Monitor InstituteA member of the Monitor Group

SAN FRANCISCO SÃO PAULO SEOUL SINGAPORE TOKYO TORONTO ZURICHSHANGHAIPARISMUNICH NEW YORK RIYADH

BEIJING CHICAGO HONG KONGCAMBRIDGE DELHI DUBAI JOHANNESBURG LOS ANGELESLONDONCASABLANCA MOSCOW MUMBAI

HOW ART WORKS: Web Conversation #221 March 2012

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

How Art WorksA theory-driven model & measurement framework for

understanding the impact of art on individuals & communities 2

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

WHERE WE ARE TODAY

3

Phase IIIFinalize

Logic Model(May- June)

Phase ILit Review &

Expert Interviews(Sept – Dec)

Phase IIConvene Working Group Meetings

(Jan – April)

Systems Map& Evaluation Framework

This document includes a more granular version of the systems map for discussion—in preparation for our next workshop in April

SynthesisReport

Introduce & refinehigh-level

systems map

Test & refine more granularsystems map

Highlight (un)certain parts of the system

Identify data to gather or track

Oakland CAWorkshopFeb 22-23

Web Conversation #1

March 14

Web Conversation #2

March 21

Asheville NCWorkshopApril 18-19

WE ARE HERE

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

TODAY’S OBJECTIVES

4

Introduce the revised systems map

Discuss: What does this map do well? What does this map miss?

Walk through the How Art Works Wiki

Success =

We’ve identified those areas in which there’s agreement / disagreement;

We’ve highlighted those areas in which further research is required.

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

A FEW WORDS ON ‘SYSTEM MAPPING’

5

1. A tool for picturing complexity

2. Starts with list of key factors

3. Adds links illustrating flows

4. Captures seeming contradictions, cascades, and feedback

Will help us with our problem…

How are ‘art’ and ‘quality of life’ connected?

Really connected?

What causes what?

And in what sequence?

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

PRIMARY OUTPUT FROM OAKLAND

6

Works of art (10) Artists (5)

Creative capacity (19) Self Actualization (18) Generativity (6)

Community (34) Resilience/memory (15) Right to culture (7) Happiness (3) Cultural Equity (3) Spiritual Literacy (0)

Market Place (11) Economic Value (6)

Values (13) Empathy (10)

Aesthetics (18) Education (10)

Time & place (4) Tech innovation (1)

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

New Modes of Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for Creative

ExpressionArts

Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE An Emergent ‘Big-Picture’ View

7

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE Four Primary Inputs

New Modes of Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for Creative

ExpressionArts

Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

8

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE Four Types of Impact

New Modes of Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for Creative

ExpressionArts

Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

9

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE Critical Impact Cascade

New Modes of Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for Creative

ExpressionArts

Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

10

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE Key Social, Cultural and Personal Derivatives

New Modes of

Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for

Creative Expression

Arts Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative

Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

11

CAS-COD-Prez-Date-CTLCUL-TUR-SystemsMap-03-12-12-DD

THE ARTS IMPACT APPLE Highlights to Facilitate Discussion

New Modes of

Expression

Human Nature

Subsidies

Arts Infrastructure

Artists

Works of ArtsCommercial Outlets for

Creative Expression

Arts Experiences

Creative Capacity of

Society

Economic Value of the Arts

Community and Social Value of

Art

Individual Value of Art

Education and Training

Social Appeal of Creative Pursuits

Personal Appeal of Creative

Pursuits

Local Vitality

Sense of Belonging

12