Upload
richard-platt
View
836
Download
2
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
This presentation was created by Richard Platt - Managing Partner of the Strategy + Innovation Group and Pete Rooks Director of the Leadership and Professional Programs of the University of Portland A PROFESSIONAL APPROACH TO OVERCOMING ORGANIZATIONAL INERTIA AND ENTROPY
Citation preview
A PROFESSIONAL APPROACH TO OVERCOMING ORGANIZATIONAL
INERTIA AND ENTROPY
INSTRUCTORS:
RICHARD PLATT: STRATEGY + INNOVATION GROUP - MANAGING PARTNER
PETE ROOKS: UNIVERSITY OF PORTLAND – DIRECTOR, LEADERSHIP and PROFESSIONAL PROGRAMS
• What is the problem / opportunity?
• Why do we care?
– Who here is happy w/ everything at work?– What are the challenges that you are having
at work?
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 3
THE NEED FOR EFFECTIVE
LEADERSHIP MODELS Increasing competitive demands meeting increasing
ineffectiveness of current leadership models
Leading more diverse (younger/international) workforce with new /different demands than previous generations
Greater emphasis on quality & service; “getting by” doesn’t cut it
Greater complexity of systems and simultaneously managing a more independent workforce
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 4
THE NEED FOR EFFECTIVE LEADERSHIP MODELS
Less employees to do more work, greater engagement required.
Conflict of managing by demand / edict vs. leading by influencing employees
Prevalent issue of dysfunctional organizational & individual performance
Leading by values, beliefs, and mission alone are not enough for the task
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 5This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 5
THE POWER OF PROFESSIONALISM
“Technical competency will get you onto the green. But a professional puts it into the cup every time”
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 6This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 6
WHY PROFESSIONALISM MATTERS
Professionals hold it together under difficult circumstances
Professionals 1. Demonstrate mastery in their work
2. Conduct themselves in a way that engenders trust
Choosing to be a Professional provides an identity that raises your sights above mediocrity
People who view themselves as professionals outperform, outsmart and outlast others
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 7This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 7
WHY PROFESSIONALISM MATTERS
The Effectiveness of a Professional is Balanced
“What You Do”(blade #1)
Skill Set(Technical Competency)
“How” you go about Your Work
(blade #2)
Mind Set(Leadership Competency)
Note: Experts are not necessarily Professionals
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 8This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 8
FOUNDATIONS OF PROFESSIONALISM
Trust: The One Thing You Have to Get Right
With Trust: people are more confident, proactive and hopeful
Without Trust: people are more skeptical, withdrawn and pessimistic
Gaining Trust is based on supporting another’s priorities, protecting their self-interests and respecting their values
3 elements needed in order to Build Trust: Character, Competence and Judgment
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 9This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 9
FOUNDATIONS OF PROFESSIONALISM
Trust: (Continued)
Consistency, an inseparable correlation between it and trust. You cannot have trust without it.
Show up as a professional, not merely when it suits your needs
No mixed messages, be clear
No double standards,
No creative rationalizations
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 10This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 10
FOUNDATIONS OF PROFESSIONALISM
The Big Picture Acting responsibly Being self-reliant Demonstrating loyalty Being industrious Exercising discipline and restraint Taking pride in one’s work and having a reputation of being trustworthy
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 11
LYING AND SPINNING
Self-Deception is the real issue
Recovery from making mistakes Insure people understand why a mistake
was made and
Lying – once you lie – trust is lost
Spinning is very close to lying
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 12This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 12
THE POWER OF PROFESSIONAL MIND-SETS
The Power of Mind-sets is about who a person is, NOT what a person does
They transcend temperament, social hierarchy or intellectual prowess
They are NOT techniques, they are NOT situational dependent – they are Principle Centered
They are relevant and applicable to ALL
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 13This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 13
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
MS#1: Professionals Have a Bias for Results
Delivering results demonstrates trustworthiness
Deliver the Right Results in the Right Way • Ensure outcomes are sustainable, not just a flash in
the pan
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 14This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 14
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
MS#2: Professionals Realize (and Act) They're part of Something Bigger Than Themselves Commit to the success of the firm, organization
or client.
