Rutgers, The State University of New Jersey Liberty Plaza, 335 George Street, New Brunswick, NJ 08901
rwjms.rutgers.edu/boggscenter p. 732-235-9300 f. 732-235-9330
Tamar Heller, PhD
Distinguished Professor and Head Department of Disability and Human Development
University of Illinois Chicago Chicago, IL
Challenges and Opportunities in Serving Adults Aging with Intellectual and
Developmental Disabilities
May 15, 2020
The attached handouts are provided as part of The Boggs Center’s continuing education and dissemination activities. Please note that these items are reprinted by permission from the author. If you desire to reproduce them, please obtain permission from the originator.
5/14/2020
1
Challenges and Opportunities in Serving Adults Aging with Intellectual and
Developmental Disabilities Tamar Heller, PhD
Distinguished Professor and HeadDepartment of Disability and Human Development
University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL
May 15, 2020
http://rwjms.rutgers.edu/boggscenter
Deborah M. Spitalnik, PhD
Executive Director, The Boggs CenterDirector, NJLEND
http://rwjms.rutgers.edu/boggscenter/links/COVID-19Resources.html• COVID-19 National & State Resources• Plain Language Information• Healthcare & Communication Resources• Resources in Support of Physical & Emotional Well-Being and Mental Health• Boggs Center Resources about Grief and Loss• Boggs Center Resources about Supported Employment • Resources about Face Masks
COVID-19 Resources on The Boggs Center WebsiteGoToWebinar Control Panel
Handouts
• Handouts may be downloaded from the Control Panel.
• The webinar recording and handouts will also be posted on The Boggs Center web site next week: http://rwjms.rutgers.edu/boggscenter/dd_lecture/audio.html
Questions
• We are planning to have a brief Question and Answer session at the end of the lecture.
• In order to ask a question, you have to type it in the Questions section of the Control Panel.
Certificates of Attendance for Continuing Education Recognition
To receive a Certificate of Attendance, you must:
Be logged onto the webinar from start to finish and
Complete the evaluation at the end of the webinar
Certificates will be emailed to attendees who meet these requirements next week
Challenges and Opportunities in Serving Adults Aging with Intellectual and
Developmental Disabilities Tamar Heller, PhD
Distinguished Professor and HeadDepartment of Disability and Human Development
University of Illinois at Chicago, Chicago, IL
May 15, 2020
http://rwjms.rutgers.edu/boggscenter
5/14/2020
2
Tamar Heller, PhD
Distinguished Professor and HeadDepartment of Disability and Human Development
University of Illinois at ChicagoChicago, IL
Tamar Heller, PhDBoggs Center on Developmental Disabilities
Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical SchoolMay 15, 2020
Department of Disability and Human Development University of Illinois at Chicago
Specialized aging corner of segregated centersSenior services as “age appropriate”Person‐Centered Planning for later lifeBeing part of communityHuman rights (United Nations, 2006)Medicaid Home and Community‐Based Services Final Rule (2014)
Aging without a disability?Ableism
Staying youthful?Ageism
“Compulsory youthfulness” (Gibbons, 2016)Intersectionality with disability studiesOld disabled as “failures”, diminished worthDepends on ones choice and effort (Rowe & Kahn, 1998)What is the state’s responsibility?
Explore how people with ID view agingAdopt empowered frameworks
Disability identityInterdependence versus independence
Take into account role of minority status, poverty, cultureTake a life course approach
Living on your own termsAdding value to society, family or friendsMaintaining health and function
5/14/2020
3
Life expectancy similar unless they havesevere levels of cognitive impairmentDown syndromecerebral palsymultiple disabilities
It means that you are settled and know what you are doing. I am more kinder, I get along a lot better. I have friends I am happy with and that I do things with. For the future I wish that I keep going happy and that I don’t feel old and that I am not in a wheelchair.
I feel people 50 years and older have the same chances as younger people have – and more! Especially people with disabilities. Finally, I feel older people with disabilities shouldn’t let their age or disability stop them from getting the job of their dreams or having fun.
