6
EXPERI MENT AL GASTROENTEROLOGY Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of nonhypotensive sepsis S rI·l'l lEN Slll l lVAN, MD, FRCPC, F RCP( LOND), M lt'llAEL TROSTER, MD, FRCPC, AnMt LINTON, MB, FRCP(EDIN), FRCPC S SULLIVAN, M TROSTER, A LI NTON. Early hepatic dysfun ction in a large animal model of nonhypotensive sepsis. Can J Ga strocnterol 1991 ;5(6):219- 223 . epsis was induced in 12 sh eep by ceca l deva~cular ization and perforation. lmravenous crysta ll oid was administered to mainta in the pulmonary capillary wedge press ure at preseptic leve l s. By 24 h t he re was ,1 signifi ca nt drop in alb umin and alkaline phosphatase with increases in aspa rtatc aminotransferase (AST), laccate de hydrogenase and bilirubin. By 48 h the alka line phos phatase had returned to presepsis levels, the bilirubin co ntinu ed co rise, the AST and lacrnte deh• 1 drogenasc had plmea ued while the a lhumin rema ined l ow. T hese bioc hemi- ca l altera tions were confir med by exa min ing data from 25 sh eer used in similar epsis expe riments. These data revealed th at marked elevat ions in AST were as~ociared wi th a high er ce n tra l ve nous pressure and worse renal impairment , but there was no relatio nship with any other h emody namic paramete r, P02, pl-! or ~erum l actare. l listo logi ca ll y these bi oc hemi ca l al terat ions were associaLed with extensi ve m icrovesicular fan y change al 24 h a nd cen trilohular necrosis at 48 h. Elec tro n. microscopy reveal ed mi toc hond rial degeneration, hyperplasia of the smooch endop lasmic ret iculum : rnd intracellular cholestasis. Key Words: Cholestasis, l lepatic dysfunction, Liver, Multiorganfailure, Sej)s is Debut de dysfonctionnement hepatique clans un grand modele animal de septicemie non hypotensive RESUME: On a provoquc une sept i cemic c h ez 12 mou tons en cffectua nt une dcvascula ri smio n et perforation J u caec um. Des cr i sta llo"ides one cce adrni nistres par vo ie int rave ineuse afin de ma inte nir la pression ca pillaire pulmonaire au nivcau anterieur a la septi ce mie. En 24 heures, on a n ote u nc dim inut io n signifi cat ive des co nce ntrations d'a lbumine et de phos ph arases alca lines ai nsi qu'u ne e l cva Li on de l'asparrate a minotransferase (AST ), de la l ac ti codes- hydrogenasc (LOH) et de la bilirubine. Au bout de 48 he ures, les va leurs des phosph mases alcalin es cta ienr remu rn ecs a lcur niveau i niti al, la bilirubinc con ti nu ait a augm enter et les AST et LOH eraienr st at ion na ires randis que l 'a lbumine resta it fa ible. Les resul tats portant sur 25 mouto ns ayant servi a des ex periences du meme type ont co n fi rmc ces modifi cat ions biochimi q ues. Ces Det,m-m1<mL, ofM~Jici11e and Paclwlo,{f.)', V1cwru1 I lmJ,iwl, London, ( )111mw Cmws/>onJ.!11c.!: /)1 Steplie11 S111/im11, De/ummenr of Medic me. 1'i11~ Flllwd r los/ntal, I'() Box 22490, R1:,otUlh I /.f26, Smuli Ara/)f(r. Fm 966 I 49/ /876 Recerwd /or Jnihlinwon Ma'/ 31, / 991. AcceJnd Nm•emher 8, / 9',) I CAN J G1\STROl·NTFRUI VL11 5 Nl 1 6 NlWE~lllER/l )WEMnl,R 1 991 H EP/\ TIC IWSl·UNC TION ( 1C< 'UR- ring dur ing the course of systemic sepsis b well recognized ( 1-6). If hypo- rensinn docs no t occur the major ah- norma I iue, me increase~ in alkaline phosphatase and biliruhin with the oc- Gb11mal deve lopment of dinical jaun- dice. Pcrs1,1 ing hyperh il irubinemra 1, a,sociat ed wirh poor prognosi:, (2). The pa th ogenc,i, uf Lhcse abnorma lities rc1 m1 ins an cn1gm,1, bur may be due to an endmoxin inducL·d reduction in bile flow (5). li\'er histul1>gy b 11,ually mild- ly abn1mn,1l ,md ,hnw, n1mspecific ch,mges ( l .Z). In wntra,t tn the chole- sLauc changes uf nurm,11cn,ive sepsi s, hypotens r on and hypoxia can produce mmked elevauuns 111 ,L·nrm I rans- am rna,es, a:,:,ociated wr rh cemri lnhu l ar h epmic nccrn:,is (8). ln the present srudy the auth1ws clocumenL the early biochemical and histological changes associated with nunhyp111 ens1vc sepsis mduccd by ex- pe n mem,11 peritnniris in ,heep. MATERIALS AND METHODS The exper imental protoco l h as been described previously (7-10). Twdve sheep aged betwee n nine and 18 mnm hs, weighing hetween 10 and 50 kg were used. Twenty -four hums prior to initial surgery solid luod wa, wllh- held, hut rhe sheep were allowed free ,1Ccess to wate r. Under halothane anes- thes ia and af t er en d,1trache,il intuh: 1- 219

Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

EXPERIMENT AL GASTROENTEROLOGY

Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of nonhypotensive sepsis

S rI· l'l lEN Slll l lVAN, MD, FRCPC, FRCP(LOND), M lt'llAEL TROSTER, MD, FRCPC, AnMt LINTON, MB, FRCP(EDIN), FRCPC

S SULLIVAN, M TROSTER, A LINTON. Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of nonhypotensive sepsis. Can J Gastrocnterol 1991 ;5(6):219-223 . epsis was induced in 12 sheep by cecal deva~cularization and perforation . lmravenous crystallo id was administe red to maintain th e pulmonary capillary wedge pressure a t preseptic levels. By 24 h t he re was ,1 significant drop in albumin and a lka line phosphatase with inc reases in aspartatc aminotransferase (AST), laccate dehydrogenase and bilirubin. By 48 h the alkaline phosphatase had returned to presepsis levels, the bili rubin continued co rise, t he AST and lacrn te deh•1drogenasc had plmeaued while the a lhumin remained low. T hese biochemi­cal alterations were confirmed by exam ining da ta from 25 sheer used in simi lar epsis experiments. These data revealed that marked elevations in AST were

as~ociared with a high er cen tral venous pressure an d worse ren a l impa irment, but there was no relationshi p with any other hemodynamic parameter, P02, pl-! or ~erum lactare. l listologically these biochemical alterat ions were associaLed with extensive m icrovesicular fan y change a l 24 h and centrilohula r necros is at 48 h. Electron. microscopy revea led mi tochondrial degeneration , hyperplas ia of th e smooch endoplasmic reticulum :rnd intrace llular ch o lestasis.

Key Words: Cholestasis, l lepatic dysfunction, Liver, Multiorganfailure, Sej)sis

Debut de dysfonctionnement hepatique clans un grand modele animal de septicemie non hypotensive

RESUME: On a provoquc une septicemic chez 12 moutons en cffectuant une dcvascularismion et perforation J u caecum. Des cr istallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capilla ire pulmo na ire au nivcau a nterieur a la sept icemie. En 24 he ures, on a note unc dimin ut ion significat ive des concentratio ns d'a lbumine et de phospharases alcalines ai nsi qu'u ne e lcva Lion de l'asparrate aminotransferase (AST ), de la lacticodes­hydrogenasc (LOH) et de la bilirubine. A u bout de 48 heures, les valeurs des phosphmases alcalines ctaienr remurnecs a lcur n iveau initial, la bilirubinc continuait a augmenter et les AST et LOH eraienr station naires randis que l'a lbumine restait fa ible. Les resultats portan t sur 25 moutons ayan t serv i a des experiences du meme type on t confi rmc ces modifications biochimiques. Ces

Det,m-m1<mL, ofM~Jici11e and Paclwlo,{f.)', V1cwru1 I lmJ,iwl, London, ( )111mw

Cmws/>onJ.!11c.!: /)1 Steplie11 S111/im11, De/ummenr of Medic me. 1'i11~ Flllwd r los/ntal, I'() Box 22490, R1:,otUlh I /.f26, Smuli Ara/)f(r. Fm 966 I 49/ /876

Recerwd /or Jnihlinwon Ma'/ 31, / 991. AcceJnd Nm•emher 8, / 9',) I

CAN J G1\STROl·NTFRUI VL11 5 Nl 1 6 NlWE~lllER/l)WEMnl,R 1991

HEP/\ TIC IWSl·UNC TION ( 1C< 'UR­

ring during the course of systemic sepsis b well recognized ( 1-6). If hypo­rensinn docs not occur the major ah­norma I iue, me increase~ in alkaline phosphatase and bil iruh in with the oc­Gb11mal development of dinical jaun ­dice. Pcrs1,1 ing hyperhil irubinemra 1, a,sociat ed wirh poor prognosi:, (2). The pathogenc,i, uf Lhcse abnormalit ies rc1m1 ins an cn1gm,1, bur may be due to an endmoxin inducL·d reduction in bile flow (5). li\'er histul1>gy b 11,ually mild­ly abn1mn,1l ,md ,hnw, n1mspecific ch,mges ( l .Z). In wntra,t tn the chole­sLauc changes uf nurm,11cn,ive sepsis, hypotensron and hypoxia can produce mmked elevauuns 111 ,L·nrm I rans­am rna,es , a:,:,ociated wr rh cemri lnhu lar hepmic nccrn:,is (8).

ln the present sr udy the auth1ws clocumenL the early biochem ical and histo logical changes associated with nunhyp111 ens1vc sepsis mduccd by ex­pen mem,11 peritnniris in ,heep.

