EAST VILLAGER NEWS, JAN. 22, 2015

| May 14, 2014 1

The Paper of Record for East and West Villages, Lower East Side, Soho, Noho, Little Italy and Chinatown

January 22, 2015 • FREE Volume 4 • Number 31

www.EastVillagerNews.com

Streit’s matzo in exodus from L.E.S..............page 4Police Blotter: Gunfire rocks Loisaida..........page 10Foes, fans share views on airbnb....................page 14

BY ZACH WILLIAMS

For about 1,000 #Black-LivesMatter activists on Martin Luther King

Jr. Day, inspiring each oth-er was just as important as spreading the word to pass-ersby about the movement’s demands for police reform and social justice.

Regaining momentum lost in the last month was on the minds of many who marched from Union Square to Foley Square on Mon., Jan. 19, in an effort to “reclaim” Martin Lu-

ther King Jr.’s legacy. Tensions with police were

minimal as they rallied down Broadway chanting, sing-ing and demanding a social awakening to ongoing dis-crimination against people of color.

Protests were held through-out the country on Jan. 19, in-cluding a march from Harlem to the United Nations head-quarters earlier that day.

“We’re not terrorists. We’re not anti-cop. We’re anti-injus-tice and anti-brutality,” said Esther Baldwin, an activist

who began organizing the march about six weeks ago.

Participants conceded that they indeed lost some ground in recent weeks after tens of thousands of New Yorkers took part in protests in early to mid-December. The fatal shootings of two New York Police Department officers in Brooklyn last month led to calls for a moratorium on demonstrations demanding police reforms. Supporters of the N.Y.P.D. meanwhile have

Hands up, don’t shoot! Protesters for police reform gathered last Friday at the African Burial Ground on Duane St.

PROTESTS, continued on p. 6

PH

OTO

BY M

ILO H

ESS

The Long March: Protestersvow they’re not going to stop

Li’s leadership at C.B. 3wasn’t biased, B.P. finds;Redacted report releasedBY LINCOLN ANDERSON

Gigi Li, the chairper-son of Communi-ty Board 3, did not

demonstrate a pattern of fail-ing to appoint black or Latino members to leadership posi-tions on the board during her first year as chairperson.

Nevertheless, Li and the

board’s leadership “failed to sufficiently emphasize the value of diversity and inclu-sion.”

Those were the findings of an Equal Employment Op-portunity investigation by Manhattan Borough Presi-dent Gale Brewer’s office.

Through a Freedom of

C.B. 3, continued on p. 7

When police and protesters clashed on the Lower East SideBY CLAYTON PATTERSON

I t is hard to wrap one’s head around the death of a person at the hands

of the N.Y.P.D., especially for something as incidental as selling loose cigarettes.

In order to make the ar-rest of Eric Garner, the cops aggressively roll up on him. As they approach him, a cop

reaches for Garner’s wrist and starts the arrest. A com-mon response to this kind of action is to pull one’s arms away and ask what he or she is being arrested for, but by then the situation is out of control.

We now have resisting ar-rest and a full-on takedown, resulting in an arrest. It

CLASH, continued on p. 20

“20in15” is a beast of a show.......page 19

2 January 22, 2015 EastVillagerNews.com

JE LIS CHARLIE: On Tuesday, New Yorkers were able to purchase the latest edition of Charlie Hebdo, published on schedule by the grief-stricken colleagues of the magazine’s four lead cartoonists, Cabut, Charb, Wolinsky and Tignous, who were murdered by two militant extremists fi ring AK-47s into their weekly editorial meeting on Jan. 7 in Paris. Six other editors, writers and guests, as well as two security guards, were killed during the attack. Tuesday morning, 100 copies of Charlie Hebdo were available for sale, for $6 apiece, at Albertine, the bookshop at the cultural services section of the French Embassy, on the Upper East Side. A New York Police Department security detail, including a K-9 unit, was positioned in front of the embassy. There was a slew of photographers awaiting exiting customers, whose copies of the satir-ical journal were hidden from view in shopping bags. The latter can now not only say, “Je suis Charlie,” but also “Je lis Charlie,” as in, “I read Charlie.” The satirical mag sports a caricature of a teary-eyed Mo-hammed, Islam’s prophet, holding a “Je Suis Charlie” sign, beneath the words in French, “All Is Forgiven.” But not everyone sees it that way. As of late Tuesday evening, in global protests and violence in response to the silly cartoon image, the worst was said to have been in Niger, where 10 people had reportedly been killed and an additional 173 injured, plus 45 church-es set ablaze in the capital, Niamey, alone. In protests in Pakistan, a photographer was shot and wounded. Angry demonstrations were also reported in Gaza, Algeria and Jordan. French fl ags were torched in Sen-egal and Mauritania. There were even some peaceful protests.

HORSES GOTTA HAVE PARK: Animal rights advocates want to know if Councilmember Corey Johnson is with them or against them on Mayor Bill de Blasio’s proposed carriage-horse ban. Johnson previously told us he supported getting the hors-es off the city’s streets and putting them in Central Park. On Wednesday, a Johnson aide reiterated that position to us. Basically, the aide said, Johnson feels the horses should be stabled in Central Park, where they would be “cared for humanely.” The equines wouldn’t ever exit the park and go on the city’s streets, but would only work in the park. Johnson is a leading animal-rights advocate, his staffer add-ed, noting that his boss has introduced four pro-pet pieces of legislation, including one to regulate irre-sponsible “puppy mill” breeders and another that would require background checks on pet purchas-ers. Johnson’s rep said a decision on the legislation won’t happen overnight, but rather “there will be a long period of discussion.” Told of Johnson’s posi-tion, Allie Feldman, a leading anti-horse carriage activist, said, “We appreciate that the councilmem-ber recognizes the inhumanity and danger of forc-ing horses to pull fl imsy wooden carts in the mid-dle of chaotic Midtown traffi c.” That said, Feldman fears that Johnson’s proposal is untenable. “There’s 200 carriage horses,” she explained. “To make it work, you’d have to have 16-foot-by-16-foot stalls for 200 horses, plus a pasture, which would take away a piece of the park the size of the softball fi elds or the Great Lawn. It’s just not a workable solution.

What would you do — pave over the Jackie Onas-sis Reservoir? We told this to him, Councilmember Johnson is aware of this,” she added, saying she’s not sure why he continues to spout this line. “It’s not possible to put 200 carriage horses in the park. There are 68 carriages and each needs two to three horses working in two to three shifts per day. Even if you had just one shift, that’s 70 horses. You need at least one acre per horse. The whole park is 800 acres. So you’re talking about one-quarter of the park and turning it into basically a tourist trap.” Feldman is the director of NYCLASS (New York-ers for Clean, Livable and Safe Streets). As for why Johnson’s rep said there will be a lengthy discus-sion about the legislation, Feldman explained that whenever the city plans to shut down an industry, under the New York City Charter, a six-month en-vironmental impact study is required to investigate what the effects would be.

SOUND OFF!

Write a letter to the editor [email protected]

COPIES & MORE SINCE 1982!

331 East 9th Street, New York, NY 10003 Phone: 212- 473-7833 / Fax: 212-673-5248

www.sourceunltd.com

COPIES • COLOR PRINTS • FAX • SCANNINGSTICKERS • RUBBER STAMPS • BUSINESS CARDS

LAMINATING • BINDING • VIDEO & CASSETTE CONVERSIONSUNIQUE GREETING CARDS • OFFICE SUPPLIES

“It’s worth the trip down the street!”

ORRRE

SAVE TIME: SEND YOUR FILES TO: [email protected] & PICK UP @ STORE! In the heart of GreenwIch VIllaGe

— Recommended by Gourmet Magazine, Zagat, Crain’s NY, Playbill & The Villager —“Gold Medal Chef of the Year”. — Chefs de Cuisine Association

Northern italian Cuisine • Celebrating Over 30 Years

69 MacDougal St. (Bet. Bleeker & Houston St.) 212-673-0390 • 212-674-0320Open Mon. - Sat. 12-11pm • www.villamosconi.comcornerbistrony.com

50 YEARS of SERVINGTHE

B ESTVILLAGEBA R

***VOTED***

******

CORNERCORNER

BIGGEST & BEST

B U R G E RI N TOW N

Corner of Jane & West 4th St. (at 8th Ave.) 212-242-9502

BISTROBISTRO

PH

OTO

BY LIZA B

EAR

A new issue of Charlie Hebdo, purchased in New York City, with the receipt to prove it.

January 22, 2015 3EastVillagerNews.com

Quality health coverage. It’s Our Mission.

“I want a health plan that covers me...and my family.”

Catholic Schools WeekJanuary 25 - 31, 2015

Fidelis Care is proudto join with schools,teachers, students,

and families incelebration of

Catholic Schools Week.

(1-888-343-3547) • 1-888-FIDELIS | fideliscare.org

To renew your coverage each year, call 1-866-435-9521H3328_FC 14160 CMS Accepted

Fidelis Care offers quality, affordable New York State-sponsoredhealth insurance for children and adults of all ages and at allstages of life.

From NY State of Health: The Official Health Plan Marketplace, toChild Health Plus, Medicaid Managed Care, Medicare Advantage,Managed Long Term Care and more, we have a program thatmeets your needs.

And, with our growing provider network, you can see a FidelisCare doctor almost anywhere you go in New York State!

We have a health insurance program that's right for you – and theones you love.

Products not available in all counties.To learn more about applying for health insurance including Child HealthPlus and Medicaid through NY State of Health, the Official Health Plan Marketplace, visit www.nystateofhealth.ny.gov or call 1-855-355-5777.

Save the Dates for Open Enrollment!

Product:

• Metal-Level Products in NY State of Health

• Child Health Plus• Medicaid Managed Care

Enroll From:

November 15, 2014 - February 15, 2015

All Year Long!

BY HANA RASKIN

This past fall, East Village Bed & Coffee, a bed-and-breakfast on Avenue C between E. Sev-enth and Eighth Sts., was shut down after 16

years at the location. Owned by Anne Ednis, a neigh-borhood resident for almost three decades, the guest-house offered visitors a “home away from home,” and the opportunity to experience the neighborhood and city in a unique way.

Ednis’s understanding of and care for her guests was evident from the thoughtful FAQ page on the place’s Web site, where she shared that she offered earplugs and ambient white-noise machines upon request for guests bothered by New York’s nighttime din.

She also addressed other concepts and customs that might confuse foreign guests: such as the fact that our subway map is not to scale, the difference between avenues and streets, and tipping customs.

Ednis’s bed-and-breakfast was closed down due to a strict law that went into effect May 2011 in an attempt to crack down on short-term rentals, such as Airbnb, and illegal hotels. The law prohibits stays of less than 30 days in Class A buildings — multi-ple-dwelling buildings that are generally permanent residences.

Unfortunately, the law took legitimate bed-and-breakfasts like Ednis’s — that pay taxes — along with it as collateral.

Another operator, Vinessa Milando owns Ivy Ter-race Bed and Breakfast in Midtown East. She start-ed the business in 1998 because she felt that, while New York City can be an expensive and intimidating

place to visit for may people, she could provide an alternative by offering visitors “warm, friendly hos-pitality and a beautifully decorated place.”

