7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 1/67
The emergence of new modes of governance of natural resources use and distribution
in Latin America and Ecuador
Titulo
Baud, Michiel - Autor/a; Ospina Peralta, Pablo - Autor/a; Autor(es)
Lugar
ENGOV Editorial/Editor
2013 Fecha
ENGOV Working paper Series no. 4 Colección
History; Natural resources; Environment; Agriculture; Exports; Modernization;
Ecuador; Latin America;
Temas
Doc. de trabajo / Informes Tipo de documento
"http://biblioteca.clacso.edu.ar/clacso/engov/20131210113410/WorkingPaperENGOV4_BaudandOspina.pdf" URL
Reconocimiento-No Comercial CC BY-NC
http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.0/deed.es
Licencia
Segui buscando en la Red de Bibliotecas Virtuales de CLACSO
http://biblioteca.clacso.edu.ar
Consejo Latinoamericano de Ciencias Sociales (CLACSO)
Conselho Latino-americano de Ciências Sociais (CLACSO)
Latin American Council of Social Sciences (CLACSO)
www.clacso.edu.ar
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 2/67
!"#$%
&'()*+, -./0(
10(*02
!"#$% ‐ !+3*('+40+5.6
#'30(+.+70 *+ 8.5*+
940(*7. .+:
5;0
<.(*==0.+> ?0306'/*+,
@(.40A'()2 B'(
1C25.*+.=60 .+: !DC*5.=60
".5C(.6 E02'C(70 F20 ‐ *2 .
7'66.='(.5*30 (020.(7;
/('G075 =05A00+ 8.5*+
940(*7.+ .+: !C('/0.+
(020.(7;0(2 BC+:0: =H 5;0
!C('/0.+ F+*'+
I11J‐<K‐LMNM‐LOOPNMQR
@'( 4'(0 *+B'(4.5*'+>
-.(. 4.H'( *+B'(4.7*S+>
-.(. 4.*2 *+B'(4.TU02>
!!!"#$%&'"#(
K;0 !"#$% A'()*+, /./0( 20(*02
20(302 5' 7'44C+*7.50 5;0 B*(25
(02C652 'B '+,'*+, !"#$% (020.(7;V
A*5; 5;0 .*4 5' 25*4C6.50 5;0
0W7;.+,0 'B *:0.2 .+: :0=.50 .5
:*BB0(0+5 603062R X+76C2*'+ 'B . /./0(
*+ 5;0 !"#$%&'()*+, -./0( 10(*02
:'02 +'5 7'+25*5C50 /C=6*7.5*'+ .+:
2;'C6: +'5 6*4*5 /C=6*7.5*'+ *+ .+H
'5;0( 30+C0R <'/H(*,;5 (04.*+2 A*5;
5;0 .C5;'(2R
)*+,- .&/01$% 234#/ *&" 56 789:
;<# #=#/%#$># &? $#! =&@#A &? %&'#/$3$># &?
$3B(/3C
/#A&(/>#A
(A#
3$@
@1AB/1D(B1&$
1$
E3B1$
F=#/1>3
3$@
)>(3@&/
F(B<&/AG Y*7;*06 Z.C: I<!?89‐F39Q .+: -.=6' $2/*+.
-0(.65. IF91Z‐1[Q
XR X:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 .+: 0W/.+2*'+> K(.+2B'(4*+,
*+:*,0+'C2 7C65C(0 .+: 7'+DC0(*+, +.5C(0 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.V 7.R N\PM
] 7.R
N^NMV
=H
Y*7;*06
Z.C:
XXR !6 2C(,*4*0+5' :0 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 :0 7'+5('6
.4=*0+5.6 0+ 06 !7C.:'( IN^`M‐N^OMQV /'( -.=6' $2/*+. -0(.65.
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 3/67
L
)*+,- &'()*+, -./0( 10(*02
-C=6*2;0: =H 5;0 <'66.='(.5*30 E020.(7; -('G075 !"#$%> !+3*('+40+5.6 #'30(+.+70 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.
.+: 5;0 <.(*==0.+> ?0306'/*+, @(.40A'()2 B'( 1C25.*+.=60 .+: !DC*5.=60 ".5C(.6 E02'C(70 F20
<'/H(*,;5 B'(
5;*2
0:*5*'+>
Y*7;*06
Z.C:
.+:
-.=6'
$2/*+.
-0(.65.
!"#$% ‐ !+3*('+40+5.6 #'30(+.+70 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. .+: 5;0 <.(*==0.+> ?0306'/*+, @(.40A'()2
B'( 1C25.*+.=60 .+: !DC*5.=60 ".5C(.6 E02'C(70 F20 ‐ 7.++'5 =0 ;06: (02/'+2*=60 B'( 0(('(2 '( .+H
7'+20DC0+702 .(*2*+, B('4 5;0 C20 'B *+B'(4.5*'+ 7'+5.*+0: *+ 5;*2 &'()*+, -./0(a 5;0 3*0A2 .+:
'/*+*'+2 0W/(0220: .(0 2'606H 5;'20 'B 5;0 .C5;'( '( .C5;'(2 .+: :' +'5 +07022.(*6H (0B6075 5;'20 'B
!"#$%R
966 A'()*+, /./0(2 .(0 .3.*6.=60 B(00 'B 7;.(,0 '+ 'C( A0=2*50 AAAR0+,'3R0CR
!"#$%&'(")&* +#,-.
H1><1#C I3(@ *2 ?*(075'( 'B <!?89 .+: -('B022'( *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 15C:*02 .5 5;0 F+*30(2*5H
'B 94250(:.4V K;0 "05;0(6.+:2R J*2 (020.(7; *+50(0252 .(0 *+:*,0+*25. *:0'6',*02 .+: 5;0*(
*+B6C0+70 '+ /(020+5‐:.H .7.:04*7 *+50(/(05.5*'+2 'B 5;0 9+:02R 95 /(020+5 ;0 *2 *+50(0250:
*+ 5;0 (06.5*'+ =05A00+ 0+3*('+40+5.6 .+: 05;+*7 *:0.2 *+ LM5; 70+5C(H 8.5*+ 940(*7.R
23DC& ,A41$3 2#/3CB3 02 -('B02'( :06 b(0. :0 !25C:*'2 1'7*.602 H #6'=.602 :0 6. F+*30(2*:.:
9+:*+. 1*4S+
Z'6c3.(
0 *+3025*,.:'(
:06
X+25*5C5'
:0
!25C:*'2
!7C.5'(*.+'2R
!2/07*.6*_.:'
0+
4'3*4*0+5'2 2'7*.602V ;*25'(*. H .+5('/'6',c. :0 /C0=6'2 *+:c,0+.2V /'6c5*7.2 .4=*0+5.602 H
/'6c5*7.2 .,(.(*.2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 4/67
`
)*+,- .&/01$% 434#/ *&" 56 789:
;<# #=#/%#$># &? $#! =&@#A &? %&'#/$3$># &? $3B(/3C /#A&(/>#A
(A# 3$@ @1AB/1D(B1&$ 1$ E3B1$ F=#/1>3 3$@ )>(3@&/
F(B<&/AG Y*7;*06 Z.C: I<0+5(0 B'( 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ E020.(7; .+: ?'7C40+5.5*'+V 94250(:.4Q .+: -.=6' $2/*+. -0(.65. IF+*30(2*:.: 9+:*+. 1*4'+ Z'6c3.( ‐ 10:0 [C*5'Q
/0.,%&),
;<1A /#4&/B 4/#A#$BA 3 ?1/AB 3BB#=4B B& C&&0 ?&/ B<# <1AB&/1>3C &/1%1$A &? #$'1/&$=#$B3C B<1$01$% 1$
E3B1$ F=#/1>3" K;0 5A' /./0(2 .5504/5 5' 2)057; . B(.40A'() 5;.5 A*66 .66'A 7'+7(050 ;*25'(*7.6
(020.(7; *+5' 5;0 :0306'/40+5 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 5;*+)*+, *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.R K;0H :0/.(5 B('4 5;0
'=20(3.5*'+
5;.5
5;0
DC025
B'(
5;0
0W/6'*5.5*'+
'B
+.5C(.6
(02'C(702
;.2
=00+
5;0
70+5(.6
B0.5C(0
'B
8.5*+ 940(*7.+ ;*25'(HR K;0H 2C,,025 . 760.( *+50(7'++075*'+ =05A00+ 3*0A2 '+ 5;0 2'7*'‐7C65C(.6
4.+.,040+5 'B 5;0 7.4/02*+'‐*+:c,0+.V A'(6: .+: 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(0R 95 5;0 2.40 5*40V
5;0H 2;'A 5;.5 5;*2 *+50(7'++075*'+ A.2 04=0::0: *+ 7'+7(050 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 /'A0(
25(C,,602 .4'+, 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502R X+ 5;0 7'C(20 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HV 040(,*+, 25.50 06*502
25.(50: 5' (0.6*_0 5;.5 5;0 BC5C(0 'B 5;0 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: :0306'/40+5.6 4':06 A'C6: :0/0+: '+ 5;0
(02/'+2*=60 .+: 2C25.*+.=60 C20 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702R K;*2 60: 5' . +0A .+: 4.*+6H 507;+*7.6 *+50(025
*+ /(':C75*3*5H .+: A.H2 'B *4/('3*+, .,(*7C65C(.6 /(':C75*'+V =C5 .62' 5' . +0A *+50(025 *+ +.5C(0V
+.5*'+.6 6.+:27./02 .+: +.5C(.6 (02'C(702R !30+5C.66HV 5;020 +0A /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 *:0.2 A'C6:
60.: 5' +0A 7'+20(3.5*'+*25 /'6*7*02 *+ 5;0 207'+: ;.6B 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HR
1-23#%4.
!+3*('+40+5.6 ;*25'(HV 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0V 4':0(+*_.5*'+V +.5C(.6 (02'C(702R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 5/67
d
5#+,-+,.
9=25(.75 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
̀
X+5(':C75*'+ RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR e
XR X:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 .+: 0W/.+2*'+> K(.+2B'(4*+, *+:*,0+'C2 7C65C(0 .+: 7'+DC0(*+, +.5C(0
*+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.V 7.R N\PM ] 7.R N^NM RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR P
NR !+3*('+40+5 .+: *:0'6',H *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ ;*25'(H RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR \
LR <'+5('66*+, .+: 7*3*6*_*+, 5;0 4.2202 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR NM
`R <'+DC0(*+, 5;0 50((*5'(H RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR N`
dR K;0 040(,0+70 'B 0W/'(5‐.,(*7C65C(0 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR NO
eR ?*220+5*+, 3'*702 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR N^
OR <'+76C2*'+ RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR LL
Z*=6*',(./;H RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR Ld
XXR !6 2C(,*4*0+5' :0 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 :0 7'+5('6 .4=*0+5.6 0+ 06 !7C.:'( IN^`M‐N^OMQ RR LO
NR X+5(':C77*S+ RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR LP
LR ?0=.760 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR L\
`R 8077*'+02> 6. :0B0+2. .,(c7'6. RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR ̀ M
dR
$=202*'+02 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR
̀O
eR -(':C75*3*24' RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR d`
OR X4.,*+.(*'2 :0 /(',(02' H +.5C(.60_. RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR eP
PR E07./*5C6.7*S+ ,0+0(.6 RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR OM
Z*=6*',(.Bc. RRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR Od
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 6/67
e
6+,%#47),"#+
X+ 5;0 207'+: ;.6B 'B 5;0 N^5; 70+5C(HV 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: *+5066075C.6 06*502 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7. 25.(50: 5'
(0.6*_0 5;.5 +.5*'+‐=C*6:*+, .+: 5;0 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 'B 5;0*( 2'7*05*02 7'C6: +'5 5.)0 /6.70 A*5;'C5
*+76C:*+, 5;0 /'/C6.(V 4'256H /0.2.+5 4.2202R K;0*( C(,0+5 20.(7; B'( . 3*.=60 B'C+:.5*'+ B'( 5;0*(
H'C+,
+.5*'+2
(0DC*(0:
+0A
*:0.2
.+:
*+2*,;52
5;.5
A'C6:
2C//'(5
5;0
7(0.5*'+
'B
.
+.5*'+‐
25.50
.+:
5;0 B'250(*+, 'B .+ *+:0/0+:0+5 07'+'4*7 :0306'/40+5R Y'25 *4/'(5.+56HV 5;0H +00:0: 5'
7'+25(C75 . 25.50 .+: .+ f*4.,*+0: 7'44C+*5Hg 5;.5 *+76C:0: 5;0 6.(,0 4.2202 'B 5;0 /'/C6.5*'+V =C5
.5 5;0 2.40 5*40 A'C6: 4.)0 5;04 (0.:H B'( *+7'(/'(.5*'+ *+ 5;0 ,(.+:*'20 /('G075 'B /(',(022 .+:
4':0(+*_.5*'+R K;0 *+:*,0+'C2 .+: 7(0'60 /0.2.+5 /'/C6.5*'+2V =C5 .62' 5;0 5(.:*5*'+.6 6.+:'A+0(2
.+: 5;0 <;C(7; 'C52*:0 'B 5;0 7*5*02 ;.: 5' .:./5 5' 5;*2 /('G075V f/'( 6.2 =C0+.2 ' /'( 6.2 4.6.2gR
K;0(0 A.2 +' :'C=5 *+ 5;0 4*+:2 'B 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 06*502 5;.5 5;*2 /(',(022 2;'C6: =0
=.20: '+ . 4'(0 /('B'C+: .+: 0BB*7*0+5 C20 'B 5;0 .=C+:.+5 +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 0W*25*+, *+ 5;0 8.5*+
940(*7.+ (0,*'+R
K'
7'+30(5
5;*2
/('G075
*+5'
7'+7(050
/'6*7*02V
.
(.:*7.6
5(.+2B'(4.5*'+
'B
8.5*+
940(*7.+
2'7*05*02
A.2 200+ .2 +07022.(HR K;0 4'25 *4/'(5.+5 (02'C(70 *+ 5;*2 B*(25 /0(*': 'B 040(,*+, 0W/'(5‐
.,(*7C65C(0 A.2 6.+:R K;0 5(.:*5*'+.6 2H25042 'B C20 .+: 'A+0(2;*/ 'B 6.+: A0(0 *+7(0.2*+,6H 200+ .2
.(7;.*7 .+: .2 . 4.G'( '=25.760 5' ,('A5; A*5; 5;0 4.*+ 7C6/(*52 =0*+, 5;0 /0.2.+5(HV 5;0 <;C(7;
.+: 5(.:*5*'+.6 6.+:‐;'6:0(2R K;0 +0A 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 25.50 06*502 A0(0 7'+3*+70: 5;.5 5;0 25.50 ;.:
5' /6.H . :07*2*30 ('60 *+ B'40+5*+, /(',(022 .+: 5;0 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 'B 5;0 C20 'B 6.+: .+: '5;0(
+.5C(.6 (02'C(702R K;020 /'6*7*02 (0.7;0: 5;0*( 7C64*+.5*+, /'*+5 *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; .+: 0.(6H LM5;
70+5C(*02 A;0+ f6*=0(.6g .+: 7'+20(3.5*30 ,'30(+40+52 205 5;04206302 5;0 5.2) 5' 7(0.50 .+ 0BB075*30
,'30(+.+70 B(.40A'() A;*7; A'C6: 0+.=60 5;0 /(':C75*30 C20 'B 5;0 7'C+5(Hg2 +.5C(.6 (02'C(702
.+: 5;0 fB'(70:g *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0*( /'/C6.5*'+2R K'/*) .+: &0662 IN^^\Q 7.66 5;*2 5;0 /0(*': 'B 5;0
f207'+:
7'+DC025gR
8.5*+
940(*7.+
*+5066075C.62
;.30
7.660:
*5
f*+50(+.6
7'6'+*.6*24g
'(
+0'‐
7'6'+*.6*24 IE*30(.V N^^`a [C*G.+' LMMMQR K;*2 207'+: 7'+DC025 (02;./0: 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 50((*5'(*02
.+: 7(0.50: +0A ,0',(./;*7.6 *4.,*+.5*'+2R 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 06*502 =07.40
*+7(0.2*+,6H 7'+3*+70: 5;.5 07'+'4*7 :0306'/40+5 A.2 +'5 '+6H +07022.(H 5' ='6250( 5;0 +0A 8.5*+
940(*7.+ +.5*'+2V =C5 5;.5 *2 A.2 .+ '=6*,.5*'+ 5' A;*7; .66 5;0*( 7*5*_0+2 ;.: 5' .:;0(0R
f!6 /(',(02'g A.2 . 2.7(0: ,'.6 5;.5 ;.: 5' =0 2C//'(50: =H 030(H'+0R J'A030(V 5;0(0 A.2 +030(
7'+20+2C2 .='C5 5;0 :02*(0: B'(4 'B 5;*2 /(',(022 '( 4':0(+*_.5*'+ .+: 5;0 2/07*B*7 7;.(.750(*25*72
5;.5 5;0H 2;'C6: ;.30 *+ . 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7'+50W5R 15('+,6H (06H*+, '+ 5;0 *+B6C0+70 'B 5;0 A'() 'B
h'2i !+(*DC0 E':SV 5;0 <;*60.+ /;*6'2'/;0( ?03i2 %.6:i2 ILMMM> Ne‐\Q 2C,,0252 . /0+:C6C4
4'3040+5 *+
A;*7;
5;0
04/;.2*2
'+
4':0(+*_.5*'+
.+:
*:0+5*5H
7'+25(C75*'+
.650(+.5*+,6H
(0/6.70:
0.7; '5;0( *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.R J0 2002 5;0 50+2*'+ =05A00+ 5;020 5A' 0220+5*.6 *+5066075C.6 /('G0752 .2
5;0 /(*+7*/.6 4'5'( 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ *+5066075C.6 I.+: '+0 4.H .::> /'6*5*7.6Q ;*25'(HR K;0(0 A0(0
/0(*':2 A;0+V *+ ;*2 3*0AV *:0+5*5H 7'+25(C75*'+ A.2 4'(0 *4/'(5.+5 5;.+ 5;0 A*2; B'(
4':0(+*_.5*'+R K;*2 7'+5(.25 4.H =0 5'' 2*4/60 . /0(2/075*30 '+ 5;0 :0306'/40+5 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
+.5*'+.6*25 *:0'6',*02V =C5 *5 *2 C20BC6 5' (04*+: C2 5;.5 5;0(0 A0(0 .6A.H2 :*220+5*+, 3'*702 .4*:25
5;0 '30(A;064*+, ;0,04'+H 'B 4':0(+*25 *:0.2 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; .+: LM5;
70+5C(*02R
X+ 5;*2 &'()*+, -./0( A;*7; *2 /(':C70: *+ 5;0 7'+50W5 'B 5;0 !"#$% /('G075 '+ !+3*('+40+5.6
#'30(+.+70
*+
8.5*+
940(*7.V
H'C
A*66
B*+:
5A'
/./0(2
A;*7;
5(H
5'
C+:0(25.+:
5;*2
4C65*‐2*:0:
;*25'(HR K;0H 5(H 5' C+:0(25.+: A;.5 A0(0 5;0 /.(.4050(2 'B 5;0 4':0(+*_*+, /'6*7*02 5.)*+, /6.70 *+
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 7/67
O
8.5*+ 940(*7.g2 6'+, LM5; 70+5C(HR 15.50 06*502 ;.: 5' 7'40 5' 50(42 A*5; 5;0 (0.6*5*02 *+ 5;0*( +0A6H
7(0.50: +.5*'+2 .+: 02/07*.66H 5(*0: 5' B*+: .+2A0(2 5' 5;0 50+2*'+2 =05A00+ 5;0*( A0250(+‐'(*0+50:
4':0(+*25 *:0'6',*02 .+: 5;0 ;.(2; .+: *+ 4.+H A.H2 *:*'2H+7(.5*7 (0.6*5*02 *+ 5;0*( 7'C+5(*02R
X+*5*.66HV 5;0H (06*0: '+ .C5;'(*5.(*.+ 4':062 A;*7; 25('+,6H B.3'(0: 07'+'4*7 4':0(+*_.5*'+ '30(
*+76C2*'+ .+: GC25*70R 92 Z.C: 2;'A2V *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(HV 4'(0 =0+03'60+5 *:0.2 25.(50: 5' 5.)0
2;./0 *+
A;*7;
5;0
*+76C2*'+
'B
5;0
/''(
I*+:*,0+'C2Q
4.2202
A.2
200+
.2
. 7(C7*.6
06040+5
'B
5;*2
:0306'/40+5.6 4':06R K;0 /./0( =H -.=6' $2/*+. :04'+25(.502 5;.5 '+6H 30(H ,(.:C.66HV *+ 5;0
7'C(20 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HV 25.50 06*502 25.(50: 5' (0.6*_0 5;.5 5;0 4':0(+ BC5C(0 'B 5;0*( 7'C+5(*02
.62' :0/0+:0: '+ (02/'+2*=60 .+: 2C25.*+.=60 C20 'B 5;0 5;0*( +.5C(.6 (02'C(702R K;*2 B*(25 2;'A0: *+
. +0A .+: 4.*+6H 507;+*7.6 *+50(025 *+ /(':C75*3*5H .+: A.H2 'B *4/('3*+, .,(*7C65C(.6 /(':C75*'+R
K;*2 60: 5' . +0A *+50(025 *+ +.5C(0V +.5*'+.6 6.+:27./02 .+: +.5C(.6 (02'C(702R !30+5C.66HV 5;*2
*:0'6',*7.6 .+: 40+5.6 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ A'C6: 60.: 5' 760.( 7'+20(3.5*'+*25 /'6*7*02 *+ 5;0 207'+: ;.6B
'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 8/67
P
68 64-#*#$"-. #9 '%#$%-.. &+4 -:'&+."#+; <%&+.9#%="+$
"+4"$-+#7. )7*,7%- &+4 )#+>7-%"+$ +&,7%- "+ ?&,"+ /=-%")&@
)&8 ABCD E )&8 AFAD
Y*7;*06 Z.C:
j-.(. 06 025.:' 7(*'66'‐4025*_'V 6. (02*250+7*. *+:c,0+.V 06 :020' :0 /0(4.+070( 0+ 6.2 5*0((.2
:0 6. 7'4C+*:.:V .2c 7'4' 6. *+2*250+7*. 0+ 4.+50+0( 6. *:0+5*:.:V 7'+25*5CH0('+ ;07;'2 DC0
*4/*:*0('+ 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :0 C+. +.7*S+ ;'4',i+0.Rk Ih.3*0( 1.+Gc+02V dOQ
j#0',(./;*7.6 *4.,*+.5*'+2 GCW5./'2*+, =.7)A.(: X+:*.+2 A*5; C+6*4*50: +.5C(.6 (02'C(702
=07.40 . /'A0(BC6 +'(4 B'( 5;0 +*+0500+5; .+: 5A0+5*05; 70+5C(*02Rk I$BB0+V e^Q
jK;0 7;.(.750(*25*72 'B /'257'6'+*.6 2'7*05H ] *52 .3*:*5H B'( *440:*.50 /('B*5V 7'+70+5(.5*'+
'B A0.65;V
B*W.5*'+
'+
3*,*6.+70
.+:
7'+5('6V
0W5(040
04/*(*7*24V
.+:
0+5*(0
:*2(0,.(:
B'(
A;.5 '+6H *+ '+0 ;C+:(0: H0.(2 .+ 0+6*,;50+0: B0A A'C6: 7;0(*2; .2 /(*706022 +.5C(.6
A0.65; ] =(*+, 5' 4*+: *+25.+56H ;'A BC5*60 *5 *2 5' (.*20 '=G075*'+2 +'AV A;0+ 5;0 :00: *2
:'+0 .+: +' 5(.702 .(0 60B5 'B *5 '+ 5;0 20(0 .+: H066'A0: ;*662 'B 5;0 -.(.c=. %.660HRk
I&.((0+ ?0.+V N^MQ
X+ ;*2 +'A B.4'C2 !"#$%&'( )*""+&%,%'- Z0+0:*75 9+:0(2'+ 5(*02 5' 0W/6.*+ 5;0 2/07*.6
7;.(.750(*25*72 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ +.5*'+ =C*6:*+,R J0 7.660: 5;0 +0A (0/C=6*72 f<(0'60 -*'+00(2g
:(.A*+, .550+5*'+ 5' 5;0 B.75 5;.5 5;0 7(0'60 7'44C+*5*02 .6(0.:H *+ 5;0 6.50 0*,;500+5; 70+5C(H ;.:
. 760.(6H
:0306'/0:
20+20
'B
f+.5*'+
‐+022gR
K'
0W/6.*+
5;*2
/;0+'40+'+V
9+:0(2'+
/'*+52
B*(25
.5
5;0
B.75 5;.5 0.7; 'B 5;0 +0A 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ (0/C=6*72 ;.: =00+ .+ .:4*+*25(.5*30 C+*5 :C(*+, 4'25 'B
5;0 7'6'+*.6 /0(*':R 965;'C,; 5;020 .:4*+*25(.5*30 C+*52 A0(0 5' . 6.(,0 0W50+5 .(=*5(.(H .+:
B'(5C*5'C2V '30( 5*40 5;0H :0306'/0: *+5' . B*(40( (0.6*5HR 9+:0(2'+ 6'')0: .5 5;0 A.H2 =H A;*7;
5;020 .:4*+*25(.5*30 '(,.+*_.5*'+2 .7DC*(0: 40.+*+,R K;0H :*: 2' =H 7(0.5*+, +.5*'+.6*25 2H4='62
.+: 7'+25(C75*+, +.5*'+.6 7';0(0+70V B'( *+25.+70 =H 5;0 (./*:6H ,('A*+, +0A2/./0(2V =C5 .62' =H .+
0W/6*7*5 .+: *:0'6',*7.66H =.7)0: /('G075 5' 5.)0 7'+5('6 .+: 5' 7'+DC0( 5;0 +.5*'+.6 50((*5'(HR
K;020 4':0(+*_*+, *:0.2 A0(0 7'+7'750: *+ 5;0 C(=.+ 70+50(2 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7. =C5 5;0H A0(0
.//6*0: 5' 5;0 7'C+5(H2*:0R K;*2 ;.: 5A' *4/'(5.+5 7'+20DC0+702 5;.5 X A*66 5(H 5' .+.6H_0 *+ 5;*2
.(5*760R @*(25V
5;0(0
A.2
. 760.(
06040+5
'B
*+50(+.6
7'6'+*.6*24
*+
5;020
+0A
/'6*7*02V
*+
A;*7;
(C6*+,
06*502 B'( 5;0 B*(25 5*40 25.(50: 5' 2;'A . (0.6 *+50(025 *+ 5;0 2*5C.5*'+ *+ 5;0 A;.5 A.2 I.+: 25*66 *2Q
'B50+ 7.660: f06 *+50(*'(g '( f6. /('3*+7*.g '(V *+ 5;0 9+:02V f6. 2*0((.gR K;0H 25.(50: 5' /C(2C0 5;0
*+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 I=C5 .62' 5;0 9B(*7.+‐940(*7.+ .+: 030+ 7(0'60Q /0.2.+5(H *+ 5;0
+.5*'+.6 25.50 .+:V *+ 5;0 2.40 /('7022V *52 :'4025*7.5*'+ .+: 7'+5('6R K;0 207'+:V 76'206H (06.50:
*22C0 A.2 5;.5 5;*2 +0A *+50(025 *+ 5;0 (0,*'+2 'C52*:0 'B 5;0 C(=.+ 70+50(2 A.2 760.(6H ,C*:0:
5'A.(:2 5;0 ,'.6 'B *+7(0.20: /(':C75*'+V .+: 5;0(0B'(0 *4/6*0: . +0A .+: 4'(0 4.()05‐'(*0+50:
3*0A '+ +.5C(0 .+: 5;0 (02'C(702 *5 7'+5.*+0:R K;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 06*502 5'') *5 C/'+
5;04206302 5' 5.)0 7'+5('6 'B 5;0 /;H2*7.6 0+3*('+40+5V A;*7; 40.+5 ='5; 5;0 50((*5'(H *+ ,0+0(.6
.+: 5;0 +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 *5 7'+5.*+0:R 9+ C(,0+5 +00: A.2 B065 5' 0W/6'*5 5;0 +.5C(.6 A0.65; 5;.5
0W*250: ]
'(
A0(0
*4.,*+0:
5'
0W*25
‐;*::0+
.+:
C+0W/6'*50:
*+
5;020
50((*5'(*02R
92
Z(.:B'(:
ZC(+2
/'*,+.+56H '=20(30: 6'+, .,'V B'( 5;0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502V j5;0 /(',(022 5;0H .7)+'A60:,0: .2
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 9/67
\
7*3*6*_.5*'+ 40.+5 5;.5 lmn /(',(022 7'C6: =0 40.2C(0: DC.+5*5.5*306H =H 5;0 .4'C+5 'B 0W/'(52V 5;0
+C4=0( 'B 250.4 0+,*+02V (.*6('.: 4*60.,0V '( ,.2 6*,;52k IZ(.:B'(: ZC(+2V N^\M> LMQ
X5 *2 ,0+0(.66H B065 5;.5 5;0 DC025 B'( 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 4.H A066 ;.30 =00+ 5;0
70+5(.6 B0.5C(0 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ ;*25'(HR X5 *2 *4/'(5.+5 5' +'50 5;.5 5;0 *:0. 'B f'(:0( .+: /(',(022gV
5;0 B.4'C2 26',.+ 'B 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(HV 5;C2 ='5; (0B0((0: 5' 5;0 7'+5('6 'B 2'7*05H .+: 5;0 C20 'B
+.5C(.6 (02'C(702R K;0(0 A.2 . 760.( 7'++075*'+ .+: 2*4C65.+0*5H =05A00+ 5;0 3*0A2 '+ 5;0
4.+.,040+5 'B 5;0 ;C4.+V 7.4/02*+'‐*+:c,0+.V A'(6: .+: 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(0R X5 *2 5;*2
*+50(‐7'++0750: /('7022 5;.5 5;*2 .(5*760 A.+52 5' 0W/6'(0V .6A.H2 5(H*+, 5' 5.)0 .77'C+5 5' ='5;
;*25'(*7.6 7;.+,0 .+: *:0'6',*7.6 7'+5(.:*75*'+2R
A8 G+H"%#+=-+, &+4 "4-#*#$2 "+ ?&,"+ /=-%")&+ (".,#%2
!+3*('+40+5.6 ;*25'(H *2 .+ 040(,*+, :*27*/6*+0 A*5; . +C4=0( 'B C+2'630: :0=.502R 9B50(
2C77022BC66H ;.3*+, .2)0: .550+5*'+ B'( 5;0 *4/'(5.+70 'B +.5C(0 .+: 5;0 0+3*('+40+5.6 06040+52 *+
;C4.+ ;*25'(HV *5 0+7'C+50(0: . +C4=0( 'B 7;.660+,02V 2'40 'B A;*7; .(0 760.(6H *4/'(5.+5 B'( 5;0
.+.6H2*2 'B 6.50 N^5; .+: LM5;
8.5*+ 940(*7.+ ;*25'(HR 9+ *4/'(5.+5 '+0 *2 5;0 (06.5*'+ =05A00+ 5;0
0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 .+: 5;0 :0306'/40+5 'B I+.5*'+.6Q *+25*5C5*'+2R K;0 B'7C2 '+
+.5C(.6 (02'C(702 I02/07*.66H 2*630(Q A.2 .6(0.:H 5;0 7'(0 'B 5;0 7'6'+*.6 /('G075 *+ <0+5(.6 940(*7.
.+: 5;0 9+:02 IB'( *+25.+70> Y*660( LMMPQV =C5 5;0 4':0(+ 0W5(.75*3*25 4':06 25.(50: *+ 0.(+025 *+ 5;0
N^5; 70+5C(HR X+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.V 5;0 DC025*'+ ;.2 =07'40 5' A;.5 0W50+5 5;*2 4':06 ;.2 60: 5' 5;0
7(C7*.6 *22C0 'B 5;0 *+;0(0+5 *+0DC.6*5H .+: /'30(5H *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05HR X+ '5;0( A'(:2V ;'A
;.2 5;0 0W5(.75*30 4':06 5;.5 :0306'/0: *+ 5;*2 /0(*': *+B'(40: 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 2'7*.6 25(C75C(02 'B
5;0 (0,*'+o &.2 5;*2 4':06 *+25(C40+5.6 *+ 5;0 7(0.5*'+ 'B 25('+, 2'7*.6 *+0DC.6*5*02o 9+'5;0( *22C0
5;.5 7'+5*+C02 5' 5;*2 :.HV 7'+70(+2 5;0 DC025*'+ A;05;0( ] .+: *B H02V ;'A ] *5 *2 /'22*=60 5' 5C(+ .+
0W5(.75*30 4':06
'B
07'+'4*7
:0306'/40+5
*+5'
. 2C25.*+.=60
4':06
A;*7;
7.+
,C.(.+500
6'+,
‐50(4
07'+'4*7 ,('A5; .+: .+ .6603*.5*'+ 'B /'30(5H .+: 2'7*.6 *+0DC.6*5HR !W5(.75*30 07'+'4*02V
.+HA;0(0 *+ 5;0 4':0(+ A'(6:V ;.30 . 25('+, 7'((06.5*'+ A*5; /'30(5H .+: *+0DC.6*5HV =C5 5;*2 *22C0
*2 /.(5*7C6.(6H (0603.+5 B'( 8.5*+ 940(*7. A;*7; *2 5':.H 7'+2*:0(0: 5;0 4'25 C+0DC.6 (0,*'+ 'B 5;0
A'(6:R 9 6.25 *22C0 5;.5 *2 'B /.(5*7C6.( *4/'(5.+70 B'( 5;0 ;*25'(*7.6 :0306'/40+5 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.
7'+70(+2 5;0 2/.5*.6 .+: 50((*5'(*.6 7'+20DC0+702 'B 0W5(.75*30 07'+'4*7 /'6*7*02 .+: 5;0*( (06.5*'+
A*5; 5;0 =C*6:*+, 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ +.5*'+ 25.502R X5 7.+ A066 =0 2.*: 5;.5 5;0 /('7022 'B 50((*5'(*.6
(07'+B*,C(.5*'+ 5;.5 25.(50: A*5; 5;0 <'+DC*25.V .+: 'B A;*7; 5;0 =''4 .+: =C25 'B -'5'2c A0(0 5;0
760.(025 0W.4/60V ;.2 7'+5*+C0: C+5*6 5':.HV A;0+ 5;0 +0A 04/;.2*2 '+ 4*+*+, *2 7(0.5*+, .66 )*+:2
'B +0A 50((*5'(*.6 .+: 2'7*.6 7;.660+,02R
966 5;020 *22C02 *4/6H . 760.( 7'++075*'+ =05A00+ *:0'6',*02 'B 07'+'4*7 ,('A5; .+: +.5*'+;'':
.+: 7'+7(050 2'7*05.6 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+2R X+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. 5;*2 40.+2 5;.5 *5 A.2 76'206H 6*+)0: 5' 5;0
.='30‐40+5*'+0: *22C02 'B *:0+5*5H .+: +.5*'+ =C*6:*+,R X:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022V *:0+5*5H .+: +.5*'+
=C*6:*+, *4/6*0: 760.( *:0.2 .='C5 5;0 (06.5*'+2;*/ =05A00+ ;C4.+ .,0+7HV 50((*5'(H .+:
0+3*('+40+5R 92 $BB0+ ILMMdQ ;.2 +'50: B'( "*7.(.,C.V *:0.2 'B 50((*5'(HV +.5C(0 .+: (.70 G'*+56H
/('3*:0: 5;0 :*27C(2*30 B'C+:.5*'+ B'( ,'30(+40+5.6 /'6*7*02 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.R !+3*('+40+5.6 ;*25'(H
25.(50: 'C5 .2 . :*27*/6*+0 B'7C2*+, '+ 5;0 7'+7(050 ;*25'(*7.6 7;.+,02 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.V =C5 (070+56H
5;*2 *+50(/6.H =05A00+ *:0'6',H .+: 2'7*05.6 7;.+,0 ;.2 .7DC*(0: 4'(0 .550+5*'+R K;*2 ;.2 7(0.50:
+0A )*+:2 'B (020.(7; *+ 0+3*('+40+5.6 ;*25'(HV =C5 ;.2 .62' :(.A+ .550+5*'+ 5' 5;0 *:0'6',*7.6 .+:
*+25*5C5*'+.6
'(*,*+2 'B
0+3*('+40+5.6
,'30(+.+70R
K;0
:0306'/40+5
'B
0+3*('+40+5.6*25
5;*+)*+,
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 10/67
^
7.+ '+6H =0 C+:0(25'': .2 . 7(C7*.6 06040+5 'B 5;0 4'(0 ,0+0(.6 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ .+: 4':0(+*_.5*'+
'B 2'7*05HR
X5 *2 760.(6H (07',+*_0: =H +'A 5;.5 5;0 6.(,0‐27.60 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B 5;0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 0+3*('+40+5
;.2 =00+ 76'206H 6*+)0: ='5; 5' 5;0 *+20(5*'+ 'B 5;0 (0,*'+ *+ 5;0 040(,*+, A'(6: 07'+'4H .+: 5'
5;0 4':0(+*_*+, *:0.2 5;.5 A0(0 ;0,04'+*7 *+ 5;0 (0,*'+ B('4 5;0 4*:‐N^5; 70+5C(H '+A.(:2R K'
*+7(0.20 5;0 /(':C75*'+ 5A' 06040+52 A0(0 7(C7*.6> .77022 5' 6.='C( .+: .77022 5' I.,(*7C65C(.6Q
6.+:R X+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.V 5;0 27.(70 /'/C6.5*'+ .+: 5;0 2C=20DC0+5 :*BB*7C65H 5' (07(C*5 6.='C( I'(
f=(._'2gV .2 A'()0(2 A0(0 (0,C6.(6H 7.660:Q 7(0.50: 2/07*B*7 B'(42 'B 2'7*.6 .+: 07'+'4*7
5(.+2B'(4.5*'+R &;0(0 (06.5*306H :0+20 I*+:*,0+'C2Q 2C=2*250+70 /0.2.+5(*02 0W*250:V 06*502 5(*0: 5'
B'(70 5;04 *+5' (06.5*'+2 'B A.,0 6.='C( '( 7'0(70: 6.='C(R X+ 5;0 4'(0 f04/5Hg (0,*'+2 'B 8.5*+
940(*7.V 6*)0 9(,0+5*+. '( 2'C5;0(+ Z(._*6V 5;0H (02'(50: 5' !C('/0.+ *44*,(.5*'+ I7BR <.(:'2'p-i(0_
Z(*,+'6*V N^P^QR K;020 4':062 7(0.50: :*BB0(0+5 *+25*5C5*'+.6 407;.+*242 'B 25.50 7'+5('6 *+ A;*7;
5;0 7'+5('6 .+: f0:C7.5*'+g 'B 5;0 (C(.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 A0(0 200+ .2 7(C7*.6R -.(56H .2 .+ 06040+5 'B
5;0*( *+7*/*0+5 +.5*'+.6*24V =C5 .='30 .66V 5' ,C.(.+500 5;0 .77022 5' .,(*7C65C(.6 6.+:2V 5;0 +0A 8.5*+
940(*7.+ 25.502
25.(50:
5'
7'+DC0(
5;0*(
50((*5'(*02
.+:
4.)0
5;04
/(':C75*30R
X5
*2
5;0
7'+50+5*'+
'B 5;*2 .(5*760 5;.5 5;020 :*BB0(0+5 /('G0752 7;.+,0: *+ 5;0 2.40 (;H5;4R @'( 5;0 /C(/'20 'B 5;*2
.(5*760V A0 7.+ :*25*+,C*2; 5;(00 /0(*':2R
X+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(HV 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 5'') /6.70 C+:0( 5;0 .0,*2 'B (.A
7./*5.6*24 *+ A;*7; 5;0 '=2022*'+ B'( :0306'/40+5 .+: /(',(022 2C=2C40: .66 '5;0( *+50(0252V 4'25
+'5.=6H *22C02 'B :0B'(025.5*'+ .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 ,'30(+.+70 *+ ,0+0(.6R K;0 *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0
(C(.6‐ *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+2V *+ . 2*4*6.( B.2;*'+V A.2 /6.++0: .77'(:*+, 5' .C5;'(*5.(*.+ .+: (.7*25V
2'7*.6 ?.(A*+*25 4':062 5;.5 .*40: .5 5;0 B'(70BC6 *+50,(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 /0.2.+5(H *+ 5;0 2.7(0: /('G075
'B +.5*'+ .+: 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0R
X+ 5;0 B*(25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HV 5;*2 5A'‐2*:0: /('7022 7.40 C+:0( *+7(0.20: 27(C5*+H .+:
7(*5*7.6 7'C+50( 3'*702 7.40 *+5' 0W*25*+,R K;*2 *+3'630: . :(.4.5*7 .6=0*5 /.(5*.6 .+: ,(.:C.6 7;.+,0
*+ (.7*.6 .+: 05;+*7 A'(6:3*0A2 .+: 60: 5' . ,(.:C.6 .+: 'B50+ .4=*,C'C2 2;*B5 B('4 N^5; 70+5C(H
27*0+5*B*7 (.7*24 5' 5;0 4C7; 4'(0 *+76C2*'+.(H .+: =0+03'60+5V .65;'C,; 'B50+ 25*66 (.7*.66H
*+B'(40:V *:0.2 'B *+:*,0+*24'R X+ 5;0 2.40 /('7022V +0A *:0.2 A0(0 B'(40: .='C5 5;0 *+50,(.5*'+
.+: 0:C7.5*'+ 'B 5;0 7(0'60 .+: 0W‐26.30 /'/C6.5*'+ *+ :*BB0(0+5 /.(52 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.R K;0
'=2022*'+ A*5; /(',(022 (04.*+0:V =C5 GC25 .2 5;0 3*0A2 '+ 5;0 /''( (C(.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 7;.+,0:V +0A
3*0A2 '+ 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 040(,0:R X5 4.H A066 =0 5;.5 *+ 5;*2 /0(*': 5;0 B*(25
2*,+2 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 4.+.,040+5 =H 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 7.40 *+5' 0W*250+70R K;*2 A.2 5;0
(02C65 'B
5;0
7'+B('+5.5*'+
=05A00+
+0A
+.5*'+.6*25
*:0.2
.+:
5;0
*+7(0.2*+,
3*2*=*6*5H
'B
5;0
:*(0
7'+20DC0+702 'B 0W5(.75*30 07'+'4*7 4':062R
X+ . 5;*(: /0(*':V .B50( N^`MV 4':0(+ *:0.2 'B +.5*'+;'':V (.70 .+: +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 ,(.:C.66H
7'+2'6*:.50:R X:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 =07.40 4'(0 *+76C2*30 .+: +.5*'+.6*25 A;*60 7'C+50(3'*702
=07.40 25('+,0( C+:0( 5;0 *+B6C0+70 'B 2'7*.6*25V *+:*,0+*25. .+: 0C,0+*25 *:0.2R F+:0( 5;0 :*(075*'+
'B +0A6H 5(.*+0: 0+,*+00(2 .+: 40:*7.6 :'75'(2V 5;0 /('5075*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 .+: 5;0
*+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B (C(.6 *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+2 60: 5' +0A /'6*5*7.6 /('G0752R
K;*2 /./0( *+50+:2 5' 0W/6'(0 5;*2 7(C7*.6 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ 'B /'6*5*7.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 *:0'6',*02 *+ 5;0
B*(25 /0(*': =05A00+ N\PM .+: 5;0 0.(6H LM5; 70+5C(HR X52 /C(/'20 *2 5A'B'6:R X5 A*66 2;'A ;'A 5;0
A*2; 5' 5(.+2B'(4 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05*02 7(0.50: *:0'6',*02 '+ (.70 .+: 2'7*05HV '+ 5;0 '+0 ;.+:V
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 11/67
NM
.+: +.5C(0 .+: 0+3*('+40+5V '+ 5;0 '5;0(R Z'5; A0(0 5;0 (02C65 'B 760.( /(':C75*30 .4=*5*'+2 .+:
5;0H 5;0(0B'(0 7'4/6040+50: 0.7; '5;0( .+: 'B50+ A0+5 ;.+: *+ ;.+:R 107'+:6HV *5 A.+52 5' :(.A
.550+5*'+ 5' 5;0 06040+52 5;.5 =('C,;5 .='C5 . ,(.:C.6 *:0'6',*7.6 7;.+,0 5;.5 A'C6: 030+5C.66H
B'(4 5;0 =.2*2 B'( +0A 0+3*('+40+5.6 *:0'6',*02 *+ 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HR
I8
5#+,%#**"+$
&+4
)"H"*"J"+$
,(-
=&..-.
X+ N\^O 5;0 ?'4*+*7.+ *+5066075C.6 h'2i E.4S+ 8S/0_ A('50 .+ 022.HV 7.660: f8. .6*40+5.7*S+ H 6.2
(._.2gV 5;.5 =07.40 B.4'C2 *+ 5;0 ?'4*+*7.+ E0/C=6*7R Y.+H '=20(30(2 ;.30 4*25.)0+6H 7'+2*:0(0:
5;*2 022.H .2 .+ 0W.4/60 'B 5;0 (.7*25 /022*4*24 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 5;.5 ;.: 6'25 .66 ;'/0 'B (0.6
:0306'/40+5 IZ.6.,C0(V N^PeQR J'A030(V *5 2;'C6: =0 200+ 4C7; 4'(0 .2 .+ *+50(025*+, .+: '(*,*+.6
.5504/5 5' .(5*7C6.50 5;0 .4=*,C*5*02 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ :0306'/40+5 5;*+)*+, *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5;
70+5C(HR X+ 4.+H A.H2V *5 7.+ =0 7'+2*:0(0: 5;0 <.(*==0.+ 7'C+50(/.(5 'B '5;0( 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
A(*50(2 6*)0 967*:02 9(,C0:.2 IZ'6*3*.QV h'(,0 X7._. I!7C.:'(QV @(.+7*27' ZC6+02 IY0W*7'Q '( <.(6'2
$75.3*' ZC+,0 I9(,0+5*+.QR 966 5;020 A(*50(2 5(*0: 5' C+:0(25.+: 5;0 '=25.7602 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
2'7*05*02
B'(
,0+C*+0
:0306'/40+5
.+:
4':0(+*_.5*'+R
K;0H
2C,,0250:
.
760.(
7'++075*'+
=05A00+
:0306'/40+5V *:0+5*5H .+: +.5C(.6 0+3*('+40+5V j06 .4=*0+50 Bc2*7'kV .2 5;0H 7.660: *5V .+: 5;0H
=06*030: 5;.5 (0.6 :0306'/40+5 7'C6: =0 /'22*=60 '+6H =H 7'+5('66*+, .+: f7*3*6*_*+,g ='5; +.5C(0 .+:
*52 *+;.=*5.+52R 8S/0_ A.2 30(H 0W/6*7*5 *+ ;*2 /'*+5 'B :0/.(5C(0 *+ A;*7; ;0 7'+2*:0(0: :0306'/40+5
.2 5;0 7(C7*.6V +07022.(H .+: C+.3'*:.=60 /(0(0DC*2*50 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05*02R J0 A('50>
j"*+,q+ /C0=6' 5*0+0 :0(07;' . ./':0(.(20 :0 C+ /0:._' :0 5*0((. H 0250(*6*_.(6' /.(. 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+V
/.(. 06 /(',(02'V /.(. 6' BC0(50V 6' =066' H 6' =C0+'k IOLQR 9+: 2'40A;.5 BC(5;0(> j!2 7C025*S+
/(*4'(:*.6 6. 7(0.7*S+ :0 (*DC0_.k IN\^O> OOQR K;0(0 A.2 +' :'C=5 *+ ;*2 4*+:> -(',(022 A.2 . 2.7(0:
:C5H 5' A;*7; 030(H5;*+, 0620 2;'C6: 2C=2C40R
ZC5 5;*2
:*:
+'5
40.+
.+
C+B0550(0:
4.50(*.6*24
5;.5
/6.70:
07'+'4*7
,('A5;
.='30
030(H5;*+,
0620R $+ 5;0 7'+5(.(HV 5;0 /(',(022 0+3*2*'+0: =H .C5;'(2 6*)0 8S/0_V A.2 .+ 04*+0+56H 4'(.6 .+: *+
2'40 A.H2 (.7*.6 '( 7C65C(.6 /('G075R X+ 6*+0 A*5; 5;0 (.7*25 /.50(+.6*24 5;.5 2'.)0: N^5; 70+5C(H
*:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022V /0'/60 6*)0 8'/0_ .770/50: 5;.5 5;*2 2.7(0: *:0.6 (0DC*(0: . 7'+70(50: 0BB'(5
'B 0:C7.5*'+ .+: 7*3*6*_.5*'+ 'B 5;0 /''( (C(.6 4.2202 'B 5;0 /'/C6.5*'+R K;0H A0(0 +'5 '+6H
7C65C(.66H .+: (.7*.66H *+B0(*'( .+: *,+'(.+5 'B 5;0 =0+0B*52 'B 4':0(+*5HV 5;0H A0(0 .62' B'(70BC66H
0W76C:0: B('4 5;04 =H 5;0 6'7.6 .C5;'(*5*02V 6.+:;'6:0(2 .+: 5;0 <;C(7;V f5;0 K(*+*5H 'B !3*6gV .2
Y.+C06 #'+_b60_ -(.:. 7.660: *5R 8S/0_ /'*+50: .5 5;0 07'+'4*7 3C6+0(.=*6*5H 'B 5;0 ?'4*+*7.+
/0.2.+5(HV A*5; 5;0 (02C65 5;.5 j06 7.4/02*+' /*0(:0 2C B*+7. H 0+ 4.+'2 :06 C2C(0(' 20 .((C*+. 6.
/(':C77*S+ .,(c7'6.k IjF+ 6.:' :0 (0,0+0(.7*S+kV .%-,/& 0%#1%*V Le>PddOa LO‐`‐N^NdQR X5 A.2 /.(5 'B
5;0 f7'6'+*.6
/('G075g
'B
4':0(+*_.5*'+
5'
.62'
=(0.)
