41
Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts Paul H. Keckley, Ph.D. Vanderbilt Medical Center August 20, 2006

Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

  • View
    212

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety ToolToolKey Concepts, Emerging ApplicationsKey Concepts, Emerging Applications

Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety ToolToolKey Concepts, Emerging ApplicationsKey Concepts, Emerging Applications

The Quality Colloquium at Harvard UniversityBoston, Massachusetts

Paul H. Keckley, Ph.D.Vanderbilt Medical Center

August 20, 2006

The Quality Colloquium at Harvard UniversityBoston, Massachusetts

Paul H. Keckley, Ph.D.Vanderbilt Medical Center

August 20, 2006

Page 2: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

What we’ll coverWhat we’ll coverWhat we’ll coverWhat we’ll cover

The momentum for safety EBM as a means to an end Implications for provider organizations

Page 3: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

BIOTECHBIOTECH

INNOVATORSINNOVATORS

ADMINISTRATORS/WATCHDOGSADMINISTRATORS/WATCHDOGS

SERVICE PROVIDERSSERVICE PROVIDERS

PhysiciansPhysicians

HCITHCIT

PharmaPharma

DeviceDevice

HospitalsHospitalsOutpatientFacilities

OutpatientFacilities

InsurersInsurers

RegulatorsRegulators

Long TermCare

Long TermCare

BioTechBioTech

Professional Societies/

Special Interests

Professional Societies/

Special Interests

Accrediting Agencies

Accrediting Agencies

DiseaseManagement

DiseaseManagement

EmployersEmployers

CAMCAM

MediaMedia

AcademicMedicine

AcademicMedicine

CONSUMERSCONSUMERS

Allied HealthProfessionalsAllied HealthProfessionals

Page 4: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

$1.9 Trillion

$1.3 Trillion

$696 Billion

$246 Billion

0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

1980 1990 2000 2005(Projected)

$ T

rilli

ons

8.8% GDP8.8% GDP

12.0% GDP

12.0% GDP

13.3%GDP

13.3%GDP

15.7%GDP

(projected)

15.7%GDP

(projected)

$6320 per person in the U.S.!$6320 per person in the U.S.!$6320 per person in the U.S.!$6320 per person in the U.S.!

Page 5: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

““The quality of care we get is far from the care The quality of care we get is far from the care we should be getting” we should be getting” — Don Berwick, IHI— Don Berwick, IHI““The quality of care we get is far from the care The quality of care we get is far from the care we should be getting” we should be getting” — Don Berwick, IHI— Don Berwick, IHI

Preventive care deficiencies•Child immunizations 76%•Influenza vaccine 52%•Pap smear 82%

Preventive care deficiencies•Child immunizations 76%•Influenza vaccine 52%•Pap smear 82%

Acute care deficiencies•Antibiotic misuse 30-70%•Prenatal care 74%

Acute care deficiencies•Antibiotic misuse 30-70%•Prenatal care 74%

Chronic care deficiencies•Beta blockers 50%•Diabetes eye exam 53%

Chronic care deficiencies•Beta blockers 50%•Diabetes eye exam 53%

Hospital care deficiencies•Proper CHF care 50%•Preventable deaths 14%•Preventable ADEs 1.8/100 admits Life threatening 20% Serious 43%

Hospital care deficiencies•Proper CHF care 50%•Preventable deaths 14%•Preventable ADEs 1.8/100 admits Life threatening 20% Serious 43%

““Quality of Care”Quality of Care”Safe

EffectivePatient-centered

TimelyEfficient

Equitable

““Quality of Care”Quality of Care”Safe

EffectivePatient-centered

TimelyEfficient

Equitable

Surgery care deficiencies•Inappropriate hysterectomy 16%•Inappropriate CABG surgeries 14%

Surgery care deficiencies•Inappropriate hysterectomy 16%•Inappropriate CABG surgeries 14%

Page 6: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

What the evidence says is what you get What the evidence says is what you get

(half the time)(half the time)

What the evidence says is what you get What the evidence says is what you get

(half the time)(half the time)

