PDPRIETI Policy Discussion Paper Series 17-P-004
ã°ããŒãã«ãªäŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ããèŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®çŸç¶
æžå 康ä¹çµæžç£æ¥ç 究æ
ææš æéŠæ©çš²ç°å€§åŠ
ç¬ç«è¡æ¿æ³äººçµæžç£æ¥ç 究æhttp://www.rieti.go.jp/jp/
RIETI Policy Discussion Paper Series 17-P-004
2017 幎 3 æ
ã°ããŒãã«ãªäŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ããèŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®çŸç¶
æžå åº·ä¹ ææšæéŠ
æ©çš²ç°å€§åŠ æ©çš²ç°å€§åŠ
èŠ æš
æ¬çš¿ã¯ãã°ããŒãã«ãªäŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ç¹åŸŽãåæãããåæã«
ããã£ãŠã¯ãäžçã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãè³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ãå ±åç 究ïŒç¹èš±å ±å
ææïŒãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«é¢ããæ å ±ãå«ãã 倧èŠæš¡ãªããŒã¿ãçšããŠããããã¯ãŒã¯ç§
åŠã®ææ³ãå©çšããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã米欧äžäŒæ¥ãšæ¯èŒããããšã§ããã®ç¹åŸŽãæããã«ã
ããæ¬çš¿ã®äž»ãªçµè«ã¯ã以äžã® 3ç¹ã§ãããïŒ1ïŒãããã®ã°ããŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯
ã«ãããŠããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ã»ãšãã©ã¯ãã®äžå¿ã«ã¯äœçœ®ããŠããªããïŒ2ïŒãããã®ã°ã
ãŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããŠããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥å士ã¯å¯æ¥ã«ã€ãªãã£ãŠããäžæ¹ãæ¥æ¬
äŒæ¥ãšæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãç¹ã«ã°ããŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããäžå¿çãªæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãª
ããã¯å°ãªããïŒ3ïŒãããã£ãŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ç¹åŸŽã¯ãã°ããŒãã«ãªäŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯
ã«ãããŠå€æ§æ§ã«æ¬ ããããšã§ãããšçµè«ã¥ãããããããè ãšã®ã€ãªãããå«ãå€
æ§ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ãäŒæ¥ã®ããã©ãŒãã³ã¹åäžã«çµã³ã€ãããšãèŠåºãããŠããã
ãšãããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãšæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãªããæ§ç¯ãæ¯æŽããŠããæ¿çïŒäŸãã°äžå°äŒæ¥
ã®æµ·å€é²åºæ¯æŽãæµ·å€ M&A æ¯æŽãç 究è ã®åœé亀æµæ¯æŽãçµæžé£æºåå®æ¡å ãªã©ïŒ
ãæ¥æ¬ã®çµæžæé·ã®ããã«å¿ èŠã§ãããšèããããã
ããŒã¯ãŒãïŒãããã¯ãŒã¯ãåœéåãäžå¿æ§ãæææ§ãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°
JEL classification: F14, F23, L14
RIETI ããªã·ãŒã»ãã£ã¹ã«ãã·ã§ã³ã»ããŒããŒã¯ãRIETI ã®ç 究ã«é¢é£ããŠäœæãããæ¿çã
ãããè°è«ã«ã¿ã€ã ãªãŒã«è²¢ç®ããããšãç®çãšããŠããŸããè«æã«è¿°ã¹ãããŠããèŠè§£ã¯å·ç
è å人ã®è²¬ä»»ã§çºè¡šãããã®ã§ãããæå±ããçµç¹åã³ïŒç¬ïŒçµæžç£æ¥ç 究æãšããŠã®èŠè§£ã瀺
ããã®ã§ã¯ãããŸããã
æ¬çš¿ã¯ãç¬ç«è¡æ¿æ³äººçµæžç£æ¥ç 究æã«ããããããžã§ã¯ããäŒæ¥ã®åœéã»åœå ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«é¢ããç 究ã
ã®ææã®äžéšã§ãããæ¬çš¿ã®åæ¡ã«å¯ŸããŠãPetr MatousïŒã·ãããŒå€§åŠïŒããã³æ³å·æ¬ä¹ïŒæ±äº¬å€§åŠïŒã®åæ°ããª
ãã³ã«çµæžç£æ¥ç 究æãã£ã¹ã«ãã·ã§ã³ã»ããŒããŒæ€èšäŒã®æ¹ã ããå€ãã®æçãªã³ã¡ã³ããé ããããŸããæ¬
çš¿ã¯æ¥æ¬åŠè¡æ¯èäŒç§ç è²»ïŒNo. 25101003ïŒããç 究å©æãåããŠãããããã«èšããŠãæè¬ã®æãè¡šãããã
2
1. ã¯ããã«
è¿å¹Žãäžçã®äž»èŠãªäŒæ¥ãå«ãã 倧èŠæš¡ãªäŒæ¥åäœã®ããŒã¿ãå©çšå¯èœãšãªããçç£ã»è³æ¬ææã»
å ±åç 究ãªã©ã«é¢ããã°ããŒãã«ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å šäœåãæãããšãªã£ãŠãããæ¬çš¿ã¯ããã®ã
ããªããŒã¿ãå©çšããŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãã°ããŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžã«å ããäœçœ®ãæããã«ããã
ããåºã«æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®çµå¶æŠç¥ããããæ¯æŽããããã®æ¿çã«ã€ããŠæèšããããšãç®çãšããŠã
ãã
ãããã¯ãŒã¯åæã¯ãçµæžåŠç 究ã«ãããŠéèŠãªåæææ³ãšãªã£ãŠããŠãã(Jackson, 2010)ãåŸ
æ¥ã®çµæžåŠã§ã¯ã財ã»ãµãŒãã¹ã»è³æ¬ã¯éãããåžå Žã§ååŒãããæ å ±ã¯çµæžå šäœã§å ±æããããš
ããããšãä»®å®ããããšãæšæºçã ããçŸå®ã«ã¯ããã§ã¯ãªãããšãå€ããäŸãã°ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ç³»
åé¢ä¿ã«è±¡åŸŽãããããã«ãéšåã®èª¿éã¯åžå Žã§ã¯ãªãã決ãŸã£ãçžæãšæ§ç¯ãããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒ
ã³ïŒçç£ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒã«ãã£ãŠãªãããããšãå€ããæ°ããç¥èã»æè¡ããåžå Žã§ã¯ãªããå ±å
ç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãéããŠåŸãããããšããŸãã§ã¯ãªãããã®ãããªç¶æ³ã§ã¯ãäŒæ¥ã®æ¥çžŸã¯èªå
èªèº«ã®å±æ§ã ãã§ã¯ãªãããããã¯ãŒã¯ãéããŠçŽæ¥ã»éæ¥ã«ã€ãªãã£ãçžæã®å±æ§ã«ãäŸåãã
ããšã«ãªãããããã£ãŠãäŒæ¥ã®æ¥çžŸãããã«äžããŠããããèããã«ããã£ãŠããã®äŒæ¥ããã
ãã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžã§ã©ã®ãããªç«ã¡äœçœ®ã«ããããåæããããšã¯å¿ èŠäžå¯æ¬ ã§ããã
ã§ã¯ãã©ã®ãããªãããã¯ãŒã¯æ§é ãäŒæ¥æ¥çžŸã®åäžã«å¯äžããã®ã§ããããããããã¯ãŒã¯ç§
åŠã®çè«çã»å®èšŒçãªç 究ã¯ãå€æ§ãªäººã»äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªããããšã§æ°ããç¥èãåžåããããšãã§ãã
æ¥çžŸã®åäžã«ã€ãªããããšã瀺ããŠãããäŸãã°ãGranovetter (1973)ã¯æ±è·è ã«ãšã£ãŠæçãªæ å ±
ã¯èŠªããå人ããã§ã¯ãªããé¢ä¿ã®ãããç¥ãåãããåŸãããããšãå€ãããšãããããè ãšã®
匱ãã€ãªããã®æ¹ãæ å ±ãåŸãã«ã¯åœ¹ã«ç«ã€ãšèãããããã匱ãã€ãªããã®åŒ·ã¿ããšè¡šçŸããã
Burt (1992, 2004) ã¯ãã°ã«ãŒãéã®æ å ±æ³¢åã«ãããŠãããã¯ãŒã¯å ã®ç°ãªãã°ã«ãŒããšã®ã€ãªã
ãïŒãæ§é çééãïŒãéèŠãªåœ¹å²ãæããããšã匷調ããããäŒæ¥å ã®äººéé¢ä¿ã調æ»ããŠã確ã
ã«ã°ã«ãŒããè¶ ããã€ãªãããæã€äººã»ã©æ¥çžŸãé«ãããšãå®èšŒãããããã¯ã身è¿ãªäººå士ã¯å€
ãã®ç¥èãæ å ±ãå ±æããŠããããèŠç¹ã䌌éãã®ã«å¯Ÿããé¢ä¿ã®ãããè ãšã¯èŠç¹ãæ å ±æºãç°
ãªãå¯èœæ§ãããé«ããªãããã匱ãã€ãªãããå€æ§ã«ãã£ãŠãããšèœåãåäžããããããã ã
äŒæ¥ã®æé·ãšããæèã§ã¯ãæµ·å€ã®äŒæ¥ã人æãšããããè ãšã®ã€ãªãããéèŠãšãªã£ãŠããã
åœé貿æã察å€ã»å¯Ÿå çŽæ¥æè³ãéããç¥èã®äŒæãçç£æ§ãåäžãããããšã¯ãMadsen (2007)ã
Coe and Helpman (1995)ãBorensztein et al. (1998)ãªã©ã®äžçã®åœã¬ãã«ããŒã¿ã®åæã«ãã£ãŠæãã
ãšãªã£ãŠãããæ¥æ¬ã®äŒæ¥ã¬ãã«ããŒã¿ã«ããåæã§ãã茞åºã察å€ã»å¯Ÿå æè³ãæµ·å€ã§ã®ç 究é
çºãããããšã§æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®çç£æ§ãäžæããããšã¯ããããŸã§ã®å€ãã®ç 究ãæããã«ããŠãã
(Hijzen et al., 2010; Kimura and Kiyota, 2006; Todo, 2006; Todo and Shimizutani, 2007)ãäŸãã°ãå³ 1 ã¯
çµæžç£æ¥çã®ãäŒæ¥æŽ»ååºæ¬èª¿æ»ããåºã«ã2000 幎ã«èŒžåºãéå§ããäŒæ¥ãš 1995 幎ãã 2007 幎ãŸ
ã§ã®é茞åºãäžåããŠããªãäŒæ¥ã®åŽåçç£æ§ã®å¹³åãšãæ¯èŒãããã®ã§ããïŒè¥æä»ã2008ïŒã
ããã«ãããšã茞åºäŒæ¥ã¯èŒžåºéå§åŸã«è¢«èŒžåºäŒæ¥ãããçç£æ§ã䌞ã°ããŠãããããã¯ã茞åºäŒ