Realize success transcends your own parochial interests.
Collaborate as an effective team member
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 15This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 15
MS#3: Professionals Know Things Get Better When They Get Better
Disaster / Aid Workers
Selfless Efforts in the For-Profit World • Giving back to the Community
Personal example • Near death, significant losses and the march back
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 16This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 16
MS#4: Professionals Have Personal Standards Often Transcending Organizational Ones
Have a personalized core set of values
Do what’s right over what’s expedient by taking a long view
Rise above the fray, stay focused and avoid pointless drama
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 17This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 17
MS#5: Professionals know That Personal Integrity is All they Have
3 Very Important underpinnings of Integrity:
1. Authenticity and honesty
2. Delivering on one’s commitments (both explicit and implicit)
3. Refusing to violate the trust others have extended to us
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 18This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 18
MS#6: Professionals Aspire to Be Masters of Their Emotions Not Enslaved by them
3 by-products of Mastering one’s emotions (and inspiring trust in others):
1. Professionals are respecting when it’s difficult to be respectful
2. Professionals maintain their objectivity and keep their wits about them – Don’t take things personally
3. Professionals manage their ego and resist the urge for immediate gratification
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 19This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 19
MS#7: Professionals Aspire to Reveal Value in Others
“Aspire” suggests intent, priority and, most importantly, proactively
Professionals who hold this mind-set: Readily extend trust
• Where & When appropriate – don’t be naive – that’s stupid
Recognize the value other professionals bring to the table.
Aspire to lift others through their demeanor and actions
7 MIND-SETS OF TRUSTED PROFESSIONALS
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 20This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 20
PROFESSIONAL IDEALS: THE CENTERPIECE OF SUCCESS
Start with yourself
Leverage people’s natural motivations
Be persistent
Build your Culture - Competitive Advantage is Hiding in Plain Sight• Make Professional Standards the Foundation
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 21This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 21
PLATT’S LEADERSHIP PRINCIPLESWhat does an (effective) leader do?
Platt’s (NCO) Leadership List*:
(1) Diagnostic Mindset (Seek reasons why things aren’t working)
(2) Effective Mindset (Seek to be Effective, NOT to be Right or perfect)
(3) Empathetic Mindset (Seek to Empathize w/ everyone, but don’t comprise your values – helps in ending conflict w/ the rational)
(4) Speak Truth to Power (be Honest & Authentic – good Exec’s want to know what is really going on)
(5) Enable the People (empower ‘em w/ knowledge of the goals)
(6) Equip the People (give ‘em the tools and the understanding)
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 22This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 22
PLATT’S LEADERSHIP PRINCIPLES What does an (effective) leader do?
Platt’s (NCO) Leadership List*:
(7) Educate the People (teach your people to do the right things right, efficiency and speed naturally follows)
(8) Evaluate the People (be fair and judicious – don’t be a petty tyrant)
(9) Entrusts the Team to Achieve (trust but verify – see #6)
(10) Removes Roadblocks (get political if necessary)
(11) Leads from the Front & Backs up the Rear (they are empowered but you are responsible, no one takes a hit that is yours to take for the team)
(12) True Care of Your People (you are a steward of the firm’s people, you don’t own them, your job is to help them, but don’t be afraid to discipline them)
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 23
ROOKS LEADERSHIP PHILOSOPHY
PEOPLE are the single most important part of any organization
TRUST and TEAMWORK are fundamental to success – and develop from individual relationships based on mutual values, assumptions, beliefs and expectations
LEADERS OF CHARACTER establish a clear direction and destination for the organization and then align, motivate, and inspire voluntary response to get there
Continuous CHANGE and IMPROVEMENT of all aspects of the organization is essential – evolutionary transformation leading to revolutionary outcomes
Ultimately, the only thing that counts is RESULTS – what gets measured gets done
There is no substitute for a positive, can-do ATTITUDE, ASK How instead of Why
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 24
RESOLVING THE DILEMMA
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
GOT LEVERAGE?
