economy and provide

tl pjt gll pplt 9 2050,

gll tt t - wl t $4t p

, t Isabelle Spiegel, dt sttg Gp / stlt, Pwc.


29/40

27T t - | s 2012

T eu t tt t - ql t

tl $1t p , gl 5% eu GdP, . a t tw, wt t l ll t eu tl tg, w

that we are nowhere near the necessary levels of nancing.

Tg t l l g tt t ppt

t lpt tlg wl , t tg

programs will not be sufcient if they continue to be isolated from each other.

T k t wll t tt lt

approach to nancing on the European and global scale and to involve actors

lg t t l , .

T ep c p tt tt t

t qt g t -, hlz t ep

c dtt Gl aglt rl dlpt. T

caP, t, pt l lpt, wlt hz 2020 wll p g t.

Tg t tt, t wt t ep c -

ttg3, tt t eu l t t , t tl

numbers, the current nancing opportunities for the bio-based economy fall

t wt gt, t mk meP. i

t c t ttg, , t i w w w wll

t t tk t ltt t t -.

a t t w, wt tl ll t eu tl tg, w ttw w t ll g.

Isabelle Spiegel, dt sttgyGp / stlty, Pwtcp (Pwc)

3 itg stl Gwt: a b- ep, pt 13 f 2012. fll tt:ttp://.p.///p/201202_tg_tl_gwt.p
http://ec.europa.eu/research/bioeconomy/pdf/201202_innovating_sustainable_growth.pdfhttp://ec.europa.eu/research/bioeconomy/pdf/201202_innovating_sustainable_growth.pdfhttp://ec.europa.eu/research/bioeconomy/pdf/201202_innovating_sustainable_growth.pdf


30/40


The measures in place are insufcient to meet the challenge, agreed Holzer.W t pl t pt t pl g l ,

t. T ep c t t t w,

t tt, t pt t. W t tgt ll

g t p pp.

T wll t pl-pt pt, g spgl,

tg tt t pt t, g p

lg tw tlt t t pptt.

T pl t g ll t lw g t p, t lkg t w tl w g .

nw l gg wt pptt

p. o t l plk ltg t g

pptg sme t p t, l.

Ptpt t t g t twkg l


31/40

29T t - | s 2012

clT - t p. a t lp t,

wll tt wll q t lt g pt

pp ll tkl. m, t l t t -

q tkg t w w t eu t gll t

g t tll tl tt l

l , t t , t lg wt . ag

ptl - t t gg g, t t gg l,

ptg w ppt tl gwt g tt tl pltl lpt.

Overcoming the EUs systemic reluctance to change, bolstered by a decit of

imagination, is no small challenge in itself. The rst step is to overcome some of

t ttl tw t tt gp t p t

cause in a holistic way, recognising that nothing signicant will be achieved by

gp tg ltll. b, plk, l

t t wk tgt.

at t t t t - l ltt t t t

gll t t l,

gwt l lpt w ep wll pt t tk

gll l.


32/40


annex i Lt dt

Mika Aalto, dt, ft cl it, ffg ag Tlg it (TeKes),fl

Antonia Andugar, s Pl a, etli, Gl ctt agltl cpt teu (coPa-coGeca)

Martin Austin, mgg dt, Tr

David Baldock, et dt, ittt epetl Pl (ieeP), ut Kg

Xavier Beulin, Pt, ct ntl st 'epltt agl (fnsea), f

Gauthier Boels, h r dlpt,

reaLcoRoel Bol, Pg dt b- e,mt e a, aglt it, tntl

David Boxer, dt, ittt f r, utKg

Ana Maria Bravo-Angel, dt Pl a, Gittl

Geert Cami, c-f & dt, Friends of Europe

Michael Carus, mgg dt, n-ittt, G

Nicolas Denis, Pt, stlt rPtt, mK & cp

Joce D'Silva, dt, Pl a, cp Wlfg, ut Kg

Olivier Dubois, Senior Natural Resources Ofcer & Leadereg T, f aglt ogzt tut nt (fao), itl

Joanna Dupont-Inglis, dt itl btlg,ep at bt (epb)

