Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    1/12

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    2/12

    techniques, and will go on to occupy a place in the history of behaviour

    modification. Extending the notion of Buddhism as a precursor to modern

    psychology, it has been argued that Buddhism itself was, and is in fact,

    specifically a psychology and dramatically not a religion (Mikulas, 1991).

    Buddhism shares with clinical psychology the motivation to facilitate beneficialgrowth and change on individual and societal levels (Kumar, 2002). The

    Buddhist monk is seen as someone who can take a detached and objective view of

    a problem, and produce sensible solutions, or at least provide support and

    consultation. This tradition is historically well grounded as the Buddha himself

    was, in his life, very much a counsellor in this way (deSilva, 1993). Nonetheless,

    the depiction of Buddhism solely as a psychology ignores the spiritual context

    within which Buddhism was developed. An analysis of the empirical and

    scientific components of Buddhism only represents one perspective of

    approaching the teachings of the Buddha. As such, although this paper focuses

    primarily on the psychological elements inherent to Buddhism, as a practicingTheravada Buddhist, the author also wishes to recognize the importance of the

    less scientific and more mystical processes of the spiritual evolution many

    Buddhists experience.

    Strictly from the scientific perspective, the concept of a Buddhist Psychology

    continues to evolve as principles and techniques outlined by the Buddha are

    subjected to the empirically scrutinizing methods of current day. This empirical

    basis of Buddhism is evident in early Buddhist discourse. During a noteworthy

    sermon (Kalama Suttra; deSilva, 1984) the Buddha advised a group of inquirers

    to not accept anything on hearsay, authority or pure argument, but instead toaccept what is empirically and experientially verifiable. deSilva (1990) further

    notes that although Buddhism clearly developed prior to and outside the context

    of modern Western science, it does, however, as a non-theistic religion, offer

    clearly testable hypotheses (unlike theistic religions: e.g., does God exist?) and

    therefore can be brought within the realm of scientific inquiry.

    Given both the increased familiarity and popularity of Zen Buddhism in

    comparison to other sects of Buddhism in Western society, the majority of

    Buddhism and Psychology literature in Western academic journals has tended

    to focus on Zen. The Zen tradition was born of Buddhist ideology and its

    founding is somewhat analogous to the development of various sects born of

    other major religions (i.e., theoretical similarity between seminal religion and

    related sect). As such, although the focus in this paper is primarily on Buddhism

    as a whole, for purposes of convenience and clarity, Zen Buddhism will often

    serve as the point of comparison. Relatedly, much of the same literature has had a

    distinctly analytical flavor, which is to be expected given the extensive attention

    Jung (1969) and other psychoanalysts gave to Zen. However, in addition to the

    psychoanalytical majority, a small minority of behavioural and cognitive-

    behavioral theorists have begun to note the philosophical and applied similarity

    between these approaches and the various sects of Buddhism, including Zen.In the winter of 2002, the academic journal, Cognitive and Behavioural Practice

    bli h d i l i i l d I i B ddhi Phil h i h C i i d

    284 Michael S. Christopher

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    3/12

    Behavioural Practice. This series provided one of the first articulations of

    Buddhism by empirically trained therapists and theorists with varying degrees

    of interest and personal involvement in Buddhist practice. Specific articles

    explored the application of Buddhist concepts to the practice of dialectical

    behaviour therapy (Robins, 2002), enhancement of mindfulness and compassion(Kumar, 2002), treatment of anxiety disorders (Toneatto, 2002), and other

    clinical areas.