Condition% Recommended Care

Received

Senile Cataract 78.7

Breast cancer 75.7

Prenatal Care 73.0

Low back pain 68.5

Coronary artery disease

68.0

Hypertension 64.7

Congestive heart failure

63.9

Cerebrovascular disease

59.1

Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

58.0

Depression 57.7

Orthopedic conditions 57.2

Osteoarthritis 57.3

Colorectal cancer 53.9

Condition% Recommended Care

Received

Asthma 53.5

Benign prostatic hyperplasia

53.0

Hyperlipidemia 48.6

Diabetes mellitus 45.4

Headache 45.2

Urinary tract infection 40.7

Community acquired pneumonia

39.0

Sexually transmitted diseases

36.7

Dyspepsia/peptic ulcer disease

32.7

Atrial fibrillation 24.7

Hip fracture 22.7

Alcohol dependence 10.5

McGlynn et al “The Quality of Health Care Delivered to Adults in the United States” NEJM June 26, 2003McGlynn et al “The Quality of Health Care Delivered to Adults in the United States” NEJM June 26, 2003McGlynn et al “The Quality of Health Care Delivered to Adults in the United States” NEJM June 26, 2003McGlynn et al “The Quality of Health Care Delivered to Adults in the United States” NEJM June 26, 2003

Page 7: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

First

Third

FourthSource: S.F. Jencks, E.D. Huff, and T. Cuerdon, “Change in the Quality of Care Delivered to Medicare Beneficiaries, 1998–1999 to 2000–2001,” Journal of the American Medical Association 289, no. 3 (Jan. 15, 2003): 305–312.

Second

WA

OR

ID

MT ND

WY

NV

CAUT

AZ NM

KS

NE

MN

MO

WI

TX

IA

ILIN

AR

LA

AL

SC

TNNC

KY

FL

VA

OH

MI

WV

PA

NY

AK

MD

MEVT

NH

MA

RI

CT

DE

DCCO

GAMS

OK

NJ

SD

Quartile Rank

Note: State ranking based on 22 Medicare performance measures.Note: State ranking based on 22 Medicare performance measures.

Quality depends on where you liveQuality depends on where you liveQuality depends on where you liveQuality depends on where you live

Page 8: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Errors aboundErrors aboundErrors aboundErrors abound

1. Adverse drug events (ADEs, ADRs)2. Iatrogenic infections

• Post-operative deep wound infections• Urinary tract infections (UTI)• Lower respiratory infections (pneumonia or bronchitis)• Bacteremias and septicemias

3. Decubitus ulcers4. Mechanical device failures5. Complications of central and peripheral venous lines6. Deep venous thrombosis (DVT) / pulmonary embolism (PE)7. Strength, agility and cognition8. Blood product transfusion9. Patient transitions

1. Adverse drug events (ADEs, ADRs)2. Iatrogenic infections

• Post-operative deep wound infections• Urinary tract infections (UTI)• Lower respiratory infections (pneumonia or bronchitis)• Bacteremias and septicemias

3. Decubitus ulcers4. Mechanical device failures5. Complications of central and peripheral venous lines6. Deep venous thrombosis (DVT) / pulmonary embolism (PE)7. Strength, agility and cognition8. Blood product transfusion9. Patient transitions

Page 9: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

80% of ADE’s avoidable80% of ADE’s avoidable80% of ADE’s avoidable80% of ADE’s avoidable

Class % Description Avoidable?

Pharm

Expected28.0 Know drug reactions Yes

Physio

Renal23.0

Failure to adjust for decreased

Renal functionYes

Physio

Age14.2 Failure to adjust for patient age Yes

Physio

Weight5.7

Failure to adjust for patient body mass

Yes

Order

Dosage5.0 Error in dosage on order Yes

Physio

Hernal4.6

Failure to adjust for known hematologic

Yes

Total

preventable80.3

Page 10: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Study: Health Care Costs, Error Rates Higher in Study: Health Care Costs, Error Rates Higher in U.S. Than in Other CountriesU.S. Than in Other CountriesStudy: Health Care Costs, Error Rates Higher in Study: Health Care Costs, Error Rates Higher in U.S. Than in Other CountriesU.S. Than in Other Countries

November 04, 2005

For the report, researchers surveyed 6,957 adults between March and June 2005 who recently had been hospitalized, had surgery or reported health problems in the U.S., Australia, Canada, Britain, New Zealand and Germany. The survey, which is the largest to examine health care in several nations during the same time period, found that U.S. residents were more likely than patients in other nations to forego medical care because of costs. In addition, U.S. respondents reported the easiest access to specialists but the most difficulty getting care during nights and weekends (Washington Post, 11/4). Patients from all six countries reported medical errors, uncoordinated care and poor management of chronic diseases (CQ HealthBeat, 11/3).