5;020
2;.7)602
.+:
5'
.66'A
5;0
(C(.6
4.2202
5'
/.(5*7*/.50 *+ 5;*2 2.7(0: ,'.6 'B 4':0(+*5HR
X+ . 2*4*6.( 30*+V 5;0 :00/6H /022*4*25 A(*50( 6*)0 967*:02 9(,C0:.2V A;'20 (.7*25 3*0A2 '+ 5;0 Z'6*3*.+
*+:*,0+'C2 4.2202 I.+: 5;0*( f4.+*B*025. *+B0(*'(*:.:g I/R dPQQ .+: '+ 5;0 :.+,0(2 'B 4*270,0+.5*'+
;.30 =07'40 +'5'(*'C2V 030+5C.66H B.3'(0: 5;0 /('5075*'+ .+: *+76C2*'+ 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 .+:
4025*_' /'/C6.5*'+2R J0 ;*4206B 3*0A0: ;*2 022.H jE._. :0 =('+70k .2 .+ *4/'(5.+5 *+70+5*30 B'( 5;*2
/('7022 *+ Z'6*3*. =07.C20 *5 :(0A .550+5*'+ 5' j6. 0276.3*5C: .=2C(:. :06 *+:*'V 2C 3*:. :0 :'6'(V :0
4*20(*. H :0 *+GC25*7*. =b(=.(.k I/ROPQR X5 *2 5(C0 5;.5 ;*2 A(*5*+,2V :02/*50 5;0*( (.7*.6 =*.202V /('3')0:
. (0.6 *+50(025 B'( 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+ .+: *52 *+76C2*'+ *+ 5;0 :0306'/40+5.6*25 /('G075 'B 5;0
Z'6*3*.+ +.5*'+R
$B
7'C(20V
.2
*+
.64'25
.66
022.H2
'B
5;*2
/0(*':V
5;0
*:0'6',H
(04.*+0:
B*(46H
(.7*25
.+: 5' . 70(5.*+ 0W50+5 .C5;'(*5.(*.+V =C5 *+76C2*'+ A.2 5;0 /(0(0DC*2*50 '=G075*30R 92 9(,C0:.2
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 12/67
NN
7'+76C:0:> jl!n6 /(',(02' 7'+2*250V :02/Ci2 :0 5':'V 0+ 02'V ' C+. /.(50 :06 /(',(02'> *6C25(.(20V
./(0+:0( H 0+(*DC070(20kR 9+: ;0 .::0:V 25(022*+, 5;0 4'(.6 06040+5 'B 5;*2 /(',(.440> j!6
/(',(02' 02 7.=.6 H 7'4/605' 7C.+:' . 025' 20 .r.:0 '5(. 7'2.> /0(B077*'+.(20 4'(.640+50mRk I/R
O^QR
KA' 70+5(.6 *22C02 ;.: 5' =0 2'630: 5' .66'A B'( 5;*2 4'(.6 6.='( 'B 7*3*6*_.5*'+ .+: 0+6*,;50+40+5R
@*(25V 5;0 4.2202 'B 5;0 /'/C6.5*'+ ;.: 5' =0 /('3*:0: A*5; 5;0 =.2*7 +00:2 +07022.(H B'( . ;0.65;H
6*B0V 40.+*+, ;H,*0+*7 6*3*+, 7'+:*5*'+2 .+: ;0.65;H B'':R $B50+ 5;0 6.7) 'B 7C65C(0 .+: .30(2*'+ 5'
4':0(+*_.5*'+ .4'+, 5;0 (C(.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 A0(0 6*+)0: 5' B'(42 'B ,0',(./;*7 :050(4*+*24R
&;05;0( *5 A0(0 5;0 7'6: .+: *+;'2/*5.=60 4'C+5.*+2 'B 5;0 Z'6*3*.+ 2*0((. '( 5;0 2CBB'7.5*+,V
5('/*7.6 ;0.5 'B 5;0 7'.25.6 6'A6.+:2 '( 5;0 -'23#V 5;0(0 A.2 . ,0+0(.6*_0: *:0. 5;.5 5;0 0+3*('+40+5
7'C6: 0W/6.*+ 5;0 /'30(5HV C+:0(:0306'/40+5 .+: 6.7) 'B 4':0(+*_*+, .4=*5*'+2 'B 5;0 8.5*+
940(*7.+ 4.2202R -('4*27C*5HV 200+ .2 5;0 (02C65 'B *+.:0DC.50 ;'C2*+,V A.2 '+0 /('=604V =C5
5;020 A(*50(2 B'7C20: .='30 .66 '+ 5;0 :0B*7*0+5 +C5(*5*'+ 5;.5 C+:0(4*+0: 5;0*( 25(0+,5; .+:
*+5066075C.6 /'50+5*.6R X5 *2 +' 7'*+7*:0+70 5;.5 5;0 022.H =H 8'/0_ 030+ ;.: 5;0 A'(: f.6*40+5.7*S+g
*+ *52
5*560R
K;0
B*(25
20+50+70
'B
;*2
022.H
‐A;*7;
A.2
/;(.20:
*+
5;0
+0,.5*30
‐A.2>
j?02:0
DC0
C+
/C0=6' 7'4*0+_. . 7'+5.( 0+5(0 2C2 3*(5C:02 6. B.7C65.: :0 /(027*+:*( . 40+C:' :06 .6*40+5'
+0702.(*'V /C0:0 .20,C(.(20 DC0 ;. 0+5(.:' 0+ :07.:0+7*.k I8S/0_V `NQR K;0 "*7.(.,C.+ A(*50(
1.63.:'( Y0+:*05. .62' 6*+)0: 5;0 f0+B0(40:.: :0 <0+5('.4i(*7.gV .2 ;*2 25C:H 'B 5;0 0.(6H :07.:02
'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(H A.2 7.660:V 5' 5;0 *+B0(*'( B'': 7'+2C4/5*'+ 'B *52 /'/C6.5*'+ I?03i2 %.6:i2V
LMMM> POQR 977'(:*+, 5' 5;020 .C5;'(2V 5;0 (C(.6 4.2202 ;.: . 6'5 'B =.: ;.=*52V 6*)0 /('4*27C*5HV
7'+20(3.5*24V 2C/0(25*5*'+V =C5 5;0*( :0B*7*0+5 B'': /.550(+2 6.H .5 5;0 =.2*2 'B *5 .66R Y.+H /0'/60
A*2;*+, B'( 5;0 /(':C75*30 *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 (C(.6 /'/C6.5*'+ 25('+,6H =06*030: 5;.5 5;0H +00:0:
5' 25.(5 A*5; *4/('3*+, *52 B'': ;.=*52R
9+'5;0(
*22C0
'B
5;0
7*3*6*_*+,
.+:
4':0(+*_*+,
4'(.6*5H
A;*7;
A.2
3*2*=60
*+
.64'25
.66
8.5*+
940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02V A.2 5;0 7'+3*75*'+ 5;.5 5;0 4.2202 ;.: 5' =0 0:C7.50: .+: 5;.5 5;0 +.5*'+.6
0:C7.5*'+.6 2H25042 ;.: 5' =0 '(,.+*_0: *+ =0550( A.H2V 60.:*+, 5' DC.+5*5.5*30 .+: DC.6*5.5*306H
*4/('30: 27;''6*+,R !:C7.5*'+ /6.H0: . 7(C7*.6 ('60 *+ 5;0 *:0.2 'B 5;020 4':0(+*_0(2R K;*2 A.2 GC25
.2 760.( *+ 5;0 *:0.2 'B 8S/0_ .2 *5 A.2 *+ 5;'20 'B 5;0 9+:0.+ *+:*,0+*25.2V 5;0 Z(._*6*.+ 4':0(+*_0(2
.+: 5;0 /('5.,'+*252 'B 5;0 f027C06.2 (C(.602g *+ Y0W*7' 'B 5;0 2.40 /0(*':R ?0306'/40+5 2;'C6:
*4/6H 5;0 *+76C2*'+ 'B 5;0 4.2202 .+: 5;0 =025 .+: 4'25 +07022.(H *+25(C40+5 B'( 5;*2 A.2
0:C7.5*'+R $B 7'C(20V .2 5;*2 A.2 . +0'‐7'6'+*.6 /('G075V 5;020 0:C7.5*'+.6 0BB'(52 ;.: 30(H 2/07*B*7V
.+: 'B50+ .C5;'(*5.(*.+ '=G075*302R Z0B'(0 .+H5;*+,V 5;0H A0(0 40.+5 5' :025('H 6'7.6 7C65C(02
:0040: 5' =0 .(7;.*7 .+: .5.3*25*7 *+ 5;0 7.20 'B *+:*,0+'C2 7C65C(02V .+: (C5*+.(*' .+: 5(.:*5*'+.6
B'( .66
'5;0(2R
92
Z('')0
8.(2'+
ILMMd>
PeBBQ
7H+*7.66H
A(*502
B'(
5;0
9+:02V
X+:*.+2V
.2
07'+'4*7
'=25.7602V ;.: 5' =0 0(.:*7.50:R @'( 4'25 .C5;'(2V 0:C7.5*'+ A.2 5;0 4'25 .//('/(*.50 *+25(C40+5
5' :(.A 5;0 /''( ;C::60: 4.2202 B('4 5;0 /'30(5H .+: 7'+20(3.5*24 5;.5 ;.: =07'40 5;0*( ;.=*5.5
.+: 5' 7;.+,0 5;04 *+ 4':0(+ 7*5*_0+2R X+ 5;0 2.40 /('7022V 5;0H =06*030: 5;0H 7'C6: (.*20 . 3*=(.+5
76.22 'B A'()0(2 .+: /(':C70(2 A;' 7'C6: 7'+5(*=C50 5' 5;0 2.7(0: ,'.6 'B 4':0(+*5HR
K;*2 :(.A2 .550+5*'+ 5' 5;0 *+;0(0+5 7;.660+,02 3*2*=60 *+ 5;020 4':0(+*_*+, 0BB'(52R 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
06*502 :*: +'5 ;.30 (0.:H‐4.:0 .+2A0(2 5' 5;0 50+2*'+ 5;020 /('G0752 0+5.*60:R K;0H 5(*0: 5'
/('4'50 7;.+,0 .+: 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+V =C5 .5 5;0 2.40 5*40 B0.(0: 5;0*( 7'+20DC0+702V ='5; *+ 2'7*.6
.+: /'6*5*7.6 (02/075 .+: 4'(.66HR Y.+H /'6*5*7*.+2 .+: *+5066075C.62 B0.(0: 5;0 2'7*.6 .+: 4'(.6
7'+20DC0+702 'B
:(.A*+,
5;0
/0.2.+5(H
'C5
'B
*52
+.5C(.6
;.=*5.5R
K;0H
(0.6*_0:
5;.5
6*B0
*+
5;0
7*5*02
A.2 'B50+ +'5 4C7; =0550( 5;.+ *+ 5;0 7'C+5(H2*:0 .+: 5;.5 5;0 /(020+70 'B . /''( C(=.+ /('605.(*.5
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 13/67
NL
7'C6: ;.30 :.+,0('C2 /'6*5*7.6 7'+20DC0+702R K;0*( /'6*7*02 .+: /6.+2 A0(0 5;0(0B'(0 BC66 'B
.4=*,C*5*02 .+: 7'+5(.:*75*'+2V 5;0 2.40 5;.5 A0 A*66 6.50( '=20(30 *+ 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6
(02'C(702R
1'405*402V 5;020 B0.(2 60: 5' 5;0 0W/6*7*5 ,'.6 'B 6'7.5*+, 5;*2 0:C7.5*'+ *+ 5;0 (C(.6 /0(*/;0(*02
5;04206302 *+ '(:0( 5' .3'*: /0(+*7*'C2 (C(.6 'C5‐4*,(.5*'+ .+: 5' )00/ 5;0 f*++'70+5g /0.2.+52 B.(
B('4 5;0 =.: *+B6C0+702 'B C(=.+ 2'7*05HR X+ 5;0 A'(:2 'B 8S/0_> j!2 4CH :*Bc7*6 H /06*,('2' 06
5(.+2/6.+50 :0 C+. 76.20 . '5(.R l8'2 7.4/02*+'2 2n0(c.+ :02,(.7*.:'2 2* 660,.(.+ . /0(:0( 6. *+,0+C.
/C(0_. :0 2C .4'( .6 7.4/'k I/R ePQR K;0 2.40 6*+0 'B 5;'C,;5 A.2 /(020+50: =H 5;0 Z(._*6*.+ .C5;'(
96=0(5' K'((02V A;' *+ 3.(*'C2 022.H2 *+ 5;0 B*(25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(H A0+5 2' B.( .2 5' (0G075
*+:C25(*.6*_.5*'+ .64'25 7'4/60506HR J*2 ('4.+5*7 .+: 5' 2'40 0W50+5 .C5;'(*5.(*.+ 7'+20(3.5*24
.5504/50: 5' 2'630 5;0 :*7;'5'4H =05A00+ 7*5H .+: 7'C+5(H2*:0 *+ Z(._*6 .+: 4.*+5.*+ 5;0 /C(0
(''52 'B Z(._*6*.+ (C(.6 7C65C(0R X+ . 2'40A;.5 /.(.:'W*7.6 A.H ;*2 *:0.2 A'C6: =07'40 .+ *4/'(5.+5
2'C(70 'B *+2/*(.5*'+ B'( 5;0 %.(,.2 ,'30(+40+5 A;*7; *+ ,0+0(.6 A.2 25('+,6H ,0.(0: 5'A.(:2 5;0
*+:C25(*.6 :0306'/40+5 'B 5;0 7'C+5(H I9+:(.:0p?(C44'+:V LMM^> `P‐^QR
Y.+H 0+,.,0: *+5066075C.62 .+: /'6*5*7*.+2 'B 5;*2 /0(*': A0(0 /0(2'+.66H 25(C,,6*+, A*5; 5;0
.4=*,C*5*02 .+: 7'+5(.:*75*'+2 7.C20: =H 5;*2 4*22*'+R K;0(0 A.2 +' :'C=5 .='C5 5;0*( '=G075*302 'B
+.5*'+;'': .+: 4':0(+*5HV =C5 5;0H A0(0 .A.(0 .5 5;0 2.40 5*40 'B 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 4'(.6
7'+5(.:*75*'+2 5;0H 4*,;5 /(':C70R &0 2;'C6: +'5 B'(,05 5;.5 B'( 4.+H 7'+504/'(.(*02 5;020 /6.+2
A0(0 /.(5 'B . (0.6 4'(.6 4*22*'+R XB +.5*'+‐;'': A.2 5' 7'40 5' .+H5;*+,V 5;0 =0+0B*52 'B
4':0(+*_.5*'+ ;.: 5' =0 0W50+:0: 5' .66 7'(+0(2 .+: 2075'(2 'B 5;0 +.5*'+.6 /'/C6.5*'+R X+ Z(._*6 5;*2
A.2 760.( *+ 5;0 25('+, .+: .5 5*402 BC+:.40+5.6*25 /'2*5*3*25 *:0.2 'B 2'40'+0 6*)0 E'+:'+R K;0(0
A.2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 /0'/60 6*)0 ;*4 A*2;0: 5' .22*4*6.50 .+: 5(.+2B'(4 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+2R
ZC5 .5 5;0 2.40 ;0 (0.6*_0: 5;.5 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 ,('C/2 A0(0 30(H 3C6+0(.=60 5' 5;0 /'22*=60
+0B.(*'C2 7'+20DC0+702
'B
5;020
*:0.2
.+:
0W/6*7*56H
A.+50:
5'
/('5075
5;04R
J0
5;0(0B'(0
030+
.770/50: 5;0 (*,;5BC6 76.*42 5' 6.+: 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+ I?*.7'+V LMMda NML‐da ;0 A.2 6022
'C52/')0+ '+ 5;0 /'2*5*'+ 'B 26.302sQR
K;0 2.40 /.(.:'W*7.6 7'4=*+.5*'+ 'B .C5;'(*5.(*.+ 4':0(+*_*+, *:0.2 .+: /.50(+.6*25 /('5075*'+ 7.+
=0 200+ *+ 5;0 *+:*,0+*25. *:0'6',*02 5;.5 040(,0: .('C+: 5;0 5C(+ 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HV 02/07*.66H *+
<0+5(.6 940(*7. .+: 5;0 9+:0.+ 7'C+5(*02R K;0H A0(0 25('+,6H *+B6C0+70: =H 5;0 2'7*.6 ?.(A*+*25
.+: /'2*5*3*25 *:0.2 'B 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(HV =C5 .5 5;0 2.40 5*40 5;0H (0/(020+50: . +0A A.H 'B
6'')*+, .5 5;0 /6.70 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+ *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. +.5*'+2R 965;'C,; .770/5*+, 5;0
(0DC*(040+52 'B 4':0(+*_.5*'+ .+: +.5*'+;'':V *+:*,0+*25. 5;*+)0(2 25.(50: 5' (0.6*_0 5;.5 5;020
(0DC*(040+52 7'C6:
'+6H
=0
BC6B*660:
*B
5;0
*+:*,0+'C2
/'/C6.5*'+2
A0(0
,C*:0:
5'A.(:2
7*5*_0+2;*/
*+
5;0*( (02/075*30 +.5*'+‐25.502R K;020 +0A *:0.2 A0(0 /.(56H 5;0 (02C65 'B 5;0 (02*25.+70 .+:
(0=066*'+2 'B 5;020 /'/C6.5*'+2V =C5 5;0H A0(0 .62' 5;0 (02C65 'B 5;0 7'+5(.:*75*'+2 7(0.50: =H
4':0(+*5HR X+ 5;*2 A.H 5;0H 7'C6: 60.: 5' 7'+7(050 .5504/52 5' *4/('30 5;0 2*5C.5*'+ 'B 5;0
*+:*,0+'C2 4.2202 .+: 5' (0:C70 5;0 /'A0( 'B 5;0 7'+20(3.5*30 6.+:'A+0(2V A;' A0(0 200+ .2
'=25.7602 5' 5;0 *+50,(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 4.2202 *+ 5;0 +.5*'+R 9B50( !6'H 96B.('g2 8*=0(.6
(03'6C5*'+ *+ !7C.:'( 'B N\^eV .C5;'(*5*02 /C5 *+ /6.70 . 7'4/6050 B(.40A'() 'B /('5075*+, f6'2
*+:*'2V 027.+:.6'2.40+50 0276.3*2.:'2 /'( 7*0(5'2 /.5('+02g I80550( <'4.+:.+7*. :0 6.2 -('3*+7*.2
:06 1C( .6 #'=0(+.:'(V <C0+7. Ne :0 4.H' N\^^a 9J"‐< O`^dQR K;*2 A.2 . B.( 7(H B('4 (0.6
04.+7*/.5*'+V =C5 *5 7'C6: =0 200+ .2 5;0 (02C65 'B 5;*2 +0A C+:0(25.+:*+, 'B 5;0 4'(.6 .+: 2'7*.6
*4/6*7.5*'+2 'B
5;0
4':0(+*_.5*'+
/('G075
=H
/.(5
'B
5;0
!7C.:'(*.+
06*50R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 14/67
N`
$B 7'C(20V 5;020 *:0'6',*7.6 0W/(022*'+2 7.+ =0 .+.6H_0: *+ :*BB0(0+5 A.H2R Y.+H ;.30 200+ 5;04 .2
('4.+5*7 :*25'(5*'+2a .2 0W/(022*'+2 'B <.5'+*24V .2 Z.((*+,5'+ Y''(0 IN^OO> d^N‐OQ 7.660: *5V A;*7;
'+6H 20(30: 5' 25(0+,5;0+ (0/(022*30 .C5;'(*5HR K;0 !7C.:'(*.+ .+5;('/'6',*25 9+:(i2 #C0((0('
IN^^dQ ;.2 .62' 25(0220: 5;0 (0/(022*30 +.5C(0 'B 5;020 *:0'6',*02 A;*7; A0(0 'B50+ ,0.(0: 5'A.(:2
4.*+5.*+*+, 5;0 C+0DC.6 25.5C2 DC'R J'A030(V *5 7.++'5 =0 :0+*0: 5;.5V A;.5030( 5;0*( =.7),('C+:
.+: C65*4.50
'=G075*302V
5;020
*:0.2
7;.+,0:
5;0
/'6*5*7.6
.+:
60,.6
/0(2/075*302
5'A.(:2
5;0
/6.70
'B *+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+2 *+ 2'7*05HR X5 *2 *4/'(5.+5 5' (0404=0( 5;.5 5;0 *+:*,0+*25. 4'3040+5
7(0.50: *4.,02 .+: (0/(020+5.5*'+2 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 A'(6: A;*7; +'5 '+6H ;.: /'6*5*7.6 .+: 60,.6
7'+20DC0+702 *+ 5;0 /0(*': 7'+70(+0: =C5 .62' ;.: ,(0.5 *+B6C0+70 '+ LM5; 70+5C(H .+5;('/'6',H
.+: /'6*5*72R &0 2;'C6: .62' 200 5;020 +0A *:0.2 .2 0W/(022*'+2 'B 2'7*05.6 7;.+,0 .+: 'B 5;0 +00:
B065 =H 2075'(2 'B 2'7*05H 5' B*+: .+2A0(2 5' 5;0 *22C02 'B 7*5*_0+2;*/ .+: 2'7*.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 7;.+,0
X+ 5;0 6.25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 N^5; 70+5C(HV A;0+ 5;0 7'+5(.:*75*'+2 'B 5;0 /('G075 'B 4':0(+*5H =07.40
760.(V 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 25.(50: 5' 6'') B'( :*BB0(0+5V 4'(0 *+25*5C5*'+.6 .+: 6022 .C5;'(*5.(*.+
A.H2 'B *+50,(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 (C(.6 4.2202R K;0H :*: +'5 A.30( *+ 5;0*( 4':0(+*25 *:0.62V =C5 5;0H ;.: .
=0550(
0H0
B'(
*52
/'22*=60
*4/6*7.5*'+2
.+:
*52
*+03*5.=60
7'+5(.:*75*'+2R
92
'+0
'B
5;0
4'(0
*+50(025*+, 'B 5;020 *+5066075C.62V !C76*:02 :. <C+;.V A('50 *+ ;*2 B.4'C2 :027(*/5*'+ 'B 5;0 (03'65
.+: (0/(022*'+ 'B 5;0 <.+C:'2 (0=062 *+ 5;0 20(5t' 'B "'(5;0.250(+ Z(.2*6> j!25.4'2 7'+:0+.:'2 u
7*3*6*_.Tt'R $C /(',(0:*4'2V 'C :02./.(0704'2k I?. <C+;.V 4- -'1,5'-V N^MLa Ndea 200 .62' Z(.:B'(:
ZC(+2V N^\M> L^QR K;0 *+03*5.=*6*5H 'B 4':0(+*5H *2 .770/50: *+ 5;*2 DC'50V =C5 5;0(0 *2 +' 6'+,0( 5;0
=06*0B 5;.5 4':0(+*5H A'C6: 2'630 .66 5;0 /('=6042 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05HR $+ 5;0 7'+5(.(HV ?.
<C+;. :04'+25(.502 5;.5 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 *+7(0.2*+,6H 25.(50: 5' (0.6*_0 5;.5 5;0(0 A.2 .62' .
/('=604.5*7V 030+ C,6H 2*:0 5' 5;0 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05H 5' A;*7; 5;0H +00:0: 5'
(02/'+:R K;*2 2.40 /('7022 .62' '77C((0: *+ 5;0 3*0A2 '+ +.5C(0 .+: 0+3*('+40+5R
K8
5#+>7-%"+$ ,(-
,-%%",#%2
K;0 207'+: 06040+5 'B 5;0 4':0(+*_*+, .,0+:. 5;.5 040(,0: *+ 5;0 6.25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 N^5; 70+5C(H
7'+70(+0: 5;0 7'+5('6 '30(V .+: /(':C75*3*5H 'BV 5;0 +.5*'+.6 50((*5'(*02R &*5; *+:0/0+:0+70V 8.5*+
940(*7.+ 06*502 ;.: *+;0(*50: 7'C+5(*02 'B A;*7; 6.(,0 /.(52 A0(0 ;.(:6H *+;.=*50: .+: 'B A;*7; 5;0H
'B50+ ;.: 6*5560 )+'A60:,0R K;0H +'5 '+6H A*2;0: 5' *4/'20 5;0 (C60 'B 6.A *+ 5;0 B.( .A.H
50((*5'(*02V 5;0H .62' A.+5 5' 4.)0 5;04 /(':C75*30 .+:V *+ 5;*2 A.HV *+50,(.50 5;04 *+ 5;0 ,(.+:
/('G075 'B 4':0(+*5HR X+ '5;0( A'(:2V 4':0(+*_.5*'+ *4/6*0: . (.:*7.6 50((*5'(*.6 (07'+B*,C(.5*'+ 5;.5
A'C6: 0+.=60 5;0 25.50 5' 0W50+: *52 /'A0( .+: 5' *+7(0.20 /(':C75*30 .75*3*5*02R
X+ . ,0+0(.6
20+20
*5
7.+
=0
2.*:
5;.5
*+
N^
5;
70+5C(H
8.5*+
940(*7.
.64'25
.66
+.5*'+.6
f='(:0(2g
A0(0
.5 5;0 2.40 5*40 fB('+5*0(2gR K;0H (0/(020+50: /0(*/;0(.6 (0,*'+2 5;.5 0W*250: B.( B('4V .+: 'B50+ *+
'//'2*5*'+ 5' 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 70+50( *+ 5;0 +.5*'+.6 <./*5.62R !7'+'4*7.66HV 5;020 ='(:0( (0,*'+2 A0(0
'B50+ C+*4/'(5.+5R K;0 6.7) 'B *+B(.25(C75C(.6 B.7*6*5*02 B'(40: . B'(4*:.=60 '=25.760 5' 5;0*(
/(':C75*30 :0306'/40+5R $B 7'C(20V 5;0(0 A0(0 0W70/5*'+2V =C5 *+ ,0+0(.6 5;0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
B('+5*0( A.2 . +'‐4.+g2 6.+: A*5; ;.(:6H .+H 40.+*+,BC6 /(':C75*30 .75*3*5HR
hC25 .2 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 7'44C+*5*02V 5;0 C+7'+DC0(0: 2/.702 *+ 5;0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ B('+5*0( =07.40
2H4='62 'B =.7)A.(:+022V #,1#-* .+: 6#16#1%' 5;.5 +00:0: 5' =0 0(.20: .+: f.22*4*6.50:gR X+ 5;*2 A.HV
5;0 B('+5*0( =07.40 . /'A0(BC6 *7'+ 5;.5 20(30: .2 .+5*+'4H 5' 5;0 *:0.62 'B /(',(022R X5 =07.40 5;0
=.(=.(*7 +'
‐4.+v2
6.+:
2C7;
.2
:0/*750:
B'(
9(,0+5*+.
*+
1.(4*0+5'v2
B.4'C2
7#8+&(*
IN\deQ
.+:
B'(
%0+0_C06. *+ E*30(.v2 ;.C+5*+, +'306 .# 9*1#$%&' IN^LdQR K;020 022.H2 /'(5(.H0: . /'A0(BC6 4022.,0 *+
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 15/67
Nd
A;*7; /(',(022 .+: 7*3*6*_.5*'+ A'C6: '+6H =0 .77022*=60 A*5; 5;0 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ '( :025(C75*'+ 'B
B('+5*0( 2'7*05HR X+ 5;*2 20+20V 5;0H 4*(('(0: 5;0 3*0A2 '+ 2'7*05H :*27C220: .='30R 8.5*+ 940(*7. A.2
7'+2*:0(0: 5' 2CBB0( B('4 3.(*'C2 2'7*.6 .+: 05;+*7 A0.)+02202 .+: :*20.202 5;.5 +00:0: 5' =0
0(.:*7.50: B*(25R !22.H2 6*)0 <i2.( wC405.g2 )*&,%&'&,' '&:'1"*; 1.63.:'( Y0+:*05.g2 .# '&:'1"'(#( ('
)'&,1*#"<1%8# .+: 9(,C0:.g2 =+'62* '&:'1"* ;.: 0+'(4'C2 *4/.75R K;0*( 0+:C(*+, *+B6C0+70 '+
+.5*'+.6
:0=.502
:04'+25(.502
5;0*(
*4/'(5.+5
2H4='6*7
('60
*+
8.5*+
940(*7.+
*:0.62
'B
/(',(022 I?03i2 %.6:i2V LMMM> PeQR K;0 B('+5*0( .7DC*(0: 5;0 2.40 7'++'5.5*'+ .2 5;0 *:0. 'B . f2*7)g 7'+5*+0+5
=('C,;5 B'(A.(: =H 4.+H *+5066075C.62 *+ :*BB0(0+5 /.(52 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.R K;0H :0/*750: 5;0 :.()V
=.(=.(*7 .+5*5;02*2 5' 7*3*6*_0: 2'7*05H 5;.5 +00:0: 5' =0 =('C,;5 C+:0( 7'+5('6 *+ '(:0( 5' *4/'20
7*3*6*_.5*'+ .+: /(',(022R
K;*2 2/07*B*7 7;.(.750(*25*7 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7. +.5*'+ =C*6:*+, B'(70: 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 5' (05;*+)
5;0*( 50((*5'(*.6 /'6*7*02R K;0H +00:0: 5' *+7(0.20 5;0*( 7'+5('6 '30( C+)+'A+ .+: C+7'+5('660:
(0,*'+2 *+ '(:0( 5' 4.)0 5;04 /(':C75*30V =C5 5;0H .62' +00:0: 5' 5(.+2B'(4 A;.5 A.2 200+ .2
5(.:*5*'+.6 (C(.6 2'7*05*02 5;.5 A0(0 :'4*+.50: =H +'+‐4':0(+ 6.+:'A+0(2R ".5*'+.6 ,'30(+40+52
5(*0: 5'
*+7'(/'(.50
5;0
4'(0
/0(*/;0(.6
(0,*'+2
'B
5;0
+.5*'+.6
50((*5'(H
.+:
5'
6*+)
5;04
5'
5;0
<./*5.6R
95 5;0 2.40 5*40V 5;0H 5(*0: 5' 5(.+2B'(4 (C(.6 2'7*05*02 .+: 5' 2C=:C0 5;0*( 5(.:*5*'+.6 6.+:'A+*+,
06*502R &;0+ 5;*2 ;.//0+0: *5 A.2 760.( 5;.5 5;0 06*502 A.2 :*3*:0: .4'+, 5;04206302R K;0 N^5; 70+5C(H
A*5+0220: . 7'+5*+C'C2 25(C,,60 =05A00+ 06*50 ,('C/2 5;.5 5(*0: 5' C20 5;0 25.50 .//.(.5C2 5'
4':0(+*_0 2'7*05H .+: 5;'20 5;.5 5(*0: 5' ;'6: '+ 5' 5;0*( (0,*'+.6 /'A0( =.20R $+6H *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5;
70+5C(H .+: 0.(6H LM5; 70+5C(*02 :*: 5;0 25.50 =07'40 . :'4*+.+5 B.75'(V ,(.:C.66H 2C='(:*+.5*+,
(0,*'+.6 60.:0(2 .+: 5;0*( /'A0(=.20R
95 5;0 2.40 5*40 f04/5Hg (0,*'+2 A0(0 ,(.:C.66H /'/C6.50:R $B50+ 5;*2 A.2 5;0 (02C65 'B A;.5 A0 7.+
7.66 76.22*7.6 fB('+5*0( 0W/.+2*'+g *+ A;*7; +0A (0,*'+2 A0(0 7'6'+*_0: .+: 4.:0 .3.*6.=60 B'(
.,(*7C65C(0 .+:
7.5560
(.*2*+,
IJ0++0220HV
N^P\QR
8'7.6
/'/C6.5*'+2
‐/0.2.+52
.+:
6.(,0
6.+:'A+0(2
]
25.(50: 5' 5.)0 '30( 04/5H 5(.7)2 'B 6.+: .+: *+ 5;*2 A.H /C2;0: 5;0 .,(*7C65C(.6 B('+5*0( *+A.(:2R
&;0(0 /('2/0752 A0(0 =0550( .+: 6'7.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 A0(0 +'5 .3.*6.=60 !C('/0.+ *44*,(.5*'+ A.2
25*4C6.50:R K;0 760.(025 0W.4/602 'B B('+5*0( .75*3*5H 7.+ 'B 7'C(20 =0 '=20(30: *+ 5;0 >#">#- *+
9(,0+5*+. .+: 2'C5;0(+ Z(._*6 .+: 5;0 2'‐7.660: 22#&*- *+ <'6'4=*. .+: %0+0_C06.R K;020 76.22*7.6 7.202
'B 5;0 7'+DC0(*+, 'B 5;0 B('+5*0( A0(0 =0B'(0 .+H5;*+, 7.5560 B('+5*0(2V *+ A;*7; 5;0 *+B6C0+70 'B ;C4.+
/'/C6.5*'+2 A.2 DC*50 6*4*50: .+: A;*7; A0(0 .64'25 0W76C2*306H 7'++0750: 5' 0W50+2*30 7.5560‐;'6:*+,R
"'5 7'*+7*:0+5.66HV 5;020 A0(0 .62' *4/'(5.+5 *44*,(.5*'+ (0,*'+2R K;0 /(':C75*30 =.2*2 'B 5;020
B('+5*0(2 :*BB0(0: DC*50 760.(6HR K;0 <'6'4=*.+V %0+0_C06.+ .+: 2'C5;0(+ Z(._*6*.+ 7.5560 B('+5*0(2
(04.*+0: 507;+'6',*7.66H =.7)A.(: .+: /'6*5*7.66H C+(C6H *+ 7'4/.(*2'+ 5' 5;0 9(,0+5*+*.+ /.4/.2 .+:
Z(._*6*.+ *+50(*'(
I16.55.V
N^^L>
`OQR
X+
2'C5;0(+
Z(._*6V
4.+H
7'6'+*252
=06'+,0:
5'
(06.5*306H
A066
‐5'
‐:'
2075'(2 .+: (*7; 6.+:'A+0(2 A0(0 .+ *4/'(5.+5 B.75'( *+ 7'+DC0(*+, *52 ,(.226.+:2 IZ066V N^^\QR
X5 *2 *4/'(5.+5 5' +'50 5;.5 5;0 7'6'+*_.5*'+ 'B 5;0 B('+5*0( :*: +'5 5.)0 /6.70 '+6H *+ 5;0 6.(,0V 27.(706H
*+;.=*50: /6.*+2 'B 5;0 6.(,0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02R X+ 24.660( 7'C+5(*02 6*)0 5;0 ?'4*+*7.+ E0/C=6*7
'( #C.504.6.V 5;0 0W/.+2*'+ 'B B('+5*0( .,(*7C65C(0 A.2 .62' 760.(6H 3*2*=60R K;0 2.40 7.+ =0 2.*: B'(
(0,*'+2 5;.5 .(0 +'(4.66H 7'+2*:0(0: .2 :'4*+.50: =H 6.(,0 6.+:;'6:*+,2V 6*)0 Y'(06'2 IY0W*7'QV 70+5(.6
<'6'4=*. '( 5;0 9+:0.+ ;*,;6.+:2R K;*2 7'+DC0(*+, 'B 5;0 .,(*7C65C(.6 B('+5*0( A.2 'B50+ 5;0 A'() 'B
/0.2.+5 /(':C70(2 A;' 0+,.,0: *+ :*BB0(0+5 B'(42 'B 26.2;‐.+:‐=C(+ .,(*7C65C(0 .+: *+ 5;*2 A.H /C2;0:
5;0 B('+5*0( =.7)R K;020 /''( B.(40(2 ;.: 6*5560 2'7*.6 '( /'6*5*7.6 6030(.,0 =C5 5;0H 5(*0: 5' 207C(0 5;0*(
6*306*;'': =H
4'3*+,
*+5'
04/5HV
/0(*/;0(.6
.(0.2R
X+
;0(
0W70660+5
7.20
25C:H
'B
<'6'4=*.+
B('+5*0(
0W/.+2*'+ <.5;0(*+0 80#(.+: IN^\OQ 2;'A2 760.(6H ;'A /.550(+2 'B 2'7*.6 .+: /'6*5*7.6 *+0DC.6*5H *+
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 16/67
Ne
<'6'4=*.+ 2'7*05H A0(0 (0/(':C70: *+ 5;0 B('+5*0( (0,*'+2R X+ <'6'4=*. 5;0 4'(0 /'A0(BC6 7'6'+*252
5'') '30( 5;0 6.+:;'6:*+,2 'B 24.66‐27.60 /0.2.+52V *+ 5;*2 A.H /C2;*+, 5;0 6.550( BC(5;0( *+5' 5;0
5('/*7.6 6'A6.+:2R
X+B(.25(C75C(.6 *4/('3040+52 A0(0 (0DC*(0: 5' 6*+) 5;020 (0,*'+2 5' 5;0 7./*5.62 .+: 5;0 +.5*'+.6
07'+'4*02R X+ B*(25 *+25.+70 5;020 A0(0 ('.:2 B'( /.7) .+*4.62 .+: 7.(52R X4/('3*+, 5;0 *+B(.25(C75C(0 *+
5;0 B'(4 'B ('.:‐=C*6:*+, .+: I*+ 5('/*7.6 6'A6.+: (0,*'+2 .2 94._'+*. .+: 5;0 <'6'4=*.+ <;'7SQ 5;0
*4/('3040+5 'B A.50( 5(.+2/'(5.5*'+ A.2 /.(5 'B 5;0 /('7022 'B +.5*'+ =C*6:*+,R 8.50( 5;0 B'7C2 4'30:
5' 7.(‐ .+: (.*6('.:2R K;0 7'+25(C75*'+ 'B (.*6('.:2 25.(50: *+ 0.(+025 .('C+: 5;0 5C(+ 'B 5;0 70+5C(HR
K;0H A0(0 76'206H 7'++0750: 5' 5;0 0W/'(5 'B 7'44':*5*02R X+ ,0+0(.6V (.*6('.:2 A0(0 B*+.+70: =H
B'(0*,+ 7./*5.6 .+: ,0.(0: 5'A.(:2 0W/'(5R Z07.C20 5;0*( 4.*+ /C(/'20 A.2 5;0 0W/'(5.5*'+ 'B
7'44':*5*02V 5;0H A0(0 7'++0750: 5' /'(5 7*5*02 .+: ;.(:6H /6.H0: . ('60 *+ +.5*'+.6 *+50,(.5*'+R
"030(5;06022V *+ 2'40 7.202V 6*)0 *+ 9(,0+5*+. .+: -0(CV 5;0H 7.40 5' /6.H 5;0*( /.(5 *+ *+7'(/'(.5*+, 5;0
*+50(*'( 5' 5;0 7./*5.6R 1'405*402 5;0H A0(0 0W/6*7*56H 40.+5 5' :' 2'V 6*)0 B'( *+25.+70 5;0 *66‐B.4'C2
(.*6('.: =05A00+ [C*5' .+: #C.H.DC*6R X+ '5;0( 7.202V 6*)0 5;0 (.*6('.: *+ 5;0 9+5'B.,.25. (0,*'+V 5;0H
A0(0 2500(0:
=H
,0'
‐/'6*5*7.6
7'+70(+2
'B
Z'6*3*.
.+:
<;*60R
X+
5;0
+0,'5*.5*'+2
=05A00+
Z(._*6
.+:
Z'6*3*. :C(*+, 5;0 (C==0( =''4V A;*7; A'C6: 030+5C.66H 60.: 5' 5;0 K(0.5H 'B -05(S/'6*2 *+ N^M`V Z(._*6
='C,;5 5;0 97(0 /('3*+70 =C5 .62' /('4*20: 5' 7'+25(C75 . (.*6('.: .6'+,2*:0 . +'+‐+.3*,.=60 /.(5 'B
5;0 Y.:0*(. (*30( 2'C5; *+5' Z'6*3*.V 2' 5;.5 Z'6*3*.+ /(':C752 7'C6: (0.7; 5;0 956.+5*7 IJ044*+,V N^\P>
LP\‐^QR
965;'C,; 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 06040+52 'B 5;*2 B('+5*0( 0W/.+2*'+ .(0 70(5.*+6H +'5 5' =0 *,+'(0:V 5;0(0 *2 +'
:'C=5 5;.5 5;0 /(*+7*/.6 :(*3*+, B'(70 =0;*+: *5 A.2 07'+'4*7R X5 *2 760.( 5;.5 *5 A.2 76'206H 7'++0750: 5'V
A0 7'C6: 030+ 2.H :0/0+:0+5 '+V 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B 5;0 +.5C(.6 (02'C(702V 7'+2*:0(0: 5;0 /(*+7*/.6
A0.65; 'B 5;0 +0A +.5*'+2R @('4 5;0 N\PM2 '+A.(:2 5;*2 60: 5' .+ 07'+'4*7 4':06 5;.5 A.2 =.20: '+
5;0 7'+3*75*'+
5;.5
5;0
0W/'(5
'B
5;020
(02'C(702
A'C6:
,C.(.+500
8.5*+
940(*7.
. 25('+,
/6.70
*+
5;0
A'(6: 07'+'4HR K;0 *:0. 'B 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: :0306'/40+5 =07.40 5;0 :050(4*+*+, 07'+'4*7 *:0'6',H
030(HA;0(0 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. .+: 5;0 :'4*+.+5 4':06 B'( 4.+H H0.(2 5' 7'40R
8.5*+ 940(*7. ;.2 .6A.H2 =00+ . 7'+5*+0+5 A*5; . (06.5*306H 6'A /'/C6.5*'+ :0+2*5HV @'( 7'+504/'(.(*02V
5;0 A0.65; 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 .//0.(0: 2' .=C+:.+5 (06.5*30 5' 5;0 +C4=0( 'B *52 *+;.=*5.+52 5;.5 +'
5;'C,;52 A0(0 ,*30+ 5' 5;0 /'22*=60 0W;.C25*'+ 'B 5;0 (02'C(702 '( 5;0 0+3*('+40+5.6 7'+20DC0+702R
@'(0252V ,.40V A.50(V 4*+0(.6 (02'C(702 20040: 5' 0W*25 *+ 2C7; .=C+:.+5 2C//6*02 5;.5 5;0H 20040:
*+B*+*50R Y':0(+*_0(2 .+: 0+5(0/(0+0C(2 /(*:0: 5;04206302 5;.5V B'( 5;0 B*(25 5*40V 5;0H C+:0(25'': 5;0
*4/'(5.+70 'B 5;0 5(0.2C(02 /(020+50: =H +.5C(0R K;*2 *+2*,;5 A'C6:V *+ 5;0*( 0H02V /('3*:0 8.5*+
940(*7.+ +.5*'+2
A*5;
5;0
7./*5.6
5'
:0306'/
.+:
5'
7*3*6*_0
*52
/'/C6.5*'+2R
K;0(0 A0(0V ;'A030(V *4/'(5.+5 :*BB0(0+702 A*5;*+ 5;0 (0,*'+R X+ 2'40 7'C+5(*02 5;0 *+B*+*50+022 'B
+.5C(.6 A0.65; A.2 ;.(:6H DC025*'+0:R Y.+H 7.+ =0 7'+2*:0(0: .2 (0.6 B('+5*0( 2'7*05*02V A;0(0 5;0
0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 A0+5 ;.+: *+ ;.+: A*5; 5;0 (060+56022 '77C/.5*'+ 'B 2/.70R 965;'C,;V
.66 'B 5;04 /'220220: ;*,;6H :0306'/0: C(=.+ 70+50(2V 5;0*( 07'+'4*7 :H+.4*24 :0/0+:0: '+ 5;0
7'6'+*_.5*'+ 'B +0A 50((*5'(*02R K;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 Z(._*6 .+: 9(,0+5*+. 5'') /(*:0 'B /6.70 ;0(0V =C5
A0 4.H .62' *+76C:0 7'C+5(*02 6*)0 <'6'4=*. .+: %0+0_C06.V A;*7; /'220220: 6.(,0 5('/*7.6 B('+5*0(2R
K;*2 B('+5*0( 4':06 'B :0306'/40+5 .62' ;.//0+0: '+ . 24.660( 27.60 *+ 4.+H 'B 5;0 4'(0 :0+206H
/'/C6.50: 7'C+5(*02V A;0(0 /0.2.+5 B.(40(2 .+: 6.(,0( 6.+:'A+0(2 ,(.:C.66H 7'6'+*_0: B'(0252 .+:
5C(+0: 5;04
*+5'
.,(*7C65C(.6
6.+:R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 17/67
NO
X+ '5;0( (0,*'+2 5;0 +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 A0(0 6022 .=C+:.+5 .6(0.:H 4.)*+, 760.( 2'40 0+3*('+40+5.6
6*4*5.5*'+2 5' 5;0 0W5(.75*3*25 4':06 'B :0306'/40+5R X+ 5;*2 7.50,'(HV 5;0 9+:0.+ 7'C+5(*02 4.H =0
7'+2*:0(0: 5;0 =025 0W.4/602R K;0 ;.(:2;*/ 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 7'+:*5*'+2 *+ ;*,; .65*5C:02 .+: 5;0
I'77.2*'+.6Q 27.(7*5H 'B (02'C(702 6*)0 6.+: .+: A.50( ;.: /('B'C+: *+B6C0+70 '+ 5;0 4*+:205 .+:
3*0A/'*+52 'B 5;0*( 06*502R X+ 5;0 9+:02V +.5C(0 A.2 +030( 5;0 206B ‐03*:0+5 5(0.2C(H 5;.5 *5 A.2 *+ 5;0
94._'+ (0,*'+
'(
*+
5;0
9(,0+5*+0
/.4/.2R
J0(0
A0
.62'
200
5;0
0.(6*025
7'+B6*752
.='C5
5;020
27.(70(
(02'C(702R K;0 25(C,,60 B'( 6.+: .+: A.50( 25.(50: .6(0.:H *+ 5;0 207'+: ;.6B 'B 5;0 N^5; 70+5C(H X+ 5;0
9+:0.+ ;*,;6.+:2V '+6H 5' *+50+2*BH *+ 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HR K;020 7'+B6*752 /*550: :*BB0(0+5 /'50+5*.6 C20(2
.,.*+25 0.7; '5;0(V =C5 'B50+ .62' .,.*+25 5;0 25.50 A;*7; 'B50+ 5'') 40.2C(02 A;*7; (0:C70: 5;0 (*,;52
.+: /'22*=*6*5*02 'B 5(.:*5*'+.6 C20(2 I7BR Ei+*DC0 LMMdQR
$B 7'C(20V 5;*2 5A'B'6: :*3*2*'+ *2 4C7; 5'' 2*4/60R X+ .66 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02 . ,(0.5 3.(*.5*'+ 'B
6'7.6 76*4.502 .+: ,0',(./;*7.6 7*(7C425.+702 0W*250:R %*0A/'*+52 '+ +.5C(0 .+: +.5C(.6 (02'C(702
:0/0+:0: '+ 5;020 2*5C.5*'+2 =C5 .62' '+ /'6*5*7.6 /('G0752 .+: 76.22 (06.5*'+2 *+ 5;020 2/07*B*7 6'7.6*5*02R
X+ 5;*2 2;'(5 .(5*760 *5 *2 *4/'22*=60 5' .+.6H_0 .66 5;020 6'7.6 :*BB0(0+702R K;0 :*3*2*'+ *2 C20BC6V =07.C20 *5
:(.A2 'C(
.550+5*'+
5'
5;0
:*BB0(0+5
3*2*'+2
'+
+.5C(0
.+:
+.5C(.6
(02'C(702
5;.5
A0(0
;*::0+
C+:0(
5;0
;'4',0+0'C2 .+: ,0+0(.6*_0: '=2022*'+2 A*5; :0306'/40+5 .+: 4':0(+*5H 'B 5;0 /0(*':R
L8
<(- -=-%$-+)- #9 -:'#%, ‐&$%")7*,7%-
K;0 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: :0306'/40+5 'B 5;*2 /0(*': 7'+70(+0: . 6'5 'B /(':C752 2'40 'B A;*7; A0 4.H
0.2*6H B'(,05R 9/.(5 B('4 .66 )*+:2 'B 24.66‐27.60 4*+*+, I,'6:V 2*630(V =C5 .62' 040(.6:2 I8.+0V LMNMQV
5;0(0 A0(0 . 3.(*05H 'B 0W5(.75*30 .75*3*5*02V (.+,*+, B('4 5;0 (060+56022 0W/'(5.5*'+ 'B '(7;*:2 B('4 5;0
Z(._*6*.+ 5('/*7.6 B'(025 ] .77'(:*+, 5' ?0.+ IN^^e> NO`QV 2'405*402 (0.7;*+, . +C4=0( 'B LMMRMMM
'(7;*:2 /0( H0.( *+ 5;0 4*:‐N^5; 70+5C(H ‐ V (C==0( 5.//*+,V 5;0 0W/6'*5.5*'+ 'B 5;0 ,C.+' :0/'2*52 '+
5;0
-0(C3*.+
7'.25.6
*26.+:2
'(
5;0
0W/6'*5.5*'+
'B
B'(025
(020(302
B'(
:'4025*7
.+:
*+:C25(*.6 7'+2C4/5*'+R
"030(5;06022V 5;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 5;0 :0306'/40+5 .+: 0W/.+2*'+ 'B .,(*7C65C(0 A.2 5;0 4'25 3*2*=60
.+: *4/'(5.+5 B.75'( *+ 5;0 :0306'/40+5 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7. *+ 5;0 /0(*': =05A00+ N\PM .+: N^`MR
Z07.C20 4'25 'B 5;*2 /(':C75*'+ A.2 40.+5 B'( 5;0 0W/'(5V 0W/'(5 B*,C(02 ,*30 5;0 =025 *+:*7.5*'+ 'B 5;0
0+'(4'C2 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ C+:0(,'+0 =H 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 07'+'4*02R Z(._*6g2 7'BB00 /(':C75*'+ A0+5
B('4 6022 5;.+ `MMRMMM 5'+2 *+ N\\M 5' P`MRMMM *+ N^N`R X+ . 24.66 7'C+5(H 6*)0 #C.504.6.V *5 A0+5 B('4
NPRMMM 5' dLRMMM 5'+2R X+ <C=. 2C,.( /(':C75*'+ *+7(0.20: B('4 dPMRMMM 5'+2 *+ N\\M 5' .64'25 5;(00
4*66*'+ *+ N^NdR X+ -0(C 5;*2 *+7(0.20 A.2 B('4 LdRMMM 5' LL`RMMM 5'+ I80A*2V N^PM> ed‐eeQR $5;0(
5('/*7.6 /(':C752
6*)0
5'=.77'V
;0+0DC0+V
7.7.'
'(
7'55'+V
2;'A0:
2*4*6.(
B*,C(02
*+
5;*2
/0(*':R
X+
. 7'C+5(H 6*)0 9(,0+5*+.V 2*4*6.( ,('A5; B*,C(02 A0(0 (07'(:0: B'( 40.5 .+: A;0.5R <'4/.(0: 5' /(020+5‐
:.H /(':C75*'+ 5;020 4.H +'5 .//0.( *4/(022*30 B*,C(02V =C5 *+ 4.+H (0,*'+2 *+ N^5; 70+5C(H 8.5*+
940(*7. 5;0H ,0+0(.50: :(.4.5*7 7;.+,02R K;*2 030+ 4'(0 2'V =07.C20 .+ *4/'(5.+5 /.(5 'B 5;*2
/(':C75*'+ 5'') /6.70 '+ +0A 6.(,0‐27.60 204*‐*+:C25(*.6 0+50(/(*202V 'B50+ B*+.+70: =H B'(0*,+V 4'256H
F1 7./*5.6 IZ(._*6 =0*+, 5;0 0W70/5*'+QR K;020 0+50(/(*202 A0(0 *+ C(,0+5 +00: 'B 6.='C(V A;*7; A.2
=.2*7.66H 5;0 '+6H /(':C75*'+ B.75'( 5;.5 7'C6: *+7(0.20 H*06:2R $B50+ 5;0H A0(0 025.=6*2;0: *+ f04/5Hg
/0(*/;0(.6 (0,*'+2 .+: 5;0(0B'(0 .75*306H 25.(50: 5' 6'') B'( 7'+5(.750: 4*,(.+52V 0*5;0( B('4 *+2*:0 '(
'C52*:0 5;0 7'C+5(HR X+ '5;0( 7.202V 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0 5'') /6.70 *+ 4'(0 5(.:*5*'+.6 .+: 4'(0
:0+206H /'/C6.50: .(0.2R J0(0V 5;0 0W/.+2*'+ 'B .,(*7C65C(.6 .75*3*5H 60: 5' 6.+: 7'+70+5(.5*'+ 5;.5 'B50+
7.C20: 7'+B6*752
A*5;
24.66
‐27.60
‐=C5
.62'
A*5;
6.(,0(
27.60
‐B.(40(2R
K;0
25.50
*+
5;020
(0,*'+2
/6.H0:
.+ *4/'(5.+5 ('60 *+ B.7*6*5.5*+, 0W/'(5 .,(*7C65C(0 .+: *+ 7'+:*5*'+*+, f.+5*‐7./*5.6*25g 5(.:*5*'+.6
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 18/67
NP
/0.2.+52 5' B*5 *+5' 5;0*( BC5C(0 ('60 .2 A'()0(2 B'( 5;0 2.7(0: 7.20 'B /(',(022R X+ (0,*'+2 A;0(0 26.30(H
;.: =00+ 5;0 5(.:*5*'+.6 *+25(C40+5 'B 6.='C( (07(C*540+5V 5;*2 60: 5' 7'+5(.:*75'(H .+: 'B50+
.4=*,C'C2 /'6*7*02 5'A.(:2 ='5; 4':0(+*_*+, .+: 7'+5('66*+, 26.30 6.='C(R
X5 *2 *4/'(5.+5 5' (07.66 5;.5 =0B'(0 5;0 6.50 LM5; 70+5C(H .,(*7C65C(0 A.2 70(5.*+6H +'5 200+ .2 .+
0W5(.75*30 .75*3*5HV =C5 .2 . 40.+2 5' 7(0.50 A0.65; .+: 7./*5.6 f'C5 'B +'5;*+,gR X5 A.2V *+ 5;0 0H02 'B
7'+504/'(.(*02V 5;0 =025 0W.4/60 'B ;'A 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 7'C6: =(*+, .='C5 /('B*5 .+: /(':C75*'+ 'C5 'B
+'5;*+,R 966 5;*2 6.+: 5;.5 6.H C+C20: .+: :'(4.+5 +00:0: 5' =0 A'()0: .+: 0W/6'*50:V 2' .2 5' 7(0.50
A0.65; .+: /('2/0(*5HR @'( 5;.5 (0.2'+V *5 A.2 +'5 '+6H 200+ .2 . /(':C75*30 2075'(V =C5 .2 . 4'(.6 .+:
/'6*5*7.6 +07022*5HR 92 . 507;+*7*.+ A('50 5' .+ !7C.:'(*.+ Y*+*250(V .,(*7C65C(0 2;'C6: =0 7'+2*:0(0:
5;0 4'25 *4/'(5.+5 2075'( 'B 25.50V j06 4b2 *4/'(5.+50 H C(,0+50 :0 5':'2 6'2 /('=604.2 /'6c5*7'2 H
+.7*'+.602 7'4' DC0 2*,+*B*7. 06 2.63.40+5' H 7C(.7*S+ :0 C+ :02/0r.:'kV =07.C20>
jl8n. 9,(*7C65C(. ImQ B07C+:*_. 06 2C06' H 6' 660+. :0 3c.2V ImQ +C5(0 H .,(.+:. 6.2 /'=6.7*'+02 H
7(0. 06 7./*5.6V :. 6'2 0W70:0+502 0+ /'=6.7*S+ H 7./*5.602 /.(. 6. 7'6'+*_.7*S+ :0 6.2 (0,*'+02
3*(,*+.602 H /.(. 6. *+:C25(*.6*_.7*S+ H 7'40(7*' :0 2C2 .=C+:.+5c2*4.2 4.50(*.2 /(*4.2kR
&;*60 5;0 7'+20DC0+70 'B .+ .=20+70 'B .,(*7C65C(.6 .75*3*5H A'C6: =0>
j0250(*6*_.:' 06 2C06'V 025.+7.:' 6. /'=6.7*S+ H 06 7./*5.6 H :0G.:' 2*+ 3c.2 . 6. 4*24. (0,*S+
/'=6.:.V .60Gb+:'20 7.:. :c. 4b2 :0 6. 7'6'+*_.7*S+ H 06 *+:C25(*.6*24'V 0W50+:*0+:' H
.;'+:.+:' /'( 5':.2 /.(502 6. 4*20(*. H 6. :024'(.6*_.7*S+k I<.(5. :06 Ki7+*7' :0 6. ?*(077*S+
#0+0(.6 :0 9,(*7C65C(.V -.=6' 9 %b27'+0_V .6 Y*+*25(' :0 X+25(C77*S+ -q=6*7.V hC25*7*.V
Z0+0B*7*0+7*. *+> X+B'(40 :06 Y*+*25(' N^L`V //R NLOQR
K;020 )*+:2 'B *:0.2 A0(0 7'44'+ 20+20 .66 '30( 8.5*+ 940(*7.V A;0(0 *+5066075C.62V 0+5(0/(0+0C(2 .+:
/'6*5*7*.+2 7'*+7*:0:
*+
5;0*(
DC025
B'(
.,(*7C65C(.6
4':0(+*_.5*'+
.+:
,('A5;R
&;0+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(H 4':0(+*_0(2 /('4'50: .+ *+7(0.20 *+ .,(*7C65C(.6 /(':C75*3*5HV 5;0H
:0B*+*506H :*: +'5 (0B0( 5' .66 .,(*7C65C(.6 .75*3*5HR 92 A0 .6(0.:H 2.AV 5;0H 50+:0: 5' 3*0A 24.66‐27.60
/0.2.+5 .,(*7C65C(0 .2 1+,%%# .+: .(7;.*7R K;0 f7*3*6*_*+,g *:0'6',*02 /C5 B'(A.(: =H 5;04V A0(0 .62'
2/07*B*7.66H 40.+5 5' 50.7; 5;0 /0.2.+5 /'/C6.5*'+2 *+ 5;0 4':0(+ A.H2 'B 6*3*+, .+: /(':C75*'+ 2' 5;.5
5;0H 7'C6: 5.)0 5;0*( /6.70 *+ 5;0 4':0(+ 07'+'4H .+: 5;0 +.5*'+ 25.50R &;0+ 5;0H 5.6)0: .='C5
.,(*7C65C(.6 7;.+,0V 5;0H 40.+5 f6.(,0‐27.60g .,(*7C65C(0 A*5; 2'/;*25*7.50: 507;+'6',*02V (.*6('.:2 .+:
4.7;*+02V .+: B*(46H '(*0+50: 5' 5;0 4.()05R K;0H A0(0 .A.(0 'B 5;0 *+:C25(*.6 (03'6C5*'+ 5.)*+, /6.70
*+ !C('/0 .+: 5;0 F1 .+: 5;0H :0306'/0: . 4':025 +.5*30 7'+2C40( *+:C25(H *+ 4.+H 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
7*5*02V =C5
5;0H
:*:
+'5
=06*030
5;.5
*+:C25(*.6*_.5*'+
A.2
. 3*.=60
25(.50,H
B'(
5;0
(0,*'+R
8.5*+
940(*7.