æ¥ãæµ·å€åžå Žã§ã®ç«¶äºã«ãããããããšã茞åºã«ãã£ãŠèŠæš¡ãæ¡å€§ããŠçç£å¹çãäžæããããš
ãªã©ãèŠå ã§ãããããæµ·å€ãšã®ã€ãªããã«ãã£ãŠæ°ããç¥èãåžåããããšã倧ããªèŠå ã§ãã
3
ãšèãããã1ãèŒžå ¥æ¥è ã«ããæå°ã«ãã£ãŠã茞åºäŒæ¥ã®æè¡ãåäžããããšãå®èšŒããç 究ã
ãã(Egan and Mody, 1992)ã察å€çŽæ¥æè³ïŒFDIïŒã«ãããŠã¯ãå€è³äŒæ¥ã§æè¡ã身ã«ã€ããæè¡è
ã®è»¢è·ãªã©ãç¥èã®äŒæã®äž»èŠå ã®äžã€ãšãããŠãã(Fosfuri et al., 2001)ã
ãŸããæ¥æ¬ã«ãããŠã¯ãæµ·å€ãšãŸã§ãããªããšãããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãéããçå€ã®äŒæ¥ãšã®ã€
ãªãããã売äžé«ãç¹èš±ååŸæ°ã®å¢å ãçœå®³ããã®åŸ©æ§ã«å¯ŸããŠå€§ããè²¢ç®ããããšãæãããšãª
ã£ãŠãã(Todo et al., 2016; Todo et al., 2015)ããããããè ãšã®ã€ãªããã®å¹æã§ãããæ§ã ãªåœ¢ã§
ããè ãšã€ãªããããšãäŒæ¥ã®æé·ã«è³ããããšãããã£ãŠããŠããã®ã§ããã
å³ 1ïŒæ¥æ¬ã«ããã茞åºäŒæ¥ãšè¢«èŒžåºäŒæ¥ã®åŽåçç£æ§
ïŒåºæïŒè¥æä»ïŒ2008ïŒãå ããŒã¿ã¯çµæžç£æ¥çãäŒæ¥æŽ»ååºæ¬èª¿æ»ãã
ãã ããã°ã«ãŒãå ã®åŒ·ãçµãç¡çšã ãšããããã§ã¯ãªããä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ã«åºã¥ã匷ãçµãããã°ã
人ãäŒæ¥ã¯ç¥èã»æè¡ãå ±æãããã(Durlauf and Fafchamps, 2005)ãäŸãã° Centola (2010)ã¯ãã°ã«
ãŒãå ã§å¯ãªãããã¯ãŒã¯ãç¯ãããŠãããšãïŒã€ãŸããã°ã«ãŒãå ã§çãçãç¥ã£ãŠãããšãïŒã
ç¥èãæ å ±ã®å ±æã¯ããæ©ãé²ãããšãã€ã³ã¿ãŒãããäžã®ç€ŸäŒå®éšã«ãã£ãŠå®èšŒçã«ç€ºãããã
ãã¯ãè€æ°ã®ç¥ãåãããåãæ å ±ãèãããšã§ããã®æ å ±ã«å¯Ÿããä¿¡é Œæ§ãå¢ãããã§ãããšè
ãããããã€ãŸããç¥èãæ å ±ã¯ãææçã®ããã« 1 ã€ã®ã€ãªãããããã°ããã«äŒæããŠãã
(Watts and Strogatz, 1998)ãšãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãã®ã ã
ããã«ãç¥èãå ±æãããã°ããã®ç¥èã«åºã¥ããŠæ°ããã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãèµ·ããããšãã§ããã
ããã¯äŸãã°ãæ¥æ¬ã®ç³»åé¢ä¿ã§ãæçµã¡ãŒã«ãŒãšãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒãé·æçãªä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ãåºã«å ±åã§
æ°ããéšåãå¹çããéçºããããšã§ã瀺ããã(Dyer and Nobeoka, 2000)ãRost (2011)ã¯ãã€ãã®
èªåè»ç£æ¥ã«ãããŠãããç 究è ãç¹å®ã®ç 究è ãšé »ç¹ã«å ±åç 究ããããšã§æ¥çžŸãåäžããããš
ã瀺ããããåæã«ãªãã¿ã®ãªãç 究è ãšãå ±åç 究ãããšããã«æ¥çžŸã䌞ã³ãããšãèŠåºããã
Phelps (2010)ã Tiwana (2008)ãåæ§ã«ãå人ã»äŒæ¥éã®åŒ·ãçµãšããè ãšã®åŒ±ãã€ãªããã®äœµåã
1 å³ 1 ã¯çµå¹Žå€åã瀺ãåçŽãªå³ã§ãã£ãŠãå¿ ãããå æé¢ä¿ã瀺ããã®ã§ã¯ãªããããããäŸãã° Kimura and Kiyota (2006)ã¯ãã粟緻ãªèšéçµæžåŠã®åæã«ãã£ãŠã茞åºãçç£æ§åäžã«å¯äžãããšçµè«ã¥ããŠããã茞åºãæµ·
å€çŽæ¥æè³ãçç£æ§ã«äžããå¹æã«é¢ããçµæžåŠã®æç®ã®ãŸãšãã«ã€ããŠã¯ãKeller and Yeaple (2003)ãæžå
ïŒ2011ïŒãæž ç°ïŒ2015ïŒãåç §ããããã
4
ããžãã¹äžã®æ¥çžŸåäžã«çµã³ä»ãããšãå®èšŒçã«èŠåºããŠããã
åŸã§è©³çŽ°ã«èŠãããã«ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯ç³»åã«ä»£è¡šããããããªåŒ·ãçµãæã£ãŠããããããè ãç¹
ã«å€åœäŒæ¥ãšã®åŒ±ãã€ãªããã«æ¬ ããåŸåãããããããã£ãŠãããå€æ§ãªã€ãªãããæ§ç¯ããæ¹
åã§ã®æŠç¥ãäŸãã°æµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã® M&A ãå ±åç 究ãäžå°äŒæ¥ã®æµ·å€é²åºãå¿ èŠã§ããããã®ãã
ã«æ¿ççãªæ¯æŽãå¿ èŠã§ãããšããã®ããæ¬çš¿ã®çµè«ã§ããã
2. ããŒã¿
æ¬çš¿ã§äœ¿ãããäŒæ¥ããŒã¿ã¯ãFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ãšãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis
ã® 2 ã€ã®ããŒã¿ã»ããã«ãã£ãŠæ§ç¯ãããŠãããLiveData ã¯ã財åæ å ±ããŠã§ãæ å ±ãªã©ã®å ¬éã
ããæ å ±æºããæœåºããæ å ±ãåºã«æ§ç¯ãããŠãããååŒé¢ä¿ã®æ å ±ãå«ãã§ããã以åã¯ç±³åœäŒ
æ¥ã®ããŒã¿ãäžå¿ã«éããããŠããããæè¿ã§ã¯ãäžåœãæ¥æ¬ãéåœãªã©ä»ã®å°åã®äŒæ¥ã«ã€ããŠ
ãããŒã¿ã®åéããªãããããã«ãªã£ãŠããŠãããã«ããŒãããŠããäŒæ¥ã®ç¯å²ãåºãã£ããäŸã
ã°ããã®ããŒã¿ã»ããã«å«ãŸããŠããäŒæ¥éååŒæ°ã¯ã2010 幎ã«ã¯ 49,000 ã§ãã£ããã2014 幎ã«
㯠117,000ã2015 幎ã«ã¯ 157,000 ãšãªã£ãŠããããã®ããã«æ¥æ¿ã«å¢å ããäŒæ¥æ°ã¯ãå®éã®äŒæ¥
æ°ã®å¢å ãšãããããããããFactSet Revere 瀟ã«ããããŒã¿ã®ã«ãã¬ããžã®å¢å ãåæ ããŠãã
ãšèããããããšãããæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯çµå¹Žå€åãè¿œãããææ°ã® 2015 幎ã®ããŒã¿ã®ã¿ã䜿çšããŠåæ
ãè¡ããããã«ã¯ãäŒæ¥éååŒãæããã«ãªã£ãŠããäŒæ¥ã 57,693 瀟å«ãŸããŠããããã®ãã¡æ¥æ¬
äŒæ¥ã¯ 3,445 瀟ãã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ 1,0234 瀟ãäžåœäŒæ¥ 4,690 瀟ãéåœäŒæ¥ 1,572 瀟ãã€ã®ãªã¹äŒæ¥ 2,232
瀟ããã€ãäŒæ¥ 1,300 瀟ã§ãããLiveData ã¯å ¬éæ å ±ãåºã«äœæãããŠããããããã®ããŒã¿ã»ã
ãã«å«ãŸããŠããäŒæ¥ã®å€ãã¯äžå ŽäŒæ¥ãšãªã£ãŠãããã«ããŒãããŠããå°åãåºãã£ãã®ãæè¿
ã§ããããšããããã®ããŒã¿ã»ãããçšããå è¡ç 究ã¯ãŸã å€ãã¯ãªãããäŸãã°ãWu (2015) ã
FactSet ããŒã¿ãçšããŠãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããåäŒæ¥ã®éèŠåºŠãèšç®ãããããåºã«æ ªåŒããŒ
ããã©ãªãªã«ã€ããŠåæãè¡ã£ãŠããããŸããAndrade and Chhaochharia (2016)ã¯ãã®ããŒã¿ã»ãã
ã掻çšããœããªã³ã»ããã©ã«ãã®ã³ã¹ããåæããŠããã
ããäžã€ã®ããŒã¿ã»ãã Orbis ã¯ããã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã«ãã£ãŠååœã®äŒæ¥ã¬ãã«ããŒã¿ã
è€åãäœæããããã®ã§ããããã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã«ããã°ãOrbis ã¯éäžå Žäžå°äŒæ¥ãå«
ãäžçã® 2 å瀟ãç¶²çŸ ããŠãããFactSet ãšç°ãªã以åããæ¯èŒçåºãåŠè¡è«æã§ã䜿çšãããŠã
ãäŒæ¥ããŒã¿ã»ããã§ãããäŸãã°ãCui and Jiang (2012)ã¯åœæäŒæ¥ã§ããããšãæµ·å€çŽæ¥æè³å€
æã«äžãã圱é¿ã«ã€ããŠåæããŠããããšãããããã®ããŒã¿ã»ããã¯è³æ¬ææã«ã€ããŠã®æ å ±ã
å«ãã§ããã®ã§ãããã䜿ã£ãŠäžçã®äŒæ¥ã®è³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ãæãããšãã§ãããæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯
2015 幎ã«è³Œå ¥ãã Orbis ãçšããããã䞻㫠2014 幎ã«åéãããããŒã¿ã䜿çšãããæ¬çš¿ã®ãµã³
ãã«ã«ã¯ãä»ç€Ÿãšè³æ¬é¢ä¿ãæã€äŒæ¥ 2,791,179 瀟ãå«ãŸããŠãããäŒæ¥éè³æ¬é¢ä¿ã®æ°ã¯ 2,625,832
ã«äžããä»ç€Ÿãšè³æ¬é¢ä¿ããã€äŒæ¥ã®æåšåœå¥å èš³ã¯ãæ¥æ¬ 31,732 瀟ãã¢ã¡ãªã« 43,438 瀟ãäžåœ
14,523 瀟ããã€ã 570,508 瀟ãã€ã®ãªã¹ 281,149 瀟ã§ããã
ããã«ãOrbis ã«ã¯ç¹èš±ã®ææè ã«é¢ããæ å ±ãå«ãŸããŠãããããäŒæ¥éã®å ±åç 究ãããã¯
ãŒã¯ã«ã€ããŠãåæã§ããã2011 幎ãã 13 幎ãŸã§ã«åºé¡ããã15 幎ãŸã§ã«ä»äžãããç¹èš±ã®ãã¡ã
è€æ°ã®äŒæ¥ã»æ©é¢ã§å ±åææãããŠãããã®ã¯äžçã®ç¹èš±å šäœã® 3ïŒ çšåºŠã«ããã 45,831 件ããã
ç¹èš±ãå ±åææããäŒæ¥æ°ã¯ 29,911 瀟ã§ãããæ¬çš¿ã®åæã§ã¯ãããã®äŒæ¥ã䜿çšããã
5
3. åæææ³
æ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ãååœäŒæ¥ã®ç¹åŸŽãæããã«ããããããããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å¯èŠåããããšå ±ã«ãäžçå šäœ
ã®äŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããåäŒæ¥ã®ç«ã¡äœçœ®ã 4 ã€ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ææšã䜿ã£ãŠè¡šçŸããã
3.1 ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å¯èŠå
