Proposal to BSEEP to adopt GreenPASS Operation (CIS 20 - CIDB) as Energy Efficiency Building Rating System

Proposal to BSEEP Project to adopt GreenPASS (Operation) as EE Building Rating System in Malaysia

(Proposal by SEDA Malaysia to BSEEP-JKR on 22 October 2013)

Low Carbon Building System in Malaysia

This proposal has been presented to the Building Services Energy Efficiency Programme (BSEEP) during the BSEEP-UNDP Project Review Committee - PRC) Bil 2/2013 at JKR CAST on 22 October 2013.

SEDA Malaysia proposed BSEEP to adopt GreenPASS (Operation) as EE Building Rating System in Malaysia since the project as EE Building Rating System in Malaysia since the project have;

a) Objective to reduce GHG emission in building sector in Malaysia.

b) BSEEP is looking for Energy Efficient Building Rating System.c) Recognized the energy & carbon reduction initiatives.d) As tool to facilitate ESCOs on the performance on Energy

Performance Contracting (EPC) especially in government buildings.

e) To facilitate government afford to reduce 40% CO2 intensity in 2020.

Low Carbon Building System in Malaysia

Low Carbon Building program by the government;

� Green Performance Assessment System (GreenPASS) by Construction Industry Development Board (CIDB) – CIS 20 (draft)Development Board (CIDB) – CIS 20 (draft)

Criteria - Objective

� Meet BSEEP Objective – To reduce GHG in Building Sector.

� Direct support Government target on CO2 emission.

� Align with the National Green Technology Policy.

� Support ‘back to back’ the Low Carbon Cities � Support ‘back to back’ the Low Carbon Cities Framework.

� Support affordable development of EE Buildings (cost efficient RM$$/kWh reduction).

� Developed from past EE in Building projects experiences.

� Had undergo industry and international review.

� Ready to be used for pilot.

Low Carbon System - GreenPASS by CIDB

- Green PASS is an assessment tool that able measure and

rate the building performance

- Green PASS estimate the carbon

emission from building construction works and

building operationsperformance

The application of Green PASS is for:

1) Building Construction; and2) Building Operations

Development of Green PASS

1) Tan Sri Dr. Ir Jamilus Hussien – CEO, KLIA Primier Holdings Sdn Bhd –

(CHAIRMAN)

2) Hjh Nor’Aini Bt Abdul Wahab – TKSU, KeTTHA

3) Datuk Dr Abdul Rahim Bin Hj Nik – TKSU, NRE

4) Tuan Syed Abdullah Syed Abdul Rahman – Pengarah Kanan, JKR Caw. Kej.

JK PEMBINAAN LESTARI (HIGH LEVEL STEERING COMMITTEE

4) Tuan Syed Abdullah Syed Abdul Rahman – Pengarah Kanan, JKR Caw. Kej.

Mekanikal

5) Pn Badriyah Abdul Malek – CEO, SEDA

6) En Sam Tan – Executive Officer, KEN Holdings Berhad

7) Dato’ Ng Sieng Liong – REHDA

8) Dato’ Omar Osman – Vice Chancellor, USM

9) En Yeow Wai Siaw – Managing Director, Guocoland (M) Bhd

10) Ar Zulkifli Tahmali – Head of Property Dev – Sime Darby Bhd

11) En Ho Hon Sang – Managing Director, The Sunway Group

12) En Mohd Elmi Bin Anas – Pengarah, Suruhanjaya Tenaga

Development of Green PASS

1) En Steve Anthony Lojuntin – SEDA – (CHAIRMAN)

2) En Ramesh V Subramaniam – Master Builders Association Malaysia

3) Prof Madya Dr Roslan Amirudin - UTM

4) En Mohsen / Mr Murugiah Suppiah - MEPA

TECHNICAL COMMITTEE OF GREEN PASS (WORKING COMMITTEE)

4) En Mohsen / Mr Murugiah Suppiah - MEPA

5) Pn Aslinda Mohd Noor – REHDA

6) Ar Abu Zarim Abu Bakar – PAM

7) En Peter Toh – AECCOM

8) En Abdul Halim Mat Yani - JKR

9) Cik Sharifah Zakiah Syed Wahab - JAS

10) Prof Madya Dr Mohd Wira Mohd Shafie

11) Ar Chan Seong Aun – PAM

12) Ir Cheong Chew Fan – IEM

13) Ir Lam Kim Seong - ASHRAE

Industry AcceptanceJoint collaboration on the development of Green PASS

GreenPASS had undergo various industry and International reviews.