    Philosophical similarities

    Particularly relevant to the comparison of Zen Buddhism to contemporary

    behavioural and cognitive-behavioural psychotherapies is an analysis of Albert

    Elliss Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy (REBT). In drawing comparisons

    between REBT and Zen, Kwee and Ellis (1998) contend that, both appreciatean empirical working mode and the logico-empirical methods of science, which

    are flexible and anti-dogmatic ( p. 19). Ellis (1979) contends that in addition

    to Epictetus and Marcus Aurelius, the Buddha had a profound influence over

    the empirical focus Ellis infused into REBT. Elliss adherence to Buddhist

    philosophy is perhaps best exemplified by REBTs implementation of the

    Buddhas active-directive teaching style, in which he challenged his students

    to look at their self constructed thoughts and feelings, to reconsider them

    when they did not work, and to work vigorously at changing them (Kwee &

    Ellis, 1998).

    Alleviation of suffering and hassle

    A striking similarity between REBT and Zen is the premise that human existence

    is essentially rooted in suffering (deSilva, 1984, 1990; Kwee & Ellis, 1998). From

    a Buddhist perspective to live means to suffer and as such life is generally

    unsatisfactory; suffering in turn is caused by craving or desire and can only be

    ended via the cessation of craving or desire (Ronruen, 1998). Similarly, in his

    seminal work, Reason and Emotion in Psychotherapy, Ellis (1962) in great detail

    describes the human compulsion toward irrational thought, and subsequently

    depicts life as a hassle riddled with difficulties.

    In striving to improve the human condition, the teachings of the Buddha

    and Ellis promote the attainment of similar goals; namely, rational and

    appropriate feeling and affect, commitment to life, and an egoless state of

    being (Kwee & Ellis, 1998, p. 26). When applied specifically to REBT, the

    ensuing goal becomes the ability to provide clients with a method by which they

    can have rational beliefs, and as a result reduce anxiety and hostility (Patterson &

    Watkins, 1996). And when applied specifically to Zen, the goal becomes theattainment of satori or illumination (Ross, 1960). In striving to achieve the state

    f i h Z d k h f li h i d

    Albert Ellis and the Buddha 285

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    4/12

    through the ages by many Buddhas. The Zen experience of satori best translates

    into self-awakening, or . . . recognizing the real noumenon of a person, his

    original feature, not necessarily recognizing the real substance of various acts

    (Ross, 1960, p. 45). Paradoxically, this self-recognition is tantamount to the

    disidentifying of ones self with ones overt and covert behaviour and signifies thetermination of the cycle of suffering due to the cessation of craving (deSilva,

    1990).

    REBT and Zen both were empirically derived and consequently adhere to

    science rather than dogmatism. Zen, although in the strictest sense is considered a

    religion, has no sacred scriptures whose words are law; no fixed cannon; no rigid

    dogma; and no Savior or Divine Being through whose favor or intercession ones

    eventual salvation is assured (Aitken, 1993). The exclusion of zealous religious

    devotion in both REBT and Zen facilitates genuine interaction between teacher

    and client/student. In REBT, the therapist guides the client toward a more

    rational lifestyle, and in Zen the master guides the novice toward enlightenment;neither technique disregarding the necessary and unique contributions the client/

    student adds to the process.

    Ethics

    Buddhist ethics merit adherence not because a violation of them will offend some

    religious dogma, but rather because bad habits (e.g., alcohol abuse) can lead todemonstrable ill effects, such as poor health, mental derangement, loss of wealth,

    and proneness to socially embarrassing behaviour (deSilva, 1984). In this way,

    even the Buddhas direct instructions were based on rational consideration.

    Moreover, the Buddha urged followers to lead a morally sound life not solely

    because it resulted in enlightenment or cessation of suffering, but also because

    such a life was conducive to tangible benefits for the individual, and perhaps

    more importantly, for society as a whole (deSilva, 1984). Essentially, a lifestyle

    characterized by the ethical standards of restraint and moderation at the

    individual level is in fact ethical because it perpetuates community well-being,

    satisfactory living, and equal rights.