æ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ãäŒæ¥ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãããããããå³ç€ºããããã« Gephi ãšããããªãŒã»ãœãããŠã§ã¢
ãå©çšãããã®ã¬ã€ã¢ãŠãã»ã¢ã«ãŽãªãºã ãšã㊠Jacomy et al. (2014)ã® ForceAtlas2 ãçšããããã
ã¯ãããŒãïŒæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯äŒæ¥ïŒå士ã¯åž¯é»ããç²åã®ããã«äºãã«åçºããããããªã³ã¯ïŒäŒæ¥ã®ã€
ãªããïŒã¯ã°ãã®ããã«äºãã«åŒãä»ãããããä»®å®ããããã®ã§ããã® 2 åã®åè¡¡ç¶æ ãæçµç
ã«éæãããããã«èšèšãããŠããããã®è©³çŽ°ã«ã€ããŠã¯ä»é²ãåç §ããããã
ForceAtlas2 ãçšããŠãããã¯ãŒã¯ãå³ç€ºãããšãçŽæ¥ã€ãªãã£ãããŒãã®æ°ïŒæ¬¡æ°ïŒæ¬¡å°ç¯ãå
ç §ïŒã®å€ãããŒããããªãã¡ãããšãªã£ãŠããäŒæ¥ãäžå¿ãšããŠãã®åšãããã®ãããšã€ãªãã£ã
äŒæ¥ãå²ããããªã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒïŒåºãŸãïŒã圢æããããããã«ãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒå士ã¯ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒéã®
ãªã³ã¯ãå°ãªãã»ã©ãããåŒãé¢ãããããã«æãããããããã£ãŠããã®ææ³ã§æãããããã
ã¯ãŒã¯ã»ã°ã©ãã®äžå¿ã«äœçœ®ããã®ã¯ãããå€ãã®äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠãããããã«ãã®ã€ãªãã£ã
çžæãå€ãã®äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠãããããªäŒæ¥ã§ãããšèããããã
ããã«ããããã¯ãŒã¯åæã§ã¯ããããã¯ãŒã¯ãå¯æ¥ã«ã€ãªãã£ããµãã»ã°ã«ãŒãïŒã³ãã¥ãã
ã£ïŒã«åå²ããããšãããè¡ãããããæ¬çš¿ã§ããBlondel et al. (2008)ã® Louvin æ³ãçšããŠäŒæ¥ã
ã°ã«ãŒãåããããšãè©Šã¿ããLouvin æ³ã®è©³çŽ°ã«ã€ããŠã¯ä»é²ã«è²ãããåºæ¬çã«ã¯ã³ãã¥ããã£
å ã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ãã³ãã¥ããã£éã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ã«æ¯ã¹ãŠã§ããéãå€ããªãããã«ãã³ãã¥ããã£
ãå®çŸ©ãããã®ã§ããã
3.2 ãããã¯ãŒã¯ææš
ã°ããŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããäŒæ¥ã®æ§è³ªãåœããšã«æ¯èŒããããã以äžã® 4 ã€ã®ãããã¯
ãŒã¯ææšã®ååžãèŠãããŸãã次æ°ïŒdegreeïŒãšããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ïŒPageRankïŒãšããææšã«ãããå
äŒæ¥ããããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããŠã©ã®çšåºŠäžå¿ã«äœçœ®ããŠããããè¡šãäžå¿æ§ã枬ã£ãã次æ°ãšã¯ãå
çŽã«ã€ãªãã£ãŠããäŒæ¥ã®æ°ã§å®çŸ©ãããããããã次æ°ã«ã¯ãããäŒæ¥ã®äžå¿æ§ã枬ããšãã«ã
ã®äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ã®äžå¿æ§ãèæ ®ã«å ¥ããŠããªããšããæ¬ ç¹ããããã€ãŸããå€ãã®äŒæ¥ãš
ã€ãªãã£ãŠãããæ±å¿çãäŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãªããããä»ã«å šãã€ãªãããæããªããããªãé å¿çãäŒ
æ¥ãšã®ã€ãªããããåãïŒã€ã®ã€ãªãããšããŠèŠãªãããŠãããããäžå¿æ§ã®ææšãšããŠã¯ååã§
ã¯ãªãã
ããã§ãããäŒæ¥ã®äžå¿æ§ãå®çŸ©ãããšãã«ãã®äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ã®äžå¿æ§ãå å³ããããã
ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®é£æ¥è¡åã®åºæå€ã®æ倧å€ããã°ãã°çšããããããããããã®åºæå€äžå¿æ§ææš
ã¯ããããã¯ãŒã¯å šäœãããã€ãã®ç¬ç«ãããµããããã¯ãŒã¯ã«åãããããããªå Žåã«ã¯é©åã§
ãªãããªããªãããã®å Žåã«ã¯æ倧ã®ãµããããã¯ãŒã¯å ã®äŒæ¥ãé€ãå šãŠã®äŒæ¥ã®åºæå€äžå¿æ§
ã 0 ãšãªã£ãŠããŸãããã§ããããŸããåºæå€äžå¿æ§ã¯ããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãè³æ¬ææé¢ä¿ãªã©ã®
6
ã€ãªããã«æ¹åã®ãããããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒæåãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒã®å Žåãäžæã«æ±ºãŸããªãå¯èœæ§ãããã
ããããåé¡ãä¹ãè¶ãããããPage et al. (1999) ãããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãšãããåºæå€äžå¿æ§ãæ¡åŒµã
ãææšãéçºãããããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã¯ãã€ã³ã¿ãŒãããäžã®ãŠã§ããµã€ãã®éèŠåºŠïŒäžå¿æ§ïŒãè©äŸ¡
ããã®ã«ããçšããããŠããææšã§ããã
ãŸããä»ã®ææšãšããŠãBurt (1992)ã®å¶çŽææšïŒconstraintïŒãçšãããBurt (1992, 2004) ã¯ãã°ã«
ãŒãéã®æ å ±æ³¢åã«ãããŠãããã¯ãŒã¯å ã®ç°ãªãã°ã«ãŒããšã®ã€ãªãããéèŠãªåœ¹å²ãæãã
ãšäž»åŒµããŠãããåããŒããæ§ã ãªã°ã«ãŒããšã®å€æ§ãªã€ãªãããæã£ãŠããããæ°éçã«è¡šãã
ãã以äžã®ããã«å®çŸ©ãããå¶çŽææšãšããææšãæèµ·ããã
2( ) , ij ij iq qjj j qc p p p i q j
ãã ããpij =1/(ããŒã iã®æ¬¡æ°)ã§å®çŸ©ããããç°¡åã«èšãã°ããã®å¶çŽææšã¯ç£æ¥éç©ã®åºŠåãã
è¡šãã®ã«ããçšããããããŒãã£ã³ããŒã«ææšã«äŒŒãŠãããå°æ°ã®ããŒããšããã€ãªãã£ãŠããªã
ããŒãã§ã¯å€§ãããå€ãã®ããŒããšã€ãªãã£ãããŒãã§ã¯å°ããå€ããšããããã«ãããããŒããš
ã€ãªãã£ãããŒããããã«å€ãã®ããŒããšã€ãªãã£ãŠãããšãå¶çŽææšã¯ããã«å°ãããªããèšã
æããã°ãå¶çŽææšã¯ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããããŒãããŒã®å€æ§æ§ã®éæ°ã§ããã
æåŸã«ãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ïŒcluster coefficientïŒãèšæž¬ãããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã¯ãåããŒããšã€ãªã
ã£ãããŒãå士ãã€ãªãã£ãŠããå²åãšããŠå®çŸ©ããããäŸãã°ãããããŒã A ã BãCãD ã® 3
ã€ã®ããŒããšã€ãªãã£ãŠãããšããããããBãCãD ã®ãã¡ B ãš C ãã€ãªãã£ãŠããããB ãš Dã
C ãš D ã¯ã€ãªãã£ãŠããªããªããA ã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã¯ 1/3 ã§ãããããããŒãã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°
ã倧ããã»ã©ããã®ããŒãã®ããŒãããŒå士ãã€ãªãã£ãŠããŠããã®ããŒãèªèº«ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒãš
ãŽã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æããŠãããšãããããã ããŠèšãã°ãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã倧
ããã»ã©ããã®ããŒãã¯äºãã«åŒ·ãçµã§çµã°ããã°ã«ãŒãã圢æããŠãããšã¿ãªãããšãã§ããã
Burt (1992, 2004) ã¯ãããããŒãã®å¶çŽææšã倧ããïŒå€æ§æ§ãäœãïŒã»ã©ããŸããã®ãšãŽãã
ãã¯ãŒã¯ãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒåãããŠããã»ã©ããã®ããŒããšããã«ã€ãªãã£ãããŒãã®ãã€æ å ±ã䌌é
ã£ãŠããŠãäºãããåŠã¹ãããšãå°ãªããªããšäž»åŒµããŠãããããã¯ãGranovetter (1973)ã®äž»åŒµã
ãã匱ãç¹ããã®åŒ·ã¿ããšåæ§ã®è°è«ã§ããã
4. ã°ããŒãã«ã»ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³
FactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ãããšã«ç¹å®ããäžç 57,693 瀟ã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®ç¹åŸŽãæãã
ã«ããããã第 3.1 ç¯ã®ææ³ã§ãããã¯ãŒã¯å šäœãå¯èŠåãããå³ïŒã«ããã®åè¡¡ç¶æ ã®ã°ã©ãã
瀺ãããŠãããæ¥æ¬ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ãäžåœãã€ã®ãªã¹ãéåœããã€ãã®äŒæ¥ïŒå«ãŸããŠããäŒæ¥æ°é ïŒ
ããã®æåšåœæ¯ã«ããããç·ããã³ã¯ããªã¬ã³ãžãèµ€ãæ°Žè²ãéã§è²åãããŠãããã¢ã¡ãªã«ãã€
ã®ãªã¹ããã€ãã®äŒæ¥ã¯ã°ã©ãã®å€§éšåã§ãã亀ããåã£ãŠããããšããã欧米äŒæ¥ã¯ã°ããŒãã«ã»
ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããŠäºãã«åŒ·ãã€ãªãããã£ãŠããããšããããã
7
å³ 1: äžçã®äž»èŠäŒæ¥ã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