Industry feedback is positive

Acceptance by High Level Steering Committee

International Review of Green PASS

Comments

from

International International

Reviewers

taken on

board

Features of Green PASS

Building

Pre -

DesignConstruction Phase:

Embodied CO2 footprint]

Carbon emission in a life cycle of a building

Building

Lifecycle Operational

Phase:

[Operational CO2

footprint mainly by

ENERGY

CONSUMPTION !]

FACT! Most of the CO2e emission is during the operation phase !!

Elements of GreenPASS (Operation)

Water

Indoor Environm

ental Quality

Intent – To ensure the effective use of water

during operation

Intent – to provide an environment that is

conducive to the health and well being of the building occupants

Energy

Quality

Intent – To ensure the effective use of

energy in during operation

Structure of Green PASS

ElementsElements

CategoriesCategories

Green PASS CertificationGreen PASS Certification Green PASSGreen PASS

Building ConstructionBuilding Construction

SiteSite MaterialMaterialEnerg

yEnerg

yWaterWater WasteWaste

Building OperationsBuilding Operations

Indoor Environmental Quality

Indoor Environmental Quality

- Thermal Comfort- Thermal Comfort

EnergyEnergy WaterWater

Diamond Rating

Scheme With Bonus

Diamond Rating

Scheme With Bonus

Diamond Rating

Scheme

Diamond Rating

Scheme

Green PASS Rating Green PASS Rating

Sub-elementsSub-elements

- Thermal Comfort

- Indoor Air Quality

- Indoor Lighting

- Indoor Acoustic

- Thermal Comfort

- Indoor Air Quality

- Indoor Lighting

- Indoor Acoustic

≥ 1 to < 10

≥ 10 to < 30

≥ 30 to < 50

≥ 50 to < 70

≥ 70 to < 100

100% Carbon Neutral

≥ 1 to < 10

≥ 10 to < 30

≥ 30 to < 50

≥ 50 to < 70

≥ 70 to < 100

100% Carbon Neutral

+ + + + + +

% of CO2e Reduction

Diamond Rating Scheme

Level of Achievement

(% of CO2e Reduction)

Diamond Rating

Scheme

Diamond Rating

Scheme

(without bonus

rating)*(with bonus rating)

100% Carbon Neutral

≥ 70 to < 100 +

+

≥ 70 to < 100

≥ 50 to < 70

≥ 30 to < 50

≥ 10 to < 30

≥ 1 to < 10

+

+

+

+

+

* Bonus Rating ONLY applicable for Building Construction Category – 70% IBS Score, 3 Star SHASSIC Rating, 70% QLASSIC Score

Carbon Emission CalculationCATEGORY : BUILDING CONSTRUCTION

Element Carbon Emissions

Baseline

(tCO2e)

[a]

Actual Carbon

Emissions

(tCO2e)

[b]

Percentage of Carbon

Emissions Reduction

(%)

c = [(a-b) / a]*100

Site

Material

Energy

Water

Waste

Total Carbon Emission

Percentage of Carbon Emission Reduction

CATEGORY : BUILDING OPERATIONElement Carbon Emissions

Baseline

(tCO2e)

[a]

Actual Carbon

Emissions

(tCO2e)

[b]

Percentage of Carbon Emissions

Reduction

(%)

c = [(a-b) / a]*100

Energy

Water

Total Carbon Emission

Percentage of Carbon Emission Reduction

Self Assessment by Consultant/

Contractor/ Client

(Online)

