106
Pathways to Successful Pathways to Successful and Sustainable Economic and Sustainable Economic Development Development The Role of Community in The Role of Community in Economic Development Economic Development

Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

This presentation was my presidential address at the joint annual meeting of the Community Development Society and Rural Sociological Association held in Boise, ID, July, 2011.

Citation preview

Page 1: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Successful and Pathways to Successful and Sustainable Economic Sustainable Economic

DevelopmentDevelopment

The Role of Community in The Role of Community in Economic DevelopmentEconomic Development

Page 2: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Taking the JourneyTaking the Journey Going to Zoobieland Going to Zoobieland

AKA Brigham Young UniversityAKA Brigham Young University

Page 3: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Taking the JourneyTaking the Journey Going to Zoobieland Going to Zoobieland

AKA Brigham Young UniversityAKA Brigham Young University Driving across America to embark on Driving across America to embark on

an adventure called graduate school an adventure called graduate school at Middle Tennessee State at Middle Tennessee State University.University. Making of a professional sociological Making of a professional sociological

colleaguecolleague

Page 4: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Taking the JourneyTaking the Journey Going to Zoobieland Going to Zoobieland

AKA Brigham Young UniversityAKA Brigham Young University Driving across America to embark on Driving across America to embark on

an adventure called graduate school at an adventure called graduate school at Middle Tennessee State University.Middle Tennessee State University. Making of a professional sociological Making of a professional sociological

colleaguecolleague Iowa State UniversityIowa State University

Making of a practitionerMaking of a practitioner

Page 5: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Taking the JourneyTaking the Journey Going to Zoobieland Going to Zoobieland

AKA Brigham Young UniversityAKA Brigham Young University Driving across America to embark on an Driving across America to embark on an

adventure called graduate school at adventure called graduate school at Middle Tennessee State University.Middle Tennessee State University. Making of a professional sociological colleagueMaking of a professional sociological colleague

Iowa State UniversityIowa State University Making of a practitionerMaking of a practitioner

Delta State UniversityDelta State University

Page 6: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Teaching Community and Teaching Community and Economic DevelopmentEconomic Development

Challenge of making the reality of Challenge of making the reality of doing development match the doing development match the theory.theory.

Page 7: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Teaching Community and Teaching Community and Economic DevelopmentEconomic Development

Challenge of making the reality of Challenge of making the reality of doing development match the doing development match the theory.theory.

Impact of academic research and the Impact of academic research and the past journeys of academicians and past journeys of academicians and practitioners are critical.practitioners are critical.

Page 8: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Teaching Community and Teaching Community and Economic DevelopmentEconomic Development

Challenge of making the reality of Challenge of making the reality of doing development match the doing development match the theory.theory.

Impact of academic research and the Impact of academic research and the past journeys of academicians and past journeys of academicians and practitioners are critical.practitioners are critical.

Learning by doing.Learning by doing.

Page 9: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

PurposePurpose

Examine the impact of community in Examine the impact of community in economic development through the economic development through the eyes of the two journals, eyes of the two journals, Rural Rural Sociology Sociology and and Journal of the Journal of the Community Development SocietyCommunity Development Society. .

Page 10: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

PurposePurpose

Examine the impact of community in Examine the impact of community in economic development through the economic development through the eyes of the two journals, eyes of the two journals, Rural Rural Sociology Sociology and and Journal of the Journal of the Community Development SocietyCommunity Development Society. .

Largely taken from the journals from Largely taken from the journals from 2000-2011.2000-2011.

Page 11: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Taking a community from point A to Taking a community from point A to point B. point B.

Page 12: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Taking a community from point A to Taking a community from point A to point B. point B.

Working to assist them in Working to assist them in accomplishing their vision.accomplishing their vision.

Page 13: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Taking a community from point A to Taking a community from point A to point B. point B.

Working to assist them in Working to assist them in accomplishing their vision.accomplishing their vision.

““Some of what I do every day is to Some of what I do every day is to keep an eye on the road from a 30,000 keep an eye on the road from a 30,000 perspective while simultaneously perspective while simultaneously trying to fix the engine in the car.”trying to fix the engine in the car.”

