Click here to load reader
Upload
werner-iucksch
View
661
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Essay about how the traditional ad industry is changing to produce campaigns that give consumers the power to remix (and spread) content for clients.
Citation preview
RemixableMediaandtheAdvertisingIndustry
byWernerIucksch
“[Kids]aren’trebellingagainstthemarketers;theywanttobethemarketers.That’stherebellion.”
RanaReevescreativedirectorofShrineCommunications
(inMason, 2008, p. 226)
Introduction
Therisingprevalenceofremixablemediaiscreatingabigchangeinthewayadvertisingagenciesoperate.Consumershavealwaysinfluencedadvertising,butremixinggoeswaybeyondit.Theworkagenciesdeliver,thekindofprofessionalstheyemployandthelevelofcontrolovertheworkarebeingimpactedbyit.Thisessaywillexploretheramificationandimplicationsofremixcultureintheadvertisingworld.
Thistopiccanbediscussedinanumberofways,suchashowtheincreasingpopularityofremixablemediaisshapingtraditionaladvertising(i.e.TV,radio,print,billboards,newspapers)intermsofvisuallanguage,format,values,etc;orhowconsumer‐ledinitiativesareaffectingbrands(e.g.aretheomnipresentuser‐generated“Priceless”parodiesdamagingMasterCard?).However,thisessaywillfocusonaparticularfacetofremixableculturethathasadeeperimpactonhowtheadindustryoperates:theflourishingofadvertisingcampaignsthataremeanttoberemixedbythepublic.
Asafirststep,tounderstandhowadvertisingpracticeischanging,itisimportanttounderstandhowtheyusedtooperate.
Thetraditionaladvertisingprocess
Traditionaladvertisingagencieshaveafairlysimpleproductionprocess.Basicallytheygetabrieffromaclient(e.g.productlaunch)andthroughitsvariousdepartments,theagencywoulddevelop(inthisexample)thefollowingdocuments:
1) Astrategicproposalshowingwhatisthebestwayofsellingtheproduct(whataretheopportunities,importantconsumerinsights,valuesthatshouldbepresentinthecommunicationandhowtotakeadvantageofthem).
2) Creativeexecutions,materializingwhatthestrategyisallabout(theadsastheywouldappeartotheconsumers:filmscriptsinstandardlength,printmock‐ups,etc.)
3) Amediaplandescribingwhere,whenandatwhatcostthecreativematerialshouldbeplaced(e.g.3x30secondinsertionsonChannel9News/dayfor2weeks).
Ifapprovedbytheclient,theexecutionswouldbeproducedanddisplayedasagreed.Everymessageaboutthisnewproductwouldbepositive,astheadvertisercontrolsthem.
Mostoftheimpactofremixablecampaignsimpactinonpoints2and3,aswellasproduction,asitisdiscussedbelow.
Theremixingimpactontheprocess
Asmanymarketsaregettingcommoditizedwithlackofdifferentiationbetweenbrands,manyadvertisersseethephenomenonofremixcultureasanopportunityto(re‐)buildstrongconnectionswiththeirclients,hopingtoincreaseloyalty,brandequityandsales,becauseofremixingengagingnature.
Thebrandthatendeavoursintocreatingcampaignsthatpromotesremixing,however,isconfrontedwithaseriesofissues:
A) ConvincingtheaudiencetoengageinameaningfulwayB) FindingwaysofreducingtheriskofnegativecontentC) Distributingthenewremixedmessage
Thesearenotalltheissuesandtheyoverlap.However,thisseparationdoesallowdiscussinghowtheprocessischanging.
A)Convincingtheaudiencetoengageintheremix
Usersknowthatwhentheyareengageindoingavideoforabrand,forexample,theyarebeingadvertisedtoandunderstandthecommercialpurposesofthebrand.Theywanttohavesomekindofreward(e.g.fame,fun,money)anditcanleadtoacompletelymeaninglessexchangeforthebrand,ifmarketing‐savvyusersjustharvestrewardofferedbybrands,givingnothinginreturn,forexample.