Development of chronic health conditions
Changes in family caregiving and supports
Retiring from employment
Receiving end of life care
Poorer health and earlier age related conditions
DementiaOsteoporosisOral healthDiabetes
Higher rate of falls
More obesitySedentary behaviorUnhealthy dietsRelated to health related quality of life
5/14/2020
4
Diagnosis of cancer at a later stagePolypharmacyDeaths amenable to health care interventionLack of testing/treatment for COVID 19
Difficulty communicating symptomsUnderstanding prevention instructionsRationingPrevention of support person at hospitalsNeed to know the rights to equal access and support
Worse outcomes with age over 65Worse outcomes for those with chronic conditions
Heart, lung, diabetes, obesity More cases in long‐term care settings
Strategies to Reduce Disparities
Greater knowledge about impairment and treatments
Reduction in poverty and unhealthy environments
Improved health behaviors through health literacy and health promotion
Improved access, accessibility, equity, and effectiveness of health care
Better health and fitness in later life
Health Matters: Exercise, Nutrition and Health Education Curriculum for People with DD (Heller et al., 2004; Marks, Sisirak, & Heller, 2010)Living Well with a Disability (RTC: Rural, University of Montana)We Walk (Hsieh, 2019)
Other HealthMattersTMPrograms
Health Messages: Peer training
Getting the Memo: Creating a culture of health promotion
Signs and Symptoms: Observe changes in health conditions
www.HealthMattersProgram.org
5/14/2020
5
HealthMattersTM Program InterventionExercise, Nutrition and Health Education Curriculum
Train‐the‐Trainer Creating a Sustainable Health Promotion Program
Marks B, Sisirak J, Heller T. Health Matters: The exercise, nutrition and health education curriculum for people with developmental disabilities. Baltimore: Brookes, 2010.
Marks B, Sisirak J, Heller T. Health Matters: Health Matters for People with Developmental Disabilities: Creating a Sustainable Health Promotion Programs. Baltimore: Brookes, 2010.
www.HealthMattersProgram.org
Fitness ClassesHealth Education Classes
1 hour of health education class three days a week
36 interactive classes
Personal notebook/tape
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dyuk09cUCYo
Exercise and Nutrition Health Education Curriculum Aims
understand attitudes toward health, exercise and food
find exercises that they like to do and set goals
gain skills/ knowledge about exercising and eating well
support each other during the course of the class
identify places in their community to exercise
Curriculum Emphasizes self‐determination and choice versus social control
responsibility
individual involvement in planning and meeting exercise goals
changes in health behaviors in five stages
support from caregivers
5/14/2020
6
(Heller, Hsieh, Rimmer 2004; Rimmer, Heller, Wang, Valerio, 2004)
knowledge about exercise confidence in ability
to exercise
life satisfaction physical activity, strength & energy, Peak VO2, & stair climbing
caregiver perceptionof exercise benefits
Access barriers
Exercise and Nutrition Health Education for Adults with DD: Train‐the‐Trainer Curriculum
Provide staff with the skills, knowledge, and abilities to… – Implement a physical activity (PA)and health education program
– Teach ways to increase PA and healthy food
– Support to maintain long‐term lifestyle changes.
(Marks, Sisirak, & Chang, 2013; Pett, et al., 2013)
Improved energy and less painImproved psychological well‐beingPositive exercise/nutrition expectationsEnvironmental supports for nutritionKnowledge of fruit and vegetable intake recommendations Organizational policies that support health promotion for direct care workers
Adults age 30 and over (n=52)Participated in 12 week , 3 days per week exercise and health education programCompared to controls showed:
Less painIncreased self‐efficacyIncreased social environmental support
1 hour of physical activity 3 days/week
Emphasis on flexibility, cardiovascular endurance, muscle strength, balance
Follow guidelines for frequency, intensity, stretching
Use the equipment and exercise safely
5/14/2020
7
Get an OK from a health care providerIncorporate PA throughout dayTailor made for personExercise a minimum of 3 days/30 minutes (moderate intensity)More benefits if more rigorous (moderate to vigorous for 60 minutes)Make it progressiveKeep it fun and rewardingFoster fitness among staff and caregivers
How many participants/clients in the program?What is the number of staff available?How much time?How many sessions per week?What is the size of the space?What kind of assistance do our clients use?What resources and equipment do we have available?Do we have staff that are doing and/or are interested in specific physical activity?