Mind Set Skill Set
StrategyDiagnosis Insights – looking for assumptions and contradictions
Strategic Intent
Strategic Policy
Strategic & TacticalActions
Competitive Frameworks / Tools / Methods
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 25
5 DYSFUNCTIONS OF TEAMSInattention to RESULTS
Avoidance of ACCOUNTABILITY
Lack of COMMITTMENT
Fear of CONFLICT
Absence of TRUST
Fear of being vulnerable with team =
Artificial harmony for the sake of peace =
Ambiguity & Failure to Buy-in to decisions =
Unwillingness to call peers on performance or behaviors =
Caring about something other than the collective goals of the group =
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 26
HOW FUNCTIONAL TEAMS BEHAVE
Artificial Harmony
Mean-Spirited Personal Attacks
Ideal Conflict Point
DestructiveConstructive
How do you define success?
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 27
Causes of Fear and Dysfunction Entitlement Self-Interest Putting Oneself Above the Rules
Some companies even have individual promotion / compensation programs that support this
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
WHAT LIMITS ORGANIZATIONS FROM BECOMING GREAT?
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 28
THE DARK SIDE OF SUCCESS
Individual and Organizational Challenge of the Inevitable Downward spiral of Repeated Successes
Basic Guideline: Honesty with oneself and NEVER, EVER believe your own PR
Repeated Successes
Attitude of “we can do no wrong”
Arrogance
Complacency
Decline
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 29
THE COST OF THE DYSFUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION
25% Avg. Profitability Difference (20-30% range) between “Remarkable” vs. “Unremarkable” firms (dysfunctional culture)
Can be as high as 50%
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
“Culture, a fancy word for the habituated thinking of an organization, rightly or wrongly”
-RP
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 30
THE COSTS OF THE DYSFUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION
Those working in an uncivil work environment• 48% decreased their work effort• 47% decreased their time at work• 38% decreased their work quality• 66% said their performance declined• 80% lost work time worrying about (an uncivil) incident• 63% lost time avoiding the (uncivil) offender • 78% said their commitment to the organization declined
Bad Apple Syndrome Negative comments are 5X stronger than good Caustic people will infect and bring down performance in short time frames
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 31
DYSFUNCTION’S IMPACT
BOTTOM LINE: Dysfunction causes 25 - 50% Lower Profitability and Productivity, Higher Healthcare costs and Higher Employee turnover
Performance gains are hindered by poor work processes that in turn creates toxic employees
Toxic Employees / Leaders • Have a significant negative financial ripple effect on an firm’s
performance and profitability (Bad Apple Syndrome)• They’ll likely block necessary strategies to achieve performance
gains (Maintaining status quo irrationally)
Organizations need a multi-pronged strategy to eradicate the effects of operating in a
dysfunctional stateThis material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 32
ROOT CAUSE
Only 1% of the population is Sociopathic so… Pointing at people alone as the problem is not a
complete answer
We Believe the workaround to the issues are..
Misunderstanding what an effective Professional Leader really means and does
Lack Knowing “How-To” effectively Influence others
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 33
ORGANIZATIONAL LIMITATIONS
Successful companies & the strategies they use often owe a great deal to the inertia and inefficiency of rivals
An organization’s greatest challenge may not be external threats or opportunities but instead to the effects of inertia and entropy
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 34
DIAGNOSIS OF THE PROBLEM
Organizational Inertia: is an organization’s unwillingness or inability to adapt to changing circumstances
Organizational Entropy: measures a organizational system’s degree of disorder, and without intervention will always increase
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
THE DIAGNOSIS AND A SOLUTION SET
By Allan Cohen and David Bradford
By James Haskett By Christine Pearson and Christine Porath
By Charles Duhigg
The Diagnosis (Inertia & Entropy) The Solution Set
Context = Your Organization’s Culture
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 36
FORMAL AND INFORMAL ORGANIZATION
Written Rules: Organizational structure, rules, procedures, values, beliefs, mission, goals,
processes, work division, reporting structure, policy, technologies, financial, products,
services
Unwritten Rules: unstated individual values, beliefs, informal processes, power, informal leaders, psychological needs, coalitions / cliques, friendships & enemies, informal
social norms and codes, feelings, perceptions etc..
