354
1 CONFIDENTIAL DRAFT For Discussion Purposes Only Subject to Change RELIANT PARK MASTER PLAN ANALYSIS

Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

1    

1   CCOONNFFIIDDEENNTTIIAALL DDRRAAFFTT

For Discussion Purposes Only Subject to Change

     

RELIANT  PARK  MASTER  PLAN  ANALYSIS  

   

Page 2: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

 

April  9,  2012    Mr.  Edgar  Colon  Harris  County  Sports  &  Convention  Corporation  One  Reliant  Park  Houston,  TX  77054    

Dear  Mr.  Colon:  

Conventions,   Sports   &   Leisure   International   (CSL)   in   association   with   the   consulting   team   comprised   of   Thinkwell  Development,  Populous,  Entertainment  +  Culture  Advisors,  Venue  Solutions  Group,  Management  Resources,  Pollavision  and  Manhattan   Construction   is   pleased   to   present   a   summary   report   regarding   the   Reliant   Park   Master   Plan   Analysis.     The  attached  report  summarizes  our  research  and  analyses,  and  is  intended  to  assist  County  representatives  with  their  decisions  regarding  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  including  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site.  

The  information  contained  in  this  report  is  based  on  estimates,  assumptions,  and  other  information  developed  from  research  of  the  market,  knowledge  of  the  public  assembly  industry,  and  other  factors,  including  certain  information  you  have  provided.    All  information  provided  to  us  by  others  was  not  audited  or  verified,  and  was  assumed  to  be  correct.    Because  the  procedures  were   limited,  we  express  no  opinion  or  assurances  of  any  kind  on   the  achievability  of  any  projected   information  contained  herein  and  this  report  should  not  be  relied  upon  for  that  purpose.    Furthermore,  there  will  be  differences  between  projected  and  actual  results.    This  is  because  events  and  circumstances  frequently  do  not  occur  as  expected,  and  those  differences  may  be  material.    We  have  no   responsibility   to  update   this   report   for   events   and   circumstances  occurring   after   the  date  of   this  report.   We   sincerely   appreciate   the   opportunity   to   assist   you   with   this   project,   and   would   be   pleased   to   be   of   further  assistance  in  the  interpretation  and  application  of  the  study’s  findings.  

Very  truly  yours,  

 

CSL  International  

Page 3: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

   

 

Table  of  Contents      Executive  Summary  ...................................................................................................................................................................  i  

1. Introduction  .......................................................................................................................................................................  1  

2. Consultant  Team  ..............................................................................................................................................................  8  

3. Reliant  Park  Analysis  ...................................................................................................................................................  14  

4. Market  Analysis  .............................................................................................................................................................  55  

5. Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis  .......................................................................................................................  100  

6. Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  ..................................................................................................................  165  

  Appendices  

Page 4: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

i    

Executive  Summary

Page 5: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

ii    

1.0  Introduction  The  history  of  Reliant  Park  began  with  the  construction  of  the  Harris  County  Domed  Stadium,  which  opened  in  1965.  With  the  Astrodome  as  its  anchor  and  the  later  addition  of  the  Astroarena  and  Astrohall,  the  complex  was  later  renamed  Astrodomain.  In  2002  the  Astrohall  was  demolished  and  two  new  venues,  Reliant  Center  and  Reliant  Stadium  were  added  to  what  is  now  Reliant  Park.  The  Astrodome  and  Astroarena  have  survived  as  Reliant  Astrodome  and  Reliant  Arena.  Reliant  Arena  is  still  used  for  events,  but  few  improvements  have  been  made  that  would  maintain  its  competitiveness  with  a  modern  building  designed  for  similar  use.  Today,  the  Astrodome  can  no  longer  be  used  for  public  events.  

In  2007,   the  Harris  County  Sports  and  Convention  Corporation  (HCSCC),  a   local  government  corporation   formed  to  manage  and  develop  Reliant  Park,  commissioned  a  study  to  assess  the  then  current  and  future  needs  of  the  on-­‐property  tenants  (the  Houston  Texans  and   the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo),   clients  and  potential   clients  of  Reliant  Park.  The  2007  study  (Reliant   Park  Master   Plan)   addressed   concerns   regarding   the   aging   Reliant   Arena,   parking   and   traffic   issues,   the   need   for  additional  exhibit  and  meeting  space  for  the  Offshore  Technology  Conference  (OTC)  and  program  elements  identified  by  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  (HLSR)  as  being  essential  to  the  continued  growth  of  their  event.  

In   2010,   the   needs   of   the   Reliant   Park  were   again   assessed   in   conjunction  with   discussions   focusing   on   the   possibility   of  repurposing   the  Astrodome   to   create  a  Science,  Technology,  Engineering  and  Mathematics   (STEM)  venue.  The  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  was  updated  to  reflect  this  new  needs  assessment.  In  July  2011,  the  HCSCC  commissioned  this  study  to  provide  an  independent   assessment   of   the   market,   financial,   economic   impact   and   funding   parameters   of   the   proposed   Reliant   Park  Master  Plan,  including  the  options  related  to  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site.  Harris  County,  The  Houston  Livestock  Show  and   Rodeo,   the   Greater   Houston   Convention   and   Visitors   Bureau,   ARAMARK   Sports   &   Entertainment,   the   Harris   County-­‐Houston  Sports  Authority,  and  the  Houston  Texans  contributed  to  the  funding  of  this  study.  The  consultant  team  conducted  an  independent  analysis,  as  well  as,  a  comprehensive  review  of  the  numerous  reports,  studies  and  plans  related  to  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan.    Meetings  were  held  with  the  Harris  County  Judge  and  Commissioners,  key  Harris   County   staff,   Reliant   Park   tenants,   operators   and   stakeholders   to   assess   existing   conditions,   site   attributes   and  constraints  and  to  establish  project  goals  for  future  use  options.  For  the  purposes  of  this  study,  the  analysis  was  separated  into  two  distinct   elements:   the  Reliant   Park  Master   Plan   and   the   Future  Use   of   the  Astrodome   Site.   Further,   the   scope   of  work  proposed   in   the   Reliant   Park  Master   Plan  was   separated   into   two   distinct   projects:   the   Replacement   Arena   Project   and   a  possible  on-­‐site  Hotel.  The  Replacement  Arena  Project  includes  the  8,000  to  10,000  seat  performance  arena,  250,000  square  feet   of   exhibition   space,   a   45,000   square   foot   ballroom  and   additional  meeting   space,   a   2,500   to  3,000   car   parking   garage,  

Page 6: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

iii    

intermodal  transportation  center,  demolition  of  the  current  arena  and  various  site  related  projects.  The  Astrodome  evaluation  focused  on  four  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site:  Maintain  Status  Quo,  Reliant  Park  Plaza,  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  and  Astrodome  Renaissance.  

The   following  are   the   consultant   team’s   conclusions   regarding   the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan   including   the   future  use  of   the  Astrodome  site:  

• It  is  recommended  that  the  Replacement  Arena  Project  be  developed  at  an  estimated  Project  Cost  of  $385.4  million,  less  any  amounts  contributed  by  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo.  

• It  is  also  recommended  that  Harris  County  pursue  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  at  an  estimated  Project  Cost  of  $270.3  million  (exclusive  of  the  outstanding  debt  on  the  Astrodome),  less  any  cost  reductions  obtained  through  available  tax  credits  or  sources  other  than  Harris  County  property  tax  collections.  

• In  the  event  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  is  not  chosen  or  available  funds  are  not  sufficient  to  support  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option,  then  Harris  County  should  choose  the  Reliant  Park  Plaza  option  at  an  estimated  Project  Cost  of  $63.9  million  (exclusive  of  the  outstanding  debt  on  the  Astrodome).  

• It  is  the  design  team’s  strong  recommendation  that  action  be  taken  on  the  Replacement  Arena  Project  and  Astrodome.  The  improvements  will  have  a  significant  positive  effect  on  the  tenants,  major  long  term  clients  like  OTC  and  committed  special  events  including  the  2016  Final  Four  and  the  2017  Super  Bowl  bid.  In  order  to  derive  these  benefits  this  work  must  begin  as  soon  as  possible.  

This  Executive  Summary  contains  the  key  findings  and  conclusions  related  to  the  feasibility  and  impacts  of  the  various  options  contained   in   the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan,   including   the   future  use  of   the  Astrodome  site.  The  Report  should  be  read   in   its  entirety  to  obtain  the  background,  methods  and  assumptions  underlying  these  findings.  

   

Page 7: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

iv    

   

Page 8: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

v    

2.0  Consultant  Team  The  consultant  team  consisted  of  the  following  companies:  

• Conventions,   Sports   &   Leisure   International   is   a   leading   advisory   and   planning   firm   specializing   in   providing  consulting  services  to  the  convention,  sport,  entertainment  and  visitor  industries.  

• Thinkwell  is  an  industry  leader  in  the  concept  development  and  design  of  large-­‐scale  destination  resorts,  theme  parks,  museums/exhibits,  live  shows,  events  and  attractions.  

• Entertainment   +   Culture   Advisors   is   an   international   advisory   firm   focused   on   economic   and  market   analysis   for  world-­‐class  destination  entertainment  and  cultural  development  projects.  

• Management  Resources  is  a  management  consulting  firm  specializing  in  leisure-­‐time  attractions  and  events,  including  museums,  aquariums,  theme  parks,  destination  resorts,  corporate  brand  centers,  world  expositions  and  Olympiads.  

• Populous  is  a  global  design  practice  specializing  in  creating  environments  that  draw  people  and  communities  together  for  unforgettable  experiences.  

• Venue   Solutions   Group   is   focused  on  management  and  operations  of  public  assembly   facilities  with  municipalities,  professional  sports  organizations,  and  private  sector  firms.  

• Pollavision   is   a   works   cinema   experience   consultant   supporting   owners/operators,   equipment   suppliers   and  architects  in  designing  and  integrating  all  aspects  of  film,  video  and  digital  presentation.  

• Manhattan   Construction   is   known   for   building   high   profile,   technically   difficult   mega   projects.   Manhattan   is  recognized   for   building   excellence   in   sports   stadiums,   healthcare,   government,   education,   laboratory,   aviation,  transportation,  convention,  casino  and  hospitality  facilities.  

   

Page 9: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

vi    

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  The  Reliant  Park  Complex  includes  four  venues:  Reliant  Stadium,  Reliant  Center,  Reliant  Arena  and  Reliant  Astrodome.    The  Complex  covers  about  350  acres   in  the  heart  of  the  Harris  County  metropolitan  area  and  provides  parking  for  up  to  26,000  automobiles.     Reliant   Park   hosts   a   variety   of   public   assembly   events   each   year   including   sporting   events,   public   consumer  shows,   conventions,   trade   shows   and   other   entertainment   events.     The   tenants   at   the   Complex   are   the   Houston   Texans  (Texans)  and  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  (HLSR).    The  Reliant  Park  Complex  is  also  host  to  the  annual  Offshore  Technology  Conference  and  many  other  consumer  shows  and  trade  shows  each  year.    Other  pertinent   facts   that   impact   the  analysis  include  the  following:  

• The  three  operational  venues  within  Reliant  Park  (Reliant  Arena,  Reliant  Center  and  Reliant  Stadium)  draw  more  than  four  million  total  visitors  and  host  a  combined  total  of  320  events  annually.  

• Since  moving  into  Reliant  Center  and  Reliant  Stadium  in  2002,  annual  attendance  at  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  has  grown  to  over  2.2  million  guests.  

• The   Offshore   Technology   Conference   currently   uses   all   of   the   available   exhibit   space   in   Reliant   Arena   and   Reliant  Center.   Show   producers   have   had   to   limit   the   growth   of   current   exhibitors   and   in   recent   years   have   used   air-­‐conditioned   tents   in  order   to  create  additional  exhibit   space   to  meet   the  demand.  The  OTC  has   indicated   that   today,  based  on  current  demand,  their  event  could  use  all  of  the  exhibit  space  proposed  in  the  Replacement  Arena  Project  and  most,  if  not  all,  of  the  exhibit  space  proposed  in  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility.    OTC  and  other  event  producers  have  expressed  serious  concerns  regarding  the  condition  and  amenities  in  Reliant  Arena.  The  location  of  Reliant  Arena  in   relationship   to   Reliant   Center,   as   it   relates   to   the   need   for   additional   outdoor   exhibit   space   on   concrete   to  accommodate  the  increased  demand  for  heavy  outdoor  exhibits,  is  also  an  issue.  

• The  lease  agreement  with  the  Texans  limits  event  activity  on  their  game  days  and  restricts  booking  events  at  Reliant  Park  to  one  week  per  month  during  their  season.  

• The  HLSR  lease  agreement  allows  for  exclusive  control  of  the  premises  during  their  show.  

• Reliant  Arena  and  the  supporting  exhibition  and  meeting  spaces  are  well  beyond  the  end  of  their  expected  useful  life.  

• In  its  current  state,  the  Astrodome  can  no  longer  be  used  for  public  events.  

Page 10: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

vii    

Financial  Summary  (in  millions)  –  Reliant  Park  Operations  

HCSCC/SMG  has  been  successful  at  operating  the  various  venues  in  Reliant  Park,  particularly  given  the  scheduling  constraints  that  are   imposed  because  of   the  Texans  and  the  HLSR  scheduling  needs.  Essentially,  HCSCC/SMG  is  able   to  schedule  events  only  one  week  each  month  (the  Protected  Week)  during  the  Texans’  season,  prior  to  the  April  preceding  those  months,  when  the  NFL  schedule  is  released.    Because  of  this  restriction,  the  number  of  large-­‐scale  conventions  and  trade  shows  that  can  be  scheduled  are  limited  because  these  types  of  shows  book  venues  several  years  in  advance.    Reliant  Park  hosts  very  profitable  events.    However,  the  overhead  and  related  expenses  incurred  annually  cause  operating  income  to  be  negative  in  some  years.    The  chart  below  summarizes  the  historical  financial  performance  at  Reliant  Park.    

                       

4.0  Market  Analysis  Local  market  conditions  and  competitive  venues  are  important  components  of  assessing  the  potential  success  of  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  and  any  proposed  operations   for   the   future  use  of   the  Astrodome   site,   including  mixed-­‐use  development  within  the  Astrodome  Renaissance.  The  ability  of  a  market  to  attract  events,  patrons,  and  generate  revenues  is  measured,  to  some   extent,   by   the   size   of   the   regional   market   area   population   and   its   income   characteristics.   Specific   demographic   and  socioeconomic   information   that   can   affect   the   ability   of   a   market   to   support   sports   and   entertainment   venues   include  

Page 11: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

viii    

population  size,  median  age,  age  distribution,  household  income  and  corporate  base.    The  following  is  a  summary  of  the  key  characteristics  of  the  Harris  County  market:  

• Harris  County  is  home  to  23  Fortune  500  companies,  ranking  only  behind  New  York  and  Chicago  in  the  United  States.  

• Harris  County  was  among  the   least   impacted  major  metropolitan  areas   in   the  U.S.  during  the  recent  global  recession  and   is   recovering   faster   than   the   general   economy,   adding   62,300   jobs   from   September   2010   to   September   2011   –  highest  in  the  United  States.  

• Based  on  the  2010  census,   the  Harris  County  metropolitan  area  has  a  population  of  approximately  5.7  million   in   the  primary  market  (within  an  hour  drive  of  the  venue  site)  and  approximately  6.9  million  in  the  secondary  market  area  (within  a  two  hour  drive  of  the  venue  site).  

• In  addition  to  Houston  being  the  fourth  largest  city  in  the  United  States,  both  San  Antonio  (7th  largest  city  in  the  U.S.)  and  Dallas  (9th)  are  within  300  miles  of  Reliant  Park,  further  increasing  the  potential  market  within  an  easy  day’s  drive  of  the  venues.  

• Total  business  and  tourist  travel  to  Harris  County  in  2010  was  approximately  9.0  million  visitors.  

• Harris   County’s   convention   business   struggles   at   both   Reliant   Park   and   the   George   R.   Brown   Convention   Center  because  of  a  lack  of  full-­‐service  hotels  in  close  proximity  to  the  exhibit  halls.  

• The   Harris   County   metropolitan   area   offers   its   residents   and   visitors   a   significant   variety   of   entertainment,   four  professional  sports  franchises,  several  major  universities  and  a  vibrant  museum  and  cultural  district.    As  a  result,  any  new  programming  considered  for  the  redevelopment  of  the  Astrodome  must  include  significant  unique  elements  that  create  a  destination  for  the  region.  

• Among  facilities  hosting  live  entertainment  in  the  greater  Harris  County  area,  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pavilion,  Toyota  Center,   BBVA   Compass   Stadium,   Merrell   Center,   Berry   Center,   Bayou   Music   Center,   and   House   of   Blues   Houston  represent  the  highest  level  of  potential  competition  to  the  proposed  performance  Arena  and/or  the  redevelopment  of  the  Astrodome.  

• While  there  are  competitive  venues  in  the  Harris  County  area,  there  is  not  a  mid-­‐size  indoor  arena  with  a  capacity  in  the  8,000  –  10,000  seat  range.    

Page 12: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

ix    

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis  As  previously  mentioned,  the  HCSCC  commissioned  a  series  of  studies  to  develop  a  Master  Plan  for  the  Reliant  Park  Complex.    These   studies   considered   various   options   to   address   Reliant   Arena   deficiencies,   the   future   use   of   the   Astrodome   site,   the  possibility  of  an  on-­‐site  hotel  and  other  concerns  regarding  the  Complex.    HLSR  and  the  Texans  were  active  participants  in  the  development   of   these   studies   and   the   conclusions   reached.   The   Reliant   Park   Master   Plan   proposed   construction   of   the  following  components:  Replacement  Arena  Project  

The  Replacement  Arena  Project  includes  the  following  components:  

• Performance  Arena  with  8,000  to  10,000  fixed  seats  • 250,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space  • 45,000  square  foot  ballroom  with  additional  meeting  space  • 2,500  to  3,000  space  parking  garage  • Intermodal  Transportation  Center  • Festival  Plaza  • Demolition  of  the  current  Reliant  Arena  and  Plant  II  • Site  improvements  and  paving  

Hotel  To  address   the  need   for  an  on-­‐site  Hotel,   the  Master  Plan  proposes  construction  of  a  hotel   tower  above   the  new  exhibition  space.  An  underground  parking  garage  with  a  dedicated  entrance  off  Fannin  would  support   the  hotel;   therefore  day-­‐to-­‐day  hotel  operations  would  not  negatively  affect  street  level  activities  during  events.  HCSCC  has  stated  that  Harris  County  property  tax  would  not  be  used  to  construct  the  hotel.  NOTE:  Detailed  cost  and  operating  information  is  provided  in  Section  5.4  On-­‐Site  Hotel.  

Astrodome  

The  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  proposed  three  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site:  Reliant  Park  Plaza,  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility,  and  Astrodome  Renaissance.  A  fourth  option,  Maintain  Status  Quo,  was  added  in  this  study.  NOTE:  For  

Page 13: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

x      

the   findings,   conclusions   and   recommendations   regarding   the   future   use   of   the   Astrodome   site   see   Section   6   of   the   Executive  Summary.  When  combined  with  the  existing  facilities,  the  redeveloped  Reliant  Park  Complex  is  anticipated  to  yield  the  following  results:  

• Satisfy  the  future  needs  of  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  

• Extend  the  long-­‐term  relationship  with  the  Offshore  Technology  Conference  

• Increase  parking  revenues  from  the  additional  spaces  available  from  the  parking  garage  

• Attract  larger  conventions  and  trade  shows  

• Create  new  business  opportunities  and  attract  additional  event  activity  

• Increase  marketability  and  bookings  for  concert  and  entertainment  events  

• Allow  more  events  to  be  booked  simultaneously  

• Increase  income  from  arena  events  

• Create  new  income  from  premium  seating  opportunities  

• Increase  income  from  advertising  and  sponsorship  sales  

• Increase  income  from  existing  events  

Page 14: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xi    

     

ReliantAstrodome

Site

ReliantStadium

Reliant Center

ParkingGarage

PerformanceArena

ExhibitionHalls

FestivalPlaza

Bridge

TransportationCenter

HotelCarruth

Plaza

Reliant Park Master Plan

Page 15: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xii    

Project  Costs  –  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  

   

Page 16: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xiii    

Preliminary  Project  Schedule  –  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  

     

Page 17: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xiv    

Financial  Summary  (in  millions)  –  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan        

Page 18: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xv    

Conclusions  and  Recommendations  

The  following  are  the  consultant  team’s  conclusions  regarding  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan.  

• It  is  recommended  that  the  Replacement  Arena  Project  be  developed  at  an  estimated  Project  Cost  of  $385.4  million,  less  any  amounts  contributed  by  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo.  

o Depending  upon  the  option  selected   for   the  Astrodome,  additional  exhibition  space   in   the  Replacement  Arena  Project  may  be  required.  

o It   is   the   design   team’s   strong   recommendation   that   action   be   taken   on   the   Replacement   Arena   Project   and  Astrodome.  The  improvements  will  have  a  significant  positive  effect  on  the  tenants,  major  long  term  clients  like  OTC   and   committed   special   events   including   the   2016   Final   Four   and   the   2017   Super   Bowl   bid.   In   order   to  derive  these  benefits  this  work  must  begin  as  soon  as  possible..  

• It  is  also  recommended  that  HCSCC  continue  its  efforts  to  secure  a  private  developer  for  the  on-­‐site  Hotel.    

o The  analysis  shows  that  the  on-­‐site  Hotel  would  have  a  positive  impact  on  Reliant  Park.  

o The  HCSCC  has  stated  that  Harris  County  property  taxes  will  not  be  used  to  develop  the  hotel.  

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  Options  

A  considerable  amount  of  time  and  effort  were  devoted  to  evaluating  various  development  and  operational  scenarios  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site.    Each  of  the  development  options  was  evaluated  based  on  the  financial  and  market  viability  of  the  possible  option.    The  following  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  have  been  considered  in  detail  in  this  report:  

Maintain  Status  Quo  

This   option   maintains   the   Astrodome   in   its   current   condition.   The   building   will   remain   unusable   and   the   cost   of  maintenance  will  continue  to  rise  as  the  building  ages  and  systems  further  deteriorate.  

Page 19: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xvi    

Reliant  Park  Plaza  

This   option  demolishes   the  Astrodome,   fills   the   existing   site   to   grade   and   constructs  Reliant  Park  Plaza  with  perimeter  support  facilities  for  outdoor  events.  

Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

This  option  would  renovate  the  Astrodome  into  a  multi-­‐use  indoor  event  facility.  A  new  event  floor  would  be  constructed  at  grade,  existing  seating  would  be  removed,  systems  would  be  upgraded  or  replaced  and  improvements  would  be  made  to  the  roof  and  exterior  skin.  

Astrodome  Renaissance  

This   option   would   overlay   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   with   Science,   Technology,   Engineering   and   Mathematics   (STEM)  programs   and/or   privately   funded   concepts,   including   retail,   dining   and   entertainment   (RD+E)   and   attractions.  Approximately   400,000   square   feet   of   new   space   would   be   created   within   the   Astrodome   to   house   the   overlaid  components.   A   new   operating   entity   would   be   established   to   develop,   fund   and   manage   the   Astrodome   Renaissance  improvements  and  operations.  Funding  for  the  new  entity  would  be  derived  from  tenant  leases,  philanthropic  sources  and  other  Astrodome  Renaissance  revenues.  

While  all  options  require  public  funding,  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  as  considered  herein  may  only  be  pursued  if  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option   is   selected.  Further,   this  option  would  only  be   considered   if  private   sector  and/or  philanthropic   funding   can  be   found   to   support   construction  and  operations.  The  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  could  be  executed  concurrently  with  the  construction  of  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  or  at  a  point  in  the  future.  However,  it  should  be  noted  that  future  construction  costs  would  be  higher.  

Summary  

The  key  findings  related  to  the  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  are  summarized  below:  

Maintain  Status  Quo  

• Requires  increasing  maintenance  and  capital  expenditures  as  the  building  ages  

• Reduces  the  appeal  of  the  Complex  due  to  ongoing  deterioration  of  the  building  

Page 20: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xvii    

• Obstructs  site  circulation  and  event  operations  

• Preserves  the  option  to  determine  a  best  use  in  the  future  

• Provides  no  benefit  from  expenditures  

Reliant  Park  Plaza  

• Is  the  lowest  publicly  funded  Project  Cost  option  

• Creates  additional  parking  

• Provides  additional  outdoor  event  space  

• Reduces  current  Reliant  Park  maintenance  costs  

• Improves  site  circulation  and  access  

Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

• Is  the  highest  publicly  funded  Project  Cost  option  

• Expands  and  supports  core  business  

• Has  a  greater  operating  loss  than  the  proposed  Reliant  Park  Plaza  

• Preserves  the  opportunity  for  additional  future  use  

• Improves  site  circulation  and  access  

• Provides  interior,  column-­‐free,  high  bay  exhibition  space  

• Creates  a  highly  marketable,  functional  and  unique  space  

• Offers  ideal  location  for  fairs,  festivals  and  performances  

Astrodome  Renaissance  

• All  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  findings  apply,  including  opportunity  for  future  use  

Page 21: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xviii    

• Provides  opportunity  for  third  party  development  

o There  are  significant  restrictions  on  the  site  that  would  impact  third  party  development  

• Creates  a  regional  destination  

General  Findings  

• Each  option  has  capital  costs  to  Harris  County.  Additionally,  all  options  have  operating  shortfalls.  

• Tenant  operating  restrictions  will  make  it  challenging  for  a  third  party  operator  to  justify  investment  in  the  Astrodome  Renaissance.  

• The  STEM  concept  is  supported  by  several  of  the  stakeholders  in  Reliant  Park  and  could  be  an  important  addition  to  the  Harris   County   area   and   the   local   education   system.   Our   conversations   with   local   colleges   and   universities   have  indicated  a  willingness  to  participate  in  a  consortium  for  the  development  of  the  STEM  program  in  the  Astrodome.  

• The  costs  associated  with  any  STEM  development  and  operation  will  require  the  financial   involvement  of  the  private  sector.   This   will   also   require   the   creation   of   management   infrastructure   to   operate   the   program   and  maintain   the  facility.  

Page 22: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xix    

Financial  Summary  (in  millions)  –  Astrodome  Future  Site  Use  Analysis    

   Astrodome)Site)Option Status)Quo Reliant)Park)Plaza Astrodome)Multi8Purpose)Facility

Astrodome)Renaissance)[3]

Harris)County)FundingProject)Cost)[)1)] 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 63.9$))))))))))))))))))) 270.3$))))))))))))))))) 385.4$)))))))))))))))))[)8)])Other)Funding)(i.e.)Private,)Philanthropic,)Other)) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (115.1)$))))))))))))))))Total)Harris)County)Funding 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 63.9$))))))))))))))))))) 270.3$))))))))))))))))) 270.3$)))))))))))))))))Annual)Repair)and)Replacement 1.0$))))))))))))))))))))) 0.7$))))))))))))))))))))) 2.0$))))))))))))))))))))) 2.0$)))))))))))))))))))))

Operating)ResultsRevenue 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.5$))))))))))))))))))))) 1.7$))))))))))))))))))))) 1.7$)))))))))))))))))))))Expenses 8)))))))))))))))))))))))) (1.2)))))))))))))))))))))) (3.6)))))))))))))))))))))) (3.6))))))))))))))))))))))Net)Operating)Income 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (0.7)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )Rent)from)Third)Party)Operations 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 12.5$)))))))))))))))))))Incremental)Expenses)Related)to)Third)Party)Revenues (4.6)$))))))))))))))))))) )Incremental)Debt)Service)Related)to)Astrodome)Renaissance 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (8.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )Total)Income)(Loss) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (0.7)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (2.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )

Economic)ImpactTax)Revenue 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.1$))))))))))))))))))))) 0.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 8.1$)))))))))))))))))))))Direct)Spending 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 6.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 77.9$)))))))))))))))))))Total)Output 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 1.3$))))))))))))))))))))) 10.8$))))))))))))))))))) 125.5$)))))))))))))))))Personal)Earnings 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.5$))))))))))))))))))))) 4.3$))))))))))))))))))))) 52.6$)))))))))))))))))))Jobs 0 18 153 2,221

["1"]"Project"costs"do"not"include"outstanding"Astrodome"debt.

Page 23: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xx      

Conclusions  and  Recommendations  The  following  are  the  consultant  team’s  conclusions  regarding  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site:  

• It   is   recommended   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   option   be   selected   for   the   future   use   of   the   Astrodome   site   at   an  estimated  cost  of  $270.3  million*,  less  any  cost  reductions  obtained  through  available  tax  credits  or  sources  other  than  Harris  County  property  tax  collections.  

o This   recommendation   considers   more   than   just   the   financial   projections.   It   recognizes   the   magnitude   of  potential   opportunities   offered  by   this   one-­‐of-­‐a-­‐kind   structure.   In   the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility   option   the   event  floor  would  be  over  300,000  square  feet,  column  free  and  rising  to  a  height  of  over  200  feet.  The  result  is  any  event  is  possible,  making  Reliant  Park  a  truly  unique  destination.  There  is  simply  no  space  like  this  in  the  world  today.  

o In  the  event  this  option  is  not  chosen  or  available  funds  are  not  sufficient  to  support  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option,  then  Harris  County  should  choose  the  Reliant  Park  Plaza  option  at  an  estimated  cost  of  $63.9  million*.  

o It   is   the   design   team’s   strong   recommendation   that   action   be   taken   on   the   Replacement   Arena   Project   and  Astrodome.  The  improvements  will  have  a  significant  positive  effect  on  the  tenants,  major  long  term  clients  like  OTC   and   committed   special   events   including   the   2016   Final   Four   and   the   2017   Super   Bowl   bid.   In   order   to  derive  these  benefits  this  work  must  begin  as  soon  as  possible.  

• Analysis  of   the  Astrodome  Renaissance  has  been  unable  to   identify  a  mix  of  uses  that  can  be  financed  today  through  traditional   sources.   However,   if   Harris   County   elects   to   pursue   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   option,   it   preserves   the  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  if  other  sources  of  funding  become  available.  

• The  Status  Quo  option  is  not  recommended.  

*These  amounts  do  not  include  the  outstanding  debt  on  the  Astrodome.    

Page 24: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xxi    

Alternative  Funding  Sources  In  addition  to  funds  provided  by  the  County,  there  are  three  primary  sources  of  funding  for  the  Master  Plan  components  and  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility:      

• Rehabilitation  Tax  Credits;  

• New  Market  Tax  Credits;  and  

• Immigrant  Investor  Program  (EB5)  Funding.  

The  two  tax  credits  are  essentially  grants  that  go  to  offset  the  total  cost  of  the  project.    The  EB5  funding  is  a  type  of  debt  that  will  need  to  be  repaid.    However,  it  can  potentially  be  subordinated  to  county  funds  and  other  debt  used  to  finance  the  project.    Additionally,  the  cost  of  the  EB5  debt  is  most  likely  very  favorable  for  a  project  of  this  type.  

Other  financing  vehicles  (e.g.  Tax  Increment  Reinvestment  Zone  bonds,  Texas  Economic  Development  Fund  loans)  have  been  identified  as  potential  financing  options,  but  not  quantified.  

A  summary  of  each  of  the  three  alternative  funding  sources  is  set  forth  below:  

Rehabilitation  Tax  Credits  

Generally,  a  project  can  receive  Rehabilitation  Tax  Credits  equal  to  twenty  percent  (20%)  of  the  total  amount  expended  to  repair   or   improve   an  historic   building.    However,   there   are   several   issues   that  would  have   to  be   addressed   in  order   to  receive  these  funds  for  the  Astrodome.      

First,   the   Astrodome   would   have   to   receive   formal   designation   as   an   historic   building.     This   is   a   process   that   would  probably  be  successful  in  this  case.    This  designation  would  impose  specific  restrictions  on  the  maintenance  of  the  building  and  would  likely  make  it  more  difficult  to  make  material  alterations  to  the  structure  in  the  future.    Second,  the  tax  credit  is  available  to  the  owner  of   the  property.    Because  the  HCSCC  is  a  tax-­‐exempt  entity,  an  arrangement  with  a  company  that  pays  taxes  would  have  to  be  developed  that  would  satisfy  this  requirement.    Third,  only  those  expenses  beyond  the  basis  of  the   building   are   eligible   in   determining   the   amount   of   this   tax   credit.     Thus,   care   must   be   taken   with   respect   to  expenditures  to  ensure  that  they  are  not  incurred  prior  to  the  historic  designation;  as  such,  expenses  could  not  be  included  and  thus  would  lower  the  total  amount  of  the  potential  tax  credit.    Fourth,  if  the  tax  credits  are  monetized,  the  value  would  

Page 25: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xxii    

be   less   than  the  total  amount  of   the  tax  credit.    Current  market  conditions   indicate   the  monetized  value  would   likely  be  75%  of  the  total  amount  of  the  tax  credit.  

New  Market  Tax  Credits  

The  New  Market  Tax  Credit   Program  provides   a   credit   against   Federal   income   taxes   for   investors   that  make   “Qualified  Equity  Investments”  (QEI)  into  “Community  Development  Entities”  (CDE).    Thus,  the  project  must  meet  the  definition  of  a  CDE  and  the  investment  must  satisfy  the  definition  of  the  QEI,  which  should  be  accomplished  in  the  case  of  rehabilitating  the  Astrodome.    Once  these  requirements  are  satisfied  and  the  credit  is  earned,  the  credit  is  taken  over  a  seven-­‐year  period.  However,  the  investment  must  remain  in  the  CDE  throughout  the  entire  seven  years  and  the  total  amount  of  the  tax  credit  taken  over  that  period  is  capped  at  39%  of  the  original  investment.    While  the  rehabilitation  costs  of  the  Astrodome  would  exceed  $50  million,  because  of   current  market  conditions  and   the   limited  availability  of  allocations   for  New  Market  Tax  Credits,   it   would   likely   be   the   case   that   the   investment   eligible   would   be   capped   at   $50   million   or   less.     (Typical  investments   for   which   New   Market   Tax   Credit   allocations   are   received   are   between   $5   million   and   $25   million.)    Additionally,  the  monetized  value  of  the  allocation  would  likely  be  65%,  making  the  total  amount  of  the  New  Market  Tax  Credits  equal  to  $12.187  million  for  all  scenarios.  

Immigrant  Investor  Program  (EB5)  Funding  

The   EB5   funding   program   is   operated   by   U.S.   Citizenship   and   Immigration   Services   (USCIS).     USCIS   requires   that   all  investments  made  through  this  program  be  “at  risk”,  with  no  guarantees  provided  to  the  investors.    Additionally,  EB5  funds  are  debt,  and  must  be  repaid.    However,  the  terms  are  usually  significantly  more  favorable  than  other  sources  of  private  debt  and  similar  types  of  financing.  

The  amount  of  funds  that  can  be  provided  to  a  project  are  determined  by  the  number  of  jobs  (direct  and  indirect)  that  are  created  or  retained  through  a  project  during  the  initial  two  years  of  the  project.    In  addition  to  indirect  jobs,  construction  jobs  are  included  in  this  calculation.    Once  the  total  jobs  created  or  retained  are  computed,  $1  million  for  every  ten  jobs  can  be   loaned   to   the  project.     (This  number  can   increase   if   the  project   is   in  a  designated  Targeted  Employment  Area  (TEA),  which   is   an   area  with   unemployment   at   or   above   150%  of   the   national   average).     The  TEA   can   be   tailored   based   on   a  specific  project  but  must  be  approved  by  USCIS.  

   

Page 26: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Executive Summary

xxiii    

The  chart  below  sets  forth  the  amounts  that  could  be  contributed  toward  development  costs  from  each  of  the  three  alternative  sources:  

 

Note:  Appendix  V  contains  additional  information  on  Alternate  Funding  Sources.  

 

 

 

 

Page 27: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

1    

1.0   Introduction

Page 28: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

2    

1.1  Background  When   the   Harris   County   Domed   Stadium   opened   in   1965,   it   did   not  disappoint.     “The   Dome”   was   the   world’s   first   multi-­‐purpose,   air-­‐conditioned,  fully  enclosed  sports  stadium.    But  it  was  so  much  more  than  a  stadium:  it  was  an  engineering  marvel—nicknamed  the  “Eighth  Wonder  of  the  World”  and  the  “Can-­‐Do  Cathedral”.    The  new  state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art  stadium  put  Houston  and  Harris  County  on  the  map  and  revolutionized  the  way  the  world  played  and  watched  sports.  

Today,   however,   the   first   domed   stadium   finds   itself   sitting   idly   on   the  sidelines,  shuttered  and  in  need  of  major  upgrades  and  improvements.  The  venue  is  no  longer  used  for  any  sporting  or  public  assembly  events  due  to  the  unusable  condition.  What  remains  is  an  opportunity  for  Harris  County  to  determine   the  highest  and  best  use  of   the  Astrodome  site  and  address  other  needs  within  the  Reliant  Park  complex.  

To   handle   this   opportunity   in   a   manner   that   is   both   responsive   to   the  needs  of  the  community  and  fiscally  responsible,  the  Harris  County  Sports  &   Convention   Corporation   (HCSCC)   developed   the   Reliant   Park   Master  Plan.  For   the  purposes  of   this   study,   the  analysis  was   separated   into   two  distinct   elements,   the  Reliant   Park  Master  Plan   and   the   future  use   of   the  Astrodome  site.    

   

Page 29: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

3    

1.2  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan    In   2007,   the   HCSCC   commissioned   a   master   plan   for   the   Reliant   Park   Complex   to   serve   as   a   roadmap   for   all   future  development   on  the  site.  The  project  team  first  met  with  the  tenants,   the  facility  operator  and  other  users  of  the  Complex  to   develop   a   program   of   spaces   based   on   each   groups’   respective   needs.     At   that   time,   both   the   HLSR   and   the   OTC  identified   the  need  and  their  preference   for  additional   exhibit  and  meeting  space  contiguous   to  Reliant  Center,  expressed  concerns   regarding   the  isolated  location  of  Reliant  Arena  and  the  overall   condition  of  the  almost  40-­‐year-­‐old   facility.  The  studies  considered   a  variety  of  options   including  renovation   of  Reliant  Arena,  but  given  the  location  and  issues  related  to  the  overall  design  characteristics   of  the  facility,  renovation  did  not  address  all  of  the  concerns   and  was  seen  viable  only  as  a  short-­‐term  solution   to  the  problems.  

Following   the  program   development   phase   of   the  project,   the  project  team  worked  with  the   tenants   and  users   to   finalize  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan.  Possible   locations   for   the  new  development   included   locations   to  either   the  west  or  south  of   Reliant  Center.     The   study   also   took   into   consideration   possible   future   uses   of   the  Astrodome   site   in   establishing   the  location   for   the   replacement   arena.   The   final   plan   established   that   the  best   location  would   be   south   of  Reliant   Center   in  the   L-­‐shaped   configuration   as   shown   on   the   Reliant   Park   Master   Plan   drawings   contained   herein.   The   Reliant   Park  Master   Plan  was   then   presented   to   the   tenants   and   the   OTC   for   review.     After   reaching   a   consensus   by   all   parties,   the  HCSCC  adopted  the  2007  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan.  

The   Reliant   Park   Master   Plan   was   updated   in   2010   in   conjunction   with   discussions   focusing   on   the   possibility   of  creating  a  Science,  Technology,   Engineering   and  Mathematics   Institute   in  the  Astrodome.   At  the  time,   concerns  related   to  the   need   for   additional   on-­‐site   parking,   improved   traffic   flow   and   the   possibility   of   incorporating   an   on-­‐site   hotel   to  improve   Reliant   Center’s  marketability   for   conventions   and  major   events  were   addressed.  The  final  plan   is  shown  on  the  following  page.  

   

Page 30: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

4    

 

ReliantAstrodome

Site

ReliantStadium

Reliant Center

ParkingGarage

PerformanceArena

ExhibitionHalls

FestivalPlaza

Bridge

TransportationCenter

HotelCarruth

Plaza

Reliant Park Master Plan

Page 31: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

5    

The  scope  of  work  proposed  in  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  was  separated  into  two  distinct  projects  for  the  purposes  of  this  analysis  and  contains  the  project  elements  described  below.  Replacement  Arena  Project  

The  Replacement  Arena  Project  includes  the  following  components:  

• Performance  Arena  with  8,000  to  10,000  fixed  seats  • 250,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space  • 45,000  square  foot  ballroom  with  additional  meeting  space  • Festival  Plaza  • 2,500  to  3,000  space  parking  garage  • Intermodal  Transportation  Center  • Demolition  of  the  current  Reliant  Arena  and  Plant  II  • Site  Improvements  and  paving  

Hotel  

To  address  the  need  for  an  on-­‐site  Hotel,  the  Master  Plan  proposes  a  privately  funded  hotel  tower  constructed  above  the  new  exhibition  space.  An  underground  parking  garage  with  a  dedicated  entrance  off  Fannin  would  support  the  hotel;  therefore  day-­‐to-­‐day  hotel  operations  would  not  negatively  affect  street  level  activities  during  events.  

   

Page 32: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

6    

1.3  Future  Use  of  the  Astrodome  Site    The  experts  reviewed  numerous  reports,  studies  and  plans  related  to  the  Astrodome,  the  overall  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan,  and  Harris   County.    Meetings  were   held  with   key  Harris   County   staff,   Reliant   Park   operators,   and  Reliant   Park   stakeholders   to  assess   existing   conditions,   site   attributes   and   constraints   and   establish   project   goals   to   address   available   options   for   the  Astrodome.     To   begin   to   establish   a   clear   vision   and   sound   organizational   principal   to   ensure   the   Astrodome’s   future   use  reaches  its  full  potential,  the  experts  organized  their  research  and  findings  into  four  distinct  options  for  the  HCSCC  to  consider  as  it  related  to  the  reuse  of  the  Astrodome:  

Maintain  Status  Quo  

This   option   maintains   the   Astrodome   in   its   current   condition.   The   building   will   remain   unusable   and   the   cost   of  maintenance  will  continue  to  rise  as  the  building  ages  and  systems  further  deteriorate.  

Reliant  Park  Plaza  

This   option  demolishes   the  Astrodome,   fills   the   existing   site   to   grade   and   constructs  Reliant  Park  Plaza  with  perimeter  support  facilities  for  outdoor  events.  

Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

This  option  would  renovate  the  Astrodome  into  a  multi-­‐use  indoor  event  facility.  A  new  event  floor  would  be  constructed  at  grade,  existing  seating  would  be  removed,  systems  would  be  upgraded  or  replaced  and  improvements  would  be  made  to  the  exterior  skin.  

Astrodome  Renaissance  

This   option   would   overlay   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   with   Science,   Technology,   Engineering   and   Mathematics   (STEM)  programs   and/or   privately   funded   concepts,   including   retail,   dining   and   entertainment   (RD+E)   and   attractions.  Approximately   400,000   square   feet   of   new   space   would   be   created   within   the   Astrodome   to   house   the   overlaid  components.   A   new   operating   entity   would   be   established   to   develop,   fund   and   manage   the   Astrodome   Renaissance  improvements  and  operations.  Funding  for  the  new  entity  would  be  derived  from  tenant  leases,  philanthropic  sources  and  other  Astrodome  Renaissance  revenues.  

   

Page 33: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

1.0  Introduction  

7    

1.4  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis  Framework  Too  many  large-­‐scale  projects  are  “design-­‐led”  which  results  in  ambitious  plans  and  designs  that  are  ultimately  unable  to  be   executed.     The   framework   for   the   project   development  process   is   the  “Value  Pyramid”.    The  focus  of   the  analysis   in  the   early   stages   is   to   better   define   the   project   economics,  program   and   operations-­‐-­‐-­‐thereby   establishing   program,  budget   and   investment   goals   first   to   inform   the   creative  development   process.   Public   investment   and   key  constituencies’   needs   and   constraints   are   also   part   of   this  evaluation.    The  ultimate  goal   is  to  achieve  the  final  stage  of  the   Value   Pyramid,   whereupon   a   project   is   executed  successfully  to  achieve  the  creative  development,  operational  and   economic   objectives.   An   important   component   of   the  consulting  team’s  process  is  recognizing  the  multiple  existing  constituencies   in   the  community   that  needed  to  be   involved  in   the   planning   and   development   and   potentially   the  operations   of   the   project.   Engaging   these   groups   in   a  preliminary   programming   process   will   allow   for   quick  discarding  of  unworkable  ideas.  

Development*Execu/on*

Content*Programming*

Design*

Planning*

Market*Research*

Project*Feasibility*

Preliminary*Program*

Preliminary*Valua/on*

Public*Investment*/*

Private*Investment*

Make*it*happen*

Create*it*and*define*it*

What*should*this*be*and*why?*

Harris*County*Sports*&*

Conven/on*Corpora/on*

Page 34: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

8    

2.0   Consultant  Team  

Page 35: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

2.0  Consultant  Team  

9    

An  overview  of  the  qualifications  of  each  of  the  consultants  follows  below:  

CSL  International  

Founded  in  1988,  Conventions,  Sports  &  Leisure  International  (CSL)  is  a  leading  advisory  and  planning  firm   specializing   in   providing   consulting   services   to   the   convention,   sport,   entertainment   and   visitor  industries.  CSL  was  established  for  the  specific  purpose  of  providing  a  source  of  focused  research  and  expertise   in   these   industries.   Services   include   new/expanded   event   facility   feasibility   studies,  organizational   reviews/performance   enhancement   studies,   destination   master   planning,   industry  benchmarking,   negotiation   assistance   and   related   services.    With   a   staff   of   15   professionals,   CSL   has  completed   over   500   consulting   engagements   throughout   North   America   and   abroad,   focusing   on   a  variety  of  event  facility  planning,  strategic  advisory  services  and  economic  development  issues.  

Thinkwell  

For   over   a   decade,   Thinkwell   has   been   an   industry   leader   in   the   concept  development   and   design   of   large-­‐scale   destination   resorts,   theme   parks,  museums/exhibits,   live   shows,   events   and   attractions.   Thinkwell’s   creativity   is  never   done   in   a   vacuum   but   rather   in   an   environment   that   brings   all   of   the   business   elements   together—operations,  architecture  and  engineering,  technical  planning,  branding  and  marketing,  education  and  evaluation  in  addition  to  the  design  

experience—ensuring  the  project’s  success.  Thinkwell’s  services  are  sought  after  by  some  of  the   most   well-­‐known   and   successful   companies   in   the   world,   including   Warner   Bros.,  Universal   Studios,   Disney,   Harrah’s   Entertainment,   Sesame   Workshop,   Hilton,   MGM,  Twentieth  Century  Fox,  Cirque  du  Soleil,  and  the  NFL,  among  many  others.  

 

 

   

Page 36: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

2.0  Consultant  Team  

10    

Entertainment  +  Culture  Advisors  

Entertainment  +  Culture  Advisors   (ECA)   is  an   international  advisory   firm   focused  on  economic  and  market   analysis   for  world-­‐class  destination  entertainment   and   cultural  development  projects.     ECA  principals,   formerly   with   Economics   Research   Associates   (ERA),   bring   a   wealth   of   knowledge   and  experience  to  each  project.  They  have  completed  more  than  one  thousand  entertainment  and  cultural  projects  working  with  leading  international  destination  development  professionals  around  the  world.    While  ECA  provides   the  necessary  quantitative  analysis   required   for  each  project,   the  added  value   is   the   insight   they  bring  from  years  of  international  experience  helping  clients  optimize  business  models  with  the  right  balance  of  visitation,  revenue  potential,  and  capital  investment.  

Management  Resources  

Management  Resources   is   a  management   consulting   firm   specializing   in   leisure-­‐time   attractions   and  events,   including   museums,   aquariums,   theme   parks,   destination   resorts,   corporate   brand   centers,  world  expositions  and  Olympiads.  Founded  in  1980,  MR  provides  business,  operational,  marketing  and  ticket  sales  planning  and  advisory  services  to  a  diverse  group  of  clients  throughout  the  world.      While  the   company’s   first   commitment   is   always   to   its   clients,   it   is   also   dedicated   to   advancing   the   field   -­‐  through  participation   in  associations  such  as   IAAPA,  as  well  as   through  the  progressive  nature  of   the  company’s  own  work.  Management  Resources  takes  considerable  pride  in  the  fact  that  many  of  the  company’s  projects  have  been  recognized  for  THEA  and  other  awards.  Management  Resources  take  equal  pride  in  knowing  that  past  clients  value  the  company  and  its  abilities  and  that  those  clients  return  again  and  again  for  help.    Management  Resources  has  been  around  for  thirty  years  but  it  continues  to  retain  the  entrepreneurial  spirit  of  a  small,  energetic  company.  That’s  due  to  the  tireless  drive  and  enduring  creativity  of  the  strategists  at  Management  Resources.  The  company  combines  the  deep  industry  knowledge  of  250  years  of  shared  experience  with  a  desire  to  apply  new  thinking  and  find  innovative  approaches  to  help  its  clients.  

   

Page 37: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

2.0  Consultant  Team  

11    

Populous  

Populous   is   a   global  design  practice   specializing   in   creating  environments   that  draw   people   and   communities   together   for   unforgettable   experiences.   With  clarity  of  vision  and  purpose  that  only  amplifies  the  company’s  expertise,  all  of  the   people,   portfolio,   capabilities   and   expertise   formerly   known   as  HOK   Sport  Venue  Event  continue  as  Populous.    Populous  continues  to  offer  comprehensive  design  services,  including  sports  architecture,  conference   and   exhibition   center   architecture,   master   planning,   events   planning   and   overlay,   interior   design,   sustainable  design   consulting,   environmental   graphics   and   way-­‐finding,   and   facilities   operations   analysis.     Populous   enthusiastically  embraces   the   expertise   they   uniquely   claim—drawing   people   together   around   teams,   athletes,   events,   places,   commerce,  industry  and   ideas   they  wholeheartedly  embrace  and  adore.  Whether   it’s  an  event  with  more  participants   than  you’ve  ever  dreamed  of,  a  city   looking  to  transform  an  area  into  a  more  economically  and  sustainable  asset,  or  a  rapidly  growing  urban  center,  Populous’  skills  uniquely  apply.  

Venue  Solutions  Group  

Three  industry  professionals  bringing  over  60  years  of  experience  in  the  management  and   operations   of   public   assembly   facilities   launched   venue   Solutions   Group   (VSG).  Their  history  involves  direct  management  of  a  variety  of  facility  types,  working  closely  with  municipalities,  professional  sports  organizations,  and  private  firms.      The  expertise  of   these   individuals  includes   venue   operations,   security/safety,   guest   services,  sustainability,   and  administration.    VSG   can  evaluate   the  overall   operations  and  processes  a  venue  utilize   in  order   to   fulfill  their   obligations   from   event   procurement   through   completion.   The   company   will   identify   strengths   and   weaknesses,  identifying  capital  improvements  (if  necessary)  that  will  allow  a  venue  to  broaden  their  appeal  to  event  producers.  VSG  will  also   assess   current   and   potential   marketing   opportunities,   review   the   organizational   structure,   compare   the   facility’s  specifications  with  competitors,  and  review  rental  structure,  including  ancillary  fees,  so  that  the  facility  is  in  the  best  possible  position  to  meet  its  goals,  whether  those  are  based  on  finances,  events,  or  a  combination  of  the  two.  

   

Page 38: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

2.0  Consultant  Team  

12    

Pollavision  

Pollavision   was   formed   to   fill   the   void   between   the   theater  owner/operator,   equipment   supplier   and   architect.   With   the  popularity   of   people   bringing   the   cinema   experience   to   their  home,   the   company   has   expanded   into   the   home   theater  marketplace.  Pollavision  can  comfortably  work  with  the  owner  of  the  theater,  the  architect  that  is  defining  the  space  for  the  theater   or   the   equipment   supplier   that   is   providing   the   equipment   in   the   theater.   Since   Pollavision   does   not   supply   any  equipment,   it   can  maintain   a  neutral   position   as   far   as   equipment   selection   and   room  design.  The   company’s  mission   is   to  provide  the  best  performance,  functionality  and  expertise  to  meet  the  budget  and  requirements  of  its  client.  

The   company   stays  up-­‐to-­‐date  with   all   new  products   and  draws  on  a  wealth  of   experience   in  designing  and   integrating  all  aspects  of  film,  video  or  digital  presentation.  Pollavision’s  vast  commercial  cinema  and  specialty  theater  experience  gives  the  company  an  advantage  that  is  not  locally  available  in  many  markets.  Pollavision  can  provide  its  clients  with  the  finest  in  design  of   sound  systems,  acoustics,  digital  or   film  projection  as  well  as   the  ability   to  provide  complete   turnkey  assistance   for  new  theatres   or   the   renovation   of   existing   theatres   or   home   theaters.     Pollavision   can   also   provide   all   costs   and   operating  projections,  as  well  as  engineering  drawings  and  architectural  drawings  for  all  projects.  

   

Page 39: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

2.0  Consultant  Team  

13    

Manhattan  Construction  

As   the   first   company   to   incorporate   in   the  State  of  Oklahoma,  Manhattan  played  an  important  part  in  building  the  Southwest.  Among  dozens  of  schools  and  courthouses,  Manhattan  also  built  the  Oklahoma  State  Capitol  building.    Since  its  founding  in  1896,  Manhattan   has   expanded   to   Texas,   Washington,   D.C.,   Georgia   and   Florida,   and  internationally   to   Mexico   and   now   performs   work   throughout   the   United   States,  Mexico  and  the  Caribbean.  

Manhattan  is  widely  known  for  building  high-­‐profile,  technically  difficult  mega  projects  like  Reliant  Stadium  in  Houston,  Texas,  with  the  first  retractable  roof  stadium  in  the  NFL;  the  Dallas  Cowboys  Stadium  in  Arlington,  which  is  recognized  as  the  premier  sports  venue  in  the  world;  and  the  U.S.  Capitol  Visitor  Center  in  Washington,  D.C.,  which  sees  nearly  three  million  visitors  per  year.   Manhattan   has   a   diverse   project   portfolio   and   is   recognized   for   building   excellence   in   sports   stadiums,   healthcare,  government,  education,  laboratory,  aviation,  transportation,  convention,  casino  and  hospitality  facilities.  

The  company  has  grown  into  one  of  the  largest  privately-­‐held  construction  firms  in  the  western  hemisphere  and  continually  ranks   on  Engineering  News  Record’s   top   lists   including   general   building,   sports,   entertainment,   education,   government   and  green  building.  

 

Page 40: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

14    

3.0   Reliant  Park  Analysis  

Page 41: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

15    

3.1  Reliant  Park  Venues  The   Reliant   Park   Complex   includes   four   venues:   Reliant   Stadium,   Reliant   Center,   Reliant   Arena   and   the   Astrodome.     The  Complex  covers  about  350  acres   in  the  heart  of  the  Harris  County  metropolitan  area  and  provides  parking  for  up  to  26,000  automobiles.    The  Complex  hosts  a  variety  of  public  assembly  events  each  year   including   sporting  events,  public   consumer  shows,  conventions,  trade  shows  and  other  entertainment  events.    The  tenants  at  the  Complex  include  the  Houston  Texans  and  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo,  both  of  which  participated  in  the  financing  of  the  Stadium.    The  Reliant  Park  Complex  is  also  host  to  the  annual  Offshore  Technology  Conference  and  many  other  consumer  shows  and  trade  shows  each  year.  

   

Page 42: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

16    

Astrodome  

Opened   in   1965,   the   Astrodome   was   the   world's   first   multi-­‐purpose,  domed   sports   stadium   and  was   nicknamed   the   "Eighth  Wonder   of   the  World”.  This  facility  was  the  home  of  the  Houston  Oilers  until  1997  and  the   Houston   Astros   until   1999.     The   facility   has   seating   for   65,000  patrons  and  has  140,000  contiguous  square  feet  of  column  free  space  for  exhibits,  general  sessions,  food  and  beverage  events  and  concerts.  

As  the  Astrodome  aged  and  the  sports  and  events  industry  evolved,  it  no  longer   met   the   standards   for   a   modern   events   venue.   The   Astrodome  lacks   the   spectator   amenities,   event   accommodations,   operational  efficiencies   and   revenue   producing   elements   that   have   become   the  industry   standard   for   stadiums.     Today,   the  Astrodome   is   no   longer   in  use.    

Conclusions  

With   the   construction   of  Reliant   Stadium,  Minute  Maid  Park,  BBVA  Compass   Stadium  and   the  new   stadium  planned   at   the  University  of  Houston,   restoration  of   the  Astrodome   to   its  original   state   is  not  warranted.     Further,   the   inability   to  use   the  Astrodome   due   to   its   dormant   state   causes   a   number   of   operational   and   logistical   issues   for   major   events   on   site.   Event  producers  and  guests  are  forced  to  work  around  the  Astrodome  and  surrounding  site.        

Page 43: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

17    

Photo  Support  

   West  Entrance   TV  Room    

   Chiller  Piping   Football  Turf    

Page 44: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

18    

   Chilled  Water  Pump   Catwalk    

   Grounds  Pump  Room   ADA  Platform    

Page 45: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

19    

   East  Seating   Telescopic  Seating    

   Suite  Level  Television   Office  Area    

Page 46: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

20    

   Main  Electrical  Distribution   Main  Electrical  Distribution    

   Secondary  Electrical  Distribution   Central  Plant  Electrical  Distribution    

Page 47: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

21    

   Lower  Bowl  Seating   Low  Roof    

Page 48: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

22    

   West  Elevation   Escalator        

Page 49: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

23    

Reliant  Stadium  

In  August  2002,  Reliant  Stadium  was  completed  at  a  cost  of  $442  million.    It  is  the  home  of   the  Houston  Texans   and   the  Houston   Livestock   Show  and  Rodeo.     This  multi-­‐purpose  stadium  has  a  seating  capacity  of  71,500,  a  total  square  footage  of  1,900,000   square   feet   with   97,000  square   feet   of   natural   grass   playing   surface.  Reliant   Stadium   is   the   only   rodeo   and   NFL   indoor/outdoor   retractable   roof,  natural  grass  stadium  that  can  be  configured  to  utilize  a  125,000  square  foot  space  for   general   sessions,   catered   functions,   exhibits,   concerts,   and   much   more.   In  addition,  Reliant  Stadium  offers   four  massive  concourse   levels   for  special  events.  The  design  of   the   stadium  roof  provides   a   very   flexible   rigging   configuration   for  major   audio   and   visual   presentations.   Two   hundred   suites   and   8,187   club   seats  complement  Reliant  Stadium.  

The  Stadium  has  also  hosted  the  2004  Super  Bowl,  the  2008  NCAA  Men’s  Regional  Semi-­‐Finals,  the  2010  NCAA  Men’s  Regional  Semi-­‐Finals  and  the  2011  NCAA  Final  Four.    The  facility  has  also  been  the  home  of  college  football’s  Texas  Bowl,  since  2006.    

Page 50: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

24    

The  following  charts  summarize  the  number  of  events  and  attendance  by  event  type  at  Reliant  Stadium  for  the  past  several  years.  

Total  Number  of  Reliant  Stadium  Events  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

 

 

 

   

0"

25"

50"

75"

100"

125"

150"

175"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FY"2011"

Num

ber'of'Events'

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Entertainment"Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Motor"Sports" NFL" Rodeo"Other"Events"

137'

161' 152'140'

131' 125'

Page 51: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

25    

Reliant  Stadium  Attendance  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

 

     

Notes: Event types are based on Reliant Stadium classifications. Source: CSL International, facility management, 2011

0"

500,000"

1,000,000"

1,500,000"

2,000,000"

2,500,000"

3,000,000"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Attendance(

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Entertainment"

Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"

Motor"Sports" NFL" Rodeo"

Other"Events"

2,421,721(

2,141,189(2,382,716(

2,253,922(2,362,652(

2,713,949(

Page 52: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

26    

 

   

Page 53: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

27    

Reliant  Center  

Reliant  Center  offers  more  than  706,000  square  feet  of  contiguous  single-­‐level  exhibit   space   divisible   into   11   separate   halls   and   boasts   61  meeting   rooms  configurable  into  over  100  variations,  2  major  conference  centers,  118  loading  bays,  over  150,000  square  feet  of  registration  space.    The  venue  is  used  for  a  wide  variety  of  events  ranging  from  major  trade  shows  to  ticketed  consumer  events.  

   

Page 54: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

28    

Over  the  past  several  years,  Reliant  Center  has  hosted  events  ranging  in  attendance  from  a  few  hundred  people  to  more  than  25,000.    However  the  typical  event  has  attendance  of  3,000  –  5,000  per  event  over  multiple  event  days.      The  charts  below  set  forth  the  number  of  events  and  the  annual  attendance  at  Reliant  Center  for  the  past  several  years  of  operation.  

 

Total  Number  of  Reliant  Center  Events  by  Event  Type  

 (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

 

   

0"25"50"75"100"125"150"175"200"225"250"275"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Num

ber'of'Events'

Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show" Convention"Entertainment" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Trade"Show" Other"Events"

124'

257'

141'

96'118'

105'

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Center'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011'

Page 55: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

29    

Reliant  Center  Attendance  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

   

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Center'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011'

0"

150,000"

300,000"

450,000"

600,000"

750,000"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Attendance(

Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show" Convention"Entertainment" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Trade"Show" Other"Events"

625,718( 604,315(

678,850( 660,676(609,918( 585,207(

Page 56: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

30    

Reliant  Arena  

Reliant  Arena  opened   in  1974  and   includes   the  arena  proper,   four  exhibit  halls  and   the  Pavilion.  Features  of  Reliant  Arena  include  a  fixed  seating  capacity  in  the  main  Arena  for  5,800;  275,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space  and  over  18,000  square  feet  of  meeting  space.    

Reliant  Arena  has  served  Harris  County  very  well  since  1974;  however,  it  is  now  well  beyond  the  end  of  its  expected  usable  life  and  should  be  replaced  with  a  new  arena  facility  and  associated  exhibition  space  in  order  to  contribute  to  the  future  success  of  Reliant   Park   and   the   greater   Harris   County   community.   It   is   only   through   an   aggressive   repair   and  maintenance   program  conducted  by  Harris  County  Sports  and  Convention  Corporations  and  SMG  that  the  facility  and  its  major  systems  continue  to  function.   The   facility   does   not   possess   the   requisite   technology   and   production   support   elements   that   are   demanded   by  today’s   event   producers.   The   guest   experience   elements   that   are   critical   customer   influencers   in   making   discretionary  spending  decisions  are  absent  from  the  facility.  

Reliant  Arena  was  designed  at  a  time  when  the  focus  was  “Public  Assembly”.  Guests  would  arrive,  view  the  event  and  depart.  There  was  not   any   reasonable  design  effort   in   guest   amenities.  The   food   service  areas   including   linear   counter   space,   food  prep,  presentation,  point  of  sale  transactions  and  cooking  were  not  designed  to  support  anything  other  than  the  most  basic  items  and  does  not  meet  even  today’s  minimum  standards.  

The  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  has  grown  in  annual  attendance  from  1.5  million  in  2002  to  over  2  million  attendees  in  2011.  Show  organizers  have  expressed  concerns  regarding  the  condition  of  Reliant  Arena,  its  location  relative  to  Reliant  Center  and  the  Arena’s  ability  to  meet  the  long  term  needs  of  the  HLSR.  Further,  the  HLSR  has  stated  that  there  is  insufficient  space  for  warm-­‐up  arenas,  practice  arenas  and  stall  space  in  Reliant  Arena.  

Page 57: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

31    

In   the   10   years   that   have   passed   since   the   opening   of   Reliant   Center,   the   OTC   has   outgrown   the   available   exhibition   and  meeting  space   in  both  Reliant  Center  and  Reliant  Arena.  Over   the  years,   event  organizers  have   tried   to   satisfy   the  need   for  additional  exhibition  space  by  using  the  Reliant  Stadium  floor  and  creating  temporary  exhibit  space  using  air-­‐conditioned  tents  in   the  parking   lots.  Resisting   for   years   to  use  Reliant  Arena  due   to   its   remote   location  on   the   site   and   the   condition  of   the  facility.  The  OTC  finally  moved  into  Reliant  Arena  following  torrential  rains  just  prior  to  the  event  in  2009  that  forced  the  OTC  to  abandon  over  200,000  square  feet  of  tents  constructed  in  the  Orange  Lot.  All  of  the  exhibits  housed  in  the  tents  were  moved  to  the  Arena  just  days  before  the  opening  of  the  show.  Since  that  time,  the  OTC  has  continued  to  use  the  Arena  and  currently  uses  all  the  available  space  in  Reliant  Center  and  Reliant  Arena.  Due  to  the  demand  for  additional  exhibition  space,  the  OTC  has  added  a  50,000  square  foot  tent  in  the  parking  lot  for  this  year’s  event.  Show  organizers  did  consider  using  the  Stadium  floor  in  

SEA

TIN

GS

TOR

AG

E

SEATINGSTORAGE

SEATIN

GS

TOR

AG

E

SEA

TIN

G

SEATING

SEATIN

G

20'x

12'

14'x

12'

13'10"x15'8'x15'

22'x15'

8'x15'

11'x11'

25'x

11'

25'x

11'

15'1

1"x1

3'9"

6'9"x9'

6'9"x9'

22'x

16'

7'x3'10"

11'x10'

20'x13'10"

10'w

3'10

"11

'w3'

10"

8'x13'10"

8'x10'EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXITEX

IT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT EXITEXIT

EXITEXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXITS EXITS EXIT EXIT

ELEV.

ELEV.

ELEV

.

ELEV. ELEV.

MEN WOMENINFO

INFO

EXIT

EXIT

EXITEXIT

EXITEXIT

EXIT

EXIT EXIT EXIT EXIT EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

EXIT

WW WW WW

WW

WW

ELECTR

ICA

LS

WITC

H B

OX

DRIVE INFRONT DOOR

20'x 20'

FREIGHT DOCKFRT. DOOR12'x13'9"

DOCK FRT. DOOR12'x13'9"

FRT. DOOR12'x13'9"

FRT.

DO

OR

20'x

13'9

"

FRT. D

OO

R22'x13'9"

SLIDING DOOR22'x13'

FRT.

