ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation

8/9/2019 ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation

1/13

Eastern Neighborhood TRIPS

Community Task Force meetingEVALUATION FRAMEWORK ROADMAP & TOOLKIT

Eastern Neighborhood TRIPS

Community Task Force meetingEVALUATION FRAMEWORK ROADMAP & TOOLKIT

08 | 23 | 2010 | SAN FRANCISCO, CALIFORNIA


2/13

2

EN Area Plans

/Other City

Projects &

Plans

ENTRIPS

Existing

Conditions

Analysis

Modeling

Scenarios

Existing

System

Deficiencies

Universeof

Potential

Projects

Model

Traffic (No

Project)

Circulation

Alternatives

Model

Traffic

(Project)

Develop/

Refine

Corridor

Project

Concepts

EVALUATION

FRAMEWORK

TRACK1 NetworkCirculationProjects

MAJOR

NETWORK

PROJECT

PACKAGES

Future

Conditions

Modal

Analysis

Future

System

Deficiencies

/ Universe of

PotentialProjects

Included in

another

plan?

TRACK2 NeighborhoodScaleProjects

NEIGHBORHOOD

SCALE

PROJECT

PACKAGES

TRACK3 AreawidePolicy

Goods Movement Policy

Shuttle Policy

Parking Policy

TDM Policy

EN TRIPS

Potential

Projects

List

Conceptual

Design

Environmental

Review

Prioritized List

of Future

Investments

(Capital and

Programming)

Fast Track

Improvements/

Pilots

BSP

Street

Typology

Street

Design

Guidance

City Policy,

FuturePlanning

Studies

DRAFT Project Development Work Flow


3/13

3

Preliminary Evaluation Framework Mix of qualitative & quantitative criteria

Key Goals-identifies the issue

Evaluation Criteria-identifies the objective:

Three Integrated Sets of Priority Settings:

1. Systemwide Network (operational, modalcapacity/priority, right of way reconfiguration,directional changes)

2. Neighborhood/specific (cross-walks, parking,

loading, specific traffic calming)3. Policies to aid street design/land-use

(shuttles, parking, loading & travel demand

management)


4/13

4

Model

Traffic (No

Project)

Circulation

Alternatives

Model

Traffic

(Project)

Develop/Refine

Corridor

Project

Concepts

EVALUATION

FRAMEWORK


MAJOR

NETWORK

PROJECT

BUNDLES

Future

Conditions

Modal

Analysis

Future

System

Deficiencies

/ Universe of

PotentialProjects

Included in

another

plan?


NEIGHBORHOOD

SCALE

PROJECT

PACKAGES



Shuttle Policy

Parking Policy

TDM Policy

EN TRIPS

Potential

Projects

List

Conceptual

Design

Environmental

Review

Prioritized List

of Future

Investments

(Capital and

Programming)

Fast Track

Improvements/

Pilots

BSP

Street

Typology

Street

Design

Guidance

City Policy,

FuturePlanning

Studies


EN Area Plans

/Other City

Projects &

Plans

ENTRIPS

Existing

Conditions

Analysis

Modeling

Scenarios

Existing

System

Deficiencies

Universeof

Potential

Projects


5/13

5

Model

Traffic (No

Project)

Circulation

Alternatives

Model

Traffic

(Project)

Develop/Refine

Corridor

Project

Concepts

EVALUATION

FRAMEWORK


SYSTEMWIDE

NETWORK

PROJECT

BUNDLES

Future

Conditions

Modal

Analysis

Future

System

Deficiencies

/ Universe of

PotentialProjects

Included in

another

plan?


NEIGHBORHOOD

SCALE

PROJECT

PACKAGES



Shuttle Policy

Parking Policy

TDM Policy

EN TRIPS

Potential

Projects

List

Conceptual

Design

Environmental

Review

Prioritized List

of Future

Investments

(Capital and

Programming)

Fast Track

Improvements/

Pilots

BSP

Street

Typology

Street

Design

Guidance

City Policy,

FuturePlanning

Studies


EN Area Plans

/Other City

Projects &

Plans

ENTRIPS

Existing

Conditions

Analysis

Modeling

Scenarios

Existing

System

Deficiencies

Universeof

PotentialProjects


6/13

6

Preliminary Evaluation Framework Evaluate the performance of the systems

Prioritize and rank projects/policies:

Identify & Prioritize EN-TRIPS systemsnetwork packages

Complete major environmental clearance

Identify EN-TRIPS neighborhood projects that canbe fast-tracked:

Low-cost/Street Innovative type pilots/trials

(develop toolkit) Policies that can be implemented in short-term

(e.g. loading/ parking)

Complete with minor environmental clearance


7/13

7

TypicalOneWaySoMaStreetscape

62.5FeetRoadwayWidth

82.5FeetPropertyLinetoPropertyLineWidth


8/13

8

TypicalSoMaStreetscapewithWiderSidewalks



Trade offs: travel lane or parking lane removal


9/13

9OnewaySoMaStreetscapewithDedicatedTransitLane

49FeetRoadwayWidth


Trade offs: travel lane or parking/bicycle lane removal

18.5 ft sidewalk (Bus Loading)


10/13

10OneWaySoMaStreetscapewithCycleTracks



Trade offs: travel lane and parking lane removal

3-10.5 ft buffer


11/13

11OneWaySoMaStreetscapewithTwoWayToolkit



Trade offs: travel lane and bicycle/parking lane removal/lefts turns

ParkingorbufferedBicycleLane 6-7.5 ft

ParkingorbufferedBicycleLane 6-7.5 ft


12/13

12

Next Steps

Future Conditions Analysis

Develop future conditions modeling inputs Perform future condition model runs using

base network assumptions

Identify initial key-corridor intersections forModeling analysis


13/13

13

EN-TRIPS 6 month Look AheadTask Milestone Date

CompleteEvaluationFramework&Sorting Sep2010

TaskforceStreet/NeighborhoodImprovementProjectsUpdate Dec2011

TaskforceFundingandImplementationStrategyUpdate Jan2011

ENTRIPSFundingandImplementationStrategyReport Feb2011

ENTRIPS

update

Citywide

Community

Meeting Mar

2011

BeginSystemwideEnvironmentalReview Jan2011

BeginNeighborhood

Pilots/Trials Jan

2011

ENTRIPSupdateCitywideCommunityMeeting Jan2011

TaskforceFuture

Conditions

Assumptions

Update Sep

2010

ENTRIPSupdateCitywideCommunityMeeting Sep2010

FutureYearLandUse&TransportationConditionsReport Sep2010

KeyENPriorityCorridorStreetscapesPublicWorkshops(Taskforce/Citywide) OctNov2010

PreliminaryStreet/Neighborhood RedesignOptions/ProjectSortingPrioritization Nov2010

KeyEasternneighborhoodsTransportationPublicRealmImprovementProjectsReport Jan2011

Documents

ENTRIPS Evaluation Framework Presentation