;.: 5' 5.)0 .:3.+5.,0 'B *52 (02'C(702 .+: C20 *52 7'4/.(.5*30 .:3.+5.,0 5' /.(5*7*/.50 *+ 5;0 A'(6:
07'+'4H .2 . /(':C70( 'B (.AV 4.*+6H .,(*7C65C(.6 7'44':*5*02R
X+ 5;*2 20+20V 5;0 :(*30 B'( .,(*7C65C(.6 /(':C75*'+ *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. *+ 5;*2 /0(*': 7.+ =0 7'+2*:0(0:
04*+0+56H 0W5(.75*3*25R X5 40.+5 .+ *+:*27(*4*+.50 :025(C75*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 .+: .+ 0(.:*7.5*'+
I.+: 2'405*402 *+7'(/'(.5*'+Q 'B 6'7.6 /'/C6.5*'+2R K;*2 A.2 +'5'(*'C26H 2' A*5; 2C,.(‐7.+0 .: 7'BB00
=C5 .62' A*5; 4.+H '5;0( /(':C752 IKC7)0(V LMMMQR YC7; 6.50( 5;0 2.40 A'C6: ;.//0+ A*5; 2'G.R K;0
0W/.+2*'+ 'B 2C,.(‐7.+0 /6.+5.5*'+2 *+ 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(H <C=. 7.C20: . 5(040+:'C2 :0B'(025.5*'+
I@C+02 Y'+_'50V LMMdQR h'(,0 94.:' ;.2 3*3*:6H :027(*=0: 5;0 :025(C75*30 B030( =('C,;5 .='C5 =H 5;0
7.7.' =''4
*+
"'(5;
‐!.250(+
Z(._*6R
<'BB00
=''42
*+
Z(._*6
.+:
9+5*'DC*.
5'')
/6.70
.5
5;0
0W/0+20
'B
(C5;6022 :0B'(025.5*'+ .+: 5;0 :025(C75*'+ 'B +.5C(.6 :*30(2*5HR &.((0+ ?0.+ :027(*=0: 5;0 ,('A5; 'B
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 19/67
N\
Z(._*6*.+ 7'BB00 B.(4*+, *+ ./'7.6H/5*7 50(42R jK;C2 7'BB00 4.(7;0: .7('22 5;0 ;*,;6.+:2V ,0+0(.5*'+ =H
,0+0(.5*'+V 60.3*+, +'5;*+, *+ *52 A.)0 =C5 :0+C:0: ;*662k I?0.+V N\NQR X5 *2 *+50(025*+, 5' :(.A .550+5*'+
5' 5;0 0W5(040 7'+5(.25 'B 5;*2 :027(*/5*'+ A*5; 5;0 GC=*6.+5 0W76.4.5*'+2 'B 5;0 7'+504/'(.(H
2C//'(50(2 'B 5;*2 )*+: 'B :0306'/40+5R
95 5;0 2.40 5*40V A0 2;'C6: (0.6*_0 5;.5 :0B'(025.5*'+ A.2 +'5 '+6H 5;0 (02C65 'B 6.(,0‐27.60V 0W/'(5‐
'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0R 14.66‐27.60 /0.2.+52 *+ B('+5*0( _'+02 6.(,06H :0/0+:0: '+ /(*4*5*30 B'(42 'B 26.2;
.+: =C(+ .,(*7C65C(0V A;*7; *+ 5;0 6'+, (C+ A.2 .62' 7'+:C7*30 5' 5;0 :*2.//0.(.+70 'B A'': 6.+:2R
Z(.*6'32)H .+: @',C064.+ IN^^N> NPe‐\dQ :(.A .550+5*'+ 5' 5;0 :025(C75*30 7'+20DC0+702 'B 2;.(0‐
7('//*+,V (0+5 .+: 504/'(.6 A'()0(2 *+ 5;0 9(,0+5*+0 *+50(*'(R 977'(:*+, 5' 5;04V 5;020 4':062 :*: +'5
,0+0(.50 . 760.( *+50(025 *+ 2C25.*+.=60 B'(42 'B 6.+: C20R K;0H .62' 2C,,025 5;.5 !C('/0.+ *44*,(.+5
B.(40(2 ,.30 .+ *4/'(5.+5 *4/C620 .5 /(.75*702 'B (0B'(025.5*'+ I/RN\`QR K;0*( 04/;.2*2 '+ 5;0
*4/'(5.+70 'B 6'7.6 .,(*7C65C(.6 /(.75*702 .+: 5;0*( *4/'(5.+70 B'( 2C25.*+.=60 B'(42 'B .,(.(*.+
/(':C75*'+ *2 30(H *+50(025*+,V =C5 *+ ,0+0(.6 5;0*( 3*0A2 .//0.( 5'' 2*4/6*25*7R YC7; :0/0+:0: '+ 5;0
2'7*.6 .+: /'6*5*7.6 7'+50W5 'B 5;020 2H25042 'B 6.='C( .+: 6.+:‐C20R &;0(0 2;.(0‐7('//*+, A.2
04=0::0: *+
25('+,
76*0+506*25
(06.5*'+2
'(
0+G'H0:
60,.6
/('5075*'+V
*5
7'C6:
=0
. 2H2504
A*5;
. 6'+,
‐
50(4 ;'(*_'+V +'5 4C7; :*BB0(0+5 B('4 4'(0 25.=60 2H25042 'B .,(*7C65C(0R
X+B(.25(C75C(.6 :0306'/40+5 .+: 02/07*.66H 5;0 (.*6('.: 0W50+:0: 5;0 (.+,0 'B /'50+5*.6 :0B'(025.5*'+R
X+ 5;0 B*(25 /6.70V 5;0H .66'A0: 6.(,0‐27.60 .,(*7C65C(0 *+ /6.702 5;.5 ;.: =00+ 5'' (04'50 5' 0W/6'*5R
E.*6('.:2V B'( 5;0 B*(25 5*40V ,.30 :0/0+:.=60 .+: B.25 .77022 5' 5;0 4'25 :00/6H 0+5(0+7;0: B('+5*0(
.(0.2 .+: .66'A0: 6.(,0‐27.60V 4.()05‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0 5' 0W/.+: *+5' 8.5*+ 940(*7.g2 *+50(*'(R
107'+:6HV 5(.*+2 5;04206302 A0(0 :0/0+:0+5 '+ B*(0A'':V =C5 4'(0 *4/'(5.+56HV (.*6('.:2 .66'A0: 5;0
5(.+2/'(5.5*'+ 'B A'': B('4 B.(‐.A.H /6.702R 92 6'+, .2 .64'25 .66 0+0(,H B'( :.*6H C20 A.2 /('3*:0: =H
A'':V :0B'(025.5*'+ A.2 C+25'//.=60R -'22*=6H *+B6C0+70: =H ;*2 /022*4*25*7 3*0A2 '+ 5;0
0+3*('+40+5.6 :025(C75*'+
7.C20:
=H
4':0(+*_.5*'+V
?0.+
/(020+52
2'40
*4/(022*30
025*4.502
.='C5
5;0 :0B'(025.5*'+ *+ Z(._*6R J0 7.67C6.502 5;.5 . 7*5H 6*)0 E*' :0 h.+0*(' 7'+2C40: .5 60.25 LPMRMMM 5'+
'B B*(0A'': 030(H H0.( *+ 5;0 N\\M2 I.64'25 LMx /('3*:0: =H 4.+,('302QR @'( 5;0 7'+25(C75*'+ 'B .
24.66 =(*7) ;'C20 `P 5'+2 'B B*(0A'': 4.H ;.30 =00+ +00:0:R K;*2 A'C6: 40.+ 5;.5 5;0 =C*6:*+, 'B
5;0 7*5H 'B E*' :0 h.+0*(' =H N\^M 7'25 5;0 :0B'(025.5*'+ 'B LMM 2DC.(0 )*6'4050(2 I?0.+V N^^e> N^O‐
PQR J0 4.H ;.30 '30(25.50: ;*2 7.20 .+: 0W.,,0(.50: 5;0 *4/'(5.+70 'B A'': .2 5;0 /(*+7*/60 2'C(70
'B 0+0(,H B'( Z(._*6g2 C(=.+ ,('A5; IZ(.++25('4V LMMeQV =C5 5;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 5;0 (060+56022
/(',(022 /('4'50: =H 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 7.40 .5 5;0 7'25 'B (./*: :0B'(025.5*'+R
$B 7'C(20V 5;020 B*,C(02 .(0 25*66 (06.5*306H *+2*,+*B*7.+5 *+ 5;0 7'+50W5 'B 5;0 +.5C(.6 (020(302 'B 5;0
7'C+5(H .+:
/.(5
'B
5;020
B'(0252
(07C/0(.50:
.B50(
. A;*60V
=C5
5;0H
2;'A
5;0
,0+0(.6
7'+50W5
'B
7;.+,0 *+ 4'25 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02R 9/.(5 B('4 (./*: 07'+'4*7 ,('A5;V 5;020 7'+20DC0+702
A0(0 5A'B'6:R $+ 5;0 '+0 ;.+:V =07.C20 'B 5;0 ,(0.5 :04.+: B'( 6.='C( 5;0H 7;.+,0: 2'7*.6
(06.5*'+2 *+ 5;0 (C(.6 .(0.2R K;0 :04.+: B'( (C(.6 6.='C( 25.(50: 5' C+:0(4*+0 /0.2.+5 2'7*05*02 .+:
7(0.50: 030( 6.(,0( ,('C/2 'B (C(.6 A'()0(2R &;0(0 6.='C( A.2 27.(70V *44*,(.+52 0+50(0: 5;0 4'25
:H+.4*7 .,(*7C65C(.6 (0,*'+2 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.V 2'405*402 5;04206302 =07'4*+, *+25(C40+5.6 *+
0W/.+:*+, 5;0 .,(*7C65C(.6 B('+5*0(R X+ 5;*2 /('7022V 0W*25*+, (C(.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 A0(0 B006*+, 5;0 2'7*.6
.+: 07'+'4*7 /(022C(0 5;(0.50+*+, 5;0*( 2'7*05*02R &;0+ 5;0*( .77022 5' 6.+: A.2 5;(0.50+0: 5;0H
*+7(0.2*+,6H (02'(50: 5' 3*'60+5 /('50252 .,.*+25 25.50 40.2C(02 .+: .,(*7C65C(.6 0+50(/(*202 5;.5
A0(0 5;(0.50+*+, 5;0*( 0W*250+70R 1'7*.6 C+(025 BC0660: 5;0 *:0. .4'+, 06*502 .+: 25.50 .C5;'(*5*02
5;.5 (0/(022*30
4':062
'B
/(':C75*30
,('A5;
;.:
5'
=0
.:./50:
.+:
5;.5
.650(+.5*30
A.H2
;.:
5'
=0
2'C,;5 5' *+7'(/'(.50 5;0 (C(.6 4.2202 *+ 5;0 /'6*7*02 'B /(',(022R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 20/67
N^
95 5;0 2.40 5*40V *5 =07.40 760.( 5;.5 5;0 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0 7.40 A*5; 5;0 7'25 'B
*+7(0.2*+, :0B'(025.5*'+ .+: 07'6',*7.6 :0,(.:.5*'+R 965;'C,; 25*66 4':025 *+ 20*_0V 5;0 2'7*.6 .+:
07'6',*7.6 7'+20DC0+702 'B 5;0 4':06 =07.40 *+7(0.2*+,6H 3*2*=60 5' 2'40 2075'(2 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
2'7*05HR 965;'C,; 0W/'(5 .,(*7C65C(0 .+: 5;0 *+7*/*0+5 4*+*+, 2075'(V =07.C20 'B 5;0*( /;H2*7.6
:*25.+70V A0(0 'B50+ '77C650: 5' 5;0 /C=6*7 0H0V :0B'(025.5*'+ .+: 7'+5.4*+.5*'+ '77C((0: 76'20 5'
5;0 C(=.+
70+50(2
.+:
*+7(0.2*+,6H
7'+B('+50:
C(=.+
06*502
A*5;
5;0
:.()0(
2*:02
'B
/(',(022R
X+
5;0
B*(25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(HV 5;020 7'+20DC0+702 'B 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0V (.*6('.:
7'+25(C75*'+ .+: C(=.+*_.5*'+ =07.40 2' '=3*'C2 5;.5 5;0H 7'C6: +'5 027./0 5;0 .550+5*'+ 'B 06*502
.+: .C5;'(*5*02 .+: 25.(50: 5' /('3')0 +0A :0=.502 '+ 07'+'4*7 ,('A5;V 2'7*.6 7';02*'+ .+: 5;0
*4/'(5.+70 'B +.5C(0 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 2C25.*+.=*6*5HR K;0 ;02*5.+5 .+: 27.(70 3'*702 5;.5
7.C5*'C26H DC025*'+0: 5;0 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50:V C+6*4*50: 0W/.+2*'+*25 4':06 *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5;0 70+5C(H
=07.40 4'(0 3'7.6 .+: ,(.:C.66H 25.(50: 5' .(5*7C6.50 .650(+.5*30 *:0.2 .+: 4':062R
M8 N"..-+,"+$ H#")-.
K;0
B.4'C2
-C0(5'‐
E*7.+
0:C7.5'(V
!C,0+*'
Y.(*.
:0
J'25'2V
A;'
6*30:
*+
5;0
?'4*+*7.+
E0/C=6*7
*+
5;0 N\\M2V ;.: 5;0 '//'(5C+*5H 5' A*5+022 5;0 7'+25(C75*'+ 'B 5;0 ?'4*+*7.+ (.*6('.:V 5;0 ;0(.6: 'B
/(',(022 B'( 5;0 06*502 *+ 5;0 +'(5;0(+ (0,*'+ 7.660: 5;0 <*=.'R J0 A.2 200+ =H 4.+H .2 . 760.(
/('/'+0+5 'B 5;0 4':0(+*_*+, *:0.2 :*27C220: .='30 I200> ?03i2 %.6:i2V LMMM> NOQV =C5 *5 *2 760.( 5;.5
5;*2 0W/0(*0+70 :*: +'5 60.: 5' C+.4=*,C'C2 .//('3.6s
jl!n+ 0B075'V 7.5b25('B0 :0 6. =.(=.(*0 02 6. ./.(*7*S+ :0 6. 6'7'4'5'(. 0+ 7C.6DC*0( /.(50R Z*0+
6' ;.+ 2.=*:' 6'2 DC0 2.63.G040+50 20 ;.+ '/C025' 0+ 06 <*=.' .6 /.2' :06 B0(('7.((*6R Z*0+ 6'
;.+ 2.=*:'V /'(DC0 6. 6'7'4'5'(. .7.=.(b 7'+ 066'2R X 7'4' 7'+ 066'2V 7'+ 5.+5.2 7'2.2 .7.=.(b
6. 6'7'4'5'(.V DC0V 0+ (0.6*:.:V 4.2 DC0 *+:*,+.7*S+ :0=0 7.C2.( .2'4=(' * ;.25. *+50(i2
/*.:'2'V 6.
BC0(_.
:0
(02*250+7*.
* 06
*+25*+5'
:0
7'+20(3.7*S+
DC0
;.
:04'25(.:'
6.
=.(=.(*0kR
I?2 @'&-#A'1*V L\‐\‐N\\Pa 7*50: *+ Z.C:V N^^`> edQR
K;*2 DC'50 *2 *+50(025*+, =07.C20 *5 2;'A2 5;.5V .65;'C,; ;0,04'+*7V 5;0 *:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 +030(
A0+5 C+7'+50250:R K;0H (.*20: :'C=52 .+: C+70(5.*+5*02 *+ :*BB0(0+5 2075'(2 'B 2'7*05H .+: '(*,*+.5*+,
B('4 :*BB0(0+5 /0(2/075*302R 966 B'(42 'B 2'7*.6 .+: 07'+'4*7 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+2 7(0.50 A*++0(2 .+: 6'20(2
.+: *+03*5.=6HV 5;0*( /0(70/5*'+2 'B 5;020 7;.+,02 3.(HR
X+ 5;0 B'(0,'*+,V X ;.30 5(*0: 5' 2;'A ;'A 5;0 *:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 A0(0 ;0,04'+*7 *+ 5;0 /0(*': .B50(
N\PMR K;0H *4/6*0: . :'C=60 .+: 7'++0750: 3*0A 'B 5;0 A'(6:> X5 A.2 .+ 0W/.+2*'+*25 3*0A 5;.5 *4/6*0:
5;0 7'6'+*_.5*'+ ='5; 'B 5;0 ;C4.+ .+: 5;0 +.5C(.6 A'(6:R X5 .62' (0B60750: .+ '=2022*30 .+: *+2.5*.=60
3*0A 'B 5;0 A'(6: A;*7; 2.A 8.5*+ 940(*7. .2 .+ *+B*+*50 2'C(70 'B +.5C(.6 (02'C(702 .+:V 5;C2V
07'+'4*7 A0.65;R K;*2 3*2*'+ A.2 25*4C6.50: =H 5;0 B.75 5;.5 8.5*+ 940(*7. A.2 . 3.25 .+: (06.5*306H
C+:0(/'/C6.50: 7'+5*+0+5 A*5; 6.(,0V C+5.//0: 6.+: .+: 4*+*+, (02'C(702R
95 5;0 2.40 5*40V C+:0( .+: A*5;*+ 5;*2 ,0+0(.6 7'+20+2C2V 4.+H 7'+5(.252V 7'+B6*752V .4=*,C*5*02V .+:
7'+5(.:*75*'+2 0W*250:R -(',(022V '(:0( .+: *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 4.2202 'B 5;0 /'/C6.5*'+ A0(0
,0+0(.66H 2;.(0: ,'.62V =C5 A;.5 5;020 ,'.62 40.+5 .+: ;'A 5;0H A0(0 5' (0.7;0: A.2 6022 760.(R 8.(,0‐
27.60 .,(*7C65C(0 .+: *+:C25(*.6*_.5*'+ A0(0 2*,+2 'B /(',(022V =C5 5;0H (0DC*(0: 4*,(.5*'+ .+: 60: 5'
6.(,0 .,,6'40(.5*'+2 'B I/(0:'4*+.+56H 4.60Q A'()0(2R K;*2 60: 5' 5;0 :*2*+50,(.5*'+ 'B 0W*25*+, B'(42 'B
6.='C( 7'+5('6 .+: 5;(0.50+0: 5;0 /.50(+.6*25 7'+5('6 'B 5(.:*5*'+.6 6.+:6'(:2V A;' 7.40 5' =0
:0/(07*.5*306H 7.660: $#"*'- =H 5;0 0.(6H LM5; 70+5C(H 6*=0(.6 9+:0.+ 4':0(+*_0(2R K;0 4'(.6 .+:
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 21/67
LM
2'7*.6 5;(0.5 /(020+50: =H 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 4':0(+*_.5*'+ A.2 .62' B065 =H 5;0 <.5;'6*7 <;C(7; /0(70*30:
=H 8*=0(.6 (0B'(40(2 .2 .+ .+5*‐4':0(+ B'(70V =07.C20 'B *52 C+/(':C75*30 6.+:0: /('/0(5*02 I"#&*-
"+'1,#-B .+: *52 +C40('C2 (06*,*'C2 ;'6*:.H2V A;*7; )0/5 A'()0(2 .+: /0.2.+52 .A.H B('4 /(':C75*30
A'()R X+ ,0+0(.6V 5;0 <;C(7; /C(2C0: :*BB0(0+5V 4'(0 2/*(*5C.6 .+: 6022 4.50(*.6*25V 3.6C02 .+: *5 7'C6: =0
2.*: 5;.5V *+ 5;*2 A.HV *5 /(020+50: 5;0 '+6H 25(C75C(.6 .650(+.5*30 5' 5;0 *:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022R X+ 5;0 LM5;
70+5C(HV 5;*2
7'C6:
.62'
60.:
5'
(06*,*'C26H
*+2/*(0:
:*27'C(202
'+
5;0
2/*(*5C.6
3.6C0
'B
+.5C(0
.+:
5;0
+00: 5' /('5075 5;0 0+3*('+40+5 B('4 *+:*27(*4*+.50 0W/6'*5.5*'+R
9+'5;0( ,('C/ 5;.5 ;02*5.50: .='C5 5;0 =0+0B*52 'B /(',(022 7'+2*250: 'B 2075'(2 'B 5;0 7'+20(3.5*302V
7'++0750: 5' 5;0 <;C(7;V =07.C20 5;0H .62' :*(0756H B065 5;0 5;(0.5 'B 2'7*05Hg2 :*22'6C5*'+R K;0
B'C+:.5*'+2 'B 5;0*( /'A0( .+: 5;0 206B ‐03*:0+70 'B 5;0*( /.5(*.(7;.6 (06.5*'+2 A*5; 5;0 /0.2.+5
/'/C6.5*'+ A0(0 5;(0.50+0:R X+ 5;0 6.550( /.(5 'B 5;0 70+5C(HV 5;020 /0(70/5*'+2 'B 6'22 'B50+ 7'++0750:
5' .+ *+7*/*0+5 7C65C(.6 +.5*'+.6*24 5;.5 A'C6: B*+: *52 _0+*5; *+ C1%'2 V A(*550+ =H 5;0 F(C,C.H.+
*+5066075C.6V h'2i !+(*DC0 E'2SR K;*2 *2 +'5 5' 2.H 5;.5 4'25 .(*06*25.2 '(*,*+.50: *+ 7'+20(3.5*30 7*(7602V '(
5;.5 .(*06*24' A.2 =.2*7.66H .+ .+5*‐4':0(+ *:0'6',HV =C5 5;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 *5 5(*0: 5' B*+: .+2A0(2
5' 5;0
4.+H
DC025*'+2
.2)0:
=H
5;0
5(.+2B'(4.5*'+
'B
8.5*+
940(*7.+
2'7*05*02R
X+
<0+5(.6
940(*7.V
2/*(*5C.6*25 *:0.2 7'+5(.:*750: .+: 'B50+ '//'20: 5;0 /(03.*6*+, 4.50(*.6*25 (.7*24R K;020 *:0.2 A0(0
'B50+ *+B6C0+70: =H 5;0 *:0.2 'B E':S .+: 7.+ =0 200+ .2 .+ .5504/5 5' 7'+25(C0 . 2/07*B*7 8.5*+
940(*7.+ 2/*(*5C.6*24 I<.2.q2 9(_CV #.(7c. #*(b6:02V LMMeQR
@*+.66HV .6(0.:H *+ 5;*2 2.40 /0(*':V 24.660( ,('C/2 'B 7(*5*7.6 *+5066075C.62 .+: /'6*5*7*.+2 25.(50: 5'
7(*5*7*_0 5;0 2'7*.6 7'+:*5*'+2 .+: 2'7*.6 .+: 05;+*7 *+0DC.6*5H *+;0(0+5 5' 5;0 4':0(+*_.5*'+ /('7022R
1'40 A0(0 *+2/*(0: =H *+7*/*0+5 2'7*.6*24 =C5 '5;0(2 GC25 (0.6*_0: 5;.5 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 7.40 .5 5;0 7'25
'B 5;0 6*3*+, 7'+:*5*'+2 'B /0.2.+52 .+: A'()0(2V 02/07*.66H *+:*,0+'C2 '+02R $B50+V 5;0H .(0 5.)0+
5',05;0( C+:0( 5;0 50(4 %&(%$'&%-"*R Y.+H 'B 5;0 *+:*,0+*25.2 A0(0 25*66 *+B6C0+70: =H (.7*.6*_0: '(
0C,0+*25*7 *:0.2
:*(0750:
5'A.(:2
f7*3*6*_*+,g
5;0
X+:*.+2V
=C5
*5 7.++'5
=0
:0+*0:
5;.5
5;0*(
*:0.2
4.:0
.
:*BB0(0+70 *+ 7;.+,*+, 5;0 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 60,.6 /0(2/075*302 5'A.(:2 5;0 +.5*'+ .+: 5;0 /6.70 'B
*+:*,0+'C2 /'/C6.5*'+2 *+ *5R K;0 *+:*,0+*25. 4'3040+5 7(0.50: *4.,02 .+: (0/(020+5.5*'+2 'B 5;0
*+:*,0+'C2 A'(6: A;*7; :*: +'5 '+6H ;.30 /'6*5*7.6 .+: 60,.6 7'+20DC0+702 *+ 5;0 /0(*': 7'+70(+0: =C5
;.2 .62' ;.: ,(0.5 *+B6C0+70 '+ LM5; 70+5C(H .+5;('/'6',H .+:V 4'(0 *+ ,0+0(.6V '+ /(020+5‐:.H
/0(2/075*302 '+ 5;0 *+:*,0+'C2 A'(6: IZ.C:V LMMOQR
K;0 :*BB0(0+702 .+: 7'+5(.:*75*'+2 /(020+50: =H 5;020 ,('C/2 .62' *+B6C0+70: 5;0*( /0(70/5*'+2 'B 5;0
0+3*('+40+5.6 7'+20DC0+702 'B 4':0(+*5HR K;020 +0A /0(70/5*'+2 7'C6: =0 200+ .5 :*BB0(0+5 603062R $B
7'C(20V 5;0H A0(0 3*2*=60 *+ 5;0 :0=.502 =05A00+ /'6*5*7.6 '//'+0+52 A;' :*: .66 5;0H 7'C6: 5'
:04'+25(.50 5;.5
5;0*(
*:0.
'B
/(',(022
.+:
2'7*05.6
7;.+,0
A.2
7'4/60506H
:*BB0(0+5
B('4
5;'20
'B
5;0*( '//'+0+52R $B50+ 5;020 7'+B6*752 '(*,*+.50: *+ :*BB0(0+5 07'+'4*7 '( /'6*5*7.6 *+50(0252 .+: 7'C6:
=0 200+ .2 40(0 A*+:'A‐:(022*+, B'( 2*4/60 *+B*,;5*+,R
$6: .+: +0A 06*502 B'C,;5 B'( 5;0*( *+50(0252 =H 5;0 '//'(5C+*25*7 C20 'B +0A .(,C40+52R X+ '5;0( 7.202V
;'A030(V 5;0H A0(0 7.C20: =H 5;0 25('+, (0,*'+.6 :*BB0(0+702 *+ 4'25 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02R 8'7.6
06*502 *+ 5;0 *+50(*'( 'B50+ :*: +'5 ;.30 4C7; *+B6C0+70 '+ 5;0 *:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 .+: :07*2*'+2 5.)0+
*+ 5;0 7./*5.6 7*5*02 .+: =H B'(0*,+ 7'4/.+*02R K;0H 0W/0(*0+70: 5;0 7'+20DC0+702 'B 5;020 /('702202 'B
5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ A*5;'C5 =0*+, .=60 5' :' 4C7;R X+ ;*2 25C:H 'B 5;0 Z(._*6*.+ 94._'+V 150/;0+ ZC+)0(
IN^\e> LeM‐eLQ 2C,,0252 5;.5 5;*2 4.(,*+.6*_.5*'+ 'B 6'7.6 2'7*05*02 .+: 5;0*( 06*502 7'C6: A066 =0 '+0 'B
5;0 4.*+
B.75'(2
'B
5;0
0+3*('+40+5.6
:025(C75*'+
=('C,;5
.='C5
=H
5;*2
4':06
'B
07'+'4*7
,('A5;R
K;0(0 *2 +' ,C.(.+500 5;.5 6'7.6 /'/C6.5*'+2 =0550( /('5075 5;0 0+3*('+40+5 .,.*+25 '30(0W/6'*5.5*'+V
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 22/67
LN
=C5 6'7.6 7'+5('6 4.H A066 =0 *52 +07022.(H 7'+:*5*'+R K;0 Z'6*3*.+ 4*+*+, 2075'( 4.H =0 .+'5;0(
0W.4/60R X+:*27(*4*+.50 0W5(.75*'+ .+: *+0BB*7*0+5 4.+.,040+5 60: 5' A*:02/(0.: 07'6',*7.6
:025(C75*'+V 5;0 0W;.C25*'+ 'B 4*+02 .+: +0A B'(42 'B /'30(5HV A*5;'C5 6'7.6 '(,.+*_.5*'+2 =0*+, .=60
5' 7'C+50( 5;.5 /('7022R Y.(5c+0_ 96*0( IN^^M> Nd`Q 7'+76C:02> jC+. 07'+'4c. 0W5(.75*3. /(':C70
6'7.640+50 /'=(0_.V H . 2C 30_ B.65. :0 /':0( /'6c5*7'V H /'( 5.+5' *+7./.7*:.: /.(. B(0+.( 6. 0W5(.77*S+
' /'+0(
C+
/(07*'
4b2
.65'
. 6'2
(07C(2'2
0W5(.*:'2kR
K;*2
2;'A2
;'A
:*BB0(0+5
/'2*5*'+2
'B
76.22
.+:
,0',(./;H *+ 5;0 0+: .62' *+B6C0+70: 5;0 *:0'6',*02 'B /(',(022 .+: 2C25.*+.=*6*5HR X+ 24.66 .+:
/0(*/;0(.6 (C(.6 5'A+2V 5;0 ;*,;‐25(C+, *:0.62 'B /(',(022 .+: 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 'B50+ 60: 5' B(C25(.5*'+V
2'7*.6 25(C,,60 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 :025(C75*'+R X+ 5;0 0+:V 5;*2 'B50+ 60: 5' 6'7.6*_0: '( (0,*'+.6
*:0'6',*02 A;*7; 030+5C.66H A'C6: 60.: 5' ='5; *+:*,0+*25. *:0.2 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 7;.C3*+*24R
X+ ,0+0(.6V +.5*'+.6*25 *:0.62 A0(0 +'5 .6A.H2 0.2*6H 7'4/.5*=60 A*5; .+ *+7(0.2*+, *+50,(.5*'+ *+ 5;0
A'(6: 4.()05R K;0 *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B 5;0 (C(.6 4.2202 *+ 5;0 +.5*'+ .+: 5;0*( *+50,(.5*'+ *+ 5;0 0W/'(5
07'+'4H 60: 5' C+:02*(.=60 7'+20DC0+702 .2 4*,(.5*'+V C(=.+*_.5*'+V 6'22 'B 2'7*.6 7';02*'+ .+: +0A
B'(42 'B A'()0(2 4'=*6*_.5*'+R K;0 :025(C75*'+ 'B B'(025 (02'C(702 .+: 5;0 7'+20DC0+702 'B
507;+'6',*7.6
*++'3.5*'+
6*)0
(.*6('.:2
'(
507;+'6',*7.6
2'/;*25*7.50:
2C,.(
4*662V
5;(0.50+0:
'6:
/'2*5*'+2 'B 07'+'4*7 .+: /'6*5*7.6 /'A0( .+: 7(0.50: 7C65C(.6 .+: 2'7*.6 +'25.6,*.2 6.40+5*+, 5;0 6'22
'B .+ '6:0(V ('4.+5*7*_0: '(:0(R X+ ;*2 25C:H '+ Z(._*6V ?0.+ IN^^e> LNLQ '=20(302V 4.H=0 7'+70:*+, 5'
26*,;56H A*2;BC6 5;*+)*+,V 5;.5 .6(0.:H *+ 5;0 6.50 N^5; 70+5C(H f4'25 *+50(025*+,6HV .4'+, 2*,+*B*7.+5
+C4=0( 'B 5;0 06*50 . 7'+27*'C2+022 2/(0.: .+: :00/0+0: 5;.5 ,0+0(.5*'+2 'B A.250 ;.: 5' =0 =('C,;5
5' .+ 0+: .+: 5;.5 (02'C(702 'B B'(025 .+: 2'*6 ;.: 5' =0 04/6'H0: 4'(0 0BB*7*0+56H .+: 7'+20(30: B'(
5;0 ,0+0(.6 ,'':kR K;0 /('4*+0+5 <C=.+ ='5.+*25 hC.+ K'4b2 E'*, A.2 .//.660: *+ N^N\ =H 5;0
f0W5(0406H (./*: :*2.//0.(.+70 'B 5;'20 4.,+*B*70+5 B'(0252 5;.5 /(03*'C26H 7'C6: =0 200+ *+ .66
:*(075*'+2g .2 . (02C65 'B 5;0 <C=.+ 2C,.( /6.+5.5*'+2 I@C+02 Y'+_'50V LMMd> NOOQR
$+ . =('.:0(
60306V
A0
7.+
200
;'A
:*BB0(0+702
*+
5;0
/0(70/5*'+
'B
5;0
5A'B'6:
'=G075*30
'B
2'7*.6
7'+5('6 .+: 07'+'4*7 0W/.+2*'+ 25.(50: 5' 040(,0R X+ ,0+0(.6 50(42V *5 7'C6: =0 2.*: 5;.5 .B50( 5;0 B*(25
25.,0 'B (.A 07'+'4*7 0W/.+2*'+ *+ 5;0 6.25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 N^5; 70+5C(HV . 4'(0 +C.+70:V 7'4/60W .+:
:*BB0(0+5*.50: 205 'B *:0.2 '+ 5;0 (06.5*'+ =05A00+ /(',(022V 2'7*05H .+: 0+3*('+40+5 :0306'/0:R K;*2 *2
5;0 /0(*': A;0(0 *+:*,0+*25. *:0.62 BC(5;0( :0306'/0: *+ 9+:0.+ .+: <0+5('‐940(*7.+ 7'C+5(*02 .+: .
B'6)6'(*25 4'3040+5 040(,0: *+ 7'C+5(*02 6*)0 9(,0+5*+. .+: Y0W*7' I<;.4'2.V LMNMQR K;*2 *2 .62' 5;0
/0(*': *+ A;*7; 5;0 *+B6C0+70 'B E':S 4.5C(0: .+: 60: 5' . 7'+20(3.5*30 .+: 5' . 70(5.*+ 0W50+5 +.5*3*25
7C65C(.6 +.5*'+.6*24 5;.5 A.2 7(*5*7.6 'B 5;0 B'(0*,+ *+B6C0+702 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. .+: A.+50: 5' ,' =.7) 5'
5;0 (''52 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 7C65C(0R 1*4C65.+0'C26HV ;'40‐4.:0 2'7*.6*242 040(,0: *+ A;*7; 2'7*.6*25
*+2/*(0: .C5;'(2 6*)0 h'2i Y.(5* '( Y.(*b50,C* '( 030+ J.H. :0 6. K'((0 5(*0: 5' .:./5 2'7*.6*25 *:0.62 5'
5;0 2/07*B*7
2*5C.5*'+
*+
8.5*+
940(*7.R
@*+.66HV
5;*2
A.2
.62'
5;0
/0(*':
*+
A;*7;V
30(H
7.C5*'C26H
.+:
B*660:
A*5; 7'+5(.:*75*'+2V .+ 0+3*('+40+5.6 4'3040+5 25.(50: 5' 040(,0V B*(25 *5 20042 *+ Z(._*6 I9+:(.:0
@(.+7' p?(C44'+:V LMM^QV =C5 ,(.:C.66H .62' *+ '5;0( /6.702 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.R Y.*+6H C+:0( 5;0
*+B6C0+70 'B 0+,.,0: 27*0+5*252 A;'V B('4 5;0*( (02/075*30 :*27*/6*+02 *+3025*,.50: 5;0 8.5*+ 940(*7.+
0+3*('+40+5V +0A *:0.2 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 /('5075*'+ 25.(50: 5' 5.)0 ;'6:R #(.:C.66HV 5;0*( *:0.2 25.(50:
5' *+B6C0+70 /'6*5*7*.+2V A;'V 'B50+ *+2/*(0: =H +.5*'+.6*25 *:0.2V 25.(50: 5' /('/'20 6.A2 .+: (0,C6.5*'+2
,0.(0: 5'A.(:2 5;0 /('5075*'+ 'B B'(0252 .+: +.5C(.6 (020(302R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 23/67
LL
O8 5#+)*7."#+
K;*2 .(5*760 ;.2 5(*0: 5' 2;'A ;'A *:0.2 '+ 5;0 2'7*.6 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 5(.+2B'(4.5*'+ 'B 8.5*+
940(*7. A0+5 ;.+: *+ ;.+:R K;0H A0(0 /.(5 'B . ;0,04'+*7 /('G075 ,0.(0: 5'A.(:2 5;0 *+7(0.20 *+
/(':C75*30 7./.7*5H *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. .+:V *+ 5;*2 A.HV 07'+'4*7 ,('A5;R K' (0.7; 5;.5 ,'.6V 5;0 5A'
4'25
*4/'(5.+5
/(':C75*30
B'(702
'B
5;0
6.(,06H
/(0‐
507;+'6',*7.6
07'+'4HV
6.='C(
.+:
6.+:
+00:0:
5'
=0 =('C,;5 C+:0( 7'+5('6R 80,*5*4.50: =H 5;0 2'7*.6‐:.(A*+*25 .+: /'2*5*3*25 *:0.2 'B 5;0 /0(*':V 8.5*+
940(*7.+ 06*502 5(*0: B'(70BC66H 5' *+7'(/'(.50 5;0 I*+:*,0+'C2Q /0.2.+5 /'/C6.5*'+ *+ 5;0*( ,(.+:*'20
/('G075 'B /(',(022R 95 5;0 2.40 5*40V 5;0H 5(*0: 5' 0W50+: 25.50 /'A0( 5' 5;0 /0(*/;0(.6 (0,*'+2 'B 5;0*(
7'C+5(*02 .+: 4.)0 5;04 .77022*=60 5' /(':C75*30 .75*3*5*02V 4.*+6H 0W/'(5‐'(*0+50: .,(*7C65C(0R X+
,0+0(.6 50(42V 5;*2 60: 5' . 7'+B6C0+70 'B /0(70/5*'+2 'B (.70 .+: 76.22 '+ 5;0 '+0 ;.+:V .+: 'B +.5C(.6
(02'C(702 .+: 0+3*('+40+5V '+ 5;0 '5;0(R Z'5; ;.: 5' =0 2C='(:*+.50: 5' 5;0 ,'.6 'B /(',(022R
X+ 5;*2 ;0,04'+*7 /('G075 'B 4':0(+*_.5*'+ .+: /(',(022V 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 06*502 B065 76'206H (06.50: 5' 5;0
B.25 :0306'/*+, A'(6:2 *+ !C('/0 .+:V 5' . 60220( 0W50+5V *+ 5;0 F+*50: 15.502R K;0H A.+50: 5' 04C6.50
5;.5
4':06V
=C5
)+0A
5;.5
*5
A'C6:
=0
:*BB*7C65
5'
B*+:
2'6C5*'+2
5'
5;0
2/07*B*7
/('=6042
'B
8.5*+
940(*7.V 02/07*.66H 5;0 .(7;.*7V 1+,%%# /0.2.+5 /'/C6.5*'+2 .+: 5;0 6.7) 'B *+B(.25(C75C(0 .+:
*+25*5C5*'+2R K;*2 7(0.50: 0+3H .+: *4/.5*0+70 .+: 2'405*402 /022*4*24 .='C5 5;0 (0,*'+g2 2'7*.6 .+:
07'+'4*7 A0.)+02202 .+: *52 2*7)6H +.5C(0R K;*2 /022*4*24 A.2 7'4/0+2.50: =H ,(.+:*'20 /6.+2 .+: .+
0W5(040 5(C25 *+ 5;0 4.660.=*6*5H 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 2'7*05HR K;0 /'/C6.(*5H 'B /'2*5*3*24 *+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.
4.H A066 =0 5;0 4'25 0W5(040 2H4='6 'B 5;020 .4=*,C'C2 .+: 'B50+ 7'+5(.:*75'(H .4=*5*'+2 5'A.(:2
/(',(022 .+: 4':0(+*_.5*'+R
X+ . 70(5.*+ A.HV 5;*2 /022*4*24 4.H =0 200+ .2 5;0 B*(25 ;0(.6:2 'B 7;.+,*+, /0(70/5*'+2 .+: *:0.2R
K;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5V .:4*550:6H A0.)V :*220+5*+, 3'*702 .6A.H2 0W*250: .+: 5;.5 .6(0.:H *+ 5;0 6.25
:07.:02 'B
5;0
N^
5;
70+5C(HV
.4*:25
5;0
760.(
;0,04'+H
'B
4':0(+*25
*:0'6',*02V
.650(+.5*30
3*0A2
.+:
7'C+50(3'*702 040(,0:R X+ 5;*2 20+20V 5;0 /0(*': N\PM‐N^NM A.2 7(C7*.6 B'( 5;0 :0306'/40+5 'B
0+3*('+40+5.6 5;*+)*+, *+ LM5; 70+5C(H 8.5*+ 940(*7.R Y'25 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ 07'+'4*02 2;'A0: (./*:
,('A5; *+ 5;*2 /0(*':V .+: C(=.+ 06*502 0W/0(*0+70: 6*3*+, 7*(7C425.+702 5;.5 A0(0 C+*4.,*+.=60 '+6H .
B0A :07.:02 0.(6*0(R ZC5V .5 5;0 2.40 5*40V 5;0 :'A+2*:0 'B 5;*2 (.:*7.6V 0W5(.75*3*25 4':06 'B
.77C4C6.5*'+ ,(.:C.66H .62' =07.40 3*2*=60R EC(.6 2'7*05H 6'25 *52 206B ‐03*:0+5 7';0(0+70 .+: ;*0(.(7;H
.+: 7'+B6*752 'B *+50(025 =05A00+ '6: .+: +0A 06*502 60: 5' 7*3*6 25(*B0R Y'25 *4/'(5.+56HV 5;0 :025(C75*'+
.+: 5;0 :(.4.5*7 7;.+,02 A;*7; A0(0 /.(5 .+: /.(706 'B 6.(,0 27.60 0W/'(5‐.,(*7C65C(0 =07.40
.//.(0+5R K;0H 60: 5' 0+3*('+40+5.6 :025(C75*'+V =C5 .62' 5' 2'7*.6 (02*25.+70R EC(.6 /('5025 4'3040+52
.,.*+25 B'(70BC6 0W/C62*'+ 'B 6.+: .+: 7'0(70: 6.='C( 7'+:*5*'+2 2A0/5 '30( 5;0 (0,*'+V B('4 5;0
/0.2.+5 B'(702
'B
!4*6*.+'
w./.5.V
5'
5;0
,.3*660('2
*+
5;0
2C,.(
/(':C7*+,
2'C5;
'B
5;0
?'4*+*7.+
E0/C=6*7V 5' 5;0 3*'60+5 6.='C( /('50252 *+ 9(,0+5*+.R X+ 5;0 9+:02V ;*25'(*.+2 030+ 5.6) .='C5 5;0 8%82*
1'6'2(' *+ A;*7; 5;0 2'7*.6 /('5025 .,.*+25 5;0 '+26.C,;5 'B 4':0(+*_.5*'+ 5'') B'(4 .('C+: 5;0 5C(+ 'B
5;0 70+5C(HR X+ 5;020 A.H2V 5;020 2.40 06*502 25.(50: 5' 0W/0(*0+70 *+ 5;0*( 'A+ /0(2'+.6 6*302 5;0 2'7*.6
.+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 /('=6042 .2 5;0 (02C65 'B 4':0(+*_.5*'+R K;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 5;0 +0A *:0.2 '+
2'7*05H .+: 0+3*('+40+5 5;.5 040(,0: *+ 5;*2 /0(*':V A0(0 76'206H 7'++0750: 5'V .+: *+B6C0+70: =H
5;020 /(.75*7.6 .+: 7'+7(050 0W/0(*0+702R X+ 5;0 7.20 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 ;*25'(HV 4C7; A'() 25*66 +00:2 5'
=0 :'+0 5' :027(*=0 .+: .+.6H_0 5;0 7'+7(050 0W/(022*'+2 'B 5;*2 +0A *:0'6',*7.6 5(0+:V =C5 5;0(0 *2 +'
:'C=5 5;.5 4.+H +0A *:0.2 '+ +.5C(0 .+: +.5*'+.6 ;0(*5.,0 040(,0: *+ 5;0 B*(25 :07.:02 'B 5;0 LM5;
70+5C(H IZ(.++25('4V LMMda B'( . =0.C5*BC6 7.20 25C:H> 1.+5*.,'V LMMOQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 24/67
L`
Y':0(+*_.5*'+ 5;0'(*02V 'B 7'C(20V 7'+5*+C0: 5' =0 ;0,04'+*7 :C(*+, 5;0 LM5; 70+5C(H .+: ;.30
/0(2*250: C+5*6 'C( :.H2V =C5 :*220+5*+, 3'*702 .+: 7(*5*7*24 =07.40 4'(0 3'7*B0('C2V .+: .650(+.5*30
*:0.2 '+ 0+3*('+40+5.6 ,'30(+.+70 =07.40 4'(0 3*2*=60R X5 *2 *+50(025*+, 5' +'50 5;.5V GC25 .2 *5
'77C((0: A*5; *+:*,0+*25. *:0.2V +.5*'+.6*24 A.2 5;0 /(*+7*/.6 =''250( 'B 5;0 /('4'5*'+ 'B
0+3*('+40+5.6 /('5075*'+R &;0(0 *+:*,0+*24' 5(*0: 5' =(*+, B'(A.(: .+: /('4'50 5;0 *+7'(/'(.5*'+ 'B
5;0 *+:*,0+'C2
/0.2.+5
/'/C6.5*'+2
*+
5;0
".5*'+V
5;0
*+7*/*0+5
*:0.2
'B
0+3*('+40+5.6
/('5075*'+
A0(0
76'206H 7'++0750: 5' +0A *:0.2 'B +.5*'+.6 ;0(*5.,0 .+: . (0G075*'+ 'B B'(0*,+ *+302540+52 .+:
07'+'4*7 :0/0+:0+7HR Z'5; 50+:0+7*02 =07.40 4'(0 .(5*7C6.50: *+ 5;0 N^NM2 .+: LM2 C+:0( 5;0
*+B6C0+70 'B 5;0 /('702202 :027(*=0: .='30R K;0H B'C+: 5;0*( C65*4.50 60,*5*4.5*'+ A*5; 5;0 A'(6: 7(*2*2
'B N^L^ A;*7; B'(70BC66H :04'+25(.50: 5;0 f/0(*62 'B /(',(022gR X5 *2 +' 7'*+7*:0+70 5;.5 5;0 B*(25 7'+7(050
0+3*('+40+5.6 /'6*7*02 '77C((0: *+ 5;0 N^`M2V A;0+ *+ .66 .(0.2 'B 8.5*+ 940(*7.+ /'6*5*72 .+: 2'7*05H
+.5*'+.6*25 *:0.2 A0(0 ;0,04'+*7R K;0 (06.5*'+2;*/ =05A00+ +.5*'+.6*24 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 *:0'6',*02
*+ 4':0(+ 8.5*+ 940(*7. (0DC*(02 BC(5;0( 25C:HV =C5 5;0(0 *2 +' :'C=5 5;.5 *5 /('3*:02 5;0 )0H 5'
C+:0(25.+: 5;0 (06.5*'+2;*/ =05A00+ 2'7*.6 .+: 0+3*('+40+5.6 /'6*7*02 .+: .2 2C7; A*66 /('3*:0 '+0 'B
5;0 7(C7*.6 06040+52 5' C+:0(25.+: *:0.2 .+: /(.75*702 'B 0+3*('+40+5.6 ,'30(+.+70 *+ 5;0 (0,*'+R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 25/67
Ld
!"0*"#$%&'(2
9+:0(2'+V Z0+0:*75V !"#$%&'( )*""+&%,%'-D E':2'8,%*&- *& ,F' 41%$%& #&( G>1'#( *: H#,%*%-"
I8'+:'+p"0A y'()> %0(2'V N^^NQa dP‐e`R
9+:(.:0 @(.+7'V h'2i 8C*_ :0V h'2i 9C,C25' ?(C44'+:V =1*,'IJ* K H#,+1'L# ' !('&,%(#(' H#8%*
&*
M1#-%2;
#&*-
NOPQ‐
NORQ
IE*'
:0
h.+0*('>
@*'7(C_V
LMM^Q
9(,C0:.2V 967*:02V =+'62* '&:'1"* IN^M^Q I8. -._> !:R hC30+5C:V N^^OQ
Z.C:V Y*7;*06V S%-,*1%# (' +& -+'T*D .*- 7'11*8#11%2'- >U62%8*- '& 2# E'>U62%8# 0*"%&%8#&#; NVVQ‐
NOWQ I1.+5' ?'4*+,'> @C+:.7*S+ <C65C(.6 ?'4*+*7.+.V N^^`Q
Z.C:V Y*7;*06V jX:0'6',c.2 :0 (._. H +.7*S+ 0+ 94i(*7. 8.5*+.V 2*,6'2 zXz H zzkV *+> S%-,*1%# X'&'1#2 ('
C"<1%8# .#,% %'6C40+ Xz> K0'(c. H 405':'6',c. 0+ 6. J*25'(*. :0 94i(*7. 8.5*+.V !2503t' :0
E0_0+:0 Y.(5*+2 .+: Ji75'( -i(0_ Z(*,+'6* I0:2RQV IY.:(*:> !:*7*'+02 F"!1<$ p !:*5'(*.6 K('55.V
LMMOQa //R NPe‐N^dR
Z066V 150/;0+ )#">#&F# X#U8F#D C M1#L%2%#& E#&8F%&$ GY-,'"; NVZQ‐NOPQ I15.+B'(:> 15.+B'(:
F+*30(2*5H -(022V N^^\QR
Z(.:B'(: ZC(+2V
!RV
[F'
=*3'1,Y
*:
=1*$1'--D
.#,%&
C"'1%8#
%&
,F'
H%&',''&,F
)'&,+1Y
IZ0()060H
057R>
F+*30(2*5H 'B <.6*B'(+*. -(022V N^\MQ
Z(.*6'32)HV 9+5'+*' !6*'V ?*+. @',C064.+V @'"*1%# 3'1('D S%-,*1%# '8*2\$%8# (' 2# C1$'&,%&# IZC0+'2
9*(02> !:*5'(*.6 1C:.40(*7.+.V N^^NQ
Z(.++25('4V <;(*25*.+V j&.2 Z(._*6*.+ X+:C25(*.6*2.5*'+ BC0660: =H &'':o !3.6C.5*+, 5;0 &'':
JH/'5;02*2V N^MM‐N^OMkV ?&3%1*&"'&, #&( S%-,*1Y NN ILMMeQa //R `^e‐d`M
Z(.++25('4V <;(*25*.+ I0:RQV ['11%,*1%'-; )*""*(%,%'- #&( ]&*^2'($'-D .#,%& C"'1%8#& ?&3%1*&"'&,#2
S%-,*1%'- %& ,F' H%&',''&,F #&( [^'&,%',F )'&,+1%'- I8'+:'+> X+25*5C50 'B 5;0 940(*7.2V LMMdQ
ZC+)0(V 150/;0+V _&('1('3'2*>%&$ ,F' C"#L*&` ?a,1#8,%*&; _&'b+#2 ?a8F#&$'; #&( ,F' 7#%2+1' *: ,F'
@*('1& G,#,' IF(=.+. H <;*7.,'> F+*30(2*5H 'B X66*+'*2 -(022V N^\eQ
<.(:'2'V <*(' @R1RV Ji75'( -i(0_ Z(*,+'6*V S%-,*1%# '8*&\"%8# (' C"<1%8# .#,%&#c P` ?8*&*"/#- ('
'a>*1,#8%\& Y ('-#11*22* 8#>%,#2%-,# IZ.(706'+.a !:*5'(*.6 <(c5*7.V N^P^Q
<.2.q2 9(_qV Y.(5. !60+. H K0(02. #.(7c. #*(b6:02V .#- 1'('- %&,'2'8,+#2'- 8'&,1*#"'1%8#&#- ̀+& -%$2*
(' %"#$%%*- %*'- dNVPQ‐NOPQB I#C.504.6.> @{# !:*5'(02V LMMeQ
<;.4'2.V $27.(V [F' C1$'&,%&' 7*2e2*1' @*3'"'&,D G+$#1 ?2%,'-; )1%*22* f*1e'1-; #&( ,F' =*2%,%8- *:
)+2,+1#2 H#,%*%-"; NOQQ‐NOZZ IKC72'+> F+*30(2*5H 'B 9(*_'+. -(022V LMNMQ
?. <C+;.V !C76*:02V 4- G'1,5'- IN^MLQD !:*Tt' 7(c5*7. /'( &.6+*70 "',0*(. #.63t'V I1t' -.C6'> !:*5'(.
Z(.2*6*0+20V N^\eQ
?0.+V &.((0+V f%,F M1*#(#a #&( 7%1'61#&(D [F' 0'-,1+8,%*& *: ,F' M1#L%2%#& C,2#&,%8 7*1'-, IZ0()060H
057> F+*30(2*5H
'B
<.6*B'(+*.
-(022V
N^^eQ
?03i2 %.6:i2V !:C.(:'V 0'2 C1%'2 (' E*(\ # 2# (' )?=C. dNOQQ‐NOZQB IZC0+'2 9*(02p 1.+5*.,' :0
<;*60> Z*=6'2p <0+5(' :0 X+3025*,.7*'+02 ?*0,' Z.(('2 9(.+.V LMMMQ
?*.7'+V K':: 9RV G,1%&$%&$ ,*$',F'1 # H#,%*&D )g&(%(* @#1%#&* (# G%23# E*&(*& #&( ,F' )*&-,1+8,%*&
*: # @*('1& M1#L%2; NOQh‐NOWQ I?C(;.4 057> ?C)0 F+*30(2*5H -(022V LMMdQ
?(C44'+:V h'2i 9C,C25'V 0'3#-,#IJ* ' >1'-'13#IJ* #"6%'&,#2 &* E%* (' i#&'%1* I"*50(S*> !:*5'(. :.
F+*30(2*:.:0 @0:0(.6 @6C4*+0+20V N^^PQ
@C+02 Y'+_'50V E0*+.6:'V j?0B'(025.5*'+ .+: 1C,.( *+ <C=.g2 <0+5(0‐!.25> K;0 <.20 'B <.4.,|0HV
N\^\‐N^LOkV *+> Z(.++25('4 I0:RQ LMMda //R Nd\‐PMR
#*6 Y'+50('V E.DC06V .# 8*&-,1+88%\& (' C1$'&,%&# Y M*2%3%# '& 2*- C&('- @'1%(%*'-D =*62#8%\&;
,%'11#- Y #"6%'&,'
'&
'2
-%$2*
j!j
IZC0+'2
9*(02>
-('4050'V
LMM\Q
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 26/67
Le
#C0((0('V 9+:(i2 }F+. X4.,0+ %0+5(c6'7C.> !6 ?*27C(2' 8*=0(.6 :0 6. f:02,(.7*.:. (._. *+:c,0+.g .
