08.10.2004 1

1. Results of call for DS, CNI, AM

2. Information on next call for TA, I3, CA, AM

3. Towards Research Infrastructures in FP7

Presentation by P. MoschopoulosOPTICON, Grenoble, 11-12 October 2004

08.10.2004 2

1. Results of call for: 1. Results of call for: Design Studies,Design Studies,

Construction of New Infrastructures andConstruction of New Infrastructures andAccompanying MeasuresAccompanying Measures

08.10.2004 3

FP6 actions in favour of RIFP6 actions in favour of RI

Actions implemented:Actions implemented:– 1. Transnational Access to RI1. Transnational Access to RI– 2. Integrating Activities:2. Integrating Activities:

• 2.1. Integrated Infrastructure Initiatives2.1. Integrated Infrastructure Initiatives• 2.2. Coordination actions2.2. Coordination actions

– 3. Electronic Communication Network Development3. Electronic Communication Network Development– 4. Design studies in preparation of new RI4. Design studies in preparation of new RI– 5. Development (Construction) of new RI5. Development (Construction) of new RI– 6. Accompanying Measures6. Accompanying Measures

To be covered: all fields of S/TTo be covered: all fields of S/T

08.10.2004 4

FP6-2003-Infrastructures-4FP6-2003-Infrastructures-4Call outlineCall outline

Indicative budget: 70 million €;Indicative budget: 70 million €;– to cover all fields of S&T;to cover all fields of S&T;

Call deadline: 4 March 2004;Call deadline: 4 March 2004;

Proposals received: 121 (Proposals received: 121 (93 submitted by EPSS);93 submitted by EPSS);– 3 ineligible;3 ineligible;

Proposals evaluated: 118;Proposals evaluated: 118;– 55 Design studies (DS);55 Design studies (DS);– 34 Construction of new infrastructures (CNI);34 Construction of new infrastructures (CNI);– 29 Accompanying measures (AM).29 Accompanying measures (AM).

08.10.2004 5

Funding requestedFunding requested

Total cost: ~ 2,7 billion €. EC contribution: ~ 400 million €

0

500.000.000

1.000.000.000

1.500.000.000

2.000.000.000

2.500.000.000

DS

CNI

AM

DS 402.711.991 209.088.062

CNI 2.251.930.701 167.798.954

AM 11.329.668 9.755.618

Total cost EC contribution

08.10.2004 6

Proposals in priority listProposals in priority listDSDS - - CNICNI - - AMAM

11 European FEL (FEL)European FEL (FEL)

22 Global TeV Linear Collider (Oth - Acc)Global TeV Linear Collider (Oth - Acc)

33 Extremely Large Telescope (Astr)Extremely Large Telescope (Astr)

44 European Virtual Observatory (Astr)European Virtual Observatory (Astr)

55 Airborne Global Observing System (Env)Airborne Global Observing System (Env)

66 Radioactive Ion Beam Facility (Nuclear Ph)Radioactive Ion Beam Facility (Nuclear Ph)

77 Multilingual resources infrastructure (ESH)Multilingual resources infrastructure (ESH)

88 Early gene expression facility (BioMed)Early gene expression facility (BioMed)

99 Upgrade of the ISIS Neutron Spallation Upgrade of the ISIS Neutron Spallation source (Neutrons, Muons)source (Neutrons, Muons)

1010 Integrated Structural Biology centre (Biology)Integrated Structural Biology centre (Biology)

1111 European Census data - Dissemination European Census data - Dissemination (ESH)(ESH)

1212 Underground facility on Safety and Security Underground facility on Safety and Security (Structural Engineering)(Structural Engineering)

1313 Incoherent Scatter Radar (Oth - Radar)Incoherent Scatter Radar (Oth - Radar)

1414 Honeypots (Computers)Honeypots (Computers)

1515 Tax benefit simulation model (ESH)Tax benefit simulation model (ESH)

1616 Sustainable aquaculture centre (Env)Sustainable aquaculture centre (Env)

1717 European Census data - Integration (ESH)European Census data - Integration (ESH)

1818 Carbohydrate database (BioMed)Carbohydrate database (BioMed)

1919 Marine chemical ecology centre (Env)Marine chemical ecology centre (Env)

2020 Highly contagious diseases centre (BioMed)Highly contagious diseases centre (BioMed)

08.10.2004 7

Proposals in Proposals in reservereserve list listDSDS - - CNICNI - - AMAM

2121 300 mm wafer R&D plant (Nanotech)300 mm wafer R&D plant (Nanotech)