Page 14: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan

Page 15: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Creating a map for successCreating a map for success

Page 16: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Creating a map for successCreating a map for success Preparation for the journeyPreparation for the journey

Page 17: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Creating a map for successCreating a map for success Preparation for the journeyPreparation for the journey Tells us if we are on courseTells us if we are on course

Page 18: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Doing DevelopmentDoing Development

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Creating a map for successCreating a map for success Preparation for the journeyPreparation for the journey Tells us if we are on courseTells us if we are on course Provides a vision of where we are going Provides a vision of where we are going

to be and whento be and when

Page 19: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Community InputCommunity Input Numerous studies have demonstrated Numerous studies have demonstrated

the need for community involvement the need for community involvement for economic development to be both for economic development to be both effective and sustainable.effective and sustainable. Pittman, et al., 2009Pittman, et al., 2009 Green, et al., 2005Green, et al., 2005 Richards & Brod, 2004Richards & Brod, 2004 Sullivan, 2004Sullivan, 2004 Korsching and Allen, 2004Korsching and Allen, 2004

Page 20: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Community-based research to Community-based research to determine the most effective meansdetermine the most effective means Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al., Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al.,

2007)2007)

Page 21: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Community-based research to Community-based research to determine the most effective meansdetermine the most effective means Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al., Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al.,

2007)2007) Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al., Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al.,

2002)2002)

Page 22: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Community-based research to Community-based research to determine the most effective meansdetermine the most effective means Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al., Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al.,

2007)2007) Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al., Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al.,

2002)2002) Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998; Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998;

Chazdon & Lott, 2010)Chazdon & Lott, 2010)

Page 23: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Community-based research to Community-based research to determine the most effective meansdetermine the most effective means Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al., Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al.,

2007)2007) Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al., Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al.,

2002)2002) Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998; Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998;

Chazdon & Lott, 2010)Chazdon & Lott, 2010) Understanding the community network Understanding the community network

(Sharp, 2001)(Sharp, 2001)

Page 24: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Community-based research to determine Community-based research to determine the most effective meansthe most effective means Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al., Focus groups (Flora, 1998; Pavey, et al.,

2007)2007) Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al., 2002)Secondary data analysis (Parisi, et al., 2002) Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998; Chazdon Key informant surveys (Flora, 1998; Chazdon

& Lott, 2010)& Lott, 2010) Understanding the community network Understanding the community network

(Sharp, 2001)(Sharp, 2001) Case studies (Zeuli, et al., 2004)Case studies (Zeuli, et al., 2004)

Page 25: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Coordination with other organizationsCoordination with other organizations Community visioning (Moss & Community visioning (Moss &

Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., 2010)2010)

Page 26: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Coordination with other organizationsCoordination with other organizations Community visioning (Moss & Community visioning (Moss &

Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., 2010)2010)

Community narratives (Steffensmeier, Community narratives (Steffensmeier, 2010)2010)

Page 27: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Coordination with other organizationsCoordination with other organizations Community visioning (Moss & Community visioning (Moss &

Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., 2010)2010)

Community narratives (Steffensmeier, Community narratives (Steffensmeier, 2010)2010)

Large group interventions (Hammer, Large group interventions (Hammer, 2010)2010)

Page 28: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Pathways to Community Pathways to Community InvolvementInvolvement

Coordination with other organizationsCoordination with other organizations Community visioning (Moss & Community visioning (Moss &

Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., Grunkemeyer, 2010; Lachapelle, et al., 2010)2010)

Community narratives (Steffensmeier, Community narratives (Steffensmeier, 2010)2010)

Large group interventions (Hammer, 2010)Large group interventions (Hammer, 2010) Creation of representative community Creation of representative community

boards (Robinson and Hales, 2007) boards (Robinson and Hales, 2007)

Page 29: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development PlanCommunity Economic Development Plan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Proactive (Blakely and Leigh, 2012) – Proactive (Blakely and Leigh, 2012) – Focuses on planning for rather than reacting to events Focuses on planning for rather than reacting to events

that occur in a community region. that occur in a community region. Establishes a forward thinking model.Establishes a forward thinking model. Builds a local economy on the basis of local needs.Builds a local economy on the basis of local needs. Helps communities adopt a long-range view of Helps communities adopt a long-range view of

development.development. Simple fact that most developers last 3-4 years in a Simple fact that most developers last 3-4 years in a

position.position.