Self Assessment by Consultant/

Contractor/ Client

(Online)

Online Submission/ Application by

applicant

Online Submission/ Application by

applicant

Assessment & Verification by GREEN PASS

accredited assessor

Assessment & Verification by GREEN PASS

accredited assessor

16

CertificationCertificationDeclarationDeclaration

EXAMPLES / CASE

Application of Energy Efficient /

Low Carbon Building Performance

NEW BUILDING DESIGNNEW BUILDING DESIGN

Low Carbon Building Performance System into the

GreenPASS Assesment System

KeTTHA’s LEO Building KeTTHA’s LEO Building : ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS: ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS

In-house Energy Manager + Operation monitoring team by SEDA

ENERGY-10 OptimisationEnergy Saving Features in LEO Building

275Reference Case

247Daylight use

223 EE Lighting 22 - 16 w/m2

239Insulation in walls and roof

EE in Building Guideline Target (136kWh/m2/yr)

Energy Index kWh/m2year

0 1000 200 300

223 EE Lighting 22 - 16 w/m2

195Equipment 27 – 20 w/m2

173EE Light 16 – 8 w/m2

123 EE Equipment 20 - 7.5 w/2

112"Energy Management”

102Room Temp 23 - 24 degrees

100Especially Tight Building

100

56% reduction

Potential GreenPASS (Operational

carbon) Rating

- Daylighting (almost 100%)- EE lighting + task lights- EE office equipment (laptops, LCD monitors, networked printers)- Green IT Network & server room (75% wireless network)

GreenTech Malaysia’s GEO Building GreenTech Malaysia’s GEO Building : DESIGN ELEMENTS: DESIGN ELEMENTS

- Green IT Network & server room (75% wireless network)- EE air conditioning & ventilation- Floor slab cooling (For radiant cooling and thermal storage)

- PCM storage cooling system (minimised air-cond chillers capacity)

- Controls & Sensors (VSDs, VAVs, CO2, BMS / Energy monitoring)- Double glazing (heat and sound insulation)

- Roof and wall Insulation (reduce outside heat gain)

- Grid connected BIPV system (Sell energy to TNB / no batteries)

- Rain water harvest system (landscape, aircond and cleaning)

Energy (& CO2) Savings

= 492,125 kWh/yrEnergy saved

GEO BEI = 65(Conventional) BEI = 220

155 kWh/m2year

a/c area 3,175 sq.m

Savings = 70%

Net saving with Renewable Energy = 85%


carbon) Rating

= 492,125 kWh/yror RM 195,374 per year

Energy saved

= 492,125 x 0.614= 302,165 kg/year CO2= 302 tones CO2/year

CO2 saved

Tariff B (Low Voltage Commercial Tariff) for all kWh

39.7 sen/kWh

0.614 kg of CO2 emitted to the atmosphere for each 1 kWh electricity generated by power plant (Peninsula Malaysia)

Old tariff B ; 40.8 sen/kWh

An Example of 40 Storey and Thin Building An Example of 40 Storey and Thin Building : ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS: ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS

Energy Saving Strategies To Reduced Building Energy Index [kWh/m2/year]

311

332

382

Use 12mm light green tinted, LT=63%, Shading=0.57)

Reduce WWR from 90 to 60%

Use normal brick wall with 90% wall glazing (6mm clear glass)

21

Ba

se

En

erg

y S

av

ing

Str

ate

gie

s

127

131

142

162

227

237

265

288

294

- 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450

Use ALC instead of bricks

Fresh air control + Heat wheel

Room temperature 24 degC

Energy Efficient aircond system with BAS, COP 3.8

Energy efficient fans and motors

Energy efficienct office equipment (10W)

Use of daylighting with daylight sensors

EE lighting (11.5W/m2)

Illuminance 300 - 400 Lux and occ.sensors

11

10

98

76

54

3

En

erg

y S

av

ing

Str

ate

gie

s

67% reduction


carbon) Rating

A Government School Computer Lab A Government School Computer Lab : ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS: ENERGY DESIGN ELEMENTS

54.8% reduction


carbon) Rating

ESB – PANASONIC GREEN WAREHOUSE

in SHAH ALAM

-Green Features:

- 100% Daylifgting. - Almost 100% Cross ventilation.