DO

OR

11'

4"x1

3'10

"

FRT. DOOR20' X 20'

FRT. DOOR20' X 20'

FRT. DOOR20' X 20'

C

WO

MEN

WO

MEN

MEN

MEN

WOMEN

WO

MEN

C

C

MEN

WO

MEN

CONCESSIONM

EN

WO

MEN

TICKET TICKET

TICKET

FIRSTAID

PH

ON

ES

PH

ON

ES

PH

ON

ESP

HO

NES

PH

ON

ES

INFO INFOCORRAL

P

D

MEN

WO

MEN

MEN

CONC

ESSI

ON

MEN

INFO

ACCESS TOLEVEL 2 ACCESS TO

LEVEL 2

HA

ND

ICA

PLIFT

LOC

KER

RO

OM

A

LOC

KER

RO

OM

B

30' CEILING

30' CEILIN

G

15' CEILING 12' CEILING

12'6" CEILIN

G

14' CEILING

47' CEILINGLIMIT TO LIGHTS

(67'MAX)

12' C

EILI

NG

30' CEILIN

G LIM

IT26' C

EILING

LIMIT

15' C

EILI

NG

FREIGHT DOCK

RAMP

101100 20

120

0

SEATIN

G SEA

TIN

G

SEATIN

G SEA

TIN

G

SEATING SEATING

103102101 20

320

220

1

107106105 20

720

620

5

107

108

109

207208209

110111112

210211212

105104103 20

520

420

3

RAMPUP

RAMPUP

RAMPUP

RAMPUP

RAMPUP

DRIVE INRAMP

A(high)25,000'

Pavilion25,000'

Lobby25,000'

C50,000'

D100,000'

A(low)50,000'

B50,000'

Arena24,000'

Level 1

Page 58: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

32    

lieu  of  tents  for  additional  exhibition  space,  but  felt  that  managing  the  traffic  flow  between  all  three  buildings  would  be  difficult  for  attendees.  

The  following  areas  have  been  identified  at  Reliant  Arena  that  support  the  recommendation  for  replacement:  

General  Condition  

Due  to  the  age  of  Reliant  Arena,  the  overall  feel  of  the  facility  is  utilitarian  and  generally  unappealing.  The  signage  is  fixed  and   is   not   consistent   with   the   look   and   feel   that   sponsors,   advertisers   and   business   partners   expect.   The   finishes   are  institutional,   and   there   are   virtually   no   premium   fan   amenities   such   as   suites,   clubs,   or   loge   boxes.   The   general   fan  amenities   including   quality   comfortable   seating,   video   boards,   high   quality   public   address   sound   system   and   fan  destinations  do  not  exist  in  the  facility  as  it  exists  today.    

Loading  Dock  

There  is  no  dedicated  Loading  Dock  space  to  service  the  arena  proper.  There  is  only  one  loading  dock  bay,  which  creates  an  increased   cost   for   events,   as   they   require   additional   labor   to   offload   the   numerous   trucks   that   contain   show   technical  equipment.  This  is  an  inconvenience  and  a  cost  that  events  consider  when  determining  show  locations.  The  loading  dock  issue   is   exacerbated   by   the   fact   that   the   production   or   stage   end   of   the   seating   bowl   actually   opens   into   what   would  normally  be  considered  the  main  entry.    Shows  conduct  their  technical  load-­‐in  through  standard  pedestrian  doors.  

Dressing  Rooms  and  Production  Spaces  

There  are  insufficient  support  spaces  including  dressing  and  locker  rooms  to  service  today’s  event  needs,  including  the  lack  of  a  Green  Room  and  flexible  band  and  production  spaces.  The  rooms  that  are  available  are  very  small  and  narrow.  They  do  not  meet   the   expectations   of   today’s   show   producers.   There   is   no   adequate   location   for   crew   catering   and   no   area   to  support  traveling  show  catering  operations.  

Seating  

The  arena  bowl  seating  is  not  consistent  with  today’s  guest  expectation  including  the  tread  depth  and  physical  seats  and  standards.  Today’s  arena  facilities  typically  utilize  retractable  seating  in  order  to  gain  more  flexible  flat  floor  space  that  can  accommodate  a  wider  variety  of  events,  increasing  the  facility’s  ability  to  generate  revenue.    

Page 59: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

33    

The  railing  along  the  front  row  of  the  lower  bowl  is  designed  in  a  way  that  fans  can  easily  slip  through  and  onto  the  floor  during  events.    The  arena  must  use  an  ADA  wheelchair  lift  to  meet  its  obligations  to  the  fans.  This  is  not  consistent  with  how  today’s  arena  facilities  provide  service.  

The   seating   capacity   of   5,800   fixed   seats   provides   limited   opportunity   for   events.     A   fixed   seating   capacity   of   8,000   to  10,000  with  the  opportunity  for  2,000  additional  floor  seats  would  provide  a  capacity  with  an  ability  to  accommodate  80%  of  all  current  concert  tours  in  North  America,  as  well  as,  all  of  the  current  touring  family  shows  and  most  special  events.  

Backstage  

In  a  rather  unique  design,  the  area  behind  the  stage  location  is  a  large  public  lobby  (an  operable  wall  separates  the  stage  area  from  this  lobby).  The  result  is  that  there  is  no  true  “backstage”  area,  and  one  must  be  created  in  adjacent  exhibit  halls.  Securing  this  lobby,  when  required,  is  extremely  difficult.    

Show  Technical  Production  

For  shows  that  use  sidewall  video,  this  is  a  challenge  in  that  the  use  of  sidewall  video  screens  requires  the  capacity  to  be  reduced,  as  the  video  screens  have  to  be  placed  out  over  the  seating  area.  Also,  the  floor  to  grid  height  is  only  37’,  which  is  extremely   low  for   today’s  events  and  severely   limits  shows  ability   to  manage   their   technical  production  of  sound,   lights  and  special  effects.  There  is  limited  upstage  power.  Due  to  the  glass  around  the  facility,  achieving  blackout  situations  in  the  bowl  have  proven  to  be  difficult  during  daytime  events,  which  would  include  family  show  events.  The  combination  of  these  multiple  production  challenges  is  a  critical  deterrent  to  events  seeking  to  book  Reliant  Arena.  

Program  

In   Reliant   Arena,   the   concourses   are   very   narrow,   offering   limited   space   for   concession   and   merchandise   sales.   The  concession   lines   frequently   cross   into   the   narrow   concourse   creating   circulation   obstructions.   The   restrooms   are  inadequate  by  today’s  standards  in  both  number  of  locations  and  guest  -­‐to-­‐restroom  ratio.  

Meeting  and  Exhibition  Space  

Reliant  Arena  includes  275,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space,  18,000  square  feet  of  meeting  space  and  its  Pavilion  also  provides  1,700  fixed  seats  in  a  presentation  format.  There  are  significant  issues  with  all  of  these  spaces  as  they  relate  to  meeting   the  needs  of  users   from  small   to   large   campus  wide   events.  The   condition  of   these   spaces  has   long   since   gone  

Page 60: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

34    

beyond  their  expected  usable  life  and  lack  appeal.  The  ceiling  heights  do  not  meet  the  needs  of  today’s  users,  the  electrical  service  and  technology  access  and  interface  are  not  adequate  to  meet  today’s  event,  convention  and  exhibition  presenters.  The  location  of  roof  support  columns  presents  a  significant  obstacle  to  exhibition  users.    

Location  

With  the  opening  of  Reliant  Center  in  2002  and  the  subsequent  demolition  of  the  Astrohall  that  same  year,  Reliant  Arena  was  left  isolated  from  the  newer  facilities  making  it  difficult  for  users  to  take  full  advantage  of  the  complex  for  major  events.  Usage   is   typically   limited   to   smaller  stand-­‐alone  events.  For   larger  events,  most  users   find   the   location  of   the  arena   too  distant  from  Reliant  Center  and/or  Reliant  Stadium  and  view  it  as  a  last  choice  when  booking  the  Reliant  Park  complex  for  anything  other  than  smaller  arena  events.  These  concerns  are  aggravated  by  having  to  navigate  around  the  Astrodome.  

Maintenance  and  Capital  Repairs  

Although  Reliant  Arena  is  operational  today,  during  recent  years  the  HCSCC  and  Harris  County  have  spent  over  $8  million  dollars   on   capital   repairs   for   Reliant   Arena   and   Plant   II,   which   provides   chilled  water   for   the   Arena’s   air-­‐conditioning  system  to  keep  the  facility  in  operation  condition.  These  repairs  include,  but  are  not  limited  to,  structural  and  foundation  repairs   to   the   northeast   exterior  wall,   roof   repairs,   operable  wall   replacement   for   the  mezzanine   level  meeting   rooms,  cooling  tower  replacement,  installation  of  a  new  fire  alarm  system,  chiller  replacement,  arena  floor   lighting  replacement  and  installation  of  a  new  building  automation  system.  Given  the  age  of  the  mechanical  and  electrical  systems  in  the  Arena  most,  if  not  all,  are  at  the  end  of  their  useful  life  expectancy  and  are  energy  inefficient.  

Electrical  Service  

The  electrical  service  for  Reliant  Arena,  Plant  II  and  large  areas  of  the  parking  lots,  feeds  through  the  Astrodome  and  the  Astrodome   substation.   Any   plans   regarding   the   future   of   the  Astrodome  must   take   into   consideration  how   to  maintain  electrical  service  to  these  areas  in  the  event  the  Astrodome  is  renovated  or  demolished  

   

Page 61: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

35    

Summary  

Reliant  Arena  does  not  meet  the  expectations  of  users  and  guests,  which  limits  its  marketability  and  revenue  generating  ability.  Listed  below  is  a  summary  of  concerns  expressed  by  users  and  potential  users  regarding  Reliant  Arena.  

• The  ceiling  in  the  arena  proper  is  too  low  and  lacks  the  rigging  capacity  required  for  major  event  production.  

• The  seating  capacity  is  too  low  to  attract  the  majority  of  touring  events.  

• The   exhibit   space   adjacent   to   the   arena   is   divided   into   five   separate   halls   of   various   sizes   making   show   layout  inefficient.    Access  and  circulation  within  the  halls  is  awkward  and  confusing.  

• The  exhibit  halls  have  low  ceiling  heights  with  poor  quality  lighting  and  inadequate  event  power  and  data  capabilities.  

• Concession   facilities  are   limited  and  outdated  and  do  not  offer  guests  attending  events   the  variety  and/or  quality  of  products  expected.  

• There  is  no  secure  backstage  area  with  loading  facilities  for  events.  

• There  are  only  two  (2)  small  locker  rooms,  which  can  only  be  accessed  from  the  public  concourse.  

• There  are  an  insufficient  number  of  restrooms  and  the  current  restroom  facilities  and  amenities  are  of  poor  quality  and  outdated.  

Conclusion  

It  is  important  to  recognize  Reliant  Arena  and  the  supporting  exhibition  and  meeting  spaces  role  in  serving  the  entire  Reliant  Center   complex,   the   primary   tenants   and   the   citizens   of   Harris   County;   however,   the   facility   no   longer   has   the   ability   to  provide  the  desired  support  to  events  and  guests  and  should  be  replaced.    A  new  arena  would  provide  the  Reliant  Center  with  the  ability  to  compete  for  a  variety  of  events  that  are  not  currently  accommodated  at  the  existing  venue.      

   

Page 62: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

36    

Photo  Support  

Arena  seating  tread  depths  and  quality  of  the  seats  (i.e.  plastic)  no  longer  meets  the  needs  of  today’s  guests.                            

Fixed  arena  wall  and  open  railings  makes  it  easy  for  guests  in  the  fixed  bowl  to  get  onto  the  floor.        

Page 63: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

37    

Low  ceiling  and  rigging  steel  height  is  a  significant  disadvantage  to  event  technical  production.                            

 The   lack  of   show  or  production   flex   space   in   the   arena  bowl   results   in   temporary   support   space  having   to  be   constructed,  lowering  the  overall  seat  count  for  events.  

                       

Page 64: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

38    

Current  technology  is  outdated.    

                       

 Public  Address  sound  system  does  not  meet  today’s  standards.  

                     

Page 65: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

39    

Event  producers  conduct  technical  load-­‐in  through  these  pedestrian  doors.                            

 Photo  of  public  concourse;  the  concourses  are  “institutional”  and  do  not  meet  the  needs  of  today’s  customer’s  expectations.      

Page 66: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

40    

Club  area  is  located  behind  the  stage  with  outdated  technology  and  finishes.                            

 Area  generally  considered  the  front  door  of  the  facility  used  for  technical  load-­‐in,  and  event  bus/truck  parking.    

                     

Page 67: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

41    

Concourses  lack  the  width  to  sell  merchandise  or  place  sponsor/advertiser  displays  and  maintain  a  reasonable  path  of  travel  for  guests.  

                         

The  area  around  Reliant  Arena  and  the  exhibit  spaces  does  not  have  the  access  and  ability  to  support  either  the  facility  or  the  event  users.  

                     

Page 68: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

42    

The  ceiling  heights,  rigging  capacity  and  technology  are  not  up  to  today’s  user  standards.    

                       

 Access   into   the   facilities   is   limited   and   inadaquate.   In   addition   the   positioning   of   facility   retated   equipment   as   in   the   air  handler  shown  in  the  photo  below  further  exacerbate  the  problems.  

               

Page 69: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

43    

The  columns  shown  in  the  photo  below  create  a  significant  obstacle  to  potential  users.        

Page 70: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

44    

Annually,  Reliant  Arena  hosts  various  events  including  concerts,  family  shows,  trade  shows,  exhibitions,  and  other  such  events.    The  following  charts  provide  summaries  of  the  events  and  attendance  hosted  at  the  facility  in  recent  years.  

 

Total  Number  of  Reliant  Arena  Events  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

                                       

 

0"

20"

40"

60"

80"

100"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Num

ber'of'Events'

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show"Entertainment" Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage"Meeting"&"Seminar" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

35'

59' 59'

41'

79'

45'

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Arena'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011.'

Page 71: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

45    

Reliant  Arena  Attendance  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

                                     

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Arena'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011.'

0"

50,000"

100,000"

150,000"

200,000"

250,000"

300,000"

350,000"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Attendance(

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show"Entertainment" Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage"Meeting"&"Seminar" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

128,418(

209,397(235,343(

303,952(

188,533( 189,423(

Page 72: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

46    

3.2  Reliant  Park  Tenants  and  Major  Users  There  are  two  tenants  located  within  Reliant  Park;  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  and  the  Houston  Texans.    Both  use  Reliant   Stadium   as   their   home   venue,   although   the  HLSR,   in   particular,   utilizes   the   entire   Reliant   Park   Complex   during   its  event.    In  addition,  the  OTC  and  Feld  Entertainment  (Feld)  are  significant  users  of  the  Complex.    The  OTC  is  held  the  first  week  of  May  each  year  and  is  the  region’s  largest  annual  convention  with  over  80,000  attendees.  Feld  books  multiple  family  shows  at  the  Complex  each  year,  accounting  for  more  than  fifty  performances  annually.  

Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  

The  HLSR  occupies  Reliant  Park  for  essentially  six  weeks  in  the  spring  each  year   and  may   occupy   Reliant   Park   for   18   consecutive   days   between   June  23rd  and   July  24th  of  any  calendar  year.    While   the  events  are  taking  place,  HLSR  has  exclusive  rights  to  occupy  the  entire  Reliant  Park  complex,  other  than  offices  and  spaces  occupied  by  the  Texans,  SMG,  HCSCC  and  the  Reliant  Park  operations  on  a  year-­‐round  basis.  During  the  spring  and  summer  HLSR  periods,  HCSCC  may  not  hold  events  at  Reliant  Park,   including   events   at   the   Astrodome.     This   exclusivity   will   have   to   be   addressed   in   any   redevelopment   plan   for   the  Astrodome.  

Two  documents  were  reviewed  related  to  HLSR:  (i)  HLSR  Stadium  Lease  agreement  by  and  between  the  HCSCC  and  the  HLSR  and  (ii)  Stadium  Tri-­‐Party  Agreement  by  and  among  the  HCSCC,  the  HLSR  and  the  Texans.    The  basic  provisions  of  these  two  agreements  provide  that  HLSR  has  a  30-­‐year  term  to  occupy  Reliant  Park,  commencing  in  2002  and  continuing  through  2031.    During  the  term,  the  HLSR  has  the  exclusive  right  to  host  (i)  events  containing  entertainment  and  agricultural  exhibitions  and  competitions,  (ii)  rodeo-­‐like  events  and  (iii)  certain  livestock  and  equestrian  events.    

Page 73: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

47    

Houston  Texans  

The  Houston   Texans   football   team   of   the   National   Football   League   is   the   other  major   tenant  within  Reliant  Park.    The  team  has  the  exclusive  right  to  exhibit  professional  football  at  any  facility  owned  by  Harris  County.    The  team  holds  ten  home  games  each  season  from  mid-­‐August  through  early  January.    When  the  team  makes  the  playoffs,  additional  home  games  can  occur.    During  home  games  the  team  has  exclusive  rights  to  the  parking  lots  within  Reliant  Park,  making  access  to  the  Astrodome  difficult.      

Two   documents  were   reviewed   related   to   the   team:   (i)   NFL   Club   Stadium   Lease   Agreement   by   and  between  HCSCC  and  the  team  and  (ii)  Stadium  Tri-­‐Party  Agreement  by  and  among  HCSCC,  the  team  and  HLSR.    The  team  has  a  30-­‐year  term  to  occupy  Reliant  Park,  commencing  in  2002  and  continuing  through  2031.  

   

Page 74: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

48    

Offshore  Technology  Conference  

The   Offshore   Technology   Conference   was   founded   in   1969   by   twelve   engineering   and   scientific  organizations   in   response   to   the   growing   technological   needs   of   the   global   ocean   extraction   and  environmental  protection  industries.  Interdisciplinary  and  cross-­‐sector  cooperation  was  becoming  acute  as  both  industries  moved  into  more  hostile  environments  and  unknown  operating  conditions.  

The   first   conference   was   held   in   the   Albert   Thomas   Convention   Center,   and   as   significance   of   the  conference  grew  overnight,  larger  facilities  at  the  Astrodome  Complex  were  booked  annually  for  the  next  33  years.  As   the  offshore   industry  continued  to  grow,  so  did   the  stature  and  size  of   the  OTC,  reaching  a  peak  attendance   in  1982   of   108,000   and   an   exhibition   of  more   than   2,500   companies.     Since   the   early   1980's,   shifting   business,   political,   and  economic  paradigms  have  altered  the  complexion  of  the  OTC,  but  not  its  status  as  the  one  "must-­‐attend"  technical  conference  for  engineers  and  scientists  working  in  the  offshore  industry.  In  2003,  the  OTC  moved  into  Reliant  Center,  and  today  occupies  the  Center,  Reliant   Stadium,   a  Pavilion  built   on-­‐site,   and  an  outdoor  exhibit   area,   totaling  an  area  equivalent   to  10   football  fields.    Throughout  its  40-­‐year  history,  the  OTC  has  maintained  its  relevance  to  the  offshore  industry,  and  has  initiated  several  programs  to  expand  the  scope  and  prestige  of  its  coverage.  

The  OTC  is  also  significant   for  Harris  County,  having  generated  nearly  $1.8  billion   in  economic   impact   for   the  area.   It   is   the  largest  convention  held  in  the  region  each  year.    The  OTC  ranks  among  the  largest  200  trade  shows  held  annually  in  the  United  States  and  is  among  the  10  largest  meetings  in  terms  of  attendance.  Each  year  the  OTC  attracts  more  than  60,000  attendees  and  2,000  exhibiting  companies  representing  more  than  110  countries.  The  current  agreement  for  the  use  of  Reliant  Park  by  the  OTC  extends  through  the  2012  event.    The  current  agreement  has  a  four-­‐year  term.    The  event  has  been  very  successful  at  the  current  location  and  has  been  based  in  the  Harris  County  area  for  its  entire  40-­‐year  history.      

Given   the  size  of   the  OTC,   the  event  would  be  able   to  use  an   indoor  space  with   the  height  of   the  Astrodome   to  expand   the  existing  scope  and  size  of  the  conference.    This  would  lead  to  increased  revenues  to  the  HCSCC  from  the  event,  as  rent,  food  and  beverage  and  parking  revenues  would  all  increase.    However,  the  OTC  has  outgrown  available  permanent  space  at  Reliant  Center   and  Reliant   Arena   and   temporary   tents   are   used   to   provide   approximately   50,000   square   feet   of   additional   exhibit  space.  Thus,  without  the  proposed  Reliant  Arena  Replacement  and/or  the  use  of  the  Astrodome  to  accommodate  these  needs  going   forward,   these   space   constraints   will   need   to   be   addressed   in   another  manner   or   there   is   a   risk   that   the   OTC  may  relocate  to  a  larger  venue.  

Page 75: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

49    

Feld  Entertainment  

Feld  Entertainment  was  established  in  1967  and  has  presented  events  in  over  65  countries  and  six  continents  since  that  time,  making  Feld  the   largest  provider  of   live  family  entertainment   in  the  world.    Over  30  million  people  attend  Feld  Entertainment's  productions  every  year.  On  any  given  day,  more  than  30  live  performances  that  bear  the  Feld  Entertainment  brand  take  place,  including  Disney  on  Ice,  Ringling  Bros.  and  Barnum  &  Bailey,  Disney  Live,  Arenacross,  Monster  Jam,  Nuclear  Cowboys,  Monster  Energy  Supercross.  In  1967,  Feld  purchased  Ringling  Bros.  and  Barnum  &  Bailey  and  subsequently  created  a  second  touring  unit.    Additional  Feld  innovations  included  television  specials,  national  advertising  campaigns  and  creative  public  relations.  With  these   efforts   and   the   many   that   followed,   Feld   catapulted   Ringling   Bros.   back   to   its   rightful   place   as   America's   premier  entertainment  experience  and  the  event  now  has  the  proud  distinction  of  being  the  only  source  of  live  family  entertainment  to  have  performed  nonstop  in  three  centuries.  

In  1980,  Feld  added  two  ice  based  shows  to  its  business  –  Ice  Follies  and  Holiday  on  Ice.    One  year  later,  an  agreement  was  reached  with   Disney   and  Walt   Disney’s  World   on   Ice  was   added   and   continues   to   be   one   of   the  most   successful   of   Feld’s  productions   to   this   day.     Feld   Motor   Sports   was   created   in   2007   and   is   the   world   leader   in   producing   and   promoting  specialized   arena   and   stadium-­‐based  motor   sports   entertainment  with  more   than  600  performances  worldwide,   attracting  over  five  million  fans  each  year.    Feld  Entertainment  also  produced  Siegfried  &  Roy  at  the  Mirage  Hotel  in  Las  Vegas  for  nearly  25  years  and  has  contributed  to  numerous  live  shows  both  on  and  off  Broadway.  

Twenty-­‐five   to   thirty-­‐five   Feld   events   are   hosted   at   Reliant   Park   each   year,   including  Ringling  Bros.   and  Barnum  &  Bailey,  Disney  on  Ice  and  Monster  Jam,  with  most  shows  being  held  at  Reliant  Stadium.    It  is  anticipated  that  many  Feld  shows  would  move  to  the  Replacement  Arena  upon  its  completion,  which  would  be  a  venue  much  more  conducive  to  hosting  these  types  of  events.    Operating  costs  would  be  reduced  dramatically  and  the  Arena  would  allow  for  a  better  overall  fan  experience.    Total  annual  attendance  for  Feld  programming  over  the  past  six  fiscal  years  has  ranged  from  200,000  to  nearly  400,000.    

   

Page 76: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park  Analysis  

50    

Operating  Agreements  

Naming  Rights  Agreement  

The  Texans  and  HLSR  have  the  exclusive  right  to  jointly  market,  negotiate  and  enter  into  agreements  covering  the  licensing  of  all  naming  rights,  branding  rights,  pourage  rights,  service  rights,  signage,  advertising  and  sponsors  and  other  marketing  rights  to   the   entirety  of  Reliant  Park   (including   the  Astrodome);  provided,   however,   that   if   the  Astrodome   is   replaced,  materially  renovated  or  expanded  for  the  purpose  of  either  (a)  changing  its  primary  use  to  a  use  other  than  as  a  spectator  facility  or  (b)  allowing  a  new  primary  tenant  who  will  not  use  the  Astrodome  as  a  spectator  facility,  the  Texans  and  HLSR  do  not  have  any  such  aforementioned  rights  as  to  the  Astrodome.  

Food  Service  Agreement  

 ARAMARK   has   the   right,   subject   to   the   various   exclusions,   to   provide   food,   beverage,   and   retail  merchandise   concessions  within   Reliant   Park,   bounded,   approximately,   by   Kirby   on   the  West,   Loop   610   on   the   South,   Fannin   on   the   East   and   the  property  line  from  Kirby  to  Fannin  on  the  North  side  of  Reliant  Park.    Accordingly,  so  long  as  the  Astrodome  is  used  as  a  public  assembly  venue  facility,  for  the  term  of  the  ARAMARK  Concessions  Agreement  (from  April  1,  2002  through  March  31,  2017),  ARAMARK  has  the  exclusive  right  to  provide  food,  beverage  and  retail  merchandise  concessions  in  the  Astrodome.    However,  if  the  Astrodome  is  redeveloped  as  a  hotel  (even  if  the  hotel  includes  public  meeting  space)  or  other  venue  that  is  not  a  public  assembly  venue  facility,  such  redeveloped  facility  will  be  excluded  from  the  ARAMARK  Concessions  Agreement.  

 

Page 77: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park Analysis  

51    

3.3  Historical  Operating  Performance  HCSCC   and   SMG   have   been   successful   at   operating   the   various   venues   in   Reliant   Park,   particularly   given   the   scheduling  constraints  that  are  imposed  because  of  the  Texans  and  the  HLSR  scheduling  needs.  Essentially,  SMG  is  able  to  schedule  events  only  one  week  each  month  (the  Protected  Week)  during  the  Texans’  season,  prior  to  the  April  preceding  those  months,  when  the  NFL  schedule  is  released.    Because  of  this  restriction,  the  number  of  large-­‐scale  conventions  and  trade  shows  that  can  be  scheduled  are  limited  because  these  types  of  shows  book  venues  several  years  in  advance.      

The  chart  below  summarizes  the  historical  financial  performance  at  Reliant  Park.  

 

 

   

Page 78: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park Analysis  

52    

The  table  below  breaks  down  the  event  operating  performance  of  Reliant  Park  over  the  past  several  years.    As  shown,  Reliant  Park  hosts   very  profitable   events.    However,   the   overhead   and   related   expenses   incurred   in  Reliant  Park  operations   cause  operating  income  to  be  negative  in  some  years,  as  shown  above.  

   Note:     In  2011,   the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  started   in  February,  whereas   in  previous  years   it  has  always  started   in  March.    We  have  not  included  the  2011  HLSR  in  the  numbers  above  though  they  would  be  included  in  SMG’s  figures  for  the  2010-­‐2011  fiscal  year  for  accounting  purposes.          

Page 79: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park Analysis  

53    

The  Event  Income,  broken  down  by  Reliant  Park  venue,  is  set  forth  below.    The  Astrodome  ceased  being  used  for  public  events  during  the  2007-­‐2008  fiscal  year  and  thus  the  data  for  that  venue  is  only  included  for  the  first  three  fiscal  years  of  this  analysis.    

 

Reliant(Stadium

Rev Exp

Event(Income((Loss) Events Event(Days Attendance NOI/Event

2005$06 16,822,048 9,059,856 7,762,192 137 73 2,421,721 $56,6582006$07 15,691,815 9,317,824 6,373,992 162 18 2,141,209 $39,3462007$08 14,952,372 7,983,642 6,968,730 152 143 2,382,716 $45,8472008$09 18,639,754 9,229,847 9,409,906 131 94 2,253,922 $71,8312009$10 18,233,021 9,414,381 8,818,640 125 81 2,362,652 $70,5492010$11 23,993,890 13,350,222 10,643,667 140 114 2,713,949 $76,026

Reliant(Center

Rev Exp

Event(Income((Loss) Events Event(Days Attendance NOI/Event

2005$06 8,578,641 2,694,052 5,884,589 124 242 625,718 $47,4562006$07 9,133,889 2,644,252 6,489,637 257 33 604,315 $25,2522007$08 10,156,762 2,960,437 7,196,325 141 266 678,850 $51,0382008$09 10,207,449 3,222,918 6,984,531 118 268 660,676 $59,1912009$10 9,767,339 3,133,675 6,633,664 105 218 609,918 $63,1782010$11 9,252,771 2,905,058 6,347,712 96 182 585,207 $66,122

Reliant(Arena

Rev Exp

Event(Income((Loss) Events Event(Days Attendance NOI/Event

2005$06 1,606,599 784,629 821,970 35 35 128,418 $23,4852006$07 3,371,391 2,117,728 1,253,663 59 12 209,397 $21,2492007$08 3,658,999 2,077,922 1,581,077 59 63 235,343 $26,7982008$09 4,980,967 2,873,734 2,107,233 79 95 303,952 $26,6742009$10 3,027,460 1,920,166 1,107,295 45 40 188,533 $24,6072010$11 2,883,599 1,698,554 1,185,045 41 41 189,423 $28,904

Parking(Lots

Rev Exp

Event(Income((Loss) Events Event(Days Attendance NOI/Event

2005$06 626,600 186,140 440,460 8 22 169,615 $55,0582006$07 1,842,758 803,876 1,038,882 33 3 281,699 $31,4812007$08 1,877,152 1,068,303 808,849 23 41 276,312 $35,1672008$09 439,444 169,325 270,118 29 52 250,083 $9,3142009$10 503,688 330,905 172,783 21 31 272,231 $8,2282010$11 497,528 215,340 282,187 25 45 300,790 $11,287

Astrodome

Rev Exp

Event(Income((Loss) Events Event(Days Attendance NOI/Event

2005$06 570,725 344,546 226,179 6 7 11,812 $37,6972006$07 235,755 131,753 104,002 19 0 22,777 $5,4742007$08 3,469 4,760 (1,292) 2 2 3,679 ($646)

Page 80: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

3.0  Reliant  Park Analysis  

54    

3.4  Summary  –  Reliant  Park  Analysis  Reliant  Park  is  a  unique  public  assembly  complex  that  provides  a  wide  variety  of  options  for  different  uses.    The  complex  is  home   to   major   economic   drivers   to   the   Harris   County   community.     Between   the   Texans,   HLSR,   and   Offshore   Technology  Conference,   the   Complex   generates   significant   economic   and   fiscal   impacts   for   the   County.     These   events   also   generate  significant  revenue  for  the  complex.        The  venues  also  vary  in  age  and  condition,  ranging  from  the  state  of  the  art  Reliant  Stadium  and  Reliant  Center  to  the  outdated  Reliant  Arena  and  unusable  Astrodome.    The  complex  has  typically  hosted  anywhere  from  300  to  500  events  per  year  with  the  total  attendance  each  year  exceeding  3.0  million  people.    Reliant  Stadium  and  Reliant  Center  provide  amenities  consistent  with  comparable  venues  around  the  country  while  the  amenities  related  to  the  Reliant  Arena  directly  influence  the  venues  ability  to  attract  new  shows   to   the  market.    The  Astrodomes  condition  also  directly   impact   the  ability  of   the  Center   to  maximize   the  usage  of  the  space  for  a  variety  of  shows  that  could  utilize  additional  space.    The  inability  of  the  complex  of  the  book  major  shows  due  to  the  restrictions  of  the  tenant  lease  agreements  also  directly  impacts  the  facility  usage.    

Page 81: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

55    

4.0   Market  Analysis  

Page 82: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

56    

The  demographic  and  socioeconomic  profiles  of  the  local  market  are  important  considerations  when  assessing  the  potential  success   of   any   large  mixed  use   real   estate   development.     The   strength   of   a  market   in   terms  of   its   ability   to   attract   events,  attract  patrons  and  generate  revenues  is  measured,  to  some  extent,  by  the  size  of  the  regional  market  area  population  and  its  income   characteristics.     Specific   demographic   and   socioeconomic   information   can   provide   an   indication   of   the   ability   of   a  market  to  support  a  sports  and  entertainment  venue  includes  population,  median  age,  age  distribution,  household  income  and  corporate  base.    

4.1  Harris  County  Market  Overview  Harris  County  had  a  population  of  4.1  million  based  on  the  2010  census,  making  it  the  most  populous  county  in  Texas  and  the  third  most  populous  county  in  the  U.S.,  ranking  only  behind  Los  Angeles  County  and  Cook  County  (Chicago).  The  cost  of  living  in  Harris  County  is  among  the  lowest  of  all  markets  in  the  United  States.  The  2010  annual  average  cost  of  living  index  shows  that  Harris  County’s  overall  after-­‐taxes  living  costs  are  nine  percent  below  the  national  average,  due  to  housing  costs  that  are  21  percent  below  the  average.    Twenty-­‐three  companies  on  the  2010  Fortune  500  list  are  headquartered  in  the  Harris  County  area.  Only  two  metropolitan  statistical  areas  have  more  Fortune  500  headquarters:  New  York  with  74  and  Chicago  with  27.    Major   institutions   of   higher   learning   include   Rice   University,   Texas   Southern   University,   University   of   Houston   (UH,   UH-­‐Downtown  and  UH-­‐Clear  Lake),  University  of  St.  Thomas,  Houston  Baptist  University,  the  Houston  Community  College  and  San  Jacinto  College.  Harris  County’s  two  medical  schools  are  the  University  of  Texas  Medical  School  and  Baylor  College  of  Medicine.  

Cultural  attractions  in  the  Harris  County  area  include  a  thriving  theater  district  and  numerous  museums.  Year-­‐round  resident  companies   in   the  major  performing   arts   include   the  Houston  Symphony  Orchestra,   the  Houston  Grand  Opera,   the  Houston  Ballet,   and   the  Alley  Theater.  Major  museums   include   the  Museum  of  Fine  Arts,   the  Contemporary  Arts  Museum,   the  Menil  Collection,   The   Children’s   Museum   and   the   Museum   of   Natural   Science.     Harris   County   is   also   home   to   a   number   of  professional   sports   teams  with   state-­‐of-­‐the  art   facilities.  The  Astros,  Houston’s  Major  League  Baseball   team,  plays   its  home  games  at  Minute  Maid  Park;  the  Texans  of  the  National  Football  League  make  their  home  at  Reliant  Park;  and  the  Rockets  of  the   National   Basketball   Association   and   the   Aeros   of   the   American   Hockey   League   share   the   Toyota   Center.   The   Houston  Dynamo  soccer   team  plays   its  home  games  at   the  University  of  Houston’s  Robertson  Stadium;  however,   a  new  $90  million  stadium   will   be   completed   during   to   the   2012   season.   In   addition,   collegiate   teams   from   the   University   of   Houston,   Rice  University,  Texas  Southern  University  and  Houston  Baptist  University  compete  in  most  major  sports.  

Page 83: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

57    

Harris  County  was  one  of  the  last  major  metropolitan  areas  in  the  United  States  to  slip  into  the  recent  global  recession  and  it  was  one  of  the  first  to  begin  to  recover.  ]Harris  County  added  62,300  jobs  from  September  2010  to  September  2011.  Most  of  the  job  growth  occurred  in  health  care  and  social  assistance;  durable  goods  manufacturing;  leisure  and  hospitality;  and  food  services  and  drinking  places.    Harris  County’s  economy  is  largely  based  on  a  broad  spectrum  of  industries  including:  

• Oil  and  gas  exploration  and  refining  • Medical  research  and  health  care  delivery    • High  technology  –  computers,  aerospace,  environmental,  etc.    • Government    • International  import  &  export    • Commercial  fishing    • Agriculture    • Education    • Banking  and  finance    • Manufacturing  and  distribution    • Related  service  industries  

Employment  gains  now  match  the  state  average,  which  is  three  times  the  national  pace.  Energy  exploration  and  manufacturing  are  leading  the  way,  but  most  other  industries,  except  for  federal  government,  are  up  year  to  year.  The  unemployment  rate  has  edged  down  to  8.3%,  even  as  the  labor  force  has  steadily  risen  on  improving  job  opportunities.  The  housing  market  remains  weak,  though  it  is  beginning  to  improve,  driven  by  the  improving  labor  market.  House  prices  are  declining,  but  new  permits  for  both  single-­‐family  and  multifamily  units  have  risen  in  recent  months.  

Medical  tourism  is  on  the  rise  in  Harris  County  and  it  is  expected  to  continue  with  the  prominence  of  the  Medical  Center  which  is  in  close  proximity  to  Reliant  Park.  Harris  County  is  the  capital  of  medical  expertise  in  Texas,  as  it  is  home  to  several  of  the  leading   health   sciences   research   institutions   in   the   state   including   the   University   of   Texas   Health   Sciences   Center,   MD  Anderson   Cancer   Center,   and   Baylor   College   of   Medicine.   The   proximity   to   Latin   America   and   the   trend   growth   in   its  economies   explain   the   increasing   inflow   of   patients   from   that   region.     The   major   hospitals   consistently   rank   among   the  nation’s  top  institutions.  The  Texas  Medical  Center  is  at  the  forefront  of  research  and  treatment  of  cancer  and  heart  disease.  

Page 84: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

58    

4.2  Reliant  Park  Primary  &  Secondary  Markets  The   demographic   and   socioeconomic   data   presented   in   this   report   are   based   on   the   anticipated   primary   and   secondary  markets  of  Reliant  Park.    The  primary  market   is  the  geographic  area  in  which  it   is  anticipated  that  the  majority  of  attendees  and  venue  users  are  expected  to  originate.      The  size  of  this  primary  market  can  be  influenced  by  such  factors  as  transportation  systems,  site  accessibility,  media  coverage  and  competing  entertainment  venues   in   the  surrounding  region.  For  purposes  of  this  analysis,  the  primary  market  is  assumed  to  be  the  area  within  a  one  hour  drive  of  the  Astrodome  and  Reliant  Park  

In  addition  to   the  assessment  of   the  primary  market  area,   the  analysis  presented  herein  also   includes  an  assessment  of   the  combined  primary  and  secondary  markets   for  the  proposed  redevelopment,  which  is  anticipated  to  include  the  area  within  a  two  hour  drive  from  the  Park,  as  outlined  on  the  following  page.            

Page 85: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

59    

Drive  Time  Map  of  Resident  Market  Segments                                                        

Page 86: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

60    

Resident  Market  

In   2010,   the   primary   resident   market   (0-­‐1   hour   drive   time)   consisted   of   approximately   3.56  million   persons   in   the   0-­‐30  minute  segment  and  approximately  2.12  million  persons  in  the  30-­‐60  minute  segment.  

• As  a  whole,  the  primary  resident  market  is  forecasted  to  grow  at  an  average  annual  rate  of  2.0%,  from  5.68  million  in  2010  to  6.28  million  by  2015.  

The  secondary  resident  market  (1-­‐2  hour  drive  time),  which  reaches  outside  of  the  Greater  Harris  County  area,  consisted  of  nearly  1.21  million  persons  in  2010.  

• It  is  anticipated  to  grow  at  an  average  annual  rate  of  0.9%  to  1.26  million  by  2015.  

By  2015,  the  total  available  resident  market  is  forecasted  to  7.54  million  persons,  an  annual  increase  of  1.8%  from  6.89  million  in  2010.  

Resident  Market  Demographics  

Household  Income  

• Households  in  the  defined  resident  market  area  are  similar  to  national  standards  

• In  2010,  median  household  income  within  the  resident  market  was  $55,869,  compared  to  $54,442  nationwide  

• Although   the   full   resident  market   is   in   line  with  national   standards,   the  primary  market   (0-­‐60  minutes)  has   a  more  affluent  median  household  income  of  $58,366    

Household  Expenditures  

• Based  on   consumer   spending  data  derived   from  Consumer  Expenditure  Surveys   in  2005  and  2006  and  projected   to  2010  values,  households   in   the   total  resident  market  spent  a   total  of  $8.1  billion  on  entertainment  and  recreation   in  2010  

• The  primary  market’s  per  capita  spending  totaled  to  $3,516  on  entertainment  and  recreation  in  2010,  while  the  total  resident  market  was  slightly  lower  with  a  per  capita  spend  of  $3,361  

Page 87: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

61    

• The  higher  average  annual  spend  in  the  primary  market  is  expected  as  the  primary  market  encompasses  the  Greater  Harris  County  metropolitan  area  and  is  comprised  of  higher-­‐earning  households  

Age  Profile/Children’s  Market  

• The  total  defined  resident  market  has  a  median  age  of  33.5,  lower  than  the  national  median  of  37.0  

• The  children’s  market  (0-­‐14),  consists  of  approximately  1.56  million  persons,  or  22.6%  of  the  total  resident  market  

o By  comparison,  the  children’s  market  in  the  United  States  as  a  whole  is  20%  

o By  2015,  the  age  distribution  is  forecasted  to  experience  little  change,  with  a  slight  proportional  decrease  (-­‐2%)  of  residents  within  the  age  range  of  35-­‐54  and  a  proportional  gain  (2%)  in  residents  age  55  and  older  

Ethnic/Racial  Breakdown  

• The  total  resident  market  population  is  predominantly  Caucasian  followed  by  Hispanic  and  African  American.  

Future  Economic  Outlook  

The  Harris  County  area,  much  like  the  rest  of  the  United  States,  has  suffered  economically  over  the  past  several  years.    While  the  State  of  Texas  did  not  suffer  as  much  of  a  decline  as  the  rest  of  the  country,  the  Harris  County  area  still  saw  a  significant  increase   in  unemployment,   and  a  decrease   in  household   income.      However,  Harris  County’s   recovery  has   firmed   in   recent  months,  with  unemployment  dropping  to  8.3%.    Employment  gains  now  match  those  in  Texas  as  a  whole,  which  is  three  times  that  of  the  rest  of  the  nation.  All  industries,  other  than  government  employment,  have  seen  gains  over  2010.    House  prices  in  the  Harris  County  market  continue  to  decline,  but  new  construction  permits  have  risen  in  recent  months.      

The   strengthening   energy   industry   will   drive   job   gains   over   the   coming   year,   raising   demand   for   employees   in   drilling  technology,  engineering  and  geological  sciences,  as  well  as  professional  services  such  as  finance  and  accounting.  Job  postings  for  professional  services  related  to  the  energy  industry  are  up  20%  over  the  previous  year,  and  compensation  is  up  7%  over  the  same  time  period.  Several  factors  will  drive  the  gains.  First,  oil  prices  are  likely  to  remain  elevated  for  an  extended  period,  keeping  drilling  profitable.    Second,  companies  are  obtaining  permits  for  additional  drilling  in  the  Gulf  of  Mexico,  following  the  moratorium  after  the  BP  spill  in  April  of  2010.    Third,  products  and  services  related  to  the  energy  sector  will  grow  as  well  as  geologists,  chemical  engineers  and  drilling  technicians  will  be  in  increasing  demand.    

Page 88: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

62    

Harris  County’s  recovery  will  stabilize  over  the  next  9-­‐15  months,  led  by  the  energy  sector.  Companies  that  provide  equipment  and  services  to  the  energy  industry  will  also  benefit.  However,  gains  in  these  areas  will  be  offset  to  some  degree  by  the  decline  in  NASA  activities  in  the  Harris  County  area.  Longer  term,  above-­‐average  population  growth  in  the  State  and  further  expansion  in  energy  and  health-­‐related  industries  will  help  the  Harris  County  area  surpass  the  nation  in  most  economic  measures.  

Employment  

The  oil  and  gas  and  health  care  industries  dominate  the  employment  landscape   in   Harris   County,   with   many   of   the   area’s   largest  employers   involving   those   industries.   The   Texas   Medical   Center  (TMC),  which   is   located   on   the   light   rail   line   less   than   three  miles  from   Reliant   Park,   employs   more   than   130,000   people.   The  significant  involvement  of  the  oil  and  gas  corporations  and  the  TMC  would   be   imperative   for   the   successful   development   of   a   STEM  center  within  the  Astrodome,  in  the  event  that  option  is  considered.  

   

University*of*Texas 30,641Wal8Mart*Stores,*Inc. 28,780Administaff 20,816United*Continental*Holdings 17,000ExxonMobil*Corporation 14,835Continental*Airlines,*Inc. 14,651Shell*Oil 11,855H.E.B. 9,405Hewlett8Packard*Company 8,500Memorial*Hermann*Healthcare*System 8,452The*Methodist*Hospital 7,147Chevron*Corporation 7,000BP 6,500JP*Morgan*Chase*and*Company 6,500AT&T 6,047Texas*Children's*Hospital 6,034Baylor*College*of*Medicine 5,635Baker*Hughes 5,369HCA 5,298KBR 5,089

TOP$EMPLOYERS

Page 89: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

63    

4.3  Visitor  Attractions  Harris  County  is  an  attractive  destination  to  visitors  from  around  the  world.    The  weather  and  location  in  proximity  to  resort  towns   like  Galveston,   as  well   as   the   level  of   entertainment  and  cultural   events   in   the  area  are   some  of   the   reasons   for   this  attractiveness.    The  data  below  summarizes  the  current  tourist  climate  in  the  Harris  County  market.  

• Total  visitation  to  Harris  County  in  2010  was  approximately  9  million.  • The   leisure  visitor  market  to  Harris  County   is  much   larger  than  the  business  tourist  market  and  comprises  a  total  of  

71%  of  the  total  visitor  market,  while  the  remaining  (29%)  are  business  tourists  and  other  tourists.  • Nationally,  US  tourism  is  recovering  from  the  late  2008-­‐2009  recession.    Although  Harris  County  was  more  resilient  in  

2009  than  the  US  as  a  whole,  the  reverse  occurs  in  2010,  where  Harris  County  loses  ground  (-­‐8%)  while  the  US  (+7%)  and  Texas  (+5%)  post  gains.  

   Houston'Market

Resident'Market 2010Primary'Resident'Market'(0'to'1'hours)0730'mins 3,561,00030760'mins 2,123,000Total'Primary'Market 5,684,000

Secondary'Resident'Market'(1'to'2'hours) 1,208,000

Total'Resident'Market 6,892,000

Visitor'MarketTotal'Visitor'MarketLeisure'Tourist'Market 6,397,000Business'Tourist/Other'Market 2,613,000

Total'Visitor'Market 9,010,000

Total'Available'Market 15,902,000

Source:'ESRI'Business'Analyst,'Greater'Houston'Convention'&'Visitors'Bureau,'ECA

Page 90: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

64    

The  Greater  Harris  County  area  has  a  diverse  offering  of   visitor   attractions   including  a   large  arts  district,  museums,   theme  parks,   sports   and   live   event   venues,   and   science   centers,   among  many   others.  Harris   County   is   home   to   the   fourth   largest  museum  district  in  the  country  with  18  museums.  General  characteristics  of  the  competitive  market  are  as  follows:  

• Attendance  ranges  at  selected  attractions  across  the  Greater  Harris  County  area  can  range  from  65,000  to  over  4  million  persons  annually.  

• Selected   science   centers,  museums,   zoos  and  aquariums   in   the  Harris  County  area   tend   to  have   lower  admission  prices  than  theme  or  water  parks  in  Texas.    Average  pricing  at  the  various  attractions  are  as  follows:  

o Science  centers,  museums,  zoos  and  aquariums  

Adult:  Free  -­‐  $20   Child:  Free  -­‐  $16  

o Water  parks  

Adult:  $17  -­‐  $60   Child:  $12  -­‐  $50  

• Average  length  of  stay  at  the  selected  attractions  in  the  Greater  Harris  County  area  range  from  30  minutes  to  a  full  day.  

   

Page 91: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

65    

The  following  tables  provide  further  detail  on  the  visitor  attractions  in  the  Harris  County  market.  

Overview  of  Harris  County  Visitor  Attractions    

 

Selected'Attractions Location Year'OpenedFacility'Size'(SF/seats) Annual'Attendance

Attractions'and'Amusement'ParksMoody%Gardens Galveston,%TX 1983 242%acres 2,000,000Six%Flags%Astroworld%A%CLOSED Houston,%TX 1968 104%acres A

AmphitheatersCynthia%Woods%Pavilion The%Woodlands,%TX 1990 16,500%seats 1,237,500

Sports'and'Live'Event'VenuesToyota%Center Houston,%TX 2003 19,000%seats 663,831Minute%Maid%Park Houston,%TX 2000 43,836%seats 2,331,490Reliant%Stadium Houston,%TX 2002 71,500%seats 2,682,442Reliant%Arena Houston,%TX 1974 5,800%seats 173,849BBVA%Compass%Stadium Houston,%TX 2012 30,000%seats n/aConstellation%Field Sugar%Land,%TX 2012 7,500%seats n/aSugar%Land%Concert/Performing%Arts%Venue%(PROPOSED) Sugar%Land,%TX PROPOSED 6,500%seats n/aBayou%Music%Center Houston,%TX 1999 2,815%seats 140,000Hofheinz%Pavilion Houston,%TX 1969 8,500%seatsRobertson%Stadium Houston,%TX 1941 32,000%seats 264,368Berry%Center%Arena Cypress,%TX 2006 8,300%seatsBerry%Center%Stadium Cypress,%TX 2006 11,000%seatsBerry%Center%Theater Cypress,%TX 2006 450%seatsLeonard%E.%Merrell%Center Katy,%TX 2005 7,200%seatsHouse%of%Blues%Houston Houston,%TX 2008 1,528%seatsSam%Houston%Race%Park Houston,%TX 1994 32,000%capacity n/a

Science'CentersHouston%Museum%of%Natural%Science Houston,%TX 1969 115,000%SF 1,637,000Space%Center%Houston Houston,%TX 1992 184,000%SF 750,000

Source:%Individual%attractions%and%venues,%ECA

Page 92: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

66    

Overview  of  Harris  County  Visitor  Attractions  (continued)  

   

Selected'Attractions Location Year'OpenedFacility'Size'(SF/seats) Annual'Attendance

MuseumsThe$Museum$of$Fine$Arts$Houston Houston,$TX 1924 300,000$SF 1,598,000Art$Car$Museum Houston,$TX 1998 n/a 10,000$@$20,000Children’s$Museum$of$Houston Houston,$TX 1984 90,000$SF 850,000The$Health$Museum Houston,$TX 1996 28,000$SF 200,000The$Menil$Collection Houston,$TX 1987 30,000$SF 130,000Holocaust$Museum$Houston Houston,$TX 1996 27,000$SF n/aHouston$Fire$Museum Houston,$TX 1980 6,360$SF 15,000Contemporary$Arts$Museum Houston,$TX 1972 n/a n/aSan$Jacinto$Battleground$State$Historic$Site$&$Monument Houston,$TX 1939 1,200$acres 500,000

Zoos'and'AquariumsHouston$Zoo Houston,$TX 1922 55$acres 1,600,000Downtown$Aquarium Houston,$TX 2003 6$acres 357,954

Retail,'Dining'and'EntertainmentBayou$Place Houston,$TX 1997 130,000$SF n/aKemah$Boardwalk Kemah,$TX 1999 40$acres 3,500,000$@$4,000,000

Other'RetailThe$Galleria Houston,$TX reopened$2003 2,400,000$SF 24,000,000Traders$Village Houston,$TX 1989 100+$acres 2,250,000City$Center$(Town$and$Country) Houston,$TX 2010 1,800,000$SF 3,500,000$@$4,500,000Uptown$Center Houston,$TX 1999 169,110$SF n/a

Source:$Individual$attractions$and$venues,$ECA

Page 93: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

67    

Harris  County  Attraction  Details  

   

Average EstimatedSelected0Attractions Location Length0of0Stay Capital0Investment Adult ChildAttractions0and0Amusement0ParksMoody%Gardens Galveston,%TX 1.556%hrs $25%million%renovation %$%%%%%49.95% %$%%%%%49.95%Six%Flags%Astroworld%5%CLOSED Houston,%TX 5 5 %5% %5%

AmphitheatersCynthia%Woods%Pavilion The%Woodlands,%TX 354%hrs $9.5%million%renovation n/a n/a

Sports0and0Live0Event0VenuesToyota%Center Houston,%TX 354%hrs $202%million $12+ $12+Minute%Maid%Park Houston,%TX 354%hrs $250%million $7+ $1+Reliant%Stadium Houston,%TX 456%hrs $352%million $28+ $28+Reliant%Arena Houston,%TX 354%hrs n/a $50+ $50+BBVA%Compass%Stadium Houston,%TX n/a $80%million $24%5%$100 $24%5%$100Constellation%Field Sugar%Land,%TX 354%hrs $30%million $8%5%$12 Free+Hofheinz%Pavilion Houston,%TX 354%hrs $40%million%expansion%(2013) $5%5%$11 $5%5%$11Robertson%Stadium Houston,%TX 354%hrs $650,000 $20%5%$54 $20%5%$54Berry%Center%Arena Cypress,%TX 254%hrs $72.9%million%(1) Free+ Free+Berry%Center%Stadium Cypress,%TX 354%hrs $72.9%million%(1) $7 $4Berry%Center%Theater Cypress,%TX 254%hrs $72.9%million%(1) Free+ Free+Leonard%E.%Merrell%Center Katy,%TX 254%hrs $18.9%million Free+ Free+House%of%Blues%Houston Houston,%TX 254%hrs $20%million $12%5%$45 $12%5%$45Sam%Houston%Race%Park Houston,%TX n/a $90%million $6+ Free+

Science0CentersHouston%Museum%of%Natural%Science Houston,%TX 458%hrs $85%million%expansion%(2012) 15.00$%%%%% 10.00$%%%%%Space%Center%Houston Houston,%TX 456%hrs $29%million 20.00$%%%%% 16.00$%%%%%

Admission0Pricing

Source:%Individual%attractions%and%venues,%ECA(1)%%Total%cost%of%Berry%complex%was%$72.9%million,%which%included%the%Center,%Stadium%and%Theater

Page 94: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

68    

Harris  County  Attraction  Details  (continued)  

   

Average EstimatedSelected0Attractions Location Length0of0Stay Capital0Investment Adult Child

Admission0Pricing

MuseumsThe$Museum$of$Fine$Arts$Houston Houston,$TX 1.576$hrs $4.5$million$(garden) 7.00$$$$$$$$ 3.50$$$$$$$$Art$Car$Museum Houston,$TX 171.5$hrs n/a Free FreeChildren’s$Museum$of$Houston Houston,$TX 1.574$hrs $3.9$million 8.00$$$$$$$$ 8.00$$$$$$$$The$Health$Museum Houston,$TX 173$hrs n/a 8.00$$$$$$$$ 6.00$$$$$$$$The$Menil$Collection Houston,$TX 172$hrs $24$million Free FreeHolocaust$Museum$Houston Houston,$TX n/a n/a Free FreeHouston$Fire$Museum Houston,$TX 171.5$hrs n/a 5.00$$$$$$$$ 3.00$$$$$$$$Contemporary$Arts$Museum Houston,$TX 172$hrs n/a Free FreeSan$Jacinto$Battleground$State$Historic$Site$&$Monument Houston,$TX 3.5$hrs $1.5$million 10.00$$$$$$ Free

Zoos0and0AquariumsHouston$Zoo Houston,$TX 376$hrs $50,000 12.00$$$$$$ 8.00$$$$$$$$Downtown$Aquarium Houston,$TX 174$hrs $38$million 9.25$$$$$$$$ 6.25$$$$$$$$

Retail,0Dining0and0EntertainmentBayou$Place Houston,$TX 1.576$hrs $23$million Free FreeKemah$Boardwalk Kemah,$TX 174$hrs n/a Free Free

Other0RetailThe$Galleria Houston,$TX 30$mins74$hrs n/a Free FreeTraders$Village Houston,$TX 30$mins72$hrs n/a Free FreeCity$Center$(Town$and$Cuntry) Houston,$TX 174$hrs $500$million Free FreeUptown$Center Houston,$TX 30$mins73$hrs n/a Free Free

Source:$Individual$attractions$and$venues,$ECA

Page 95: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

69    

4.4  Harris  County  Area  Sports  and  Entertainment  Venues  There   is   a   limited   supply   of   events,   spectators   and   attendees   within   any   marketplace   and   the   number   and   type   of   local  facilities  that  could  compete  for  those  will  impact  the  market  potential  for  the  redevelopment  of  Reliant  Arena.  The  following  table   presents   a   summary   of   other   sports   and   entertainment   venues   located  within   Reliant   Park’s   primary   and   secondary  market  areas    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                       

Venue Location

Berry%Center%Arena Cypress,%TXCynthia%Woods%Mitchell%Pavilion The%Woodlands,%TXBBVA%Compass%Stadium Houston,%TXHofheinz%Pavilion Houston,%TXHouse%of%Blues%Houston Houston,%TXLeonard%E.%Merrell%Center Katy,%TXSugar%Land%Concert/Performing%Arts%Venue Sugar%Land,%TXToyota%Center Houston,%TXVerizon%Wireless%Theater Houston,%TXAlley%Theatre Houston,%TXBerry%Center%Stadium Cypress,%TXBerry%Center%Theater Cypress,%TXConstellation%Field Sugar%Land,%TXHobby%Center%for%the%Performing%Arts Houston,%TXJesse%H.%Jones%Hall Houston,%TXMinute%Maid%Park Houston,%TXStafford%Centre Stafford,%TXWortham%Center Houston,%TX

(1)%The%University%of%Houston%has%approved%a%renovation/expansion%of%Hofheinz%Pavilion%that%will%expand%seating%capacity%to%8,600.(2)%%The%Alley%Theatre%consists%of%the%824Vseat%Hubbard%Stage%and%an%additional%300Vseat%stage.(3)%%The%Hobby%Center%for%the%Performing%Arts%consists%of%the%2,650Vseat%%Sarofim%Hall%and%the%500Vseat%Zlikha%Hall.(4)%%The%Wortham%Center%consists%of%the%2,423Vseat%Alice%&%George%Brown%Theater%and%the%1,100Vseat%Cullen%Theater.

Source:(Pollstar(and(CSL(International(Research

Primary/and/Secondary/Market/AreaLevel/of/Competition/of/Local/Venues

Total PotentialSeating Degree/ofCapacity Competition

8,300 High16,500 High30,000 Medium8,600 (1) Medium1,529 Medium7,200 Medium6,500 Medium19,000 Medium2,815 Medium824 (2) Low

11,000 Low465 Low

9,500 Low2,650 (3) Low2,911 Low42,000 Low1,115 Low2,423 (4) Low

(1)%The%University%of%Houston%has%approved%a%renovation/expansion%of%Hofheinz%Pavilion%that%will%expand%seating%capacity%to%8,600.(2)%%The%Alley%Theatre%consists%of%the%824Vseat%Hubbard%Stage%and%an%additional%300Vseat%stage.(3)%%The%Hobby%Center%for%the%Performing%Arts%consists%of%the%2,650Vseat%%Sarofim%Hall%and%the%500Vseat%Zlikha%Hall.(4)%%The%Wortham%Center%consists%of%the%2,423Vseat%Alice%&%George%Brown%Theater%and%the%1,100Vseat%Cullen%Theater.

Primary/and/Secondary/Market/AreaLevel/of/Competition/of/Local/Venues

Page 96: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

70    

As  shown  above,  the  venues  representing  the  highest  potential  competition  to  the  possible  replacement  of  Reliant  Arena  are  the  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pavilion,  the  House  of  Blues,  the  Bayou  Music  Center,  the  Toyota  Center,  and  the  Hofheinz  Pavilion.    It   is   important   to  note   there   is  a   “gap”   in   the  marketplace  with   respect   to  a   smaller   sized  arena   (capacity  between  8,000  –  10,000).     The   only   indoor   arena   available   for   events   currently   is   the   19,000   seat   Toyota   Center.     That   capacity   is   not   an  efficient  venue  for  many  shows,  concerts  and  other  events,  which  would  be  much  better  served  to  perform  in  a  smaller  venue.      

The  following  case  studies  provide  a  summary  of  the  events  and  attendance  held  at  competitive  area  venues,  as  reported  by  Pollstar.    It  should  be  noted  that  some  smaller  concerts  and  shows,  as  well  as  trade  shows,  exhibitions,  swap  meets,  and  other  such  events  are  not  reported  by  Pollstar  and  are  in  addition  to  the  events  and  attendance  discussed  herein.  

Toyota  Center  

Toyota  Center  is  a  19,000-­‐seat  multi-­‐purpose  arena  that  opened   in   2003   in   downtown   Houston,   and   serves   as  the  home  of  the  NBA  Rockets  and  AHL  Aeros.  The  $308  million   arena   is   owned   by   the   Harris   County-­‐Houston  Sports  Authority  and   is  operated  by  Clutch  City  Sports  and   Entertainment.     Premium   seating   offered   at   the  arena   includes   2,900   club   seats   that   cost   $8,000   per  year,  105  luxury  suites  that  lease  for  $225,000  per  year,  and  567  courtside  seats  that  cost  $20,000  annually.  

In   addition   to   tenant   basketball   and   hockey   games,  Toyota   Center   hosts   a   variety   of   concerts   and  family/children   shows,   with   Live   Nation   being   the  preferred  promoter  for  the  facility.  

According  to  Pollstar,  the  Toyota  Center  hosted  48  non-­‐tenant  events   in  2010,  with  an  average  attendance  of  approximately  7,131.    Approximately  50  percent,  or  24,  of   the  events  held  at  the  Toyota  Center  in  2010  could  potentially  be  accommodated  by  the  anticipated  capacity  of  the  new  arena  in  Reliant  Park.     It   is  anticipated  that  the  new  Reliant  Arena  and  the  Toyota  Center  could  directly  compete  to  host  mid-­‐sized  concerts,  

Page 97: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

71    

family  shows,  and  other  such  events.    However,  the  proposed  expanded  Reliant  Arena  could  potentially  have  an  advantage  in  scheduling   these   events   due   to   the   large   number   of   dates   reserved   by   professional   sports   tenants   of   the   Toyota   Center.    Competition  will  also  exist  for  the  sponsorship/advertising  dollars  of  area  companies.  

Minute  Maid  Park  

Opened  in  2000,  Minute  Maid  Park  is  the  home  of  Major  League  Baseball’s  Houston  Astros.    The  stadium  has  a  capacity  of  approximately  43,800  for  Astros  games  and  is  owned   and   operated   by   the   Harris   County-­‐Houston   Sports   Authority.     While  primarily  a  baseball  venue,  the  stadium  can  host  soccer  and  rugby  events  as  well  as  large  concerts  and  live  entertainment.  Its  debut  as  a  soccer  venue  happened  during  the  2006  edition  of  the  CONCACAF  Champions  Cup.  The  stadium  hosted  the  first  leg  of  the  quarterfinal  between  Portmore  United  of  Jamaica  and  Club  América  of  Mexico.  The   stadium   also   is   the   host   of   the   Houston   College   Classic   college   baseball  tournament,  part  of  the  winter  fan  festival  held  in  February  and  in  November  of  this  year,  and  Taylor  Swift  performed  before   the  stadium’s   largest  crowd   for  a  concert,  with  just  more  than  42,000  in  attendance.    Because  of  Minute  Maid  Park’s  focus  on  the  Astros  and  the  fact  the  team  occupies  the  stadium  almost  exclusively  from  April  through  early  October,  the  venue  does  not  provide  significant  competition  for  live  entertainment  at  the  Reliant  Park  venues,  with  the  exception  of  Reliant  Stadium  during  certain  times  of  the  year.  

 

   

Page 98: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

72    

BBVA  Compass  Stadium  

BBVA   Compass   Stadium,   currently   being   built   for   the   Houston   Dynamo   of   Major  League   Soccer,   will   be   a   state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art,   soccer   specific,   open-­‐air   stadium   and   is  planned  to  be  open  in  May  of  2012.    When  completed,  BBVA  Compass  Stadium  will  be  a  central  feature  of  Houston’s  East  Downtown  Redevelopment  Plan.    The  stadium  will   be   part   of   a   true   stadium   and   entertainment   district,   which  will   also   include  Toyota   Center,   Minute   Maid   Park,   Discovery   Green,   The   House   of   Blues   and   the  George   R.   Brown   Convention   Center.     Aside   from   Major   League   Soccer   and  international   soccer   matches,   the   new   stadium   will   also   host   Texas   Southern  University   football,   concerts,   boxing   matches,   and   much   more.     BBVA   Compass  Stadium  will  have  a  capacity  of  22,000   for  Dynamo  games  but  will  be  capable  of  expansion   to  30,000   for  certain  events.    A  concert  stage  and  other  components  are  included  in  the  stadium  project  and  AEG  has  been  engaged  as  the  promoter  for  the  venue,  with  a  strong  track  record  of  attracting  third  party  events.  

Constellation  Field  

In   addition   to   the   professional   sports   venues   in   the   Harris   County   area,   the  suburb   of   Sugar   Land   commenced   construction   on   a   minor   league   baseball  stadium   that  will   be   located   approximately   25  miles   from  downtown  Houston  and   is   expected   to   be   completed   for   the   2012   baseball   season.     Constellation  Field   will   be   a   state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art   multi-­‐purpose   Triple-­‐A   ballpark.   In   addition   to  high   level   professional   baseball,   the   park  will   also   host   other   sports   including  football,   soccer,   lacrosse,   cheerleading   and   band   competitions,   etc.,   as   well   as  concerts,   group   outings,   and   scout   sleepovers.   Total   ballpark   capacity   will   be  approximately  7,500   for  baseball   (expandable   to  10,000)   and  9,500   in   concert  configuration.    Like  Minute  Maid  Park  and  BBVA  Compass  Stadium,  Constellation  Field  would  not  be  considered  significant  competition   for   live  entertainment  events.    Constellation  Field  has  a  capacity   that  would  be  competitive  for  more  events  than  the  other  larger  stadiums;  however,  the  venue  is  exclusively  an  outdoor  venue  that  will  be  heavily  occupied  by  the  baseball  team  from  April  through  September,  which  is  the  primary  season  for  outdoor  shows.  