Page 30: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Representative – Representative – Encourages collaboration with Encourages collaboration with

community/regional entities (Aigner, et al. 2002)community/regional entities (Aigner, et al. 2002) GovernmentGovernment BusinessBusiness Civil societyCivil society

Page 31: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Representative – Representative – Utilizes diverse approaches (Robinson & Green, Utilizes diverse approaches (Robinson & Green,

2011)2011) Technical assistance approachTechnical assistance approach Self-help approachSelf-help approach Interactional approachInteractional approach

Page 32: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development PlanCommunity Economic Development Plan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Asset-based (Kretzmann & McKnight, 2003) – Asset-based (Kretzmann & McKnight, 2003) – Focuses on asset verses deficit model of developmentFocuses on asset verses deficit model of development Focuses on promoting development using existing assets as Focuses on promoting development using existing assets as

the base for development efforts (Crowe, 2006)the base for development efforts (Crowe, 2006) Treats external assets as ancillary assets that assist in the Treats external assets as ancillary assets that assist in the

development process rather than drive it (Albrecht, 2004)development process rather than drive it (Albrecht, 2004) Works to build the collective and individual assets in a Works to build the collective and individual assets in a

community (Grinstein-Weiss, et al., 2007)community (Grinstein-Weiss, et al., 2007)

Page 33: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development PlanCommunity Economic Development Plan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Asset-based (Green & Haines, 2012)Asset-based (Green & Haines, 2012) Based on the notion of nested development where Based on the notion of nested development where

each development effort builds on the efforts and each development effort builds on the efforts and outcomes of the past. outcomes of the past.

Assessment based on a nested logic model (Robinson Assessment based on a nested logic model (Robinson & Hales, 2007).& Hales, 2007).

Immediate outputsImmediate outputs Intermediate outcomesIntermediate outcomes End outcomesEnd outcomes

Page 34: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Identification of Existing Identification of Existing Community ResourcesCommunity Resources

Community Economic Development PlanCommunity Economic Development Plan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Forms of Resources/Capital (Flora and Flora, Forms of Resources/Capital (Flora and Flora, 2008)2008)

Natural capitalNatural capital Cultural capitalCultural capital Human capitalHuman capital Social capitalSocial capital Political capitalPolitical capital Financial capitalFinancial capital Built capitalBuilt capital

Page 35: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Inclusive (Beer, 2009)Inclusive (Beer, 2009) IndustryIndustry RetailRetail EntrepreneursEntrepreneurs All sectors of the communityAll sectors of the community

Diverse voices - Age, sex, race/ethnicity, Diverse voices - Age, sex, race/ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, etc.religion, sexual orientation, etc.

Page 36: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development PlanCommunity Economic Development Plan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Sustainable (Anglin, 2011; Hembd & Silberstein, Sustainable (Anglin, 2011; Hembd & Silberstein, 2011)2011)

““Development that meets the needs of the present Development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs” (The World Commission on to meet their own needs” (The World Commission on Environment and Development, 1987, p. 43.)Environment and Development, 1987, p. 43.)

Focuses on development that emerges from or with the Focuses on development that emerges from or with the community rather than to or for the community.community rather than to or for the community.

Page 37: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Holistic – PRAISEworthyHolistic – PRAISEworthy

Equitable (Richardson and London, 2007)Equitable (Richardson and London, 2007) The U.S. has a history of promoting uneven The U.S. has a history of promoting uneven

development in both policy and practice.development in both policy and practice. Equitable development engages efforts to address Equitable development engages efforts to address

social justice (Salkin and Lavine, 2008).social justice (Salkin and Lavine, 2008). Works to insure that the costs and benefits of Works to insure that the costs and benefits of

development efforts are spread across the development efforts are spread across the community/region (Blakely and Leigh, 2010).community/region (Blakely and Leigh, 2010).

