21
5/15/2013 1 ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ERTAC Webinar May 15 th , 2013 1 Presentation Overview 1. Process Overview and Timelines 2. Inputs 3. Algorithm Details 4. Results 5. Outstanding issues 2

ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

  • Upload
    lethien

  • View
    217

  • Download
    3

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

1

ERTAC EGU Growth ToolStakeholder Rollout

ERTAC Webinar 

May 15th, 2013

1

Presentation Overview

1. Process Overview and Timelines

2. Inputs

3. Algorithm Details

4. Results

5. Outstanding issues

2

Page 2: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

2

1. Process Overview and Timelines

a. What is the ERTAC Growth Committee? 

b. Product criteria

c. Committee structure

d. Progress & Timeline

3

Eastern Regional Technical Advisory Committee (ERTAC)

ERTAC convenes ad‐hoc groups to solve specific inventory problems

Collaboration:

– States ‐ NE, Mid‐Atlantic, Southern, and Lake Michigan

– Multi‐jurisdictional organizations

– Industry 

4

Page 3: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

3

ERTAC EGU Growth

5

ERTAC EGU convened 3 years ago

Goal: Build a low cost, stable/stiff, fast, and transparent model to project future EGU emissions

Utility representatives also joined and provided guidance on model design and inputs

• AEP – Dave Long

• AMEREN ‐ Ken Anderson

• RRI – John Shimshock

• NY Energy – Roger Caiz

Helped refine the logic, such as reserve capacity

ERTAC EGU Subcommittees & Co‐Chairs

Committee Co‐chairsLaura Mae Crowder, WV DEP Bob Lopez, WI DE Danny Wong, NJ DEP 

Subcommittees and LeadsImplementation/Doris McLeod VA, Mark Janssen, LADCO

Create logic for software

Growth/Bob Lopez, WI & Laura Mae Crowder, WVRegional specific growth rates for peak and off peak

Data Tracking/Wendy Jacobs, CTImprove default data to reflect state specific information

Renewables & Conservation Programs/Danny Wong, NJCharacterize programs not already included in growth factors

6

Page 4: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

4

State Involvement

• Regional lead identified to coordinate state review of model and inputs

• State Lead identified to QA the input files

• These representatives also review the output to provide guidance

• If Future Year (FY) emission goals are not met with known controls, states will indicate what strategy are applied to meet the goal

7

How does it work?

Starting point: 2007 CEM data by regionUnits ordered from maximum to minimum hours operated

States provide info:  new units, controls & other changes

Regional growth ratesBase – Department of Energy (EIA) Annual Energy Outlook (AEO)Peak – North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC)

Future hourly estimates based on base year activityTemporal profile matches meteorology 

Unit demand beyond capacity moved to other units using 2007 ordering

Growth beyond regional capacity results in “Demand Deficit Units”

Test hourly reserve capacity 

8

Page 5: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

5

Benefits of ERTAC EGU Model

Conservative predictionsNo big swings in generation

No unexpected unit shutdowns

Inputs are completely transparent

Software is not proprietary

Output files are hourly and reflect base year meteorology Hourly emissions reflect HEDD concerns

Quickly evaluates various scenariosRegional and fuel modularity 

Can test retirements, growth, and controls 

9

Progress So Far ....

Model Development: 

Methodology created, documentation crafted 

Preprocessor & projection running on Linux and Windows (GA, VA, MARAMA, IN, NJ, OTC) 

Developing post‐processing software

Estimating Growth in Generation: 

Growth rates and regions defined 

Created growth rate inputs using AEO/NERC 2013

10

Page 6: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

6

Progress So Far ....Input File Development: 

Unit file and future controls file reviewed by statesCap files developed based on CAIR caps Further state input ongoing

Results:Version 1.65 complete for Continental USUsed AEO/NERC 2013 growth factorsImproved output through post‐processorsDistributed to member states for review and comment twice

Sensitivities:Conducted many scenarios with varied input valuesRan alternative growth rate sensitivities(with high coal rates)