The study also found the following:

34% of U.S. patients surveyed reported getting the wrong medication or dose, incorrect test results, a mistake in their treatment or late notification of abnormal test results, compared with 30% of Canadians, 27% of Australians, 25% of New Zealanders, 23% of Germans and 22% of Britons;

About half of U.S. residents reported that they had decided not to fill a prescription, see a physician when sick or have recommended follow-up tests because of costs, compared with 38% of patients in New Zealand, 34% in Australia, 28% in Germany, 26% in Canada and 13% in Britain;

Nearly one-third of U.S. patients reported paying more than $1,000 in out-of-pocket medical expenses in the past year, compared with 14% of Canadian and Australian patients and a much lower proportion of patients in the other countries (Washington Post, 11/4);

7% of U.S. residents who had been hospitalized in the past two years reported developing an infection while in the hospital, compared with 10% of Britons and 3% of Germans

November 04, 2005

For the report, researchers surveyed 6,957 adults between March and June 2005 who recently had been hospitalized, had surgery or reported health problems in the U.S., Australia, Canada, Britain, New Zealand and Germany. The survey, which is the largest to examine health care in several nations during the same time period, found that U.S. residents were more likely than patients in other nations to forego medical care because of costs. In addition, U.S. respondents reported the easiest access to specialists but the most difficulty getting care during nights and weekends (Washington Post, 11/4). Patients from all six countries reported medical errors, uncoordinated care and poor management of chronic diseases (CQ HealthBeat, 11/3).

The study also found the following:

34% of U.S. patients surveyed reported getting the wrong medication or dose, incorrect test results, a mistake in their treatment or late notification of abnormal test results, compared with 30% of Canadians, 27% of Australians, 25% of New Zealanders, 23% of Germans and 22% of Britons;

About half of U.S. residents reported that they had decided not to fill a prescription, see a physician when sick or have recommended follow-up tests because of costs, compared with 38% of patients in New Zealand, 34% in Australia, 28% in Germany, 26% in Canada and 13% in Britain;

Nearly one-third of U.S. patients reported paying more than $1,000 in out-of-pocket medical expenses in the past year, compared with 14% of Canadian and Australian patients and a much lower proportion of patients in the other countries (Washington Post, 11/4);

7% of U.S. residents who had been hospitalized in the past two years reported developing an infection while in the hospital, compared with 10% of Britons and 3% of Germans

Page 11: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Lack of capital and resources

Lack of capital and resources

Explosion in clinical knowledge

Explosion in clinical knowledge

Lack of political will, leadership

Lack of political will, leadership

Lack of consumer

involvement

Lack of consumer

involvement

Lack of appropriate technology

Lack of appropriate technology

Lack of trust among Key

Players

Lack of trust among Key

Players

Lack of incentives for

right behaviors

Lack of incentives for

right behaviors

Runaway Costs

Runaway Costs

Lack of Access

Lack of Access

InconsistentQuality

InconsistentQuality

The system is in meltdown..The system is in meltdown..The system is in meltdown..The system is in meltdown..

Page 12: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

““Quality” is our number one concern!!Quality” is our number one concern!!““Quality” is our number one concern!!Quality” is our number one concern!!

Evidence Based Care

Patient Centered Approach

System Orientation

Evidence Based Care

Patient Centered Approach

System Orientation

Page 13: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

To most, quality means safe, accessible To most, quality means safe, accessible carecareTo most, quality means safe, accessible To most, quality means safe, accessible carecare

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes

•Adherence to evidence-based pathways in the diagnosis and intervention planning with patients

•Safe, effective, timely, patient-centered care•Collaborative care management

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes

•Adherence to evidence-based pathways in the diagnosis and intervention planning with patients

•Safe, effective, timely, patient-centered care•Collaborative care management

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes

•Access to needed services in appropriate settings•Paperwork/administrative procedures to access services

and document transactions

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes

•Access to needed services in appropriate settings•Paperwork/administrative procedures to access services

and document transactions

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Satisfaction with care management processes•Amenities to reduce anxiety, increase comfort

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Satisfaction with care management processes•Amenities to reduce anxiety, increase comfort

Clinical

Excellence!

Clinical

Excellence!

SupportiveSupportive

PrimaryPrimary

Page 14: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Patient (consumer)preferences, beliefs

and values

Patient (consumer)preferences, beliefs

and values

Evidence-based medicine is not understoodEvidence-based medicine is not understoodEvidence-based medicine is not understoodEvidence-based medicine is not understood

“Evidence-based medicine is the judicious application of relevant scientific studies to patient preferences and values.”

