81
Projections for the Performance of New Casinos Proposed for Southeastern Kansas Presentation to the Kansas Lottery Lottery Gaming Facility Review Board June 10, 2015 1

Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

  • Upload
    krgc

  • View
    161

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Projections for the

Performance of New

Casinos Proposed for

Southeastern Kansas

Presentation to the Kansas Lottery Lottery Gaming Facility Review Board

June 10, 2015

1

Page 2: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Will E. Cummings

Cummings Associates

2

Page 3: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Questions Please!

– at any time –

3

Page 4: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Overview

Projections in General

Gravity Modeling

“Reilly’s Law of Retail Gravitation”

Extensions by Huff et al.

Projections for Gaming Revenues

Projections for Financial Results

Comparisons

4

Page 5: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Will E. Cummings

Sloan School at MIT

Racing, Sports, Lotteries ... Gaming

60+ Studies of New/Improved Casinos

Private Sector

Regulatory Agencies

Public Policy, Financial, Other Analyses

5

Page 6: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Market Analysis and

Projected Performance of

New Casinos

6

Page 7: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Methodology for Projections

Gravity Model

Year-Round Residents

“Near” Neighbors

Traffic Intercept?

Seasonal Residents?

Hotel Guests?

7

Page 8: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Overview

Location

Location

Size

Everything Else

8

Page 9: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Overview

Location I

Location II

Size

Everything Else

9

Page 10: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Location I:

The Closer, the Better

10

Page 11: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Location I:

The Closer, the Better

=“Friction”

11

Page 12: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Las Vegas Visitation/Distance

0.0

5.0

10.0

15.0

20.0

25.0

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500

La

s V

eg

as V

isito

rs /

00

0 a

du

lts

Distance (miles)

Page 13: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Mississippi Visitors/Day/000

0.0

4.0

8.0

12.0

16.0

20.0

0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700

Mis

sis

sip

pi V

isito

rs/D

ay/0

00

ad

ults

Distance (miles)

Page 14: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Casino X / players’ club data

$0

$200

$400

$600

$800

$1,000

0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400

Ave

rag

e A

nn

ua

l S

pe

nd

ing

/Ad

ult

Distance from Casino X (miles)

Page 15: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Casino Y: players’ club data

$0

$100

$200

$300

$400

$500

0 20 40 60 80 100 120

Ave

rag

e A

nn

ua

l S

pe

nd

ing

/Ad

ult

Distance from Casino Y (miles)

Page 16: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5

ln(distance)

ln(L

as V

eg

as v

isito

rs/0

00

0)

16

Las Vegas Visitation [ log-log ]

Page 17: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Las Vegas: linear slope

y = -1.0082x + 10.75

R2 = 0.9631

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5

ln(distance)

ln(L

as V

eg

as v

isito

rs/0

00

0)

17

Page 18: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Mississippi: steeper slope

y = -1.4088x + 11.25

R2 = 0.9353

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0

ln(distance)

ln(M

issis

sip

pi vis

ito

rs/d

ay/0

00

0)

18

Page 19: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Laughlin: even steeper slope

y = -1.9121x + 16.299R² = 0.9552

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 7.0 7.5 8.0 8.5

ln(L

au

gh

lin v

isito

rs/0

00

0)

ln(distance)

19

Page 20: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Casino X: isolated market

y = -0.8982x + 7.8944

R² = 0.6804

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5

ln(a

dju

ste

d a

nn

ua

l sp

en

din

g/a

du

lt)

ln(distance from Casino X)

20

Page 21: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Casino Y: competitors afar

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5

ln(a

nn

ua

l sp

en

din

g/a

du

lt)

ln(distance from Casino Y)

21

Page 22: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Casino Y: cleaner close

y = -0.886x + 8.0919R² = 0.8505

0.0

1.0

2.0

3.0

4.0

5.0

6.0

7.0

2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5

ln(a

nn

ua

l sp

en

din

g/a

du

lt)

ln(distance from Casino Y)

22

Page 23: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

23

(1.00)

0.00

1.00

2.00

3.00

4.00

5.00

6.00

7.00

1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50

ln(s

pen

din

g p

er

ad

ult

)

ln(distance)

Exhibit A-9: Slot Spending Declines With Distance at Casino Z

per model

per club

per W-2s

Page 24: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

24

(1.00)

0.00

1.00

2.00

3.00

4.00

5.00

6.00

7.00

1.50 2.00 2.50 3.00 3.50 4.00 4.50 5.00 5.50

ln(s

pen

din

g p

er

ad

ult

)

ln(drive time)