MATERIALS AND METHODS The exper imental protocol has been

described previously (7-10). Twdve sheep aged between nine and 18 mnmhs, weighing hetween 10 and 50 kg were used. Twenty-four hums prior to initial surgery solid luod wa, wllh­held, hut rhe sheep were allowed free ,1Ccess to water. Under halothane anes­thes ia and af ter end,1trache,il intuh:1-

219

Page 2: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

SUI.IIV,\N ~L Lii

donnees ont de p lus revele quc les hausscs marquees d'AST crnient assoc,ees l1 unc prcssion veincuse centrale plus c levee et a une insuffisance hcpntique plus grave, mais qu'il n'cxisrnit aucun lie n avec d'aurres para metres hemn<lynamiqucs, P02, pH ou lactates seriq ucs. Sur le plan histologiquc, ccs modifications hiochi miques s'accompngnaient d'unc dcgcncrescencc gra isseusc micro­vesicu laire etenduc a 24 heures et d'unc nccrnsc centro-lobulaire a 48 heurcs. Un examen au m icroscope c lcctronique a revelc une dcgcnere~cence mito­chondrialc, une hypcrplasie du reticulum endoplasmmique agranulaire ct une cho le.stase intracellula ire.

Linn rhe .1orta was cmhcteri:ed with a

si last ic GHhe1er, the pulmonary artery

with c1 tnplc lumen fl nw directed right heart catheter, and the urinnry hladder with a self rewin1ng Foley c.nheter. The~hcep wcre allmvcd l\l recover 111 a

metahnlic cage with free :1CCL'ss 10 food and water fnr m least 24 h hcfc1rc induc­

tion ot scpsis. J 111 raven nus Ringers' lac­rate wns adm1n istercd HI a rnte of 8 L/24 h to volume In.id rhc animab.

Control measun.?menrs n( hemndy­namic, ren,1 I and hepatic (unction were

obrnined 4 h hcfme induct ion o( sepsis. Under general ant::sthesi:i a mid-linc laparotomy was perfimrn:d. The cccum and ilencecal junction were 1dcnttficLI and al l of the cecum to with in 5 cm nf the ileoceca, valvc was dt::\'ascu lari:ed. A quanmy llf fecal material wa, al­

lowed to remain in the cccum and the distal cecum wa, lig,iu.:d w1Ch ~ 2 silk . A

local omcntcctomy was rerformed tn

prevent locali:arion of° int'ect ion . A 2 cm perforatilln was 1nc1de 1n the cecal lip and fec.11 material wa;, a llowed ro spill into the pern111,1l C.l\'i ty. T he ahdomcn

was ckised with a running sutu rc. Animals were ,1lluwed to recover in a mt::tnbol,c cage. Over 1hc ensuing 12 h all animals hcg;1n ro , how cli nic.1 1

TABLE 1

evidence of ~Yl:>temic infection as evi­dcnccd by increasing re:.piratory ratc

and devclopmem of fever, lethargy and ,morexia.

PoMoperatively, fluid admin1Mra­t inn was guided by the pulmonary

capillary wedge pressure. Sufficient 1ntravenou:. cry:.talloid was infused to

111ainta111 the balloon occluded wedge pressure at presepsis levels.

The pulmonary capi llary wedge pressure, mean arterial pressure, cemrnl venous pressure, h eart rnte, respiratory

rate, thermudilution cardiac output and systemic vascular resistance index wt::re measured prior to surgery and re­pcated daily for the duration of the ex­periment. Blood was obtained fro m the artt::rial line for daily measuremems of hlood gases and from the venous line

for hemoglobin, whire blood cell count, albumin, creatinine, urea, total bili ru­

bi n , asrartate aminotransferase (AST),

and lactate dehydmgenase. Blood was abn drawn for aerobic and anaerobic culture in broth and subculture on hlond and chocolate ag,1r. U rine was collected for measurement of creatin­ine ,md calcubtion nf creatinine clear-ancc.

ln six sheep I ivcr biopsies were per-

Hemodynomic parameters at baseline, and 24 and 48 h ofter induction of sepsis

Parameter

Number

Mean arterial pressure (mmHg)

Heart rate (beats/min)

Cardiac Index CL/min/m2)

Systemic vascular resistance index Cd·s·cm-5/m2)

Pulmonary capillary wedge p ressure (mmHg)

Central venous pressure (cm H20)

·change from baseline significant P<005

220

Baseline

12 108±13 87±24 5.0±1. l

1727±356

12+4

3±3

24 h

12 104±12 149±31 ' 5.3±1.8

1636±441

13:!.7

5.t6

48 h

10 115±8 152±21' 6.7±3.3'

1452±413'

