46
We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Presentation on Citizen Voices Matter for Environmental Policy in Wisconsin

Citation preview

Page 1: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

We use the power of the law to support grassroots groups working for environmental justice in the Western Great Lakes region

Page 3: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Wisconsin native Gaylord Nelson believed deeply in the power of ordinary people

The first Earth Day in 1970 allowed 20,000,000 people to stand together and demand federal laws to protect

public health and the environment

Citizens were given significant rights in the major environmental laws passed in response to Earth Day 1970

Page 4: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Richard Nixon signing the Environmental Protection Act into law

Page 5: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The federal Clean Water Act, passed in 1972 is implemented and enforced by the WI-DNR

Page 6: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

What’s Earth Day

and the creation of the US-EPA

got to do ALEC?

Page 7: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Lewis Powell, father of corporate lobbying as we know it today. ALEC was formed in response to Powell’s memo for the national Chamber of Commerce. Nixon appointed him to the Supreme Court.

Page 8: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 9: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

For almost 70 years, Wisconsin’s Secretary was appointed by the seven citizen members of the Natural Resources Board. That process successfully kept the DNR separate from constant political influence and made Wisconsin a model of conservation.

The idea of an independent conservation agency was originally established by Aldo Leopold. Leopold wrote that the 1927 law was needed because "Conservation must have continuity of purpose and policy, and freedom from interference by political control or manipulation.”

Page 10: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Environmental laws don’t enforce themselves and the environment doesn’t have a voice unless we speak up for it.

Arlen ChristensonPublic Intervenor Board

Co-Founder of MEA

Page 11: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

“While I recognize the need for global support for the environment, Ihave always thought that the slogan ‘Think Globally, Act Locally,’ isan important plan of action for everyone.” — Governor Warren Knowles

Republican Governor Warren Knowles created the Public Intervenor Office in 1967

Page 12: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The Public Intervenor defended public rights in the waters and

other natural resources in Wisconsin. These are rights all

Wisconsin citizens are supposed to be able to enjoy without

having to sue special interests that threaten them.

Wisconsin Stewardship NetworkThomas Dawson1976-1995 Kathleen Falk

1983-1995

Page 13: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Governor Tommy Thompson ended the 70-year history of an independent DNR and abolished the Public Intervenor Office in 1995

Melissa Scanlan, MEA’s founder, while still in law school, became determined to restore access to legal and technical services to the people of Wisconsin

People showed up and did their part

Page 14: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

In 2009, Governor Jim Doyle, Democrat, vetoed a bill to restore an independent DNR even though he campaigned on restoring the independence of the DNR and Public Intervenor Office

Page 15: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 16: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 17: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 18: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 19: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Wisconsin passed the first numeric criteria for limiting phosphorus pollution in 2010. Newly elected Walker tried to repeal the rules and since they are now part of federal law, EPA said no. The space between federal standards and state action is what much litigation

is based on, federal oversight matters

Page 20: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The Treml family nearly lost their daughter to Ecoli poisoning after a factory farm contaminated their drinking water well.

The family helped pass restrictions on winter spreading

Page 21: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Where does all the manure go?Karst area of Northeast WIhas one of the highest concentrations of CAFOs in the world

Town of Lincoln in Kewaunee County24% of private wells exceed safedrinking water standards for nitrates42% of private wells are contaminated with coliform bacteria

Page 22: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

One factory farm produces as much as 100 million gallons of untreated animal waste each year. The

waste is then spread on vulnerable Karst areas. One dairy cow produces the waste of 23 humans. In the Town of Lincoln in Kewaunee County, one factory farm generates animal waste

equivalent to a city of 220,000 humans.

Page 23: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The Cocharts are one of several families in the Town of Lincoln challenging the expansion of a factory farm with a history of

polluting drinking water wells.

Page 24: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Citizens in Kewaunee County have taken on the costs and burdens off monitoring pollution that their government can’t or won’t do.

Photo of water samples upstream and downstream from a factory farm

Page 25: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Kewaunee Cares takes an active role in educating their neighbors about the risks from industrial livestock facilities

Page 26: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Frac Sand Mining in Western Wisconsin isCreating landscape-scale destruction and is virtually

unregulated by the DNR

Page 27: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The most dangerous particles are what is left behind and used in “reclamation” of the mining sites.The DNR rejected a citizen petition to regulate respirable crystalline silica dust in spite of known danger

Page 28: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 29: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

The costs and burdens of protecting public health and the environment are wholly on the backs of citizen advocates

WI-DNR refuses to regulate silica dust as a hazardous pollutant and won’t do a cumulative impact study

Page 30: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Gov. Scott Walker speaks at a Freight Rail conference in Madison Wednesday. "I like to say thanks to God and the glaciers" for leaving behind the right kind of sand in Wisconsin, he said. Capital Time 10/10/2013

Page 31: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 32: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 33: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Bright lights, truck traffic, industrial noise 24/7MEA is involved in two air permit challenges and has contracted for technical review of 5 draft permits on behalf of residents in Trempealeau County

Page 34: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 35: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

A majority of Wisconsin citizens were against weakening our environmental laws to allow the construction of the largest

open pit iron mine in the country, in the headwaters of one of the most pristine landscapes remaining in the world, and the home of the Bad River Band of Lake Superior

Chippewa Indians

Page 36: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 37: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Mining Special Interests donated over $15,000,000 to state legislative campaigns before the vote. Signing the Ferrous Mining Law was the first act of Governor Walker in 2013.

Page 38: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 39: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Iron County Board Supervisors have consistently violated open government requirements by back room dealing with the mining company

Citizens in Iron County are holding their county board accountable. 11 of the 14 County Board seats are being contested in spring elections

Page 40: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 41: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Wild Rice Beds in the Kakagon Sloughs40% of ALL wetlands in the Lake Superior Basin are within the Bad River Band’s Reservation Boundaries

Page 42: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Empire open-pit iron mineCliff Natural Resources company, Michigan

Page 43: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2
Page 44: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Ordinary people are the only group that has consistently protected the rights of future generations. We are motivated by love. We will not sell out the future of our children and grandchildren for special interest politics or dirty money.

Page 45: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

Citizen Voices Matter

Citizens have legal rights in the environmentSpecial interest politics & corporate lobbies have diminished the role of science in protecting our air, land and water under a political DNRCitizens’ rights must not be the path of least resistance for lawmakers and regulatorsThe people of Wisconsin don’t see clean air, land and water as a partisan issue

Page 46: Citizen voices matter jan 2014 2

www.midwestadvocates.org

@MidwestAdvocate

/MidwestEnvironmentalAdvocates