- EE Lighting Design and features. - Solar Compund Lighting.

- Inverter Aircond System (office) - Rain water Harvest System

-Green Features:

- 100% Daylifgting. - Almost 100% Cross ventilation.

- EE Lighting Design and features. - Solar Compund Lighting.

- Inverter Aircond System (office) - Rain water Harvest System

- Net BEI = 15.6kWh/m2/year (more than 70% energy reduce)

- 384.2 TonCO2/year

- SME Green Award 2012

- ASEAN Energy Award : 2012 : 1st Runner-up Tropical Buildings

- Net BEI = 15.6kWh/m2/year (more than 70% energy reduce)

- 384.2 TonCO2/year

- SME Green Award 2012

- ASEAN Energy Award : 2012 : 1st Runner-up Tropical Buildings


carbon) Rating

RETROFIT BUILDINGRETROFIT BUILDING

EXAMPLES / CASE

RETROFIT BUILDINGRETROFIT BUILDING

Retrofitted Warehouse / Workshop Building with Enhance Energy Management in Shah Alam

kWh/yr RM/yr

No Cost Measures

De-lamping office lighting 13,476 3,153.38

Low Cost Measures

Measures

Annual Saving

Electrical

Use timer controller for temperature and operate silo ventilation 687,760 160,935.84

Use of daylight in warehouse 19,943 4,666.66

Replace normal EXIT signage to LED 2,208 516.67

Awareness campaigns 703,931 164,719.85

High Cost Measures

Replace the Metal Halide lamps to T5HO lamps 957,012 223,940.81

Lighting zoning 498,584 116,668.66

TOTAL 2,882,914 674,602 Actual Cost Reduction

50%Potential GreenPASS (Operational

carbon) Rating

Examples of Green / Low Carbon Buildings by the Government

Net BEI = 114 (59% reduce)

1,490 TonCO2/year

GBI : Silver (2011)

ASEAN Energy Award : 2006


1,490 TonCO2/year

GBI : Silver (2011)



637 TonCO2/year (**To verify)

GBI & GreenMark : Platinum (2011)



637 TonCO2/year (**To verify)

GBI & GreenMark : Platinum (2011)



65 TonCO2/year

GBI : Certified (2009)

ASEAN EA : 2009/2010/2011


65 TonCO2/year

GBI : Certified (2009)

ASEAN EA : 2009/2010/2011

Why Low Carbon Building System is Affordable ?

Cheaper way

The longer the way = $$$$$

WHY GreenPASS IS RECOMMENDED?

� Easy to evaluate the actual performance through its life cycle.

� Straight forward and transparent of accounting emissions through energy consumption / carbon footprint.

� Has potential to support carbon trading purposes (if � Has potential to support carbon trading purposes (if applicable) or NAMA mechnisme (in future).

� Complement to the existing conventional GB systemby helping to narrow the gap and maturing the green building industry.

� Supporting government efforts for reaching national climate reduction target for 2020

� Provide flexibility for designers to achieve the design target.

� Economical and affordable by all stakeholders

BASED ON SERIES OF R&D AND

STUDIES SHOWS THAT

SUSTAINABLE ENERGY ARE THE SUSTAINABLE ENERGY ARE THE

FUNDAMENTAL TO REDUCE

OPERATIONAL CARBON

FOOTPRINT IN BUILDINGS !!

Thank you for your attention

31

SEDA Malaysia,Galeria PjH, Level 9

Jalan P4W, Persiaran Perdana,

Presint 4, 62100 Putrajaya, Malaysia.