Page 38: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan FIVE “tions”FIVE “tions”

PromotionPromotion Community buzzCommunity buzz Community buy-inCommunity buy-in

Page 39: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan FIVE “tions”FIVE “tions”

ImplementationImplementation The best laid plans….The best laid plans…. Starting with a bangStarting with a bang Following throughFollowing through Changing on the flyChanging on the fly

Page 40: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan FIVE “tions”FIVE “tions”

DocumentationDocumentation Gas stations, restaurants, and restroomsGas stations, restaurants, and restrooms Potholes and pitfallsPotholes and pitfalls Orange barrels and hard hatsOrange barrels and hard hats

Page 41: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan FIVE “tions”FIVE “tions”

EvaluationEvaluation Checking the oilsChecking the oils Kicking the tiresKicking the tires RefuelingRefueling Checking the mapChecking the map

Page 42: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Creating a Plan for SuccessCreating a Plan for Success

Community Economic Development Community Economic Development PlanPlan Five “tions”Five “tions”

CelebrationCelebration Looking at slide showsLooking at slide shows Sharing with friendsSharing with friends Planning the next tripPlanning the next trip

Page 43: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

What?What? When?When? Where?Where? Who?Who? How?How? WHY?????WHY?????

Page 44: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

What? (The principle of low hanging What? (The principle of low hanging fruit)fruit) What is it you are proposing to do?What is it you are proposing to do? What will the project do to promote What will the project do to promote

where you want to go?where you want to go? What needs to happen to be successful What needs to happen to be successful

at this project?at this project?

Page 45: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

WhenWhen When will the project take place?When will the project take place? When must critical decisions be made When must critical decisions be made

regarding specifics of the plan?regarding specifics of the plan? DeadlinesDeadlines FundingFunding

When will you know if you have arrived?When will you know if you have arrived?

Page 46: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

WhereWhere Where will the project take place?Where will the project take place?

Page 47: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

Who?Who? Who needs to be involved in the project Who needs to be involved in the project

for it to succeed?for it to succeed? Who are the starters?Who are the starters? Who are the stoppers?Who are the stoppers? Who will take the lead?Who will take the lead?

Page 48: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

How?How? How will the event come together?How will the event come together? How will the project affect the residents? How will the project affect the residents?

Will the effects be equitable?Will the effects be equitable?

Page 49: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Six Development QuestionsSix Development Questions

Why?Why? Why do this project over another Why do this project over another

project?project? Is there another project that may be Is there another project that may be

more effective to take on first?more effective to take on first? Will this project increase our community Will this project increase our community

and economic viability?and economic viability?

Page 50: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Page 51: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Largely abandoned downtownLargely abandoned downtown

Page 52: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Largely abandoned downtownLargely abandoned downtown University located a business incubatorUniversity located a business incubator

Page 53: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Largely abandoned downtownLargely abandoned downtown University located a business incubatorUniversity located a business incubator Established a Historic Downtown District Established a Historic Downtown District

with accompanying board and directorwith accompanying board and director

Page 54: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Largely abandoned downtownLargely abandoned downtown University located a business incubatorUniversity located a business incubator Established a Historic Downtown District Established a Historic Downtown District

with accompanying board and directorwith accompanying board and director Focused on promoting downtown Focused on promoting downtown

redevelopmentredevelopment

Page 55: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Page 56: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Page 57: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses

Page 58: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses Developed an asset-based nested 7-year Developed an asset-based nested 7-year

strategic planstrategic plan

Page 59: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #1Case Study #1 Historic Downtown Hattiesburg, MSHistoric Downtown Hattiesburg, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses Developed an asset-based nested 7-year Developed an asset-based nested 7-year

strategic planstrategic plan Currently ahead of schedule in Currently ahead of schedule in

development initiativesdevelopment initiatives

Page 60: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Downtown BeforeDowntown Before

Page 61: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Downtown AfterDowntown After

Page 62: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Downtown AfterDowntown After

Page 63: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Page 64: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Historically impoverished, rural, lumber Historically impoverished, rural, lumber dominated countydominated county

Page 65: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Historically impoverished, rural, lumber Historically impoverished, rural, lumber dominated countydominated county

Dramatically affected by Hurricane Dramatically affected by Hurricane KatrinaKatrina

Page 66: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Historically impoverished, rural, lumber Historically impoverished, rural, lumber dominated countydominated county

Dramatically affected by Hurricane Dramatically affected by Hurricane KatrinaKatrina

Significant grant monies identified Significant grant monies identified

Page 67: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Historically impoverished, rural, lumber Historically impoverished, rural, lumber dominated countydominated county

Dramatically affected by Hurricane Dramatically affected by Hurricane KatrinaKatrina