    The REBT ethical code mirrors the Buddhas emphasis on empiricism and

    anti-dogmatism, such that clients are encouraged to test theories co-generated

    by client and therapist during session in a real-life setting. Moreover, REBT

    also stresses the notion that individual acts can and often do have a global result,

    to the extent that enlightened self-interest (that recognizes the rights of others),

    social interest, and commitment to something outside of oneself are key

    therapeutic components of REBT (Ellis, 1979). That is, as the individual

    facilitates his own well being, he reciprocally benefits society. Relatedly, the

    ability to give more to others is eased by the unconditional acceptance ofoneself as a fallible human being who is ready to take action for change

    (Elli 1973)

    286 Michael S. Christopher

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    5/12

    Applied similarities

    A-B-Cs and the Middle Way

    It is through the pursuit of a rational and ethical lifestyle that REBT and Zenadherents seek to terminate hassle and suffering, respectively. The direct method

    whereby an individual can terminate hassle is achieved therapeutically via

    treatment according to Ellis REBT framework. The Buddhist equivalent is

    through adherence to the Buddhas Four Noble Truths, which incorporate the

    Buddhas seminal works (Pinyunchon & House, 1996). These are: (1) all life is

    suffering, (2) suffering comes from desires, (3) the cure for suffering is the

    extinction of desire, and (4) the extinction of desire can be obtained by following

    a path of right, which is called the Noble Eightfold Path (Pinyunchon & House,

    1996, p. 16).

    The Noble Eightfold Path advocates the Middle Way, that is, the avoidanceof extremes of either overindulgence and luxurious life on the one hand or a life of

    rigorous self-mortification on the other (deSilva, 1990). More specifically, the

    Buddha espoused the view that the rational man incorporates the idea of the

    Middle Way into eight paths of life: right understanding, right thought, right

    speech, right action, right livelihood, right effort, right mindfulness, and right

    concentration (deSilva, 1990). In following the right (or rational) aspects inherent

    to the Middle Way, the individual expedites and ensures his steady progression

    toward satori.

    The Buddhas Middle Way, essentially a lifestyle that avoids extremes,is rational and leads to the cessation of suffering, is nearly isomorphic with the

    A-B-Cs of REBT. That is, as the core of Elliss framework, the A-B-Cs are

    designed to provide insight into the individuals ability to determine, in good part,

    his own behavioural and emotional experience (Patterson & Watkins, 1996). The

    B or Belief component of the model is the crucial factor, for rational beliefs (rB)

    lead to rational consequences (rC) and irrational beliefs (iB) lead to irrational

    consequences (iC). Thus, an irrational consequence and subsequent emotional

    disturbance is caused, not by the A or Activating events, but by the views people

    take of these events (Ellis, 1976a). Similarly, the message that humans are largely

    responsible for their own emotions and disturbances echoes in the Buddhas

    words, . . . it is foolish to see any other person as the cause of our own misery

    or unhappiness (Storig, 1964, p. 93). In successfully navigating the Noble

    Eightfold Path, the individual attempts to see reality as it is, without distortions

    arising from the various factors that characterize the unenlightened persons

    functioning (deSilva, 1990). An integral aspect of reaching the state of satori is

    the freeing of ones perceptions from these distorting internal influences; when

    one reaches a state of perfection, ones perceptions become free of such

    distortions and allow for a rational appraisal of the objects (or events) (deSilva,

    1990).The REBT therapeutic focus is on the present life situation of the client.

    I i l b li f k d i h h d h i h

    Albert Ellis and the Buddha 287

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    6/12

    that Zen facilitates progression along the Noble Eightfold Path in present time.

    As Sato (1958) remarks, It is interesting to note that the emphasis on the

    now and here in recent Western psychotherapy has been one of the fundamental

    principles of the Zen mode of thought ( p. 215).

    Active style

    An active therapist style is perhaps the most notorious feature of Ellis REBT.