Formal Organization
Informal Organization
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 37
FORMAL AND INFORMAL ORGANIZATION
Written Rules: Organizational structure, rules, procedures, values, beliefs, mission, goals,
processes, work division, reporting structure, policy, technologies, financial, products,
services
Unwritten Rules: unstated individual values, beliefs, informal processes, power, informal leaders, psychological needs, coalitions / cliques, friendships & enemies, informal
social norms and codes, feelings, perceptions etc..
Formal Organization
Informal Organization
ManagerLeader
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 38
VISUAL CULTURE DEFINITION (Intersecting Leaders and Managers)
Manager: Manages Processes, Systems,
etc…
Leader: Leads People
“How We Do Things Here”
“What We Do Here”
Formal Organization
Informal Organization
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 39
A GOOD-TO-GREAT VISION
Good-To-Great company transformations don’t happen without Level 5 Leaders driving the organization
Very Important Factors
1. Getting the Right people on the bus
2. Getting the Wrong people off the bus
3. Creating a Culture of Discipline
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 40
THE PERFORMANCE MODEL
Performance
=
Ability x Mindset x Opportunity
A x M x O = P
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 41
WHAT WE KNOW
The Challenge to becoming a Level 5 Leader is that they haven’t overcome their own attitudes of self-interest, entitlement or putting themselves above the rules. (Level 4 and below)
Skill Set
Mind Set
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 42
WHAT A LEVEL 5 LEADER DOES Mr. Collins
emphasizes attempt to start from a level 5 leadership position.
Contrarily, we recommend “Disciplined Thought” 1st , “Disciplined Action 2nd” then develop into a Level 5 Leader
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 43
PLATT & ROOKS RECOMMEND
1st Disciplined
Thought
2nd Disciplined
Action
Develop into a Level 5 Leader
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 44
WHY THIS APPROACH INSTEAD?As much as 70% of what we do every day is based
on Habit…Overcoming the Challenge:
Habit vs. Conscious Thought
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 45
Why This Works
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 46This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 46
STRATEGIES FOR CHANGE
“The change’s (and innovations) implemented in an organization are effectively introduced using Currencies of Exchange”
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 47
INFLUENCE WITHOUT AUTHORITY MODEL STEPS
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 48
WHAT EVERYONE MISSES ABOUT ORGANIZATIONS
(Change Management Iceberg)
Formal______________
Informal
Image: courtesy of 12manage.com
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 49
RECOMMENDED CURRENCIES (FREQUENTLY VALUED IN ORGANIZATIONS)
Source: Table 3.1 Currencies Frequently Valued in Organizations “Influence Without Authority” Allan R. Cohen and David L. Bradford.—2nd ed.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 50
RECOMMENDED CURRENCIES (FREQUENTLY VALUED IN ORGANIZATIONS)
Source: Table 3.1 Currencies Frequently Valued in Organizations “Influence Without Authority” Allan R. Cohen and David L. Bradford.—2nd ed.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 51
SOMETIMES NECESSARY NEGATIVE CURRENCIES
(STRONG CAUTION IN THEIR USE)
Source: Table 3.2 Common Negative Currencies “Influence Without Authority” Allan R. Cohen and David L. Bradford.—2nd ed.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 52Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 52
RISKY COMMUNICATIONS
1 N = 3 P(One negative statement is equal to three positive statements)
– Vince Covello, PhD, Speaker National Public Health Leadership Development Network April, 2003
Biggest Behavior Issue Noted for Many: Negative Currency Exchanges are a Default setting
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 53
BARRIER’S TO INFLUENCE
Source: Table 1.2 and 2.4 Common Barriers to Influence “Influence Without Authority” Allan R. Cohen and David L. Bradford.—2nd ed.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 54
IDENTIFY CURRENCIES (WHAT IS VALUED): THE ALLY’S AND YOURS
To make trades, you need to be aware of many things people care about and all the valuables you have to offer.