Page 99: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

73    

Berry  Complex  

The  Richard  E.  Berry  Educational  Support  Center  (Berry  Center)  was  funded  by  a  Bond  Referendum  passed  by  the  Houston  suburb  of  Cypress  in  December  2001.    The  Complex  consists  of  four  venues:  the  Arena,  Conference  Center,  Stadium  and  Theater  and  cost  more  than  $72  million  to  construct.    The  Arena  (Berry  Center)  has   8,300  permanent   seats,  with   an   additional   1,700  portable   seats   for   a   total  capacity   of   nearly   10,000.Berry   Center   hosts   concerts,   indoor   sporting   events,  meetings   and   conferences,   graduation   ceremonies;   school   performances   and  competitions   and   catering   and   banquets   for   honors,   awards,   and   celebrations.  And   is   the   current   home   of   the   Texas   Copperheads   of   the   Southern   Indoor  Football  League.      The  Conference  Center  is  a  multi-­‐use  indoor  space  offering  17  possible  room  sizes  and  configurations  totaling  more  than  150,000  square  feet  of  floor  space.  The  Stadium  is  an  11,000  seat  outdoor   venue  used  primarily   as   a   home   for   Cypress-­‐Fairbanks   ISD  high   school   football   teams,   but  which   also   hosts   trade  shows,  outdoor  concerts  and  large  banquets.    Finally,  the  Theater  has  a  capacity  of  450  for  banquets,  performing  arts  events  and  small  concerts  and  other  performances.  

Merrell  Center  

The  Leonard  E.  Merrell  Center  opened  in  the  Houston  suburb  of  Katy  in  2005.    The   145,000   square   foot   facility   has   a   seating   capacity   of   7,200   for   concerts  and  1,200  for  banquets  and  theater  shows.    The  Merrell  Center  also  has  3,000  square  feet  of  meeting/conference  space  that  can  be  divided  into  four  smaller  rooms  of  various  sizes.    Funds   for   the  $18.9  million  construction  costs  of   the  Merrell   Center   came   from   a   Tax   Increment   Reinvestment   Zone   (TIRZ),  developed   in   partnership   with   the   City   of   Katy   and   the   Katy   Development  Authority.    Since  2008,  the  Merrell  Center  has  hosted  the  Southland  Conference  Men’s  and  Women’s  Basketball  Championships  and   is  also   the  home  venue  of   the  Houston  Stallions  of   the  Lone  Star  Football  League.    Each  year   the  venue  also   schedules  conferences,  concerts  and  conventions  as  well  as  events  for  the  schools  within  the  Katy  Independent  School  District,  including  basketball  and  other  sports,  graduations  and  award  ceremonies.  

Page 100: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

74    

Hofheinz  Pavilion  

Hofheinz  Pavilion  opened  in  December  1969  of  the  University  of  Houston  campus  at  a  cost  of  $4.2  million  ($26.6  million  in  2012  dollars)  and  serves  as  the  home  for  men’s   and   women’s   basketball.     The   multipurpose   facility   is   also   used   for  concerts,   special   events,   convocations   and   student-­‐sponsored   activities.   It   has  also   been   the   site   for   numerous   University   functions,   such   as   commencement  exercises  and  professional  seminars  and  forums.    

Hofheinz  Pavilion  has  been  renovated  multiple   times  over   the  past  20  years.    A  new  ceiling,  lighting  and  sound  system  were  installed  in  1991.    In  1992,  the  men's  and  women's  basketball  locker  rooms  were  enlarged,  and  equipped  with  personal  lockers  for  each  player.    Prior  to  the  1998-­‐99  season,  luxury  suites  were  added  at  the  top  of  the  arena,  bringing  capacity  to  8,479  currently.    With  the  addition  of  luxury  suites  ringing  the  top  rim  of  seats  for  the  1998-­‐99  season,  capacity  of  Hofheinz  Pavilion  now  stands  at  8,479.      In  June  2010,  the  University  approved  another  renovation  project  that  would  include  practice  facilities  for  both  the  men’s  and  women’s  teams  and  increase  capacity  slightly  to  8,600,  at  a  cost  of  approximately  $40  million.  

   

Page 101: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

75    

Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pavilion  

The  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pavilion  opened  in  1990  in  The  Woodlands,  Texas,  and  is  owned  and  operated  by  The  Center  for  the  Performing  Arts  at  The  Woodlands,  a  non-­‐profit   501(c)()(3)   organization.     The   pavilion   has   a   total   seating   capacity   of  16,500,   including  6,500  fixed  seats  and   lawn  seating   for  approximately  10,000.     In  2009,  a  $9.5  million  expansion  was  completed  in  order  to  repair  damage  sustained  during   Hurricane   Ike.     Renovations   included   construction   of   2,000   new   reserved  seats  and  building  a  new  expanded  canopy  structure  covering  all  6,500  fixed  seats.    Premium  seating  options  include  season  tickets  and  approximately  50  luxury  boxes,  which  include  VIP  parking  passes,  private  entrance,   in-­‐seat   wait   service,   and   access   to   the   Woodforest   Bank   Club.     The   pavilion   hosts   a   variety   of   outdoor   events  including  concerts,  family/children  shows  and  other  events,  which  are  promoted  and  produced  by  Live  Nation.    

According   to   Pollstar,   the   pavilion   hosted   45   events   in   2010,   with   an   average   attendance   of   approximately   8,153.    Approximately   49   percent,   or   22,   of   the   events   held   at   the   pavilion   in   2010   could   potentially   be   accommodated   by   the  anticipated  capacity  of  the  new  Reliant  Arena  in  Reliant  Park.    Due  to  their  similar  fixed  seating  capacities,  it  is  anticipated  that  the  new  Reliant  Arena   could  directly   compete  with   the  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell   Pavilion   to  host  mid-­‐sized   concerts,   family  shows,  and  other  such  events  during  the  amphitheater  season,  which  runs  from  late  April  to  late  October.    Competition  could  also  exist  for  outdoor  events  between  the  pavilion  and  the  proposed  Reliant  Park  festival  site.  

House  of  Blues  Houston  

Opened  in  2008  in  downtown  Houston,  the  1,528-­‐seat  House  of  Blues  Houston  is  owned  and  operated  by  Live  Nation.    The   facility  serves  as  an  anchor   for   the  Houston  Pavilions  outdoor  shopping  and  entertainment  complex.    Patrons  can  purchase  membership   to   the  Foundation  Room,  which  provides  lounge  seating,  fine  dining,  and  a  private  outdoor  balcony  with  views  of  downtown   Houston.     According   to   Pollstar,   the   facility   hosted   63   events   in   2010,   with   an  average  attendance  of  approximately  920.    All  of  the  events  held  at  the  facility  in  2010  could  potentially  be  accommodated  by  the  anticipated  capacity  of  the  new  Reliant  Arena  in  Reliant  Park.    It  is  anticipated  that  the  proposed  venue  and  the  House  of  Blues  Houston  could  directly  compete  to  host  small  concerts,  family  shows,  and  other  such  events  requiring  a  smaller  capacity.    Competition  will  also  exist  for  the  sponsorship/advertising  dollars  of  area  companies.  

Page 102: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

76    

Bayou  Music  Center  (Formerly  Verizon  Wireless  Theater)  

The   2,815-­‐seat   Bayou   Music   Center   opened   in   1999   in   downtown   Houston’s   theatre  district.    The  130,000  square   foot   theater  has  a  seating  capacity   that  can  be  reduced   in  order  to  accommodate  a  wide  variety  of  events,  and  provide  smaller  events  a  “full  house”  atmosphere.    The  theater,  owned  and  operated  by  Live  Nation,  hosts  a  variety  of  events  including  concerts,  comedy  shows,  and  spectaculars.    

According  to  Pollstar,  the  theater  hosted  21  events  in  2010,  with  an  average  attendance  of  approximately  2,518.    All  of   the  events  held  at   the   theater   in  2010  could  potentially  be  accommodated  by  the  anticipated  capacity  of  a  new  Reliant  Arena   in  Reliant  Park.     It   is  anticipated   that   the   proposed   new   venue   and   the   Bayou   Music   Center   could   directly  compete  to  host  concerts,  family  shows,  and  other  such  events  requiring  a  smaller  capacity.    Competition  will  also  exist  for  the  sponsorship/advertising  dollars  of  area  companies.  

     

Page 103: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

77    

4.5  Retail/Dining/Entertainment  Destinations  Bayou  Place  

Downtown   dining   and   entertainment   destination   Bayou   Place   is   experiencing   a  renaissance.     Two  new  bars   opened   in   2011   as   part   of   the   center's   re-­‐imagined  nightlife   experience,   Bayou   Place   Live!   Western-­‐themed   PBR   Houston   brings  country   dancing   and   a   little   bull-­‐riding   action   while   Lucie's   Liquors   offers   an  upscale   sports   bar   experience,   Vegas-­‐style.   Retro   beach   concept   Shark   Bar   and  whiskey  bar  Chapel  Spirits  debuted  in  May.  The  Blue  Fish,  a  Dallas  outpost  serving  up  sushi,  opened  in  March  2011.  

Robert  Redford's  highly-­‐anticipated  Sundance  Cinemas,  opened  November  2011,  features   both   general   release   and   art   films   along   with   several   drink-­‐and-­‐dine  options.    The  Verizon  Wireless  Theater  stages  a  variety  of  live  concerts,  and  Hard  Rock  Cafe  has  long  been  a  Theater  District  staple.  Samba  Grille  offers  up  a  diverse  lunch  menu  and  Brazilian-­‐style  rodizio  service  during  the  dinner  hour.  

     

Page 104: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

78    

Uptown  Park  

Located   ten   miles   west   of   downtown   Houston,   Uptown  Park   has   over   50   different   stores,   shops,   restaurants   and  clubs.   The   development   is   less   than   one   mile   from   the  Houston   Galleria   on   the   west   side   of   Loop   610.     Uptown  Park  is  lined  with  shops,  boutiques  and  cafes  that  create  an  intimate  atmosphere  with  an  emphasis  on  charm  all  on  the  ground   level   of   the   development.   With   lush   fountains,  detailed   architecture   and   lavish   landscaping,   the  surroundings   are   warm   and   inviting   and   attract   people  from  the  Harris  County  area  and  from  around  the  country.  

There  are  a  number  of  hotels  in  close  proximity  to  Uptown  Park,  with  all  levels  of  service  from  luxury  brands  like  the  St.  Regis  and  Hotel  Granduca,  to  family  accommodations  at  the  Marriott  Courtyard  and  Embassy  Suites.    

     

Page 105: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

79    

The  Galleria  

Owned  and  managed  by   the  Simon  Property  Group,  The  Galleria   is  an  upscale  mixed-­‐use   urban   development   located   in   the   Uptown   District   of   Houston,   Texas.     The  development   consists   of   a   retail   complex,   an   ice   rink,   as   well   as   the   Galleria   Office  Towers   complex,   two  Westin  hotels,   and   a  private  health   club.   The  office   towers   and  hotels   are   separately   owned   and   managed   from   the   shopping   center.   The   Galleria  opened  in  1970  and  expanded  to  its  current  size  in  2003.  

The  development  includes  approximately  2.4  million  square  feet  in  gross  leasable  area  with  over  375  tenants  making  it  the  largest  mall  in  Texas.  The  Galleria,  which  receives  a  reported   24   million   annual   visitors,   is   currently   anchored   by   Saks   Fifth   Avenue,  Nordstrom,  Neiman  Marcus  and  two  separate,  full-­‐line  Macy’s.  

Memorial  City  Mall  

Memorial  City  Mall  is  a  super-­‐regional  center  and  offers  merchants  1.7  million  square  feet  of  retail   space,   featuring   anchors  Macy’s,  Dillard’s,   JCPenney,  Target   and  Sears,   as  well   as  150  specialty  stores  and  restaurants.    Memorial  City  Mall  is  the  focal  point  of  Memorial  City,  a  200-­‐acre  mixed-­‐use  destination  which  includes  1.3  million  square  feet  of  Class  A  office  space,  2.1  million   square   feet   of   medical/office   space,   a   267-­‐room  Westin   hotel   and   more   than   600  residential  units.      

A  $300  million   renovation  and  remerchandising  project  was  completed   in  2003.  Sales  have  increased   dramatically   every   year   since   the   renovation,   with  many   key   retailers   achieving  sales  above  $1,000  per  square  feet.    Comp  store  sales  at  Memorial  City  Mall  rose  13%  in  2010,  

the  largest  increase  among  all  enclosed  regional  malls  in  Harris  County.    Amenities  at  the  mall  include  an  NHL-­‐sized  ice  rink,  a  Children’s  Play  Castle,  a  double-­‐decker  Venetian-­‐style  carousel  and  a  Cinemark  16  Theatre.  

   

Page 106: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

80    

Sugar  Land  Town  Square  (City  Walk)  

Sugar   Land   Town   Square   is   a   32-­‐acre,   1.3   million   square-­‐foot   mixed-­‐use  development   located   approximately   20   miles   southwest   of   downtown   Houston.    Sugar  Land  Town  Square  is  a  public/private  partnership  between  the  City  of  Sugar  Land,  Fort  Bend  County,  Fort  Bend  County  Levee   Improvement  District  Number  2  and  Planned  Community  Developers,  Ltd.    Throughout  the  2000’s,  various  phases  of  the  development  were  opened.    

The  development  is  adjacent  to  the  First  Colony  Mall  and  includes  a  300-­‐room  full-­‐service   Marriott   hotel   and   conference   center,   an   82,000   square-­‐foot   Sugar   Land  Town   Square   City   Hall,   167   mid-­‐rise   residential   condos,   566,000   square   feet   of  office  space,  238,000  square  feet  of  Main  Street  retail  and  restaurants  and  a  1.4-­‐acre  pedestrian  plaza.    Other  amenities  include  a  24  screen  AMC  Theater,  Lifetime  Fitness  and  sports  centers  for  local  high  schools.        

First  Colony  Mall  

The   First   Colony  Mall   is   a   regional  mall  with   adjacent   streetscape   outdoor   shopping  (Sugar   Land   Town   Square)   located   in   Sugar   Land   which   is   approximately   20   miles  southwest   of   downtown   Houston,   Texas.     The   mall   is   owned   by   General   Growth  Properties  and  opened  in  1996  with  renovations  in  2006.  

It  encompasses  approximately  1.1  million  square  feet  of  gross  leasable  area  with  150  tenants  with   its  anchor  tenants  being  Dillard’s,  Macy’s  and   JCPenney.    Other  retailers  within  the  mall  generally  cater  to  upper-­‐middle  class.    Amenities   include  a  24-­‐screen  AMC  theatre  adjacent  to  the  property  in  the  Sugar  Land  Town  Square.    The  mall  brings  in  an  estimated  15  million  visitors  annually.      

   

Page 107: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

81    

Kemah  Boardwalk  

Located   20   miles   from   downtown   Houston,   the   Kemah   Boardwalk   is   open   daily   year-­‐round.   Located   just   20   miles   from  downtown,   the  Boardwalk   is   home   to   fabulous  waterfront   restaurants   and   the  Kemah  Boardwalk   Inn,   a  52-­‐room  boutique  hotel  adjacent  to  the  restaurants  and  amusements  and  attracts  more  than  3  million  visitors  annually.    The  main  attractions  of  the  42-­‐acre  complex,  which  opened  in  2001,  are  its  many  restaurants  overlooking  Galveston  Bay.  The  area  was  developed  by  Landry's  Restaurants,  which  owns  all  of  the  restaurants  on  the  boardwalk.  Activities  include  shopping  and  midway  games,  as  well   as   a  miniature   train   that   traverses   the   entire   area.   Additional   attractions   include   a   36-­‐foot   carousel,   a   65-­‐foot   (20  m)  Ferris  wheel,  and  a  new  wooden  roller  coaster.  The  Boardwalk  is  also  now  the  nearest  recreational  and  entertainment  park  in  the   Harris   County   area.     The   South   End   Historic   District   of   the   Kemah   Boardwalk   features   many   local,   family   owned  businesses.  The  businesses  range  from  bed  and  breakfasts  to  shopping.  The  Clipper  House  Inn  has  several  cottages  to  choose  from.    

                             Source:  Individual  venue/mall  websites  

Page 108: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

82    

4.6  Cultural  Attractions  and  Museums  The  Harris  County  metropolitan  area  is  home  to  numerous  cultural  attractions  and  premier  museums,  which  complicates  the  task  of  redeveloping  the  Astrodome,  as  most  any  type  of  attractions  geared  toward  one  or  more  concept  that  has  traditionally  been  the  purview  of  a  museum  of  cultural  venue  already  exists  in  the  marketplace.    The  following  pages  summarize  many  of  the  attractions.  

Space  Center  Houston  

Since   1992,   this   $75  million,   180,000   square   foot,   'edutainment'  complex   has   entertained   and   informed   over   11   million   guests.  Space  Center  Houston   is   located  approximately  25  miles  south  of  downtown  Houston   in   the   NASA/Clear   Lake   area   and   features   a  multitude  of  permanent  exhibits,  attractions,  theatres  and  exhibits.  In   addition,   the   venue   presents   an   amazing   array   of   traveling  exhibits  and  astounding  events  created  exclusively  by  SCH's  own  creative   exhibit   team.   In   2011,   the   Space   Center   added   ‘Summer  Sports  Slam’,  a  sports  experience  where  visitors  can  step  into  the  world  of  professional  sports  and  hit  a  grand  slam,  score  a  winning  touchdown  or  even  make  the  winning  goal  with  unique  challenges  such  as  Bazooka  Outfielding,  Human  Foosball  and  JumpShot  Basketball.  

Page 109: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

83    

Houston  Museum  of  Natural  Science  

Hundreds  of   thousands  of  people  visit   the  Houston  Museum  of  Natural  Science  (HMNS)  each  year.     The   primary   venue   is   located   near   Rice   University.     The   HMNS   also   has   a   satellite  museum  in  Sugar  Land  and  also  operates  the  George  Observatory  in  Needville,  Texas,  about  40  miles  southwest  of  downtown.    The  Museum  has  a  number  of  permanent  exhibits  and  several  that  are  temporary  in  nature,  such  as  “Ancient  Ukraine”  and  “Texas!”.    There  is  also  an  IMAX  theater  and  a  Planetarium,  which  serve  as  two  of  the  primary  attractions  at  the  HMNS.        

Holocaust  Museum  Houston  

Charged  with  educating  students  and  the  public  about  the  dangers  of  prejudice  and  hatred  in  society,   the  Holocaust  Museum  Houston   is  dedicated  to  remembering  the  6  million   Jews  and  other   innocent   victims   of   the  Holocaust   and  honoring   the   legacy   of   the   survivors.  Using   the  lessons  of  the  Holocaust  and  other  genocides,  they  teach  the  dangers  of  hatred,  prejudice  and  apathy.    The  permanent  exhibit  at  the  Museum  is  Bearing  Witness:  A  Community  Remembers,  which   focuses  on   the  stories  of  Holocaust  survivors   living   in   the  Harris  County  metropolitan  area.  A  tour  begins  with  a  look  at  life  before  the  Holocaust.  Visitors  then  see  the  beginnings  of  Nazism   and   Adolf   Hitler’s   rise   to   power.   The   displays   progress   through   the   disruption   of  normal   life,   to   segregation,   to   imprisonment   in   concentration   camps   and,   finally,   to  extermination.  The  roles  of  collaborators,  by-­‐standers,  rescuers,  and  liberators  are  portrayed  through   artifacts,   film   reels,   photographs,   and   text   panels.   The  main   exhibit   ends  with   the  moving   short   films,   Voices   and  Voices  II,  which  alternate  daily  in  the  100-­‐seat  theater.  These  films  are  compilations  of  verbal  testimony  from  area  survivors.  

The  Museum's  newest  addition  to  the  Permanent  Exhibit  is  a  1942  World  War  II  railcar  of  the  type  used  to  carry  millions  of  Jews   to   their  deaths.  The   railcar  was   formally  dedicated   and  opened   to   the  public  during  10th  Anniversary   ceremonies  on  Sunday,  March  5,  2006.    The  Museum  also  includes  two  changing  galleries  for  art  and  photography  exhibits,  the  Lack  Family  Memorial  Room  -­‐  a  quiet  place  for  contemplation,  and  the  Eric  Alexander  Garden  of  Hope.  

Page 110: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

84    

Museum  of  Fine  Arts  

Founded  in  1900,  The  Museum  of  Fine  Arts,  Houston's  (MFAH)  collection  numbers  more  than  56,000  works  and  embraces  the  art  of  antiquity  to  the  present.  Located  in  the  heart  of  Houston’s  Museum  District,   the  MFAH  is  a  dynamic  cultural  complex  comprising  two  gallery   buildings,   a   sculpture   garden,   visitors   center,   library,   movie   theater,   gift   shop,  café,  two  art  schools,  and  two  house  museums.  

Children’s  Museum  of  Houston  

“America’s   No.   1   Best   Children’s   Museum”   by   Parents  magazine,   winner   of  Nickelodeon  Parents’   Picks   “Best   Museum   in   Houston   2009   &   2010,”   Click2Houston’s   “Best   Museum  2010,”  the  Children’s  Museum  of  Houston  is  a  Citysearch.com’s  nationwide  5-­‐star  children’s  museum.     Housed   in   a   whimsical   building   designed   by   internationally   acclaimed   architect  Robert   Venturi,   the   Children’s  Museum   of   Houston   offers   a  multitude   of   exhibits   bursting  with  action-­‐packed  fun  that  engage  kids  in  the  ultimate  learning  experience.      The  Museum  was  founded  in  1980  by  a  group  of  Houston  parents  who  hoped  to  elevate  early  childhood  development   to   a   community-­‐wide   priority.     Since   then,   the  Museum   has   grown   to   serve  more   than   850,000   people   annually,   focusing   on   bilingual   (Spanish/English)   learning  programs   for   kids   ages   birth   to   12   years   and  workshops   in   literacy,   science,  math,   health,   engineering,   civic   engagement,  culture   and   social   studies.   The   Museum   operates   as   a   501(c)(3)   under   the   direction   of   a   Board   of   Directors.  In  2005,  the  Museum  launched  its  Take  Another  Giant  Step  Capital  Campaign  to  fund  the  doubling  of  the  Museum’s  exhibition  space,  the  expansion  of  the  Museum’s  outreach  programs  and  the  formal  launch  of  the  Museum’s  Institute  for  Family  Learning.  On  March  14,  2009,  the  Museum  opened  its  doors  to  a  new  building  addition  featuring  more  than  39,000  square  feet  of  new  exhibition  space,   including  seven  new,  permanent  exhibits:  Cyberchase  –  The  Chase  Is  On!,  based  on   the  award-­‐winning  PBS  KIDS  GO!  animated  series;  Invention  Convention;  PowerPlay,  FlowWorks,  Kidtropolis,  U.S.A.  and  a  new  TotSpot.    

   

Page 111: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

85    

Downtown  Aquarium  

Located   in   downtown   Houston,   near   City   Hall,   the   500,000-­‐gallon   under-­‐water   adventure  complex  includes  a  Ferris  wheel,  an  aquatic  carousel,  Shark  Voyage,  a  white  tiger  exhibit  and  a  restaurant.    Harris  County's  first  public  aquarium,  the  Downtown  Aquarium  was  designed  to  entertain  the  masses.  The  world-­‐class  complex,  perched  on  the  redeveloped  400  block  of  Bagby,   boasts   500,000   gallons   of   visible   underwater   tanks  with  more   than   200   species   of  marine  life  -­‐  and  that's  just  skimming  the  surface.  

Menil  Collection  

The  Menil  Collection  opened  to  the  public  in  June  1987  as  the  primary  repository  of  John  and  Dominique  de  Menil’s  private  collection.  One  of  the  most  significant  of  the  twentieth  century,  the  collection  consists  of  nearly  15,000  works  dating  from  the  Paleolithic  era  to  the  present  day.   Although   historically   vast,   it   uniquely   resists   the   conventional  museum  model   of   the  encyclopedia.   Instead,   within   the   four   areas   that   largely   define   the   collection—Antiquity,  Byzantine   and   Medieval,   Tribal,   and   Twentieth-­‐Century   Art   (with   a   concentration   in  Surrealism)—one  finds  a  selective  approach  to  acquisition  that  yields  depth  with  regard  to  particular  areas  and  artists.  

     

Page 112: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

86    

Houston  Symphony  

Founded   in   1913,   the   Houston   Symphony   is   one   of   America's   oldest   performing   arts  organizations,   with   a   distinguished   musical   history.   Over   the   years,   the   orchestra   has  grown  and  matured  under   the  direction  of  distinguished   leaders  such  as  Ernst  Hoffmann  (1936-­‐47),  Efrem  Kurtz   (1948-­‐54),  Ferenc  Fricsay   (1954),  Leopold  Stokowski   (1955-­‐61),  Sir  John  Barbirolli  (1961-­‐67),  André  Previn  (1967-­‐69),  Lawrence  Foster  (1971-­‐78),  Sergiu  Comissiona  (1979-­‐88)  and  Christoph  Eschenbach  (1988-­‐99).  Maestro  Hans  Graf,  who  took  the  podium  in  September  2001,  is  the  Houston  Symphony's  fifteenth  music  director.    

The  orchestra  moved  into  Jones  Hall,  its  current  home,  in  1966,  and  in  1971,  the  Symphony  signed   its   first   52-­‐week   contract  with   the  musicians.   Today,   the  Houston   Symphony   is  widely   acclaimed   as   one   of   the   top  orchestras   in   the  world.     Each   year   the   Houston   Symphony   performs   approximately   170   concerts   for  more   than   350,000  Houstonians.   The   season   includes   the   Fidelity   Investments   Classical   Series;   the   6-­‐concert   classical   Shell   Favorite   Masters  series,  Great  Performers  and  TOTAL  Gold  Classics  series;  the  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pops  at  Jones  Hall  series;  Weatherford  Family   Concerts;   the   Chevron  Fiesta   Sinfónica   Familiar   and   the  Houston  Chronicle  Dollar   Concert;   a   summer   series   at   The  Cynthia  Woods  Mitchell  Pavilion  and  KPRC  Local  2  Summer  Symphony  Nights  at  Miller  Outdoor  Theatre  where  the  orchestra  has  performed  for  more  than  60  years.  The  season  also  includes  six  SoundPlusVision  concerts  underwritten  by  the  Albert  and  Margaret  Alkek  Foundation,  and  the  JPMorgan  Chase  Summer  in  the  City  series.    

     

Page 113: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

87    

The  Health  Museum  

The   John  P.  McGovern  Museum  of  Health  &  Medical   Science,   also   known  as  The  Health  Museum,   is   Harris   County's   most   interactive   science   learning   center   and   a   member  institution  of  the  world-­‐renowned  Texas  Medical  Center.  Located  in  the  heart  of  the  city's  Museum   District,   The   Health   Museum   encourages   growing   interest   and   regard   for  healthier   lifestyles,   fitness   and   good   physical,   mental   and   spiritual   health.   The   Health  Museum   currently   serves   more   than   200,000   visitors   annually,   including   more   than  40,000   schoolchildren   in   organized   field   trips.   Since   the   grand   opening  more   than   ten  years  ago,  the  facility  has  seen  more  than  1.5  million  visitors.  The  Health  Museum  is  the  most  visited  health  museum  of  its  kind  in  the  country  and  one  of  the  top  public  attractions  in   the  Harris  County  area.    The  Health  Museum  is  committed   to  excellence   in   innovative  and   interactive  health  and  science  educational  experiences  such  as:  

• A  hands-­‐on  walk  through  the  human  body    

• New  and  exciting  exhibits    

• Real  organ  dissections    

• Obesity  prevention  and  nutritional  awareness    

• Science  mini-­‐classes  and  mini-­‐med  schools    

• Health  fairs  and  community  outreach    

• Family  science  labs    

• School  field  trip  experiences    

• Home  school  classes  and  programs    

• Scout  programs    

Summer  camps    

Page 114: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

88    

In  addition  to  the  permanent  exhibits,  the  Amazing  Body  Pavilion  and  You:  The  Exhibit,  other  attractions  include  the  McGovern  4D  Theater,  the  Sue  Trammell  Whitfield  Gallery,  seasonal  exhibits,  and  learning  centers.    

American  Cowboy  Museum  

Dedicated   to   the   preservation   and   understanding   of   western   multicultural   heritage,   the  American   Cowboy   Museum,   a   501(c)(3)   organization,   offers   a   unique   setting,   introducing  groups   to   the   contributions   of   Blacks,   Hispanics,   Native   Americans,   and   women   to   the  development   and   culture   of   the  west.       This   learning   experience   expands   the   horizons   and  enhances   the   academic   studies   of   all   children,   especially   inner-­‐city   youths  who   often   never  leave  their  immediate  neighborhoods.    Less  than  five  miles  from  the  Reliant  Park  Complex,  in  sight   of   the  Houston   skyline,  museum  visitors  may  be   greeted  by   "Peter"   and   "Paulette"   the  peacocks,   plus   "Nibbles"   and   "Nefertiti"   the   goats.   They   all   live   on   the   historic   Taylor-­‐Stevenson  Ranch  -­‐  working  ranch  with  seven  generations  of  family  pride  and  western  heritage.  The  1940  Air  Terminal  Museum  

The  1940  Air  Terminal  Museum  is  the  only  educational  institution  in  Harris  County  dedicated  to   promoting   the   city's   significant   civil   aviation   history.     The   Houston   Municipal   Airport  Terminal   is   a   beautiful   and   rare   example   of   classic   art   deco   airport   architecture   from   the  golden  age  of   flight.  The  Terminal   served  Harris  County  during   the  years  when  air   travelers  dressed  in  their  finest  and  embarked  for  exotic  destinations  aboard  roaring  prop-­‐liners  like  the  Douglas  DC-­‐3  and  the  Lockheed  Constellation.    Designed  by  noted  architect  Joseph  Finger  (who  also   designed  Houston's   City  Hall),   the   Terminal  was   built   to  meet  Harris   County's   growing  role  as  a  major  center  for  air  commerce  in  the  1930s.  The  Terminal  was  completed  in  1940  and  served  as  the  primary  commercial  air  terminal  for  Harris  County  until  1954.    While  most  major  cities  have  razed  the  beautiful  art  deco  airport  terminals  of  the  1930s  and  1940s  to  make  way  for  modern  buildings,  jet  traffic  or  the  closing  of  airports,  the  Houston  Municipal  Airport  Terminal  stands  on  William  P.  Hobby  Airport  as  a  quiet  monument  to  the  rich  and  varied  history  of  aviation  in  the  region.  

   

Page 115: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

89    

Buffalo  Soldiers  National  Museum  

The  Buffalo  Soldiers  National  Museum  is  the  only  museum  in  the  U.S.  dedicated  primarily  to  preserving   the   legacy   and   honor   of   the   African-­‐American   soldier.   It   houses   the   largest  repository   of   African-­‐American   military   history   in   the   world.     The   10th   Cavalry,   an   all  African-­‐American  Army  unit,  was  nicknamed  Buffalo  Soldiers  by  Cheyenne  warriors  in  1867  out  of  respect  for  their  fierce  fighting  ability.  Over  time,  the  term  Buffalo  Soldier  was  applied  to   all   African-­‐American   soldiers.     The   mission   of   the   museum   is   to   interpret,   articulate,  collect,  display  and  preserve  historic  artifacts,  documents,  videos,  prints  and  other  historic  memorabilia  which  detail  the  history  of  the  brave  men  and  women  who  overcame  extreme  adversity  while  gallantly  fighting  the  great  American  wars.  

Houston  Zoo  

Set   in  a  55-­‐acre   lush   tropical   landscape,   the  Houston  Zoo   is  home  to  more   than  4,500  exotic  animals  representing  more  than  900  species.  The  Houston  Zoo  was  named  one  of  the  top  10  zoos   in   the   U.S.   by   Parents   magazine   in   2009.     The   Zoo   is   located   in   close   proximity   to   a  number   of   other   cultural   attractions,   including   the  Houston  Museum   of  Natural   Science.     In  2011,   the   Zoo   opened   its   largest   new  habitat   ever   –   the  African   Forest,  which   recreates   the  wilderness  habitats  of  some  of  the  continent’s  most  majestic  animals.    The  Forest  encompasses  6.5  acres  and  cost  more  than  $35  million  to  develop.  

   

Page 116: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

90    

4.7  Convention  Centers  and  Meeting  Space  The   George   R.   Brown   Convention   Center   was   opened   on   the   east   side   of   downtown  Houston   on   September   26,   1987.   The   center   was   named   for   the   late   Houston  entrepreneur,  civic   leader  and  philanthropist  George  R.  Brown.  Brown’s  Texas  Eastern  Corp.  donated  six  of  the  11  blocks  required  to  build  Houston’s  sparkling  new  Pompeduei  inspired  convention  center.  

The   facility   is   owned   by   the   City   of   Houston   and   managed   by   the   Houston   First  Corporation.  The  bonds  issued  to  finance  the  Center  were  repaid  by  hotel  occupancy  tax  revenues,  with  no  local  taxes  being  used  to  pay  back  the  debt.  The  first  convention  held  in   the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center  was   the  American  Society  of  Travel  Agents  beginning  on  October  11,  1987.  

On   July   28,   2001,   ground   was  broken  on  a  project  to  expand  the  

convention   center   and   build   an   adjacent   1,200-­‐room   convention  headquarters  hotel.  At  a  cost  of  $165  million  and  requiring  27  months  of   construction,   the   Brown   grew   from   1,150,000   square   feet   to  1,800,000  square  feet  of  built  space.  Three  exhibit  halls  were  added  to  increase  exhibition  space   from  451,500  square   feet   to  853,500  square  feet.  Fifty-­‐seven  meeting  rooms  were  added  bringing  the  total  number  of   meeting   rooms   to   100.   Expansion   was   completed   on   December   3,  2003.     A   comparison   of   the   top   16   convention  markets   in   the   United  States  was  conducted  by  CSL   to  determine  where  Houston  ranks  with  respect   to   convention   space,   exhibit   space,   meeting   space   and   hotel  inventory.    Out  of  the  markets  surveyed,  Houston  ranked  near  the  mid-­‐point   in   terms  of   sellable   space,   and   in   the   lower  half  with   respect   to  hotel  inventory.      

Facility City, StateAnaheim Convention Center Anaheim, CABoston Convention & Exhibition Center Boston, MAColorado Convention Center Denver, CODallas Convention Center Dallas, TXGeorge R. Brown Convention Center Houston, TXGeorgia World Congress Center Atlanta, GAHenry B. Gonzalez Convention Center San Antonio, TXLas Vegas Convention Center Las Vegas, NVMcCormick Place Chicago, ILMoscone Center San Francisco, CANew Orleans Morial Convention Center New Orleans, LAOrange County Convention Center Orlando, FLPhoenix Convention Center Phoenix, AZSan Diego Convention Center San Diego, CAWashington Convention Center Washington, DC

Page 117: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

91    

 

As   this   data   clearly   demonstrates,   the   Harris   County  market   needs   additional   convention   and  meeting   space,   particularly  adjacent  to  or  within  walking  distance  of  hotel  rooms.    The  proposed  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  and  the  redevelopment  of  the  Astrodome  could  address  these  needs  to  some  extent.    As  discussed  elsewhere,  the  fact  that  Reliant  Park  is  more  than  10  miles  from  the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center  makes  having  large  events  that  would  utilize  both  venues  virtually  impossible.  However,  the  Master  Plan  would  significantly  increase  the  types  and  number  of  events  that  would  be  able  to  bring  convention  and  trade  shows  to  Reliant  Park,  particularly  with  a  hotel  included  in  the  redevelopment.  

These  data  are  useful   to  consider  when  evaluating  potential  demand   for  additional   space.     In  addition,  data  as   to  historical  occupancy  levels  for  existing  Reliant  Park  and  Brown  Convention  Center  space,  national  demand  trends,  competitive  facility  development,  event  hotel  needs  and  the  opinions  of  target  market  event  planners  will  be  considered  in  evaluating  potential  development  of  future  Reliant  Center  convention  and  trade  show  space.      

Exhibit Meeting Ballroom Total2Sellable Hotel2Rooms HeadquarterSpace Space Space Space w/in21/22Mile Hotel2Rooms

Houston2Rank* 6 13 13 6 12 10

*"out"of"16"markets"surveyed

Page 118: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

92    

4.8  Hotels  The  availability  of  hotel  rooms  to  serve  the  requirements  of  event  attendees  is  a  critical  factor  in  the  success  of  a  convention  and   trade   show   center.     Based   on   conversations  with   Convention   and  Visitors   Bureau   representatives   in   each  market   and  other  industry  research,  we  have  measured  the  inventory  of  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  the  respective  event  facilities  in  competitive  and  comparable  markets.    This  is  an  important  analysis  because  event  planners  typically  prefer  to  achieve  their  room  block  in  hotel  properties  located  within  a  relatively  short  distance  from  the  event  facility.  

• Currently   there   are   approximately   803   hotel   properties   with   room   inventory   totaling   74,199   in   the   Greater   Harris  County  area  according  to  Smith  Travel  Research.  

• Total  length  of  stay  for  overnight  visitors  to  Harris  County  averaged  3.4  nights  in  2010.  

• Average  length  of  stay  for  hotel/motel  visitors  to  Harris  County  was  1.2  nights.  

• Overnight   leisure  visitors  shortened   their   time   in  Harris  County,  with  an  average  stay   that  dropped  by  almost  half  a  night  in  2010  (3.3  vs.  3.7  in  2009);  now  placing  near  the  US  average  (3.4).  

• The  proportion  of  leisure  overnight  visitors  remains  high  (60  %  of  visitors  spent  the  night  for  leisure  in  2010  versus  61  %  in  2009  –  much  higher  than  the  51  %  in  2008)  and  very  beneficial  for  Harris  County.  

• Harris  County  enjoys  an  above  average  proportion  of  business  visitors  (18  %),  who  generally  spend  more  on  each  trip  (versus  13  %  of  business  travelers  for  US  destinations).  

• In  2010,  average  travel  party  size  totaled  2.6  persons.  

• Annual  market-­‐wide  occupancy  in  2010  was  55.8  %,  which  fell  from  56.1  %  in  2009.  

• Average  Daily  Rate  (ADR)  was  $92.09  in  2010,  down  from  $96.09  in  2009.  

• National   hotel   occupancy   increased   to   57.6%   in   2010,   reflecting   national   hospitality   trends   and   overall   economic  conditions.  

   

Page 119: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

93    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The  number  of  events  currently  held  at  Reliant  Park  combined  with  the  operating  restrictions  that  exist  due  to  the  leases  of  the  HLSR  and  the  Texans  would  not  seem  to  support  the  development  of  a  convention  hotel  at  Reliant  Park  today.    However,  the   implementation   of   the  Master   Plan   and   the   addition   of   a   multi-­‐use   facility   on   the   current   Astrodome   site  may   create  enough  demand  for  rooms  and  related  amenities  to  convince  a  private  developer  to  construct  a  hotel  in  the  future.  

!$#!!!!

!$20!!

!$40!!

!$60!!

!$80!!

!$100!!

!$120!!

0!

10!

20!

30!

40!

50!

60!

70!

80!

90!

100!

2000! 2001! 2002! 2003! 2004! 2005! 2006! 2007! 2008! 2009! 2010!

$/day&

Average&Occupancy&Rate&(%

)&Greater&Houston&Occupancy&Rate&&&ADR&(2000>2010)&

Occupancy!Rate! ADR!

Page 120: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

94    

4.9  Constituent  Interviews  As   a   primary   component   of   the   research   conducted   throughout   the   redevelopment   analysis,   the   team   conducted   extensive  interviews   with   Astrodome/Reliant   Park   constituents,   stakeholders   and   other   interested   parties.     These   interviews   are  summarized  below.    Parties  interviewed  included  but  were  not  limited  to  the  following:  

• Ed  Emmett  –  Harris  County  Judge  

• El  Franco  Lee  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  

• Steve  Radack  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  

• Jack  Morman  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  

• R.  Jack  Cagle  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  

• Dave  Walden  –  Chief  of  Staff  for  Jack  Morman  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  –  Precinct  No.  2  

• Joanye  Henderson  –  Chief  of  Staff  for  R.  Jack  Cagle  –  Harris  County  Commissioner  –  Precinct  No.  4  

• Mark  Miller  –  General  Manager,  SMG-­‐Reliant  Park  

• David  Turkel  –  Director,  Harris  County  Community  Services  Department  

• Nancy  Powell  –  Economic  Development  Director,  Harris  County  

• Andy  Icken  –  Chief  Development  Officer,  City  of  Houston  

• Janis  Schmees  –  Executive  Director,  Harris  County-­‐Houston  Sports  Authority  

• Susan  Young  –  Director,  South  Main  Alliance  

• Dr.  Richard  Wainerdi  –  President/CEO/COO,  Texas  Medical  Center  

• Skip  Wagner  –  President,  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo    

• Jamey  Rootes  –  President,  Houston  Texans  

• Dr.  Mary  Spangler  –  Chancellor,  Houston  Community  College  System  

Page 121: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

95    

• Emil  Pena  –  Executive  Director  –  Energy  &  Environmental  Systems  Institute,  Rice  University  

• John  Marsh  –  Operations  Director,  Rice  University  

• Kareem  Ayoub  –  Student,  Rice  University  (Empower  Program)  

• Dr.  John  Rudley  –  President,  Texas  Southern  University  

• Dr.  Bill  Flores  –  President,  University  of  Houston  Downtown  

Below  is  a  sample  of  comments  from  these  discussions:  

• There  is  a  realization  that  the  on-­‐going  maintenance  and  other  carrying  costs  relative  to  the  financial  and  event  benefits  associated  with   the  Astrodome  may  ultimately  point   to  support   for  a  demolition  scenario.    However,   it   is   imperative  that  every  possible  option  be  considered  before  reaching  that  conclusion.      

• One  possibility  for  redevelopment  initiative  involves  renovating  the  Astrodome  to  a  festival  pavilion  to  host  the  city’s  annual  festivals.    While  this  may  not  create  positive  net  cash  flow,  it  would  complement  the  other  Reliant  Park  tenants  and  allow  for  scheduling  to  meet  those  tenants’  needs.    Furthermore,  it  would  create  a  central  location  for  festivals  and  ease  the  burden  on  the  downtown  area  that  occurs  when  those  events  are  taking  place.  

• The  proposed  multi-­‐faceted  STEM  Center  that  has  been  promoted  previously   in  conjunction  with  several  of   the   local  universities   –   University   of   Houston,   Rice,   Texas   Southern,   and   St.   Thomas   –   is   supported   by   a   large   number   of  stakeholders.  The  STEM  concept  would  include  research  and  show  space  for  all  of  the  schools,  along  with  residential  dorm-­‐type  facilities  to  accommodate  students  and  researchers.    As  with  most  other  proposals,  working  around  the  six-­‐week  long  Rodeo  schedule  will  have  to  take  place.    However,  there  are  certainly  opportunities  for  a  STEM  concept  to  be  tailored  to  unique  Reliant  Park  event  patterns.  

• Because  the  initial  cost  of  renovating  the  Astrodome  to  a  condition  capable  of  redevelopment  is  significant,  demolition  of  the  Astrodome  is  viewed  as  a  potential  solution  for  consideration.  

• The  Commissioners  do  not  appear   to  have  any  preconceived  notions  of  concepts   that  would  or  would  not  be   looked  upon  favorably,  so  long  as  they  make  economic  sense.  

Page 122: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

96    

• Houston  City  Council  has  approved  a  Tax  Increment  Reinvestment  Zone  (TIRZ)  that  includes  the  350  acres  of  Reliant  Park;  however,  further  steps  have  not  been  taken  towards  implementation.  

• There  are  strong  feelings  that  a  larger  scale  project  that  included  land  adjacent  to  Reliant  Park  and  the  old  Astroworld  site  was  needed  to  make  any  redevelopment  financially  viable,  given  the  issues  related  to  the  Astrodome.  

• A  6  or  7-­‐level  parking  garage  within  the  Astrodome  could  free  up  some  of  the  land  used  for  surface  lots  to  create  green  space   and   allow   developers  much  more   financially   viable   options   to   create   projects   in   the   future.     This  would   also  alleviate  some  of  the  operating  issues  related  to  the  Rodeo’s  use  of  Reliant  Park  and  the  impact  those  operations  have  on  access  to  the  Astrodome  during  the  month  the  Rodeo  takes  place.  

• The  Texas  Medical  Center  submitted  a  proposal  for  expansion  that  utilized  the  Astrodome  in  2004.    Since  that  time,  the  largest  agency  of  the  nearly  50  that  comprise  the  Medical  Center,  MD  Anderson,  has  constructed  a  new  facility  and  thus  would  likely  not  need  any  additional  space.      

• The  largest  issue  the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center  has  currently  in  attracting  events  to  Harris  County  is  a  lack  of  full   service  hotels  within  walking  distance  of   the  Center.    This   is  also  an   issue  with   the  Reliant  Park  site,   though   the  proposed  Master  Plan  does  include  a  hotel.  

• It  has  been  reported  that  Disney  has  acquired  significant  acreage  in  eastern  Montgomery  County  for  a  potential  EPCOT  type  project.    Assuming  Disney  has  purchased  this  land,  their  financing  and  final  plans  are  unknown.  

• There   are   significant   operational   issues   associated   with   the   HLSR   and   the   Texans   with   any   redevelopment   of   the  Astrodome.    One  proposed  solution  is  to  construct  a  tunnel  (similar  to  tunnel  capabilities   in  San  Antonio)  to  provide  access  between  major  Reliant  Park  facilities  during  these  events.     It   is  estimated  that  the  cost  of  the  tunnel  would  be  approximately  $20  million,  adding  to  the  site  costs  related  to  any  redevelopment.  

• It   is   believed   that   when   the   proposed   renovations   of   Reliant   Arena   and   the   other   proposed   site   renovations   are  completed,  the  completed  facilities  would  position  Reliant  Park  to  fully  compete  for  events  in  the  varied  target  market  segments.  

• The  entire  area  around  Reliant  Park,  including  adjacent  land  and  the  old  Astroworld  site,  should  be  contemplated  when  evaluating  the  redevelopment.      

Page 123: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

97    

• The  Light  Rail  line  runs  along  the  eastern  edge  of  Reliant  Park  and  provides  a  direct  link  to  the  Medical  Center  as  well  as  downtown.    This  access  allows  for  the  inclusion  of  adjacent  land  in  a  large-­‐scale  potential  development.    

• Given  the  costs  associated  with  bringing  the  Astrodome  to  a  point  where  something  could  be  built  within  its   interior  and  the  restrictions  associated  with  any  use  given  the  operating  rights  of  the  Rodeo  and  the  Texans,  it  is  felt  by  many,  that  a  much  larger  scope  must  be  utilized  to  ensure  the  successful  adoption  of  any  redevelopment  plan.  

• The  STEM  concept  would  be  an  important  addition  to  the  Harris  County  area  and  the  national  education  system  if  done  properly.    Creating  a  STEM  center  as  has  been  contemplated  would  provide  for  an  environment  that  excites  persons  of  all  ages  to  get  involved  and  learn  about  the  STEM  subjects  and  also  allows  multiple  universities  and  area  corporations  to  share  the  costs  and  creative  burden  of  developing  and  operating  a  facility  of  this  type  and  magnitude.    

• The   costs   associated   with   the   STEM   center   development   and   operation   will   require   the   financial   involvement   of  corporations  in  the  Harris  County  area  and  will  also  require  the  creation  of  significant   infrastructure  to  maintain  the  facility  on  an  on-­‐going  basis.      

• All   of   the  Universities   and   colleges   that   the   team  met  with   expressed   strong   interest   in  being   involved   in   the   STEM  center   and   expressed   the   need   for   additional   classroom   and   laboratory   space.     In   addition,   the   schools   all   felt   that  having   some   edutainment/entertainment   component   was   imperative   to   generate   interest   from   children   and   adults  outside  of  the  schools’  respective  student  bodies.  

• Rice  University’s  Empower  program  can  serve  as  a  possible  model  for  the  structuring  of  the  basic  STEM  programming  and   perhaps   provide   the   needed   infrastructure   to  manage   this   component   of   the   venue.     The   program   is   a   service  venture  in  which  Rice  students,  physicians,  and  scientists  provide  information  and  hands-­‐on  experience  to  students  in  elementary,  middle  and  high  schools,  promoting  and  realistically  portraying  medical  and  scientific  careers.    Empower  also  focuses  efforts  on  the  general  population  to  increase  scientific  literacy.  

 

 

Page 124: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

98    

4.10    Summary  –  Market  Analysis  Harris  County’s  demographics  provide  a  very   strong  basis   for  additional  Reliant  Park  development.    The  city   is   the   fourth  largest  in  the  United  States  and  continues  to  grow.    It  is  within  300  miles  of  two  of  the  other  ten  largest  cities  in  the  United  States   –   San  Antonio   (7th)   and  Dallas   (9th)   –   and   serves   as   an   international   hub   for  United  Airlines,   providing   access   for  millions  of  additional  potential  visitors.  

The  State  of  Texas  as  a  whole,  and  the  Harris  County  market  specifically,  have  weathered  the  economic  downturn  better  than  most   other   parts   of   the  United   States.  While   the   area   has   suffered,   it   has   stabilized   and   is   poised   to   rebound  with   strong  potential  growth  in  both  the  short  and  long-­‐term.  

As   seen   through   the   analysis   summarized   above,   the   level   of   sports   franchises,   live   entertainment   venues   and   cultural  attractions   within   the   Harris   County   metropolitan   area   offers   its   residents   and   visitors   with   a   very   significant   base   of  entertainment.    That  being  said,  with  the  closing  of  Astroworld,  the  area  lacks  a  major  theme  park  and  this  is  often  looked  at  as  detracting  from  Harris  County  as  a  destination  market.      

There  clearly  is  potential  for  the  addition  of  full  service  hotel  rooms  in  close  proximity  to  Reliant  Park.  For  many  Reliant  Park  events,  there  is  a  deficiency  of  area  hotel  rooms,  and  those  that  do  exist  are  generally  limited  service  properties  that  do  not  fully  meet  the  needs  of  conventions  and  other  similar  events.      Provided  hotel  rooms  are  added,  the  potential  exists  to  support  additional  convention  and  meeting  space.    However,  it  must  be  reiterated  that  the  convention  and  meeting  space  included  in  the  proposed  Reliant  Arena  replacement  merely  replaces  the  existing  space  that  would  be  lost  with  the  demolition  of  Reliant  Arena  –  no  net  additional  space  is  being  added  under  the  current  plans.  

Furthermore,  although  there  are  a  significant  number  of  live  entertainment  venues  in  the  Harris  County  market,  there  truly  is  a  need  for  a  mid-­‐size  indoor  venue  with  a  seating  capacity  of  between  8,000  to  10,000  permanent  seats.    The  existing  Reliant  Arena  has  5,800  fixed  seats  and  lacks  the  amenities  that  are  attractive  to  most  touring  shows.      The  capacity  also  prevents  the  Arena  from  hosting  many  types  of  shows,  including  family  shows  like  Disney  on  Ice  and  the  circus,  which  presently  are  held  at  Reliant   Stadium.   The   Stadium   is   not   an   efficient   venue   for   these   types   of   shows   because   of   the   costs   associated   with  reconfiguring   the   seating   areas   (which   are   approximately   $100,000   per   event)   and   the   lack   of   intimacy   even   after   the  reconfiguring.    By  constructing  a  new  venue,  significantly  more  shows  could  be  brought   to  Reliant  Park,  more  dates  at   the  

Page 125: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4.0  Market  Analysis  

99    

Stadium   could   be   opened   for   larger   events,   and   the   shows   that   are  moved   from   the   Stadium   to   an   arena  would   generate  better  financial  performance.  

Given  the  proximity  of  the  Houston  Museum  of  Natural  Science  (HMNS)  to  Reliant  Park,  the  addition  of  a  second  planetarium  Harris   County/Houston   would   also   seem   to   be   problematic.     Furthermore,   the   existing   planetarium   has   a   number   of  complimentary  venues  and  exhibits  at  the  HMNS,  putting  it  in  a  strong  position  to  compete  for  visitors  with  a  second  similar  venue.  

Page 126: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

100    

5.0   Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis  

Page 127: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis  

101    

 

Page 128: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

102  

The  purpose  of  this  section  is  to  analyze  the  market  potential  for  two  of  the  components  of  the  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan:  the  Replacement  Arena  and  the  on-­‐site  Hotel.  Further,  the  analysis  for  the  Replacement  Arena  is  separated  into  market  segments  for  the  Performance  Arena  and  the  Exhibition  and  Meeting  Space.  Throughout  this  section,  we  outline  key  findings  associated  with  the  analysis  of  historical  Reliant  Park  operations,  competitive  and  comparable  markets  and  facilities,  and  potential  future  event  demand  specific   to  Reliant  Park.    Operational   characteristics  of   the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center   (GRBCC)  are  also  considered.  This  research  is  used  to  present  findings  as  to  the  market  demand  implications  associated  with  the  proposed  improvements.    

5.1  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Overview  The  Harris  County  Sports  and  Convention  Corporation  has  spent  a  great  deal  of  time  and  resources  over  the  past  decade  on  various  discussions  and  formal  studies  in  an  effort  to  develop  a  Master  Plan  for  the  Reliant  Park  Complex.    In  2007,  the  HCSCC  commissioned  a  study  to  assess  the  then  current  and  future  needs  of  the  on-­‐property  tenants,  clients  and  potential  clients  of  Reliant  Park.    The  HCSCC,  in  particular,  wanted  to  address  concerns  regarding  the  aging  Reliant  Arena,  address  the  need  for  additional   exhibit   and  meeting   space   for   the  Offshore  Technology  Conference,   incorporate   in   the  Master   Plan   the   program  elements  identified  by  the  HLS&R  as  being  essential  to  the  continued  growth  of  their  event,  address  parking  and  traffic  issues  related  to  the  site  and  to  develop  a  comprehensive  plan  for  future  development  at  the  complex.  

In   2010,   the  needs   of   the   complex  were   once   again   assessed   in   conjunction  with  discussions   focusing   on   the  possibility   of  creating  a  Science,  Technology,  Engineering  and  Mathematics  (“STEM”)  Institute  in  the  Astrodome.    This  effort  stressed  that  any  planning  efforts  regarding  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  must  be  coordinated  with  the  2007  Master  Plan  Study  to  ensure   the   functionality   of   a  modified   complex.   In   developing   the   revised   plan,   HCSCC  worked   closely  with   the   tenants   to  ensure  that   the   final  outcome  would  be  acceptable  to  all  stakeholders.  The  results  of   the  HCSCC’s  efforts  were  presented   in  June   of   2010   to   the   public   in   the   “Reliant   Park  Master   Plan”.     The   Reliant   Park  Master   Plan   proposes   construction   of   the  following  components:  

Replacement  Arena  Project  

The  Replacement  Arena  Project  includes  the  following  components:  the  Performance  Arena,  250,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space,   a   45,000   square   foot   ballroom,   additional   meeting   space,   Festival   Plaza,   Parking   Garage   and   the   Intermodal  Transportation  Center.  Below  is  a  description  of  the  major  program  elements.  

Page 129: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

103  

• The  Performance  Arena  would  feature  a  U-­‐shaped  seating  bowl  and  have  a  capacity  of  8,000-­‐10,000  seats.  This  multi-­‐purpose   venue  would   be   designed   to   allow  multiple   seating   and   presentation   configurations.   Other   features   of   the  Performance  Arena  would  include:  

o Multiple  seating  and  event  configurations.  Seating  capacities  for  events  would  range  from  concert  configuration  with  a  maximum  capacity  of  12,000  seats  with  temporary  seating  on  the  floor  to  a  theater  configuration  with  a  seating  capacity  of  1,500  to  2,500  seats.  

o The  arena   floor  would  have  a  maximum  size  of   300’   x  125’   for   equestrian  events  which   through   the  use  of   a  portable   seating   platform   can   be   reduced   to   200’   x   85’   for   ice   hockey   and   standard   arena   productions.   A  permanent  ice  floor  will  be  incorporated  into  the  arena  floor  slab.  

o Premium  seating  options  would  be  included.  The  current  program  has  10  to  12  suites  with  14  to  16  seats  each,  loge  boxes  with  6  to  8  seats  each  and  a  club  level.    These  assumptions  will  be  verified  with  future  programming  and  market  analysis.  

o The  ceiling  height  over  the  main  arena  floor  would  be  a  minimum  of  65’.    A  rigging  grid  with  increased  rigging  capacity,  catwalk  access  and  fall  protection  system  would  also  be  designed  into  the  roof  structure.    

• To   replace   the  exhibition   space   that  would  be   lost  with   the  demolition  of   the   current   arena,   approximately  250,000  square   feet   of   column   free   exhibit   space  divisible   into   three  halls  would  be   located  between  Reliant   Center   and   the  Performance  Arena.     It   is   important   to  note   that   if   an  Astrodome  option   is   selected   that  does  not  provide  additional  exhibit  space,  consideration  should  be  given  to  an  additional  85,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space  at  a  minimum.    The  proposed   250,000   square   feet   does   not   add   any   new   exhibition   space   to   the   complex,   it  merely   replaces   the   space  currently  available  in  the  arena.    

• To  enhance  opportunities  for  outdoor  events,  Festival  Plaza  would  be  created  in  the  area  between  the  Astrodome  site,  the  Replacement  Arena  and  the  Parking  Garage.  This  320  foot  wide,  curb-­‐less  plaza  will  function  as  an  indoor/outdoor  venue  for  festivals  and  entertainment  events,  an  area  for  outdoor  exhibit  space,  and  support  space  for  major  sporting  events.  In  addition,  this  area  will  serve  as  the  main  Grand  Stand  and  start/finish  line  for  the  Shell  and  Pennzoil  Grand  Prix  of  Houston,   scheduled   to  return   to  Reliant  Park   in  2013.  Festival  Plaza  would  be   lined  with   lush  green  planters  providing  a  park-­‐like  setting  while  also  providing  permanent  seating  and  shade.  

Page 130: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

104  

• A  parking  garage  with  2,500   to  3,000  parking  spaces  would  be   located  south  of   the  Performance  Arena.  The  ground  floor   of   the   garage  would   be   approximately   two   stories   high.   This   design  would   allow   flexible   programming   of   the  space,  allowing  it  to  serve  as  more  than  just  a  parking  area;  it  would  also  be  used  for  covered  outdoor  exhibit  space  and  support  for  arena  events.  For  example,  this  area  could  also  be  transformed  into  horse  stables  during  rodeo  season  or  animal  holding  pen  space  for  the  Ringling  Bros.  and  Barnum  &  Bailey®  Circus.  

• An  Intermodal  Transportation  Center  would  be  located  at  the  south  end  of  the  Parking  Garage.  In  addition  to  serving  as  a  bus  depot,  the  Intermodal  Transportation  Center  would  serve  as  an  arrival/departure  point  for  taxis,  limousines,  and  METRORail  riders.  

• Various  other   improvements  are  also  proposed   in   the  Master  Plan  and   include  (i)  pedestrian  bridges  connecting   the  Astrodome  to  both  Reliant  Stadium  and  Reliant  Center,  if  the  Astrodome  remains,  (ii)  demolition  of  the  current  arena  and  Plant  II,  (iii)  lowering  the  Westridge  drive  lane  at  the  Kirby  entrance  and  the  construction  of  a  pedestrian/vehicle  bridge  to  improve  traffic  flow  at  the  Westridge  entry,  (iii)  reconfiguration  of  Reliant  Parkway  and  its  extension  to  the  610  feeder,  and  (iv)  site  improvements  and  paving  following  the  demolition  of  the  current  arena.  

Hotel  

To  address  the  need  for  an  onsite  Hotel,  the  Master  Plan  proposes  the  construction  of  a  hotel  tower  above  the  new  exhibition  space.  An  underground  parking  garage  with  a  dedicated  entrance  off  Fannin  will  support  the  hotel,  therefore  day  to  day  hotel  operations  will  not  negatively  affect  street   level  activities  during  events   like  the  annual  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  and  the  Houston  Texans  football  games.  Development  of  the  Hotel  will  only  take  place  if  a  private  developer  can  be  found  to  fund  the  construction  and  operation  of  the  Hotel.  

   

Page 131: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

105  

Project  Costs  

A   breakdown   of   the   projected   costs   for   the   Replacement   Arena   and   Hotel   are   set   forth   below.   The   Construction   Cost  represents   the   hard   costs   associated   with   the   construction   of   each   of   the   project   elements.     Project   costs   include   the  construction   costs   plus   design   fees,   owner’s   representative   fee,   furniture,   fixtures   and   equipment,   permits,   legal   fees   and  testing.  A  5%  escalation  estimate  is  also  included.  

     

Page 132: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

106  

Anticipated  Results  

When  combined  with  the  existing  facilities,  the  redeveloped  campus  is  anticipated  to  yield  the  following  results:  

• Satisfy  the  future  needs  of  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo.  

• Extend  the  long-­‐term  relationship  with  the  Offshore  Technology  Conference.      

• Increase  parking  revenues  from  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  due  to  the  continued  growth  in  the  event  and  the  additional  spaces  available  from  the  parking  garage.      

• Attract  larger  conventions  and  trade  shows:  as  a  result  of  the  addition  of  the  contiguous  exhibit  space  included  in  the  Replacement  Arena.  Marketability  for  conventions  and  trade  shows  would  be  further  enhanced  if  a  private  developer  can  be  secured  for  the  onsite  hotel.  

• The  proposed  Replacement  Arena  would  better  suit  the  needs  of  professional  sports  franchises  given  its  higher  seating  capacity  and  enhanced  amenities,  which  should  result  in  increased  event  activity.  Professional  sports  franchises  could  bring  an  additional  35  to  38  event  days  to  the  complex  with  an  average  attendance  between  6,000  and  8,000  guests.  

• Increase   marketability   and   bookings   for   concert   and   entertainment   events:   primarily   due   to   the   increased   seating  capacity  in  the  arena  and  improvements  in  the  amenities  of  the  arena.  

• Allow   more   events   to   be   booked   simultaneously:   due   to   the   addition   of   the   new   high-­‐quality   exhibition   space.  Scheduling  is  always  an  issue  at  Reliant  Park  especially  during  the  NFL  season.  The  new  exhibit  space  would  create  the  opportunity  for  more  simultaneous  bookings  throughout  the  year  and  more  specifically  during  Reliant  Park’s  protected  weeks  during  the  fall.  

• Create  new  business  opportunities:  historically  Reliant  Park  has  not  been  a  destination  for  food  and  beverage  events.    With  the  addition  of  the  Ballroom  and  additional  meeting  space,  Reliant  Park  should  see  a  significant  increase  in  this  business  segment.  

• Increase   income   from   arena   events:   the   enhanced   amenities   and   concession   facilities   planned   for   the   arena   should  greatly  increase  the  food  and  beverage  income  for  events  currently  hosted  in  the  arena  as  well  as  the  new  event  activity  that  is  anticipated.  

Page 133: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

107  

• Create  new  income  from  premium  seating  opportunities:  through  the  addition  of  suites,  loge  boxes  and  club  seating  in  the  arena.    These  amenities  do  not  exist  in  the  Reliant  Arena  and  are  considered  essential  elements  in  new  facilities.    In  addition  to  the  usage  fees  associated  with  the  purchase  of  premium  seating,  additional  revenues  are  also  anticipated  from  food  and  beverage  sales  and  premium  parking  offerings.  

• Increase   income   from  advertising  and  sponsorship  sales:  due   to   the  upgraded   facilities  and  overall   increase   in  event  activity   and   attendance.   While   the   upgraded   arena   alone   will   create   new   advertising   and   sponsorship   income,   the  anticipated   increase   in   event   activity   and   attendance   should   add   value   to   the   existing   facilities   and   add   value   for  advertising  and  sponsorship  income  for  the  entire  campus.  

• Increase  income  from  existing  events:  by  moving  Circus  and  Disney  on  Ice  from  the  Stadium  to  the  arena,  eliminating  the  cost  to  install  the  blackout  curtain  and  reducing  staffing,  cleaning  and  utility  costs.  

   

Page 134: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

108  

5.2  Performance  Arena  Reliant  Arena  Operating  History  

Reliant  Arena  has  a  fixed  seating  capacity  of  5,800  and  total  capacity  of  8,500,  which  fills  a  niche  in  the  Harris  County  market  for  mid-­‐size  indoor  arenas  as  there  are  no  other  venues  of  this  size  in  the  area.    However,  with  the  venue  being  opened  in  1974  and   lacking  premium  seating  and  other  modern  amenities,  Reliant  Arena   is  not  adequate   to  host  many  of   the  events   that   it  otherwise  would  be  able  to  given  the  lack  of  comparable  sized  venues  in  the  Harris  County  area.  Annually,  Reliant  Arena  hosts  various  events  including  concerts,  family  shows,  trade  shows,  exhibitions,  and  other  such  events.    The  following  charts  provide  summaries  of  the  events  and  attendance  hosted  at  the  facility  in  recent  years.  

 

Total  Number  of  Reliant  Arena  Events  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

                           

 

0"

20"

40"

60"

80"

100"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Num

ber'of'Events'

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show"Entertainment" Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage"Meeting"&"Seminar" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

35'

59' 59'

41'

79'

45'

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Arena'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011.'

Page 135: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

109  

Reliant  Arena  Attendance  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

                                     

0"

50,000"

100,000"

150,000"

200,000"

250,000"

300,000"

350,000"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Attendance(

Amateur"&"Professional" Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show"Entertainment" Family"Shows" Food"&"Beverage"Meeting"&"Seminar" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

128,418(

209,397(235,343(

303,952(

188,533( 189,423(

Notes:''Event'types'are'based'on'Reliant'Arena'classi6ications.'Source:''CSL'International,'facility'management,'2011.'

Page 136: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

110  

Comparable  and  Competitive  Facilities  

The  following  sections  present  an  overview  of  selected  arenas  that  are  comparable  to  the  new  Reliant  Arena.    An  assessment  of   the   physical,   operational   and   financial   characteristics   of   comparable   arenas   provides   a   framework   from   which   to  benchmark  the  potential  operations  of  the  new  Arena.    The  analysis  is  divided  into  two  parts.    First,  the  primary  comparable  facilities  reviewed  were  selected  based  on  one  or  more  of  the  following  criteria,  including  but  not  limited  to:  (a)  location  in  a  major  metropolitan  area  in  competition  with  a  larger  sports  arena,  (b)  seating  capacity  of  at  least  7,500  seats,  and  (c)  opened  in  the  past  10  years.    