    The therapist is verbally active throughout the entire therapy process, and Ellis

    (1973) recognizes that he does a great deal of talking rather than passively

    listening to what the client has to say. In a decidedly direct fashion, the

    identification of irrational beliefs, helping the patient to understand that these

    irrational beliefs cause emotional difficulties, and ultimately changing the

    irrational beliefs constitute the applied focus of REBT. Accordingly, Ellis

    argues that psychotherapy is the curing of unreason by reason (Patterson &

    Watkins, 1996). It is asserted in REBT that strong irrational beliefs, neurotic

    feelings, and dysfunctional behaviour may need forceful, dramatic, and affective

    approaches if they are to change (Ellis, 1962). Similarly, the active or directive

    therapeutic style evident in Zen is perhaps best exemplified by the following

    parables:

    Once Ma-tsu and Pai-chang were walking along and they saw some ducks

    fly by. What is that the master asked. Wild ducks, Pai-chang replied.

    Where have they gone? Theyve flown away, Pai-chang said.

    The master then twisted Pai-changs nose, and when Pai-chang cried

    out in pain, Ma-tsu said, When have they ever flown away?

    Elder Ting asked Lin-chi, Master, what is the great meaning of

    Buddhas teachings? Lin-chi came down from his seat, slapped Ting

    and pushed him away. Ting was stunned and stood motionless. A monk

    nearby said, Ting, why do you not bow? At that moment Ting attained

    great enlightenment (cited in Watson, 1993).

    Many examples illustrating the use of such an approach can be found in Buddhist

    texts (deSilva, 1984). Relatedly, a particularly functional method of identifying

    and changing irrational beliefs inherent to both REBT and Zen is the narrative

    technique.

    Narratives and koans

    The Zen narrative technique is conceivably the most utilized method to assist

    d i i h f i I h l diffi l h d h

    288 Michael S. Christopher

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    7/12

    narrative teachings or koans can be best described as a profound story or riddle

    that is a tool for the master to help the novice attain an insightful experience

    (Sato, 1958). Paramount to Zen practice, koans began in the 7th century and

    were more fully developed by the Rinzai school of Zen beginning in the 12th

    century (Aitken, 1993). In Zen training the koan can become a process to focusones questioning and corresponding doubt; it becomes a means to see through

    the false mind of duality that creates and perpetuates a life of pain, suffering and

    anxiety (Nhat Hanh, 1995). With intense effort the koan takes ones natural

    questioning beyond thought and perception, beyond the relative and the absolute,

    to awaken that which has always been there but has been obscured by clouds of

    delusion (Loori, 1994).

    Koans can also employ dramatic, forceful, and strongly evocative methods.

    Traditionally, the Rinzai school represents a dynamic, powerful Zen, in which

    adherents are demanded to experience enlightenment and realize this

    experience in their own lives (Kapleau, 1989). Eisai, the fonder of the RinzaiSchool was well-known for his unusual methods, (e.g., shouting, hitting, use of

    paradox) which were employed to jolt students out of their fixed ways of

    thinking and their habits (Kapleau, 1989). These methods often take the form

    of a question and answer session between disciple and master, which involves

    sudden beatings and illogical answers all in an attempt to wake or stimulate the

    disciples mind to make it ready for the discovery of the truth inside. This style

    is perhaps best exemplified by the following koan entitled Chu-chih Raises One

    Finger:

    Whenever Chu-chih was asked a question, he simply raised one finger.

    One day a visitor asked Chu-chihs attendant what his master preached.

    The boy raised a finger. Hearing of this, Chu-chih cut off the boys finger

    with a knife. As he ran from the room, screaming with pain, Chu-chih

    called to him. When he turned his head, Chu-chih raised a finger. The

    boy was suddenly enlightened. When Chu-chih was about to die, he said

    to his assembled monks: I received this one-finger Zen from Tien-lung.

    I used it all my life but never used it up. With this he entered his eternal

    rest (cited in Schloegl, 1976).