Exhibit A-10: Slot Spending Declines With Travel Time at Casino Z

per model

per club

per W-2s

Page 25: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

25

$0

$500

$1,000

$1,500

$2,000

$2,500

$3,000

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0-10 miles 10-20 miles

20-30 miles

30-40 miles

40-50 miles

50-70 miles

70-100 miles

100-150 miles

150-300(±) miles

> 300(±) miles

An

nu

al V

isit

s (

an

d $

Win

) P

er

Pla

yer

Exhibit A-4: Rates of Visitation (and Win) vs. Distance at Casino Z

Trips / Player

$ Win / Player

Page 26: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Overview

Location I

Location II

Size

Everything Else

26

Page 27: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Location II:

Competition

27

Page 28: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

28

Page 29: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

29

Page 30: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Location II:

Reilly’s Law

30

Page 31: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Reilly’s Law:

ms ~ S/d2

Where

ms : market share

S : outlet size (capacity)

d : distance

31

Page 32: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Newton’s Law:

F = m/d2

Where

F : gravitational force

m : mass (conjoined)

d : distance

32

Page 33: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Reilly’s Law:

ms ~ S/d2

Where

ms : market share

S : casino size (capacity)

d : distance

33

Page 34: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Reilly’s Law Extended:

ms ~ S/tt2

Where

ms : market share

S : casino size (capacity)

tt : travel time / convenience

34

Page 35: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

35

Midwest Market Projections

Average Distances:

Impacts:

Closest 2010 Adult ---------------------------------------------

State County ZIP Spdway KStar Campt KSCr CasR Dodge KC7thS Wh Cl Horton Mayetta Powhat Argosy IOC Harrahs St Jo Effective Population 2010 PCI Facility Dstnce Urban? Income Dist-Adj Adults

etc

KS ALLEN 66732 99 129 49 41 76 267 106 155 141 121 146 109 109 111 . . . 144 71 229 $18,125 104% 20% 100% 87% 41 41 41

KS ALLEN 66748 109 115 62 54 87 252 117 152 133 112 138 120 120 122 . . . 152 82 1,991 $18,125 104% 18% 100% 87% 322 322 54

KS ALLEN 66749 100 121 67 59 93 257 108 144 126 105 131 111 111 113 . . . 143 88 6,015 $18,125 104% 17% 100% 87% 925 925 59

KS ALLEN 66751 97 126 62 54 89 261 105 145 129 109 134 108 108 110 . . . 141 84 719 $18,125 104% 18% 100% 87% 114 114 54

KS ALLEN 66755 90 135 57 48 84 271 97 146 133 113 138 100 100 102 . . . 135 80 862 $18,125 104% 18% 100% 87% 142 142 48

KS ALLEN 66772 103 127 45 37 72 267 110 159 145 125 150 113 113 115 . . . 148 67 210 $18,125 104% 21% 100% 87% 39 39 37

KS ANDERSON 66014 66 157 68 59 95 288 73 133 121 102 126 76 76 78 . . . 112 66 231 $17,973 100% 21% 100% 86% 41 41 59

KS ANDERSON 66015 89 130 74 66 101 263 97 133 117 97 122 100 100 102 . . . 132 89 549 $17,973 100% 17% 100% 86% 80 80 66

KS ANDERSON 66032 70 147 82 73 109 277 78 121 107 87 112 82 82 84 . . . 114 70 3,396 $17,973 100% 20% 100% 86% 583 583 70

KS ANDERSON 66033 60 158 83 74 111 287 68 118 105 86 111 72 72 74 . . . 104 60 513 $17,973 100% 22% 100% 86% 98 98 60

KS ANDERSON 66039 78 144 66 57 93 277 86 136 123 103 128 89 89 91 . . . 123 78 464 $17,973 100% 18% 100% 86% 74 74 57

KS ANDERSON 66091 80 139 77 69 104 270 88 128 113 93 118 91 91 93 . . . 123 80 227 $17,973 100% 18% 100% 86% 36 36 69

KS ANDERSON 66093 87 130 83 75 110 261 96 129 109 88 114 99 99 101 . . . 130 87 445 $17,973 100% 17% 100% 86% 66 66 75

KS ATCHISON 66002 42 226 164 155 192 342 50 37 32 44 38 47 52 52 . . . 25 24 9,532 $19,607 100% 42% 100% 90% 3,631 3,631 25