13±4

3+3

formed at the rnne of induction uf scp·

sb. ln three Trucut li ver hll1ps1es were performed at 24 hand in nnocher three at 48 h . The t ts.sue for light micm,nipy wa~ immed iately fi xcd in IO'rc, tonnalm

and subsequently pruccs~ed hy the

usua l paraffin emhcdd111g techntques. All ~ect ions were sta111ed with hcma­toxylin and t'Osin, Chrnmotrupe­Aniline blue (for collagen) an,I

colloidal iron (for ulhum in). Thc speci­mens for e lectron 111 icmsc,1py were

fixed in 3% cold glurnraldchydl' anJ post fixed in I l}(, osmium lei rox1de. The

tissues were dehydrmcd in ;1 grndeJ series of a lcohols nnd cmheddcd 111

Epon-Aralvite. Sect ions nf 80 nm wen' cu t on the Reichcn Om-2 ulirn­microtome and , tamed wi t h akllhl1l1t

uranyl acetate and Rcynnld\ 11:aJ acetate. The section, Wl'rc examined

on a Ph ilips 410 clccrrnn microscope. This model of scpsts prnved uni­

formly fatal. no ani1m1l surviv 111g hc­

yllnd 72 h. S heep that appeared agnnal were immediately kill ed hy intr;11•enou, injection nf penroharhiwl. During rh~ studies sheep were cared for hy qualified

tcchniciam. Postnpcrmivc ancsthl!sta consisted of meperidine given tnlrn·

venously at 6 t() 8 h inrcrvab. Sheep showing a ny signs of distrcss were 1111-medimely killed as previliusly described. The study prntllCol wa, ap­

p roved by the local ethics com,nittce governing med ical research and 1he care of experimental animals.

T he data are cxprcsscd as t he mean ± standard deviat ion. Analysis of \';Jrt ·

ance was used to exam inc rhc effect of

time o n each o( the dcpendent vmi­ablcs. Data from the presenr group of sht::ep wcrc compared hy two ,ample Student '.s r test with darn from sheep used in similar ,cpsis expcriments (9, 13, 14 ).

RESULTS ln all sheep 1he prcsence o( poll'­

microhial sepsis was cnnfirmed at 24 h by blond culture. The moM frequendy

grown organ isms inc luded Serrwia mar­cescens, En1ero/x1c1cr cloacae, Pseudo­m<mas spccics, /3acrernides speuc, and various strains ut £scheric/1ia coli Autopsy examination rcvealcd marked ahdrnninal distcnsi( ,n wi1 h di,tcmbl

Page 3: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

loops o( howel and large quarn 111cs nf

free peritoneal iluid. An intlammatnry

ma~s was always present in the right

lower quaJrnnt. Hemodynamics: I lenwd yn amic, a t

ha~eline, 24 h .mJ 40 h a rc , hown in

Table I . The mt:,lll arte ria l pressure,

pulmnnar~ capillary ll"edge pre,surl' anJ

cen t ra l vcnnus pressu rl' 11 ere un­

changed whi le heart rate anJ cml1ac

index mcrcased and systemic vascuhr

re~iMance imkl, dl·creased sign ificantly

O\'Cf 48 h. Hematology: The henl(lglohm remain­

ed unchanged (lw,eline 98±1 10 g/L;

24 h I 05±122 g/L, 48 h 98±15 g/L). The

whne hlnod cell count dropped signi fi­

cantly (hasclm e 7.7±4.0 x109/L; 24 h

3.1±1.3; 4 8 h 2.HI.O). Renal parameters: Afte r the mducrilln

oi sepsis the hlood u rea n1tn1gen and

creaun1nc grndu,1 ll y rose while the crcarminc clc.1r:111el' fe ll (Tahk 2). These cl1,111ges were , ignific 1nt a t 48 h. Hepatic biocht:mi!>try: T he ch anges in

hepa tic hinchem is try ,ire shcl\\ n in

Table 2. Bv 24 h the albumin a nd .il kal i ne phc,,,,h.itn,c had d rnppt:d,

while rhc AST and !act ate dchyd ro­genas had nsen. Ar 48 h the a lkaline

pho~phatase had returned to prcseps1s

level~. the a lhumin n:mained lll,1' nnd

the AST and l.icrnte de hydrogen ,1se

had plateaued. Identical changes were

seen in 25 sheep fn,m nther sepsis ex­

periments (Ta hie 1 ). Four of the sheep in this expcn menr

had deq1t1om Ill AST greater than "300 IU/L at 24 h . Therefore, their he mo­

,lynamic and biochemical data wne comhi tll'd \.\ ith data from 25 .,cptic

sheep of orher l'Xperimcms. Fourteen

sheep with ASTs greater th:m 100 lU/L

(mean±Sl), 447±259) wt:re rnmpare,I with 2°3 sheep \\'Ith AST, le,s th,111 mo !U/L (menn±SD, 17 H I 50) . Thm· were no significan t dtffrrences in me,m

arteri a l pressurc, heart rate, card iac in ­

Jex, or ,yste111 1c va,cu lar rcs1stancc in ­

dex. The sheep with lw~h AST had

higher ccntrnl , ·cnous pressures

(6.5±15.8 mml lg \"Crsus 3.3±1.7

mmHg) P=0.02. There were nu di(­

ferences in />Oz, pl l m l.tetate. S imilar­ly, there wt:re no differences in albu­

min, hiliruhtn l,r alkal in e phosphatase.

