8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 1/24
We Media Week
3 –
Marques of Queensbury
Week “The
Gloves are Off”
Lesson Aim:
Learn 10 big concepts you need for your exam and be able to talk about
them.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 2/24
10 Concepts You Need To
Understand1. Democracy
2. Free Speech
3. Free Press
4. Ideology5. Hierarchy
6. Egalitarian
7. Hegemony
8. Power Elites
9. Monopoly
10. Oligarchy
THE DEAL
Don’t want to write a wiki on one of these
concepts?
Talk more – Wiki Article duties this week
go to the least involved in class room
debates.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 3/24
Round 1
Democracy
Free SpeechA Free Press
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 4/24
Democracy
• A system of government in whichindividual freedom is protected bygiving all members of that societythe right to decide how the societywill run.
Traditionally organised by giving allcitizens* the right to vote in regular election of officials and the right toFree Speech.
*By “traditionally” we mean from the 20th century
onwards previous to that if you were a woman,
a different colour, disabled or just generally
different you DID NOT have this right.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 5/24
Democracy and The Media
• Democracy relies on aninformed set of voters who
can make the best choice.
• For most voters this
information comes from
the information media –
the press.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 6/24
Free Speech
• Free Speech: The right of a member of ademocratic society to speak out against thedecisions of the government in an appropriate
way.
IT IS
– The right to protest
– The right to disagree with government policy
– The right to form your own political groupsNOT
– The right to slag off whoever you like
– The right to promote racism or bigotry of any kind
– The right to be listened too
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 7/24
The Free Press
No government ought to be without censors & where the press is free, noone ever will.
Thomas Jefferson (1743 - 1826), letter to George Washington, September 9,1792
• A news-reporting service that is protected by law fromgovernment interference or censorship. – The ability to write and tell others about the facts you KNOW about
Gordon Brown that he doesn’t want everyone else to know.
• Old Year 13 Press Regulation Wiki
• Press Complaints Commission• Reporters without Borders – Freedom Index
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 8/24
The Free Press at Work
• Watergate Scandal – Five men are arrested while
planting audio bugs in thedemocratic offices of theWatergate Hotel. They are found to
be linked to the President of theTime and leader of the RepublicanParty Richard Nixon – whichultimately ended in his resignation.
– The Washington Post is credited for investigating the story andbringing out facts that forced theevents that led up to theresignation.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 9/24
End of Round 1 Discussion
• What are the advantages/disadvantagesof living in a democracy?
• In what ways is our press free/not free?• Freedom of the press is limited to those who own one.
A. J. Liebling (1904 - 1963)
• How does the informationrevolution/web 2.0 contribute to a:
– Free Speech
– Free Press
– Democracy
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 10/24
Round 2
Ideology
Hierarchy
EgalitarianHegemony
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 11/24
Ideology
• The body of ideas reflecting the social needs and aspirations of an individual, group, class, or culture.
THOUGHT:
“I like cheese”
IDEOLOGY:
“Cheese is very good, it’s
important, everyone
should like and enjoy
Cheese”
What ideologies are evidently a part of Chadwell HeathFoundation School? Your Family? England?
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 12/24
Egalitarian Vs Hierarchies
• The theory of Egalitarianism - (Heath, Patel,
Birdi 2010) : this suggests that Media
technology is infinate and enables everyone
to work together as equal contributors.
Egalitarianism – a group of people or a
society in which all are equal in
contribution and rights.
Hierarchy - any system of persons or things ranked one above another.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 13/24
Hegemony
• Karl Marx 19th century philosopher whose ideas influenced the labour movement (unions) and socialism(communism) states that – those who
rule society control both: – The means of production (food, land,
factories etc.)
– The production of ideas (newspapers,books, websites, search engines)
Karl Marx – “The
Philosopher’s haveonly interpreted the
world in various ways,
the point is to change
it.”
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 14/24
Hegemony• Coined by (Gramsci, A – a Marxist Theorist)
The influence of ideology of one dominant group in society over others in a way that makes it seem right and just.
EXAMPLES:
– The Monarchy
– Capitalism
• Often described as a
– ‘hierarchy of ideologies’ – where one point of view is held up as better than others
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 15/24
False ConsciousnessWith thanks to Stacia and Charan
Fredrich Engels (Another Marxist Philosopher)
• Suggests that the power of Hegemonies creates aFalse Consciousness on
individuals in a society,influencing them to adoptideologies that they maynot willingly have chosen.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 16/24
How Hegemonies are Maintained
• Althusser (another Marxist theorist)states that control can happen in twoways:
– Repressive State Apparatus (RSA) –
laws, armies, police – Ideological State Apparatus (ISA) –
media, religion, education
• He suggests that if you have an
effective ISA to control a population youdon’t need as much RSA – would youagree?
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 17/24
Implications of Hegemony
• The dominant group’svalues and needs arealways listened to.
• Alternative minority viewpoints are not heard.
• This kind of system is veryhard to change.
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 18/24
End of Round 2 Discussion
We like to think that our
democracy promotes
egalitarianism and eliminates
hegemonies – does it?
Who is our society create the
dominant hegemony? Who’s
voice is not being heard?
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 19/24
Round 3
Power Elites
MonopolyOligarchy
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 20/24
Problems with Democracy
• People don’t feel involved or that their voice is heard.
• People are not informedabout who their leaders areaccurately and so don’t votewell or vote at all.
• Information that is passedthrough the press could besubject to bias and be
unreliable.
Recent years have seen arguments
made against free speech as critical
and unhelpful in tough times
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 21/24
Power ElitesThe powers of ordinary men are circumscribed by the
everyday worlds in which they live, yet even in theserounds of job, family, and neighbourhood they oftenseem driven by forces they can neither understand nor govern. 'Great changes' are beyond their control,but affect their conduct and outlook none the less.The very framework of modern society confines themto projects not their own, but from every side, suchchanges now press upon the men and women of themass society, who accordingly feel that they arewithout purpose in an epoch in which they are without power.
(Mills, C W 1956)
• Those in a society who have disproportionate
control of wealth, influence, access to decisionmaking processes.
• These people often share a similar ideology (they arethe hegemony in society)
• Who are the power elites in your society?
aka “The Ruling Class” aka “The
bourgeoisie” aka “The Man”
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 22/24
Monopoly and Oligarchy
• Monopoly – Where oneindividual controls all access toa particular resource or servicewithout competition
• Oligarchy – Where a smallgroup controls all access to aparticular resource or servicewithout competition.
• How much competition isenough?
• Is this different for “real world”
and online businesses?
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 23/24
We Media and Democracy
Traditional Linear Model
– Producers passinformationto audiences
- Oligarchy/Power Elites- Little democracy
New Media Model
– Audiences as Producers
– Greater democracy?
8/14/2019 We Media Week 3
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/we-media-week-3 24/24
Weekly Discussion:The US is spending hundreds of billions on a war tobring democracy to Iraq. Yet only 4% of people in the
Arab world have broadband access. The most potent way to promote democracy in the Middle East would be to get that figure above 50%.
Leadbeater 2008
Considering the importance of Free Speech to aDemocracy, would you agree with Leadbetter’sstatement that broadband access is the “mostpotent way to promote democracy”? Or is theinternet simply another part of society controlledby a hegemony and power elites?
Post your ideas using some online examples in thediscussion forum “Broadband and Democracy”. Makesure your post does not simply repeat previous postsbut comments on them and reacts to their ideas.
Aim to draw on some of the key words and theorists wehave looked at in class to lend your arguments weight.