11

ERTAC TimelineMay , 2013

•Third Generation of  “CONUS” test runs Using AEO2013 Growth Rates

•Goal: Demonstrate a “Proof of Concept”

•Review output, revise and rerun

•Present results to Stakeholders for comment

June 28th , 2013  

•Identify Sensitivity runs for next round of modeling

•Close comment window for next round of comments on 2011 base year

July‐October, 2013

•Run 8‐12 sensitivity runs and present to full ERTAC Committee

•Goal: Improve inputs and model output processors

•Enhance ERTAC to SMOKE post‐processors and data. 

Anticipated Future tasks

•Support states with Transport modeling

•Improve Documentation

•Enhance Software Functionality(needs additional funding) 

12

Page 7: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

7

Data Importation

a. Inputs

b. Preprocessing

c. Growth Rates

13

ERTAC Inputs

• Emission Unit Start Point: Base Year CAMD activity data – Gross load hourly data, unit fuel, unit type, location – Units categorized by:

• Fuel Type [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined Cycle, Coal]• Region [AEO regions (e.g. MACE, LILC, WUMS)] 

• States review provides known new units, controls, retirements, fuel switches, etc 

• Energy Information Agency (EIA) AEO growth factors 

• NERC peak growth factors

14

Page 8: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

8

Preprocessing Functions

• Data Edit Checks

– Unit availability file

– Controls file

– Growth rates file

– Base Year hourly CAMD data

• Removes non‐EGUs

• Determines hourly temporal hierarchy 

– Based on regional hourly Gross Load (GL)

– Important for load distribution and growth rates

15

Preprocessing Functions

• New units are assigned future hourly usage profile

• Assesses partial year reporting units

• Creates unit hierarchies for generation distribution

• Calculates “hourly load values” by region and fuel/unit type considering:– Retired generation

– New unit generation

– Existing generation

• Calculates “non peak” growth rates

16

Page 9: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

9

Growth Rates (GR)

• Hour specific growth rates• Program adjusts unit temporal profile based on regional 

and fuel/unit type hourly growth profiles– Resulting FY profile might different from BY

• Provides ability to understand effects of peak episodic Growth Rate and control programs on air quality

• AEO Growth combined with NERC peak growth – Peak Growth – First 200 hour in hierarchy– Transition growth – 200‐2000 hours in hierarchy– Non‐peak growth – last remaining hours in hierarchy out to 

8760 hours.

• Combined factor is further adjusted to account for:– Retirements & new units

17

The evolution of growth rates from annual to hourly

Transition(hours 201‐2000 in 

hierarchy)

AEO2010 (by region/fuel)

Nonpeak Growth(hours 2001‐8760 

in hierarchy)

NERC (by region/fuel)

Peak Growth(hours 1‐200 in 

hierarchy)

Final Hourly Growth

Adjusted for retirements/new units each hour

18

Page 10: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

10

Growth Rates (GR)• Peak GR = 1.07

• Annual GR = 0.95

• Transition hours of 200 & 2,000

• Non Peak  GR = 0.9328 (calculated)

19

Adjusted Future Year Growth Rates (AFYGR), Hour Specific

• For every region and fuel/unit type, each hour has a variable value for:– Total FY Load (Hour Specific GR * BY Load=FY Gen)

– Total Retired Generation (RetGen)

– Total New Unit Generation (NU Gen)

• Growth Rate for each hour adjusted before application to existing unit hourly Base Yr loads!