2222 NG pulsed magnets (H Magnetic F)NG pulsed magnets (H Magnetic F)

2323 Ion & antiproton beams (Nuclear Ph)Ion & antiproton beams (Nuclear Ph)

2424 KmKm22 array (Radioastronomy) array (Radioastronomy)

2525 DNP for Structural Biology (Bio-NMR)DNP for Structural Biology (Bio-NMR)

2626 NG of X-ray scattering (Synchrotrons)NG of X-ray scattering (Synchrotrons)

2727 Bio-nanotech plant (Biology)Bio-nanotech plant (Biology)

2828 Ion & antiproton beams phase1 (Nuclear Ph)Ion & antiproton beams phase1 (Nuclear Ph)

2929 ALMA (Radioastronomy)ALMA (Radioastronomy)

3030 KmKm22 neutrino detector (Astroparticles) neutrino detector (Astroparticles)

08.10.2004 8

2. Next call for: 2. Next call for: Transnational Access, Transnational Access,

Integrating Activities Integrating Activities andandAccompanying MeasuresAccompanying Measures

08.10.2004 9

FP6 actions in favour of RIFP6 actions in favour of RI

Actions implemented:Actions implemented:– 1. Transnational Access to RI1. Transnational Access to RI– 2. Integrating Activities:2. Integrating Activities:

• 2.1. Integrated Infrastructure Initiatives2.1. Integrated Infrastructure Initiatives• 2.2. Coordination actions2.2. Coordination actions

– 3. Electronic Communication Network Development3. Electronic Communication Network Development– 4. Design studies in preparation of new RI4. Design studies in preparation of new RI– 5. Development (Construction) of new RI5. Development (Construction) of new RI– 6. Accompanying Measures6. Accompanying Measures

To be covered: all fields of S/TTo be covered: all fields of S/T

08.10.2004 10

FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5 Call outline (1) Call outline (1)

Publication date: 4 November 2004Publication date: 4 November 2004

Call deadline: 3 March 2005Call deadline: 3 March 2005

Remote evaluation: March - April 2005Remote evaluation: March - April 2005

Panel meetings: Brussels, 9-13 May 2005Panel meetings: Brussels, 9-13 May 2005

Results: available in JulyResults: available in July

Negotiations: Sept. 2005 - Dec. 2005Negotiations: Sept. 2005 - Dec. 2005

First contracts: January 2006First contracts: January 2006

All fields of S&T are coveredAll fields of S&T are covered

08.10.2004 11

FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5 FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5 Call outline (2)Call outline (2)

Indicative budget: 145 million €Indicative budget: 145 million €– Integrating Activities (CA, I3): 126 million €Integrating Activities (CA, I3): 126 million €– Transnational Access (SSA): 17 million €Transnational Access (SSA): 17 million €– Accompanying Measures (SSA): 2 million €Accompanying Measures (SSA): 2 million €

Expected proposals: 150Expected proposals: 150– Integrating Activities (CA, I3): 50 Integrating Activities (CA, I3): 50 – Transnational Access (SSA): 70Transnational Access (SSA): 70– Accompanying Measures (SSA): 30Accompanying Measures (SSA): 30

3 ranking lists3 ranking lists

08.10.2004 12

FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5Evaluation procedureEvaluation procedure

Expert evaluators: 90 Expert evaluators: 90 (+ Chairman + Independent Observer)(+ Chairman + Independent Observer)

5 thematic sub-panels for Integrating Activities 5 thematic sub-panels for Integrating Activities and Transnational Accessand Transnational Access

One multidisciplinary sub-panel for One multidisciplinary sub-panel for Accompanying MeasuresAccompanying Measures

08.10.2004 13

Main differences betweenMain differences between call 1 and the new call 5 call 1 and the new call 5

I3:I3:– All three activities (Networking, Access, Joint All three activities (Networking, Access, Joint

Research) are Research) are mandatorymandatory

AM:AM:– Round-table workshops not supportedRound-table workshops not supported

General:General:– Final threshold increasedFinal threshold increased– Some specific evaluation criteria modified (see revised Some specific evaluation criteria modified (see revised

Work Programme)Work Programme)– Results from previous calls taken into accountResults from previous calls taken into account

08.10.2004 14

Summary of FP6 support to RISummary of FP6 support to RIBudget increased from 655 to 738 M€Budget increased from 655 to 738 M€

First call for TA, IA:First call for TA, IA: 190190+35 M€+35 M€

First calls for Géant / Grids:First calls for Géant / Grids: 150150 M€ M€ (Remaining to allocate: 80 M€ for a(Remaining to allocate: 80 M€ for a

“ “Consolidation” call and a 2nd Consolidation” call and a 2nd “Grids” call)“Grids” call)

First call for DS, CNI, AM:First call for DS, CNI, AM: 7070+20 M€ +20 M€ (Remaining to allocate: 48 M€ to a (Remaining to allocate: 48 M€ to a

new call or funding of more new call or funding of more proposals)proposals)

Last call for TA, IA, AM:Last call for TA, IA, AM: 145 M€ 145 M€

08.10.2004 15

3. 3. TowardsTowardsResearch Infrastructures in Research Infrastructures in FP7FP7

08.10.2004 16

From FP6 to FP7:From FP6 to FP7:European Strategy Forum on RIEuropean Strategy Forum on RI