ïŒæ³šïŒåç¹ã¯äŒæ¥ãè¡šããŠãããåç·ã¯äŒæ¥éãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãªã³ã¯ãè¡šããŠãããäžåœããã€ãã
æ¥æ¬ãéåœãã¢ã¡ãªã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹ä»¥å€ã®åœã®äŒæ¥ã¯ç°è²ã§è¡šãããŠããã ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
äžæ¹ã§ãæ¥æ¬ã®äŒæ¥ã¯ãäžéšã¢ã¡ãªã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹ããã€ãã®äŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãªãããèŠããããã®ã®ã
å€ãã¯ãã³ã¯ãšèµ€ãšéãæ··ãã£ãäžå¿éšããé¢ãããšããã«äœçœ®ããŠããããããã£ãŠã欧米諞åœ
ãšæ¯ã¹ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãäžå¿ãšããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã«å±ããäŒæ¥ãå€ãããšããããããŸããéåœäŒæ¥ãå
æ§ã®åŸåãèŠããããäžåœäŒæ¥ã¯æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãéåœäŒæ¥ãšæ¯ã¹ãŠãããã«åšèŸºã«äœçœ®ããŠãããå€åœ
äŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãªããã匱ããäž»ã«äžåœäŒæ¥ã®ã¿ãããªãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æããŠããããšãèŠãŠåããã
åœããšã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®ç¹åŸŽããã詳现ã«ã¿ããããïŒã€ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ææšïŒæ¬¡æ°ãããŒãž
ã©ã³ã¯ãå¶çŽææšãã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ïŒã®å€ãæ¥æ¬ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹ãäžåœããããã«ã€ããŠ
èšç®ãããå³ 2 ã¯äžå¿æ§ææšã§ãã次æ°ãšããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã«é¢ããæ£åžå³ã瀺ããŠããããã®å³ã
ããæ¥æ¬ã«ã¯äžå¿æ§ãäžçãããã¬ãã«ã®äŒæ¥ããããã®ã®ãã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ã«æ¯ã¹ããšæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥
ã¯å šäœãšããŠã¯äžå¿æ§ãäœãããšãããããäžåœäŒæ¥ãšæ¯èŒããŠããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯ããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã§
ã¯å£ã£ãŠãããããã¯ãå³ 1 ã§èŠãããã«äžåœäŒæ¥ãå¿ ãããä»åœã®äŒæ¥ãšã¯å€ãã®ã€ãªããã
æã£ãŠããªãåé¢ãäžçã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®äžå¿ã«ããäžççäŒæ¥ãšã¯ã€ãªãã£ãŠããããšã®
è¡šãã§ãããšèããããã
8
å³ 2: ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããäžå¿æ§ïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
å³ 3 ã¯ãå¶çŽææšãšã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã«é¢ããæ£åžå³ã§ããããããèŠããšãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã§ã¯å¶çŽ
ææšãäœãã«ããããããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ãæ¯èŒçé«ãäŒæ¥ãããªãã¡ã°ã«ãŒãå ã®åŒ·ãçµãšã
ãè ãšã®å€æ§ãªã€ãªãããšã䜵ãæã£ãäŒæ¥ãå€ãååšããŠããããšãããããåé¢ãæ¥æ¬ãäž
åœãã€ã®ãªã¹ã§ã¯ãã®ãããªäŒæ¥ã¯å°ãªãã第 1 ç¯ã§è¿°ã¹ãããã«ã匷ãçµãšããè ãšã®åŒ±ãã€
ãªããã®äž¡æ¹ãæã€å Žåã«ãäŒæ¥ãå人ã¯ããã€ãããŒãã£ãã«ãªãããšãå®èšŒãããŠãããã
ã®æå³ã§ãã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ã®ãã®ç¹åŸŽã¯ãã¢ã¡ãªã«çµæžã®ã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³åã®é«ãã®èŠå ã瀺åã
ããã®ã§ããã
å³ 3ïŒãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããå€æ§æ§ïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
9
次ã«ããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããäŒæ¥ã®åœéåã«ã€ããŠããã詳现ã«èŠãŠã¿ãããå³ 4 ã«ã¯ã
æ¥æ¬ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ãäžåœããããã«ã€ããŠãåœå äŒæ¥ãšããããšçŽæ¥ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã§ã€ãªãã£
ãå€åœäŒæ¥ïŒå€åœã«ç«å°ããäŒæ¥ãšå®çŸ©ãããæ¥ç³»äŒæ¥ãå«ãïŒã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã瀺ãããã®ã§
ãããé»è²ãšç·ã®ããŒãã¯ããããåœå äŒæ¥ãæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãè¡šããŠãããLiveData ã§ã¯ãäžå€®æ¿åº
ã¯ãã®ååããç¹å®ããããšãã§ããèµ€ã®ããŒãã¯äžå€®æ¿åºãè¡šããŠãããåããŒãã¯æ¬¡æ°ã倧
ãããã®ã»ã©ããŒããµã€ãºã倧ãããªãããã«æãããŠããã
ã¢ã¡ãªã«ãšäžåœã®ã°ã©ãã§ã¯ãç·è²ã®ããŒããšé»è²ã®ããŒãããŸãã¹ããªãæ··ããåã£ãŠãã
ããšãããäž¡åœã§ã¯å€ãã®äŒæ¥ãã°ããŒãã«ãªãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«çµã¿èŸŒãŸããŠããããšããã
ããããããæ¥æ¬ã®å Žåã¯å·Šäžæ¹ã«é»è² 1 è²ãšãªã£ãäŒæ¥çŸ€ãèŠãããããã¯ãæ¥æ¬ã«ã¯å€åœãš
ã®ã€ãªãããåžèãªäŒæ¥ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒããããªãã®èŠæš¡ã§ååšããŠããããšã瀺åããŠããã
å³ 4: ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®åœéåïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
A: æ¥æ¬ B.ã¢ã¡ãªã«
C: äžåœ
ïŒæ³šïŒ ããããã®ã°ã©ãã§ã¯ãåœå äŒæ¥ãšçŽæ¥ååŒã®
ããæµ·å€äŒæ¥ã瀺ãããŠãããé»è²ã®ããŒããåœå äŒ
æ¥ãç·è²ãæµ·å€äŒæ¥ã§ãããèµ€è²ã¯åœè©²åœã®äžå€®æ¿åº
ãè¡šããŠããã ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
10
ããã«ãç¹ã«èªåè»ç£æ¥ã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®åœéåã«ã€ããŠçŠç¹ãåœãŠãŠã¿ãããå³ 5 ã®é
ãæ£ã°ã©ãã¯æ¥ç±³æ¬§ã®ããã 3 ã®èªåè»ã¡ãŒã«ãŒã® 1 次ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã®ãã¡å€åœäŒæ¥ã®å²åã瀺
ããŠããããããèŠããšãæ¥ç±³æ¬§ãšãã« 70ïŒ ååŸã§ãããããã»ã©å€§ããªå·®ã¯ãªãããããããª
ã¬ã³ãžè²ã®æ£ã§ç€ºãããããã 3 ã® 1 次ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã®è²©å£²å ã®ãã¡ã®å€åœäŒæ¥ã®å²åãèŠã
ãšãæ¥æ¬ã¯ 35ïŒ çšåºŠã§ã欧米ã 50ïŒ ãè¶ ããŠããã®ã«ããã¹ããšäœããããã¯ãæ¥æ¬ã®æçµã¡ãŒ
ã«ãŒã¯ãã§ã«åœéåãé²ãã§ãããã®ã®ããµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã¯åœå ã®ç³»åé¢ä¿ã«ãšããããŠãæµ·å€ã¡
ãŒã«ãŒã«å¯ŸããŠéšåãäŸçµŠã§ããŠããªãããšã瀺åããŠããã
å³ 5ïŒæ¥ç±³æ¬§ããã 3 èªåè»ã¡ãŒã«ãŒã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®åœéåïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
次ã«ããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¿åºã®åœ¹å²ã«ã€ããŠåæãè©Šã¿ããå³ 4 ã®æ¥æ¬ã®ãµãã©ã€ã
ã§ãŒã³ãããäžåºŠèŠãŠã¿ããšãåœéåããŠããªãé»è²ã®æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥çŸ€ã®äžè§ã«èµ€è²ã§ç€ºãããäžå€®
æ¿åºãããããšããããããã®ãããªåŸåã¯æ¥æ¬ã«ç¹åŸŽçã§ãããç±³äžã§ã¯åœå äŒæ¥ãšå€åœäŒæ¥
ããŸãããã£ãäžã«æ¿åºãäœçœ®ããŠãããããã«å¥ã®ææ³ã§ããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¥æ¬æ¿
åºã®ç¹åŸŽãæµ®ã圫ãã«ããŠã¿ããããŸãã第 3.1 ç¯ã§èª¬æãã Louvain æ³ãå©çšããŠããããã¯ãŒ
ã¯ã§ã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ãããã€ãã®ã³ãã¥ããã£ïŒãµãã»ã°ã«ãŒãïŒã«åå²ããã次ã«ãæ¿åºã®ãš
ãŽã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãããªãã¡æ¿åºãšçŽæ¥ã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ãããªãæ¿åºã®ãµãã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ã
