Upload
saciwaters
View
946
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Ethnographic and participatory
methods in periurban researchmethods in periurban research
Vishal Narain
Kathmandu, August 2010
Qualitative research vs
quantitative research• Difference in assumptions about social science
– Positivism vs interpretivism
• Nature of research questions– How and why questions, process-based rather than
how much questionshow much questions
• Nature of data analysed– Events, anecdotes, relationships, processes, and
evidence as against numbers
• Approach to data collection– More open-ended, unstructured
Characteristics of qualitative
research/ reports• Rich contextual detail
• Data in the form of words, sentences, expressions, photos, videotapes
• Researcher’s personality plays a role • Researcher’s personality plays a role
• Require improvisation
• Need good writing skills
The qualitative research
orientation• A non-positivist perspective
– Interpretive and critical approaches to social
science
• Circular path • Circular path
– Not necessarily linear, or one step after the
other
Qualitative Research: some
basic principles and concepts • Ethnography
– Description of people
• Grounded theory– Immerse in data to theorize; say something about the phenomena that
we see
– Data and theory interact
– Inductive vs deductive method– Inductive vs deductive method
• Case study research – Look for patterns
– Develop and refine concepts
– Immersion in the data
– Domain of generalization• Analytic generalization as against statistical generalization in quantitative
research
• E.g, each of our villages can be a case study that we use to illustrate or generalize on certain relationships
Qualitative Techniques.. Ctd.
• Focus Groups
• PRAs, RRAs
• Semi-structured interviews
• Action Research• Action Research
• Process Documentation Research
Doing qualitative research
• Studying process, sequence and time
• Levels of interpretation – Different levels of coding
• Quotations• Quotations
• Thick descriptions– Detailed account of a specific activity
• Photographs
• Build on anecdotes and experiences: they are part of evidence
Ethnographic methods
• What is ethnography ?
• When do researchers do it ?
• Why is it carried out ?
• What does it entail ?• What does it entail ?
What is ethnography ?
• Ethnos + Graphein
• Anthropology (anthropos + logos)
• Entails fieldwork – Long period of observation– Long period of observation
– Direct interaction
– An iterative, semi-structured approach
– “Playing by the ear”
– Keeping eyes and ears open
When is it suited ?
• Answer “how” questions ?
• Study of
– Social movements
– Occupations– Occupations
– Social interactions and processes
– Deviant behavior
Principles of field work
• Methodological pragmatism
• Naturalism
• Socialization
• Researcher’s personality plays a role • Researcher’s personality plays a role
Steps in field work
• Start with a research question
• Defocus
• Select a site
• Dealing with gate-keepers• Dealing with gate-keepers
• The access ladder
• Disclosure
• Listen, see and observe
• Regular field notes – Building blocks of field work
– Analysis starts while in the field
Dealing with key informants
• Who is an informant ?
• The informant interview
– Context is important
– Semi-structured – Semi-structured
• What makes a good informant ?
– Familiarity with the site
– Currently engaged
– Some one who can give time
Sampling in field work
• Theoretical sampling
– Sample on the basis of theoretical relevance, or the
ability of the specific case to say something about the
issue being researched
• Snowball sampling• Snowball sampling
– Follow leads from one to another
• Sample
– People
– Locations
– Timing
Intricacies of field work
• Dealing with freeze-outs
• Ethical issues– Extent of disclosure
– Intrusion
– Confidentiality – Confidentiality
– Dealing with deviants
• Managing stress– Physical
– Mental
• When does field work end? When can you exit ?– When theory building ceases
– Just call it a day ?
Participatory Rural Appraisal
• A method of enabling communities to share
information about themselves using visual
techniques and discussions
• Evolved from• Evolved from
– Disenchantment with questionnaire surveys
• High costs
• Errors
• Delays
• Manipulation
Principles of PRA
• A paradigm shift in the social sciences
• Question of attitude
• Direct learning from the local people
• ‘Handing over the stick’• ‘Handing over the stick’
• Plurality of methods
• Optimal ignorance
• Information shared and owned by local people, as against being extracted by outsiders
Some PRA tools
• Village transects
• Village maps
• Venn Diagrams
• Seasonality Calendar• Seasonality Calendar
• Wealth-ranking
• Time line
• Trend analysis
• Focus groups
• Semi-structured interviews
• Do-it-yourself exercises
Modes of analysis
• Done by local people, in groups
• Visual
• Comparisons
• Interactive• Interactive
• Iterative
Applications of PRAs
• Natural Resource Management
• Village Development Plans
• Programmes for women and the poor
• Agriculture and food security• Agriculture and food security
• Used by NGOs, students and universities– MYRADA, Action Aid, AKRSP in India
promoted it extensively
Some benefits of PRAs
• Rapport building
• Create an atmosphere of shared learning
• Often more cost-effective and quicker than questionnaires questionnaires
• Present “aggregate picture”
• Fun, interest
Some practical points about
PRAs • How long ?
– Depends on time and resources
– Not done hurriedly
– Ten days- four weeks– Ten days- four weeks
• Who does it ?– Inter-disciplinary teams
– Groups of people
• Consistency checks– Triangulation
Practical points
• Sequencing
– No rigid sequence
– Start with maps, graphs and move to
sensitive subjectssensitive subjects
Dangers of PRA: how not to do
a PRA • Who participates in these exercises ?
• ‘Instant fashion’
• Often Hurriedly done to impress donors and get funding and get funding
• Pitfalls of ‘rural tourism’
• Formalism: emphasis on manuals and procedures
• Routinisation: loss of spontaneity