The sheep with high AST h ;1d higher

Hepatic dysfunction in hypotensive sepsis

TABLE 2 Renal and hepatic parameters at baseline, and 24 and 48 h after induction of sepsis

Parameter Baseline 24 h 48 h Number 12 12 10 Blood urea nitrogen (mmol/L) 5.012 6.5.12.2 8.213.6" Creatinine (µmol/L) 73:t:11 130,78· 176172" Creotinine clearance (ml/min) 162.+47 1131.51 80130" Albumin (g/L) 30±3 22.13· 221_3· Bilirubin (µmol/L) 3tl 814 " 20± 10' Alkaline phosphatase (IU/L) 84t50 48125· 86±72 Lactate dehydrogenase (IU/L) 456±81 572:±.135" 685±208" Aspartate aminotransferase (IU/L) 153±52 241±97' 219± 101 "Change from baseline significant. P<0.05

TABLE 3 Hepatic parameters at baseline, and 24 and 48 h in 25 sheep from other sepsis experiments

Para meter Number Albumin (g/L) Bilirub1n (~1mol/L) Alkaline phosphatase (IU/L) Lactate dehydrogenase (IU/L) Aspartate aminotransferase (IU/L) "Change from baseline significant P<O 05

le,·eb n( urea (5. 3± 1.2 versus 4. 3±1.2 mmnl/L) ,md cre,lt inim· ( 126±73 ver­

sus 96±49 µm u l/L) bur these changes

were not significant.

Ligh t m icroscopy: A lte r 24 h uf sepsb ,

the liver shl1wed quire extensive micro­

vesicular fa t ty c hm1gc and intraccll11lnr

t:dcma (Figure I ). There ,1·,1s Kupffcr

cel l h ypt:rplas1a a nd leukocytes in the

sinusoids. Isolat ed liver cell necmsis

was noted with formation of Counci l­

man hod ies. A ftt:r 48 h of sepsb, the

changes consisted o f cenrri lohular n ec­

rnsis of th e live r lnhulc and dcpos ib of alhumin in the smusl1ids.

Electron m icroscopy: Elccrmn micro­

scopy results uf liver hiups)' arc shuwn

1n Fi.i.:ure 2. A t 24 h the li ver Cl' ll,

shnwed l1p1d Llroplct s in the hcp. 11 0-cyres. The mi r, ichc llldri,1 were increased

tn size and numher with dcgener,ltlve

ch m1ges including luss llf crisrnc, 1ntn1-

mitL>chundrial c rystallrnds ,md mycl 1n

figure furmat ion. Ci.int mitlichnndri;i

were occastonall) seen. The smunth

e ndoplasmic rt:llcu lum was hyperplas­

t ic and in ,llrnc instances thc rough

cndnplasm1c reticulum abo slwwed in­

crc,1sed prnmmcncc with ddatiun ,rnd

Baseline 24 h 48 h

25 25 14 31±4 23±4" 25+4 ' 4±3 11±9" l7t9"

155155 86±33" 112178" 493±84 627±254' 6821311 · 132±48 291±244' 249198"

stacking. After 48 h of sepsts the mun­her of lipid droplets increased. Int racel-

1 u lar chnlc-,tasis was ~l'en with deposits

o(hile pigment and collagen deposition

in the space , if l'lissc. I ncrcascd numher,

ol lysnsome, and pcroxisomcs were al,n

noted.

D1SCUSS10N The c1usl' of the hepatic dysfunc­

L iLlll that uccurs in ~eptic sta tes is un­

clear. S tudies in humans are difficult

ht:c,1use n f the uimplexn ies of the c l in 1-

ca l ,it uat ion and the uncenaint y cau,ed hy the necessary concomit ant

use nf hlllml t ramf1l'tons and porenual heparot ox ms such as ant1h1mics ,md

parenteral nutrit ion.

In septic humans the mnjur hepalll hiochemic.11 ahnmm,1lity is cle,·,Hion

in rnnjugatt:d hilirubin with tnilJ lLl

mllderme increases in a lkalinc phn,­

phatasc and trnnsmnin,1st:s ( 1,2,6). Oc­casionally thl·rc may he marked clev;1 -

l11llls in alkaline phuspharasc ( 15). I(

h ypux ia llr se,crc h ypotenston dc­

vellips rhere may he marked e levation~

int ramnmina~c, (8).

In patients d),mg nf septic ~hPck,

CANJ (,A..;JR,11:N'JEKtlJ Vtll 5 No6 N,Wl:~IHl·R/l)l'( l~!l'IR ll/91 221

Page 4: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

SULLIVAN er al

Figure I ) Light microsco/r; of liw r afL(.'1" 24 h of sepsis showing diffuse micrnvasicular fa uy change, degena aiin,g /11:/>awc'l!e.1 wiLh elll·ly formation of Councilman body (short arrow), and hy1>erplm 1ic K1 1/>ffer celL1 ( rnn•ecl amiw). l lemawxylm and eosin X 170

Figure 2 ) E/ectron microsco/>y of /iw r after 24 Ii of sepsis sliotl'ing li/Jid deposits ( L), /1)'/>ertro/>l1ied, smooth endopla,m11c recrcu/mn (SER) , m)'l.'lin fig11r~s ( long am,ws) and bile deposi1.1 ( short amJtvs). X 6700

post mo rtem li ve r histology sh ,1ws

changes ot venous congest inn , ische­m,c necni~is, fo rty ch ange, Kupffe r cel l hyperplasia and intrahepatic cho les­

tasi~. Occasio nally chnle~rasis may be evide nt m the c hola ngiolar level (2 ) .