In 2011, Milando founded Short Term Alternatives for You NYC (StayNYC) in response to the increas-ing crackdown against the city’s bed-and-breakfasts. StayNYC members — mostly minority- or wom-en-owned businesses — are all licensed New York City “small-facility operators.” They collect and pay the New York City hotel tax, occupancy tax, city and state sales tax, and operate in small buildings that are exclusively used as bed-and-breakfasts, with less than 10 rooms.

According to StayNYC, its members are seeking an exemption to the law to allow “a specific class of small-facilities operators in New York City to remain accepted, legal, taxpaying small businesses.”

However, while many legislators seem to agree

that these well-run, tax-compliant bed-and-breakfasts were not the legislation’s intended targets, the regulation has yet to be amend-ed and the situation has not im-proved.

The Villager profiled Milando and the StayNYC members’ strug-gle in August 2013. Since then, she said, “More mom-and-pop B&B’s have shuttered their doors,” due to fines and violations or simply out of fear of their imminent shutdown.

“Others have chosen to be far less visible, or changed how they operate in order to avoid fines and

violations,” she said. Rather than offer hope, Bill de Blasio’s becoming

mayor meant a significant administration change, with many supporters in the Bloomberg administra-tion with whom StayNYC had developed relation-ships moving on to other jobs.

“In many ways, we had to start over,” Milando said.

Though StayNYC has lost many of its members, Milando and the B&B operators are fighting on. They continue to meet with Department of Buildings offi-cials and local legislators to explain the law’s crush-ing impact on them.

StayNYC has an online petition — addressed to the state Senate and Assembly and Governor Cuomo — urging that New York City B&B’s be allowed to keep operating. The petition can be found at http://www.staynyc.org/getinvolved.htm .

Illegal hotel law inhospitable to B&B’s, their operators say

Vinessa Milando, who operates Ivy Terrace Bed and Breakfast, in a room with a kitchen, which allows guests to cook.

FILE PH

OTO

BY TEQ

UILA M

INSK

Y


Named best weekly newspaper in New York State in 2001, 2004 and 2005by New York Press Association

PUBLISHERJENNIFER GOODSTEIN

EDITOR IN CHIEFLINCOLN ANDERSON

ARTS EDITORSCOTT STIFFLER

CONTRIBUTORSIRA BLUTREICHTEQUILA MINSKYJEFFERSON SIEGELJERRY TALLMER

ART / PRODUCTION DIRECTORTROY MASTERS

SENIOR DESIGNERMICHAEL SHIREY

GRAPHIC DESIGNERSCHRIS ORTIZANDREW GOOS

EXECUTIVE VP OF ADVERTISINGAMANDA TARLEY

SENIOR VP OF ADVERTISING / MARKETINGFRANCESCO REGINI

ACCOUNT EXECUTIVESJACK AGLIATAALLISON GREAKERJENNIFER HOLLANDJULIO TUMBACO

CIRCULATION SALES MNGR.MARVIN ROCK

PUBLISHER EMERITUSJOHN W. SUTTER

The Villager (USPS 578930) ISSN 0042-6202 is published every week by NYC Community Media LLC, One Metrotech North, 10th floor Brooklyn, NY 11201 (212) 229-1890. Periodicals Postage paid at New York, N.Y. Annual subscription by mail in Manhattan and Brooklyn $29 ($35 elsewhere). Single copy price at office and newsstands is $1. The entire contents of newspaper, including advertising, are copyrighted and no part may be reproduced without the express permission of the publisher - © 2011 NYC Community Media LLC.

PUBLISHER’S LIABILITY FOR ERRORThe Publisher shall not be liable for slight changes or typographical errors that do not lessen the value of an advertisement. The publisher’s liability for others errors or omissions in connection with an advertisement is strictly limited to publication of the advertisement in any subsequent issue.

Published by NYC Community Media, LLC

One Metrotech North 10th floor Brooklyn, NY 11201Phone: (718) 260-2500 • Fax: (212) 229-2790On-line: www.thevillager.comE-mail: [email protected]© 2012 NYC Community Media, LLC

Member of the National Newspaper Association

Member of the New York Press Association

And that’s how the matzo crumbles;

BY ZACH WILLIAMS

The Streit’s matzo company will vacate its longtime Lower East Side factory and relocate later

this year.For nine decades the family-owned

company has manufactured matzo from four adjacent former tenement buildings at 148-154 Rivington St., growing over that time from a local to international brand. But just as com-pany founder Aron Streit moved the business there in 1925 from a smaller operation on Pitt St., the time has come to secure a more modern space for the manufacture and distribution of the unleavened, pockmarked bread eaten at Passover.

“We’re basically at the same cross-roads now,” said Aaron Gross, a great great-grandson of Streit who works at the company. “Manufacturing for na-tional distribution on the Lower East Side of Manhattan is not an easy thing to do. We’re good at it. I think we do it as well as anyone could.”

A critical factor in the decision to move is the factory’s aging equipment, Gross said. The two 72-foot-long ov-ens are more than 70 years old and repairing them is simply not economi-cal anymore, according to Gross. New ovens are typically 150 to 200 feet long, an obvious challenge in a factory that’s only 100 feet from front to back.

The machines that form flour and

water into sheets of dough before bak-ing, known as sheeters, also present spatial challenges, Gross said.

“Our sheeters are about 12 feet,” he explained. “You can’t get a new sheeter that’s under 30 feet long.”

A decision on where the compa-ny will next set up shop will be an-nounced this year around Passover, Gross said. He declined to give further details or divulge to which real estate developer the current site has been sold.

Streit’s matzo production, which now comprises about 40 percent of the U.S. market, will continue without in-terruption, he added.

Consolidating operations into one new location will allow for some ob-vious efficiencies to be added into the production process. The current facil-ity has no loading dock, leaving the shipments prone to delays on busy neighborhood streets. A move would also eliminate the need to bag matzo mix only for the trip to the company’s warehouse in New Jersey. In one facil-ity, a single person with a hand truck could accomplish that task, Gross said.

The current factory has six floors among the four buildings, necessitat-ing the employment of six rabbis in order to ensure products adhere to re-ligious strictures. Two or three rabbis could handle that task in a single-sto-ry building, he added.

“I want to make this move and go

from making matzo the most ineffi-cient way to making it the most effi-cient way,” he said.

Certain characteristics of a Streit’s matzo derive from the factory’s some-times-zany setup. The archaic ovens utilize convection rather than direct flames to bake matzo, said Gross, who credited this method with producing the brownish blistering on their prod-uct, as well as an even complexion on both sides. The squares of unleavened bread then travel in package-sized portions via a basket system, carry-ing them from floor to floor. As they do this, they cool off, giving them a freshness absent from matzo from other companies that use refrigerators, Gross said.

Staircases and corridors appear through walls and ceilings in the same places where Aron Streit wanted them way back when. Not a lot has changed since the last relocation in how they make matzo.

“When we started looking to design a new factory, the equipment man-ufacturers came through and were amazed that the old stuff still works and that the place was so well-de-signed, especially the basket system,” said Alan Adler, the company’s chief operating officer and great-grandson of Aron Streit.

Gross added that certain elements

The finished, boxed product rolls off the production line at Streit’s Rivington St. matzo factory.

PH

OTO

S BY ZAC

H W

ILLIAMS

STREIT’S, continued on p. 5


Are You Looking for Full-Time Work?BACK TO WORK 50+ at Borough of Manhattan Community College can help you learn new networking strategies, target your job search, get job leads, enroll in short-term training and find resources that can help you stay strong while you are looking for your next job.

CALL TOLL FREE (855) 850–2525 to get a free job search guide and register for a local BACK TO WORK 50+ Information Session.

To learn more, visit: www.aarp.org/backtowork50plusFunded in part by Walmart Foundation.

East Villager_4.29x5.69_BMCC.indd 1 9/2/14 1:30 PM

378 Greenwich St. • 212-732-5959 212-941-9163Mon - Wed 11 am - 10 pm • Thur - Sun 12 pm - 12 am

We Specialize in CateringLet us cater your next party — Your place or ours

Pizza PiesNeapolitan 17.50 Sicilian 12 slices 25.00Chicago 16.75Small Neapolitan 13.00Mini Pie 7.50LarGe SeLeCTioN of ToPPiNGS 3.75 each

Daily sPecialty Pies (call for price)

calzones 6.75 topping 1.75

selection of aPPetizers, souPs & siDes (see full menu)

salaDsHouse Salad 5.75/6.75Caesar Salad 12.00Grilled Chicken 10.75Spinach Salad 7.00/8.75Greek Salad 7.00/8.75Pasta Salad 7.00/8.75Caesar with Chicken 8.75/12.00

HomemaDe macaroniravioli 11.75Baked Ziti 11.75Lasagna 12.75

Hot PlatescHickeneggplant Parmigiana 14.75Chicken Parmigiana 13.75Chicken Marsala 14.75Chicken francaise 14.75Chicken Sorrentino 14.75VealVeal Milanese or Parmigiana 15.75Veal Marsala 15.75rolatiniChicken rolatini 15.00seafooDfried Calamari (appetizer 10.00) 15.75Shrimp Scampi 15.75Calamari & Linguini (red sauce) 15.75Grilled Salmon 15.75

Hot Hero sanDWicHesChicken Parmigiana 9.75Chicken Cutlet 9.75Sausage & Peppers 9.75Potato & egg 9.75eggplant Parmigiana 9.75Meatball Parmigiana 9.75Veal Cutlet Parmigiana 11.00Grilled Marinated Chicken 9.75Chicken, Mozzarella & Lemon 9.75italian Philly Cheese Steak 9.75

* Prices may vary

aSK for DaiLY

SPeCiaLS~ free Delivery

($7.00 Minimum) ~

Streit’s to make exodus from Lower East Sideof the current production process, such as paper packaging and the basket system, might continue in a new factory.

The move will also involve a human cost, with some longtime employees unable to continue working for the company once it leaves the Low-er East Side. An upcoming documentary fi lm, “Streit’s: Matzo and the American Dream,” will portray the company, its employees and the sur-rounding neighborhood.

One of the last bastions of manufacturing in the neighborhood, Streit’s got its start at a time when the Lower East Side was fi lled with Jewish im-migrants. Such a readily available customer base made Rivington St. a convenient site for business back then.

But international competition, particularly from Israel, now threatens Streit’s market share. Deep-pocketed investors now control Man-ischewitz and two other former domestic com-petitors, making Streit’s the last of four original family-owned matzo producers in the U.S.

Ten years ago, Adler told The Villager that the company retained hopes of remaining in the neighborhood for the long term.

Emotions will take over the day when the Riv-ington St. factory closes, but the greater tradition of maintaining a family business will remain in place as the company fi nally undergoes the inev-itable, said Gross.

“To hang on here just for the sake of hanging on doesn’t make sense,” he said.

After the matzo are baked, they are put into baskets that carry them through the factory.

STREIT’S, continued from p. 4


been more vocal since then in portray-ing the protests as detrimental to pub-lic safety and dismissive of the dangers police face in their jobs.

Actions continued after the police deaths but not at the frequency or volume as in the weeks following the Dec. 3 announcement of a grand jury’s non-indictment of Police Offi-cer Daniel Pantaleo, who placed the N.Y.P.D.-banned chokehold on Eric Garner that led to his death. The re-cent holiday season also disrupted the rhythm of the protests, according to Jonathan Laraque-Ho, a student at Bard High School Early College on the Lower East Side, who has been ac-tively involved in student organizing.