Daniel Fraile Montoro, Senior Policy Ofcer, EU Climate andeg, clt at ntwk ep (can)

Nathalie Furrer, dt, Friends of Europe

Andrew Hagan, dt, h cl it,Wl e f, swtzl

Lars Christian Hansen, Pt rg ep,nz

Edwin Hecker, mgg Pt, sttl Pt

Markus Holzer, h ut, bg, b, ft clt cg, ep c dttGl aglt rl dlpt

Karen Johnstone-Hobbs, cll, s &Tlg, m c t t eu

Manfred Kircher, m t a b, cltitll btlg (cLib-2021), G

Robert Kleiburg, Chief Operating Ofcer, ECN, thentl

Hans Langeveld, dt, b r, tntl

Albert Markusse, mgg dt, sk u, tntl

Judith Merkies MEP, ep Plt ctt it, r eg

Giles Merritt, st Gl, Friends of Europe

Karin Metzlaf, et dt, ep Plt sogt (ePso)

Nella Mikkola, Pl a, rl dlpt ft, Gl ctt agltl cpt t eu (coPa-coGeca)

Christine Moeller, Policy Ofcer, Economic Assessment ofclt Pl, ep c dtt Gl clt at

Clemens Neumann, dt Gl, mt f,aglt c Ptt, G

Kre Riis Nielsen, dt, ep a, nz

James Philp, Pl alt, itl etlbtlg, ogt e c-pt dlpt (oecd), dtt s, Tlg it, f

Jaroslaw Pietras, cl t ep u dttGl et, et, Tpt eg

John Ro Porter, P al st elg,ut cpg, dk

Marie-Christine Ribera, dt Gl, ct ep ft s (cefs)

Edward Ricketts, ep a, ut Kgbtlg blgl s r cl(bbsrc)

Ton Runneboom, Pt, bwl bPlt, t ntl

Christophe Rupp-Dahlem, Pg dt, Plt-bt, rqtt f, f

Maive Rute, dt, btlg, aglt, f,ep c dtt Gl r

itBruno Schmitz, h ut nw rwl egs, ep c dtt Gl r it

Bernd Uwe Schneider, Head of Staff of the Scienticet b, hlltz ct Pt, GfZ Gr ct G

Willem Sederel, Gl mg, s it Plt,t ntl

Jean Sentenac, Chairman and Chief Executive Ofcer,a, f


33/40

31T t - | s 2012

Stephan Singer, dt Gll eg Pl, WlWide Fund for Nature (WWF) European Policy Ofce

Anne Snick, ct, fl ntwk ept rl

Patrick Sorgeloos, P h dptt,flt b egg, Gt ut

Isabelle Spiegel, dt sttg Gp / stlt,Pwtcp, f

Nikolaus Tacke, dt ep Gt a, Tc-cl cp

Menno van der Veen, P, flt appls, dlt ut Tlg, t ntl

Jacco van Haveren, Pg mg bcl, ctb, t ntl

Johannes van Kasteren, P, cah dt ut appl s, t ntl

Marc Van Montagu, f & c, ittt Pltbtlg dlpg ct (iPbo)

Hasso von Pogrell, mgg dt, epbplt, G

Niklas von Wemarn, c r stt, vTTTl r ct fl

Peter Wehrheim, h ut, clt f dtt, ep c dtt Gl clt at

Marcel Wubbolts, Chief Technology Ofcer, DSM, thentl


34/40


annex ii Pg

09.00 09.30 Welcome coffee and registration of participants

SESSION I WHy MOVING TOWARDS A BIO-BASED ECONOMy?09.30 11.15

mg t - l pwl tl t p t t tg

g, l tl wl tg gwt

plt ttg t tl ptt. T lk t t

pttl t -, t ep c ppg ep t

pl p t 2020. bt wt tl l llg t lg-l t tw - t ? i -

l llt ep tl tl pl, l t

gt - tl t? hw ep t t

its technological leadership and avoid it is implemented rst in other regions like Asia

t us?

