Diverse Network Services and Remaining Challenges

Diverse Network Servicesand

Remaining Challenges

SRCCS Winter 2005 Workshop on

Internet Modeling and Analysis

Sue B. MoonDivision of Computer Science

Dept. of EECSKAIST

2

Diverse Data Sets in Korea

• Data from major ISPs– Non-existent in public

• Data from academia– DAGMON traces at KAIST– Long-term, sampled flow-level traces at POSTECH– 4-month-worth NetFlow traces at CNU

• Others– 3G video streaming service data– 2-day packet-level traces from a home network

3

Diverse Data Sets in Korea

• Data from major ISPs– Non-existent in public

• Data from academia– DAGMON traces at KAIST– Long-term, sampled flow-level traces at POSTECH– 4-month-worth NetFlow traces at CNU

• Others– 2-day packet-level traces from a home network– 3G video streaming service data

4

2005.11.23 at KAIST

FTP HTTP

P2P

OthersOthers

P2P

FTP

In Bits/Sec No. of Pkts / sec

5

2004.12.9. at KAIST

FTP

HTTP

P2P

OthersOthers

P2P

In Bits/Sec No. of Pkts / sec

6

REMOVE after chat with SY

• Previous slides upstream or downstream?• According to JH Youn

– Upstream 70%/85% (Bytes/Pkts) p2p– Downstream Web and VOD more dominant that p

2p.

7

Home Networking in Korea

• Architecture– Simple, tree-like topology– To each home = 100ME– Internal links = 1GE– Outbound speed = OC-3 or up

• Reality in new apt complexes– Control home appliances thru the net

• washing machine, gas stove, lights, heater/airconditioner, door lock• by PDAs at home or remotely by cellphones/web access

– Replace DSL/cable lines– Will be "backbone" for home ubiquitous sensor network

• Need for remote monitoring– Lack of resources

8

2004.12.11. at a Home Network

9

Video Streaming over 3G

• Goals of Monitoring– To satisfy every user:

• High revenue-generating customers• More focus on per-user performance

• Challenges– E2E performance segmented over cellular

and wired networks– No integrated monitoring solutions yet– No good metric for overall/single-user

performance

10

Provisioning for Interactive Streaming

• Interactive Streaming– Not a driving force behind b/w– A candidate for growing revenue

• Examples– VoIP gradually taking over PSTN traffic– Remote video viewing at door by cell phone– Online game traffic

• "Good" routing more important than bandwidth

11

Routing in the Internet

Intra-domain:shortest path routing

Inter-domain:policy-based routing

12

Issues in "Good" Routing

• Misbehaving routing protocols– BGP misconfigurations– Pathological behaviors– Frequent changes

• Even under normal circumstances– Transient behaviors– Inter/intra-domain routing not well understood

13

Scenario for a Transient Routing Loop

In Normal Operation

14

When a link fails, R1 is the first to detect.

15

R3 is updated before R2.

16

Finally R2 is updated, and the loop is resolved.

17

CDF of Routing Loop Duration in Time

18

VoIP experimental setup [Boutremans2002]

• Traffic injected in the network: – 200 byte UDP packets– every 5ms.

• Packets captured and timestamped at end-systems.

• Traceroute runs continuously during the experiment.

19

Information Sources

• IS-IS & BGP listener logs • Router logs from both ends of

“failing” links• Controlled bi-directional VoIP traffic

between Reston and ATL• SNMP data

20

Delays (1 sec timescale)

2 links down

~3.4ms

2 links up

~2.6ms

3 links down

3 links up

21

When the two interfaces went down …

6.6 seconds

22

When three links came back up …

For 30 secs packets follow a shorter path

Traffic “black-holed”for 1.745 seconds

Traffic “black-holed”for 0.975 seconds

23

Approaches To Fix It

• Fine-tuning parameters– Timer values [Alattinoglu2002]

• Modify Routing Protocols– Suppress advertisement and perform local rerouti

ng using a backwarding table [Lee04]– Centralized path computation [Feamster04,Rexfor

d04]

24

Our Approach

• Key Idea:– Find disjoint overlay path and send duplicate

packets• Assumptions

– Sender and receiver both within an AS– Bidirectional link weights– Extra income for extra b/w consumption

• Pros and cons– Advantages

• No modification to current infrastructure• Selective use by only those that need it

– Disadvantages• Extra b/w consumption

25

Basic Ideas

source

destination

candidate relay nodes!!!

26

Resilient to Failures

27

Future Work

• Answer questions raised about diverse data sets

• Find best places for relay nodes in Inter-domain

BACKUP

29

Summary: Local Convergence

• Convergence delay during failures hurts more• After IS-IS converges, extra delay due to FIB update

Experiment

IS-IS Convergence Service Disruptions

2 links down 5.1 sec 6.6 sec

2 links up 17.6 sec ~ 0 sec

3 links down 5.9 sec 8.0 sec

3 links up 17.5 sec 0.95 sec

30

Causes and Open Questions

• Why only after 30 secs? – spf-interval set to 30secs

• What caused the 1.745 secs disruption?• Unknowsn in GSR architecture• What is the right timescale to propagate good

news?