Staff/family members can support: .• Give encouragement to stick with it• Offer to exercise together• Plan for exercise on recreational outings• Discuss ways to get more exercise• Ensure transportation• Identify ways of paying• Show how to exercise
Caregiver Support for Exercise
Staff/family can influence choice/control in meal preparation and access to food Support can be provided:• Encourage healthy food choices• Assist in developing plans and goals for changing eating habits
• Remind people to avoid high fat, salty foods and to eat more fruits and vegetables
• Compliment people on changing eating habits • Offer fruits and vegetables as a snack
Caregiver Support for Nutrition
• Supportive environment and attitudes within your organization
• Policies supporting health and safety• Supportive attitudes among staff and
management for healthy lifestyles for adults with I/DD and themselves
5/14/2020
8
Work with a local /state entityConduct Request for ProposalsConduct webinar trainings with certified instructorsDevelop wellness committeesConduct HM Assessments and evaluationImplement programDevelop sustainability plan
CBO Interest and Commitment1. HealthMatters Assessments
• 146 Service providers in Kentucky in 20142. Getting the Memo Webinar
• 270 Service providers participated 3. HealthMatters, Kentucky:
Scale‐Up Research Project• CBOs completing letter of commitment• HealthMattersWebinar Workshops to teach staff
to start a HealthMatters Program
Copyright ©2014 HealthMattersProgram.org
45
Train‐the‐trainers program to teach adults with IDD to become coaches along with staff mentorsFocused on teaching participants to increase their weekly PA and to drink more water75 minute webinar, toolkit/coaching manualPaired with mentor in learning content and developing leadership skills
Deliver 12 sessions with about 10 peopleBooklets and 2 wristbands displaying the weekly health messages
One to keepOne to pass on the message to another
Can share health messagesPeople are about the same ageCommon interestsBenefits the coaches as well
34 staff and 67 adults with IDD aged 30 plusRandomized intervention results:Coaches increased PA and hydration knowledgeMentors increased confidence to teach program Program participants
increased PA and hydration knowledgeincreased social support for engaging in PAImproved PA and hydration
Need to include health promotion in CBO mission, vision and job descriptions
5/14/2020
9
“We Walk,” a technology intervention to improve the PA of adults with ID and their family caregivers.Use of technology intervention in promoting PA in adults with ID and their family caregivers
A single group pre‐post designDriven by social cognitive and self‐efficacy theories (Bandura, 1986; Bandura, 1997)A 12‐week walking program with wearable PA trackers(i.e., Fitbit Charge HR) and texting messages interventionIncrease in moderate and vigorous physical activity
We Walk
Recruited from LHIDS online
cohort(23 pairs)
Fitbit Training
Baseline Assessment
7‐day Fitbit data Proxy survey
12‐week intervention
FitbitTexting messages
Monthly phone interviews
Post‐intervention(21 pairs)
Rationing of health care for older and disabled?Organ transplantsDialysis
Key criteriaYears of life expectancyAbility to keep regimenAmount of support available
Will these interventions improve quality of life balanced with burden for person and carers?
Health checks and preventive screeningRisk versus benefitsEquality of access
Patient centered care and health literacyNeed for health literacy educationTime for listeningCarer involvement
Generic versus specialized servicesCase of woman in generic nursing home
Getting needs met through access to quality services.
“I was able to receive a good psychiatrist, one that has been really helpful to me, and I was able to get my glasses.”
Humanizing treatment by healthcare professionals
“The doctors have been listening and they find the better solution.”
5/14/2020
10
Skilled, knowledgeable, and experienced providers
“My doctors tells me to take my pills every day and sees how I am doing.”
Accessible communication “My doctors take care of me good, I understand when they talk to me.”
