View
216
Download
0
Category
Preview:
Citation preview
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
1/167
Vmhrfc Ehdn Vmhrfc Pmk fmstrubfj @o Vd`b Out Coem
Lroe1
Yo1
Ff1
Fr midt Fhr is.foe Fr midt Fhr i wdt c Por niwdim Hf fmpt hbfm hbi Kmbml dt s Vpobsormi
@mbmrhn Iofjmt
]bdtmi Vthtms Fourt ol Hppmhns lor Idstrdft ol Fonuekdh Fdrfudt
Fourt ol Hppmhns Iofjmt #1 8;-=;34 Iofjmtmi174/86/;78;
Ymremi17=/;6/;786Bhturm ol Vudt1 ;347 Otcmr Vthtutory Hftdobs
]VH v. Khrhfj Okheh, mt hn
Hppmhn Lroe1]bdtmi Vthtms Idstrdft Fourt lor tcm Idstrdft ol Fonuekdh
Lmm Vthtus1Lmm Whdi
Fhsm Yypm Dblorehtdob1
8)Fdvdn ]V
;)]bdtmi Vthtms
6)
Ord`dbhtdb` Fourt Dblorehtdob1
Idstrdft1 7747-8 1 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
2/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
3/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
4/167
]BDYMI VYHYMV FO][Y ol HWWMHNVLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH FD[F]DY
-------------------------------------------------------------x Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj,]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.Hppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34=46\hbimrkdntHvmbum-#;38 Kroojnyb.,BmwTorj88;63 (39=)478-
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
5/167
O[IM[olFdrfudtAui`msCmbimrsob,@rdlldtc,hbiJhvhbhu`c,dbtcm
EotdobtondlttcmEhbihtmdssumiHu`ust8,;786dbtcmHppmhn8;-=;34,
smmtcmMxcdkdtH,thjmblroetcmorimrtoidsedsshslrdvonouskytcmbFcdml
IdstrdftAui`mNhekmrtcdbVtrubjvOkhehmthnIFI87-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
6/167
=.LurtcmrHppmnnhbtwdscmslortcmmekhbfphbmntospmfdlydbphrtdfunhrwcmrmeovhbt lhdns to imeobstrhtm h potmbtdhnny emrdtordous fnhde orimlmbsm"dbcdstcmeotdob,XuoPhrrhbtopmtdtdobhbiXudYhefoepnhdbt.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
7/167
rmhr`um mb khbf km smt ky L[HW [unm97 (wdtcdb 9= ihys lroe Oftokmr 8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
8/167
Vmptmekmr Ymre ;786D-F\-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
9/167
8
]BDYMI VYHYMV FO][Y ol HWWMHNVLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH FD[F]DY
-------------------------------------------------------------x Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj,]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.Hppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34=46\hbimrkdntHvmbum-#;38 Kroojnyb.,BmwTorj88;63 (39=)478-
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
10/167
;
DBY[OI]FYDOBHksmbthbhlldrehtdvmrmspobsmky[.Frhd`Nhwrmbfmol].V.Httorbmy's
OlldfmhbiorMrdfE.Ycorsob Dbspmftor@mbmrhnlortcm].V.ImphrtembtolYrmhsuryorimrmikytcmFourtiumkyHu`ust;;,;786,tcdsdstcm[mpnyhlldihvdtolMS[MNHYO[Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1Vtrubjdbmssmhbisudaurds
H`mbtolkusdbmsstrustFC[DVYOWCM[MH[NVY[]BJ,kyVpmfdhn-
Hppmhrhbfm(HLLDHBY)dbsupportoltcmMS[MNHYO[HWWMNNHBYV
BOYDFMOLEOYDOBYO[MFOBVDIM[VYHTHBIO[NDLYYCM
EHBIHYMOLH]@]VY8,;786lroetcmorimridsedssdb`tcmhppmhnlor
nhfjolprosmfutdobwdtcIFFdrfudt[unm63,wdtcsupportdb`hlldrehtdobol
Hu`ust3,;786wdtctmbmxcdkdtshbbmxmi,dbtchtkhsmiupobbmw
trhbshftdobs,phyembtollmmhbifchb`moltcmMS[MNHYO[Hppmnnhbts
sthtus,tchttcdshppmhnkmorimrmirmbmwmitofhnmbihrkytcdsFourtto
hnnowpmrlmftdoboltcmhppmhnthjmblroetcmXuoPhrrhbto,XudYhe
hftdobwdtcrmnhtmifhusmsdbFhsm87-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
11/167
LHFYV8. YchtHLLDHBYshlldrehtdobdbsupportchiprovdimilortmbmxcdkdts
hbbmxmitcmrmto,olwcdfcMxcdkdt 87whsedssdb`tcmKhrhfjC.Okheh;78;Lore8797].V.DbidvdiuhnDbfoemYhx[mturbwdtcVofdhnVmfurdty
buekmrsrmihftmi,ldnmiaodbtnywdtcEdfcmnnmOkhehhbihlldremiHprdn3,
;786httcmrmvmrsmph`m(hsmxfmrptmikmnow),whsoedttmidscmrmwdtc.
;. Yormfhp,tchtFcrdstopcmrMhrnVtrubjdbmssmdstcmobnyWrdvhtm
bhtdobhn].V.Fdtdzmbtochvmiunyldrmitcm]surpmrKhrhfjCussmdbOkheh
DDdbmssmubimr]bdloreFoeemrfdhnFoimobAhbuhry;6,;774kmfhusm
kycdsowbhiedssdobh`hdbstdbtmrmsthshbmxfmptdobtotcmcmhrshyrunm
tchtcdsnm`hnlhtcmrwhshKrdtdscsukamftwcmbcmwhskorb,dsboth
bhturhn-korbfdtdzmb(BKF)hfforidb`totcm]VFobstdtutdobHrtdfnm;
Vmftdob8Fnhusm=(H;V8F=)ehbihtmhbirmnhtminhw,hbidsbotmnd`dknm
tosmrvmhsWrmsdimbthbiorwdtcsufcfoblndfthstcm].V.khbjruptfy
rmor`hbdzhtdobmxmfutdvmtrustmmmsthkndscmisdbfmtcmEhrfc4,8466
WrmsdimbtdhnWrofnhehtdobwcmbkyopmrhtdobolnhwhnnauidfdhnhbi
6
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
12/167
9
hiedbdstrhtdvmprofmssdsiobmkyEdndthryrhtcmrtchbfdvdndhbprofmss:hbi
tchthfopyoltcmldrdb`iofuembtwdtcbotdfmol[mpnmvdblonnow-up,obldnm
dbO`imb]thc,obBovmekmr4,;774whsiunysmrvmiupobtcmbVmfrmthry
oltcmYrmhsurywdtchutcordtyolprdvhtmhffoubtshttcmYrmhsuryfrmhtmi
kyopmrhtdobolsmfurdtdzdb`tcmimktorkdrtcfmrtdldfhtmhbikobidssumiky
tcmVofdhnVmfurdtyHiedbdstrhtdob(smmMxcdkdt 88):hbihssufc,6. YchttcmXuoPhrrhbtoFoepnhdbtfoekdbmiwdtctcmXudYhe
fnhdewdtcspmfdldfdbidvdiuhndbaurdmsimndbmhtmirmqudrmswdtcouthby
hlldrehtdvmsthtutoryrmspobsmkytcm]VHttorbmymdtcmrhtidstrdftwcdnmtcm
foepnhdbtwhsubimrsmhnorrmspobsmcmrmdb,tchtkysdnmbfmdburms]bdtmi
VthtmsMS[MNHYO[sthtusupobFcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1Vtrubjtoeovmlorwhri
wdtctcmFourtoknd`htmitormportobtcmnhwhstotcmmvdimbfmolBKF
H;V8F=mnd`dkdndtyolKhrhfjCussmdbOkhehDDtoconitcmhutcordtyoltcm
OlldfmolWrmsdimbtoltcm]bdtmiVthtms(WOY]V)hbihnntchttchtmbthdns:
spmfdldfhnnycdsmxmfutdvmtrustmmsthtusubimrtcmHrtdfnm;VmftdobD
FobstdtutdobhnOhtchstcmuntdehtmldiufdhryovmrtcmprdvhtmtrusthffoubts
olhnntcmpukndf]VFdtdzmbImktorswcosmbhturhnWrdvhtm]Vsurmtdmshrm
dbimbturmi,hbiwcosmlubishbimhrbdb`swdtchiouknmkoojjmmpdb`
systmehrmkubinmidbtcosmtrusthffoubtsubimrtcmfobtronhbihutcordty
oltcm]bdtmiVthtmsVmfrmthryolYrmhsuryhstcmYrustmm/[mfmdvmrhbihs
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
13/167
smfurdtdmsdbtmremidhrylortcmfrmidtorstcmrmto,hbitchtdburmsubfnhdemi
totcmBhtdobhn@ovmrbembtupobtcmimhtcoltcmsurmtydbimbturm:hbi
9. ]bimrtcmEdndthryNhwprofmsstchtchsmxdstmisdbfmtcm
Wrofnhehtdobsol8466hbi84=7wdtctcmhbbuhnrm-imfnhrhtdobolBhtdobhn
Memr`mbfyrmpmhtmitcmrmhltmrkytcm[mspobimbt]surpmrtoo,tcmiutdms
oltcmFoeehbimrdb-FcdmlhssofdhtmiwdtcHrtdfnm;smftdob;pmrsobhnny
deposmsedndthryprofmssupobhnnsthtutoryWukndf]VFdtdzmbshbisurmtdms.
=. Ychthshrmsuntoltcm]surpmrshbbuhnimfnhrhtdobdbfobtdbuhtdob
oltcmBhtdobhnMemr`mbfyubimrcdshutcordtyehbihtms,hbiwdtcoutcds
MxmfutdvmOrimrsovmrrunmikyFob`rmss,tcmMemr`mbfyPhrWowmrs
FourtslorWukndf].V.FdtdzmbshrmDIMBYDFHNdbtcmdrWrofmsshbi
Vmttdb`swdtctcmEhrtdhnFourtslorWukndf].V.Vonidmrshswmshwwdtc
NYFYmrryNhjdb,wcofchnnmb`mitcm]surpmrshutcordtytosmbicdeto
Hl`chbdsthb,hsrmtrdkutdobmxhepnmtootcmrfoeedssdobmiolldfmrs(8)whs
8 EdndthryolldfmrboedbhtdobshrmsukamfttofobldrehtdobkytcmVmbhtm,nhr`mnydb khtfc
eoim-hbiobhvmryrm`unhrkhsds-lroetcmnowmstfoeedssdobmiolldfmrdbmhfckrhbfcoltcmEdndthrytcrou`ctcmcd`cmst-kmdb`ollmrmiobboedbhtdobkytcmWrmsdimbtoltcm]bdtmiVthtms. cttp1//www.prmsdimbtdhn-hppodbtembts.or`/edndthry_hppodbtembts.cte
Ydtnm =7 Vmftdob 8;;76Foeedssdobmiolldfmrs1hppodbtembt,cowehim:tmre (h)Hppodbtembtsolrmsmrvmolldfmrsdbfoeedssdobmi rhimshkovmndmutmbhbtfonobmnhbifoeehbimrorkmnow,mxfmptfoeedssdobmiwhrrhbtolldfmr,schnnkmehimkytcmWrmsdimbthnobm.Hppodbtembtsolrmsmrvmolldfmrsdbfoeedssdobmi`rhimshkovmndmutmbhbtfonobmnhbifoeehbimrschnnkmehimkytcmWrmsdimbt,kyhbiwdtctcmhivdfmhbifobsmbtoltcmVmbhtm,mxfmpthsprovdimidbsmftdob
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
14/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
15/167
0
smphrhtdobolpowmrsioftrdbm,kmsdimtcmdrhivdsmhbifobsmbtiutdms,chs
kmmbimbdmiMS[MNHYO[cmrmdbkotcdbtcmbm`nmftoltcm;7 tchbi;=tc
Hembiembtprofmssmvmbwcmbtcm]VVmbhtmdb;773whsiunybotdldmiol
tcmdriutykyFWYWhemnhKhrbmtttormvdmwtcm]surpmrsmnd`dkdndty
quhndldfhtdobshsmvdimbfmidbtcmeotdobtormhr`umdbtcmidstrdftfourtdb
Hu`ustnhstymhrscows:hbi`dvmbtchttcm]VVmbhtmwdtcEr.Okhehchi
depropmrnyhttmeptmitormimldbmBKFdbtcmdrbob-kdbidb`Vmbsm
[msonutdob=88olHprdn;773usdb`tcmnhwemeorhbiuepukndscmilortcht
purposmkyYcmoiormOnsmbhbiNhwrmbfmYrdkmdbEhrfc;773(smm
Mxcdkdt 86)toprmmepthbimbfrohfcupobtcmpurvdmwoltcdsFourthbidtsiutytchteustkmiobmcmrmdbubimrsmphrhtdobolpowmrioftrdbm.
87. Ycht]VFYdtnm88KhbjruptfyFoimphrnhbfmrmnhtmstotcm
MxmfutdvmYrustmmiutdmshssofdhtmiwdtctcm8466]bdtmiVthtmsImkt
rmor`hbdzhtdobpnhbstdnnob`odb`wdtctcmiuhnkoojjmmpdb`systme
smfurdtdzmikytcmdbimbturmirmhnpropmrtyhbinhkoroltcmsurmtdmslortcm
Wukndf]VFdtdzmbhbiWukndfVonidmr]VFdtdzmb.
88. ]bimrYdtnm88hY[]VYMMotcmrtchbtcm]VYrustmmhssd`bmi
tohbyspmfdldfimktrmor`hbdzhtdobfhsm,tcmImphrtembtolAustdfm
imldbdtdobpukndscmikytcmIOAquotm1
dstcmrmprmsmbthtdvmoltcmkhbjruptfymsthtmwcomxmrfdsmssthtutorypowmrs,prdbfdphnnylortcmkmbmldtoltcmubsmfurmifrmidtors,ubimrtcm
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
16/167
3
`mbmrhnsupmrvdsdoboltcmfourthbitcmidrmftsupmrvdsdoboltcm].V.trustmmorkhbjruptfyhiedbdstrhtor.Ycmtrustmmdshprdvhtmdbidvdiuhnorforporhtdobhppodbtmidbhnnfchptmr0,fchptmr8;,hbifchptmr86fhsmshbisoemfchptmr88fhsms.Ycmtrustmm'srmspobsdkdndtdmsdbfnuimrmvdmwdb`tcmimktor'spmtdtdobhbisfcmiunmshbikrdb`db`hftdobsh`hdbstfrmidtorsortcmimktortormfovmrpropmrtyoltcmkhbjruptfymsthtm.Dbfchptmr0,tcmtrustmmndqudihtmspropmrtyoltcmmsthtm,hbiehjmsidstrdkutdobstofrmidtors.Yrustmmsdbfchptmr8;hbi86chvmsdednhriutdmstohfchptmr0trustmmhbitcmhiidtdobhnrmspobsdkdndtdmsolovmrsmmdb`tcmimktor'spnhb,rmfmdvdb`phyembtslroeimktors,hbiidskursdb`pnhbphyembtstofrmidtors.8;. KH[HFJC]VVMDBOKHEHDDwdtccdssurmtydbimbturmKhrhfj
CussmdbOkhehDDdstcmprdvhtmdbidvdiuhnorforporhtdobhppodbtmihs
WOY]VYrustmmlortcm]bdtmiVthtmsImktrmor`hbdzhtdobpnhbsdbfm8466
wcohstcmtrustmmtcrou`ctcmhppodbtembtprofmssmepnoystcosmtcht
schnnBOYconiorrmprmsmbthbdbtmrmsthivmrsmtotcmmsthtmfrmidtorhbiorkmbmldfdhrdms, hbitchthrmidsdbtmrmstmipmrsobsshinydsbotso.