Significant grant monies identified Significant grant monies identified University asked to assist in strategic University asked to assist in strategic

planning processplanning process

Page 68: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Historically impoverished, rural, lumber Historically impoverished, rural, lumber dominated countydominated county

Dramatically affected by Hurricane Dramatically affected by Hurricane KatrinaKatrina

Significant grant monies identified Significant grant monies identified University asked to assist in strategic University asked to assist in strategic

planning processplanning process Determined that there were already 15 Determined that there were already 15

existing strategic plansexisting strategic plans

Page 69: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Page 70: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Rather than do yet another strategic Rather than do yet another strategic plan, examined existing plansplan, examined existing plans

Page 71: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Rather than do yet another strategic Rather than do yet another strategic plan, examined existing plansplan, examined existing plans

Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on specific outcomesspecific outcomes

Page 72: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Rather than do yet another strategic Rather than do yet another strategic plan, examined existing plansplan, examined existing plans

Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on specific outcomesspecific outcomes

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Page 73: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Rather than do yet another strategic Rather than do yet another strategic plan, examined existing plansplan, examined existing plans

Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on Neither PRAISEworthy nor focused on specific outcomesspecific outcomes

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses

Page 74: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Created a 5-year action plan to Created a 5-year action plan to capitalize on the existing strategic plans capitalize on the existing strategic plans and focus on the 5 “tions”and focus on the 5 “tions”

Page 75: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Created a 5-year action plan to Created a 5-year action plan to capitalize on the existing strategic plans capitalize on the existing strategic plans and focus on the 5 “tions”and focus on the 5 “tions”

Lacked community buy-in/ownershipLacked community buy-in/ownership

Page 76: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #2Case Study #2 Southern CountySouthern County

Created a 5-year action plan to Created a 5-year action plan to capitalize on the existing strategic plans capitalize on the existing strategic plans and focus on the 5 “tions”and focus on the 5 “tions”

Lacked community buy-in/ownershipLacked community buy-in/ownership Few measureable outcomes resulted in Few measureable outcomes resulted in

part due to the foundational issues of part due to the foundational issues of the county and the lack of ownership in the county and the lack of ownership in the development processthe development process

Page 77: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Page 78: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Historically impoverished, Historically impoverished, undereducated, racially segregatedundereducated, racially segregated

Page 79: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Historically impoverished, Historically impoverished, undereducated, racially segregatedundereducated, racially segregated

Few perceived resources or alternativesFew perceived resources or alternatives

Page 80: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Historically impoverished, Historically impoverished, undereducated, racially segregatedundereducated, racially segregated

Few perceived resources or alternativesFew perceived resources or alternatives Grant funding identifiedGrant funding identified

Page 81: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Historically impoverished, Historically impoverished, undereducated, racially segregatedundereducated, racially segregated

Few perceived resources or alternativesFew perceived resources or alternatives Grant funding identifiedGrant funding identified Funding used to conduct strategic Funding used to conduct strategic

planning session and establish bi-planning session and establish bi-community boardcommunity board

Page 82: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Page 83: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses

Page 84: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses Developed an asset-based nested 5-year Developed an asset-based nested 5-year

strategic planstrategic plan

Page 85: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Case Study #3Case Study #3 Drew, MSDrew, MS

Conducted preliminary secondary data Conducted preliminary secondary data analysis, focus groups, key informant analysis, focus groups, key informant surveys, and later community meetingssurveys, and later community meetings

Conducted resource analysesConducted resource analyses Developed an asset-based nested 5-year Developed an asset-based nested 5-year

strategic planstrategic plan Results on-going 7 years laterResults on-going 7 years later

Page 86: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Downtown BeforeDowntown Before

Page 87: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

DowntownDowntown

Page 88: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Downtown AfterDowntown After

Page 89: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Analysis of Case StudiesAnalysis of Case Studies When conducted effectively, When conducted effectively,

strategic planning can have strategic planning can have meaningful, long-lasting resultsmeaningful, long-lasting results

Page 90: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Analysis of Case StudiesAnalysis of Case Studies When conducted effectively, When conducted effectively,

strategic planning can have strategic planning can have meaningful, long-lasting resultsmeaningful, long-lasting results

Community buy-in is critical in the Community buy-in is critical in the processprocess