Doctors who did not demonstrate respect for them “I am unhappy with my doctor…if he’s the only one there, I won’t go…I know that’s bad for my health but…he is very rude and makes me feel stupid…I know my body and I know if something is wrong with me…he thinks he’s better and smarter than I am and we bump heads.”
Delays in getting services“I needed a personal assistant and it took a long time, had to have family members help and they didn’t always know what to do.”
Lower healthcare appraisal Having worse health statusLiving in institutional settings Having more unmet transportation needs
More unmet healthcare needs Having worse health statusBeing a racial/ethnic minorityAlso having a physical disability
Greater family involvementinput in healthcare decisionsfamily support needs met
Better care coordinationknowledgeable care coordinatorsrespectful of ones wishes and input
Journey to Better HealthcareMy Health Passport: Important in pandemic
Documentary on health care and IDDVoice to advocates to share their storiesExamples of how changes can be made on all levels of a healthcare organization to better treat these patients.Produced by Rush University Medical Center and Georgetown University Center for Excellence in Developmental Disabilities. https://vimeo.com/415331167
5/14/2020
11
More likely to live with parentsOften need LTSS life‐longFamilies and persons with disabilities need to engage in future planning
Fewer opportunities for employmentRestricted social networkImpact on physical and mental health and stress for some groupsGreater difficulties as parents and person with IDD ageCaring also has its positive aspects
Only 15% of families caring for person with IDD received public family support (Braddock et al., 2017)
5/14/2020
12
“I wish my child dies 4 minutes before I do”Four Bodies in Elmhurst
Why would an 82‐year‐old man kill hisson, his daughter, his wife and himself?Photo by Jeff Himmelman, Dec. 2, 2015 / New York Times
Experts say probation understandable for woman who killed disabled daughter
Liltz pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter in the death of her daughter. Photo by Stacey Wescott / Chicago TribuneBonnie Liltz and her attorney.
Over 5500 siblings and supporters27 state chaptersStarted in 2007Resources, research, advocacy
www.siblingleadership.org
Charting the Life Course(www.lifecourse.com)
Family Support Research and Training Center Promising Practices
Caring for the CaregiverFuture is Now
5/14/2020
13
Future is Now (Heller & Caldwell, 2006)PLAN (Etmanski) CanadaUse of social media to support families (Hoosier TYZE Project)The Arc Center on Future Planning www.futureplanning.thearc.org/
Background:Research showing need & input from stakeholdersExperience with different interventions
Purpose:Develop future planning goals Develop letter of intentIncrease advocacy for supports
Caregivers experience less burden, including less worry about futurePersons with IDD have greater voice in decisions about their life
Taking the First Step : Identifying Dreams and NightmaresBuilding Relationships and Support NetworksDesired Living Arrangements Post‐Secondary Education, Work, and Retirement OpportunitiesIdentifying Key Succession Person
Learning takes place over time Families learn from each other and support each other to take risks.Homework assignments completed jointly by families and their relative with a disabilityBreaks the process down into manageable steps
Pre‐session on legal/financial planning
Facilitators guide for families
Workbook for families
Facilitators guide for people with disabilities
Workbook for people with disabilities
Integration of person‐centered and family‐centered philosophiesPeer supportInclusion of Peer TrainersProblem solving around family dynamics and family valuesFocus includes both current and potential community supports
5/14/2020
14
Includes essential information about the individual with a disability’s strengths, preferences, interests, support needs, and health. Identifies goals:
to expand friendships and supports; make future living arrangements; arrange for postsecondary education, work, or retirement; and designate a successor caregiver.