ObjectivesObjectives– Support a coherent and strategy-led approach to policy Support a coherent and strategy-led approach to policy

making on RI in Europemaking on RI in Europe– Facilitate multilateral initiatives for the development of RI: Facilitate multilateral initiatives for the development of RI: best best

use of existing infrastructures and creation of new onesuse of existing infrastructures and creation of new ones

AchievementsAchievements– Strategy roadmaps and coordination: neutron sources, free Strategy roadmaps and coordination: neutron sources, free

electron lasers, marine science, social sciences infrastructureselectron lasers, marine science, social sciences infrastructures

Future: reinforcement and consolidation of ESFRI roleFuture: reinforcement and consolidation of ESFRI role– Coherent strategic agenda, improved working methods, Coherent strategic agenda, improved working methods,

common approaches, multilateral initiativescommon approaches, multilateral initiatives– Contacts with EIRO forum and other stakeholdersContacts with EIRO forum and other stakeholders

08.10.2004 17

First thoughtsFirst thoughts

Continuation of the FP6 actions on RIContinuation of the FP6 actions on RI

Discussion on the actions related to the construction Discussion on the actions related to the construction and functioning of new infrastructures of EU interestand functioning of new infrastructures of EU interest

– through a ‘TEN’ – like mechanism ?through a ‘TEN’ – like mechanism ?– taking into account strategic criteria on:taking into account strategic criteria on:

• a priority lista priority list

• the location of new RIthe location of new RI

Perspectives of collaboration with the EU Structural Perspectives of collaboration with the EU Structural funds and the EIBfunds and the EIB

08.10.2004 18

A “top-down” approach A “top-down” approach

Support for the development of future RI of EU interest Support for the development of future RI of EU interest based on:based on:

– a strategic, long term vision and identification of priority needs a strategic, long term vision and identification of priority needs for large, new or upgraded RI for large, new or upgraded RI in the next 15-20 years: in the next 15-20 years: roadmap(s)roadmap(s)

– more targeted support for specific RI projectsmore targeted support for specific RI projects– increased use of financial engineering to support new RIincreased use of financial engineering to support new RI

In consultation with ESFRIIn consultation with ESFRI

In close cooperation with EIRO forum, ESF,In close cooperation with EIRO forum, ESF,and other potential stakeholdersand other potential stakeholders

08.10.2004 19

Strategic Roadmap(s)Strategic Roadmap(s)Guiding Principles:Guiding Principles:

– Clear methodology for elaborating the roadmap(s)Clear methodology for elaborating the roadmap(s)– Transparency and impartialityTransparency and impartiality– Support by all stakeholdersSupport by all stakeholders– Endorsement by the Council of MinistersEndorsement by the Council of Ministers– Periodic revision(s)Periodic revision(s)

Criteria for inclusion:Criteria for inclusion:– New infrastructures (or major upgrades)New infrastructures (or major upgrades)– Scientific importance and excellenceScientific importance and excellence– Endorsement by the EU scientific communityEndorsement by the EU scientific community– Technology feasibility study existsTechnology feasibility study exists– Justification for EC interventionJustification for EC intervention

Criteria for prioritisation:Criteria for prioritisation:– Timeliness and readiness for constructionTimeliness and readiness for construction– Management and long-term budget estimatesManagement and long-term budget estimates– Potential impacts and long term user needsPotential impacts and long term user needs– International added valueInternational added value

08.10.2004 20

Proposed priority list of new RI

Council Resolution

Inclusion in Specific RTD

Programme(s)

Inclusion in FEDERRELEX

strategic plans

Stakeholdersincl. EIROs

Member states European Commission

Inclusion in national

ProgrammesProjects

EIB

08.10.2004 21

Design studies

Construction

Running costs, upgrades and interconnections

M€

FP

With continuous national support, also for running costs

FEDERBEIAgencies Private Other

Timeline: 20 to 50 years

FP7 and after:FP7 and after:Levels of support at project levelLevels of support at project level

Preliminary studies

08.10.2004 22

Next StepsNext Steps

Consolidation of approaches: Consolidation of approaches: Autumn 2004Autumn 2004

Working groups & task forces: Working groups & task forces: Winter 2004 - Summer 2005Winter 2004 - Summer 2005

First elements for an EU draft roadmap: First elements for an EU draft roadmap: Summer 2005Summer 2005

Commission draft communication: Commission draft communication: Autumn 2005Autumn 2005

Specific programme: Specific programme: Spring 2006Spring 2006

08.10.2004 23

Further InformationFurther Information

General information on research including FP6General information on research including FP6– http://http://europa.eu.int/comm/researcheuropa.eu.int/comm/research

Information about research programmesInformation about research programmes– http://http://www.cordis.luwww.cordis.lu

Information on FP6 infrastructuresInformation on FP6 infrastructures– http://http://www.cordis.luwww.cordis.lu/infrastructures/infrastructures

Information on call FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5Information on call FP6-2004-Infrastructures-5– http://fp6.cordis.lu/infrastructures/calls.cfmhttp://fp6.cordis.lu/infrastructures/calls.cfm