KS ATCHISON 66016 44 214 164 155 191 330 53 37 27 32 33 51 56 55 . . . 37 27 418 $19,607 100% 39% 100% 90% 145 145 27

KS ATCHISON 66023 52 207 170 161 197 321 61 37 20 24 26 59 64 64 . . . 44 20 888 $19,607 100% 49% 100% 90% 389 389 20

: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

: : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : : :

KS WYANDOTTE 66106 9 216 120 110 146 338 7 86 79 65 85 10 11 13 . . . 54 9 15,781 $19,088 100% 84% 100% 89% 11,837 11,837 7

KS WYANDOTTE 66109 7 217 127 117 154 338 10 78 70 58 76 10 14 14 . . . 46 7 10,305 $19,088 100% 100% 100% 89% 9,160 9,160 7

KS WYANDOTTE 66111 7 216 122 112 148 338 7 84 76 63 82 10 11 13 . . . 51 7 7,037 $19,088 100% 100% 100% 89% 6,255 6,255 7

KS WYANDOTTE 66112 7 217 124 115 151 338 8 81 74 61 80 10 11 13 . . . 49 7 7,773 $19,088 100% 100% 100% 89% 6,909 6,909 7

KS WYANDOTTE 66118 13 223 124 115 147 346 7 88 81 69 88 7 7 7 . . . 55 7 1 $19,088 100% 100% 100% 89% 1 1 7

Total KS 1,943,042 870,821

Page 36: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Overview

Location

Location

Size

Everything Else

36

Page 37: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Bigger IS Better

Consumer choice

Micro-environments

Ancillary attractions

Queuing issues even if not capacity-constrained

Economies of scale Ancillary attractions

Player rewards

37

Page 38: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

More Slots, More Spending

y = 43.304x + 207.05

R2 = 0.8607

$0

$200

$400

$600

$800

$1,000

$1,200

$1,400

$1,600

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

"Density" of Slots in Iowa Markets ( = Number of Slots / 000 Adults)

Slo

t S

pendin

g / A

dult

/ Y

ear

38

Page 39: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Overview

Location

Location

Size

Everything Else

39

Page 40: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else” 1

Personal Income

Micro-Access

Spaciousness

Game Mix

Fit & Finish

Management Skill

Marketing / Player Rewards

40

Page 41: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else” 2

Hotel

Parking Garage

Variety of Dining Choices

“ / Retail

“ / Entertainment

“Brand”

Tax / Retention Rate

41

Page 42: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

The Effects of Gaming

Tax / Retention Rate

on Casino Performance

Presentation to the 15th International Conference on

Gambling and Risk Taking

May 31, 2013

42

Page 43: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

43

y = 52.683x + 67.417R² = 0.5478

60.0

70.0

80.0

90.0

100.0

110.0

120.0

30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Po

wer

Rati

ng

Retention Rate

Exhibit 13: Slot Power Rating vs. Casino Retention % (Detail)

Page 44: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

44

y = 54.962x + 66.374R² = 0.8798

60.0

70.0

80.0

90.0

100.0

110.0

120.0

30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%

Po

wer

Rati

ng

Retention Rate

Exhibit 14: Slot Power Rating vs. Retention % (State± Averages)

Page 45: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else”

= “Attractiveness”

45

Page 46: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Reilly’s Law Generalized (Huff+)

weightij = Kn x sizejscoeff x (distij/7)(grav1+grav2)

weightij : weight of casino j in market segment I

Kn: “attractiveness” parameter(s)

sizej : size of casino j

scoeff : size coefficient ≈ 1.0

distij : distance of casino j from market segment i

grav1 : “competitive” gravity coeff. ≈ -2.0

grav2 : “aggregate” gravity coeff. ≈ -0.7

[ Corresponds to Huff lambda, or “friction” = -2.7 ]

46

Page 47: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else”

= “Attractiveness”

47

Page 48: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Attractiveness”

≠ Aesthetics

48

Page 49: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else”

= “Power Ratings”

49

Page 50: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

50

Exhibit 5: Gaming-Device "Power Ratings" in Various US Markets(vs. $700 Benchmark Spending on Slots and/or VLTs Per "Distance-Adjusted" Adult in 2012-14)

(better half only)