Family Support Research and Training Center (FSRTC) and The Arc’s Center for Future Planning
https://futureplanning.thearc.org/https://fsrtc.ahslabs.uic.edu/
Piloted two types of future planning interventions for professionals working with adults with IDD and families
Conducted with agencies in eight US states. Evaluated participants’ outcomes and outreach initiated by the trained professionals
Under‐recognition of health issuesNeed for palliative care trainingGreater barriers to hospice careUnderstanding of death and losses (disenfranchised grief)Training needs of staff
Teaching concepts of deathCausesEnd of life functionsAll dieCan’t return to life
Understanding griefEmotional responsesBehaviors
MourningDeath happenedFeel painGet used to lossesBegin to do new things
Turning to others for comfortRituals (account for religion and culture)
FuneralsVisitation
Allowed in 5 U.S. states 51% U.S. pro‐assisted suicide
Equating disability with poor “quality of life”Concern about “burden” on familyTerry Schiavo case
not terminalwithdrawal of food and water
5/14/2020
15
AGING as a field has a lot to contribute to the DISABILITY and vice versaMany common needsEfficiency in services
Historical segmentation of service systemsDifferent philosophies, terms, and definitionsDistinct fields of knowledge and practice, limited sharing or exchange Protection and duplication of fundsMissed opportunities for knowledge translation, innovative policy change, and co‐funding
Exchange of researchAdaptation of interventionsDevelopment of policy embracing ideas from both fields
Geriatric Assessments (Hahn)Falls Prevention Programs (Otago Program)Chronic Disease Self‐Management
Diabetes adaptations for DD (Centers for Excellence in Aging and Community Wellness, University of Albany)
Family CaregivingFamily Support Research and Training Center (UIC)Caring for the Caregiver (Kennedy Center and SE Connecticut Agency on Aging)
Aging in Place, Aging in Community, Disability and Aging Friendly Communities
Few (16%) in integrated employment (2015 National Core Indicators) and in full time employment (13%) (American Community Survey, 2015)Mostly (43%)in facility based and non‐work setting (Winsor et al., 2017) including retirement options, such as volunteering, recreational and health promotion activities, senior center participation, and continuing education (Sulweski et al., 2017). Some states no longer funding facility based
Transition to Retirement
Attending community group or volunteeringUse of MentorsPlanning meetingTraining of mentorsChoice of activities and mentorsOngoing support
Stancliffe, Bigby, Balandin, Wilson (2013)
5/14/2020
16
Understanding Aging and Life Stages: Life StoryRights & Choice MakingExercise I and II Healthy EatingStress ReductionWhere We LiveFriendships & Community SupportsWork, Volunteering, & Free TimeReview & Goal Setting
Administration for Community LivingAging and Disability Resource CentersNational Respite ActNational Family Caregiving Support ProgramNational Alzheimer's Project ActChronic Disease Self Management
National Plan to Address Alzheimer’s Disease (NAPA)National Task Group on ID and Dementia Practices (NTG)
www.aadmd.org/NTGNTG projects funded (ACL)
FL, ME, RI, HI
3 day workshops on dementia in 17 states with 1300 support workers with 500 staff using curriculumCo‐sponsor 1018 NDSS Adult Down Syndrome Summit for family caregivers of older adults with DSOn‐line support group for familiesNTG caregiver newsletterCaregiver’s guide for families in Rhode Island
Planful cooperation can help institute proactive and helpful screenings, interventions, and programmatic supports, and cooperative cross‐cutting research Models to cooperatively deliver services and increase the public benefit Given growth of the aging population, ‘special’ populations call for special attention and collaborative planning
Greater use of technology and universal design to address age related changesTransportation assistancePressure on system and families with lack of work force and community capacityGrowing recognition of supportive decision‐making and interdependenceNeed for research on better ways to bridge aging and IDD
5/14/2020
17
Funded by National Institute on Disability, Independent Living and Rehabilitation Research, Administration on Community Living, grant # 90RT5012-01-03 to the University of Illinois at Chicago.
Tamar [email protected]
Q & A
Certificates of Attendance for Continuing Education Recognition
To receive a Certificate of Attendance, you must:
Be logged onto the webinar from start to finish and
Complete the evaluation at the end of the webinar
Certificates will be emailed to attendees who meet these requirements next week
Stay on your screen, and if prompted, click CLOSE for the evaluation to pop up.
Thank you for attending and completing the evaluation.
Evaluation
Notes
Notes
Cover HellerBW 6 slides per page FINAL Heller DDLS 5-15-20 combinednotes pages