Page 91: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Analysis of Case StudiesAnalysis of Case Studies When conducted effectively, strategic When conducted effectively, strategic

planning can have meaningful, long-planning can have meaningful, long-lasting resultslasting results

Community buy-in is critical in the Community buy-in is critical in the processprocess

When based on existing assets, much When based on existing assets, much more sustainablemore sustainable

Page 92: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Analysis of Case StudiesAnalysis of Case Studies When conducted effectively, strategic When conducted effectively, strategic

planning can have meaningful, long-planning can have meaningful, long-lasting resultslasting results

Community buy-in is critical in the processCommunity buy-in is critical in the process When based on existing assets, much When based on existing assets, much

more sustainablemore sustainable Synergistic natureSynergistic nature

Page 93: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for ResearchImplications for Research

Community-based research in Community-based research in economic development remains a economic development remains a viable body of research.viable body of research.

Page 94: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for ResearchImplications for Research

Community-based research in Community-based research in economic development remains a economic development remains a viable body of research.viable body of research.

Must examine the impact of Must examine the impact of community in economic development community in economic development with measureable outcome variables.with measureable outcome variables.

Page 95: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase

Page 96: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork

Page 97: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork Representative body and tacticsRepresentative body and tactics

Page 98: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork Representative body and tacticsRepresentative body and tactics Asset-based developmentAsset-based development

Page 99: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork Representative body and tacticsRepresentative body and tactics Asset-based developmentAsset-based development Inclusivity of ideas and groupsInclusivity of ideas and groups

Page 100: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork Representative body and tacticsRepresentative body and tactics Asset-based developmentAsset-based development Inclusivity of ideas and groupsInclusivity of ideas and groups Sustainability of the initiativesSustainability of the initiatives

Page 101: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Implications for PracticeImplications for Practice Utilization of community groups in Utilization of community groups in

economic development will increase economic development will increase Proactive stance to doing development Proactive stance to doing development

workwork Representative body and tacticsRepresentative body and tactics Asset-based developmentAsset-based development Inclusivity of ideas and groupsInclusivity of ideas and groups Sustainability of the initiativesSustainability of the initiatives Equitable distribution of costs and benefitsEquitable distribution of costs and benefits

Page 102: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

ReferencesReferences Aigner, S. M., V. J. Raymond, and L. J. Smidt. 2002. “Whole community organizing Aigner, S. M., V. J. Raymond, and L. J. Smidt. 2002. “Whole community organizing

for the 21for the 21stst century.” century.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 33(1)., 33(1). Albrecht, D. E. 2004. “Amenities, natural resources, economic restructuring, and Albrecht, D. E. 2004. “Amenities, natural resources, economic restructuring, and

socioeconomic outcomes in nonmetropolitan America.” socioeconomic outcomes in nonmetropolitan America.” Journal of the Community Journal of the Community Development SocietyDevelopment Society, 35(2), 36-52., 35(2), 36-52.

Anglin, R. V. 2011. Anglin, R. V. 2011. Promoting Sustainable Local and Community Economic Promoting Sustainable Local and Community Economic DevelopmentDevelopment, Cleveland, OH: CRC Press., Cleveland, OH: CRC Press.

Beer, A. 2009. “The theory and practice of developing locally.” In J. E. Rowe’s Beer, A. 2009. “The theory and practice of developing locally.” In J. E. Rowe’s (Ed.) (Ed.) Theories of Local Economic Development. Theories of Local Economic Development. Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 63-92.Burlington, VT: Ashgate, 63-92.

Blakely. E. J. and N. G. Leigh. 2012. Blakely. E. J. and N. G. Leigh. 2012. Planning Local Economic Development: Planning Local Economic Development: Theory and Practice (4Theory and Practice (4thth Ed.) Ed.). Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.

Chazdon, S. A. and S. Lott. 2010. “Ready for engagement: Using key informant Chazdon, S. A. and S. Lott. 2010. “Ready for engagement: Using key informant interviews to measure community social capacity.” interviews to measure community social capacity.” Journal of the Community Journal of the Community Development SocietyDevelopment Society, 41(2), 156-175., 41(2), 156-175.

Crowe, J. A. 2006. “Community economic development strategies in rural Crowe, J. A. 2006. “Community economic development strategies in rural Washington: Toward a synthesis of natural and social capital.” Washington: Toward a synthesis of natural and social capital.” Rural Sociology, Rural Sociology, 71(4), 573-596.71(4), 573-596.