The MLK holiday was an ideal time to pick up the tempo and get people excited once more about the #Black-LivesMatter movement, he added.

“We’re trying to get back on the streets,” he said. “A lot of people have been pretty bored with what’s happening over the break.”

On a day when many people, in-cluding President Obama, volunteer in local communities in commemora-tion of MLK Jr., remembering the civil rights leader as a non-violent rabble rouser who challenged authority is important to continuing efforts to battle contemporary racism in Ameri-ca, activists said on Monday.

The newly released film “Selma” inspires young people to view their current activism from an historical perspective stretching back 50 years to King’s work, according to Ash Laraque-Ho, older sister to Jonathan.

Though King is best known for advocating for suffrage for Afri-can-Americans, social issues — such as poverty within an economic sys-tem tilted toward white people —became a more prominent theme in his work in the years before his 1968 assassination. Activists are quick to note that gaps in employment, in-come and education between people of color and white Americans persist to the present time.

Reforming a judicial system where people of color often receive dispro-portionately harsher punishments for drug offenses compared to whites is one way to bridge such divisions, according to Andrew Slack of Brook-lyn. More ethnic diversity within the N.Y.P.D. would help as well, accord-ing to a Lower East Side resident named Omar, who declined to give his last name.

About half of the department’s offi-cers are white.

“It’s not just about police brutali-ty — it’s the war on drugs,” he add-

ed about the issues at hand as he marched down Broadway toting a book entitled “The New Jim Crow.”

“Broken windows,” though — the police doctrine that enforcement against low-level crime prevents more serious offenses — remains a target of activists. Police supporters note that Garner had a history of petty offenses. His death would not have happened had he not resisted officers’ efforts to arrest him, they say.

Akai Gurley was fatally shot by Po-lice Officer Peter Liang while walking down a stairwell in Brooklyn public housing on Nov. 20. The shooting was an accident, according to police.

Relatives of both Gurley and Gar-ner spoke at Foley Square on Mon-day, noting that circumstances of the two incidents aside, police demon-strated a disregard for people of color as the men had lain dying.

A video of the incident that led to Garner’s death shows no effort by medical personnel or police to revive him. Meanwhile, the officer who shot Gurley was reportedly texting his union representative in the minutes following his fatal pull of the trigger.

Activists said they are in the movement for the long haul. Their demands include the firing of Pan-taleo, the end of “broken windows,” and greater transparency within the N.Y.P.D., as well as more community

involvement in setting department policies.

The example of Martin Luther King Jr. illustrates that ambitions to trans-form American society take years if not decades to realize. Nonetheless, Erica Garner of Staten Island told the crowd assembled at Foley Square

that a certain thought inspires her to continue seeking justice for her fa-ther, despite the obstacles ahead in reforming one of the most powerful and respected law enforcement agen-cies in the U.S.

“What comes to mind for me is that he never gave up,” she said of King.

PROTESTS, continued from p. 1

Marching to reform N.Y.P.D. and reshape society

Before Monday’s march on MLK Day, protesters for police reform gathered last Friday at the African Burial Ground on Duane St.

PH

OTO

S BY M

ILO H

ESS


Information Law (FOIL) request, The Villager obtained a copy of the E.E.O. investigation final report. Yet, marked “Confidential,” it was extremely heavily redacted, to the point where the “3” was blotted out in each and every reference to Com-munity Board 3, as were all persons’ names — and frequently even any pronouns, too, such as “she” and “her,” that might help identify an in-dividual via gender.

In addition, the borough presi-dent’s office dragged its feet a bit in releasing the documents within the required time frame — taking more than a month too long — with a spokesperson repeatedly explaining that it was a “sensitive” situation.

The investigation was sparked by a complaint by Ayo Harrington, an African-American member of C.B. 3, who charged that Li, who is Asian-American, had refused Har-rington’s request to appoint her chair-person of the board’s Health, Seniors and Human Services / Youth, Educa-tion and Human Rights Committee when the position became open.

Harrington further charged that two other board members — one of whom is African-American — asked to jointly co-chair that same commit-tee but were also rejected by Li, who responded that C.B. 3’s bylaws do not allow for committee co-chairpersons.

According to the report, Har-rington filed her complaint with the B.P.’s office in late April of last year. (Harrington, however, told The Villager she didn’t actually file the complaint, but that Brewer’s office launched the investigation independently after The Villager published a letter by Harrington, in which she made the accusation.)

As part of the investigation, inter-views were subsequently conducted with Harrington and Li, as well as with “witnesses,” including possibly at least one other C.B. 3 member and apparently Susan Stetzer, the board’s district manager.

By August, Brewer’s office had fin-ished the probe, and letters regard-ing its findings were sent to Li and Harrington.

The reason why the final report, as well as the letters to Li and Har-rington — copies of which were also provided to The Villager — were all so heavily redacted is because the ac-cusation was ultimately found to be “unsubstantiated,” according to the borough president’s office.

“The complaint that [redacted name] declined to appoint you or [re-dacted name] as [redacted] Commit-tee chair on the basis of race or color was not substantiated by the E.E.O. Officers’ investigation,” the letter to

Harrington, as redacted for The Vil-lager, says.

The letters do conclude by stating, however, that the borough president — who appoints community board members — recommended four “re-medial actions.” These measures are delineated by four bullet points, though, again, are completely re-dacted, leaving only the bullet points showing.

(According to a source who re-quested anonymity, and who tipped The Villager off that the investigation had been concluded, Brewer recom-mended that both Li and Stetzer un-dergo E.E.O. training.)

Reading between the redactions, the investigators found that Li nei-ther had made enough appoint-ments — she had made six up to that point — nor chaired the board long enough, to have established a “consistent pattern” of failing to put qualified black and Latino members in leadership positions.

Again, reading between the redac-tions, Li told the investigators that she made appointments based on individuals’ qualifications, and that “race was never a factor in any of her decisions.” Rather, Li said, she “relies on outgoing committee, subcom-mittee and task force chairpersons to make recommendations for new chairpersons.”

Li added that, in the case of one of the committee chairperson hope-fuls whom she rejected — again, the name is redacted — Li had received reports that this individual had demonstrated “disruptive behavior at [full board] meetings and commit-tee meetings,” and so Li “felt that the behavior would not fit in very well.”

Of the two other board members who Li snubbed for top spots, she ex-plained that “neither had taken any leadership initiative during the time that they had been on the board.”

Again, this is reading between the redactions and filling in the blanks.

Neither Li nor Harrington would comment to The Villager regarding the substance of the final report or the recommendations because the in-vestigation was deemed confidential by Brewer’s office.

In fact, Brewer’s office — even though providing the final report and the two letters to The Villager — would not confirm that any of the above individuals were questioned, or for that matter, that there had been any investigation at all.

After receiving the majorly redact-ed materials, The Villager requested that Brewer’s office provide a less heavily crossed-out copy of the re-port — and specifically pressed to find out what the four “remedial actions” were. But Brewer’s office would not budge.

In a Dec. 28 letter to The Villager, Adele Bartlett, Brewer’s FOIL officer, wrote, in part, “[T]he Office of the Borough President has at all times de-clined to confirm or deny the identity of any parties to any Equal Employ-ment complaint, and our response to your request can in no way be inter-preted as confirming the identify of any party involved.

“The extensive redaction was nec-essary and proper pursuant to Equal Employment Policy of this Office, as well as the Equal Employment Policy of the City of New York, to protect the identity of the parties to an unsubstantiated discrimination claim.”

Bartlett recommended contacting the borough president’s FOIL ap-peals officer, James Caras.

In response to the newspaper’s ap-peal seeking a reduction of the redac-tions, Caras responded on Jan. 6 that,

under the Public Officers Law, to do so would represent an “unwarranted invasion of personal privacy,” since there were no findings of misconduct or disciplinary action.

In a brief phone interview, Caras added that all E.E.O. complaints are taken extremely seriously because there could be liability involved for the city — plus, it’s something Brew-er personally takes very seriously. If the complaint had, in fact, been sub-stantiated, more information would have been divulged, he said.

In a phone interview, Harrington said, “All I’m prepared to say is, the result of my concern has resulted in a board that is more reflective — as in one African-American being appointed the ad hoc Nominating Committee chairperson [head-ing the temporary committee that

C.B. 3, continued from p. 1

Bias charge against Li ‘unsubstantiated’: B.P.

C.B. 3, continued on p. 23

The first page of a heavily redacted letter from the Manhattan borough president’s office to C.B. 3 member Ayo Harrington, notifying her that E.E.O. investigators found her complaint against Chairperson Gigi Li to be unsubstantiated. Three of four recommended “remedial actions” are shown blacked out; a fourth is on the letter’s second page and is also completely blacked out.


E D U C A T I O N

Mendez defies D.O.E., holds charter hearingBY LINCOLN ANDERSON

The Department of Education tried to call off the hearing at the 11th hour, but that didn’t

stop 300 people from turning out at P.S. 20 last Thursday night to voice their opposition to a proposed new Success Academy charter school co-location in School District 1.

Councilmember Rosie Mendez forged ahead with the hearing, which D.O.E. had canceled with less than 24 hours notice. Success Academy is deferring opening a new charter elementary school in the East Side district until 2016, but apparently still plans to move ahead with the school. Whether the plan is that the charter would be co-lo-cated with one or more existing dis-trict schools in a school building, or would be sited in another location was not immediately clear. What is known is that no location for the proposed charter has been publicly identified yet.

Joining Mendez at last Thurs-day’s hearing were Assemblymem-ber Deborah Glick, as well as Lisa Donlan, president of Community Education Council District 1, and scores of parents and community members who came to share their frustration over the cancellation of the long-awaited hearing to discuss the charter school’s request to open in School District 1.

In fact, last October, the SUNY Charter School Institute board of trustees had voted to approve a charter school for School District 2. Without notification to the com-munity or local politicians, Success Academy send a letter to the SUNY charter board requesting a change of location from School District 1 to Districts 2 or 6. Last Thursday’s hearing had been scheduled after Mendez and Councilmember Mar-garet Chin protested that a hearing for that change should be required, even though the bureaucrats dubbed it a “nonmaterial change.”

D.O.E. cancelled last Thursday’s hearing, saying, “In light of the fact that D.O.E. is not planning to site a school in District 1, tomorrow’s hearing has been cancelled.”

Yet, to date, Success Academy has not rescinded its request to change its application to School District 1. Plus, last week, a Success Academy spokesperson told The Villager that the new school’s opening is simply being “deferred” until next year.

“It is very frustrating that the De-partment of Education would cancel a meeting with less than 24 hours’

notice to the community and elect-ed officials,” said Mendez. “D.O.E. states that Success Academy Charter School gave notice that they will not open a site in School District 1. How-ever, Success Academy hasn’t with-drawn its application nor provided said notice in writing. The parents of School District 1 deserve an oppor-tunity to be heard, and D.O.E. has taken that opportunity away from them.”

Glick said, “I find it incredibly concerning that this proposed pub-lic hearing on Success Academy has been cancelled with less than 24 hours’ notice, especially in light of the fact that Success Academy has not made any formal commitment to remain out of District 1 in the future. Success Academy and D.O.E. need to publicly state their intentions for the record.”