Northeastern US Medium to Large Markets Rural / Remote Markets

and Florida Elsewhere Elsewhere

Mississippi average 135.6 n

Deadwood, SD 126.2

Cripple Creek, CO (2) 124.2 n

S Dakota Tribes (avg of 8) 121.3

San Felipe (ABQ), NM 119.1 n Lagunas (3 facils), NM 119.6 n

Downstream Resort, OK 118.8 Black Hawk/CC, CO (2) 118.5 n

Upstate Michigan avg. 118.0 e

Santa Ana (ABQ), NM 117.3 n Kansas Tribes (avg of 4) 116.9 e

Louisiana average 117.1 n Other NM (avg. of 9) 116.6 n

Dodge City, KS 116.1

Turning Stone, NY 115.0 e Sandia (ABQ), NM 115.6 n Upstate Wisconsin avg. 115.0 e

Seneca Salamanca, NY 115.0 e

Diamond Jo Worth, IA 112.9

Emmetsburg, IA 112.1

Iowa Tribes (avg of 3) 111.9 e

Isleta (ABQ), NM 111.4 n Zia Park (Hobbs), NM 111.7 n

Atlantic City, NJ avg. 109.2 SunRay Park, NM 111.3 n

Seneca Niagara, NY 109.2 e Harrahs NKCMO 108.8

Grand Falls, IA (S. Falls, SD) 107.5

Vernon Downs, NY 106.8 Lakeside, IA 106.7

Tioga Downs, NY 106.7 Taos, NM 106.7 n

(Buffalo) Fairgrounds, NY 105.7 Hard Rock Sioux City, IA 105.5

Kansas Star (Wichita) 104.8 Mt. Pleasant, MI 105.0 e

The Downs at ABQ, NM 104.1 n IOC Boonville, MO 104.0 n, o

Mohegan Sun, CT 103.1 Horseshoe / Bluffs Run, IA 103.8 Wisconsin Dells 104.0 e

Michigan City, IN 102.3 n IOC Marquette, IA 102.0 o

Riverside, IA 101.9

Mountaineer Park, WV 101.5 IOC Waterloo, IA 101.2

Foxwoods, CT 100.6

Mohegan @ Pocono Downs, PA 100.4 Dubuque Diamond Jo, IA 100.1

Harrahs Council Bluffs, IA 100.1

Argosy Riverside, MO 100.1

Ocean Downs, MD 99.6 Dubuque Mystique, IA 99.6

Presque Isle, Erie, PA 98.9 Ruidoso Downs, NM 98.9 n

Finger Lakes, NY 98.8

Wheeling, WV 98.0 Ameristar Council Bluffs, IA 98.2

Dover Downs, DE 97.7

The Meadows / Pittsburgh 97.3 Ameristar KCMO 97.2

Saratoga, NY 97.0 Belterra, Florence, IN 96.8 n, o

Harrington Raceway, DE 96.5

Delaware Park 96.2

Mount Airy / Pocono, PA 94.6 Harrahs Joliet, IL 94.0 n, o St Jo MO 94.4 o

Penn National / Harrisburg, PA 93.7 Hollywood @ Speedway, KS 93.6

Jumers Rock Island, IL 93.5

Indiana Grand 92.4

Catfish Bend Burlington, IA 92.0

Hollywood W St Louis 91.6 n

Hoosier Park, IN 91.1

Batavia, NY 90.8 Detroit (avg / 3 facils) 90.7 n

Ameristar, E Chicago IN 90.5 n, o

Prairie Meadows, IA 90.3 Metropolis, IL/KY 90.2 n, o

Midwest Standard +10%

"Midwest Standard"

Page 51: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

51

Exhibit 6: Table-Game Power Ratings in the Midwest(Benchmark = Total Annual Spending of $80 per Distance-Adjusted Adult)

Large Urban Markets Smaller Cities

(or Fed From Such) & Misc. Markets Remote Markets

Des Plaines, IL (Chicago) 143.4

Hammond, IN (Chicago) 129.2

Ameristar E Chicago IN 123.4

Ameristar, Omaha / IA 122.7

Harrahs NKCMO 122.4

Harrahs Joliet, IL (Chicago) 120.8

Ameristar KCMO 118.3 Black Hawk, Colorado 118.1

Hollywood Aurora, IL (Chicago) 117.5

Horseshoe, Omaha / IA 116.5

Holllywood Joliet, IL (Chicago) 116.3 Michigan City, IN 116.4

Elgin, IL (Chicago) 113.9 Dodge City, KS 114.5

H'wood @ KS Speedway 111.5 Kansas Star 111.6 Metropolis, IL / KY 111.6

Majestic Star, Gary IN (Chicago) 111.0 Horseshoe Louisville 111.0 Cripple Creek, Colorado 111.0

