Upload
aerona
View
42
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
A comparison between the IOCCG Simulated Data Set and NOMAD V2 from an OWT perspective. Timothy S. Moore University of New Hampshire GIOP meeting Sept. 25, 2010 Anchorage Alaska. Distribution of OWTs in Data sets vs. Ocean Obsverations. (numbers are in percent). - PowerPoint PPT Presentation
Citation preview
A comparison between the IOCCG Simulated Data Set and NOMAD V2 from an OWT
perspective
Timothy S. Moore
University of New Hampshire
GIOP meeting
Sept. 25, 2010
Anchorage Alaska
OWT NOMAD*
w/ IOPs
IOCCG
Sim.
Global Avg.
1 3 (9) 7 31
2 8 (14) 8 31
3 18 (17) 10 21
4 20 (26) 4 9
5 19 (14) 10 4
6 22 (13) 40 2
7 9 (7) 20 1
8 2 (1) 1 <1
Distribution of OWTs in Data sets vs. Ocean Obsverations (numbers are in percent)
* - AOP without matching IOPSs
N=41N=45
N=180
N=91
N=6N=19
N=45
N=43
OWT 1
OWT 2
OWT 3
OWT 4
OWT 5
OWT 6
OWT 7
OWT 8
ag411
OWT 1
OWT 4
OWT 3
OWT 2
OWT 5
OWT 6
OWT 7
OWT 8
bbp slope
aph
aph 443
Comparison to NOMAD data
IOCCG
OWT 1
NOMAD
ag s
IOCCG
NOMAD
log ag443
OWT 1
log aph443 ag443/at443 bbp slope
log ag443bbp slope
log aph443
OWT 2
IOCCG
NOMAD
-2.5 -2 -1.5 0.5-1 -0.5 0 -2.5 -2 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 3.52.5 32
ag443/at443
OWT 3
log ag443 bbp slopelog aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
OWT 4
log ag443 bbp slopelog aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
OWT 5
log ag443 bbp slopelog aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
OWT 6
log ag443 bbp slopelog aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
OWT 7
log ag443 bbp slopelog aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
OWT 8
log ag443bbp slope
log aph443
IOCCG
ag443/at443
All
Summary
• There are some inconsistencies in the OWT-based distributions of IOPs between NOMAD and the IOCCG simulated data set.
• Both data sets are skewed towards coastal/case 2 waters.
• Both data sets have some questions regarding the spectral slope of CDOM.
• If a new simulated data set is being considered, the generation of IOPs and IOP pairs could be further constrained by the variance and co-variance as seen in NOMAD within different OWTs.
• In addition, the representation of data points could be guided by the global distribution of naturally occurring OWTs.