21
Crowdsourcing Grows Up Hutch Carpenter Strategic Consultant [email protected] @bhc3

Crowdsourcing Grows Up - Hutch Carpenter

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Crowdsourcing Grows Up

Hutch CarpenterStrategic [email protected]@bhc3

Growing up

2Crowdsourcing grows up

Area Initially Maturation

Idea generation Open suggestion box Campaigns and back-end management

Focus areas Cost savings Wide variety of solutions and insights

Gamification Points, leaderboards Multiple techniques to influence outcomes

Idea Generation

3Crowdsourcing grows up

Initially…Social Suggestion Box

4Crowdsourcing grows up

Online Suggestion Box

Tell us your idea

Submit

SocialSuggestion Box

20

9

An awesome idea

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Nullam scelerisque felis sed.

Jane Smith

Great idea! Have you considered adding…

Thanks! I like your thought…

Suggestion Box

But we ran into problems

5Crowdsourcing grows up

Participation not sustained

Ideas aren’t realistic or

relevant

Ideas don’t get attention

?

No plan to evaluate,

select ideas

Social suggestion box shortcomings…

Addressing the shortcomings

6Crowdsourcing grows up

Campaigns Evaluate & SelectAnswer a specific question Methodically determine

ideas to pursue

We needed to innovate…innovating…

Campaigns

7Crowdsourcing grows up

?

SponsorsSenior executives with bona fide innovation needs

QuestionsWell-formed questions that focus efforts

TimeboxedLimit the duration to drive urgency and meet upcoming milestones

Selection Establish the criteria for selecting ideas addressing the campaign

Evaluate & Select

8Crowdsourcing grows up

EvaluatorsPeople entrusted by the business sponsors to assess ideas

Evaluation CriteriaCharacteristics used to identify ideas’ strengths and weaknesses

ValidationConfirm idea fits internal requirements and beneficiaries’ needs

Selection Establish the criteria for selecting ideas addressing the campaign

Focus Areas

9Crowdsourcing grows up

Harvesting abundance

10Crowdsourcing grows up

Physical proximity

Technologically enabled

Consciously accessed

Progression in tapping our ideas…

Our cognitive abundance

11Crowdsourcing grows up

Participants have lots to offer…

Expansion of crowdsourcing

12Crowdsourcing grows up

Going beyond its roots…

Internal

External

Mature Emerging Future

Cost savings

Products

Services

Margin enhancement

HR policies

Customer jobs-to-be-done

Challenging orthodoxy

What works

Customer experience

Client consulting engagements

Business model

Work processes

Product logistics

Gamification

13Crowdsourcing grows up

Gamification…?

14Crowdsourcing grows up

What motivates us?

15Crowdsourcing grows up

Intrinsic ExtrinsicDesire to act comes

from withinDesire to act is a response

to external stimuli

Extrinsic: increasing utility

16Crowdsourcing grows up

Gamification is a means of shifting the utility curve out

quantity of activity

valu

e de

rived

per

un

it of

acti

vity

In economics, individuals’ utility curves describe the value they receive from something.

Extrinsic motivation is a way of increasing the value derived for each unit of activity.

What is ‘gamification’?

Incorporation of stimuli into an activity to influence people’s actions toward desired outcomes.

17Crowdsourcing grows up

We experience gamification daily

18Crowdsourcing grows up

Lots of gamification techniques!

19Crowdsourcing grows up

1. Achievement2. Appointment dynamic3. Avoidance4. Behavioral contrast5. Behavioral momentum6. Blissful productivity7. Cascading information theory8. Chain schedules9. Communal discovery10. Companion gaming11. Contingency12. Countdown13. Cross situational leaderboards14. Disincentives15. Endless games16. Envy

33. Privacy34. Progression dynamic35. Ratio reward schedules36. Real-time vs. delayed mechanics37. Reinforcer38. Response39. Reward schedules40. Rolling physical goods41. Shell game42. Social fabric of games43. Status44. Urgent optimism45. Variable interval reward schedules46. Variable ratio reward schedule47. Viral game mechanics48. Virtual items

Sources: SCVNGR’s Secret Game Mechanics Playdeck, Techcrunch; Badgeville Gamification Wiki

17. Epic meaning18. Extinction19. Fixed interval reward schedules20. Fixed ratio reward schedule21. Free lunch22. Fun once, fun always23. Interval reward schedules24. Levels25. Lottery25. Loyalty26. Meta game27. Micro leaderboards28. Modifiers29. Moral hazard of game play30. Ownership31. Pride

Four types of gamification

20Crowdsourcing grows up

AchievementI work to attain

an objective

Recognition

My contribution is acknowledged

CompetitionI compete for a limited number

of awards

ValuablesI want to secure

something of value

Tailor gamification to reflect community culture and desired outcomes…

Thank you

21Crowdsourcing grows up

Hutch CarpenterStrategic [email protected]@bhc3