In experimen tal enduw xic ~hock the early mo rpho logical changes in the

liver include inj ury to sinusoidal epi -

thelium , sinusoidal congest io n with J c­granulated leukocytes, fibrin and p latele t aggregates, focal mid zonal necrosis, Kupffcr disru ption , micro­vesicular fa t , swollen mitochondria and

pro life ration nf smooth enJopla~mic re ti culum ( 16-20).

In t he presen t st ud y the au thors used a large aninrnl mode l nf systemic sepsis

which m1m1cs the c hanges in ,ept ll:

humnns undergoing acti ve resuscna tio n (2 l ). [1 prnduces a normo tcmive ~tatc c ha racteri ::ed hy high card iac mn put, low peripheral res istance a nd the

gradua l developme nt of renal dysfunc­tion. The hepat ic biochemier1l change~

con~isted o f an early and plateauing 111·

c rease in A ST and lactate dchydrogl'· nase with progress ive inc reases in biliruhin. The emly d rop in albumin 1, no t due to impaired h epatic synthesi,. but rn ther w inc reased vasculc1r endo­thelial permeahil ity a nd lnss of alhumm fro m the vascular space ( l 0, l l).

While a portio n of the increase 111

biliruhin may represent inc reased bi! ,. rubin load from hemolys1s this is likely

a ~mall compone n t as rhere were 1111

significant changes 111 hemoglobin. It 1,

likely that the primary explanation for hype rbilirubincmia i~ decreased bile flow which ha:. heen sho wn in prev1ou., experiments to fo llow infusio n ot en­do toxin o r bacteria. A t whm level this

defect occurs is not c lc,ir, hut expl:n· mentally endom xin hns been shown t,i

decrease bile fl ow at the cana licular level poss ibly hy inhibitio n o f l l+K+.

A TPase (22). Elevated AST a nd lactate dchydro­

genasc arc b ioche mica l evidence of hepatoccllu[ar necrosis. I liswlogicallv

this was characterized at 24 h by focal hepatoccllular nccro~is with occasional

C ounc ilma n bodies while at 48 h there was ex te nsive centri!,)hular necrns1,.

As there was no h ypotensinn or hypox­emi a and no anc rial hcmodyna mic Jif­fercnccs between the sheep with or

wi thout high AST levels, it is like!} that this necrosis represents ischem1a

1>ccurring a~ a result of ~inusoidal events, perhaps from sinus,1ida l conges­

tion anJ collagen depositinn in the space o f Disse. It is possible rhm hepatocellular necrosis cnuld arise from cemrilo bular venous congestio n. The sheep wirh ve ry h igh AST s had higher central venous pressures tha n tho~e with normal AST s; however, the dif­

fe re nces were small and unlikely, by the mse lves, to he of c linical impm· tance. Fina lly, 'tox ic' even ts are a lso a possibility, particu larly in v iew of the marked microvc icular fatty changt and mitoc ho ndrial degenernrion .

222 CAN ] GASTROENTHl()l VOL 5 Nl) 6 NtWEMBER/DECEMRER 1991

Page 5: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

Usually thl' h cr,nic dysfunction ,if the nnrmotl'nsi\'c ,cp~i~ syndrome in

hum.in~ b clurncu.:·ri:cd by cholesrn~is. Therefl>n', thl' early clrup in :dblinc phrn,phatasc wc1s unl'xp,:ctl'd a, it has

not been prl'viously dl',crihl'd in human ur animal ,tud ics. By 48 h alkaline pho,phat,1Sl' had returned t1i pre~epsis le\'els; hnwl'vcr, as a 11 an i 111,1b were lk:td hy 72 h it is unkn1>1vn whether thl' levels \\'1ltild hH ve cnn­tinued in rbe ii' the animab had sur­vived. The cau,e ,,r this ea rl y dmp and

~uhseq uent rise in ,ilb linc phn~ph:1tasc is unknown. A lkal11w phosph,1rn,e is

REFERENCES I. Miller [)J, Keeton (,R, Wchher BL,

Saunder, SJ. Jaundice 111 severe hncr,rial 1nfectiun. l,.1,1n1e11terology 1976;7 I :94-7.

2. Ranb U, rou l1s AK. Ledmgh.im IMA. Mac,wecn RNM. Liver h111c1 iun ,n scpl ic ,hock. J l'I in P,11 hnl 1982; 35: 1249-52.