Sears  Centre  

                 

 Sears  Centre  is   located  in  Hoffman  Estates,  Illinois  (a  suburb  of  Chicago)  and  opened  in  Fall  2006.    The  building  seats  9,700  people   for   hockey   and   up   to   11,800   for   concerts.     Sears   Centre   is   owned   by   Ryan   Companies   US,   Inc.   and   Sears   Holding  Corporation  (the  publicly  traded  parent  of  Kmart  and  Sears  Roebuck)  and  was  developed  in  partnership  with  the  Village  of  Hoffman  Estates.    CCO  Entertainment  manages  the  building.        

Location:   Hoffman  Estates,  IL  (Chicago)  Year  Opened:   2006  Capacity:   9,700  (hockey),  11,800  (concert)  Size:   252,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:   $62  million  Funding:   100%  private  Ownership:   Ryan  Companies  &  Sears  Holdings  Management:   CCO  Entertainment  Total  Events:   135  Total  Attendance:   630,500  

Page 137: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

111  

Sears  Centre  is  home  to  three  minor  league  sports  tenants,  the  NLL  Chicago  Shamrox  (lacrosse),  MISL   Chicago   Storm   (soccer)   and   CIFL   Chicago   Slaughter   (football).     The   building’s   hockey  tenant,  the  Chicago  Hounds  of  the  UHL,  folded  operations  after  the  2007  season.    As  shown,  the  Sears   Centre   hosted   approximately   135   events   in   a   stabilized   year,   48   of   which   were   tenant  events.  

There  are  43  suites  at  the  Sears  Centre  that  lease  for  an  average  annual  total  of  $35,000  and  24  loge  boxes  that  lease  for  an  average  of  $22,500  annually.  Suite  and  loge  box  leases  include  tickets  to  concerts,  sporting  events  and  family  shows.    The  Sears  Centre  also  has  1,000  club  seats  that  lease  for  an  average  of  $1,250  per  year.    All  premium  seating  includes  VIP  parking  and  access  to  private   lounges   and   restrooms.     There   are   3,200   parking   spaces   available   for   arena   patrons,  along  with  additional  off-­‐site  parking  lots  available  to  the  public  in  case  of  traffic  overflow.  

Sears   Centre   cost   $62   million   to   construct.     The   Village   of   Hoffman   Estates   provided   a   first  mortgage  to  the  private  developers  of  the  arena  by  issuing  $50  million  in  general  obligation  bonds,  which  are  expected  to  be  paid  back  through  revenues  generated  by  the  ongoing  operations  of  Sears  Centre.    Remaining  project   funding  included  a  $6  million  land  donation  by  Sears  and  $6  million  in  equity  contributions  by  the  Ryan-­‐Sears  partnership.  

Competitive  arenas   include   the  United  Center   in  downtown  Chicago  which   is  home   to   the  NBA  Bulls  and  NHL  Blackhawks,  Allstate  Arena  in  Rosemont,  and  several  other  collegiate  arenas.  

   

Page 138: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

112  

Sovereign  Bank  Arena                      

Opened   in   1999,   Sovereign   Bank   Arena   is   located   in   Trenton,   New   Jersey   (approximately   30   miles   from   downtown  Philadelphia)  and  seats  8,100  for  hockey  and  10,500  for  concerts.  The  facility  has  17,000  square  feet  of  space  for  floor  shows  on  the  arena  floor.    It  is  owned  by  Mercer  County  and  operated  by  Global  Spectrum.        

The  arena  is  home  to  the  New  Jersey  Devils’  ECHL  affiliate,  the  Trenton  Titans.    The  table  to  the  right   presents   a   summary  of   the  historical   event   activity   at   Sovereign  Bank  Arena   in   a   recent  year.    The  facility  hosted  141  events  and  attracted  352,291  patrons.  Event  activity  included  38  Titans   hockey   games,   seven   concerts,   36   family   shows,   23  non-­‐tenant   sporting   events   and  37  other  events,  including  trade  shows,  graduations  and  religious  events.    

There  are  32  suites  at   the  Sovereign  Bank  Arena  and   they   lease  at  an  average  annual  price  of  $45,000  per  year   for   three  or   five  year   terms.    A  multi-­‐year   contract   includes   tickets   to  every  event   in   the   arena.     Included   in   the   suite   prices   are   18   tickets,   VIP   parking   and   a   private  entrance.    Suite  packages  include  concierge  service,  cable  TV  and  an  invitation  to  all  VIP  events.    

There  are  1,100  club  seats  in  the  Sovereign  Bank  Arena,  which  lease  for  $900  per  year  with  terms  ranging  from  three  to  five  years.  The   seats   include   season   tickets   to   all  Trenton  Devils  home  hockey  games,   the   first   option   to  purchase   tickets   to   all  arena  events,  VIP  parking  and  access  to  two  Club  Lounges  and  concierge  services.    

   Location:   Trenton,  NJ  (Philadelphia)      Year  Opened:   1999      Capacity:  

8,100  (hockey),  10,500  (concert)      Size:   200,000  sq.  ft.      Cost:   $53  million      Funding:   100%  public      Ownership:   Mercer  County      Management:   Global  Spectrum      Total  Events:   141      Total  Attendance:   352,291  

Page 139: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

113  

The  $53  million  Sovereign  Bank  Arena  was  financed  by  Mercer  County  via  general  obligation  bonds  guaranteed  by  the  County.    There  was  no  private  money  used  in  the  construction  of  the  facility.      Sovereign  Bank  Arena  competes  with  several  arenas  in  the   greater   Philadelphia   marketplace   including   the   Wachovia   Center,   home   to   the   NBA   Philadelphia   76ers   and   the   NHL  Philadelphia  Flyers,  the  Wachovia  Spectrum  and  the  Liacouras  Center.  

   

Page 140: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

114  

Gwinnett  Center  

                   

The   Arena   at   Gwinnett   Center   opened   in   2003   in   Duluth,   Georgia   as   an   addition   to   an   existing   convention   complex.   The  366,049  square  foot  facility,  which  seats  12,000  for  basketball  and  13,000  for  concerts,  has  17,000  square  feet  of  arena  floor  space   for   conventions   and   trade   shows   and   22  meeting   rooms   located   in   the   convention   center.     The   arena   is   owned   by  Gwinnett  County  and  operated  by  the  Gwinnett  County  Convention  and  Visitors  Bureau.    

The   table   to   the  right   summarizes  event  activity  at   the  Gwinnett  Center   in  a   recent  year.    The  arena   hosted   110   events   and   drew   620,979   attendees.     Events   included   ECHL   Gwinnett  Gladiators   games,   AFL   Georgia   Force   games,   concerts,   family   shows   and   other   sports   and  religious  events.      

The   facility  has  36  suites   that  seat  12  to  14  people  and   lease   for  $50,000  to  $70,000  per  year.    Suite  lease  terms  range  from  three  to  seven  years.    Included  in  the  ticket  price  are  12  or  14  suite  tickets   to   all   arena   events,   two   guest   passes   and   three   parking   passes,   plus   the   option   to  purchase  up  to  four  additional  suite  tickets.    Accommodations  in  the  suite  include  a  refrigerator,  storage   cabinets,  wet  bar,   large   screen   television   (50"   to  60")  with   in-­‐house   feed   and   cable,   a  telephone  with  an  in-­‐house  line  and  local  service  and  signage  on  the  exterior  of  suite.        

Location:   Duluth,  GA  (Atlanta)  Year  Opened:   2003  Capacity:   11,500  (hockey),  13,000  (concert)  Size:   380,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:  

$91  million  Funding:   100%  public  Ownership:   Gwinnett  County  Management:   Gwinnett  County  CVB  Total  Events:   110  Total  Attendance:   620,979  

Page 141: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

115  

The  Gwinnett  Center  also  has  1,390  club  seats  that  lease  for  $1,500  to  $1,700  per  year  with  one-­‐year  terms.    Included  in  club  seats  are  season  tickets  to  all  regular  season  Gwinnett  Gladiators  games  and  the  first  right  of  refusal  for  post-­‐season  tickets  and  additional  arena  events.    Amenities  include  access  to  a  private  club  lounge,  a  private  entrance  and  elevator  to  club  level  and  VIP  parking  with  purchase  of  four  or  more  seats.    

The  $91  million  arena  was  100  percent  publicly  funded  through  $65  million  in  revenue  bonds  issued  by  Gwinnett  County  and  backed  by  hotel/motel  tax  collections,  another  $25  million  in  revenue  bonds  that  were  issued  by  the  Gwinnett  Development  Authority   and   also   backed   by   hotel/motel   taxes,   and   a   $1   million   contribution   from   the   Gwinnett   Convention   &   Visitors  Bureau.      

Gwinnett  Center  primarily  competes  with  Philips  Arena,  the  home  of  the  NBA  Hawks  in  downtown  Atlanta.  

   

Page 142: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

116  

Paul  Tsongas  Arena  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Paul   Tsongas   Arena   is   located   in   Lowell,  Massachusetts   (a   suburb   of   Boston)   adjacent   to   the  University   of  Massachusetts-­‐Lowell   (“UMass-­‐Lowell”)   campus.    Tsongas  Arena   is   a  multi-­‐purpose   indoor   facility   that  opened   in   January  1998  and  has  a  capacity   of   6,500   for   hockey   and  7,800   for   concerts.     The   arena   also  maintains   a   lawn  with   a   capacity   of   3,500  people   for  outdoor  concerts,  festivals,  and  special  events.    The  venue  offers  30,000  square  feet  of  exhibit  space  on  the  arena  floor.    The  venue  is  owned  by  the  City  of  Lowell  an  operated  by  Global  Spectrum.  

Tsongas   Arena   is   home   to   two   hockey   teams   including   the   NHL   New   Jersey   Devils’   AHL  affiliate,   the   Lowell   Devils,   and   the   NCAA   Division   I   UMass-­‐Lowell   River   Hawks.     Arena  management   indicated   that   the   facility   hosted   approximately   92   event   days   in   the   most  recent  fiscal  year,  as  illustrated  to  the  right.    Arena  events  included  41  AHL  games,  17  UMass-­‐Lowell   sporting   events,   10   concerts,   five   family   shows,   and   various   other   sporting   events,  trade  shows,  conferences  and  banquets.      

The  arena  does  not  have  any  private  suites,  but  includes  approximately  250  club  seats  that  lease  for  an  average  annual  fee  of  $299  per  seat.    Seats  can  be  leased  on  a  one  year  or  three  year   basis.     Club   seat   prices   include   season   tickets   to   all   regular   season   home   games   for  UMass-­‐Lowell  River  Hawks  hockey  and  the  first  right  to  purchase  tickets  for  all  other  arena  

Location:   Lowell,  MA  (Boston)  Year  Opened:   1998  Capacity:   6,500  (hockey),  7,800  (concert)  Size:   175,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:   $28  million  Funding:   86%  public,  14%  private  Ownership:   City  of  Lowell  Management:   Global  Spectrum  Total  Events:   92  Total  Attendance:   236,409  

Page 143: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

117  

events.     Club   seat   amenities   include   center-­‐ice   location   with   optimum   sightlines,   padded   seats   with   cup   holders,   one   VIP  parking  pass  for  every  two  seats  purchased  and  access  to  the  Talon  Club  Room.    

The  $28  million   facility  was   funded   through  a  $4  million  City  of  Lowell  municipal  bond  and  $4  million   from   the  University  fund.    US  Senator  Paul  Tsongas,  who  the  arena  is  named  after,  was  also  instrumental  in  acquiring  state  funding  for  the  project.    The  remaining  $20  million  was  funded  by  state  grants,   including  $3  million  for  a  canal  and  river  walkway  around  the  arena  and  $3.5  million  for  an  access  road  and  rotary  connecting  the  arena  with  an  existing  parking  garage.      

Tsongas  Arena  is  located  30  miles  northwest  of  Boston,  drawing  from  an  audience  of  4.5  million  residents.    However,  a  facility  representative  indicated  that  despite  its  proximity  to  Boston  and  its  competing  facilities,  Tsongas  Arena  has  been  successful  in  drawing  events  due  to  its  ease  of  access  relative  to  facilities  in  downtown  Boston,  and  its  intimate  size  which  provides  better  sightlines  than  the  larger  TD  Banknorth  Garden  in  Boston.    Other  competing  arenas  in  the  Boston  area  include  the  DCU  Center  in  Worcester,   as   well   as   collegiate   arenas   such   as   Conte   Forum   (Boston   College),   Agganis   Arena   (Boston   University)   and  Matthews  Arena  (Northeastern  University).  

   

Page 144: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

118  

Comcast  Arena  at  Everett  Events  Center  

                     

Comcast  Arena  at  Everett  Events  Center  was  completed  in  2003  and  has  a  seating  capacity  of  10,000  for  concerts  and  8,300  for  hockey.    The  Everett  Events  Center  complex,  located  in  Everett,  Washington  (a  suburb  of  Seattle),  also  has  a  57,000  square  foot  floor  for  trade  shows  and  conventions.    The  facility  is  owned  by  the  Everett  Public  Facilities  District  and  operated  by  Global  Spectrum.    Naming  rights  were  sold  to  Comcast  in  2007  for  $3.4  million  over  10  years.  

With   the   arena’s   af2   indoor   football   team   folding  operations   after   the  2007   season,   the   sole  tenant   in  Comcast  Arena   is   the  Everett  Silvertips  of   the  Western  Hockey  League.    The  arena  also  hosts  concerts,  circuses  and  other  family  shows,  ice  shows,  motor  sports,  trade  shows  and  graduations.    The  table  at  the  right  presents  a  breakdown  of  events  hosted  by  Comcast  Arena  in  a  recent  year.      

The  arena  has  20  suites  that  range  in  price  from  $30,000  to  $40,000  per  year  and  lease  for  one,  three,   five   or   seven   year   terms.   Suite   prices   include   12   tickets   to   all   events,   a   private   VIP  entrance  and  a  VIP  club   lounge.  Additional   suite   features   include  a  wet  bar,   a   refrigerator,   a  television  with  high-­‐speed  Internet  access  and  a  nameplate  at  the  suite  entrance.    

Location:   Everett,  WA  (Seattle)  Year  Opened:   2003  Capacity:   8,300  (hockey),  10,000  (concerts)  Size:   300,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:  

$54.5  million  Funding:   100%  public  Ownership:   Everett  Public  Facilities  District  Management:   Global  Spectrum  Total  Events:   148  Total  Paid  Attendance:  470,417  

Page 145: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

119  

The  facility  has  761  club  seats  that  lease  for  an  average  of  $775  per  year  with  one-­‐year  terms.  Amenities  for  club  seats  include  the  first  right  to  purchase  tickets   for  arena  events,  one  parking  pass  for  every  two  club  seats  purchased,  access  to  a  private  club  lounge  and  priority  booking  for  the  club  lounge  on  non-­‐event  days.    

The  $71.5  million   construction  project,   $54.5  million  of  which  was  attributed   to   the  arena,  was   funded  with   state   sales   tax  rebates   and  City   contributions.    The  City  of  Everett   contributed  $15  million   toward   facility   construction  by   issuing  general  obligation  bonds.    While   the  bonds  are  not  backed  by  a   specific   source,   the  City  anticipates   that   it  will   recoup  a   significant  portion  of   its  contribution  through  a   five  percent  admissions  tax  as  well  as  rent  received  from  retail  spaces   in  the  complex.    The   remaining   $56.5   million   was   financed   through   bonds   issued   by   the   Everett   Public   Facilities   District   (“EPFD”).    Approximately  $33.9  million  of  the  EPFD  bond  issue  is  anticipated  to  be  backed  by  Everett  Events  Center  revenues,  and  the  remaining   $22.6  million   is   backed  by   sales   tax   rebates   received   from   the   State   as  well   as   City   and  County   hotel/motel   tax  revenues.    The  EPFD  uses  state  sales  tax  revenue  for  the  $2.8  million  annual  debt  payment.      

The  Everett  Events  Center  competes  in  the  greater  Seattle  marketplace  with  Key  Arena,  home  to  the  NBA  Seattle  Supersonics,  and  the  Tacoma  Dome,  among  other  facilities.    

   

Page 146: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

120  

Family  Arena                      

Located  in  St.  Charles,  Missouri  (a  suburb  of  St.  Louis),  Family  Arena  was  completed  in  1999  and  seats  11,522  for  concerts  and  9,643  for  ice  events.    Additionally,  there  is  a  30,000  square  foot  area  for  flat  shows.    The  arena  is  owned  and  operated  by  the  St.  Charles  Public  Arena  Authority.    

The  Missouri  River  Otters  of   the  United  Hockey  League   folded  operations   following   the  2007  season,   leaving   the  River  City  Rage  of  the  United  Indoor  Football  League  as  the  sole  tenant  of  Family  Arena.    The  table  below  summarizes  historical  event  activity  at  the  Family  Arena  during  a  recent  year.    Family  Arena  hosted  91  events,  including  the  Rage,  concerts,  family  shows,  motor  sports,  trade  shows  and  graduations.  

Family  Arena  has  44  suites  that  range  from  $15,000  to  $30,000  per  year  and  lease  from  one  to  seven  year  terms.    Lease  fees  include  VIP  parking.    There  are  also  296  club  seats  that  lease  for  two  years  at  $888  per  year.    

Family  Arena  was  funded  through  $35  million  in  taxable   leasehold  revenue  bonds  secured  by  lease  payments.    The  bonds  were  issued  through  the  St.  Charles  Public  Arena  Authority,  which  is  a  not-­‐for-­‐profit  arm  of  the  government,  so  voter  approval  was  not  required.    The  original  57-­‐acre  land  donation  came  from  Station  Casino  St.  Charles  in  St.  Charles  County  and  was  valued  at  approximately  $6.2  million.      

Location:   St.  Charles,  MO  (St.  Louis)  Year  Opened:   1999  Capacity:   9,643  (hockey),  11,522  (concerts)  Size:   192,855  sq.  ft.  Cost:  

$35  million  Funding:   82%  public,  18%  private  Ownership:   St.  Charles  Public  Arena  Authority  Management:   St.  Charles  Public  Arena  Authority  Total  Events:   91  Total  Attendance:   248,251  

Page 147: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

121  

Originally,  the  Family  Arena  Management  Enterprise  LLC  (“FAME”),  a  private  entity,  was  responsible  for  paying  $2.2  million  of  the  $2.8  million  annual  debt  payment,  two  years  of  which  they  contributed  up  front,  and  the  County  was  responsible  for  the  remaining  $600,000.    However,  FAME  turned  over  operations  of   the   facility   to   the  St.  Charles  Public  Arena  Authority  a   few  years  after  opening,  and  FAME’s  portion  of  annual  debt  payments  is  now  paid  by  a  combination  of  arena  revenues  and  County  sales  tax  revenue.  

Family  Arena  primarily  competes  with  the  Scottrade  Center,  home  of  the  NHL  St.  Louis  Blues,  and  Chaifetz  Arena,  a  10,600-­‐seat  venue  on  the  campus  of  St.  Louis  University  that  was  completed  in  April  2008.  

E-­‐Center  

                   

Located   in  West  Valley  City,  Utah  (a  suburb  of  Salt  Lake  City),   the  E-­‐Center  opened   in  1999  and  gained   international   exposure  as   the  host   venue   for   the   Ice  Hockey  Championships  at   the  2002  Olympic  Winter  Games.     The   arena   seats   8,200   for   hockey   and  up   to   12,000   for   concerts.  With  20,910  square  feet  of  arena  floor  space,  the  facility  can  also  accommodate  floor  shows.    The  center  is  publicly  owned  by  West  Valley  City  and  privately  managed  by  Centennial  Management  Group.    

The  table  at  the  right  summarizes  the  events  hosted  by  the  E-­‐Center  in  a  recent  year.    The  facility  hosted  a  total  of  83  events,  including  ECHL  hockey  games,  concerts,  family  shows,  other  sporting  events,  graduations  and  religious  events.      

Location:   W.  Valley  City,  UT  (Salt  Lake  City)  Year  Opened:   1999  Capacity:   8,200  (hockey),  12,000  (concert)  Size:   300,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:  

$49.3  million  Funding:   100%  public  Ownership:   West  Valley  City  Management:   Centennial  Management  Total  Events:   83  Total  Paid  Attendance:  311,217  

Page 148: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

122  

The  E-­‐Center  has  38  suites  that  range  in  price  from  $35,000  to  $50,000  per  year  with  lease  terms  ranging  from  three  to  seven  years.     The   suites   can   accommodate   16   to   20   people   and   include   regular   season   and   playoff   tickets.     Amenities   include   a  private  suite  attendant/concierge  service,  BOSE  Wave  Radio,  27”  cable  television  with  remote  control,  double-­‐sided  sink  and  refrigerator  and  local  telephone  access.    

The  1,750  club  seats  in  the  E-­‐Center  lease  for  $1,200  to  $1,500  annually,  with  terms  ranging  from  two  to  four  years.    The  lease  terms  include  tickets  to  all  Utah  Grizzlies  games  and  the  first  right  of  refusal  to  purchase  tickets  for  other  events.      

Funding  for  the  $49.3  million  E-­‐Center  came  from  West  Valley  City.    The  initial  round  of  financing  came  in  the  form  of  revenue  bonds   issued   by   the   Building   Authority.     The   E-­‐Center   competes   in   the   greater   Salt   Lake   City   marketplace   with  EnergySolutions   Arena,   home   of   the   NBA   Utah   Jazz,   as   well   as   several   collegiate   venues,   including   Huntsman   Center  (University  of  Utah),  Dee  Events  Center  (Weber  State),  Marriott  Center  (BYU),  and  McKay  Events  Center  (Utah  Valley  State).  

   

Page 149: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

123  

Desoto  County  Civic  Center                        

Desoto  County  Civic  Center  is   located  in  Southaven,  Mississippi,  about  15  minutes  south  of  downtown  Memphis,  Tennessee.    The   facility   opened   in   2000   and   holds   a  maximum   capacity   of   10,000   people.     Desoto   County   Civic   Center   also   includes   a  20,000  square  foot  convention  and  meeting  space,  a  35,000  sq.  ft.  arena  floor,  as  well  as  a  400-­‐person  theater.    The  venue  is  owned  and  operated  by  Desoto  County.  

In  a  recent  year,  the  arena  at  Desoto  County  Civic  Center  hosted  approximately  200  events.    Tenant  sporting  events  featured  32   CHL  Mississippi   RiverKings   games   and   nine   games   for   the   now   defunct   af2  Memphis   Xplorers.     The   arena   also   hosted  graduations,   high   school   sporting   events   and   other   community   events,   as   well   as   concerts,   family   shows,   and   religious  gatherings.  Desoto  County  Civic  Center  has  two  types  of  luxury  suites,  seating  either  10  or  17  people.    The  arena’s  12  suites  range  from  $35,000  to  $45,000  per  year,  with  lease  terms  ranging  from  three  to  seven  years.    Suite  packages  include  tickets  to  all  RiverKings  home  games,  VIP  parking  and  the  option  to  purchase  tickets  for  all  other  public  arena  events.  

Funding   for   the  Desoto  County  Civic  Center  was  generated  via  a  special   tourist  promotion   tax  of   two  percent   levied  on   the  gross  proceeds  of   restaurants,   hotels   and  motels   in  Desoto  County.     Competitive   arenas   in   the  market  place   include  FedEx  Forum  (home  of  the  NBA  Memphis  Grizzlies  and  University  of  Memphis  basketball)  and  Pyramid  Arena.  

   

Location:   Southaven,  MS  (Memphis)  Year  Opened:   1999  Capacity:   8,500  (hockey),  10,000  (concert)  Size:   200,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:  

$27.5  million  Funding:   100%  public  Ownership:   Desoto  County  Management:   Desoto  County  CVB  Total  Events:   200  Total  Paid  Attendance:  255,663  

Page 150: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

124  

Citizens  Business  Bank  Arena  

                   

Citizens  Business  Bank  Arena  opened  on  October  24,  2008,  in  Ontario,  California,  which  is  located  approximately  35  miles  east  of  downtown  Los  Angeles.      The  arena  was  developed  as  the  centerpiece  of  Piemonte  at  Ontario  Center,  a   large-­‐scale  office,  retail,  hotel,  entertainment  and  urban-­‐living  complex.    The  arena   is  also  adjacent   to   the  San  Manuel   Indian  Bingo  &  Casino.    The   225,000   square   foot  multi-­‐purpose   facility   seats   9,736   for   hockey   and   11,089   for   concerts,   and   features   3,500   on-­‐site  parking  spaces  for  use  by  arena  patrons.    The  arena  is  owned  by  the  City  of  Ontario  and  managed  by  AEG.  

The  arena  is  home  to  the  NHL  Los  Angeles  Kings’  ECHL  affiliate,  the  Ontario  Reign.  Citizens  Business  Bank  Arena  hosted  125  events   in   a   recent   fiscal   year,   including   36   ECHL   games,   20   concerts,   25   family   shows,   19   other   sporting   events   and   25  miscellaneous  other  events.  

There  are  36  suites  at  Citizens  Business  Bank  Arena  that  lease  for  an  annual  average  of  $63,000  and  include  tickets  to  all  arena  events,  as  well  as  access  to  the  Sky  Box  Bar.  Suites  are  sold  on  a  minimum  five-­‐year  lease.    The  arena  also  has  one  14-­‐person  suite  available  for  nightly  rental,  with  costs  dependent  upon  event  and  ticket  price.    Citizens  Business  Bank  Arena  also  has  770  club  seats,  which  lease  for  $1,100  per  year  and  include  Reign  season  tickets,  first  right  of  refusal  for  all  other  arena  events  and  access  to  the  VIP  Club,  which  is  located  in  the  adjacent  San  Manuel  Indian  Bingo  &  Casino.      

Citizens   Business   Bank  Arena   cost   $150  million   to   construct   and   has   been   paid   for   in   full   by   the   City   of   Ontario.   The   City  generated   $62   million   from   the   sale   of   several   public   properties   to   developers   and   received   $12   million   from   the   City’s  

Location:   Ontario,  CA  (Los  Angeles)  Year  Opened:   2008  Capacity:   9,736  (hockey),  11,089  (concert)  Size:   225,000  sq.  ft.  Cost:   $150  million  Funding:   100%  public  Ownership:   City  of  Ontario  Management:   AEG  Total  Events:   125  -­‐  projected  Total  Attendance:   577,500  -­‐  projected  

Page 151: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

125  

redevelopment  department  to  build  the  parking  lot  and  freeway  signs  for  the  arena.  The  remaining  $76  million  came  from  an  annual  budget  surplus  that  the  City  of  Ontario  allocated  to  a  facility  development  fund.  

Citizens   Business   Bank   Arena   is   the   primary   multi-­‐purpose   arena   in   the   Inland   Empire   region,   which   comprises   San  Bernardino   and   Riverside   counties.     However,   there   are   two  major   professional   arenas  within   45  miles.     Honda   Center   is  located  in  Anaheim  and  is  home  of  the  NHL  Anaheim  Ducks.    Staples  Center  is  located  in  Los  Angeles  and  is  home  to  the  NBA  Los   Angeles   Lakers,   NBA   Los   Angeles   Clippers,   NHL   Los   Angeles   Kings,   NBA  D-­‐League   Los   Angeles   D-­‐Fenders,  WNBA   Los  Angeles  Sparks  and  AFL  Los  Angeles  Avengers.  

   

Page 152: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

126  

Key  findings  regarding  the  primary  comparable  venues  included  the  following:  

• The  eight  primary   comparable   facilities  profiled  have  an  average   fixed   seating   capacity   for  hockey  of   approximately  8,900  people.    Average  concert  capacity  is  around  10,800.  

• The   average   total   development   cost   of   the   primary   comparable   facilities   was   approximately   $79.8   million   in   2012  dollars.    On  average,  they  were  built  around  2002  and  public  funds  accounted  for  94  percent  of  project  funding.      

• Ownership  of  comparable  venues  is  primarily  through  a  municipal  entity,  with  Sears  Centre  in  the  suburbs  of  Chicago  as  the  only  exception.      

• The  majority  of  comparable   facilities  are  operated  by  private  contract   firms,  such  as  Global  Spectrum  or  SMG,  which  specialize   in   management.     Desoto   County   Civic   Center   and   the   Gwinnett   Center   are   the   only   publicly-­‐operated  comparable  arenas.  

• Primary   comparable   arenas   hosted   an   average   of   125   events,   ranging   from   a   low   of   83   events   at   E-­‐Center   in  West  Valley  City,  Utah  to  a  high  of  200  events  at  Desoto  County  Civic  Center  in  Southaven,  Mississippi.      

• In  terms  of  non-­‐tenant  events,  comparable  facilities  hosted  an  average  of  85  events,  with  a  low  of  34  at  Tsongas  Arena  in   Lowell,   Massachusetts,   and   a   high   of   159   at   Desoto   County   Civic   Center.     Non-­‐tenant   events   typically   included  concerts,  family  shows,  high  school  sports,  graduations,  flat  floor  shows,  and  other  miscellaneous  events.  

• Average  total  attendance  for  the  facilities  was  approximately  411,000,  ranging  from  a  low  of  236,409  at  Tsongas  Arena  to  a  projected  high  of  630,500  at  Sears  Centre.  

• Seven  of  eight  primary  comparable  facilities  have  private  suites.    The  average  number  of  private  suites  was  33,  ranging  from  a  low  of  12  at  Desoto  County  Civic  Center  to  a  high  of  44  at  Family  Arena  outside  of  St.  Louis.    The  average  annual  suite  price  was  approximately  $42,375.      

• Seven  of  the  primary  comparable  facilities  have  club  seats.    The  average  number  of  club  seats  was  915,  ranging  from  a  low  of  250  at  Tsongas  Arena  to  1,750  at  E-­‐Center.    The  average  annual  club  seat  price  was  approximately  $1,020.  

   

Page 153: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

127  

Market  Demand  Analysis  –  Performance  Arena  

The  proposed  plans  for  the  Performance  Arena  include  a  U-­‐shaped  seating  bowl  with  a  fixed  seating  capacity  of  between  8,000  to  10,000.  This  multi-­‐purpose  venue  will  be  designed  to  allow  multiple  seating  and  presentation  configurations.  Other  features  include  a  125’  x  250’  playing  floor,  10-­‐12  suites  and  loge  boxes.  This  facility  would  allow  Reliant  Park  to  host  more  events  than  in  the  current  arena,  and  it  will  also  address  the  need  for  more  space  for  some  larger  events,  such  as  the  OTC  and  the  HLSR.  

The  new  arena,  with  increased  capacity  and  better  amenities,  will  allow  for  the  booking  of  several  additional  shows  each  year  and   also   will   allow   for   certain   events   currently   held   at   Reliant   Stadium,   particularly   family   shows   like   Ringling   Brothers  Barnum  and  Bailey  Circus  and  Disney  on  Ice,  to  move  to  the  new  arena.    This  will  save  operating  expenses  of  over  $100,000  for  each   of   these   shows,  which   are   the   costs   of   reconfiguring   and  hosting   the   events   in   Reliant   Stadium,   and  will   also   free   up  additional  dates  at  the  Stadium.  It  is  anticipated  that  the  new  Performance  Arena,  with  its  increased  capacity  and  modern  amenities  should  double  the  number  of  events  held  annually.    As  discussed  above,  the  family  shows  currently  held  at  the  Stadium,  which  total  between  25-­‐35  events  annually,  will  move  to  the  Performance  Arena.    In  addition,  the  larger  capacity  and  the  lack  of  competitive  venues  in  the  Harris  County  area  will   significantly  expand   the  number  of  entertainment  and  sporting  events   that  would  consider  booking  at   the  Performance  Arena.      The  existing  Arena  generates  an  average  of  $25,000  of   revenues  after  expenses   from  each  of   the  events  held  at   the   facility.    Increasing   the  capacity  of   the  venue  by  nearly  double  will   allow   for  an   increase   in  operating   income   from  each  event   from  historical  levels.    It  is  anticipated,  that  the  types  of  events  the  new  venue  will  attract  will  also  ensure  that  the  income  increases  on   a   per   event   basis,   to   approximately   $40,000   for   an   average  non-­‐sporting   event   and   $30,000   for   each   team  game   at   the  arena.    Using  the  assumptions  set  forth  above,  the  number  of  annual  events  could  increase  to  151,  including  40  minor  league  hockey   games.     The   family   shows   currently   being   held   at   Reliant   Stadium   each   year  would   relocate   to   the   Arena   as  well,  accounting  for  approximately  23  additional  events  each  year.      The  increased  capacity  would  also  allow  for  additional  concerts  and  sporting  events  to  be  booked  that  currently  will  not  play  at  the  Arena.  As  a   result  of   the   increase   in  number  of  events  as  well  as   the  profitability  of  each  show,   the   total  annual  operating   income  generated  by  events  at  the  proposed  Reliant  Arena  should  be  approximately  $4.4  million,  a  dramatic   increase  from  the  $1.3  million  currently  generated  in  an  average  fiscal  year.    

   

Page 154: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

128  

5.3  Exhibition  and  Meeting  Space  Historical  Performance  –  Harris  County  Facilities  

The  key  operational   elements   of  Reliant  Center   and   the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center   (GRBCC)  have  been   analyzed.    Understanding  utilization  levels,  event  mix  and  other  such  characteristics  of  the  facility  is  important  to  provide  a  basis  from  which  to  evaluate  potential  unmet  demand  for  event  space  in  the  market.  

Reliant  Center  hosts  a  wide  variety  of  both   local  and  non-­‐local  events.    Based  on  classifications  provided  by  Reliant  Center  management,  event  data  for  the  six  year  period  spanning  fiscal  years  ending  2006  through  2011  have  been  segmented  into  the  following  six  event  types:  Community  and  Religious,  Consumer  Show,  Convention,  Entertainment,  Food  and  Beverage,  Meeting  and  Seminar,  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo,  Trade  show,  and  Other  Events.    Data  presented  herein  is  inclusive  of  events  utilizing  space  in  at  least  some  portion  of  Halls  A  through  E.  

 Total  Number  of  Reliant  Center  Event  Days  by  Event  Type  

(FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)      

                           

0"

50"

100"

150"

200"

250"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Num

ber'of'Event'Days'

Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show" Convention"Entertainment" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Rodeo" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

166'

199' 192'

156'

213'

178'

Page 155: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

129  

Over  the  past  six  fiscal  years,  the  number  of  event  days  at  Reliant  Center  exhibit  space  ranged  from  156  to  213,  with  a  spike  to  213  in  2009.    Consumer  shows  have  comprised  the  largest  segment  of  event  days,  increasing  from  81  event  days  in  fiscal  year  ending  2008  to  85  event  days  in  fiscal  year  ending  2011,  including:    

• Houston  Auto  Show  • Bridal  Symposium  • International  Gem  and  Jewelry  Show    • Houston  Gun  Collectors  and  Antiques  Show  • Home  and  Design  Show  • Texas  Home  and  Garden  Show  • International  Boat  Sport  &  Travel  Show  • Houston  RV  Show  • Houston  Ballet’s  Nutcracker  Market  

Trade  shows  also  comprise  a  significant  segment  of  events  utilizing  Reliant  Center  exhibit  space.    The  number  of  total  trade  show  events  held  at  Reliant  Center  has  decreased  from  17  in  fiscal  year  ending  2007  to  just  eight  in  fiscal  year  ending  2011.    This  trend  follows  a  pattern  similar  to  that  experienced  in  many  large  event  public  assembly  facilities  across  the  United  States  in  light  of  the  recent  economic  downturn  and  recovery  process.  

   

Page 156: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

130  

In   an   effort   to   characterize   the   overall   event  mix   and   utilization   of   Reliant   Center,   the   following   exhibit   presents   the   total  number  of  utilization  days  (including  move-­‐in,  event  and  move-­‐out  days)  by  event  type  for  fiscal  years  ending  2006  through  2011.  

   

Total  Number  of  Reliant  Center  Utilization  Days  by  Event  Type  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

   

                                         

0"50"100"150"200"250"300"350"400"450"500"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Num

ber'of'Utilization'Days'

Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show" Convention"Entertainment" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Rodeo" Trade"Show" Other"Events"

352'

435' 424'

342'

451'410'

Page 157: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

131  

Over  the  past  six  years,  the  number  of  utilization  days  has  ranged  from  approximately  342  to  451;  though  if  we  remove  the  25  event  days  due  to  FEMA’s  usage  of  Reliant  Park  as  part  of  their  response  to  Hurricane  Ike  in  September  2008,  FYE  2007  had  the  most  utilization  days  with  435.    Consumer  show  event  days  comprise  an  average  of  46  percent  of  total  annual  event  days  at  Reliant  Center,  and  have  remained  relatively  consistent  over  the  past  six  fiscal  years  ranging  from  177  event  days  in  fiscal  year  ending  2008  to  203  event  days  in  fiscal  year  ending  2009.    The  large  number  of  total  event  days  reflects  Reliant  Center’s  ability  to  accommodate  numerous  events  consisting  of  multiple  event  days  and  multiple  concurrent  events.  

The  following  exhibit  outlines  total  attendance  by  event  type  for  the  same  six  year  period  among  all  events  utilizing  Reliant  Center.      

 Reliant  Center  Attendance  by  Event  Type  

(FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)                                        

0"

150,000"

300,000"

450,000"

600,000"

750,000"

FYE"2006" FYE"2007" FYE"2008" FYE"2009" FYE"2010" FYE"2011"

Attendance(

Community"&"Religious" Consumer"Show" Convention"Entertainment" Food"&"Beverage" Meeting"&"Seminar"Trade"Show" Other"Events"

625,718( 604,315(

678,850( 660,676(609,918( 585,207(

Page 158: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

132  

As  shown,  attendance  at  Reliant  Center  events  has  steadily   increased  over   the  past  six   fiscal  years   from  approximately  585  thousand   in   fiscal  year  ending  2011   to  nearly  700   thousand   in   fiscal  year  ending  2008,  driven   largely  by  attendance  at   the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo.    Consumer  show  attendance  has  experienced  an  approximate  five  percent  decline  during  the  past  six  years,  which  may  largely  be  a  result  of  recent  overall  economic  conditions.    Combined,  convention  and  trade  show  event  attendance  represents  a  small  share  of  overall  complex  attendance,  and  has  remained  largely  constant  during  this  time  period,   increasing   from   86,100   attendees   in   fiscal   year   ending   2006   to   nearly   115,300   in   fiscal   year   ending   2007   before  settling  closer  to  90,000  attendees  in  each  of  the  past  two  fiscal  years.    It  is  also  important  to  measure  Reliant  Center  exhibit  space  use  from  the  perspective  of  square  footage  occupancy.    Occupancy  levels   (measured  by  dividing   the   total   amount   of   sold   event   space  by   the   total   amount   of   sellable   space  within   the   facility  multiplied  by  365),  can  indicate  the  degree  to  which  usage  of  the  facility  has  reached  a  maximum  capacity.    The  occupancy  of  a  facility  is  determined  to  be  within  a  practical  maximum  capacity  range  when  the  actual  occupied  space  in  a  facility  reaches  a  level   of   70   percent   of   total   sellable   capacity.     Above   70   percent   occupancy,   a   facility   has   exceeded   “practical   maximum  capacity”  and  may  be  turning  away  significant  business.      

These   assumptions   account   for   the   reality   that   a   portion   of   the   facility’s   total   capacity   is   unsellable   due   to   holidays,  maintenance  days  and  inherent  booking  inefficiencies  that  result  when  events  cannot  be  scheduled  immediately  back-­‐to-­‐back.    Occupancy  levels  below  50  percent  may  indicate  that  a  center  has  not  attracted  sufficient  market  share  necessary  to  support  space   levels.     However,   it   is   important   to   assess   the   wide   variety   of   factors   impacting   event   demand   before   making   a  determination  that  a  lack  of  event  demand  exists.  At  Reliant  Center,  there  are  significant  booking  restrictions  due  to  the  HLSR  and  the  Texans  being  the  primary  tenants  at  Reliant  Park.    For  all  practical  purposes,  Reliant  Center  can  only  be  booked  one  week  a  month  (The  Protected  Week)  during  the  football  season  because  the  Texans  hold  the  other  weeks  until  the  release  of  the  NFL  schedule   in  April  prior  to  the  start  of   the  applicable  season.    Because  these  holds  remain   in  place  until  5-­‐8  months  prior   to   the  actual  date,   it   is  not   feasible   to  book  most   conventions  and   trade   shows  within   such  a   short   time   frame.    This  substantially  reduces  the  number  of  event  days  that  would  be  considered  available  for  Reliant  Center’s  capacity.      

Page 159: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

133  

In  order  to  identify  the  types  of  activities  that  are  generating  the  most  facility  use,  the  exhibit  below  presents  a  summary  of  exhibit  space  occupancy  by  event  type  for  each  of  the  individual  halls  from  fiscal  years  2006  through  2011.    

Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Space  Occupancy  Percentages  by  Hall  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

   

                                   Overall   Reliant  Center  exhibit  space  occupancy  rates  have  experienced  a  slight  decline  during  the  past  two  fiscal  years  after  a  six-­‐year  high  60.5  percent  occupancy  rate   in  FYE  2009.    Reliant  Center  experienced  a  48.3  percent  occupancy  rate   in  FYE  2010  and  44.1  percent  occupancy  rate  in  FYE  2011.    These  compare  to  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center  occupancy  rates  of  48.5  percent,  45.1  percent  and  48.2  percent  exhibit  space  occupancy  rate  in  FYE  2009,  FYE  2010  and  FYE  2011,  respectively.  

Source:((CSL(International,(facility(management,(2011(

0%#

10%#

20%#

30%#

40%#

50%#

60%#

70%#

80%#

90%#

FYE#2006# FYE#2007# FYE#2008# FYE#2009# FYE#2010# FYE#2011#

Occupancy(

Hall#A1# Hall#A2# Hall#A3# Hall#A4# Hall#B# Hall#C# Hall#D# Hall#E1# Hall#E2# Hall#E3# Hall#E4#

Page 160: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

134  

It  is  important  to  note  that  the  Texans  and  the  HLSR  hold  dates  that  prevent  booking  of  other  events.    For  example,  there  were  137  days  on  which  holds  were  placed  for  last  year’s  calendar,  significantly  impacting  the  ability  to  book  events.    If  these  days  are  removed  from  inventory,   the  resulting  Reliant  Center  occupancy  percentages   increase  significantly.    Certainly  not  every  hold  day  would  yield  an  actual  event,  and  we  would  expect  that  scheduling  adjustments  could  be  made  in  some  cases  to  the  holds  and/or  a  potential  event,  so  that  the  lost  inventory  due  to  holds  would  not  be  so  severe.    However,  even  assuming  a  loss  of   50   percent   of   the   hold   dates,   occupancy   levels   for   Reliant   Center   space   reach   high   levels,   as   presented   in   the   following  exhibit.    

Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Space  Occupancy  Percentages  by  Hall  Adjusting  for  Hold  Dates  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

   

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

FY 2006 FY 2007 FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011

Occ

upan

cy

Hall A1 Hall A2 Hall A3 Hall A4 Hall B Hall C Hall D Hall E1 Hall E2 Hall E3 Hall E4

Source: CSL International, facility management, 2011

Page 161: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

135  

As   noted   above,   occupancy   percentages   adjusted   for   hold   dates   range   between   60   and   80   percent.     These   data   are  more  indicative  of  a  full  facility,  creating  potential  pressure  for  additional  space.  As  the  economy  continues  to  rebound  in  the  coming  years,   it   is  reasonable  to  expect  that  Reliant  Center’s   largely  consumer  show   based   events   will   again   allow   the   facility   to   generate   occupancy   rates   above   50   percent.     However,   considering   the  excess   capacity   available   at   the  GRBCC,   it  may  be  difficult   for  Reliant  Center   to   attract   a   significant  number  of   incremental  nationally   rotating   conventions   and   trade   show   events   that   oftentimes   prefer   downtown   convention   facilities  with   greater  access  to  hotel  inventory  and  entertainment  options.  The   following  exhibit   summarizes   the  size  distribution  on  a  per-­‐event  basis   for  exhibit   space  events  at  Reliant  Center   from  fiscal  year  ending  2006  through  fiscal  year  ending  2011.  

Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Hall  Event  Distribution  by  Size  (FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)  

   

 

   

Note:&&Figures&only&represent&those&events&utilizing&exhibit&space.&Source:&&CSL&International,&facility&management,&2011&

0

150,000

300,000

450,000

600,000

750,000

1& 3& 5& 7& 9& 11&13&15&17&19&21&23&25&27&29&31&33&35&37&39&41&43&45&47&49&51&53&55&57&59&61&63&65&67&69&71&73&

Square'Feet'of'Exhibit'Space'

FYE&2006& FYE&2007& FYE&2008& FYE&2009& FYE&2010& FYE&2011&

Page 162: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

136  

The  number   of   events   utilizing   all   706,200   square   feet   of   exhibit   space   at  Reliant   Center   over   the   past   six   fiscal   years   has  ranged  from  five  in  fiscal  year  ending  2011  to  nine  in  both  fiscal  year  ending  2007  and  fiscal  year  ending  2009.    Some  of  these  events  include  the  HLSR,  OTC,  the  Boat  Show,  Nutcracker  Market  and  the  Reliant  Park  World  Series  of  Dog  Shows.     In  fiscal  year  ending  2011  there  were  four  events  that  utilized  four  of  the  five  exhibit  halls  including  the  Houston  Auto  Show,  Fiestas  Patrias  and  Los  Magnificos  Car  Show,  which  each  utilized  the  full  allotment  of  exhibit  space  in  previous  years  (a  Cinco  de  Mayo  celebration  was  the  fourth  event  utilizing  four  of  the  five  halls).  

Over   the   period   analyzed,   between   59   and   80   percent   of   overall   Reliant   Center   event   activity   used   no  more   than   300,000  square  feet  of  exhibit  space.    However,  the  two  largest  annual  events  at  Reliant  Center,   the  HLSR  and  the  OTC  use  all  of  the  available   space   within   the   facility,   as   well   as   additional   space   in   Reliant   Arena   and   the   surrounding   grounds,   including  additional  space  under  temporary  tents  for  the  OTC.  Another   important  metric   to  analyze   is   the  seasonality  of  demand,  which  can  assist   in  understanding  demand  potential   for  multiple   overlapping   events.     For   example,   heavy   demand   for   a   particular   event   type   during   historically   busy   periods   at   a  center   can   indicate   a   “clustering”   of   demand,   and   highlight   the   need   for   a   facility   to   be   able   to   accommodate   multiple  overlapping  events.        

Page 163: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

137  

The  following  exhibit  displays  Reliant  Center  exhibit  hall  average  occupancy  on  a  monthly  basis  for  the  past  six  fiscal  years.  Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Space  Monthly  Occupancy  

(FYE  2006  –  FYE  2011)    

   

Monthly  occupancy  rates  at  Reliant  Center  vary  greatly,  ranging  from  the  high  occupancy  rates  in  January  through  April  to  the  generally   low  occupancy  months  of   July   through  December.     Some  of   the   large  events   that   create   the  high  occupancy   rates  during   the  early  part  of   the   calendar  year   include   the  HLSR,   the  Houston  Auto  Show,  and   the  Houston  RV  Show.    The  OTC  occupies  Reliant  Center  exhibit   space   in  April  and  May.     It   should  be  noted   that   these  data  do  not  reflect  hold  dates,  which  would  provide  for  higher  general  occupancy  throughout  the  year  It  is  also  useful  to  consider  Reliant  Center  use  on  a  daily  basis,  as  presented  in  the  following  exhibit  for  fiscal  year  ending  2011.  

   

Page 164: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

138  

Daily  Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Hall  Utilization  (March  2010  through  August  2010)  

 

 

Note:    Multiple  colors  reflect  multiple  events  held  on  the  same  day.  

   

Page 165: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

139  

The  full  706,200  square  feet  of  exhibit  space  at  Reliant  Center  was  utilized  in  approximately  30  percent  of  the  calendar  in  fiscal  year  2011.    There  are  significant  gaps  between  event  use  within  the  exhibit  halls  in  June,  July  and  October  and  large  stretches  in  August  and  September   in  which  there   is  relatively   low  use  of  exhibit  hall  space.   In  some  cases,   these  gaps  correspond  to  dates  held  by  the  Texans  and/or  HLSR.  Analysis  of  Competitive  and  Comparable  Facilities  and  Markets  –  Exhibition  and  Meeting  Space  

This   section   provides   an   analysis   of   various   physical   characteristics   and   resources   of   both   competitive   and   comparable  facilities   and   communities.     This   data   helps   place   the  Reliant   Center   product  within   a   competitive   and   comparable  market  context  with  respect  to  facility  space,  hotel  inventory  and  other  related  destination  features.      There  are  two  types  of  exhibit  space  offered   at   the   facilities   reviewed:  prime   space   and  gross   space.     Prime   space   refers   to   the  dedicated   exhibition   area,  typically   used  by   conventions   and   trade   shows   for   exhibits   that   is   column-­‐free   or  with  minimal   columns,   has   high   ceilings  (typically  35  feet  in  height),  utility  floor  grids  (supplying  electricity,  telecommunications,  water,  etc.),  convenient  accessibility  to  each  hall  for  load-­‐in/load-­‐out  and  other  such  amenities.    Gross  space  refers  to  the  total  area  that  can  be  used  for  exhibits  and  often   includes  surrounding  areas  such  as   lobbies  and  substandard  space   in   terms  of  columns,  ceiling  heights  and  other  characteristics.     The   following   exhibit   presents   a   comparison   of   exhibit   space,   highlighting   the   square   footage   of   both  contiguous   and   total   exhibit   space   offerings   within   a   set   of   competitive   facilities.     The   facilities   included   in   this   set   are  primarily  located  in  the  central  states  and  could  be  seen  as  primary  competitors  for  large  convention/trade  events.    In  terms  of  total   exhibit   space  offerings,  McCormick  Place   in  Chicago  offers   the   largest   space  of   the   facilities   reviewed,  with  nearly  2.6  million   square   feet,   while   the   New   Orleans   Morial   Convention   Center   offers   the   largest   contiguous   space   with   nearly   1.2  million   square   feet  of   exhibit   space.    On  average,   the   largest   contiguous  exhibit   space  available  among   the   competitive  and  comparable   facilities   reviewed   is   approximately   477,700   square   feet,   while   the   total   available   exhibit   space   averages  approximately  690,400  square  feet.    Reliant  Center  ranks  sixth  among  the  17  facilities  reviewed  in  terms  of  total  exhibit  space,  and   offers   the   fourth   most   contiguous   exhibit   space.   In   the   Harris   County   market,   the   GRBCC   competes   effectively   for  nationally  rotating  conventions  and  trade  shows  requiring  up  to  700,000  square  feet  of  exhibit  space.  If  plans  for  added  hotel  inventory  proximate  to  the  GRBCC  materialize,  this  would  improve  its  ability  to  attract  such  events  

There  are  several  large  trade  centers  that  operate  outside  large  urban  areas,  and  which  could  be  instructive  to  potential  future  development  decisions  for  Reliant  Center.    Centers  such  as  the  Kentucky  Expo  Center  (KEC)  in  Louisville,  located  outside  the  downtown   core   and   with   limited   adjacent   hotel   inventory,   attract   several   very   large   non-­‐local   trade   events   annually,  particularly  those  with  a  need  for  some  type  of  outdoor  exhibit  space  and/or  large  general  session  space.    In  addition  to  the  KEC,   there   are   several   other   large   venues   that   cater   to   significant   trade   and   consumer   shows,   and   operate   with   a   hotel  

Page 166: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

140  

inventory  similar  to  that  provided  proximate  to  Reliant  Center.    We  have  focused  specifically  on  these  venues,  summarizing  available  exhibit  space  below.      

Comparison  of  Prime  Exhibit  Space  Competitive  Facilities  

 

191,000 205,800

246,100

253,200 350,000

388,800 426,600

475,000 566,600

579,000 584,500

706,200 719,600

726,600

813,600 862,000

1,068,500

0" 500,000" 1,000,000" 1,500,000" 2,000,000" 2,500,000" 3,000,000"

Louisville,"KY"

Birmingham,"AL"

Austin,"TX"

Fort"Worth,"TX"

Nashville,"TN"

Kansas"City,"MO"

San"Antonio,"TX"

Minneapolis,"MN"

Indianapolis,"IN"

Denver,"CO"

Phoenix,"AZ"

Reliant"Center"

Dallas,"TX"

GRBCC"

New"Orleans,"LA"

Atlanta,"GA"

Chicago,"IL"

Square"Feet"

Largest"Contiguous"Exhibit"Space" Other"Exhibit"Space"

Source:""facility"Uloorplans,"management,"and"industry"publications,"2011"

Total"Average"="690,400"Total"Median"="579,000"

"Contiguous"Average"="477,700"Contiguous"Median"="388,800"

Page 167: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

141  

 Comparison  of  Prime  Exhibit  Space  

Comparable  Non-­‐Urban  Trade  Facilities      

 

   

706,000%

787,000%

905,500%

957,500%

0% 500,000% 1,000,000% 1,500,000% 2,000,000% 2,500,000% 3,000,000%

Reliant%Center%

Rosemont,%IL%

Cleveland,%OH%

Louisville,%KY%(KEC)%

Square%Feet%

Largest%Contiguous%Exhibit%Space% Other%Exhibit%Space%

Source: facility floorplans, management, and industry publications, 2011

Total Average = 838,900 Total Median = 846,000

Contiguous Average = 515,500 Contiguous Median = 552,900

Page 168: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

142  

These  facilities  are  in  markets  that  offer  another  primary  convention  facility  located  in  the  downtown  core.    The  I-­‐X  Center  in  Cleveland  primarily  hosts  large  consumer  shows  such  as  the  Ohio  RV  Supershow,  the  Cleveland  Auto  Show  and  the  Great  Big  Home  and  Garden  Expo,  several  trade  shows  such  as  AmCon  Design  and  Contract  Manufacturing  Expo  and  the  Rubber  Expo  and  special  events  such  as  the  I-­‐X  Indoor  Amusement  Park  event.  The   KEC   hosts   a   number   of   large   trade   shows   including   the   National   RV   Show,   Mid-­‐America   Trucking   Show,   the   Green  Industry  and  Equipment  Show  and  the  National  Farm  Machinery  Show;  as  well  as  consumer  shows  such  as  the  Louisville  Boat,  RV  and  Sport  Show,  and  equine  events  such  as  the  World’s  Championship  Horse  Show.  The  inventory  of  large  national  trade  events  hosted  on  a  fixed  basis  at  the  KEC  may  serve  as  a  model  for  future  event  activity  at  Reliant  Park.    The   large   indoor  exhibit  space,  significant  outdoor  exhibit  space,  ample  parking  and   large   fixed  seating  areas  effectively   accommodate   the   event   needs   of   large   trade   and   consumer   events.     However,   it   is   important   to   note   that   the  Louisville  market  is  located  within  driving  distance  of  a  very  significant  share  of  domestic  U.S.  population.    The  Harris  County  market  does  not  offer  drive  capability  to  as  large  of  a  population.    Also  of  note,  the  KEC  does  not  offer  significant  adjacent  hotel  inventory,  however  they  are  aggressively  trying  to  attract  a  large  headquarter  hotel  to  help  address  concerns  that  they  may  lose  events  due  to  lack  of  hotel  inventory.    

Market  Demand  Analysis  –  Exhibition  and  Meeting  Space  Large   convention   centers   typically   host   events   that   vary   widely   in   space   needs,   attendance   levels   and   hotel   room  requirements.     The   size,   type   and   flexibility   of   the   space   within   many   facilities   can   accommodate   large   exhibitions   and  consumer   shows,   as   well   as   large   and   mid-­‐sized   conventions   and   trade   shows.     To   form   a   basis   for   the   market   demand  analysis,  detailed  surveys  were  completed  with  planners  of  large  conventions  and  trade  shows  that  may  represent  a  potential  event  market  for  Reliant  Center.    Our  research  was  conducted  to  evaluate  facility  and  hotel  requirements,  current  perceptions  of  Reliant  Center  as  an  event  facility  and  opinions  as  to  the  future  of  the  industry  overall.  

Telephone  and  Internet-­‐based  surveys  were  completed  with  representatives  of  the  following  types  of  organizations:  

• Current   and   past   users   of   Reliant   Center   event   space   –  We   have   surveyed   event   planners  with   a   history   of   hosting  events  at  Reliant  Center.    Given  their  familiarity  with  the  facility,  they  provide  valuable  insight  with  regard  to  facility  conditions  and  limitations.  

• Largest  200  national  conventions  and  trade  shows  –  National  associations  are  membership-­‐based  organizations   that  typically  have  annual  conventions  that  rotate  among  various  cities  throughout  the  United  States.    Data  was  compiled  

Page 169: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

143  

regarding  the  largest  conventions  and  trade  shows  in  the  country  in  terms  of  net  square  feet  of  exhibit  space  required.    These  events  generate  significant   levels  of  non-­‐local  attendees  and  have  sizable  requirements   in  terms  of  both  event  space   and  hotel  needs.    Given   the   limited  number  of   facilities   capable  of  hosting   their   events,   they  provide  valuable  insight  with  regard  to  a  key  market  segment  if  Reliant  Center  is  to  expand.  

Following  several   introductory  questions,  current  and  past  users  were  asked  to   indicate  the   likelihood  of  their  organization  returning  to  Reliant  Center  in  the  future,  assuming  the  facility  and  community  continues  to  meet  the  needs  of  their  events  in  terms  of  space  availability,  hotel  requirements,  etc.    Respondents  were  given  various  options  of  indicating  interest  in  holding  a  future  event  at  Reliant  Center  from  “definitely”  to  “definitely  not”  hold  an  event.  

All   of   the   current   and   past   users   of   Reliant   Center   surveyed   indicated   that   they   would   “definitely”   or   “likely”   consider  returning  to  the  facility  with  their  event,  with  79  percent  of  respondents  indicating  that  they  would  “definitely”  return.    The  overall   interest  among  current  and  past  users  of  Reliant  Center   indicates  a  high  level  of  satisfaction  with  the  Reliant  Center  product.    Some  strengths  of  Reliant  Center,  as  cited  by  surveyed  current  and  past  users  include:  

• Great  facilities,  amount  of  space,  location  and  parking.  

• Great  staff,  from  sales,  to  event  coordinating,  and  event  ushers/security.  

• SMG  personnel  are  extremely  knowledgeable  and  work  to  facilitate  the  needs  of  the  client.  

• Facility  size,  good  location,  lots  of  hotels,  good  mix  of  space  between  conference  and  exhibit  space.  

• Parking  is  great;  good  access  to  highways,  staff  is  great.  

A   series   of   questions   were   posed   in   which   event   planners   were   asked   to   comment   on   various   aspects   of   Reliant   Center  including   the   current   levels   of   exhibit   space,   limitations   to   registration,   circulation   and   other   Reliant   Center   areas,   and  surrounding  hotel  inventory.  

First,   event   planners   were   asked   whether   demand   exists   from   their   events   for   additional   exhibit,   meeting   and/or  multipurpose  space.    Approximately  92  percent  of  respondents  indicated  that  the  existing  Reliant  Center  space  offering  was  sufficient  to  accommodate  their  events  in  either  the  short-­‐term  or  foreseeable  future.    As  is  well  documented,  the  events  that  have  indicated  a  need  for  added  space  are  primarily  the  OTC  and  the  HLSR.    Later  in  this  analysis,  we  discuss  potential  demand  

Page 170: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

144  

for  expanded  space  from  other  events  not  currently  hosted  at  the  Center.    In  evaluating  future  space  additions,  it  is  important  to  develop  a  demand  or  occupancy  framework  that  could  sustain  the  use  of  any  significant  addition  to  sellable  space.  

Planners  were  asked  about  the  configuration  of  Reliant  Center  event  space,  to  which  nearly  all  respondents  indicated  that  the  existing   configuration   adequately   accommodates   their   event.     Planners   were   also   asked   whether   their   event   requires  additional   registration,   circulation   or   other   non-­‐sellable   event   space.     Approximately   88   percent   of   respondents   again  indicated  that  the  existing  space  offering  at  Reliant  Center  currently  accommodates  their  event.    The  results  of  these  questions  suggest  that  a  limited  number  of  current  and  past  Reliant  Center  users  would  benefit  from  expanded  or  improved  facilities.  

Following  the  questions  regarding  existing  Reliant  Center  event  space  offerings,  current  and  past  event  planners  were  asked  a  series  of  questions   regarding   the   supporting  hotel   inventory.    Of   those   surveyed,   approximately  13  percent  of   respondents  indicated  that  their  event  requires  hotel  rooms,  suggesting  a  more  local  attendee  orientation  for  many  of  the  existing  Reliant  Center  events.    At  the  same  time,  the  OTC,  as  well  as  other  large  convention/trade  events  that  could  potentially  be  attracted  to  Reliant  Center,  do  require  a  significant  inventory  of  hotel  rooms,  with  a  large  on-­‐site  headquarter  hotel  an  ideal  component  of  this  inventory.  

Finally,   respondents  were  asked  to  comment  on  any   improvements   they  would   like   to  see  made  at  Reliant  Center   to  better  serve  their  event.    Sample  comments  collected  include:  

• Moving  walkways  to  get  from  one  side  of  the  facility  to  the  other.  

• Parking  is  always  an  issue;  location  of  parking  related  to  the  event  space  being  used.  

• An  on-­‐site  hotel  would  be  nice  to  avoid  the  need  for  shuttles.  

• Would  like  to  see  the  Astrodome  converted  to  a  hotel,  casino,  or  indoor  amusement  park.  

• The  Astrodome  could  house  at   least  two  layers  of  parking,  which  would  alleviate  parking  problems  during  the  rodeo  and  football  games.  

• Astrodome  could  be  converted  to  exhibit  space  on  ground  level  with  meeting  space  on  upper  levels;  also  could  consider  (a  portion  of)  it  as  a  banquet  hall.  

• Astrodome  could  be  developed  into  a  planetarium  or  a  covered  park.  

Page 171: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

145  

• On-­‐site  electrical  hookups  and  RV  waste  water  dumping  stations.  

• The  availability  of  water,  drainage  (general  plumbing),  gas,  and  electric  are  not  as  readily  available  as  at  other  facilities.  

• We  would  like  a  better  quality  hotel  facility  nearby.  

• A  wider  selection  of  on-­‐site  food  service  would  be  nice.  

• On-­‐site  transportation  between  parking  and  event  halls  and  moving  sidewalks.  

• The   lack   of   full   service   hotels   in   close   proximity   is   a  major   problem.    With   the   high   cost   of   parking  with   no   in/out  privileges,  our  customers  need  to  be  able  to  walk  to  restaurants,  and  other  venues  and  return  to  the  event.  

• An  outdoor  park  area  with  dining  options  would  be  a  great  addition.  

• Would   like  more   handicapped   parking   spaces   and  maybe  more   flexibility   with   certain   events   that   attract   an   older  demographic.  

In  order  to  gain  insight  into  events  that  could  potentially  utilize  expanded  or  improved  Reliant  Center  event  space,  data  has  been  compiled  regarding  many  of  the  largest  conventions  and  trade  shows  in  the  country  in  terms  of  net  square  feet  of  exhibit  space  used.    Many  of  the  largest  conventions  and  trade  shows  in  the  U.S.  between  2008  and  2010  have  been  considered,  and  218  events  have  been  analyzed  as  part  of  this  effort.    Of  these  events,  82  rotate  among  destinations  and/or  facilities,  while  the  remaining  events  are  held  in  a  fixed  location  or  on  a  fixed  rotation  of  locations.  

The  following  exhibit  outlines  the  destinations  that  have  hosted  large  rotating  convention  and  trade  events  between  2008  and  2010.  It  is  important  to  note  that  some  of  these  events  were  held  in  each  of  the  three  years  reviewed,  while  some  events  were  held  just  once  or  twice.      

Page 172: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

146  

Rotating  Events  Hosted  by  Destination  –  Top  US  Conventions  and  Trade  Shows  2008-­‐2010  

     

   

Note%(A):%%Five%markets%hosted%three%events,%including:%Cleveland,%OH;%Denver,%CO;%Houston,%TX;%Indianapolis,%IN;%and,%San%Antonio,%TX.%Note%(B):%%Five%markets%hosted%two%events,%including:%Boston,%MA;%Essex%Junction,%VT;%Miami,%FL;%New%York,%NY;%and,%Phoenix,%AZ.%Note%(C):%%Fourteen%markets%hosted%one%event.%Source:%Red7Media,%2011%

1%

2%

3%

4%

6%

6%

7%

10%

15%

15%

18%

29%

29%

30%

0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35%

Note%(C)%

Note%(B)%

Note%(A)%

Reno,%NV%

Washington,%DC%

Dallas,%TX%

San%Francisco,%CA%

Anaheim,%CA%

San%Diego,%CA%

Atlanta,%GA%

New%Orleans,%LA%

Las%Vegas,%NV%

Chicago,%IL%

Orlando,%FL%

Page 173: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

147  

Of  the  top  200  trade  shows  largest  trade  shows  (in  terms  of  net  exhibit  space  used)  held  between  2008  and  2010  that  rotate  destinations,  approximately  42  percent  held  their  event  in  Orlando,  Chicago  or  Las  Vegas.  The  Harris  County  market  hosted  three  of  the  top  200  rotating  trade  show  events  during  this  three  year  period,  including  the  2008  Windpower  Conference  held  at  the  GRBCC.  

Of  the  82  rotating  events,  18  of  them  (or  approximately  22  percent)  are  medical  events,  which  typically  require  a  significant  amount  of   first-­‐class  meeting  space   in  order   to  accommodate   the   large  number  of  educational  and  certification  classes   that  occur  during  these  events.    As  a  result,  they  generally  look  for  event  facilities  that  are  surrounded  by  a  significant  supply  of  private  (hotel)  meeting  space  at  which  they  can  host  breakout  meetings  and  other  smaller  functions.    Often  times  these  events  are  more  suited  to  downtown  event  facilities.  