Positive Currencies1. Inspiration-related
2. Task-related
3. Position-related
4. Relationship-related
5. Personal
Negative Currencies
1. Withholding payment of a known valuable currency
2. Using directly undesirable currencies
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 55
CHANGE MANAGEMENT ICEBERG(according to Wilfried Krüger)
Top of the Iceberg: – Most managers only consider
the topBelow the Surface:
– Management of Perceptions and Beliefs
– Power and Politics Management
People Involved in Change– Opponents– Promoters– Hidden Opponents– Potential Promoters
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 56This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
WHAT EVERYONE MISSES ABOUT ORGANIZATIONS
(An Early Change Implementation Toolbox)
The myriad tasks to do with the Organization
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 57
AN INTENTIONAL PLAN
FOR ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE (Implementation Management)
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 58
IGNORE THE LAW OF RECIPROCITY
AT YOUR PERIL
Reciprocity is the almost universal belief that people should be paid back for what they do — that one good (or bad) turn deserves another.
This belief about behavior, in societies all over world, carries over into organizational life.
Example: “an honest day’s work for an honest day’s pay”
People generally expect that those people they’ve done things for “owe them,” and will roughly balance the ledger and repay costly acts with equally valuable ones.
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 59This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 59
“EXERTING INFLUENCE” WITHOUT AUTHORITY
We think is about developing:Lateral Leadership a constellation of skills and honing those
skills over time and practicing them.
How do you start building your capabilities?
Networking: Cultivate a broad network of relationships (internally / externally) to carry out your intentions.
Constructive Persuasion: Make persuasion and negotiation constructive rather than manipulative, view everyone as an ally (not a target).
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 60This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 60
“EXERTING INFLUENCE” WITHOUT AUTHORITY
We think is about developing:
Consultation: Take time to visit the people whose buy-in you need before starting to work on a project.
Coalition Building: Fact: several people who are collectively advocating an idea exert more influence that a lone proponent.
THE TOOLS AND
TEMPLATES
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 62
ARE YOU READY FOR THE CHALLENGE?Conviction Courage Capability
Firm belief thata) Change isneeded, andb) The change isright …anIntellectualcommitment
Willingness to “do the right thing” and take on the necessary personal and professional risks and sacrifices…a ‘gut” emotional commitment
The ability to act effectively on commitments…a matter of talent, skills, experience and support
Yourself
Others Around and Below You
Top Management
→ →
Source: “Real Change Leaders”, Jon R. Katzenbach and the RCL Team. 1999
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 63This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 63
CAREFUL DIAGNOSIS
Evaluate the other’s interests, assess your currencies, attention to the relationship — is necessary when: The other person or group is known to be resistant. You don’t know the other people and are asking
something that might be costly to them. You have a poor relationship (or are part of a group that
has a poor relationship with the group the other person belongs to).
You are asking for something that could be a big burden to give.
You might not get another chance.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 64
ORGANIZATIONAL CHANGE MODEL FORMULA
Important Note: All 3 components must be present to overcome the resistance to change:
• Dissatisfaction with the present situation
• A Vision of what is possible in the future
• Achievable First steps towards reaching that vision
Powerful tool for quick 1st impression of the possibilities and conditions to change an organization
If any of these are zero or near zero, then the possibility of change will also be near zero and the resistance to change will dominate
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 65
SOME BASIC GUIDANCE ON INFLUENCE
Know Yourself Know Your Opponent / Ally Know the Terrain / Environment
- Sun Tzu author of “The Art of War”
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 66
FORCES THAT SHAPE BEHAVIOR AND PERSONALITY
Source: Table 4.1 Contextual Forces that Shape Behavior along with Personality “Influence Without Authority” Allan R. Cohen and David L. Bradford.—2nd ed.
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 67
HOW TO KNOW WHAT MIGHT BE
IMPORTANT TO THE OTHER PERSON
The Potential Ally’s Job Tasks1. Does the person deal with numbers all day or with people?
2. Is the work repetitive or highly varied?
3. Does the person experience demands for careful accuracy and replicability or get rewarded for originality and improvisation?
4. Is the person subject to constant demands from others or the one who makes many demands on them?
5. Is the person in a high-risk, high-visibility position or a secure protected role?
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 68
POTENTIAL ALLY’S ENVIRONMENT
Other factors that shape task demands include degree of contact with:
The environment outside the organization Top management Headquarters The sales / marketing force The factory floor Exotic or temperamental equipment The media Task Uncertainties Ally’s Worries
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 69
ALLY’S EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
Major Forces Outside the Organization that drive behavior include:
The state of the economy
How threatened people feel about jobs and mobility
Major competition (China example)
Legal rulings affecting the industry or company
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 70
POTENTIAL ALLY’S WORRIES
Ask yourself what keeps the boss up at night? If you don’t know, think about it. You never will get what you want from your boss if you can’t quite pinpoint what it is that worries him or her most:
Long-term competition from China? Or issues of off-sourcing jobs?