Donlan said it’s time to put a hold on new charters.

“The lack of transparency, clarity and community input for this char-ter school proposal,” she declared, “calls into question the entire char-tering process at the very moment when the state Legislature is dis-cussing raising the charter cap in New York City and New York State. There can not be any more charters issued or co-locations considered until the chartering and siting pro-cess have been clarified and we can put the public back in public educa-tion.”

Orna Silver, a School District 1 teacher and parent, said the charter operators are wrong if they think they can pull a fast one on District 1, which encompasses the East Village and most of the Lower East Side.

“‘They’ think that the parents of District 1 won’t fight back,” Silver said. “ ‘They’ think that because many of us speak Spanish or Chi-

nese that we are an easy target. ‘They’ think that we don’t have great schools and great choices. ‘They’ think that it will be easy to sneak in a Success Academy and we will run to send our children there. Let me tell you, ‘they’ are wrong. We have voices, we have rights and we will protect our children and our schools.”

CALL TO SUBSCRIBE 646-452-2475

CALL TO SUBSCRIBE646-452-2475


E D U C A T I O N

Exceeded benchmarks for closing the achievement gap & improving student growth

Music every day for every child | Two K-5 public schools on the Lower East Side

Apply now for K, 1st, or 2nd grade! Preference given to applicants that speak a language other

than English at home

Info & applications | Info. y solicitudes | 信息和申请 Manhattan Charter School: (212) 533-2743 | Manhattan Charter School 2: (212) 964-3792

www.manhattancharterschool.org

EDUCATION FOR THE GLOBAL GENERATION

A Learning School

Summer Arts Extended Day

STEAM Saturdays Summer Exchange

Program

Where the neighborhood meets the world and learning is a state of mindfulness

Councilmember Rosie Mendez, at podium with microphone, forged ahead with the hearing, even though the Department of Education had tried to cancel it at the last minute.

PH

OTO

BY C

LAYTON

PATTERSO

N


HCS Home CarePhone: 1(855) 239-Care (2273) Ask for Ron

In the Business of Caring

My loved one needs care at home....HCS Home Care has the solution! CDPAP Program

Why CDPAP?Our Consumer Directed

Personal Assistance Program allows individuals more control over their caregiver services

by permitting you to choose your own caregiver.• Friends • Family • Neighbors

No Certificate Needed

E.V. gunshots

Bullets fl ew around the East Village on Tues., Jan. 20, in two sepa-rate incidents. Luckily, only one man was left slightly injured.

In the fi rst incident, a man, 39, told police offi cers that he had been sitting in his car at 6:15 p.m. while waiting at a red light at Avenue C and E. 12th St., when he saw several males running northbound chasing another male.

He said he then heard three loud bangs — gunshots. One bullet shat-tered his driver’s side-view mirror and he suffered an abrasion to his arm from a piece of the debris. His injury was non-life-threatening. There were no arrests.

Later that same day, at 10:40 p.m., shots were fi red in the vicinity of E. Sixth St. and Avenue D. According to the Ninth Precinct, multiple witness-es phoned in reports, giving different locations for where the shots were fi red.

However, the precinct said the shots seemed to have originated in the vicinity of 91 Avenue D, the

Manhattan Express Deli. A police spokesperson said an employee at the bodega reported hearing two to three gunshots, and discovered a bul-let hole in the shop’s window. A dif-ferent police spokesperosn said there were two bullet holes found in the window.

As offi cers were arriving at the location, they spotted a vehicle that suddenly made a U-turn. An offi cer stopped the car and arrested two males and one female in connection with the incident.

Police did not provide more details about the arrested individuals. As for whether the two shooting incidents were related and what it was all about, as of Wednesday afternoon it was still under investigation.

“At this time it’s still being looked at,” a Ninth Precinct source said.

Baruch delivery bandit Police are seeking the public’s help

in locating and identifying an indi-vidual wanted in connection with an armed robbery pattern in the Baruch

Houses, specifi cally in one building in the complex. In each case, the suspect robs deliverymen.

Police said that on Sun., Jan. 11, at around 7 p.m., the suspect approached a 16-year-old delivery boy inside an apartment building at 130 Columbia St., displayed a fi rearm, and removed

$60 in cash and food from him. On Thurs., Jan. 15, around 2:30 p.m.,

the suspect approached a 45-year-old deliveryman inside 130 Columbia St., displayed a gun and stole food.

Also on Thurs., Jan. 15, around 7:25

POLICE BLOTTER

Two images of the alleged Baruch Houses deliveryman robber, one with a beard and one without.

POLICE BLOTTER, continued on p.11


119 West 23rd Street • 212.929.3645 • tekserve.com

With 14.7 million pixels, the new iMac® with

Retina® 5K display is the most powerful iMac

ever, with the top-of-the-line quad-core Intel

processor, the latest AMD graphics, Fusion

Drive, and great built-in apps. All in the same

ultrathin design that’s just 5mm at the edges.

From $2,499

Apple, the Apple logo, iMac and Retina are trademarks of Apple Inc., registered in the U.S. and other countries. Intel is a trademark of Intel Corp. in the U.S. and other countries.

p.m., the suspect approached a man, 22, inside 130 Columbia St., showed a gun and stole $100 in cash from him.

The suspect is described as a male white Hispanic, about 5-foot-9, 200 pounds, with short hair, and wearing black sneakers and a black coat. In the first incident, the suspect had a beard. In the second one, he was clean-shaven.

Anyone with information about these incidents is asked to call the Crime Stoppers hotline, at 1-800-577-TIPS (8477). Tips can also be submitted by logging onto the Crime Stoppers Web site, www.nypdcrimestoppers.com, or by texting to 274637 (CRIMES) then entering TIP577. All tips are confi-dential.

Bridge jump

Police reported that shortly after 10 p.m. on Mon., Jan. 19, a person jumped off the Manhattan Bridge and landed in the street in the vicinity of South St. and Pike Slip. Emergency Service Unit police reported the individual was D.O.A. Police did not provide more information. A spokesperson for the city’s Chief Medical Examiner said the victim had been ID’d and that it was a suicide. But it wasn’t clear if police had notified family members yet, which police require before they release the name to the press.

Sex crimes pattern

Police have linked more incidents to a suspect wanted for an attempted rape in the East Village.

The suspect is wanted for an attempted rape of a woman, 22, after he followed her into her building’s stairwell, on E. Sixth St., around 6 a.m. on Dec. 28.

On Dec. 30, police also linked the suspect to a Dec. 16 incident where a man followed a woman, 19, as she walked into an elevator from the lobby of a building on F.D.R. Drive, then tried to grab her buttocks and breasts and forcibly kiss her. A struggle ensued, and he fled.

On Jan. 15, police included three more incidents in the pattern.

According to police, on Tues., Dec. 9 at 6:25 a.m., in the East Village’s Ninth Precinct, a 25-year-old woman was entering her apartment building when the suspect came in behind her and grabbed her buttocks. The victim

screamed and the suspect fled. On Wed., Dec. 17, at 4:25 a.m.,

within the confines of the 30 Precinct — which includes West Harlem, Hamilton Heights and Sugar Hill — a 20-year-old woman was entering her apartment building when a man that police believe to be the same suspect entered behind her. He grabbed the victim and covered her mouth, and began to forcibly touch her back and buttocks. The suspect then fled the scene.

On Wed., Jan. 14, at 2:30 a.m., in the Fifth Precinct, which includes Chinatown and Little Italy, a woman, 31, was opening the door of her apart-ment building when, police say, the same suspect approached her from behind and grabbed her waist. The man then pulled the victim’s pants down, and when she yelled, he pushed her away and fled the scene.

The suspect is described as dark-complexioned black, about 5-feet-4 to 5-feet-11, age 20 to 25, and 150 to 180 pounds. He wears a black Yankees baseball hat.

Anyone with information about these incidents is asked to call the Crime Stoppers hotline, at 1-800-577-TIPS (8477). Tips can also be submitted by logging onto the Crime Stoppers Web site, www.nypdcrimestoppers.com, or by texting to 274637 (CRIMES) then entering TIP577. All tips are con-fidential.

Not-so-great escape

Two men got into a verbal dispute at about 12:10 a.m. on Tues., Jan. 13. One of them, Amara Toure, 20, then snatched the glasses off the face of the other man, 44, tossed them down and ground his shoes into them, police said. Toure then fled the scene.

Police tracked him to a residence at 24 Fifth Ave. the following evening. But despite the handcuffs, Toure broke free and ran away following arrest.

According to a news report, unknown to police, the apartment’s bathroom had two doors, and Toure snuck out the back one, then made his escape wearing only sweatpants. But police apprehended him later in an unlocked basement at 40 E. 11th St.

Toure was slapped with one charge of criminal mischief for smashing the man’s glasses, valued at $250, and a misdemeanor charge of escape.

Lincoln Anderson and Zach Williams

POLICE BLOTTER, continued from p. 10


Bus service is a bust

To The Editor:I have contacted many politicians about the very

poor bus service here in the East Village, but have gotten zero response.

I have, in the past few years, become a user of the M14A crosstown. The Downtown Select bus does not stop at E. Ninth St. as the limited bus did. As a result, there is a 17-block distance from 14th St. to Houston and Allen Sts.

Usually, when the bus was limited service, I

would get off at the E. Ninth St. stop and walk a few blocks to Avenue A and E. Sixth St. Now I get off at 14th St. and change for the 14A. The osten-sible schedule is every 15 minutes between buses — but the reality is 25 minutes or more.

Also the ratio is allegedly three 14D buses to one 14A. It is more likely five or more to one. Last week it was nine 14D to one 14A, after a 30-minute wait. Most of the latter D’s go by empty.

The 14A bus has a mix of passengers — white ethnics, Latinos, African-American, poor, the new gentrification citizens — who need public trans-portation.

The Second Ave. Select bus stops at 34th, 28th and 23rd Sts. to accommodate those going to and from the hospitals on First Ave. But it’s crazy to skip the East Village stop at Ninth St., creating a 17-block distance to the next stop.

So now the transfer I make at 14th St. becomes imperative. Again, I have written to our local pol-iticians, and gotten no reply. State Senator Daniel Squadron has an electronic response, but nothing else.

Who will help solve this bus-service crisis?

Bert Zackim

E-mail letters, not longer than 250 words in length, to [email protected] or fax to 212-229-2790 or mail to The Villager, Letters to the Editor, 1 Metrotech North, 10th floor, Brooklyn, NY, NY 11201. Please include phone number for confirmation purposes. The Villager reserves the right to edit letters for space, grammar, clarity and libel. The Villager does not publish anonymous letters.

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR

As we’re still at the beginning of this new year, there’s no question that these are very

fraught times, both at home and abroad.

The city continues to feel tense af-ter the non-indictment of a police offi-cer in the death of Eric Garner during Garner’s arrest this past summer. There are ongoing protests — with marches and die-ins still “alive” more than a month later, even after the cold-blooded execution of two police officers in Brooklyn.

In a low point, the sight of cops turning their backs on Mayor de Bla-sio at the two slain officers’ funerals is one that will not soon be forgotten.

There has been a slight thaw, with de Blasio seemingly now making ev-ery effort to ingratiate himself to the cops, and Patrick Lynch, of the Pa-trolmen’s Benevolent Association — realizing he was pushing it too far, too stridently — no longer demand-ing the mayor apologize to the police.