Rotating  national   events   typically  have   specific  preferences  and/or   requirements  with   regard   to   the  months   in  which   their  event(s)  occur.    The  following  exhibit  presents  the  seasonality  patterns,  by  month,  for  the  82  identified  events  that  represent  the   primary   event  market   demand   for   an   expanded/improved   Reliant   Center.     For   purposes   of   comparison,  we   have   also  presented  the  average  occupancy  rate  for  Reliant  Center,  by  month,  from  2008  through  2010.  

Largest  US  Conventions  and  Trade  shows  2008-­‐2010  Rotating  Events  Hosted  by  Month  and  Average  Reliant  Center  Exhibit  Hall  Occupancy  FYE  2006-­‐FYE  2011  

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Source: Red7Media, CSL International, facility management, 2011.

9%

16%

9%

6%

14%

9%

4%

4%

4%

14%

9%

1%

96%82%

86%

65%

50%

36%38%

19%26%

34%41% 40%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

Page 174: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

148  

The  seasonality  of  demand  can  assist  in  understanding  demand  potential  for  multiple  overlapping  events.    For  example,  heavy  demand  for  a  particular  event  type  during  historically  busy  periods  can  indicate  a  “clustering”  of  demand,  and  highlight  the  need  for  a  center  to  be  able  to  accommodate  multiple  overlapping  events.    As  presented  above,  seasonal  preference  among  the  top   national   trade   shows   that   rotate   destinations   follow   a   pattern   somewhat   similar   to   industry   standards,   with   stronger  demand  in  the  spring  and  fall  months.  

National   convention   and   trade   show   event   demand   peaks   in   February,  May   and   October   at   approximately   16   percent,   14  percent  and  14  percent,  respectively,  with  December,  generating  the  lowest  demand  at  just  one  percent  of  the  events.    Reliant  Center  occupancy  rates  correlate  somewhat  with  demand  among  the  rotating  events  analyzed,  especially  with  respect  to  the  diminishing  occupancy  rates  from  July  through  September  and  strong  occupancy  numbers  in  February.    With  the  exception  of  May/June  and  October/November,  the  low  utilization  periods  for  Reliant  Center  correspond  with  periods  of  low  demand  from  large  national  conventions  and  trade  shows.  

 

   

Page 175: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

149  

In  order  to  approximate  exhibit  space  requirements  of  the  national  event  market  analyzed,   the  amount  of  gross  square  feet  used  by  each  rotating  convention  and  trade  show  from  2008  through  2010  has  been  summarized  in  the  exhibit  below.  

 Summary  of  Exhibit  Space  Used  –  

Largest  US  Conventions  and  Trade  Shows  2008-­‐2010      

 

 

   

Source:((Red7Media,(2011(

0(

300,000(

600,000(

900,000(

1,200,000(

1,500,000(

1,800,000(

2,100,000(

2,400,000(

2,700,000(

5%(

10%(

15%(

20%(

25%(

30%(

35%(

40%(

45%(

50%(

55%(

60%(

65%(

70%(

75%(

80%(

85%(

90%(

95%(

100%

(

Average(=(545,600(Median(=(396,200(

Reliant(Center(

Page 176: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

150  

As   presented,   the   average   amount   of   exhibit   space   needed   among   the   largest   national   conventions   and   trade   shows  approximates  545,600  gross  square  feet.    With  approximately  706,000  square  feet  of  contiguous  prime  exhibit  space,  Reliant  Center   currently   satisfies   approximately   80   to   85   percent   of   the   potential  market   for   national   convention   and   trade   show  events.    The  GRBCC,  with  639,000  square   feet  of   contiguous  exhibit   space  can  accommodate  nearly  80  percent  of   the   large  convention/trade  event  market,  and  is  better  positioned  to  offer  significant  nearby  hotel  inventory.  

These  data  are   important   to   consider  when  evaluating   the  potential   for   expansion  of  Reliant  Center   space   to  attract   added  large  convention/trade  event  activity.    Challenges  include:  

• There   is   a   very   small   segment   of   the  market   that   requires  more   space   than   is   currently   available   at   Reliant   Center  today.  

• The   GRBCC   can   accommodate   the   large   majority   of   large   convention/trade   events   that   require   headquarter   hotel  inventory  and  are  typically  hosted  in  an  urban  environment.  

• Large  trade  show  venues  located  outside  the  downtown  core  in  Louisville,  Cleveland  and  Chicago  tend  to  attract  several  very   large   trade   events   held   annually   at   the   complex.     The   large   population   base  within   drive   distance   from   these  destinations  is  an  important  component  of  their  success.  

On   average,   large   convention/trade   events   attract   approximately   15,400   total   delegates   and   5,700   exhibitor   attendees.    Approximately  fifty  percent  of  the  market  consists  of  events  with  11,300  delegates  and  4,800  exhibiting  personnel  or  more.    The  largest  trade  show,  in  terms  of  total  attendance  attracts  approximately  67,600  delegates  and  24,500  exhibiting  personnel.  

Detailed  telephone  interviews  were  completed  with  event  planners  representing  the  largest  conventions  and  trade  shows  (in  terms  of  net  square  feet)  throughout  the  country.    The  survey  resulted  in  21  completed  interviews  out  of  a  potential  82  events  that   rotate  among  various  destinations,   or   a  26  percent   capture  percentage.    The  primary  objectives  of   the   survey  were   to  ascertain   the  perceived   interest   in  using  expanded/improved  Reliant  Center   facilities   for  one  or  more   future  events  and   to  better  understand  the  overall  facility/destination  requirements  of  large  trade  events.  

Respondents  were  asked  to  indicate  the  likelihood  of  their  organization  using  Reliant  Center  facilities  in  the  future,  assuming  the  facility  and  community  met  the  needs  of  their  event(s)  in  terms  of  space  availability,  hotel  requirements,  etc.    The  positive  response  percentage  (“definitely  use”,  “likely  use”  and  “possibly  use”)  by  national  conventions  and  trade  shows  approximates  

Page 177: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

151  

86  percent;  however,  a  significant  percentage  of  this  positive  interest  (64  percent)  is  considered  “tentative”  interest  (i.e.  those  that  indicated  “possibly”  hold  an  event  at  Reliant  Center,  rather  than  “likely”  or  “definitely”).  

Several  events  indicating  a  modest  interest  in  Reliant  Center  tend  to  fit  the  profile  of  needing  large  amounts  of  exhibit  space,  with  less  emphasis  on  headquarter  hotel  needs.    These  include:  

• The  International  Builders  Show  –  requiring  up  to  2  million  gross  square  feet  of  exhibit  space.    The  show  has  recently  been  held  in  Las  Vegas  and  Orlando,  both  of  which  offer  venues  with  2  million  square  feet  of  exhibit  space.  

• InfoComm  International  –  requiring  approximately  1  million  square  feet  of  exhibit  space,  and  recently  held  on  a  pattern  between  Orlando  and  Las  Vegas.    Consideration  is  being  given  to  expanding  the  cities  in  which  the  event  will  be  held.  

• The  Hearth,   Patio   and  BBQ   Show   –   requiring   up   to   425,000   gross   square   feet   of   exhibit   space   and   recently   held   in  Orlando,  Reno  and  Atlanta.    Reliant  Center  can  accommodate  this  event  currently,  however  show  dates  conflict  with  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo.  

In   addition,   there  were   several   events   that   indicated   a   likeliness   to   consider  Reliant   Center,  most   of  which   are   large   trade  oriented  events  that  can  be  accommodated  in  the  space  currently  provided  by  Reliant  Center  or  the  GRBCC.    Others  are  more  convention  oriented,  including:  

• American  Dental  Association  

• American  Society  of  Clinic  Oncology  

• American  Urological  Society  

• National  Cable  and  Television  Association  

• American  Public  Health  Association  

We  note   that   these  convention  events   (several   in   the  medical   field)   tend   to   rotate   to  more  urban   locations  with   significant  nearby  hotel   inventory.    Of  all  planners  expressing  some  level  of   interest   in  using  Reliant  Center,  approximately  47  percent  require  a  headquarter  hotel  attached  or  within  close  walking  distance  of  the  event  facility.  

On  average,  events  expressing  an  interest  in  rotating  future  events  to  an  expanded/improved  Reliant  Center  require  5.1  days  to  move-­‐in,  2.5  days  to  move-­‐out  and  3.7  total  event  days.    The  number  of  attendees  at  an  event  influences  the  number  of  guest  

Page 178: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

152  

rooms  occupied.    The  following  exhibit  presents  a  summary  of  peak  night  guest  room  demand  associated  with  the  potential  national  convention  and  trade  show  market  for  Reliant  Center.  

 Summary  of  Peak  Night  Hotel  Guest  Room  Demand  –  Top  US  Conventions  and  Trade  shows  2008-­‐2010  

   

 

 

   

0"

5,000"

10,000"

15,000"

20,000"

25,000"

30,000"

5%"

10%"

15%"

20%"

25%"

30%"

35%"

40%"

45%"

50%"

55%"

60%"

65%"

70%"

75%"

80%"

85%"

90%"

95%"

100%

"

Average"="8,770"Median"="4,000"

Note:"Of"those"respondents"with"a"positive"interest"in"Reliant"Park."Source:""CSL"Top"US"Conventions"and"Tradeshows"Survey,"2011."

Page 179: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

153  

As  shown  above,   the  average  national  convention  or   trade  show  event  with  a  potential   interest   in  rotating   future  events   to  Reliant  Center  requires  a  room  block  of  8,770  peak  night  guest  rooms.    As  noted  earlier  in  this  report,  there  is  a  total  capacity  of  2,030  guest  rooms  proximate  to  Reliant  Park.    Assembling  a  greater  room  block  requires  shuttling  to  a  number  of  properties  located  further  from  Reliant  Park.    As  discussed  earlier,  the  lack  of  hotel  inventory  proximate  to  Reliant  Park  will  continue  to  negatively  impact  Reliant  Center’s  ability  to  successfully  attract  and  retain  events  within  this  segment.  

In  an  effort  to  collect  open-­‐ended  feedback  with  regard  to  current  perceptions  of  Reliant  Park’s  position  in  the  convention  and  trade  show  industry,  national  event  planners  were  asked  to  provide  comments  on  how  they  see  the  needs  of   their  event(s)  changing  over  the  next  several  years.    Responses  included,  but  were  not  limited  to  the  following:  

• Seeing  slight  growth  with  the  economy  coming  back,  but  not  enough  to  change  the  needs  of  our  event  

• Need  more  meeting  space  inventory  

• Look  for  more  environmentally  aware  facilities  

• Increasing  demand  for  improved  wireless  coverage  (signal  and  bandwidth)  

• General  seating  component  with  flexible  seating  capacity  (1,000  to  5,000  seats)  

Additionally,   we   asked   event   planners   to   describe   any   creative   facility   and/or   operational   innovations   they   have   seen   at  convention  centers  around  the  country.    A  sample  of  responses  is  presented  below:  

• Free  Wi-­‐Fi  

• Messaging  and/or  wayfinding  on  digital  video  screen  

• Recharging  stations  for  cell  phones,  laptops,  tablets,  etc.  

Finally,  we  asked  respondents  for  their  overall  impressions  of  Reliant  Park  and  the  Harris  County  market  as  a  potential  host  site  for  their  events.    Responses  included,  but  were  not  limited  to  those  summarized  below:  

• Since   we   have   special   requirements   (i.e.,   fridge   trailers   for   produce;   ability   to   provide   steam   for   laundering/dry  cleaning,  etc.)   for  our  event  we  go  wherever  we  can   that  will  accommodate  our  needs.     If  Harris  County  and  Reliant  Park  can  accommodate  our  needs,  we  would  consider  bringing  our  event  there.  

Page 180: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

154  

• We  want   a   central   location  where   guests   can   eat,   shop   and  walk   around.     San  Antonio’s   Riverwalk   is   a   really   good  example.    Reliant  Park  may  be  too  far  from  entertainment  options  to  be  a  viable  consideration.  

• Need  more  hotel  rooms  within  walking  distance.  

• Don’t  know  about  Harris  County  or  Reliant  Park  and  have  never  heard  anyone  say  anything  positive  or  negative  about  it.    At  the  same  time,  we  don’t  want  to  rule  out  any  destination  without  first  looking  at  them.    Our  first  priority  is  facility  size  and  nearby  hotels.    We  like  “touristy”  locations,  but  it  is  not  a  top  priority.  

• Have  looked  at  Reliant  Park  in  the  past  and  thought  the  facility  and  destination  package  was  excellent.    The  only  conflict  was  that  a   large  recurring  event  occurs  within  the  same  month  our  event   is  held  and  takes  up  a  significant  chunk  of  date  availability.    If  our  dates  were  available,  we  would  definitely  bring  our  event  to  Reliant  Park.  

Summary  

Based  on  the  research  summarized  here,  there  are  several  key  points  that  impact  the  potential  market  support  for  the  future  need  for  exhibition  and  meeting  space.    

• Reliant  Center  has  hosted  a  significant  number  of  exhibition  hall  utilization  days  over  the  past  five  years,  ranging  from  352  days  to  451  days.    This  reflects  the  Center’s  ability  to  accommodate  numerous  events  consisting  of  multiple  event  days  and  multiple  concurrent  events.    Consumer  shows  comprise  an  average  of  46  percent  of  total  annual  event  days  at  Reliant  Center.  

• Attendance  at  Reliant  Center  events  has  steadily   increased  over   the  past  several   fiscal  years   from  approximately  1.4  million   in   fiscal  year  ending  2006   to  over  1.7  million   in   fiscal  year  ending  2011,  driven   largely  by  attendance  at   the  HLSR.    Convention  and  trade  show  event  attendance  represents  a  small  share  of  overall  complex  attendance,  and  has  remained  largely  constant  during  this  time  period.  

• Reliant  Center  exhibit  hall  occupancy  rates  have  experienced  a  slight  decline  during  the  past  two  fiscal  years  after  a  six-­‐year  high  60.5  percent  exhibit  hall  occupancy  rate  in  fiscal  year  ending  2009.    Reliant  Center  experienced  a  48.3  percent  occupancy  rate  in  fiscal  year  ending  2010  and  44.1  percent  occupancy  rate  in  fiscal  year  ending  2011.  These  compare  to  George   R.   Brown   Convention   Center   occupancy   rates   of   48.5   percent,   45.1   percent   and   48.2   percent   exhibit   space  occupancy  rate  in  fiscal  year  2009,  fiscal  year  ending  2010  and  fiscal  year  ending  2011,  respectively.    As  the  economy  

Page 181: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

155  

continues  to  rebound  in  the  coming  years,  it  is  reasonable  to  expect  that  Reliant  Center’s  largely  consumer  show  based  events  will  allow  the  facility  to  generate  occupancy  rates  above  50  percent.    However,  considering  the  excess  capacity  available  at  the  GRBCC,  it  may  be  difficult  for  Reliant  Center  to  attract  a  significant  number  of  incremental  conventions  and   trade  show  events   that  oftentimes  prefer  downtown  convention   facilities  with  greater  access   to  hotel   inventory  and  entertainment  options.  

• Over   the   period   analyzed,   between   59   and   80   percent   of   overall   Reliant   Center   event   activity   used   no   more   than  300,000   square   feet  of   exhibit   space.  Monthly  occupancy   rates   at  Reliant  Center  vary  greatly,   ranging   from   the  high  occupancy  rates  in  January  through  April  to  the  low  occupancy  months  of  July  through  December.    Some  of  the  large  events  that  create  the  high  occupancy  rates  during  the  early  part  of  the  calendar  year  include  the  HLSR,  the  Houston  Auto  Show,  and  the  Houston  RV  Show.    OTC  occupies  a  significant  amount  of  Reliant  Center  exhibit  space  in  April  and  May.  From  June  through  December,  Reliant  Center  generally  has  significant  excess  exhibit  hall  capacity.      

• In   terms  of   total   exhibit   space  offerings  McCormick  Place   in  Chicago,   Illinois   offers   the   largest   space  of   the   facilities  reviewed,   with   nearly   2.6   million   square   feet,   while   the   New   Orleans   Morial   Convention   Center   offers   the   largest  contiguous  space  with  nearly  1.2  million  square  feet  of  exhibit  space.    On  average,  the  largest  contiguous  exhibit  space  available  among   the  competitive  and  comparable   facilities   reviewed   is  approximately  477,700  square   feet,  while   the  total   available   exhibit   space   averages   approximately   690,400   square   feet.     Reliant   Center   ranks   sixth   among   the   17  facilities  reviewed  in  terms  of  total  exhibit  space,  and  offers  the  fourth  most  contiguous  exhibit  space.  

   

Page 182: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

156  

5.4  On-­‐Site  Hotel  Harris  County  Market  Analysis  –  Convention  Hotels  

There  are  approximately  2,030  hotel   rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  Reliant  Park,  and   the   largest  hotel  property   is   the  630-­‐room  Crowne  Plaza  Houston  –  Reliant  Park/Medical  Center.    Only  Kansas  City,  Missouri  (2,020  rooms),  Los  Angeles,  California  (1,685  rooms)  and  Chicago,  Illinois  (1,090  rooms)  offer  fewer  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile,  and  all  of  these  markets  are  in  the  process  of  adding  additional  hotel  rooms.    As  previously  mentioned,  the  majority  of  hotel  properties  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  Reliant  Park  are  limited  service  properties,  or  properties  that  do  not  offer  an  on-­‐site  restaurant,  and  much  of  this  inventory  is  utilized  by  Texas  Medical  Center  business.    While  these  properties  are  generally  sufficient  (and  sometimes  preferential)  for  budget  conscious  attendees,  a  greater  mix  of   full-­‐service  hotel  properties  with  a  significant  committable   inventory  of  rooms  for  Reliant  Park  may  be  necessary  to  attract  a  greater  share  of  non-­‐local  convention  and  trade  show  events.  

By  comparison,  there  are  approximately  3,250  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center,  including  the  1,230  room  Hilton  of  the  Americas.    On  average,  there  are  approximately  5,000  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  event  facilities  located  in  the  competitive  and  comparable  markets  analyzed.  Plans  for  added  hotel  inventory  proximate  to  the  GRBCC  could  improve  its  ability  to  attract  such  events.    Most  of  the  other  markets  that  offer  fewer  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half   mile   are   significantly   smaller   than   Houston   in   terms   of   population,   corporate   base,   convention   center   size   and   other  characteristics.  

   

Page 183: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

157  

 

   

1,031 1,089

1,327 1,685 1,700 1,828

2,017 2,027

3,251 3,776

3,940 4,169

5,617 6,486 6,594

8,317 8,614

9,354 10,544

0" 2,000" 4,000" 6,000" 8,000" 10,000" 12,000"Birmingham,"AL"

Chicago,"IL"Fort"Worth,"TX"Los"Angeles,"CA"

Phoenix,"AZ"Louisville,"KY"(KEC)"

Kansas"City,"MO"Reliant"Center"

GRBCC"Dallas,"TX"

Louisville,"KY"(KICC)"Minneapolis,"MN"

Austin,"TX"Indianapolis,"IN"

Denver,"CO"Atlanta,"GA"

New"Orleans,"LA"San"Antonio,"TX"

Anaheim,"CA"

Number"of"Rooms"

Average"="5,000"Median"="3,860"

Note:"(1)"Includes"new"1,003Zroom"Marriott"Marquis"(expected"to"break"ground"midZ2012"and"open"in"2015)"and"296Zroom"Hyatt"Place"(expected"to"open"early"2013)."Source:"Industry"publications,"Hotel"and"Lodging"Association"of"Greater"Houston,"2011."

Hotel  Rooms  Within  One-­‐Half  Mile  Competitive  and  Comparable  Facilities  and  Markets  

 

Page 184: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

158  

Market  Demand  Analysis  

In  order   to  provide  a  broad  perspective  of  overall   lodging   trends  and   their   impact  on  potential  Reliant  Center  headquarter  hotel  development,  we  have  analyzed  Smith  Travel  Research  (STR)  trends  for  the  overall  United  States   lodging  market,  and  evaluated   the   performance   of   a   set   of   specific   properties   in   Houston  market   area  with   relevance   to   the   proposed   project.    Smith  Travel  Research  is  a  nationally  recognized  firm  that  collects,  analyzes  and  distributes  occupancy,  revenue,  demand,  and  supply  statistics  for  the  lodging  industry.      In  addition,  as  part  of  this  analysis  the  following  tasks  have  been  completed  

• Reviewed  existing  Reliant  Center  facilities,  as  well  as  proposed  improvements  in  terms  of  impact  on  performance  of  a  headquarter  hotel.  

• Considered  existing  performance  metrics  for  large  convention-­‐oriented  hotels  in  the  Houston  market.  

• Considered  the  performance  of  large  headquarter  hotels  generally  in  large  markets  throughout  the  country.  

• Considered  broad  national  hospitality  demand  and  financial  performance  measures.  

• Met  with  Reliant  Center  management  to  discuss  the  project.  

In   terms   of   market-­‐wide   demand   and   supply   considerations,   we   note   that   there   are   plans   in   place   to   develop   a   new  headquarter  hotel  adjacent  to  the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center.    This  would  potentially  have  a  positive  impact  on  event  demand  for  the  Brown,  and  would  also  serve  to  attract  smaller  in-­‐house  meetings  and  conferences  to  the  market.  

We  also  note  that  the  downtown  provides  a  distinct  event  attendee  experience  as  compared  to  Reliant  Center,  and  planners  looking  for  an  urban  experience  would  not  typically  include  the  Reliant  Center  area  as  a  potential  event  site.  Other  important  factors  incorporated  into  this  headquarter  hotel  analysis  include  the  following:  

• Historical  recent  data  for  occupancy  levels,  average  daily  rate  (ADR)  and  revenue  per-­‐available-­‐room  (RevPAR)  for  a  set  of  large  Houston  market  area  hotels.    This  information  is  useful  in  putting  parameters  around  the  potential  rate  and  ADR  performance  levels  for  the  proposed  Reliant  Center  property.  

• The  typical  room  night  generation  provided  by  an  adjacent  large  convention  and  trade  venue.    It  is  not  uncommon  for  a  headquarter  hotel  do  derive  approximately  20  percent  of  its  overall  room  night  demand  from  the  adjacent  or  attached  center.     In  addition,  as  much  as  50  percent  of   the  demand  can  originate   from   in-­‐house  events  not   tied   to   the  center.    

Page 185: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

159  

Finally,  the  remaining  demand  can  originate  from  demand  sources  in  the  general  area,  including  the  extensive  medical  industry  presence.  

• The  seasonality  of  demand  in  the  Houston  market,  as  well  as  the  influence  of  major  tenant  events  such  as  OTC  and  the  Houston  Livestock  Show  &  Rodeo.    These  recurring  events,  along  with  the  presence  of  the  NFL,  can  provide  an  important  base  of  annual  demand.  

• The  potential  investment  in  the  proposed  improvements  to  Reliant  Center,  and  the  impact  on  potential  demand  levels.    Estimates  of  financial  performance  presented  herein  are  predicated  on  improvements  taking  place  to  Reliant  Center.  

It  is  expected  that  the  hotel  will  have  stabilized  operations  at  68%  occupancy  during  the  third  year  of  operations  (2019).    A  convention   center   hotel   located   at  Reliant   Center   offers   an   opportunity   to   expand   revenue   generating   opportunities   at   the  convention   center   by   attracting   corporate   group   and   association   group   business.     Meeting   planners   representing   large  corporate  groups  and  large  association  groups  generally  do  not  utilize  convention  centers  which  do  not  have  close  proximity  to  hotels  that  can  accommodate  their  groups  for  overnight  lodging.    In  general,  meeting  planners  wish  to  accommodate  their  meeting  attendees  in  two  hotels  or  less.    The  vast  majority  of  meeting  planners  wish  to  house  all  meeting  attendees  in  a  single  hotel.    A  single  hotel  eases  group  transportation  issues,  offers  the  meeting  planner  the  opportunity  to  deal  with  a  single  hotel  sales  and  management  organization,  and  minimizes  potential  guest  issues  when  group  members  are  located  in  differing  hotels  which   likely  have  differing   room  quality,   food  &  beverage   facilities,   amenities  and  customer  service  models.     It   is   therefore  possible  that  a  large  convention/conference  hotel  could  attract  significant  in-­‐house  group  business,  as  well  as  supporting  hotel  needs   from   large  Reliant   Park   users.     Significant   restaurant   capabilities  would   have   to   be   provided  within   and   nearby   the  hotel.  

Development  Considerations  

It  is  imperative  to  attract  a  “first  tier”  hotel  brand  to  the  convention  center  hotel.    Companies  such  as  Hilton,  Hyatt,  Marriott  and  Starwood  (Sheraton  and  Westin)  have  the  national  and  international  name  recognition  to  attract  guests  from  all  customer  segments.     In  addition,  each  of  these  hotel  brands  has  substantial  national  sales  office  organizations,  which  manage  existing  contract   relationships  with   group   and   association   customers   around   the   country.     The   sales   effort   for   a   convention   center  similar  to  that  suggested  for  Reliant  Center  would  likely  begin  24  months  prior  to  the  hotel  actually  opening.    Given  that  many  groups  and  associations  book  convention  center  hotels  as  far  out  as  five  years  before  an  event,  having  access  to  the  existing  

Page 186: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

160  

“book   of   business”   of   the   selected   hotel   brand  will   provide   an   opportunity   to   stabilize   hotel   operations   sooner   than  may  otherwise  occur.  

There  are  literally  hundreds  of  hotel  management  companies  in  the  domestic  U.S.    However,  a  hotel  of  the  size  contemplated  at  Reliant  Center  would   likely  be  corporately  managed.    That   is,   the  corporate  entity   that  controls   the  hotel  brand  would  also  manage  the  hotel.    This  is  somewhat  different  than  most  hotels  which  are  managed  by  a  company  which  uses  a  hotel  brand  name  by  acquiring  a  license  for  a  franchise  and  paying  the  company  which  controls  the  brand  name  a  franchise  fee.    In  general,  the  corporations  which  control  hotel  brands  are  only  franchise  hotels  which  are  smaller  than  500  rooms.    

In  our  opinion,  the  most  significant  participant  in  the  convention  center  hotel  development  is  the  hotel  brand/operator.    The  success  of   the  hotel  operation,  measured   in   financial   terms  such  as  debt   service   coverage   ratios,   is  dependent  on   the  hotel  operator’s   ability   to   generate   revenue   and   “flow-­‐through”   to   Net   Operating   Income.     No   other   transaction   participant   has  nearly  as  significant  a  role  to  play.    In  addition,  regardless  of  the  type  of  capital  structure  employed,  not  only  will  the  “quality”  of  the  hotel  underwriting  be  assessed,  but  so  will  hotel  brand/operator  “incentives”  and  the  operator’s  participation  in  some  form  of  credit  support.  

Every  large  scale,  municipally  sponsored  transaction  completed  in  the  last  several  years  included  a  sizeable  contribution  by  the  hotel  brand/operator.    These  contributions  have  most  often  taken  the  form  of  “key”  money  and  debt  service  guarantees.    It  is   interesting   to   note   that   transactions   initiated   by   hotel   brands/operators,   or   developers   in   concert   with   hotel   brands,  typically   have   had   the   least   amount   of   financial   contribution.     The   transactions   that   have   included   the   highest   hotel  brand/operator  contributions  have  been  municipally  sponsored  and  controlled.    

In  order  to  maximize  the  potential  financial  contribution  of  the  hotel  brand/operator,  it  is  essential  to  isolate  the  selection  of  the   hotel   brand/operator   from   the   selection   of   any   other   participant   in   the   development  management   process.     There   are  other  benefits  as  well.    By  separating  the  hotel  brand  from  the  developer,  for  example,  “hidden”  developer  fees  are  eliminated  and,   more   importantly,   brand   specifications   for   the   hotel   itself   can   be   integrated   into  master   planning,   site   selection   and  spatial   programming   activities   far   earlier   in   the   planning   process   than   may   otherwise   occur.     In   addition,   an   “early”  announcement  of  hotel  brand/  operator   to   the  market  will   serve  as  an   “accelerant”   for  Convention  and  Visitor  Bureau  and  convention  center  sales  &  marketing  activities.    This  would  be  a  most  effective  way  to  let  the  meetings  marketplace  know  that  Harris  County  is  moving  forward  with  a  convention  center  hotel  in  a  substantive  way.  

Page 187: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

161  

Certain  entities  within  the  developer  “community”  will  seek  to  encourage  the  County  to  create  an  request  for  proposal  process  for  the  convention  center  hotel  that  could  colloquially  be  called  the  “team  approach”.    Under  this  approach,  a  developer  creates  a   team  that   includes  architects,   the  prime  contractor,   the  hotel  brand/operator  and  others  among  what  would  be  the  many  professional   entities   that   would   be   a   part   of   a   hotel   development.     In   general,   the   developer   seeks   to   have   the   hotel  brand/operator  execute  an  exclusivity  agreement  so  that  the  hotel  brand/operator  cannot  participate  on  any  other  “team”  in  response  to  a  “team  approach”  request  for  proposal.    

This  method  is  highly  effective  for  developers  that  are  able  to  secure  exclusive  agreements  with  hotel  brand/operator  entities.    The  reason  is  that  this  approach  drastically  reduces  the  pool  of  qualified  developers  who  can  compete.  This  is  so  because  the  only   hotel   brands   that   are   “available”   for   the   convention   center   hotel   are   those   that   are   not   currently   represented   in   the  market.    Alternatively,  hotel  brands  that  may  be  available  could  also  include  those  that  are  in  the  market  area  but  are  outside  the   geographic   area   defined   in   the   radius   restriction   covenants   contained   in   the  management   contracts   of   these   branded  hotels.    For  example,   the  Hilton  brand  may  be  unavailable  not   just  because   it   is  represented   in  the  market  but  because   it   is  precluded,  through  its  management  contract,  from  having  another  Hilton  hotel  within  a  certain  defined  geographic  area.    

By separating the hotel brand/operator selection process from the developer/builder selection process, the County will not only generate a higher financial contribution from the hotel brand/operator, but it will expand the universe of potential developers and large scale builders that can participate in the developer/builder selection process.      

   

Page 188: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

162  

5.5  Financial  Projections    The  projected  net  operating  income  for  the  proposed  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  is  set  forth  in  the  chart  below  

 

Page 189: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

163  

5.6  Conclusions  and  Recommendations  Replacement  Arena  Project  

It   is   recommended   that   the   Replacement   Arena   Project   be   developed   at   an   estimated   cost   of   $385.4  million.     This   would  include  construction  of  the  following  components:  

• Performance  Arena  with  8,000  –  10,000  fixed  seats;  

• 250,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  space;  

• 45,000  square  foot  ballroom,  with  additional  meeting  space;  

• 2,500  –  3,000  space  parking  garage;  

• Intermodal  transportation  center;  and  

• Festival  Plaza.  

Depending  upon  the  option  selected  for  the  Astrodome,  additional  exhibition  space  in  the  Replacement  Arena  Project  may  be  required.     By   utilizing   the   Astrodome   site   as   either   the  Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   or   Astrodome   Renaissance,   floor   space   that  exceeds   300,000   square   feet   of   covered,   column-­‐free,   high   ceiling   space   is   retained   for   use   by   the   OTC   and   other   users  occupying  Reliant  Park.    If  the  Astrodome  is  demolished  for  use  as  Reliant  Park  Plaza,  or  if  the  Status  Quo  is  maintained,  the  additional  exhibition  space  proposed  in  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  or  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  options  would  not  be  available.  Although  250,000  square  feet  of  exhibition  hall  space  would  be  created  with  the  Replacement  Arena  Project,  approximately   the   same  amount  of   space  would  be  eliminated  due   to   the  demolition  of   the   current  arena.    As  a   result,   the  Master  Plan  would  simply  retain  the  exhibit  space  square  footage  that  currently  exists  within  Reliant  Park  if  the  Astrodome  floor  could  not  be  used.    

Hotel  

It   is   also   recommended   that  HCSCC  continue   its   efforts   to   secure  a  private  developer   for   the  on-­‐site  hotel.    A  hotel   located  within  the  Complex  would  have  a  positive  impact  on  Reliant  Park.  Events  that  require  hotel  rooms  within  close  proximity  to  the  event  site,  which  include  most  large  conventions,  would  be  more  likely  to  consider  Reliant  Park  if  this  development  were  to  occur.    As  has  been  discussed  above,  the  lack  of  hotel  rooms  within  one-­‐half  mile  of  convention  center  space  is  a  significant  

Page 190: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

5.0  Reliant  Park  Master  Plan  Analysis

164  

hindrance  both  at  Reliant  Park  and  the  George  R.  Brown  Convention  Center.    While  one  hotel  would  not  completely  eliminate  this  issue  at  Reliant  Park,  it  would  have  a  dramatic  impact  on  the  types  of  events  that  can  be  brought  to  the  Complex.      

Notwithstanding  the   foregoing,   the  HCSCC  has  stated  that   the  on-­‐site  hotel  would  only  be  developed  with  primarily  private  funding.  Thus,  this  component  of  the  Master  Plan  would  require  a  third  party  to  conduct  its  own  analysis  and  decide  to  invest  the  capital  necessary  to  construct  the  hotel.  

 

Page 191: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

165  

6.0   Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  

Analysis

Page 192: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

166  

A  considerable  amount  of  time  was  devoted  to  evaluating  various  development  and  operational  scenarios  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site.    Each  of  the  development  options  was  evaluated  based  on  the  financial  and  market  viability  of  the  possible  option.    The  following  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  have  been  considered  in  detail  in  this  report:  

Maintain  Status  Quo  

This   option   maintains   the   Astrodome   in   its   current   condition.   The   building   will   remain   unusable   and   the   cost   of  maintenance  will  continue  to  rise  as  the  building  ages  and  systems  further  deteriorate.  

Reliant  Park  Plaza  

This   option  demolishes   the  Astrodome,   fills   the   existing   site   to   grade   and   constructs  Reliant  Park  Plaza  with  perimeter  support  facilities  for  outdoor  events.  

Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

This  option  would  renovate  the  Astrodome  into  a  multi-­‐use  indoor  event  facility.  A  new  event  floor  would  be  constructed  at  grade,  existing  seating  would  be  removed,  systems  would  be  upgraded  or  replaced  and  improvements  would  be  made  to  the  exterior  skin.  

Astrodome  Renaissance  

This   option   would   overlay   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   with   Science,   Technology,   Engineering   and   Mathematics   (STEM)  programs   and/or   privately   funded   concepts,   including   retail,   dining   and   entertainment   (RD+E)   and   attractions.  Approximately   400,000   square   feet   of   new   space   would   be   created   within   the   Astrodome   to   house   the   overlaid  components.   A   new   operating   entity   would   be   established   to   develop,   fund   and   manage   the   Astrodome   Renaissance  improvements  and  operations.  Funding  for  the  new  entity  would  be  derived  from  tenant  leases,  philanthropic  sources  and  other  Astrodome  Renaissance  revenues.  

While  all  options  require  public  funding,  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  as  considered  herein  may  only  be  pursued  if  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option   is   selected.  Further,   this  option  would  only  be   considered   if  private   sector  and/or  philanthropic   funding   can  be   found   to   support   construction  and  operations.  The  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  could  be  executed  concurrently  with  the  construction  of  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  or  at  a  point  in  the  future.  Future  construction  costs  would  be  higher.  

Page 193: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

167  

Each  of   these  potential  options  will  be  analyzed   in  detail   in   this   section,   including   the  projected  costs  associated  with  each  option.  

6.1  Maintain  Status  Quo  Since   2008,   Reliant   Astrodome   has   been   unable   to   host   public   events   due   to   the   lack   of   an  Occupancy  Certificate.    HLSR  last  used  the  Dome  in  2008  to  host  The  Hideout  but  has  not  held  the  Rodeo  or  any  concert  performances  in  the  facility  since  2002.  Following  the  Astros  move  to  Minute  Maid  Park   in  1999,  no  professional   sports   team  has  been  a   tenant  of   the  Astrodome.  The  HCSCC  spends   between   two   and   three   million   dollars   annually   on   regular   maintenance   of   the   venue  including  fire  alarm  systems,  fire  suppression  systems,  water-­‐proofing  and  roof.    These  costs  do  not  include  periodic  capital  expenditures,  such  as  the  $750,000  that  was  required  due  to  a  fire  that  took  

place  within  the  interior  of  the  Astrodome  in  2011.  It  is  important  to  note  that  utilities  for  portions  of  the  Reliant  Park  complex  run  through  the  Astrodome.  

The  proposed  Replacement  Arena  Project  would  include  relocation  of  the  utilities  that  currently  flow  through  the  Astrodome,  alleviating  one  of  the  significant  issues  with  maintaining  the  status  quo  of  the  facility.    However,  in  spite  of  this  fact,  the  annual  maintenance  and  periodic  capital  needs  are  likely  to  increase  over  time.    Maintaining  status  quo  of  the  Astrodome  also  fails  to  address  its  negative  impact  on  operations  for  Reliant  Park.    The  venue  also  is  an  eyesore  and  a  potential  safety  hazard,  which  negatively  impacts  marketability  of  the  Complex  and  the  experience  of  all  guests  attending  events  at  Reliant  Park.    

Under  this  option,  Harris  County  would  continue  to  maintain  the  Astrodome  in  its  present  condition.    The  Astrodome  would  remain  closed  to  the  public,  with  only  maintenance  workers  and  security  guards  permitted  to  enter  to  perform  basic,  essential  maintenance  and  security  activities.  The  Astrodome  would  not  generate  any  income  for  Harris  County.  

Page 194: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

168  

6.2  Reliant  Park  Plaza  

The  Reliant  Park  Plaza  would  provide  expanded  space  for  outdoor  events  that  are  currently  hosted  on  site  and  for  potential  new  events  and  festivals.  The  Plaza  would  be  designed  to  recognize  the  contributions  of  the  Astrodome  over  its  life  to  Harris  County,   the  surrounding  community  and   the  State  of  Texas.  The  work   to  be  undertaken   involves  removal  of  any  remaining  hazardous   material,   which   still   exists   within   the   Astrodome.     The   structure   would   be   taken   down.     Site   utilities   currently  supplying  and  passing   through   the  building  would  be   rerouted  or  moved   to  another   location  on  site  as   required.    The  hole  created  by  razing  the  building  would  be  filled  and  paved.    Carruth  Plaza  would  be  retained  and  incorporated  into  the  design  of  the  Reliant  Park  Plaza  and  permanent  rest  rooms  and  concession  buildings  would  be  added  on  the  perimeter  of  the  Plaza.    

The   Plaza   would   be   an   ideal   venue   for   outdoor   fairs,   festivals,   performances,   receptions   and  events.     Surrounding   the   Plaza  would   be   plenty   of   pathways   for   strolling   and   green   space   for  relaxing  or  tossing  around  a  football  with  family  and  friends  before  game  time.  A  signature  water  feature  could  serve  as  a  focal  point  of  the  Plaza.  A  programmed  fountain  show,  designed  to  evoke  memories   of   the  historic  Astrodome,   could  provide   a   fitting   tribute   to   the   landmark   that   once  stood  there  and  a  “do  not  miss”  photo  opportunity  for  visitors.    At  night,  this   impressive  water  feature   could   light   up,   creating   an   eye-­‐catching   centerpiece   and   filling   visitors  with   a   sense  of  wonder  and  excitement.  Public  art  installations,  some  even  constructed  from  remnants  from  the  

demolished  Dome,   could   inspire   and   energize   the   Plaza.    When   needed,   the   Plaza  would   double   as   additional   parking   and  support  facilities  for  Reliant  Park  events.  

Because  tearing  down  the  Astrodome  would  remove  the  icon  that  (along  with  NASA)  helped  put  Houston  on  the  map,  it  may  be  unpopular  with  many  Harris  County  residents.    However,  tearing  down  the  Astrodome  and  replacing  it  with  a  plaza  area  would  have  positive  impact  to  Reliant  Park.  The  visual  blight  and  safety  hazard  that  currently  exists  because  of  the  Dome’s  condition   would   be   eliminated,   creating   flexibility   for   the   site’s   future   development.   The  plaza   area   would   allow   for   the   hosting   of   a   limited   number   of   events   each   year   such   as  festivals,  outdoor  concert  series  and  similar  events.    

   

Page 195: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

169  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Reliant  Park  Plaza  

 

   

Page 196: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

170  

 6.3  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

The   concept   of   this   option   is   to   preserve   the  Astrodome  while   creating   a   truly  multi-­‐purpose  facility  that  provides  spectator  amenities  and  a  large  open  and  air-­‐conditioned  interior  space  for  hosting  a  wide  variety  of   special  events.  Throughout   the  year,   the  multi-­‐purpose   facility  could  feature  a  constantly  changing  roster  of  events—ranging  from  large  spectator  events,  (e.g.  HLSR’s  Summer  Festival  or  a  high  school   football   championship  game)   to  conventions,   exhibits,  press  conferences,   private   parties,   and   support   service   activities   thereby   infusing   the   Dome   with  energy,  activity  and  events  once  again.    The  multi-­‐purpose  facility  would  also  offer  Harris  County  a  spacious,  ideal  location  for  fairs,  festivals,  performances  and  other  events  but  with  one  key  difference:  the  location  would  be  air-­‐conditioned,  while  preserving  the  historic  Astrodome  experience.  

A   new   event   floor   constructed   at   grade   will   support   a   flexible   seating   system   used   to  accommodate  events  of  all  shapes  and  sizes.    By  adding  a  the  event  floor  at  grade,  the  Astrodome  multi-­‐purpose  facility  would  provide  significant  support  and  storage  space  below  the  slab,  which  would,   among   other   uses,   could   provide   space   for   chilled  water   and   rain  water   storage.     This  would   save   significant   operating   expenses   annually.   On-­‐site   concession,   retail   and   restrooms  areas  would  also  service  the  facility.  

This   option   could   also   provide   the   base   for   future   development   incorporating   the   concepts  discussed  under  the  “Astrodome  Renaissance”  in  the  following  section  and  preserve  the  iconic  structure.  

   

Page 197: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

171  

   

Page 198: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

172  

Design  Program  -­‐  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

Floor  area  by  level  and  uses:  

Level  1  -­‐  394,000  square  feet  

• Vertical  circulation    • Festival/Exhibition  expansion    • Support  space    • Central  plant  &  chilled  water  storage    • Event  storage    • Staging,  loading  and  marshaling    

Level  3  –  410,000  square  feet  

• Multi-­‐purpose  floor    • Permanent  restrooms    • Food  and  beverage  service    • Entrance  to  leasable  floors  above    

   

Page 199: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

173  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility        

Page 200: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

174  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)    

Page 201: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

175  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)      

Page 202: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

176  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 203: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

177  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)            

Page 204: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

178  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)    

     

Page 205: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

179  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 206: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

180  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 207: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

181  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 208: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

182  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 209: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

183  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 210: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

184  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)      

Page 211: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

185  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)        

Page 212: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

186  

Event  Set-­‐Ups  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  (continued)      

Page 213: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

187  

Summary  –  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility    

In  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  the  event  floor  would  be  over  300,000  square  feet,  column  free  and  rising  to  a  height  of  over  200  feet.  The  resulting  space  would  be  truly  unique  and  would  create  new  event  opportunities  for  Reliant  Park  as  well  as  growth  opportunities  for  existing  events.  Retaining  the  Astrodome  as  a  multi-­‐purpose  facility   in  conjunction  with  the   Replacement   Arena   Project   increases   the   total   available   exhibition   space   by   nearly   33   percent,   further   expanding   the  number  and  types  of  events  that  can  be  brought  to  the  Complex  each  year.    This  additional  space  will  also  allow  the  Complex  to  satisfy   the  needs  of   the  OTC  and  will  greatly  enhance   the   likelihood   that   the  OTC,  will   continue   to  use  Reliant  Park   for   this  event  that  is  vital  to  the  Harris  County  economy.  Through  the  use  of  portable  seating,  the  column  free  space  is  highly  flexible  and  capable  from  supporting  almost  any  event  configuration.  

This  option  could  also  provide  the  base  for  future  development  by  incorporating  the  concepts  discussed  under  the  “Astrodome  Renaissance”   in   the   following   section.     Furthermore,   this   option  would   eliminate   the   visual   blight   and   address   safety   and  security  concerns  regarding  the  facility.    It  would  also  preserve  the  iconic  structure.  

By   adding   a   the   event   floor   at   grade,   the   Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility  would   provide   significant   support   and   storage  space   below   the   slab,  which  would,   among  other   uses,   could  provide   space   for   chilled  water   and   rain  water   storage.     This  would  save  significant  operating  expenses  annually.  

   

Page 214: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

188  

6.4  Astrodome  Renaissance  

The  vision  of  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  is  to  become  the  leading  entertainment  destination  in  Harris  County.  It  would  offer  a  diverse  and  unique  package  of  hospitality,  retail,  entertainment,  educational  and  food  and  beverage  options  that  would  be  an  enhancement  of  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility.  The  Astrodome  Renaissance  assumes  that  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   would   be   developed   first   with   the   additional   components   being   added   when   interest   from   third   parties  justifies  these  concepts.  

The  Astrodome  Renaissance  would  target  a  broad  base  of  visitors  appealing  to  business,   tourists  and  family  markets  with  a  high   level  of  repeat  visitation.  There  are  also  opportunities   for  year  round  or  seasonal  experiential  attractions,  exhibits  and  retail  opportunities  to  enhance  the  menu  of  customer  offerings.  These  can  be  designed  to  be  complimentary  to  the  programs  currently  being  offered  by  both  the  tenants,  which  would  allow  for  redevelopment  that  would  greatly  benefit  Harris  County,  its  residents  and  the  Harris  County  area.    

Taking  advantage  of  the  enormous  volume  of  space  within  the  Astrodome,  new  floors  would  be  added  at  the  perimeter  of  the  structure  above  the  main  event  floor  to  house  the  Renaissance  improvements.    The  development  plan  assumes  that  the  HCSCC  or  a  new  entity   created   to  operate   the  new   facilities  would  develop   the   “core  and   shell”  of   the  Renaissance   space  with   the  individual   tenants   responsible   for   the   interior   construction   and   operation,   similar   to   a   typical   shopping  mall.   To   eliminate  conflicts,  a  sole  provider  should  operate  the  food  and  beverage  services.  

An   in  depth  assessment  of   this  option  has  been  completed  to  provide  a  comprehensive  analysis  of   the  menu  of  alternatives  available  as  well  as  a   realistic  assessment  of   the  economics  corresponding   to  each  component   idea.   In  order   to  achieve   the  goals  of  the  Renaissance,  the  team  recommends  a  three-­‐step  approach,  as  follows:  

(1) The  Harris  County  Sports  and  Convention  Corporation  and  SMG  should  leverage  and  capitalize  on  existing  anchors  and  infrastructure.  Reliant  Park  already  has  a  built-­‐in,  active  market  with  +/-­‐  350  event  days  annually.  Reliant  Park  is  home  to   Reliant   Stadium,   which   offers   a   diverse   list   of   annual   events   including   the   Houston   Livestock   Show   and   Rodeo,  Houston  Texans  (NFL),  Texas  Bowl  (NCAA),  major  events  (Super  Bowl,  Final  Four,  WrestleMania),  concerts,  and  family  shows.   Reliant   Center   hosts   the   OTC,   and   multiple   other   trade   and   consumer   shows   throughout   the   year.   Finally,  Reliant  Arena  hosts  concerts,  sporting  events  and  the  equestrian  events  associated  with  the  HLSR.  

Page 215: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

189  

(2) The  HCSCC  should  develop  complements  to  the  existing  anchors  to  extend  visitor   length  of  stay  and  increase  on-­‐site  spending.  This  can  be  done  through  two  primary  modes  –  retail,  dining  and  entertainment  (RD+E)  and  hotels.  Retail  could  come  in  the  form  of  destination  anchor  stores,  medium  format  and  specialty  or  boutique  shops.  Dining  could  be  developed  with  destination  restaurants,  local  interest  outlets,  and  quick-­‐service  food  offerings.  Finally,  the  creation  of  entertainment  options  would  complement  the  retail  and  food  and  beverage  options,  further  driving  visitors  to  the  site,  beyond  what  is  already  provided  by  the  existing  on-­‐site  anchors.  Other  complements  could  come  in  the  form  of  a  major  cinema,  attractions,  clubs  and  bars,  or  other  indoor  entertainment.  The  hotels  and  on-­‐site  accommodations  will  serve  to  extend  visitor   length  of  stay  and  provide  overnight  options  for  business  and  convention  visitors  as  well  as  sports,  leisure  and  attraction  guests.  

(3)   The  creation  of  new  attractions  could  help   to   fully  develop  and  complete   the  build  out  of   the  Astrodome  Renaissance  program.  This  can  be  done  by  designing  entertainment  options  that  fit  and  further  complement   the  anchors  and  proposed  RD+E  and  Hotel  components.    

A  multitude  of  attractions  and  experiences  will  create  critical  mass  for  the   Astrodome   Renaissance   and   Reliant   Park   Complex.   The   complete  entertainment  offering  will  combine  fixed  anchor  attractions,  multi-­‐use  event   space   and   other   soft   program   “fill”   attractions.   It   should   offer   a  variety   of   entertainment   options   and   price   points   and   capitalize   on  sponsorship   opportunities   by   utilizing   the   environment,   events   and  entertainment.   Finally,   the   Astrodome   Renaissance   will   provide   the  opportunity   to   appeal   broadly   to   multiple   users   (local   and   regional  residents,  business  and  leisure  visitors)  and  age  groups  in  order  to  fully  activate  the  site.  

   

Full$Renova+on$

and$Repurpose$Alterna+ves$

Hotels'+'Retail,'Dining'and'

Entertainment'(RD&E)'

Culturally'Driven'–'STEM'Orienta@on'ABrac@on'Driven'

Page 216: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

190  

Destination  Driven  Programming  

The   location   of   Reliant   Park   requires   the   development  program  to  be  destination  oriented   in  nature.   In  other  words,  the   site   needs   to   attract   visitors   through   the   actual   program  elements   as   opposed   to   having   patrons   visit   the   site   in  conjunction  with  an  existing  use.  

Some   of   this   targeted   programming   already   exists   as  illustrated   in   the   graphic   on   the   right.     In   order   to   be  economically   sustainable,   and  be  a   consistent  driver  of   traffic  to  Reliant  Park,  the  project  needs  to  be  programmed  as  a  multi-­‐purpose  project,  maximizing  the  number  of  days  and  the  time  of  days  that  the  site  is  active.  

 

   

Reliant(Park(

Spor/ng(events(

Live(music(program(mul/ple(

size(venues(

Blue(Man(Group,(Cirque(de(Soleil(

and(other(traveling(produc/ons(

Restaurant(and(retail(district(

Hospitality((Themed(hotel(/(Great(Wolf(Lodge)(

NonIprofit(culturally(themes(

aKrac/ons(

Indoor(entertainment(

complex,(aKrac/ons([Water(based,(ice/snow(

based,(condi/oned(space](

Mee/ng(spaces,(conven/on(

business([EXISTING(AND(IMPROVED](

Page 217: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

191  

The  chart  below  outlines  the  funding  options  available  for  the  Astrodome  Renaissance.  

                                   

Reliant(Park(Redevelopment(Authority(

Site(Development(and(Building(Redevelopment(

U:li:es( Parking( Build(Astrodome(“Core(and(Shell”(

Develop(new(mee:ng,(exhibi:on(and(flexible(space(

Private(Investment(

Retail,(Dining,(Entertainment(and(Events(

Hotel((s)(

Regional(AJrac:ons,(

(reference(the(AJrac:on(Matrix)(

NonNprofit,(Cultural(

AJrac:ons(

Texas(Sports(Museum(

Permanent(Rodeo(Exhibit(

STEM(based(exhibit(

Single(Operator(for(Food(and(Beverage,((Concessions,(and(Parking(

Page 218: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

192  

Concept  List  and  Matrix  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  

The   team   has   compiled   and   reviewed   a   set   of   potential   entertainment   attraction   formats   for   the   Reliant   Park-­‐Astrodome  Renaissance  project.  Each  option  was  evaluated  based  on  its  merit  for  the  site  with  consideration  given  to  a  number  of  factors  including  Business  Model  (commercial,  non-­‐profit,  corporate),  Compatibility  (scheduling  fit,  parking  demand,  size  and  scale),  and  Market  Context  (drawing  power  and  competitive  environment),  as  shown  in  the  matrix  below.    

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Category Use Business/Model1 Compatibility2 Drawing/Power3Competitive/Environment4

EntertainmentLarge&Scale Outdoor-Theme-Park Comm 3 8 7

Outdoor-Water-Park Comm 5 6 6Spectacle-Attraction Comm 5 8 9

Medium&Scale Indoor-Theme-Park Comm 6 6 6Indoor-Water-Park Comm 6 5 6Indoor-Attraction Comm 7 5 7

Small&Scale Family-Entertainment-Center Comm 7 5 7Corporate-Attraction Corp 9 4 6Cinema Comm 8 6 5

Arts/Cultural Cultural-District NP/Comm 2 6 3Theatre NP/Comm 6 5 4Amphitheater NP/Comm 5 5 4

Museum/Science-Center Children's-Museum NP 7 4 4Natural-History-Museum NP 7 4 4Science-Center NP 7 4 4Houston-History-Museum NP 8 3 4

Sports Sports-Academy NP/Comm 4 3 5Rec/Tournament-Field-Complex NP/Comm 2 5 5Houston-Sports-Hall-of-Fame NP/Comm 9 3 7Center-for-Sports-Medicine NP/Comm 9 3 5

Education/Training STEM-Center NP 8 3 6Art-Institute NP 5 2 4Culinary-Institute NP 5 2 4Medical-Institute NP 6 3 4

Wildlife-Attraction Zoo NP 3 6 3Aquarium NP/Comm 6 6 3Oceanarium NP/Comm 3 6 4

Industry Movie-Studio Comm 3 2 7Community Events-Plaza NP/Comm 8 4 7Footnote:*Arena,-Convention-and-Conference/Meeting-Space-assumed-to-be-covered-as-part-of-Step-1-and-2-programming.1-Y-NP-=-NonYprofit;-Comm-=-Commercial;-Corp-=-Corporate

3-Y-Drawing-power-based-on-consideration-of-attractiveness-to-the-resident-and-tourist-market.-1-=-low-drawing-power.-10-=-high-drawing-power.4-Y-Competitive-environment-based-on-level-of-competition-within-the-Houston-local-and-regional-market.-1-=-strong-competition.-10-=-weak-competition.

Source:-ECA

Market/Context

2-Y-Compatibility-rank-based-on-consideration-of-the-attraction-or-facility's-scheduling-fit,-parking-demand,-relative-size/scale-with-the-existing-and-proposed-program-at-Reliant-Park.-1-=-low-compatibility.-10-=-high-compatibility.

Page 219: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

193  

Below  are  more  detailed  analyses  of  the  primary  components  that  have  been  proposed  and  considered  to  be  included  in  the  complete  renovation  of  the  Astrodome.  Some  of  the  concepts  are  worth  considering  in  more  detail,  while  others  would  not  be  good  fits  given  cost  and/or  operating  constraints.  

Science,  Technology,  Engineering  and  Mathematics  [STEM]  Programming    

Transforming   the   Astrodome   into   a   magnet   of   Science,   Technology,   Engineering   and   Mathematics   (STEM)   education   and  transformative  experience,  the  programming  in  this  theme  would  promote  Harris  County’s  role  as  a   leader  in  both  informal  and  formal  STEM  education  and  industry.    Interactive  attractions,  programs  and  events  focused  on  STEM  would  offer  hands-­‐on  opportunities   for   locals  and  visitors  to  explore,  discover,  play  and   learn.  The  Astrodome  itself  would  become  a   landmark  of  applied  technology  and  engineering  in  creating  a  responsible  and  sustainable  environment—from  solar  panels  on  its  roof  to  point  of  use  water  treatment  and  heating.    

Multiple  opportunities  exist  within  the  Astrodome  itself.    A  Science  Center  (similar  to  the  Center  of  Science  and  Industry  (COSI)   in  Columbus,  Ohio)  would  offer  edutainment  exhibits,   state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art,  flexible   labs   and   classrooms   to   support   a   variety   of   programming,   unique   evening   and   holiday  events  such  as  sleepovers  and  camps,  and  a  flexible,  multi-­‐use  theater  space.    An  interactive  Energy  Exploratorium  centered  on   fossil   fuels  as  well   as  energies  of   the   future   could   tell  Harris  County’s  story   as   the   Energy   Capital   of   America   in   a   way   that   stimulates   curiosity   and   STEM   exploration  through  highly  immersive  and  interactive  exhibits  and  programming.  

In   a   nod   to   Harris   County’s   aeronautical   heritage,   a   branded   educational   space   experience   like  Sesame  Street  Presents:  The  Planets  or  a  NASA  Kids  Space  Place  would  allow  children  to  explore  the  science  of   the  universe  at  a  very  young  age   in  a   relatable,   immersive  environment.    A  Museum  of  Technology   and   Innovation  would   inform,   provoke   thought   and  motivate   people   of   all   ages  with  content   and   programs   centered   on   the   region’s   scientific   and   technological   innovations   and  contributions.     A   Technology   and   Innovation   Hall   of   Fame   would   showcase   the   work   of   Harris  County’s  many  corporate  and   individual   leaders   in  STEM  fields,   including  Nobel  Laureate  Richard  Smalley  who  discovered  Buckyballs.  

Page 220: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

194  

State-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art  office  and  incubation  space  and  a  cutting-­‐edge  conference  center  would  make  the  Astrodome  a  hub   for  STEM  focused  non-­‐profit   foundations,   community  education  outreach,   city  wide   teacher   training   and   professional   development,   corporations,   start-­‐ups   and   university  programs   (from   neighboring   universities   like   Rice   University   and   University   of   Houston).     By  providing  flexible  space  designed  not  just  to  accommodate  such  diverse  groups  but  incubate  and  encourage   relationship   building,   the   Astrodome   could   become   the   apex   for   STEM  development  across   disciplines   and   industries   in   Harris   County.   Special   STEM   events   such   as   science   fairs,  

robotics   competitions   and   STEM   symposiums   could   provide   an   ever-­‐changing  mix   of   STEM   activities,   beckoning   guests   to  return  again  and  again.  

The  original  Master  Plan  presentation  proposed  that  a  planetarium  serve  as  the  focal  point  for  the  STEM  activities.  However,  this   analysis   indicates   that   the   planetarium   concept   is   unsupportable,   given   the   presence   of   the   existing   Burke   Baker  Planetarium.      

Page 221: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

195  

Summary  of  Science,  Technology,  Engineering  and  Mathematics  [STEM]  Programming  Options:  

     

Page 222: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

196  

Summary  of  Science,  Technology,  Engineering  and  Mathematics  [STEM]  Programming  Options  (continued):  

   

Page 223: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

197  

Texas  Experience  Programming  

This  theme  would  bring  the  heart  of  Texas  to  the  heart  of  Reliant  Park.    Flanked  by  Reliant  Stadium,  home  of  the  Texans,  and  the  world’s   largest   livestock  show,   the  HLSR,   the   landmark  Astrodome  would  be   the  perfect   setting   for   the  ultimate  Texas  Experience.  The  Texas  state   tourism  slogan   is  "Texas:   It's   like  a  whole  other  country."    Here,  guests  would   find  themselves  delightfully   immersed  within   the  great,  expansive  “country”  of  Texas  all  under  one  roof.    From  history  and  culture   to  BBQ,  music  and  sports,  visitors  would  see,  feel  and  savor  what  it  means  to  “be  Texan”.  

The  Texas  Experience  could  begin  with  the  Museum  of  Texas  Culture,  where  interactive  exhibits  and   specialized   programs   tell   a   constantly   evolving   story   of   Texas   culture   and   traditions.    Special   cultural   events   including   “kicker   dancing”   lessons,   Folklorico   performances   and  Oktoberfest   could   be   celebrated   at   the   Museum’s   Texas   Cultural   Center,   a   venue   for   music,  theatrical  and  literary  performances  as  well  as  workshops,   lectures  and  educational  seminars.    After  absorbing  Texas  culture,  guests  could  step  back  in  time  in  Wild  West  World,  where  the  old  west   would   unfold   before   their   eyes!     Attractions   and   shows   could   bring   to   life   the   history,  legends  and  lore  of  Texas  and  the  western  frontier.    

With   highly   interactive   media,   including   high-­‐definition   holographic   effects,   and   immersive   technology,   a  Texas  Sports  Experience  would  commemorate  Texas  sports  history  and  legends.    Guests  could  cycle  alongside  Lance  Armstrong,  box  with  George  Foreman  and  get  golfing  tips  from  Lee  Trevino,  among  other  Texas  greats.    Long  a  center  of  music  innovation  and  a  top  filmmaking  state,  a  Texas  Film  and  Music  Hall  of  Fame  would  pay  homage   to   the   impressive   contributions   Texans   have   made   to   the   music   and   film   industries.   Updatable  exhibits  could  explore  the  history,  legacies  and  contributions  Texas  has  made  to  all  forms  of  music  and  film.    A  state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art   performance   venue   would   host   live   music   events   and   film   screenings,   including   special  features  of  past  and  present  films  set  in  Texas.  

   

Page 224: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

198  

Devoted  exclusively  to  the  sport  of  rodeo,  a  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  Museum  could  offer  year-­‐round   excitement   and   inspiration   via   hands-­‐on   exhibits   and   extensive   collections   of   memorabilia.     An  authentic  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  Store  could  extend  the  museum  experience,  offering  a  one-­‐of-­‐a-­‐kind  collection  of  merchandise  and  souvenirs.  

Through  educational  programs  and  exhibits,  a  Texas  Museum  of  Industry  would  preserve  and  showcase  the  industrial   and   technological   heritage   of   Texas,   including   Texas’   powerful   presence   in   the   energy,  information  technology,  oil  and  natural  gas,  aerospace,  biomedical  research,  fuel  processing,  electric  power,  agriculture,  and  manufacturing  industries.  

Guests   would   also   be   enticed   by   a   collection   of   uniquely   Texan   shopping,   dining   and   nightlife  offerings.   A   Texas  Market   could   showcase   culture,   products   and   delicacies   exported   from   regions  around  Texas.    After  sampling  Jalapeno  Jelly  and  stocking  up  on  western  wear,  guests  could  get  their  Barbacoa  or  cowboy  style  fix  at  The  Round-­‐up,  a  BBQ  restaurant  serving  a  cornucopia  of  South,  East,  Central  and  West  Texas  fare  and  then  head  over  to  a  Saloon  to  learn  the  Texas  Two-­‐Step  or  Austin:  Live,  an  intimate  live  music  venue,  to  groove  to  indie  rock.    The  Sam  Houston  Revue,  a  Texan  musical  comedy  revue  and  dining  opportunity,  could  tell  the  story  of  the  Texas  Revolution  and  the  resulting  short-­‐lived  Republic  of  Texas.      

A  Texas  Nighttime   Spectacular,   a   stunning   show  under   the  Dome  would   feature   digital   projection,  sound  and  special  effects  guaranteed  to   thrill  and   leave   lasting  memories  of  a   full  day  and  night  of  true  Texas  entertainment.  

Page 225: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

199  

Summary  of  Texas  Experience  Programming  Options:        

Page 226: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

200  

Summary  of  Texas  Experience  Programming  Options  (continued):  

Page 227: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

201  

Summary  of  Texas  Experience  Programming  Options  (continued):  

Page 228: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

202  

Summary  of  Texas  Experience  Programming  Options  (continued):                                                    

NOTE:    Appendix  III  contains  a  list  of  additional  museum  attractions  considered  in  this  study.      

Page 229: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

203  

Astrodome  History  Programming  

This   theme  would   honor   the   Astrodome’s   rich   sports,   entertainment   and   architectural   legacy.     Guests  could  travel  back  in  time  via  The  Astrodome  Experience,  a  ticketed,  free-­‐flow  attraction  that  would  allow  guests  to  explore  more  than  50  years  of  Dome  history  through  a  slate  of   immersive  experiences.    Here,  artifacts,  interactive  exhibits,  media  displays,  and  hands-­‐on  demos  would  highlight  unforgettable  athletes  and  performers.    Large  LED  panels  would  feature  an  endless  loop  of  the  Astrodome’s  greatest  sports  and  entertainment  performances  from  the  Battle  of  the  Sexes  to  the  Cougars  upset  of  UCLA  to  Elvis  in  concert.    

On  Judge’s  Tour,  guests  would  get  an  exclusive  all-­‐access,  behind-­‐the-­‐scenes  look  at  the  Astrodome  while  learning  about  the  history  of  the  Astrodome,  and  the  man  behind  it  (Judge  Hofheinz).    Highlights  of  the  tour  could  include  a  visit  to  the  Judge’s  exclusive  apartment  as  well  as  the  Astrodome’s  chapel,  tilt  room,  bowling   alley,   barbershop,   Polynesian   room  and   the  presidential   suite.     Additional   tours   offered   could  include  architectural  and  sports  history  tours,  among  others.    

A   gift   shop   would   sell   unique   Astrodome   relics   and   keepsakes,   including   AstroTurf,   souvenir   programs,  books  and  photographs.  The  Astrodome  could  also  host  a  fully  functioning,  state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art  Broadcast  Studio.  Here,  television  hosts  and  radio  DJs  could  interview  Harris  County’s  sports  legends  of  yesterday  and  today,  recap  Texans  games  and  report  on  the  goings  on  at   the  HLSR.    Visitors  could  catch  a  glimpse  of   the  action  through  the  studio’s  windows  or  as  part  of  a  live  studio  audience.  

In   a   tribute   to   its   predecessors   Astrodomain   and   Astroworld,   an   indoor   world-­‐class  retail,  dining  and  entertainment  complex  would  offer  an  array  of  options  day  and  night.    