c-t Giles Merritt, st Gl Friends of Europe

Hans Langeveld, dt b r, t ntl

IntroductorydIscussantsIncluded:

11.15 11.45 Coffee break

Lars Christian HansenPt rg ep,nz

Stephan Singer

dt Gll egPl, WWf epPolicy Ofce

Xavier Beulin

Pt t ftntl stepltt agl(fnsea)

Maive Rutedt btlg,aglt & f,ep c dG r ivt

Michael Carus

mgg dt tn-ittt, G


35/40

33T t - | s 2012

SESSION II HOW TO MAKE IT HAPPEN?09.30 11.15

Among the major obstacles to a bio-based economy is the lack of nancing. Governments

t g vtt tlg y tg kt tly gltg

t tlt p. aglt wll t t - y: ep

1.22 t yly gltl l tly vt wtt

ltg l- ptt t t pl wt l t

pp. hw l t c agltl Ply t eu g tt

t lk t pttl? c pl pt - pt

tl, l pl pg t tw pl-pvt ptp

tt pjt ep? Wt t eu t tt t

t l pltl tt tt ply ?

c-t Giles Merritt, st Gl Friends of Europe

Hans Langeveld, dt b r, t ntl

IntroductorydIscussantsIncluded:

13.30 14.30 Lunch

Judith Merkies MEPm t epPlt ctt it, r eg

Isabelle Spiegel

dt sttgGp / stlt,Pwtcp

(Pwc)

David Baldock

et dt tittt epetl Pl (ieeP)

Markus Holzerh ut, bg& b, epc dG aglt& rl dlpt

Roel Bol

Pg dt tb- ey, dtmty e a,aglt ivt

Marcel Wubbolts

Chief Technology Ofcer,dsm, t ntl


36/40


annex iii Lt o

Nour Amrani, mg Pl a & Pl rlt,nz

Bela Atzel, Assistant Policy Ofcer, European Commission,Jt r ct

yvonne Barcelona, st Gl, ep clctg at (ecca)

Winston Beck, cltt, K G a

Catherine Berens, Policy Ofcer, Food and Healthcareit, btlg, ep c,dtt Gl etp it, tntl

Douwe-Frits Broens, b b a,Wgg ut

Antoine Brossier, dt Gl, ep sltit Gp (esiG)

Attilio Caligiani, ep a a, sttl Pt

Tomasz Calikowski, Project Ofcer, Biotechnologies,ep c, dtt Gl r it

Paula Campos, ct att, epc, dtt Gl r it

Julio Cardoso, Policy Ofcer for International Aspects stl itl Pl, ep c,dtt Gl etp it

Dirk Carrez, mgg dt, cl clt

Stefanie Chirico, Interim Policy Ofcer, Europeanc, dtt Gl hlt c

Jarka Chloupkova, Brussels Correspondent, Pro Press,cz rpl

Pierre Conrath, stlt Pl a mg,ittl at sg t nw & rltit (edana)

David Criekemans, ut Lt, ittl Plt,

ut atwpEd D'Hooghe, mg, it Pg, epcl it cl (cefic)

Sian Davies, att dt, bt agltl b

Chantal de Cooman, dt cl P,ep cl it cl (cefic)

Thierr de l'Escaille, st Gl/c etOfcer, European Landowners' Organisation (ELO)

Barbara Debusschere, et Jlt, d mg

Pierre Dechamps, a, eg clt cg,ep c b ep Pl a

(bePa)Cristina Degano, Institutional Relations Ofcer, Chemtexitl

Alain Deletroz, v Pt ep, ittl cGroup (ICG) Brussels Ofce

Mireille Delprat, a, stl dlpt,ep c dtt Gl r it

Nathalie Devriendt, Pjt mg b-g, flittt Tlgl r (viTo)

Onur Durmus, mg Gll etl a, TtPk ittl

Jamie Fortescue, mgg dt, ep stit at (aaf)

Elvira Grassi, Pg mg, ep c,dtt Gl aglt rl dlpt

Frans Green, mgg dt Pt, aptcltg

Gerfried Gruber, m, aglt, rl dlpt et (naT), ep e slctt (eesc)