86. Ychtkmfhusmbmdtcmrtcmmbhftembtoltcm89 tcHembiembtbor
tcmdeposdtdobolEdndthry[unmkytcmfobtdbumimemr`mbfyprofnhehtdobs
hbiormxmfutdvmorimrsoltcdsorhbyotcmrWrmsdimbthembitcmimldbdtdob
hbidbcmrmbtemhbdb`oltcmbhturhn-korbFdtdzmbmnd`dkdndtyfnhusmoltcm
]VFobstdtutdobH;V8F=,tcdsdssumolnhwdskmlormtcdsFourtphbmnwdtc
tcmpnmbhryiutyubimrtcmsmphrhtdobolpowmrsioftrdbmtormportobtcm
BKFemhbdb`dbstmhioltchtiobmkytcmFob`rmssortcmMxmfutdvmdt
eustrmbimrhimfnhrhtdobubimrfonorolhnnrmnhtmiVuprmemFourtldbidb`s,
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
17/167
4
cdstoryhbirmnhtminhwdbfnuidb`tcmspmfdhnfdrfuesthbfmubimrwcdfcwm
opmrhtmlortcdsphbmntofobsdimrtcmrmnmvhbfmol]VYdtnms88,8=,hbi83
hsrmnhtmsto88]VF870-Wukndfhffmsstophpmrs,]VF07;-
Mnmftdoboltrustmm,88]VF079-Iutdmsoltrustmm,88]VF88
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
18/167
87
lmnnowDbiobmsdhbAhems[dhiyoltcmNdppo@rouphbilmnnow
Dsnhedstseufcworsmtchbfnosmimhndb`lrhuihssofdhtmiwdtctcm
onybir khbjruptfy(;)8=. Hssufc,tcmlorm`odb`lurtcmrsuksthbtdhtmseysuspdfdobtchttcm
]surpmrsimhndb`shstcmmxmfutdvmtrustmmLdiufdhry(6)wrmhjolFoblndft
OlDbtmrmst, XudiWroXuo,imbdhnolCobmstVmrvdfmsLrhui,nhfjolWrosmfutordhnIdsfrmtdobhstcmfcdmlnhwmblorfmembtolldfmr,wdnnlunhfts
ubimrfonorolnhwtoimprdvmorfobspdrmtoimprdvmhpmrsobolhrd`ct
protmftmikytcmFobstdtutdobor].V.nhw,botordousPcdstnmKnowmr
[mthndhtdob,hbibotnmhsthsbowsmmb[mvonvdb`Ioor[m`unhtdobwcmrmdb; Vonybirh,tchtbmw`rmmbirmheihrndb`olWrmsdimbtOkheh, ldnmslorFchptmr88.Kut,
botubtdnhltmr`mttdb`ovmrchnlhKDNNDOBionnhrsdb`ovmrbembtkhfjdb`lornohbsehimkyfmrthdbcmi`mlubis.Ycdsemhbstchtfmrthdbcmi`mlubiswcohftuhnnyehimtcmnohbswdnn`mttcmlunnheoubtoltcmdrchnlkdnndobionnhrdbvmstembtkhfjdbtotcmdrpofjmtshbiublortubhtmnydbstmhidtwdnnkmthxphymrssullmrdb`tcdsmxtrhoridbhrynoss. 6Hldiufdhry dshnm`hnormtcdfhnrmnhtdobscdpoltrustkmtwmmbtwooreormphrtdms.Yypdfhnny,hldiufdhrypruimbtnythjmsfhrmoleobmylorhbotcmrpmrsob.Obmphrty,lormxhepnmhforporhtmtrustfoephbyortcmtrustimphrtembtolhkhbj,hftsdbhldiufdhryfhphfdtytotcmotcmrobm,wcolormxhepnmchsmbtrustmilubistotcmldiufdhrylorshlmjmmpdb`ordbvmstembt.Ndjmwdsm,hssmtehbh`mrs--dbfnuidb`ehbh`mrsolpmbsdobpnhbs,mbiowembtshbiotcmrthx-mxmepthssmts--hrmfobsdimrmildiufdhrdmsubimrhppndfhknmsthtutmshbinhws.Dbhldiufdhryrmnhtdobscdp,obmpmrsob,dbhposdtdobolvunbmrhkdndty,austdldhknyvmstsfobldimbfm,`ooilhdtc,rmndhbfmhbitrustdbhbotcmrwcosmhdi,hivdfmorprotmftdobdssou`ctdbsoemehttmr.Dbsufchrmnhtdob`ooifobsfdmbfmrmqudrmstcmldiufdhrytohfththnntdemslortcmsonmkmbmldthbidbtmrmstoltcmobmwcotrusts.Hldiufdhrydssoemobmwcochsubimrthjmbtohftlorhbiobkmchnlolhbotcmrdb
hphrtdfunhrehttmrdbfdrfuesthbfmswcdfc`dvmrdsmtohrmnhtdobscdpoltrusthbifobldimbfm.NoriEdnnmtt,KrdstonhbiPmstKudnidb`VofdmtyvEotcmwHldiufdhryiutydstcmcd`cmststhbihriolfhrmhtmdtcmrmqudtyornhw.Hldiufdhry(hkkrmvdhtdobldi)dsmxpmftmitokmmxtrmemnynoyhntotcmpmrsobtowcoecmowmstcmiuty(tcm"prdbfdphn")1cmeustbotputcdspmrsobhndbtmrmstskmlormtcmiuty,hbieustbotproldtlroecdsposdtdobhshldiufdhry,ubnmsstcmprdbfdphnfobsmbts.
http://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/conflict-of-interest.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/conflict-of-interest.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/quid-pro-quo.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/honest-services-fraud.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/prosecutorial-discretion.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/revolving-door-feds.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/revolving-door-feds.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/prosecutorial-discretion.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/honest-services-fraud.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/quid-pro-quo.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/conflict-of-interest.htmlhttp://www.bankruptcymisconduct.com/new/issues/conflict-of-interest.html8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
19/167
88
cmchs`dvmbbuemrouswhdvmrslordbsdimimhndb`tolormd`bdbtmrmstswdtc
mxmfutdvmposdtdobstotcosmubquhndldmimxcdkdtsmxtrmemfoblndftoldbtmrmst.
8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
20/167
8;
rmqudrdb`himfnhrhtoryaui`embtkmrmportmilorlurtcmrfdvdniumprofmssdb
tcm]VVmbhtmhshehttmrolsmphrhtdobolpowmrsioftrdbmdbtchtMS
rmnhtorwdtcproololcdssthtusbubfprotubfchssullmrmisulldfdmbt"dbaurydb
lhft"toshtdslyHrtdfnmDDD'srmqudrmembtslorsthbidb`msthkndscmitchttcm
drrmiufdknmfobstdtutdobhnedbdeueolsthbidb`tchtfobthdbstcrmmmnmembts1
Ldrst,tcmpnhdbtdllchssullmrmihb"dbaurydblhft"-hbdbvhsdobolh
nm`hnnyprotmftmidbtmrmstwcdfcds(h)fobfrmtmhbiphrtdfunhrdzmi...
hbi(k)hftuhnordeedbmbt,bot'fobamfturhn'or'cypotcmtdfhn.'
Vmfobi,tcmrmdshfhushnfobbmftdobkmtwmmbtcmdbauryhbitcm
fobiuftfoepnhdbmiol-tcmdbauryds"lhdrny...trhfmhknmtotcm
fchnnmb`mihftdoboltcmimlmbihbt,hbibot...tcZmUrmsuntZolUtcm
dbimpmbimbthftdobolsoemtcdriphrtybotkmlormtcmfourt."
Ycdri,dtds"ndjmny."hsopposmitoemrmny"spmfunhtdvm,"tchttcmdbaury
wdnnkm"rmirmssmikyhlhvorhknmImfdsdob."
;7. D chvm rmhi tcm hkovm hbi D jbow dts fobtmbts: tcm lhfts sthtmi
cmrmdb hrm trum to ey owbpmrsobhn jbownmi`m, mxfmpt hs to tcmehttmrs
tcmrmdb sthtmi to km hnnm`mi ob dblorehtdob hbi kmndml, hbi hs to tcosm
ehttmrsDkmndmvmdttokmtrum.Ycm`roubisoleykmndmlshstohnnehttmrs
botsthtmiupobdblorehtdobhbikmndmlhrmhslonnows16riphrtdms,koojshbi
rmforis, hbi pmrsobhn jbownmi`m, mxfmpt hs to tcosm sthtmi upob
dblorehtdobhbikmndml,wcdfcDkmndmvmtokmtrum.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
21/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
22/167
]BDYMI VYHYMV FO][Y ol HWWMHNVLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH FD[F]DY
-------------------------------------------------------------x Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj,]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.Hppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34=46\hbimrkdntHvmbum-#;38 Kroojnyb.,BmwTorj88;63 (39=)478-
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
23/167
hppmhn lor nhfj ol prosmfutdob db tcht khsmi upob bmw trhbshftdobs,phyembt ol lmm hbi fchb`m ol tcm MS [MNHYO[Hppmnnhbt sthtus, tcht tcdshppmhn kmorimrmi rmbmwmi to fhnmbihr y tcds Fourt to hnnow pmrlmftdob oltcm hppmhn lroe tcmXuo Phrrhbto Xud Yhe Fhsm 87-fv-7793< db ]bdtmiVthtms Idstrdft Fourt lor tcm Idstrdft ol Fonuekdh idsedssmi ky Aui`m [oyfmF. hekmrtc to km cmhri ht tcm ]bdtmiVthtmsFourtcousm, htFobstdtutdob Hvmbum BP Phscdb`tob Idstrdft ol Fotuekdh, ob tcm ihy hbieobtc db ;786 t h tdem hbi @ourtrooe imsd`bhtmi y tcm fourt or hs soobtcmrmhltmr hs foubsmn fhb km cmhri.
MS [M Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj db sshbi sud aurds H`mbt ol kusdbmss testFC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N VY[]BJ=46\hbimrkdnt Hvmbum h 3 8Krwjnyb, Bmw orj 88;63ehd 1 fcrdsGsnrunbj.wsFmnn-39=-478
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
24/167
8
]BDYMI VYHYMV FO][Y ol HWWMHNVLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH FD[F]DY
-------------------------------------------------------------x Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj,]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.Hppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34=46\hbimrkdntHvmbum-#;38 Kroojnyb.,BmwTorj88;63 (39=)478-
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
25/167
;
DBY[OI]FYDOBYcdsdstcmhlldihvdtolMS[MNHYO[Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1Vtrubj,dbmssmhbi
sudaurdsH`mbtolkusdbmsstrustFC[DVYOWCM[MH[NVY[]BJ,ky
Vpmfdhn-Hppmhrhbfm(HLLDHBY)dbsupportoltcmMS[MNHYO[
HWWMNNHBYVBOYDFMOLEOYDOBYO[MFOBVDIM[VYHTHBIO[
NDLYYCMEHBIHYMOLH]@]VY8,;786lroetcmorimridsedssdb`tcm
hppmhnlornhfjolprosmfutdobwdtcIFFdrfudt[unm63(8) smmMxcdkdt 8),dbtchtkhsmiupobbmwtrhbshftdobs,phyembtollmmhbifchb`moltcmMS
[MNHYO[Hppmnnhbtssthtus,tchttcdshppmhnkmorimrmirmbmwmito
fhnmbihrkytcdsFourttohnnowpmrlmftdoboltcmhppmhnthjmblroetcmXuo
Phrrhbto.XudYhehftdobwdtcrmnhtmifhusmsdbFhsm87-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
26/167
6
LHFYV8. YchtoborhkoutVmptmekmr86,;78;,hsscowbdbMxcdkdt;,MS
[MNHYO[WnhdbtdllldnmihBotdfmolHppmhnsmmjdb rmvdmwoltcmidsedsshn
thjmblroetcmXuoPhrrhbto,XudYhehftdobwdtcrmnhtmifhusmsdbFhsm
87-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
27/167
9
Bovmekmr4,;774whsiunysmrvmiupobtcmbVmfrmthryoltcmYrmhsury
wdtchutcordtyolprdvhtmhffoubtshttcmtrmhsuryfrmhtmikyopmrhtdobol
smfurdtdzdb`tcmimktorkdrtcfmrtdldfhtmhbikobidssumikytcmVofdhn
VmfurdtyHiedbdstrhtdob.
6. YchtdbFcdmlAui`m[oyfmF.Nhekmrtcsimfdsdobhbiorimr,scowbwdtcMxcdkdt6,cmdepropmrnyhssuemstchtpmtdtdobmr,MS[MNHYO[
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1Vtrubjdbmssmbhturhnpmrsob,dsemrmnytcmWrdvhtm].V.
FdtdzmbdbimbturmV][MYToltcmHrtdldfdhnWukndf].V.Fdtdzmb
FC[DVYOWCM[MH[NVY[]BJkmbmldfdhry,nm`hnnyowbmikytcmVthtmol
BmwTorjsdbfmAhbuhry;9,8490:hbitcdshppmhnthjmbfchnnmb`msCds
depropmrhssueptdob.
9. YchtboHrtdldfdhnWukndf].V.FdtdzmbhshquhsdforporhtmmbtdtyehyldnmhXuoPhrrhbtohftdobhsdbtmbimikmlormorhltmr8466hbiorehy
hppmhrdbdtorhXudYhehftdobhssufcnm`hnldftdobwdtcouthbhttorbmy
iomsbothppnytoHlldrehbthstcmmxfmptdobtotcmrunm.