3. Gnt tl1ch JF, Mcna,h,· 1)1. Cru: E. Gastrointestin,d compl1c: 11 1on, 111 cntically ill patients: Th,• 1111<.:nsi,·bi~· ,n·en·1ew. Am J Uastr<>,nte1'<1l 1986;8 I :2 27- B.

4. U1mson AES. I lep,ll1<.. dysfull\.llllll during hact<.:rial ,<.:p,1~. lntl·ns1,-c Care Med 1987; I>: 162-6.

5. Quale JM, Mandel LJ , Bcrga,ci NV, S1ra11s EW. Clin ic:d ,1gn1fic:mce :111,I pathogenc,1, of hyp,•rhil in1hin<.: rn i,1 ,lS',llC l:Hcd \VI I h \lll/J/iy/ornccH.I llltrt'ILI

septicemia. ,.l\ m J Med I 988;85:615- >. 6. Sikuler E, Ut1eua V, J-:cy rnrn A,

Neuman L, Schhil'ffor F. Ahnormali ­tk:s 111 hiliruhin and li ver cn;:yme levels in ,lllu l1 p:1tien1s with hactcremia. Arch Intern Med 19tN;l49:2246-8.

7. Uu li R, Ahcrnaihy CU, Li mmerin:m HJ. Chol<.:,wt ic d"fen, nf Eschaid11a coli endllloxtn llll 1he is,1la1cd pcrfus<.:d rm liver. Ua, trn<.:ntcni log~ 1976;70:248-51.

8. Ldl11w1tch JI I. Men,k: L. Mnrphll­log1c features nf hepatic injury in cardiac d1se,lsl' and ,h,,ck. J I ll'pat<il 1986:2:"3 l 'l-27.

9. R,chmon,I JM, W,tlk<.:r JF, Avih1 A. cl al. R<.:n ,11,md c:ml1lw:1,c11 l:ir n:,pllnSl' lll nnnhypn1e1is1vl' ,q,-is 111 a large ,mimal m,ldcl wit h pc·ritonitis. Surgery I 985;97:2L15- I 'i.

111,mufacturcd hy the 11\'cr in resp,mse to ,1 variety of imults. The marked hy­pertrophy of rhc sm, lmh endopl.tsmic

reticulum may represent the lh-cr\ syn­thetic re,p11n,l' tu the sqisb. [ l,nvc\'er,

why the albline t'hosphmrn,e drnpped initi,11ly is unknown.

Cen l'ra ll y, physiciath arc more im­pressl·d hy increases in I iver en:ymcs than decreases. Ou:.as1,1rn1ll y, low levels ,,r li \'er cn:yme., m,1y .iid in diag-

11,1,i,. Perhaps an tmexpl:iinl'd d rop in

alkaline phosplwtase 111 a fehrilc, c riti ­rnlly ill patient might he ,tn cmly mantfcstal i\111 of l hl' scpsb syndrrnlll',

IL\ A"ila A, W:ir,h:11Vsk 1 r, S1hh.1kl W, c'I :ii. f\·npheral lymph fln,1 in ,hccp w11h hactl'l'l,tl pent,Hlllts: t\'tdcncc l<ir incr,a,ed p<.:riph<.:r.il microvascular permcahdtt y accllmpanymg sy,1em1c scp,i,. Surgery I 985;97:685-95.

11. Judges [). Sharkey I', Cheung 11, c1 .11. 1'11 l1mm.tr\' 111icnwasud,1r lluid nu ;.. Ill

:1 l:irgl' :1nimal nmdel ,if sep,": l:\'1dc•nce f,,r 111creas..:d ptdmnnary <.:ml,nh<.:l i,1! pcrmeahdny accompany­lllg ,urg1ctlly ,nduced pt·n1,,11111, 111 shc<.:p. Surgery I 986;99:222 14.

12. W:1 lker JF, C umnmg Al), L1nd,a1· RM, S,,le: K. Linwn AL. ·rhe renal r<.:,p1H1s.: pwdlll:cd hy nn11hypntl' t1'1vc ,cpsi., 111 a large ,tn 1m;tl lll<ltkl Am J J-:idncv Dis I 986;Vl ll :88-97.

I) . Cumming Al), Lind,a; RM, McDonald JWI), Lm1"n AL. Au11e dfrct nf a thn1111hn,i111e ,yn1 hetasc 1nhih11,>r ,m renal f11nc1 i,m in unanae,rhcu:cd slll'l'J', C lm Su 1987;73: 171 -6.

14. Cummmg Al), McDnnald JW I), Linds.ty RJ\1, S,,lc: K, Linton AL. The pnllecl i\'e effetl nf I hnimhnxane ,ynthcl:lst' inhih1t1,1n ,m ren,tl f11nll11>11 m ,ystemic sepsis. AmJ Kidney[),, I 989;X I II : 11 4-9.

15. Fang Ml I, G ,11,hcrg AL, l)nhhins WO. Marked clcv:1tinn m ,crum alka line pho,phat:1se ,icti v11y ,h :1m,mif,,1a110n nf ,ystemic mfcu inn.(. ;,1,rroenrcrnk,gy 1980; 78: 592-7.