@*+02 :06 1*,6' zXz}V *+> Z6.+7. YC(.5'(*' I0:RQV !"k$'&'- ' !"#$%&'1*-D E'>1'-'&,#8%*&'- (' 2*-
%&(/$'&#- '8+#,*1%#&*-; G%$2*- j!j Y jj I[C*5'> @89<1$V N^^dQa //R N^P‐LeLR
J044*+,V h';+ C"#L*&%#& 71*&,%'1` [F' 0':'#, *: ,F' M1#L%2%#& !&(%#&- I<.4=(*:,0> J.(3.(:
F+*30(2*5H -(022V N^\PQ
J0++022HV 96*25.*(V
[F'
71*&,%'1
%&
.#,%&
C"'1%8#&
S%-,*1Y
I8'+:'+k>
!:A.(:
9(+'6:V
N^P\Q
8.+0V ~(*2V )*2*+1 *: =#1#(%-'D [F' ?"'1#2( %& ,F' C$' *: X+&>*^('1 ?">%1'- I"0A J.30+> y.60
F+*30(2*5H -(022V LMNMQR
8.(2'+V Z('')0V [1%#2- *: H#,%*& @#e%&$D .%6'1#2%-"; E#8'; #&( ?,F&%8%,Y %& ,F' C&('-; NVNQ‐NONQ
d <.4=(*:,0 F+*30(2*5H -(022V LMMdQ
80#(.+:V <.5;0(*+0V 71*&,%'1 ?a>#&-%*& #&( ='#-#&, =1*,'-, %& )*2*"6%#; NVWQ‐NOWh I96=CDC0(DC0>
F+*30(2*5H 'B "0A Y0W*7' -(022V N^\OQ
80A*2V &R 9(5;C( I0:RQ [1*>%8#2 0'3'2*>"'&,; NVVQ‐NONWD G,+(%'- %& ?8*&*"%8 =1*$1'-- I8'+:'+>
#0'(,0 9660+ .+: F+A*+V N^PMQ
8S/0_V h'2i E.4S+V j8. .6*40+5.7*S+ H 6. (._.k IN\^OQV *+> h'.DCc+ Z.6.,C0( I0:RQ ?2 $1#& >'-%"%-"*
(*"%&%8#&* I1.+5*.,'>
F<YYV
N^PeQ
Y.(5c+0_ 96*0(V h'.+V j8. *+50(/(05.7*S+ 07'6',*25. :0 6. ;*25'(*. 2'7*'‐07'+S4*7.> .6,C+'2 0G04/6'2
.+:*+'2kV S%-,*1%# G*8%#2 P IN^^MQa //R N`P‐OLR
Y*660(V 1;.A+ &*66*.4V C& ?&3%1*&"'&,#2 S%-,*1Y *: .#,%& C"'1%8# I<.4=(*:,0> <.4=(*:,0 F+*30(2*5H
-(022V LMMPQ
Y''(0V Z.((*+,5'+V G*8%#2 *1%$%&- *: 0%8,#,*1-F%> #&( 0'"*81#8YD .*1( #&( ='#-#&, %& ,F' @#e%&$ *:
,F' @*('1& f*12( IJ.(4'+:2A'(5;> -0+,C*+V N^OOQ
$(5*_V @0(+.+:'V )*&,1#>+&,'* 8+6#&* ('2 ,#6#8* Y #LU8#1 I8. J.=.+.V N^dMQ
Ei+*DC0V h'2i 8C*2V .# 6#,#22# >*1 =+&*D )*&:2%8,* #$1#1%* Y %\& '& 2*- C&('- >'1+#&*- I8*4.> X!-V
1FEV <!-!1V LMMdQ
E*30(.V 1*63*.V j8. (.*_> 7'6'+*_.:'(02 H 7'6'+*_.:'2kV *+> 9%*2'&8%#- '&8+6%'1,#- '& M*2%3%#D )+2,+1# Y
=*2/,%8# I8. -._> <X-<9‐9(CA*H*(*V N^^`Q
1.+G*+02V h.3*0(V ?2 '->'A%-"* ('2 "'-,%L#A' I8. -._> -X!ZV LMMeQ
1.+5*.,'V YH(+. XRV [F' ?8*2*$Y *: 4%2D ?&3%1*&"'&,; .#6*1; #&( ,F' @'a%8#& 1'3*2+,%*&; NOQQ‐NOWV
I<.4=(*:,0> <.4=(*:,0 F+*30(2*5H -(022V LMMOQ
10:(0_V 8*20V j!+3*('+40+5.6 J*25'(H 'B Y':0(+ 8.5*+ 940(*7.kV *+> K;'4.2 JR J'66'A.H I0:RQV C
)*">#&%*& ,* .#,%& C"'1%8#& S%-,*1Y IY.6:0+p$WB'(:p<.(65'+> Z6.7)A066V LMM\Qa //R dd`‐OMR
16.55.V E*7;.(: &RV }J*25'(*7.6 @('+5*0( X4.,0(H *+ 5;0 940(*7.2}V *+> 8.A(0+70 9R J0(_', I0:RQV
)F#&$%&$ M*+&(#1%'- %& ,F' C"'1%8#-D H'^ >'1->'8,%3'- *& ,F' _DGD‐@'a%8#&; )'&,1#2 C"'1%8#&
#&( G*+,F
C"'1%8#&
M*1('1-
1.+
?*0,'>
<0+50(
B'(
FR1R
‐Y0W*7.+
15C:*02V
N^^LQa
//R
Le
‐dO
K0(b+V $27.( I7''(:RQV !('#- '& '2 G%$2*D !&,'2'8,+#2'- Y 8+2,+1# '& '2 -%$2* jj 2#,%&*#"'1%8#&* IZC0+'2
9*(02> 1*,6' zzXV LMMdQ
KC7)0(V E*7;.(:V !&-#,%#62' C>>',%,'D [F' _&%,'( G,#,'- #&( ,F' ?8*2*$%8#2 0'$1#(#,%*& *: ,F' [1*>%8#2
f*12( IZ0()060H 057R> F+*30(2*5H 'B <.6*B'(+*. -(022V LMMMQ
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 27/67
LO
668 G* .7%$"="-+,# 4- *&. #%$&+"J&)"#+-. -.,&,&*-. 4- )#+,%#*
&=0"-+,&* -+ -* G)7&4#% PAFKD‐AFODQ
-.=6' $2/*+.
-0(.65.
N
10 +'2 /*:*S H 20 +'2 /*:0 C+ !Gi(7*5' . 6. 4':0(+.V 7*C:.:02 7.+.6*_.:.2 H
/.3*40+5.:.2V 4.,+cB*7'2 7.4*+'2 DC0 7(C70+ +C025(' 50((*5'(*'V C+.
*+25(C77*S+ /q=6*7. .4/6*.40+50 :*204*+.:. ImQR -0(' /'7'2 /0+2.('+ 6'
DC0 7C025.+ 025'2 .:06.+5'2 5.+ *4/'(5.+502 H 6' DC0 ,.25.+ 6.2 '5(.2
".7*'+02 DC0 6'2 /'200+R -'7'2 /*0+2.+ DC0 6' /(*40(' /.(. +'2'5('2 02
B.=(*7.( 06 :*+0(' H 6' :*Bc7*6 02 027',0( 06 7.4*+' /.(. 7'+20,C*(6' ImQ
@(.+7*27' hR Z'6'r.V N^`M
Y*+*25(' :0 -(03*2*S+ 1'7*.6 H 9,(*7C65C(. :06 !7C.:'(RL
1'6.40+50 06 :02.(('66' 07'+S4*7'V DC0 02/07*.640+50 2*,+*B*7. B'40+5' :0
6. /(':C77*S+V /0(4*5*(b 7C4/6*( 6'2 :0=0(02 :06 /(',(02' DC0 +'2 ;.,.+
(07C/0(.( 06 5*04/' /0(:*:' H 0DC*/.(.(+'2 .6 .:06.+5' :0 6'2 :04b2 /.c202
.40(*7.+'2R 1'6.40+50
/(':C7*0+:'
4b2V
/':(b
06
!7C.:'(
B*+.+7*.(
2C2
/(',(.4.2 C(,0+502 :0 4b2 H 40G'(02 027C06.2V :0 4b2 H 40G'(02 3*3*0+:.2
=.(.5.2V :0 7'+:*7*'+02 2.+*5.(*.2 2*DC*0(. 06040+5.602V :0 .6*40+5.7*S+
2.+. H 7'4/605.V :0 3025*:'V :0 7'4C+*7.7*'+02V :0 5(.+2/'(502V :0
C(=.+*_.7*S+V :0 5':' .DC066'V 0+ B*+V DC0 02 c+:*70 :0 .65. 7'+:*7*S+ :0 C+
/C0=6'
#.6' -6._. 8.22'V N^d^
-(02*:0+50 :06 !7C.:'(V N^d\‐N^eL`
N 9,(.:0_7' 6'2 7'40+5.(*'2 7(c5*7'2 .6 5(.=.G' DC0 ;*7*0('+ 6'2 7'60,.2 :06 /(',(.4. !"#$%V 0+ 02/07*.6 . Y*7;*06 Z.C:V
Y*+. ~60*7;0V !:C.(:' 1*63.V <;(*25*.+ -.()0(V Z0+0:*750 ZC66 H -.=6' 9+:(.:0R K.4=*i+ .,(.:0_7' 6'2 ./C+502 H
2C,0(0+7*.2 DC0
,0+0('2.40+50
;*7*0(.
"*7'6b2
<C3*R
L Z'6'r. IN^`M> eQR
` -6._. 8.22' IN^d^> dQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 28/67
LP
A8 6+,%#47))"R+
!250 5(.=.G' /(050+:0 :'7C40+5.( 6'2 7.4=*'2 0+ 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ H 6.2 /'6c5*7.2 025.5.602 (02/075' .6
.4=*0+50 . 40:*.:'2 :06 2*,6' zzR -.(. 066' +'2 ;04'2 7'+70+5(.:' 0+ 6. (03*2*S+ :0 6'2 *+B'(402
4*+*250(*.602 0+5(0 N^Le H N^OMV DC0 02 6. i/'7. 0+ DC0 +.70+ 2*60+7*'2.40+50 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 0
*+25*5C7*'+02
.4=*0+5.602
.+502
:0
6.
076'2*S+
/q=6*7.
:0
:*27C(2'2
H
/(0'7C/.7*'+02
07'6S,*7.2
0+5(0 6'2 .r'2 N^OM H N^^MR !+ 0B075'V 0+ N^e^ 20 7(0S 06 -.(DC0 ".7*'+.6 #.6b/.,'2V 7'+ 6. :07*2*3.
*+B6C0+7*. :0 7*0+5cB*7'2 +.5C(.6*25.2 :06 4C+:'R -C0:0 7'+2*:0(.(20 020 .r' 7'4' 06 *+*7*' :0 C+.
+C03. 05./. DC0 *+76C*(b 6. ./('=.7*S+ :0 6. 80H :0 -(030+7*S+ :0 6. <'+5.4*+.7*S+ IN^POQV 06
+.7*4*0+5' :0 @C+:.7*S+ ".5C(. IN^P\QV 6. 7(0.7*S+ :0 6. 4.H'( /.(50 :0 6.2 b(0.2 /('50,*:.2 :06
/.c2 IN^P^QV H 6. 80H @'(025.6 H :0 %*:. 1*63025(0 IN^\NQR !6 4':0(+' 0+B'DC0 .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:'
2C(,*S 0+ 020 /0(c':' *+40:*.5.40+50 /'250(*'(R 96 2*5C.(+'2 0+ 06 /0(c':' #&,'1%*1 . 6. /60+.
B'(4.6*_.7*S+ :0 6.2 /'6c5*7.2 /q=6*7.2 .4=*0+5.602V =C27.4'2 4'25(.( :*25*+5.2 30(5*0+502 H
7'((*0+502 DC0 7'+B6C*(b+ 0+ 06 /('702' :0 j*+25*5C7*'+.6*_.7*S+k :0 6.2 /(0'7C/.7*'+02 /'( 6.
/('5077*S+ .4=*0+5.6 0+ 06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+' ;.7*. 6'2 .r'2 N^eMR
!6 *+50(i2 DC0 ,Cc. 025. *+:.,.7*S+ /(06*4*+.( 02 06 :0 4'25(.( 06 /('702' :0 B'(4.7*S+ :0 6'2
407.+*24'2 :0 j,'=*0(+'k :06 /.5(*4'+*' +.5C(.6 :06 /.c2V 02 :07*(V 6'2 40:*'2 0 *+25(C40+5'2 DC0
2*(30+ /.(. (0,C6.( 5.+5' 06 .7702' 7'4' 06 C2' :0 :*7;' /.5(*4'+*' /.(. B*+02 ;C4.+'2R K.+5' 0+
/'6c5*7.2 /q=6*7.2 7'4' 0+ 7*0+7*.2 2'7*.602V 20 :05075. C+ 7(07*0+50 *+50(i2 0+ 6. 7'+2*:0(.7*S+ :0
6'2 2*2504.2 :0 j,'=0(+.+_.k :06 /.5(*4'+*' .4=*0+5.6 .C+DC0 06 5i(4*+' 02 5':.3c. '=G05' :0
4C7;.2 7'+5('30(2*.2 H 20 C2. /.(. *+:*7.( 7'4=*+.7*'+02 3.(*.=602 :0 407.+*24'2 :0 /.(5*7*/.7*S+
2'7*.6V /(020+7*. 04/(02.(*.6 H (0,C6.7*S+ 025.5.6Rd -'( +C025(. /.(50V 0250 .(5c7C6' 20 7'+70+5(. 0+ 6.
B'(4.7*S+ :0 6.2 *1$#&%L#8%*&'- '-,#,#2'- 0+7.(,.:.2 :0 6603.( . 7.=' 6. 3*,*6.+7*.V 06 7'+5('6 H 6.
(0,C6.7*S+ :0 .7702' H C2' .6 /.5(*4'+*' .4=*0+5.6 :06 /.c2R 8. ;*/S502*2 ,0+0(.6 :0 6. DC0 /.(5*4'2
02
DC0
.
/.(5*(
:0
6.2
/(*40(.2
:i7.:.2
:06
2*,6'
zz
20
;.+
*:'
:02.(('66.+:'
/.C6.5*+.40+50
407.+*24'2 DC0 /(',(02*3.40+50 :02/6._.+ C+. /.(50 :06 7'+5('6 :0 6'2 40:*'2 :0 4.+0G' :06
/.5(*4'+*' .4=*0+5.6 :06 /.c2 :02:0 C+. 20(*0 :0 .75'(02 /(*3.:'2 H 7'4C+*5.(*'2 ;.7*. 06 !25.:'R
9C+DC0 6. /.(50 :06 7'+5('6 .4=*0+5.6 DC0 20 :02/6._. 02 /0DC0r.V +' 02 0+ 4':' .6,C+'
:02:0r.=60R
8'2 025C:*'2 :*2/'+*=602 2'=(0 6'2 '(c,0+02 :06 .4=*0+5.6*24' 0+ 06 !7C.:'( ;.+ 20r.6.:' 6.
*4/'(5.+7*. :0 6. *+B6C0+7*. :0 ,(C/'2 :0 7*0+5cB*7'2 +.5C(.6*25.2 *+50(+.7*'+.602 0+ 6.2 /(*40(.2
:i7.:.2 :06 2*,6' zz DC0 04/CG.('+ 6. 7(0.7*S+ :0 6. (020(3. :0 /027. 0+ #.6b/.,'2 0+ N^`O
I#(0+*0( LMMP lLMMMnV %'+ J.,0+ N^\\Q ' 6. /(02*S+ 7'+25.+50 :0 C+ ,(C/' :0 7*0+5cB*7'2
07C.5'(*.+'2 6*:0(.:'2
/'(
Y*2.06
97'25.
1'6c2
H 06
X+25*5C5'
!7C.5'(*.+'
:0
<*0+7*.2
".5C(.602
IX!<"Q
I<C3* LMMeV LMMe.QR 94='2 ,(C/'2 20(c.+ 6'2 /(*40('2 *4/C62'(02 5.+5' :0 6. 60,*26.7*S+ :0
/('5077*S+ H 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 (07C(2'2 . *+*7*'2 :06 2*,6' zz 7'4' :0 6. j*+25*5C7*'+.6*_.7*S+k :0 6.
7'+20(3.7*S+ B'(025.6 0+ 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ :06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+' :02:0 6'2 .r'2 N^dMR
!+ 020 4.(7'V +C025(' *+50(i2 02 ./'(5.( 03*:0+7*.2 :0 DC0 GC+5' . 6. /(020+7*. :0 02'2 ,(C/'2 :0
*+506075C.602V 7*0+5cB*7'2 H BC+7*'+.(*'2V ;.=c.+ 2C(,*:' /(03*.40+50 .6,C+'2 '5('2 B.75'(02 DC0
6603.('+ .6 !25.:' . '7C/.(20 :06 4.+0G' .4=*0+5.6R Yb2 02/07cB*7.40+50V 7'4' 6' *6C25(. 06 :'=60
0/c,(.B0 :0 0250 .(5c7C6'V 4'25(.(04'2 DC0 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 :0 7'+5('6 .4=*0+5.6
d F+. (020r. 2'=(0 06 (07*0+50 C2' :06 7'+70/5' 0+ 804'2 H 9,(.A.6 ILMMOQR %0( C+ .+b6*2*2 :0 2C2 BC0+502 50S(*7.2 H
/'6c5*7.2 0+ <.25(' ILMN`> 02/07*.640+50 d‐\QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 29/67
L\
2C(,*0('+ 0+ .DC066'2 7.4/'2 0+ 6'2 DC0 (02C65.=. *4/0(*'2' 7C*:.( 4.50(*.2 /(*4.2 /.(. 2'250+0(
06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'R !20 7(07*4*0+5' BC0V :C(.+50 5':' 06 /0(c':' .+.6*_.:'V 06 '=G05*3'
/(*+7*/.6 :0 5':.2 6.2 /'6c5*7.2 /q=6*7.2 H :0 5':'2 6'2 :02306'2 :0 6'2 .65'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 H :0 2C2
4.+:'2 40:*'2R <'4' 30(04'2V 6'2 /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602 20+7*66.40+50 +' 0W*25c.+V +' 20
/6.+50.=.+ 7'4' 5.602V 0(.+ %&3%-%62'- .+50 06 !25.:'V 7C.+:' +' .40+._.=.+ :*(075.40+50 06
7(07*4*0+5'
07'+S4*7'R
!+
0B075'V
6'
DC0
.75C.640+50
20
66.4.+
j20(3*7*'2
:0
.=.2507*4*0+5'k I4.50(*.2 /(*4.2V .6*40+5'2V /(':C75'2 0W5(.75*3'2 H 2C06'2Q BC0('+ 6'2 /(*40('2 0+ 66.4.( 6.
.50+7*S+ :0 6'2 20(3*7*'2 /q=6*7'2Re 1'6' 5.(:c.40+50V 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^eMV H 3*+7C6.:. .6 4.+0G'
B'(025.6V 2C(,*S 0+5(0 7*0(5'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 :0 6. .:4*+*25(.7*S+V 6. /(0'7C/.7*S+ /'( '5(.2 BC+7*'+02
.4=*0+5.602 :0 6'2 b(='602V 7'4' 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 2C06'2V 6. (0,C6.7*S+ :06 76*4. H 6. /(020(3.7*S+
:0 6. ;C40:.: I6'2 66.4.:'2 j20(3*7*'2 :0 (0,C6.7*S+kQR
9 2C 30_V 5.+5' 06 '=G05*3' :06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 7'4' 06 4.+0G' :0 6'2 7'+:*7*'+.+502
.4=*0+5.602 DC0 6' *+;*=0+ ' 6' B.7*6*5.+V 025b+ 025(07;.40+50 3*+7C6.:'2 . C+. 7'+B*.+_. 2*+ B*2C(.2
0+ 06 7'+'7*4*0+5' 7*0+5cB*7' /'2*5*3' 7'4' BC+:.40+5' :0 6. '(:0+.7*S+ :0 6. 3*:. 2'7*.6 H 2C
0+7.4*+.4*0+5'
;.7*.
06
=*0+025.(R
!25.
.2'7*.7*S+
0+5(0
7*0+7*.V
7'+'7*4*0+5'
H
7(07*4*0+5'
07'+S4*7' /C0:0 0+50+:0(20 40G'( 0+ 06 4.(7' :0 C+. /0(2*250+50 .2/*(.7*S+ 2'7*.6 DC0 .+502 :0 6.
10,C+:. #C0((. YC+:*.6 20 66.4S j/(',(02'k H DC0 6C0,' :0 066. 04/0_S . 66.4.(20 j:02.(('66'k
I!27'=.( N^^OV Z.C: LMNLQR -'( +C025(. /.(50V (06.7*'+.(04'2 02. .2/*(.7*S+ /0(2*250+50 7'+ :'2
*4.,*+.(*'2 2'7*.602 :'4*+.+502 DC0 0+B.5*_.+ 06 /./06 2C='(:*+.:' 0 *+B*+*5' :0 6. +.5C(.60_. 0+ 6.
3*:. 2'7*.6R !+ 0250 0+2.H'V 06 5i(4*+' j*4.,*+.(*'k ' j*4.,*+.(*'2k :02*,+. 6.2 (0/(020+5.7*'+02
40+5.602 DC0 C+ :050(4*+.:' ,(C/' I' *+76C2' C+. i/'7.Q 5*0+0 :06 4C+:'R !2.2 (0/(020+5.7*'+02
20 7'+25(CH0+ 7'+ 6. .HC:. :0 *4b,0+02 :'5.:.2 H :'5.:'(.2 :0 20+5*:' I80 #'BB N^\e H <.25'(*.:*2
N^PeQR Y0 /.(070 C+ 5i(4*+' ./('/*.:' /'(DC0 >1*Y'8,# 2# %"#$'& :0 C+ /('702' 40+5.6 40+'2
025(C75C(.:' H 7'+27*0+50 DC0 06 5i(4*+' j*:0'6',c.kR
!6 .(5c7C6' /('70:0 405':'6S,*7.40+50 :0 4.+0(. j*+:C75*3.kR !4/*0_. 7'+ 6.2 (._'+02 4b2
02/07cB*7.2 0 *+40:*.5.2 :0 6. *+3025*,.7*S+ H 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ .,(c7'6. /.(. *( /(',(02*3.40+50
4'25(.+:' 2C2 7'+0W*'+02 7'+ 4.5(*702 4b2 .4/6*.2 :0 /0+2.4*0+5' H .77*S+R -':04'2 0W/6*7.( 06
/('70:*4*0+5' 405.BS(*7.40+50 7'4' 6. j.+*:.7*S+k 2C702*3. :0 S(:0+02 :*27C(2*3'2 7.:. 30_ 4b2
.=.(7.:'(02RO $5(. 405bB'(. /.(. 0W/6*7.(6' /C0:0 20( :07*( DC0 *4*5. C+. 02/07*0 :0 "#,1%*-Fe# .
/.(5*( :0 (._'+02 .:4*+*25(.5*3.2 /.(. 6. .77*S+ /.(. :0(*3.( 2C702*3.40+50 ;.7*. 6'2 ,(.+:02
*4/0(.5*3'2 0 *4.,*+.(*'2 DC0 2C=H.70+ . :*7;.2 (._'+02R
I8
N-0&)*-
!+ 06 *+*7*'V BC0 6. 7.5b25('B0R ?02:0 N^N` 7'4' C+. .40+._. H 4C7;' 4b2 :(.4b5*7.40+50 :02:0
N^LMV 7'4' C+ B.+5.24.V 6.2 /6.,.2 :0 6. j027'=. :0 =(CG.k H 6. j4'+*6*.k :03.25.('+ 6.2
/6.+5.7*'+02 :0 7.7.' :0 6. <'25. 07C.5'(*.+.R !6 025.66*:' :0 02. .50((.:'(. 7(*2*2 .4=*0+5.6 :0
50((*=602 7'+207C0+7*.2 07'+S4*7.2 BC0 06 :05'+.+50 :0 6. 7(0.7*S+ :0 6.2 /(*40(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 H
/(0'7C/.7*'+02 :0 4.+0G' .4=*0+5.6 /'( /.(50 :06 !25.:'R
!+ 6. ;*25'(*',(.Bc. 07C.5'(*.+. 20 :0=.5*S 6.(,.40+50 2'=(0 6.2 7.C2.2 :0 6. 7(*2*2 7.7.'50(. :0 6'2
.r'2 N^LMR !6 *4/'(5.+50 .(5c7C6' :0 15C.(5 Y7<'') ILMML> LL`‐dOQ +'2 'B(070 C+. 02/6i+:*:.
e Y*660++*C4 !7'2H2504 92202240+5 ILMMeQR
O E05'4' 6. *:0. :0 jS(:0+02 :*27C(2*3'2k :0 @'C7.C65 ILMMe lN^PNnQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 30/67
L^
4*(.:. . 0250 :'=60 :02.25(0V . 6. 30_ .4=*0+5.6 H 07'+S4*7'R 10 5(.5S :0 6. 7'4=*+.7*S+ :0 C+.
7.c:. 02/075.7C6.( :0 6'2 /(07*'2 *+50(+.7*'+.602 :06 7.7.' 7'+ 06 ._'50 :0 C+. 20(*0 :0 /6.,.2R
94=.2 20 (0B'(_.('+ 0+ 6. 4*24. 7'HC+5C(. 0+ 6. DC0 7'*+7*:*0('+R 8' DC0 60 :*' 6. 0B075*3*:.:
:03.25.:'(. . 6.2 /6.,.2 BC0V /(07*2.40+50V DC0 ./.(07*0('+ 0+ C+. 7'HC+5C(. 07'+S4*7.40+50
7(c5*7.> C+ 4'40+5' :0 7(*2*2 6.='(.6 H 2'7*.6 0+ 6. <'25. H :0 (0702*S+ 07'+S4*7. 0+ 6. DC0 Z(.2*6 H 06
'0250 :0
•B(*7.
/':c.+
'B(070(
C+.
/(':C77*S+
4C7;'
4.H'(
/('3'7.+:'
C+.
7.c:.
=(C27.
H 605.6
:0
6'2 /(07*'2R $7C((*SV /C02V 0+ C+. i/'7. 0+ DC0 6'2 04/(02.(*'2 0(.+ 40+'2 ;b=*602 /.(. 0+B(0+5.(
6.2 /6.,.2R
€<Cb602 BC0('+ 6.2 /6.,.2o 8. /(*40(. 0/*:04*. 20 /(020+5S I' BC0 :05075.:.Q . *+*7*'2 :0 6. :i7.:.
:0 N^NMV .C+DC0 5.6 30_ 0W*25c. H. :02:0 N\^M> 6. 4'+*6*. ' 4.+7;. =6.+7.R -.(. N^Nd 025.=. 0+
[C030:'V .6 +'(50 :0 6. 7C0+7. :06 #C.H.2V .6 6c4*50 :0 6. +.30,.=*6*:.: :0 6'2 (c'2V H /.(. N^NP 0+
Z.6.'V .6 2C(V 70(7. :0 Y.7;.6.R 8. /6.,. 02 C+. 02/'(. DC0 20 :*BC+:*S 7'+ 06 3*0+5' H DC0 20
:*2/0(2S (b/*:.40+50 0+ 6.2 _'+.2 ;q40:.2 :06 +'(50R !2 /'2*=60 DC0 +' BC0(. C+. /6.,. B'(b+0.V
2*+' C+. 3*0G. .4*,. :0 7*0(5'2 b(='602 +.5*3'2 04/.(0+5.:'2 7'+ 06 7.7.'R
8. 76.30 /.(. 2C (b/*:. :*BC2*S+ /.(070 C=*7.(20 0+ C+ :'=60 7.4=*' DC0 B.3'(070 6. :*2/0(2*S+ :0
6'2 /.5S,0+'2R !6 7.7.' +.5C(.6 6'7.6V :0 =.G' (0+:*4*0+5'V BC0 2*2504b5*7.40+50 (004/6._.:' /'(
C+. 3.(*0:.: 4b2 /(':C75*3. 7'+'7*:. 7'4' j7.7.' 30+0_'6.+'kR @C0 C+ 7.4=*' 0+ 06 ;Ci2/0:
/'50+7*.6 :0 6. /6.,.V DC0 B(.,*6*_S 06 2*2504. .,(c7'6. .6 7.4=*.( 6. 3.(*0:.: :0 7.7.' 204=(.:'V 4b2
(02*250+50V H 2C25*5C*(6' /'( C+. 3.(*0:.: DC0 50+c. 40+'2 :0B0+2.2 B(0+50 . /.5S,0+'2 6'7.602R
-0('V .:04b2V 20 /(':CG' C+ 7.4=*' 0+ 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02 .4=*0+5.602 ,0+0(.602 :0 6. _'+. 7.7.'50(.
DC0 5.4=*i+ B.3'(07*S 6. (b/*:. :*BC2*S+ :0 6. /6.,.R 9+50 06 .C40+5' :0 6'2 /(07*'2 H 6'2 40(7.:'2V
20 7'+70+5(.('+ 4*66'+02 :0 /6.+5.2 :0 7.7.' 0+ ,(.+:02 4'+'7C65*3'2R 8'2 /(*40('2 .r'2 :06 2*,6'
zz 3*0('+ 7(070( 06 +q40(' :0 4.5.2 :0 7.7.' :0 B'(4. :02/('/'(7*'+.:. ;.25. 660,.( . 4b2 :0 ^e
4*66'+02 0+ N^LMR $7C((c. DC0 4*0+5(.2 06 7.7.' 6'7.6 7(07c. BC+:.40+5.640+50 . 6. 30(. :0 6'2 (c'2V
6. +C03. 3.(*0:.: 20 /':c. 7C65*3.( 0+ _'+.2 4b2 4'+5.r'2.2 H :0 5*0((. B*(40R
!6 (02C65.:' .,(0,.:' 20(c. B.5.6R 8. 4C65*/6*7.7*S+ :0 6'2 ;Ci2/0:02 0+ ,(.+:02 4'+'7C65*3'2 2'6'
/':c. B.3'(070( 6. 0W/.+2*S+ :0 6.2 /6.,.2R "' :0=0 2'(/(0+:0( 0+5'+702 DC0 6'2 /0DC0r'2
/(':C75'(02 BC0(.+ 4b2 ;b=*602 ' 4b2 ('=C25'2 /.(. (02*25*( 06 .5.DC0 :0 6.2 /6.,.2 :0=*:' . 6.
.C20+7*. :0 4'+'7C65*3'2 0W50+2'2V . 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 3.(*0:.:02 6'7.602 :06 7.7.' +.7*'+.6 H . 2C
/(020+7*. 0+ 6C,.(02 .60G.:'2 H 50((0+'2 40+'2 /(':C75*3'2RP
!6 ,'6/0 :0 ,(.7*. 30+:(c. 0+ N^N` 7'+ 6. /6.,. 7'+'7*:. 7'4' 6. j027'=. :0 =(CG.kV DC0 .B075. 5':'
06 b(='6R
1C2
0B075'2
BC0('+
(b/*:'2
H BC64*+.+502R
1C
'(*,0+
/':(c.
025.(
0+
1C(*+.4V
.C+DC0
+'
025b /60+.40+50 7'+B*(4.:'R 8.2 7.c:.2 :0 6. /(':C77*S+ BC0('+ *+40:*.5.2 H 7'+B6CH0('+ 7'+ 6.
(0:'=6.:. 7'4/050+7*. :0 6. /(':C77*S+ :0 '5('2 /.c202 0+ 06 40(7.:' 4C+:*.6 H 7'+ 06 :0((C4=0
:(.4b5*7' :0 6'2 /(07*'2 IY7<'') LMMLQR !6 /.*2.G0 :0 6'2 ,(.+:02 7.7.'5.602 DC0 ;*7*0(.+ 6.
/('2/0(*:.: :06 !7C.:'( '6*,b(DC*7' H 6*=0(.6 6C7*(c. /.(. 6'2 '=20(3.:'(02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^`M 7'4' 6.
*4.,0+ 4*24. :06 .=.+:'+' H 6. :02'6.7*S+R\
P F+. (03*2*S+ (07*0+50 .6 (02/075' 0+ 15'60( ILMNL> 7./R XQV DC0 (02.65. 7S4' 6. /(':C77*S+ .75C.6 :0 7.7.' 2*,C0 025.+:'
=.2.:. 0+
/0DC0r'2
/(':C75'(02
:*30(2*B*7.:'2R
\ 8'2 40G'(02 025C:*'2 2'=(0 025. i/'7. H 025. _'+. 2*,C0+ 2*0+:' 6'2 :0 Y.+C06 <;*(*=',. IN^\MQV 8'*2 <(.AB'(: IN^\MQ H
9+:(i2 #C0((0(' IN^\MQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 31/67
`M
"' 02 i250 06 6C,.( /.(. (06.5.( 6.2 :07*2*3.2 7'+207C0+7*.2 ;*25S(*7.2 DC0 5C3' /.(. 06 !7C.:'( 6*=0(.6
6. 7.5b25('B0 .4=*0+5.6 H 07'+S4*7. 7.7.'50(.R YC7;'2 ;*25'(*.:'(02 6' ;.+ ;07;'R -.(. 6'2
/('/S2*5'2 :0 0250 0+2.H' 6' *4/'(5.+50 02 DC0 6603S .6 !25.:' . 7'+25(C*( 6.2 /(*40(.2 *+25*5C7*'+02
H '(,.+*_.7*'+02^ /q=6*7.2 :0 ,025*S+ .4=*0+5.6> 6.2 !25.7*'+02 :0 !W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 0 X+3025*,.7*S+
9,(c7'6. H 6'2 20(3*7*'2 :0 2.+*:.: .+*4.6 H 30,05.6 DC0 20 :02/60,.('+ /'( 06 /.c2 . /.(5*( :0 6'2
.r'2
N^LMR
!25.2
*+25*5C7*'+02
H
'(,.+*_.7*'+02
+.7*0('+
0+
C+.
i/'7.
0+
DC0
20
0W/.+:c.+
6.2 BC+7*'+02 H (02/'+2.=*6*:.:02 :06 !25.:' 0+ 5':.2 /.(502 :06 4C+:'RNM
!4/0704'2 0W.4*+.+:' 6.
B'(4. 0+ DC0 5.+5' 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 7'4' 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 /'6c5*7'2 0+50+:*0('+ 6. 6077*S+ :06
30(5*,*+'2' :02.25(0 DC0 .7.=.=.+ :0 3*3*(R
K8 ?-))"#+-.; *& 4-9-+.& &$%S)#*&
8' DC0 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 66.4.=.+ 6. j:0B0+2. .,(c7'6.k 0(. C+ .2/075' 7(C7*.6 :06 5(.=.G' 5.+5' :0 6.2
!25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602 7'4' :06 5(.=.G' :0 7'+GC+5' :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. DC0
BC+7*'+S /(*40(' 0+ 06 Y*+*250(*' :0 -(03*2*S+ 1'7*.6 H DC0 /0(0,(*+.(c. 6C0,' /'( 06 Y*+*250(*' :0
$=(.2
-q=6*7.2V
20
7(0.(c.
BC,._40+50
C+
Y*+*250(*'
:0
9,(*7C65C(.
.
B*+02
:0
6'2
.r'2
N^`MV
/.(.
6C0,' /.2.( .6 :0 !7'+'4c. H 50(4*+.( 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^eM 0+ 06 :0 @'40+5'R K.+ *4/'(5.+50 0(. 2#
2+8F# 8*&,1# 2#- >2#$#- DC0 C+' :0 6'2 /(*40('2 :*(075'(02 :0 .,(*7C65C(.V 7'64.:' /'( 6'2 (07'(502
/(02C/C025.(*'2V 0W76.4.=. 0+ 40:*' :0 6. 7(*2*2 07'+S4*7.>
1*0+:' 2# "%-%\& (' &+'-,1* *1$#&%-"* #$1/8*2#; >1%&8%>#2"'&,' 2# (' 'a>'1%"'&,#1; '&-'T#1
Y (%3+2$#1; >1*,'$'1; (':'&('1 Y 2+8F#1 8*&,1# 2#- >'-,'-V +' 20 /':(b 50+0( iW*5' 2* /.(. 066'
+' 7C0+5. 7'+ 06 06040+5' /(0/.(.:' H 02/07*.6*_.:' DC0 20 (0DC*0(0 /.(. 025'2 B*+02
IZ.('+. N^``> `Oa 06 2C=(.H.:' 02 4c'Q
8. '=202*S+ DC0 5':'2 6'2 *+B'(402 4*+*250(*.602 5*0+0+ 7'+ 6'2 0+2.H'2 /.(. (07C/0(.( 6.2
:03.25.:.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 :0 7.7.' 2'+ C+. *+:*7.7*S+ 2CB*7*0+50 :06 4'5*3' /'( 06 20 2'25C3*0('+
7'4' 6. /(*+7*/.6 *+50(30+7*S+ 025.5.6 0+ 06 .,(' 07C.5'(*.+' 0+5(0 N^Le H N^eMR !6 7'4=.50 7'+5(.
6.2 /6.,.2 +' BC0V /'( 2C/C025'V 06 q+*7' 4'5*3'R ?02:0 .+502 *+50(02.=. 5.4=*i+ 6. /('4'7*S+ :0
6'2 7'+'7*4*0+5'2 7*0+5cB*7'2 0+ 6. .,(*7C65C(.R ?0 ;07;'V 6. /(*40(. 025.7*S+ 0W/0(*40+5.6 .,(c7'6.
07C.5'(*.+. 20 BC+:S 0+ 94=.5' 0+ N^N`V 0+ 6. [C*+5. "'(4.6 :0 9,(*7C65C(. DC0 .:GC+5S C+.
027C06. /'7' :02/Ci2 I<C3* LMM^> PNQR !+ N^LO 20 BC+:S C+. !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 9,('/07C.(*. 0+
[C*5' 0+ :'+:0 5(02 .r'2 :02/Ci2 20 *+*7*.('+ 6'2 /(*40('2 3*30('2 B'(025.602 7'+ C+. /(':C77*S+ :0
LeM 4*6 b(='602 204025(.602R
-.(. N^L^V 06 Y*+*250(*' :0 -(03*2*S+ 1'7*.6 50+c. 06 /('H075' :0 *+25.6.( 6. 1C=025.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6
:0 -.25'(0' H 1063*7C65C(. 9+:*+.2 0+ 06 /b(.4' :06 +C:' :06 K*'/C66' 0+ 6. /('3*+7*. :0 80S+
I<'5'/.W*QV :'+:0 20 ;.(c. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ /.(. 6. 7(*.+_. 7*0+5cB*7. :0 (._.2 :0 '30G.2V .6/.7.2 H
66.4.2 .6 5*04/' DC0 02/0(.=. /6.+5.( LMM 4*6 b(='602 :0 OM 3.(*0:.:02 :0 7'+cB0(.2 I!,|0_
Z.DC0(*_' N^L\> P\‐^QR -.(. N^`L 0W*25c.+ 7C.5(' 025.7*'+02 .,(c7'6.2 0W/0(*40+5.602V :'2 025.7*'+02
/*27c7'6.2V C+. 025.7*S+ B'(025.6 H C+. ,(.+G. 0W/0(*40+5.6 I%0( <C.:(' NQR
^ €J.70 B.65. (07'(:.(6'o !25.4'2 C2.+:' 6'2 5i(4*+'2 j*+25*5C7*'+02k H j'(,.+*_.7*'+02k 0+ 6'2 20+5*:'2 .5(*=C*:'2 /'(
?'C,6.22 "'(5; IN^^MQR 8.2 /(*40(.2 2'+ 6'2 2*2504.2 :0 (0,6.2 DC0 ,'=*0(+.+ C+ /('702' :050(4*+.:' 4*0+5(.2 DC0 6.2
20,C+:.2 2'+ 6.2 025(C75C(.2 H ./.(.5'2 :0 ,025*S+ /q=6*7'2 ' /(*3.:'2R NM
!25.
0W/.+2*S+
;.
2*:'
:'7C40+5.:.
/'(
06
Z.+7'
YC+:*.6
IN^^PQR
F+.
0W/6*7.7*S+
:0
6.2
(._'+02
2C=H.70+502
:0
025.
0W/.+2*S+ 0+ 06 4.(7' :0 C+ 7.4=*' 0+ 06 (i,*40+ :0 .7C4C6.7*S+ . 027.6. ,6'=.6 H 06 /.2' :0 6. ;0,04'+c. =(*5b+*7.V 6*=0(.6 H 6*=(07.4=*25.V . 6. ;0,04'+c. +'(50.40(*7.+.V /('5077*'+*25. 0 *+50(30+7*'+*25.V 0+ 9((*,;* IN^^^ lN^^dnQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 32/67
`N
J(3@/& 9" )AB3>1&$#A 3%/K>&C3A #L4#/1=#$B3C#A #$ #C )>(3@&/ M9N:7O
*&=D/# P#><3 Q 3@=1$1AB/3>1R$ F>B1'1@3@#A
4/1$>143C#A
!25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 [C*5' N^LOV 20 60 .+0WS 6. <6c+*7.
%050(*+.(*.
0+
B0=(0('
:0
N^`M
I6.
/(*40(. 0+ !7C.:'(Q
%*30('2 ;'(5c7'6.2 H
2*63*7C65C(.
!25.7*S+ -*27c7'6. :06 10+. N^L\V (0*+25.6.:. 0+ N^`M -*27*7C65C(. :0 5(C7;.2
#(.+G. :0 -*7;*+7;. H !25.7*S+ :0
E04'+5. I0+ K.4=*66' ] FHC4=*7;'Q
N^`N #.+.:0(c.V 5(*,'V /./.2
!25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 [C*+5. "'(4.6
:0 94=.5'V .+0W. . 6. !27C06. H
!25.7*S+ :0 E04'+5.Q
N^N`V (0*+25.6.:. 0+ N^Le @(C5*7C65C(.V
;'(5*7C65C(. H
0+20r.+_.
!25.7*S+
<'5'/.W*
I/b(.4'
:06
K*'/C66'Q N^L^ -.25'(0'V
2*63*7C65C(.
H
/*27*7C65C(.
!25.7*S+ -*27c7'6. :0 -C+H.('
IX4=.=C(.Q
N^`L I7'+ 06 ./'H' :06 YC+*7*/*' :0
$5.3.6'Q
-*27*7C65C(.
!25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 <C0+7.
I9_C.HQ
N^L^ I7'+ 06 .C2/*7*' :0 6. 1'7*0:.:
:0 9,(*7C65'(02 :0 9_C.HQ
9,(*7C65C(. H
B(C5*7C65C(.
!25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 X26. :0 1*63.
I0+ Z.=.;'H'Q
N^L^ <.7.'V /6.+5.2
5('/*7.602 H ,.+.:0(c.
@C0+50> Y'6025*+. IN^`L> `P‐\Q
1*+ 04=.(,'V 6. :0B0+2. .,(c7'6. B*,C(. :0 4.+0(. /('4*+0+50 0+5(02 2C2 5.(0.2R !+ 0B075'V
/.(.606.40+50 . 6.2 025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602V 20 7(0S /.C6.5*+.40+50 C+ 2*2504. :0 2.+*:.:
30,05.6 H .+*4.6R 97'(:0 7'+ 6. ,(.30:.: :0 6. 7(*2*2 2.+*5.(*. :06 7.7.'V 6' /(*40(' BC0 *+25.6.( 0+
N^LO C+. !25.7*S+ 7C.(0+50+.(*. 0+ ?C(b+ H '5(.V 0+ N^`N 0+ 6. X26. :0 1*63.V 0+ 06 (c' Z.=.;'H' 0+
6'2 6c4*502 :0 6.2 /('3*+7*.2 :0 #C.H.2 H 8'2 Ec'2V :'+:0 20 *+25.6S 5':' C+ <.4/' <C.(0+50+.(*'
%0,05.6 DC0 20(3c. /.(. 3*,*6.( 6.2 /6.+5.2 5(.c:.2 :06 0W50(*'( .+502 :0 :*25(*=C*(6.2 . 6.2 ;.7*0+:.2
/.(5*7C6.(02 H :'+:0 20 (0.6*_.=.+ 025C:*'2 7'+25.+502 /.(. 0+7'+5(.( .650(+.5*3.2 . 6.2 /02502 :06
7.7.' IY'6025*+. N^`L> d H P‐\QR !+ .6,C+'2 *+B'(402 6' 66.4.+ 20(3*7*' :0 j-'6*7c. 1.+*5.(*. %0,05.6k
0+ [C*5' H 0+ #C.H.DC*6R !(. 5.(0. BC+:.40+5.6 :0 025'2 20(3*7*'2 3*,*6.( 6. *4/'(5.7*S+ H
0W/'(5.7*S+ 0+ 06 -C0(5' :0 #C.H.DC*6R 10,q+ 06 Y*+*25(' :06 (.4'V 6' 4b2 *4/'(5.+50 :0 6.
1C=:*(077*S+ :06 8*5'(.6 0+ 6. _'+. 5('/*7.6 . B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^LM 0 *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^`M 0(.
7C*:.( :0 6.2 /02502 H 0+B0(40:.:02V /(*+7*/.640+50 0+ 06 7.7.'V /0(' 5.4=*i+ 0+ 06 /6b5.+'V 0+ 06
7'7'50(' H 0+ 6'2 7c5(*7'2R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 1.+*:.: %0,05.6 *+3025*,.=. 06 5(.5.4*0+5' :0 6.2
/6.,.2 :0 6'2 B(C5.602V :06 0C7.6*/5' H 02/07*.640+50 :06 /C6,S+ 6.+c,0('V /.(b2*5' :06 4.+_.+'V 0+ 6.
/('3*+7*. :0 KC+,C(.;C.a .:04b2V ./'H.=. . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 0+ 6. /':. :0 b(='602V 06 /C630(*_.:'V
6. BC4*,.7*S+ H 06 =6.+DC0.:' 0+ 6'2 /(0:*'2 .,(c7'6.2 H 20 7'+5('6.=.+ 6.2 B(C5.2 0W/'(5.:.2 I!,|0_
Z.DC0(*_' N^L\> PM‐PNa Y'6025*+. N^`L> `‐ \QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 33/67
`L
-0(' 0(.+ 02BC0(_'2 .*26.:'2V /0DC0r'2 0 *+50(4*50+502R 9 /02.( :0 .6,C+'2 .3.+702 +'5.=602V 0+ 6.
/(b75*7.V 6'2 *+B'(402 :0 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 /C0:0+ 600(20 7.2* :0 4.+0(. C+b+*40 7'4' C+ ,(.+
6.40+5' H C+. 7'+25.+50 DC0G. :0 BC+7*'+.(*'2 DC0 +' :*2/'+0+ :0 :*+0(' 2CB*7*0+50 /.(. /.,.( .
6'2 G'(+.60('2V DC0 (07*=0+ 5.(:0V 4.6 H +C+7. 6.2 /.(5*:.2 .2*,+.:.2V DC0 2C/6*7.+ 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :0
40G'( *+B(.025(C75C(. H DC0 0W/(02.+ 2C Gq=*6' 7C.+:' ;.+ 6',(.:' ;.70(V .6 /(07*' :0 ,(.+:02
2.7(*B*7*'2V .6,C+.
*+30(2*S+
.:*7*'+.6R
!2
03*:0+50
DC0
06
5(.=.G'
:0
025.2
025.7*'+02
20
:020+3'63c.
0+ 40:*' :0 6. /(07.(*0:.: H 6. 027.20_R
10 :*25*+,C0+ 0+ 025.2 DC0G.2 6.2 3'702 :*B0(0+502 :0 5i7+*7'2 .,(c7'6.2 H :0 (02/'+2.=602 /'6c5*7'2>
4*0+5(.2 6'2 /(*40('2 *+2*250+ 0+ 06 /./06 :0 6. 7*0+7*.V :0 6. *+3025*,.7*S+V :06 025C:*' /.7*0+50 H
7'+25.+50 . 6' 6.(,' :0 4C7;'2 .r'2V 6'2 20,C+:'2 .7',0+ *+2*250+ 0+ 6. +0702*:.: :0 20( /(b75*7'2 H
=C27.( (02C65.:'2 4b2 (b/*:'2 H 0B*7*0+502V 7'+2*+5*0+:'V . 30702 . (0,.r.:*0+502V 0+ 6. *4/'(5.+7*.
:0 :'5.( :0 4b2 40:*'2 07'+S4*7'2 . 6'2 *+3025*,.:'(02R F+' :0 6'2 /'7'2 *+B'(402 :'+:0 6.
:*2/C5. 2'(:. 0+5(0 j5i7+*7'2k H j/'6c5*7'2k 20 ;.70 4b2 0W/6c7*5. H j.C:*=60k 02 0+ 6.2 DC0G.2 2'=(0
06 ,.25' *++0702.(*' H :*2/0+:*'2' 0+ 5.+5'2 5i7+*7'2 0W5(.+G0('2 :06 4*+*25(' h0(S+*4' 93*6i2
9,C*((0>
?0=' 4.+*B025.( DC0V . /02.( :0 6. 7(0.7*S+ :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. .:27(*5' . 0250
Y*+*250(*'V ;.25. 6. B07;. +' 20 ;. ;07;' .6,' /(b75*7'R 10 ;. ,.25.:' :*+0(' 0+ 6. 7'4/(.
:0 !25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602a 20 ;.+ *4/'(5.:' 5i7+*7'2 0W5(.+G0('2 /.(. DC0 +'2 ,C*.20+ H
20r.6.20+ +'(4.2 . 20,C*(a /0('V /'( :02,(.7*. 0+ 6. /(b75*7.V 5':' ;. (02C65.:' 0+ B(.7.2'R
8. jX26. :0 1*63.k !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 6. <'25.V 02 ;.25. .;'(. C+. *+30(2*S+ :0 :*+0('
2*+ /('307;' .6,C+' /.(. 06 !25.:' +* /.(. 6'2 9,(*7C65'(02 IN^`L> P^Q
%'630(04'2 . 0+7'+5(.( 025.2 :*B0(0+7*.2 0+5(0 :'2 .75'(02 :*25*+5'2 7'+ 3'702 . 30702 0+ 7'+B6*75'
0+ 06
20+'
4*24'
:06
!25.:'
0+
6.
040(,0+7*.
:0
6.
/(0'7C/.7*S+
/'(
6'2
='2DC02
+.5*3'2
0+
6'2
.r'2 N^eMR
"' '=25.+50 025.2 '7.2*'+.602 :*2/C5.2V 6. :0B0+2. .,(c7'6. H ,.+.:0(. 20 7'+2'6*:.(c. :02:0 6'2
.r'2 N^`MR [C*_b 6' 4b2 :025.7.:' H 0W50+:*:' :0 6'2 02BC0(_'2 2.+*5.(*'2 ,C=0(+.40+5.602 ;.H.
2*:' 06 7C*:.:' :06 ,.+.:'R ?02:0 6'2 .r'2 30*+50 20 ;.=c.+ :02.(('66.:' 20(3*7*'2 :0 -'6*7c.
1.+*5.(*. 9+*4.6V DC0 *+25.6.('+ =.r'2 ,.((./.5*7*:.2 '=6*,.5'(*'2 /.(. 06 ,.+.:'V C+. !25.7*S+
<C.(0+50+.(*. 9+*4.6 0+ ?C(b+ H 20(3*7*'2 :0 3050(*+.(*. H .202'(c. . 6'2 ,.+.:0('2 I!,|0_
Z.DC0(*_' N^L\> PL‐dQRNN !6 20(3*7*' ,C=0(+.40+5.6 :0 =.r'2 ,.((./.5*7*:.2 .7.2' BC0(. 06 4b2
7'+'7*:' H 0B075*3' 0+ 660,.( . 6'2 /(':C75'(02R 8.2 2*,C*0+502 025.:c25*7.2 I30( <C.:(' LQ 4C025(.+ 06
7(07*4*0+5' H 6.
4.,+*5C:
:0
6.2
5.(0.2
(0.6*_.:.2
. B.3'(
:0
6.
2.+*:.:
.+*4.6>
0+
2C2
40G'(02
.r'2V
6'2 .r'2 N^dMV 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. /':c. .50+:0( ;.25. LMM 4*6 7.=0_.2 :0 ,.+.:'
7C.+:' 20,q+ 06 70+2' .,('/07C.(*' :0 N^edV ;.=c. 0+ 5'5.6 0+ 06 /.c2 N 4*66S+ LMM 4*6 7.=0_.2R F+.
0W50+2*S+ 7'+2*:0(.=60V 7.2* ;0('*7.V :.:.2 6.2 6*4*5.7*'+02 /(02C/C025.(*.2 H :0 /0(2'+.6 0W*250+502R
!25' ;.70 2C/'+0( C+. 7'6.='(.7*S+ .75*3. :0 6'2 ,.+.:0('2 :06 /.c2R -0(' 6.2 7*B(.2 5.4=*i+
/0(4*50+ .70(7.(+'2 . C+. 7('+'6',c.> 6'2 =.r'2 ,.((./.5*7*:.2 2'+ 6. /(*+7*/.6 40:*:. :0 2.+*:.:
.+*4.6 :02:0 B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^`M ;.25. 6'2 .r'2 N^dM 4*0+5(.2 DC0 6'2 20(3*7*'2 3050(*+.(*'2 20
3C0630+ :'4*+.+502 :02:0 6'2 .r'2 N^eMR !+ 0B075'V :02:0 *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eM 6'2 =.r'2
,.((./.5*7*:.2 /0(:0(c.+ 2C /('5.,'+*24' H B*+.640+50 :02./.(070(c.+ :0 6. 6*25. :0 20(3*7*'2
NN !6 =.r' ,.((./.5*7*:. 7'+2*25c. 0+ 6. *+40(2*S+ :06 ,.+.:' 0+ C+. 2'6C7*S+ .(20+*7.6> 06 9(20+*5' :0 2':*' .C+DC0 .6,C+.