    Koans (or narratives) also have therapeutic value in REBT, particularly as a

    method of establishing rapport or infusing humor into the therapeutic situation

    (Kwee & Ellis, 1998). Moreover, Kwee and Ellis (1998) contend that from an

    REBT perspective, emotional disturbances are largely due to over-seriousness,

    and humorous interventions can, (a) highlight the fatuous nature of irrational

    beliefs, (b) be an effective teaching device, (c) become a vehicle for rapport

    building (p. 10). Accordingly, the following koan was used during an REBT

    group therapy session to address guilty feelings when one member reported thathe thinks about other women during sex with his wife. This was done to

    ha i that h id a a n al and it i ft n diffi lt t aintain a hi h

    Albert Ellis and the Buddha 289

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    8/12

    degree of attraction within a long-term marriage (Yankura & Dryden, 1990,

    p. 129):

    A couple had a good sexual and marital relationship. Theyd been

    married for 25 years, their children were grown-up and marriedthemselves, and everything was fine. They decided, Hell its our 25th

    wedding anniversary wed better do something special! So they went

    for a gourmet meal, which they love. But neither one got very aroused or

    excited. Finally, after about ten minutes, the wife patted her husband on

    the shoulder and said, Well dear, I guess on this night of all nights,

    youre having trouble of thinking of someone else too!

    Unwanted cognitions

    Another focal point for therapeutic intervention in nearly all psychotherapies is

    the issue of dealing with unwanted, intrusive cognitions. Here REBT and Zen

    differ somewhat with regard to their exact methodologies. To bring about a

    change in irrational thinking the REBT therapist confronts the clients irrational

    beliefs, that is, the therapist attacks the irrationality of the cognition (Ellis,

    1976b). In contrast, Zen often relies on more non-verbal, internal techniques to

    eliminate unwanted cognitions (deSilva, 1985). deSilva (1985) outlines several

    techniques based in Buddhist literature that are used to eliminate unwanted

    cognitions; these are presented in hierarchical fashion, each to be tried if thepreceding one fails ( p. 438):

    (1) Switch to an opposite or incompatible thought

    (2) Ponder on harmful consequences

    (3) Ignore and distract

    (4) Reflect on removal of causes

    (5) Control with forceful effort

    Meditation, homework, and modelling

    Unwanted cognitions are a phenomenon that hold a particularly problematic

    significance in Zen training because they distract the novice during meditation

    (deSilva, 1985). A mastery of mindfulness meditation becomes essential to the

    novice as he progresses toward the state of satori via the Noble Eightfold Path.

    The Pali word for meditation, bhavana, etymologically means development or

    cultivation (Rajsuddhinanamongkol, 1997), the aim of which is to achieve total

    and immediate awareness or mindfulness of all phenomena. Thus, the competent

    meditator is able to gradually remove all thoughts and images, thereby allowinghim to let go of cognitive labels, to reopen the senses, and to be more receptive to

    int nal and t nal ti li in th d f a Z n a t th indi id al

    290 Michael S. Christopher

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    9/12

    learns to be able to see the flower for the five hundredth time as he saw it the first

    time (Shapiro & Zifferblatt, 1976, p. 588).

    Although relevant, meditation plays a much less significant role in REBT

    where it is primarily utilized as a relaxation method (Ellis, 1984; Shapiro &

    Zifferblatt, 1976). Often practiced outside of the therapy session, Ellis (1984)notes, . . .meditation usually requires a great deal of self-training, especially

    cognitive self-regulation through homework ( p. 672). Meditation from the

    REBT perspective in and of itself will not change irrational thinking, but can,

    however, help patients with their overwhelming anxieties and dysfunctional

    obsessions and compulsions.