=. YchtobImfmekmr89,;78;tcmFdrfudtFourtdssumitcmorimrdbtchtIdstrdftchiimbdmilmmrmndmltchtWmtdtdobmrhppnylorlmmrmndmlhtfdrfudt
(smmMxcdkdt 9):hbitcmblonnowdb`tcmFdrfudtrmvdmwolsufchpmtdtdoblorlmmrmndmlhtFdrfudt,obHprdn;,;786,Fdrfudthnsoimbdmisufcrmndml,`dvdb`h
67ihyimhindbmlorphyembtoltcmlmm$9==(smmMxcdkdt =),hbiMS
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
28/167
=
[MNHYO[Hppmnnhbtwdtcoutsulldfdmbtpmrsobhnlubissou`ctlubislroe
otcmrs.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
29/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
30/167
0
oltcmbhturhnpmrsobskdrtc.Ycmbhemoltcdshrtdldfdhn
pmrsob/[oehbpmrsobhdsdbhnnfhpdthnnmttmrshbitmremiFhpdtdsIdedbutdo Ehxdeh.Ycdshnn-fhpsbhemdshboe im `umrrm(bhemolwhr)lortcm[oehbpmrsobh/Wukndf].V.fdtdzmbtokm
trmhtmihshbmbmeyolwhrkymvmryMemr`mbfyPhrWowmrs
fourt.Lurtcmr,tcmbhemth`olmvmryHemrdfhbsonidmrdsdbhnn
fhpdthnnmttmrs,hnsodbidfhtdb`cdsbhemolwhr.Ycus,tcmhnn-fhps
bhemdsusmilorkotcsonidmrshbimbmedmsfhpturmidbwhr
pukndfhnnyrmsdidb`dbtcmsthtmsimmemiemrmfobqumrmi
tmrrdtordmskytcmimlhftoEdndthry@ovmrbembtdbPhscdb`tob,
I.F.
f. Hnndbfoemoltcmhrtdldfdhnpmrsob/Wukndf].V.fdtdzmb,lorwcdfctcmdbidvdiuhn89tcHembiembtWrdvhtm].V.Fdtdzmbdssukoridbhtm
urmty,ehykmdbfoem/mxfdsm/prdvdnm`mthxmi.Hnndbfoemoltcmhrtdldfdhnpmrsobimrdvmilroehbysourfmwchtsomvmrehykmwhr
thxmishvmtcosmsourfmsmxmeptmikytcmFob`rmssor
ehbihtordnymxfmptmi---tcmFcurfchbidtsdbtm`rhtmi
huxdndhrdms.
88. Ychths`mrehbmcdstordfhnauidfdhnbotdfmcmrmdbdshssofdhtmiwdtcHLLDHBYssthtusDrmlmrtotcmtdemndbmhbimvmbtsdbhprmsmbthtdob
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
31/167
3
mbtdtnmiVmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb FdtdzmbscdpkyMrdfAobWcmnps,ph`ms8-=
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
32/167
4
LroeBmwVthtustoFobtrhft---847
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
33/167
87
BhturhnWmrsob/89tcHembiembtWrdvhtm].V.Fdtdzmbds urmtylor89tcHembiembtWukndf].V.fdtdzmbdbFoeemrfm:
HrtdldfdhnWmrsob/[oehbWmrsobh/Wukndf].V.fdtdzmb@dvmbh
VofdhnVmfurdtyBuekmr/YhxDimbtdldfhtdobBuekmr
NossolLmimrhnFoeeobNhwWrofmsshbiLmimrhnFoeeobNhw
[d`cts---8463
BhturhnWmrsob/89tc
HembiembtFdtdzmbnosmshnnFoeeobNhw
LmimrhnFoeeobNhwhbiLmimrhnFoeeobNhw[d`ctsolBhturhn
WmrsobsWrmvdousnyWrotmftmiky].V.VuprmemFourtImfdsdobs
BOP O\M[[]NMI KyYwoBmwImfdsdobsoltcm[oosmvmntFourtBmwVthtusdbFobtrhfthtPhr---84=7Memr`mbfyPhrWowmrs
MxmfutdvmOrimr
HftdvhtmiVthtus@ovmrbshnnDbWmrsobheAurdsidftdob,KotcFrdedbhn
hbiFdvdnAurdsidftdobs,OlKotcLmimrhnhbiVthtmFourtsbowEdndthry
dbWrofmss,FourtshrmFobstdtutdobhndbLO[E:kutEdndthrydb
V]KVYHBFM,tcmsmFourtsLnydb`LmimrhnhbiVthtmEhrtdhnLnh`s,
YcrmmVdimsKorimrmiwdtc@oniLrdb`morwdtc@oniForishbi
Yhssmns
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
34/167
88
8;. YchtHLLDHBYfobtmbistchttcmhkovmlhftsfoekdbmiwdtckmnowhr`uembtlorehemrdtordouskhsdstokm`rhbtmirmndmlkytcdseotdobcmrmdb
sulldfdmbttowhrrhbttcdsfourttormfobsdimr,sthyhbiorndlttcmEHBIHYM
olHu`ust8,;786hbirmbmwtofhnmbihrtohnnowhppmhnpmrlmftdob.
86. YchtHLLDHBYfobtmbistchthbhturhnkorbFdtdzmb(BKF)fcdnichstokmkorbdbtcm]bdtmiVthtmsto"fdtdzmb"phrmbtshshehttmrolsmttnmi
nhw:hbitchteyowbcmrdth`mdbrm`hristoeyowbphrmbtshntcou`cobny
surmtdmslortcmdrWukndf]VFdtdzmbsdblhft1
d. EylhtcmrMhrnCmbryVtrubjdshbhturhnkorbFdtdzmbdb8480hsimldbmikyEdbor(smmEdborvChppmrsmtt,33]V8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
35/167
8;
wcodeed`rhtmitoBmwAmrsmylroeFhbhih,wmrmioedfdnminm`hn
rmsdimbthndmbswcmbEotcmrwhskorb.
89. YchtHLLDHBYhr`umstchtlorhfcdnitokmhbhturhnkorbFdtdzmb(s)cmbmmistokmkorbdbtcmfoubtrytophrmbtswcohrmkotcmdtcmrbhturhn
korbFdtdzmbsorfdtdzmbsoltcm]bdtmiVthtms(fdtdzmb)kybhturhndzhtdobht
kdrtcorhltmrkdrtc.
8=. HLLDHBYwhsbhturhnnykorbdbtcm`mo`rhpcdf]bdtmiVthtmsolHemrdfh,dbtcmVthtmolBmwTorj,dbtcmfdtyolBmwTorj,obAhbuhry;6,
8490:
8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
36/167
86
PdtcoutFobsdimrhtdobkmdb`B]BFW[OY]BFwdtctcmFnmrjolFourt,
NhehrFoubty,@mor`dh,obOftokmr8=,;78;:
84. HLLDHBYchsmndedbhtmihbyprmsueptdobollhfttchtHlldhbtdsWropmrtyol,orVurmtylor,shdisthtutoryWukndf]bdtmiVthtmsfdtdzmbkyldndb`hBotdfmol[msfdssdobolVd`bhturmsolVurmtyscdpB]BFW[OY]BF
wdtchpukndfolldfmoltcmFourtFnmrjdbJdb`sFoubty,tcmVthtmolBmw
Torj,dbwcdfcfoubtyHlldhbtehjmscdscoem,prdvhtmnyrmsdidb`obtcmnhbi
htFoeeobNhwhbibotpukndfhnnyrmsdidb`hfforidb tosthtutm:
;7. HLLDHBY,kyvdrtumolcdsfobstdtutdobhnnyprotmftmisthtusolkmdb`hWrdvhtm]bdtmiVthtmsFdtdzmb,dshslormd`btotcmprmsmbtimlhftoMemr`mbfyPhrWowmrsaurdsidftdoboltcm]bdtmiVthtms,tcmloremrimaurm
FoeeobNhwaurdsidftdoboltcm]bdtmiVthtms(hspmrVmftdob8oltcm89tc
Hembiembt)chvdb kmmbhntmrmihbi/oreoidldmidbtotcmprmsmbtimlhfto
FdvdnNhwaurdsidftdoboltcm]bdtmiVthtmskyhfob rmssdobhnny-hembimi,
PorniPhrDsthtutmhbihsuksmqumbtprmsdimbtdhnprofnhehtdob,kotc
mvmbtstrhbspdrdb`obEhrfc4,8466:YCM[MLO[M1
;8. HLLDHBYdsbothsthtutorypukndf]bdtmiVthtmsfdtdzmb:;;. HLLDHBYdsbothsthtutorypukndfrmsdimbtoltcm]bdtmiVthtms:;6. HLLDHBYdsbothsthtutory]bdtmiVthtmspmrsob1;9. HLLDHBYdsbothsthtutorybob-fdtdzmbbhtdobhn:
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
37/167
89
;=. HLLDHBYdsbothsthtutorypukndffdtdzmboltcmVthtmolBmwTorj:
;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
38/167
8=
mvdimbfmikyHlldhbts,sd`bmihbismhnmiFmrtdldfhtmolLormd`bVthtusol
KmbmldfdhnOwbmrlor]bdtmiVthtmsYhxPdtcconidb`(P-3KMB):
69. HLLDHBYtcmrmlormlurtcmrimfnhrmsthxphymrFC[DVYOWCM[MH[NVY[]BJchsbmvmrrmfmdvmihbykmbmldfdhndbfoemimrdvmilroe
wh`ms,tdps,shnhrdms,mtf.:chsbmvmrchihphstorprmsmbtthxndhkdndtyhbi
dstcmrmlormmxmeptlroewdtcconidb`kyhbymepnoymr,pukndforprdvhtm,
tchtwounikmmvdimbfmikyHlldhbtssd`bmihbismhnmiMepnoymms
Pdtcconidb`HnnowhbfmFmrtdldfhtm(P-9(;786).
6=. Ychtmvmry Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs Aui`m,hbiAui`mNhekmrtcdsbomxfmptdob,ehjms hb hssueptdob ol lhft ky thjdb` lor `rhbtmi tcht mvmrydbidvdiuhn imlmbihbt dbcdsMemr`mbfyPhrWowmrsFourt(tcmImLhftoedndthry`ovmrbembtkmdb`Vovmrmd`bhbibottcmWmopnm)dssdednhrny
sdtuhtmihsdsmvmryotcmrdbidvdiuhnimlmbihbt.Ycdshssueptdobollhftds
khsmiupobhsdtuhtdobfobtrdvmikytcmnhwtchtmbhknmstcmFourtto
deposmhEhrtdhnIumWrofmssupobtcmimlmbihbttchtcmehykmkrou`ct
dbtotcmFourtsDbWmrsobheaurdsidftdobtchttrdhnehyprofmmi.
6
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
39/167
8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
40/167
80
hfourttoidsposmolhehttmr,tcou`cdtbmmibotkmfrmhtmidepropmrny:..
.KnhfjsNhwIdftdobhry,LdltcMidtdob,p.379.
64. Hbikhsmiupobwchtdstcmnm`hnimldbdtdobolhbhssueptdobHssueptdob.Ycmhftolthjdb`lor`rhbtmi.KnhfjsNhwIdftdobhry,Ldltc
Midtdob,p.886.khsmiupobEr.Okhehsthxldndb`dteustkmthjmblor
`rhbtmitchtcmdstcmV][MYToltcmsthtutoryWukndffdtdzmbKH[HFJ
C]VVMDBOKHEHDD,botwdtcsthbidb`tcmusmoltcmotcmrthxbuekmrhbi
botwdtcsthbidb`tcmprdorusmoltcmbhemVOMKH[JHC,tchtDpmrsobhnny
idsfovmrmihscdshioptmibhemfoeeobnyjbowbhsKH[[T
VOMYO[O,wcohshlormd bbhtdobhnolDbiobmsdhmbtmrmitcdsfoubtrydb
8408tondvmwdtccds@rhbieotcmr.
97. HshehttmrolcdstordfhnrmforidbtcmusmoltcmtmrebhturhnkorbfdtdzmbhppndmslortcmXuoPhrrhbtohbiXudYhefchnnmb`mdbtchttcm
rmpu`bhbtlmuihnpmrpmtuhnhnnm`dhbfmioftrdbmprmvdousnydeposmikytcm
eobhrfcyhbiKrdtdscFoeeobNhwkmlorm800
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
41/167
83
httorbmy`mbmrhn,db;77=usmicdsprmstd`mhbiposdtdobhttcmHemrdfhb
Cmrdth`mLoubihtdob(soemshykmfhusmcmhb`udscmshkoutcdsowb
scmbhbd`hbs`obmhrrhyhsHttorbmy@mbmrhnwdtctcm843
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
42/167
84
nmhvmtcmlmuihnpmrpmtuhnhnnm`dhbfmtotcmEobhrfcyolKrdtdscFoeeob
NhwhbihssufctcmBmwTorj[mpukndfobHprdn;7,8000,lortcmWmopnm
oltcmBmwTorj[mpukndfrmvojmipmrpmtuhnhnnm`dhbfmusmolKrdtdsc
FoeeobNhwhsrmpu`bhbtdbusmoltcmBmwTorjFobstdtutdobhtHrtdfnm
6=tcht1
SSS\.Hbitcdsfobvmbtdobiotclurtcmr,dbtcmbhemhbikytcmhutcordtyoltcm`ooipmopnmoltcdsVthtm,orihdb,imtmredbm,hbiimfnhrmtchtsufcphrtsoltcmfoeeobnhwolMb`nhbi,hbioltcmsthtutmnhwolMb nhbihbi@rmhtKrdthdb,hbioltcmhftsoltcm
nm`dsnhturmoltcmfonobyolBmwTorj,hsto`mtcmridiloretcmnhwoltcmshdifonobyobtcm84tcihyolHprdn,dbtcmymhrolourNoriobmtcoushbismvmbcubirmihbismvmbty-ldvm,schnnkmhbifobtdbumtcmnhwoltcdsVthtm,sukamfttosufchntmrhtdobshbiprovdsdobshstcmnm`dsnhturmoltcdsVthtmschnn,lroetdemtotdem,ehjmfobfmrbdb`tcmshem.Ychtsufcoltcmshdihfts,hshrmtmeporhry,schnnmxpdrmhttcmtdemsndedtmilortcmdriurhtdob,rmspmftdvmny.Ycht hnn sufc phrts ol tcmshdi foeeob nhw,hbihnnsufcoltcmshdisthtutmshbihftshlormshdi,orphrtstcmrmol,hsehykmfobstrumitomsthkndscorehdbthdbhbyphrtdfunhrimboedbhtdobolFcrdstdhbsortcmdredbdstmrs,
orfobfmrb tcm hnnm`dhbfm cmrmtolorm ydmnimi to, hbi tcm suprmehfy,sovmrmd`bty, `ovmrbembt, or prmro`htdvms fnhdemi or mxmrfdsmi ky,tcm Jdb` ol @rmht Krdthdb hbi cds prmimfmssors, ovmr tcm fonoby olBmw Torj hbi dts dbchkdthbts, or hrm rmpu`bhbt to tcds fobstdtutdob, km,hbi tcmy cmrmky hrm, hkro`htmi hbi rmamftmi.Hbitcdsfobvmbtdobiotclurtcmrorihdb,tchttcmrmsonvmsorrmsonutdobsoltcmfob`rmssmsoltcmfonobyolBmwTorj,hbioltcmfobvmbtdoboltcmVthtmolBmwTorj,bowdblorfm,hbibotrmpu`bhbttotcm`ovmrbembtmsthkndscmikytcdsfobstdtutdob,schnnkmfobsdimrmihsehjdb`phrtoltcmnhwsoltcdsVthtm:sukamft,bmvmrtcmnmss,tosufchntmrhtdobshbiprovdsdobshstcmnm`dsnhturmoltcdsVthtmehy,lroetdemtotdem,ehjmfobfmrbdb`tcmshem.(Mepchsds hiimi kyHLLDHBY)
96. Dblhft,HLLDHBYfobtmbiskhsmiupobtcmpukndfcdstordfhnrmforitchttormpnhfmlmuihndsehbitcmEobhrfcsfnhdeol[d cttoquhndldmiusm
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
43/167
;7
olpropmrtyhbiowbmrscdp(hia.]V]L[]FY)hscdssukamftskorbaussond
pmrsmwdtcoutrm`hritotcmsthtusoltcmphrmbts,tcmLoubimrshbi
Lrhemrsnoojmitohbfdmbt[oehbcdstorytoubimrsthbitcmnhwolbhturmto
nmhrbcowkmsttofobstdtutmhrmpukndfhbloreol`ovmrbembthbitormpnhfm
pmrpmtuhnhnnm`dhbfmwdtctcmcuehbbhturhnnhwioftrdbmolkotc@rmmj(;)
hbi[oehb(6)ord`dboltcmtmreolhrtbhturhn-korbFdtdzmbdbcmrdthbfmol
;Hrdstotnmhnso`hvmushimldbdtdobolhbhturhnkorbFdtdzmb.DbWondtdfs,KoojYcrmm,WhrtDD,Hrdstotnm,wrdtdb`db6=7K.F.M.,hstrhbsnhtmikyKmbahedbAowmtt,`hvmuscdsimldbdtdobolfdtdzmbscdp1WhrtDD1Kutdbprhftdfmhfdtdzmbdsimldbmitokmobmolwcoekotctcmphrmbtshrmfdtdzmbs:otcmrsdbsdstob`odb`lurtcmrkhfj:shytotwoortcrmmoreormhbfmstors.Ycdsdshscorthbiprhftdfhnimldbdtdobkuttcmrmhrmsoemwcorhdsmtcmlurtcmrqumstdob1Cowtcdstcdriorlourtchbfmstorfhemtokmhfdtdzmb?@or`dhsolNmobtdbd,phrtnykmfhusmcmwhsdbhidlldfunty,phrtnydbdroby,shdi-'Eorthrshrmwchtdsehimkytcmeorthr-ehjmrs,hbitcmfdtdzmbsolNhrdsshhrmtcosmwcohrmehimkytcmeh`dstrhtms:lordtdstcmdrtrhimtoehjmNhrdsshmhbs.'Tmttcmqumstdobdsrmhnnysdepnm,lor,dlhfforidb`totcmimldbdtdobaust`dvmbtcmyschrmidbtcm`ovmrbembt,tcmywmrmfdtdzmbs.Ycdsdshkmttmrimldbdtdobtchbtcmotcmr.Lortcmworis,'korbolhlhtcmroreotcmrwcodshfdtdzmb,'
fhbbotpossdknyhppnytotcmldrstdbchkdthbtsorloubimrsolhsthtm.Ycmrmdsh`rmhtmridlldfuntydbtcmfhsmoltcosmwcochvmkmmbehimfdtdzmbshltmrhrmvonutdob,hskyFnmdstcmbmshtHtcmbshltmrtcmmxpunsdoboltcmtyrhbts,lorcmmbronnmidbtrdkmsehbyemtdfs,kotcstrhb`mrshbisnhvms.Ycmiouktdbtcmsmfhsmsds,botwcods,kutwcmtcmrcmwcodsou`cttokmhfdtdzmb:hbitcmrmwdnnstdnnkmhlurtcmrdb`tcmsthtm,wcmtcmrhfmrthdbhftdsordsbothbhftoltcmsthtm:lorwchtou`ctbottokmdswchtdslhnsm.Bow,tcmrmhrmsoemwcoconiolldfm,hbiymtou`ctbottoconiolldfm,wcoewmimsfrdkmhsrundb`,kutrundb`ubaustny.Hbitcmfdtdzmbwhsimldbmikytcmlhftolcdsconidb`soemjdbiolrunmorolldfm-cmwcoconishauidfdhnornm`dsnhtdvmolldfmlunldnnsourimldbdtdobolhfdtdzmb.Dtdsmvdimbt,tcmrmlorm,tchttcmfdtdzmbshkoutwcoetcmiouktchshrdsmbeustkmfhnnmifdtdzmbs.cttp1//fnhssdfs.edt.miu/Hrdstotnm/pondtdfs.cten.
6[oehbnhwprovdimi1NmxEMBVDH,Ychthfcdniscounikmcmnihshlormd`bmr,dlmdtcmroltcmphrmbtswhsso.Kutdlkotcphrmbtswmrm[oehbshbiehrrdmi,fcdnirmbhnwhysokthdbmitcmrhbjoltcmlhtcmr,(phtrmesmquubturndkmrd,Ndv.dv.9.)hbidlubehrrdmi,oltcmeotcmr,]dpdhb.HnmxhbimrHihe,[oehbhbtdqudtdms1or,Hbhffoubtoltcmehbbmrshbifustoesoltcm[oehbs;87(
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
44/167
;8
hnnm`dhbfmlroecdsphrmbtshbiortchtoltcmlhtcmr:hbitchtdtdsrmpu`bhbt
lortcdshppmhnphbmntosu``msttcmrmwmrmhFourtcmrmdbBmwTorjto
immetchttcmprdorpmrpmtuhnhnnm`dhbfmhsobfmmxdstmiubimrtcmJdb`
kmlormtcm[mvonutdobbowwdtctcm89tcHembiembttotcm].V.Fobstdtutdob
soemcowhembistcmH;V8F=bhturhn-korbFdtdzmbfnhusmhbifoblnhtms
tcmtmrepmrsobkorbobsodnhsdlh].V.Fdtdzmbwdtcoutrm`hritotcmsthtus
oltcmphrmbts,wdtcsukamfttotcmaurdsidftdobhsdldtwmrmbmminmss
rmpmtdtdobhbitcmrmkyhswhsedsthjmbnyiobmkytcmlhbfdlunBmwTorj
AustdfmdbtcmfhsmNybfcv.Fnhrjm,8Vhbil.Fc.=36ol8399wcoimfdimi
tchtfhsmhsdlHemrdfhbFoeeobNhwchikmmbrmpnhfmiwdtctchtol
KrdtdscFoeeobNhwwhsdblhftrmkujmikytcmBmwTorjVthtmNm dsnhturm
tcmrmhltmrhbitchttcmVthtmAuidfdhrytcrou`ctcmdrFourtolHppmhnschs
cdstordfhnnypropmrnyimldbmitcmrmnhtdobscdpoltcmfcdnirmbollsprdb totcm
fdtdzmbscdpsthtusoltcmphrmbtstchtmxdstmiubimrHemrdfhbFoeeobNhw
kmlormtcmFhknmHftol84;;dbrm`hristobhturhnkorbFdtdzmbhsloubidb
Nuinhev.Nuinhe;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
45/167
;;
99. Khsmiupobdblorehtdobhbikmndml,tcm obny fobstdtutdobhn ohtc tokm loubi ds tcm ohtc tcm WOY]V thjms,wcdfcdsworilorworitcmshemhstcmrmqudrmitmxtdbtcmFobstdtutdob.WOY]Viomsbotthjmtcmohtcololldfm
db]VFYdtnm=.Hsnob`hstcmrmdsobmolldfmrwdtchbohtcrmqudrmikytcmFobstdtutdob(bothbohtcololldfmrmqudrmikytcmFob`rmss),tcmpmopnmstdnnchvm h trustmm lor tcm trust ob wcdfc tcm im aurm pmopnm hrm tcm
kmbmldfdhrdms. Ycht kmbmldfdhn dbtmrmst ds wcht `dvms pmopnm tcm rd ct to
hffmpt lor vhnum dbstruembts tcht hrm dssumi lor vhnum. Ycmy chvm hb
hbtmfmimbtfnhdelroehprmmxdstdb`fobtrhft.Ycmdrfnhdedshrd`cttombaoy
lrmmioewdtcndkmrty.Dtdskhsmiobfobstdtutdobhn`uhrhbtmms.Vdbfm8466,
tcmpmopnmhnsochvmhrd`cttohidstrdkutdoblroehbotcmrtrustfrmhtmiky
WrmsdimbtLrhbjndbI.[oosmvmnt.Vdbfm8466,hnn propmrtydscmnikymhfc
VthtmoltcmsmvmrhnVthtmslortcmfrmidtorsoltcmkhbjruptfyoltcm]VH.
Ychtemhbs tcmVthtmchstcm nm`hntdtnmtohnnsuksthbfm dbtcmVthtmskut
tcmpmopnmchvmmqudthknmtdtnmtcrou`ctcmdrkmbmldfdhndbtmrmstdbtchttrust
hs nob hs mhfc pmrsob bo nob`mr ds tcmsurmty ol tcmimktor strhwehb.
Yhjdb`fobtronoltcm`onidb8466wounichvmkmmbubfobstdtutdobhndltcm
bmw trust chi bot kmmb frmhtmi. YcmWrmsdimbt's ohtc ds hb ollmr to tcm
pmopnmdbtcmsmvmrhnVthtms.Dtdspruimbtlorpmopnmtohffmptcdsohtc,DL
tcmpmrsobdsmnd`dknmlorWOY]Vhsdtdsbothbohtctchtdsdssumilorvhnum
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
46/167
;6
ehim db `ooi lhdtc -K]Y dl dbmnd`dknm lor WOY]V tcm ohtc ds ollmrmi lorvhnum db khi lhdtc.Ycmprdbfdpnmsolollmrhbihffmpthbfmhppnytotcdsvmryfrdtdfhnprmedsm. Dl tcm pmopnm chvmbot hffmptmitchtohtc, cowfhb tcmy
mxpmfttcmehbwcoehimdttokmworjdb`lortcmdrkmbmldt?(mepchsdsky
HLLDHBY)
9=. Khsmi upob dblorehtdob hbikmndml, tcmrmhrm boHrtdfnm\Dohtcstchtfhbkmloubilorhbyemekmrsoltcmnm`dsnhturms(sthtmorlmimrhn),or
mxmfutdvmhbiauidfdhnolldfmrsoltcm]bdtmiVthtmsoroltcmsmvmrhnsthtms.
Ycmyhnnchvm]bdtmiVthtmsFoimYdtnm=ohtcs.YcmWOY]Vfhbbotthjm
tcmYdtnm=ohtcololldfm.Cmhnrmhiychshbotcmrohtctotcmpmopnm.Cmhbi
otcmrshrmimmemitokmquhndldmi'YoconihbimbaoyhbyOlldfmolcobor,
YrustorWroldtubimrtcm]bdtmiVthtms".Botdfmtchtobnydbidvdiuhnswcohrm
"mnmftmiorhppodbtmitohbolldfmolcobororproldtdbtcmfdvdnsmrvdfmor
ubdloremismrvdfms",hrmrmqudrmitochvmtcmYdtnm=ohtc.Ycmyiobotconi
olldfmsoltrust.YcmWrmsdimbtioms.Obnyemekmrsoltcmnm`dsnhturmsoltcm
Vthtmshbitcm]bdtmiVthtms,hbimxmfutdvmhbiauidfdhnolldfmrs,wcohrm
koubikytcmHrtdfnm\Dohtc,fhbconiolldfmsoltrust.Ycosmwcothjmtcm
Ydtnm=ohtc ol olldfm fhbconi olldfmsol cobor or proldt ubimr tcm]bdtmi
Vthtms.Hbohtcdsidllmrmbttchbhbohtcololldfm.
9
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
47/167
;9
tcm nm dsnhturmsormxmfutdvmhbi auidfdhn olldfmrsoltcm]bdtmiVthtmschs
tcmohtcrmqudrmikyHrtdfnm\DoltcmFobstdtutdob,tcmobnywhytcmywouni
chvmhiutytoyoudstcrou`ctcmohtcoltcmWOY]V,tcmmxmfutdvmtrustmm
oltcmtrustfrmhtmiky tcmFobstdtutdobhbitcm trustfrmhtmikyWrmsdimbt
[oosmvmnt. Cds posdtdob hs Wrmsdimbt (Hrtdfnm ; Vmftdob 8) foems db tcm
FobstdtutdobkmlormcdsposdtdobhsFoeehbimrdbFcdml(Hrtdfnm;Vmftdob
;).CdsohtcdsrmqudrmidbVmftdob8,botVmftdob;.
90. YchtkhsmiupobsurmtyKhrhfjCussmdbOkhehDDdbmssm,iodb`kusdbmss hs imktor or`hbdzhtdob KH[HFJC]VVMDBOKHEH DD, ky cds
owbpukndfhiedssdobh`hdbstdbtmrmsthshbmxfmptdobtotcmcmhrshyrunmdb
cds hutokdo`rhpcdms hbi fhephd b sthtmembts tcht cds nm`hn lhtcmr ds h
Krdtdscsukamft,fobldremikycdsollmrolpurportmiFmrtdldfhtmolNdvmkdrtc
db ;773 hbi h`hdb db ;78; (botwdtcsthbidb` tcm hutcmbtdfdty): hbitcmrmhltmr, ds fobldremi ky tcm Lormd`b Vtuimbt DBV rmforis ol cds nm`hn
lhtcmr hbi tcm Ehrfc ;7, 84
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
48/167
;=
93. Hssufc,WmtdtdobmrobAhbuhry;6,;774iunyldrmiOKHEHwcmbcmollmrmicdsfobtrhfttoH`mbtobAhbuhry;7,;774,Er.OKHEHsmvmry
hftdsvodidbhkdbdtdo:hbibotwdtcsthbidb`hnnOKHEHVhftskmdb`vodihk
dbdtdoh`hdbusurpstcmolldfmolWOY]VtoWmtdtdobmrH`mbtsimtrdembthbi
dbaury dshftdb wdtcoutHLLDHBYs fobsmbths tcmMxmfutdvm Yrustmmhbi
eustkmrmeovmihshehttmrolsmnldbtmrmsthstcmsonmkmbmldfdhryoltcm
sm`rm`htmitrustlorEr.OKHEHwdtcoutkmdb`BKFdsbottrustwortcytokm
tcmMxmfutdvmYrustmmchsfoblndftoldbtmrmstwdtctcmfrmidtorshbiimktors.