“Evidence-based medicine is the judicious application of relevant scientific studies to patient preferences and values.”

Judiciousintegration

of relevant science

Judiciousintegration

of relevant science

Clinician trainingClinician trainingand experienceand experience

Clinician trainingClinician trainingand experienceand experience

Page 15: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Guidelines: Guidelines: The Framework for Evidence-based MedicineThe Framework for Evidence-based MedicineGuidelines: Guidelines: The Framework for Evidence-based MedicineThe Framework for Evidence-based Medicine

“Systematically developed statements to assist practitioner and patient decisions about appropriate health care for specific clinical circumstances”

– IOM ’92

Derived from… 20,000 RCTs annually 4,000 guidelines since 1989 2,500 periodicals in NLS

Every guideline is not evidence-based, and someguidelines are about who, what should be done

Derived from… 20,000 RCTs annually 4,000 guidelines since 1989 2,500 periodicals in NLS

Every guideline is not evidence-based, and someguidelines are about who, what should be done

Page 16: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

PICO: the framework for guidelines…PICO: the framework for guidelines…

P… what’s the population?I…what intervention am I testing?C… compared to what other intervention?O… what outcome is being tested?

P… what’s the population?I…what intervention am I testing?C… compared to what other intervention?O… what outcome is being tested?

Page 17: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Then evidence-linked algorithms form the Then evidence-linked algorithms form the framework for guidelinesframework for guidelinesThen evidence-linked algorithms form the Then evidence-linked algorithms form the framework for guidelinesframework for guidelines

Page 18: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Studies are graded using various schemes..Studies are graded using various schemes..

Page 19: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

In practice, tools are used to stay abreast..In practice, tools are used to stay abreast..

Systematic ReviewsCochrane LibrarySystematic ReviewsCochrane Library

Clinical EvidencePOEMsClinical EvidencePOEMs

Valu

e

Medline, PubMedMedline, PubMed

EBM Practice GuidelineEBM Practice Guideline

CATs, Best Evidence,ACP Journal ClubCATs, Best Evidence,ACP Journal Club

Reviews: Up-to-Date, 5-Min Clinical Consult

Reviews: Up-to-Date, 5-Min Clinical Consult

Page 20: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Better care is the result; it is also a more Better care is the result; it is also a more efficient way to operate a clinical enterpriseefficient way to operate a clinical enterpriseBetter care is the result; it is also a more Better care is the result; it is also a more efficient way to operate a clinical enterpriseefficient way to operate a clinical enterprise

Outcomes (p<0.0001)

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

Death RespiratoryFailure

ProlongedLength of Stay

Elevated TotalCharges

Blood Cultures AppropriateAntibiotics

Pathway non Pathway Ann. Epidemiology 2004:14:669-675

Page 21: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

And then we draw conclusions: what do we learn And then we draw conclusions: what do we learn by examining the evidence?by examining the evidence?And then we draw conclusions: what do we learn And then we draw conclusions: what do we learn by examining the evidence?by examining the evidence?

Observational Study (n=1): why women live longer than men!”Observational Study (n=1): why women live longer than men!”

Page 22: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

The data correlates adherence to evidence-based practice with…The data correlates adherence to evidence-based practice with…

Improved outcomes Reduced variation Improved patient adherence Improved efficiency Reduced errors

So why isn’t evidence-based practice more consistently provided?

Improved outcomes Reduced variation Improved patient adherence Improved efficiency Reduced errors

So why isn’t evidence-based practice more consistently provided?

Page 23: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Knowledge ExplosionChallenge: Knowledge Explosion

20,000 biomedical journals >150,000 medical articles

published each month >300,000 randomized controlled

trials

““We are drowning in We are drowning in information but starved information but starved for knowledge.”—Naisbitt, ‘82for knowledge.”—Naisbitt, ‘82

Page 24: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Lack of EvidenceChallenge: Lack of Evidence

How many questions have any evidence? (BMJ 2000)

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Uncertain 375Uncertain 375

Partial Answer 299Partial Answer 299

Answered 358Answered 358Beneficial ……………………..

248Ineffective or harmful ………..

