39
Evaluating a resource for online teacher professional development across four continents: the MESH Guide to Spelling Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham Marilyn Leask, University of Bedfordshire Richard Proctor, University of Bedfordshire Sarah Younie, De Montfort University

EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Presentation to Network 16 at EERA-ECER 2014 Reports research demonstrating that teachers prefer more challenging content on cognition to simply downloading lesson plans

Citation preview

Page 1: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Evaluating a resource for online teacher professional development across four continents: the MESH Guide to Spelling

Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham Marilyn Leask, University of BedfordshireRichard Proctor, University of BedfordshireSarah Younie, De Montfort University

Page 2: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Who uses it? When? How?

… and Why?

The MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling

What is it?

Page 3: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Who uses it? … and Why?

The MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling

“Online teacher professional development has increased exponentially, [but] evidence of the effectiveness of such self-directed learning is often anecdotal and based on immediate rather than long-term impact” (Dede, 2009).

Page 4: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

The MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling

“Online teacher professional development has increased exponentially, [but] evidence of the effectiveness of such self-directed learning is often anecdotal and based on immediate rather than long-term impact” (Dede, 2009).

Self-directed learning

Page 5: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

The MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling

“Online teacher professional development has increased exponentially, [but] evidence of the effectiveness of such self-directed learning is often anecdotal and based on immediate rather than long-term impact” (Dede, 2009).

Page 6: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Plan B Plan CPlan A

Plan D

Page 7: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Plan B Plan CPlan A

Plan D

Plan E

Page 8: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Plan B Plan CPlan A

Plan D

Plan E

Page 9: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Plan E

Page 10: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Plan E

Page 11: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 12: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 13: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 14: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 15: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What is MESH?? 

Page 16: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What is MESH? 

Page 17: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What is MESH?•Mapping Educational Specialist knowHow•A global partnership•A quality assured 'wikipedia' of professional knowledge for teaching •http://www.meshguides.org/•All resources are free

Page 18: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What is the MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling?•“A quality assured 'wikipedia' of professional knowledge for teaching spelling” (My Dad, personal communication, 2014)

•http://www.richprocter.co.uk/cgi-bin/pathways/spelling.pl

Page 19: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 20: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 21: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison
Page 22: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Site visit data - Google Analytics: How many?

Page 23: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Who is using the MESH Guide to Teaching Spelling?•Questionnaire - Google Docs•Site visit data - Google Analytics

Page 24: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Questionnaire - Google Docs

Page 25: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Site visit data - Google Analytics: From where?

Page 26: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Site visit data - Google Analytics: Country

OECD?

Page 27: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Google Analytics: How is the site being used?

Page 28: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Google Analytics: How is the site being used?• Which pages are popular? Theory or Resources?

Page 29: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

• Google Analytics: How is the site being used?• Which pages are popular? Theory or Resources?

Plan E

Page 30: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

123 January- 18 AugN = 1,570 site visits

Page 31: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12

Page 32: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12 3

Page 33: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12 3 4

Page 34: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12 3 4

5

Page 35: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12 3 4

5

Plan E

Page 36: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

12 3 4

5

Plan E

Page 37: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What does accommodation involve?

• It is multifactorial:• New theories of how

children learn• New discourse tools• New schemata for

pedagogy• It involves restructuring

cognitive architecture• It requires criticality• It implies provisionality

and uncertainty

Page 38: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

What is the take-home message from this data?

1,221 teachers from 50 nations want well-informed theory to develop theirpractice more than they want resources

Page 39: EERA2014 Evaluating the MESH Guide to teaching spelling. Colin Harrison

Evaluating a resource for online teacher professional development across four continents: the MESH Guide to Spelling

Colin Harrison, University of Nottingham Marilyn Leask, University of BedfordshireRichard Proctor, University of BedfordshireSarah Younie, De Montfort University