Argosy Riverside, (KC)MO 109.8

Belterra, IN 107.9

E St Louis, IL (avg. of 2) 105.4

Ameristar St. Charles, MO 105.3 French Lick, IN 104.8

Worth County, IA 104.7

Boonville, MO 103.3

St Louis, MO (avg. of 3) 100.5

Waterloo, IA 99.7

Lakeside, IA 99.5

Harrahs, Omaha / IA 97.7 DBQ Diamond Jo, IA 96.7

Sioux City, IA 95.3 Deadwood, SD 95.8

Riverside, IA 94.9

Rising Star, IN (Cincin.) 93.4 Evansville, IN 93.9

Hollywood Lawrenceville, IN ( " ) 92.8

Isle of Capri, KCMO 92.0 DBQ Mystique, IA 92.3 Emmetsburg, IA 92.0

Catfish Bend, IA 90.0

E Peoria, IL 88.6

St Jo, MO 87.0 o

Marquette, IA 85.2 o

Downstream, OK 83.3 e

Mark Twain, MO 82.2

Jumers Rock Island, IL 81.9

Clinton, IA 75.4

Grand Falls, IA 73.1

Bettendorf, IA 70.7 o

Davenport, IA 64.0 o

a = annual rate, e = estimated, n = mileage-based or low-resolution estimate, o = old boat, hotel- or capacity-constrained market

Midwest Standard +20%

Midwest Standard +10%

"Midwest Standard"

Midwest Standard -10%

Midwest Standard -20%

Page 52: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Power Ratings Modulate:

Local propensity to spend

Absolute “attractiveness”

Relative ” / Market Share

“Reach” = Rate of exponential decline with distance

52

Page 53: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Gravity Models – Summary

Location

Location

Size

Everything Else

53

Page 54: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

54

$0

$500

$1,000

$1,500

$2,000

$2,500

$3,000

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

0-10 miles 10-20 miles

20-30 miles

30-40 miles

40-50 miles

50-70 miles

70-100 miles

100-150 miles

150-300(±) miles

> 300(±) miles

An

nu

al V

isit

s (

an

d $

Win

) P

er

Pla

yer

Exhibit A-4: Rates of Visitation (and Win) vs. Distance at Casino Z

Trips / Player

$ Win / Player

Page 55: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

55

Page 56: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

More Slots, More Spending

y = 43.304x + 207.05

R2 = 0.8607

$0

$200

$400

$600

$800

$1,000

$1,200

$1,400

$1,600

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

"Density" of Slots in Iowa Markets ( = Number of Slots / 000 Adults)

Slo

t S

pendin

g / A

dult

/ Y

ear

56

Page 57: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else” 1

Personal Income

Micro-Access

Spaciousness

Game Mix

Fit & Finish

Management Skill

Marketing / Player Rewards

57

Page 58: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

“Everything Else” 2

Hotel

Parking Garage

Variety of Dining Choices

“ / Retail

“ / Entertainment

“Brand”

Tax / Retention Rate

58

Page 59: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Projected Gaming

Revenues

59

Page 60: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Assumptions

New casinos’ performance (“power ratings”)

very similar to other new Midwest

Minor modifications for $/position, square footage, etc.

Very similar to Downstream except for “tax” advantage

Rest of the world remains as is No new casinos / enhancements of existing

Exception: “Stressed Case”

Gravity model x local & regional residents Plus small contributions to Castle Rock / I-44

60

Page 61: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

61

Exhibit 7: Slot Power Ratings, etc.

(for comparison)*

Camptown KS Crossing Castle Rock Downstream

Slot Machines 750 625 1,400 2,000

Table Games (not inc. poker) 16 15 35 36

Total Gaming Positions ( " " ) 846 715 1,610 2,216

Baselines for Slots:

Midwest Standard (+) 102.00 102.00 102.00 102.00

Distance from Major Population Center 7.00 6.00 4.00 4.00

Intensity of Competition 1.00 2.00 4.00 3.00 *

Low Payments in lieu of Taxes at Downstream 7.80

Bricks & Mortar $ / Gaming Position (in $100ks) 0.63 0.77 0.59 1.01

Casino Square Footage / Gaming Position (x .02) 0.77 0.56 0.96 0.63

Hotel Rooms / Gaming Position (x 2) 0.15 0.34 0.25 0.35

---------- ---------- ---------- ----------

Total Slot Power Rating 111.55 111.66 111.80 118.80 *

"Reach" (miles before extra decline with distance) 200 200 200 200

Compare: 2008 est. at this location 102.0 N/C 102.0 105.0

* Downstream power rating tuned to actual performance in 2010-11; competition was less intense then.