AFYGR = (Future Yr Generation – New Unit Generation)

(Base Yr Generation – Retired Generation)

20

Page 11: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

11

3. Algorithm Details

a. Regional modularity

b. Adjusted Future Year Growth Rates

c. Excess generation pool

d. New Unit Utilization

e. Demand Deficit units 

f. Spinning Reserve 

21

Regional/Fuel Modularity

• Each ERTAC region analyzed independently

• Reserve analyzed on a regional basis

• Algorithm determines if capacity has been met for each hour for the region and fuel/unit type

22

Use new units

For all ERTAC Regions

For all Fuel/Type Bins

Analyze capacity versus demand

Assign generation

Spinning Reserve

Page 12: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

12

Regional and Fuel Modularity

Units assigned to a region/fuel

Growth rates by region/fuel

Growth rates account for:Regional generation transfer

Changes in fuel mix

Renewables and some energy efficiency 

Allows modular operation.

With unrealistic growth rates:Results will also be unrealistic

Should we manually balance fuels or regions?

23

Updated Regional Map

DRAFT ‐ DO NOT DISTRIBUTE 24

Page 13: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

13

Excess Generation Pool

• If unit growth exceeds capacity– Unit is limited to capacity– Demand beyond capacity added to the excess generation pool for that hour/region/ fuel/unit type bin

• The pool is distributed to other units in unit allocation hierarchy order– Units receive power up to optimal threshold or max capacity in two distribution loops

– Power distribution ceases when pool is depleted or all units are at capacity (Demand Deficit unit must be created to meet demand and run restarts)

25

New Unit Utilization• New units mainly receive generation from overall future year power demand. Existing units’ growth rates are adjusted accordingly.– Annual power production limited by default or state input

– Temporal profile based on similar unit (mimic) —program allows user to change the “mimic” unit

• New units (demand deficit and state supplied) are high in utilization order relative to other similar units because they are assumed to be:– Very efficient– Very clean

• Variables assigned to region and fuel/unit type characteristics are adjustable

26

Page 14: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

14

New Demand Deficit Units

• Added to meet demand

• Utilization determined on a fuel/unit type basis

(like new state supplied units)

• Receive unmet demand

• Size/location of Demand Deficit units adjustable

• Future temporal profile assigned by region and fuel/unit type

• If a Demand Deficit unit is added, the allocation hierarchy is recalculated and the loop begins at the first hour

27

First/next hour in the hierarchy

Does capacity meet demand?

Add Demand Deficit unit

Reallocate unit order

Begin at first hour in the hierarchy

Y

N

Spinning Reserve check

• Following assignment of generation

• Check if reserve capacity is available for each hour in each region

• If in any hour there is not reserve capacity equal 100% of the capacity of the largest unit operating of any fuel type, a flag is raised

28

Determine reserve capacity needs for that hour

Is unused capacity > reserve capacity ?

Y

NAlert: More capacity needed

First/next hour 

Page 15: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

15

Results

a. Output

b. Examples

c. Runtime

29

Output/Results

• Future year hourly activity– Heat input (mmbtu)– Gross load (MW)– SO2 emissions (lbs)– NOx emissions (lbs)

• File includes 8,760 hours for each:– Existing unit that is not retired– New state supplied unit– New Demand Deficit unit created by the code

• Summary files• Post‐projection processing:  graphs, more summaries, etc

30

Page 16: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

16

Output from ERTAC EGU V1.65

• Unit level

• Overall output

31

Unit Level Example:  Coal Fired Existing Unit, 800 MWAnnual GR=1.018, Peak GR=1.056, Nonpeak GR=1.012

DRAFT ‐ DO NOT DISTRIBUTE 32

9000

8000

7000

6000

5000

4000

3000

2000

1000

0

Base Future

Mmbtu/hr

Calendar Hours

Variations in growth rate

Page 17: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

17

Unit Level Example:  Coal Fired Existing Unit, 800 MW – SO2 ControlAnnual GR=1.018, Peak GR=1.056, Nonpeak GR=1.012

33

Base Future

Base Year lbs/hr

Calendar Hours

FY lbs/hr

Unit Level Example:  Combined Cycle New Unit, 300 MWAnnual GR= 0.904, Peak GR=1.2, Nonpeak GR=0.901

DRAFT ‐ DO NOT DISTRIBUTE 34

New units are supplied with temporal variability with grounding in base year meteorology