43Trade-off ………………………

67

Likely to be beneficial ………. 235

Unlikely to be beneficial ……. 64

Unknown effectiveness …….. 375 Number of Interventions

Page 25: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Source CredibilityChallenge: Source Credibility

Shaneyfelt et al: (JAMA, 1999)Of 279 guidelines developed by medical societies, most do not adhere to IOM standards for methodological review (evidence-grading)

Grilli et al: (Lancet, 2000)431 guidelines reviewed; 82% lack evidence-grading review assessment

Shaneyfelt et al: (JAMA, 1999)Of 279 guidelines developed by medical societies, most do not adhere to IOM standards for methodological review (evidence-grading)

Grilli et al: (Lancet, 2000)431 guidelines reviewed; 82% lack evidence-grading review assessment

Page 26: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: ReliabilityChallenge: Reliability

Page 27: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

YOU ARE

HERE

Challenge : TimelinessChallenge : TimelinessChallenge : TimelinessChallenge : TimelinessThe solid line represents the Kaplan-

Meier curve for the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)

guidelines.

Dashed lines represent the 95% confidence

interval (JAMA. 2001;286:1461-1467)

◙–

Page 28: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Commercial InterestsChallenge: Commercial InterestsChallenge: Commercial InterestsChallenge: Commercial Interests

1. Digital imaging2. Drug-coated stents3. Oral cancer treatments4. Minimally invasive surgery5. Sepsis treatment6. Implantable devices7. Microscopic cameras8. Diabetes devices9. At-home health test kits10. Embryonic stem cell research

$$$$

Page 29: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Media AttentionChallenge: Media Attention

Page 30: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Challenge: Physician TrainingChallenge: Physician Training

Provide patient centered care

Work in interdisciplinary teams

Employ evidence-based practice

Apply quality improvement

Utilize informatics

Health Professions Education: A Bridge to Quality

Institute of Medicine 2003

Page 31: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

73% of patients depend on physicians to make decisions for them!73% of patients depend on physicians to make decisions for them!

“INFORMED” PARENTAL

“INFORMED” PARENTAL

INTERMEDIATE SHARED DECISION MAKING

INTERMEDIATE SHARED DECISION MAKING

PATIENT AS DECISION-MAKER

PATIENT AS DECISION-MAKER

4.8%Stronglydisagree

4.8%Stronglydisagree

*Adapted from Guyatt et al. Incorporating Patient Values in: Guyatt et al. Users’ Guide to the Medical Literature:

Essentials of Evidence –based Clinical Practice. JAMA 2001

**Arora NK and McHorney CA. Med Care. 2000; 38:335

17.1% Strongly

Agree

17.1% Strongly

Agree

45%Agree45%

Agree11%11% 22.5%

Disagree22.5%

Disagree

Challenge: Consumer ExpectationsChallenge: Consumer Expectations

Page 32: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Lots of explanations and excuses…Lots of explanations and excuses…Lots of explanations and excuses…Lots of explanations and excuses…

“they don’t pay for it..” “the tools aren’t available” “my patients don’t care” “it’s a fad” “the only evidence I need is what I know”

So what does this have to do with So what does this have to do with safety?safety?

Page 33: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

EBM, quality and safety are closely EBM, quality and safety are closely related…related…EBM, quality and safety are closely EBM, quality and safety are closely related…related…

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes

•Adherence to evidence-based pathways in the diagnosis and intervention planning with patients

•Safe, effective, timely, patient-centered care•Collaborative care management

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes

•Adherence to evidence-based pathways in the diagnosis and intervention planning with patients

•Safe, effective, timely, patient-centered care•Collaborative care management

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes

•Access to needed services in appropriate settings•Paperwork/administrative procedures to access

services and document transactions

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes

•Access to needed services in appropriate settings•Paperwork/administrative procedures to access

services and document transactions

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Satisfaction with care management processes•Amenities to reduce anxiety, increase comfort

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Satisfaction with care management processes•Amenities to reduce anxiety, increase comfort

Clinical

Excellence!

Clinical

Excellence!

SupportiveSupportive

PrimaryPrimary

Page 34: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

QualityQualityImprovementImprovement

““Do things well”Do things well”

““It’s cookbook It’s cookbook Medicine”Medicine”

““we don’t have we don’t have the tools”the tools”

““we never didwe never didit that way before”it that way before”

SafetySafety““Do no harm”Do no harm”

Clinical ExcellenceClinical Excellence““Do right things well”Do right things well”

The application of EBM to safety is foundationalThe application of EBM to safety is foundational

Page 35: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Safe, evidence-based careSafe, evidence-based careSafe, evidence-based careSafe, evidence-based care

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes•EffectiveEffective

•Patient CenteredPatient Centered

Clinical ProcessesClinical Processes•EffectiveEffective

•Patient CenteredPatient Centered

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes•Equitable•Accessible

Structural ProcessesStructural Processes•Equitable•Accessible

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Timeliness, Efficient•Equitable

Service Delivery ProcessesService Delivery Processes

•Timeliness, Efficient•Equitable

Clinical

Excellence!