Veronique Gurin, dt, ft ntl st 'epltt agl (fnsea)

Roman Haken, m, aglt, rl dlpt et (naT), ep e slctt (eesc)

David King, h ittl rlt, st aglt f (saf), f

Irena Krasteva, Chief Executive Ofcer, New Bulgarianm Gp hlg (nbmG), blg

Jan Kretzschmar, Liaison Ofcer, Energy & Environment,T L ag fl-ep (vLeva vZW)

Eveline Lecoq, Policy Ofcer for Biotechnologies, Europeanc, dtt Gl r it

Janusz Luks, Chief Executive Ofcer, Central Europe EnergyPt (ceeP)

Abhijeet Malik, eu b dlpt a,Pwtcp

Tim Masselink, b- cll, Pt

rptt t ntl t t euElena Mengon, att, at P bz& st Tl, itl

Felix Mittermaer, e a t f c,ep c, dtt Gl hlt c

Ward Mosmuller, dt Pl a, dsm, tntl

Florian Nitzinger, att, dt ittl, euLiaison Ofce

Herbert Oberhnsli, h e ittlrlt, ntl, swtzl

Valer Oknansk, cll, Pt m tr ft t naTo

Lumi Ollila, T, ep ft Wtmgt (fead)

(For the List of Discussants, please see page 30)


37/40

35T t - | s 2012

Mrton Plmai, bl rptt, moL hg ol G cpt

Antoine Peeters, mg, ep at bt (epb)

Eleonora Pinna, T, ep c, dttGl hlt c

Andreea Lorena Plesea, Pt et, epPjt et

Daniel Rahier, s a, sp cltg

Jose Antonio Ruiz, Advocacy Ofcer, ExxonMobil Petroleum cl

Peter D. Schellinck, c, sllt sttgcltt

Andreas Schmidt, Policy Ofcer - Coordination Agri Team,ep c, dtt Gl T

Annette Schneegans, Research Programme Ofcer, CropPlt Pt st cp Plt blg, epc, dtt Gl r it

Dorota Sienkiewicz, hlt eqt Pl cct, ep Pl hlt all (ePha)

Andreas Sommer, ep a mg, bg

Monika Sormann, s Pl a, dptt te, s it, fl Gt

Mark Stalmans, Scientic External Relations Manager,Pt & Gl

Agnieszka Stasiakowska, Pl alt, epc, dtt Gl r it

Arij van Berkel, dt it cl,Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientic Research(Tno), t ntl

Marina Tamagnini, ep Pl a a,nt

Arij van Berkel, dt it cl,Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientic Research

Guido van Gorp, att ep a, a f KLm

Christian Vanden Bilcke, Head of Ofce, United Nationset Pg (uneP)

Robert F. Vandenplas, mgg dt, blgp nv

Barend Verachtert, dpt h ut, btlg,ep c, dtt Gl r it

Marc Vermeulen, dt f & Ptt applt,ep cl it cl (cefic)

Matthew Willis, mgg dt, fTi cltg blg


38/40


How to use a QR code?

1. Download a QR code reader for your smartphone

2. Open it and scan this QR code using your phones camera

3. Read this and many other publications and articles online on Friends of Europes

website

To read this and many other publications and articles on theFriends of Europe website, scan this QR code or go to:bit.ly/BioBasedFOE
http://bit.ly/GreenWeek2012http://bit.ly/GreenWeek2012http://bit.ly/GreenWeek2012http://bit.ly/GreenWeek2012


39/40

Friends of Europe Les Amis de lEurope

Bibliothque Solvay

137 rue Belliard, B-1040 Brussels, Belgium

Tel.: +32 (0) 2 737 9145 Fax: +32 (0) 2 738 7597Email: [email protected] Website: www.friendsofeurope.org
mailto:info%40friendsofeurope.org?subject=http://www.friendsofeurope.org/http://www.friendsofeurope.org/mailto:info%40friendsofeurope.org?subject=


40/40

With the support of the Europe for Citizens

programme of the European Union

Documents

FoE 2012 the Rise of the Bio-based Economy Report WEB