    In addition to homework, REBT patients are given assignments and in vivo

    experiences to complete. Kwee and Ellis (1998) argue that these shame-attacking

    exercises of REBT in which clients engage publicly in behaviours normally

    considered foolish or silly resemble ordeals that could also be assigned to Zen

    novices on their way to satori. Whereas Ellis would urge a client to go into adrugstore at a crowded hour and say to the clerk in a loud enough voice for

    everyone to hear, I want a gross of condoms. And because I use so many of them,

    I want a special discount (Kwee & Ellis, 1998, p. 35), a Zen master would

    perhaps, instead instruct a novice who is fearful of public speaking to work

    toward himself becoming a master via giving a public sermon.

    Another extension of the homework process is bibliotherapy, whereby

    REBT clients familiarize themselves with REBT literature. Similarly, a Zen

    master will often train his novice to read and commit to memory the original

    Buddhist cannon, the Tipitaka, which consists of three parts: Sutta Pitaka, whichcontains the discourses of the Buddha on various occasions throughout his

    preaching life; Vinaya Pitaka, which contains the rules of discipline for the

    monks; and Abhidhamma Pitaka, which contains highly systematized philosophi-

    cal and psychological analyses.

    Both Ellis and the Buddha espouse the notion of setting examples for

    followers via modelling or vicarious learning. Teaching by example is a trademark

    of both REBT and Zen, and it is through role playing techniques that the client or

    novice can begin to generalize to a more rational philosophy of life. More

    specifically, to succeed in generalizing to a more rational philosophy of living, the

    REBT client will substitute irrational attitudes and beliefs for rational ones. This

    goes beyond dealing with specific illogical ideas of clients, it gives consideration to

    irrational ideas in general (Patterson & Watkins, 1996). The development of a

    rational lifestyle from a modern Zen perspective entails the use of Zen practices

    for prophylactic purposes (deSilva 1984, 1990). Mindfulness meditation training,

    self-monitoring, following the Middle Way, and other Buddhist techniques

    appear to play a potential role in the prevention of certain kinds of psychological

    disorders (deSilva, 1990). And finally, the REBT client usually meets with his

    therapist once a week, whereas the Zen relationship between novice and master is

    continuous and lengthy.The degree of overlap between REBT and Zen becomes rather evident when

    di i b h i d I l i Z h i d

    Albert Ellis and the Buddha 291

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    10/12

    concepts to the REBT therapeutic framework, a shared identity between the two

    ideologies emerges. Both Ellis and the Buddha sought to improve the human

    condition; and to do so in a rational, empirical manner. An analysis of their

    respective theories reveals that the birth of REBT was heavily influenced by the

    Buddhas teachings and modern Zen includes Elliss predilection for relativism.Ultimately, as the founding father of REBT, Ellis wryly notes that, like the

    Buddha, I try to practice what I preach, and worked my ass off to achieve self-

    mastery from my childhood onwards (Kwee & Ellis, 1998).

    Author note

    The author wishes to thank Randal P. Quevillon, PhD, and two anonymous

    reviewers for their helpful comments on an earlier draft of this article.

    References

    AITKEN, R. (1993). Encouraging Words: Zen Buddhist teachings for western students. New York:

    Pantheon Books.

    DESILVA, P. (1984). Buddhism and behaviour modification. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 22,

    661678.

    DESILVA, P. (1985). Early Buddhist and modern behavioural strategies for the control of unwanted

    intrusive cognitions. The Psychological Record, 35, 437443.

    DESILVA, P. (1990). Buddhist psychology: A review of theory and practice. Current Psychology:Research and Reviews, 9, 236254.

    DESILVA, P. (1993). Buddhism and counselling. British Journal of Guidance and Counselling, 21, 3034.

    ELLIS, A. (1962). Reason and Emotion in Psychotherapy. Secaucus, NJ: Citadel Press.

    ELLIS, A. (1973). Humanistic Psychotherapy. New York: McGraw-Hill.

    ELLIS, A. (1976a). RET abolishes most of the human ego. Psychotherapy, 13, 343348.

    ELLIS, A. (1976b). The biological basis of human irrationality. Journal of Individual Psychology,

    32, 145168.