It   would   be   a   great   place   to   catch   a   film,   mingle   over   cocktails   or   enjoy   a   relaxing   meal   under   the  Astrodome  with  family  and  friends  after  a  day  of  visiting.    An  indoor  theme  park  could  be  home  to  the  world’s  largest  indoor  Ferris  wheel  (surpassing  the  125  foot  high  wheel  at  the  I-­‐X  Center  in  Cleveland),  a  roller  coaster  and  other  amusement  park  rides  and  attractions.      

Page 230: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

204  

Summary  of  Astrodome  History  Programming  Options:        

Page 231: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

205  

Entertainment/Edutainment  Programming  

Intended  for  both  afternoon  trips  and  all  day  excursions,  the  Astrodome’s  entertainment  offerings  in  this  theme  would  create  fun,  excitement,  and  learning  in  an  environment  that  encourages  parents  and  children  to  explore  and  play  together.  

Family  fun  turns  aquatic  at  the  WaterDome,  an  indoor  water  park,  filled  with  entertaining  children’s  water-­‐play  areas,  exhilarating  slides,  pools  and  a  lazy  river.    The  SnowDome,  a  breathtaking  indoor  world   of   outdoor   wintry   landscapes   and   awe-­‐inspiring   ice   statuaries,   would   bring   year-­‐round  winter  fun  to  Harris  County.    A  snow  park,  slides,  sled  runs,  skating  pond  and  ice  maze  would  be  just  

some   of   the   attractions   featured   in   this   icy   wonderland.     Adventurous   families   would   find   outdoor   thrills   indoors   at   the  AdventureDome,  a  unique  experience   that  would  combine  high-­‐adrenaline  recreational  activities  and  hands-­‐on  experiential  learning,  including  rock  climbing,  zip  lining,  a  ropes  course  and  a  skydiving  simulator,  all  under  the  Dome  

Kids   and   their   parents   could   get   hands-­‐on   with   entertainment   that   enriches   and   inspires   at  branded  children’s  experiences  such  as  LEGOLAND  Discovery  Center,  the  ultimate  LEGO  playland,  complete   with   LEGO   models   of   local   landmarks,   interactive   rides,   and   a   4-­‐D   cinema,   and   The  Crayola  Factory,   an   immersive  and  colorful   creative  space   full  of   interactive  and   imaginative  art  projects.     For   the   littler   ones,   attractions   like   a   Sesame   Place   or   Nickelodeon   Fun   Zone   would  magically  bring  characters  to  life  with  rides,  shows  and  attractions.    Family  dining  establishments  like  Rain  Forest  Café  would  serve  up  family  friendly  fare.      

Flexible,   world-­‐class   performance   spaces   would   attract   live   music   entertainment,   ranging   from   local   performers   and  musicians,  as  well  as  globally  recognized  blockbuster  acts.    A  state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art  cinema  would  be  a  perfect  place  for  nighttime  activities  

A   sportsplex   would   offer   a   wide   variety   of   traditional   recreation   activities:   a   state-­‐of-­‐the-­‐art  fitness   center,   indoor   turf   fields,   batting   cages,   driving   ranges,   a   dance   studio,   and   more,   all  available  for  lessons,  league  play,  tournaments  and  facility  rental.  

Attraction  Driving  Programming  will  have  strong  market  appeal  as  it  will  create  potential  appeal  from  outside  Harris   County   and   bring   visitors   to   the   area   from  outside   the   region.     It  will   also  

Page 232: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

206  

provide  a  unique  attraction   for  Harris  County  residents,  all  on  a  year-­‐round  basis.    Because  of   the  nature  of   the  attractions  proposed,   the   lack   of   themed   attractions   in   the   region  will   be   addressed.    However,   as   discussed   above,   access   limitations  during  other  Reliant  Park  events  like  Texans  games,  the  HLSR  and  the  OTC  and  other  conventions  will  restrict  the  ability  to  generate  revenues  as  patrons  will  most  likely  not  be  able  to  attend  the  attractions  on  a  365-­‐day  per  year  basis.  

 

Summary  of  Entertainment/Edutainment  Programming  Options:  

   

Page 233: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

207  

Summary  of  Entertainment/Edutainment  Programming  Options  (continued):      

Page 234: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

208  

Summary  (Cultural  and  Education  Driven  Programming)  

The   addition   of   cultural   programming   and   components   within   the   Astrodome   creates   the   potential   for   additional   similar  attractions  in  the  future  and  thus  a  strong  compliment  to  the  existing  Museum  District  nearby.    These  types  of  attractions  also  create  good  public  relations  opportunities  and  support  policy  and  political  agendas  due  to  their  philanthropic  nature.    Because  Reliant   Park   does   not   have   these   types   of   attractions   currently,   the   addition   of   these   venues   would   bring   a   new   type   of  attendee  to  the  Park  and  expand  the  annual  attendance  and  allow  for  additional  events  each  year  as  well.      

There   are   concerns   that   exist  with  museum   and   cultural   attractions   in   that   they   generally   are   expensive   to   build   and   are  commercially   challenging   as   they   usually   operate   at   negative   cash   flow.     They   thus   would   require   supplemental   funding  through  foundations  or  similar  organizations  and  also  would  require  the  creation  of  support  staff  and  related  infrastructure  to  operate  on  a  daily  basis.    This  too  is  difficult  and  would  require  the  efforts  of  a  wide  range  of  companies,  organizations  and  individuals.    The  nearby  Museum  District,  which  could  serve  as  a  strong  compliment  to  this  programming  would  need  to  be  included  in  the  development  plans  as  it  would  be  imperative  to  avoid  competing  attractions.    

Flexible  Space  and  Seasonal  Overlays  

Flexible  event  space  would  create  new  opportunities   for  changing  attractions  and  exhibits  and  support   facilities   for  Reliant  Park  events.  Ongoing  performing  arts  events,  festivals  and  art  installations  would  infuse  the  Dome  with  international  energy  and  spirit.    The  look  and  feel  of  the  Astrodome  would  morph  and  change  with  seasonal  events  and  holidays.    Lighting,  audio,  façade,  dressing  and  digital  projections  could  enhance  and  transform  public  spaces,  activating  and  shaping  the  environment.    

Summary  of  Flexible  Space  and  Seasonal  Overlays  Programming  Options:  

 

   

Page 235: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

209  

Conference  Center  and  Hotel  

100,000   square   feet   of   high-­‐end   configurable  meeting   and   event   space  with   an   eco-­‐friendly  design,   complete   sound   separation  between   rooms,   and  on-­‐site   complete   food  and  beverage  service   would   address   important   facility   selection   criteria   for   most   convention,   conference,  meeting  and  trade  show  planners.    Connected  to  the  Conference  Center,  a  hotel  could  offer  a  balance  of  full-­‐service  resort/spa  and  meeting/convention  hotel,  including  a  pool,  spa,  fitness  center  and  business  center.  

The   Conference   Center/Hotel   would   also   provide   additional   support   facilities   for   Reliant   Park   events,   including   the   OTC,  Texans  games  and  Houston  Livestock  Show  and  Rodeo  activities.    As  discussed,  elsewhere,  there  is  a  lack  of  hotel  rooms  within  close  proximity   to  Reliant  Park,   and   those   that   currently   are   available   are   limited   service  hotels   that   are  not   acceptable   to  typical   attendees   at   conventions   and   trade   shows.   In   order   to   determine   the   size   and   brand   of   the   hotel   as   well   as   the  conference  space  that  would  be  added  through  the  redevelopment  process,  much  further  analysis  will  be  needed.    

The  Retail,  Dining  &  Entertainment  components  would  also  enhance   the  existing  businesses  within  Reliant  Park.    However,  selecting  the  right  components  that  complement  each  other  as  well  as  the  existing  anchors  is  essential  to  the  success  of  the  Astrodome   Renaissance.     Offering  more   food   and   beverage   options   for   the   game,   rodeo   and   other   event   attendees  would  enhance   the   overall   guest   experience.     Additionally,   the   RD+E   programming   could   foster   future   development   as   well,   by  increasing  the  annual  attendance  at  Reliant  Park  new  projects  both  within  and  adjacent  to  the  Park  would  want  to  capitalize  on  the  new  found  life  in  the  Astrodome.  Summary  of  Conference  Center  and  Hotel  Programming  Options:  

     

Page 236: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

210  

Phase  I  Program  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  

Based  on  the  proposed  strategy  for  Reliant  Park  and  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  as  outlined  earlier,  the  preliminary  overview  of   the   Harris   County   market   (resident   and   tourist   and   competitive)   as   well   as   the   review   of   benchmark   attractions   and  subsequent   concept   ideas   matrix,   the   project   team   has   outlined   a   preliminary   Phase   I   Program,   with   the   projected   costs  related  to  the  development  of  this  Phase  included  as  well.    These  costs,  which  are  set  forth  in  the  table  below,  assume  that  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  was   selected  and   the   “core  and   shell”   elements  were   constructed   in  order   for   the  development  of  the  individual  components  to  take  place.  

   

 

   

SF Project*Cost Cost/SF [/]*Core*&*Shell [/]*Adjustment Buildout*Cost/SF Revised*Project*Cost

Retail

Anchor 50,000 8,750,000$3333333333 3 175333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 7533333333333333333333333 3,750,000$3333333333 3

Medium 50,000 8,000,000$3333333333 3 160333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 6033333333333333333333333 3,000,000$3333333333 3

Small 50,000 7,000,000$3333333333 3 140333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 4033333333333333333333333 2,000,000$3333333333 3

Subtotal 150,000 23,750,000$333333333 158333333333333333333333 8,750,000$3333333333 3

Food3&3Beverage

Destination 40,000 8,000,000$3333333333 3 200333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 4,000,000$3333333333 3

Local3Mid5Size 60,000 10,500,000$333333333 175333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 7533333333333333333333333 4,500,000$3333333333 3

Small 25,000 3,750,000$3333333333 3 150333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 5033333333333333333333333 1,250,000$3333333333 3

Subtotal 125,000 22,250,000$333333333 178333333333333333333333 9,750,000$3333333333 3

Entertainment

STEM5Related3Museum/Attraction 40,000 35,000,000$333333333 875333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 125333333333333333333333 650333333333333333333333 26,000,000$333333333

Indoor3Attraction 40,000 20,000,000$333333333 500333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 400333333333333333333333 16,000,000$333333333

Subtotal 80,000 55,000,000$333333333 688333333333333333333333 42,000,000$333333333

Educational/Research

STEM3Center 70,000 30,000,000$333333333 429333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 329333333333333333333333 23,000,000$333333333

Subtotal 70,000 30,000,000$333333333 429333333333333333333333 23,000,000$333333333

Hotel/Conference3Center

Hotel3(1253Rooms) 92,000 25,000,000$333333333 272333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 172333333333333333333333 15,800,000$333333333

Conference3Center 140,000 49,000,000$333333333 350333333333333333333333 100333333333333333333333 533333333333333333333333333 250333333333333333333333 35,000,000$333333333

Subtotal 232,000 74,000,000$333333333 319333333333333333333333 50,800,000$333333333

TOTAL 657,000 205,000,000$****** 312********************* 204********************* 134,300,000$******

Page 237: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

211  

As  discussed  earlier,  the  goal  is  for  each  of  the  components  to  work  together,  complementing  not  only  each  other,  but  also  the  existing   anchors   on   the   site.     The   proposed   program  will   help   extend   visitor   length   of   stay   and   increase   on-­‐site   spending  through   the   addition   of   Retail,   Dining,   and   Entertainment   (RD+E),   hotels   and   various   entertainment   options   that   fit   and  further  complement  the  anchors.  Business  Models  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  

The  potential  business  models  for  the  suggested  entertainment  components  are  outlined  in  this  following  section.  Two  sets  of  attraction  business  models  are  outlined  –  Core-­‐Phase  I  attractions,  which  could  be  part  of  the  initial  Astrodome  Renaissance  Master  Plan  and  Phase  II  attractions,  which  could  be  incorporated  into  a  longer  term  master  plan.    Due  to  costs  related  to  the  planetarium  and  the  consensus  among  the  consultant  team  that  an  attraction  of  that  type  was  not  ideal,  it  was  not  included  in  the  Phase  I  components  set  forth  below.    The  Museum  of  Natural  Science  currently  has  a  planetarium,  further  strengthening  the  belief  that  a  second  facility  of  that  type  would  not  be  successful  at  the  Astrodome  site.  

   

Page 238: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

212  

Entertainment  Business  Models  (Phase  I  –  Core  Attractions)  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance                                                            

Market'and'Economic'CharacteristicsSTEM4related'Attraction/'

Museum

Concept

Sizing&Range&(footprint) 30,000&4&50,000&sq.ft.

Pricing&Model&(gated/non4gated) pay4one4price

Average&Length&of&Stay&(range) 2&4&3&hours

Concept&Positioning Family&market.&Education4based&potential

Attendance'PotentialAttendance/Visitation&Range 100,000&4&500,000

FinancialBusiness&Model non4profit

Headline&Price&(midpoint&of&range) $15.00

Admissions&Yield&Range 40%&4&60%

Per&Capita&Expenditure&Range $6.00&4&$12.00(incl.&admissions,&food&&&beverage,&merchandise,&other)

Total&Revenue&Generation&(range) $600,000&4&$6&million(based&on&medium&attendance/per&capita&range)

Operating&Margin&(%&NOI/EBITDA) (20%)&4&(50%)(based&on&earned&income)

InvestmentPreliminary&Investment&Level&(based&on&industry&standards) $20&4&$50&million(cost&of&attraction&development&only,&no&additional&allocation&for&land&or&infrastructure&development&costs)

Development'and'Operations

Developer/Operator Joint&Venture&(HCSCC/SMG/Operator)

Source:&ECA

Examples California&Science&Center,&AMNH,&Johnson&Space&Center

Page 239: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

213  

Entertainment  Business  Models  (Phase  I  –  Core  Attractions)  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  (continued)                                                            

Market'and'Economic'Characteristics

Concept

Sizing&Range&(footprint)

Pricing&Model&(gated/non7gated)

Average&Length&of&Stay&(range)

Concept&Positioning

Attendance'PotentialAttendance/Visitation&Range

FinancialBusiness&Model

Headline&Price&(midpoint&of&range)

Admissions&Yield&Range

Per&Capita&Expenditure&Range

(incl.&admissions,&food&&&beverage,&merchandise,&other)

Total&Revenue&Generation&(range)

(based&on&medium&attendance/per&capita&range)

Operating&Margin&(%&NOI/EBITDA)

(based&on&earned&income)

InvestmentPreliminary&Investment&Level&(based&on&industry&standards)

(cost&of&attraction&development&only,&no&additional&allocation&for&land&or&

infrastructure&development&costs)

Development'and'Operations

Developer/Operator

Source:&ECA

Examples

Indoor'Attraction

25,000&7&75,000&sq.ft.

pay7one7price

3&7&5&hours

Children's/family&market.&

Education7based&potential

250,000&7&750,000

commercial

$20.00

50%&7&60%

$15.00&7&$20.00

$4&7&$15&million

20%&7&35%

$15&7&$30&million

Joint&Venture&

(HCSCC/SMG/Operator)

KidZania,&WonderWorks,&LEGO&

Discovery,&Sesame&Workshop,&

SeaLife&Center

Page 240: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

214  

Design  Program  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  

Floor  area  by  level  and  uses:  

Level  1  –  394,000  sf  

• Vertical  circulation    • Festival/Exhibition  expansion    • Support  space    • Central  plant  &  chilled  water  storage    • Event  storage    • Staging,  loading  and  marshaling    

Level  2  –  170,000  sf  

• Undeveloped  space    • Vertical  circulation  for  each  building  quadrant    

Level  3  –  61,200  sf  

• Events  plaza  &  spectacle  attraction  space  • STEM-­‐related  attraction  • Medium  retail  • Local  mid-­‐size  food  and  beverage  • Entrance  to  floors  above  

Level  4  –  127,000  sf    

• Events  plaza  &  spectacle  attraction  space  • STEM-­‐related  attraction  • Corridors  and  plaza  • Anchor,  medium  and  small  retail  • Local  mid-­‐size  and  small  food  and  beverage  

Page 241: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

215  

Level  5  –  125,500  sf  

• Education/research  plaza  &  attraction  space  • STEM-­‐related  attraction  • Corridors  and  plaza  • Conference  Center  • Anchor,  medium  and  small  retail  • Destination  and  small  food  and  beverage  

Level  6  –  124,500  sf    

• Education/research  plaza  &  attraction  space  • STEM-­‐related  attraction  • Corridors  and  plaza  • Conference  Center  • Medium  and  small  retail  • Local  mid-­‐size  and  small  food  and  beverage  

Level  7  –  125,500  sf    

• Events  plaza  &  spectacle  attraction  space  • Hotel  • Indoor  attraction  • Corridors  and  plaza  • Hotel  • Medium  and  small  retail  • Destination,  local  mid-­‐size  and  small  food  and  beverage  

   

Page 242: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

216  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  Program        

Page 243: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

217  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  Program  (continued)        

Page 244: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

218  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  Program  (continued)      

Page 245: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

219  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  Program  (continued)      

Page 246: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

220  

Schematic  Drawings  –  Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  Program  (continued)        

Page 247: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

221  

Financial  Projections  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance    

As  shown  below,   there   is  potential   for   the  proposed  Phase   I  programming   to  generate  moderate  profits   for   the   third  party  operations.    Whether  the  operating  profits  translate  positively  to  overall  economic  performance  will  ultimately  depend  on  the  leases/operating   agreements   that   are   executed,   as   well   as   the   type   of   financing   and   related   costs   to   develop   each   of   the  concepts.    The  STEM  facility  and  related  attractions  will  almost  certainly  operate  at  a  loss  and  will  require  either  corporate  or  philanthropic  support  to  sustain  operations.  

   

   

SF

RetailAnchor 50,000Medium 50,000Small 50,000Subtotal 150,000

Food8&8BeverageDestination 40,000Local8MidASize 60,000Small 25,000Subtotal 125,000

EntertainmentSTEMARelated8Museum/Attraction 40,000Indoor8Attraction 40,000Subtotal 80,000

Educational/ResearchSTEM8Center 70,000Subtotal 70,000

Hotel/Conference8CenterHotel8(1258Rooms) 92,000Conference8Center 140,000Subtotal 232,000

TOTAL 657,000

Gross0Revenues Operating0Margin NOI

40,000,000$888888888 5.0% 2,000,000$8888888888 830,000,000$888888888 5.0% 1,500,000$8888888888 825,000,000$888888888 5.0% 1,250,000$8888888888 895,000,000$888888888 4,750,000$8888888888 8

10,000,000$888888888 7.5% 750,000$888888888888812,000,000$888888888 7.5% 900,000$88888888888886,250,000$8888888888 8 7.5% 468,750$888888888888828,250,000$888888888 2,118,750$8888888888 8

3,250,000$8888888888 8 A35.0% (1,137,500)$888888888 88,000,000$8888888888 8 25.0% 2,000,000$8888888888 811,250,000$888888888 862,500$8888888888888

5,000,000$8888888888 8 A50.0% (2,500,000)$888888888 85,000,000$8888888888 8 (2,500,000)$888888888 8

5,560,547$8888888888 8 31.5% 1,750,000$8888888888 82,500,000$8888888888 8 10.0% 250,000$88888888888888,060,547$8888888888 8 2,000,000$8888888888 8

147,560,547$000000 4.9% 7,231,250$000000000

Page 248: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

222  

Summary  -­‐  Astrodome  Renaissance  

The  retail  and  food  and  beverage  components  will  determine  the  ultimate  financial  success  of  the  venue.  For  the  purposes  of  these   financial   projections,   it   was   assumed   that   the   rent   and   occupancy   costs   for   the   retail   and   food   and   beverage  programming  elements  were  roughly  $37  per  square  foot  and  that  third  party  operators  would  pay  rent  to  the  HCSCC.    The  rent   form   the   tenant   leases  would   be   used   to   fund   the   capital   costs   required   to   construct   the   “core   and   shell”   spaces   and  operate  the  Renaissance  improvements  within  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility.    The  projected  annual  rent  that  could  be  anticipated  from  the  third  party  tenants  in  Phase  I  of  the  Renaissance  Program  is  set  forth  below.      

RetailAnchorMediumSmallSubtotal

Food4&4BeverageDestinationLocal4Mid<SizeSmallSubtotal

EntertainmentSTEM<Related4Museum/AttractionIndoor4AttractionSubtotal

Educational/ResearchSTEM4CenterSubtotal

Hotel/Conference4CenterHotel4(1254Rooms)Conference4CenterSubtotal

TOTAL

Astrodome,Rent,($/SF)

Annual,Rent

35.00$44444444444444444 1,750,000$4444444444 442.00$44444444444444444 2,100,000$4444444444 442.00$44444444444444444 2,100,000$4444444444 4

5,950,000$4444444444 4

35.00$44444444444444444 1,400,000$4444444444 435.00$44444444444444444 2,100,000$4444444444 435.00$44444444444444444 875,000$4444444444444

4,375,000$4444444444 4

14.00$44444444444444444 560,000$444444444444414.00$44444444444444444 560,000$4444444444444

1,120,000$4444444444 4

10.50$44444444444444444 735,000$4444444444444735,000$4444444444444

4.0% 222,242$44444444444444.0% 100,000$4444444444444

322,242$4444444444444

12,502,242$,,,,,,,,

Page 249: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

223  

6.5  Summary  The  key  findings  related  to  the  options  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  are  summarized  below:  

Maintain  Status  Quo  

• Maintenance  and  capital  costs  will  increase  as  the  building  ages.  

• Deterioration  of  the  building  detracts  from  the  appeal  of  the  Complex.  

• Obstructs  site  circulation  and  event  operations.  

• Preserves  the  option  to  determine  a  best  use  in  the  future.  

• Continue  to  cost  money  while  returning  no  benefit.  

Reliant  Park  Plaza  

• Lowest  publicly  funded  Project  Cost.  

• Provides  additional  outdoor  event  space.  

• Includes  limited  additional  parking.  

• Reduces  current  Reliant  Park  maintenance  costs.  

• Improves  site  circulation  and  access.  

Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  

• Highest  publicly  funded  Project  Cost.  

• Expands  and  supports  core  business.  

• Reduces  operating  income.  

• Provides  interior,  column-­‐free,  high  bay  exhibition  space.  

• Creates  highly  marketable,  functional  and  unique  space.  

Page 250: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

224  

• Preserves  the  opportunity  for  additional  future  use.  

• Improves  site  circulation  and  access.  

• Creates  ideal  location  for  fairs,  festivals  and  performances.  

Astrodome  Renaissance  

• All  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  findings  apply,  including  opportunity  for  future  use.  

• Provides  opportunity  for  third  party  development.  

o There  are  significant  restrictions  on  the  site  that  would  impact  third  party  development.  

• Creates  a  regional  destination.  

General  Findings  

• Each  option  has  capital  costs  to  Harris  County.  Additionally,  some  options  have  operating  shortfalls.  

• Operating  restrictions  on  the  site  make  it  challenging  for  a  third  party  operator  to  justify  investment  to  redevelop  the  Astrodome.  

• The  STEM  concept  is  supported  by  several  of  the  stakeholders  in  Reliant  Park  and  could  be  an  important  addition  to  the  Harris   County   area   and   the   local   education   system.   Our   conversations   with   local   colleges   and   universities   have  indicated  a  willingness  to  participate  in  a  consortium  for  the  development  of  the  STEM  program  in  the  Astrodome.  

• The  costs  associated  with  any  STEM  development  and  operation  will  require  the  financial   involvement  of  the  private  sector.   This   will   also   require   the   creation   of   management   infrastructure   to   operate   the   program   and  maintain   the  facility.  

   

Page 251: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

225  

6.6  Financial  Projections  

 

Astrodome)Site)Option Status)Quo Reliant)Park)Plaza Astrodome)Multi8Purpose)Facility

Astrodome)Renaissance)[3]

Harris)County)FundingProject)Cost)[)1)] 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 63.9$))))))))))))))))))) 270.3$))))))))))))))))) 385.4$)))))))))))))))))[)8)])Other)Funding)(i.e.)Private,)Philanthropic,)Other)) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (115.1)$))))))))))))))))Total)Harris)County)Funding 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 63.9$))))))))))))))))))) 270.3$))))))))))))))))) 270.3$)))))))))))))))))Annual)Repair)and)Replacement 1.0$))))))))))))))))))))) 0.7$))))))))))))))))))))) 2.0$))))))))))))))))))))) 2.0$)))))))))))))))))))))

Operating)ResultsRevenue 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.5$))))))))))))))))))))) 1.7$))))))))))))))))))))) 1.7$)))))))))))))))))))))Expenses 8)))))))))))))))))))))))) (1.2)))))))))))))))))))))) (3.6)))))))))))))))))))))) (3.6))))))))))))))))))))))Net)Operating)Income 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (0.7)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )Rent)from)Third)Party)Operations 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 12.5$)))))))))))))))))))Incremental)Expenses)Related)to)Third)Party)Revenues (4.6)$))))))))))))))))))) )Incremental)Debt)Service)Related)to)Astrodome)Renaissance 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (8.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )Total)Income)(Loss) 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) (0.7)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (1.9)$))))))))))))))))))) ) (2.9)$))))))))))))))))))) )

Economic)ImpactTax)Revenue 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.1$))))))))))))))))))))) 0.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 8.1$)))))))))))))))))))))Direct)Spending 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 6.8$))))))))))))))))))))) 77.9$)))))))))))))))))))Total)Output 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 1.3$))))))))))))))))))))) 10.8$))))))))))))))))))) 125.5$)))))))))))))))))Personal)Earnings 8$)))))))))))))))))))))) 0.5$))))))))))))))))))))) 4.3$))))))))))))))))))))) 52.6$)))))))))))))))))))Jobs 0 18 153 2,221

["1"]"Project"costs"do"not"include"outstanding"Astrodome"debt.

Page 252: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Use  Analysis  

226  

6.7  Conclusions  and  Recommendations  It  is  recommended  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  be  selected  for  the  future  use  of  the  Astrodome  site  at  an  estimated  cost  of  $270.3  million,  not  including  the  debt  currently  outstanding  on  the  Astrodome.    This  recommendation  considers  more  than  just  the  financial  projections  as  it  recognizes  the  magnitude  of  potential  opportunities  offered  by  this  one-­‐of-­‐a-­‐kind  structure.  In  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option  the  event  floor  would  be  over  300,000  square  feet,  column  free  and  rising  to  a  height  of  over  200  feet.  The  result  is  any  event  is  possible,  making  Reliant  Park  a  truly  unique  destination.  There  is  simply  no  space  like  this  in  the  world  today.      

Retaining   the  Astrodome  as   a  multi-­‐purpose   facility   in   conjunction  with   the  Replacement  Arena  Project   increases   the   total  available  exhibition  space  by  nearly  33  percent,  further  expanding  the  number  and  types  of  events  that  can  be  brought  to  the  Complex  each  year.    This  additional  space  will  also  allow  the  Complex  to  satisfy  the  needs  of  the  OTC  and  will  greatly  enhance  the  likelihood  that  the  OTC,  will  continue  to  use  Reliant  Park  for  this  event  that  is  vital  to  the  Harris  County  economy.  

If  Harris  County  elects  to  pursue  the  Astrodome  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option,  it  preserves  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  option  if  sources  of  funding  become  available.    Analysis  of  the  Astrodome  Renaissance  has  been  unable  to  identify  a  mix  of  uses  that  can   be   financed   today   through   traditional   sources   but   the   Multi-­‐Purpose   Facility   allows   the   Renaissance   option   to   be  developed  when  funding  becomes  available.  

In  the  event  available  funds  are  not  sufficient  to  support  the  Multi-­‐Purpose  Facility  option,  then  Harris  County  should  consider  the  Reliant  Park  Plaza  option  at  an  estimated  Project  Cost  of  $63.9  million,  again  not  including  the  debt  currently  outstanding  on   the   Astrodome.     The   Reliant   Park   Plaza,   as   opposed   to   the   Status   Quo,   would   significantly   enhance   the   overall   guest  experience  and  site  circulation  and  create  new  event  opportunities  something  that  is  not  possible  with  the  Astrodome  in  its  current  condition.      

The  Status  Quo  option  is  not  recommended.    As  noted  above,  the  Astrodome  in  its  current  condition  negatively  impacts  event  operations  and  site  circulation.    The  facility  also  costs  between  $2  million  and  $3  million  annually  to  maintain,  an  amount  that  will   only   increase   as   the   venue   deteriorates   further.   The   Status  Quo   option   does   have   the   lowest   initial   cost   and   keeps   all  development  options  open  in  the  future.    However,  as  have  been  noted  above,  keeping  the  Astrodome  in  its  current  state  is  not  recommended.  

   

Page 253: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

227  

Appendices

Page 254: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

228  

Appendix  I:  Illustration  of  Nearby  Hotel  Support  –  Competitive  and  Comparable  Markets    

 

 

 Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  2,027    

 Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  3,251    

½ Mile Radius

Reliant Park

1

65

7

3

42

5 – Hyatt Place Hotel (164) 6 – Hilton Garden Inn (132) 7 – Hampton Inn and Suites (120)

1 – Crowne Plaza (630 rooms) 2 – Holiday Inn (235) 3 – Quality Inn (196) 4 – Homestead Studio Suites (165)

6 – In at the Ballpark (201) 7 – Courtyard by Marriott (191) 8 – Residence Inn by Marriott (171) 9 – Holiday Inn Express (112)

1 – Hilton Americans (1,230 rooms) 2 – Four Seasons (404) 3 – The Magnolia Hotel (314) 4 – Club Quarters (274) 5 – Embassy Suites Hotel (262)

½ Mile Radius

4

5

6

78

9

2

3

George R. BrownConvention Center1

Page 255: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

229  

 

 Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  1,089      

   Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  3,777  

       

1 – Hyatt Regency McCormick Place (800 rooms) 461 additional rooms expected to be added mid-2013 2 – Chicago South Loop Hotel (232)

6 – Aloft Dallas Downtown (193) 7 – Hotel Indigo (170) 8 – The Joule, Dallas (129) 9 – Hotel Lawrence Dallas (118)

1 – Hyatt Regency Dallas (1,122 rooms) 2 – Omni Dallas Conv. Cnt. Hotel (1,001) 3 – Adolphus Hotel (422) 4 – The Magnolia Hotel (330) 5 – Crowne Plaza Dallas (292)

½ Mile Radius

2

1McCormick Place 1

5

6

78

9

3

½ Mile Radius

4

2Dallas

Convention Center

Page 256: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

230  

 

 

 Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  6,594    

 Total   Hotel   Rooms   within   ½   Mile   =  2,017    

10 – Comfort Inn Downtown (231) 11 – Residence Inn by Marriott (229) 12 – Hilton Garden Inn (221) 13 – Ritz-Carlton Denver (202) 14 – Hotel Monaco (189) 15 – Courtyard by Marriott (177) 16 – Hampton Inn and Suites (148) 17 – Hotel Teatro (110)

1 – Sheraton Denver Hotel (1,225 rooms) 2 – Hyatt Regency Denver at CCC (1,100) 3 – Denver Marriott City Center (615) 4 – Grand Hyatt Denver (512) 5 – Westin Hotel Tabor Center (430) 6 – Crowne Plaza (634) 7 – The Curtis (336) 8 – Magnolia Hotel (246) 9 – Sheraton Denver Hotel (1,225)

1

3

5

2

4

6

78

910

11

12

13

14

1516

½ Mile Radius

ColoradoConvention Center

17

½ Mile Radius

Kansas CityConvention Center

12

3

4

5

1 –Marriot Kansas City Downtown (946 rooms) 2 – Crowne Plaza Kansas City (385) 3 – Hotel Phillips (217) 4 – Hilton President Hotel (213) 5 –Aladdin Holiday Inn (193)

Page 257: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

231  

 

   Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  1,828    

 

   Total  Hotel  Rooms  within  ½  Mile  =  10,803    

     

½ Mile Radius

1

KentuckyExpo Center

3

2

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

8 – Comfort Inn and Suites (97) 9 – Airport Expo Center Sleep Inn (75) 10 – Residence Inn by Marriott (72) 11 – Super 8 Airport Expo (68) 12 – Ramada Limited Airport (49) 13 – Howard Johnson Express (44)

1 – Crowne Plaza Airport (588 rooms) 2 – Hilton Garden Inn (208) 3 – Courtyard by Marriott Airport (150) 4 – Hampton Inn Airport/Expo Center (130) 5 – Country Inn and Suites Airport (121) 6 – SpringHill Suites (120) 7 – Holiday Inn Airport and Expo Center (106)

10 – Days Inn Convention Center (219) 11 – Comfort Suites (214) 12 – Hamton Inn Convention Center (170) 13 – Springhill Suites Convention Center (167) 14 – Hawthorn Suites Orlando Conv. Ctr. (135) 15 – Red Roof Inn (134) 16 – Extended Stay America (119) 17 – Extended Stay Deluxe Orlando (113)

1 – Peabody Orlando (1,641 rooms) 2 – Westgate Lakes Resort & Spa (1,596) 3 – Hilton Orlando Convention Center (1,417) 4 – Rosen Centre Hotel (1,334) 5 – DoubleTree Resort Orlando (1,094) 6 – Quality Inn Plaza (1,020) 7 – Rosen Plaza (800) 8 – Westin Imagine Orlando (315) 9 – Clarion Inn and Suites (221)

½ Mile Radius

7

Orange CountyConvention Center

124

5

11

8

9 10

1213

14

15

1716

3

6

Page 258: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

232  

Appendix  II:  Program  Benchmarks  In  order   to   analyze   the  potential  program   for   the  Astrodome  Renaissance  at  Reliant  Park,   the   team  assessed  a   selection  of  benchmarks   throughout   the   United   States   based   on   program,   performance   and  market.   The   following   case   studies   outline  those  benchmarks.  Selected  benchmarks  include:    

• L.A.  Live,  Los  Angeles,  California  

• Champions  Square,  New  Orleans,  Louisiana  

• Yerba  Buena  Gardens,  San  Francisco,  California  

• Georgia  World  Congress  Center,  Atlanta,  Georgia  

• PETCO  Park  &  Convention  Center,  San  Diego,  California  

• Kansas  City  Power  &  Light  District,  Kansas  City,  Missouri  

• Kentucky  Expo  Center,  Louisville,  Kentucky  

• Patriot  Place,  Foxboro,  Massachusetts  

• Lambeau  Field  –  Titletown,  Green  Bay,  Wisconsin  

• Columbus  Arena  District,  Columbus,  Ohio  

   

Page 259: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

233  

L.A.  Live,  Los  Angeles,  California  

Overview:  A  mixed-­‐use  urban  district  positioned  as  tourist-­‐oriented  sports  and  entertainment  hub  located  in  downtown  Los  Angeles,  CA.  

Opening  Date:  2007    

Size:  27  acre  site  and  350,  000-­‐400,000  net  square  feet  of  LA  Live  RD+E  

Tenant  Mix:  Dining,  entertainment  and  hotels  

Anchor  Tenants:  Nokia  Theater,  Club  Nokia,  Grammy  Museum,  ESPN  West  Coast  Broadcast  Headquarters  

Retail:  None  (currently)  

Dining:  ESPN  Zone,  Fleming’s  Prime  Steakhouse  &  Wine  Bar,  Katsuya,  Trader  Vic’s,  Wolfgang  Puck  Bar  &  Grill,  Yard  House  

Entertainment:   Nokia   Theater,   Club   Nokia,   Grammy  Museum,   14-­‐screen   Regal   Cineplex,   Lucky   Strike   Bowling,   The   Conga  Room  

Hotel  &  Residences:  Ritz-­‐Carlton  Hotel  and  Residences,  JW  Marriott  Hotel      

Page 260: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

234  

Major  Attractions:  Staples  Center,  Los  Angeles  Convention  Center  

Visitor  Volumes:  8-­‐10  million  (75-­‐  80%  resident,  20-­‐25%  tourists)  

Development  Costs:  $2.5  billion  (total  project)    

Parking/Access/Transportation:    

• A  parking  structure  on-­‐site  with  5,300  spaces    • MTA  station  on  7th  St.  and  Flower  St.  

   

Page 261: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

235  

Champions  Square,  New  Orleans,  Louisiana  

Overview:   Champions   Square   is   an   outdoor   festival   venue   used   for  corporate   events,   festivals   and   concerts.     It   is   located   in   the   Central  Business  District  of  New  Orleans,  Louisiana.  

Tenant  Mix:  Restaurants,  entertainment  

Attractions:  LaSalle  Street,  Club  XLIV,  Louisiana  Superdome    

Surrounding  Uses:  New  Orleans  Arena,  hotels,  office  

Sizing:  121,000  square  feet  

Opening  Date:  2010  

Parking  /  Access  /  Transportation:  

• Champions  Garage  is  adjacent  to  the  development  with  2,000  spaces  

• Multiple  garages  and  lots  are  available  around  the  Superdome  

 

Page 262: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

236  

Yerba  Buena  Gardens,  San  Francisco,  California  

Overview:  Located  on  87  acres  in  downtown  San  Francisco,  California,  an  urban  redevelopment  that  includes  retail  and  residential  space,  gardens  and  a  cultural  arts  district  

Tenant   Mix:   Hotels,   gardens,   retail,   attractions,   convention   center   and  entertainment  

Attractions:   Sony   Metreon,   Moscone   Convention   Center,   six   acres   of   gardens,  Zeum  (children’s  museum)   ,  Yerba  Buena  Center  for  the  Arts  (showcasing  local  San   Francisco   arts),   Historic   Charles   Looff   Carousel,   Yerba   Buena   Ice   Skating  Center,  Yerba  Buena  Bowling  Center  

Surrounding   Uses:   Residential   –   including   low   and  moderate   income   housing,  convention  center,  entertainment  and  recreation  facilities,  cultural  facilities  

Opening  Date:  1992    

Phasing  /  Expansions:  

• Phase  1  –1992    

• Phase  2  –1993  

• Phase   3   –1999,   opened  Metreon   and   added   Children’s   Garden   and  the  restored  carousel  

Parking  /  Access  /  Transportation:  

• Served  by  Bay  Area  Rail  Transit  (BART)  and  MUNI  (bus  system)  • Parking  available  at  3  garages  with  4,216  total  spaces  available  

Page 263: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

237  

Georgia  World  Congress  Center  Authority  Campus,  Atlanta,  Georgia  

Overview:    The  Georgia  World  Congress  Authority  Campus   is   located   in  the  convention   corridor   of   downtown   Atlanta   and   ranks   among   the   top   five  largest  convention  destinations  in  the  country.        

Tenant  Mix:  Entertainment,  convention  center  

Attractions:   The   Georgia   World   Congress   Center,   the   71,250-­‐seat   Georgia  Dome  and  21-­‐acre  Centennial  Olympic  Park    

Surrounding  Uses:  Cultural  attractions,  retail,  dining,  entertainment,  hotel  

Opening  Date:  Phase  1-­‐1976  (convention  center)    

Phasing/Expansions:  

• Phase  II  –  1985  (convention  center  expansion)  • Phase   III   –   1992   (convention   center   expansion   and   Georgia   Dome  

opening)  • 1996  -­‐  Centennial  Olympic  Park  opens  for  Olympic  games  • Phase  IV  –  2002  (convention  center  expansion)  

Owner:  State  owned  and  operated  

Visitation:  More  than  a  million  guests  attend  functions  at   the  convention  center  annually  and  an  estimated  3  million  people  visit  Centennial  Olympic  Park  annually  

   

Page 264: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

238  

Parking/Access/Transportation:  

• The  Georgia  World  Congress  Center  Authority  operates  six  surface   lots  and  two  parking  decks  on  campus  totaling  to  approximately  7,000  parking  spaces  

• The   campus   is   walking   distance   to   the   13,000   hotel   rooms   in   Downtown  Atlanta  

• The   GWCC   campus   is   served   by   two   MARTA   (Metropolitan   Atlanta   Rapid  Transit  Authority)  stations    

   

Page 265: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

239  

PETCO  Park  &  Convention  Center,  San  Diego,  California  

Overview:  PETCO  Park  and   the  San  Diego  Convention  Center   are  adjacent   to   each  other  and  adjacent  to  the  Gaslamp  Quarter  (an  outdoor  walk  able  urban  retail  and  dining  district)  in  Downtown  San  Diego  

Opening  Date:  PETCO  Park  opened  in  2004  while  the  convention  center  opened  in  1989  with  an  expansion  in  2001  to  double  its  size  

Owner/Manager:   City   of   San   Diego   and   the   San   Diego   Padres   are   owners   of   the  stadium  and  the  Padres  manage  the  stadium;  the  convention  center  is  managed  by  San  Diego  Convention  Center  Corporation  

Sizing:  The  convention  center  is  approximately  2.6  million  gross  square  feet  

Capacity:  PETCO  Park’s  capacity  is  approximately  42,500  and  the  convention  center  can  hold  up  to  125,000  at  one  time    

Estimated  Capital  Investment:  $450  million  to  construct  PETCO  Park;  $164  million  to  construct  the  San  Diego  Convention  Center  

   

Page 266: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

240  

Kansas  City  Power  &  Light  District,  Kansas  City,  Missouri  

Overview:  The  Kansas  City  Power  &  Light  District  is  a  mixed-­‐use  district  located  in  downtown  Kansas  City.    The  district  holds  more  than  50  restaurants,  bars,  shops  and  entertainment  venues.  The  district  is  a  nine-­‐block  neighborhood  that  links  the  Convention  Center  to  the  Sprint  Arena.  

Tenant  Mix:  Retail,  dining,  entertainment,  hotel  

Attractions:  Midland  Theater  by  AMC,  The  AMC  Mainstreet  Movie  Theater,  Convention  Center,  Sprint    

Arena,  KC  Live!  Entertainment  District  

Surrounding   Uses:   Hotel,   residential,  retail,   dining,   parks,   convention,   office,  parking  

Sizing:  500,000  square  feet  RDE    

Opening  Date:  2007  

Parking  /  Access  /  Transportation:  

• The   District   is   about   20  minutes   south   of   the   Kansas  City  International  Airport  and  less   than   8   minutes   south   of  the  Downtown  Airport    

   

Page 267: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

241  

Kentucky  Expo  Center,  Louisville,  Kentucky  

Overview:  The  Kentucky  Expo  Center   is  a  multi-­‐use  facility  with  other  sporting  venues  and  outdoor  facilities  on-­‐site  and  hosts  a  number  of  events  including  the  Kentucky  State  Fair,  the  North  American  International  Livestock  Exposition  and  the  National  Farm  Machinery  Show.    The   Kentucky   Exposition   Center   is   approximately   4   miles   south   of   downtown   Louisville  Kentucky.  

Tenant  Mix:  Convention  and  conference,  entertainment,  hotel    

Attractions:  Freedom  Hall  Coliseum,  Cardinal  Stadium,  Broadbent  Arena  

Surrounding   Uses:   Churchill   Downs,   Six   Flags   Kentucky   Kingdom   (closed),   Kentucky  International   Convention   Center,   Louisville   International   Airport,   University   of   Louisville,  residential,  golf,  dining,  retail  and  hotel  

Sizing:  1.3  million  square  feet  of  flexible  exhibit  space,  2,000  rooms  within  walking  distance  and  300  acres  of  outdoor  exhibit  and  demonstration  space  

   

Page 268: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

242  

Parking/Access/Transportation:  

• 19,000  parking  spots    • Five  minutes  from  Louisville  International  Airport  

   

Page 269: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

243  

Patriot  Place,  Foxboro,  Massachusetts  

Overview:   Patriot   Place   is   a   mixed   use   development   located   in   Foxboro,  Massachusetts,   approximately   30   miles   south   of   downtown   Boston   which   includes  Gillette  Stadium  as  the  anchor.  

Tenant  Mix:  Retail,  dining,  entertainment,  office,  hotel,  healthcare  and  theatre  

Attractions:  Gillette  Stadium,  Cinema  De  Lux,  Showcase  Live,  The  CBS  Scene,  Brigham  and   Women’s   /Mass   General   Health   Care   Center,   The   Hall   at   Patriot   Place   and  Renaissance  Hotel  

Surrounding   Uses:     Patriot   Place   is   located   in   a   low   density   residential   area   with  parking   surrounding   the   development   which   is   used   by   stadium   visitors.   Adjacent  Wynn  Casino  has  been  proposed  

Sizing:  1.3  million  square  feet  of  retail,  dining  and  entertainment  

Opening  Date:  2007;  Gillette  Stadium  opened  in  2002  

   

Page 270: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

244  

Parking/Access/Transportation:  • Free  parking  for  retail  customers  is  available  at  Patriot  Place  even  on  event  and  game  days  

   

Page 271: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

245  

Sports  and  Entertainment  District,  Green  Bay,  Wisconsin  

Overview:  A   sports   and   entertainment  district   adjacent   to   Lambeau  Field  which   is   located   about  5  minutes   away   from   the  downtown  area  of  Green  Bay.    There  is  no  defined  district  area  or  district  name  but  there  is  talk  of  future  plans.    

Tenant  Mix:  Retail,  hotel,  restaurant  

Attractions:  Lambeau  Field  

Surrounding   Uses:   Industrial   and   residential   neighborhoods,   hotels,   restaurants,   Brown   County   Memorial   Complex   where  sporting  events,  shows  and  concerts  are  held  and   includes  the  Resch  Center,    Shopko  Hall  and  the  Brown  County  Memorial  Arena  

Parking  /  Access  /  Transportation:  

• No  parking  structures  • Parking   lots   at   Lambeau   Field   and   adjacent   sports   and  

entertainment  district  • Residents  open   their  personal  homes   for  parking  during  games  

at  Lambeau  Field  • Close  access  to  freeway  

   

Page 272: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

246  

Columbus  Arena  District,  Columbus,  Ohio  

Overview:   The   Arena   District   is   a   75-­‐acre   mixed-­‐use   development   located   in  downtown   Columbus,   Ohio.   This   urban   neighborhood   features   premier   office  space,   a   variety   of   restaurants,   entertainment   venues   and   residential   housing.  Acres   of   park   and  plaza   areas   provide   open   space.   The   district   is   home   to   the  NHL’s  Columbus  Blue  Jackets  (Nationwide  Arena)  and  AAA  baseball’s  Columbus  Clippers  (Huntington  Park).        

Tenant  Mix:  Office,  residential,  retail,  dining,  entertainment,  and  hotel  and  park  space  

Attractions:   Nationwide   Arena,   Huntington   Park,   Arena   Grand   Movie   Theatre,   Dispatch   Ice   Haus,   Lifestyle   Communities  Pavilion,  Arena  District  Athletic  Club  

Surrounding  Uses:  Columbus  Convention  Center,   arts  and   entertainment   area   (The   Short   North),   public  market  (The  North  Market),  residential,  office  retail  

Opening  Date:  The  district  began  development   in   the  late  1990s  

Owner/Manager:     Developed   and   managed   by  Nationwide  Realty  Investors  (NRI)  

Sizing:   1.5   million   square   feet   of   office   and   RD+E  space,  685,000  square  feet  Nationwide  Arena,  10,000-­‐seat  Huntington  Park,  500  residential  units  

Visitation:   2.5   million   visitors   annually   to   the  Columbus  Convention  Center  

   

Page 273: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

247  

Proposed  Astrodome  Renaissance  –  Entertainment  Business  Models  (Phase  II  –  Attractions)                                                            

Market and Economic Characteristics Indoor Entertainment Center Concept

Sizing Range (footprint) 40,000 - 80,000 sq.ft.

Pricing Model (gated/non-gated) pay-as-you-go Average Length of Stay (range) 1.5 - 2.5 hours

Concept Positioning Family market

Attendance Potential Attendance/Visitation Range 300,000 - 600,000 Financial Business Model commercial Headline Price (midpoint of range) n/a Admissions Yield Range 50% - 60% Per Capita Expenditure Range $15.00 - $20.00 (incl. admissions, food & beverage, merchandise, other) Total Revenue Generation (range) $4.5 - $12 million (based on medium attendance/per capita range) Operating Margin (% NOI/EBITDA) 25% - 35% (based on earned income) Investment Preliminary Investment Level (based on industry standards) $20 - $30 million

(cost of attraction development only, no additional

allocation for land or infrastructure development costs) Development and Operations

Developer/Operator Joint Venture

(HCSCC/SMG/Operator)

Source: ECA

Examples Dave & Buster's, Lucky Strike!, Sega Republic

Page 274: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

248  

             

Market and Economic Characteristics Corporate Attraction Concept

Sizing Range (footprint) 30,000 - 50,000 sq.ft.

Pricing Model (gated/non-gated) pay-one-price Average Length of Stay (range) 1 - 1.5 hours

Concept Positioning Family market (some

business market)

Attendance Potential Attendance/Visitation Range 150,000 - 450,000 Financial Business Model corporate Headline Price (midpoint of range) $15.00 Admissions Yield Range 45% - 60% Per Capita Expenditure Range $12.00 - $18.00 (incl. admissions, food & beverage, merchandise, other) Total Revenue Generation (range) $2 - $8 million (based on medium attendance/per capita range) Operating Margin (% NOI/EBITDA) (20%) - (35%) (based on earned income) Investment Preliminary Investment Level (based on industry standards) $10 - $25 million

(cost of attraction development only, no additional

allocation for land or infrastructure development costs) Development and Operations

Developer/Operator Joint Venture

(HCSCC/SMG/Corporation)

Source: ECA

Examples

World of Coke, Ben & Jerry's, Louisville Slugger, Corning Museum of Glass, Crayola

Factory

Page 275: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

249  

                 

Market and Economic Characteristics Texas Museum/Hall of Fame Concept

Sizing Range (footprint) 40,000 - 80,000 sq.ft.

Pricing Model (gated/non-gated) pay-one-price Average Length of Stay (range) 2 - 3 hours

Concept Positioning Family market. Education-

based potential

Attendance Potential Attendance/Visitation Range 100,000 - 500,000 Financial Business Model non-profit Headline Price (midpoint of range) $10.00 Admissions Yield Range 40% - 60% Per Capita Expenditure Range $6.00 - $12.00 (incl. admissions, food & beverage, merchandise, other) Total Revenue Generation (range) $600,000 - $6 million (based on medium attendance/per capita range) Operating Margin (% NOI/EBITDA) (20%) - (50%) (based on earned income) Investment Preliminary Investment Level (based on industry standards) $20 - $50 million

(cost of attraction development only, no additional

allocation for land or infrastructure development costs) Development and Operations

Developer/Operator Joint Venture

(HCSCC/SMG/Operator)

Source: ECA

Examples

Bob Bulluck Texas State History Museum, National

Museum of American History, Pro Football HOF, Kentucky Derby Museum,

Country Music HOF

Page 276: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

250  

Appendix  III:  Additional  Museum  Concepts  Considered    In  addition  to  the  ideas  listed  in  6.0  Astrodome  Site  Future  Analysis,  below  is  a  list  of  additional  museum  attractions  considered  for  this  study:    

• Energy  • Space  • Harris  County  History  • Area  Icons  and  Personalities  • Texas  Medical  Center  and  healthcare  Leadership  • Diversity/Racial  Transformation  and  Internalization  • Harris  County  “Over  the  Horizon”  Future  • Planetarium  • International  Museum  of  Houston  • National  Petroleum  Hall  of  Fame  • Museum  of  Play  • Interactive  Live  Broadcasting  Museum  

     

Page 277: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

251  

Appendix  IV:  Construction  Cost  Estimates  Included   in   this   section  are  construction  estimates   for  each  of   the  Master  Plan  Components.    These  estimates  are  based,   in  most  cases,  on  assumptions  derived  from  historical  construction  costs  for  work  similar  in  scope  to  the  proposed  Master  Plan  component  or  subcomponent.  Not  included  in  these  estimates,  are  other  costs  related  to  design,  permitting,  legal  fees,  project  management   fees,   escalation,   furniture,   fixtures   and   equipment,   delivery   of   utilities   to   the   component   site,   contingency   or  other  soft  costs.  Allowances  for  these  costs  are  included  in  the  Project  Cost  estimates  used  within  the  report.        

Page 278: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2

,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2

8)6;84 ?=97!;)6;84C(?DE"(8F'$D&- G9H 6D'%#(IJKL"'(7D- M(/(G9H 486=9

!"#$%&'()%*+()#%N%

)*+#,-.-#/ 01234)456"7")456"080265692:")654;<2<49"="<5>432"?<;; !:@AA:AAA""""""" (%:A(B:BB' !CD(%

>,EFE"G#/H.IJK.-#/ 36;<092">03L">;0M0 !:@AA:AAA""""""" (%:NB':AN@ !CDO@

6D'%#(!"#$%&'()%*+()#%N% %A:NO(:%!! @'DC'

,J#'$O)J*FD-"(H%P$#$'Q 5P;2<7>P3>416"?0G<;<2Q !:@'(:AAA""""""" (!A:A!@:!CN !%!DCN

3-'*DKDE"(!"&%$--%&P" 01234)456"3690<1109G6 !:'NO:AAA""""""" (C(:C%B:!BN !%NDC!

!"F#%P"E"&'(3*"&%()*DR"P'

>*I$#I+E/K*"0I*/E 03690"RS(O%&T1?"E,,#UE/K*"-/K,JV-/W"+EIXJYH&K#/.-/W*/KZ[ (%A:AAA"""""""""" N':O%A:AAA (O%DAA 9#"V*.E-,*V"\JVW*."E.".]-H".-+*

6^]-\-.-#/"="5**.-/W"1YEK* G69263"6_>091<49 NOA:@%@"""""""""" !%':O(!:B'C (@NDOO 8JVW*."]EH"/#."\**/"JYVE.*V

?*H.-`E,">,EFE C:O(B:N!O

8I-VW*"R3*,-E/."G*/.*I".#"0H.I#V#+*[ )456"G4996G243 (B:AAA"""""""""""" !(:N(N:A@A %(NDA' 8JVW*."]EH"/#."\**/"JYVE.*V

>EIX-/W"TEIEW* 03690"T030T6 !:A%A:AAA""""""" @%:N'(:@C( @@DC' 8JVW*."]EH"/#."\**/"JYVE.*V

1-.*">E`-/W </K,JV*H"a*H.I-VW*"2J//*, N:'C!:@%O

)*+#,.-#/"R0I*/E"=">,E/."<<[ %:B%!:(BB 9#"V*.E-,*V"\JVW*."E.".]-H".-+*

6D'%#(!"F#%P"E"&'(3*"&%()*DR"P' (CO:'BO:!('

5D'"#

b#.*,"R!:AAA"X*ZH[ N'B:AAA"""""""""" (O(:@@%:'AO @C'D!% 8JVW*."]EH"/#."\**/"JYVE.*V

b#.*,"TEIEW* B!:C%A:(!!

6D'%#(5D'"# @!B:('N:A!C

IJKL"'("-'$E%'"($-(S%-"K(DTT(DT()DFJ#DJ-(9'JKQU(("E%$#(K%'"K(.2O2.O21..(%&K(E""'$&L/PD&T"*"&P"(P%##(1.O1VO21.2U((6W$-(SJKL"'(*"T#"P'-(PJ**"&'(K%Q(F*$P$&L(%&K(KD"-(&D'($&P#JK"("-P%#%'$D&U((

Page 279: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2396!8?8,=(C(?8,=(3D36=,=46E(?=,8F;6;84(G(;,)8!6(H;FF

.E011E111((((( I9H

(?"-J*$K'$L&( M'N :, :&$'(7L-' 6L'%#(7L-'

?$O$-$L&(2(9$'"PL*+ACM Abatement (SC) Including Helix Ramps 1 LS %*&++*+++,++ %*&++*+++

Haz / Mat Abatement: W/ Above

Demo Structure & Remove from Site (Implosion) !*-++*+++"""""" ./0 1,+) 2*()+*%++(This assumes that the salvage value belongs to the demolition subcontractor. This does not include removal of the foundations.)

Demo & Remove from Site Existing Concrete Paving, Sidewalks and Curbs !+%*)++""""""""" /0 !,&+ !&1*-++

Temp Protection @ Adjacent Buildings / Clean Glass !""""""""""""""""""""" 34456 )++*+++,++ )++*+++

Fill at Plaza Area w/ Rough Surface Grading to Drain &11*)27""""""""" 89 !+,++ &*11)*2(((No Select Fill and Assume 90% Compaction)

Remove Berms - Assume 20' tall berms, 85% around the Dome plus 1.4 Swell Factor (Truck Yards) 19,613 89 (,++ !&1*7+%(Includes laod & removal form the site.)

Temporary Sub-Surface Dewatering for Fill Operations 1 34456 )&+*+++,++ )&+*+++Equipment Rental / Diesel / Maintenance 6 :5 !)*+++,++ 2)*+++(Assume 6 Months)

Site UtilitiesStorm Drainage System 18 38;</ /=

Sanitary Sewer System 18 38;</ /=

Domestic Water at Support Buildings 18 38;</ /=

Chilled Water - connected @ Carruth plaza (Not Required: Packaged units at Support Buildings) - 40 /=

Grease Traps for Concessions 20,000 /0 /=4" PVC Site Grease Waste Piping 400 40 /=

Site Gas Piping to Out Buildings 18 38;</ /=

Event Water Distribution @ Plaza Areas 1 ALLOW /=

Saw Cut / Repair Existing Concrete & Asphalt Paving for Utility Tie-ins and Haul Traffic Damages (Allowance) 15,000 /0 /=

Patch / Plug Existing Utilities 1 34456 /=

Page 280: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

)"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2396!8?8,=(C(?8,=(3D36=,=46E(?=,8F;6;84(G(;,)8!6(H;FF

.E011E111((((( I9H

(?"-J*$K'$L&( M'N :, :&$'(7L-' 6L'%#(7L-'Site Paving6" VIP Parking Area at South West Quad (Includes Sub- Grade Grading) !%7*27+""""""""" /0 /=

6" Site Paving Outside Plaza (Includes Sub Grade Grading) )7&*-&2""""""""" /0 /=

6" Site Paving at Previous Dome Location (Includes Sub-Grade Grading) -7-*27+""""""""" /0 /=

Assumed Paving Upgrades @ 6" Site Paving (50%) -%%*&2%""""""""" /0 /=

Curb and Gutter Tie-in 1*)(+""""""""""""" 40 /=

Misc Paving: Assume 12' wide circumference around Dome "island" 2&*-1+""""""""""" /0 /=

Assumed Paving Lime Stabilization: 100% of the VIP Parking & Site Paving Areas !+!*&(7""""""""" /9 /=

Water Feature !""""""""""""""""""""" 34456 /=

Landscaping / Irrigation (18 acres minus paving area) 7%*7--""""""""""" /0 /=

Temporary Painted Wood Construction Fence w/ Gates: Up & Down 1*)(+""""""""""""" 40 )+,++ !)&*1++

Division 2 Subtotal .QER@0ERR2

Division 9 FinishesToilet/Concessions/Support at grade level (8EA - 5,000 SF each). Includes CMU walls, roof, finishes and MEP. Food Service equipment OFOI. &+*+++""""""""""" /0 /=

Awnings at Support Buildings (2000 LF x 10' wide, both sides) %+*+++""""""""""" /0 /=

Division 9 Subtotal 1

?$O$-$L&(.1(9K"J$%#'$"-

6>?$@AB@AC".D>EF@GH"'"/@CA>CI"'"/JD@E@AC !""""""""""""""""""""" 34456 /=

Page 281: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

-"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2396!8?8,=(C(?8,=(3D36=,=46E(?=,8F;6;84(G(;,)8!6(H;FF

.E011E111((((( I9H

(?"-J*$K'$L&( M'N :, :&$'(7L-' 6L'%#(7L-'KID@LIJID"8D#MB"8#AJD#N"O>DD@IDH !""""""""""""""""""""" 34456 /=

(?$O$-$L&(.1(9K"J$%#'$"-(6L'%#( 1

?$O$-$L&(.A(=F=76!;73FDemo Existing Sub-Station D<(8S4=! +

New Underground Primary Electric Service (Fannin to Arena) 1,050 LF 2&+,++ 2(2*&++

New Electrical Service from Arena Plaza and Plant 2 500 LF 2&+,++ -2&*+++

New Switchgear for Arena - (2) 4000 Amp Panels (primary duct bank included above) 1 ALLOW )++*+++,++ )++*+++

New Switchgear for Plaza - $50k per Support Building 1 ALLOW /=

Site Lighting 784,080 GSF /=Decorative Light Pole Upgrades 1 ALLOW /=

Low Voltage: Conduit/Cabling/Site Landscape Lighting 400 EA /=

Event Cabling Raceways / Pits 1 ALLOW /=

Event Electrical Distribution Raceways 4 EA /=

Event Show Power, per Quad 4 EA /=1,362,500

Temporary Electrical Service / Electrical Consumption Charges 20 MO /=

Low Voltage: Surveillance SystemPOS Surveillance Cameras 16 EA /=Plaza Pole Mounted Surveillance Cameras 30 EA /=3" PVC Raceway w/ Inner-duct and Cabling to Stadium 800 LF /=Site Conduit Raceways w/ Cabling 3,000 LF /=Recording Equipment Revisions/Racks 1 ALLOW /=Conduit and Connections to Existing Building 1 ALLOW /=

0

Division 16 Subtotal .E0A2ET11

6863F(7896(8H(S8!U 21E01AE@R2

9:D6863F(7896(8H(S8!U )+*-+1*%7) !&,1).IAID>N"8#AB@J@#AH"P1QR !*)!(*-7+ +,7%/STG#AJD>GJ#D"O#AB"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V"!,)&QR )&-*(-! +,)+

Page 282: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2396!8?8,=(C(?8,=(3D36=,=46E(?=,8F;6;84(G(;,)8!6(H;FF

.E011E111((((( I9H

(?"-J*$K'$L&( M'N :, :&$'(7L-' 6L'%#(7L-'OS@NB@AC"KIDL@J"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V,)+%QR %!*%)& +,+-OS@NBIDH";@HU"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V",-12QR 2%*&)& +,+1.IAID>N"4@>T@N@J?"=AHSD>AGI"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V",2+(QR !%-*22+ +,!!)*LV"J'(9WX'L'%# ))*+-(*%-- !1,7&8:W;"0II"W"-,&Q 22!*-%& +,&7.8"O#AB"P/STJ#J>N"V",(-&QR !(%*+)! +,!%)*LV"J'(6L'%# ))*77-*277 !2,178#AJ@ACIAG?"W"!+Q"X"G#HJ"#$"M#DU )*+-+*1%7 !,&1)*LV"J'(I*%&Y(6L'%# )&*+)%*%%( !7,)&

Page 283: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2!=C;346()3!D()C3E3

.F011F111((((( G9H

(?"-I*$J'$K&( L'M :, :&$'(7K-' 6K'%#(7K-'

?$N$-$K&(2(9$'"OK*+ACM Abatement (SC) Including Helix Ramps 1 LS *+

Haz / Mat Abatement: W/ Above

Demo Structure & Remove from Site (Implosion) !,-..,..."""""" /*0 *+

Demo & Remove from Site Existing Concrete Paving, Sidewalks and Curbs !.%,)..""""""""" *0 *+

Temp Protection @ Adjacent Buildings / Clean Glass !""""""""""""""""""""" 12234 *+

Plaza Area Final Grading: Top Dress Existing Subgrade (9") & Fine Grade for Hardscaping (No Select Fill: 90% Compaction) !!,!55""""""""""" 67 !89.. !5(,()&

Remove Berms - Assume 20' tall berms, 85% around the Dome plus 1.4 Swell Factor (Truck Yards) 19,613 67 *+

Temporary Sub-Surface Dewatering for Fill Operations 1 12234 *+Equipment Rental / Diesel / Maintenance 6 :3 *+(Assume 6 Months)

Site UtilitiesStorm Drainage System 18 16;<* )&,...9.. %&.,...

Sanitary Sewer System 18 16;<* (,...9.. !%%,...

Domestic Water at Support Buildings 18 16;<* 8,...9.. !.(,...

Chilled Water - connected @ Carruth plaza (Not Required: Packaged units at Support Buildings) - 20 !,&..9.. .

Grease Traps for Concessions 20,000 *0 )9.. %.,...4" PVC Site Grease Waste Piping 400 20 !(9.. 5,)..

Site Gas Piping to Out Buildings 18 16;<* 8,...9.. !.(,...

Event Water Distribution @ Plaza Areas 1 ALLOW )&.,...9.. )&.,...

Saw Cut / Repair Existing Concrete & Asphalt Paving for Utility Tie-ins and Haul Traffic Damages (Allowance) 15,000 *0 59&. !!),&..

Patch / Plug Existing Utilities 1 12234 &.,...9.. &.,...

Site Paving6" VIP Parking Area at South West Quad (Includes Sub- Grade Grading) !%=,5=.""""""""" *0 89.. (=(,5%.

Page 284: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

)"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2!=C;346()3!D()C3E3

.F011F111((((( G9H

(?"-I*$J'$K&( L'M :, :&$'(7K-' 6K'%#(7K-'6" Site Paving Outside Plaza (Includes Sub Grade Grading) )=&,-&5""""""""" *0 89.. !,55),!%)

6" Site Paving at Previous Dome Location (Includes Sub-Grade Grading) -=-,5=.""""""""" *0 89.. ),-8),5%.

Assumed Paving Upgrades @ 6" Site Paving (50%) -%%,&5%""""""""" *0 89.. ),.85,%%!

Curb and Gutter Tie-in 8,)(.""""""""""""" 20 !%9.. (5,=).

Misc Paving: Assume 12' wide circumference around Dome "island" 5&,-8.""""""""""" *0 (9.. 8.),((.

Assumed Paving Lime Stabilization: 100% of the VIP Parking & Site Paving Areas !.!,&(=""""""""" *7 &9.. &.5,=%-

Water Feature !""""""""""""""""""""" 12234 ),...,...9.. ),...,...

Landscaping / Irrigation (18 acres minus paving area) =%,=--""""""""""" *0 &9.. %5%,88&

Temporary painted Wood Constr. Fence w/ Gates: Up/Dn 8,)(.""""""""""""" 20 *+

Division 2 Subtotal .2F222FPPA

Division 9 FinishesToilet/Concessions/Support at grade level (8EA - 5,000 SF each). Includes CMU walls, roof, finishes and MEP. Food Service equipment OFOI. &.,...""""""""""" *0 =.9.. %,&..,...