Clinical

Excellence!

SupportiveSupportive

PrimaryPrimary

Page 36: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Admissions ManagementAdmissions ManagementEvaluating appropriately, directing Evaluating appropriately, directing

resources effectivelyresources effectively

Admissions ManagementAdmissions ManagementEvaluating appropriately, directing Evaluating appropriately, directing

resources effectivelyresources effectively

Care Team ManagementCare Team ManagementRecruiting, equipping and Recruiting, equipping and

holding accountable care teamsholding accountable care teams

Care Team ManagementCare Team ManagementRecruiting, equipping and Recruiting, equipping and

holding accountable care teamsholding accountable care teams

Pathway ManagementPathway ManagementBuilding and updating pathways, Building and updating pathways,

order sets and guidelines for care teamsorder sets and guidelines for care teams

Pathway ManagementPathway ManagementBuilding and updating pathways, Building and updating pathways,

order sets and guidelines for care teamsorder sets and guidelines for care teams

Outcome ManagementOutcome Management Measuring what works best and whyMeasuring what works best and why

Outcome ManagementOutcome Management Measuring what works best and whyMeasuring what works best and why

Risk ManagementRisk ManagementAvoiding error, conducting Avoiding error, conducting

root cause analysisroot cause analysis

Risk ManagementRisk ManagementAvoiding error, conducting Avoiding error, conducting

root cause analysisroot cause analysis

Discharge ManagementDischarge ManagementTeaching, equipping patients for Teaching, equipping patients for

guided self-care, follow-upguided self-care, follow-up

Discharge ManagementDischarge ManagementTeaching, equipping patients for Teaching, equipping patients for

guided self-care, follow-upguided self-care, follow-up

For a provider organization, there are six key For a provider organization, there are six key operational applications where EBM is central…operational applications where EBM is central…For a provider organization, there are six key For a provider organization, there are six key operational applications where EBM is central…operational applications where EBM is central…

Physician leadership is essential!Physician leadership is essential!

Page 37: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

Point of care decision-support tools are essentialPoint of care decision-support tools are essentialPoint of care decision-support tools are essentialPoint of care decision-support tools are essential

Page 38: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

0 50 100 150 200 250 300

Clinical Information

ComputerizedPhysician Order Entry

Decision Support

Electronic MedicalRecord

Medical Management

HCIT: Where do we start selecting companies?HCIT: Where do we start selecting companies?Numbers of companies currently supporting these applicationsNumbers of companies currently supporting these applicationsHCIT: Where do we start selecting companies?HCIT: Where do we start selecting companies?Numbers of companies currently supporting these applicationsNumbers of companies currently supporting these applications

Source: 2005 Healthcare Informatics, Resource GuideSource: 2005 Healthcare Informatics, Resource Guide

129129

259259

197197

165165

246246

Page 39: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

The cat is out of the bag!!The cat is out of the bag!!The cat is out of the bag!!The cat is out of the bag!!

Page 40: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

SummarySummary

EBM is a journey to clinical excellence: it’s about safety, quality improvement and evidence-based care

Applying EBM to error avoidance is fundamental: it leverages research about efficacy and effectiveness

To deliver safe evidence-based care, an organization must invest in processes and information technologies to support leaders in the journey

Our results will be public.

EBM is a journey to clinical excellence: it’s about safety, quality improvement and evidence-based care

Applying EBM to error avoidance is fundamental: it leverages research about efficacy and effectiveness

To deliver safe evidence-based care, an organization must invest in processes and information technologies to support leaders in the journey

Our results will be public.

Page 41: Evidence-based Medicine as a Patient Safety Tool Key Concepts, Emerging Applications The Quality Colloquium at Harvard University Boston, Massachusetts

ContactContactContactContact

Paul H. Keckley, Ph.D.Paul H. Keckley, Ph.D.Executive DirectorExecutive DirectorVanderbilt Center for Evidence-based MedicineVanderbilt Center for Evidence-based MedicineAssociate ProfessorAssociate ProfessorVanderbilt University School of MedicineVanderbilt University School of MedicineD-3300 Medical Center NorthD-3300 Medical Center NorthNashville, TN 37232-2104Nashville, TN [email protected]@vanderbilt.edu615-343-3922615-343-3922www.ebm.vanderbilt.eduwww.ebm.vanderbilt.edu