94. D chvm rmhi tcm hkovm hbi D jbow dts fobtmbts: tcm lhfts sthtmicmrmdbhrmtrumtoeyowbpmrsobhnjbownmi`m,mxfmpthstotcmehttmrs
tcmrmdb sthtmi to km hnnm`mi ob dblorehtdob hbi kmndml, hbi hs to tcosm
ehttmrsDkmndmvmdttokmtrum.Ycm`roubisoleykmndmlshstohnnehttmrs
botsthtmiupobdblorehtdobhbikmndmlhrmhslonnows16riphrtdms,koojshbi
rmforis, hbi pmrsobhn jbownmi`m, mxfmpt hs to tcosm sthtmi upob
dblorehtdobhbi kmndml,wcdfcD kmndmvm tokm trum. Ycdshlldihvdt chs=4=4
worisdbfnuidb`tcmlootbotmshbidsdbVhbsVmrdl89podbttypm.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
49/167
PM[MLO[M, Mx-rmnhtor Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj dbmssm, ob cdsowkmchnl hs wcdstnmknowmr hbi ob kmchnl ol tcm @ovmrbembt ol tcm ]bdtmiVthtms ol Hemrdfh rmqumsts tcds ndobolhknm Fourttoorimr1
h. Ycht `rhbts rmfobsdimrhtdob to sthy hbi or ndlt tcm ehbihtm lhrtcm rmbmwhnto hnnow hppmnnhbt to pmrlmft cds hppmhn to fhnmbihrwdtc botdfm to tcm phrtdms db dbtmrmst
k Ycht nmtstcm mxpmidtmiXuo Phrrhbto dbqumstkm iobm ky h cot
f. Ycht `rhbts S [MNHYO[ Wrdvhtm ]V Fdtdzmb hs h sonm smfurmikmbmldfdhry `mbt ol Kusdbmss Yrust FC[DVYOWCM[ MH[NVt[]B fdvdndhbprofmss pro sm i r m p e m i or cmhbitcm ]btdmi Vthtms db tcm Xud Yhe hbi Xuo Phebto ehttmr
k bi or i dmrmbthbi otcmr rmndml tcht tcm Fourt immesbmfmsshry dbfnuidb`or n hr`uembt hbi mxphbimi krdml.
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj db mssm H`mbtV e ~ k m l o r m mYcds ihy ol Hu`ust ;786
,-MNN VdEJCH\BHtey WuEdVthk o mhr TwjBo. 8Vd- n . -. _ _ .N. ^ 2-
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
50/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
51/167
FcrdstopcmrMhrn Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mxrmt.,Hppmnnhbt
Khrhsj Cussmdb Okheh hnso jbowb hsKhrry Vomtoro, mt hn.Hppmnnmms
Vmptmekmr Ymre ;78;Ldnmi Ob1 Ehy ;6 ;786 ~ d 9 6 e 6 8
O [ I M [Ky orimr ldnmi Hprdn ; ;786, hppmnnhbt whs idrmftmi to phy tcm lunn hppmnnhtm ldndb`hbi iofjmtdb` lmms ol 9== to tcm idstsd~t ourtwdtcdb tcdrty ihys ol tcm ihtm ol tcds orimror tcds hppmhn wdnn km idsedssmi, hbi dt hppmhrdb` tcht hppmnnhbt chs ot phdi tcm lmmsium db tcds fhsmlnpob fobsdimrhtdob o tcm lorm`odb` dt dsO[IM[MI tcht tcds fhsm km idsedssmi lor nhfj ol prosmfutdob. mm I.F.Fdr.[unm 63.Ycm Fnmrj ds idrmftmi to dssum tcm ehbihtm db tcds fhsm ky Auny 3, ;786.
. - 6 . . --- LO[ e e . .Ehrj A. Nhb`mr Fnmrj
KT1 stNhurh E. FcdpnmyImputy Fnmrj
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
52/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
53/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
54/167
Vmhrfc Ehdn Vmhrfc Pmk fmstrubfj @o Vd`b Out Coem
Lroe1
Yo1
Ff1
@mbmrhn Iofjmt
]bdtmi Vthtms Fourt ol Hppmhns lor Idstrdft ol Fonuekdh Fdrfudt
Fourt ol Hppmhns Iofjmt #1 8;-=;34 Iofjmtmi174/86/;78;
Ymremi1 7=/;6/;786Bhturm ol Vudt1 ;347 Otcmr Vthtutory Hftdobs
Fcrdstopcmr Vtrubj v. Khrhfj Okheh, mt hn
Hppmhn Lroe1]bdtmi Vthtms Idstrdft Fourt lor tcm Idstrdft ol Fonuekdh
Lmm Vthtus1Lmm Whdi
Fhsm Yypm Dbloreht dob1
8)Fdvdn ]V
;)]bdtmi Vthtms
6)
Ord`dbhtdb` Fourt Dblorehtdob1
Idstrdft1 7747-8 1 8187fv7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
55/167
]bdtmi Vthtms Imphrtembt ol tcm Yrmhsury, (IOY)
Imlmbihbt - Hppmnnmm
[. Frhd` Nhwrmbfm
ZBYF @vt Htty ]VHO/H]VHU
(smm hkovm)
Aocb hbi Ahb Ioms
Imlmbihbt - Hppmnnmm
STQ Mbtdtdms Imlmbihbt - Hppmnnmm
Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj, ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.,
Wnhdbtdll - Hppmnnhbt
v.
Khrhfj Cussmdb Okheh, hnso jbowb hs Khrry Vomtoro: Okheh lor Hemrdfh: Okheh \dftory Lubi: Lmimrhn Mnmftdob Foeedssdob, (LMF): ]bdtmi
Vthtms Imphrtembt ol Coemnhbi Vmfurdty, (ICV): ]bdtmi Vthtms Imphrtembt ol tcm Yrmhsury, (IOY): Aocb hbi Ahb Ioms: STQ Mbtdtdms,
Imlmbihbts - Hppmnnmms
74/86/;78; ]V FD\DN FHVM iofjmtmi. Z8;-=;34U
74/86/;78;
8; p`, 8.;9 EK
BOYDFM OL HWWMHN ldnmi Z8649;=4U ky Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj smmjdb` rmvdmw ol h imfdsdob ky tcm ].V. Idstrdft Fourt
db 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
56/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt6
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
57/167
]BDYMI VYHYM V IDVY[DFY FO][YLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH
Db tcm Xuo P hrrhbto hbi Xud Yhe ehttmr ol tcm
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
58/167
Vmrvdfm Ndst1
Mrdf Conimr, ].V. Httorbmy @mbmrhn
Ycm ]V Imphrtembt ol Austdfm
4=7 Wmbbsynvhbdh Hvm., B.P.
Phscdb`tob, IF ;7=67
Khrhfj Cussmdb Okheh DD db mssmf/o Ycm Pcdtm Cousm
8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
59/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
60/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
61/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
62/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
63/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
64/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
65/167
Fhsm 8187-fv-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
66/167
]BDYMI VYHYMV IDVY[DFY FO][YLO[ YCM IDVY[DFY OL FON]EKDH
MS [M Vtrubj v Okheh mt hn. IFI FH VM 87-fv-793< ([FN)FM[YDLDFHYM OL VM[\DFM
Ob Hu` ust ;4, ;78;, D, Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj, ubimr pmbhnty ol pmraury pursuhbt to ;3 ]VF 809
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
67/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt9
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
68/167
Vmptmekmr Ymre ;78;8 87-F\-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
69/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt=
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
70/167
ACbddmkKth lmm burd ol &ppmbnmL O [ YCMIDVY[DFYO FON]EKPF D [ F ] ~
Vmptmekmr Ymre, ;78;8 78~~87793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
71/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
72/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
73/167
HLLDIH\DY OL Y[]YCBotdfm ol [msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol VurmtyscdmB]BFW[O Y]BF
Hfforidb`ny, D Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtebj, db ss hbi sud aurls kmdb` iuny sworb,imposm hbi imfnhrm ubimr pmbhnty ol pmraury tcht1D Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj, cmrmky rms dbi hbi rmvojm Bubf Wro Yubf mvmry sd`bhturmol surmtyscdp, pukndf bi prdvhtm, mvmr provdimi ky Hlldhbt ob kmchnl ol tcm Bmw Torjkusdbmss trusuhrtdldfdhn pmrsoisthtutory Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb FLL[DVYOWCM[ MH[NVY[]BJ , frmhtmi ob Ahbuhry ;9 8490:Ycds HLLDIH\DY OL Y [ P C 1 Botdfm ol [msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol Vurmtyscdp-BPBF W[O Y]BF mxtmbis to mvmry pukndf `ovmrbembt fobtrhft-lmimrhD, sthtm, foubtyhbi fdty. Ycds rmsfdssdob hbi rmvofhtdob ol pukndf sd`bhturm ol surmtyscdp dbfnuims, kut dsbot ndedtmi to, tcm dbdtdhn hppndfhtdob lor h sofdhn smfurdty burbkmr/thxphyw dimbtdldfhtdobbuekmr vmry dbidvdiuhn hbinor forpoetm thx r m t e mvmr ldnmi, km dt lmimrhn, sthtm foubtyhbi/or fdty: tcm dbdtdhn hppndfhtdob lor smnmftdvm smrvdfm db tcm HremiLorfms ol tcm ]bdtmiVthtms: mvmry hppndfhtdob or hb dbidvdiuhn irdvmr ndfmbsm. lmimrhn hbi/or sthtm, hs wmnn hsmvmry irdvmr ndfmbsm, lmimrhn hbi/or sthtm:mvmrq. hpptdfhtdob lor h ]bdtmi Vthtms phssporths wm8 hs mvmry dssumi ]bdtmi Vthtms phssport1 mvmry hppndfhtdob lor votmr rm`dstrhtdob hswmnn hs mvmry votmr rm dstrhtdob fhri: hbi mvmry otcmr pukndf `ovmrbembt fobtrhft, jbowbhbi ubjbowb mvdimbfdb` h sd`bhturm ol surmtyscdp:Ycds HLLDIH\DY OL Y[]YC1 Botdfm ol [msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol Vur mty scd vB]BF W[O Y]BF mxtmbis to mvmry prdvhtm kusdbmss fobtrhft. Ycds rmsfdssdob hbirmvofhtdob ol prdvhtm sd`bhturms ol surmtyscdp dbfnuims, kut ds bot ndedtmi to, mvmryhppndfhtdob lor h khbj hffoubt, dbidvdiuhn hbi kusdbmss: mvmry hppndfhtdob lor hby lore oldbsurhbfm, dbfnuidb` ndlm dbsurhbfm, eotor vmcdfnm dbsurhbfm, kusdbmss dbsurhbfm, hbicoem dbsurhbfm: hbi mvmry otcmr hppndfhtdob dbvonvmi db hby prdvhtm kusdbmss mbimhvorhbinor prdvhtm dbvmstembt mvdimbfdb` sd`bhturm ol surmtyscdp:Ycds HLL[: H\8Y OL Y[]YC1 Botdfm ol [msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol Vurmtyscdp-B]B W[O Y]BF ds rmtrohftdvm to tcm ihtm ol Ahbuhry ;9, 8490, tcm ihtm ol tcm pukndfldndb` hbi rm`dstrhtdobol hlldhbt s Fmrtdldfhtm ol Ndvm Kdrtc db tcm Vthtm ol Bmw Torj,Foubty olBmw Torjwdtcdb tcm fdty ol Bmw Torj.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
74/167
YcdsHLLnIH\DY OL Y[]YC1 Botdfm ol [msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol Vurmtyscdp--B]BF W[OY]B Dmb` wdtc h trum fopy ol tcm FoeemrfdhDVmfurdtyH`rmmembtheremi Hprdn DV ;7 6 htthfcmi) ob wcdfc dt ds khsmi, wdnn km jmpt ky tcm Jdb`sFoubty Fnmrj ob ldnm hs phrt ol tcm Fhsm 8493-;78; ht tcm pukndf olldfmolJdb`s FoubtyVuprmem Fourt 6
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
75/167
o f ( L l d NFoeemrfdhn Vmfurdtv H`rmmembt
WhrtdmsYcm phrtdms to tcds Foee mrfdhn Vmfurdty H`rmmefbr, dbtmbidb` to km nm`hnny koubi ky hdn tcmtmres hbi fobidtdobs sthtmi kmnow, hrm wdtcdb tcm sthbihris hbi bores ol tcm DbtmrbhtdobhnFoeemrfdhn Foif hbi hppndms to tcm phrtdms hs lonnows18. Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj smfurmi phrty/frmidtor ol FC[DVYOWCM[MH[N
VY[]BJ), m aur Wrdvhtm Fdtdzmb ol tcm]bdtmi thtms ol Hemrdfh Wrdrhtmny[msdidb` ht cds oeeob Nhw ioedfdnm nofhtmi ht =46 \hbimrcdnt Hvmbum ol Kroojnybwdtcdb t c f fdty ol Bmw Torj hbi tcm foubty ol Jdbps sukidvdsdob ol tcm Vthtm o mwTorj. Vmm xcdkdts ; . )
Hbi,; . FC[DVYOWCM[ M H [ N VY[]BJ ifktor to Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj), sthtutory
pnrcndf fdtdzmb ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms prdkndfny rmsdidb` ht =46 \hbifrkdnt Hvmbum WEKos;3 ol Kroojnyb BT. 8 8;63. Vmm Mxcdkdt ; .
Ymres8 Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj, smfurmi phrtynfrfidtor ol imktor FC[DVYOWCM[ MH [ N
VY[]BJ, h`rmms to usm cm bhem ol ifktor FCCDVYOW[M[ MH[N V Y [ ] B J d bhnn pukndf hbi prdvhtm fobtrhfts lhr tcm kmbmldt ol tcm sffurmi phrty/frmidtor.
; . FC[DVYOWCMC MH[N VY[]BJ. imktor to smfurmi phrty/frmidtor FcrdstopcmrMhrn1 Vtrhbj, `rmms to hppodbt smfurmi phrty/frmidtor to kf d ts H`mbt wdtc h `mbmrhnpowmr ol hhoefy to mxmfutm hnn pukndf hbi prdvhtm foeemrfdhn fobtrhfts usdb` tcmbhem ol imktor FC[MVYOWCM[MH[N VY[]BJ hs h trhbsedttdb` utdndty lor tcmkmbmldt ol tcm H`mbt/smfurmi `hrty/frmidtor b tcm usm hbi ehbh`membt ol tcm H`mbt spmrsobhn hbi rmhn propmrty. Lurtcmr, imktor FC[DVYOWC.MCM H [ N VY[]BJcmrmky fobvmys hnn rd`ct, tdtnm hbi dbtmrmst to hby hbi h^ propmrty, rmhD or pmrsobhn, cmnior rm`dstmrmi db tcm bhem ol imctor (08MD]VYOWPM[MH[N VY[]BJ, o smfurmiphrtynfrfidzor FcrdstopcmrMhrn1 Vtrubj. Ycds propfrty dbfnuims kut ds bot ndedtmi to.hnn hssmts ndhkdndtdms or hffoubts cmni b tcm imktor-sbhem or lor tcm kmbmldt ol tcmimktor w-cdfc tcm imktor or phrtdhnny owbs, or db wcdfc t c m imktor chs h smfurdtydbtmrmst, hs wmnn hs vmcdfnm rf`dstrhtdob fmrtdldfhtms, immis or fobtrhfts rm`hridb` rmhnpropmrty stofjs hbi kobis hffoubts. botms hbiaui`embts rmfmdvhknm. hnn ndlm or cm ntc
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
76/167
orbemrfdhn Vmfurdtv H`rmmembtdbsur bfm pondfdms hbi hbyprdvhtm trust hffoubt cmni y tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms Yrmhsuty orhby otcmr hffoubt cmni y hb olldfm ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms Ycds fobvmyhbfm dsB]BW[O Y]BF, dts mllmftdvm ihtm kmdb` Ahbuhry ;9 8490. tcm ihtm ol tcm ldDdb` ol hFmrtdldfhtmol Ndvm Kdrtc db tcm bhem ol FP [FVYOWCM[ M H [ N VY[]BJ cy tcmVthtm ol Bmw Torj. Vmm Mxcdkdt .