Awnings at Support Buildings (2000 LF x 10' wide, both sides) %.,...""""""""""" *0 )&9.. !,...,...

Division 9 Subtotal QFQ11F111

?$N$-$K&(.1(9J"I$%#'$"-

4>?$@AB@AC"/D>EF@GH"'"*@CA>CI"'"*JD@E@AC !""""""""""""""""""""" 12234 !5&,...9.. !5&,...

KID@LIJID"6D#MB"6#AJD#N"O>DD@IDH !""""""""""""""""""""" 12234 !&.,...9.. !&.,...

(?$N$-$K&(.1(9J"I$%#'$"-(6K'%#( 02QF111

Page 285: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

-"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2!=C;346()3!D()C3E3

.F011F111((((( G9H

(?"-I*$J'$K&( L'M :, :&$'(7K-' 6K'%#(7K-'

?$N$-$K&(.A(=C=76!;73CDemo Existing Sub-Station R<(8S4=! .

New Underground Primary Electric Service (Fannin to Arena) 1,050 LF *+

New Electrical Service from Arena Plaza and Plant 2 500 LF *+

New Switchgear for Arena - (2) 4000 Amp Panels (primary duct bank included above) 1 ALLOW *+

New Switchgear for Plaza - $50k per Support Building 1 ALLOW %..,...9.. %..,...

Site Lighting 784,080 GSF .95& &((,.8.Decorative Light Pole Upgrades 1 ALLOW &.,...9.. &.,...

Low Voltage: Conduit/Cabling/Site Landscape Lighting 400 EA -&.9.. !%.,...

Event Cabling Raceways / Pits 1 ALLOW %..,...9.. %..,...

Event Electrical Distribution Raceways 4 EA &.,...9.. )..,...

Event Show Power, per Quad 4 EA &.,...9.. )..,...1,978,060

Temporary Electrical Service / Electrical Consumption Charges 20 MO &,...9.. !..,...

Low Voltage: Surveillance SystemPOS Surveillance Cameras 16 EA %,)..9.. 85,)..Plaza Pole Mounted Surveillance Cameras 30 EA %,)..9.. !)8,...3" PVC Raceway w/ Inner-duct and Cabling to Stadium 800 LF )&.9.. )..,...Site Conduit Raceways w/ Cabling 3,000 LF -.9.. =.,...Recording Equipment Revisions/Racks 1 ALLOW !5&,...9.. !5&,...Conduit and Connections to Existing Building 1 ALLOW &.,...9.. &.,...

708,200

Division 16 Subtotal 2F1TUF1A1

6863C(7896(8H(S8!D [email protected]

9:R6863C(7896(8H(S8!D ).,%(.,!&8 !&95&/IAID>N"6#AB@J@#AH"P8QR !,))(,(.= .9=&*STG#AJD>GJ#D"O#AB"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V"!9)&QR )&8,..) .9).OS@NB@AC"KIDL@J"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V9).%QR %!,5(. .9.-OS@NBIDH";@HU"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V"9-85QR 5&,!8) .9.8/IAID>N"2@>T@N@J?"+AHSD>AGI"PG#HJ"#$"M#DU"V"95.(QR !%&,... .9!!)*KV"I'(9WX'K'%# )),))8,=.( !59!.6:W;"0II"W"-9&Q 555,=%) .98.

Page 286: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%& ./01/.2,34536634(78496!:76;84(78,)34< !=>;9=?(@/1A/.2B(@/.0/.2B(@/2@/.2!=C;346()3!D()C3E3

.F011F111((((( G9H

(?"-I*$J'$K&( L'M :, :&$'(7K-' 6K'%#(7K-'/6"O#AB"P*STJ#J>N"V"9(-&QR !(&,&=& .9!%)*KV"I'(6K'%# )-,!=.,%%& !59(%6#AJ@ACIAG?"W"!)Q"X"G#HJ"#$"M#DU ),%&5,8!= !9(=)*KV"I'(G*%&Y(6K'%# )&,8%(,.8- !=95-

Page 287: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

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

.NO0.AO@V0 9UT(I(&$

</0#"F-;:1@"#D.B:E/",8E@"8:1/":198DE/E":1"F-;:1@",/8#T 6 6 6766 6

</0#"B/-.:1@"V"$8##AB".#"W<W"8:1/"=:198DE/E"-,#;/C 6 6 6766 66

X/0F"BY#A:1@"Z"B.AD9.DA-8"E/0# NL45666 3J 67>% (L%5%666

H-A.YT#AU"=:198DE/E":1"F-;:1@"1D0,/AB",/8#TC 66

"#RIF#!H#*R- 6R/0#;/"S/A0B"Z")BBD0/"(6[".-88",/A0B5"'%?"-A#D1E".Y/"<#0/"F8DB"!74"3T/88"J-9.#A"=XAD9U"\-AEBC !L5P!N *\ '766 !%P5L64

69%(#!:(%$%(%#- 63:./"2:@Y.:1@]"^1"/8/9.A:9-8 6

Page 288: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

("#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(3.#A0"EA-:1-@/5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

3-1:.-AK"B/T/A5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

<#0/B.:9"T-./A5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666011O111 9UT(I(&$

*Y:88/E"T-./A"Z"9#11/9./E"a"*-AAD.Y"F8-b- !5%66 2J !5%66766 (5(%656666

XD11/8"$A#0"I-AU:1@".#"P!6"=3/F-A-./"HB.:0-./C 6 23 1&- 66

9%(#!;RY*IF#R#'(-!]!5&*L-X&Y# 6PW"39#A/E"9#19A/./"F-;:1@"=,D:8E:1@".#"9DA,"8:1/C"^198DE/B"BD,"@A-E/"FA/F7">%?"F-;:1@"&"(%?"@A//1"-A/- NNN5'P6 3J P766 (566N5!P(

PW"*#8#A/E"&"B.-0F/E"9#19A/./"=cF@A-E/"%6?C !PP5LN6 3J P766 !566!5%'!

*DA,"-1E"MD../A"X:/Z:1 P5('6 2J !4766 '>5L(6

+:B9"I-;:1@ >%5NP6 3J '766 P6(5''60OANVOV@2 9UT(I(&$

</0#"/G:B.:1@"A-0FB"-1E"8#-E:1@"E#9UB '%5666 3J !7%6 !(>5%66

</0#"/G:B.:1@"B:E/T-8UB N%5666 3J !7%6 %(5%666

J/19:1@"V"M-./B"a"2#-E:1@"<#9U")A/-"_18K P(' 2J %6766 N!54666

C&'L-X&Y#!]!;**%Q&(%I' 6 6 6766 6PW"39#A/E"9#19A/./"F-;:1@"=,D:8E:1@".#"9DA,"8:1/C"^198DE/B"BD,"@A-E/"FA/F7">%?"F-;:1@"&"(%?"@A//1"-A/- !!!5('> 3J N766 NNN5'P6

6QKEA#"0D89Y"&"B#EE:1@ ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

63.-,:8:b/E"9#1B.AD9.:#1"/1.A-19/ ( H) P5%66766 !N5666

63.#A0"`-./A"RD1#$$"IA/;/1.:#1 N5%!( 2J %7%6 !L5N!P

6^18/."IA#./9.:#1 46 H) !66766 45666

?%F%-%I'!2!6I(&$ 2AOANVONSV

Page 289: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

N"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(?%F%-%I'!0!7I'X*#(# 6EIU'L&(%I'-!]!H#$IJ!K*&L# 6)D@/A"*-B."I:8/B"$#A"2/;/8"N"38-,"=-BBD0/"N6["G"N6["@A:E"5"L6["8#1@C7")BBD0/"%"-D@/A"9-B."F:8/B"F/A"9-F7")A/-":B"-BBD0/E".#",/":1B:E/".Y/"N"/G:B.:1@"9#8D01B"-."F/A:0/./A !%(5'N6 2J !L766 (5L6N5>>6

6I:8/"*-FB N46 H) !65666766 N5NLP5(((

6*#19A/./"B8-,"#1"@A-E/"=/G:B.:1@"F8-K:1@"$:/8E".#"A/0-:1C 6 3J P766 6

6d/T"H8/;-./E"38-,"-."2/;/8"N5":198DE/B"9#8D01B"$A#0"F8-K:1@"$:/8E"8/;/8 NL45666 3J N'766 !45L>(5666

*#19A/./"/19-B/0/1."-."-88"/GF#B/E"B.//8"9#8B"Z"1#."-FF8:9-,8/5"-BBD0/E"$:A/"FA##$/E"=B//"<:;">C (!> H) 6766 6

+#E:$K"/G:B.:1@"=/8/;-./E"$A#0"F8-K:1@"8/;/8C"B.AD9.DA/"-."F/A:0/./A"=-BBD0/"(((%[GN6[C PP5>%6 3J !(766 '6!5666

+#E:$K"B8-,"TY/A/"0#;/-,8/"E/9U"T-B"A/0#;/E" PN5%(6 3J !(766 >P(5(46

^1$:88"&"F#DA"B8-,"-."#8E"ED@#D."8#9-.:#1B"=-BBD0/"("/-5"!6[G>%[GN["E//FC !P> *\ !%>766 (P5!P>

^1$:88"&"F#DA"B8-,"-."#8E".DA$"F:."8#9-.:#1B"=-BBD0/"('6[GN6[G!(["E//FC N5>NN *\ !%>766 %'P5!NN

^1$:88"-."HG:B.:1@"+#;/-,8/"</9U"XA-9UB !4' *\ !%>766 (N5(%L

^1$:88"-."HG:B.:1@"XA/19Y"<A-:1 ' *\ !%>766 !5(%P

+:B9"^1$:88"-."E/FA/BB/E"-A/-B ! )22_` >%5666766 >%5666

")EE"1/T"HB9-8-.#A"I:.B"=-BBD0/"("/B9-8-.#AB"F/A"F:.C"d_X"RHec^RH<" H) (%5666766 6

"d/T"H8/;-.#A"I:.B"$#A"I-BB/1@/A"H8/;-.#AB"Z"d_X"RHec^RH<" H) !%5666766 6

"d/T".-F/A/E"9#19A/./",/-0"=:1$:88C"-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A" N6"""""""""""""""""""" JX 4%6766 !N5%66.SO2@SO1VA 9UT(I(&$

Page 290: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(d/T"XAD9U")99/BB"R-0FB"$#A"H;/1."3/.DF"=("/-9Y"-."N66["G"!P["T:E/"$#88#T:1@".Y/"F/A:0/./A"#$".Y/"E#0/5":198DE/B"E/0#"-1E"/-A.YT#AUC L5P66 3J P6766 %>P5666

6=P(#*%I*!)*#X&-(!"#Y$&X#R#'( 6766 6NNN5>%6"B$"#$"BU:1"=P6?"FA/9-B."46?"@8-b:1@C5"F#T/AT-BY"-1E"B/-8" (665(%6 3J 1&- 6

"^1$:88"IA/9-B."-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A" !56L("""""""""""""" 3J N%766 N'5((66

?%F%-%I'!0!6I(&$ [email protected]@OSAW

?%F%-%I'!@!,&-I'*[ 6c1:."+-B#1AK""=O.K"-B"-88#T-19/C" 6^1$:88"HG:B.:1@"<##A")A/-B !5>L( 3J !%766 (P5''6

"H8/;-.#A"3Y-$."$#A"d/T"3/A;:9/"H8/;-.#AB"" P5(46 3J !%766 LN5P66

"*+c"3Y-$."`-88B"$#A"I-BB/1@/A"H8/;-.#AB"=4"/-9Y5"!6[G!6[G46[".-88"2/;/8"!ZNC" P5466"""""""""""""" 3J !%766 LP5666

"(6"["*+c"T-88B"-."-88"8/;/8B"TY/A/"B/-.B"Y-;/",//1"A/0#;/E".#",8#9U";:/T"#$"9#19#DAB/"-A/-" !(%5N(6"""""""""" 3J !%766 !5'>L5'66

"^1$:88",A:9U"&"*+c"-."HG/"H8/;"X#T/A" %(% 3J (%766 !N5!(%

2/;/8"!"SD:8E#D. NL45666 3J (766 >''5666

2/;/8"("Z"1#1/ 6 3J !P766 66

?%F%-%I'!@!6I(&$ 2OWNSO@1V?%F%-%I'!V!,#(&$-3.AD9.DA-8"3.//8"=!(f&B$C"d_dH 6 Xd N5P66766 6

6cF@A-E/"<#0/"3.AD9.DA/"JA-0:1@"d_X"RHec^RH< 6 Xd N5P66766 6

6J8##A&R##$"</9U:1@"Z"1#1/ 6 6 6766 6

6+:B97"+/.-8"J-,A:9-.:#1B"=7>%f&3JC N%L"""""""""""""""""" Xd 45%66766 !5P!P5P(%

6I#T/AT-BY"/G:B.:1@"9#AAD@-./E"0/.-8"F-1/8B"T:.Y"9#0F#B:./"0/.-8"F-1/8B N>5!6( 3J %766 !'%5%6L

Page 291: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(

d/T"3.//8"3.-:AB"V"R-:8B 4(P R^3HR3 P%6766 (>P5'4(

)BBD0/"'"3.-:AB5"N"$8##AB"/-9Y"=N%[".-88C 6

d/T"Q-1EA-:8B"-."-88"8/;/8B"TY/A/"B/-.B"Y-;/",//1"A/0#;/E"Z"d_"Q)d<R)^235"*+c"`)223 P5(PP 2J 6766 6

6HGF-1B:#1"*#1.A#8 ! )22_` N665666766 N665666

6R/F8-9/"/G:B.:1@"Hg"a"d/T"3.AD9.DA/"d_X"RHec^RH< 6 2J !!%766 6

6?%F%-%I'!V!6I(&$ 2O0SWONSA

?%F%-%I'!A!7&*Y#'(*[R#D@Y"*-AF/1.AK 4'N5666"""""""""" M3J 67(% !(65>%6

^1./A:#A"S8#9U:1@ 4'N5666 M3J 67N% !PL56%6

HG./A:#A"S8#9U:1@ 6 d&) 6766 6

6?%F%-%I'!A!6I(&$ 2WNOW11?%F%-%I'!S!\&(#*Y*II^%'Q!/!"II^%'Q 6\&(#*Y*II^%'Q!]!?&RY*II^%'Q 6I/A:0/./A"`-88"=T:.Y"<:;"LC 6 3J 67>% 6

R/0#;/"/G:B.:1@"`I"-."A/.-:1:1@"T-88",/Y:1E"/-A.Y",/A0B NN5N>% 3J 4766 !NN5%666

3#D1E":1BD8-.:#1"-."0/9Y-1:9-8"A##0B"=1#."A/OD:A/EC 6 )22_` 6766 6

"II^%'Q!]!E$&-_%'QR/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"$8-."A##$ '65666 3J (N766 !5'465666

63UK8:@Y.B"&"XA-1B8D9/1."J-,A:9 ! )22_` (54665666766 (54665666^1./A0:../1."A/F-:A"#A"A/F8-9/0/1.hh 6

6"3FA-KZ#1"J:A/FA##$:1@"Z"-BBD0/""2/;/8"N"-1E"#D./A"A:1@"3J"#18K"=46["T:E/"A:1@"-."-88">"8/;/8B"DF".#",#..#0"#$"A##$C" P(N5666"""""""""" M3J (7(% !546!5>%6

6J:A/B.#FF:1@ ! 23 !665666766 !665666

6

Page 292: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

P"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(*-D8U:1@"V"3/-8:1@"-."HG./A:#A"3U:1"=:198DE/B"A/0#;-8"-1E"A/F8-9/0/1."#$"/G:B.:1@"9-D8U:1@C NNN5>%6 3J N7%6 !5!P'5!(%

?%F%-%I'!S!6I(&$ SO1@0O0SV

?%F%-%I'!W!?II*-!&'L!\%'LIJ-Q#88#T"+/.-8"<##AB&JA-0/B&Q-AET-A/"=!F/A"!5666B$C 4'N"""""""""""""""""" H) !5%66766 >(45%66

69Y#X%&$!?II*- 6 6 6766 6*#:8:1@"<##AB"-."HG./A:#A"$#A"W#F/1"9#19/F.W"-1E"8#-E:1@"E#9UB"=("E##AB"F/A"S-K5"4"S-KB"F/A"eD-EC N( H) !%5666766 4'65666

6

3/9DA:.K"@A:88B"-."9#19/BB:#1B"=T:.Y"*#19/BB:#1",D:8E#D."FA:9/C 6766 66

7U*(&%'J&$$ 6NNN5>%6"B$"#$"BU:1"=P6?"FA/9-B."46?"@8-b:1@C !NN5%66 3J 1&- 6

")88#T-19/".#"A/F8-9/",A#U/1"@8-BB" !"""""""""""""""""""""" )22_` (%65666766 (%65666

R/0#;/"HG:B.:1@"HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A"*DA.-:1T-88"3KB./0"=(![G!([G!6'[".-88C" >5!(' 3J !%766 !6P5L(6

"^1$:88"@8-BB"-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A"=.#F"#$"E#0/C" %64"""""""""""""""""" 3J '%766 4(5'466

d/T"H1.AK"<##AB"-."MA-E/ N( H) N5%66766 !!(56666

?II*!5&*LJ&*# 6^198DE/E":1"E##AB&$A-0/B"-,#;/ 6 6 6766 6

?%F%-%I'!W!6I(&$ .OS.AO2A1

?%F%-%I'!N!E%'%-_#-I8-B./A"-."<##A"^1$:88")A/- !5>L( 3J !%766 (P5''6

I8-B./A"-."A/.-:1:1@"T-88",/Y:1E"/-A.Y",/A0B NN5N>% 3J !%766 %665P(%

"<AKT-885"/G./A:#A"BY/-.Y:1@5"^1BD8-.:#1"=8/;/8"!"-1E"8/;/8"N"-A/-B"#18KC" >''5666"""""""""" M3J (7%6 !5L>65666

6

Page 293: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

>"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(X#:8/.&*#19/BB:#1B"-."1/T"@A-E/"8/;/8"='H)"Z"%5666"3J"/-9YC7"^198DE/B"*+c"T-88B5"$:1:BY/B5"9#:8:1@"@A:88/B5"A##$"-1E"+HI7 465666 3J !66766 456665666

^1./A:#A"SD:8E#D."#$"2/;/8"!" NL45666 3J !%766 %5L!656666

+:B9ZcB/",D:8E#D."-A/- !%5666 3J %6766 >%656666

J8##A"J:1:BY/B5"-BBD0/"B-1E&B/-8:1@"9#19A/./ NNL5666 M3J 67>% (%45(%66

*/:8:1@"J:1:BY/B M3J %766 66

+:B9"c1E/$:1/E"^1./A:#A"J:1:BY/B ! )22_` >%65666766 >%656666

I-:1.:1@" NNL5666 M3J (766 P>'5666

I-:1.:1@"3.//8"R##$"3.AD9.DA/" ! )22_` %56665666766 %56665666

JRI"a"U:.9Y/1B 6 3J >766 66

I#T/AT-BY"&"3/-8"-."IA/9-B. (P'5%(% 3J N7%6 LNL5'N'

?%F%-%I'!N!6I(&$ (65>>L5%LN

?%F%-%I'!.1!9Y#X%&$(%#-6

2#D;/AB ! )22_` (665666766 (6656666

i:E/#"S#-AEB"=d#.":198DE/EC 6 6 6766 66

*/1.A-88K"8#9-./E"B#E-"E:BF/1B/AB"=d#.":198DE/EC 6 6 6766 6

`-K$:1E:1@"MA-FY:9B"&"3:@1-@/ !5N'(5666"""""" M3J 67N% 4'N5>66

?%F%-%I'!.1!6I(&$ AW0OS11

Page 294: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

'"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(?%F%-%I'!..!=`U%YR#'( 6J##E"3/A;:9/"HOD:F0/1."Z",K"#T1/A d^* ,K"#T1/A 6

6)FF8:-19/B"Z",K"#T1/A d^* ,K"#T1/A 6

6<#9U"8/;/8/AB&,D0F/AB P H) !%5666766 L65666

?%F%-%I'!..!6I(&$ N1O111

?%F%-%I'!.2!EU*'%-_%'Q- 6 6 67666

)9#DB.:9-8".A/-.0/1.B5"0:B97":./0B"$#A"F8-.$#A0"Zd_X"^d*2c<H< 6 d^* 6766 6

6XY/0/"J#D1.-:1"Z"d_X"^d*2c<H< 6 d^* 6766 6

R:@@:1@"MA:E ! )22_` 456665666766 4566656666

?%F%-%I'!.2!6I(&$ @O111O111

?%F%-%I'!.@!>#*(%X&$!6*&'-YI*(&(%I' 6)&--#'Q#*!=$#F&(I*- 6"4"I-BB/1@/A"/8/;-.#AB5"NZ3.#F5"d_X"RHec^RH<" 3X_I3 6766 6

69#*F%X#!=$#F&(I*- 6("JA/:@Y."/8/;-.#AB"Z"N"B.#F P 3X_I3 %65666766 N665666

6"HB9-8-.#AB"$A#0"@A-E/"8/;/8".#"F8-K:1@"$:/8E"8/;/8"=-BBD0/"4"/-9Y5"N6["Y/:@Y.C"d_X"RHec^RH<" H) 6766 6

6?%F%-%I'!.@!6I(&$ 011O111

Page 295: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

L"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(?%F%-%I'!.V!,#X_&'%X&$ 6+/9Y-1:9-8 6+/9Y-1:9-8"i/1.:8-.:#1"-1E"HGY-DB."3KB./0"=*#0,#"30#U/"H;-9&HGY-DB.C"(%5666"F/#F8/5"!6"*J+"F/A"F/AB#15"4"/G9Y-1@/B"F/A"Y#DA7"^198DE/B"8#D;/AB7"=*#1E:.:#1/E"-:A"-."-88"$8##AB5"466"*J+&3JC"^198DE/B"9/1.A-8"F8-1."DF@A-E/B P5666 X_d3 (5%66766 !%56665666

<D9.T#AU"-1E"<:B.A:,D.:#1"-."SD:8E:1@ P5666 X_d3 (5%66766 !%566656666

S)3".#"0-.9Y"/G:B.:1@5"2/;/8"N"#18K NL45666 M3J !7%6 %L!56666

30#U/"/;-9D-.:#1"BKB./0""Z"-BBD0/"4"/G9Y-1@/B"F/A"Y#DA"$#A"@A#BB"3J"-A/- 456665666 *J+ !7>% >56665666

"2#D;/AB"$#A"B0#U/"/;-9D-.:#1"BKB./0" !65666"""""""""""" 3J %6766 %665666

"*D."&"IA/F"2#D;/A"_F/1:1@B" !65666"""""""""""" 3J (%766 (%656666

I8D0,:1@5"A/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"A##$"EA-:1"BKB./0 !5N'(5666 M3J (766 (5>P45666

H;/1."N6GN6"@A:E"=`-./A"-1E"<A-:1C 4N' H) N5(%6766 !54((5>>'

IDA9Y-B/",#G/B"$#A"/;/1."F#T/A 4N' H) !5%66766 P%P5PP>6

E%*#!)*I(#X(%I'!9[-(#R 6"R/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"-."2/;/8"!" 'L5666 3J N7(% ('L5(%6

")EE"1/T"$:A/"FA#./9.:#1"-."2/;/8"N" 'L5666 3J N7(% ('L5(%6

+:B9"R/F-:AB"-.",-8-19/"#$",D:8E:1@ ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

?%F%-%I'!.V!6I(&$ @0OWA2ON@@

?%F%-%I'!.A!=$#X(*%X&$</0#"/G:B.:1@"3D,Z3.-.:#1"Z",K"#T1/A ,K"#T1/A 6

d/T"D1E/A@A#D1E"FA:0-AK"/8/9.A:9"B/A;:9/"=J-11:1".#")A/1-C !56%6 2J >%6766 >'>5%66d/T"/8/9.A:9-8"B/A;:9/"$A#0")A/1-"I8-b-"-1E"I8-1."( %66 2J >%6766 N>%5666

d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A")A/1-"Z"=(C"4666")0F"I-1/8B"=FA:0-AK"ED9.",-1U":198DE/E"-,#;/C ! )22_` (665666766 (665666

Page 296: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!6"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A"I8-b-"Z"j%6U"F/A"3DFF#A."SD:8E:1@ ! )22_` 4665666766 4665666

d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A"<#0/"Z ! )22_` !56665666766 !566656666

H8/9.A:9-8"-."_99DF:/E")A/-B"=2/;/8B"!ZNC L%'5666 M3J !'766 !>5(445666

H8/9.A:9-8"-,#;/"2/;/8"N"=8:@Y.:1@"-1E"9#E/"9#0F8:-19/C 4(45666 M3J N766 !5(>(5666

R/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"/G:B.:1@"BF#A.B"8:@Y.:1@ ! )22_` N665666766 N665666

H;/1."I#T/A"N6GN6"@A:E"=-BBD0/"N6"-0F"F/A",#GC 4N' H) !%5666766 P5%PP5PP>6

9%(#!=$#X(*%X&$ 63:./"8:@Y."F#8/B ! )22_` (%65666766 (%65666

SD:8E:1@"J-k-E/"2:@Y.:1@""Z"-BBD0/"1#."A/OD:A/E 6 d^* 6766 66

3/9DA:.K"V"**Xi"3KB./0B !5N'(5666 M3J 67P% 'L'5N666

*#00D1:9-.:#1"3KB./0 !5N'(5666 M3J 67%6 PL!5666

H;/1."J8##A"<-.-"<:B.A:,D.:#1"N6GN6"@A:E 4N' H) N5666766 !5N!N5NNN6

J:A/"-8-A0 !5N'(5666 M3J !7(% !5>(>5%666

)&i"-."2/;/8"N"#18K NL45666 M3J N7(% !5('65%666

X/0F#A-AK"H8/9.A:9-8 (4 +_ %65666766 !5(665666

!?%F%-%I'!.A!6I(&$! 0VOV1VOW11

6863C!7896!8E!\8"a [email protected]

Page 297: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!!"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2,:C6;D):")89=!E37;C;6<

C#F#$!.!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M 0N@O111 #P%-(%'Q!(I!*#R&%'C#F#$!2!GH#$IJ!K*&L#M .S1O111C#F#$!0!G&(!K*&L#M 0N@O111 '#J!-$&TC#F#$!@ .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!V .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!A .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#C#F#$!S .1AO111 'I'DU-#&T$#

.O0W2O111 K9E

!?#-X*%Y(%I'! Z([ :, :'%(!7I-( 6I(&$!7I-(9:H6863C!7896!8E!\8"a !>654!'5%LP !(N7N!M/1/A-8"*#1E:.:#1B"=P?C !65((%5!!P >7463D,9#1.A-9.#A"S#1E"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"!7(%?C (5!N65(N( !7%4SD:8E:1@"I/A0:."=9#B."#$"T#AU"l7(64?C N4>5P%4 67(%SD:8E/AB"R:BU"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"7NP>?C P(%54NP 674%M/1/A-8"2:-,:8:.K"^1BDA-19/"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"7>6'?C !5(6P5%P4 67'>)*Ib#X(!9UT(I(&$ !'45L%N5%L' !NN7'N*+aR"J//"a"N7%? P54>N5N>P 47P'M*"S#1E"=3D,.#.-8"l"7'N%?C !5%445NPN !7!()*Ib#X(!6I(&$ !L(5L>!5NN> !NL7PN*#1.:1@/19K"a"!6?"G"9#B."#$"T#AU !>564!5'P6 !(7NN)*Ib#X(!K*&'L!6I(&$ (!656!N5!LP !%!7LP

Page 298: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

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

.ST0.AT@W0 9K](C(&$</0#"F-;:1@"#D.B:E/",8E@"8:1/":198DE/E":1"F-;:1@",/8#T 6 6 6766 6</0#"B/-.:1@"V"$8##AB".#"W<W"8:1/"=:198DE/E"-,#;/C 6 6 6766 6

6X/0F"BY#A:1@"Z"B.AD9.DA-8"E/0# NL45666 3J 67>% (L%5%66

6H-A.YT#AU"=:198DE/E":1"F-;:1@"1D0,/AB",/8#TC 6

6"#JCN#!P#*J- 6R/0#;/"S/A0B"Z")BBD0/"(6[".-88",/A0B5"'%?"-A#D1E".Y/"<#0/"F8DB"!74"3T/88"J-9.#A"=XAD9U"\-AEBC !L5P!N *\ '766 !%P5L64

69%(#!:(%$%(%#- 63:./"2:@Y.:1@]"^1"/8/9.A:9-8 6

3.#A0"EA-:1-@/5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

Page 299: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

("#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

3-1:.-AK"B/T/A5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

<#0/B.:9"T-./A5"-BBD0/"1/T"B:./"8-./A-8B ! )22_` !665666766 !665666011T111 9K](C(&$

*Y:88/E"T-./A"Z"9#11/9./E"a"*-AAD.Y"F8-b- !5%66 2J !5%66766 (5(%656666

XD11/8"$A#0"I-AU:1@".#"P!6"=3/F-A-./"HB.:0-./C 6 23 1&- 66

9%(#!;JL*CN#J#'(-!^!5&*E-G&L# 6PW"39#A/E"9#19A/./"F-;:1@"=,D:8E:1@".#"9DA,"8:1/C"^198DE/B"BD,"@A-E/"FA/F7">%?"F-;:1@"&"(%?"@A//1"-A/- NNN5'P6 3J P766 (566N5!P(

PW"*#8#A/E"&"B.-0F/E"9#19A/./"=cF@A-E/"%6?C !PP5LN6 3J P766 !566!5%'!

*DA,"-1E"MD../A"X:/Z:1 P5('6 2J !4766 '>5L(6

+:B9"I-;:1@ >%5NP6 3J '766 P6(5''60TASWTW@2 9K](C(&$

</0#"/G:B.:1@"A-0FB"-1E"8#-E:1@"E#9UB '%5666 3J !7%6 !(>5%66

</0#"/G:B.:1@"B:E/T-8UB N%5666 3J !7%6 %(5%666

J/19:1@"V"M-./B"a"2#-E:1@"<#9U")A/-"_18K P(' 2J %6766 N!54666

M&'E-G&L#!^!;**%U&(%C' 6 6 6766 6PW"39#A/E"9#19A/./"F-;:1@"=,D:8E:1@".#"9DA,"8:1/C"^198DE/B"BD,"@A-E/"FA/F7">%?"F-;:1@"&"(%?"@A//1"-A/- !!!5('> 3J N766 NNN5'P6

6QKEA#"0D89Y"&"B#EE:1@ ! )22_` !665666766 !665666

63.-,:8:b/E"9#1B.AD9.:#1"/1.A-19/ ( H) P5%66766 !N5666

63.#A0"`-./A"RD1#$$"IA/;/1.:#1 N5%!( 2J %7%6 !L5N!P

6^18/."IA#./9.:#1 46 H) !66766 45666

?%N%-%C'!2!6C(&$ .@_01 `/9Y 2ATASWTSVW

Page 300: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

N"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(?%N%-%C'!0!7C'G*#(# 6YCK'E&(%C'-!^!P#$CI!Q*&E# 6)D@/A"*-B."I:8/B"$#A"2/;/8"N"38-,"=-BBD0/"N6["G"N6["@A:E"5"L6["8#1@C7")BBD0/"%"-D@/A"9-B."F:8/B"F/A"9-F7")A/-":B"-BBD0/E".#",/":1B:E/".Y/"N"/G:B.:1@"9#8D01B"-."F/A:0/./A !%(5'N6 2J !L766 (5L6N5>>6

6I:8/"*-FB N46 H) !65666766 N5NLP5(((

6*#19A/./"B8-,"#1"@A-E/"=/G:B.:1@"F8-K:1@"$:/8E".#"A/0-:1C 6 3J P766 6

6d/T"H8/;-./E"38-,"-."2/;/8"N5":198DE/B"9#8D01B"$A#0"F8-K:1@"$:/8E"8/;/8 NL45666 3J N'766 !45L>(5666

*#19A/./"/19-B/0/1."-."-88"/GF#B/E"B.//8"9#8B"Z"1#."-FF8:9-,8/5"-BBD0/E"$:A/"FA##$/E"=B//"<:;">C (!> H) 6766 6

+#E:$K"/G:B.:1@"=/8/;-./E"$A#0"F8-K:1@"8/;/8C"B.AD9.DA/"-."F/A:0/./A"=-BBD0/"(((%[GN6[C PP5>%6 3J !(766 '6!5666

+#E:$K"B8-,"TY/A/"0#;/-,8/"E/9U"T-B"A/0#;/E" PN5%(6 3J !(766 >P(5(46

^1$:88"&"F#DA"B8-,"-."#8E"ED@#D."8#9-.:#1B"=-BBD0/"("/-5"!6[G>%[GN["E//FC !P> *\ !%>766 (P5!P>

^1$:88"&"F#DA"B8-,"-."#8E".DA$"F:."8#9-.:#1B"=-BBD0/"('6[GN6[G!(["E//FC N5>NN *\ !%>766 %'P5!NN

^1$:88"-."HG:B.:1@"+#;/-,8/"</9U"XA-9UB !4' *\ !%>766 (N5(%L

^1$:88"-."HG:B.:1@"XA/19Y"<A-:1 ' *\ !%>766 !5(%P

+:B9"^1$:88"-."E/FA/BB/E"-A/-B ! )22_` >%5666766 >%5666

")EE"1/T"HB9-8-.#A"I:.B"=-BBD0/"("/B9-8-.#AB"F/A"F:.C"d_X"RHec^RH<" H) (%5666766 6

"d/T"H8/;-.#A"I:.B"$#A"I-BB/1@/A"H8/;-.#AB" '""""""""""""""""""""" H) !%5666766 !(65666

"d/T".-F/A/E"9#19A/./",/-0"=:1$:88C"-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A" N6""""""""""""""""""" JX 4%6766 !N5%66

"38-,"#1"+/.-8"</9U"-."d/T"SD:8E#D." 4'%5666""""""""" 3J P766 (5L!65666

Page 301: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

4"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

"38-,"#1"+/.-8"</9U"-.".#F"$8##A"W3.AD9.DA/"*-FW" !665666""""""""" 3J P766 P66566621TXS1TWWA 9K](C(&$

d/T"XAD9U")99/BB"R-0FB"$#A"H;/1."3/.DF"=("/-9Y"-."N66["G"!P["T:E/"$#88#T:1@".Y/"F/A:0/./A"#$".Y/"E#0/5":198DE/B"E/0#"-1E"/-A.YT#AUC L5P66 3J P6766 %>P5666

6=F(#*%C*!)*#G&-(!"#L$&G#J#'( 6R/F8-9/"NNN5>%6"B$"#$"BU:1"=P6?"FA/9-B."46?"@8-b:1@C5"R/0#;/5"-BBD0/"!([G!4["F-1/8B !5!L( H) %5646766 P566>5%66

"^1$:88"IA/9-B."-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A" !56L(""""""""""""" 3J N%766 N'5((66

?%N%-%C'!0!6C(&$ .X_.. `/9Y 00TX.2T2AX

?%N%-%C'!@!,&-C'*[ 6c1:."+-B#1AK""=O.K"-B"-88#T-19/C" 6

^1$:88"HG:B.:1@"<##A")A/-B !5>L( 3J !%766 (P5''6

"H8/;-.#A"3Y-$."$#A"d/T"3/A;:9/"H8/;-.#AB"=4"/-9Y5"!([G!4[G!>6["2/;/8B"!Z>" N%5NP6 3J !%766 %N65466

"*+c"3Y-$."`-88B"$#A"I-BB/1@/A"H8/;-.#AB"='"/-9Y5"!6[G!6[G!%6[".-88"2/;/8"NZ>C" 4'5666 3J !%766 >(65666

"(6"["*+c"T-88B"-."-88"8/;/8B"TY/A/"B/-.B"Y-;/",//1"A/0#;/E".#",8#9U";:/T"#$"9#19#DAB/"-A/-"=`^XQ"^dXHR^_R"M2)33"SH2_`C" 3J !%766 6

"^1$:88",A:9U"&"*+c"-."HG/"H8/;"X#T/A" %(% 3J (%766 !N5!(%

2/;/8"!"Z"1#1/ NL45666 3J (766 >''5666

2/;/8"("Z"1#1/ 6 3J !P766 6

6?%N%-%C'!@!6C(&$ ._.. `/9Y 2T1VXT@1W

?%N%-%C'!W!,#(&$-

Page 302: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(3.AD9.DA-8"3.//8"=!(f&B$C5"4'%5666"1/T"3J"-A/-"3.AD9.DA/ (5L!6 Xd N5P66766 !654>P5666

6cF@A-E/"<#0/"3.AD9.DA/"JA-0:1@"d_X"RHec^RH< 6 Xd N5P66766 6

6J8##A&R##$"</9U:1@"Z"1#1/ 6 6 6766 6

6+:B97"+/.-8"J-,A:9-.:#1B"=7>%f&3JC >66""""""""""""""""" Xd 45%66766 N5!%65%PN

6R/F8-9/"/G:B.:1@"9#AAD@-./E"0/.-8"F-1/8B"T:.Y"9#0F#B:./"0/.-8"F-1/8B N>5!6( 3J %6766 !5'%%56L4

d/T"3.//8"3.-:AB"V"R-:8B !5>LL R^3HR3 P%6766 !5!PL5N>L)BBD0/"'"3.-:AB5"N"$8##AB"/-9Y"=!%6[".-88C 6

d/T"Q-1EA-:8B"-."-88"8/;/8B"TY/A/"B/-.B"Y-;/",//1"A/0#;/E"Z)33c+H<"*+c"`)22

6HGF-1B:#1"*#1.A#8 ! )22_` N665666766 N665666

6R/F8-9/"/G:B.:1@"Hg"a"d/T"3.AD9.DA/"d_X"RHec^RH< 6 2J !!%766 6

6?%N%-%C'!W!6C(&$ S_1X `/9Y .ATSW.T10W

?%N%-%C'!A!7&*L#'(*[R#D@Y"*-AF/1.AK !5'P>5666"""""" M3J 67(% 4PP5>%6

^1./A:#A"S8#9U:1@ !5'P>5666 M3J 67N% P%N54%6

HG./A:#A"S8#9U:1@ 6 d&) 6766 66

?%N%-%C'!A!6C(&$ 1_A1 `/9Y .T.21T211

?%N%-%C'!V!\&(#*L*CCH%'U!/!"CCH%'U 6\&(#*L*CCH%'U!^!?&JL*CCH%'U 6I/A:0/./A"`-88"=T:.Y"<:;"LC 6 3J 67>% 6

R/0#;/"/G:B.:1@"`I"-."A/.-:1:1@"T-88",/Y:1E"/-A.Y",/A0B NN5N>% 3J 4766 !NN5%666

3#D1E":1BD8-.:#1"-."0/9Y-1:9-8"A##0B"=1#."A/OD:A/EC 6 )22_` 6766 6

"CCH%'U!^!Y$&-a%'U

Page 303: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

P"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(R/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"$8-."A##$ '65666 3J (N766 !5'465666

63UK8:@Y.B"&"XA-1B8D9/1."J-,A:9 ! )22_` (54665666766 (54665666^1./A0:../1."A/F-:A"#A"A/F8-9/0/1.hh 6

6"3FA-KZ#1"J:A/FA##$:1@"Z"-BBD0/""2/;/8"N"-1E"#D./A"A:1@"3J"#18K"=46["T:E/"A:1@"-."-88">"8/;/8B"DF".#",#..#0"#$"A##$C" !5%6(5666"""""" M3J (7(% N5N>L5%66

6J:A/B.#FF:1@ ! 23 !665666766 !665666

6*-D8U:1@"V"3/-8:1@"-."HG./A:#A"3U:1"=:198DE/B"A/0#;-8"-1E"A/F8-9/0/1."#$"/G:B.:1@"9-D8U:1@C NNN5>%6 3J N7%6 !5!P'5!(%

?%N%-%C'!V!6C(&$ @_X0 `/9Y ST12.T.2W

?%N%-%C'!X!?CC*-!&'E!\%'ECI-Q#88#T"+/.-8"<##AB&JA-0/B&Q-AET-A/"=T:.Y"W</;/8#F0/1."*#B.BW",/8#T H) !5%66766 6

69L#G%&$!?CC*- 6*#:8:1@"<##AB"-."HG./A:#A"$#A"W#F/1"9#19/F.W"-1E"8#-E:1@"E#9UB"=("E##AB"F/A"S-K5"4"S-KB"F/A"eD-EC N( H) !%5666766 4'65666

6

3/9DA:.K"@A:88B"-."9#19/BB:#1B"=T:.Y"*#19/BB:#1",D:8E#D."FA:9/C 6766 66

7K*(&%'I&$$ 6R/F8-9/"NNN5>%6"B$"#$"BU:1"=P6?"FA/9-B."46?"@8-b:1@C" !NN5%66 3J '%766 !!5N4>5%66

R/0#;/"HG:B.:1@"HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A"*DA.-:1T-88"3KB./0"=(![G!([G!6'[".-88C" >5!(' 3J !%766 !6P5L(6

"^1$:88"@8-BB"-."HG/"H8/;-.#A"X#T/A"=.#F"#$"E#0/C" %64""""""""""""""""" 3J '%766 4(5'466

"^1./A:#A"M8-BB"T-88B"-."-88"8/;/8B"TY/A/"B/-.B"Y-;/",//1"A/0#;/E".#",8#9U";:/T"#$"9#19#DAB/"-A/-"=1#",D.."@8-b:1@C" !(%5N(6""""""""" 3J 4%766 %5PNL5466

d/T"H1.AK"<##AB"-."MA-E/ N( H) N5%66766 !!(56666

?CC*!5&*EI&*# 6^198DE/E":1"E##AB&$A-0/B"-,#;/ 6 6 6766 6

Page 304: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

>"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

?%N%-%C'!X!6C(&$ S_W1 `/9Y .VTV2XTAA1

?%N%-%C'!S!Y%'%-a#-</;/8#F0/1."9#B.B"$#A"IY-B/"^"FA#@A-0"-B"F/A"*3V2"BD00-AK"A/F#A."E-./E"!(Z!(Z(6!!"=d_X"^d*2c<H<C 4'%5666 3J d&) 6

R/1#;-./"-1E"A/$DA,:BY"1/T"IY-B/"^"-A/-7""d/T"38-,"-1E"WTY:./",#GW",D:8E"#D.7"d/T"X/1-1."3F-9/ N''5666 3J !%766 %5'(65666

R/1#;-./"-1E"A/$DA,:BY"1/T"IY-B/"^"-A/-7"d//E"-EE:.:#1-8":1$#A0-.:#1"$#A"-A/-B"F/A"$8##A7"d/T"38-,"-1E"WTY:./",#GW",D:8E"#D.7"ID,8:9"*:A9D8-.:#1 L>5666 3J %6766 45'%65666

I8-B./A"-."<##A"^1$:88")A/- !5>L( 3J !%766 (P5''6

I8-B./A"-."A/.-:1:1@"T-88",/Y:1E"/-A.Y",/A0B NN5N>% 3J !%766 %665P(%

"<AKT-885"/G./A:#A"BY/-.Y:1@5"^1BD8-.:#1"M3J"-88"8/;/8B"" >''5666""""""""" M3J (7%6 !5L>656666

X#:8/.&*#19/BB:#1B"-."1/T"@A-E/"8/;/8"='H)"Z"%5666"3J"/-9YC7"^198DE/B"*+c"T-88B5"$:1:BY/B5"9#:8:1@"@A:88/B5"A##$"-1E"+HI7" 465666 3J !66766 456665666

6^1./A:#A"SD:8E#D."#$"2/;/8"!" NL45666 3J !%766 %5L!65666

+:B9ZcB/",D:8E#D."-A/-" !%5666 3J %6766 >%656666

J8##A"J:1:BY/B5"-BBD0/"B-1E&B/-8:1@"9#19A/./"-."2/;/8"N NNL5666 M3J 67>% (%45(%66

*/:8:1@"J:1:BY/B M3J %766 66

+:B9"c1E/$:1/E"^1./A:#A"J:1:BY/B ! )22_` >%65666766 >%656666

I-:1.:1@" NNL5666 M3J (766 P>'5666

I-:1.:1@"3.//8"R##$"3.AD9.DA/"Z"d_X")II2^*)S2H ! )22_` %56665666766 %56665666

JRI"a"U:.9Y/1B 6 3J >766 66

I#T/AT-BY"&"3/-8"-."IA/9-B."Z"d_X")II2^*)S2H5"A/F8-9/"FA/9-B. 3J N7%6 6

Page 305: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

'"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

?%N%-%C'!S!6C(&$ .A_0@ `/9Y N65%6L5>%%

?%N%-%C'!.1!9L#G%&$(%#-6

2#D;/AB ! )22_` (665666766 (6656666

i:E/#"S#-AEB"=d#.":198DE/EC 6 6 6766 66

*/1.A-88K"8#9-./E"B#E-"E:BF/1B/AB"=d#.":198DE/EC 6 6 6766 6

`-K$:1E:1@"MA-FY:9B"&"3:@1-@/ !5'P>5666"""""" M3J 67N% P%N54%6

?%N%-%C'!.1!6C(&$ 1_@A `/9Y XW0T@W1

?%N%-%C'!..!=bK%LJ#'( 6J##E"3/A;:9/"HOD:F0/1."Z",K"#T1/A d^* ,K"#T1/A 6

6)FF8:-19/B"Z",K"#T1/A d^* ,K"#T1/A 6

6<#9U"8/;/8/AB&,D0F/AB P H) !%5666766 L65666

?%N%-%C'!..!6C(&$ 1_1W `/9Y S1T111

?%N%-%C'!.2!YK*'%-a%'U- 6 6 67666

)9#DB.:9-8".A/-.0/1.B5"0:B97":./0B"$#A"F8-.$#A0"Zd_X"^d*2c<H< 6 d^* 6766 6

6XY/0/"J#D1.-:1"Z"d_X"^d*2c<H< 6 d^* 6766 6

R:@@:1@"MA:E ! )22_` 456665666766 4566656666

?%N%-%C'!.2!6C(&$ 2_.@ `/9Y @T111T111

?%N%-%C'!.@!>#*(%G&$!6*&'-LC*(&(%C' 6)&--#'U#*!=$#N&(C*- 6"'"I-BB/1@/A"/8/;-.#AB5""-BBD0/">"B.#FB"/-9Y" %P 3X_I3 6766 6

69#*N%G#!=$#N&(C*- 6

Page 306: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

L"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(4"JA/:@Y."H8/;-.#AB5"L"B.#FB"/-9Y NP 3X_I3 %65666766 !5'665666

6"HB9-8-.#AB"$A#0"@A-E/"8/;/8".#"F8-K:1@"$:/8E"8/;/8"=-BBD0/"P"/-9Y5"N6["Y/:@Y.C"2/;/8"N5"45"%" P H) 6766 6

6?%N%-%C'!.@!6C(&$ 1_SA `/9Y .TX11T111

?%N%-%C'!.W!,#Ga&'%G&$ 6+/9Y-1:9-8 6+/9Y-1:9-8"i/1.:8-.:#1"-1E"HGY-DB."3KB./0"=*#0,#"30#U/"H;-9&HGY-DB.C"(%5666"F/#F8/5"!6"*J+"F/A"F/AB#15"!6"/G9Y-1@/B"F/A"Y#DA7"^198DE/B"8#D;/AB P5666 X_d3 (5%66766 !%56665666

<D9.T#AU"-1E"<:B.A:,D.:#1"-."SD:8E:1@ P5666 X_d3 (5%66766 !%566656666

+/9Y-1:9-8"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/- N''5666 M3J >766 (5>!P5666

+/9Y-1:9-8"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/-"=ID,8:9"*:A9D8-.:#1C L>5666 M3J !!766 !56P>5666

6S)3".#"0-.9Y"/G:B.:1@ !5'P>5666 M3J !7%6 (5'665%66

630#U/"/;-9D-.:#1"BKB./0""Z"-BBD0/"4"/G9Y-1@/B"F/A"Y#DA"$#A"@A#BB"3J"-A/- 456665666 *J+ !7>% >56665666

"2#D;/AB"$#A"B0#U/"/;-9D-.:#1"BKB./0" !65666""""""""""" 3J %6766 %665666

"*D."&"IA/F"2#D;/A"_F/1:1@B" !65666""""""""""" 3J (%766 (%656666

I8D0,:1@5"9#0F8/./"A/1#;-.:#1 !5N'(5666 M3J (766 (5>P45666

I8D0,:1@"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/- N''5666 M3J (766 >>P5666

I8D0,:1@"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/-"=ID,8:9"*:A9D8-.:#1C L>5666 M3J '7%6 '(45%66

H;/1."N6GN6"@A:E"=`-./A"-1E"<A-:1C 4N' H) N5(%6766 !54((5>>'

IDA9Y-B/",#G/B"$#A"/;/1."F#T/A 4N' H) !5%66766 P%P5PP>6

Y%*#!)*C(#G(%C'!9[-(#J 6"R/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"-."2/;/8"!" 'L5666 3J N7(% ('L5(%6

Page 307: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!6"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

")EE"1/T"$:A/"FA#./9.:#1"-."2/;/8"N" 'L5666 3J N7(% ('L5(%6

+:B9"R/F-:AB"-.",-8-19/"#$",D:8E:1@ %L45666 3J N7(% !5LN65%66

J:A/"IA#./9.:#1"3KB./0"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/- N''5666 M3J !7%6 %'(5666

J:A/"IA#./9.:#1"3KB./0"$#A"X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/-"ID,8:9")A/- L>5666 M3J (766 !L45666

?%N%-%C'!.W!6C(&$ 2X_SA `/9Y 1_11 W@T1A2T@@@

?%N%-%C'!.A!=$#G(*%G&$</0#"/G:B.:1@"3D,Z3.-.:#1"Z",K"#T1/A ,K"#T1/A 6

d/T"D1E/A@A#D1E"FA:0-AK"/8/9.A:9"B/A;:9/"=J-11:1".#")A/1-C !56%6 2J >%6766 >'>5%66

d/T"/8/9.A:9-8"B/A;:9/"$A#0")A/1-"I8-b-"-1E"I8-1."( %66 2J >%6766 N>%5666

d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A")A/1-"Z"=(C"4666")0F"I-1/8B"=FA:0-AK"ED9.",-1U":198DE/E"-,#;/C ! )22_` (665666766 (665666

d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A"I8-b-"Z"j%6U"F/A"3DFF#A."SD:8E:1@ ! )22_` 4665666766 4665666

d/T"3T:.9Y@/-A"$#A"<#0/"Z ! )22_` !56665666766 !56665666

H0/A@/19K"M/1/A-.#A"=2:$/"3-$/.K"#18KC ! H) (%65666766 (%656666

H8/9.A:9-8"-."_99DF:/E")A/-B"=2/;/8B"!ZNC L%'5666 M3J !'766 !>5(445666

H8/9.A:9-8"-,#;/"2/;/8"N"=8:@Y.:1@"-1E"9#E/"9#0F8:-19/C 4(45666 M3J N766 !5(>(5666

H8/9.A:9-8"-."X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/- N''5666 M3J 4766 !5%%(5666

H8/9.A:9-8"-."X/1-1."SD:8E#D.")A/-"ID,8:9")A/- L>5666 M3J %766 4'%5666

H;/1."I#T/A"N6GN6"@A:E"=-BBD0/"N6"-0F"F/A",#GC 4N' H) !%5666766 P5%PP5PP>

R/0#;/"-1E"A/F8-9/"/G:B.:1@"BF#A.B"8:@Y.:1@ ! )22_` N665666766 N6656666

9%(#!=$#G(*%G&$ 63:./"8:@Y."F#8/B ! )22_` (%65666766 (%65666

Page 308: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!!"#$"!! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'(!)&*+!,&-(#*!)$&'! ./01/.2!,34536634!78496":76;84!78,)34<! "=>;9=?!@/1A/.2B!@/.0/.2B!@/2@/.2396"8?8,=!"=43;99347=

4C(#D!"#E!(#F(!%'E%G&(#-!E%HH#*#'(/'#I!E&(&!H*CJ!,K$(%!)K*LC-#!8L(%C'M#N#$!.!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 #F%-(%'U!(C!*#J&%'M#N#$!2!OP#$CI!Q*&E#R .V1T111M#N#$!0!O&(!Q*&E#R 0S@T111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!@ .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!W .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!A .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&M#N#$!V .1AT111 '##E!L*CU*&J!&*#&6#'&'(!PK%$ECK(!3*#& @XWT111

.TXAVT111 Q9Y

!?#-G*%L(%C'! Z([ :, :'%(!7C-( 6C(&$!7C-(

SD:8E:1@"J-k-E/"2:@Y.:1@""Z"-BBD0/"1#."A/OD:A/E 66

3/9DA:.K"V"**Xi"3KB./0B !5N'(5666 M3J 67P% 'L'5N666

*#00D1:9-.:#1"3KB./0 !5N'(5666 M3J 67%6 PL!5666

H;/1."J8##A"<-.-"<:B.A:,D.:#1"N6GN6"@A:E 4N' H) N5666766 !5N!N5NNN6

J:A/"-8-A0 !5'P>5666 M3J !7(% (5NNN5>%66

)&i"-."2/;/8"N"#18K NL45666 M3J N7(% !5('65%666

X/0F#A-AK"H8/9.A:9-8 NP +_ %65666766 !5'665666

!?%N%-%C'!.A!6C(&$! 21_XS `/9Y 0XTSSST1W1

6863M!7896!8Y!\8"c 20VTV22T0AX

9:P6863M!7896!8Y!\8"c (N>5>((5NP' !(>7NNM/1/A-8"*#1E:.:#1B"=P?C !45(PN5N4( >7P43D,9#1.A-9.#A"S#1E"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"!7(%?C (5L>!5%N6 !7%LSD:8E:1@"I/A0:."=9#B."#$"T#AU"l7(64?C 4'45L%4 67(PSD:8E/AB"R:BU"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"7NP>?C '>(544! 674>M/1/A-8"2:-,:8:.K"^1BDA-19/"=9#B."#$"T#AU"l"7>6'?C !5P'N56>4 67L6)*Cd#G(!9K](C(&$ (%>5LL>5>6L !N'7!L*+aR"J//"a"N7%? L56(L5L(6 47'4M*"S#1E"=3D,.#.-8"l"7'N%?C (5!%45('! !7!%)*Cd#G(!6C(&$ (PL5!'!5L6L !447!'*#1.:1@/19K"a"!6?"G"9#B."#$"T#AU (N5>>(5(N> !(7>N)*Cd#G(!Q*&'E!6C(&$ (L(5L%45!4P !%P7L!

Page 309: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<

!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-'?$H$-$2&(<(5$'"I2*+(E+F#"/043-4,G"H31=27-"I264,G )B&9:::"""""""""" ;< :J&: !8B9&::

E+F#"/043-4,G"I.+K23-"L2773"'"D7233 &&9&::"""""""""""" ;< BJ&: C!%9)&:

E+F#"/043-4,G"*#,K.+-+"I72A2 )C!9:::"""""""""" ;< :JB& !(:9B&:J:@KL;;(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

E+M2-+.4,G"NM4-="=#-+7O ::

;4-+"P-474-4+3" !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL !9B&:9:::J:: !9B&:9:::

;-#.F';2,4-2.R'L2-+." !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL !9&::9:::J:: !9&::9::::

52,S3K214,G"'"T..4G2-4#, !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL &::9:::J:: &::9:::

U+7#K2-+"-.++3"NC:"-.++3"V"W89:::O !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL !):9:::J:: !):9::::

X+M";4-+"*#,K.+-+"I264,G"5#2S4,G"E#KY !:C9Z::"""""""""" ;< &JB& %:89!B&

?$H$-$2&(<(5$'"I2*+(G2'%# LK<;JKAJL

?$H$-$2&(:(F2&7*"'"<#[,S2-4#,3 C(898:("""""""""" ;< !:J&: &9:BC9B8C

/0K262-4#,"$#."$#[,S2-4#,3"NM4-="2>#6+O :

/7+62-#."I4-3 B"""""""""""""""""""""" /H &9:::J:: 8&9::::

;QD"(\";72> C(898:("""""""""" ;< %J:: )9(ZZ9(C(

;72>"#,"@+-27"E+KY"2-"@+AA2,4,+ !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;< 8J&: %&C9%&(

P1G.2S+";72>3"2-"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;< &J:: !9)&:9:::

N)"5+6+73"P,S+.G#[,S"I2.Y4,G"M4-="?#-+7O:

X+M"*#,K.+-+"U2F13"2-"5#2S4,G"E#KY ):9)%("""""""""""" ;< 8:J:: %:(9:C:

I.+K23-"/0-+.4#."2-"/23-"/7+62-4#,"N-#"!:]O B9%%:"""""""""""""" ;< )(J:: )!C9C(:

I.+K23-"/0-+.4#."2-"L+3-"/7+62-4#,"5+6+7"!"N!:^"[1"-#"):]O !9&&("""""""""""""" ;< )(J:: C89%)C(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((<LMK8;@( :

?$H$-$2&(:(F2&7*"'"(G2'%# 8;KJM;K:M@

?$H$-$2&(@(,%-2&*D

Page 310: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

)"#$"% &'!('!)

./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<

*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-'*@P"2-"/7+62-#.";=2$-3"N)"1233+,G+.'"&"<.+4G=-O ):9C::"""""""""""" ;< !)J:: )CC9(::

*@P"2-";#[-="/0-"L277"NH.+,2"*#FF#,"L277O )%9C::"""""""""""" ;< !)J:: 8!%9(::LA8KA;;(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

?$H$-$2&(@(,%-2&*D(G2'%# LA8KA;;

?$H$-$2&(L(,"'%#-/012,34#,"*#,-.#7"2-"/043-4,G"*+,-+. Z)&"""""""""""""""""" 5< !!&J:: !:%98B&

/012,34#,"*#,-.#7"2-"@4S";12, &::"""""""""""""""""" 5< !!&J:: &B9&::

/012,34#,"*#,-.#7"2-"X+M"H.+,2 CC:"""""""""""""""""" 5< !!&J:: &:9%::<8@K@JL(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

;-.[K-[.27";-++7"2-"/0=4>4-";12K+"N)(_';<O 89&::"""""""""""""" `QX; )9%::J:: Z9!::9:::

;-.[K-[.27";-++7"2-"5+6+7"!"N!)_';<O !9C::"""""""""""""" `QX; )9%::J:: 89%8Z9%:&

;-.[K-[.27";-++7"2-"U##$"N(_';<O !9%(!"""""""""""""" `QX; )9%::J:: C98B!9%B!8JK888K<JA((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

@+-27"E+KY"2-"@+AA2,4,+ !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;< 8J:: &%!9!8&

@+-27"E+KY"2-"U##$ C(898:("""""""""" ;< 8J:: !9CCZ9Z)C<K;88K;LN((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

:@43K"@+-273"NJ&"7>3';<O !%("""""""""""""""""" `QX; )9%::J:: C8&9B)Z

@43K";[11#.-3"2-"*@P"L2773 !"""""""""""""""""""""" 5;P@ &:9:::J:: &:9:::

/7+62-#."E464S+."a+2F3 !%"""""""""""""""""""" /H )9&::J:: C:9:::

/7+62-#."D[4S+"U247";[11#.-3 !98):"""""""""""""" 5< &:J:: %%9:::LN8KJ<N((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((

Q.,2F+,-27";-24. %Z"""""""""""""""""""" UT;/U; )9&::J:: !B)9&::

I.+$2>.4K2-+S"@+-27";-24.3"N&"3+-3O 8C&"""""""""""""""""" UT;/U; %::J:: ):B9:::<;JK;;;(((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

?$H$-$2&(L(,"'%#-(G2'%# <;K:;MK;:N

?$H$-$2&(A(,$##I2*+U#[G="K2.1+,-.R"N,#-"4,K7[S4,G"+0=4>4-"=2773O C):98&8"""""""""" D;< :J&: )!:9!BB

@43K"@477M#.Y"N,#-"4,K7[S4,G"+0=4>4-"=2773O C):98&8"""""""""" D;< %J&: )9B8)9)Z&

Page 311: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

8"#$"% &'!('!)

./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<

*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-':

?$H$-$2&(A(,$##I2*+(G2'%# <KN@<K@J8

?$H$-$2&(J(G0"*O%#()*2'"7'$2&L2-+.1.##$4,G"2-"/7+62-#."I4-3 B"""""""""""""""""""""" /H )9:::J:: !C9:::

E2F11.##$4,G"2-"@+-27"I2,+73 %&9&::"""""""""""" ;< )J:: !8!9:::

*2[7Y4,G"2-"/0-+.4#."@+-27"I2,+73"'"I.+K23- BC9B!("""""""""""" ;< !J:: BC9B!(:

*#F1#34-+"@+-27"I2,+73"2-"/23-"/7+62-4#,"N2>#6+"1.+K23-"-#"%:]O C)9!8:"""""""""""" ;< 8CJ:: !9C8)9C):

*#F1#34-+"@+-27"I2,+73"2-"L+3-"/7+62-4#,"5+6+7"!"N!:^O !9&&("""""""""""""" ;< 8CJ:: &)9ZB)

*#F1#34-+"@+-27"I2,+73"2-"L+3-"/7+62-4#,"5+6+7")"NB:^"[1"-#"%:]O )!9(!)"""""""""""" ;< 8CJ:: BC!9%:(

<K<<JK;;;((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

@#S4$4+S"a4-[F+,"U##$4,G C(898:("""""""""" ;< !(J:: (9%ZZ9&CCMKANNKL@@

:?$H$-$2&(J(G0"*O%#()*2'"7'$2&(G2'%# 88K8@AK<A<

?$H$-$2&(M(?22*-(%&P(Q$&P2I-E##.3"'"<.2F+"'"?2.SM2.+"N!"EU"'")::";<9",#-"4,K7[S4,G"+0=4>4-"=277"312K+O )9C!B"""""""""""""" 5b; !9)::J:: )9(ZZ9(C(

:U#77"P1"E##.3"2-"5#2S4,G"E#KY"N):]"-277O ):"""""""""""""""""""" /H 8&9:::J:: B::9:::

@43K"K#474,G"S##.3 !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL C:9:::J:: C:9::::

D7233"2-"L+3-"/7+62-4#,"5+6+7"!"N(:^O !)9C%C"""""""""""" ;< B&J:: Z8C9(::

D7233"2-"L+3-"/7+62-4#,"5+6+7")"N8:^"[1"-#"%:]O Z98C("""""""""""""" ;< B&J:: B:!9!:::

T,-+.4#."D7233"2,S"D72A4,G"N,#"3-#.+$.#,-O !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL &:9:::J:: &:9:::

:?$H$-$2&(M(?22*-(%&P(Q$&P2I-(G2'%# LK:<LKJ@M

E46434#,"Z"<4,43=+3E.RM277"c"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" D;< (J:: !9(%%9C%C

E.RM277"c"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" D;< BJ&: !9(B&9:::

E.RM277"c@+AA2,4,+ !(B9:C&"""""""""" D;< ZJ&: !9BB%9Z)(

Page 312: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

C"#$"% &'!('!)

./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<

*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-'&9&!(98Z)""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" :

I723-+.";#$$4-"2-"/,-.R !B9&::"""""""""""" ;< !&J:: )%)9&::<A<KL;; :

T,-+.4#."<4,43=+3"2-"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" D;< 8)J:: B9C%&9(&%

T,-+.4#."<4,43=+3"2-"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" D;< )J:: &::9:::

T,-+.4#."<4,43=+3"2-"@+AA2,4,+ !(B9:C&"""""""""" D;< !&J:: )9(:&9%B&8;KJJ8KL:8((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

I24,-"2-"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" D;< )J:: C%%9%!%

I24,-"2-"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" D;< 8J:: B&:9:::

I24,-"2-"@+AA2,4,+ !(B9:C&"""""""""" D;< )J:: 8BC9:Z:8KLN;KJ;A((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((((( :

?$H$-$2&(N(R$&$-0"-(G2'%# 8MK8@:K8<N

?$H$-$2&(8;(56"7$%#'$"-`#47+-"HKK+33#.4+3"N)&".+3-.##F39"("3-2773"+2O )&"""""""""""""""""""" /H C9:::J:: !::9:::

`#47+-"I2.-4-4#,3"N)&".+3-.##F39"("3-2773"+2O )::"""""""""""""""""" ;`H55; !9:::J:: )::9::::

<#7S4,G"I2.-4-4#,3"2-"/0=4>4-"?2773"N)&]"-277O C:9%)&"""""""""""" ;< %&J:: )9%C:9%)&

<#7S4,G"I2.-4-4#,3"2-"a277.##F3 89(%C"""""""""""""" ;< %&J:: )&!9!%::

<4.+"/0-4,G[43=+.3" !"""""""""""""""""""""" H55QL &:9:::J:: &:9::::

L2R$4,S4,G"D.21=4K3"'";4G,2G+ %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< :J8& )8C9%)C

:(?$H$-$2&(8;(56"7$%#'$"-(G2'%#( :K@JAK@;N

?$H$-2&(88(.ST$6O"&'<##S";+.64K+"/d[41F+,-"Nae"QLX/UO :

:5#2S4,G"E#KY"/d[41F+,- 8"""""""""""""""""""""" /H !!9&::J:: 8C9&::

5#2S4,G"E#KY"5+6+7+.3 ):"""""""""""""""""""" /H (&:J:: !B9:::

:?$H$-2&(88(.ST$6O"&'(G2'%# L8KL;;

Page 313: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

&"#$"% &'!('!)