Police have been ratcheting their

arrest numbers back up after a stun-ning slowdown following the exe-cution of Officers Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liu.

Ironically, this all comes amid the fact that crime in the city — such as, most important, murders — is at his-toric lows. In short, police are sav-ing lives — a lot of lives, black, white, brown and every other skin tone in the spectrum — simply because the city is that much safer. And where the most lives are being saved is in the most dan-gerous inner-city neighborhoods.

Clearly, de Blasio’s clash with the cops is threatening to undermine his entire progressive agenda. In his first year, he has had successes on pre-K, paid sick leave, creating an affordable housing plan and, most recently, mu-nicipal ID cards. His forward-think-ing Vision Zero plan is paving the way for greatly increased street safe-ty.

Yet all everyone is talking and thinking about — what is being felt most viscerally — is the mayor’s rocky relationship with the police. It all gives the city a surreal feeling of tremendous instability.

De Blasio came into office saying he would end “The Tale of Two Cit-

ies” by addressing income inequality and, in general, New York’s afford-ability crisis. Yet new polls, for what-ever they’re worth, show that his ap-proval rating is down sharply among many voters and that many now feel race relations in the city are actually worse than before.

Is it any coincidence that other leaders are suddenly emerging to grab headlines, such as former City Council Speaker Christine Quinn — last year’s onetime mayoral front-runner — being appointed a special adviser to Governor Cuomo. And an article recently highlighted how City Comptroller Scott Stringer’s cam-paign war chest is near bursting, and how he’s likely raring to run for may-or if de Blasio stumbles further.

As many have noted, now, partic-ularly, is not the time for the mayor to be in conflict with the police, not in the wake of Muslim extremists’ sickening slaughter of the cartoon-ists at Charlie Hebdo. Not now, with Europe on high alert as police hunt down sleeper cells of more home-grown terrorists — many of whom have honed their hatred and killing skills in Syria — and with anti-Sem-itism at truly frightening levels in

France and elsewhere.Getting back to New York...we sup-

port the protesters’ right to march, hold die-ins and air their views. But at this point, we think there are more constructive steps that can be taken. For example, one idea we like is a se-ries of town halls and “digital youth dialogues” on police-community re-lations that Brooklyn Borough Pres-ident Eric Adams — a former cop — and civil-rights attorney Norman Siegel recently kicked off. This is ex-actly what we need more of — dia-logue, and a search for real solutions.

In an encouraging note, an op-ed in the Daily News a few weeks ago noted that police reform in New York City tends to occur in 20-year intervals. Al-most always, it’s sparked by protests over what is seen as an unjustified kill-ing by police. The good news is that, after each wave of reform, the Police Department actually emerges better off, and, thus, so does the city.

Hopefully, after all this discomfort we’re going through, that’s where we’ll end up — as a safer, more uni-fied city. That’s the place we do need to get to. Because, frankly, given the state of the world today, we don’t have much choice.

Right now more than ever, the city needs unityEDITORIAL

Cartooning can be dangerous to your health.

IRA BLUTRIECH

SOUND OFF!Write a letter to the editor

[email protected]


BY TED RALL

Terrorism doesn’t scare political cartoonists nearly as much as editors — and the corpo-rate bean-counters who tell them what to do.

The Charlie Hebdo massacre couldn’t have hap-pened here in the United States. But it’s not because American newspapers have better security.

Gunmen could never kill four political cartoon-ists in an American newspaper office because no paper in the U.S. employs two, much less four, staff political cartoonists — the number who died on Jan. 7 in Paris. There is no equivalent of Charlie Hebdo, which puts political cartoons front and cen-ter, in the States. (The Onion never published polit-ical cartoons — and it ceased print publication last year. MAD, for which I draw, focuses on popular culture.)

When I began drawing political cartoons pro-fessionally in the early 1990s, hundreds of my col-leagues worked on staff at newspapers, with full salaries and benefits. That was already down from journalism’s midcentury glory days, when there were thousands. Many papers employed two. Short-ly after World War II, The New York Times, which today has none, employed four cartoonists on staff. Today there are fewer than 30.

Most American states have zero full-time staff political cartoonists.

Many big states — California, New York, Texas, Illinois — have one.

No American political magazine, on the left, cen-ter or right, has one.

No American political Web site (Huffington Post, Talking Points Memo, Daily Kos, Slate, Salon, etc.) employs a political cartoonist. Although its launch video was done in cartoons, eBay billionaire Pierre Omidyar’s new $250 million left-wing start-up, First Look Media, refuses to hire political cartoonists — or pay tiny fees to reprint syndicated ones.

These outfits have tons of staff writers.During the last two weeks, many journalists and

editors have spread the “Je Suis Charlie” meme through social media in order to express “solidar-ity” with the victims of Charlie Hebdo, political cartoonists (who routinely receive death threats, whether they live in France or the United States) and freedom of expression. That’s nice.

No it’s not. It’s annoying.As far as political cartoonists are concerned, edi-

torials pledging “solidarity” with the Charlie Heb-do cartoonists is an empty gesture — corporate slacktivism. Less than 24 hours after the shootings at Charlie Hebdo, the Fort Lauderdale Sun-Sentinel fired its longtime award-winning political cartoon-ist, Chan Lowe. Political cartoonists: editors love us when we’re dead. While we’re still breathing, they’re laying us off, slashing our rates, stealing our copyrights and disappearing us from where we used to appear — killing our art form.

American editors and publishers have never been as willing to publish satire, whether in pictures or in words, as their European counterparts. But things have gone from bad to apocalyptic in the last 30 years.

Humor columnists like the late Art Buchwald earned millions syndicating their jokes about poli-ticians and current events to American newspapers through the 1970s and 1980s. Miami Herald hu-

mor writer Dave Barry was a rock star through the 1990s, routinely cranking out bestselling books. Then came 9/11.

When I began working as an executive talent scout for the United Media syndicate in 2006, my sales staff informed me that, if Barry had started out then, they wouldn’t have been able to sell him to a single newspaper, magazine or Web site — not even if they gave his work to them for free. Barry was still funny, but there was no market for satire anywhere in American media.

That’s even truer today. The youngest working political cartoonist in the

United States, Matt Bors, is 31. When people ask me

who the next up-and-comer is, I tell them there isn’t one — and there won’t be one any time soon.

Americans are funny. Americans like funny. They especially like wicked funny. We’re so des-perate for funny that we think Jon Stewart is hilari-ous. (But Richard Pryor. He really was.) But editors and producers won’t give them funny, much less mean-funny.

Why not?Like any other disaster, media censorship of

satire — especially graphic satire — in the U.S. is caused by several contributing factors.

Most media outlets are owned by corporations,

not private owners. Publicly traded companies are risk-averse. Executives prefer to publish boring/safe content that won’t generate complaints from advertisers or shareholders, much less force them to hire extra security guards.

Half a century ago, many editors had work-ing-class backgrounds and rose through the ranks from the bottom. Now they’re graduates of pricey graduate university journalism programs that don’t offer scholarships — and don’t teach a single class about comics, cartoons, humor or graphic art. It takes an unusually curious editor to make the effort to ed-ucate himself or herself about political cartoons.

Corporate journalism executives view cartoons as frivolous, less serious than “real” commentary like columns or editorials. Unfortunately, some editori-al cartoonists make this problem worse by drawing silly gags about current events (as opposed to tren-chant attacks on the powers that be) because they’ve seen their blandest work win Pulitzers and coveted spots in the major weekend cartoon “roundups.” When asked to cut their budget, editors often look at their cartoonist first.

There is still powerful political cartooning online. Ironically, the Internet contributes to the death of satire in America by sating the demand for hard-hit-ting political art. Before the Web, if a paper canceled my cartoons they would receive angry letters from my fans. Now my readers find me online — but the Internet pays pennies on the print dollar. I’m stub-bornly hanging on, but many talented cartoonists, especially the young, won’t work for free.

It’s not that media organizations are broke. Far from it. Many are profitable. American newspapers and magazines employ tens of thousands of writers — they just don’t want anyone writing or drawing anything that questions the status quo, especially not in a form as powerful as political cartooning.

The next time you hear editors pretending to stand up for freedom of expression, ask them if they employ a cartoonist.

Rall’s next book is “After We Kill You, We Will Wel-come You Back As Honored Guests: Unembedded in Af-ghanistan.”

Editors, not terrorists, killed U.S. political cartoonists

At the “Je Suis Charlie” rally in Washington Square Park on Jan. 10, a sign showed French satirical cartoonists Bernard Verlhac (Tignous) and Stéphane Charbonnier (“Charb”), both slain three days earlier in the Charlie Hebdo terrorist attack.

American newspapers and magazines don’t

want to publish anything that questions the

status quo.

PH

OTO

BY LIZA B

EAR

TALKING POINT


855.692.5289 katzmoving.com

Katz Moving has a stellar reputation for excellence in the moving industry.

Please mention “Community Media” when placing your move.

Katz Moving will donate 5% of your move to The Ali Forney Center

Check out our 5 Star Customer Reviews

47-47 Austell Pl., Long Island City, NY 11101 • NYSDOT #T-38598 • USDOT #2280679 Terms and conditions apply, can't be applied with any other offer, offer expires on 3/31/2015.

Must mention "community media" when calling.

BY LINCOLN ANDERSON

ACity Council hearing Tues-day on illegal apartment rentals in New York City was

dominated by debate about airbnb, the exploding online “home-sharing” operation.

Titled “Short-term Rentals: Stimu-lating the Economy or Destabilizing Neighborhoods?” the hearing was led by Councilmember Jumaane Wil-liams, chairperson of the Housing and Buildings Committee.

The crowd packing the City Coun-cil Chambers included tenants and tenant advocates opposed to airbnb, as well as others who praised the easy fi nancial pickings of renting out their places to perfect strangers, which can pay for a vacation, for example, or just supplement one’s income.

A fast-growing global phenome-non, airbnb’s biggest and most lucra-tive market is reportedly New York City.

Councilmembers heard over-whelming complaints about how airbnb is helping deplete the city’s affordable housing stock, while also creating building-wide security, safe-ty and nuisance issues. Meanwhile, many noted, the city’s enforcement unit for dealing with the problem of illegal rentals is tiny and can’t keep up with the mushrooming underground industry.

“Over the past fi ve years,” Coun-cilmember Helen Rosenthal said, “airbnb rentals grew from 900 to 21,000, and according to the New York State attorney general, 72 percent of these units are illegal. Until short-term rental platforms accept responsibility for their users who profi t from illegal rentals, we have to equip the Mayor’s Offi ce of Special Enforcement to shut them down, one by one.”

Assemblymember Richard Gottfried sponsored the 2010 Illegal Hotel Law that forbids renting out apartments for less than 30 days at a time.

“For years, tenants have been fi ght-ing to rid our city of illegal hotels,”

Gottfried said. “Now companies like airbnb are using their hotel-brokerage services to promote illegal hotel use. Their misleading propaganda tries to paper over the fi re and safety viola-tions, harassment of tenants and loss of needed housing that comes with illegal hotels. We want to protect the Illegal Hotel Law and get increased enforcement of the law, and more re-sources and strong penalties for vio-

lating the law. Illegal hotels are bad for New York, bad for tourists and bad for housing.”