30_ 20 *+50+5S C2.( C+. 2'6C7*S+ :0 =.(=.27' *+30+5.:. /'( C+ 5i7+*7' 6'7.6 I!2/*+'2. N^dM> OPQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 34/67
``
/('/'(7*'+.:'2 /'( 06 !25.:'R !6 ?*(075'( #0+0(.6 :0 #.+.:0(c. H %050(*+.(*.V 0+ N^eLV #.6' $6*3'
$RV :. C+. /*25. :0 6.2 (._'+02 :0 2C :07.:0+7*.> 2*04/(0 02 :*Bc7*6 0+7'+5(.( 06 6C,.( 4b2 .:07C.:'
/.(. *+25.6.(6'2V (02C65. 4CH 7.('V 06 ,.+.:' 660,. .,'5.:' H /.(. 7'64'V :C(.+50 2C 5(.26.:' /C0:0
*( :0G.+:' ,.((./.5.2 /'( :'+:0 /.2. I0+ h.6*6 Y'+502:0'7. N^eL> NMdQR
J(3@/& 7" F>B1'1@3@#A @# C3 @1'1A1R$ @# %3$3@#/K3 @#C =1$1AB#/1& @# 3%/1>(CB(/3 M9N::‐9NS:O
FT&
F$1=3C#A 3B#$@1@&A 4&/
'#B#/1$3/1&A
I3T&A
%3//343B1>1@3A
F$1=3C#A B/3B3@&A
MB&B3CO
U3>1#$@3A
'1A1B3@3A
N^`` L^RN^O
N^`P NRP\O eRMMM ORP\O dP
N^`\ `R^Md NORLLd LMRNL\ NeM
N^`^ NReMM LeRMOO LOReOO Pe
N^dM
\MROd\
d\RPLO NL^R`Pd
d\^
N^dN N`PRN^N
N^dL eOReN` N^MRNPP LdORO^M
N^d` \eR\ee N^PRLe^ L\`RNNd
N^dd `R^dO N\R`^P LLR`d`
N^d\‐d^ PPReNL O\L
N^d^‐N^eM
PdR^M\
NLORe^^ LMNReMP
NRN`O
N^eN‐eL NMeRMN ̀
N^e` ^NR\Ne ONRe\\ Ne`RdM`
%.7C+.7*'+02 /(030+5*3.2V /(C0=.2 :0 :*.,+S25*7'V 0+B0(40:.:02 :05075.:.2
%.7C+.7*'+02 /(030+5*3.2 H 5(.5.4*0+5' :0 0+B0(40:.:02 '(,b+*7.2 ' /.(.2*5.(*.2 ' 7'+5.,*'2.2R
!+ N^d`V 06 4'40+5' 7C64*+.+50 :0 0250 20(3*7*'V ;.=c. NP =.r.:0('2 ,.((./.5*7*:.2 7'+5('6.:'2 /'( 06
?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. H NM 0+ 7'+25(C77*S+R
@C0+502> !2/*+'2. IN^dMV .+0W' :06 X+B'(40 :0 6. ?*3*2*S+ :0 #.+.:0(c.V 2R/RQa <(02/' $(:Sr0_ IN^dL> OOQa E'7.
<.(=' IN^d`> `e‐OQa "0='5 %06.27' IN^ed> N^^Qa h.6*6 Y'+502:0'7. IN^eL> .+0W'Qa F(,066i2 <..4.r' IN^eM> d^ H
eL‐O`Qa 1Cb(0_ %0*+5*4*66. IN^dd> z%XQa Z.('+. IN^``> `eQR
€[Ci 0+B'DC0 /(0:'4*+S 0+ 6. *+3025*,.7*S+ 2'=(0 025.2 0+B0(40:.:02 H /6.,.2o 8. B'(4. 0+ DC0
0+7.(.('+ 2C 5.(0. /C0:0 20(3*(+'2 :0 /C+5' :0 /.(5*:. /.(. 0W.4*+.( 7S4' 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2
,C=0(+.40+5.602 0+50+:c.+ 06 5(.=.G' :0 :*27*/6*+.( 6.2 BC0(_.2 +.5C(.602 DC0 025.=.+ 0+ GC0,' H
7Cb6 0(. 6. +.5C(.60_. :0 2C2 '=G05*3'2 /'6c5*7'2 H 07'+S4*7'2 4b2 .7.(*7*.:'2R
<'4' :*G*4'2 .+502V 6'2 0+2.H'2 H 0W/0(*40+5'2 /.(. 5(.5.( :0 (07C/0(.( 6.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 :0 7.7.'
BC0('+ C+. 7'+25.+50 0+ 6'2 *+B'(402 'B*7*.602 0+5(0 N^LM H N^OM .6 (0B0(*(20 .6 5(.=.G' :0 6.2
025.7*'+02
0W/0(*40+5.602R
K':'2
6'2
*+50+5'2
B(.7.2.('+
7'+
06
4.H'(
iW*5'R
?02:0
N^`M
6'
0W/6*7.=. 06 Y*+*25(' :0 9,(*7C65C(.>
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 35/67
`d
?02,(.7*.:.40+50 5':.3c. 6. 7*0+7*. +' ;. 0+7'+5(.:' 06 (040:*' 7'+5(. 025. 0+B0(40:.:
l6. 027'=. :0 =(CG.na 6. '/*+*S+ :0 5':'2 6'2 5i7+*7'2 7'+2C65.:'2 .6 (02/075' 02 DC0 +' ;.H
4.+0(. :0 DC0 06 4.6 :02./.(0_7. :06 5':'V H 6. 30(:.: 02 DC0 0+ 6.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 :06
1C(*+.4V 0W*250 6. /0250 :02:0 ;.70 4b2 :0 7C.(0+5. .r'2 ImQR l-.(. 7'4=.5*(6. 20 +0702*5.
6.n (.7*'+.6*_.7*S+ DC0 7'+2*250 0+ 6*4*5.( 6.2 _'+.2 7.7.'50(.2 . 6'2 50((0+'2 ./('/*.:'2a
:*25.+7*.( 6.2
4.5.2
C+.2
:0
'5(.2a
/':.(6.2
' 7'(5.(6.2V
:*3*:*0+:'
6.
;.7*0+:.
0+
7C.5('
6'502 /.(. *( ;.7*0+:' 0250 5(.=.G' 7.:. .r' /.(50 /'( /.(50a :*24*+C*( 6. 2'4=(.V 057R 057R
IZ'6'r. N^`M> N\‐^Q
!6 Y*+*25(' (07'+'7c. 504/(.+.40+50 DC0 2'6' 0(. /'2*=60 C+. 2'6C7*S+ 2* 20 6*4*5.=.+ 6'2
4'+'7C65*3'2R !6 504. 3'630(b . 2C(,*( :i=*640+50 4b2 5.(:0a *,C.6 DC0 06 :0 =C27.( 6'2 50((0+'2 4b2
./('/*.:'2 /.(. 06 7.7.' 03*5.+:' 2*5C.(6' 0+ 6C,.(02 0W/C025'2V 0+ C+. 2C0(50 :0 '(:0+.4*0+5' :06
C2' :06 2C06'R !+ 020 0+5'+702 20 7(0c. DC0 06 /('=604. 0(. 06 0W702' :0 B'66.G0 DC0 /(':C7c. 4b2
2'4=(. H ;C40:.:V B.7*6*5.+:' 6. :*BC2*S+ :0 6. 50((*=60 /6.,.R 92cV 9(7.:*' 9H.6.V G0B0 :06
:0/.(5.40+5' :0 .,(*7C65C(. :0 6. <'25. 0+ N^`` (07'40+:.=. DC0 0+ 6C,.( :0 DC0 6'2 b(='602 :0
7.7.' 20
2*04=(0+
. NVe
H L 405('2
:0
:*25.+7*.
IH
7'+
06
5*04/'
B'(40+
C+
30(:.:0('
='2DC0
;q40:' 7'+ b(='602 :0 7.7.7' :0 ;.25. NN 405('2 :0 .65C(.QV 20 (0DC*0(0 C+. :*25.+7*. :0 /'( 6'
40+'2 e 405('2 /.(. DC0 20.+ B.75*=602 6'2 4i5':'2 :0 7'4=.50 . 6.2 /6.,.2V 06 C2' :0 5(.75'(02 H 6.
/(020+7*. :06 2'6 H 06 .*(0 DC0 5'+*B*7.+ H .HC:.+ . 6. :0B0+2. B(0+50 . 6. !27'=. :0 Z(CG. I0+ Z.('+.
N^``> dMQR -0(' 02/.7*.( 6.2 2*04=(.2 0DC*3.6c. . 50+0( 40+'2 4.5.2 /'( ;075b(0. H /'( 6' 5.+5'
40+'2 /(':C77*S+ /'( C+*:.: :0 2C/0(B*7*0R 8. (07'40+:.7*S+ *=. 0+ 7'+5(. :06 '=G05*3' /'( 06 DC0
20 ;.7c. 06 025C:*' H /.(. 06 DC0 0W*25c.+ 6'2 4*24'2 20(3*7*'2 025.5.602 0+7.(,.:'2 :0 025C:*.(R
"C+7. 6'2 *+B'(402 660,.+ . 40+7*'+.( 06 /('70:*4*0+5' :0 *+50(7.6.( '5(.2 /6.+5.2 0+5(0 6.2 4.5.2
:0 7.7.' 0+ 7C65*3'2 3.(*.:'2 H /'6*BC+7*'+.602R !25'2 /'6*7C65*3'2 2'+ 6'2 DC0 .6 7.=' :0 6. /(C0=.
:06
5*04/'
BC+7*'+.('+
j02/'+5b+0.40+50kV
02
:07*(V
/'(
*+*7*.5*3.
7.4/02*+.V
0+
6.2
/0DC0r.2
/.(706.2 B.4*6*.(02 DC0 7'+20(3.('+ 6. 3.(*0:.: +.7*'+.6 :0 6. B(C5.R -0(' 6. /'6c5*7. 'B*7*.6 BC0 '5(.R
y. :02:0 B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^LMV 6'2 0W/0(5'2 *+50(+.7*'+.602 .7'+20G.=.+V :02'6.:'2V DC0 ;.=c. DC0
2C25*5C*( 06 7.7.' /'( '5('2 7C65*3'2 5('/*7.602 I0+ !,|0_ Z.DC0(*_' N^L\> \LQR !2. BC0 6. 2'6C7*S+ DC0
0+7'+5(.(c. 06 !25.:'V .6 B*+.6 :0 7C0+5.2V /.(. +' (0+C+7*.( .6 4*24' 4':06' .,(c7'6. DC0 6603S .6
7'6./2'R -0(' 6. ;*25'(*. /':c. (0/05*(20R y 20 (0/*5*SR
8. 6S,*7. 2C=H.70+50 :0 =C27.( 06 *+7(040+5' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ . ,(.+ 027.6. :0 C+. 40(7.+7c.
(0+5.=60 0(. *4/6.7.=60R !6 7C65*3' :0 0W/'(5.7*S+ DC0 =C27.('+ :0+':.:.40+50 H DC0 /0(4*5*(c.
2.6*( . B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dM :0 6. 7(*2*2 /('3'7.:. /'( 06 :02/6'40 :06 7.7.'V 06 =.+.+'V 30+c.
/(070:*:'
:0 6.
0W50+2*S+
:0
6.2
/6.,.2
0+
<0+5('.4i(*7.V
.6,'
/0(B075.40+50
7'+'7*:'
/'(
6.2
.C5'(*:.:02 H 6'2 04/(02.(*'2>
8.2 0+B0(40:.:02 :06 =.+.+' 0+ <0+5('.4i(*7. ;.+ (0:C7*:' 06 b(0. :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 H 06
:iB*7*5 /('3'7.:' /'( 025. 7.C2. 6' 025b 660+.+:' 6. .75C.6 /(':C77*S+ 07C.5'(*.+. I!2/*+'2.
N^dM> N\Q
!6 ?*(075'( :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. :06 !7C.:'( ;.=c. 3*.G.:' 0+ N^dM . <'25. E*7. :'+:0
3*2*5S 6.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 :0 6. F+*50: @(C*5 <'4/.+H 0+ 6. <'25. :06 -.7cB*7' H 6. B'(4. 0+ DC0
7'4=.5c.+ 6. j50((*=60 0+B0(40:.:k :0 6. 1*,.5').V DC0V .B'(5C+.:.40+50V .7'5. 06 :*(075'(V +' ;.
2*:' 7'+25.5.:. 0+ !7C.:'( H ;.H DC0 03*5.(6.R j8. 1*,.5'). 02V 2*+ :C:. .6,C+.V C+. .40+._. /.(. 06
/'(30+*( :06 =.+.+' 0+ 06 !7C.:'( H 5':. /(07.C7*S+ DC0 20 5'40 20(b :0 ,(.+ C5*6*:.:k I!2/*+'2.
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 36/67
`e
N^dM> `^‐dMQR @C0 *+q5*6R 9r'2 4b2 5.(:0V 6. 5(.,0:*. 20 (0/05*(c.> 0(. 06 (02C65.:' 7'+'7*:' :06
4':06' :0 /(':C77*S+ 0+ 4'+'7C65*3' H . ,(.+ 027.6.RNL -.(. N^eM 20 :05075S 6. /(020+7*. :06 jY.6
:0 -.+.4bkV /.(. N^eL 025.=. 0+ !6 $(' H #C.H.2a H 6. -%$#,*e# 0+ !240(.6:.2 IF(,066i2 <..4.r'
N^eM> LLa h.6*6 Y'+502:0'7. N^eL> e^QR
1'6' 4CH 5.(:c.40+50V 7C.+:' 06 =.+.+' 20 30c. .2'6.:' /'( /6.,.2 2*4*6.(02V 2C(,*0('+ 3'702 DC0
.=',.=.+ /'( 6. 7'4=*+.7*S+ :0 7C65*3'2R #.25S+ "'(Cr.V :*(075'( 0+7.(,.:' :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0
9,(*7C65C(. 0+ N^ed 7'+25.5. 6.2
:*B*7C65.:02 DC0 /('3'7. 06 4'+'7C65*3' H 02/07*.640+50 6. ./6*7.7*S+ :0 6'2 7'+'7*4*0+5'2
04/c(*7'2 0+ 06 04/0r' :02402C(.:' /'( .C40+5.( 025.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 ImQR 8.2 /('/*0:.:02
:0 5.4.r' 40:*.+' H ,(.+:0V .75C.640+50 /(':C75'(.2 :0 =.+.+' :0=0+ 20( '(*0+5.:.2
7'+ 06 7(i:*5' .,(c7'6. /.(. 6. *+50+2*B*7.7*S+ :0 C+. 0W/6'5.7*S+ 4*W5. 50+:*0+50 . 4.+50+0(
C+ 0DC*6*=(*' 7'+ 6. :*30(2*B*7.7*S+ .,(c7'6. H .+50 5':' 7'+ 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ :0 /'5(0('2 ImQR
l10 +0702*5.+ .,(S+'4'2 DC0 50+,.+ 7'4'n BC+7*S+ :0 0+7.((*6.( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 0+ B'(4.
(.7*'+.6 ;.7*. 6. :*30(2*B*7.7*S+ .,(c7'6. H 6. :0B0+2. :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 :0 =.+.+' 0+ 6.2 b(0.2
4b2 .:07C.:.2 ImQ I0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> de‐OQR
-'7' .+502 :0 6. 7(*2*2 DC0 .2'6.(c. 6.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 :0 =.+.+' 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^OMV 06 Y*+*25(' :0
@'40+5' 66.4.=. *+76C2' . /'+0( 6c4*502 .6 7(07*4*0+5' :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 /'( B.65. :0 40(7.:'2 H 025.(
.6 ='(:0 :0 6. 2C/0(/(':C77*S+> 2C,0(c. DC0 2'6' 20 /0(4*5. 6. (0/'2*7*S+ :0 204=(c'2 0+ _'+.2
:03.25.:.2 /'( 6.2 0+B0(40:.:02 IY'(50+20+ N^OM> W3***QR
"' '=25.+50 025.2 3'702 02/'(b:*7.2V 6. *+3025*,.7*S+ 0W/0(*40+5.6 2*04/(0 025C3' :'4*+.:. /'(
'5(' /('/S2*5' H '5(. 6c+0. :0 (._'+.4*0+5'2R 10 =C27.=. .+50 5':' H .B.+'2.40+50 0+7'+5(.( C+.
3.(*0:.: .65.40+50 /(':C75*3. *+4C+0 . 6.2 /6.,.2R -'( 02'V . 6' 6.(,' :0 5':' 06 /0(c':' :0 025C:*'V
06 *4/'2*=60
'=G05*3'
:0
6.
/'6c5*7.
:0
*+3025*,.7*S+
0+
7.7.'
2*,C*S
2*0+:'
0+7'+5(.(
6.
.650(+.5*3.
:0
C+. 3.(*0:.: (02*250+50 . 6. /6.,. DC0 /0(4*5*0(. 4.+50+0( 06 4*24' 2*2504. :0 /(':C77*S+ 0+
4'+'7C65*3'2 . ,(.+ 027.6.R !+ N^eMV 06 X+25*5C5' :0 @'40+5' 20,Cc. =C27.+:' 6. 2'6C7*S+ 5i7+*7.
DC0 +.:*0 ;.=c. 0+7'+5(.:' 0+ 06 4C+:' :C(.+50 7C.(0+5. .r'2>
-.(. .50+:0( . 6. '=(. BC+:.40+5.6 :0 6. /(':C77*S+ H 4C65*/6*7.7*S+ :0 /6.+5.2 :0 7.7.'
(02*250+502 . 6.2 0+B0(40:.:02 ImQ H 7'+ .:DC*2*7*S+ :0 76'+02 206075'2 .:DC*(*:'2 :0 6.2
40G'(02 3.(*0:.:02 :0 K(*+*:.:V /('30+*0+502 :0 6.2 ;.7*0+:.2 j8. <6040+5*+.kV jZ'6c3.(k H
j-*7;*6*+,C0kV 5':'2 7'+ 7.(.750(c25*7.2 DC0 .20,C(.+ 2C (02*250+7*. . 6.2 0+B0(40:.:02 DC0
.5.7.+ .6 7.7.' IX+25*5C5' :0 @'40+5' N^eM> \V 06 4*24' /6.+ ;.=c. 2*:' .+C+7*.:' C+ .r'
.+502 /'(
06
/('/*'
#.6'
-6._.
8.22'
N^d^>
NO
‐PQ
J.,.4'2 C+. /(*40(. 2c+502*2R 8.2 /(*40(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 :06 2075'( /q=6*7' 07C.5'(*.+'
0+7.(,.:.2 :0 6*:*.( 7'+ /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602 +.7*0('+ 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^LM 6C0,' :06 :02/6'40
07'+S4*7' 7.7.'50(' /('3'7.:' /'( :'2 /6.,.2 H C+. 7(*2*2 :0 /(07*'2R 10 '(,.+*_.('+ 20(3*7*'2 :0
3*,*6.+7*. 2.+*5.(*. .,(c7'6. H /07C.(*. H 20 7(0.('+ 025.7*'+02 :0 *+3025*,.7*S+ :0:*7.:.2 . 025C:*.(
/'2*=602 2'6C7*'+02 .6 /('=604.R !+5(0 6.2 2'6C7*'+02 *+3025*,.:.2V DC0 BC0('+ 3.(*.2 . 6' 6.(,' :0
7C.5(' :i7.:.2V :025.7.=. 6. *+3025*,.7*S+ 2'=(0 3.(*0:.:02 :0 7C65*3.(02 B'(b+0'2 4b2 (02*250+502 .
NL 15030 15(*BB60( ILMML> 7./R N H LQ ;. 4'25(.:' DC0 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 :0 6. F+*50: @(C*5 <'4/.+HV 6. /(*+7*/.6 /(':C75'(. :0
=.+.+' 0+
6'2
.r'2
N^dM
0+
!7C.:'(V
7'+'7c.+
/0(B075.40+50
06
/('=604.
H 2.=c.+
DC0
2C
+0,'7*'
7'+2*25c.
0+
0W/.+:*(20
. +C03.2 5*0((.2 ;.25. DC0 3'63*0(.+ . 20( .67.+_.:'2 /'( 6.2 4*24.2 /6.,.2 :0 6.2 DC0 ;Cc.+ /.(. :*(*,*(20 ;.7*. '5('2
50((0+'2 . *+*7*.( 06 /('702' '5(. 30_R <B(R 5.4=*i+ 1'6C(* ILMMOQ 2'=(0 6. /(':C77*S+ :0 =.+.+' 0+ J'+:C(.2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 37/67
`O
6.2 /6.,.2 H 0+B0(40:.:02R 8'2 7'+5*+C'2 B(.7.2'2 0W/0(*40+5.602 H /(b75*7'2 +C+7. :0=*6*5.('+ 6. B0
DC0 6'2 5i7+*7'2 50+c.+ 0+ 6. 7*0+7*. H 06 7'+'7*4*0+5' 7'4' 6. 2'6C7*S+ .6 /('=604. .,(c7'6.R
!2/'(b:*7.2 66.4.:.2 :0 .50+7*S+ 2'=(0 6. +0702*:.: :0 7.4=*'2 0+ 6'2 2*2504.2 :0 7C65*3'V :0
7'+20,C*( C+. '(:0+.7*S+ :*B0(0+50 :06 C2' :06 2C06' ' :0 4':*B*7.( 06 i+B.2*2 0+ 06 025C:*' :0 6.2
3.(*0:.:02 :0 7C65*3.(02 0WS5*7'2 (03.6'(.+:' 6. /'50+7*.6*:.: :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 *+:c,0+.2V +C+7.
.650(.('+ 06
20+5*:'
70+5(.6
:0
6.2
*+3025*,.7*'+02R
€-'( DCi 2040G.+50 04/07*+.4*0+5' 6C0,' :0 5.+5'2 .r'2 :0 (02C65.:'2 5.+ /'=(02o €[Ci B.75'(02
*4/0:c.+ (07'+'70( :0B*7*0+7*.2 :0 B'+:' 0+ 06 4':06' :0 7'+'7*4*0+5' :02.(('66.:' H 0+ 6.
'(*0+5.7*S+ :0 6. *+3025*,.7*S+o !2 ;'(. :0 2*5C.( 025.2 /'6c5*7.2 7'+7(05.2 H 025. B'(4. :0 0+50+:0(
6. :0B0+2. .,(c7'6. 7'+5(. 6.2 /6.,.2 0+ 2C2 /(*+7*/.602 4.5(*702 7C65C(.602 H /'6c5*7.2 :0 .+*:.7*S+R
L8
T0.-."#+-.
8'2 0/c,(.B02 :0 @(.+7*27' Z'6'r. H #.6' -6._.V 7*5.:'2 .6 *+*7*' :0 0250 0+2.H'V +'2 (0603.+ :0
,(.+:02 7'40+5.(*'2R 8. /(*'(*:.: :027'66.+50 :0 5':. 6. /'6c5*7. .,(.(*. H :0 5':. 6. /'6c5*7.V .
207.2V 02 6. .7'(:.:. .6 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'V BC+:.40+5' :06 j/(',(02'k /(*40('V H :06
j:02.(('66'kV :02/Ci2R !+ 025' +' ;.=c. ,(.+:02 4*250(*'2 +* ,(.+:02 *++'3.7*'+02 2*+' .4/6*.2
7'+5*+C*:.:02 7'+ 6' DC0 BC0(. C+. *:0'6',c. '4+*/(020+50 0+ 94i(*7. 6.5*+. :02:0 40:*.:'2 :06
2*,6' zXz IZ.C: LMNLQR !+ B'(4. 7(C:. H 2*+ .+02502*.V 06 /('/*' @(.+7*27' Z'6'r. (02C4*S 6. /(*'(*:.:
DC0 /(02*:c. 06 5(.5.4*0+5' :0 6. .,(*7C65C(.>
E02C65. 7.+2.:' (0/05*( 06 .W*'4. :0 DC0 j;.H DC0 ,.25.( :*+0(' 0+ =0+0B*7*' :0 6.
9,(*7C65C(.k H :0 DC0 6. 5*0((.V .C+DC0 02 4.:(0 ,0+0('2.V +0702*5. DC0 20 6. 2*04=(0 :0
=*660502 /.(. DC0 /(':C_7. 06 7*0+5' /'( C+' IZ'6'r. N^`M> d`QR
-'( 02'V
6.
6C7;.
7'+5(.
6.2
/6.,.2V
/.(.
0+50+:0(20
./('/*.:.40+50V
:0=0
20(
2*5C.:.
:0+5('
:06
4.(7' :0 025. '=202*S+R K.4=*i+ /':04'2 0+50+:0( 0+ 6.2 7''(:0+.:.2 :0 6. /('4'7*S+ :06
7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 06 2C(,*4*0+5' /.C6.5*+' :0 '5(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 0 *+25*5C7*'+02 /q=6*7.2 :0
4.+0G' H ,'=*0(+' .4=*0+5.6 0+ 06 !7C.:'( :0 025'2 .r'2RN`
8.2 !25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602 9,(c7'6.2 +' 2'6' :0=c.+ *+3025*,.( 6.2 /6.,.2 DC0 .2'6.=.+ 6'2
7.4/'2 :0 6. 1*0((. H 06 8*5'(.6a :0=c.+ 5.4=*i+ .C40+5.( 6. /(':C77*S+R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0
9,(*7C65C(. :06 Y*+*250(*' :0 -(03*2*S+ 1'7*.6 B*G.=. .2c 2C2 '=G05*3'2 0+ N^`PV :C(.+50 6. :*75.:C(. :0
@0:0(*7' -b0_>
9R‐
-(':C77*S+
:0
.6*40+5'2
H
:0
4.50(*.2
/(*4.2
/.(.
6.2
*+:C25(*.2
+.7*'+.602
;.25.
7'+20,C*( DC0 06 /.c2 20 =.250 . 2c 4*24' 7'+ 2C .,(*7C65C(.R ZR‐ X+7(040+5' :0 6'2 7C65*3'2
:0 /(':C75'2 0W/'(5.=602 H ./('307;.4*0+5' :0 6.2 (*DC0_.2 .,(c7'6.2 +.5C(.602 I#C0((0('
N^`P> Nd^QR
Y*0+5(.2 06 /(*40( '=G05*3' 20 0+7'40+:.=. . 6. .,(*7C65C(. :0 6'2 3.6602 H 40205.2 *+50(.+:*+.2V 06
20,C+:' 20 .2*,+.=. .6 7C*:.:' :0 6.2 (0,*'+02 7b6*:.2 :06 8*5'(.6 I#C0((0(' N^`P> NeMQR 9 020
j/0(B077*'+.4*0+5' :0 6'2 4i5':'2 :0 /(':C77*S+k I#C0((0(' N^`P> NeLQ 025.=.+ 0+5(0,.:.2 6.2
N` "' .='(:.(i .DCc 06 504. :0 6. 2.6C: /q=6*7.V :'+:0 02 /'2*=60 2C/'+0( DC0 6.2 +.7*0+502 /'6c5*7.2 .4=*0+5.602 :06
!25.:' 20 6*,.('+ 4b2 .6 '=G05*3' :0 03*5.( 6. :*BC2*S+ :0 0+B0(40:.:02 0+ 6'2 ;C4.+'2R K.4/'7' +'2 0+B'7.4'2 0+ 6'2
7'+B6*75'2 2'=(0
5*0((.2
H .,C.2V
:'+:0
20,C(.40+50
20
0+7'+5(.(b
4.H'(
/('5.,'+*24'
:02:0
6.
2'7*0:.:
0+
6'2
(076.4'2
H .77*'+02 2'=(0 025'2 (07C(2'2 H :'+:0 ;.H 5':.3c. 4C7;' 5(.=.G' /'( ;.70( 0+ 7C.+5' . (07C/0(.( 6. :*40+2*S+
.4=*0+5.6 :0 025. ;*25'(*.R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 38/67
`P
!25.7*'+02 :0 X+3025*,.7*S+ H 6.2 !27C06.2 9,(c7'6.2R !+ 7*0(5' 4':' 20 6.2 7'+2*:0(.=. C+ +q760'
*((.:*.:'( :0 C+. 7C65C(. :0 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+V C+ 0G04/6' 4'(.6*_.:'( DC0 20r.6.=. 6.2 3*(5C:02 :0
C+. .,(*7C65C(. 4':0(+. H 5i7+*7.V 04=.:C(+.:. :0 /(',(02'R 92cV 0+ N^`P 20 7(0S 6. !27C06. :0
9,(*7C65C(. K('/*7.6 :0 Y*6.,('V 7CH'2 0:*B*7*'2 20 04/0_.('+ . 7'+25(C*( 0+ NeM ;075b(0.2 :'+.:.2
/'( 06 X+25*5C5' :0 -(03*2*S+ 1'7*.6>
8. B*+.6*:.: :0 6. !27C06. :0 9,(*7C65C(. K('/*7.6 +' 20(b 2'6.40+50 6. 0+20r.+_.V 066.
7'+25*5C*(b C+ 70+5(' 7C65C(.6 :0 /(*40(. 76.20V q5*6 . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 0 *4/C62.:'( :06
/(',(02' .,(c7'6. :06 /.c2 I#C0((0(' N^`P> Ne`Q
!6 :*.,+S25*7' 2C=H.70+50 0(. DC0 06 !7C.:'( 6.+,C*:07c. /'( 7C6/. :0 C+. .,(*7C65C(. .5b3*7.V
(C5*+.(*. H 5(.:*7*'+.6*25.R <'4' 6' :07c.+ 6'2 :*(075'(02 :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. 0+ 2C2
*+B'(402 :0 N^`d H N^`^>
!2 :0 +0702*:.: *4/0(*'2. 0 *4/'250(,.=60 :0250((.( 06 04/*(*24' :0 +C025(.2 .75*3*:.:02V
H. 20.+ .,(.(*.2V *+:C25(*.602 ' 7'40(7*.602 H 02 5*04/' :0 *+*7*.( C+. =.20 '(,b+*7. :0 6.2
4*24.2 IZ.('+.
N^`d>
NNQ
!6 6.='(0' :0 +C025(.2 5*0((.2 20 ;.70 /'( 6' ,0+0(.6 :0 C+. 4.+0(. /(*4*5*3.V +' ;04'2
03'6C7*'+.:' +.:. H 0+ 7*0(5.2 /('3*+7*.2 .+:.4'2 7.2* .6 +*306 :0 6. B'(4. 0+ DC0
5(.=.G.=.+ 6'2 ('4.+'2a 0+ 6. 4.H'(c. :0 6'2 7.4/'2 6. HC+5. C+7*:. .6 .(.:' :0 4.:0(.
,.25. 6.2 0+0(,c.2 :06 *+:*' 7'+ C+ (0+:*4*0+5' :0B*7*0+50a 02 06 HC,' :06 5(.:*7*'+.6*24' DC0
+'2 *4/*:0 /(',(02.(R !2 +0702.(*' 2.7C:*(+'2 :0 025. *+0(7*. .5b3*7. H 0+5(.( 7'+ /.2' B*(40
0+ 06 7.4*+' :0 6. 7C65C(. .,(.(*. I?06 J*0((' N^`^> ``Q
!6 04/*(*24' /(*4*5*3'V 6'2 4i5':'2 5(.:*7*'+.602 H 6.2 4.6.2 7'25C4=(02 :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 :0=c.+
2C25*5C*(20 /'(
C+
4.+0G'
(.7*'+.6V
5i7+*7'
H 7*0+5cB*7'R
<'4'
;.
20r.6.:'
"*7'6b2
<C3*
ILMM^>
O^
‐PNQV
6.2 !25.7*'+02 9,(c7'6.2 20 :*BC+:*0('+ /'( 5':' 06 4C+:' 0+ 6. /(*40(. 4*5.: :06 2*,6' zz =.2.:.2
0+ 6'2 /.(.:*,4.2 :0 6. .,(*7C65C(. 7*0+5cB*7. H '(*0+5.:.2 . 6. /('4'7*S+ :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 7'40(7*.602R
10(3c.+ /.(. 4'25(.( /(b75*7.40+50 6. ='+:.: :06 7.4=*' 7C65C(.6 0W*,*:'R 10 2C/'+c. DC0 .6
:04'25(.( 2C2 ='+:.:02 :0 .65. /(':C77*S+ H (02*250+7*.V 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 6.2 .:'/5.(c.+
*+40:*.5.40+50>
!6 (0+:*4*0+5' .,(c7'6. 02 :*(075.40+50 /('/'(7*'+.6 . 6. 7.6*:.: :0 6. 204*66.V . 6. +'=60_.
:0 6. 02/07*0 H 3.(*0:.: :0 6'2 30,05.602 DC0 20 2*04=(.+V . 6.2 /(07.C7*'+02 DC0 20 5'40+
:0 .7C0(:' 7'+ 06 40:*' .4=*0+50 H 6. 2.+*:.: 30,05.6 DC0 20 '=20(3.V .6 2*2504. :0
6.='(0' DC0
20
04/600
H . 6'2
4i5':'2
:0
7C65*3'V
02
:07*(V
.6
7'+'7*4*0+5'
:0
6.2
60H02
=*'6S,*7.2 H DCc4*7.2 :06 .,(' I?06 J*0((' N^`^> `dQ
-0(' 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02V . GC*7*' :0 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2V 20 (02*25c.+ 5'_C:.40+50 . .:'/5.( /(b75*7.2 DC0 .
5':.2 6C702V /.(. 6'2 5i7+*7'2V 0(.+ 76.(.40+50 2C/0(*'(02R -0'(R 8'2 025C:*.+502 DC0 (07*=c.+ 6.2
0+20r.+_.2 H ='+:.:02 :0 6. 7*0+7*.V 7'4' /(b75*7'2 .,(c7'6.2 0+ 94=.5'V 0+ 6C,.( :0 7'+30(5*(20
0+ .:.6*:02 :06 /(',(02' .,(c7'6. 0+ 2C2 (0,*'+02 :0 '(*,0+V 5.+ 2'6' .2/*(.=.+ . 7'+20,C*( C+
04/60' /q=6*7' I?06 J*0((' N^`^> d`QR !6 /('=604. 0(. 6. ,0+50R
!+ 6'2 .r'2 :0 0+5(0,C0((.2V 7C.+:' 06 8*5'(.6 07C.5'(*.+' 025.=. .2'6.:' /'( 6.2 /02502V
.=.+:'+.:' 0+ 4.+'2 :0 7.4/02*+'2 4*,(.+502 H 4'+5C3*'2V /0+:0+7*0('2 0 *+:0/0+:*0+502V 0+
C+ ,*(' *+02/0(.:' H (.:*7.6V /.(. 025'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2V /'( 6' ,0+0(.6 6*=0(.602V 6. /C+5. :0 6.+_. :06
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 39/67
`\
7'+20(3.:C(*24' :0GS :0 2*5C.(20 0+ 6.2 7C4=(02 .+:*+.2 /.(. :02/6._.(20 ;.7*. 6.2 /6.+*7*02
7'250(.2 6*=(.:.2 .6 =.+:'60(*24' H 6. .+.(DCc.R !6 :*.,+S25*7' 20 ;.7c. 0W50+2*3' . 6.2 06*502 :06
8*5'(.6 DC0 ;.=c.+ .=.+:'+.:' 06 =.(7' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ /'( 6'2 /6.70(02 :06 7'+2C4'>
8. .,(*7C65C(. :0 6. <'25. .:'6070V 7'+ (.(.2 0W70/7*'+02V :0 6. *+:'60+7*. :0 6'2
.,(*7C65'(02a +' ;.H 0+ 066. *+*7*.5*3.a +' 20 *+3*0(50+ 7./*5.602 /.(. 40G'(.( 7C65*3'2 '
=0+0B*7*.( 40G'( 2C2 /(':C75'2a 40G'(.( (._.2V 057R 057R 9,(*7C65C(. /(*4*5*3.> 204=(.( H
7'207;.( H 6C0,' 7'4/(.( 7i:C6.2V 3*.G.( . !C('/. H (0,(02.( 2*+ .:'/5.( C+. *:0. /.(. 06
/(',(02' /.(5*7C6.( :06 /('/*05.(*' ' :06 /.c2 0+ ,0+0(.6 ImQR 8. .,(*7C65C(. :0 6. 1*0((. 2*
5':.3c. (C:*40+5.(*. /(020+5.V 2*+ 04=.(,'V C+ 7'+5(.250 +'5.=60 7'+ 6. :0 6. <'25.R 8'2
.,(*7C65'(02 20((.+*0,'2V 6'2 /('/*05.(*'2 :0 ;.7*0+:.2 :0 :*30(2'2 7C65*3'2 H :0 ,.+.:0(c. 20
/(0'7C/.+ 0+ 06 /(',(02' :0 2C2 /('/*0:.:02V .6 /C+5' DC0 ;.H .6,C+.2 ;.7*0+:.2 :0
,.+.:0(c. 4'+5.:.2 7'4/605.40+50 . 6. 0C('/0.> /0('V /'( :02,(.7*. H /'( 06 40:*'
.4=*0+50 DC0 +'2 (':0.V +' /C0:0+ /(':C7*(602 2*+' /0DC0rc2*4' *+50(i2 .6 7./*5.6
*+30(5*:' I93*6i2 9,C*((0 N^`L> \M H \\Q
!+ 0250 (07C0+5'V 06 /(',(02' /.(07c. *4/C62.:' 0+ 6'2 9+:02 /'( C+ 4*250(*'2' H ,0+0(.6*_.:'
02/c(*5C 04/(0+:0:'( DC0 :0=c. 30+70( 06 0,'c24' :06 .4=*0+50 7*(7C+:.+50R -0(' 6. /0(70/7*S+
7.4=*.(c. 7'+ 06 5*04/'R !6 0,'c24' .4=*0+5.6V 7'+2*:0(.:' . *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^`M /'( 06
Y*+*25(' h0(S+*4' 93*6i2 7'4' C+ :.5' :06 /.*2.G0V 20 7'+30(5*(c. 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^dMV 7C.+:' 6.
0('2*S+ 04/0_S . 20( 7'+2*:0(.:. C+ /('=604. +.7*'+.6V 0+ C+ /(':C75' :0 6. *+:'60+7*. :0 6'2
.,(*7C65'(02R 966cV 0+ 0B075'V 06 04/(0+:*4*0+5' 20 :*BC+:c. . (0,.r.:*0+502 H /'( 7C0+5.,'5.2>
!+ 6. 2*0((. 07C.5'(*.+.V B06*_40+50 025b ;.7*i+:'20 7'+27*0+7*. :0 6. +0702*:.: :0
03'6C7*S+ H 0W*250+ ;.7*0+:.2V /'7.2 :02:0 6C0,'V l7'4' 6. :0 Y.+C06 H !+(*DC0 @(0*60
9+,C6'V ' 6. :06 :'75'( E*7.(:' <(02/' $(:Sr0_n DC0 5*0+0+ 2C2 5(.=.G'2 407.+*_.:'2 I?06
J*0((' N^`^> `dQ
<C.5(' .r'2 4b2 5.(:0 H. +' /.(07c. ;.=0( +* 2*DC*0(. 06 :i=*6 2.6/*7.:' :0 ;.7*0+:.2 4':0(+.2
.*26.:.2 0+ C+ 4.( :0 :027C*:'>
8. /(':C77*S+ :0 6. 1*0((. ;. :*24*+C*:' :0=*:'V 0+5(0 '5('2 B.75'(02V .6 04/'=(07*4*0+5'
:0 6.2 5*0((.2R 9r' 5(.2 .r'V 2.63.+:' 4CH (.(.2 0W70/7*'+02V 20 3*0+0 7C65*3.+:' 6'2 4*24'2
50((0+'2 2*+ /(0'7C/.(20 /'( 2C 7'+20(3.7*S+ +* ;.70( +.:. /.(. 2C 40G'(.4*0+5'R YC7;.2
/6.,.2 DC0 .75C.640+50 .B075.+ 6'2 7C65*3'2 :0 6. _'+. X+50(.+:*+. '=0:070+ . 6. /'7.
(02*250+7*. :0 6.2 /6.+5.2 /'( 2C B.65. :0 3*5.6*:.:R 8'2 *+3*0(+'2 /('6'+,.:'2 :02,.25.+ 6.2
7./.2 30,05.5*3.2
7C.+:'
0+
6.
6.=(.+_.
+'
20
5'4.+
6.2
:0=*:.2
/(07.C7*'+02V
/'(
6'
7C.6
:02/Ci2 :0 .6,C+'2 6C25('2V 7'4' 7'+207C0+7*. :0 025'2 5(.=.G'2 *+.:07C.:'2V 6.2 5*0((.2 20
3C0630+ .+i4*7.2 (*+:*0+:' 40+'( /(':C77*S+ 0+ 3'6C40+ H /(':C75'2 :0 *+B0(*'( 7.6*:.:
IE'7. <.(=' N^d`> %XXQ
8. BC0+50 q65*4. :06 :*.,+S25*7' 02 2*04/(0 06 4*24' .C+DC0 20 *+50(7.4=*0+ 6.2 (0,*'+02> 6. (.c_ :06
4.6 025i 0+ 6. 5'(/0_.V 06 :027C*:'V 6. *+:'60+7*. H 06 :027'+'7*4*0+5' :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02R <C.+:'
6.2 7'2.2 3.+ =*0+ 0+ 6. 1*0((. 02 /'( 6. 7.6*:.: 0C('/0. :0 2C2 .,(*7C65'(02R <C.+:' 3.+ 4.6V 02 /'(
06 :027C*:'V 6. *4/0(*7*. H 6. B.65. :0 /(07.C7*'+02 :0 6'2 4*24'2 .,(*7C65'(02 DC0 .+502 BC0('+
.6.=.:'2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 40/67
`^
!25. '/*+*S+ 02/07*.640+50 +0,.5*3. :0 6'2 =0+0B*7*.(*'2 :0 2C2 02BC0(_'2 :0=0 7'6'7.(20 0+ 2C
7'+50W5'R 96 (03*2.( 6'2 *+B'(402 5i7+*7'2 0W*250+502 66.4. 6. .50+7*S+ 06 i+B.2*2
:02/('/'(7*'+.:.40+50 ,(.+:0 0+ 6. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 7'+ /6.+5.2 H 3.(*0:.:02 B'(b+0.2R <C.+:'
9(+.6:' Z.('+.V 0+7.(,.:' :06 :0/.(5.40+5' :0 .,(*7C65C(. 0+ N^`dV 0W/6*7.=. 6'2 02BC0(_'2 :0
0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 7'+ 3.(*0:.:02 :0 .6,':S+V 5(*,'V 70=.:. H /.25'2 B'((.G0('2V /(b75*7.40+50 5':'2
6'2 0W/0(*40+5'2V
2.63'
C+.2
/'7.2
3.(*0:.:02
:0
5(*,'2
+.7*'+.602V
2'+
*4/'(5.:.2
IZ.('+.
N^`d>
`N‐d^QR !6 *+B'(40 :0 !(+025' Y'6025*+. 0+ N^`L 02 4b2 *4/.75.+50> 7.r. :0 ._q7.( :0 -C0(5' E*7'V
.(('_ :0 J'+:C(.2 H !25.:'2 F+*:'2V .,C.7.50 :0 6.2 9+5*66.2V 7.4'502 :0 ~0H &025V ;C03'2
B07C+:.:'2 :0 5(C7;. j9(7' X(*2k '=20DC*.:'2 /'( 06 ZC(0.C :0 @*2;0(*02 :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0
<'40(7*' :0 6'2 !25.:'2 F+*:'2V 70(:'2 :0 /C(. (._. Z0()2;*(0V 7*/(0202V /*+'2 /.(. /6.+5.( 0+ 6'2
/b(.4'2V '30G.2 :0 (._. 1;('/2;*(0V 3.(*0:.:02 :0 5(*,' /0:*:.2 . @(.+7*.V !25.:'2 F+*:'2V
9(,0+5*+. H -0(q IY'6025*+. N^`L> LMV NPV NdV ^V LeV LOV L\QRNd X+76C2' 0+ 06 7.2' :0 j3*0G'2 7C65*3'2
20((.+'2k 7'4' 6. 60+50G.V 06 /(*40( *4/C62' 02 7.4=*.(6'
4':0(+*_b+:'6' 7'+ 6. *+5(':C77*S+ :0 204*66.2 206077*'+.:.2 :0 3.(*0:.:02 0W5(.+G0(.2 DC0
5*0+0+ 40G'(02
40(7.:'2
H /(07*'2
0+
6'2
!!RFFR
H '5('2
/.c202
:06
"'(50
I!2/*+'2.
N^dM>
dOQ
8' 4b2 70(7.+' .6 025C:*' :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 6'7.602 DC0V 7'4' 2.=04'2 ;'HV 025b+ /'( 6' ,0+0(.6
40G'( .:./5.:.2 . 6. (02*250+7*. . 6.2 /6.,.2 6'7.602V 2'+ 6'2 0W/0(*40+5'2 :0 7(C70 0+5(0 .6/.7.2 H
66.4.2 5(.c:.2 :0 -0(q H 6'2 0+2.H'2 7'+ 3.(*0:.:02 :0 5(*,' +.7*'+.6R
9DCc 5.4=*i+ ;C=' .6,C+.2 3'702 .*26.:.2 H :*27'(:.+502R 9 7'+5(.7'((*0+50 :0 6. 50+:0+7*.
:'4*+.+50V C+ *+B'(40 :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(.V /C=6*7.:' 7'4' .+0W' .6 *+B'(40 :06
Y*+*25(' 0+ N^dMV 20r.6.=. 6. *4/'(5.+7*. :0 5(.=.G.( 0+ 06 7.7.' 2'6' 7'+ 6. 3.(*0:.: +.7*'+.6 0+
6C,.( :0 0W/0(*40+5.( 7'+ 3.(*0:.:02 B'(b+0.2>
<'+3*0+0 . 5':' 5(.+70 4.+50+0( 6. 0W7060+50 7.6*:.: :06 7.7.' 07C.5'(*.+' 2*+ 5(.5.( :0
*+5(':C7*( +C03.2 3.(*0:.:02V /'( 4CH (07'40+:.:.2 DC0 20.+ =.G' 06 /C+5' :0 3*25. :0 6.
7.6*:.: :06 ,(.+' ImQR -'( '5(' 6.:'V .6 5(.5.(20 :0 ;C0(5.2 :0 6. 3.(*0:.: j".7*'+.6k 7'4' 20
*+:*7. .+50(*'(40+50V 06 7'+5('6 7'+5(. 6.2 :'2 /(*+7*/.602 0+B0(40:.:02 :06 7.7.' I!27'=.
:0 =(CG. H Y'+*6*.Q 20 B.7*6*5.(c.R Ki+,.20 0+50+:*:' DC0 6.2 0+B0(40:.:02 0+ +*+,q+ 7.2'
:02./.(070(b+ /'( 7'4/605' ImQ I0+ !2/*+'2. N^dM> .+0W'V /R eP‐\QR
!+ 06 +*306 :0 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 /'6c5*7'2V 20(b 2'6.40+50 C+ BC,._ Y*+*25(' 7'+20(3.:'( :0 6. 1*0((.V
Y.(*.+' 1Cb(0_ %0*+5*4*66.V :C(.+50 06 20,C+:' ,'=*0(+' :0 %06.27' X=.((.V 6C0,' :0 6. (03'6C7*S+
:0 4.H'
:0
N^ddV
06
DC0
. 6'2
:'2
40202
:0
0+7.(,.(20
:0
6.
7.(50(.
:0
9,(*7C65C(.
H 0+
3c2/0(.2
:0
2.6*( :0 066. /'( 2C BC2*S+ .:4*+*25(.5*3. 7'+ 6. :0 !7'+'4c.V /(020+5.(b 6.2 7'2.2 :0 '5(' 4':' H
7C025*'+.(b 5':. 6. '(*0+5.7*S+ :0 6. *+3025*,.7*S+R -0(' BC0 C+. 3'_ .*26.:.a .6 B*+.6 +' BC0('+
027C7;.:'2 2C2 7'+20G'2 +* 20,C*:.2 2C2 2C,0(0+7*.2>
?0 .6,q+ 5*04/' . 025. /.(50 ;04'2 025.:' 04/0r.:'2 0+ 0+2.H.( 3.(*0:.:02 0W5(.+G0(.2
:0 204*66.2 :0 /./.2 /.(. 5(.5.( :0 .76*4.5.(6.2 0+ +C025(' 40:*' 2*+ (0/.(.( DC0 0W*250 C+.
7*0+7*. 66.4.:. #0+i5*7.V 40(70: . 7CH. ./6*7.7*S+ 02 /'2*=60 7C65C(*_.( 204*66.2 H /6.+5.2
/.(. 7.:. 2C06' H 76*4.a +' ;04'2 (0/.(.:' 5.4/'7' DC0 6. 4*2*S+ :0 ='5b+*7'2 (C2'2
Nd !25. 02 C+. 7'+25.+50 0+ 6'2 *+B'(402 :0 6.2 025.7*'+02 .,(c7'6.2 0W/0(*40+5.602V 7B(R 5.4=*i+ <(02/' $(:Sr0_ IN^dL>
eNQ 2'=(0 6. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 7'+ 3.(*0:.:02 B'(b+0.2 0+ 6. !25.7*S+ j8. E04'+5.k :0 <.H.4=0R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 41/67
dM
7'4/C025. /'( 6'2 20r'(02 1R %R hC_0/7_C) H 1RYR ZC)._'3 025C:*S 6'2 5*/'2 *+:c,0+.2 :0
/./.2 0+ 1C: 94i(*7. ImQ H 660,S . 025.=6070( 6.2 30+5.G.2 :0 025'2 5*/'2 *+:c,0+.2 2'=(0 6.2
3.(*0:.:02 0C('/0*_.:.2V 5.602 7'4' 2C ,(.+ (02*250+7*. . 6. ;06.:. H 2C 40+'( 504/0(.5C(.
:0 ,0(4*+.7*S+V .65' ,(.:' :0 *+4C+*:.: . 6. j6.+7;.kV 6. 027.6. .4/6*. :0 2C /0(*':'
,0(4*+.5*3'V 6. 7.6*:.: :0 6'2 5C=i(7C6'2 H :0 6. Bi7C6. H '5(.2 4C7;.2 ImQR 96 *+5(':C7*(
3.(*0:.:02 0W5(.+G0(.2
/.(.
5(.5.(
:0
.76*4.5.(6.2
0+
06
!7C.:'(V
6'
DC0
20
;.
7'+20,C*:'
H 6' DC0 20 3. . 7'+20,C*( 02 (0:C7*( 06 b(0. 30,05.5*3. :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 :0 /./.2 0+ 6.2 (0,*'+02
B(c.2 :0 +C025('2 9+:02V ;.70( 4b2 ,(.30 06 /('=604. :06 .64.70+.4*0+5'V .C40+5.( 6.2
B'(4.2 B*2*'6S,*7.2 :06 =F%,*>F1# /.(. DC0 20. 4b2 :*Bc7*6 7'4=.5*(6.2V 5'(+.( 4b2 20+2*=602 .
6. :0/(02*S+ 07'6S,*7. . 6'2 /./.602 07C.5'(*.+'2a DC0:.( (0_.,.:'2V 7'4' 025.4'2 0+
5(*,'2V 0+ 6. 5.(0. :0 ;.70( B(0+50 . 6. /(':C77*S+ 0W5(.+G0(. ImQR !+ 06 5(*,' .6 *,C.6 DC0 0+
6.2 /./.2V 20 ;.+ ;07;' 0+2.H'2 H 0W/0(*40+5'2 :0 3.(*0:.:02 5(*,C0(.2 0W5(.+G0(.2 /.(.
.:./5.(6.2 . 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02 :06 /.c2R 8. 206077*S+ /'( 2c 2'6. 5(.0 (02C65.:'2 40:*'7(02V 2*(30
. 6' 4b2 /.(. .20,C(.( 6. /C(0_. :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 5(*,C0(.2a 0+ 7.4=*' 02 06 .CW*6*.( 4b2
3.6*'2' /.(. 6. ;*=(*:.7*S+V 4i5':' 06 4b2 (b/*:' /.(. .67.+_.( ,(.+:02 (0+:*4*0+5'2V
7C.+:' 025b
,0+i5*7.40+50
:*(*,*:'
I1Cb(0_
%0*+5*4*66.
N^dd>
W‐W*QR
€<S4' 0+50+:0( 025. 7'+5(./'2*7*S+ :0 3*2*'+02 5i7+*7.2 0+5(0 C+ Y*+*25(' 7'+20(3.:'( DC0
.=',.=. . B.3'( :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 *+:c,0+.2 :0 6'2 7C65*3'2V (0*3*+:*7.+:' .2c 6. 206077*S+ DC0 /'(
,0+0(.7*'+02 ;.=c.+ ;07;' 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 6'7.602V H 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2V ,0+0(.640+50 6*=0(.602V DC0 6'
(':0.=.+ H DC0 3.6'(.=.+ .+50 5':' 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 B'(b+0.2o 8. =q2DC0:. :0 .76*4.5.( 02.2
3.(*0:.:02 30,05.602 H .+*4.602 025b (06.7*'+.:. 7'+ C+ *4.,*+.(*' 4b2 .4/6*' 20,q+ 06 7C.6 '2
>1*$1'-* 3%'&' ('2 'a,'1%*1 R 8. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ .,(c7'6. 70+5(.:. 0+ 3.(*0:.:02 :0 (._.2 .+*4.602 H
30,05.602 5(.c:.2 :0 BC0(. 20 7'4/6040+5. 7'+ 6. /(020+7*. :07*2*3. :0 5i7+*7'2 .,(c7'6.2
0W5(.+G0('2R !+ 6'2 *+B'(402 20 40+7*'+.+ *+:*'2V *5.6*.+'2V B(.+70202 H 025.:'C+*:0+202R "' 2S6'
02'R "*7'6b2
<C3*
ILMM^>
\N
‐^eQV
=.2.:'
0+
6.
*+B'(4.7*S+
:0
6'2
.(7;*3'2
025.:'C+*:0+202V
4C025(.