16. f'x ,le r RI--:, l1ih1glrnus AJ. Ulira-,1 ruLI ur,1 I , dtlT,ll l<lllS nl dllg Ii \'ers during 1: mlntnxm ,l11Kk. Lah ln\'esl 1967;17:5>7-ol

17. Whitt· RR, Mela L. Fbc:11:o LV, Ulnfs,,,n K, Miller LI). I kp,11,l

Hepatic dysfunction in hypotensive sepsis

j11,1 HS 111cre,1si:s in G1rd1.i1. 011t pu1 and decreases in systemic vascular re,1s­ta11ce mdy hi: early hmhingns.

T he cl i111c,1I signific111cc nl t hi:,c ch :m ges is uncle.tr. (;cnn:illy, the poor progn,1s1s a,socimed wtth lin·rdy,func-

11,m m thc s1.·11 ingo( systemic infcct illll i:,, murc ,l reflection of the s1.·1·crity uf th<.: s<.:psis ,y11drn1111.• than uf a,,oci,11cd liver f: til11re. This is suppurt cd hy thl'

frequent ,1ccu1Tcnce of li ver dy,func­l inn in scptil patients whu :ibu ha,'l' renal failure, rcspirn tory di~Ml'" ,yn­

d rntnL', \11' cnccphalup,ll hy ilSS\lU,lll'd with scpsb (21-25).

ul 1 ra,t rue! urc In endnlllx<.:111 ia, ht·murrh.tg,, :ind hypwo:i: Empha,1, on miwch,mdnal changl''· Surt.!t'r\ 197>;7>:525-34.

18. l-\.1!1, JU, Rappapnn ES.(. ,nher L. cl ,11. A primate modl'I fnr pml,mgl'd endotnxin ,hock. L«h lnvl'st 1978;18:5 11 -2>.

19. Balis ,Ill, P;1t eN1n JF, Shdil'y SA. et a I. ( ,I ucn(ort icoid ,rnd ,111 ll hint ic cff<:us \lll hcpatK rnicnicirt ula11on and ass\ll 1;11 <.:d hl ist response~ 1 n let h:1 I C,ra111-nt•g;11 ivl' hactcre111ia. Lah ln vl'st 1979:4l\55-65.

20. Y, ,ung RSK, Wnn,I, C, To\\'figh i J. I lcpat 1c d:unage 111 neonatal rat d11t' In I:. co/1 cmlo1oxin. Dig Di, SLi 1986; l I :65 1 6.

21 S11ifrt·d1111 AI·. l·n1111m RE, Parker MM. ct al. The c1rd1tn·.1,ud.1r rl',ponse of normal humans to the ,1dmmi,trntinn nl <.:ndo1ox1n. N Engl J Med 1989; )2 1 :28(1.(1,

22. U1il1 R, Ahern,11h1 CO, /immcmrn11 I IJ . I nh1hn 1nn ,if Na ' ,K ' - adcnll,im· triph,,sph,Ha,c h; c11dotnx1n: A pos,ihle lll('lh:1111,m, fllrt•ndn1nx 1n­md11led chnlL"SL:t,is. J I nb:t Dis 1977; I )6:5/H 7.

2 \. W<.:rh R, L1n1on AL. Euol\lgy, d1agno,1,, 11,at 111cn1 and prognosis l ,f .1L11te renal f,1i lu re in an intcnsivl' care 11n11. l\<.:su,ci1,1tinn 1979;7:95- 100.

24. Slhwan: [) I\ Bone RC', Balk RA. S:idon J 11. I kp:11 ic dy,fun, 1 i, lll in I ht· ,1du lt rl',plr:tlllry di,trc~s syndrome. ( 'hc,1 1989;95:87l-'i.

25. Young(:n. l\1lton CF, Au, 1111 I"W, l' I ;11. The l'net·phalop.ithy ,hsi1t.1,11ed wi th 'l'Pl ll dln,ss. Clin ln v<·,1 l\,kd. (In press)

22)

Page 6: Early hepatic dysfunction in a large animal model of ... · Des cristallo"ides one cce adrni nistres par voie intraveineuse afin de maintenir la pression capillaire pulmonaire au

Submit your manuscripts athttp://www.hindawi.com

Stem CellsInternational

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

MEDIATORSINFLAMMATION

of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Behavioural Neurology

EndocrinologyInternational Journal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Disease Markers

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

BioMed Research International

OncologyJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Oxidative Medicine and Cellular Longevity

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

PPAR Research

The Scientific World JournalHindawi Publishing Corporation http://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Immunology ResearchHindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Journal of

ObesityJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Computational and Mathematical Methods in Medicine

OphthalmologyJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Diabetes ResearchJournal of

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Research and TreatmentAIDS

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Gastroenterology Research and Practice

Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com Volume 2014

Parkinson’s Disease

Evidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine

Volume 2014Hindawi Publishing Corporationhttp://www.hindawi.com