Added state Senator Brad Hoylman, “Illegal hotels give unscrupulous landlords an incentive to drive up apartment prices and drive out long-time residents, reducing our city’s already-limited affordable housing stock. According to data released by Attorney General Eric Schneiderman,

my district has one of the highest con-centrations of illegal hotels in the city, and I applaud my colleagues at both the state and local level who are work-ing to ensure that our fi re, building safety and zoning laws are enforced.”

Meanwhile, in his testimony, Da-vid Hantman, airbnb’s head of global public policy, said that, in fact, airbnb now has more than 25,000 “hosts” in New York City, serving hundreds of thousands of users.

“More than 26 million people have now stayed in an airbnb listing around the world,” he said. “And we know from experience here and around the globe that when you learn more about airbnb and our amazing community of hosts, you see how we make cities even better places to visit and call home.

“That is why Amsterdam, Ham-burg, San Jose, Portugal, San Fran-cisco, Portland and Paris have all passed new laws within the last year to clear the path for renting out one’s own home.

“New York policymakers shouldn’t be left behind or advocate against their own citizens who depend on home-sharing to pay their bills,” Hantman urged. “We can protect reg-ular New Yorkers who are sharing their home and still prohibit and pun-ish illegal hotels.

“A vast majority of New Yorkers al-ready believe that residents should be able to rent out their own homes once in awhile.”

Hantman claimed that most of airb-nb’s hosts — about 90 percent — “sim-ply rent out their own homes once in awhile. The typical host in New York might rent out their home for a few days when away on vacation, or maybe a couple of weeks a year for a work trip,” he asserted. But others have been found to be stockpiling and renting out multiple units.

Tenant advocates have been warn-ing that airbnb has been spending millions of dollars to lobby Albany leg-islators to change the law to allow the booming business to operate legally.

Foes and fans of airbnb share views at hearing

Supporters of airbnb, outside City Hall before the hearing, top, and oppo-nents, holding yellow signs, inside the hearing, above.

PH

OTO

S BY W

ILLIAM ALATR

ISTE / NYC

CO

UN

CIL


BY PUMA PERL (pumaperl.blogspot.com)

Imet Kat Georges and Peter Car-laftes for the first time at the HOWL Festival in Tompkins

Square Park, close to ten years ago. They were manning their Three Rooms Press table, an operation that they co-founded in 1993 whose name references a theme (the pa-rameters that one needs to get the job done) of Harold Pinter’s play “The Homecoming.” One may also look at the three rooms as the ego, id and superego, as per Peter. Their warmth and friendliness immedi-ately engaged me and they greet-ed me as a dear friend every time I ran into them, which was, literally, everywhere that I went. The Small Press Book Fair, the Bowery Poetry Club, galleries, arts events — they were there. I had recently returned to the poetry scene after a long hi-atus and their openhearted accep-tance and enthusiasm encouraged me to stick around.

These days, running into them regularly might entail a passport and a lot of airplane miles, as they have expanded globally, hosting cultural and literary events all over the world while maintaining their New York City base, and continu-ing their monthly series at the Cor-nelia Street Cafe, called, appropri-ately, “The Monthly.”

Three Rooms Press continues to publish newly emerging writers as well as established artists, includ-ing Gerard Malanga, Israel Hor-ovitz and Mike Watt (best known as the bassist for the Minutemen and the reunited Stooges). When his volume of poems and photos,

“Mike Watt: On and Off Bass” was released, it resulted in one of the most epic blowouts of a book party I have ever attended. In addition to the usual book signing and Q&A, he played an intense eighteen-minute set of Stooges songs with his pals J Mascis and Murph, and includ-ing special guests such as Thurston Moore.

Upcoming Three Rooms Press

releases include April 28’s “Dark City Lights,” an anthology of New York stories edited by the esteemed crime master, Lawrence Block, and “Moon Poem” (Fall, 2015), a col-lection of forty years of memories by Living Theater founder Judith Malina. In June, the eighth annual (and first color) edition of “Main-tenant: A Journal of Contemporary Dada Writing and Art” hits the

stands, accompanied by a series of surreal celebrations and readings. The journal is archived in the Mu-seum of Modern Art and includes a legendary list of American and international writers and artists (including Charles Plymell, Jerome Rothenberg, Philip Meersman, Wil-liam Burroughs and Puma Perl).

Passion and partnership at Three Rooms PressIn print and on stage, local publisher has global reach

THREE ROOMS, continued on p.16

Three Rooms Press founders Kat Georges and Peter Carlaftes, in the Paris studio of Susan Shup.

PH

OTO

BY SU

SAN SH

UP


Yes, I just mentioned myself. That is because I sometimes cannot believe my good fortune in having the opportunity to share a stage and pag-es with my literary idols. I am able to maintain my cool around rock stars, but I am an absolute geek around the writers I most admire. I stut-tered and babbled when I asked Lawrence Block to sign “Have a NYC,” a Three Rooms Press short story collection in which we were both pub-lished. Kim Addonizio, one of my favorite living writers, was on the roster at January 2’s annual Charles Bukowski Memorial event, at which I also read. I once saw her perform, then gave her one of my books after I finished the stammering thing — and now, I’ve participated in an event with her. Like I said, I’m a total geek — the type of geek that hugged a signed copy of Gerard Malanga’s newest volume, “Malanga Chasing Vallejo.” The work is a translation of eighty-two of Cesar Vallejo’s poems, revealing a mysterious, spiritual connection between the two. It is so named because of the many years that Malanga had yearned to find a home for this vision. Sev-eral days after the book release party, which was held at Le Poisson Rouge, I attended a screening of previously unseen Andy Warhol films at BAM. Onscreen, a young, beautiful Malanga sits on a couch with Kerouac, Ginsberg, Corso and others, all of whom were punching and tickling him. In another filmstrip, he lies on the floor as Mary Woronov grinds her stiletto heel into his neck. And I had just met and been enchanted by the recital from this man, who remains as beautiful as ever. I am the luckiest geek ever.

Kat and Peter make their creative partnerships look easy, and they bring people together in a natural and unforced way. When you work with Three Rooms Press in any capacity you are fam-ily, and family goes out to one of their favorite West Village haunts after readings — and since everyone is family, the after parties are some-times as good as the real events. They are born to be the mayors of the neighborhood, bringing people together to break bread and get drunk, hosting out of town visiting artists, greeting ev-ery restaurant owner, waiter and bartender by name. Their engaging spirit, coupled with a qual-ity press and a growing staff, continues to attract

a wide and disparate group of artists and friends from all walks of life.

Peter, a Bronx boy whose love for the Yankees is high art, and Kat, a Southern California girl with roots in the punk and hardcore scenes, first laid eyes on each other in a San Francisco bar called the Rite Spot, where they were sitting at opposite ends editing their poetry. “Simultaneous combus-tion!” Peter called it, describing their initial meet-ing and the collaborations that quickly followed. “Our motto,” he add-ed, “was ‘Don’t Think,’ because as soon as you think, you are you in the world, and there is no escape. That’s what we learned to do in the

theater — provide escape, and maybe because of that, there was no need to escape each other.”

For several years, they lived in a tiny loft space above a stage where they each produced fifteen plays. With the first dot-com boom, the rent quintupled, and, in 2003, they made the move to New York City, arriving the day after Thanksgiv-ing and staying at the Edison Hotel. Once they were settled, Three Rooms Press, still a humble

THREE ROOMS, continued from p. 15

‘Burroughs 101’ at Feb. 6 Three Rooms reading

Three Rooms Press continues to publish newly emerging writers as well as established artists, includ-ing Gerard Malanga (seen here, at Le Poisson Rouge).

Bassist Mike Watt (right) at the book release party for his collection of poetry and photographs (“On and Off Bass”). At left, poet David Lawton.

THREE ROOMS, continued on p.17

PH

OTO

BY LYN

N C

APP

IELLOP

HO

TO B

Y PU

MA P

ERL


chapbook venture, began to grow. In 2009, they published their first perfect bound poetry collection, and, in 2010, began their foray into the world of fiction and nonfiction. The press is now distributed nation-ally and internationally by PGW/Perseus. Recent international activ-ities include hosting a book launch in Corsica, participating in the Ber-lin performance art festival, CUT, hosting a Dada festival in Paris, as well as a three-day International Festival of Underground Poetry in Brussels. Not bad for what started as a two-person operation living and working over a theater and us-ing the stage as a kitchen, since their quarters did not include one.

Prior to sitting down for a chat with Kat and Peter, I emailed them five questions so I would have some additional background information. They decided to play an updated version of “The Newlywed Game” and answer separately, not reveal-ing their responses to one another until the day of our meeting. None of us were surprised that their re-plies not only mirrored, but also en-

hanced one another, as they seem to do in life. There was one variation. In one of my queries, I asked about what their dream show would be. Peter replied, “The dream would be to keep going, to keep putting out meaningful work to the world.” Kat wrote, “Iggy Pop and David Bow-ie, performing side by side after a launch of books on Three Rooms Press.” I reminded Peter that he had not completely answered the ques-tion. He paused for thirty seconds. “Iggy Pop!” he yelled, suggesting to me that this dream may, in the future, be realized, and forcing me to admit that I may have lied a little about my extreme cool around rock stars.

The next Three Room Press “Month-ly” will take place at 6 p.m. on Fri., Feb. 6, at the Cornelia Street Cafe (29 Cor-nelia St., west of 6th Ave., off Bleecker). “Burroughs 101” is an informative, inspirational exploration into the mind and writings of William S. Burroughs with Anne Waldman, Penny Arcade, Burroughs publisher Jan Herman and others in TRP’s second annual WSB memorial reading. Admission is $12, and includes one drink.

Peter Carlaftes’ new book, “TE-

ATROPHY: Three More Plays,” will launch on Mon., Feb. 23, with a perfor-mance of his play, “ANTI,” at Barrow Street Theater (27 Barrow St., at 7th Ave., South of Christopher St.). Show-time is 7 p.m. (free admission). Keep up with TRP through their website: three-roomspress.com.

Puma Perl and Friends will join a special Valentine’s Day show on Sat., Feb. 14, at Beast of Bourbon (710 Myr-

tle Ave., Brooklyn, btw. Spencer & Walworth Sts.). Monica Passin (L’il Mo), with special guest Johnny Jake, will open the show at 7:30 p.m. and the Love Pirates will follow Puma Perl at 11. No cover or admission, great BBQ and a full bar, including over 100 kinds of bourbon. This is a Bicycle Joe Low Fi Sound and Vision Production. More information about Puma Perl can be found at pumaperl.blogspot.com.

THREE ROOMS, continued from p. 16

Creativity and combustion

Ryan Buynak, at Cornelia Street Cafe, taking part in Three Rooms Press’ “Prose! Poetry! Party! 2!” event.

Jane LeCroy, at a Three Rooms Press installment of “The Monthly.”