ããŠãäŒæ¥ãã³ãã¥ããã£ããšã«è²åãããŠè¡šç€ºãããã€ãŸããããŒãã®åè²ã¯ãã®ããŒããå±
ããã³ãã¥ããã£ãŒãè¡šããŠãããç°ãªãè²ã§å¡ãããããŒãã¯ç°ãªãã³ãã¥ããã£ã«å«ãŸã
ãããããæ¥ç±³äžã«ã€ããŠè¡šããã®ãå³ 6 ã§ãããäžå€®ã®èµ€ãããŒãã¯æ¥ç±³äžããããã«ããã
äžå€®æ¿åºã§ããããããèŠããšãæ¥æ¬æ¿åºã¯ãã³ã¯è²ã®ã³ãã¥ããã£ã«å±ããäŒæ¥ãšã®ã€ãªãã
ãäžå¿ã§ãæ¿åºãšã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ã«å€æ§æ§ãå°ãªããããã«å¯ŸããŠãç±³äžã§ã¯æ¿åºãæ§ã ãªè²ã®
äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãããæã£ãŠãããæ¥æ¬æ¿åºãšåãã³ãã¥ããã£ã«å±ããäŒæ¥ã®å èš³ãã¿ãŠã¿ããšã
91ïŒ ãåœå äŒæ¥ã§ãããäž»èŠååœã®äžã§ããã®å€ã¯ç¹ã«é«ããäŸãã°ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã§ã¯ãã®å²åã¯
68ïŒ ãäžåœã§ã¯ 58ïŒ ã§ãããæ¥æ¬ã«ããã¹ä»åœã§ã¯äžå€®æ¿åºãå€ãã®æµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠã
ããã€ãŸããä»åœã«ããã¹ãŠæ¥æ¬æ¿åºã¯éãããåœå äŒæ¥ããç©åã»ãµãŒãã¹ã調éããããã
ã®äŒæ¥ã¯åœéåããã«æ¿åºèª¿éã«äŸåããŠããããšã瀺åãããã
11
å³ 6ïŒãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¿åºã®ãšãŽã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒ2015 幎ïŒ
AïŒæ¥æ¬
BïŒã¢ã¡ãªã«
CïŒäžåœ
ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
ããã«ããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¿åºã®åœ¹å²ãããå€ãã®åœã«ã€ããŠæŠèŠ³ãããããLiveData
ã«å«ãŸããäŒæ¥æ°ã§äžäœãå ãã 20 ãåœ2ã«ã€ããŠãå šäŒæ¥æ°ã§æšæºåããååœæ¿åºã®æ¬¡æ°ããã
2 å°æ¹Ÿã¯äŒæ¥æ°äžäœ 20 äœä»¥å ã«å ¥ãããWorld Bank ã® World Development Indicators ã«å«ãŸããŠããªããããå°æ¹Ÿ
12
ã¯ããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãšäžäººåœããå®è³ª GDP ãšã®é¢ä¿ãæ£åžå³ã«æããïŒå³ 7ïŒãæ¥æ¬ïŒJPïŒæ¿åºã®äžå¿
æ§ã¯äœãããäžåœïŒCNïŒãã€ã³ãïŒINïŒããã©ãžã«ïŒBRïŒãã¿ã€ïŒTHïŒãšãã£ãæ°èåœã«ãããŠã¯ã
äžå€®æ¿åºã®æ¬¡æ°äžå¿æ§ãæ¯èŒçé«ããæ°èåœã®ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããŠæ¿åºãéèŠãªåœ¹å²ãæã
ããŠããããšã瀺åããŠãããç¹ã«ãäžåœæ¿åºã¯å€ãã®äžçã®äžå¿çãªäŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠããããŸ
ããã¢ã¡ãªã«ïŒUSïŒæ¿åºã®ããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã¯éåžžã«é«ããã¢ã¡ãªã«æ¿åºã¯äžçã®äžå¿çãªäŒæ¥ãšã€ãª
ãã£ãŠããããšããããã
å³ 7ïŒãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¿åºã®äžå¿æ§ãšäžäººåœãã GDP
AïŒæ¬¡æ°
BïŒããŒãžã©ã³ã¯
ïŒåºæïŒäžäººåœãã GDP ã¯ãWorld Bank ã® World Development Indicators ã«ãã賌買å平䟡調æŽæžã¿ã®
å®è³ªå€ïŒãã«ïŒã§ãããäžå¿æ§ææšã¯ FactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè ãäœæãããã®ã
ãé€ã 21 äœã®åœãå«ãã 20 ãåœã«ã€ããŠæ£åžå³ãæããã
13
ãªãããã®ããã«ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããæ¿åºã®ååšæã®å·®ãã¿ãŠãããšãå³ 2 ã«ãããŠã
ãŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãé«ã次æ°ã®äœãäžåœäŒæ¥ãå°ãªãããååšããŠããããšã«ã€ããŠãå¥ã®è§£éããã
ãããã€ãŸãããããã®äŒæ¥ã¯äžå¿æ§ã®é«ãäžåœæ¿åºãšã€ãªãã£ãŠãããããã«ããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã
é«ããªã£ãŠãããæ¿åºé¢ä¿äŒæ¥ã矀ã§ãã£ãŠãäžçã®éèŠãªäŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠããããšã瀺åã
ãŠããããã§ã¯ãªããããããªããããã§ãå³ 2 ã«ãããŠäžå€®æ¿åºã®çŽæ¥ã®ååŒå äŒæ¥ãèµ€ãè²
ã¥ãããŠæããªããããã®ãå³ 8 ãšããŠç€ºãããããã«ãããšãããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãé«ã次æ°ã®äœã
äŒæ¥çŸ€ã®ãã¡èµ€ãå¡ãããŠãããã®ãå€ããªãããšããããäžåœäŒæ¥ã¯å¿ ãããå€ãã®äŒæ¥ãšã€ãª
ãã£ãŠããããã§ã¯ãªãããäžçã®éèŠãªäŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠããããšããæã ã®è§£éã¯åŠ¥åœã§ã
ããšèãããããåé¢ãæ¥æ¬ã«ã€ããŠã¯æ¬¡æ°ãæ¯èŒçé«ããŠãããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãå°ããèµ€ãç¹ãå€
ããæ¥æ¬ã§ã¯æ¿åºãšã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ãäžçã®äžå¿çãªäŒæ¥ãšã¯ã€ãªãã£ãŠããªãããšãå確èªã§
ããã
以äžã®ããšãããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯å¹³åçã«ã¯å¿ ãããåœéåãé ããŠããããã§ã¯ãªããã®ã®ãç¹
ã«æçµã¡ãŒã«ãŒä»¥å€ã«ãããŠããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã®äžæµãæ¿åºèª¿éã«äŸåããäŒæ¥ãªã©åœéåã
é²ãã§ããªãäŒæ¥ãäžå®çšåºŠååšããŠãããšçµè«ã¥ããããã
å³ 8ïŒãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ã«ãããŠæ¿åºãšã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ã®äžå¿æ§
ïŒæ³šïŒèµ€ãç¹ã¯æ¿åºãšçŽæ¥ã€ãªãã£ãäŒæ¥ããéãç¹ã¯ãã®ä»ã®äŒæ¥ãè¡šãã ïŒåºæïŒFactSet Revere 瀟㮠LiveData ã«ããçè äœæã
5. äžçã®è³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯
次ã«ãäžçäŒæ¥ã®è³æ¬ïŒæ ªåŒïŒææãããã¯ãŒã¯ãåæããã第 2 ç¯ã§è¿°ã¹ãéããããã§äœ¿çš
ããããŒã¿ã«ã¯çŽ 300 äžç€Ÿã300 äžã®äŒæ¥é¢ä¿ãå«ãŸããŠããããã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžæ žéšãæã
ãã®ãå³ 9 ã§ããã
14
å³ 9: äžçäŒæ¥ã®è³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒ2014 幎ïŒ
ïŒæ³šïŒåç¹ã¯äŒæ¥ãè¡šããŠãããåç·ã¯äŒæ¥éã®è³æ¬ææãè¡šããŠãããäžåœããã€ããæ¥æ¬ãéåœãã¢
ã¡ãªã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹ä»¥å€ã®åœã®äŒæ¥ã¯ç°è²ã§è¡šãããŠããã ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãè¡šãå³ 1 ã«ããã¹ããšãå€ãã®åœéåããŠããªãäžå°é¶çŽ°äŒæ¥ãå«ãŸããŠã
ãããã«ãå³ 9 ã®æ¹ãåè²ã®ããŒããæ··ãããã£ãŠããããåœããšã«åãããŠã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æã
ãŠããããšãã¯ã£ããèŠããããã ãããããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ã§ã¯ããã¯ãã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ïŒãã³ã¯ïŒã
ã€ã®ãªã¹äŒæ¥ïŒèµ€ïŒããã€ãäŒæ¥ïŒéïŒãæ··åšããŠããã欧米äŒæ¥ãã€ãªãããªããã°ããŒãã«è³æ¬
ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ã«äœçœ®ããŠããããšãããããããã€ãã®æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ïŒç·ïŒã¯ã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ãšäº€
ããã€ã€äžå¿ä»è¿ã«äœçœ®ããŠããããå€ãã¯åšèŸºé åã«æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã ãã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æããŠããã
æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®å€ãã¯è³æ¬ææé¢ã§åœéåããŠããªãããšãããããå®éãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®æè³å ã®ãã¡
74ïŒ ã¯æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã§ãããã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ã®å Žå㯠35ïŒ ã§ããã®ã«ããã¹ããšãåœå æè³ãéç«ã£ãŠå€
ãã