DC0 6.2 025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dM 660,.('+ . 20( B*+.+7*.:.2 7'+ B'+:'2
07C.5'(*.+'2 /0(' 2*04/(0 :*(*,*:.2 /'( 5i7+*7'2 +'(50.40(*7.+'2 060,*:'2 /'( 6.2 .C5'(*:.:02
+'(50.40(*7.+.2R 92c>
Y0:*.+50 C+ <'+30+*' 0+5(0 0250 Y*+*250(*'V 6. <'(/'(.7*S+ !7C.5'(*.+. :0 @'40+5' H 06
?0/.(5.40+5' :0 9,(*7C65C(. :0 6'2 !25.:'2 F+*:'2V :0 NL :0 .,'25' :0 N^dLV 20 7(0S 0+
j-*7;*6*+,C0k 6. !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 9,(c7'6. :06 !7C.:'( /.(. 7C65*3'2 5('/*7.602V 7CH'
4.+50+*4*0+5' 20 ;.70 7'+ B'+:'2 :0 6'2 #'=*0(+'2 :06 !7C.:'(V :0 6'2 !25.:'2 F+*:'2 :0
"'(50 94i(*7. H :0 6. <'(/'(.7*S+ !7C.5'(*.+. :0 @'40+5'R !6 ?*(075'( :0 025. !25.7*S+ 02
06
20r'(
800
J*+02
.
DC*0+
.7'4/.r.
C+
,(C/'
:0
5i7+*7'2
.40(*7.+'2V
0W/0(5'2
0+
:*B0(0+502 (.4'2 :0 6. .,(*7C65C(. IE'7. <.(=' N^d`> ^Q
-.(. *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eM 025. j!25.7*S+ :06 !7C.:'(kV :*(*,*:. /'( 06 10(3*7*' <''/0(.5*3'
X+50(.40(*7.+' :0 9,(*7C65C(.V 50+c. =.G' 2C 4.+:' 6. 4.H'( /.(50 :0 6.2 !25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602
07C.5'(*.+.2V ./'(5.=. 40+'2 :0 6. 4*5.: :0 6'2 B'+:'2 /.(. 2C 4.+C50+7*S+ /0(' 6. :*(077*S+
7'((02/'+:c. . 7*0+5cB*7'2 025.:'C+*:0+202RNe 8. .C5'(*:.: /.(. .2C4*( 6. :*(077*S+ +' 30+c.
0+5'+702 :0 DC*0+ ./'(5.=. 6'2 B'+:'2 /.(. 2C BC+7*'+.4*0+5'2 2*+' :0 DC*0+02 0+5(0,.=.+ 2C
0W/0(*0+7*. H /':c.+ 0W;*=*( 06 iW*5' :0 ;.=0( 6',(.:' 660,.( .6 B*+ . 6. .+2*.:. 405. :06 /(',(02'R
Ne
E07*i+
0+
N^e`
6'2
./'(502
B*+.+7*0('2
07C.5'(*.+'
H 025.:'C+*:0+20
660,.(c.+
. 20(
0DC*5.5*3'2
I7B(R
X+B'(40
:0
#.25S+
"'('r.V ?*(075'( :0 9,(*7C65C(.V 0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> P H NM‐NNQR %0( 06 *+B'(40 7'4/605' :0 "'(4.+ &.(:V ?*(075'( :06 10(3*7*' X+50(.40(*7.+' :0 9,(*7C65C(. 0+ //R `M^‐NdR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 42/67
dN
!2 /'( 02' DC0 0+ '/*+*S+ :0 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 /'6c5*7'2 07C.5'(*.+'2V 025.2 40G'(.2 7*0+5cB*7.2
=.2.:.2 0+ 06 ./'H' :0 0W/0(5'2 :06 (025' :06 4C+:' H 0+ 6. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 7'+ 3.(*0:.:02 :0
7C65*3'2 B'(b+0.2 20 (0306.=. *+2CB*7*0+50V 7'4' 6' .5025*,C. 2C 4*24' H ('5C+:' B(.7.2'R -C0:0+
0+50+:0(20 6.2 B(.7.2.:.2 *+50+7*'+02 :0 7'6'+*_.7*S+ .,(c7'6. 04/(0+:*:.2 :02:0 06 2*,6' zXz /'( 06
!25.:' 07C.5'(*.+' 7'4' C+ 7'4/6040+5' . 025. /'6c5*7. :0 40G'(. :0 (._.2 .+*4.602 H 30,05.602R
JC=*0(. 2*:'
*+7'4/605'
DC0
2'6.40+50
20
*+G0(5.(.+
3.(*0:.:02
:0
.(('_
H DC0
3*+*0(.+
5i7+*7'2
. 0+20r.( 6'2 +C03'2 7'+'7*4*0+5'2 :0 6. 7*0+7*.a 0(. +0702.(*' 5.4=*i+ DC0 6'2 /('/*'2 .,(*7C65'(02
0+7.(,.:'2 :0 ./6*7.( 6'2 +C03'2 7C65*3'2 H 6.2 +C03.2 5i7+*7.2 .,(c7'6.2 H ,.+.:0(.2V BC0(.+V 066'2
5.4=*i+V :0 3.(*0:.:02 40G'(.:.2R !6 Y*+*25(' :0 $=(.2 -q=6*7.2 H 9,(*7C65C(. :0 N^`L 6' 0W/(02.
7'+ =(C5.6 2*+70(*:.:>
10 ;. ;07;' 4C7;'2 0+2.H'2 :0 5(*250 (07'(:.7*S+R 8. 7'6'+*_.7*S+ 7'+2*:0(.:. :0+5(' :0
+C025(' 40:*' 02 /('=604. =b2*7'V /'( 6.2 (.:*.7*'+02 :0 7C65C(. DC0 :0 2C 2'6C7*S+
04.+.+R 966c 50+04'2 /.c202 7*3*6*_.:'2 7'4' 9(,0+5*+.V YiW*7'V !25.:'2 F+*:'2 :06 "R DC0
'7C/.+ 6C,.( /(04*+0+50V :0=*:' . 2C2 2*2504.2 :0 7'6'+*_.7*S+ =*0+ 5(._.:'2 H
/0(B075.40+50 025.=607*:'2R
!2
40+0250(
40G'(.(
6.2
(._.2
H /'=6.(
6'2
0W50+2'2
50((*5'(*'2
:02/'=6.:'2 ' ;.=*5.:'2 /'( *+:c,0+.2 *+:'60+502 H 204* ] 2.63.G02R !6 /('=604. :0
*+7'(/'(.( .6 *+:*' . 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+V :0 4.+0(. DC0 0+5(0 . B'(4.( /.(50 :0 6. C+*:.:
+.7*'+.6V GC+5' 7'+ 6.2 :04b2 76.202 2'7*.602V 02 06 /('=604. 2'7*.6 07C.5'(*.+' I93*6i2
9,C*((0 N^`L> Nd\Q
"' 02 :*Bc7*6 3*+7C6.( 025.2 .B*(4.7*'+02 7'+ 6'2 /(*+7*/*'2 :06 j;*,*0+*24'kV DC0 025.=. 0+ =',. 0+
6'2 4*24'2 .r'2V DC0 +C5(*S 6'2 0+'(402 02BC0(_'2 /'( 40G'(.( 6'2 2*2504.2 2.+*5.(*'2 H :0 .,C.
/'5.=60 0+ 6.2 7*C:.:02 :06 /.c2 H DC0 20 3*+7C6.=. 7C65C(.640+50 7'+ C+. *:0'6',c. 70+5(.:. 0+ 6.
0W5*(/.7*S+ :0 6.2 7'25C4=(02 2.63.G02 0 *+7*3*6*_.:.2RNO "' ;04'2 0+7'+5(.:' 7'+ /'250(*'(*:.:V 0+
6'2 .r'2
N^dM
H N^eMV
(0B0(0+7*.2
:*(075.2
. 6.
+0702*:.:
:0
7.4=*.(
6.2
(._.2
:0
6'2
.,(*7C65'(02
H
40G'(.(6.2R -0(' 5':.2 6.2 '=20(3.7*'+02 /(020+5.:.2 /b,*+.2 .5(b2 2'=(0 6. *+:'60+7*. H 06 :027C*:'
7'+ DC0 5(.=.G.+V 2'+ 2CB*7*0+502 /.(. *6C25(.( 06 /C+5'R
!+ 06 4.(7' :0 C+ :*.,+S25*7' 2040G.+50V 02 Bb7*6 0+50+:0( DC0 5C3*0(. 5.+5' iW*5' 0+5(0 6'2
BC+7*'+.(*'2 /q=6*7'2 6. 2C/'2*7*S+ :0 DC0 06 7'+'7*4*0+5' .,('/07C.(*' 20 :02.(('66. 0+
7'+:*7*'+02 :0 .*26.4*0+5' H DC0 6.2 !25.7*'+02 :0=c.+ (0/6*7.( 6.='(.5'(*'2 :'+:0 6.
0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ /C:*0(. 20( 025(*75.40+50 7'+5('6.:.R 1.=04'2 DC0 020 B'(4.5' :0 #(.+G.2
!W/0(*40+5.602 :'4*+S 06 4C+:' 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^dM H 50+c. 2C '(*,0+ 0+ C+. 7'+70/7*S+ B*(4040+50
/'2*5*3*25. :0 6. /(':C77*S+ 7*0+5cB*7.RNP 9DCc 6' DC0 +'2 *+50(02. (02.65.( 02 DC0 C+. 7'+70/7*S+
2040G.+50 :0
6.
7*0+7*.
20
7'+075.
Bb7*640+50
7'+
6.
*:0.
:0
DC0
06
/(',(02'
3*0+0
:0
BC0(.
H DC0
/'7' ' +.:. 7.=0 02/0(.( :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02V :0 2C *+30+5*3.V :0 2C2 7'+'7*4*0+5'2 H :0 2C 7'5*:*.+.
0W/0(*40+5.7*S+R 9 7'+5(.3c. :0 6. .B*(4.7*S+ :0 1Cb(0_ %0*+5*4*66. 2'=(0 6.2 ='+:.:02 :0 6.
;*=(*:.7*S+ :0 204*66.2 6'7.602 7'+ +C03.2 3.(*0:.:02V 06 0+7.(,.:' :0 6. !27C06. :0 9,(*7C65C(. :0
94=.5' 20 DC0G.=. :0 6. 025(07;0_ :06 50((0+' /.(. 6. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+R 8' (0:C7*:' :06 02/.7*'
:. 6C,.( . DC0 6'2 7C65*3'2 :0 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 660,C0+ . 20( :0 C+. B'(4. 4*W5.V
/(':C7*i+:'20 B(07C0+5040+50 ;*=(*:.7*'+02 DC0 7.C2.+ 4C7;.2 30702 6. :0,0+0(.7*S+ :0
.6,C+'2 7C65*3'2 H :*B*7C65.+ 2C ./(07*.7*S+ 30(:.:0(. I0+ Z.('+. N^``> e^‐OMQR
NO -.(. C+. (03*2*S+ :05.66.:. :06 ;*,*0+*24' 0+ [C*5' 0+ 6. 4*24. i/'7.V 7B(R ~*+,4.+ ILMMOQR
NP 96 (02/075' 02 4CH q5*6 06 025C:*' :0 "*7'6b2 <C3* ILMM^QR %0( 5.4=*i+ Y7<'') ILMMMQV $2='(+0 ILMMNQ H ?(.H5'+ ILMMMQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 43/67
dL
-0(' (02C65. DC0 i2. 02V GC25.40+50V 6. 2*5C.7*S+ 0+ 6. DC0 20 :020+3C0630 6. .75*3*:.: :0 6. 4.H'(c.
:0 .,(*7C65'(02V 02/07*.640+50 :0 DC*0+02 5*0+0+ 50((0+'2 /0DC0r'2R 9DCc 20 0+7C0+5(. 0+70((.:.
C+. :0 6.2 76.302 DC0 0W/6*7. /'( DCi (02C65S 5.+ :*Bc7*6 DC0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 .:'/5.(.+ 6.2 3.(*0:.:02
206077*'+.:.2 /'( 6'2 5i7+*7'2 H DC0 5.+5'2 .r'2 :0 *+3025*,.7*S+ :*0(.+ 5.+ /'7'2 B(C5'2 0+ 06
.C40+5' :0 6. /(':C75*3*:.:R 8'2 5i7+*7'2 .,('/07C.(*'2 50+:c.+ . .5(*=C*(6' . 6. *+:'60+7*. H
5(.:*7*'+.6*24' :0
6'2
7.4/02*+'2V
*+:c,0+.2
H .,(*7C65'(02V
DC0
20
+0,.=.+
. 6.2
*++'3.7*'+02
H 504c.+ 06 /(',(02'R F+. 4*(.:. 4b2 :050+*:. C=*7. 6.2 (._'+02 0+ 06 /('/*' :*20r' :06 2*2504. :0
*+3025*,.7*S+>
ImQ /(*40(' :0=04'2 7'4/('=.( /60+.40+50 6. ='+:.: :0 6.2 02/07*02 30,05.602 0+
+C025(.2 !25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602 /'( 40:*' :0 7C65*3'2 5i7+*7'2 H 6C0,' /('/'(7*'+.( .
6'2 *+50(02.:'2 2* BC0(0 /'2*=60 0+ /(i25.4'V 0+ 7.+5*:.:02 2CB*7*0+502 H 7./.702 :0 660,.( .
;.70( 7C65*3'2 *+50+2*3'2V 6'2 DC0 20 (0.6*70+ 04/60.+:' 204*66.2 ,.(.+5*_.:.2 /'( 2C 7.6*:.:V
/':0( ,0(4*+.5*3' H /0(B075.40+50 :02*+B075.:.2 0+5(0,.:.2 /'( 06 ?0/.(5.40+5'V .6 *,C.6
:0 6' DC0 20 ;.70 0+ '5('2 /.c202 0+ DC0 02 C+. /(0'7C/.7*S+ 7'+25.+50 06 ./'H' . 6.
.,(*7C65C(. I?06
J*0(('
N^`^>
`eQR
1* 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02 0+ 6.2 DC0 20 (0.6*_. 6. 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ 0+ 025'2 6.='(.5'(*'2 :*B*0(0+ 5.+5' :0
.DC066.2 0+ 6.2 DC0 20 :0=0 (0.6*_.( 6. .:'/7*S+ :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 /'( /.(50 :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02V
€7S4' 02/0(.( DC0 6.2 .:'/50+o €<S4' .20,C(.( DC0 2C :0204/0r' 20. 06 4*24' 2*+ (*0,'V 0+
_'+.2 7'+ ;06.:.2V 0+ 5*0((.2 /.(7*.640+50 0('2*'+.:.2V 2*+ 6.2 /('5077*'+02 :06 7.2'V 2*+ 06 7C*:.:'
:*.(*' :0 0DC*/'2 /0(4.+0+502 H '5(.2 5.+5.2 :*B0(0+7*.2 4b2o <.:. 7C65*3' 7C4/60 0+ 6.2
07'+'4c.2V 6. 3*:. H 6'2 07'2*2504.2 4.+0G.:'2 /'( 6'2 7.4/02*+'2V C+. 3.(*0:.: :0 BC+7*'+02
2*4C65b+0.2 DC0 C+. 3.(*0:.: :0 204*66. 5*0+0 DC0 (0/6*7.(R
9+50 6.2 0+'(402 :*B*7C65.:02 0+ 6. .:'/7*S+ :0 6.2 507+'6',c.2 0+2.H.:.2 0+ 06 6.='(.5'(*' :0 6.2
!25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602V 6. 2'6C7*S+ 0+7'+5(.:. . *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eM BC0 6. j0W50+2*S+k
.,(c7'6.R !+ 0B075'V 7'4' 0W/6*7. #.25S+ "'(Cr.V :*(075'( :0 9,(*7C65C(.V 06 /(',(.4. :06 10(3*7*'
<''/0(.5*3' 20 '(,.+*_S 7'4' j20(3*7*'k 0+ GC6*' :0 N^eL /'(DC0 0+ N^eM 025*4.('+ DC0 6.2
*+3025*,.7*'+02 H. ;.=c.+ 660,.:' . C+ /C+5' 0+ DC0 20 /':c.
/(*+7*/*.( . /('/'(7*'+.(6. 0+ B'(4. :0 .HC:. . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02V .2c 02 7'4' /C0:0 :07*(20
DC0 6. .75*3*:.: :0 !W50+2*S+ . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 7'40+_S 0+ N^eM ImQR !6 5(.=.G' :0
*+3025*,.7*S+ 7'40+_S 7'+ 6'2 /(':C75'2 020+7*.602 /.(. 06 02BC0(_' :0 ,C0((. :0 6.2
".7*'+02 F+*:.2V /(*+7*/.640+50 7.C7;' H /6.+5.2 40:*7*+.602 I0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> PV
7B(R 5.4=*i+ 0+ /R `M^QRN\
9/0+.2 50(4*+S 6. ,C0((.V 06 /(',(.4. :0 *+3025*,.7*'+02 04/0_S . :0:*7.(20 . 6'2 7C65*3'2
07C.5'(*.+'2 7'+70+5(b+:'20 2'=(0 5':' 0+ 06 7.7.' j/.(. 7'+20,C*( 3.(*0:.:02 (02*250+502k I0+
"0='5 %06.27' N^ed> \QR 8. !W50+2*S+ .,(c7'6. 02 :0B*+*:. 7'4' C+ j4':0(+' 4i5':' :0 0:C7.( .6
.,(*7C65'( H .6 7.4/02*+' ImQk I"'(Cr.V 0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> `M^Q ' 7'4' j6. :*3C6,.7*S+ 0+5(0
6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 :0 6'2 (02C65.:'2 :0 6.2 *+3025*,.7*'+02 /(03*.2k I&.(:V 0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed>
`M^QR ?0 ;07;' j6. /.(50 40:C6.(k :06 +C03' <'+30+*' B*(4.:' 0+ B0=(0(' :0 N^ed 02 6. !W50+2*S+
9,(c7'6. ".7*'+.6 /.(. 6. DC0 /(030c. C+ /(02C/C025' 4.H'( DC0 06 /(03*25' /.(. *+3025*,.7*S+ INVP
N\
F+
/'7'
.+502V
0+
06
*+B'(40
:0
.75*3*:.:02
:0
N^d^
H N^eMV
./.(070
H.
6.
/.6.=(.
j0W50+2*S+kV
/0('
066.
2*(30
/.(.
.,(C/.( 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 :0 6.2 !27C06.2 9,(c7'6.2V 6'2 7'+30+*'2 7'+ 06 Y*+*250(*' :0 !:C7.7*S+V 6.2 /C=6*7.7*'+02 H 6'2
76C=02 GC30+*602 IF(,066i2 N^eM> LMQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 44/67
d`
4*66'+02 /.(. 0W50+2*S+ 7'+5(. N 4*66S+ /.(. *+3025*,.7*'+02Q I0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> NM‐NNQR ?0
020 /(02C/C025'V ^L` 4*6 :S6.(02 20 :025*+.(c.+ . 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 :0 0W50+2*S+ 2'=(0 6.2
0+B0(40:.:02 :06 =.+.+'R
%*25'2 0+ 025. /0(2/075*3.V 0+5'+702V 6'2 '=G05*3'2 :0 6.2 025.7*'+02 :0 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ .:DC*0(0+
'5(. :*40+2*S+R 1'+ /.(50 :0 C+. 025(.50,*. 4b2 .4/6*. :025*+.:. . .C40+5.( 6. /(':C77*S+ H .
7(0.( .=C+:.+502 (*DC0_.2 7'40(7*.602R !6 7'+5('6 :0 6.2 /6.,.2 02 2'6' C+ 7'4/'+0+50 :0 6.
=q2DC0:. :0 C+. /(':C77*S+ (0:'=6.:. H C+. (*DC0_. 4C65*/6*7.:.R !+ 06 7.4*+' :0 ;.70(6'V 6.2
025.7*'+02 7C4/60+ 6. BC+7*S+ :0 C+. *((.:*.7*S+ 7C65C(.6 2*+ 6. 7C.6 5':' 02BC0(_' 07'+S4*7' 20(b
3.+' /'( 6. +.5C(.60_. *+:'60+50 H 5(.:*7*'+.6*25. :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02R ?02:0 06 /C+5' :0 3*25. DC0
*+50(02. . 0250 .(5c7C6'V 06 7'+5('6 :0 6.2 /6.,.2 :06 7.7.' H :0 '5('2 7C65*3'2 .,(c7'6.2 H :06 ,.+.:'
BC0 6. B'(4. ;*25S(*7. 40:*.+50 6. 7C.6 06 .4=*0+50 0+5(S 0+ 06 7.4/' :0 *+50(i2 :06 !25.:'R 9C+DC0
20 /C0:0 .(,C40+5.( DC0 20 5(.5. :0 C+. B'(4. 6*4*5.:. H 025(07;. :0 7'+2*:0(.( 06 j.4=*0+50kV
6*4*5b+:'6' . C+ /('=604. 2.+*5.(*'V BC0 .2c 7'4' 2C(,*0('+ 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 /.(. 06
,'=*0(+' .4=*0+5.6R !+ 6. 2*,C*0+50 2077*S+ 20 :025*+.(b . 4'25(.( 2C 7'+0W*S+ 7'+ 06 '=G05*3' :0
/(':C7*( 4b2
40(7.+7c.2a
0+
6.
2C=2*,C*0+50
20
.='(:.(b
06
'=G05*3'
:0
/(':C7*(
40G'(02
;'4=(02V
6*=0(.:'2 :0 6. 40+5.6*:.: .(7.*7. DC0 6'2 7'+:0+.R
M8
U%#47),"H".=#
J04'2 .(,C40+5.:' DC0 6.2 !25.7*'+02 9,(c7'6.2V 0+B'7.:.2 *+*7*.640+50 0+ 06 4.+0G' :0 6.2 /6.,.2
.,(c7'6.2V BC0('+ 6.2 /(*40(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 :0:*7.:.2 .6 ,'=*0(+' .4=*0+5.6 0+ 06 !25.:'
07C.5'(*.+'R Y'25(.4'2 DC0 2C 0+B'DC0 :0 5(.=.G' 025.=. 7'+:*7*'+.:' /'( 06 '=G05*3' :0
.C40+5.( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'R ?0 ;07;'V 2'6' .DC066'2 B.75'(02 .4=*0+5.602 DC0V 7'4' 6.2
/6.,.2V 50+c.+ 0B075'2 :.r*+'2 2'=(0 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' /':c.+ 20( j:05075.:'2k /'( 6'2
(.:.(02 :06
!25.:'R
!2
6'
DC0
'7C((*SV
7'4'
3*4'2V
7'+
06
7.7.'
H 6'2
/(*40('2
02BC0(_'2
025.5.602
/'( B'(4.( 2*2504.2 2.+*5.(*'2 .,('/07C.(*'2 H /'( *+3025*,.( 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 (02*250+502 . 6.2 /6.,.2R
!2 5.4=*i+ 6. (._S+ /'( 6. 7C.6 7*0(5.2 2'6C7*'+02 40+7*'+.:.2 . 6' 6.(,' :0 6'2 .r'2 +' BC0('+
.7',*:.2R !+ 0B075'V 6. 40+'( *+50+2*:.: :06 7C65*3' 7'40(7*.6V 6. :*30(2*B*7.7*S+ .,(c7'6. 0+ 6.2
/.(706.2 ' 6. (0:C77*S+ :0 6. 2C/0(B*7*0 :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 7'40(7*.602 . 6.2 b(0.2 4b2 ./('/*.:.2V
/':c.+ (0:C7*( ' :*B0(*( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'R F+. 2'6C7*S+ DC0 /(':CG0(. 2040G.+50 0B075'V +'
0(. 2'6C7*S+R
!6 '=G05*3' :0 025. 2077*S+ 02 .4/6*.( 06 (.:*' :0 *+:.,.7*S+ ;.7*. '5('2 7.4/'2 0+ 6'2 DC0 20
0W50+:*0('+ 6.2 /(0'7C/.7*'+02 .4=*0+5.602 :06 !25.:' 0+ 06 4*24' /0(c':'R [C0(04'2 7'4/('=.(
2* 20
(0/*50
6.
4*24.
/(*'(*:.:
/'(
06
7(07*4*0+5'
07'+S4*7'
H 2*
06
7.4/'
:0
j3*2*S+k
025.5.6
5*0+0
6.2 4*24.2 (025(*77*'+02 DC0 0+7'+5(.4'2 0+ 6.2 /6.,.2 :06 7.7.'R "C025(' .(,C40+5' 02 DC0 0+
0B075' 20 (0/*50+R -.(. :06*+0.( 6'2 7'+5'(+'2 H 6c4*502 :0 0250 .(,C40+5'V 60 20,C*(04'2 6. /*25. .
5(02 7.2'2 :0 /'6c5*7.2 .4=*0+5.602 +.7*0+502 DC0 20 .4'6:.+ /0(B075.40+50 . 6. /(*'(*:.: :06
7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'> 6. /027.V 6. 0('2*S+ :0 2C06'2 H 6. B'(025.7*S+R F+ 7'+5(.250 7'+ 6.
I*+Q0W*250+7*. :0 /'6c5*7.2 .4=*0+5.602 0+ 6. 4*+0(c. :0 *+*7*'2 :06 2*,6' zz .HC:.(b . B*G.( 40G'( 6.2
/(C0=.2 04/c(*7.2 :06 .(,C40+5'R
='-8#
?02:0 06 /(*+7*/*'V 6'2 *+B'(402 2'=(0 6. /027. 4.(c5*4. 2'+ 4CH 76.('2R ?02:0 6.2 7'+702*'+02 :0
7._. H /027. 0+ #.6b/.,'2 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^`M ;.25. 6'2 7'+B6*75'2 H :07'4*2'2 :0 .5C+0('2
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 45/67
dd
025.:'C+*:0+202 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^eMV 06 '=G05*3' BC0 2*04/(0 03*5.( DC0 '5('2 /.c202 ./('307;.(.+ 6'2
(07C(2'2 /02DC0('2 +.7*'+.602 2*+ .+502 :0G.( *+,(02'2 .6 B*27'R
!+ N^`LV (0B*(*i+:'20 . 6.2 *26.2 #.6b/.,'2V 06 Y*+*25(' 7'+76CH0>
!2 :0 5':' /C+5' *+:*2/0+2.=60 DC0 06 #'=*0(+' 5'40 40:*:.2 C(,0+502 /.(. 03*5.( DC0
=.(7'2 :0
5':.
+.7*'+.6*:.:
20
:0:*DC0+
. 6.
/027.
0+
06
9(7;*/*i6.,'
:0
<'6S+
H 0+
+C025(.
<'25.V 2*+ :0G.( =0+0B*7*' .6,C+' .6 /.c2 I93*6i2 9,C*((0 N^`L> NMO‐Pa 7B(R 6. 4*24.
/(0'7C/.7*S+ 0+ Z.('+. N^`d> LMQR
8.2 /02DC0(c.2 20 5(.5.+ 4b2 =*0+ 7'4' C+ (07C(2' :02/0(:*7*.:'V 7CH' 4.H'( /06*,(' 02 DC0
=0+0B*7*0 . '5('2R Y.+50+*0+:' 06 4*24' 5'+' :06 :*27C(2' :0 2C /(0:0702'(V 7.2* 30*+50 .r'2
:02/Ci2V 06 Y*+*25(' :06 (.4' /*:0 . 6'2 07C.5'(*.+'2 5'4.( 7'+7*0+7*. :0 6. *4/'(5.+7*. :06 4.( H
:0 6. /027.R "' /':04'2 3*3*( 2'6' :0 6. 5*0((.>
#(.7*.2 . 6. 0W/6'(.7*S+ 0B075C.:. /'( 06 Ki7+*7' -*27*7C65'( :C(.+50 06 402 :0 GC+*' :0 N^d^
20 ;.
/':*:'
7'+25.5.(
6.
*+40+2.
*4/'(5.+7*.
DC0
5*0+0+
/.(.
6.
07'+'4c.
+.7*'+.6
6'2
(07C(2'2 /02DC0('2 :0 #.6b/.,'2a /C02 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ :0 :*7;'2 4.(02 7'+2*:0(.:'2 7'4'
C+. :0 6.2 ,(.+:02 BC0+502 4C+:*.602 :0 .5q+V /':(c. /('/'(7*'+.( .6 @*27' BC0(502 *+,(02'2
/'( 7'+70/5' :0 :0(07;'2 0 *4/C025'2 :0 /027.V .2c 7'4' :*3*2.2 0W5(.+G0(.2 /'( 6'2
/(':C75'2 06.='(.:'2 0+ 06 50((*5'(*' +.7*'+.6V C5*6*_.+:' 5.4=*i+ 06 =.7.6.'V 5*=C(S+V 6'='
4.(*+'V 6.+,'25.V 057R IF(,066i2 <..4.r' N^eM> NMQR
"' ;0 0+7'+5(.:' 5025*4'+*'2 :0 /(0'7C/.7*S+ .6,C+. /'( C+. 030+5C.6 2'=(0 ] 0W/6'5.7*S+R Yb2
=*0+V ;.H DC0 :02.(('66.( 6.='(02 :0 3*,*6.+7*. H /.5(C66.G0 /.(. /('50,0( 0250 (07C(2'm :06 C2' *60,.6
/'( =.(7'2 :0 '5('2 /.c202R X+76C2' 2C,*0(0
K(.+2B'(4.( 6. <'6'+*. -0+.6 :0 X2.=06. 0+ C+ <0+5(' -02DC0(' 7CH. 4*2*S+ 20(c. 6. :0
/('7C(.( 7'+ C+ 5(.=.G' 2.+'V 6. (0,0+0(.7*S+ :0 6'2 /0+.:'2 H /'( DCi +' :07*(6'V 6. :0
(0;.=*6*5.( ;'4=(02 /.(. 06 4.(V q5*602 0+ 7C.6DC*0( 4'40+5' /.(. 6. :0B0+2. :0 +C025('
/.5(*4'+*' *+2C6.( IF(,066i2 <..4.r' N^eM> NNQR
?0 4.+0(. 4b2 02/07cB*7.V :C(.+50 5':' 06 /0(c':' 7'+2*:0(.:'V /.(. 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 0+7.(,.:'2
:06 504. /02DC0('V 06 /('=604. +' 02 06 0W702' :0 /027. H 06 7C*:.:' :0 6'2 7.(:q40+02V 2*+' 6.
/('4'7*S+ :0 40G'(02 H 4b2 0B*7*0+502 40:*'2 /.(. 0W/6'5.( 6'2 4.(02 50((*5'(*.602R !+ N^edV 06
?*(075'( :0 <._. H -027.V #'+_.6' "'='. !6*_.6:0V .B*(4.=.>
F+' :0
6'2
/(*+7*/.602
/('=604.2
:0
6.
/027.
0+
06
!7C.:'(
H .6
DC0
:0=04'2
:.(
2'6C7*S+
7'+ C(,0+7*. 02 06 (0B0(0+50 . 6. /0DC0r. 7.+5*:.: :0 /0702 DC0 20 '=5*0+0+ .+C.640+50 0+
7'4/.(.7*S+ 7'+ '5('2 /.c202 DC0 .67.+_.+ 0+'(402 7*B(.2 /'( 0250 7'+70/5' ImQR "' 20
/C0:0 7'+70=*( 0+ 6. i/'7. .75C.6 DC0 6. /027. 20 66030 . 7.=' 7'+ 40:*'2 :0 7./5C(. 5.+
/(*4*5*3'2 7'4' 6'2 DC0 04/60. 025. ,0+50 l6'2 /027.:'(02n ImQ 0+ 30_ :0 ='502 . (04'
:0=0(c. B.7*6*5b(20602 6. .:DC*2*7*S+ :0 /0DC0r'2 4'5'(02 ImQa 0+ 30_ :0 7.r.2 (C:*40+5.(*.2
H (0:02 .+5*7C.:.2 02 +0702.(*' /('/'(7*'+.(602 40G'(02 *+25(C40+5'2 :0 /027.a 0+ 7.:.
/C0=6' :0 /027.:'(02 /':(c. ,025*'+.(20 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :0 /0DC0r'2 B(*,'(cB*7'2 0+ 6'2 DC0
:0/'2*50+ 06 7.(,.40+5' '=50+*:' /.(. DC0 /C0:.+ 30+:0( 06 /027.:' . C+ /(07*'
(._'+.=60 ImQ I0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed> L\`QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 46/67
de
!250 '=G05*3' DC0:. 4b2 76.(' 5':.3c.V 7C.+:'V . B*+.602 :0 6. :i7.:. :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eMV 06 ,'=*0(+'
:07*:0V 6C0,' :0 6.2 *+50+2.2 6C7;.2 7'+ 6'2 .5C+0('2 025.:'C+*:0+202 H :0 6'2 7'+B6*75'2 7'+ 06
,'=*0(+' :0 6'2 !25.:'2 F+*:'2 /'( 6. 0W50+2*S+ :0 6.2 .,C.2 50((*5'(*.602 :0 6'2 /.c202 :06 -.7cB*7'
1C(V .=(*( 6.2 .,C.2 :06 #'6B' :0 #C.H.DC*6 . 6'2 =.(7'2 .5C+0('2 0W5(.+G0('2R ?.:' DC0V 20 025*4.=.V
5':.3c. 0+5'+702V DC0 +' ;.=c. C+. 7./.7*:.: :0 /027. 2CB*7*0+50V 0(. 40G'( .=(*( 6. /027. .6
0W5(.+G0(' /.(.
.2c
7'=(.(
:0(07;'2
/'(
2C
0W/6'5.7*S+R
8.
GC25*B*7.7*S+
:06
?*(075'(V
2*+
04=.(,'V
BC0
/6.+50.:. 0+ C+ (0,*25(' DC0 20 3'630(c. B(07C0+50 4b2 5.(:0 /0(' DC0 /'( 0+5'+702 +' 0W*25c. 0+ 6.
/027. 4.(c5*4.>
8'2 025C:*'2 7*0+5cB*7'2 2'=(0 6'2 .5C+02 6'2 /0702 7.(+.:.V :050(4*+.+ DC0 0+ 2075'(02 :06
$7i.+' -.7cB*7' :'+:0 20 ;. 0G0(7*:' /027. 4.2*3. 7'+ ,(.+:02 B6'5.2V j+' ;.H 03*:0+7*. :0
DC0 6. .=C+:.+7*. ./.(0+50 5*0+:. . 6. 40(4.kV H .q+ 6.2 3.(*.7*'+02 0+ 06 5.4.r' :0
7*0(5.2 02/07*02V /C0:0+ .5(*=C*(20 . B.75'(02 +.5C(.602 H :06 =*'5'/' 4.(*+' 0+ DC0 20
:02.(('66. H .6*40+5.+R !+ 6. /027. :0 7.(+.:. /.(. .5q+ 2'6' 20 C5*6*_. C+. 4c+*4. /.(50 :0
6. .=C+:.+7*. H +C025(. B6'5. +' 025b /'( ;'HV 0+ 7'+:*7*'+02 :0 .,'5.(6. ImQ IY'(50+20+
N^OM> \NQR
1'6' .6 B*+.6 :06 /0(c':' :0 025C:*' ./.(070 0+ 6.2 :*27C2*'+02 2'=(0 6. /027. 4.(c5*4. 6. +0702*:.:
:0 .76.(.( DC0 7*0(5'2 025C:*'2 .3.6.=.+ DC0 ;.=c. 02/.7*' /.(. C+. /02DC0(c. DC0 +' :025(CH0(. 2C
=.20 :0 (07C(2'2R !+ C+ 7'+50W5' :0 ./.(0+50 .=C+:.+7*. *+B*+*5.V 7C.+:' 06 (07C(2' DC0 ;.70 6.
=.20 :06 +0,'7*' +' /.(070 0+ /06*,('V 5.(:.+ 0+ .B6'(.( 6.2 /(0'7C/.7*'+02 .4=*0+5.602 :06 !25.:'R
!6 7'+5(.250 7'+ 6. /027. :0 .,C. :C670 02 +'5'(*'R 8. /(0'7C/.7*S+ /'( 6'2 (07C(2'2 BC0 4C7;' 4b2
504/(.+. H 5*0+0 DC0 30( .+50 5':' 7'+ C+ 7'+B6*75' :0 *+50(0202 0+5(0 :*25*+5'2 .75'(02 2'7*.602R !+
0B075'V H. 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^`MV 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 *+2*250+ 0+ DC0 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 6'2 (07C(2'2 H 06
4.+0G' :0 6'2 7'+B6*75'2 2'7*.602 0W*,0+ 7.4=*.( 06 0+B'DC0 :06 7'+5('6 :0 6'2 (c'2 :02:0 .75'(02
/(*3.:'2 ;.7*. 06 !25.:'R !6 #'=0(+.:'( :0 6. /('3*+7*. 7'250(. :0 8'2 Ec'2 0W/6*7.>
!2 7'25C4=(0 025.=607*:. H 5'60(.:. :02:0 ;.70 4C7;' 5*04/' DC0 6'2 /('/*05.(*'2 :0
/(0:*'2 /'( 6'2 DC0 .5(.3*02.+ 6'2 (c'2 /0DC0r'2 ' (*.7;C06'2 20 7(00+ :C0r'2 :0 066'2 H
30+:0+ 06 66.4.:' :0(07;' :0 /027. H 0W76C2*3. . 7'+5(.5*25.2 DC0V . 2C 30_V 0W/6'5.+
*+4*20(*7'(:040+50 . 6'2 *+B06*702 7.4/02*+'2 DC0 3*30+ :06 +0,'7*' :0 6. /027. H .7./.(.+
0+ 7025'2 ' 5(.4/.2 06 /027.:' /.(. ;.70(6' 2C=*( :0 /(07*'2 0+ 06 40(7.:' :0 3c30(02 ImQR !6
2*2504. :0 /027. 7'+2*250 0+ 5./.( 6'2 (c'2 H 0250('2 7'+ /.r' ' (0:02 /.(.V ./('307;.+:' 6.
7'((*0+50 :0 6.2 .,C.2V 0B075C.( 6. (07'6077*S+ :0 6'2 /0702 DC0 2'+ 7'+:C7*:'2 . 7025'2 H
5(.4/.2 ImQ I7*5.:. 0+ Z.('+. N^`d> LLQ
96,C+'2 :0 6'2 /027.:'(02 .7'25C4=(.+ 06 C2' :06 30+0+' ' 6. :*+.4*5.R -C025' DC0 6'2 (c'2 +' ;.+
2*:' 7'+25(C*:'2 /'( '=(. :06 ;'4=(0V .(,C40+5. 06 #'=0(+.:'( 7'+ 06 <S:*,' <*3*6 . 6. 4.+'V
/0(50+070+ . 6. ".7*S+ H :0=0+ 7'+2*:0(.(20 4C+*7*/.602R -('/'+0 0+5'+702 C+. '(:0+.+_. 2'=(0 6.
/027. 0+ 6'2 (c'2 0+ 6. DC0 20 /(';c=0 6. /027. 7'+ 30+0+'V 7'+ 0W/6'2*3'2 ' 0+ i/'7. :0 *+7C=.7*S+
I7*5.:' 0+ Z.('+. N^`d> LeQRN^ "' ;0 /':*:' .q+ 0+7'+5(.( 6. 60,*26.7*S+ B*+.640+50 ./('=.:. 2'=(0
06 504. /0(' 6' DC0 2.=04'2 (0306. C+. 504/(.+. /(0'7C/.7*S+ /'( 4':*B*7.( :02:0 06 !25.:' 6'2
.((0,6'2 :0 .7702' H C2' /(*3.:'2 :0 6'2 (07C(2'2 /02DC0('2 0+ 6'2 (c'2 /.(. 7'+20(3.( 6'2 (07C(2'2R
N^
!+
'75C=(0
:0
N^d^V
6'2
BC+7*'+.(*'2
07C.5'(*.+'2
DC0
.2*25*0('+
.6
<'+,(02'
8.5*+'.40(*7.+'
:0
-027.
H
Z*'6',c. Y.(*+. 0+ %.6/.(.c2'V <;*60V /('/C2*0('+ DC0 20 /(';*=*0(. 06 C2' :0 =.(=.27' H '5('2 30+0+'2 0+ 6. /07. IF(,066i2
<..4.r' N^eM> NM\QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 47/67
dO
?1*-%\&
8. /(*40(. 40+7*S+ DC0 ./.(070 0+ 6'2 *+B'(402 4*+*250(*.602 .6 504. :0 6. 0('2*S+ 02 C+. 6.(,.
(0B60W*S+ :0 N^dL 2'=(0 06 .,'5.4*0+5' :0 6. 5*0((. 0+ 6.2 ;.7*0+:.2 :0 6. .2*250+7*. /q=6*7.R 8'
66.4.5*3' :06 5025*4'+*' 02 DC0 06 Y*+*25(' .(,C40+5. DC0 06 2*2504. :0 .((0+:.4*0+5' :0 6.2
;.7*0+:.2V .6 6*4*5.( 06 ;'(*_'+50 504/'(.6 :06 4.+0G' 07'+S4*7' /'( /.(50 :06 .((0+:.5.(*'V
*+70+5*3. 06 :027C*:' :0 6. 5*0((.R -('/'+0 6. /(*3.5*_.7*S+ 0+ /.(706.2 6' 2CB*7*0+5040+50 ,(.+:02
7'4' /.(. .20,C(.( C+. /(':C77*S+ (0+5.=60 H 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 6'2 (07C(2'2>
!2 4* :0=0( :.( 6. 3'_ :0 .6.(4. (02/075' .6 *+40:*.5' BC5C(' 7.5.25(SB*7' .6 /C+5' :0 3*25.
:0 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 5.602 2C06'2R 1CG05'2 7'4' 025b+ . C+ 2*2504. :0 0W/6'5.7*S+
7'40(7*.6V 02 6S,*7' H 7'4/(0+2*=60 ImQ DC0 06 .((0+:.5.(*' 7'+:C_7. 2C 04/(02. 7'+ 06
7(*50(*' :06 4bW*4' (0+:*4*0+5' H :0 6. 4c+*4. (0;.=*6*5.7*S+ :0 6.2 5*0((.2 ImQ 2* +' 2'+ 6'2
:C0r'2 :0 6.2 5*0((.2 +* ;.H 60H DC0 602 '=6*,C0 . 40G'(.(6'2V /C02 0W/6'5.(6.2 . 2C 4bW*4.
7./.7*:.: ;.25. DC0 50(4*+0 06 .((0+:.4*0+5' ImQR 1C,*0('V /C02V DC0 20 7'+2*:0(0> ' 6.
7'+30+*0+7*. :0 :*75.( C+. 60H DC0 '=6*,C0 . 6'2 .75C.602 .((0+:.5.(*'2 . /('70:0( . 6.
(07C/0(.7*S+ :0 6'2 2C06'2 :0 025. 7C.+5*'2. H 3.6*'2c2*4. (*DC0_. /.5(*4'+*.6 :06 !25.:'a '
20,C+:'V 6. 7'+30+*0+7*. :0 30+:0( 5.602 /(0:*'2 H 7'+ 06 4'+5' :0 2C 3.6'( BC+:.( 06 =.+7'
:0 6. Z0+0B*70+7*. -q=6*7.R [C0 20 7'+3*0(5.+ 6'2 .((0+:.5.(*'2 0+ :C0r'2 :0 02.2 5*0((.2V 0+
=C0+. ;'(.a /0(' DC0 +' /0(2*25. 06 (i,*40+ 02DC*64.+50 :0 0250 /.5(*4'+*' 66.4.:' .
:02./.(070( 5.6 7C.6 3.+ 6.2 7'2.2R 8. 30+5. :0 025.2 ;.7*0+:.2 :0=*0(. ;.70(20 +' 7'+ 06
7(*50(*' /.(706.(*' 4*+*BC+:*25.V 2*+' 7'+ 06 :0 6'5*_.7*S+ :0 b(0.2 6' +0702.(*.40+50
.:07C.:.2 7'4' /.(. .20,C(.( 6. 3*:. '(,b+*7. H /0(4.+0+7*. :0 6. 04/(02. .,(c7'6. .
7(0.(20R !6 0+2.H' ;.25. ;'H (0.6*_.:' 0+ 06 /.c2V :0 6. /0DC0r. /.(706.7*S+ +' ;. :.:' 06
(02C65.:' DC0 20 02/0(.=. ImQR !+ 06 40G'( :0 6'2 7.2'2V 6'2 /'200:'(02 :0 2C /0DC0r.
/.(706.
(02'63*0('+
2C2 +0702*:.:02
:'4i25*7.2
2*+
6',(.(
./'(5.(
+*+,q+
7'+5*+,0+50
:0
/(':C77*S+ . 40(7.:' +.7*'+.6 ImQ DC0 7.:. /0DC0r. ;.7*0+:. 7C0+50 7'+ (07C(2'2 7'4' 2*
:*Gi(.4'2 '(,b+*7'2 /.(. 6. 20,C(*:.: H /0(4.+0+7*. :0 2* 3*:. 0+ BC+7*S+ /(':C75'(.> b(0.2
2CB*7*0+502 /.(. 6. ('5.7*S+ :0 7C65*3'2a 7C'5. :0 .,C.2 H ='2DC02 +0702.(*'2a :06*4*5.7*S+ :0
6.2 2C/0(B*7*02 /'( .77*:0+502 +.5C(.602V 057RV 20(c. C+ 2*2504. /.(706.(*' DC0 ;.=*6*5.(c.
*+76C2*30 . 6'2 +C03'2 :C0r'2 :0 02.2 B*+7.2 . '=50+0( 7'+ B.7*6*:.: 06 7(i:*5' .,(c7'6.
2CB*7*0+50 /.(. B'40+5.( 2C 04/(02. ImQ I<(02/' $(:Sr0_ N^dL> N\‐N^QRLM
!6 :0=.50 2'=(0 6. /.(706.7*S+ :0 6.2 5*0((.2V 2'=(0 6. 7'6'+*_.7*S+ H 06 (0/.(5' .,(.(*'V 2'=(0 06
5.4.r' .:07C.:' :0 6. /('/*0:.:V 2C2 0B075'2 /(':C75*3'2V 2'7*.602 H /'6c5*7'2V BC0 4CH *+50+2' 0+
06 !7C.:'(
0+
6.
/(*40(.
4*5.:
:06
2*,6'R
96,C+'2
0+B.5*_.=.+
06
3.6'(
:0
6.
/0DC0r.
/('/*0:.:
H
'5('2 6. 7'+30+*0+7*. :0 6. ,(.+:0V 7'4' 06 Y*+*25(' E*7.(:' <(02/'RLN -0(' i25. 02 6. q+*7. 40+7*S+
DC0 ;0 0+7'+5(.:' .6 0B075' DC0 5*0+0 2'=(0 6. 0('2*S+ H 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 6'2 2C06'2R
?0 ;07;'V 6. 0('2*S+ 2'6' /.(070 ;.=0(20 7'+30(5*:' 0+ C+ 504. :0 /'6c5*7. .,('/07C.(*. . /.(5*( :0
6'2 .r'2 N^dMR 8.2 40+7*'+02 .+50(*'(02 2'+ 5.+,0+7*.602R 92cV 0+ 6.2 025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602
30+c.+ ;.7*i+:'20 .6,C+.2 *+3025*,.7*'+02 2'=(0 (025*5C7*S+ :0 6. 4.50(*. '(,b+*7. :02:0 6'2 .r'2
N^`M 0+ 06 7.2' :0 7C65*3'2 0W*,0+502 7'4' 06 .6,':S+R j!6 0W702' :0 7C65*3' 0+ C+ 4*24' 50((0+' 2*+
LM !6 :0=.50 5.4=*i+ 0W*25*S 0+ 6. 9(,0+5*+. :0 *+*7*'2 :06 2*,6' zz .6(0:0:'( :0 6'2 0B075'2 .4=*0+5.602 :0 6'2 2*2504.2 :0
.((0+:.4*0+5' H ./.(70(c.
I7B(R
Z.C:
.DC*QR
LN -.(. C+. 0W/'2*7*S+ :0 DC*0+02 025.=.+ . B.3'( :0 6. /0DC0r. /('/*0:.: H 2C2 (._'+02V 7B(R 6. 0W/'2*7*S+ :06 Y*+*25(' :0
$=(.2 -q=6*7.2 -0:(' Y*660( IN^`N> ^OQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 48/67
dP
+*+,C+. (025*5C7*S+ :0 6.2 4.50(*.2 B0(5*6*_.+502 .,'5.:.2 0+ 7'207;.2 2C702*3.2 02 6. 7.C2. :0 0250
:0=*6*5.4*0+5'k IZ.('+. N^``> NLQR -'( 02'V 6. 7'25C4=(0 :05075.:. 0+ 6. /('3*+7*. :0 X4=.=C(. :0
204=(.( 4.c_ GC+5' .6 .6,':S+ /.(. B*+.+7*.(6' :0=0 (07;._.(20V /('2*,C0 06 Y*+*25('R -0(' 6.
/(0'7C/.7*S+ 20 3C0630 2*2504b5*7. 0+ 6. 2*,C*0+50 :i7.:.R
!+ 7*0(5. B'(4.V 06 0W /(02*:0+50 h'2i Y.(c. %06.27' X=.((. 'B(070 06 5'+' H 06 7'+50+*:' :0 6'2
:*27C(2'2 BC5C('2 2'=(0 06 504.>
K0+04'2 DC0 7'+70+5(.( +C025(. .75*3*:.: 0+ 6. (0,*S+ 4b2 (*7. l6. <'25.n H 5(.5.( :0
40G'(.( 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 .,(c7'6.2 0+ +C025(. 1*0((. 7CH. _'+. 7C65*3.=60 025b 7.2* .,'5.:.R 10
60 /*:*S . 6. 1*0((. 5':' 6' DC0 /C:' :.(V /0(' +' 20 60 .HC:SV +' 20 60 0+5(0,S +.:.R 8. 1*0((.
5*0+0 DC0 B'40+5.( 6. ,.+.:0(c.V (02'63*0+:' .2c C+' :0 6'2 /('=604.2 4b2 ,(.302 :06 -.c2 ]
6. 027.20_ :0 7.(+0 H 607;0 ] H /('7C(.( C+ :027.+2' 0+ 6'2 50((0+'2 04/'=(07*:'2 /'( 6.
0('2*S+ I%06.27' X=.((. 0+ Z.6.+70 N^dO> L`OQR
F+ /'7' .+502 :0 6. (03'6C7*S+ :0 4.H'V 6.2 025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602 .,(c7'6.2 ;.=c.+ 04/0_.:'
*+3025*,.7*'+02 2*2504b5*7.2
2'=(0
06
4.+0G'
.,(c7'6.
/.(.
03*5.(
6.
0('2*S+
7'4=*+.+:'
6.
('5.7*S+
:0 7C65*3'2V 06 ./'(50 :0 /6.+5.2 B'((.G0(.2 H 2*2504.2 2*63'/.25'(*602>
92c 7'4' 6. *+7'(/'(.7*S+ :0 +C03.2 5*0((.2 =0+0B*7*.(c. . 6. /(':C77*S+V .2c 5.4=*i+ 06
025.=607*4*0+5' :0 C+ 2*2504. :0 .650(+.=*6*:.: ' ('5.7*S+ :0 7C65*3'2 0+ _'+.2 0W/6'5.:.2V
02/07*.640+50 0+ .DC066.2 0+ DC0 20 /(020+5.+ H. 76.('2 B0+S40+'2 :0 04/'=(07*4*0+5'V
20(c. .65.40+50 =0+0B*7*'2'R E.7*'+.6*_.( 6'2 5(.=.G'2V .='+.( 6'2 50((0+'2V 03*5.( :026.302V
+*5(',0+.( 6'2 2C06'2V 02 .6,' BC+:.40+5.6 0+ 06 /('702' :0 40G'(.4*0+5' .,(c7'6. ImQ 8.
B'(4.7*S+ :0 /'5(0('2 H 7.4/'2 :0 /.25'(0' 0+ 6.2 5*0((.2 4CH 5(.=.G.:.2 7'4' 40:*' :0
(07C/0(.7*S+ :06 /':0( 30,05.5*3' 02 .2/075' 5i7+*7' +0702.(*' ImQ 7'+ 6. .:'/7*S+ :06
2*2504.
:0
7C65*3'2
DC0
30+,'
/(0,'+.+:'V
025'H GC25.40+50
5(.5.+:'
:0
0+7.C2.(
6.
/(':C77*S+ /'( C+ (*54' 20,C(' :0 40G'(.4*0+5'> H. DC0 6'2 7.4/'2 DC0 ;.+ 50+*:'
./('307;.4*0+5' :0 .='+'2 +*5(',0+.:'2 ./'(5.:'2 /'( 6.2 /6.+5.2 B'((.G0(.2 .2c 7'4' /'(
6'2 :02/0(:*7*'2 '(,b+*7'2 .+*4.602V .6 7'+30(5*(6'2 4b2 5.(:0 0+ 5*0((.2 6.='(.=602V 2C c+:*70
:0 (0+:*4*0+5' 02 4.,+cB*7' H 6'2 (02C65.:'2V =0+0B*7*'2'2 2'+ /.(. 5':'2 IE'7. <.(=' N^d`>
%XXX‐XzQR
1'6' . B*+02 :0 6. :i7.:.V 7'+ #.6' -6._. 8.22' H 6. *((C/7*S+ :0 C+ ,(C/' 7(07*0+50 :0 5i7+*7'2
/(0'7C/.:'2 /'( 6. B'(025.7*S+V 20 3*+7C6.(c. :0B*+*5*3.40+50 06 504. :0 6. 0('2*S+ H 06 :0 6'2
b(='602>
Y.50(*. :0 2*+,C6.( /(0'7C/.7*S+ /'( /.(50 :0 025. !+5*:.: ;. 2*:' 06 /('=604. :0 6.
B'(025.7*S+ H (0B'(025.7*S+ :06 /.c2V :06 DC0 5.+5' 20 ;. 30+*:' ;.=6.+:' H /'( 06 7C.6 7.2'
+.:. 20 ;.=c. ;07;' /020 . DC0 6.2 5*0((.2V 02/07*.640+50 6.2 70(7.+.2 . 6'2 70+5('2
*+:C25(*.602 H :0 7'+2C4' *=.+ DC0:.+:' 5.6.:.2 :0 2C2 b(='602 H +' 20 (0/'+c.+ 6'2
='2DC02 0W/6'5.:'2 :02:0 5*04/' *+404'(*.6V 7'+ 6' 7C.6 06 /.c2 025.=. .B('+5.+:' C+
,(.3c2*4' /('=604. 5.+5' 0+ 6' DC0 . 027.20_ :0 4.:0(. 20 (0B*0(0 7'4' . 6. 7'4/6*7.7*S+
7'+2*,C*0+50 DC0 06 :02./.(07*4*0+5' :06 b(='6 2*,+*B*7. /.(. 6'2 50((0+'2V /'( B.65. :0
:0B0+2.2 +.5C(.602 . 6. 0('2*S+ IX+25*5C5' N^eM> L^QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 49/67
d\
!+ (02C40+V 2'6' . /.(5*( :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dM 6. 0('2*S+ ./.(070 7'4' C+ /('=604. :0 /'6c5*7. /q=6*7.