PH

OTO

BY LYN

N C

APP

IELLO

PH

OTO

BY LYN

N C

APP

IELLO


BY SCOTT STIFFLER

MRS. MAYFIELD’S FIFTH-GRADE CLASS OF ‘93 20-YEAR REUNION

Created in collaboration with the original 2013 cast — five of whom got back together for this current pro-duction — this self-professed “party play” has its own tale to tell about the reunion of a once-tight ensemble. “When you’re in fifth grade, child-hood becomes more complicated,” says playwright Mariah MacCarthy, who grafts that loss-of-innocence theme onto a group of thirtysomething former school chums who assemble in an East Village apartment for an eve-ning of revelations, romance and re-assessment. With bellies warmed by chili and inhibitions lowered by beer, this immersive class reunion lets you wander the apartment, soak in the proceedings and participate according to your personal comfort level (a red name tag means “Don’t talk to me,” while a green one gives the “go” signal for interaction). Emotionally epic and physically intimate (only 15 audience members at each performance), this unabashed display of adults revert-ing to their childhood (and childish!) selves doesn’t shy away from conflict — but knows when to call a time out and take an awesome 90s music dance break.

Performances through Feb. 8. Thurs.–Sun. at 8 p.m. in an East Village apart-ment (exact location and directions provid-ed upon ticket purchase). For reservations ($18), visit brownpapertickets.com. For info on the play, visit capslocktheatre.com.

THE TRAGEDY OF ROMEO AND JULIET

Founded in 2010 by NYU Tisch School of the Arts freshmen Dan Hasse and Rose Bochner, Shake-speare in the Square has grown by leaps and bounds — while never straying far from their academ-ic stomping grounds or the origi-nal Elizabethan staging practices that typify this youthful ensemble’s back-to-basics approach. “Our hope is to blow the dust of Shakespeare’s plays and revive the bear-baiting, beer-drinking rowdiness of Eliza-bethan theatre,” says Hasse, whose company makes their Off-Broadway debut at The Gym at Judson. Equally auspicious is the fact that they’ll be indoors this time (Washington Square

Park has provided a venue four years running, and they’ll be back when the weather improves). Based on text from the 1623 First Folio collection of Shakespeare plays, this fast and ac-cessible production (“The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet”) has its small com-pany of four men and one woman interacting with some of the audience members.

Through Feb. 8. Tues., Thurs., Sat. & Sun. at 8 p.m. Fri. at 7 p.m. & 10 p.m., with matinees every Sun. at 2 p.m. $15 student matinees on Mon., Jan. 26 & Feb. 2 at 10:30 a.m. At The Gym at Judson (243 Thompson St. | btw. South Wash-ington Square & 3rd St.). Tickets: $45. For $75, seating up front gets you one drink and the opportunity to interact with the characters. Reservations at shakespearein-thesquare.com.

TALKING BAND presents THE GOLDEN TOAD

Now in its 40th year — having created over 50 original works while making stops at stalwart spaces in-cluding PS122, Theater for the New City, Dance Theater Workshop, The Ohio Theater, The Flea Theater and HERE Arts Center — Talking Band can hardly be accused of failing in their commitment to “radical col-laboration and a fusion of diverse theatrical styles and perspectives.” If only the same confident sense of self could be said for the shifting, searching characters who populate “The Golden Toad.” Asking “Where is the ‘real’ person to be found in the ebb and flow of identity?” more out of curiosity than the need for a defin-itive answer, “Toad” unifies site-spe-cific works undertaken over the past few years: at a townhouse garden in downtown Brooklyn, on a bus tour of the New Jersey Meadowlands, and in a pop-up thrift store. This La MaMa production moves its audi-ence through reimagined versions of those locations — then concludes at the titular Golden Toad karaoke bar, where all the characters’ lives finally intersect for an evening of revelation and transformation.

Jan. 23–Feb. 7, at La MaMa’s Ellen Stewart Theatre (66 E. 4th St. | btw. Bow-ery & 2nd Ave.). Jan. 23, 26, 28, 29, 30 & Feb. 4–6 at 7 p.m. Jan. 24, 31 & Feb. 7 at 2 p.m. Jan. 25 & Feb. 1 at 4 p.m. Addi-tional Mon. performance, Jan. 26 at 7 p.m. Tickets: $25 ($20 for students & seniors). Reservations: call 646-430-5374 or visit lamama.org. For artist info, visit talking-band.org.

Just Do Art

Former fifth-grade classmates reunite, in an actual East Village apart-ment. The immersive, interaction-optional party play happens through Feb. 8, at a location revealed only to ticket buyers.

Wherefore art thou? Indoors, for a change, when Shakespeare in the Square brings its “Romeo and Juliet” to The Gym at Judson.

A karaoke bar is your fourth and final stop, when the audience joins a cast of intersecting characters at “The Golden Toad.”

PH

OTO

BY K

ACEY STAM

ATSC

OU

RTESY O

F SHAK

ESPEAR

E IN TH

E SQU

ARE

PH

OTO

BY SU

ZANN

E OP

TON


Buhmann on Art

BY STEPHANIE BUHMANN (stephaniebuhmann.com)

As if to advocate a year of rich diversity ahead, this eclectic group show brings together

20 contemporary artists. Here, sub-jects vary as much as the styles in which they are depicted, covering figurative, abstract and some nuanc-es in-between.

While the sculptural installation by Gabriel Specter, Richard Hambleton’s figurative and yet Franz Kline-in-spired “Dancing Shadowman” and Deborah Claxton’s photographic im-ages might have little in common, they gain by playing against each other candidly. It is this contextual contrast that allows “20in15” to slow-ly gather steam. While each of the art-ists represents a certain aesthetic and medium, they share the roles of com-mentators and explorers of their time.

Interestingly, Susan Breen, Thomas Buildmore, Hiro Ichikawa and Mark Mastroianni, among others, comment on today’s world by dipping into vari-ous references to the past. Jo Ellen Van Ouwerkerk’s remarkable composition “A Gift of Wind to Amuse and Mysti-fy” — which depicts an array of per-haps identical female figures flowing freely in space — alludes to the Surre-alist fantasies of Leonora Carrington. Cycle’s circular rendition of a Tyranno-saurus rex chasing, and being chased by, a wolf offers an unusual blend of street art, Native American symbolism and pop. By allowing for such unpre-dictable discoveries, “20in15” guar-antees a playful and refreshingly not self-important slice of the Downtown New York art world of 2015.

GROUP EXHIBITION“20in15”

Through February 28

At Woodward Gallery133 Eldridge St.btw. Broome & Delancey Sts.

Tues.–Sat., 11a.m.–6 p.m.Sun., 12–5p.m. and by private appointment

Call 212-966-3411 or visit WoodwardGallery.net

Jo Ellen Van Ouwerkerk: “A Gift of Wind to Amuse and Mystify” (2010 | Acrylic on canvas | 11 x 14 inches; 27.9 x 35.6 cm | Signed on verso | Framed).

Cycle: “Rex vs. Rex” (2013 | Acrylic on canvas | 48 x 48 inches; 121.92 x 121.92 cm | Signed on verso).

Stickman: “Threaded” (2014 | Acrylic on plexiglass | 27 x 15 inches; 68.58 x 38.1 cm).

CO

UR

TESY WO

OD

WAR

D G

ALLERY

CO

UR

TESY WO

OD

WAR

D G

ALLERY

CO

UR

TESY WO

OD

WAR

D G

ALLERY


seems that it is time to look at police procedures and education.

Beginning on the night of Aug. 6, 1988, there was a protest over a cur-few in Tompkins Square Park that resulted in what was subsequently dubbed a police riot.

The previous week, the cops in the park had been involved in what they perceived to have been a compro-mised situation with some local an-archists. The police felt they needed to instill some respect for authority, so they convinced the community board to set a curfew on Tompkins Square Park, the only park in the city without a curfew.

The cops made a deal with the homeless and the other late-night park hang arounds that they could stay in Tompkins as long as they kept away from the front section of the park, by the Avenue A and St. Mark’s Place entrance.

Within minutes, the park’s front section was cleared and the conflict began to get out of hand. The angry police charged out of the park and into the streets, indiscriminate-ly attacking anyone in their path, beating and shoving those who hap-pened to have the misfortune to be on the streets.

Eventually, the police settled on Avenue A and E. Sixth St. At least that is the location where I spent the rest of the night with Elsa. At 6 a.m. the curfew was over, the park was back open, and Elsa and I ended up with a 3-hour-and-33-minute video-tape of the night’s goings-on.

The tape exposed much police misconduct. There were more than 125 complaints related to police vi-olence, and numerous residents — most of them unrelated to the protest — ended up in the hospital. These people had just been at the wrong place at the wrong time.

The evidence on the tape led to six cops being criminally indicted, the Ninth Precinct captain moving out of the precinct, cops fired. But the most damning detail was the part of the tape where a commanding officer was attempting to exercise some control over the situation. The lower-ranking cops, however, paid no attention and took off chasing protesters. There was no respect for authority or the chain of command.

The tape was a breakthrough in the use of the new technology, Ci-vilian Journalism, the community’s defense against police misconduct. However, it sent me into 20 years worth of criminal, civil and depart-mental court battles, numerous ar-rests, and an inside look and educa-tion into the inner workings of the judicial system.

It also was the beginning of a pe-riod of four solid years worth of pro-tests, a number of riots, hundreds of arrests, and the reorganizing of the N.Y.P.D. In addition to my record of the events, there was another au-thoritative 20-minute videotape tak-en that night by Paul Garrin.

In short, the Lower East Side be-came a hands-on training ground for the N.Y.P.D. On Aug. 6, 1988, cops on horses, in helicopters, along with several hundred riot police and a command center could not close a 10.5-acre park on the L.E.S.

But by 1992, the police could con-trol the streets. In 2001, the cops, in a couple of hours, were able to shut down three airports, and all the bridges, tunnels, ferries, railways, subways, buses and street traffic.

Early on, the focus of the protests was on police brutality, the inef-fective Civilian Complaint Review Board (C.C.R.B.), the effort to impose a park curfew, the homeless crisis, the closing of the park, the tearing down of the park’s band shell, the housing crisis, squat evictions and the encroaching gentrification that was starting to take over the neigh-borhood.

In the beginning, it was rank-ing cops, like Captain Fry, pushing the blue shirts with his nightstick, screaming, “Form a line, form a line.”

It was not unusual for a protest to go on for more than a day. For the cops, it was an overtime bonanza. During that time, a cop retired at his last year’s salary. It was possible to retire at double salary. For the smart

commander, it became a golden ladder moving up the chain of com-mand.

Several chiefs of police came out of the struggle, including Hoehl, Ju-lian, Gelphan and Esposito. Esposito boasted that he would never have become a chief it had not been for the Tompkins Square Park conflicts.

Dinkins became mayor and the administration focused on reorga-nizing the Police Department. Many older cops retired, and a new crop of younger cops was hired. The new Mollen Commission cleaned out a number of cops involved in the il-legal drug business and started to

centralize the department. The protesters could rule the

L.E.S. streets until 1992. The police practiced different forms of organiz-ing, including putting one sergeant in charge of six cops. They brought in scooters, tried a wedge formation, and after practice, practice, practice, by 1992 they gained control of the streets. If a protester stepped into the street, he would be arrested.

The Police Riot was at the end of Koch’s third term. The department’s reorganization was under Dinkins. Giuliani inherited a well-organized, razor-sharp, paramilitary Police De-partment. Giuliani brought in Brat-ton as his police commissioner. Brat-ton partnered with the transit cop Jack Maple, and they changed the streets of New York City, probably forever.