ããã«ãäžå¿æ§ã«ã€ããŠã®æ£åžå³ãå³ 10 ã«ç€ºããããã«ãããšãæ¥æ¬ã¯ã¢ã¡ãªã«ãã€ã®ãªã¹äŒ
æ¥ã«ããã¹ãŠäžå¿æ§ææšã®å€§ããªäŒæ¥ãå°ãªããäžåœãšããã¹ãŠããç¹ã«ããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ã倧ããäŒ
æ¥ãå°ãªããå³ 9 ã§ãäžåœäŒæ¥ã«ã€ããŠã¯æ¬§ç±³äŒæ¥ãšäº€ãã£ãäŒæ¥ãäžå®çšåºŠã®å€§ãããæã£ãã¯
ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒãæ§æããŠãããã®ã®ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã«ã€ããŠã¯ãã®ãããªäŒæ¥ã¯å°æ°ãç¹åšããŠããã«ãšã©
ãŸã£ãŠãããããã¯æ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãäžåœäŒæ¥ãšããã¹ãŠãããŒãžã©ã³ã¯ãå°ãããã€ãŸãäžçã®äžå¿ç
ãªäŒæ¥ãšã€ãªãã£ãŠããªãããšãšæŽåçã§ããã
15
å³ 10ïŒè³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããäžå¿æ§ïŒ2014 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
ãŸããå¶çŽææšãšã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã«é¢ããæ£åžå³ãå³ 11 ã«ç€ºããã€ã®ãªã¹ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã§ã¯ãå¶
çŽææšãå°ããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ãæ¯èŒçé«ãäŒæ¥ãã€ãŸãå¯ãªã€ãªãããšå€æ§ãªã€ãªããã®äž¡æ¹ã
æã€äŒæ¥ãå€ããããã«å¯ŸããŠãæ¥æ¬ã§ã¯ãã®ãããªäŒæ¥ã¯å°ãªããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒä¿æ°ã 1 ã«è¿ãã
ããªãã¡ã°ã«ãŒãå ã®å¯ãªã€ãªããã®ã¿ãæã£ãäŒæ¥ãéåžžã«å€ãååšããŠãããããã¯ãæ¥æ¬äŒ
æ¥å士ãæ ªåŒãæã¡åãããšãå€ãããšãåæ ããŠãããšèããããã
ã€ãŸããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®æè³ã¯ãããŸã§ãåœå äŒæ¥åããäžå¿ã§ãäžçã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããäžå¿
çãªæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãžã®æ ªåŒæè³ãååã«ãªãããŠããªãã
å³ 11ïŒè³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããå€æ§æ§ïŒ2014 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
16
6. å ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯
æåŸã«ãç¹èš±ã®å ±åææã«ãã£ãŠç€ºãããäŒæ¥éã®å ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ã€ããŠåæãè¡ãã
ç¹èš±ã®å ±åææãšå ±åç 究ã¯å¿ ãããäžèŽãããã®ã§ã¯ãªãããå ±åç 究ã«ãããªãç¹èš±ã®å ±åæ
æã®å Žåã§ããäŒæ¥éã§ç¥èãæè¡ã®ããåããè¡ãããŠããå¯èœæ§ã¯é«ããããã§ã¯å ±åç 究ã
ããã¯ãŒã¯ãšãšãããããšãšããã
å³ 12 ã¯ãäžçã®å ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ãè¡šããŠããããã®å³ããããµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ïŒå³ 1ïŒã
è³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒå³ 9ïŒã«ããã¹ããšãå ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã¯åœããšã«ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒãšãªã
åŸåãé¡èã§ãåœéçãªå ±åç 究ã¯ãŸã ãŸã å°ãªãããšããããããšã¯èšããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®åœéåã¯
ä»åœãšããã¹ãŠç¹ã«è²§åŒ±ã§ããã欧米ã®äŒæ¥ããããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ã§ã¯ããã¶ã亀ãã£ãŠãããäž
åœäŒæ¥ãã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ãšäº€ããå§ããŠããã®ã«ããã¹ããšãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã¯äžå¿ããããª
ãå€ãããšããã«ç¬ç«ããŠãããå³ 13 ã«ãããšãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ç¹èš±å ±åææçžæã®ãã¡å€åœäŒæ¥ã¯
ããã 13ïŒ ã§ãããã€ã®ãªã¹ã® 80ïŒ ãã¢ã¡ãªã«ã® 40ïŒ ã¯ããããäžåœã® 32ïŒ ãšããã¹ãŠãçžåœã«
äœããäžåœäŒæ¥ã¯ 2005-07 幎ã®ããŒã¿ã§ã¯äžçã®å ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒçŽå¹ ã®é¢ä¿ã§å³ã¯çç¥ïŒ
ã«ã»ãšãã©å§¿ãèŠããªããã6 幎åŸã® 2011-13 幎ã®ããŒã¿ã§ã¯ã¢ã¡ãªã«äŒæ¥ãäž»ãšããã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒ
ãååšããããããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ä»è¿ã«ã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æããŠããããšã¯ç¹çãã¹ãã§ããããã
ã«ããã¹ãŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯ 2005-07 幎æç¹ã§ã 2011-13 幎æç¹ãšåæ§ã«åœå çãªã¯ã©ã¹ã¿ãŒã圢æã
ãŠãããããŸãå€åãèªããããªãã
å³ 12ïŒäžçäŒæ¥ã®å ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ïŒ2011-13 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
17
å³ 13ïŒç¹èš±å ±åææçžæã®å€åœäŒæ¥ã®ã·ã§ã¢ïŒïŒ ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
ãã ããå³ 14 ã«ç€ºãããããã«ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯å¶çŽææšãå°ããåŸåãèŠããããããã¯ãåœé
çã«ã¯å ±åç 究ããã»ã©è¡ã£ãŠããªããã®ã®ãåœå ã§ã¯å€æ§ãªçžæãšå ±åç 究ãè¡ã£ãŠããããšã
瀺åããŠãããåœå ã«å€æ§ãªç 究ããŒãããŒã確ä¿ããããšã§ãå€æ§ãªç¥èãæè¡ãå©çšããããš
ãã§ããŠããããã«ãç 究é¢ã§åœéåããŠãããæ°ããç¥èãæµå ¥ãã«ãããšãããã¡ãªãããå€
å°ãªããšãç·©åããŠããã®ãããããªãã
å³ 14ïŒå ±åç 究ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããå€æ§æ§ïŒ2011-13 幎ïŒ
ïŒåºæïŒãã¥ãŒãã»ãã³ã»ãã€ã¯ç€Ÿã® Orbis ã«ããçè äœæã
18
7. çµè«ãšæ¿çæèš
æ¬çš¿ã¯ãã°ããŒãã«ãªãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãè³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ãç¹èš±ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ã«æ³šç®
ããåœéåãå«ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®ç¹åŸŽãã欧米ãäžåœãšæ¯èŒããªããåæããããã®çµæãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯
ãµãã©ã€ãã§ãŒã³ãè³æ¬ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ãç¹èš±ææãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®ãããã«ãããŠããåœå ã§å¯
ãªã€ãªããã¯ãã£ãŠããããäžçã®äŒæ¥ãšååã«ã€ãªãããŠããªãããšã瀺ãããã
第 1 ç¯ã§è¿°ã¹ãããã«ãäŒæ¥ãå¹ççã«ç¥èãåžåããŠã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ãèµ·ãããŠããããã«
ã¯ãã°ã«ãŒãå ã§ã®åŒ·ãçµïŒå¯ãªã€ãªããïŒãšããè ãšã®åŒ±ãã€ãªããã䜵ãæã£ãå€æ§ãªã€ãªã
ããå¿ èŠã§ããããã®æå³ã§ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã¯ç¹ã«æµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšããããè ãšã®ã€ãªããã«æ¬ ããããã
æ¥æ¬çµæžã®åæ»ã®äžå ãšãªã£ãŠããå¯èœæ§ãããã
ãšã¯ãããæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãã¯ãããšããããè ãšã®ã€ãªããã®æ§ç¯ã«ã¯ç©ççã»å¿ççã«å€§ããªè²»çš
ãããããããã«ãè²»çšããããŠããè ãšã®ã€ãªãããæ§ç¯ããŠæ°ããç¥èãåŸãŠããããã¯åŸã
ã«ããŠæ§ã ãªçµè·¯ã§ä»ç€Ÿã«æ³¢åããŠããŸãããšãªããšãäŒæ¥ã¯èªãè²»çšããããŠã€ãªãããæ§ç¯ã
ãããããä»ç€Ÿã®æ§ç¯ããã€ãªããã«ããªãŒã©ã€ãããããšããããã«ãããè ãšã®ã€ãªããã¯å
åã«æ§ç¯ãããªãããšãå€ããçµæžåŠçã«èšãã°ããããã¯ãŒã¯ããã®åçããã»ã¹ã«å€éšæ§ãã
ãããã«åžå Žã®å€±æããããŠãåžå Žçµæžã«ããããããã¯ãŒã¯ã¯æé©ãªã¬ãã«ãäžåããšããããš