/'( 06 .,'5.4*0+5' :06 /'50+7*.6 .,(c7'6. :0 6. 1*0((.R !+ 020+7*. 02 7'+2*:0(.:' C+ (02C65.:' :0 6.2
/(b75*7.2 .,(c7'6.2 H 2'6' 4b2 5.(:c.40+50V . B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dMV 20 6' .2'7*. . 6. :0B'(025.7*S+R
?0 +C03'V 20 3C0630 C+ /('=604. /.(. 06 !25.:' 7C.+:' 660,. . .B075.( +0,.5*3.40+50 6. /(':C77*S+V
20. 0+ 6.2 ;.7*0+:.2 /q=6*7.2V 20. 0+ 6.2 5*0((.2 :0 6. (0,*S+ 4b2 /'=6.:. :06 /.c2R
7*1'-,#8%\&
8. *+30(2*S+ 0+ B'(025.7*S+ 7'+ 02/07*02 :0 *+50(i2 4.:0(0(' 2C(,*S 4C7;' .+502R J.=c. 3*30('2
B'(025.602 0+ 7.2* 5':.2 6.2 025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602 H H. :02:0 B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^LM 20 B'(4.('+
3*30('2 0+ 94=.5' H <C0+7.R 8. *:0. 0(. /(':C7*( 4.:0(.V +' /('50,0( 6'2 2C06'2 :0 6. 1*0((.V
:'+:0 5.+5' 20 7.(070 :0 b(='602V l025. (0,*S+n /':(b :*2/'+0( :0 C+. :*25(*=C7*S+ 20,C(.
:0 7.2* C+ 4*66S+ :0 b(='602 .+C.640+50V 2'=(0 5':' :0 6'2 :0 020+7*.2 B'(025.602V :0
4.:0(.2 2C.302V DC0 +' 6.2 ;.H I!,|0_ Z.DC0(*_' N^L\> P^QR
!+ N^L^
20
7(0S
C+.
025.7*S+
0+50(.40+50
:0:*7.:.
. 6.
/('4'7*S+
:0
6.
2*04=(.
:0
7'+cB0(.2
0+
6'2 /b(.4'2V 6. !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 <'5'/.W*R !6 02BC0(_'V 7'+ (02C65.:'2 :*27(05'2V 20
4.+50+:(c. . 6' 6.(,' :06 2*,6'R Yb2 .66b :0 6.2 *+50+7*'+02 :0 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2V 6.2 :*40+2*'+02 :06
02BC0(_' 7.4=*.('+ 7'+ 06 5*04/'> 0+ N^`L 6. !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 :0 <'5'/.W* 0+5(0,S d 4*6
7*/(0202V /*+'2 H '5(.2 /6.+5.2 . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 IY'6025*+. N^`L> ^Q 4*0+5(.2 DC0 0+5(0 N^eM H N^e`
20 (0/.(5*(c.+ LV^ 4*66'+02 :0 /6.+5.2 I"0='5 %06.27' N^ed> `M`QR !+ N^`M 6. !25.7*S+ :0 <'5'/.W* +'
0(. 6. q+*7. 0+ 0+5(0,.( b(='602> 6. ,(.+G. .,(c7'6. :0 [C*5' ;.=c. 0+5(0,.:' ,(.5C*5.40+50 dMM 4*6
7'+cB0(.2 . 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02 BC0(. :0 6.2 DC0 204=(.('+ 0+ <'5'/.W* IZ'6'r. N^`M> LdQR
!+ 6'2 .r'2 N^`M 6. B'(025.7*S+ 5.4=*i+ 7C4/6c. C+. 5.(0. :0 4b2 .4/6*.2 *4/6*7.7*'+02 7CH'2
7'+5'(+'2 +'2
.HC:.+
. B*G.(
6.
4.,+*5C:
:0
6'2
7.4=*'2
DC0
20
*(c.+
B'(G.+:'
0+
6.
:i7.:.
2*,C*0+50R
8.2 /6.+5.7*'+02 7C4/6c.+ 06 '=G05*3' :0 ./('307;.( 6'2 /b(.4'2V ;.25. 0+5'+702 j:02/0(:*7*.:'2k>
!6 !7C.:'( BC0V :C(.+50 6. i/'7. :06 7'6'+*.G0V C+ =C0+ /(':C75'( :0 6.+. H 02 +.5C(.6 H
/'2*=60 DC0 /C0:. 3'630( . 20(6' 0+ 6. /(020+50V ;'H DC0 5*0+0 5.+ =C0+ /(07*' :*7;'
.(5c7C6'R 9:04b2V 6. 0+'(40 0W50+2*S+ :0 50((0+' 7.2* :02/0(:*7*.:' DC0 (0/(020+5.+
+C025('2 /b(.4'2V /C0:0 C5*6*_.(20 0+ 06 7C65*3' :0 7'+cB0(.2V (*DC0_. B.=C6'2. DC0 (02'630(c.
+' 2'6' 06 /('=604. :0 6. 027.20_ :0 4.:0(. 0+ 06 *+50(*'( :0 6. E0/q=6*7. 2*+' 7'+25*5C*(c.
5.4=*i+ C+ 4.,+cB*7' (0+,6S+ :0 0W/'(5.7*S+ IZ'6'r. N^`M> LdQR
8.2 ,.+.+7*.2 /(':C7*:.2 /'( 6. 0W5(.77*S+ :0 3.(*'2 /(':C75'2 B'(025.602 0+ 6.2 2063.2 5('/*7.602
.60+5.=.+ 06 *+50(i2 /'( C+. 0W/6'5.7*S+ .:07C.:. H (.7*'+.6R ?0 ;07;'V :C(.+50 6. :i7.:. :0 6'2
.r'2 N^`M 6.2 0W/'(5.7*'+02 :0 /(':C75'2 B'(025.602 ;.=c.+ 7(07*:' 7'+2*:0(.=6040+50 0+
4'40+5'2 0+ DC0 20 =C27.=.+ .B.+'2.40+50 2C25*5C5'2 :06 7.7.' 2*+ DC0 +*+,C+' 5':.3c. 6' 6',(.(.
/60+.40+50R !+ 06 <C.:(' d /C0:0 ./(07*.(20 DC0 ;C=' .6 40+'2 7C.5(' /(':C75'2 B'(025.602 7CH.
0W/'(5.7*S+ 7(07*S 0+ 6. :i7.:. 4b2 (b/*:.40+50 DC0 06 /('40:*' :0 5':'2 6'2 /(':C75'2
0W/'(5.:'2 H DC0 /.(. *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dM GC+5'2 2C/0(.=.+ 6.2 0W/'(5.7*'+02 :0 .(('_ ' :0 7.Bi
H 5(*/6*7.=.+ 6.2 :0 =.+.+'R 8. 5.,C. 0(.V . B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^`MV 06 7C.(5' (C=(' :0 0W/'(5.7*S+ :06
/.c2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 50/67
d^
J(3@/& 5" )L4&/B3>1&$#A @# 4/&@(>B&A 3%/K>&C3A M9N:7‐9N57O M#$ =1C#A @# A(>/#AO
-E$?F<K$ [C*+DC0+*' N^`L‐`O [C*+DC0+*' N^`P‐dN x :0 .C40+5'
9(('_ NdRNL` ePRNed `MdVP
<.7.' NMLRd` ̀ N^MRMN` \eVe
<.Bi O\Re^P ^ORPed dNVM
<.C7;' eRPLN L`Rd^N `NMVO
Z.+.+' NNR\ML `NROLM NOPV^
8*4'+02 NO `L NMMVM
Y.+,'2 NP` eOP LLPVP
".(.+G.2 NRdOL dRLLN N\\VP
-*r.2 NNM `L\ N^\VL
8.+. :0 <0*=' LRN^P eRd`` NdPV`
Y.:0(. :0 Z.62. LROO ̂ NPR\`O eO\V`
K.,C. LdRMLd d^RO^P NMOV^
;,;FE 7::":7V 5VV"95W 9856S
@C0+50> <(02/' $(:Sr0_ IN^dL> 9+0W'V 2R/Q
?0 ;07;'V i250 BC0 06 7.4/' :0 .6,C+'2 :0 6'2 /(*40('2 :07(05'2 :0 /('5077*S+ :0 (07C(2'2 0+ 06
/.c2R !6 LO :0 :*7*04=(0 :0 N^`OV 06 4*24' .r' :0 7(0.7*S+ :06 .(020(3. :0 /027. 0+ #.6b/.,'2V 20
:*75S 6. 80H "'R NMd DC0 /('50,c. .6 -.6' :0 Z.62. H .6 <0*='R !6 ?07(05' 0W/6*7. DC0 j:0=*:' . 2C
7'+5*+C. 7'((*0+50 :0 0W/'(5.7*S+ l06 /.6' :0 =.62.n 3. :02./.(07*0+:' /.C6.5*+.40+50k H 5.4=*0+
06 b(='6 :0 <0*=' Ij6.+. 30,05.6 :0 ,(.+ *+50(i2 /.(. 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+kQR -'( 066'V /'( 7.:. NMM b(='602
:0 =.62. DC0 7'(50+ 20 :07(05. 6. '=6*,.7*S+ :0 204=(.( C+. ;075b(0. . C+. :*25.+7*. :0 /'( 6'
40+'2 NM 405('2 0+5(0 066'2R K':' .,(*7C65'( DC0 (0.6*70 C+ /(i25.4' 0+ 06 Z.+7' J*/'507.(*' 0+
_'+.2 :0 /(':C77*S+ :0 /.6' :0 =.62. 025.(b '=6*,.:' . 04/60.( 06 NMx :06 3.6'( :06 /(i25.4' /.(.
025.=6070( 7C65*3'2 :0 /.6' :0 =.62. 2.63' DC0 ;.H. *+B'(40 :0 6. 2077*S+ 5i7+*7. :06 =.+7' DC0
.7(0:*50 DC0 6. /(':C77*S+ :0 =.62. +' 02 /'2*=60R 9 2C 30_V 6'2 /('/*05.(*'2 :0 50((0+'2 :'+:0 06
70*=' 7(070 02/'+5b+0.40+50 5*0+0+ DC0 204=(.( NM b(='602 :0 70*=' ' :0 ~./') /'( 7.:. ;075b(0.
:0 50((0+' DC0 /'20.+ I#C0((0(' N^`P> LLL‐`QR
!6 .Bb+ :0 0W/6'5.( 025'2 (0+,6'+02 2*+ /0(:0( 6. BC0+50 :0 6'2 (07C(2'2 6603S . .6,C+'2 7.4=*'2
*+25*5C7*'+.602 . *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dMR !6 Y*+*25(' :06 E.4' 0+ N^dM 0(. /0(B075.40+50
7'+27*0+50 DC0 06 4i5':' :0 0W5(.77*S+ 2*+ (0/'2*7*S+ +' /':c. :C(.(a /0(' 7'+2*:0(.=. DC0 0(.
*4/'2*=60 03*5.( 6. :025(C77*S+ 2*+ 40:*:.2 (0/(02*3.2 /C025' DC0 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ :0 ='2DC02
+.5C(.602 0(. 4b2 =.(.5. DC0 06 7C65*3' 0+ /6.+5.7*'+02R hC+5' . 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ :0 C+ 7C0(/' :0
3*,*6.+7*. /.(. 6'2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602V /('/C2' 6. *+25.C(.7*S+ :0 C+ 2C=2*:*' /.(. 6. /6.+5.7*S+ :0 6.2
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 51/67
eM
02/07*02 7'40(7*.602 7'4' 6. /.G. 5'DC*66.V 06 /.6' :0 =.62.V 06 7.C7;'V 06 70*='V 6. 5.,C.V H 6.2
4.:0(.2 B*+.2 I!2/*+'2. N^dM> LNQR
<'4' B(C5' :0 025'2 02BC0(_'2V H +0702*:.:02V .2c 7'4' :0 6.2 7.4/.r.2 :0 6'2 +.5C(.6*25.2
6*:0(.:'2 /'( Y*2.06 97'25. 1'6c2V 0+ N^dL 20 7(0S 06 20(3*7*' :0 1*63*7C65C(. H E0B'(025.7*S+ :0+5('
:06 Y*+*250(*' :0 9,(*7C65C(. 7'+ 6. *+50+7*S+ :0 ./6*7.( 6. j80H :0 E0B'(025.7*S+ $=6*,.5'(*.k DC0V
20,q+ (07'+'70 06 0+7.(,.:' ,C=0(+.40+5.6V +' 20 /C0:0 7C4/6*( /'( 06 (0:C7*:' /0(2'+.6R !6
20(3*7*' :0 ,C.(:.='2DC02 /.(. *4/0:*( 6. :03.25.7*S+ :0 b(='602 :0 7.27.(*66.V :0 7.C7;' H :0 /.6'
:0 =.62. 5':.3c. +' 20 ;.=c. 7(0.:' 0+ GC+*' :0 N^d` IE'7. <.(=' N^d`> `N‐LQR 92cV /C02V . *+*7*'2 :0
6'2 .r'2 N^dMV .2'7*.:' . 6. +0702*:.: :0 4.+50+0( C+. (*DC0_. 0W/'(5.:'(. 7(07*0+50 DC0 20 /'+0
0+ (*02,'V 04/*0_. :i=*640+50 6. .77*S+ 025.5.6 /.(. 06 7C*:.:' :0 6'2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602V /0('
2*04/(0 .2'7*.:. . 6. /('5077*S+ :0 b(='602 02/07cB*7'2 :0 *+50(i2 7'40(7*.6R
!+ 0B075'V 204=(.( b(='602 02 C+. 7'2.V 6'2 b(='602 +' 204=(.:'2 2'+ '5(. 7'2. 4CH :*25*+5.R @C0(.
:06 4C+:' :0 6'2 5i7+*7'2 02/07*.6*_.:'2V .C+DC0 6. 4.:0(. 02 3*25. 0+ 025'2 .r'2 7'4' .6,'
/'2*5*3' H C+. (*DC0_. ./('307;.=60V 6'2 ='2DC02 H 2063.2V 0+ 7.4=*'V (0/(020+5.+ C+ 0+04*,'R 96
40+'2 .2c 6' 0+50+:c. 06 4b2 *4/'(5.+502 /'6c5*7' :06 2*,6' zz 07C.5'(*.+'V h'2i Y.(c. %06.27' X=.((.
0+ N^de>
#'=0(+.( 02 /'=6.(R K0+04'2 DC0 /'=6.( 06 $(*0+50R 9=(*( 7.4*+'2R !25.=6070( 7'6'+*.2R
J.70( DC0 6. 5i7+*7. 7*3*6*70 6.2 2063.2 ImQR 8. 5i7+*7. 6' 30+70 5':'R 1063.2 H /.+5.+'2 :0
.H0( 2'+ ;'H 6.2 7*C:.:02 4b2 02/6i+:*:.2 :06 4C+:' ImQR 8. 0:C7.7*S+ 0+ 06 $(*0+50 5*0+0
DC0 20( .7'4/.r.:. :06 02BC0(_' 4*2*'+0('a /0(' 6. 03.+,06*_.7*S+ +' ;. :0 50+0( B'(4.
(C5*+.(*. H .C5'4b5*7. 2*+' DC0 ;. :0 *+2/*(.(20 0+ 6'2 :.5'2 :0 6. /2*7'6',c. 4':0(+. 2'=(0
06 ;'4=(0 :0 6.2 2063.2 I0+ Z.6.+70 N^dO> `OdQRLL
1*+ 04=.(,'V
0+
6'2
.r'2
N^dMV
0+
7'+5(.250
7'+
6.
*4.,0+
4*2*'+0(.
H 03.+,06*_.:'(.
:0
6.2
2063.2V
/('/*. :0 6'2 .65'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 H /'6c5*7'2V C+ /0DC0r' ,(C/' :0 7*0+5cB*7'2 +.5C(.6*25.2
07C.5'(*.+'2V 6*:0(.:'2 /'( Y*2.06 97'25. 1'6c2V :02.(('66.(b+ 0+ /.(.606' C+. 6c+0. :0
.(,C40+5.7*S+ :*25*+5.R 9DCc 0+7'+5(.4'2 :0 +C03' 6. :*25*+7*S+ 0+5(0 5i7+*7'2 H /'6c5*7'2 :0+5('
:06 !25.:'R !25'2 7*0+5cB*7'2 H BC+7*'+.(*'2 :0 +*306 40:*' 5(.5.(b+ :0 4'25(.( *,1*- =0+0B*7*'2 :0 6'2
b(='602 7'4' 6. (0,C6.7*S+ :06 76*4. ' 06 7'+5('6 :0 6. 0('2*S+R 9:04b2V =C27.(b+ 4'25(.( DC0 6.2
2063.2 +.5C(.602 5.4=*i+ 2'+ q5*602V +' 2'6' C+ :02/0(:*7*' ' C+ (0_.,' DC0 ;.H DC0 30+70(a 2'+ C+
(07C(2' DC0 ;.H DC0 ./('307;.(R
"*7'6b2 <C3* ILMMe> NNe‐\Q ;. 66.4.:' 6. .50+7*S+ 2'=(0 6. *4/'(5.+7*. :0 6. 7.4/.r. :0 7*0+5cB*7'2
+.5C(.6*25.2
07C.5'(*.+'2
0+
6.
7(0.7*S+
:06
?0/.(5.40+5'
@'(025.6
:0+5('
:06
Y*+*250(*'
:0
!7'+'4c. /'( 06 ,'=*0(+' :0 #.6' -6._. 0+ N^d\R !2 .=2'6C5.40+50 76.(' DC0 0+ 6'2 .r'2 2*,C*0+502
6'2 02BC0(_'2 :0 (0B'(025.7*S+ 025b+ 6*,.:'2 BC+:.40+5.640+50 .6 02BC0(_' /(':C75*3*25. H :0
7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'R 92c /(020+5. 06 Y*+*25(' :0 !7'+'4c. 6.2 5.(0.2 :0 6. (07*i+ 7(0.:.
?*(077*S+ :0 @'(025.7*S+>
.50+5. 6. 2*+,C6.( ,(.30:.: DC0 /.(. 6. 07'+'4c. +.7*'+.6 2*,+*B*7.=. 6. 5.6. *+7'+5('6.:. :0
+C025('2 ='2DC02 H 6. B.65. :0 /(0'7C/.7*S+ /.(. (0/'+0(6'2 H .C40+5.(6'2 0+ 0W50+2*S+ 5.6
DC0 2.5*2B.,. 6. 7(07*0+50 :04.+:. :0 4.:0(.2 H 6. 7'+2*,C*0+50 :0B0+2. :0 +C025(.2
LL 8. '/'2*7*S+ 0+5(0 7*3*6*_.7*S+ H 2063. 02 76.(. 0+ %06.27' X=.((.> j:'+:0 .+502 *4/0(.=. 6. 2063.V ;'H 20 (0.6*_.+
204=(c'2V .(('_V 7.BiV 7.7.'k IZ.6.+70 N^dO> z%XXXQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 52/67
eN
02/07*02 B'(025.602R ?0 +' /'+0(20 (040:*' . 0250 4.6V 06 !7C.:'( 20 ;.=(c. 3*25' '=6*,.:'V
0+ /6._' 7'(5'V . :*25(.0( C+. *+,0+50 7.+5*:.: :0 :*3*2.2 /.(. *4/'(5.( 4.:0(.2V BC0(. :0
0+B(0+5.(20 7'+ 06 50((*=60 /('=604. :0 6. 0('2*S+ :0 6'2 2C06'2 IF(,066i2 <..4.r' N^eM> OQR
1'6' 20 40+7*'+. 6. /(':C77*S+ :0 4.:0(.V 7'4' 0+ 6'2 .r'2 5(0*+5.R -0(' 6'2 7*0+5cB*7'2 +.5C(.6*25.2
/C,+.+ /'( :.(60 . 6'2 b(='602 H . 6'2 ='2DC02 C+ 2*,+*B*7.:' 4.H'(R hC+5' .6 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6V
06 ,'=*0(+' :0 -6._. 7(0S C+ X+25*5C5' :0 @'40+5' :0 6. -(':C77*S+ DC0 20 0+7.(,.=. :0 B*+.+7*.(
*+30(2*'+02 /(*'(*5.(*.2R F+. :0 066.2 0(. 6. (0B'(025.7*S+R ?'5.:. :0 4.H'(02 40:*'2V 6. /'6c5*7. :0
B'(025.7*S+ 7(07*S :0 4.+0(. DC0 06 X+25*5C5' :0 @'40+5'V 0+ 7'+30+*' 7'+ 06 ?0/.(5.40+5'
@'(025.6 :06 Y*+*250(*' :0 !7'+'4c.V *+25.6S 3*30('2 0+ <.(7;*V X4=.=C(.V -*7;*+7;.V <'5'/.W*V
<;*4='(._'V 9_C.HV #C.H.2 H Y.+.=c /.(. /('300( :0 0C7.6*/5'2V 4'6602 H '5(.2 02/07*02 .:./5.:.2
. 7.:. (0,*S+R 9:04b2V 0+ 6. !25.7*S+ !W/0(*40+5.6 <0+5(.6 :0 6. 1*0((. I0+ 6. ;.7*0+:. 1.+5'
?'4*+,' :0 <'+'7'5'Q 20 5(.=.G.=. 2'=(0 .30+.V 70=.:.V 5(*,'V 4.c_ ;c=(*:'V .(30G.2 H 60+50G.2 j. B*+
:0 7'+20,C*( 06 .C40+5' :0 6. B0(5*6*:.: :0 6'2 2C06'2 /'=(02k H j6. 0W7.3.7*S+ :0 .6,C+.2 _.+G.2 :0
7'+5'(+' /.(. /('50,0( 06 2C06' 7'+5(. 6. 0('2*S+k IX+25*5C5' N^eM> OeQR Yb2 02/07cB*7.40+50V j06
/(',(.4.
:0
(0B'(025.7*S+
:0
025.
;.7*0+:.
;.
7'40+_.:'V
/('70:*i+:'20
.
6.
2*04=(.
:0
0C7.6*/5'2 0+ 6'2 50((0+'2 0+ /0+:*0+50k IX+25*5C5' N^eM> OOQR 8. (06.7*S+ 0+5(0 6'2 b(='602 H 6.
0('2*S+V DC0 +' 025.=. /60+.40+50 .B*+7.:. 5':.3c. 0+5(0 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 /'6c5*7'2V 0(. C+. B'(4.
:0 (02.65.( =0+0B*7*'2 *+:*(075'2 /.(. 6. /(':C77*S+V 7'4' 20 :*(c. .75C.640+50V H. +' 2'6' 20(3*7*'2
:0 j./('3*2*'+.4*0+5'k 2*+' 5.4=*i+ 20(3*7*'2 :0 j(0,C6.7*S+kRL`
-0(' 6. 6C7;. :0 6'2 +.5C(.6*25.2 0(. =(0,.( 7'+5(. 6. 7'((*0+50R 92c 6' :*70 Y*2.06 97'25. 1'6c2V
:*(075'( :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6V :02.60+5.:'V 0+ 2C /(*40( *+B'(40 .6 B(0+50 :06 '(,.+*24'R
8C0,' :0 ;.=0( 06.='(.:' C+ :05.66.:' -(',(.4. ".7*'+.6 :0 @'(025.7*S+ H E0B'(025.7*S+ 20
0+7'+5(.('+ 7'+ DC0 +' ;.=c. :*+0(' /.(. 025.2 .75*3*:.:02R !+ 4.(_' :06 N^d^V .6 7(0.(20 06
X+25*5C5' :0
@'40+5'V
3*0('+
6.
'/'(5C+*:.:
:0
/(020+5.(
6'2
/('H075'2
:0
3*30('2
H 6',(.('+
*+25.6.(
+C030 3*30('2 0+5(0 B*+02 :0 N^d^ H B0=(0(' :0 N^eMR K':' BC+7*'+.=. +'(4.640+50 ;.25. DC0 C+
402 :02/Ci2 :0 6. q65*4. *+25.6.7*S+V 2q=*5.40+50 DC0:.('+ 2C2/0+:*:.2 5':.2 6.2 6.='(02 /'( 6.
2C/(02*S+ :06 ./'H' 07'+S4*7' /'( /.(50 :0 6. <'(/'(.7*S+ :0 @'40+5' I0+ F(,066i2 N^eM> `dQR 10
0+5(0,.('+ 0+5'+702 6.2 /6.+5.2 . 6'2 70+5('2 .,(c7'6.2 H 4C+*7*/*'2 /.(. DC0 +' 20 4C0(.+R 96 .r'
2*,C*0+50 2'=(03*3c.+ 7C.5(' 3*30('2 DC0 ;.=c.+ (0/.(5*:' PMM 4*6 /6.+5.2>
?02,(.7*.:.40+50V 6. (025(*77*S+ 07'+S4*7. /'( 6. DC0 .5(.3*02. 06 :0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6
*4/*:0 6603.( . 7.=' 06 ,(.+ /6.+ :0 .77*S+ 5(._.:' :02:0 06 /(*+7*/*'V ' 20.V 6. (0: :0 3*30('2
B'(025.602 . 5(.3i2 :06 /.c2R 1*+ 3*30('2 02 *4/'2*=60 ;.70( B'(025.7*S+ H (0B'(025.7*S+ I0+
h.6*6 Y'+502:0'7.
N^eL>
NePQR
y. 7'+ Y*2.06 97'25. BC0(. :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' H 7'+ %06.27' X=.((. 0+ 2C 50(70(. /(02*:0+7*.V
:*2/'+04'2 :0 C+ *+B'(40 /C=6*7.:' . *+*7*'2 :06 .r' N^e` DC0 +'2 /0(4*50 7'+'70( 06 5*/' :0
.77*'+02 :06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 0+ C+ 5*04/' DC0 0W/(02. =*0+ 06 *+*7*' :0 /60+. B'(4.6*_.7*S+
:0 6.2 *+25*5C7*'+02 :0 B'40+5' B'(025.6 0+ 06 /.c2 I10*2 40202 N^e`> P\‐^QR
!6 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 20 ;.66. 3*3.40+50 *+50(02.:' 0+ 7'+'70( 7Cb6 02 2C (0.6*:.:
B'(025.6V . B*+ :0 :050(4*+.( 2C 7./.7*:.: .75C.6 H /'50+7*.6 7'+ 4*(.2 .6 ./('307;.4*0+5'
:0 C+' :0 2C2 (07C(2'2 +.5C(.602 7'+25*5C*:'2 /'( 6'2 ='2DC02 02/'+5b+0'2 :0 6.2
L` <B(R Y*660+*C4 !7'2H2504 92202240+5 ILMMeQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 53/67
eL
025(*=.7*'+02 0W50(*'(02 0 *+50(*'(02 :0 6'2 9+:02 7'4' 6'2 :0 6.2 E0,*'+02 $77*:0+5.6 H
$(*0+5.6 I10*2 40202 N^e`> P\QR
9:04b2V ;. 30+*:' (0.6*_.+:' j0W7C(2*'+02 ='5b+*7' ] B'(025.602 :0 7.(b750( 7*0+5cB*7'kR
!2 .2c 7'4' 20 ;.+ ;07;' .6,C+'2 025C:*'2 2*2504b5*7'2 H :0 *+3025*,.7*S+ DC0 20(3*(b+ :0
=.20 /.(.
025.=6070(
0+
06
BC5C('
6.2
b(0.2
B'(025.602
:0
*4/'(5.+7*.
07'+S4*7.V
6'2
='2DC02
(*7'2 0+ 02/07*02 07'+S4*7.2 H /(*+7*/.640+50V *+:C25(*.602 H 2C 6'7.6*_.7*S+V 057R K(.=.G'2
DC0 /0(4*5*(b+ 7'+ 06 5*04/'V ;.70( 06 -(*40( 956.2 Z'5b+*7' @'(025.6V .6 /('/*' 5*04/' DC0
06 <.5b6',' 1*2504b5*7' :0 6.2 !2/07*02 I10*2 40202 N^e`> P\Q
!+ 20,C*:. /(020+5.+ 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 :06 YC20' Z'5b+*7' @'(025.6 H C+. 6.(,. 0W/6*7.7*S+ :0 2C2
7'6077*'+02 /.(. /.2.( . /(020+5.( 025.:c25*7.2 B'(025.602 /(0/.(.:.2 /.(. (02/'+:0( . C+ /0:*:' :0
6. @9$ DC0 20(c. /C=6*7.:' 0+ 06 Z'605c+ :0 <'+2C4' YC+:*.6 :0 Y.:0(.R
X+40:*.5.40+50 20 (020r.+ 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 :0 ./'H' . 4*2*'+02 7*0+5cB*7.2> C+. 4*2*S+ :0 6. @9$
DC0 ;*_'
/(C0=.2
/.(.
30(
2*
7*0(5.2
4.:0(.2
2*(30+
/.(.
/C6/.
H 20
6603.('+
4C025(.2
:0
B(.*60GS+
IG>'28,%# F#1,^'$&%#&#Q H '5(.2 /6.+5.2 :0 /b(.4' /.(. C+ 6.='(.5'(*' 0+ X66*+'*2R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5'
.7'4/.rS . '5(. 4*2*S+ :0 *+3025*,.:'(02 :0 Y*7;*,.+ /.(. (07'6075.( B6'(. :0 .6,.2 :0 /.+5.+'2 H
6.,C+.2R $5(.2 4*2*'+02 ./'H.:.2 BC0('+ ,(C/'2 :0 6. ".5C(.6 17*0+70 @'C+:.5*'+ :0 6'2 F19 0+
7'+0W*S+ 7'+ 6. 9(4.:. 025.:'C+*:0+20V 6. 4*2*S+V :06 X+25*5C5' -.+.40(*7.+' :0 #0',(.Bc. 0
J*25'(*. :0 6. $!9V H C+. q65*4. 4*2*S+ B(.+702. :0 *+3025*,.7*S+ 0+ 6'2 ='2DC02 :06 "'('77*:0+50V
0+ !240(.6:.2R
8. 4.H'( /.(50 :06 *+B'(40 025bV /C02V :0:*7.:. . 20r.6.( 06 :02.(('66' :0 *+3025*,.7*'+02R "' /C0:0
C+' :0G.( :0 600(6' 7'4' 06 02BC0(_' :0 ,(C/'2 :0 *+3025*,.:'(02 +.5C(.6*25.2 07C.5'(*.+'2 DC0 20
02BC0(_.+ /'(
7'+30+70(
. 6'2
(02/'+2.=602
/'6c5*7'2
:0
6.
*4/'(5.+7*.
:0
6.
*+B'(4.7*S+
H 06
025C:*'
7*0+5cB*7'R
-0(' ;.H .6,C+.2 .75*3*:.:02 4b2 /('/*.40+50 :0 j*+50(30+7*S+kV 7.2* 5':.2 4'5*3.:.2 /'( 06
(0DC0(*4*0+5' :0 50(70('2 *+50(02.:'2R 8. /(*40(. 02 C+ /0:*:' :0 6'2 ?*/C5.:'2 :0 Y.+.=c H !6 $('
:0 DC0 20 /(';c=. /'( .6 40+'2 7C.5(' .r'2 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+ :0 7'(50_. :0 4.+,60R 8. 2'6*7*5C: BC0
'B*7*.640+50 ./'H.:. /'( 6. <b4.(. :0 ?*/C5.:'2R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5' '/*+S DC0 +' 0(. +0702.(*.
:*7;. /(';*=*7*S+ /'(DC0 06 ?07(05' !G07C5*3' "'R dPP :06 NP :0 4.(_' :0 N^d^ (0,6.40+5. 06
./('307;.4*0+5' H 0W/'(5.7*S+ :0 6. 7'(50_. :0 B'(4. 0B*7*0+50R 9:04b2V 06 Y*+*250(*' :0 !7'+'4c.
+' 5*0+0 B.7C65.: /.(. /(';*=*( 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+ I10*2 40202 N^e`> P^QR F+ 20,C+:' 7'+B6*75' 0+ 06 DC0
*+50(3*+' 02
0+5(0
6'2
4'(.:'(02
:06
(07*+5'
j1.=.+*66.k
IEc'
"C03'QV
/.(('DC*.
-0:('
<.(='V
7.+5S+
?.C60V #C.H.2V 7'+5(. @(.+7' !R Y.5.4'('2 <.660 /'( 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ :0 6'2 ='2DC02 :0 020 6C,.(R
8C0,' :0 C+ 6.(,' 5(b4*50 20 *+;*=*0('+ :0 7'+'70( 06 /('=604. /'(DC0 5.4/'7' 50+c.+ B.7C65.:02
/.(. 7'+2*:0(.(6'R -'7' :02/Ci2V '5('2 7'+:C0r'2 :0 1.=.+*66. (076.4.('+ DC0 Y.5.4'('2 20,Cc.
0W/6'5.+:' 6'2 ='2DC02R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5' *+B'(4S 2'=(0 6. *+7'+30+*0+7*. :0 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ 0+ C+
6C,.( :04.2*.:' 207'V 6' DC0
5(.0(c. C+ :02B.3'(.=60 7.4=*' 0+ 06 76*4. :0 6. (0,*S+V 2'=(0 5':' 0+ 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 6.
;C40:.: .4=*0+5.6 7'+ (0:C77*S+ 7'4/605. :0 6'2 027.2'2 .(('H'2 DC0 0W*250+ .66c H :.+
3*:. .6 6C,.(V 7'((*i+:'20 06 (*02,' *+4*+0+50 :0 DC0 :02./.(0_7.+ :*7;.2 B'(4.7*'+02
.(=S(0.2 :0
6.
2.=.+.V
6'
DC0
5(.0(c.
7'+207C0+7*.2
:0
*+7.67C6.=602
/0(GC*7*'2V
5.+5'
0+
06
'(:0+ =*'6S,*7' :0 7'+20(3.7*S+V 7'4' 0+ 06 07'+S4*7' +.7*'+.6 I10*2 40202 N^e`> P^QR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 54/67
e`
F+. 50(70(. *+50(30+7*S+ '7C((*S . /0:*:' :0 J0(+b+ Z(.3' <.25*66' DC0 /0:c. 20 60 7'+70:.
0W76C2*3*:.: /.(. 0W/6'5.( 6. 7'(50_. :06 4.+,60 :0 h.4=06cV 1.+5. E'2.V !6 $('R $B(07c. NVLM /'(
DC*+5.6 .6 YC+*7*/*' :0 1.+5. E'2. 0+ 6C,.( :0 6'2 MVLM DC0 7'=(.=. 06 4C+*7*/*'R !6 ?0/.(5.40+5'
(02/'+:*S :*7*0+:' DC0 7.(07c. :0 j2CB*7*0+502 06040+5'2 :0 GC*7*' /.(. :*75.4*+.( 2'=(0 6.
2'6*7*5C:V 2C,*(*0+:' 06 DC0 /(03*.40+50 20 B.7*6*50+ .6 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 6'2 40:*'2 +0702.(*'2
/.(. ;.70( C+. *+2/077*S+ '7C6.( :0 6'2 (0B0(*:'2 4.+,6.(02 H :0 6.2 _'+.2 :0 /'2*=60 0W/6'5.7*S+V H.
DC0 06 Y*+*250(*' :*2/C2' .+502 DC0 20 ;*7*0(. 5.6 (07'((*:' :0 025C:*'k I10*2 40202 N^e`> P^QR
@*+.640+50V .+50 06 /0:*:' :0 7'+702*S+ /.(. 0W/6'5.7*S+ H 0W/'(5.7*S+ :0 _'+.2 ='27'2.2 :0
!240(.6:.2 /.(. #C25.3' ?*0_ ?06,.:'V 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 '/*+S B.3'(.=6040+50R
<'4' 304'2V 2'+ 4CH /'7.2 *+50(30+7*'+02 H 0+ 4C7;.2 :0 066.2 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' 7.(070 :0
40:*'2 /.(. *+50(30+*( 0B075*3.40+50V 20. /'( 6. B.65. :0 /0(2'+.6 20. /'( 6. B.65. :0 .5(*=C7*'+02R
"' '=25.+50 025.2 03*:0+502 6*4*5.7*'+02 :0 (07C(2'2 H :0 /':0( /'6c5*7'V 20 '=20(3. DC0 04/*0_.+ .
040(,0( 7'+2*:0(.7*'+02
:0
6'2
3c+7C6'2
0+5(0
6'2
='2DC02
H '5('2
B.75'(02
+.5C(.602
7'4'
06
76*4.V
.6,' DC0 +' 0+7'+5(.4'2 0+ 6.2 GC25*B*7.7*'+02 :0 6'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 /q=6*7'2 .+50(*'(02R 10 '=20(3.
5.4=*i+ DC0V .2c 20. :0 4.+0(. 6*4*5.:.V 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 6',(. 7.+.6*_.( :04.+:.2 H
DC0G.2 :0 7*C:.:.+'2 /'( 06 C2' :0 6'2 ='2DC02 H 4.+,6.(02R "' '=25.+50 +.:. 2C,*0(0 0+ 6'2
:'7C40+5'2 :0 6'2 0+7.(,.:'2 :06 4.+0G' :0 504.2 .,(.(*'2 ' B'(025.602 0+ 5':' 06 /0(c':' :0
.+b6*2*2V 6. /(020+7*. .2c 20. BC,*5*3. :0 .6,C+. *4.,0+ ('4b+5*7. ' =C7S6*7. :0 6. 2063. H 6.
+.5C(.60_. j3*(,0+kR 8. /'6c5*7. .4=*0+5.6 2*,C0 2*0+:' C+ 2C=‐/(':C75' :06 02BC0(_' /'( 06 /(',(02'
07'+S4*7' /0(' 04/*0_. . (02/'+:0( . 6'2 /0:*:'2 :0 C+ /q=6*7' DC0 (076.4.RLd
8'2 :*27C(2'2 :0 6'2 +.5C(.6*25.2 DC0 '7C/.('+ 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^eM 4C025(.+
06
02BC0(_'
/'(
(03.6'(.(
6'2
='2DC02
+.5C(.602
H
4'25(.(
DC0
.:04b2
:06
/'50+7*.6
4.:0(0('V
7C4/60+ '5(.2 BC+7*'+02 07'6S,*7.2 *4/'(5.+502R h'(,0 #.660,'2 K0(b+V 06 2C702'( :0 Y*2.06 97'25.V
:07c. 0+ N^ed>
j!+5(0 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02 Bc2*7.2 DC0 4b2 7'+5(*=CH0+ .6 :02.(('66' 07'+S4*7' B*,C(. 06
./('307;.4*0+5' :06 2C06' 7'4' BC0+50 *+.,'5.=60 :0 /(':C77*S+ .,(c7'6.a /0(' G.4b2 20
;. (0B60W*'+.:' DC0 6.2 +C03.2 7'+DC*25.2 :0 5*0((.2 /.(. 06 7C65*3' 5(.0+ 7'+2*,' 6. /'=(0_.
B'(025.6 :06 /.c2R <'+ 6. :025(C77*S+ :0 6'2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602V 6. 07'+'4c. +.7*'+.6 ;.
(07*=*:' C+ :C(' ,'6/0V H 2* /'( 06 4'40+5' +'2 /.(070 *+2*,+*B*7.+50V 20 5'(+.(b 4C7;' 4b2
,(.30 0+ 7C.+5' 6.2 (0/.(.7*'+02 :0 6'2 :.r'2 20 3C063.+ 7.:. 30_ 4b2 0W*,0+502k I0+ "0='5
%06.27' N^ed>
L^PQR
-.(. 06 .r' N^ed 06 :0/.(5.40+5' ;.=c. /(0/.(.:' H. C+ 9+50/('H075' :0 80H @'(025.6 DC0 +' 20(c.
./('=.:' 2*+' ;.25. N^e\R 10 .(,C40+5.=. 0+ 06 .+50/('H075' DC0 7'+ 6. 80H @'(025.6 /C0:0 03*5.(
Ld !2 /('=.=60 DC0 0+ 6.2 .(502V 7'4' 6. /*+5C(. H 6. B'5',(.Bc.V 20. /'2*=60 0+7'+5(.( 0+ 025'2 .r'2 20r.602 :06
('4.+5*7*24' :0 C+. +.5C(.60_. =066. H 60G.+. DC0 5.6 30_ /0(40.('+ . .6,C+'2 :0 025'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 I.,(.:0_7' 6. '=20(3.7*S+ :0 Y*7;*06 Z.C:V 7'4R /0(2R LMNLQR -0(' +' 6. ;0 0+7'+5(.:' 0+ 6.2 BC0+502 (03*2.:.2R 9,C25c+ <C03. .2'7*. 06 2C(,*4*0+5' :0 025. +C03. 3*2*S+ :0 6. +.5C(.60_. IH 06 4C+:' (C(.6 0+
,0+0(.6Q 0+ 6. +'306. <*0+ 9r'2 :0 1'60:.: :0 #.=(*06 #.(7c. Yb(DC0_ . j6. 4*(.:. +'25b6,*7. DC0 7*0(5'2 025(.5'2 C(=.+'2 07;.+ 2'=(0 2C '(*,0+ /(07*5.:*+' ImQ +' 02 C+ ._.( DC0 025. B.4'2. +'306. ;.H. 2C(,*:' 0+
06
0W.75'
4'40+5'
0+
DC0
94i(*7.
8.5*+.
20
7'+30(5c.
0+
C+.
2'7*0:.:
/(0:'4*+.+5040+50
C(=.+.
H
7C.+:'
6. ;0,04'+c. .70+5C.:. :06 7./*5.6*24' 7(0.=. B'(4.2 7.:. 30_ 4b2 7'4/60G.2 H /('=604b5*7.2 :0 0W*250+7*.k I7*5.:' /'( -('.r' 9(.+:* LMNL> NLMQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 55/67
ed
6. 0('2*S+ :0 6'2 2C06'2 H 6. (07C/0(.7*S+ :0 6'2 DC0 6. ;.+ 2CB(*:' ' 6. B0(5*6*_.7*S+ :'+:0 BC0(0
/'2*=60 40:*.+50 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ :0 ='2DC02 .(5*B*7*.602V 5i7+*7.40+50 :*(*,*:'2R 8'2 ='2DC02V :*70 06
?*(075'(V /C0:0+ 40G'(.( 06 76*4. 03*5.+:' BC0(502 *+2'6.7*'+02V 2*(3*0+:' 7'4' 7'(5*+.2 DC0
(0,C6.+ 6'2 3*0+5'2 H 4':0(.:'(02 :0 7.4=*'2 =(C27'2 :0 504/0(.5C(. I0+ "0='5 %06.27' N^ed>
L^PQR !+ 06 .+50/('H075' :0 80H 6'2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602 /0(4.+07c.+ 7'4' /('/*0:.: :06 !25.:' H 20
025.=607c. C+
<C0(/'
:0
X+2/075'(02
@'(025.602
-('3*+7*.602
DC0
:0=c.+
;.70(
025C:*'2V
3*,*6.(
06
7C4/6*4*0+5' :0 6. B'(025.7*S+ H :0 6. 60,*26.7*S+V H (07',0( *+B'(4.7*S+ B*:0:*,+. 2'=(0 6'2
/(':C75'2 B'(025.602R
J.7*. N^OM 06 :*27C(2' .4=*0+5.6 :0 0250 ,(C/' :0 +.5C(.6*25.2 DC0 (0*3*+:*7.=. 6. /6C(.6*:.: :0
BC+7*'+02 q5*602 DC0 7C4/60+ 6'2 ='2DC02 025b /60+.40+50 .B*.+_.:'R 8. ?*(077*S+ ".7*'+.6
@'(025.6V 0+5'+702 C+. :0/0+:0+7*. :06 Y*+*250(*' :0 @'40+5'V 0W/6*7. .2c 2C 3*2*S+ :0 6. /'6c5*7.
B'(025.6 0+ C+ /.c2 7'+ 4b2 :06 dMx :0 2C 2C/0(B*7*0 7C=*0(5' :0 ='2DC02>
YC7;'2 :0 025'2 ='2DC02 :0=0+ 20( 7'+2*:0(.:'2 7'4' /('5075'(02 H. DC0 2C BC+7*S+
/(*+7*/.6 02 6. :0 /('50,0( 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 6'2 2C06'2V :0 6.2 .,C.2 ' :0 3.(*'2 '5('2
(07C(2'2 +.5C(.602 H /'( 7'+2*,C*0+50 :0=0 03*5.(20 DC0 :02./.(0_7.+V +' /0(4*5*0+:' 0+
066'2 6.2 6.='(02 :0 7'6'+*_.7*S+ /C02 +* 06 .,(*7C65'( '=50+:(c. =0+0B*7*'2 /'( 5(.5.(20 :0
2C06'2 +' ./5'2 ImQ +' 20 /('50,0(c.+ 6.2 7C0+7.2 ;*:(',(bB*7.2 +* 6'2 2C06'2V DC0 0+ _'+.2
4b2 ./5.2 025b+ /('50,*:'2 /'( 025'2 ='2DC02 ImQR $5('2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602 /C0:0+ 20(
0W/6'5.:'2 H 2C2 5*0((.2 ./('307;.:.2 0+ 6.='(02 :0 7'6'+*_.7*S+ /'(DC0 (0q+0+
7'+:*7*'+02 BC+:.40+5.602 /.(. 5(.=.G'2 .,(c7'6.2 ' ,.+.:0('2R $5(. ,(.+ /'(7*S+ :0
='2DC02 :0=0 4.+50+0(20 7'4' 5.602 H =C27.( 0+ 066'2 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ H 06 ./('307;.4*0+5'
*+50,(.6 .6 4*24' 5*04/' DC0 2C (0,0+0(.7*S+ H 40G'(.4*0+5' /.(. 4.+50+0(
/0(4.+0+5040+50 0250 3.6*'2' (07C(2'R @*+.640+50 '5(.2 0W50+2*'+02 DC0 +' /C0:0+ 20(
./('307;.:.2 0+
6.
.75C.6*:.:
H.
20.
/'(
B.65.
:0
3c.2
:0
7'4C+*7.7*S+
H .7702*=*6*:.:
' /'(
*+2CB*7*0+50 40(7.:'V :0=0+ /0(4.+070( 7'4' ='2DC02 7'+25*5CH0+:' C+. (020(3.
/'50+7*.6 /.(. 06 BC5C(' I0+ Y'(50+20+ N^OM> NdQR
-0(' 025. 3*2*S+ /'6*BC+7*'+.6 :0 6'2 ='2DC02 H :0 6. (*DC0_. B'(025.6 :06 /.c2 0(. 2'6' 06 /.5(*4'+*'
:0 C+ ,(C/' /0DC0r' H .*26.:' :0+5(' :06 !25.:'R !6 /(02*:0+50 <.4*6' -'+70 !+(cDC0_V 7.=0_. :06
4*24' ,'=*0(+' .6 DC0 /0(50+07c. 06 BC+7*'+.(*' B'(025.6 DC0 /0:c. 6*4*5.( 6. 7'6'+*_.7*S+ DC0
:025(Cc. 6.2 2063.2V /0+2.=. :*B0(0+50R 9r'2 .+502V 7C.+:' 20 7060=(.=. 06 j?c. :06 $(*0+50kV 06 NL :0
B0=(0(' :0 N^eP 0+ 06 K0+.V 0+ 6.2 /C0(5.2 :0 6. 94._'+c. 07C.5'(*.+.V 0+ 06 4*24c2*4' 50((*5'(*' :0
6.2 4.H'(02 (020(3.2 :0 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602 :06 /.c2V -'+70 :07c. 7'+ 30;040+7*.>
025.2 ,(.+:02 2063.2V 025'2 (c'2 4.,+cB*7'2V 6.2 0+5(.r.2 :0 6. 5*0((. :S+:0 DC*i+ 2.=0
7Cb+5.2 (*DC0_.2 20 ,C.(:.+V 4*+0(.602V /05(S60'V /'2*=*6*:.:02 :0 /(',(02' ImQ 50+04'2
DC0 0W7.3.( 06 2C06' 7'+ 06 3*,'( :06 4q27C6' H 50+04'2 DC0 :025(C*( 6. 2063. H :'4*+.(6. H
7'4=.5*( 6.2 /02502 H 50+04'2 DC0 .=(*( 6.2 7.((050(.2V /.(. DC0 .B6CH. 06 0W702' :0 6.
/'=6.7*S+ 20((.+. ;.7*. 2C2 5*0((.2 3c(,0+02 H B0(.702 I-'+70 !+(cDC0_ N^eP> d`‐ddQRLe
Le
8.
*:0.
:0
6.
B0(.7*:.:
:0
6.2
5*0((.2
0+
06
'(*0+50
07C.5'(*.+'
0(.
7'4/.(5*:.
/'(
4C7;.2
/0(2'+.2
0+
6.
/(*40(.
4*5.:
:06 2*,6' zzR <B(R 6. DC0G. :0 "0/5.6c wqr*,. /'( 6. 4.6. C5*6*_.7*S+ :0 6.2 5*0((.2 0+ 06 !7C.:'( /C02 6.2 4b2 Bi(5*602 :06 $(*0+50 H :0 6. <'25. +' 2'+ 5.+ ./('307;.:.2 7'4' 6.2 :0 6. 1*0((.V 40+'2 Bi(5*602 IwCr*,. N^dM> `LQR
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 56/67
ee
-C025'2 0+ 6. =.6.+_. :0 6. ;*25'(*.V 0+5(0 06 :*27C(2' :06 BC+7*'+.(*' B'(025.6 H 06 :06 /(02*:0+50 :0 6.
(0/q=6*7.V DC0:.+ /'7.2 :C:.2 :0 7Cb6 50+c. 4b2 /02' H .((.25(.=. 4.H'(02 7'+207C0+7*.2R
)*&,1#-,'- ̀"%&'1/# Y >',1\2'*
[C*_b2 /.(. *6C25(.( 0250 /C+5'V 06 40G'( 7'+5(.250 7'+ 025'2 5(02 7.4/'2 :'+:0 ./.(07*0('+
;0((.4*0+5.2 :0
4.+0G'
.4=*0+5.6
/('4'3*:.2
/'(
06
!25.:'
20.
06
:0
6.
4*+0(c.
H 06
/05(S60'R
!+
+*+,C+' :0 6'2 *+B'(402 ,C=0(+.40+5.602 2'=(0 4*+0(c. H /05(S60' (03*2.:'2 . 6' 6.(,' :0 025.
*+3025*,.7*S+ 20 ;.70 6. 40+'( (0B0(0+7*. . /'2*=602 *4/.75'2 .4=*0+5.602 /'( 6. 7'+5.4*+.7*S+R
E07'(:04'2 DC0 6. 7'+5.4*+.7*S+ .4=*0+5.6 4*+0(. ' /05('60(. +' .B075. +* 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02 :0
/(':C77*S+ +* 06 '=G05' :0 5(.=.G' :0 6. .75*3*:.:V /'( 6' DC0 6. (0+5.=*6*:.: 4*24. +' :0/0+:0 :06
7C*:.:' DC0 20 /'+,. 0+ 06 7C*:.:' :06 .4=*0+50R
!+ N^`M 025.=.+ *+3'6C7(.:.2 0+ 7'+702*'+02 4*+0(.2 .:GC:*7.:.2 d^ 4*6 ;075b(0.2V 6. 4.H'(c. 0+ 6.
-0+c+2C6. :0 1.+5. !60+.V 4*0+5(.2 DC0 6'2 .((0+:.5.(*'2 :0 50((0+'2 /.(. 0W/6'(.7*S+ H 0W/6'5.7*S+
4*+0(. '7C/.=.+ eM 4*6 ;075b(0.2 H 20 /(':C7c.+ Oe 4*66'+02 :0 ,.6'+02 :0 /05(S60' H NV\ 4*66'+02
:0 ,.6'+02
:0
,.2'6*+.2
IY*660(
N^`N>
Pe
H \MQR
!+
N^`N
6.
/(':C77*S+
/05('60(.
5'5.6
.270+:*S
. P`V^
4*66'+02 :0 ,.6'+02 H 6. :0 ,.2'6*+.2 20 4.+5C3' 0+ NV\ 4*66'+02 I93*6i2 9,C*((0 N^`L> NdNQR J'H
2.=04'2 6' DC0 02' 2*,+*B*7. 0+ 7C.+5' . (*02,'2 .4=*0+5.602R !+ N^`N 06 (0,*25(' :0 6.2 5.(0.2 :0
7'+5('6 0(. (02C4*:' 7'4' 2*,C0 /'( /.(50 :06 4*+*25(' :06 (.4'>
8. 3*,*6.+7*. :0 6'2 5(.=.G'2 :0 0W/6'5.7*S+ DC0 6603.+ . 7.=' 6'2 7'+702*'+.(*'2 20 0B075q.
/'( 40:*' :0 6. X+2/077*S+ ,0+0(.6 :0 Y*+.2 DC0 5*0+0 2C .2*0+5' 0+ 06 70+5(' 4*+0(' :0
1.+5. !60+.R 9:04b2 :0 7'+5('6.( 6. /(':C77*S+ :0 /05(S60'V 2C/0(3*,*6. 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+V 6.
(0B*+.7*S+ H 06 7'+2C4'V .2c 7'4' 06 025(*75' 7C4/6*4*0+5' :0 5':.2 6.2 /(027(*/7*'+02
/0(5*+0+502 :06 <S:*,' :0 Y*+0(c. H :0 6. 80H 2'=(0 J*:('7.(=C('2V *+76C2*30 5(.5' :0
04/60.:'2V
/'(70+5.G0
+.7*'+.6
:0
'=(0('2V
7'+:*7*'+02
;*,*i+*7.2
:0
6'2
7.4/.40+5'2V
0G07C7*S+ :0 5(.=.G'2 ,0'6S,*7'2V 5'/',(bB*7'2V 057R IY*660( N^`N> \NQR
"' 0W*250 6. 40+'( 40+7*S+ . .6,q+ 5*/' :0 7'+5('6 .4=*0+5.6 :0 6.2 04/(02.2R E07'(:04'2 DC0 06
4*+*25(' 20 DC0G. 5.4=*i+ :0 6. B.65. :0 /0(2'+.6 DC0 +' 20 :. .=.25' /.(. (07'((0( ddM /'_'2
/0(B'(.:'2V PMM . 4.+' H L\M 5.+DC02 IY*660( N^`N> \LQR !+ N^`P H 0+ N^dMV 7'+ '7.2*S+ (03*2*'+02
:0 6. 60,*26.7*S+ H :0 6'2 7'+5(.5'2 /05('60('2V 20 ./('307;. /.(. B*G.( .6,C+.2 +C03.2 '=6*,.7*'+02
6.='(.602 H 06 7'4/('4*2' :0 6.2 04/(02.2 /.(. ;.70( 7*0(5'2 7.4*+'2 H 0:*B*7*'2 /q=6*7'2 I9H.6.