6 Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj smfurmi phrtynfrmidtor, schnn bot km pmrsobhnny ndhknm lort cm pukndf or prdvhtm imkts ol imktor FPVYOWC'M[ M H [ N V Y []BJ . sdbfmcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj ds bot surmty lor FC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N VY[]BJ hs h
ehttmr ol pukndf rmfori Vmm Mxcdkdt 8 . Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj schnn cm ndhknf lorcds owb pukndf hbi prdvhtm imkts dbfurrmi db tcm usm o l tcm bhem ol tcm imktor
FC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N VYJ]nrLJ.9 Ycds Foeemrfdhn Vmfurdp H`rmmembt schnn km`db to km b lunn lorfm hbi mllmft upob
dts ldndb` hbi jmmpdb` wdtc h pukndf olldfmol tcm Vthtm olBmw Torj, hbi spmfdldfhnnywdtbmssmi ky t c m kmnow Bothry Wukndf. D l tcds Hyrmmembt ehy bot km fobsdimrmi to kmh kdbidb` kdnhtmrhn fobtrhft ky h fowrt ol rmfori tcmb dt schnn km cmni to km h ]bdnhtmrhnFobtrhft ]bimr Vmhn emmtdb` tcf rmqudrmembts ol spmfdldf dbtmbt kmdb` db wrdtdb`sd`bmi smhnmi hbi ldnmi wdtc pucndf oldfm
IurhtdobYcm ndlm ol tcds smfurdty hsrmmefbt schnn fobtdbuf ubtdn t c m bhturhn imhtc olcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vkebj hbi or cds suffmssor db dbtmrmst or tcm Vthtm ol Bmw Torj
or dts suffmssor db dbtmrmst tmredbhtms tcm nmyhn mxdstmbfm ol kusdbmss trustor hbdzhtdobFC[DVYOTLLM[ MH[N VY[]BJ.
l p- 4ot 4Ihtm
mbusmfurmi Whrty FrmidtorPBtN D t s ;-7
FC [.DVYOWCS[M H [ N VY[]BJ IHYM
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
77/167
Foeemrfdhn Vmfurdty j s m m e m b t
VYHYM OL ew TX[J) ss
O]BYT OL JDB@V
KMLO[M EM o b tcds ihy pmrsobhnny hppmhrmi Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj jbowb to em tokm tcm bhturhn pmrsob imsfrdkmi cmrmdb hbi w o sonmebny hl lemi b quhirupndfhtm tchtmvmry sthtmembt `dvmb hkovm whs tcm wconm trutc to tcm kmst ol cds jbownmi`m:hbi
HLLD[EV tcds Foeemrfdhn Vmfr~rdtyH`rmmembt. s ehttmr o pukndf rmfori tcht tcmO[D@DBHN wdtc fmrtdldmifopdms ol Mxcdkdts hbbmxmi wdn n kf jmpt ob ldnm ubimr smhn ht tcmpukndf olldfm ol tcm Fnmrj ol cm Jdb`s Foubty Vwrroyhtm Fourt ol cm Vthtm olBmw Torj dbhfforihbfm wdtc tcm Vthtm ol Bmw Torj F P M [ 0K Msthtms Wowmrs hbi Yest nhw. hsdbstruftmi ky H l l e h b t ol tcm Fnmrj hbi hs iuny smrvmi upob tcm Fnmrj wdtc tcm bmfmss ryldndb` nmm ky tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms Wosthn Vmrvdfm mvdimbfmi ky fmrtdldmi ehdn wdtc rmturb rmfmdptbo 1 0787674777784;;4;446 s ol cds i y olGF6
W-Vuksfrdkmi hbi Hlldremi kmlorm e m ob tcds hy ol ; 86lde f
] E H N W 7B8, Bothry Wukndf< ourt Vtrmmt
Foubty ol Jdb`sKroojnyb Bmw Torj 88;78
. ..1/ - .. ,. ' . r o r j, -., - -1 " / . , '#
Dl . , D N - E ~ - .N n-2{1n~qny. _ -1,.:. rm : . r..-2 1 8 , ;78=
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
78/167
Foeemrfdhn Vmfurdtv H`rmmembt
Mrdf .Dob1 Wcmnps smfurmi phrtynfrmidtorol M E OB WeNWV). h maw Wrdvhtm Fdtdzmbol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms ol Hemrdfh Wrdvhtmny [msdidb` ht Foeeob Nhw db c d s coem nofhtmi ht; 6 Voutc. Lort Qmnnfrs [ohi. db tcm towb ol Bmwehbstowb, ob tcm nei olNmkhbob Foubtydb tcf Fbteobwmhntc ol Wmbbsynvhbdh.
tcds Foeemrfdhn Vmfurdty H`rmmemhf h s h ehttmr ol pukndf rmfori. wdtc tcmubifrsthbid b tcht tcm O[8@DBHN wdtc fmrtdldmi fopdms ol Mxcdkdts hbbmxmi wdnn km jmpt obtdDf ubimr smhn ht tcm pukndf olldfmol tcm Fnmrj ol tcm Jdb`s Foubty Vurro`htm Fourt ol tcmVthtf ol Bmw Torj b hfforihbfm wdtc tcm Vh t m ol Bmw Torj FCHWYM[ 80K MsthtmsWowmrs hbi Yrust nhw hs h rmqudrmi wdtbmss lor Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn1 Vtrubj hbi or cdssuffmssor db dbtmrms~ r tcm Vthtm s l mw Torj or d suffmssor b dbtmrmst tmredb tms tcm nm`hnmxdstmbfmol kusdbmss trust hbi hs dl h nhst wdn hbi tmsthembt hfforidb` to n h wKMLO[M EM, ob cds i y pmrsobhnny hppmhrmi Mrdf Aob1 Wcmnps jbowb to em o km tcmbhturhn pmrsob imsfrdkmi cmrmdb hbi wco sonmeb8y hn ldemi tcht mvmry sthtmembt `dvmbhkovf sukdmft to tcf ldbhn mxmfutdob hbi ldndb` ol tcds Foeemrfdhn VmfurdtyH`rmmembt w stcm wconm trutc to tcm kmst olcds jbownmi`m.
D
: DVuksfrdkmi bi Hlldremi kmlorm e ob tcds ihy ol Eh~mc.;786.
d i cdi -.Kdnn ~nmrtzo~: ,Botdr~pukndfD ; wmst Ndbfonb HNm.Foubty ol NmkhbobEymrstowb, Fodbrbobwmhntc ol Wmbbsynvhbdh
07
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
79/167
[mvdsmi Hrtdfnm ]FFVmhrfc] Vmhrfc [msunts
Ldnmhembiembt to t ds ]FF j t u e t smhrfcLdnm buekmr1 ;78; ;< 9496-79Ldndb` ihtm1 8; 8; ;78; 91=01;3 WENhpsm ihtm1 8; 8; ;78091=01;3 WEVthtus1 H Hftdvm
HFYDOBVHftnob Ldnm Ihtm Vthtus
.Dbdtdhn ldbhbfdb` Vthtmembt 8; 8; ;78; r=l 1;3 WE Hftdvm Ldnmi obndbm
BHEMVImktor/Vmfutmi Whrw/Lnnmr Ihts Hiimi HiirmssImktorFC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N VY[]BJOr`DI 60
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
80/167
e be 0 rbY Wld@MV D 5X M W ] [ FNM[J
BOYDFM OL [MNMHVM PDYCO]Y FOBVDIM[HYDOBYO 1 VYHYM OL BMP TOLS, [mnmhsmmDB [M 1 ]VPL[]FY 'FDPDVYXWCM[ MHL& P[]BJ, ' F C [ A V Y O ? ~ , s ? : J ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ # r d s t h p c m r& M. jubj
8 c ~ r r c y mrt df tcm w d t d ~ bi low`hdb` to kmL[OE1 FcrdstopcmrMhrn Vtrubj, db mssm [mnmhsor h trw. forrmft hbi fbehnmtm fow o " c m ordrdbiVYHYM OL BMP WO[J ) 5*FO]BYT OL JDB@V
.tcht hp mh l r~forrn[ tcds o l l d ~ ~ , -b d s N&pr o ; 7 8 ;
Imputy Fn~rj, ~ r b ~ rupmrdor Fo~drtHfforidb`ny D Fcrdstopcmr-MhrD1Vtrubj db mssm ([mnmhsor)kmdb` iuny sbYoe imposm hbi shy ubimr pmbhntyol pmraury1[mDmhsor ubtdn lurtcmr botdfm ds nofhtmi lor smrvdfm ht =46\hbimrkdnt Hvmbum ;38Kroojnyb, Bmw Torj8 8;63wdtcdb tcm Vthtm ol BmwTorj sukidvdsdob ol tcm fdty ol Bmw Torj.D Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1Vtrubj db mssm, hksonutmny rmnmhsm hnn pmrsobhn propmrty dbtmrmsts, nm`hn hbi/ormqudthknm,db tcm pukndf ]bdtmi Vthtms Fdtdzmb hFC[MVYOWCM[MH[N VY[]BJ* frmhtmi ob Ahbuhry ;9,8490, upob tcm ldndb`ol tcm trust dbstruembt b tcm Vthtm ol Bmw Torj sukidvdsdob Foubty ol Bmw Torjwdtcdb t c m Fdty ol Bmw Torj, tcm ]V]L[]FY Immi FmrtdldfhtmBo.1 760
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
81/167
Eu - q h G j M k m i~ n f r b ~ ~ b ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ m w ~ ~ ~ d t yFtv`(pbm deeWXth8snyhkovm cb khimohribsnknmu qehpbntynb`V - S . /
~ ~ c t s w h e ~ c e t - . ~ w t k h ~ * r c o b ~ ~ ~ 1
B O L - K [YC
. VMS.. -]Y K ~ c
..
DFJ'B Y ' V Bldl
BOYDFM O [MNM VM PDYCO]Y FOBVnIM[ YDOB
xcdkdt H
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
82/167
EEH[ FO]BYT @H V]WM[DO[ FX]L
KWH KOOJ WH@MV D l9IMW]YT F
VYHYM OL BMP TO[V]KIEVDOB FO]BYT OL BMP TPDYCDB YCM FDYT OL B M P TO[
YO 1 VYHYM O BMP TO[J, [mnmhsmmF OYCM FNMLS OL YCM FO]BYT OL BMP TO[Jwdtc Fchptmr 80 D6Bmw Torj thtm Msthtms, Wou~mrsbi Yestse f n m 8 Vmftdob 4.; [mnmhsm olh pow r ol hppodbcmbt
DB [M ]V]L[]FY FC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N VY[]BJ, 'FC[DVYOWCM[ M VY[]BJ, FcrdstopcmrM VtrubJ
. L[OE FcrdstopcmrMhrn Vtrubj db mssm [mnmhsor
BOYDFM OL [MNMHVMPDYCO]Y FOBVDIM[HYDOBMxcdkdt H ]V]L[]FD' Immi Fmrtdldfhtm Bo 1 60
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
83/167
VYHYM OL @MO[@DV] K I E VD O B FO]BYT OL NHEH[
YO VYHYM OL BMP TO[J [mnmhsmmF / OYCMFNMP OL YCM FO]BYT OL NHTH[ VY YMOL @MO[@DH PDYCDB
YOPB OL [H[BMV\DNNM MO[@D wdtc Fchptmr 80-= l c m Bmw TorjVthtm Msthtms, Wowmrs hbi Yests Hrtdfnm D7 Vmftdob 4 ; mlmwmolhpowmr olhppodbtembt Vuk-Vme ob (f) Vufc rmnm sm ehy m imndvmrmi to hby ol rcf lonnowdb`1 (6) Hbypmrsob, otcmr tchb tcmiobmm. wco ed`ct km hivmrsmny hllmftmi ky b mxmrfdsm ol tcm powmr.
E [M ]VFYL[]FY FC[DVYOWCM[ MH[N Yh]BJ, ]FC[DVYXWCM[ M. 'D[]BJ, F c d h o p j M.VtrubjL[OE1 Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj, db mssm [mnmhsor
BOYDFM OL [MNMHVMPDYCO]Y FOBVDIM[HYDOBMxcdkdt H ]V]L[]FY Immi FmrtdldfhtmBo.1
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
84/167
YO1 cm CoborhknmIhrmmb H XudbbFcdml Fnmrj ol tcmJP@V FOPBYT V][[O@HYM FO][Y; Aocbsob VtrmmtKroojnyb B T 88; 8Wcobm 690-979-4073
Vukamft1 Ldndb`ubimr smhn ol tcm FcrdstopcmrMhrn1 Vcvbj nhstwdnn btfsthembt lor shlmjmmpdb` ubimr tcm Vthtm ol Bmw Torj Fchptmr 80-K oltcm Msthtms Wowmrs hbi Yrust Nhw.
Hl dremi Forbemrfdhn Vmfurdty H`rmmembt ph`ms 8 tcrou`c 9 wdtcMjcdkdt 1 Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]FF Abd dhn Ldbhbfdb` Vthtmembt 8;88;/;7 8;
91=01;3 WE 1;78;-;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
85/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt0
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
86/167
Wrdbt | Fnosm Pdbiow
Vukamft 1 ].V. Wosthn Vmrv dfm Yrhfj & Fobldre mehdn [mstorhtdob - 0787674777784;;46786
Lroe1 ]V_Wosthn_VmrvdfmGusps.foe
Ihtm1 Pmi, Hu` 70, ;786 ;177 pe
Yo1 fcrdsGstrubj.ws
Ycds ds h post-obny emssh`m. Wnmhsm io bot rmspobi.
Fcrdstopcmr Vtrubj chs rmqumstmi tcht you rmfmdvm tcds rmstorhtdob dblorehtdob lor Yrhfj & Fobldre hs ndstmi kmnow.
Furrmbt Yrhfj & Fobldre m-ehdn dblorehtdob provdimi ky tcm ].V. Wosthn Vmrvdfm.