    ELLIS, A. (1979). The theory of rational-emotive therapy. In A. ELLIS & J.M. WHITELEY (Eds.),

    Theoretical and Empirical Foundations of Rational-Emotive Therapy ( pp. 4360). Monterey,

    CA: Brooks/Cole.

    ELLIS, A. (1984). The place of meditation in cognitive-behavioural therapy and Rational-EmotiveTherapy. In D.H. SHAPIRO & R.N. WALSH (Eds.), Meditation: Classic and contemporary

    perspectives ( pp. 671673). New York: Aldine.

    JUNG, C.G. (1969). Psychology and Religion: West and east. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University

    Press.

    KAPLEAU, R.P. (1989). The Three Pillars of Zen. New York: Doubleday.

    KAZDIN, A.E. (1982). History of behavior modification. In A.S. BELLACK, M . MERSEN & A.E.

    KAZDIN (Eds.), International Handbook of Behaviour Modification and Therapy ( pp. 231245).

    New York: Plenum Press.

    KUMAR, S.M. (2002). An introduction to Buddhism for the cognitive-behavioural therapist.

    Cognitive and Behavioural Practice, 9, 4043.

    KWEE, M.G.T. & ELLIS, A. (1998). The interface between rational-emotive behaviour therapy

    (REBT) and Zen. Journal of Rational-Emotive and Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, 16, 543.

    LOORI, J.D. (1994) Two Arrows Meeting in Mid-air: The Zen koan. Boston: Charles E. Tuttle Co.

    292 Michael S. Christopher

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    11/12

    MIKULAS, W.L. (1991). Eastern and Western psychology: Issues and domains for integration.

    Journal of Integrative and Eclectic Psychotherapy, 10, 229240.

    NHAT HANH, T. (1995). Zen Keys. New York: Doubleday.

    PATTERSON, C.H. & WATKINS, C.E. Jr. (1996). Theories of Psychotherapy (5th Edn.). New York:

    HarperCollins.

    PINYUNCHON, M. & HOUSE, R.H. (1996). Past, present, and future of guidance and counselingin Thailand. In W. EVARIFF (Ed.), Counseling in the Pacific Rim Countries ( pp. 137151).

    San Francisco: Lake Press.

    RAJSUDDHINANAMONGKOL, P. (1997). Advantages of Chanting and how to Practice Vipassana

    Meditation. Bangkok, Thailand: Samakkhisarn Co., Ltd.

    ROBINS, C. (2002). Zen principles and mindfulness practice in dialectical behaviour therapy.

    Cognitive and Behavioural Practice, 9, 5057.

    RONRUEN, S. (1998). Good questions and answers about Buddhism. Washington, DC: Wat Thai.

    ROSS, N.W. (1960). The World of Zen. New York: Vintage Books.

    SATO, K. (1958). Psychotherapeutic implications of Zen. Psychologia, 1, 213218.

    SCHLOEGEL, I. (1976). The Zen Teachings of Rinzai. Berkeley: Shambhala.

    SHAPIRO, D.M. & ZIFFERBLATT, S.M. (1976). Zen meditation and behavioural self-control:Similarities, differences, and clinical applications. American Psychologist, 31, 519523.

    STORIG, H.J. (1964). Geschiedenis van de Filosofie. Utrecht: Prisma.

    TONEATTO, T. (2002). A metacognitive therapy for anxiety disorders: Buddhist psychology applied.

    Cognitive and Behavioural Practice, 9, 7278.

    WATSON, B. (1993). The Zen Teachings of Master Lin-chi. Boston: Shambhala.

    YANKURA, J. & DRYDEN, W. (1990). Doing RET: Albert Ellis in action. New York: Springer.

    Albert Ellis and the Buddha 293

  • 7/27/2019 Albert Ellis and the Buddha Rational Soul Mates

    12/12