ã«ãªãããããã£ãŠãæ¿åºãä»å ¥ããŠããè ãšã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®æ§ç¯ãæ¯æŽããããšã瀟äŒå šäœã®
å©çãšãªãã
ãããã£ãŠãæ¥æ¬æ¿åºã¯äŒæ¥ã®åœéåãä¿é²ãããããªæ¿çãããç©æ¥µçã«è¡ãå¿ èŠããããç¹
ã«å¿ èŠãã€æå¹ã§ãããšæãããåéã¯ä»¥äžã® 3 ç¹ã§ããããŸã第 1 ã«ãå³ 5 ã§ç€ºãããããã«ã
äžå°ã®ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã®è£œåã®èŒžåºãé²ãã§ããªããããããæ¥æ¬ã®ãããã¡ãŒã«ãŒã«éšåãäŸçµŠã
ãŠãããµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã¯æè¡çã«ã¯ååæµ·å€ã¡ãŒã«ãŒãšã®ååŒãå¯èœãªã¯ãã§ããããã®ããã«æœåš
çã«æµ·å€åžå Žã§ã®ç«¶äºåããããªããæµ·å€ã«åºãŠããªãäŒæ¥ãæ¥æ¬ã«å€æ°ååšããããšã¯ãããŸ
ã§ã瀺ãããŠãã(è¥æéå¹³ et al., 2008)ããè¥éŸäŒæ¥ããšç§°ãããŠãã(æžå 康ä¹, 2011)ããããŸã§
ã¯ãæ¥æ¬çãªç³»åé¢ä¿ã®ãã°ãã®ããã«ãåœå ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã®æµ·å€ãšã®ååŒã¯é²ãŸãªãã£ãããã
ããæ¥æ¬ã®ã¡ãŒã«ãŒã¯ãã§ã«ç³»åãè¶ ããŠæµ·å€ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒããã®éšå調éãå¢ãããŠããïŒå³ 5ïŒã
ç³»åé¢ä¿ã¯åŽ©ãå§ããŠãã(Matous and Todo, 2015)ããããã£ãŠãåœå ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒãçãæ®ãã®ã
ãã«ãç³»åã«ãšããããã«æµ·å€ã¡ãŒã«ãŒãå«ãå€ãã®äŒæ¥ãšç©æ¥µçã«ååŒãè¡ã£ãŠãããªããã°ãª
ããªãããã®ãããªããè ãšã®ã€ãªããã¯ãåœå ãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã«æ°ããç¥èãæ å ±ããããããç
ç£æ§ã®åäžã«å¯äžãããšèããããã
ãããã£ãŠãäžå°äŒæ¥ã«å¯Ÿããæµ·å€é²åºæ¯æŽãå¿ èŠã ãäŸãã°ãæµ·å€åžå Žã®æ å ±æäŸãæµ·å€å±ç€º
äŒåå ãã€ã³ã¿ãŒãããã«ããããžãã¹ãããã³ã°ãªã©ã«å¯Ÿããæ¯æŽã«ãã£ãŠããã§ã«ååã«æè¡
ã¬ãã«ã®é«ãäžå°ã®è¥éŸãµãã©ã€ã€ãŒã¯æ¯èŒç容æã«æµ·å€ã¡ãŒã«ãŒãšã®ååŒãå§ããããšãã§ã
ãã¯ãã ããããããããã®æœçã¯ãã§ã«æ¥æ¬è²¿ææ¯èæ©æ§ïŒJETROïŒãèªæ²»äœãäŒæ¥å£äœãªã©ã
è¡ã£ãŠãããããããã®æœçããã䜿ããããå¹ççãªåœ¢ã§çºå±ãããŠãããã°ãªããªãã
第 2 ã«ãå³ 9 ããã³ 10 ã§ç€ºãããããã«ãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã«ããæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãç¹ã«ã°ããŒãã«ã»ããã
ã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ã«äœçœ®ããäŒæ¥ã«å¯Ÿããè³æ¬æè³ãååã§ãªããã°ããŒãã«ã»ãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®äžå¿ã«
äœçœ®ããäŒæ¥ã¯å€ãã®ç¥èãæ å ±ãæã£ãŠãããšèããããããããããã®ã°ããŒãã«äŒæ¥ã«æè³
ããããšã§ãçŽæ¥çãªå©çã ãã§ã¯ãªãå€ãã®ç¥èãæ å ±ãæ¥æ¬ã«æµå ¥ããã¯ãã ã2015 幎ã«ã¯æ¥
19
æ¬äŒæ¥ã«ããæµ·å€ M&A ã®éé¡ãéå»æé«ã® 11 å åãšãªããæ¥æ¬ã®å¯Ÿå€çŽæ¥æè³é¡ã¯ GDP ã® 3.2ïŒ
ãš OECD è«žåœã® 2.8ïŒ ãäžåã£ãŠããïŒWorld Bank ã® World Development IndicatorsïŒãã€ãŸããéç
ã«ã¯å¿ ãããæ¥æ¬ã®æµ·å€æè³ãååã§ãªãããã§ã¯ãªããããããã°ããŒãã«çµæžã®äžå¿çãªäŒæ¥
ã«å¯Ÿããæè³ãå°ãªããšããç¹ã§ã質çã«åé¡ãããã
ãã®ãããªæµ·å€äŒæ¥ã«å¯Ÿãã M&A ã¯ãäºåã®ãã¥ãŒãã£ãªãžã§ã³ã¹ã«ãããŠæµ·å€äŒæ¥ã®äŸ¡å€ã
æ£ç¢ºã«æ»å®ããããšãé£ããããšã倧ããªéå£ãšãªã£ãŠããããããããã®ãããªæ»å®æè¡ã¯äžçŸ©
çã«ã¯åäŒæ¥ã®è²¬ä»»ã«ãããŠç£šãããã¹ããã®ã§ãããããã¥ãŒãã£ãªãžã§ã³ã¹ã«é¢ããç¥èãäŒ
æ¥ãå ±æããåç£ç¢ç£šããå Žãæ¿åºãæäŸããããšããã£ãŠãããã¹ãã§ãããã
第 3 ã«ãå³ 12 ããã³ 13 ã§ç€ºãããããã«ãæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã®å ±åç 究ãååã§ãªããæ å ±æè¡ïŒITïŒ
ã人工ç¥èœïŒAIïŒãçºå±ãããšãšãã«çµæžã«ãããã€ãããŒã·ã§ã³ã®éèŠæ§ãå¢ããŠããããŸãã
é»æ°èªåè»ãèªåé転æè¡ãªã©ã«ä»£è¡šãããããã«ããããŸã§ã®æè¡åéã®å£æ ¹ãè¶ ããåæ¥ãã€
ãããŒã·ã§ã³ã«ãããŠéèŠãšãªã£ãŠããŠããããã®ããã«ã¯ãå€æ§ãªæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã®å ±åç 究ãå¿ èŠ
ãšãªãããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã«ã¯ããã決å®çã«æ¬ ããŠãããä»åŸã¯å€ãã®è³æºãæµ·å€ã®äŒæ¥ãç 究æ©é¢ãš
ã®å ±åç 究ã«æå ¥ããå¿ èŠãããã
ããããæµ·å€äŒæ¥ãšã®å ±åç 究ã«ã€ããŠããæµ·å€äŒæ¥ã®ç 究掻åã«é¢ããæ å ±ãäžè¶³ããŠãããš
ããåé¡ããããããã«ãå ±åç 究ãéå§ããã«ã¯ãé¡ã®èŠããé¢ä¿ã«ãã£ãŠä¿¡é Œé¢ä¿ãç¯ãå¿ èŠ
ãããããããã®åé¡ã¯ãç 究è ãåœéåŠäŒã«åå ããããšã§è§£æ±ºãããããšãå€ãããããã£ãŠã
äŒæ¥ç 究è ãå«ããç 究è ã®åœéåŠäŒåå ã«å¯Ÿããæ¯æŽãæ¥æ¬ã§ã®åœéåŠäŒéå¬ã«å¯Ÿããæ¯æŽãª
ã©ã®æ¿çãæå¹ã§ããã
æåŸã«ãããå æ¬çã«ã¯ 2 åœéããã³å€åœéã®çµæžé£æºåå®ïŒEPAïŒãããç©æ¥µçã«çµãã§ãã
ããšãå¿ èŠã ãè¿å¹Žã® EPA ã¯èªç±è²¿æåå®ã ãã§ã¯ãªããæµ·å€çŽæ¥æè³ã«å¯ŸããèŠå¶ãç·©åãã
èŠå®ãç¥ç財ç£æš©ä¿è·ã匷åããèŠå®ãå«ãã§ããããšãå€ããæµ·å€æè³ãæµ·å€ãšã®å ±åç 究ã®ä¿
é²ã«å¹æçã ãæ¥æ¬ã¯ãã®ãã㪠EPA ã 2 åœéã§ãå€åœéã§ãç· çµããŠãããªããã°ãªããªããã
ãã®ããã«ã¯æ¥æ¬ã蟲ç£ç©ã®è²¿æãå«ããŠããèªç±åããŠããããšãæ±ãããããã
ãããã®æ¿çã«ãã£ãŠãæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ãããç©æ¥µçã«ãã€æå¹ã«æµ·å€ãšã®ã€ãªãããäœãããã®æè³
ãè¡ããããã€ãããŒãã£ãã«ãªãããšãæåŸ ããããè¿å¹Žãã€ã®ãªã¹ã EU é¢è±ã決è°ãããã©
ã³ã米倧統é ãç°å€ªå¹³æŽæŠç¥ççµæžé£æºåå®ïŒTPPïŒé¢è±ã宣èšããç±³äŒæ¥ïŒã¢ã¡ãªã«ã«ç«å°ãã
å€åœäŒæ¥ãå«ãïŒã®æµ·å€å±éãé»æ¢ããããšãããªã©ãäžççµæžã«ãããŠéé䞻矩ã»ä¿è·äž»çŸ©çãª
åããã¿ããããããããæŽå²ã瀺ãããã«ãéé䞻矩ã»ä¿è·äž»çŸ©ã¯ç€ŸäŒãçµæžã«ç Žæ» çãªåž°çµã
ããããã1930 幎代ã«äžççµæžãééçã«ãªã£ãŠãããã¯çµæžåããããšã§ã第 2 次äžç倧æŠã«çª
å ¥ããŠãã£ãã1950 幎代ã60 幎代ã«ã¯ãã©ãã³ã¢ã¡ãªã«ã貿æèŠå¶ã§ç£æ¥è²æãããããšããŠé
ã«çµæžåæ»ã«é¥ãããã®åŸé貚å±æ©ã»éèå±æ©ãé »çºããããã°ããŒãã«çµæžã«ãããäž»èŠåœã§ã
ãè±ç±³ãéé䞻矩ã»ä¿è·äž»çŸ©ã«åŸããŠããçŸåšãæ¥æ¬æ¿åºããã®æµãã«ç«¿ãå·®ãããããªãŒãã³ã§
ã€ãããŒãã£ããªã°ããŒãã«çµæžãæ§ç¯ããããšã¯ãäžçã«å¯Ÿãã責åã§ããããšãèšãããã
20
ä»é²ïŒãããã¯ãŒã¯ã®å¯èŠåã®ææ³
FortAtlas2 ã«ãããããã¯ãŒã¯ã»ã°ã©ãã®æåææ³ã説æããããã®ææ³ã§ã¯ãããŒãå士ã¯å
çºããããããªã³ã¯ã¯åŒãä»ãããããä»®å®ãããŠããããã® 2 åã®åè¡¡ç¶æ ãæçµçã«éæãã
ãããã«èšèšãããŠããã2 åã®å³å¯ãªå®çŸ©ã¯ä»¥äžã®éãã§ããããªã³ã¯ã§çµã°ããïŒã€ã®ããŒã
ãš ã®åŒå , )㯠2 ç¹ã®ãŠãŒã¯ãªããè·é¢ã«ãªã³ã¯ e ã®ãŠã§ã€ããããããã®
( , ) = w e d ,
ãšããŠå®çŸ©ããããÎŽã¯ãªã³ã¯ã®ãŠã§ã€ãã®åœ±é¿ã®å€§ããã調æŽããå€æ°ã§ãããæ¬çš¿ã§ã¯ããªã³
㯠e ã®ãŠã§ã€ãã¯æ¬¡æ°ãåºã«ããÎŽ ã¯ïŒã«èšå®ãããäžæ¹ãïŒã€ã®ããŒãéã®åçºå ( , )ã¯ã
以äžã®éãããããããŒãã®æ¬¡æ°ã«ïŒã足ãããã®ãæãåãããïŒã€ã®ããŒãã®è·é¢ã§å²ã£ãã
ã®ãšããŠä»¥äžã®ããã«å®çŸ©ãããã
( , ) = (Wu)/d( , )
ã¯ã°ã©ãå šäœã®ãµã€ãºã決ããä¿æ°ã§ããã
Gephi ã«ãã㊠ForceAtlas2 ãå©çšãããšãã«ã¯ããŸãåæç¶æ ãšããŠããŒããã©ã³ãã ã«åºãŸã
ããªããŠé 眮ãããããã®ç¶æ ãããäžã§è¿°ã¹ããããªåŒåãšæ¥åãåããããããŒãã¯åŸã ã«ç§»
åããŠãåãã®ãªãå®åžžåè¡¡ã«åæããŠããããã ããäžè¬çã«ã¯å®åžžåè¡¡ãè€æ°ãããšèãããã
æçµçã«åŸããããããã¯ãŒã¯ã»ã°ã©ããåæç¶æ ã«äŸåãå€åããŠããŸããšããæ¬ ç¹ããããã
ãããæ¬çš¿ã®åæã§ã¯ãè€æ°åã®è©Šè¡ã«ããå³ã倧ããå€ããããšã¯ãªãããšã確èªããŠããã
次ã«ãBlondel et al. (2008)ã® Louvin æ³ã«ããã³ãã¥ããã£åå²ã®ææ³ã説æãããã³ãã¥ããã£
ã«åå²ããéã«åé¡ãšãªãã®ããã©ã®ãããªåå²æ³ãæé©ããšããããšã§ããããLouvin æ³ã§ã¯ã