Note: 100 = "Midwest Standard" power rating. Latest major facilities in Iowa range from 100 to 107. Kansas Star today = 104.8, Boot Hill = 116.1

Slot power ratings at the "Big Three" KCMO facilities currently range from 97 to 104; table ratings from 110 to 123.

I have assumed 111 for tables at all SE KS facilities. Existing Kansas facilities' tables range from 111.7 to 114.5.

Page 62: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

62

Page 63: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Top-Line Gross Gaming $$

63

Camptown KS Cr CasRock

Slots $29.1 $30.3 $44.8

Tables 5.5 6.3 15.0 -------------------------- ---------------------------- ----------------------------

Totals: $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

Number of Slots: 750 625 1,400

Gaming Revenue Projections in 2019 in millions of then-year dollars. Also reflects different numbers of table games at each.

Page 64: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Sources by State

64

Source Market Camptown KS Cr CasRock

Kansas $20.7 $20.3 $10.9

Missouri 10.0 11.8 31.0

Oklahoma 3.4 4.1 14.8

Other Midwest 0.5 0.4 0.6

Traffic Intercept * 0.0 0.0 2.5 -------- ------- ------- Total $34.6 $36.6 $59.8 Net Exports + / - + 18.9 + 21.1 + 55.4

(All $ million in 2019) * Traffic intercept includes some visitors from the states above.

Page 65: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Sources by Type

65

Source Type Camptown KS Cr CasRock

New Spending / Kansas $13.5 $13.6 $2.0

Diverted within Kansas 2.2 1.9 2.4

Import Substitution 5.0 4.8 6.5

Exports 13.9 16.3 48.9

-------- ------- -------

Total $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

Net Exports + / - + 18.9 + 21.1 + 55.4

(All $ million in 2019)

Page 66: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

66

Page 67: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Visitation by State

67

Source Market Camptown KS Cr CasRock

Kansas 335 317 174

Missouri 150 172 485

Oklahoma 43 51 213

Other Midwest 6 5 7

Traffic Intercept * 0 0 29 ------- ------- ------- Total 534 545 908 “Tourists” 121 126 197

(All in thousands in 2019 ) * Traffic intercept includes some visitors from the states above.

Page 68: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

68

Page 69: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Projected Financial

Results

69

Page 70: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Key Financial Metrics

70

Camptown KS Cr CasRock

GGR $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

EBITDA * $3.4 $5.4 $7.9

EBITDA ROI 4.1% 7.2% 5.5%

Total Invested $84.0 $75.2 $144.5

All dollar figures in millions of then-year dollars; GGR in 2019;

EBITDA and ROI average annual rates 2017-2021.

Page 71: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Comparisons

71

Page 72: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

72

Page 73: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

73

Page 74: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

74

Page 75: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

75

Page 76: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

76

Page 77: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Will E. Cummings

Cummings Associates

135 Jason Street

Arlington, MA 02476

(781) 641-1215

[email protected]

77

Page 78: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Questions Please!

78

Page 79: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Top-Line Gross Gaming $$

63

Camptown KS Cr CasRock

Slots $29.1 $30.3 $44.8

Tables 5.5 6.3 15.0 -------------------------- ---------------------------- ----------------------------

Totals: $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

Number of Slots: 750 625 1,400

Gaming Revenue Projections in 2019 in millions of then-year dollars. Also reflects different numbers of table games at each.

Page 80: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Sources by Type

65

Source Type Camptown KS Cr CasRock

New Spending / Kansas $13.5 $13.6 $2.0

Diverted within Kansas 2.2 1.9 2.4

Import Substitution 5.0 4.8 6.5

Exports 13.9 16.3 48.9

-------- ------- -------

Total $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

Net Exports + / - + 18.9 + 21.1 + 55.4

(All $ million in 2019)

Page 81: Cummings Associates (Will Cummings)

Key Financial Metrics

70

Camptown KS Cr CasRock

GGR $34.6 $36.6 $59.8

EBITDA * $3.4 $5.4 $7.9

EBITDA ROI 4.1% 7.2% 5.5%

Total Invested $84.0 $75.2 $144.5

All dollar figures in millions of then-year dollars; GGR in 2019;

EBITDA and ROI average annual rates 2017-2021.