./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<

*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-'?$H$-$2&(8<(RT*&$'T*"X#,+ :

?$H$-$2&(8<(RT*&$'T*"(G2'%# ;

?$H$-$2&(8:(56"7$%#(F2&-'*T7'$2&X#,+ :

?$H$-$2&(8:(56"7$%#(F2&-'*T7'$2&(G2'%# ;

?$H$-$2&(8@(F2&H"D$&4(5D-'"O-/3K272-#. C"""""""""""""""""""""" /H !8&9:::J:: &C:9:::

I233+,G+."/7+62-#.3"N)"3-#13"+2K=O %"""""""""""""""""""""" /H !):9:::J:: B):9:::

T,-+.4#."/7+62-#."*2>"<4,43=+3 %"""""""""""""""""""""" /H (9:::J:: C(9:::

<.+4G=-"/7+62-#. &"""""""""""""""""""""" /H !&:9:::J:: B&:9::::

?$H$-$2&(8@(F2&H"D$&4(5D-'"O-(G2'%# <K;LMK;;;

(?$H$-$2&(8L(,"70%&$7%#(?bH* %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< )%J:: !B9C)Z9!B(

I7[F>4,G %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< BJ:: C9%Z)9CB!

<4.+"I.#-+K-4#, %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< 8J:: )9:!!9:&Z:

(?$H$-$2&(8L(,"70%&$7%#(G2'%#( <@K8:<KJ;M

?$H$-$2&(8A(.#"7'*$7%#/7+K-.4K27 %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< )CJ:: !%9:((9CB)

<4.+"H72.F %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< 8J:: )9:!!9:&Z

5#M"b#7-2G+f"E2-2'*#FF[,4K2-4#,3" %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< )J)& !9&:(9)ZC

5#M"b#7-2G+f";[.6"'";+K[.4-R %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< 8J)& )9!B(9%CB

5#M"b#7-2G+f"H'b" %B:98&8"""""""""" D;< )J)& !9&:(9)ZC

(?$H$-$2&(8A(.#"7'*$7%#(G2'%#( <:K<N@KJAJ

GUGVW(FU5G(UR(QU!X 8<JK@<MKAN8

5EYGUGVW(FU5G(UR(QU!X !)B9C)(9%Z! !Z:J:ZD+,+.27"*#,S4-4#,3"N%^O B9%C&9B)! !!JC!

Page 314: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!)

./0$1$'$2&(3(,""'$&4(56%7" 89:;98<!.=>5.?(@9;A98<B(@98:98<B(@9<@98<

*+,-+."/012,34#,*+,-+."/012,34#,"5+6+7"! )8898:("""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"/0=4>4-"?2773 )&:9:::"""""""""" ;<*+,-+."/012,34#,"@+AA2,4,+"5+6+7 !(B9:C&"""""""""" ;<

D;< %B:98&8"""""""""" ;<

?"-7*$6'$2& C'D E2, E&$'(F2-' G2'%#(F2-';[>G[2.S"NK#3-"#$"M#.Y"g"!J)&^O !9&Z)9(&Z )J8(a[47S4,G"I+.F4-"NK#3-"#$"M#.Y"gJ):C^O )&Z9Z&& :J8Za[47S+.3"U43Y"NK#3-"#$"M#.Y"g"J8%B^O C%B9%%8 :JB:D+,+.27"542>474-R"T,3[.2,K+"NK#3-"#$"M#.Y"g"JB:(^O Z:)9!Z& !J8&)*2Z"7'(5T1'2'%# !8(9)ZB9:(C ):%J8:@**"<++"V"8J&^ C9(C:98Z( BJ))D*"a#,S"N;[>-#-27"g"J(8&^O !9!&C9B(! !JB))*2Z"7'(G2'%# !CC9)Z)9)%) )!&J)&@**"*#,-4,G+,KR"V"!:^"0"K#3-"#$"M#.Y !C9C)Z9))% )!J&))*2Z"7'([*%&P(G2'%# !&(9B)!9C(Z )8%JBB

Page 315: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&."-'$/%#()#%0%

)&'&!( %*+,(!%"""""""""" -./

012345675#8 97: ;#< ;857"=#27 >#7?@"=#27ABC"D"(BC"E2@?8F2"G)'"52@?8F2,"!(B"H/"3I4J&52@?8FK A%*B H/ )LBBM"""""""""""""""""""""" !),*'BM"""""""""""""""">N1O1"/#I87?58 !"""""""""""""""""""""" PHHQR !,%BB,BBBLBBM""""""" """""""""""""!,%BB,BBB"

H?8F23?658S"?7"E2@?8F2 )' TP (%%LBBM"""""""""""""""""" +,*+BM""""""""""""""""""U@?V?"U?W58S"G'X".7?J5@5V1F".?8F"&"'X"=#834171K %*+,(!%"""""""""" ./ %LY%M"""""""""""""""""""""" ),(Y(,+'*M"""""""""""H?8F23?658S"GZ1@#3?71")B"74112"$4#O"P418?K )B TP %,BBBLBBM"""""""""""""" !%B,BBBM""""""""""""""U@IOJ58S"G27IJ"?7"1?3N"52@?8FK )' TP ),BBBLBBM"""""""""""""" !!A,BBBM""""""""""""""T@137453?@"G!(B&(B'")U"?7"1?3N"52@?8FK )' TP *,%BBLBBM"""""""""""""" (AY,BBBM""""""""""""""

[M"""""""""""""""""""""""\5F1#"]#?4F ! PHHQR (,%BB,BBBLBBM""""""" (,%BB,BBBM"""""""""""

[M"""""""""""""""""""""""=Q.>"Q/"RQZ^ Y,'BY,)%*M"""""""""""

12345467(8514(5.(95!: Y,'BY,)%*M"""""""""""" !)LY(M""""""""""""""""""-1814?@"=#8F575#82"G*_K A*',AA!M""""""""""""""" BL'(M""""""""""""""""""""".IJSI?4F"G3#27"#$"`#4a"b"!L(%_K +Y,%+(M"""""""""""""""""" BL!YM"""""""""""""""""""""]I5@F58S"U14O57"G3#27"#$"`#4a"bL(BA_K !%,+(YM"""""""""""""""""" BLB)M"""""""""""""""""""""]I5@F142"Z52a"G3#27"#$"`#4a"b"L)*Y_K (',*%)M"""""""""""""""""" BLB%M"""""""""""""""""""""-1814?@"H5?J5@57:"E82I4?831"G3#27"#$"`#4a"b"LYB'_K %%,(Y*M"""""""""""""""""" BL!BM""""""""""""""""""""")*;<"='(1>?';'%# ',AY),(A*M"""""""""""" !AL'+M""""""""""""""""""<=="/11"c")L%_ (+*,%*AM""""""""""""""" BL%(M"""""""""""""""""""""-="]#8F"G.IJ7#7?@"b"L')%_K YB,Y%(M"""""""""""""""""" BL!(M""""""""""""""""""""")*;<"='(4;'%# ','AB,%*!M"""""""""""" !%L%)M""""""""""""""""""<=="=#8758S183:"c"!B_"D"3#27"#$"`#4a ''A,B%*M""""""""""""""" !L%%M""""""""""""""""""""")*;<"='(@*%&A(4;'%# +,Y(A,*!YM"""""""""""" !YLB'M""""""""""""""""""

Page 316: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&.*$/0"(1(!"#$%&'(2"&'"*('3(4-'*3/35" 678976:

:;<999(((((((((( =>? !@AB>@C(;79D76:E(;76876:E(;7:;76:

C"-F*$G'$3& H'I J3, J&$'(23-' K3'%#(23-'C$L$-$3&(:(>$'"M3*+(*+,#"'"-.+"./0#"12.30./4"56.78./43 !"""""""""""""""""""" 9:;< )&=>===?== )&=>===

C$L$-$3&(:(>$'"M3*+(K3'%# :N9<999

C$L$-$3&(8(23&F*"'"@#6/8A0.#/3 )B>==="""""""""" C:@ )=?== B(=>===

C$L$-$3&(8(23&F*"'"(K3'%# ;O9<999

C$L$-$3&(;(,%-3&*IDED1 =

C$L$-$3&(;(,%-3&*I(K3'%# 9

C$L$-$3&(N(,"'%#-:7AF"#/"<+0A7"*+GH )B>==="""""""""" C:@ B?== IJ>===

:0K6G06KA7":0++7"@KA,./4"L&=M':@N J==""""""""""""""" -ED: %>J==?== )>!J=>===

:0K6G06KA7":0++7"@KA,./4"A0"O##$L)=M':@N )B=""""""""""""""" -ED: %>J==?== (JB>===

<.3G"<+0A73"L?&M':@N J"""""""""""""""""""" -ED: B>&==?== )P>===

<+0A7"*+GH"A0"17+QA0+8":0K6G06K+ )B>==="""""""""" C:@ %?== P)>===

<+0A7"*+GH"A0"O##$ )B>==="""""""""" C:@ %?== P)>===

C$L$-$3&(N(,"'%#-(K3'%# 8<:P6<999

C$L$-$3&(D(,$##M3*+O#64R"GAKS+/0KT )B>==="""""""""" C:@ =?&= !)>===

<.3G"<.77U#KH" )B>==="""""""""" C:@ J?&= !&J>====

C$L$-$3&(D(,$##M3*+(K3'%# 6DO<999

C$L$-$3&(Q(KR"*5%#()*3'"F'$3&12SA/3.#/"V#./03"A0"*#,+"'"W+/0+K"12SA/3.#/ (&J""""""""""""""" 9@ !!&?== I(>BB=

XA0+KSK##$./4 )B>==="""""""""" C:@ )?&= J=>===

*A,SK##$./4'WA67H./4"A0"<+0A7"YA/+73 %J>I=="""""""""" :@ %?== !!=>P==

@.K+SK##$./4 )B>==="""""""""" C:@ %?&= (B>===

@.K+SK##$./4"A0"K##$"30K6G06K+ )B>==="""""""""" C:@ )?&= J=>===

<+0A7"YA/+73"L)PZ"0A77"30K6G06K+",./63"47A33N !)>I=="""""""""" :@ %B?== B%(>J==

Page 317: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

)"#$"% &'!('!)

.*$/0"(1(!"#$%&'(2"&'"*('3(4-'*3/35" 678976::;<999(((((((((( =>? !@AB>@C(;79D76:E(;76876:E(;7:;76:

C"-F*$G'$3& H'I J3, J&$'(23-' K3'%#(23-'<+0A7"YA/+73"A0":#$$.0 )B>==="""""""""" :@ %B?== (!J>===

O##$./4 )B>==="""""""""" :@ !(?== B%)>===

C$L$-$3&(Q(KR"*5%#()*3'"F'$3&(K3'%# :<9PP<Q;9

C$L$-$3&(O(C33*-(%&/(S$&/3M-*##K3"'"@KA,+3"'"[AK8UAK+"L!"*O"'"%>===":@N ("""""""""""""""""""" 1\ !>&==?== !)>===

C7A33"A/8"C7A]./4"L!=Z"0A77>"F#0R"3.8+3N J>==="""""""""""" :@ (&?== &!=>===

C$L$-$3&(O(C33*-(%&/(S$&/3M-(K3'%# N::<999

C$L$-$3&(P(?$&$-R"-

@./.3R+3"'"120+K.#K"@KA,./4 )B>==="""""""""" C:@ &%?== !>)P)>===

C$L$-$3&(P(?$&$-R"-(K3'%# 6<:Q:<999

C$L$-$3&(69(>G"F$%#'$"-=

@.K+"120./46.3R+K3" !"""""""""""""""""""" \99EX P>===?== P>====

XAT$./8./4"CKASR.G3 !"""""""""""""""""""" \99EX )&>===?== )&>====

(C$L$-$3&(69(>G"F$%#'$"-(K3'%#( 8:<999

C$L$-3&(66(@TU$G5"&'D#/+ =

=C$L$-3&(66(@TU$G5"&'(K3'%# 9

C$L$-$3&(6:(?U*&$'U*"D#/+ =C$L$-$3&(6:(?U*&$'U*"(K3'%# 9

C$L$-$3&(68(>G"F$%#(23&-'*UF'$3&D#/+ =

C$L$-$3&(68(>G"F$%#(23&-'*UF'$3&(K3'%# 9

C$L$-$3&(6;(23&L"I$&0(>I-'"5-DED1 =

=C$L$-$3&(6;(23&L"I$&0(>I-'"5-(K3'%# 9

(C$L$-$3&(6N(,"FR%&$F%#([^\W )B>==="""""""""" C:@ !(?&= BBB>===

Y76,F./4 )B>==="""""""""" C:@ J?== !BB>===

@.K+"YK#0+G0.#/ )B>==="""""""""" C:@ %?P& I=>===

Page 318: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!)

.*$/0"(1(!"#$%&'(2"&'"*('3(4-'*3/35" 678976::;<999(((((((((( =>? !@AB>@C(;79D76:E(;76876:E(;7:;76:

C"-F*$G'$3& H'I J3, J&$'(23-' K3'%#(23-'

(C$L$-$3&(6N(,"FR%&$F%#(K3'%#( DQO<999

C$L$-$3&(6D(@#"F'*$F%#17+G0K.GA7"'"@.K+"\7AK, )B>==="""""""""" C:@ )B?== &PJ>===

(C$L$-$3&(6D(@#"F'*$F%#(K3'%#( 6<8;;<999

KVK4W(2V>K(V?(SV!X 69<68D<Q;9

>J.KVK4W(2V>K(V?(SV!X !=>!%J>PB= B))?%JC+/+KA7"W#/8.0.#/3"LJ_N J=(>)=B )&?%B:6FG#/0KA0G#K"5#/8"LG#30"#$"U#KH"`"!?)&_N !)J>P=I &?)(56.78./4"Y+K,.0"LG#30"#$"U#KH"`?)=B_N )=>JPI =?(J56.78+K3"O.3H"LG#30"#$"U#KH"`"?%JP_N %P>)=) !?&&C+/+KA7"9.AF.7.0T"a/36KA/G+"LG#30"#$"U#KH"`"?P=(_N P!>PJ( )?II)*3Y"F'(>UZ'3'%# !!>==!>%=% B&(?%I<WW"@++"b"%?&_ %(&>=BJ !J?=BCW"5#/8"L:6F0#0A7"`"?(%&_N I!>(J! %?(%)*3Y"F'(K3'%# !!>BP(>)=I BP(?)JW#/0./4+/GT"b"!=_"2"G#30"#$"U#KH !>!BP>()! BP?(%)*3Y"F'(=*%&/(K3'%# !)>J)J>=%= &)J?=(

Page 319: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'

?$F$-$5&(1(>$'"N5*+(*+,-,+,./ !"""""""""""""""""""""""""" 01123 4&5666766 4&5666

8.9#":;,/+,<="0/>?@-+ ))65&66"""""""""""""" AB 67&6 !!65)&6:;C@D@+."EF )G5&66"""""""""""""""" HI !%766 EJ)5666B,--"EF )G5&66"""""""""""""""" HI !%766 EJ)5666

?$F$-$5&(1(>$'"N5*+(M5'%# J%J5)&6?$F$-$5&(6(L5&7*"'"

B#K<L@+,#</ )!65666"""""""""""""" AB &766 !56&65666:;C@D@+,#<"$#M"$#K<L@+,#</"NO,+?"@P#D.Q 6

:-.D@+#M"R,+/ %"""""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 &5666766 E656666

A2S"N(T"A-@PQ )!65666"""""""""""""" AB %766 !5)%65666

L5&7*"'"(G:!:):G(0=&7#CD"-(O5$-'$&.(%&D()*"P$CP(Q5*(A4R(75#(-H%7$&.8 6H@/+",<"R-@C."1.D.-") )!65666"""""""""""""" AB !J766 E5JJ65666H@/+",<"R-@C."1.D.-"E )!65666"""""""""""""" AB !J766 E5JJ65666H@/+",<"R-@C."1.D.-"G )!65666"""""""""""""" AB !J766 E5JJ65666H@/+",<"R-@C."1.D.-"& )!65666"""""""""""""" AB !J766 E5JJ65666"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""!&5J%65666" 6

RM.C@/+"R@<.-/"@+"1.D.-")":;+.M,#M"NE"/,L./Q G54%6""""""""""""""""""" AB E6766 !G)5(66RM.C@/+"R@<.-/"@+"1.D.-"E":;+.M,#M"NE"/,L./Q G54%6""""""""""""""""""" AB E6766 !G)5(66RM.C@/+"R@<.-/"@+"1.D.-"G":;+.M,#M"NE"/,L./Q G54%6""""""""""""""""""" AB E6766 !G)5(66RM.C@/+"R@<.-/"@+"1.D.-"&":;+.M,#M"NE"/,L./Q G54%6""""""""""""""""""" AB E6766 !G)5(66

&4!5)66"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" 66

H#<CM.+."UM.@L/ E&)"""""""""""""""""""""" :0 !&7&6 &5G&%

?$F$-$5&(6(L5&7*"'"(M5'%# !(5(4%5%&%

Page 320: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

)"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'?$F$-$5&(@(,%-5&*J:-.D@+#M"A?@$+/" 45)66""""""""""""""""""" AB !%766 !!&5)66

A+@,M":<C-#/KM./"NG".@C?Q &54%6""""""""""""""""""" AB !%766 J)5!%6

HV*"@+"1.D.-"!"UM@</>#M+@+,#<"H.<+.M %5%66""""""""""""""""""" A$ !%766 !6&5%66

?$F$-$5&(@(,%-5&*J(M5'%# E!)5J%6

?$F$-$5&(3(,"'%#-A+@,M/"NG"/.+/Q E&)"""""""""""""""""""""" WXA:WA %&6766 ))(5(66

Y@MM,.M"H@P-./"@+"RM.C@/+"R@<.-/"N!!"C@P-./".@"$-##MQ"Z2U"W:[*XW:8 4G5(66"""""""""""""""" 1B 6

Y@MM,.M"H@P-./"@+"W@9>/ !5)66""""""""""""""""""" 1B !7)& !5&66

RM.$@P"V.+@-"H@<#>\"@+"1.D.-"&":-.D@+#M !"""""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 E&5666766 E&5666

Y#--@ML/"@+"1.D.-"!"UM@</>#M+@+,#<"H.<+.M E)"""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 G&6766 !G5G66

V,/C"9.+@-/"N7!6]'SABQ &E"""""""""""""""""""""""" U2ZA G5&66766 )E%5)&6

?$F$-$5&(3(,"'%#-(M5'%# &!&5J&6

?$F$-$5&(A(,$##N5*+<#<. 6

6?$F$-$5&(A(,$##N5*+(M5'%# 6

?$F$-$5&(S(MT"*P%#()*5'"7'$5&UM@$$,C"H#@+,<="1.D.-")"N>M#+.C+,#<"$#M"-,D./+#C^Q )!65666"""""""""""""" AB G7&6 JG&5666

3@+.M>M##$,<="@+":-.D@+#M"R,+/ %"""""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 )5&66766 !&5666

A@<LO,C?"A-@P"@+"1.D.-"&"NZ2Z:Q )!65666"""""""""""""" AB 6

:;>@</,#<"_#,<+"N!".@C?"O@\Q G5%66""""""""""""""""""" 1B !&6766 %J65666

?$F$-$5&(S(MT"*P%#()*5'"7'$5&(M5'%# !5%&65666

?$F$-$5&(U(?55*-(%&D(V$&D5N-8##M/"'"BM@9."'"`@MLO@M."N(">.M"$-##MQ G6"""""""""""""""""""""""" 1aA !5)66766 G(5666

?$F$-$5&(U(?55*-(%&D(V$&D5N-(M5'%# G(5666

Page 321: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

E"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'

?$F$-$5&(W(G$&$-T"-3@-^O@\"@+"1.D.-")"+#"0M.<@ &5)(6""""""""""""""""""" AB &&766 )J65G66

R@,<+"C.,-,<="@--"-.D.-/ (G65666"""""""""""""" AB 67(6 %4)5666

R@,<+".;+.M,#M"C#-K9</ !!%"""""""""""""""""""""" :0 !&6766 !45G666

?$F$-$5&(W(G$&$-T"-(M5'%# J4J5(66

Page 322: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

G"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'?$F$-$5&(94(>H"7$%#'$"-B,M.":;+,<=K,/?.M/"NG">.M"$-##MQ )6"""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 !&6766 E5666

3@\$,<L,<="SM@>?,C/"'"A,=<@=. !56&65666""""""""""" SAB 67E& E%45&66

(?$F$-$5&(94(>H"7$%#'$"-(M5'%#( E465&66

?$F$-5&(99(;XC$HP"&'R@M^,<=":bK,>9.<+ !"""""""""""""""""""""""""" 01123 4&5666766 4&5666

6?$F$-5&(99(;XC$HP"&'(M5'%# 4&5666

?$F$-$5&(91(GC*&$'C*"Z#<. 6?$F$-$5&(91(GC*&$'C*"(M5'%# 6

?$F$-$5&(96(>H"7$%#(L5&-'*C7'$5&Z#<. 6

6?$F$-$5&(96(>H"7$%#(L5&-'*C7'$5&(M5'%# 6

?$F$-$5&(9@(L5&F"J$&.(>J-'"P-R@//.<=.M":-.D@+#M/"c"%".@5"&"/+#>/ E6"""""""""""""""""""""""" AU2RA E&5666766 !56&65666

:/C@-@+#M/"c"G".@C? G"""""""""""""""""""""""""" :0 E)&5666766 !5E6656666

?$F$-$5&(9@(L5&F"J$&.(>J-'"P-(M5'%# )5E&65666

(?$F$-$5&(93(,"7T%&$7%#(`a0H !56&65666""""""""""" SAB 676& &)5&66

`a0H"K>=M@L."@+"1.D.-"!"$#M"1,D./+#C^"NZ2Z:Q )!65666"""""""""""""" AB 6

`a0H"K>=M@L."@+"3@-^O@\ &5)(6""""""""""""""""""" AB !6766 &)5(66

R-K9P,<= !56&65666""""""""""" SAB 67E& E%45&66

R-K9P,<="K>=M@L."@+"1.D.-"!"$#M"1,D./+#C^ )!65666"""""""""""""" AB 67G6 (G5666

A+@<L"R,>. !56&65666""""""""""" SAB 67)& )%)5&66

A>M,<^-.M"A\/+.9"@+"1.D.-"! )!65666"""""""""""""" AB 67)& &)5&666

(?$F$-$5&(93(,"7T%&$7%#(M5'%#( (4!5(66

Page 323: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

&"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'?$F$-$5&(9A(;#"7'*$7%#:-.C+M,C@- !56&65666""""""""""" SAB !7)6 !5)%65666

*>=M@L."1,=?+,<="@+"SM#K<L"1.D.-" )!65666"""""""""""""" AB 67&6 !6&5666

A.CKM,+\ !56&65666""""""""""" SAB 67)& )%)5&66

(?$F$-$5&(9A(;#"7'*$7%#(M5'%#( !5%)45&66

MYMZE(LY>M(YG(VY![ 1U2A@S2@9A

Page 324: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!)

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&)%*+$&.(/%*%."(012344('5(62444(7%*-8( 49:64:91

!;<=>;?(@:4A:91B(@:96:91B(@:1@:91/*5C&D(E"F"# 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(1 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(6 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(@ 1942444(((((((((((((( >GE"F"#(3 1942444(((((((((((((( >G

924342444((((((((((( />G

?"-7*$H'$5& I'J K5, K&$'(L5-' M5'%#(L5-'>K\MYMZE(LY>M(YG(VY![ )(5%G45G!% )47)(S.<.M@-"H#<L,+,#</"N%dQ !54!(5(G& !7%GAKP=K@ML"NC#/+"#$"O#M^"e"!7)&dQ E&(56JE 67EGYK,-L,<="R.M9,+"NC#/+"#$"O#M^"e7)6GdQ &(5GG! 676%YK,-L.M/"W,/^"NC#/+"#$"O#M^"e"7E%4dQ !6&5!E% 67!6S.<.M@-"1,@P,-,+\"X</KM@<C."NC#/+"#$"O#M^"e"746(dQ )6)5()G 67!J)*5]"7'(>C^'5'%# E!56J654&G )J7%!VHH"B.."f"E7&d !56((5!4% !76GSH"Y#<L"NAKP+#+@-"e"7(E&dQ )&J5%6( 67)&)*5]"7'(M5'%# E)5GE(5&E( E67(JVHH"H#<+,<=.<C\"f"!6d";"C#/+"#$"O#M^ E5)GE5(&G E76J)*5]"7'(/*%&D(M5'%# E&5%()5EJ) EE7J(

Page 325: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&.$'"()%/$&0

)&'&!( (%'*!++"""""""""" ,-

./0123453#6 758 9#: 9635";#05 <#5=>";#05953>353/0 ! ?, !(%*@@@A@@B"""""""""" !(%*@@@B"""""""""""""""./C#"/D30536E".#C/".23F/ (%'*!++"""""""""" ,- @A(%B"""""""""""""""""""""" +G*%G(B"""""""""""""""""./C#"/D30536E".#C/&,5=H3IC".23F/ %'*J@@"""""""""""" ,- @A(%B"""""""""""""""""""""" !G*+J%B"""""""""""""""""./C#"/D30536E"1#612/5/"=5"1#26/2"#$"+!@&-=6636"$#2"<I2$"-=2C ((%*@@@"""""""""" ,- @A(%B"""""""""""""""""""""" %+*(%@B"""""""""""""""""

KB"""""""""""""""""""""""L=F36E"=5".#C/".23F/"'M",5=N&'M";#612/5/ (%'*!++"""""""""" ,- JA@@B"""""""""""""""""""""" !*'@J*!+(B"""""""""""L=F36E"=5".#C/&,5=H3IC".23F/"'M",5=N&'M";#612/5/ %'*J@@"""""""""""" ,- JA@@B"""""""""""""""""""""" G!@*O@@B"""""""""""""""

L=F36E"=5"1#26/2"#$"+!@&-=6636"$#2"<I2$"-=2C ((%*@@@"""""""""" ,- JA@@B"""""""""""""""""""""" !*%J%*@@@B"""""""""""KB"""""""""""""""""""""""

P/Q#2R"S/0523HE/"T652=61/"U0/4=2=5/"35/CV !"""""""""""""""""""""" W??XS !*)@@*@@@A@@B""""""" !*)@@*@@@B"""""""""""KB"""""""""""""""""""""""

P#>>36E";I2N0"=5".#C/".23F/ +*J'G"""""""""""""" ?- !%A@@B"""""""""""""""""""" !@!*J+@B"""""""""""""""P#>>36E";I2N0"=5".#C/&,5=H3IC".23F/ (*G@@"""""""""""""" ?- !A@@B"""""""""""""""""""""" (*G@@B"""""""""""""""""""

KB"""""""""""""""""""""""T>/15231=>"K"2/>#1=5/"/D30536E">3EY5"4#>/0 ! W??XS J%*@@@A@@B"""""""""""" J%*@@@B"""""""""""""""""

;X,<"X-"SXPZ %*%)(*+'OB"""""""""""

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`")A%\ (!@*!+@B""""""""""""""" @A'!B"""""""""""""""""""""[;"^#6H"U,IN5#5=>"]"A')%\V %@*!)'B"""""""""""""""""" @A!OB""""""""""""""""""""")*;<"='(3;'%# +*(+G*'J@B"""""""""""" (GA(JB""""""""""""""""""":;;";#6536E/618"`"!@\"D"1#05"#$"Q#2R +(+*G'JB""""""""""""""" (AG)B""""""""""""""""""""")*;<"='(@*%&A(3;'%# +*'O!*)%JB"""""""""""" (+A+OB"""""""""""""""""""

Page 326: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"! %&!'&!(

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&./012 3456437

!189:1;(<46=437>(<435437>(<47<4372"?"#(3@3A(BC--DE"(5=F666(:G(HII'J*$&'K =L<F666((((((((( :G

=L<F666((((((((( M:G

!IIH 5=F666((((((((((( :G0NJ$O%#(MD"-'*IIE-(B=6(P"N-(4(G#II*K A66((((((((((((((((( 1C:D$'"- 366((((((((((((((((( 1C

;"-O*$J'$I& Q'N RI, R&$'(SI-' 0I'%#(SI-';$?$-$I&(7(:$'"TI*+()*+,"-#+./"01213. 4

4

;$?$-$I&(5(SI&O*"'"

"5#6781+*#79"$#2"-#+./":;7,17<.=.7+"$2#=">.7+.2";?@179*#7A" BCD444""""""""""" E5 %F44 !'4D444

";?<1G1+*#7":;7,17<.=.7+"$2#=">.7+.2";?@179*#7"H"!4IA" !BDBBB""""""""""" >J !CF44 (!BDBBB4

>#9+"@.2"K.L":M7</68.9"1//"<#9+".?<.@+"$#6781+*#79A !D444""""""""""""" K;JE !N%D444F44 !N%D444D444

O##/"P//#Q17<.":1+">.7+.2";?@179*#7"R##$A !""""""""""""""""""""" PSST) N%4D444F44 N%4D444

55U;" !D444""""""""""""" K;JE V4D444F44 V4D444D444

5##8"E.2G*<.";W6*@=.7+ !""""""""""""""""""""" PSST) (D444D444F44 (D444D444

S16782L";W6*@=.7+" !""""""""""""""""""""" PSST) %44D444F44 %44D444

0/0C2(S/:0(/G(U/!P 73LF=<5F555

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

Page 327: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

!"#$"% &'!('!%

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&./'"#(0%*%1"

)'('!%*+,-./.#0+,"12.34+/"5%"6-7-689 &:!;!<< => !(!: 8?2@-8"5)%&"8$9A#B-."A-7-6"C#D-6"A#EEF"5%"A-7-689 &(;%:G =>A#B-."A-7-6"=-.74@-"H.-2"5%"A-7-689 &I;&GI =>

JII;III""""""""" K=>

2"-3*$4'$/& 5'6 7/, 7&$'(8/-' 9/'%#(8/-'2$:$-$/&(;(<$'"=/*+(L-B2D-.4+/"5M-N?#.2.F"$#."!OF-2.9 %;<I:""""""""""""" A> %&IPIIQ"""""""""""""""""" GI%;%&IQ"""""""""""""""=R#.4+/ &%;::(""""""""""" => !JPIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" :II;:GGQ"""""""""""""""

OQ"""""""""""""""""""""""""S288"TU@272D4#+"$#."*+,-./.#0+,"12.34+/"5%&V",--?9" G%<;J<!""""""""" WX !<PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" (;J<G;)JIQ"""""""""""""=4D-"*D464D4-8"5B4DR"W-+D-."TU?2+84#+9" OQ"""""""""""""""""""""""""=D#.N'=2+4D2.F'Y2D-."5B4DR"W-+D-."TU?2+84#+9" OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""

OQ"""""""""""""""""""""""""A2+,8@2?4+/"'"Z..4/2D4#+" !""""""""""""""""""""" HAA[Y OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""\-6#@2D-"D.--8" O"""""""""""""""""" OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""

OQ"""""""""""""""""""""""""]-B"=4D-"W#[email protected]"1274+/"5B4DR"W-+D-."TU?2+84#+9" OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""

2$:$-$/&(>(8/&3*"'">#0+,2D4#+8"5B4DR"@-+D-."-U?2+84#[email protected]"W#[email protected]"L-@3"5Z+D-.N-,42D-"A-7-69 )&I;III""""""""" => %IPIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" J;III;IIIQ""""""""""""[email protected]"W#[email protected]"L-@3"5C#D-6"A-7-6"!9 )&I;III""""""""" => %IPIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" J;III;IIIQ""""""""""""T6-72D#."14D8 G""""""""""""""""""""" TH &;&IIPIIQ"""""""""""""" ));IIIQ""""""""""""""""""

%%;JJ:;)JI"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""" OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""2$:$-$/&(?(,"'%#- OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""=D24.8"'"\2468"5<"8-D89 !;J!(""""""""""""" \Z=T\= J&IPIIQ"""""""""""""""""" !;%((;J((Q""""""""""""S48@"S-D268"5P&^'=>9 !J&""""""""""""""""" M[]= <;&IIPIIQ"""""""""""""" J(J;&IIQ"""""""""""""""

OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""2$:$-$/&(@(A%'"*4*//B$&1 OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""Y2D-.?.##$4+/"2D"T6-72D#."14D8 G""""""""""""""""""""" TH !;&IIPIIQ"""""""""""""" :;IIIQ""""""""""""""""""""

OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""2$:$-$/&(C(D$&$-E"- OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""124+D"K2.2/- &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> IP)IQ"""""""""""""""""""""" !JJ;)<)Q"""""""""""""""_046,#0D"C#D-6"T6-72D#."A#EE4-8 &(;%:G""""""""""" K=> )&PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" %;I<I;)GIQ""""""""""""_046,#0D"C#D-6"=-.74@-"A#EE4-8 &I;&GI""""""""""" K=> !&PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""" J&(;<IIQ"""""""""""""""

OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""2$:$-$/&(FG(H#":%'/*- OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""1288-+/-."T6-72D#.8"5G"-2@R;"%"8D#?89 !%""""""""""""""""""" =M[1= )G;IIIPIIQ"""""""""""" <)%;IIIQ"""""""""""""""

(2$:$-$/&(F?(,"3E%&$3%#(C`HW"5-UR208D"K2.2/-"#+6F9 &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> IP&IQ"""""""""""""""""""""" %:&;&J%Q"""""""""""""""C`HW"2D"A#EE4-8 !I(;(&G""""""""" K=> <PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""""" <)&;<%<Q"""""""""""""""160NE4+/ &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> IP(IQ"""""""""""""""""""""" <J%;:!&Q"""""""""""""""=D2+,"14?-"2D"K2.2/- &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> IP)&Q"""""""""""""""""""""" %IG;:IIQ"""""""""""""""=?.4+36-."=F8D-N"2D"A#EE4-8 !I(;(&G""""""""" => !P%&Q"""""""""""""""""""""" !)G;IJIQ"""""""""""""""

OQ""""""""""""""""""""""""

Page 328: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

%"#$"% &'!('!%

!"#$%&'()%*+(,%-'"*()#%&./'"#(0%*%1"

)'('!%*+,-./.#0+,"12.34+/"5%"6-7-689 &:!;!<< => !(!: 8?2@-8"5)%&"8$9A#B-."A-7-6"C#D-6"A#EEF"5%"A-7-689 &(;%:G =>A#B-."A-7-6"=-.74@-"H.-2"5%"A-7-689 &I;&GI =>

JII;III""""""""" K=>

2"-3*$4'$/& 5'6 7/, 7&$'(8/-' 9/'%#(8/-'2$:$-$/&(FI(H#"3'*$3%#

[email protected]@26"'">4.-"H62.N"'"A#B"`#6D2/-"2D"K2.2/- &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> %P&IQ"""""""""""""""""""""" !;<JJ;(GIQ""""""""""""[email protected]@26"'">4.-"H62.N"'"A#B"`#6D2/-"2D"A#EE4-8 !I(;(&G""""""""" K=> )PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""""" )%G;&G(Q"""""""""""""""[email protected]"2D"K2.2/- &:!;!<<""""""""" K=> IPJ&Q"""""""""""""""""""""" <<);)&(Q"""""""""""""""[email protected]"2D"A#EE4-8 !I(;(&G""""""""" K=> !PIIQ"""""""""""""""""""""" !I(;(&GQ"""""""""""""""

W[=M"[>"Y[\a ));GJ:;&I!Q""""""""""

<7J9K9LM(8K<9(KD(AK!N ));GJ:;&I!Q"""""""""" <(P!!Q""""""""""""""""""""K-+-.26"W#+,4D4#+8"5Gb9 %;I%I;JJIQ"""""""""""" %P(:Q""""""""""""""""""""""=0E/02.,"5@#8D"#$"B#.3"c"!P%&b9 <%I;::<Q""""""""""""""" IPGIQ""""""""""""""""""""""_046,4+/"1-.N4D"5@#8D"#$"B#.3"cP%I<b9 G(;JIGQ"""""""""""""""""" IP!IQ""""""""""""""""""""""_046,-.8"\483"5@#8D"#$"B#.3"c"P)GJb9 !%);GI<Q""""""""""""""" IP!(Q""""""""""""""""""""""K-+-.26"A42E464DF"Z+80.2+@-"5@#8D"#$"B#.3"c"PJI(b9 %)(;<&!Q""""""""""""""" IP)<Q"""""""""""""""""""""")*/O"3'(<PQ'/'%# )G;&&%;I%GQ"""""""""" &%P%%Q""""""""""""""""""""SWW">--"d")P&b !;%J:;)%!Q"""""""""""" !P()Q""""""""""""""""""""""KW"_#+,"5=0ED#D26"c"P()&b9 )I&;%I:Q""""""""""""""" IP<<Q"""""""""""""""""""""")*/O"3'(9/'%# )(;!)G;&&GQ"""""""""" &<P<(Q""""""""""""""""""""SWW"W#+D4+/-+@F"d"!Ib"U"@#8D"#$"B#.3 );(!);G&GQ"""""""""""" &P<&Q"""""""""""""""""""""")*/O"3'(0*%&R(9/'%# <!;:&I;%!!Q"""""""""" &:P:)Q""""""""""""""""""""

Page 329: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

 

Appendix  V:  Preliminary Analysis of Potential Capital Structures for Astrodome Redevelopment  

   

Page 330: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Contacts:

Michael Bartolotta Trey Cash Phillip MartinMichael Bartolotta Trey Cash Phillip MartinVice Chairman Senior Vice President Vice President700 Milam Street, Suite 500 700 Milam Street, Suite 500 700 Milam Street, Suite 500 Houston, TX 77002 Houston, TX 77002 Houston, TX 77002Phone: 713.654.8641 Phone: 713.654.8651 Phone: 713.654.8620Fax: 713.651.9361 Fax: 713.651.9361 Fax: 713.651.9361E il i h l b t l tt @fi t E il t h@fi t E il hilli ti @fi tEmail: [email protected] Email: [email protected] Email: [email protected]

Harris County Sports & Convention CorporationPreliminary Analysis of Potential Capital Structures for Astrodome Redevelopment

Page 331: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Table of ContentsPreliminary – For Discussion Purposes Only

HA

Tab A: Estimated Capital Structure

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab B: Pro-Forma Cash Flows

Tab C: Rehabilitation Ta Credits YS

PO

RT

S&

Tab C: Rehabilitation Tax Credits

Tab D: New Market Tax Credit Program &

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

Tab E: EB-5 Program

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

Tab F: Tax Increment Financing

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

1 May 23, 2012

Page 332: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

AEstimated Capital Structure

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab A

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 333: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Multipurpose with Expansion (‘000’s)H

A

MultiPurpose

Estimated Project Cost(1) 385,358 270,331 655,689

Expansion Total

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Projected Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit(2) - 40,550 40,550 Projected New Market Tax Credit(3) 7,315 4,872 12,187 Projected EB5(4) 65,000 15,000 80,000

Subtotal 72 315 60 422 132 737 YS

PO

RT

S&

Subtotal 72,315 60,422 132,737

Required other financing (5) 313,043 209,909 522,952 (6)

Notes:Th i li i d d k d dili fi d if ( ) h i k il bl d (b) k

&

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market costs are similar to projected.

(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.

(2) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).(3) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of O

NC

OR

PO

RA

g , q ( )effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million.

(4) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 800 jobs(650 for expansion & 150 for multipurpose), and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity.

(5) Other financing vehicles ( e.g. Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds, Texas Economic Development Fund loans) have been identified as potentialfinancing options but not quantified

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

3

financing options, but not quantified.(6) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.

Page 334: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Multipurpose with Expansion (‘000’s) MultiExpansion Total

HA

Equity: PurposeProjected Rehabilitation (Historic)

Tax Credit(1) n/a 40,550 40,550 Funding Breakdown ('000's):Projected New Market Tax Credit(2) 7,315 4,872 12,187 Equity (Tax Credits) 52,737

Equity Subtotal: 7,315 45,422 52,737 [A] Debt 602,952

Expansion Total

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

q y , , , [ ] ,

Debt: Total 655,689 Projected EB5 Loan(3) 65,000 15,000 80,000 [B]

Total Tax Credits/Loans:(4)72,315 60,422 132,737 [C] = [A]+[B]

YS

PO

RT

S&

Required other financing (Debt) (5) 313,043 209,909 522,952 [D] = [F]-[C]

Total Sources of Funds: 385,358 270,331 655,689 [E] = [C]+[D]

Estimated Project Cost: (6)385,358 270,331 655,689 [F] &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

Notes:These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market costs are similar to projected.

(1) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).(2) New Market TaxCredit assuming allocation can be found with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62 5% of O

NC

OR

PO

RA

New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of

effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million. (3) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 800 jobs

(650 for expansion & 150 for multipurpose), and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. (4) Other financing vehicles ( e.g. Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds, Texas Economic Development Fund loans) have been identified as potential

financing options but not quantified

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

4

financing options, but not quantified.(5) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.(6)

Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.

Page 335: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Expansion Only (‘000’s)H

A

Expansion

Estimated Project Cost(1) 385,358

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Projected New Market Tax Credit(2) 12,187 Projected EB5(3) 78,000

Subtotal 90,187

YS

PO

RT

S&

Required other financing (4) 295,171 (5)

Notes: &

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market

costs are similar to projected.

(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.(2) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million. (3) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 780 jobs, and

every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. (4) Other financing vehicles ( e.g. Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds, Texas Economic Development Fund loans) have been identified as potential

financing options, but not quantified.

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

5

(5) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.

Page 336: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Expansion Only (‘000’s) H

A

Equity: Expansion Funding Breakdown ('000's):Projected New Market Tax Credit(1)

12,187 [A] Equity (Tax Credits) 12,187 Debt: Debt/Loans 373,171

P j t d EB5 L (2) RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Projected EB5 Loans(2)78,000 [B] Total 385,358

Total Tax Credits/Loans:(3)90,187 [C] = [A]+[B]

Required other financing (Debt) (4)295,171 [D] = [F]-[C]

YS

PO

RT

S&

Total Sources of Funds: 385,358 [E] = [C]+[D]

Estimated Project Cost: (5)385,358 [F]

&

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

Notes:

These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market

costs are similar to projected.

(1) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of

effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million. ON

CO

RP

OR

A

(2) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 780 jobs, and

every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. (3) Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment

Zone bonds and Texas Economic Development Fund loans.(4) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

6

The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.(5) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.

Page 337: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Multipurpose Only (‘000’s)H

A

Multipurpose

Estimated Project Cost(1) 270,331

Projected Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit(2) 40 550 RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Projected Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit 40,550 Projected New Market Tax Credit(3) 12,187 Projected EB5(4) 15,000

Subtotal 67,737

( ) ( ) YS

PO

RT

S&

Required other financing (5) 202,594 (6)

Notes:

These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market &

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

costs are similar to projected.

(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.(2) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).(3) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

at 62.5% of effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million. (4) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 150 jobs,

and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. (5) Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment

Zone bonds and Texas Economic Development Fund loans.

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

7

(6) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.

Page 338: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Estimated Capital Structure – Multipurpose Only (‘000’s) Equity: Multipurpose

HA

Projected Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit(1)40,550 Funding Breakdown ('000's):

Projected New Market Tax Credit(2)12,187 Equity (Tax Credits) 52,737

Equity Subtotal: 52,737 [A] Debt 217,594

Debt: Total 270,331 RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Debt: Total 270,331 Projected EB5 Loan(3)

15,000 [B]

Total Tax Credits/Loans:(4)67,737 [C] = [A]+[B]

Required other financing (Debt) (5)202 594 [D] [F] [C] Y

SP

OR

TS

&

Required other financing (Debt) ( )202,594 [D] = [F]-[C]

Total Sources of Funds: 270,331 [E] = [C]+[D]

Estimated Project Cost: (6)270,331 [F]

&

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

Notes:These estimates are very preliminary and need market due diligence to find if (a) there is a market available and (b) market costs are similar to projected.

(1) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).(2) New Market TaxCredit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of O

NC

OR

PO

RA

New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured ($50 million) with market value at 62.5% of

effective credit. Due to the limited availability of allocations, the maximum amount available has been capped at $50 million. (3) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon 150 jobs,

and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. (4) Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment

Z b d d T E i D l t F d l

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

8

Zone bonds and Texas Economic Development Fund loans.(5) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized.(6) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.

Page 339: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

APro-Forma Cash Flows

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab B

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 340: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Pro-Forma Cash Flows - Multipurpose with Expansion (‘000’s) Assumes 3% Annual Growth (1) Multi-Purpose with Expansion

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2022 2023 2027 2028 2032 2033 2037 2038 2042

HA

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 - 2022 2023 - 2027 2028-2032 2033-2037 2038-2042Revenues(1)

Event Revenues 45,106 46,459 47,853 49,288 50,767 277,614 321,831 373,091 432,514 501,402 Non-Event Revenues 3,127 3,221 3,318 3,417 3,520 19,246 22,312 25,866 29,985 34,761 Additional Required Revenues (1.50x) - 9,868 56,447 56,281 56,105 288,161 298,621 292,552 285,525 277,360 Total Revenues 48,233 59,548 107,617 108,986 110,391 585,022 642,764 691,508 748,024 813,523

Expenses(1)

Salaries 10 043 10 344 10 654 10 974 11 303 61 809 71 654 83 066 96 296 111 634 RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Salaries 10,043 10,344 10,654 10,974 11,303 61,809 71,654 83,066 96,296 111,634 Utilities (Incremental) 1,545 1,591 1,639 1,688 1,739 9,509 11,024 12,779 14,815 17,174 G&A 279 288 296 305 314 1,718 1,992 2,309 2,677 3,103 Event expenses 18,241 18,789 19,352 19,933 20,531 112,271 130,152 150,882 174,914 202,773 Non-Event expenses 12,787 13,170 13,565 13,972 14,392 78,699 91,233 105,764 122,610 142,139 Total Expenses 42,895 44,181 45,507 46,872 48,278 264,005 306,055 354,801 411,312 476,823

Projected NOI (with Additional Revenues) 5,338 15,366 62,111 62,114 62,113 321,016 336,710 336,707 336,712 336,700

YS

PO

RT

S&

Projected NOI (without Additional Revenues) 5,338 5,498 5,663 5,833 6,008 32,855 38,088 44,155 51,188 59,341

Projected D/S Requirements:(7)

EB5 Loan(2) (3% Int Only): - 2,400 2,400 2,400 2,400 7,200 - - - - EB5 Fix-out(2) (6%, 30yr): - - - - - 11,770 29,432 29,430 29,432 29,435

Required Other Financing(5)(6%, 30yr): - 7,844 39,007 39,009 39,009 195,041 195,041 195,042 195,043 195,032 Total Projected Debt Service: - 10,244 41,407 41,409 41,409 214,011 224,473 224,472 224,475 224,467 &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

Revenues in Excess of 1.00x Coverage(8) 5,338 5,122 20,704 20,705 20,704 107,005 112,237 112,236 112,237 112,233

Coverage (with Additional Revenues)(3) n/a 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x

Coverage (w/o Additional Revenues)(3) n/a 0.54x 0.14x 0.14x 0.15x 0.15x 0.17x 0.20x 0.23x 0.26x

Notes:(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation. Projected Sources of Funds (000's)(7)

Sources MP w/Exp(2) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon the creation of 780 jobs, and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. ON

CO

RP

OR

A

Sources MP w/Exp

Historic Tax Credit(9) [Equity] 40,550 (3) Coverage based on 3% growth. Rating agencies may require coverage without growth in revenues. New Market Tax Credit(4)[Equity] 12,187

EB5 Loans(2) [Debt] 80,000

Subtotal 132,737

Required Other Financing(6) 522,952 (6)

(5) Estimated debt service on additional required funds needed to finance the project, after accounting for the EB5 loan funds, NMTC and Historic Tax Credits. Assumes a 30 year level debt service financing at the fixed rate of 6.0% with principal amortized from 2015 through 2041.

Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds

( ) p g j y y p j , y j p yThe EB5 loan assumes a seven year interest only period and upon expiration is refinanced by the issuance of 30 year level debt (the "EB5 Fix-out"), at a rate of 6.0% and principal amortized from 2021 through 2049.

(4) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured with market value at 62.5% of effective credit. Due to their limited availability, assumes allocation capped at $50 million.

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

10

Total Project Funding(1) 655,689 (7) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized. Last year of additional revs: 2043(8) Excess Revenues may be used for additional project funding, M&O, early repayment of outstanding debt, etc. Yr of final debt payment: 2049(9) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).

g p g p q pand Texas Economic Development Fund loans.

Page 341: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Pro-Forma Cash Flows – Expansion Only (‘000’s) Assumes 3% Annual Growth (1) Expansion Only

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2022 2023 2027 2028 2032 2033 2037 2038 2042

HA

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 - 2022 2023 - 2027 2028-2032 2033-2037 2038-2042Revenues(1)

Event Revenues 43,930 45,247 46,605 48,003 49,443 270,375 313,439 363,361 421,235 488,327 Non-Event Revenues 2,612 2,690 2,771 2,854 2,940 16,077 18,637 21,606 25,047 29,036 Additional Required Revenues (1.50x) - 9,604 29,641 29,408 29,167 152,185 160,306 151,995 142,357 131,199 Total Revenues 46,542 57,542 79,017 80,265 81,550 438,637 492,381 536,962 588,640 648,563

Expenses(1)

S l i 10 043 10 344 10 654 10 974 11 303 61 809 71 654 83 066 96 296 111 634 RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Salaries 10,043 10,344 10,654 10,974 11,303 61,809 71,654 83,066 96,296 111,634 Utilities (Incremental) 515 530 546 563 580 3,170 3,675 4,260 4,938 5,725 G&A 232 239 246 253 261 1,426 1,654 1,917 2,222 2,576 Event expenses 17,922 18,460 19,013 19,584 20,171 110,305 127,874 148,241 171,852 199,224 Non-Event expenses 10,511 10,826 11,151 11,486 11,830 64,693 74,997 86,943 100,790 116,844 Total Expenses 39,222 40,399 41,611 42,859 44,145 241,404 279,853 324,427 376,099 436,002

Projected NOI (with Additional Revenues) 7,319 17,143 37,406 37,406 37,404 197,233 212,528 212,535 212,540 212,561

YS

PO

RT

S&

Projected NOI (without Additional Revenues) 7,319 7,539 7,765 7,998 8,238 45,048 52,223 60,540 70,183 81,361

Projected D/S Requirements:(7)

EB5 Loan(2) (3% Int Only): - 2,340 2,340 2,340 2,340 7,020 - - - - EB5 Fix-out(2) (6%, 30yr): - - - - - 11,476 28,696 28,694 28,696 28,699

Required Other Financing(5)(6%, 30yr): - 9,089 22,598 22,597 22,596 112,993 112,989 112,996 112,997 113,008 Total Projected Debt Service: - 11,429 24,938 24,937 24,936 131,489 141,686 141,690 141,694 141,707 &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

j , , , , , , , , ,

Revenues in Excess of 1.00x Coverage(8) 7,319 5,714 12,469 12,469 12,468 65,744 70,843 70,845 70,847 70,854

Coverage (with Additional Revenues)(3) n/a 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x

Coverage (w/o Additional Revenues)(3) n/a 0.66x 0.31x 0.32x 0.33x 0.34x 0.37x 0.43x 0.50x 0.57x

Notes:(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation.

P j t d S f F d (000' )(7) ON

CO

RP

OR

A

Projected Sources of Funds (000's)(7)

Sources Expansion(3) Coverage based on 3% growth. Rating agencies may require coverage without growth in revenues. New Market Tax Credit(4)[Equity] 12,187

EB5 Loans(2) [Debt] 78,000

Subtotal 90,187

Required Other Financing(6) 295,171

Estimated debt service on additional required funds needed to finance the project, after accounting for the EB5 loan funds, NMTC and Historic Tax Credits. Assumes a 30 year level debt service financing at the fixed rate of 6.0% with principal amortized from 2015 through 2041.

(5)

EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon the creation of 780 jobs, and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. The EB5 loan assumes a seven year interest only period and upon expiration is refinanced by the issuance of 30 year level debt (the "EB5 Fix-out"), at a rate of 6.0% and principal amortized from 2021 through 2049.

(2)

New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured with market value at 62.5% of effective credit. Due to their limited availability, assumes allocation capped at $50 million.

(4)

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

11

(6)

Total Project Funding(1) 385,358 (7) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized. Last year of additional revs: 2043(8) Excess Revenues may be used for additional project funding, M&O, early repayment of outstanding debt, etc. Yr of final debt payment: 2049

Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds and Texas Economic Development Fund loans.

Page 342: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Pro-Forma Cash Flows – Multipurpose Only (‘000’s) Assumes 3% Annual Growth (1) Multi-Purpose Only

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2022 2023 2027 2028 2032 2033 2037 2038 2042

HA

2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 - 2022 2023 - 2027 2028-2032 2033-2037 2038-2042Revenues(1)

Event Revenues 32,926 33,914 34,931 35,979 37,059 202,651 234,928 272,346 315,724 366,011 Non-Event Revenues 2,096 2,159 2,224 2,291 2,359 12,902 14,957 17,340 20,101 23,303 Additional Required Revenues (1.50x) 2,287 12,147 25,767 25,844 25,914 132,746 137,933 140,533 143,550 147,051 Total Revenues 37,309 48,220 62,922 64,114 65,332 348,299 387,819 430,219 479,375 536,364

Expenses(1)

Salaries 9 830 10 125 10 429 10 742 11 064 60 503 70 140 81 311 94 262 109 275 RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Salaries 9,830 10,125 10,429 10,742 11,064 60,503 70,140 81,311 94,262 109,275 Utilities (Incremental) 1,030 1,061 1,093 1,126 1,159 6,339 7,349 8,520 9,877 11,450 G&A 258 265 273 281 290 1,585 1,837 2,130 2,469 2,862 Event expenses 14,696 15,137 15,591 16,059 16,541 90,452 104,859 121,560 140,921 163,366 Non-Event expenses 11,495 11,840 12,195 12,561 12,937 70,748 82,016 95,079 110,222 127,778 Total Expenses 37,309 38,428 39,581 40,768 41,992 229,627 266,200 308,599 357,751 414,732

Projected NOI (with Additional Revenues) - 9,792 23,341 23,345 23,340 118,672 121,618 121,620 121,624 121,632

YS

PO

RT

S&

Projected NOI (without Additional Revenues) (2,287) (2,355) (2,426) (2,499) (2,574) (14,073) (16,315) (18,914) (21,926) (25,418)

Projected D/S Requirements:(7)

EB5 Loan(2) (3% Int Only): - 450 450 450 450 1,350 - - - - EB5 Fix-out(2) (6%, 30yr): - - - - - 2,207 5,518 5,518 5,519 5,519

Required Other Financing(5)(6%, 30yr): - 6,078 15,111 15,113 15,110 75,558 75,561 75,562 75,564 75,569 Total Projected Debt Service: - 6,528 15,561 15,563 15,560 79,115 81,079 81,080 81,083 81,088 &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

Revenues in Excess of 1.00x Coverage(8) - 3,264 7,780 7,782 7,780 39,557 40,539 40,540 40,541 40,544

Coverage (with Additional Revenues)(3) n/a 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x 1.50x

Coverage (w/o Additional Revenues)(3) n/a -0.36x -0.16x -0.16x -0.17x -0.18x -0.20x -0.23x -0.27x -0.31x

Notes:(1) Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation. Projected Sources of Funds (000's)(7)

Sources Multipurpose(2) EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility. The amount is an estimate based upon the creation of 150 jobs, and every 10 jobs creates $1 million in loan capacity. ON

CO

RP

OR

A

p p

Historic Tax Credit(9) [Equity] 40,550 (3) Coverage based on 3% growth. Rating agencies may require coverage without growth in revenues. New Market Tax Credit(4)[Equity] 12,187

EB5 Loans(2) [Debt] 15,000

Subtotal 67,737

Required Other Financing(6) 202,594 (6)

(5) Estimated debt service on additional required funds needed to finance the project, after accounting for the EB5 loan funds, NMTC and Historic Tax Credits. Assumes a 30 year level debt service financing at the fixed rate of 6.0% with principal amortized from 2015 through 2041.

Other financing vehicles have been identified as potential financing options, but not quantified. Examples include Tax Increment Reinvestment Zone bonds

The EB5 loan assumes a seven year interest only period and upon expiration is refinanced by the issuance of 30 year level debt (the "EB5 Fix-out"), at a rate of 6.0% and principal amortized from 2021 through 2049.

(4) New Market Tax Credit assuming allocation can be found, with credit equal to 39% of allocation secured with market value at 62.5% of effective credit. Due to their limited availability, assumes allocation capped at $50 million.

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

12

Total Project Funding(1) 270,331 (7) The cost of raising funds and necessary carrying costs have not been factored in at this time, because time horizon for revenue has not been finalized. Last year of additional revs: *N/A*(8) Excess Revenues may be used for additional project funding, M&O, early repayment of outstanding debt, etc. Yr of final debt payment: 2049(9) Rehabilitation (Historic) Tax Credit, assuming full 20.00% with 75% realization of tax credits (multipurpose project only).

and Texas Economic Development Fund loans.

Page 343: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

ARehabilitation Tax Credits

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab C

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 344: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Summary of Key Points for Rehabilitation Tax Credits

T dit i il bl t th ( ) d/ th tit h h ld titl t th t

HA

• Tax credit is available to the person(s) and/or the entity who holds title to the property

• In general, project can receive a tax credit equal to 20% of total costs directly related to the repair or improvement of structural and architectural features of the historic building

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

– Construction period interest and taxes, architect fees, engineering fees, construction management costs, reasonable developer fees, and any other fees paid that would normally be charged to a capital account may also be used towards the tax credit basis Y

SP

OR

TS

&

be charged to a capital account may also be used towards the tax credit basis

• Expenditures must exceed adjusted basis of building

&

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

– Must be careful on expenditures occurring before the rehabilitation period, potentially increasing the basis

• The entity may then sell these tax credits in exchange for cash to be used towards these ON

CO

RP

OR

A

• The entity may then sell these tax credits in exchange for cash to be used towards these qualified costs

– If trying to monetize rehabilitation credit, value will be less than value of tax credit

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

14

Page 345: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Summary of Key Points for Rehabilitation Tax Credits

• Rehabilitation credit is available in the year the building is placed in service

HA

Rehabilitation credit is available in the year the building is placed in service

• Rehabilitation tax credit for taxpayers using straight line depreciation, non residential up to 39 years

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

– This may imply that the owner of the building is a taxpayer

• Rehabilitation must be done according to the “Standards for Rehabilitation” as defined by YS

PO

RT

S&

• Rehabilitation must be done according to the Standards for Rehabilitation as defined by Secretary of Interior

– Final work must be certified by the Secretary of Interior &

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

• Will want to consult with Project Developer/Contractor with respect to program, their experience with program and restrictions of program, which may impede building completion timelines O

NC

OR

PO

RA

timelines

• Consider seeking RFPs from qualified responders to work with Corporation with respect to Historic Tax Credit project funding

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

15

Page 346: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

ANew Market Tax Credits

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab D

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 347: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Summary of Key Points for New Market Tax Credit Program

P id dit i t f d l i t f i t th t k Q lifi d E it

HA

• Provides a credit against federal income taxes for investors that make Qualified Equity Investments into Community Development Entities (“CDEs”)

• CDEs in turn use the proceeds of these investments to make Qualified Low-Income

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Community Investments

• The credit is taken over a 7 year period

YS

PO

RT

S&

• The credit rate is:– In each of the first three years, 5% of the original investment amount– In each of the final four years, 6% of the original investment amount &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

y , g• Above equals 39% of amount of original investment

• New Market Tax Credits are offered to investors for “Qualified Equity Investments” (QEIs) in h C

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

the CDE

• QEIs must remain invested in the CDE during the 7 year tax credit period

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

17

Page 348: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Key Provisions of the New Market Tax Credit Program

• General Items of Consideration:

HA

General Items of Consideration:– If the investment in the project is structured with required repayment (as opposed to donation)

the term of repayment is generally equal to the 7 year tax credit period

– Qualified Active Low-Income Community Businesses may be required to be a tax paying entity i Q lifi d L I C i I R

RI

SC

OU

NT

to receive Qualified Low-Income Community Investments

– Transaction size generally ranges from $5 to $25 Million • For project sizes larger than this, a separate component of the total project might be

broken out as a possibility YS

PO

RT

S&

broken out as a possibility

• The transaction size for this contemplated project is much larger than ordinary, which may make the total amount of eligible allocation more difficult to obtain, because of this we have capped the amount of allocation available at $50 million.

&

CO

NV

EN

TI

O

– Large banks with a separate New Market Tax Credit Group are potential investors and NMTC purchasers for qualified projects

– In the event the project qualifies, we anticipate ample supply of credits from entities who have been funded with New Market Tax Credits O

NC

OR

PO

RA

been funded with New Market Tax Credits

– Consider issuing a RFP to qualified entities and consultants to respond with NMTC equity proposals

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

– Fees and costs tend to be extremely high on the percentage of equity received and structure will result in added level of complexity and creation of various legal entities required for program

18

Page 349: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

AEB-5 Program

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab E

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 350: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Key Provisions of the EB-5 Program

EB5 i l h i l d h b f j b d b h f ili

HA

• EB5 is a loan program that is related to the number of jobs created by the facility

• Assumes a maximum of 800 of the 934* jobs created will be on a full-time basis

• EB5 loans have 7 year term Analysis assumes interest only until expiration Loan amount is RR

IS

CO

UN

T

• EB5 loans have 7 year term. Analysis assumes interest only until expiration. Loan amount is refinance over 30 years upon expiration.

• Assumes project location is not designated in a Targeted Employment Area. Non-TEA designation requires minimum of $1,000,000 per investor

YS

PO

RT

S&

• A Regional Center (RC) is usually the conduit through which the investments are made

• Investors may be required to participate in the operational management; in practice, this can be satisfied by: &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

satisfied by:– taking a managing position, – participating in the decision-making process, or– being a limited partner in a LLP

• In some cases, the participation requirement may be waived ON

CO

RP

OR

A

• USCIS requires confirmation that all such investments are classified as being "at risk" with no specific guarantees being made by the project developers to the EB-5 investor

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

_____________*Source: Harris County Sports & Convention Corporation

20

Page 351: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Preliminary – For Discussion Purposes OnlyH

ATax Increment Financing

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

Tab F

YS

PO

RT

S&&

C

ON

VE

NT

IOO

NC

OR

PO

RA

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

H A R R I S C O U N T Y S P O R T S & C O N V E N T I O N C O R P O R A T I O N May 23, 2012

Page 352: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Tax Increment FinancingH

A

• Tax Increment Financing is a financing that is financed through an entity that captures the growth in ad valorem tax base, resulting in capturing of tax dollars for a specific purpose

RR

IS

CO

UN

T

• Captured value is on real property, not personal property

• To be effective, multiple governmental entities opt in to create a more robust revenue stream.

YS

PO

RT

S&

School districts can not participate in Tax increment financings

• The growth in tax base is critical to financing a project predicated on increasing the assessed value in an area &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

value in an area

• Usually requires a separate entity to finance and/or administer financing over the life of the increment period

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

Page 353: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

Tax Increment Financing Characteristics

T i t i ll 20 b t t t t d b d i d f t i t

HA

• Term is typically 20 years, but must not extend beyond period of tax increment

• Significant analysis of taxpayers within tax increment district:• Concentration/Diversification of captured appraised value R

RI

SC

OU

NT

Concentration/Diversification of captured appraised value• Due diligence on top taxpayers• Ability of major taxpayers to protest tax rolls• Historical tax collections

YS

PO

RT

S&

• Risk of devaluation of assets in increment

• Most likely, credit agencies will not allow significant growth, if any, in analyzing ability to repay debt for an investment grade rating &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

repay debt for an investment grade rating

• Debt usually has limitation on issuance of additional debt

ON

CO

RP

OR

A

• If during ramp up period of assessed valuation related to project, capitalized interest may be used, but reduces net proceeds available for project

• Most likely will require a debt service reserve fund further reducing net proceeds

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

• Most likely will require a debt service reserve fund, further reducing net proceeds

Page 354: Astrodome FINAL Report 5-23-12

DisclaimerFirst Southwest Company (“FirstSouthwest”) has received certain documents, reports, financial statements and other items

HA

p y ( ) , p ,of information (such information and data referred to in this paragraph as the “Information”) for the purpose of preparingthis preliminary analysis. With respect to the Information provided to us by the Harris County Sports & ConventionCorporation (the “Corporation”) for the purpose of this discussion, with the Corporation’s permission, (i) we have assumedthe accuracy and completeness of such information for purposes of this discussion, (ii) we have made no effort toindependently verify or confirm the accuracy or completeness of such Information and (iii) we make no representation or R

RI

SC

OU

NT

depe de t y ve y o co t e accu acy o co p ete ess o suc o at o a d ( ) we a e o ep ese tat o owarranty with respect thereto, including but not limited to the work product of any of the Corporation’s other consultants.

All opinions and estimates are given as of the date hereof and are subject to change. Any preliminary financial analysis issubject to uncertainties. Inevitably, some assumptions used will not be realized and unanticipated events and circumstances

A l h b t ti t t thi ti ith th i f ti il bl Th id d f YS

PO

RT

S&

may occur. Any values shown are our best estimate at this time with the information available. They are provided forinformation purposes only and are not guaranteed for accuracy or as realizable values.

This preliminary analysis is provided as an overview for the Corporation’s information and benefit only and may not berelied upon in any manner whatsoever by any other person, and shall not be not be disclosed, redistributed, provided to or &

C

ON

VE

NT

IO

p y y y p , , , putilized by others without the prior written consent of FirstSouthwest.

Neither FirstSouthwest nor any of its affiliates shall have any liability, contingent or otherwise, for any use of theinformation set out or referred to herein. FirstSouthwest assumes no liability and shall not be responsible for any resultsfrom the use of this analysis or any subsequent modification whatsoever to the analysis provided to the Corporation from O

NC

OR

PO

RA

from the use of this analysis or any subsequent modification whatsoever to the analysis provided to the Corporation fromFirstSouthwest, and the Corporation waives any claims against FirstSouthwest that may be connected thereto.

FirstSouthwest, its representatives and affiliates make no representation and have given the Corporation no adviceconcerning the appropriate accounting treatment or possible tax consequences of the information contained herein. The

Member FINRA & SIPC© 2012 First Southwest Company

TI

ON

g pp p g p qCorporation should consult with its own accounting and tax advisors, as applicable, to the extent it deems appropriate toensure that the risks are fully understood

24