Meeting next week’s payroll?
Merger rumor mill?
Fear of boss’s wrath for missing a budgeted expense number?
Impact of exotic new technologies?
How to confront dug-in resisters on their nasty political games?
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 71
THE APPROACH – MANAGING UP, ACROSS, OR DOWN
To get the kind of influence with your boss that will pay off, there are 4 main things to do:
1. See the boss as a potential ally (a partner).
2. Make sure you really understand the boss’s world.
3. Be aware of the resources (currencies) you already have or can acquire.
4. Pay attention to how the other wants to be related to.
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 72
CLARIFY YOUR GOALS AND PRIORITIES
Knowing what you want from the potential ally isn’t always easy. The dimensions that affect the choice of how you should proceed are:
What are your primary versus your secondary goals?
Are they short-term or long-term objectives?
Are they “must-have” needs or “nice-to-haves” that can be negotiated away?
Is your priority task accomplishment or preserving / improving the relationship?
This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 73This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 73
Staying on course:1. Everyone with whom you interact should be seen as a
potential ally.
2. It pays to begin by making positive assumptions about your potential allies.
3. In a marketplace, everyone is a potential customer.
4. We all have more power than we realize. We just do not realize which currencies we have in our pocket.
Its essence: “Do unto others as they would have themselves have done unto them”
INFLUENCE WITHOUT AUTHORITYBy Allan Cohen and David Bradford
THE HOMEWORK
Working on a real issue, at work, at home, at school, anywhere…
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 75This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 75
10X YOUR INFLUENCE
Source: Change Anything
DisconfirmingData
Denial
Anger
Bargaining
Despair
Experimentation
Hope
Integration
Emotional response to change
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 76This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 76
SIX SOURCES OF INFLUENCE
Source: Change Anything
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 77This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 77
THE 6 SOURCES STRATEGY MATRIX
Source: Change Anything
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 78This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 78
THE 6 SOURCES STRATEGY MATRIX
Source: Change Anything
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 79This material MAY NOT be distributed to others, copied or reproduced without the express consent of the author
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 79
THE 6 SOURCES STRATEGY MATRIX
Source: Change Anything
Q&A BACKUP
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 81
PROOF OF DYSFUNCTIONCompany Industry # of employees Customer’s Served Dysfunctional Behavior identified
Intel Corp Semiconductor ~100,000 (2006) Major OEM’s and ODM’s in the Electronics industry,
Observed co-option (stealing of employee ideas and passing them off as your own), employee manipulation, bullying of employees to get results at all costs, “brute forcing” problem solving versus a process orientation. Observed conflicting styles, perceptions, pressures, roles and unpredictable policies between managers and employees. Multiple instances of refusal to reasonable suggestions for improvement
Company A Electronic Manufacturing Services, contract manufacturing
~100 (2008) Aerospace, Consumer Electronics, Military
Observed VP of Engineering (a co-owner) denigrating and verbally abusing employees, and marginalizing employee contributions. Observed conflicting styles and perceptions
Company B Electronics, Military and Aerospace
~130,000 (2010) Government, Military and Aerospace
Observed conflicting styles, perceptions, pressures, roles and unpredictable policies between managers and employees.
Company C HR and Recruiting Services
~100 (2011) Hiring function of company HR departments
Observed President (owner) publically, verbally abusing employees, marginalized employee contributions. Refusal to reasonable suggestions for improvement
Company D Industrial Equipment Manufacturing
~300 (2011) Printed Circuit Board Manufacturers
Observed conflicting styles, perceptions, goals, pressures and unpredictable policies between managers and employees. Refusal to reasonable suggestions for improvement
Company E Printed Circuit Board Manufacturer
~2000 (2011) Electronics Manufacturing Services firms, OEMs and ODMs in consumer electronics, military and aerospace
Observed conflicting styles, perceptions, goals, pressures and unpredictable policies between managers and employees. Refusal to reasonable suggestions for improvement
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 82
IMPORTANT DEFINITIONS
Definitions: Civility: (Noun) Formal politeness and courtesy in behavior or speech.
