1
European Eating Disorders Review Eur. Eat. Disorders Rev. 9, 64–65 (2001) Book Reviews Eating Disorders: Anatomy of a Social Epidemic Richard A. Gordon Blackwell (1999), £50.00 (Hardback), ISBN 0-631-21495-X; £14.99 (Paperback), ISBN 0-631-21496-8. Gordon’s book represents a worthwhile attempt to synthesize the available knowledge about the nature and causes of eating disorders. He has successfully produced a very useful volume, which can be recommended as a primer which is readable, informative and well referenced. The book starts with a discussion of ‘Ethnic disorders’, comparing eating disorders with other culture-bound syndromes, and goes on to review the history, definitions and classification of eating disorders, and then their epidemiology. The second half of the book is devoted to the social determinants of female body dissatisfaction, which begins in childhood and, in a proportion of predisposed individuals, makes its appearance as clinical eating disorders. This section is interesting and persuasive, although the discussions sometimes lack depth and could well benefit from a social scientist’s perspective. It is to be hoped that, in future editions, Gordon will co-author at least part of the book with such an academic. It is, perhaps, surprising that he views treatment resources as ‘continuing to decline’, although this may reflect the battle between clinicians and US Health insurance companies over funding of inpatient care. In view of the contemporary rise of evidence-based medicine some information is presented somewhat uncritically, such as Minuchin’s ‘Psychosomatic family’ concept, which has hardly withstood close examination. In general, however, coverage of the field is broad and most approaches are represented. A good read. Paul Robinson Overcoming Low Self-Esteem Melanie Fennell Robinson (1999) £7.99 (paperback), pp. 275. The publication of a well written and clinically sound book on self-esteem is long overdue. Melanie Fennell’s Overcoming Low Self-Esteem is a significant step in the right direction. Low self-esteem and eating disorders are closely European Eating Disorders Review Copyright # 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and Eating Disorders Association. 9(1), 64–65 (2001)

Eating disorders: anatomy of a social epidemic. Richard A. Gordon. Blackwell (1999), £50.00 (hardback), ISBN 0-631-21495-X; £14.99 (paperback), ISBN 0-631-21496-8

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

European Eating Disorders ReviewEur. Eat. Disorders Rev. 9, 64±65 (2001)

Book Reviews

Eating Disorders: Anatomy of a Social EpidemicRichard A. GordonBlackwell (1999), £50.00 (Hardback), ISBN 0-631-21495-X; £14.99(Paperback), ISBN 0-631-21496-8.

Gordon's book represents a worthwhile attempt to synthesize the availableknowledge about the nature and causes of eating disorders. He has successfullyproduced a very useful volume, which can be recommended as a primer whichis readable, informative and well referenced. The book starts with a discussionof `Ethnic disorders', comparing eating disorders with other culture-boundsyndromes, and goes on to review the history, de®nitions and classi®cation ofeating disorders, and then their epidemiology. The second half of the book isdevoted to the social determinants of female body dissatisfaction, which beginsin childhood and, in a proportion of predisposed individuals, makes itsappearance as clinical eating disorders. This section is interesting andpersuasive, although the discussions sometimes lack depth and could wellbene®t from a social scientist's perspective. It is to be hoped that, in futureeditions, Gordon will co-author at least part of the book with such an academic.

It is, perhaps, surprising that he views treatment resources as `continuing todecline', although this may re¯ect the battle between clinicians and US Healthinsurance companies over funding of inpatient care. In view of thecontemporary rise of evidence-based medicine some information is presentedsomewhat uncritically, such as Minuchin's `Psychosomatic family' concept,which has hardly withstood close examination. In general, however, coverageof the ®eld is broad and most approaches are represented.

A good read.

Paul Robinson

Overcoming Low Self-EsteemMelanie FennellRobinson (1999) £7.99 (paperback), pp. 275.

The publication of a well written and clinically sound book on self-esteem islong overdue. Melanie Fennell's Overcoming Low Self-Esteem is a signi®cant stepin the right direction. Low self-esteem and eating disorders are closely

European Eating Disorders ReviewCopyright # 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd and Eating Disorders Association. 9(1), 64±65 (2001)