Page 18: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

18

Unit Level Example:  Simple Cycle Existing Unit, 53 MWAnnual GR=1.39, Peak GR=1.549, Nonpeak GR=1.377

35

Post‐projection Processing Graphical Output – Page 1 Example

36

Page 19: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

19

Post‐projection Processing Graphical Output – Page 2 Example

37

38

0

20000000

40000000

60000000

80000000

100000000

120000000

140000000

160000000

180000000

200000000

Ash

tabu

laA

von

Lake

Pow

er P

lant

Bay

Sh

ore

Ca

rdin

al

Co

nesv

ille

Eas

tlake

Gen

J M

Gav

inH

am

ilton

Mu

nici

pal P

ower

Pla

ntJ

M S

tuar

tK

illen

Sta

tion

Kyg

er C

reek

Lake

Sh

ore

Mia

mi F

ort

Gen

era

ting

Sta

tion

Mu

skin

gum

Riv

erN

iles

O H

Hut

chin

gsP

icw

ayR

E B

urge

rR

ich

ard

Gor

such

W H

Sam

mis

W H

Zim

me

r G

ene

ratin

g S

tatio

nW

alte

r C

Bec

kjor

d G

ene

ratin

g S

tatio

nF

reem

ont

En

ergy

Cen

ter

Ha

ngin

g R

ock

Ene

rgy

Fac

ility

Was

hing

ton

Ene

rgy

Fa

cilit

yW

ate

rfo

rd P

lan

tA

von

Lake

Pow

er P

lant

Eas

tlake

Edg

ew

ate

r (2

857

)M

ad

Riv

erN

iles

Wal

ter

C B

eckj

ord

Ge

nera

ting

Sta

tion

Wes

t Lo

rain

AM

P-O

hio

Ga

s T

urb

ines

Bo

wlin

g G

reen

AM

P-O

hio

Ga

s T

urb

ines

Gal

ion

AM

P-O

hio

Ga

s T

urb

ines

Nap

oleo

nD

arb

y E

lect

ric G

ene

ratin

g S

tatio

nD

icks

Cre

ek S

tatio

nF

rank

M T

ait S

tatio

nG

reen

ville

Ele

ctric

Ge

n S

tatio

nM

adi

son

Gen

erat

ing

Sta

tion

O H

Hut

chin

gsO

me

ga J

V2

Bow

ling

Gre

enO

me

ga J

V2

Ha

milt

on

Ric

hla

nd P

eaki

ng S

tatio

nR

obe

rt P

Mo

neR

olli

ng H

ills

Ge

nera

ting

LLC

Tai

t Ele

ctri

c G

ene

ratin

g S

tatio

nT

roy

En

ergy

LL

CW

est L

ora

inW

ood

sdal

e

coal combined cycle gas oil simple cycle gas

OH

RFCW

Sum of Base year heatinput (mmbtu)

Sum of Future year heatinput (mmbtu)

Page 20: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

20

In summary

• The model has been built

• Output has been generated

• Continuing effort to evaluate output and update inputs– Demand Deficit units

– Unit hierarchies

– Exporting to Chemical Transport Models

• Scenarios Will be built to evaluate policies and alternate growth scenarios. 

39

40

1200

1500

1800

2100

2400

2700

3000

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030

Million M

egawatt‐Hours

EIA's AEO Projection of Coal‐based Electricity Generation

AEO2008

AEO2009

AEO2010

AEO2011

AEO2012

AEO2013

Page 21: ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout - MARAMA · ERTAC EGU Growth Tool Stakeholder Rollout ... [Boiler Gas, Oil, Simple Cycle, Combined ... Gas Turbines Bowling Green AMP-Ohio

5/15/2013

21

41

500

600

700

800

900

1000

1100

1200

1300

2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 2030

Million M

egawatt‐Hours

EIA's AEO Projection of Gas‐based Electricity Generation

AEO2008

AEO2009

AEO2010

AEO2011

AEO2012

AEO2013