Flora, C. B. and J. L. Flora. 2008. Flora, C. B. and J. L. Flora. 2008. Rural Communities: Legacy and ChangeRural Communities: Legacy and Change (3 (3rdrd Ed.). Ed.). Boulder, CO: Westview Press. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Flora, J. 1998. “Social capital and communities of place.” Flora, J. 1998. “Social capital and communities of place.” Rural SociologyRural Sociology, 63(4), , 63(4), 481-506481-506..

Page 103: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

References (Cont.)References (Cont.) Green, G. P., S. C. Deller, and D. W. Marcouiller. 2005. Green, G. P., S. C. Deller, and D. W. Marcouiller. 2005. Amenities and Rural Amenities and Rural

Development: Theory, Methods, and Public PolicyDevelopment: Theory, Methods, and Public Policy. Northampton, MA: Edward . Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar Publishing.Elgar Publishing.

Green, G. P. and A. Haines. 2012. Green, G. P. and A. Haines. 2012. Asset Building and Community Asset Building and Community DevelopmentDevelopment. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.

Grinstein-Weiss, M, J. Curley, and P. Charles. 2007. “Asset building and rural Grinstein-Weiss, M, J. Curley, and P. Charles. 2007. “Asset building and rural communities: The experience of individual development accounts.” communities: The experience of individual development accounts.” Rural Rural Sociology, Sociology, 72(1), 25-46.72(1), 25-46.

Hammer, J. M. 2010. “Large group interventions as a tool for community Hammer, J. M. 2010. “Large group interventions as a tool for community visioning and planning.” visioning and planning.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, , 41(2), 209-222.41(2), 209-222.

Hembd, J. and Silberstein. 2011. “Globalization and community Hembd, J. and Silberstein. 2011. “Globalization and community development: Synergy or disintegration.” Indevelopment: Synergy or disintegration.” In J. W. Robinson and G. P. Green’s J. W. Robinson and G. P. Green’s (Eds.) (Eds.) Introduction to Community Development: Theory, Practice, and Service Introduction to Community Development: Theory, Practice, and Service Learning.Learning. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.

Korsching, P. K. and J. C. Allen. 2004. “Local entrepreneurship: A Korsching, P. K. and J. C. Allen. 2004. “Local entrepreneurship: A development model based on community interaction field theory.” development model based on community interaction field theory.” Journal of Journal of the Community Development Societythe Community Development Society, 35(1), 25-43., 35(1), 25-43.

Kretzmann, J. P. and J. L. McKnight. 2003. Kretzmann, J. P. and J. L. McKnight. 2003. Building Communities from the Building Communities from the Inside Out: A Path Toward Finding and Mobilizing a Community's AssetsInside Out: A Path Toward Finding and Mobilizing a Community's Assets , , Evanston, IL: Institute for Policy Research.Evanston, IL: Institute for Policy Research.

Page 104: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

References (Cont.)References (Cont.) Lachapelle, P., M. Emery, and R. L. Hays. 2010. “The pedagogy and the practice Lachapelle, P., M. Emery, and R. L. Hays. 2010. “The pedagogy and the practice

of community visioning: Evaluating effective community strategic planning in of community visioning: Evaluating effective community strategic planning in rural Montana.” rural Montana.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 41(2), 176-191., 41(2), 176-191.

Moss, M. L. and W. T. Grunkemeyer. 2010. “Building a shared vision for Moss, M. L. and W. T. Grunkemeyer. 2010. “Building a shared vision for sustainable communities.” sustainable communities.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, , 41(2), 240-254.41(2), 240-254.

Parisi, D., S. M. Grice, M. Taquino, and D. A. Gill. 2002. “Building capacity for Parisi, D., S. M. Grice, M. Taquino, and D. A. Gill. 2002. “Building capacity for community efficacy for economic development in Mississippi.” community efficacy for economic development in Mississippi.” Rural SociologyRural Sociology, , 33(2), 19-38. 33(2), 19-38.