Bratton and Maple were influ-enced by the concept Safe Streets, which allowed police to believe that if they concentrated on petty crime, the number of more serious crimes would be cut. If the police could stop people from hanging out on street corners, in front of bodegas and out-side the projects, that would thwart the opportunities of street criminal activity and would help bring order to a community.

Bratton’s zero-tolerance policy ini-tiated programs like stop-and-frisk. At the same time, Bratton worked on making the department more ethi-cally diverse.

Bratton was as hard on the pre-cinct commanders as he was on

When police and protesters clashed on the L.E.S.;

CLASH, continued on p. 21

CLASH, continued from p. 1

Protesters took over Avenue A — as they often did — in 1991.

In a grab from Clayton Patterson’s 1988 Tompkins Square Park riot vid-eotape, Ken Fish is shown bloodied after being struck by police. A New York Times article on the riot report-ed that Fish, 29, was a bystander who had been clubbed by police and need-ed 44 stitches to close a 3-inch gash in his forehead.

PH

OTO

S BY C

LAYTON

PATTERSO

N


The cops won, but what were the lessons learned?those residents who were active in the inner-city street culture. He was influenced by a new community po-lice management philosophy called Comp Stat — an analysis of comput-er statistics on crime for each pre-cinct.

A main focus of CompStat was holding commanders accountable for any rise in crime in their pre-cincts. Crime took a dramatic down-turn, and Bratton became the dar-ling of mainstream America, even making the cover of TIME magazine — though he was not such a hero to many in the inner-city minority community.

But in a universe where Giuliani had to be the center of attention, Bratton’s success became his down-fall, and soon he was pushed out the door.

Ghosts from the past can reappear. Bratton comes back as de Blasio’s po-lice commissioner, and ex-Mayor Gi-uliani becomes an expert commen-tator for Fox TV.

Giuliani’s tendency is to find fault in most black leaders — including President Obama, Attorney Gener-al Holder, Al Sharpton — and talk about family values.

Yet, there is no question that Giuliani ended all the costly squat-eviction protests on the L.E.S. the day he made the remaining buildings legal, and the squatters became property owners.

During the L.E.S. years of turmoil, the cops who became police chiefs had the ability and the expertise to deal with both the cops and the pro-testers, as well as, to appease City Hall. This was a delicate balance. The chief had to keep a close rein on the cops, as there were some who had the tendency to take the law into their own hands, with the belief that they had the right to deal out jus-tice by inflicting severe punishment with the use of their nightstick.

If a commander was too aggres-sive and antagonistic toward the protesters, the end result could be a riot, or at the very least, injured protesters or cops, and a conflict that could go on for a long period of time.

On the other hand, to maintain respect and to have the confidence of the rank-and-file cops, the com-mander could not be perceived as being too passive or compromising in any way.

Police chiefs also had to evaluate whether the arrest was worth clog-ging the criminal courts or if a ticket would suffice. It was all about the bottom line.

There were many times during the years of protests when the ten-

sions between the protesters and the cops were high. But never, from what I am aware of, did anyone in-tentionally try to maim a cop. There were certainly no plots to kill a cop.

Considering how many battles were fought, there were few per-manent injuries on either side of the conflict. There is no question that there was hardcore resistance on both fronts, just as each side had their own radicals. The radical pro-testers did random acts of vandal-ism, broke windows, set fires on the street and burned down a homeless camp before it was evicted. They spray-painted resistance graffiti, threw bottles, flattened a few tires, but did not use Molotov cocktails, or any kind of deadly force.

The radical cops would pep-per-spray protesters in the eyes, whack people on the head with their nightsticks. They would also tar-get individuals by making a ques-tionable arrest and trump up the charges. And after an arrest, cops would bend the handcuffs, which caused severe pain, or tighten the handcuffs to the point of causing the hands to go numb.

Another trick was they would make up a false complaint, go to an approachable judge, and get a search warrant.

Both sides made verbal threats to each other. As time went on, though, the equation changed and there is no question that the police had more power.

The recent vitriolic rhetoric by Patrick Lynch, the head of the Pa-trolmen’s Benevolent Association — blaming the mayor, civil rights lead-ers and protesters for contributing to the killing of the two cops — is using a terrible tragedy for political grandstanding. Perhaps he is mak-

ing a play for his next election, or he is losing control.

The cops turning their backs on the mayor — their boss, our elected official — is disregarding the will of the people, and is not only disre-spectful but dangerous.

I understand why white Ameri-cans — especially white cops — dis-like Al Sharpton. He has the ability both to hold the system accountable and to bring mass public attention to a questionable death of a black per-son at the hands of the police. But he never calls for violence. Protests and free speech are protected under the Constitution.

De Blasio, as a mayor of all of the people, was trying to be protect the rights of the protesters to express their point of view, and to give the cops enough authority to take con-trol if a situation got out of hand, which I am sure the N.Y.P.D. can do. Too much resistance can incite violence and unnecessary hostility. Most protests will remain peaceful and “walk themselves out.”

My experience taught me that the masses just want a way to ex-press their outrage, not be violent. If you stop the protest march from crossing a bridge, the mass blockage stops traffic. If they march across the bridge, the inconvenience passes with the march. They need an end goal where they can hold a protest rally.

The solution Lynch is suggesting — to give the police the ultimate authority — would mean we are living in a police state. And what is the problem with de Blasio, even as mayor, telling his children that because they are black, it can mean dealing with a different set of rules?

No, I do not believe most cops are racist. The system is set up to be un-

equal. The divisions are wide. It took me a few years of living in a

drug-saturated community to get an inside look at who sells drugs, who buys drugs, who uses drugs, the in-stitutional racial discrimination.

Starting with Operation Pressure Point in 1984, hundreds of people involved in the illegal drug business went to jail — and with the Rocke-feller Drug Laws, it was not unheard of to get a sentence of 20 years or more.

Over the years, hundreds of peo-ple involved in the drug trade were incarcerated. That is the law. But what the law doesn’t explain is why most of the people in jail are black and Hispanic. The majority of peo-ple coming into our community to buy drugs were white, often from New Jersey. It is a common practice for a buyer to be supplying more than just him- or herself.

After President Reagan was elect-ed, it was no secret: It was snowing cocaine on Wall St. Back then, there was all the glamour connected to co-caine — using hundred-dollar bills or specially designed gold spoons to sniff the powder, the keychain orna-ments to hold your coke, the razor-blade jewelry.

The out-of-control celebrity types were being habitually arrested and going to rehab, and there were the oft-told public tales of rock’n’roll-ers’ use of illegal drugs, the Mollen Commission’s findings exposing the drug-related corruption in the Police Department, and on and on.

Yet, the prison system does not reflect this difference. Illegal drugs are everywhere. Yet the ones ending up in jail are black or Hispanic. Just as the majority of individuals who end up dead in a situation involving the police are black men.

We are in self-denial if we cannot see this point. We need an Al Sharp-ton to keep us aware of what is going on. Let the courts settle the matter.

I believe the majority of New Yorkers — certainly including the mayor, Al Sharpton and most of the protesters — are outraged two police officers were assassinated. It is time for a little restraint and to start to ac-tually deal with our social problems before things spin completely out of control. There have to be splits in the Police Department as the rhetoric starts to become so divisive.

In the end, the police proved that by having a disciplined force, com-petent experienced leaders, using standard police procedure, they could control the streets. I am not sure how things got so out of control that the police needed to become so militarized. How did the police be-come so afraid of the citizens they are paid to protect?

CLASH, continued from p. 20

Clayton Patterson being swarmed and arrested by plainclothes police offi-cers. For years after his infamous riot videotape, Patterson was a marked man as far as the police were concerned.

PH

OTO

BY Q

. SAKAM

AKI



Bias charge against Li ‘unsubstantiated’: B.P.recommended candidates for last June’s board elections, in which Li was re-elected C.B. 3 chairperson] and three other African-Americans being appointed to leadership posi-tions.”

Indeed, in November, Alysha Lew-is-Coleman was appointed the sec-ond vice chairperson of the C.B. 3 Ex-ecutive Committee, while Vaylateena Jones was named chairperson of the Health, Seniors and Human Services Committee, and Lisa Burriss was tapped to chair the newly formed Public Housing Subcommittee.

Harrington added, “I’m also very

hopeful because the borough presi-dent has created so many opportuni-ties for community board members — and their staff — to take Leadership in Diversity and E.E.O. training.”

As she spoke, Harrington notice-ably emphasized the word “staff.”

All city employees — including community board staff — must take E.E.O. training, and board staff must also take Leadership in Diversity training, according to Brewer’s office.

As opposed to paid community board staff, such as a district man-ager, community board members — including board chairpersons — are not city employees but volunteers.

However, Caras said, “We’re high-

ly encouraging all community board members to participate [in E.E.O. training] as well.”

Similarly, Bartlett said, “the new thing” being pushed by Brewer is that community board members are being urged to take an E.E.O. and Leadership in Diversity “training series.” These sessions are relatively brief, done over a few days.

Asked if one of the recommended “remedial actions” in the letter sent to her at the investigation’s conclusion was that she undergo E.E.O. stan-dard non-discrimination training, Li told The Villager, “I cannot speak to the Manhattan borough president’s investigation or its results. The Man-

hattan borough president’s office en-couraged all board chairpersons and board members to attend both the E.E.O. training, as well as the Lead-ership in Diversity training. Many C.B. 3 board members attended those trainings, myself included.”

She added, “I continue to make leadership appointments based on a variety of factors, including but not limited to knowledge related to com-mittee area, ability to work well with others, and diversity in representa-tion.”

Stetzer, when asked if the report recommended that she, too, take E.E.O. training, responded, “Some-body told you wrong.”

C.B. 3, continued from p. 7

Feeling quite chipper; Mulch ado about old trees

New Yorkers celebrated the 19th annual MulchFest last weekend by recycling their Christmas trees at more than 80 locations citywide. The chipped trees become compost that will nourish parks, gardens and woodsy public areas around the city. At left, Mitchell Silver, the Parks Department’s commissioner, showed how it’s done as he mulched the program’s first trees this year on Thurs., Jan. 8, in Tompkins Square Park. Participants were invited to take a free bag of mulch home. In all, more than 30,000 trees were recycled. In a statement, Mayor de Blaiso said, “This city is committed to being the greenest big city in the world, and events like MulchFest are an important step toward achieving this critical goal.”

PH

OTO

BY D

ANIEL AVILA / N

YC PAR

KS


OUR BRAND-NEW EMERGENCY

DEPARTMENT IS NOW OPEN.

AND WE HOPE YOU NEVER

GET TO SEE IT.

We’ve completely rebuilt our emergency department since the devastation of Hurricane Sandy. State-of-the-art improvements have been made, and it’s now triple the size of the former ED, with treatment areas that have room for families at bedside. We provide experts in virtually every specialty to handle emergencies for both adults and children, and specialized teams on call for stroke and heart attack. But to truly appreciate our new emergency department at Tisch Hospital, you have to see it in person. And we hope you never get to do that. To learn more, visit nyulmc.org/emergency

INTRODUCING THE RONALD O. PERELMAN CENTER FOR EMERGENCY SERVICES. 570 FIRST AVENUE AT 33RD STREET.

NYU1470_ER_NYC_Community_8.75x11.5_release.indd 1 8/19/14 5:25 PM

Documents

EAST VILLAGER NEWS, JAN. 22, 2015