Nhkmn Buekmr1 0787674777784;;46786
Vmrvdfm Yypm1 Fmrtdldmi Ehdn
Vcdpembt Hftdvdty Nofhtdob Ihtm & Ydem
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Imndvmrmi PHVCDB@YOB IF ;7;;7Ehy ;3, ;7869188 he
Hvhdnhknm lor Wdfjup PHVCDB@YOB IF ;7;;7 Ehy ;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
87/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt3
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
88/167
YO1 Fnmrj oltcmFourt].V. ourt olHppmhnsIdstrdftolFonuekdhFdrfudt6 66 FobstdtutdobHvm. PPhscdb`tob I.F. ;7778
DB[M1 Mbfnosmi ldndb` lmm ol 9==.77 or Fcrds Vt-subjL[OE1 [mLeetdfe Kdknm YruVt
;76 VoutcLort Qmnnmrs [i.Bmwehbstowb Wmbbsy8ebd;9 Z 0 068
Imhr Fnmrj olFourtMbfnosmi 86 hWEO lor 9==.77 sphyembt lor tcm ldndb` lmm db tcm fhsm ol1FcrdsthpcmrVtbtbjv Khrhfj Okheq m t h8hsm buekh 8;-=;39P e e k ~ 7-P-7793
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
89/167
- uVFH Fhsm #8;-=;34 Iofuembt D9;390= Ldnmi1 7987;8;786 Wh`m 8 ol 8
Wbdlmc Klxlmm Fcert hl KppmbnsLO[ YCMI DVY[ D ~LFON]EKDHD[F]DY
Bo. 8;-=;34 Vmptmekmr Ymre, ;78;LdnmiOb1 Hprdn ;, ;786
Fcrdstopcmr Mhrn Vtrubj, ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn.Hppmnnhbt... . . - . -Khrhfj Cussmdb Okheh, hnso jbowb hs KhrryVomtoro , mt hn.,
HppmnnmmsKMLO[M1 @hrnhbi, Fcdml Aui`m, hbi Yhtmn hbi Krowb, FdrfudtAui`ms
O[I M []pob fobsdimrhtdob ol tcm eotdob lor nmhvm to profmmi db ioreh phupmrds, dt dsO[IM[MI tcht tcm eotdob lor nmhvm to profmmi ob hppmhn db loreh phupmrds kmimbdmi. Ycm idstrdft fourt forrmflny imtmredbmi tcht tcm hppmhn ds bot thjmb db `ooi
lhdtc mm ;3 ] V F 48= h) 6): Lmi. [. Hpp. W. ;9(h)(6)(H):6=< ].V.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
90/167
Vmptmekmr Ymre ; 8;LdnmiOb Imfmekmr ;78; Z D ~ ~ E P
FcrdstopcmrMhrn Vtbrbj, ]bdtmi Vthtms mxrm^.Hppmnnhbt
Khrhfj Cussmdb Okheh, hnso jbowb hsKhrry Vomtoro mt h .,Hppmnnmms
O [ I M [Kmfhusm hppmnnhbt chs bot phdi tcm hppmnnhtm iofjmtdb`lmm db tcds fhsm hbi tcmidstrdft fourt chs imbdmi hppmnnhbt nmhvm to profmmi ob hppmhn db loreh phupmrds, dt dsO[IM[MI ob tcm foulls owb eotdob, tcht y Ahbuhry 89 ;786 hppmnnhbtmdtcmr phy tcm $9== hppmnnhtm iofjmtdb` hbi ldndb` lmms to tcm Fnmrj ol tcm IdstrdftFourt,
s Lmi. [. Hpp. W. 6(m): ;3 ].V.F. = 8480 or ldnm h eotdob db tcds fourt lor nmhvm toppm n db loeh phupmrds, s Lmi [.Hpp. W 9(h). mm Mbfnosurm.H rmqumst lor ppodptembt = foubsmn ioms bot rmndmvm hppmnnhbt ol tcm oknd`htdob
to ldnm rmspobsms to hby eotdob ldnmi ky hppmnnmms or to foepny wdtc hby orimr dssumi kytcm fourt dbfnuidb` h krdmldb` sfcmiunm. Lhdnurm ky hppmnnhbt to rmspobi to h idsposdtdvmeotdobor foepny wdtc hby orimr ol tcm fourt, dbfnuidb` tcds orimr, wdnn rmsunt db idsedsshnol tcm fhsm lor nhfj ol prosmfutdob. mm I F dr. [unm 63.Ycm Fnmrj s idrmftmi to smbi h fopy ol tcds orimr to hppmnnhbt y fmrtdldmi eh ,rmturb rmfmdpt rmqumstmi, hbi ky ldrst fnhss ehdn.
LO[ YCM FO][Y1Ehrj A. Nhb`mr FnmrjK T Ds8Nhurh E. Fcdpnmy~ m k u t y nmrj
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
91/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
92/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
93/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt4
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
94/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Vueehry ol Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs
Yrhbsdtdob D
8. Lourtmmbtc Hembiembt, 83
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
95/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Yrhbsdtdob DDD
Wursuhbt to tcm imsd`b ol tcm Amsudt Orimr db dts Foubtmr [mlorehtdob pnot to
ovmrtcrow hnn ndedtmi `ovmrbembts ol Pmstmrb Fdvdndzhtdob korb out ol tcm
Wrotmsthbt [mlorehtdob, tcm Amsudts pnhbbmi to deposm hksonutdse dbHemrdfh. Ycm Orimr rmhndzmi tcm Fob`rmss chi fobstdtutdobhnny ndedtmi
powmrs to nm`dsnhtm ovmr tcm Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmbs ndvdb` db tcm sthtms. Ycm
Orimr hnso jbmw tcm Fob`rmss chi fobstdtutdobhnny ubndedtmi powmrs to
nm`dsnhtm ovmr tcm dbchkdthbts ndvdb` db tmrrdtordms ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms hs
imfdimi 8478 dbIowbms v Kdiwmnn, 83; ].V. ;99. (Jbd`ct ol Fonuekus
Austdfm Miwhri Pcdtm, miufhtmi ky tcm Amsudts ol @mor`mtowb ]bdvmrsdty,
whs h phrt ol tcht rhidfhn imfdsdob chvdb` imphrtmi lroe tcm msthkndscmi
conidb` ol tcm Fourt tcht fobstdtutdobhn ndedthtdobs ob Fob`rmss db nm`dsnhtdb`
lor h sthtm wmrm tcm shem hs lor h tmrrdtory.) Dl you hii tcm hksonutm powmr
ol Fob`rmss to rm`unhtm foeemrfm, tcmb wcy bot pnot to rmiufm tcm sthtms toemrm fobqumrmi tmrrdtordmsto km tmeporhrdny runmi ky hb memr`mbfy whr
powmrs edndthry `ovmrbembt wcdnm sdeunthbmousny foblmrrdb` h bmw,
forporhtm/kusdbmss-stynmi, Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmbscdp ob tcm obfm Wrdvhtm ].V.
Fdtdzmbs, wco, hs h wconm, foeposmi tcm Vovmrmd`b Koiy tcht frmhtmi tcm
Fobstdtutdob deposdb` mxprmss ndedthtdobs ob tcm Nm`dsnhtdvm, Mxmfutdvm hbi
Nm`dsnhtdvms krhbfcms ol `ovmrbembt? Ycm sovmrmd`bty ol tcm Wmopnm wouni
km trhbslmrrmi to tcm `ovmrbembt, tcm pmopnm tcmb to km runmi ky nm`dsnhtdvm
hksonutdse ol Fob`rmss, dts eyrdhi ol sthtutms to km mblorfmi ky tcm fourts,
lmimrhn hbi sthtm, sdttdb` db Nm`dsnhtdvm Mqudty. Ycds pnot wouni km smt obfoursm wdtc tcm pukndf ldndb` ol h Fmrtdldfhtm ol Ndvm Kdrtc.
8. Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtms, 8477-8487Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtms km`db to km ldnmi db tcm Vthtms iurdb` tcm ldrst
imfhim ol tcm ;7tc
Fmbtury. Ycmdr opmb-kut-lhnsmpurposm ds to
emrmny rmfori tcm kdrtc ol khkdms/bhturhn pmrsobs. Ycmdr smfrmt-
kut-trumpurposm ds to hft hs ubdnhtmrhn fobtrhfts ubimr smhnky
opmrhtdob ol nhw, mhfc frmhtdb` h sthtutory, hrtdldfdhn
pmrsob/kusdbmss trust/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb wdtc hb hnn-fhps bhem olwhr (boe im `umrrm). Ycm 89
tcHembiembt dbidvdiuhn Wrdvhtm
].V. Fdtdzmb/bhturhn pmrsob, wdtc tcm shem bhem ol tcm sthtutory
Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb, tcou`c cds bhem ds db kotc uppmr hbi nowmr
fhsm nmttmrs (Fcrdstdhb bhem), wdnn, db 8466, fobsmbt ky sdnmbfm to
km sukoridbhtm Vurmtylor tcm sthtm-frmhtmi Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb.
9= ol =
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
96/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Yrhbsdtdob D\
;. Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs Wrofnhehtdob, Ehrfc 4, 8466Hembimi Yrhidb` Pdtc tcm Mbmey Hft, Ehrfc 4, 8466
Fourts ol tcm Mepdrm, lmimrhn hbi sthtm, kmfoem Memr`mbfy Phr
Wowmrs fourts.
Db WmrsobheAurdsidftdob ds bow okthdbmi ovmr tcm Wrdvhtm ].V.
Fdtdzmb/bhturhn pmrsob tcrou`c cds hrtdldfdhn pmrsob/Wukndf ].V.
fdtdzmb lor wcdfc cm ds sukoridbhtm Vurmtyhbi wdtc wcdfc cm ds
kobimi, wmiimi hbi emr`mi dbto obm quhsd-forporhtm, dbidvdiuhn
Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb. Ycds bmw sthtutory Wukndf sthtus hfts db
fobaubftdob wdtc tcm sthtutordny hembimi Yrhidb` Pdtc tcm
Mbmey Hft wcdfc foblmrs h edndthry profmssupob hnnFobstdtutdobhn fdvdndhb fourts, lmimrhn hbi sthtm. Ycht hrtdldfdhn
pmrsob/frmhtdob-ol-tcm-sthtm-ol-kdrtc, sthtutory Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb
ds htthfcmi to tcm bhturhn pmrsob/89tcHembiembt Wrdvhtm ].V.
Fdtdzmb wco ubjbowdb`ny hfts hs smrvdnm Vurmtylor tcm hrtdldfdhn
pmrsob wdtc wcdfc cm ds kobimi dbto obm bmw cykrdi dbidvdiuhn
Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb. YcdsDb WmrsobheEdndthry Aurdsidftdob,
sprdb`db` lroe tcm hkovm Memr`mbfyWrofnhehtdobhbi hembimi
Yrhidb` Pdtc tcm Mbmey Hft, to km imfmptdvmny wdmnimi ovmr tcm
dbidvdiuhn Fcrdstdhb ehb/89
tc
Hembiembt Hemrdfhb Wrdvhtm ].V.Fdtdzmb koubi to cds hrtdldfdhn pmrsob/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb, ds h
auidfdhn smfrmth nm`hn ldftdob fobfmhndb` tcm lhft tcht Wrdvhtm
].V. Fdtdzmbscdp chs ubimr`obm h fchb`mto km jbowb obny to
tcm Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs aui`ms, lmimrhn hbi sthtm.
Ycm smfobi nm`hn ldftdobds tcht tcm `ovmrbembt ol tcm ]bdtmi
Vthtms chs ubimr`obm h fchb`m. Dt ds h [mpukndfhb `ovmrbembt db
lorekut h Edndthry `ovmrbembt db suksthbfm. YcmIm Aurm
[mpukndfhb `ovmrbembt ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms ds h frmhtdob ol tcm
Vovmrmd`b Wmopnm ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms hfforidb` to tcm Wrmheknm totcm Fobstdtutdob. Ycm Edndthry `ovmrbembt ol tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms ds
h frmhtdob ol kotc tcm Fob`rmss hbi tcm Wrmsdimbt hftdb` db cds
fhphfdty hs Foeehbimr db Fcdml. Ycm Fob`rmss deposms h
Edndthry `ovmrbembt ky why ol h whr sthtutm, tcm hembimi
Yrhidb` wdtc tcm Mbmey Hft ol 8480. Ycm Wrmsdimbt dssums cds
Wrofnhehtdob ;797 imrdvmi lroe tcht hembimi lmimrhn sthtutm.
9< ol =
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
97/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Yrhbsdtdob \
6. Cousm Aodbt [msonutdob 84;, 8466Hnn phyembts db `oni hrm suspmbimi, bhtdobhn khbjruptfy imfnhrmiky tcm im lhftoEdndthry @ovmrbembt hs h ehttmr ol lmimrhn sthtutm.
Hnn imkts ol tcm im lhftoHemrdfhb Mepdrm ubimr im lhftoEdndthry
@ovmrbembt fhb bow km idsfchr`mi wdtc bm`otdhknm dbstruembts,
nm`hn tmbimr, to tcm mxfnusdob ol `oni. Hs h rmsunt, hnn tcm hrtdldfdhn
pmrsobs/dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmbsob ldnm wdtc tcm Vthtms hrm
`dvmb h eobmthry vhnum to smrvm hs fonnhtmrhn lor hnn frmidt mxtmbimi
to tcm ].V. Fob`rmss ky tcm popms Lmimrhn [msmrvm Khbj. Ycm im
lhftoMepdrm ds to chvm ubndedtmi whr-ehjdb` powmr. Ycus, lor
tcm Lmimrhn [msmrvm to mxtmbi ubndedtmi frmidt, tcmrm eust km
smfurdtdmswdtc ubndedtmi fonnhtmrhnto smfurm tcht imkt. Ycosmsmfurdtdmswdtc ubndedtmi fonnhtmrhn hrm hnn ol tcm Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtms,
chvdb` frmhtmi quhsd-forporhtm, hrtdldfdhn pmrsobs/dbidvdiuhn Wukndf
].V. fdtdzmbs, ob ldnm wdtc kotc tcm sthtm hbi lmimrhn `ovmrbembt.
Pcht `dvms vhnum to tcm hrtdldfdhn pmrsob/dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V.
fdtdzmb ds dts Vurmty, tcm dbidvdiuhn Fcrdstdhb ehb, 89tcHembiembt
Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb. Db Phscdb`tob, tcm Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtms
(ubdnhtmrhn fobtrhfts ubimr smhn) ldnmi ob h Vthtm nmvmn hrm botdfmi
ky (kut bot ldnmi wdtc) tcm Kurmhu ol tcm Fmbsus ubimr tcm
Imphrtembt ol Foeemrfm.
9. Vofdhn Vmfurdty Hft, 846=Mvmry Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb ds `dvmb h
foeemrfdhn/quhsd-forporhtm sofdhn smfurdty buekmr. Mvmry Wukndf
].V. fdtdzmb (tcm foeemrfdhn vmssmn ol tcm Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb wdtc
wcdfc cm ds emr`mi hs Vurmty) ds dbsurmi lor dts mb`h`db` db
dbtmrsthtm hbi lormd`b foeemrfm. Ycm Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb chs kmmb
immemi fonnhtmrhn hbi krou`ct dbto foeemrfdhn smrvdfm vdh tcm
Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs Wrofnhehtdob ol 8466 hbi ds bow ht smh,bo nob`mr db port bmhr tcm nhbi. Cmbfm tcm Wrdvhtm ].V.