Thereisanendlessnumberofwaystoengageconsumersintoremixingcontent,varyingdramaticallyincomplexityand,therefore,itsimpactonhowtheindustryoperate.Belowaresomeofthesewaysandtheirimplicationforagenciesandmarketers:
1) Togivegreatamountofmediamaterialtoenabletheremixinginapre‐definedway.HyundaiUSA(2009)launchedthe“EpicLap”campaign,in
whichwebsitewithfootageofatestdrivewassetuptoconsumerstoletthemedititastheywish.Inthiscasethebiggerchallengeisnottoproducethematerial,buttomaketheremixtechnologyavailable.Adagenciesdon’thaveahistoryofdevelopingtoolsforconsumers,butithastochangetomakeinitiativesofthiskindviable.
2) Tofocusonextensivecontentonthemesrelevanttotheconsumerandrequestingcollaborationtokeepitinteresting.SpriteAustralia (2008)isagoodexample,asitscampaigndiscusses“unsaidtruths”generatingongoingparticipationwithdirectreferencefromtheaudienceindifferentmedia.Advertisingagenciestraditionallydon’tmasterthisformat,fortheusualdistributionandproductionchannelsmakescost‐prohibitivetomakelongerstories.Gettingliberatedfrominternalizedoldproduction+broadcastingmentalbarriersisachallenge.
3) Ifthebrand/productcountswithsomesympathyandengagement,suchasentertainmentproducts,thereisthepossibilityofgoingverydeepwiththeremixablecontent.Thelaunchoffilm“A.I.”,forexample,hadateasermaterializedbytheinteractivereal‐timepuzzle“TheBeast”(Jenkins, 2006, p. 123),encouraginguserstoremixandcreatecommunitiesaroundthefilm.Theskilltocreatethiskindofinteractionisclosertothatoffilmwritingthantoadvertisingcopy;thekindofsoftwarenecessaryisdifferent;themetricstoanalysesuccessaredifferent.
B)Findingwaysofreducingtheriskofnegativecontent
CorporationsarelookedatsuspiciouslyontheInternetfortheyusuallystandforhierarchyandcontrolandthesearevaluescompletelyoppositetothoseprevalentinmostInternetcircles(Dijk, 2006, p. 33).
Whenacompanyissponsoringthecreationofcontentaboutitselfitisperfectlypossibleforuserstomockthecompanyinmanyways.GMwasoneofthefirstcompaniestosufferwithitastheyenabledconsumerstoeditanduploadbrandedvideosdirectlytotheInternet.ManyuserstookthechancetoprotestagainstGMinstead(Huba, 2006).
Therealsoaremanycopyrightissues.AnygivenconsumermayuseunauthorisedsongsofU2toremixavideo,forexample,thepotentiallawsuitsarerarelyworththerisk.Legaldepartmentshavetobemoreinvolvedandcaneffectivelyimpactonthecreativeprocesslikeneverbefore.
Asanorm,therefore,mostcompanieswilltrytocreatesomekindofrestrictionthatallowsthemtofilterexcesses.Examplesincludeallowingtheremixedversiontobeuploadedtothecompany’swebsiteonlyand/orlettheremixbecomesharableonlyafterapproval.
However,thatisnotalwayssatisfactoryandfeasible.Consumerscangetveryfrustratedbyrestrictionsandwhentheremixedcontentistextandstillimages,it’smoredifficulttostopusersfromspreadingwhatevertheywant.Thisiswhythemarketershavetounderstandwelltheirroleinthecommunityofcontentgeneratingusers.It’simportanttokeepaconstantandrespectfulpresence,notonlytalking,butalsolisteningand,mostimportantly,collaboratingwiththecommunity(e.g.newproducts,content).ThesearethefundamentalstonesofInternetculture(Castells, 2001, pp. 37-63)andshouldbeembracedbymarketers.
Thisisafull‐timejobtowhichadvertisingagenciesarealsoadaptingtoexecute.Theadvertisingworldworkswiththelogicofcampaigns,withwell‐definedbeginningandenddates,thishastobechangedbecausethemanagementofameaningfuldigitalpresencemustbeongoing.