Phone : +603-8870 5800Email: [email protected]: www.seda.gov.my

Get copy of paper? - Tel / SMS / WhatsUp :+6019-2829102

[email protected] / [email protected]

Steve Anthony Lojuntin

Sustainable Energy Development

Authority (SEDA) Malaysia

www.seda.gov.my

SEDA Malaysia Background

• Establishment of Sustainable Energy Development Authority of Malaysia (SEDA Malaysia) in May 2011

• Centralized Agency for RE.

• Renewable Energy Act & Feed In- Tariff (FiT) in Malaysia.

• Development & operation of e-FiT

• Assisting KeTTHA / Government on National Energy Efficiency • Assisting KeTTHA / Government on National Energy Efficiency Master Plan (2011-2012) (Until Sept 2012).

• Government NKEA EPP9 Programme : Energy Efficiency� - EE in Government Buildings / Universities.

� - SAVE EE Programme / EE Appliances & Chillers rebate prog.

� - Development of Energy performance Contracting (EPC) (Until Sept 2012)

• Assisting Government on the development of the Energy Efficiency & Conservation Act (until Sept 2012).

• Government NKEA EPP4 : Green Technology Business Sector

• ESCO Voluntary Accreditation Programme (until Sept 2012).

• Demonstrate and retrofitting EE projects in Government Buildings.

Program by SEDA Malaysia

• Sustainable Low Carbon Building Performance System ***

� Documentation of the Low Carbon Building Framework based on past experiences (R&D, demonstration, energy monitoring, etc).

� To support National carbon reduction target.

� Compatible & direct support to LCCF, GreenPASS and Green RE, and it can be used to support other green building rating system.

Development of Low Carbon Buildings (new design & existing buildings).� Development of Low Carbon Buildings (new design & existing buildings).

� Application & Promotion of MS1525 : Code of Practice Use of Energy Efficiency & Renewable Energy for Non-residential Buildings.

• Sustainable Energy in Buildings (supporting the Gov. Lead By Example)

� - Facilitate, assist and providing technical advices on sustainable energy in buildings from time to time.

� - Sustainable Energy Management program.

� - Technical matters on Energy Performance Contracting activities.

� - Energy Auditing & Retrofitting.

� - Monitoring & Verification and Reporting.

Program by SEDA Malaysia

• Low Carbon ICT (“of ICT” and “by ICT”).� Promotion and Development of Low Carbon ICT in government.

� To support the Green ICT program by government.

� To support the Sustainable Low Carbon Building Performance.

� Baseline of energy / carbon emission in ICT.

� Development of Green ICT standard (committee in MCMC/MDeC).

� Building Energy Management System / Energy Monitoring System.

� Auditing, Retrofitting & Performance Monitoring.� Auditing, Retrofitting & Performance Monitoring.

• Capacity Building & Technical Services in Sustainable Energy.� Solar PV Installation.

� Mini Hydro Installation.

� Power Quality Study.

� Energy Audit / Energy management (including thermal energy)

� Energy Efficiency in Chillers & Air conditioning.

� Sustainable Low Carbon Buildings / MS1525 program.

� Low Carbon ICT.

� Retrofitting, Finetuning & Performance Monitoring.

� - Facilitate Energy Performance Contracting (EPC).

� - Facilitating the Government & Private agencies including the Local Councils / PBTs.

Low Carbon Program by SEDA Malaysia

� SEDA’s Low Carbon equation;

Low Carbon

= Sustainable Energy X Operational = Sustainable Energy X Operational Carbon factor (0.747 kgCO2/kwh)

� The low carbon scope is only within the sustainable energy programme. E-waste, recycling, product labelling, waste management are not included since it is out of SEDA

Malaysia scope.

Thank

YouYouTERIMA KASIH

Steve Anthony LojuntinSteve Anthony LojuntinSEDA MalaysiaSEDA Malaysia

Tel / SMS : 019Tel / SMS : 019--2829102 UMS Fax: 0192829102 UMS Fax: 019--23245932324593EE--mail : [email protected] : [email protected]

For further information

THANK YOU

38