3
318 ϫЇٺጯăͱߺጯᄃጯጯ۞ጯछ ᇇաܛĂٺ2007ѐ9ၷᒔᐒႬಢᅫهࡔረĞHolberg International Memorial Prize 2007ğĄᐒႬಢᅫهࡔߏهࡔ˞ࠎع߆ރ ރᆐүछᄃጯүछᇇჯԓĆᐒႬಢĂд2003ѐనϲ۞ረĂͽ ረᐽдᘹఙăˠăጯăޠڱᄃৠጯտᅳાѣјಶ ᄃᚥ۞ጯ۰ 1 Ą۞ᒔረ۰Β˞߁ᇇጯ۰ݣұăͽҒЕ ጯछғপăڱޥຐछҹఆའݾඈĄᇇաߏܛረనϲ ͽҜᒔѩঅၷ۞ޠڱጯछĄ ॲፂᐒႬಢጯఙ؎۞ෞᄬĂĶᇇաܛ൴ण˘इໂ ౹ᄃᇆᜩ˧۞ޠڱநኢĂᄮޠڱࠎѣᇇᖂĂͷ ڱޠநኢߏགྷϤߙপঅ۞ёĂ٩෪۞ጯهᄃኢᙋĂඕ זវ۞૱ޠڱăᇇᄃڼ߆ᙯᘃĄķćĶᇇաܛ20ࡔ͵ ޠڱ——ڱ၁ᙋཌྷᄃҋڱ——มᙱͽྋՙ۞ ۋĂ೩˞˘۞ྋՙĄķኢᇇաߏܛӎৌ۞Ķྋՙķ 1 ᇇաܛ˵Яѩረᒔ75༱۞ረܛĄᐒႬಢهࡔ ܛТॡᔛኛ˞ೀҜጯछĂ੫၆ᇇաޠڱ۞ܛăᇇᄃڼ߆ኢĂᓝᏱШᇇա ܛະ۞ጯఙ Ąኛዦშ৭टĈ http://www.holbergprisen.no/HP_prisen/en_hp_2007_symposium.html ᆒអጯछᇇաܛ2007ѐᐒႬಢᅫهࡔ 319 ˞ޠڱۋ۞ࠁᛉĂ۞ޠڱநኢҌѣҾٺĂ ҋј˘छ֏Ăͷ၆ޠڱٺ۞هᛖ˵۞ቁᑝ˘זਠˠ၆ ڱ࠻۞ޠڱٺĄ Ķޠڱķ၆˘ٺਠˠ֏Ăజᄮ˘ߏĶఢķј ۞វրĄтĂԧд˯ז࠻ϹᄫĂтĶ༰࿅ॡ ˝ȈķâਠˠΪᄮ˘ߏ୧΄ఢćຐϡᇇᙋј୧ ߏΩγ˘аĂЯޠڱᙯĄڱ၁ᙋཌྷ۰тႬ ĞHans KelsenğĂӈߏפޠڱӈఢᄃ΄۞ ڱ࠻ĄᄮĂ ޠڱᄃ૱Ᏺч۞ᇇఢቑᙯĂޠڱΪਕజෛ˘ࠎજၗ൴ण۞ ۏĂТ࠹ٺ၆˯ߏٺᐖၗ۞ᇇĄͽĂޠڱ ˘ߏЯг۰Яॡ۞آטڍĂᐌၗ൴णѣតĄдछ ۞ڱᝋ˭Ăᓝ˲ϲڱᙯϲ۞ޠڱă۞ءڱҿՙăҖ߆րҖᝋ˧۞ቑಛඈඈĂᐌၗ۞ซणѣТĄҭߏĂ ݒߏᆃ˘аĄᇇҬͼߏॡ۩۞ఢቑĂт Ķ୬Ăٺ߉ˠķ۞ᇇĂΞᐌॡឰˠдᓜᇇӧ ဩॡගĂͽܮଯጱᑕѣ۞ඍ९ĄЯѩĂ၆ڱٺ၁ᙋཌྷ۰ ֏ĂޠڱᄃᇇߏТăѣॡҌ࠹ߏ၆ϲ۞ጱቑᘞĄ ᇇաܛ၆˯ڱ၁ᙋཌྷ۞ڱ࠻ͽĄᄮޠڱࠎᇇጱቑᘞᑕтѩડĂЯߏᄱྋ˞ޠڱᄃᇇ۞ᙯ Ąѝд1970ѐĂᇇաܛдĮᄮৌ၆ޞᝋӀį 2 ˘३ฟր г߄ڱ၁ᙋཌྷ۞ᕇĄᇇաܛĂޠڱߏϤఢᄃᇇ ј۞វրĄপҾдژᏜ۞Ķᓞᙱ९ІķĞhard casesğ ॡĂᇇաܛ൴னĶķᄃĶᆊķдޠڱᛖĞinterpretationğ߿ 2 Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously )Cambridge : Harvard University Press, 1977*.

7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢¼ k T G · 2018. 5. 15. · 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢ ¼ k T G ( 321 Ã ¯ à Ø m Q Ç a z i Ø N À á 6 > 2 7 Þ g 2 ± ! 4 y D ± Y n * D Þ

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢¼ k T G · 2018. 5. 15. · 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢ ¼ k T G ( 321 Ã ¯ à Ø m Q Ç a z i Ø N À á 6 > 2 7 Þ g 2 ± ! 4 y D ± Y n * D Þ

� 318 �

2007 9 Holberg International

Memorial Prize 2007

2003

1

20

—— ——

1 75

http://www.holbergprisen.no/HP_prisen/en_hp_2007_symposium.html

2007

� 319 �

Hans Kelsen

1970 2

hard cases

interpretation

2 Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously Cambridge : Harvard

University Press, 1977 .

Page 2: 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢¼ k T G · 2018. 5. 15. · 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢ ¼ k T G ( 321 Ã ¯ à Ø m Q Ç a z i Ø N À á 6 > 2 7 Þ g 2 ± ! 4 y D ± Y n * D Þ

8

� 320 �

interpretive concepts

3

—— integrity ——

3 Ronald Dworkin, Law’s Empire Cambridge, MA.: Belknap Press,

1986 .

2007

� 321 �

4

5 6

7

equal respect and concern

4

Neil MacCormick, “Ronald Dworkin Mr. Justice,” Times Literary Supplemen, Dec. 5, 2007.

5 Ronald Dworkin, Life’s Dominion New York: Knopf, 1993 . 6 Ronald Dworkin, Freedom’s Law New York: Oxford University Press,

1996 . 7 Ronald Dworkin, Sovereign Virtue Cambridge, MA: Harvard

University Press, 2000 .

Page 3: 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢¼ k T G · 2018. 5. 15. · 7 ¢ ö ð / Ç a 2007 P ¬ ¢ ¼ k T G ( 321 Ã ¯ à Ø m Q Ç a z i Ø N À á 6 > 2 7 Þ g 2 ± ! 4 y D ± Y n * D Þ

8

� 322 �

911

—— 8

8 Ronald Dworkin, Is Democracy Possible? Princeton, N.J.: Princeton

University Press, 2006 .