ã®åºæºãšããŠã¢ãžã¥ã©ãªãã£ãå©çšãããã¢ãžã¥ã©ãªãã£ãšã¯ããããããã¯ãŒã¯ã«ãããŠããŒã
ãã³ãã¥ããã£ã«åå²ãããŠãããšããã³ãã¥ããã£å ã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ãšã³ãã¥ããã£éã®ãªã³ã¯ã®
æ°ãšãæ¯èŒããæ°åã§ãããQ = â â ãšå®çŸ©ããããããã§ãeijã¯ã³ãã¥ãã㣠iã«
å«ãŸããããŒããšã³ãã¥ãã㣠jã«å«ãŸããããŒããçµã¶ãã¹ãŠã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ã®ãããã¯ãŒã¯å ã®
å šãªã³ã¯æ°ã«å¯Ÿããã·ã§ã¢ã§ããããããã£ãŠãeii ã¯ã³ãã¥ããã£å ã®ãªã³ã¯æ°ã®ã·ã§ã¢ãè¡šãã
ã€ãŸããã¢ãžã¥ã©ãªã㣠Q ã¯ãã³ãã¥ããã£å ã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ãã³ãã¥ããã£éã®ãªã³ã¯ã®æ°ã«æ¯ã¹
ãŠã©ã®çšåºŠå€ãããè¡šããŠããããã®ã¢ãžã¥ã©ãªãã£ãæ倧ã«ãªãããã«ã³ãã¥ããã£ãæœåºããã
ãã®éã«ããŸãã©ã³ãã ã«ããŒããéžæããã¢ãžã¥ã©ãªãã£ãæ倧ãšãªãããã«ããã®ããŒããšã€
ãªãã£ãããŒãã®éšåéåã 1 ã€ã®ã³ãã¥ããã£ãšããŠå®çŸ©ããããã®äœæ¥ãç¹°ãè¿ãããšã§ãã¢
ãžã¥ã©ãªãã£ãæ倧ãšãªããããªã³ãã¥ããã£æœåºã®ä»æ¹ãæ¢çŽ¢ããŠããã®ã Louvin æ³ã§ããã
ã³ãã¥ããã£æœåºã«ãããŠèšç®é床åã³ç²ŸåºŠã®äž¡é¢ã«ãããŠçŸæç¹ã§ã¯æãåªããŠãããšããŠæ
ãåºãçšããããŠããææ³ã§ããã
21
åèæç®
Andrade, S.C., and Chhaochharia, V., 2016. The costs of sovereign default: Evidence from the stock
market. SSRN.
Blondel, V.D., Guillaume, J.-L., Lambiotte, R., and Lefebvre, E., 2008. Fast unfolding of communities
in large networks. Journal of statistical mechanics: theory and experiment 2008, P10008.
Borensztein, E., De Gregorio, J., and Lee, J.-W., 1998. How does foreign direct investment affect
economic growth? Journal of International Economics 45, 115-135.
Burt, R.S., 1992. Structural holes: The social structure of competition. Harvard University Press,
Cambridge.
Burt, R.S., 2004. Structural holes and good ideas. American Journal of Sociology 110, 349-399.
Centola, D., 2010. The spread of behavior in an online social network experiment. Science 329, 1194-
1197.
Coe, D.T., and Helpman, E., 1995. International r&d spillovers. European Economic Review 39,
859-887.
Cui, L., and Jiang, F., 2012. State ownership effect on firms' FDI ownership decisions under institutional
pressure: A study of chinese outward-investing firms. Journal of International Business Studies 43,
264-284.
Durlauf, S.N., and Fafchamps, M., 2005. Social capital, in: Aghion, P., Durlauf, S.N. (Eds.), Handbook
of economic growth. Elsevier B.V., Amsterdam.
Dyer, J., and Nobeoka, K., 2000. Creating and managing a high performance knowledge-sharing network:
The toyota case. Strategic Management Journal 21, 345-367.
Egan, M.L., and Mody, A., 1992. Buyer-seller links in export development. World Development 20, 321-
334.
Fosfuri, A., Motta, M., and RÞnde, T., 2001. Foreign direct investment and spillovers through workersâ
mobility. Journal of International Economics 53, 205-222.
Granovetter, M.S., 1973. The strength of weak ties. American Journal of Sociology 78, 1360-1380.
Hijzen, A., Inui, T., and Todo, Y., 2010. Does offshoring pay? Firm-level evidence from Japan. Economic
Inquiry 48, 880-895.
Jackson, M.O., 2010. Social and economic networks. Princeton University Press.
Jacomy, M., Venturini, T., Heymann, S., and Bastian, M., 2014. Forceatlas2, a continuous graph layout
algorithm for handy network visualization designed for the gephi software. PloS one 9, e98679.
Keller, W., and Yeaple, S.R., 2003. Multinational enterprises, international trade, and productivity
growth: Firm-level evidence from the united states. National Bureau of Economic Research Working
Paper Series No. 9504.
Kimura, F., and Kiyota, K., 2006. Exports, FDI, and productivity: Dynamic evidence from Japanese firms.
Review of World Economics 142, 695-719.
Madsen, J.B., 2007. Technology spillover through trade and tfp convergence: 135 years of evidence for
the oecd countries. Journal of International Economics 72, 464-480.
22
Matous, P., and Todo, Y., 2015. "Dissolve the keiretsu, or die": A longitudinal study of disintermediation
in the Japanese automobile manufacturing supply networks. RIETI Discussion Paper, No. 15-E-039.
Page, L., Brin, S., Motwani, R., and Winograd, T., 1999. The pagerank citation ranking: Bringing order
to the web. Technical Report, Stanford InfoLab, No.
Phelps, C.C., 2010. A longitudinal study of the influence of alliance network structure and composition
on firm exploratory innovation. Academy of Management Journal 53, 890-913.
Rost, K., 2011. The strength of strong ties in the creation of innovation. Research Policy 40, 588-604.
Tiwana, A., 2008. Do bridging ties complement strong ties? An empirical examination of alliance
ambidexterity. Strategic Management Journal 29, 251-272.
Todo, Y., 2006. Knowledge spillovers from foreign direct investment in R&D: Evidence from Japanese
firm-level data. Journal of Asian Economics 17, 996-1013.
Todo, Y., Matous, P., and Inoue, H., 2016. The strength of long ties and the weakness of strong ties:
Knowledge diffusion through supply chain networks. Research Policy 45, 1890-1906.
Todo, Y., Nakajima, K., and Matous, P., 2015. How do supply chain networks affect the resilience of
firms to natural disasters? Evidence from the Great East Japan earthquake. Journal of Regional
Science 55, 209-229.
Todo, Y., and Shimizutani, S., 2007. Overseas R&D activities and home productivity growth: Evidence
from Japanese firm-level data. Journal of Industrial Economics.
Watts, D.J., and Strogatz, S.H., 1998. Collective dynamics of 'small-world' networks. Nature 393, 440-
442.
Wu, L., 2015. Centrality of the supply chain network SSRN.
æžå 康ä¹, 2011. æ¥æ¬çµæžã®åºåïŒè¥éŸãç®èŠãããšãïŒ. äžå€®å ¬è«æ°ç€Ÿ.
è¥æéå¹³, æžå 康ä¹, äœè€ä»å¿, 西岡修äžé, æŸæµŠå¯¿å¹ž, äŒè€è¬é, and ç°äžé®å€¢, 2008. åœéå
ããæ¥æ¬äŒæ¥ã®å®å-äŒæ¥ã¬ãã«ããŒã¿ã«åºã¥ãåæ. çµæžç£æ¥ç 究æãã£ã¹ã«ãã·ã§ã³ã»
ããŒã㌠(RIETI-DP), No. 08-J-046.