Pavey, J. L., A. B. Muth, D. Ostemeier, and M. L.E. Steiner Davis. 2007. “Building Pavey, J. L., A. B. Muth, D. Ostemeier, and M. L.E. Steiner Davis. 2007. “Building capacity for local governance: An application of interactional theory to developing capacity for local governance: An application of interactional theory to developing a community of interest.” a community of interest.” Rural Sociology Rural Sociology 72(1), 90-110.72(1), 90-110.

Pittman, R., E. Pittman, R. Phillips, and J Cangelosi. “The community and Pittman, R., E. Pittman, R. Phillips, and J Cangelosi. “The community and economic development chain: Validating the links between processes and economic development chain: Validating the links between processes and outcomes.” outcomes.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 40(1), 80-93., 40(1), 80-93.

Richards, R.T. and R.L. Brod. 2004. “Community support for a gold cyanide Richards, R.T. and R.L. Brod. 2004. “Community support for a gold cyanide process mine: Resident and leader differences in rural Montana.” process mine: Resident and leader differences in rural Montana.” Rural SociologyRural Sociology 16(4), 552-575.16(4), 552-575.

Richardson, J. A., Jr. and J. K. London. 2007. “Strategies and lessons for reducing Richardson, J. A., Jr. and J. K. London. 2007. “Strategies and lessons for reducing persistent poverty: A social justice approach to funding rural community persistent poverty: A social justice approach to funding rural community transformation.” transformation.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 38(1), 92-107., 38(1), 92-107.

Page 105: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

References (Cont.)References (Cont.) Robinson, J. W, Jr. B. D. Hales. 2007. “Models and methods for creating sustainable Robinson, J. W, Jr. B. D. Hales. 2007. “Models and methods for creating sustainable

community-based development organizations in diverse communities.” community-based development organizations in diverse communities.” Community Community DevelopmentDevelopment, 38(2), 33-51., 38(2), 33-51.

Robinson, J. W., Jr. and G. P. Green. 2011. Robinson, J. W., Jr. and G. P. Green. 2011. Introduction to Community Introduction to Community Development: Theory, Practice, and Service Learning.Development: Theory, Practice, and Service Learning. Los Angeles, CA: Sage Los Angeles, CA: Sage Publishers.Publishers.

Salkin, P. and A. Lavine. 2008. “Understanding community benefits agreements: Salkin, P. and A. Lavine. 2008. “Understanding community benefits agreements: Equitable development, social justice and other considerations for developers, Equitable development, social justice and other considerations for developers, municipalities and community organizations.” municipalities and community organizations.” UCLA Journal of Environmental Law & Policy, 26..

Sharp, J. 2001. “Locating the community field: A study of interorganizational Sharp, J. 2001. “Locating the community field: A study of interorganizational network structure and capacity for community action.” network structure and capacity for community action.” Rural Sociology, Rural Sociology, 66(3), 403-66(3), 403-424.424.

Steffensmeier, T. 2010. “Building a public square: An analysis of community Steffensmeier, T. 2010. “Building a public square: An analysis of community narratives.” narratives.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 41(2), 255-268., 41(2), 255-268.

Sullivan, D. M. 2004. “Citizen participation in nonprofit economic development Sullivan, D. M. 2004. “Citizen participation in nonprofit economic development organizations.” organizations.” Journal of the Community Development SocietyJournal of the Community Development Society, 34(2), 58-72. , 34(2), 58-72.

World Commission on Environment and Development. 1987. World Commission on Environment and Development. 1987. From One Earth to From One Earth to One World: An OverviewOne World: An Overview. Oxford: Oxford University Press,. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 43.43.

Zeuli, K., D. Freshwater, D. Markley, and D. Barkley. 2004. “Cooperatives in rural Zeuli, K., D. Freshwater, D. Markley, and D. Barkley. 2004. “Cooperatives in rural community development: A new framework for analysis.” community development: A new framework for analysis.” Journal of the Community Journal of the Community Development SocietyDevelopment Society, 35(2)., 35(2).

Page 106: Community in Economic Development - Brent D. Hales

Thank YouThank You

Brent D. Hales, Ph.D.Brent D. Hales, Ph.D.

Department of Economic and Workforce Department of Economic and Workforce DevelopmentDevelopment

University of Southern Mississippi University of Southern Mississippi

118 College Drive, #5022118 College Drive, #5022

Hattiesburg, MS 39406Hattiesburg, MS 39406

[email protected]