Polite remarks used in formal conversation.
Remarkable: (Adjective) Worthy of attention; striking. Synonyms: notable - noteworthy - extraordinary – outstanding
Bullying: (Verb) To use superior strength or influence to intimidate (someone), typically to force him/her to do what one wants. Bullying is an act of repeated aggressive behavior in order to intentionally hurt another person, physically or mentally.
Dysfunctional: (Adjective) Not operating normally or properly. Deviating from the norms of social behavior in a way regarded as negative.
Dysfunction is a far better description of the cause• Civility, can be used to hide dysfunctional / destructive behavior, like a veil
covering up what is actually going on in a firm.• Remarkable / Unremarkable definitions are not readily defined in Dr.
Haskett’s work
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 83
BUILDING TRUST
Trust is the foundation of teamwork
On a team, trust is all about vulnerability which is difficult for most people
Building trust takes time but the process can be greatly accelerated
Like a good marriage, trust on a team is never complete; it must be managed over time
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 84
MASTERING CONFLICT
Good conflict among team members requires trust, which is all about engaging in unfiltered, passionate debate around issues
Conflict will at times be uncomfortable; Conflict norms, must be discussed and made clear
The fear of occasional personal conflict should not deter a team from having regular, productive debate
Most people don’t really need to have their ideas adopted (e.g. “get their way”), in order to buy in to a decision. They just want to have their ideas heard, understood, considered and explained within the context of the ultimate decision
Artificial Harmony
Mean-Spirited Personal Attacks
Ideal Conflict Point
DestructiveConstructive
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 85
ACHIEVING COMMITMENT
Commitment requires clarity and buy-in
Clarity requires teams avoid assumptions and ambiguity, and they end discussions with a clear understanding about what they’ve decided upon
Buy in does not require consensus. Members of great teams learn to disagree with one another and still commit to a decision
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 86
EMBRACING ACCOUNTABILITY
Peer pressure and distaste for letting down a colleague will motivate a team player more than fear of authoritative punishment or rebukes
The most important challenge of building an accountable team is overcoming the hesitance to give one another critical feedback
Help people realize that when they fail to provide peers with constructive feedback they are letting down the team and you personally. By holding back, we are hurting not only each other but the team as well
The best opportunity for holding one another accountable is during meetings, between peers, and best done by a leader’s willingness to tackle difficult issues
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 87
FOCUSING ON RESULTS
Teams have to eliminate ambiguity and interpretation when it comes to success
Results oriented teams establish their own measurements for success. They don’t allow themselves wriggle room of subjectivity, even though it’s attractive
When team members stop caring about the scoreboard, they inevitably stop caring about something else
The key to team success is that members go beyond barter and compromise to embrace a collective pursuit of the best interests of the whole
Self interest, sometimes drowns out the cry of the team and the collective results of the group are left behind
Copyright Protected | Property of the Strategy + Innovation Group 88
EXAMPLE: CHALLENGE & COMMITMENT MAPConviction Courage Capability
Firm belief thata) Change isneeded, andb) The change isright …anIntellectualcommitment
Willingness to “do the right thing” and take on the necessary personal and professional risks and sacrifices…a ‘gut” emotional commitment
The ability to act effectively on commitments…a matter of talent, skills, experience and support
John Olden (purchasing dept. head; critical to success of product design reengineering team)
- sees no big issues in product design processes (sees main problem as sales)-Doesn’t see big role for purchasing in improving design process- May think entire reengineering effort is just a fad pushed by someone for their own glory
+ Good record of taking on tough projects (dept consolidation in 2003)+ Always willing to speak his mind (reamed CEO for awarding Acme contract)
+ 20 years of experience+ Knows vendors capabilities intimately- Probably doesn’t understand reengineering concept and mechanics
→ →In this situation some fact sharing (to build conviction) and exposure to reengineering (to build capability) would go a long
way to build Jim’s commitment