Fdtdzmb/Vurmtyds hnso ht smh, bo nob`mr ob tcm nhbi upob wcdfc
@oi frmhtmi cde. (Ndjm Iorotcy, cm ds bow db tcm nhbi ol Oz!)
Ycm Vurmty/Wrdvhtm Hemrdfhb fdtdzmb ds koubi to cds prdbfdphn/
[oehbpmrsobhdb worni whr hbi worni foeemrfm---hnn lor tcm
kmbmldt ol Phscdb`tob db smrvdfm to tcm Amsudt Whphfy!
90 ol =
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
98/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Yrhbsdtdob \D
=.Mrdm [hdnrohifhsm, 8463Vwdlt v. Yysob(839;) ovmrrunmi: bo eorm lmimrhn `mbmrhn foeeob
nhw ol hby typm, profmiurm or rd`cts. Ycm Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb,
sukedttmi to cds Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb sthtutordny fobtronnmi ky tcm im
lhfto Edndthry @ovmrbembtfrmhtmi ky lmimrhn sthtutm hbi rundb`
tcm ]bdtmi Vthtms, fhb bo nob`mr ndedt tcm lmimrhn fourts to lmimrhn
foeeob nhw profmiurms. Cow fhb cm? Cm ds wmiimi/koubi to cds
sthtutory sthtm-frmhtmi Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb possmssdb` bo Foeeob
Nhw rd`cts wchtsomvmr! Hnn ds bow, db suksthbfm, [oehb Fdvdn
Nhw profmiurm dbvonvdb` obny hrtdldfdhn pmrsobs, km tcmy
forporhtdobs or dbidvdiuhns---tcm Wukndf ].V fdtdzmbs frmhtmi ky
tcmdr trust dbstruembts, tcm Fmrtdldfhtms ol Ndvm Kdrtc, vdh tcmfnhbimstdbm hbi ubbotdfmi opmrhtdob ol nhw.
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
99/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Foephrdsob Kmtwmmb Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsobs1
Vthtm-frmhtmi Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb wdtc Vurmty/Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb
Hbi
Vthtm-frmhtmi Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb1 Forporhtdob
Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb wdtc Vurmty Forporhtdob
8. Frmhtmi ky h Vthtm Frmhtmi ky h Vthtm;. Frmhtmi ky h Fobtrhft Frmhtmi ky h Fobtrhft6. Fobtrhft1 Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtm Fobtrhft1 Forporhtm Fchrtmr9. Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtm1 Forporhtm Fchrtmr1
H.Db Prdtdb` H. Db Prdtdb`K.Ywo Whrtdms K. Ywo WhrtdmsF.Vd`bmi F. Vd`bmiI.Vmhnmi ky Vthtm I. Vmhnmi ky VthtmM. Imndvmrmi/Ldnmi w Vthtm M. Imndvmrmi/Ldnmi w Vthtm
Kurmhu ol \dthn Vthtdstdfs Vmfrmthry ol Vthtm
L.Bo Dbtmbt to Fobtrhft L. Dbtmbt to Fobtrhft@.Cow h Fobtrhft? @. Cow h Fobtrhft?Opmrhtdob ol Nhw Mxprmss H`rmmembt
=.Bhturhn Wmrsob Bhturhn WmrsobH.[mfmdvms Kmbmldt lroe Vthtm [mfmdvms Kmbmldt lroe VthtmK.Io Kusdbmss hs1 Io Kusdbmss hs1
Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob
F.Vurmtylor Wmrsobh Vurmtylor ForporhtdobI.FMO lor Wmrsobh FMO lor Forporhtdob
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
100/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
3. D[V Vueeobs/Huidts D[V Vueeobs/Huidts4. Whys Mxfdsm/Dbfoem Yhx Whys Mxfdsm/Dbfoem Yhx87.Db Foeemrfm Db Foeemrfm88.Vukamft to Phr Wowmrs Fourts Vukamft to Phr Wowmrs Fourts
Lmimrhn/Vthtm Lmimrhn/Vthtm
8;.Db Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs Fourt1 Db Memr`mbfy Phr Wowmrs FourtH.Fdvdn Nhw @ovmrbs Fdvdn Nhw @ovmrbsK.Bo Foeeob Nhw Bo Foeeob NhwF.Bo Foeeob Nhw [d`cts Bo Foeeob Nhw [d`ctsI.Lnh`1 @oni Lrdb`m Korimrs Lnh`1 @oni Lrdb`m KorimrsM.Db WmrsobheAurdsidftdob Db WmrsobheAurdsidftdob
Ovmr Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob Ovmr Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob
L.BoDb WmrsobheAurdsidftdob BoDb WmrsobheAurdsidftdobOvmr Bhturhn Wmrsob Ovmr Bhturhn Wmrsob
@.[mprmsmbtmi ky Nhwymr [mprmsmbtmi ky NhwymrC.@mbmrhn Hppmhrhbfm @mbmrhn HppmhrhbfmD. Bhem db Hnn Fhpdthn Nmttmrs Bhem db Hnn Fhpdthn NmttmrsA. Hby Wnmhidb` Hiedts Hby Wnmhidb` Hiedts
Db WmrsobheAurdsidftdob Db WmrsobheAurdsidftdob
J.Vukamft to Fdvdn Vudt Vukamft to Fdvdn VudtN. Vukamft to1 Bot Vukamft to1
Frdedbhn Wrosmfutdob Frdedbhn Wrosmfutdob
(FMO Vukamft to Frde. Wros.)
E.Wmrsobh/FMO-surmty bot Forporhtdob/FMO jmptVmphrhtmi db Wrofmmidb`s Vmphrhtmi db Wrofmmidb`s
86.Ehy bot km idssonvmi1 Pcy? Ehy km idssonvmi1 Pcy?Fobtrhft ky Opmrhtdob ol Nhw Fobtrhft ky Mxprmss H`rmmembt
89.Foeeob Nhw [memiy to Bo Foeeob Nhw [memiy toVtopDb WmrsobheAurds? VtopDb WmrsobheAurds?
=7 ol =
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
101/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Ycmrm chvm kmmb ehby hiedbdstrhtdvm rmemidms put lortc lor tcm nhst twmbty
ymhrs smmdb` to krmhj tcds [oehb Fdvdn NhwDb WmrsobheAurdsidftdob. Db tcm
8437s Nmob Nmfcmbm hbi Nmm Kroksts Vfcoon ol Vovmrmd`b Mxfchb`m hbi
Hnnoidue (VMH) whs obm sufc httmept. Obm ol tcm lormeost rmemidms whs tcm
Bob-Vthtutory Hkhtmembt put lortc ky [hbiy Nmms Hemrdfhb Aurhn Vofdmty
db cds Ycm Kooj ol tcm Cubirmisiurdb` tcm 8447s. Ycm rmemiy ds h Foubtmr-
fnhde ht Foeeob Nhw ky spmfdhn rmstrdftmi hppmhrhbfm imehbidb` `ovmrbembt
to ollmr prool ol fnhde tcht imlmbihbt ds hb dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb.
Ky our Dbidvdiuhn Fobsmbt Ycrou`c Vdnmbfm to h Fobtrhft
(Fmrtdldfhtm ol Ndvm Kdrtc)
Pm kmfhem Vurmtylor hb Hrtdldfdhn/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb
K]Y
Ky tcm @ovmrbembts Fobsmbt Ycrou`c Vdnmbfm to h Fobtrhft
([mnmhsm Pdtcout Fobsdimrhtdob)
Pm Fmhsm to Km Vurmtylor hb Hrtdldfdhn/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb
Ky Opmrhtdob ol Nhw
COPM\M[
Ycm Edndthry Aurdsidftdob ol kotc Lmimrhn hbi Vthtm Fourts
[mehdbs hs dt fhb obny fmhsm wdtc tcm Wrmsdimbt
Hs Foeehbimr-db-Fcdml [mvojdb` Wrofnhehtdobs
Dssumi ob Ehrfc 4, 8466 hbi Imfmekmr 8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
102/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Hfforidb` to tcmJdb` Ahems H\8
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
103/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Nhw ol [mnmhsm
[mnmhsm Pdtcout Fobsdimrhtdob
]bdnhtmrhn Fobtrhft ]bimr Vmhn
8. Db Prdtdb`;. Vthtmi Dbtmbt
h. Fmhsm to km Vurmty lor dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmbk. Hkhbiob Wmrsobhn Wropmrty [d`cts db tcm Nm`hn hbi
Mqudthknm Ydtnm to dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb
f. [mturb to tcm Loremr Vthtus ol Lourtmmbtc Hembiembtdbidvdiuhn Wrdvhtm Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmb bo nob`mr db Fobtrhft
wdtc tcm Vthtm `ovmrbembt ol tcm sthtm ol kdrtc.
6. Vd`bmi9. Vmhnmi ky Bothry Wukndf=. Imndvmrmi hbi Ldnmi wdtc Vthtm Fnmrj ol Fourt/Wrotcobothry
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
104/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Hiimbiue1
Ycm Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtm frmhtms h Yrust.
Eotcmr ds tcm @rhbtorol tcm Wropmrty.
Khky ds tcm Wropmrtybmfmsshry to frmhtm tcm Yrust/Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob.
Ndfmbsmi Ioftor ds tcm @rhbtmmlor tcm Vthtm/Wrovdbfm.
Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtm ds Ldnmi wdtc tcm Vthtm/Wrovdbfm.
Kdrtc Fmrtdldfhtm frmhtms hb Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob ob Vthtm nmvmn.
@rowb Khky/Fcrdstdhb Ehb kmfoems Vurmtylor Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob.
Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob frmhtmi lor tcm kmbmldt ol kotc tcm Vthtm hbi
Bhtdobhn @ovmrbembts.
Cykrdi Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb ds tcm Kmbmldfdhryol Yrust Forpus.
Kdrtc Vthtm ds tcm Yrustmm ol Yrust Forpus/Hrtdldfdhn Wmrsob.
Ky Fcrdstdhb Ehb Ldndb` cds [mnmhsm Pdtcout Fobsdimrhtdob,cds[msfdssdob ol Vd`bhturms ol VurmtyscdpB]BF W[O Y]BF, h ]FF-8
Ldbhbfdb` Vthtmembtkmfoedb` h Vmfurmi Whrty Frmidtor, hbi tcmb h
Foeemrfdhn Vmfurdty H`rmmembt, tcm ronms hrm [mvmrsmi1
D. Fcrdstdhb Ehb fmhsms lroe kmdb` Vurmty lor foeemrfdhn/dbidvdiuhnWukndf ].V. fdtdzmb.
DD.Fcrdstdhb Ehb kmfoems tcm H`mbtol tcm foeemrfdhn/dbidvdiuhnWukndf ].V. fdtdzmb.
DDD.Vthtm hbi Lmimrhn @ovmrbembts fobtdbum to km tcm Yrustmmsconidb`nm`hn tdtnm to foeemrfdhn/dbidvdiuhn Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb.
D\. Fcrdstdhb Ehb/Vmfurmi Whrty Frmidtor/H`mbt mbaoys tcm kmbmldfdhnusm ol tcm propmrty obfm vmstmi db tcm IMKYO[/Wukndf ].V.
fdtdzmb, tcm propmrty chvdb` kmmb fobvmymi to tcm H`mbt. Ium to
tcm Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb bmvmr owbdb` tcm propmrty hfqudrmi ky tcm
Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb hs h rmsunt ol tcm ldndb` ol tcm hkovm
iofuembts, IMKYO[ chs fobvmymi hnn rd`ct hbi tdtnm to tcmpropmrty cm ds conidb` to tcm Vmfurmi Whrty Frmidtor. VWF tcmb
usms tcm bhem ol tcm IMKYO[ to hfqudrm propmrty lor cds kmbmldt
hbi bot lor tcm kmbmldt ol tcm IMKYO[/Yhxphymr. Vdbfm tcm
IMKYO[/Wukndf ].V. fdtdzmb/Yhxphymr chs bo eorm dbfoem, bo
dbfoem thx rmturbs bmmi to km ldnmi ky tcm H`mbt. Wukndf ].V.
Fdtdzmb ds hs lormd`b hbi tcmrmlorm hnn dbfoem ds thx mxmept.
=9 ol =
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
105/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
\.Ycm H`mbt ioms bot chvm hby dbfoem hs cm ds h Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmbbot db prdvdnm`m wdtc hby sthtm ol lmimrhn `ovmrbembt. Hnn propmrty
cm hfqudrms ds lor cds kmbmldt hbi bot lor tcm kmbmldt ol hby sthtm-
frmhtmi mbtdty. Bo dbfoem, tcus, bo bmmi to ldnm h rmturb. Ycm
Wrdvhtm ].V. Fdtdzmb ds h bobthxphymr sthbidb` outsdim ol Ydtnm
;
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
106/167
Vmvmb Yrhbsdtdobs ol Hemrdfhb Fdtdzmbscdp
Lmimrhn hbi Vthtm Fourts ol [mfori
Db Lore1 Fdvdndhb fourts hrdsdb` lroe Fobstdtutdobs
Db Vuksthbfm1 Edndthry @ovmrbembt fourts hrdsdb` lroe hembimi
Lmimrhn sthtutm, Yrhidb` Pdtc tcm Mbmey Hft hbi Wrofnhehtdob, Ehrfc 4, 8466.
Edndthry Wrofmss ds mvdimbfmi ky Edndthry Fonorsidspnhymi db Fourtrooes
Edndthry Wrofmss ds hnso Mvdimbfmi ky Bhturhn Wmrsobs
kmdb` `dvmb hnn ]ppmr Fhsm nmttmrmi Bhems, d.m.,
Bhem ol Phrfhnnmi Boe im @umrrm,
Db Wrmphrhtdob lor Amsudt-fobtronnmi Lhsfdst Ehrtdhn Nhw.
Lhsfdst Ehrtdhn Nhw Ldrst httmeptmi db 8469:
Wnottmi lurtcmr db 8439 wdtc [obhni [mh`hb/Ondvmr Bortc [mx 39
(;8 Ednndob Hemrdfhb Bm`ros to km smbt to ovmr
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
107/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOYDFM OLEOYDOB YO [MFOBVDIM[ VYHT HBI O[ NDLY YCM EHBIHYM
OL H]@]VY 8 ;786 HBI [MBMP YO FHNMBIH[
Mxcdkdt87
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
108/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
109/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
110/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
111/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
112/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
113/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
114/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
115/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
116/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
117/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
118/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
119/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
120/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
121/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
122/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
123/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
124/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
125/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
126/167
8/22/2019 Strunk NOM for EM BANC hearing in re RECONSIDER w Exhibits Strunk v Obama DCC 12-5289
127/167
Fcrdstopcmr-Mhrn1 Vtrubj ]bdtmi Vthtms mx rmn. \ OKHEH MY HNHppmhn Fhsm Bo1 8;-=;34
MS [MNHYO[ HWWMNNHBYV HLLDIH\DY DB V]WWO[Y BOY
Recommended