3)Distributingtheremixedmessage
Inmanycasesthebrandswillwanttheremixedmessagestobedisseminatedasafundamentalpartoftheoverallstrategy.However,asusersutilizeanetwork(e.g.internet)tospreadmessagesandthisisverydifferentfromtraditionalbroadcastmedia.Barabàsi(2003)demonstratedthatinnetworksit’sparamounttodetectwhoarethehubstoreachthetargetaudience.Gettingthehubstoagreetohelpdisseminatethemessageisnotsimple,becauseitdoesnotdependonlyoncommercialinterests,butalsosocialrelationshipsbasedontrust.Thereachofacampaignisneveraspredictableasintraditionalmedia.
Thisisasignificantshift.Socialmediais“wordofmouthonsteroids”,butthelogictomakeuseofitisnotstraightforward,manythingsareimportanttomotivatepeopletoforwardtheirremixandcompaniesarelearningwithusers,suchastheadagencyFallonWorldwidethatrecentlypreparedacasestudyoftheusergeneratedvideo“KittensInspiredbyKittens” (Kelly, 2008)toshowhowitmanagedtoreachmorethan4millionviewsand1.5millionGooglecitations. (Spicer, 2009)
Conclusion
“Remixablecampaigns”withoutadoubtischangingthewaytheadvertisingindustryoperates.Thisis,however,adoubled‐edgedswordthathastobewellthoughtbeforebeingunleashed.Theindustryisstilllearninghowtouseitnowandgetscutfromtimetotime.Embracing“remixablecampaigns”withouthavingdoneagoodjobintheareasmentionedcanhaveharmfuleffect.
However,thetremendousopportunitiestogeneratemoredistinctiveandmeaningfulrelationshipswithconsumersareclear.Inordertoseizetheopportunitiestheindustryhastoadjusthumanresources,formats,controlmechanisms,legalframeworkand,mostimportantly,mindsetfrommarketers.
Thisprocesstendstobegoodforadvertisingagencies,marketersandconsumers.Despitepotentiallossesintheway,theindustrymightfinditself
renovatedintermsofcapabilitiesinthenearfuture.Advertiserstendtogainrelevancefromconsumersastheystarttogetitright.Andconsumersmayfindthebrandsmoreinterestingthantheyaretoday.
BibliographyBarabàsi,A.‐L.(2003).LinkedHoweverythingisconnectedtoeverythingelseandwhatitmeansforbusiness,scienceandeverydaylife.Cambridge,Massachusetts,USA:Plume.
Castells,M.(2001).TheInternetGalaxy:reflectionsontheinternet,businessandsociety.NewYork:OxfordUniversityPress.
Coca‐ColaCompany.(2008).TruthHunters.RetrievedMarch19,2009,fromSprite:http://www.thirstfortruth.com.au/
Dijk,J.v.(2006).NetworkSociety.ThousandOaks,California,USA:Sage.
Huba,J.(2006,April).WhyChevytahoecampaignwasdoomedbeforeitlaunched.RetrievedOctober30,2008,fromChurchofCustomerBlog:http://customerevangelists.typepad.com/blog/2006/04/why_chevy_tahoe.html
HyundaiUSA.(2009,January).HuyndaiGenesisCoupe:AffordablePerformance300+hpSportCoupe.RetrievedMarch20,2009,fromHyundai:http://hyundaigenesis.com/coupe
Jenkins,H.(2006).ConvergenceCulture:WhereOldandNewMediaCollide.NewYork,NY,USA:NewYorkUniversityPress.
Kelly,A.(2008,September).Kittensinspiredbykittens.RetrievedMarch18,2009,fromYouTube:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FtX8nswnUKU
Mason,M.(2008).ThePirate'sDilemma:HowYouthCultureisReinventingCapitalism.NewYork,NY,USA:FreePress.
Spicer,A.(2009,February).FallonBrainfood:InspiredbyKittens.RetrievedMarch20,2009,fromSlideShare:http://www.slideshare.net/akispicer/fallon‐brainfood‐inspired‐by‐kittens