N^`P> NPa !2/*+'2. N^dM> ^\‐^QR -0(' 5':.3c. +*+,C+. /('3*2*S+ .4=*0+5.6R 10r.604'2 :0 /.2' DC0
0+ 5':'2 6'2 *+B'(402 4*+*250(*.602 (03*2.:'2 7'((02/'+:*0+502 . 5(0*+5. .r'2V +' 20 40+7*'+. +* C+
2'6' :0((.40
+*
.77*:0+50
/05('60('RLO
<'+ 6. 4*+0(c. :06 '(' 5.4/'7' 20 0+7C0+5(. 6. 40+'( 20r.6 :0 C+. /(0'7C/.7*S+ .4=*0+5.6R 96
:027(*=*( 06 /('702' :0 /(':C77*S+ :0 6. 7'4/.rc. 1'C5; 940(*7.+ ?0306'/40+5 <'4/.+H IF19Q 0+
w.4'(. 20 40+7*'+. DC0>
8'2 7C.(_'2 .C(cB0('2 C+. 30_ /C630(*_.:'2 20 2'4050+ .6 5(.5.4*0+5' :0 7*.+C(.7*S+V /.(.
7'+30(5*( i25'2 0+ 5*0((. 4*+0(.6 ./('/*.:. /.(. 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+ . 6.2 (0B*+0(c.2 :0 !25.:'2
F+*:'2 :0 "R9R I93*6i2 9,C*((0 N^`L> NdLQR
LO y 2*+ 04=.(,'V 0W*25*0('+V H 2C2 *4/.75'2 0+ 6. -0+c+2C6. BC0('+ 3*2*=602R <B(R #.6.(_. w.3.6. IN^P`QV C+' :0 6'2 /'7'2
.60,.5'2 :'+:0 20 40+7*'+. 6. :025(C77*S+ .4=*0+5.6 /('3'7.:. 0+ 6. _'+. /'( 6.2 7'4/.rc.2 /05('60(.2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 57/67
eO
9;c 50(4*+. 5':'R !6 *+B'(40 20 :0:*7. 0+20,C*:. . 0W.4*+.( 6. 2*,C*0+50 04/(02. 4*+0(.R J.H
.6,C+.2 /(0'7C/.7*'+02 /'( 6. 2.6C: /0(' +' 5*0+0+ DC0 30( 7'+ /'2*=602 .B075.7*'+02 /'(
7'+5.4*+.7*S+ .4=*0+5.6R !+ -'(5'306'V 6. 1'C5; 940(*7.+ ?0306'/40+5 <'4/.+H 0+ 2C ;'2/*5.6
5(.5S NRP`e 7.2'2 :0 4.6.(*.V :0+5(' H BC0(. :06 7.4/.40+5'R 96 4*24' 5*04/'V 6. 04/(02. /*:*S .6
4C+*7*/*' :0 w.(C4. 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :06 .,C. /'5.=60>
<'+25.+50 /(0'7C/.7*S+ 02 :0 6. 1'C5; 940(*7.+ ?0306'/40+5 <'4/.+H 6. 307*+:.: :06
66.4.:' =.((*' jY.7;.6.k 06 DC0 7'+25*5CH0 C+ /06*,('2' B'7' :0 *+B077*S+V /'( 2C2
:0B*7*0+502 7'+:*7*'+02 ;*,*i+*7.2 .2c 7'4' 5.4=*i+ /'( 20( C+ 70+5(' :0 7'((C/7*S+ 0+ 06
7C.6 7'+ B(07C0+7C. 2C2 '=(0('2 7'+5(.0+ 0+B0(040:.:02 *+B075' 7'+5.,*'2.2 I30+i(0.2Q
I!2/*+'2. N^dM> ^MQR
!+ 6. 4*+0(c.V 7'4' 0+ 6' :04b2V 6' DC0 *4/'(5. 02 6. '=50+7*S+ :0 4.H'(02 (*DC0_.2V 7'4' 6'
0W/(02. 9(+.6:' Z.('+. IN^`d> NMO‐PQV . /('/S2*5' :0 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ :06 '('>
!2 . +' :C:.(6'V C+. B06*_ *+*7*.5*3. :0 +C025('2 7.4/07*+'2 I2*7Q DC0 *4/C62.:'2 /'( 6.
:0202/0(.+50 2*5C.7*'+
07'+S4*7.
DC0
602
.B6*,0V
0W5(.0+
*+B.5*,.=6040+50
06
/(07*'2'
405.6
:0
6.2 4b(,0+502 H 7.C702 :0 +C025('2 (c'2 2'/'(5.+:' 6.2 *+76040+7*.2 :06 76*4. H 6.2 (C:0_.2 ImQR
?0=04'2V /'( *4/0(.5*3' :0 7'+20(3.7*S+V 0W5(.0( 6.2 *++C40(.=602 (*DC0_.2 :06 B'+:' :0 6.
5*0((.V H. DC0 +' 02 7'+70=*=60 '63*:.( /'( 4b2 5*04/' DC0 06 2C=2C06' 07C.5'(*.+' 02 4b2 (*7'
DC0 06 2C06'R
!+ N^d` 06 Y*+*25(' :0 Y*+.2 (02C40 6.2 /(*'(*:.:02 4b2 C(,0+502 0+ 06 7.4/' 4*+0('V 0+50 6.2 DC0
B*,C(. B'(4.( C+. !27C06. :0 Y*+.2V ;.70( 6. 7.(5',(.Bc. 4*+0(. H 7(0.( C+. 7.G. 4*+0(.V /0('
+*+,C+. 5*0+0 DC0 30( 7'+ /'2*=602 /('=604.2 :0 7'+5.4*+.7*S+ IE'7. <.(=' N^d`> eMQR !6 4*+*25('
(07'+'70 DC0 +' 0W*250+ 30(:.:0(.2 7./.7*:.:02 /.(. 06 7'+5('6 :0 6. 4*+0(c. H 06 /05(S60' H DC0
5':. 6.
2C/0(3*2*S+
:0/0+:0
:0
6.
7'6.='(.7*S+
:0
6.2
/('/*.2
04/(02.2R
-0('
6'
4b2
(0306.:'(
02
6.
(030(2*S+ :0 6. 7'+702*S+ 4*+0(. :0 ._CB(0 :0 K*Wb+V /('3*+7*. :0 <;*4='(._'>
?02:0 ;.70 4C7;' 5*04/' 6'2 7'+702*'+.(*'2 :0 025. _'+. ;.+ 30+*:' 5(.=.G.+:' 6.2 Y*+.2 :0
9_CB(0 2*+ +*+,q+ /6.+ 7*0+5cB*7' +* (0,6. 5i7+*7.V (._S+ /'( 6. 7C.6 6. (*DC0_. DC0 02'2
H.7*4*0+5'2 0+7*0((. 0(. :02/0(:*7*.:. 0+ B'(4. .6.(4.+50R 8. ?*(077*S+ #0+0(.6 :0 Y*+0(c.
7'4/('=S 6.2 .+'4.6c.2 0W*250+502 :0 5(.=.G' :0 02. _'+. 40:*.+50 :'2 *+2/077*'+02 ImQR
l!+5'+702n 20 :*75S 06 ?07(05' !G07C5*3' "'R \LO :0 \ :0 GC+*' :06 .r' 0+ 7C(2' /'( 06 7C.6 20
:076.(.('+ 50(4*+.:'2 6'2 :0(07;'2 DC0 6'2 20r'(02 #.(_'_* ;.=c.+ .:DC*(*:' 0+ 6'2 H.7*4*0+5'2
._CB(0('2 :0 K*Wb+R !25. *4/'(5.+50 _'+. 20(b 7'+70:*:. 0+ 40G'(02 7'+:*7*'+02 /.(. 06 !25.:'V
q+*7.40+50
.
C+.
04/(02.
:0
7'4/('=.:.
2'630+7*.
07'+S4*7.
H
5i7+*7.V
DC0
6.
0W/6'50
7*0+5cB*7.40+50 IE'7. <.(=' N^d`> eeQR
F+ .r' .+502 06 Y*+*25(' :06 (.4' 20 ;.=c. DC0G.:' :0 6. B'(4. 0+ DC0 20 4.+0G.=. 0250
.((0+:.4*0+5'
7.(0+50 :0 5':' /(*+7*/*' 5i7+*7' 0 ;*,*i+*7'V (0/(020+5.+:' 5':' 025' C+ 0+'(40 /0(GC*7*'
/.(. 06 !25.:' H C+ ,(.+ /06*,(' /.(. 06 '=(0(' DC0 /(025. .66c 2C2 20(3*7*'2 I<(02/' $(:Sr0_
N^dL> NM\QR
8. (07'40+:.7*S+ 0(. ;.70( 6. 0W/6'5.7*S+ . 7*06' .=*0(5'R <'4' 20 .:3*0(50 /0(B075.40+50V *+76C2'
0+ 0250 7.2'V 0+ DC0 20 /C0:0+ .:*3*+.( ,(.302 *4/.75'2 .4=*0+5.602V 6. GC25*B*7.7*S+ :0 6. (030(2*S+
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 58/67
eP
:0 6. 7'+702*S+ 02 06 :02/0(:*7*' 07'+S4*7'V .C+DC0 5.4=*i+ 20 ;.=6. :0 6. 20,C(*:.: 6.='(.6R -0('
+' 20 40+7*'+.+ /'2*=602 :.r'2 .4=*0+5.602R
@*+.640+50V 7C.+:' 0+ N^d^V 0+ C+ .r' '27C(' /.(. 6. 4*+0(c.V 660,.=.+ . 2C B*+V 2*+ iW*5'V 6'2
5(.=.G'2 :0 6.2 7'4/.rc.2 1;066 H !22' 15.+:.(: $*6 0+ 06 $(*0+50a H 20 (05*(.=. .6 4*24' 5*04/'V
6C0,' :0 :i7.:.2V 6. 1'C5; 940(*7.+ ?0306'/40+5 <'4/.+H :0 -'(5'306'V 6. /(0'7C/.7*S+ /(*+7*/.6
:06 Y*+*25(' :06 (.4' 0(. 6. :0 6. (*DC0_. DC0 20 :0G.(c. :0 ,0+0(.(V 6'2 0B075'2 2'=(0 6. BC5C(.
*4/'(5.7*S+ :0 7'4=C25*=602 H 6'2 04/60'2 DC0 20 /0(:0(c.+R !+ 02.2 ;'(.2 .7*.,.2 /.(. 6. 4*+0(c.V
06 0+7.(,.:' :06 (.4' :0+5(' :06 Y*+*250(*' :0 !7'+'4c. ;.70 C+ .75' :0 B0>
ImQ DC*0(' 4.+*B025.(60 C+. 30_ 4b2 l20r'( Y*+*25('n DC0 6. ?*(077*S+ #0+0(.6 . 4* 7.(,'
5*0+0 /60+' 7'+30+7*4*0+5' :0 6. /'50+7*.6*:.: 4*+0(. :0 +C025(. /.5(*.V DC0 02 /'2*=60
*+30+5.(*.(6. 7'+ =C0+. 3'6C+5.: H C+ ./'H' 07'+S4*7' :07*:*:' DC0 . 6. 6.(,. :.(b
(02C65.:'2 *+2'2/07;.:'2 I0+ F(,066i2 <..4.r' N^eM> ^MQR
K.4/'7' .DCc 6'2 504.2 .4=*0+5.602 2'+ 40+7*'+.:'2 0+ +*+,q+ 4'40+5'R !6 7'+5(.250 7'+ 06
02/.7*'
.7'(:.:'
.
6'2
/('=604.2
:0
6.
0('2*S+V
6.
7'+20(3.7*S+
:0
02/07*02
B'(025.602
H
6.
/('5077*S+ :0 6. /027. :0 6'2 (c'2 02 /.50+50R 1* .6,' DC0:. 76.(' 02 DC0 4*0+5(.2 06 +0,'7*' +' 20
30. .B075.:'V 6'2 /'2*=602 /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602 :0 6. 4*+0(c. 2'+ 5'5.640+50 *+3*2*=602 H +'
40(070+ C+. 40+7*S+ :*(075.R "' 2'+V 0+ 30(:.:V j/('=604.2k /.(. 06 !25.:' €<S4' *+50(/(05.(
0250 2*60+7*'V 0250 30(:.:0(' j/C+5' 7*0,'k 0+ 6. ,025*S+ H .:4*+*25(.7*S+ 025.5.6 :06 .4=*0+50o -.(.
;.70(6'V 02 q5*6 2*5C.( 025. /(*'(*:.: /'( 06 .C40+5' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ H :0 6. (*DC0_. 0+ C+ q65*4'
02/.7*' :0 .+*:.7*S+R
O8 6=&$"+&%"#. 4- '%#$%-.# 2 +&,7%&*-J&
-.(. 2*5C.(
025.
.C20+7*.
0+
2C
7'+50W5'V
+'
02
2CB*7*0+50
7'+25.5.(
6.
7'+5*+C*:.:
:0
6.2
*:0'6',c.2
:'4*+.+502 :06 /(',(02' 0+ 6.2 :06 :02.(('66' I!27'=.( LMMOQR J.H .6,' 4b2R 8. '=202*S+ /'( 06
7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 20 C=*7. :0+5(' :0 '5(. 4.5(*_V 6. :0 6'2 :*25*+5'2 *4.,*+.(*'2 2'=(0 06 /./06
:0 6. +.5C(.60_. 0+ 6. 3*:. 2'7*.6R
!+ 2C 20,C+:. /(02*:0+7*.V %06.27' X=.((. ./06S . C+ /.( :0 405bB'(.2 (0306.:'(.2 DC0 .6C:0+ . 6.
+0702*:.: :0 30+70(V :'4025*7.( H 03*5.( 6. .+.(DCc. :0 6. +.5C(.60_.>
!+ 06 <;*4='(._' 20 025b '=6*,.+:' .6 <;.4=' . .=.+:'+.( 2C 0,'c24' H . 20( 06040+5' :0
3*:. .,(c7'6. H 0+0(,c. 06i75(*7. ImQR -'( '=(. :0 0250 #'=*0(+'V ‚S*,.6' =*0+ 7*0(5. /(0+2.s
/'(
'=(.
:0
0250
#'=*0(+'V
20
50(4*+S
6.
3c.
@6'(02
H
;'H
20
/C0:0
660,.(
.
Z.=.;'H'
0+
.C5'4S3*6 . /02.( :06 *+3*0(+' H :0 6. 66C3*.R !6 (c' <(*25.6 20 :02='(:SV *((C4/*SV :025('_S
2075'(02 .+5*,C'2 :0 6. 3c. @6'(02R X+40:*.5.40+50 06 #'=*0(+' (05S .6 (c' .+.(DC*_.:'V H
3C0630 6. 3c. @6'(02 . 20( 6._' :0 C+*S+ 0+5(0 6. <'25. H 6. 1*0((. ImQR Ec'2 5.+ .*26.:'2 :0 6.
2'7*0:.: 7'4' 06 -*2DC0V 0+ 06 +'(50 :0 6. E0/q=6*7.V 2*0+50+ .;'(. DC0 6. 5i7+*7. 7'+2/*(.
7'+5(. 066'2 /.(. 7*3*6*_.(6'2 H (0+:*(6'2 .6 02BC0(_' ;C4.+' I0+ 8'2 2C702'2 N^dO> 3'6R LV /R
`L` H `LdQR
8.2 '=(.2 /q=6*7.2 7'+25*5CH0+ C+' :0 6'2 .2/075'2 4b2 *4/'(5.+502 :0 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+R !6
.+*4.6 20 .:./5. . 6. +.5C(.60_.R !6 ;'4=(0 (*,0 6. +.5C(.60_.V 6. .:./5. . 6.2 +0702*:.:02
;C4.+.2R
9
4.H'(
7*3*6*_.7*S+V
4.H'(02
H
4b2
*4/'(5.+502
'=(.2
/q=6*7.2R
9
4.H'(
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 59/67
e\
20+2*=*6*:.: ;C4.+.V 4b2 0W*,0+7*.2 (02/075' . 6.2 '=(.2 /q=6*7.2 /.(. DC0 6. ,0',(.Bc. 20
(*+:. . 6'2 .+;06'2 ;C4.+'2 I0+ Z.6.+70 N^dO> LL\QR
!+ 025. 30(2*S+ :0 6.2 7'2.2V 6. +.5C(.60_. 02 C+. BC0(_. DC0 20 +'2 '/'+0 H 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+ 7'+2*250 0+
2'4050(6. .6 /':0( ;C4.+'R !6 4*24' .6*0+5' /('4050*7' 20 0+7C0+5(. 0+ 6. 7*5. :06 /(02*:0+50
<.4*6' -'+70 !+(cDC0_V (0/(':C7*:. /b,*+.2 .5(b2R
-0(' +' 02 06 q+*7' *4.,*+.(*' DC0 /':04'2 (.25(0.( 0+ 025'2 .r'2R J.H .6 40+'2 '5(' :*25*+5' DC0
0+B.5*_.V 0+ 7.4=*'V C+. 7'4C+*S+ 0 *:0+5*:.: 0+5(0 6. ;C4.+*:.: H 6. +.5C(.60_.V 0+5(0 06 '(:0+ :0
6. 2'7*0:.: H 06 '(:0+ :06 7'24'2R !2 06 (.25(' DC0 0+7'+5(.4'2 0+ 7*0(5.2 B'(4.2 :0 3*5.6*24'
7'+20(3.:'( DC0 (07.67.+ 6. +0702*:.: :0 20,C*( 6.2 2.=*.2 (0,6.2 :0 6. +.5C(.60_.V :*75.:.2 /'( ?*'2V
0 *4*5.(6.2 0+ 2C =0660_.V 2C 2.=*:C(c. H 2C .(4'+c. 706025*.6R
-'( 7'+2*,C*0+50V /.(. 7'+'70( . ?*'2 .C5'( :0 6. +.5C(.60_.V +' 02 +0702.(*' 603.+5.( 6.
3*25. .6 7*06' H /.20.(6. /'( 6'2 *+40+2'2 02/.7*'2 2*:0(.602 2.6/*7.:'2 :0 /C+5'2 =(*66.+502
DC0 5*5*6.+ 7'+ 6C_ 2'+(*0+50 7.:. +'7;0V 7'4' C+ B025c+ :0 ;'+'( /0(4.+0+50 . 2C :*3*+'
J.70:'(
ImQR
-.(.
7.0(
:0
;*+'G'2
.+50
6.
03*:0+7*.
:0
6.
2.=*:C(c.
H
/':0(
:0
C+
10(
1C/(04' DC0 5':' ;. ;07;'V 7'+20(3. H ,'=*0(+.V =.25. B*G.( 6. 3*25. H 6. 7'+2*:0(.7*S+ 0+ 6.
,'5. :0 .,C. 7(*25.6*+. H 504=6'('2. DC0 7C06,. :0 C+. ;'G. H 6C7;. 7'+ 6. /(0/'+:0(.+50
60H :0 6. ,(.30:.:a =.25. 4*(.( 6. B6'( 7CH'2 /i5.6'2 20 .=(0+ B025*3'2 . 6. /(*40(. 6C_ :06 2'6
:0 6. 4.r.+.V ' 06 +*:' :0 (C*20r'(02 0+ :'+:0 6. 3*:. /.6/*5. .4'('2.V H 7'+5*0+0 4b2
025C/0+:'2 4*250(*'2 DC0 06 4*24' 7*06' :0 .25('2 6C4*+'2'2R ?02:0 06 b5'4' 4b2
*4/0(B075' :0 6'2 4C+:'2 ;.25. 06 ;'4=(0 (0H :0 6. 7(0.7*S+V 5':' 0+ 06 7'4/605'
0+,(.+.G0 :06 C+*30(2'V +'2 ;.=6. :0 6. ,6'(*. :0 ?*'2 IZ'605c+ !7602*b25*7'N^`d> NLeQR
!2. /0(B077*S+ 5(.270+:0+50 +' 02 5.+ 2'6' C+ 5025*4'+*' 06'7C0+50 :025*+.:' . .60+5.( 6. /C(.
7'+504/6.7*S+ :0
6.
,6'(*.
:*3*+.R
!2
C+
4':06'
:0
'(,.+*_.7*S+
/.(.
6.
2'7*0:.:V
7'+
2C
G0(.(DCc.V
2C '(:0+ H 2C2 *4/6*7.7*'+02>
<'+504/604'2 20r'(02V 6. +.5C(.60_.a 0+ 066. 5':' 02 .(4S+*7'a C+'2 20 2*(30+ . '5('2V 6'2
(0*+'2 +.5C(.602V 06 .+*4.6 .6 30,05.6V 06 30,05.6 .6 .+*4.6 H 5':'2 .6 ;'4=(0R "' ;.H 7(*.5C(.
:0 6.2 *+B0(*'(02 . i250 0+ 6. 027.6. w''6S,*7. DC0 +' 50+,. .6,C+. 4.+0(. :0 6*4*5.7*S+ 0+
=0+0B*7*' :0 '5(. 7(*.5C(.a +*+,C+. /C0:0 .6_.( 2C 3'_ /.(. /(0,'+.( (0=06:c. .=2'6C5.V
.=2'6C5. *+:0/0+:0+7*.a /.(. :07*(> H' 40 2'H 5':' 0+ 06 '(:0+ :0 5':. (0.6*:.:a 6'2 :04b2
20(02 .+50 4c 2'+ 7'4' +.:.R €y ;. :0 20( 06 ;'4=(0 (.7*'+.6V 06 ;'4=(0 (.7*'+.6 H (*7'V 06
q+*7' DC0 20 603.+50 0+ 40:*' :0 6. +.5C(.60_.V 7'4' C+. 02/07*0 ./.(50 :0 4'+.(7.
.=2'6C5' /(0,'+.+:'
DC0
5*0+0
:0(07;'
. ;.70(
:0
7C.+5'
02
2CH'
6'
DC0
20
60
.+5'G0a
2*+
5'4.( 0+ 7'+2*:0(.7*S+ 6.2 60H02 :0 6. 4'(.6 7(*25*.+.V +' :*,' :0 066.V :0 6. 4'(.6 C+*30(2.6a
2*+ +'5.( 6. 4C5C. :0/0+:0+7*. H 7'+:*7*'+.6*:.: :0 C+'2 20(02 7'+ '5('2 :0 DC0 +'2 :.
6077*S+ 06'7C0+50 06 4*24' 4C+:' *+.+*4.:'o IY.+C06 !6*7*' @6'( N^`LQR
"' 02 C+. :*B0(0+7*. 40+'(R 8'2 *4.,*+.(*'2 :0 6'2 /(*40('2V 4C7;' 4b2 BC0(50 0+5(0 6'2 .:0/5'2 .6
6*=0(.6*24'V 7'+2*:0(.+ . 6. +.5C(.60_. C+. BC0(_. =(C5. H /(0 ] 7C65C(.6 DC0 :0=0 20( 2'405*:. H
30+7*:. 0+ 6' DC0 405.BS(*7.40+50 20 .2'7*. 7'+ C+. ,C0((.R !+50+:0( 2C2 60H02 :0 BC+7*'+.4*0+5'
02 C+. 025(.5.,04. ' C+ .(:*: /.(. :0(('5.(6.LPR !+ 025'2 *4.,*+.(*'2V 20 7'+2*:0(. 06 02/c(*5C
LP j-'( /(*40(. 30_ l7'+ 06 7./*5.6nV 6. +.5C(.60_. 20 7'+3*0(50 0+ C+ 40(' '=G05' /.(. 6. 02/07*0 ;C4.+.V 0+ C+ /C('
'=G05' :0 C5*6*:.:a :0G. :0 20( (07'+'7*:. 7'4' C+ /':0( 0+ 2c 4*24'V H 06 :027C=(*4*0+5' 50'(i5*7' :0 2C2 60H02
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 60/67
e^
(q25*7'V 5'(/0 0 *+:'60+50 :0 6'2 7.4/02*+'2 0 *+:c,0+.2 . 7*3*6*_.( 7'4' C+. 0W50+2*S+ :0 6.
+.5C(.60_. /(*4*5*3. H /(0 ] 2'7*.6 . :'4025*7.(L\R 8'2 *4.,*+.(*'2 :0 6'2 20,C+:'2V /'( 2C /.(50V 4b2
70(7.+'2 .6 7'+20(3.:C(*24'V *4.,*+.+ 6. 2'7*0:.: 7'4' C+ 5':' '(,b+*7' DC0 7'4/.(50 7'+ 6.
+.5C(.60_. 2C2 (0,6.2V 2C2 G0(.(DCc.2 H 7CH' 4':06' ;.H DC0 *4*5.(R "' ;.H C+. ,C0((.V
405.BS(*7.40+50 ;.=6.+:'V 2*+' C+. B(.50(+*:.:V /.(07*:. .6 j7C65' :0 6. +.5C(.60_.k 20r.6.:' /'(
Y.(WR "'
+*0,.+
06
/(',(02'
+*
6.
7*0+7*.
+*
6.
+0702*:.:
:0
7*3*6*_.(
. 6'2
*+:*'2V
/0('
0+
066'
+'
20
.60G.+ :06 '(:0+ +.5C(.6 2*+' DC0 6' (07C/0(.+RL^
!+ 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :06 ./.(.5' (0,C6.:'( H 3*,*6.+50 :06 !25.:'V :'4*+.('+ 6.2 C(,0+7*.2
*+25(C40+5.602 4.(7.:.2 /'( 06 '=G05*3' :0 6',(.( 06 /(',(02' 4.50(*.6 40:*.+50 06 7(07*4*0+5'
07'+S4*7'R 96,C+.2 .75*3*:.:02 /.(070+ .4'6:.(20 . 6. *:0. :0 C+. (c,*:. 20/.(.7*S+ 0+5(0 6.
;C4.+*:.: H 6. +.5C(.60_.V 7'4' 6.2 DC0 /(02*:0+ 6. 7'+:C75. ;.7*. 6.2 2063.2V 4*0+5(.2 DC0 '5(.2
/.(070+ 3*+7C6.(6.2 025(07;.40+50 7'4' 6.2 DC0 .2*4*6.+ 06 4.+0G' :0 6.2 (._.2 30,05.602 .6 :0 6.2
(._.2 ;C4.+.2R 96,C+.2 :0 066.2V 7'4' 06 7'+5('6 :0 /6.,.2 0+ 6'2 7C65*3'2 7'40(7*.602V /':(c.+
(06.7*'+.(20 Bb7*640+50 7'+ 6. *:0. :06 02BC0(_' /'( (0+:*( . C+ '/'+0+50 DC0 20 04/0r. 0+
*+50(/'+0(
'=25b7C6'2
0+
+C025('
7.4*+'
.6
/(',(02'R
$5(.2V
7'4'
6.
2*04=(.
:0
b(='602
/.(.
4.:0(. 0+ (004/6._' :0 6'2 b(='602 DC0 20 5.6.+ ' 6. :0 .:07C.( 6.2 .75*3*:.:02 .,(c7'6.2 . 6'2
(*54'2 :0 :027.+2' H ('5.7*S+ DC0 (0DC*0(0+ 6'2 2C06'2 /.(. (07C/0(.(20V /':(c.+ 3*+7C6.(20 . 6.
*:0. :0 .7'4':.(20 . 7*0(5.2 0W*,0+7*.2 H 7*76'2 +.5C(.602 DC0 +' /':04'2 ' :0=04'2 B'(_.(R 8'2
66.4.:'2 :0 Y.(*.+' 1Cb(0_ %0*+5*4*66. . 0W/0(*40+5.( 7'+ 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 6'7.602 :0 /./.V .C+DC0
+' BC0(.+ 20,C*:'2 /'( 6'2 (02/'+2.=602 5i7+*7'2 /'250(*'(02V /C0:0+ 04/.(0+5.(20 7'+ 6. *:0. :0
DC0 ;.H C+ '(:0+ H C+. 6S,*7. 2C/0(*'(02 0+ .DC066' DC0 /'7' . /'7' 20 .:./5S . 6.2 7'+:*7*'+02
6'7.602 0+ 06 6.(,' 7C(2' :0 6'2 2*,6'2R "' 02 .6,' . 30+70( H . :0207;.( 7'4' C+ '=25b7C6' .6
/(',(02'V 2*+' .6,' :0 6' DC0 /':04'2 ./(0+:0( H 2.7.( /('307;'R
"' ;.H
C+
2'6'
*4.,*+.(*'
/'2*=60
:05(b2
:0
6.2
/(0'7C/.7*'+02
DC0
*+B'(4.+
06
2C(,*4*0+5'
:0
6.2
*+25.+7*.2 :0 ,'=*0(+' .4=*0+5.6 :0+5(' :06 !25.:'R -0(' ;.H .6,' DC0 7'4/.(50+V 4b2 .66b :0 2C2
:*B0(0+7*.2 4.+*B*025.2> C+. 7'4q+ 7'+3*77*S+ 0+ 6. 2C/0(*'(*:.: 4'(.6 :06 ;'4=(0 2'=(0 6'2 :04b2
20(02 3*3'2a 6. *:0. :0 C+. ./.=C66.+50 G0(.(DCc. 7'+ 6'2 20(02 ;C4.+'2 0+ 6. 7C4=(0R !25.
7'+3*77*S+ 6'2 3'63c. 7*0,'2 .+50 .DC066. +.5C(.60_. DC0 BC+7*'+.=. /'( 2C 7C0+5. H DC0 /':c. 20(
.B075.:. :0 4':'2 DC0 +' /.(07c.+ 3'630(20 :*(075.40+50 7'+5(. 6'2 20(02 ;C4.+'2R 8' DC0
DC0:.=. /'( BC0(. :0 6. S(=*5. :06 C2' ;C4.+' 20 3'63c. *+3*2*=60V H 06 C2' ;C4.+' 4b2 *+40:*.5'
0(. 06 ./('3*2*'+.4*0+5' :0 (07C(2'2R
92cV 0+5(0 6'2 .r'2 N^`M H N^OMV 6. .77*S+ .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:' 20 0W50+:*S 60+5. H :i=*640+50 2'=(0
6. =.20
:0
/(0'7C/.7*'+02
jC+*6.50(.602k>
06
7C*:.:'
:0
5.6
' 7C.6
/(':C75'V
:0
5.6
' 7C.6
06040+5'
B*+.+7*0(.40+50 q5*6 :0 6'2 2*2504.2 +.5C(.602R X+76C2' 2* ;.H *+:*7*'2 :0 DC0 20 7'+'70+ 6.2 (._'+02
DC0 025b+ 0+ 6. =.20 :0 6'2 /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602V 7'4' '7C((*S 7'+ 6.2 /6.,.2 :06 7.7.' ' 06
=.+.+'V 6.2 2'6C7*'+02 . 6.2 DC0 20 .B0((.=.+ 7'+ B0(3'( 7.2* (06*,*'2' 025.=.+ 2*04/(0 .5.:.2 .6
.C5S+'4.2 ./.(070 40(.40+50 7'4' C+ .(:*: :025*+.:' . 2'4050(6. . 6.2 +0702*:.:02 ;C4.+.2 IRRRQ !6 7./*5.6 (0=.2. 6.2 =.((0(.2 H /(0GC*7*'2 +.7*'+.602 .2c 7'4' 06 7C65' . 6. +.5C(.60_.k IY.(W N^P\ lN\eP‐N\e\nQR L\
Y*7;*06 Z.C: I.DC*Q ;. 5(.=.G.:' 025. .2'7*.7*S+ 0+5(0 +.5C(.60_. 2.63.G0 H /(*4*5*3*24' *+:c,0+. 0+ 6.2 94i(*7.2R !+ 06 !7C.:'( :0 02'2 .r'2V 6'2 *4.,*+.(*'2 6*=0(.602 2'=(0 6'2 *+:*'2V ;.+ 2*:' 025C:*.:'2 /'( -(*05' ILMMdQV YC(.5'(*' IN^^dQ H
#C0((0(' ILMNMQR L^
1* +' 40 0DC*3'7'V 06 /0+2.4*0+5' 7'+20(3.:'( 6.5*+'.40(*7.+' ;. 2*:' 40+'2 025C:*.:' 5.+5' 0+ 2C 7'+70/7*S+ :0 6'2
*+:c,0+.2 7'4' 0+ 2C ./('W*4.7*S+ . 6. +.5C(.60_.R 1'=(0 !7C.:'( 30( ./0+.2 6.2 40+7*'+02 . 6.2 7'+70/7*'+02 2'=(0 6'2
*+:c,0+.2 0+
h'(,0
K(CG*66'
IN^^`Q
H 06
025C:*'
/S25C4'V
/'7'
.+.6*_.:'V
:06
*4/'(5.+50
/'6c5*7'
0 ;*25'(*.:'(
7'+20(3.:'(
hC6*' K'=.( ?'+'2' IN^^LQR ?0 5':.2 B'(4.2V 6. .2'7*.7*S+ 0+5(0 7'+20(3.:'(02 H 025. B'(4. :0 j3*5.6*24'k +' 02 /0(B075.V 7'4' 6' 4C025(. <.4*6' -'+70V 7CH.2 *:0.2 20 .70(7.+ 4C7;' 4b2 . 6.2 :0 6'2 6*=0(.602R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 61/67
OM
0+B'DC0 C+*6.50(.6> +' 7.4=*.( 6'2 2*2504.2 :0 /(':C77*S+ 2*+' 40G'(.( 6. 3.(*0:.: 5.6 :06 7C65*3'
7C.6R 8. (._S+ 02 5(.+2/.(0+50> /6.+50.(20 C+ 0+B'DC0 4C65*6.50(.6 0W*,c. '=G05*3'2 4b2 3.(*.:'2 0
*4.,*+.(*'2 7'+ G0(.(DCc.2 40+'2 (c,*:.2R
1'6' . B*+02 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^dM 0 *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eMV ./.(070+ 7*0(5'2 7*0+5cB*7'2 +.5C(.6*25.2
:0+5(' :06 !25.:' 7CH'2 :*27C(2'2 =C('7(b5*7'2 04/*0_.+ . 3*+7C6.( 6'2 06040+5'2 +.5C(.602 7CH'2
C2'2 *+50(02. /'50+7*.( 7'+ '5('2 06040+5'2 +.5C(.602 2'=(0 6'2 DC0 5*0+0+ *+B6C0+7*.> 6'2 ='2DC02
2'=(0 06 76*4.V 2'=(0 6. ;C40:.: ' 2'=(0 06 2C06'R Kc4*:.40+50 04/0_.=. . /0+05(.( 0+ 6.
*+25*5C7*'+.6*:.: 025.5.6 6. 7'+2*:0(.7*S+ :0 DC0 6'2 06040+5'2 :*(075.40+50 q5*602 /.(. C2'2
07'+S4*7'2 ;C4.+'2 0(.+ /.(50 :0 2*2504.2 07'6S,*7'2 *+50,(.:'2 0 *+50(:0/0+:*0+502 7CH.2
1'2#8%*&'- H +' 2'6' 7CH'2 '2'"'&,*-V :0=0+ 20( 7'+2*:0(.:'2 /.(. C+. /'6c5*7. :0 /('5077*S+
.4=*0+5.6R
8. ./('W*4.7*S+ C+*6.50(.6 .6 4.+0G' .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:' 20 0W/(02. 7'+ 76.(*:.: 40(*:*.+. 0+ 6.
*+0W*250+7*. :0 /(0'7C/.7*'+02 (02/075' . 6. 7'+5.4*+.7*S+ /('3'7.:. /'( 6. 4*+0(c. H 06 /05(S60'a
/0(' 5.4=*i+ 0+ C+. 4*(.:. :0 6'2 /b(.4'2 H 6'2 ='2DC02 +.5C(.602 7'4' 02/.7*'2 :02/0(:*7*.:'2 '
*+q5*602R !2 6. 4*24. C+*6.50(.6*:.: DC0 /C0:0 0+7'+5(.(20 0+ 6. B'(4. 0+ DC0 20 .='(:.=. 06 7'+5('6
:0 /6.,.2R
-0(' *+76C2' :02:0 025. ./('W*4.7*S+ C+*6.50(.6V 6'2 02BC0(_'2 025.5.602 *+*7*.602 /.(. 6. ,025*S+
.4=*0+5.6 BC0('+ :i=*602 H 0+5(07'(5.:'2R !+ 40:*' :0 6. 7(*2*2 B*27.6 DC0 3*3c. 06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+'V
6.2 !25.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602V 6.2 'B*7*+.2 B'(025.602 H 6'2 /(',(.4.2 :0 2.+*:.: .+*4.6 ' 30,05.6
7.(07c.+ :0 .C5'(*:.:V :0 /0(2'+.6 H :0 *+B'(4.7*S+ /.(. .75C.( :0 4.+0(. 0B*7*0+50 H '/'(5C+.R 8.
DC0G. 02 5.+ B(07C0+50 DC0 20 3C0630 C+. 605.+c.R E0306. 06 /'7' /':0( /'6c5*7' DC0 .7C4C6.('+
025.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 /(07C(2'(.2 :0 6. /(0'7C/.7*S+ .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+'R
-0(' BC0('+ 06 *+*7*'R !+ 0250 5c4*:' 7'4*0+_'V 6. *4.,0+ DC0 040(,0 :0 6'2 :'7C40+5'2 (03*2.:'2
02 DC0 2C '(*,0+ 025b BC+:.:' 4b2 0+ 6.2 C(,0+7*.2 :06 .C40+5' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ H 0+ 6. /('4'7*S+
:06 :02.(('66' 07'+S4*7' DC0 0+ 6.2 :04.+:.2 :0 6'2 3.(*.:'2 .75'(02 2'7*.602 .B075.:'2 /'( 6.
:025(C77*S+ :06 .4=*0+50 H :0 2C2 40:*'2 :0 3*:.R K.6 30_ 20. 2'6' C+ (0B60G' :0B'(4.:' :0 6.2
BC0+502 (03*2.:.2 ‐ 6'2 *+B'(402 4*+*250(*.602 BC+:.40+5.640+50 ‐ DC0 4CH '/.7.40+50 :0G.+
0+5(030( 6. /(020+7*. :0V /'( 0G04/6'V 6'2 7.4/02*+'2 (076.4.+:' 2C :0(07;' :0 .7702' . 6. /027.
0+ 6'2 (c'2 :0 6. <'25.V /0(' 5.6 30_ 20. 6. 20r.6 :0 C+. 7.(0+7*. 4b2 /('BC+:.a DC*_b2 20. C+' :0 6'2
B.75'(02 *4/'(5.+502 DC0 0W/6*7.+ 6.2 :0=*6*:.:02 0+ 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ H 0+ 6. 7./.7*:.: :0
*+50(30+7*S+ .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+'R
C8
V-)&'",7*&)"R+
$-+-%&*
!6 .(5c7C6' 4C025(. 6'2 7.4=*'2 0+ 6. '(,.+*_.7*S+ H 6.2 /'6c5*7.2 025.5.602 :06 !7C.:'( (02/075' .6
.4=*0+50 0+5(0 N^Le H N^OMV DC0 02 06 /0(c':' 0+ 06 DC0 +.7*0('+ 6.2 /(*40(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 0
*+25*5C7*'+02 0+7.(,.:.2 02/07cB*7.40+50 :06 504. .+502 :0 2C /60+. B'(4.6*_.7*S+ 0+5(0 6'2 .r'2
N^OM H N^^MR
8.2 /(*40(.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 :06 2075'( /q=6*7' 07C.5'(*.+' 0+7.(,.:.2 :0 6*:*.( 7'+ /('=604.2
.4=*0+5.602 +.7*0('+ 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^LM 6C0,' :06 :02/6'40 07'+S4*7' 7.7.'50(' /('3'7.:' /'( :'2
/6.,.2 H C+. 7(*2*2 :0 /(07*'2R !25. 7(*2*2 30(:.:0(.40+50 :03.25.:'(. 6603S .6 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+' .6
7'+30+7*4*0+5' :0 DC0 :0=c. *+50(30+*( 0+ 6. .,(*7C65C(. 7'+ 20(3*7*'2 :0 :0B0+2. H :0 3*,*6.+7*.
2.+*5.(*. .,(c7'6. H /07C.(*.V ./'H' . 6. 0((.:*7.7*S+ 0 *+3025*,.7*S+ /'2*=602 2'6C7*'+02 .6 /('=604.
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 62/67
ON
:0 6.2 /02502 :0 7C65*3'2 H ,.+.:'R !+ C+ 7'+50W5' 4C+:*.6 :0 0W/.+2*S+ :0 6'2 20(3*7*'2 :06 !25.:' H
:0 7(0.7*S+ :0 025.7*'+02 :0 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+V 06 !7C.:'( 20 :*(*,*S 2*+ 4.H'(02 2'(/(02.2 . C+
/('702' /.C6.5*+' :0 *+50(30+7*S+ 025.5.6 0+ 06 7.4/' :06 4.+0G' .,('/07C.(*'V DC0 ;.25. 0+5'+702
;.=c. 2*:' .5(*=C7*S+ 0W76C2*3. :0 .75'(02 /(*3.:'2R
10 .(,C40+5.V 0+5'+702V DC0 06 7'+5('6 :0 6.2 /6.,.2 :06 7.7.'V :0 '5('2 7C65*3'2 H :06 ,.+.:' BC0 6.
B'(4. ;*25S(*7. 40:*.+50 6. 7C.6 06 .4=*0+50 *+,(02S 0+ 06 7.4/' :0 *+50(i2 :06 !25.:'R 9C+DC0 BC0
2*+ :C:. C+. B'(4. (025(*+,*:. H 025(07;. :0 7'+2*:0(.( 06 j.4=*0+50kV 6*4*5b+:'6' . C+ /('=604.
2.+*5.(*' H /(':C75*3'V i25. BC0 6. B'(4. :0 +.7*4*0+5' :0 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 025.5.602 /.(. 06
4.+0G' .4=*0+5.6R
8'2 0+B'DC02 :06 5(.=.G' :0 6.2 !25.7*'+02 9,(c7'6.2 !W/0(*40+5.602 (0306.+ DC0 0+5(0 6.2 3.(*.2
2'6C7*'+02 *+3025*,.:.2 . 6' 6.(,' :0 7C.5(' :i7.:.2V :025.7.=. 6. *+3025*,.7*S+ 2'=(0 3.(*0:.:02 :0
7C65*3.(02 B'(b+0'2 4b2 (02*250+502 . 6.2 /6.,.2 H 0+B0(40:.:02R 10 =C27.=.+ .+50 5':' H
.B.+'2.40+50 4b,*7.2 3.(*0:.:02 :0 7.7.' H '5('2 7C65*3'2 DC0 BC0(.+ . C+ 5*04/' .65.40+50
/(':C75*3.2 0 *+4C+02 . 6.2 /6.,.2R ?0 025. 4.+0(. 20 /':c. 4.+50+0( 06 4*24' 2*2504. :0
/(':C77*S+ 0+ 4'+'7C65*3'2 *+50+2*3'2 . ,(.+ 027.6.R 8'2 7'+5*+C'2 B(.7.2'2 0W/0(*40+5.602 H
/(b75*7'2 +C+7. :0=*6*5.('+ 6. B0 DC0 6'2 5i7+*7'2 50+c.+ 0+ 6. 7*0+7*. H 06 7'+'7*4*0+5' 7'4' 6.
2'6C7*S+ .6 /('=604. .,(c7'6.R
!2/'(b:*7.2 66.4.:.2 :0 .50+7*S+ 2'=(0 6. +0702*:.: :0 7.4=*'2 0+ 6'2 2*2504.2 :0 7C65*3'V :0
7'+20,C*( C+. '(:0+.7*S+ :*B0(0+50 :06 C2' :06 2C06' ' :0 4':*B*7.( 06 i+B.2*2 0+ 06 025C:*' :0 6.2
3.(*0:.:02 :0 7C65*3.(02 0WS5*7'2 (03.6'(.+:' 6. /'50+7*.6*:.: :0 6.2 3.(*0:.:02 *+:c,0+.2V +C+7.
.650(.('+ 06 20+5*:' 70+5(.6 :0 6.2 *+3025*,.7*'+02R J.7*. *+*7*'2 :0 6'2 .r'2 N^eM 06 4.H'( 7.4=*' 0+
6. .75*3*:.: :0 6.2 025.7*'+02 !W/0(*40+5.602 '7C((*S /'(DC0 6. j*+3025*,.7*S+k 04/0_S . 20(
:02/6._.:. /'( 6. j0W50+2*S+k 7'4' C+ 40:*' /.(. 6603.( 6. 6C_ :06 7'+'7*4*0+5' 0+,0+:(.:' 0+ 6.2
025.7*'+02 0W/0(*40+5.602 . 6'2 7.4/'2 660+'2 :0 .,(*7C65'(02 H 7C=*0(5'2 :0 5*+*0=6.2R !+ 06 7.4*+'
:0 *+3025*,.( H :*BC+:*( 06 7'+'7*4*0+5' .:DC*(*:'V 6.2 025.7*'+02 7C4/6c.+ 6. BC+7*S+ :0 C+.
*((.:*.7*S+ 7C65C(.6 2*+ 6. 7C.6 5':' 02BC0(_' 07'+S4*7' 20(c. 0+ 3.+' /'( 6. +.5C(.60_. *+:'60+50V
(C5*+.(*. H 5(.:*7*'+.6*25. :0 6'2 .,(*7C65'(02R
!6 ,(.+ /('=604. DC0 6.2 025.7*'+02 :0 0W/0(*40+5.7*S+ :0=c.+ (02'630( 0(. 7S4' (02'630( 6'2
/('=604.2 2.+*5.(*'2 DC0 :050+c.+ 06 7(07*4*0+5' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ H 06 .C40+5' :0 6.2 (*DC0_.2
7'40(7*.602R !6 7'+5('6 :0 6.2 /6.,.2 02 2'6' C+ 7'4/'+0+50 :0 6. =q2DC0:. :0 C+. /(':C77*S+
(0:'=6.:. H C+. (*DC0_. 4C65*/6*7.:.R !2. BC0 6. (._S+ /'( 6. 7C.6 7*0(5.2 2'6C7*'+02 . 6'2 /('=604.2
2.+*5.(*'2V 40+7*'+.:.2 02/'(b:*7.40+50 . 6' 6.(,' :0 6'2 .r'2V +' BC0('+ .7',*:.2R 8. 40+'(
*+50+2*:.: :06 7C65*3' 7'40(7*.6V 6. :*30(2*B*7.7*S+ .,(c7'6. 0+ 6.2 /.(706.2 ' 6. (0:C77*S+ :0 6.
2C/0(B*7*0 :0 6'2 7C65*3'2 7'40(7*.602 . 6.2 b(0.2 4b2 ./('/*.:.2V /':c.+ (0:C7*( ' :*B0(*( 06
7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7'R 1'6C7*'+02 DC0 /(':CG0(.+ 2040G.+502 0B075'2V +' 0(.+ 2'6C7*'+02R
!+5'+702V +' 2'6' DC0 2C 0+B'DC0 :0 5(.=.G' 025.=. 7'+:*7*'+.:' /'( 06 '=G05*3' /(*+7*/.6 :0
/('4'30( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 2*+' DC0 2'6' .DC066'2 B.75'(02 .4=*0+5.602 DC0V 7'4' 6.2
/6.,.2V 50+c.+ 0B075'2 :.r*+'2 2'=(0 :*7;' 7(07*4*0+5' /':c.+ 20( j:05075.:'2k /'( 6'2 (.:.(02 :06
!25.:'R
8. .4/6*.7*S+ :06 7.4/' :0 .+b6*2*2 ;.7*. 6.2 /'6c5*7.2 :0 7'+5('6 :0 6.2 /02DC0(c.2V :0 6. 0('2*S+V :0
6. 0W5(.77*S+ B'(025.6 H :0 6.2 7'4/.rc.2 4*+0(.2 H /05('60(.2 /0(4*5*S 7'4/('=.( DC0 6. 4*24.
/(*'(*:.: /'( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 20 (0/05c. H DC0 06 7.4/' :0 j3*2*S+k 025.5.6 50+c. 0+ 5':.2
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 63/67
OL
066.2 6.2 4*24.2 (025(*77*'+02 0+7'+5(.:.2 0+ 6.2 /6.,.2 :06 7.7.'R !+ 7.:. C+' :0 025'2 7.4/'2
+C03'2 20 7'+B*(4.=. 6. 4*24. '=202*S+> 5':. .75*3*:.: 025.5.6 2'=(0 504.2 .4=*0+5.602 025.=.
7'+075.:. 7'+ 06 '=G05*3' :0 .4/6*.( 6.2 (*DC0_.2 4.50(*.602 H 06 :*+.4*24' 07'+S4*7'R 8. 0('2*S+
04/0_S . 20( C+ /('=604. 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^dMV 7C.+:' 06 :050(*'(' :0 6.2 5*0((.2 0+ 6. 1*0((.
.40+._.=.+ 6. /(':C77*S+ H 20 /(':C7c.+ C+ .40+._.+50 0W702' :0 /'=6.7*S+ 7.4/02*+.R 8.
B'(025.7*S+ BC0
C+.
B'(4.
:0
3.6'(*_.(
/b(.4'2
*+C5*6*_.:'2V
:0
/('300(
:0
4.:0(.
. 6'2
7.4/'2
:0
6. 1*0((. ' . 6. 0W/'(5.7*S+a 4*0+5(.2 DC0 6. /(0'7C/.7*S+ /'( 6. 7'+20(3.7*S+ :0 02/07*02 +.5*3.2 20
(025(*+,c. . .DC066.2 :0 3.6'( 7'40(7*.6 DC0 7'4' 6. DC*+*+.V 6. 5.,C. ' 6. =.62. 20 ;.=c.+ 7'+30(5*:'
0+ C+ (0+,6S+ :0 0W/'(5.7*S+ *4/'(5.+50 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^`MR !+ 6. /027. 4.(c5*4. 6. /(*+7*/.6
/(0'7C/.7*S+ 02 DC0 025.=. 2*0+:' ./('307;.:. /'( =.(7'2 0W5(.+G0('2 2*+ :0G.( =0+0B*7*'2 .6 B*27' H
DC0 6'2 /027.:'(02 +' 50+c.+ 2CB*7*0+50 7./.7*:.: 0W5(.75*3. /.(. ./('307;.( C+. (*DC0_. DC0 +'
=0+0B*7*.=. .6 /.c2R 1'6' 4CH 5.(:c.40+50V 0+ N^OMV ./.(070 6. /(*40(. 40+7*S+ .6 6c4*50 :0 /027.
20,q+ 6. :*2/'+*=*6*:.: :0 7.(:q40+02R
!+ 6. 4*+0(c. H 06 /05(S60' 5':. 6. /(0'7C/.7*S+ 20 (0:C7c. . .C40+5.( 6. 0W/6'(.7*S+ /.(. 0W/.+:*(
6.2 (020(3.2V
.C40+5.(
6.
/(':C77*S+
:0
'('
H 03*5.(
6.2
*4/'(5.7*'+02
:0
,.2'6*+.2R
"C+7.V
0+
4b2
:0 5(0*+5. .r'2V 20 40+7*'+. 06 /06*,(' :0 6. 7'+5.4*+.7*S+ +* 20 ;.70 .6C2*S+ . C+ 2'6' :0((.40R
<'4' 6'2 (c'2 H 6'2 2C06'2 .B075.:'2 +' 6*4*5.+ 6. /(':C77*S+ +* 6. /'+0+ 0+ (*02,'V 20+7*66.40+50 +'
0W*250+R 1'+ C+ 02/.7*' :0G.+:' 0+ =6.+7'R -.(. 6.2 '(,.+*_.7*'+02 0 *+25*5C7*'+02 025.5.602
0+7.(,.:.2 :06 7'+5('6 :06 /05(S60' H 6. 4*+0(c.V 6'2 030+5C.602 /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602 :0
7'+5.4*+.7*S+ 20+7*66.40+50 :02./.(07c.+ :06 ;'(*_'+50 :0 3*2*=*6*:.:R 1* .6,' DC0:. 76.(' 02 DC0
4*0+5(.2 06 +0,'7*' +' 20 30. .B075.:'V 6'2 /'2*=602 /('=604.2 .4=*0+5.602 :0 6. 4*+0(c. +'
40(070+ C+. 40+7*S+ :*(075.R "' 2'+V 0+ 30(:.:V j/('=604.2k /.(. 06 !25.:'R
8. '=202*S+ /'( 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' .+*:. 0+ C+ *4/0(.5*3' 4b2 .4/6*'> 20 6' 7'+2*:0(. 6.
=.20
4.50(*.6
:06
j/(',(02'kV
DC0
;.
2*:'
C+.
/0(2*250+50
.2/*(.7*S+
2'7*.6
DC0
:02/Ci2
:0
6.
10,C+:. #C0((. YC+:*.6 20 66.4S j:02.(('66'kR !+ C+ 0+5(06._.4*0+5' *+:*2'7*.=60V 06 /(',(02' +'
20 (06.7*'+. 2'6' 7'+ 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' 2*+' 7'+ 06 .C40+5' :0 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+ H 06 :02/6*0,C0
:0 +C03.2 7C.6*:.:02 4'(.602R -0(' 06 .C40+5' :0 6. /(':C77*S+ H 6. (*DC0_. 02 C+' :0 2C2
BC+:.40+5'2 4b2 :07*2*3'2R 10 0+5*0+:0 0+5'+702 2C /02' :027'66.+50 5.+5' /.(. .65'2 (02/'+2.=602
/'6c5*7'2 +0702*5.:'2 :0 +C03.2 '=(.2 7'4' /.(. 5i7+*7'2 H BC+7*'+.(*'2 (0='2.+502 :0 7'+B*.+_. 0+
6. 7*0+7*. H 06 7'+'7*4*0+5'R
8. *+3*2*=*6*:.: /.(. 06 025.:' :0 .DC066'2 B.75'(02 .4=*0+5.602 DC0 +' 5*0+0+ ' +' /.(070+ 50+0(
:*(075. (06.7*S+ 7'+ 06 7(07*4*0+5' 07'+S4*7' .+*:. 0+ 7.4=*' 0+ :'2 *4.,*+.(*'2 7'+5(.25.+502 H
/('BC+:'2 2'=(0
2'=(0
06
/./06
:0
6.
+.5C(.60_.
0+
6.
3*:.
2'7*.6R
!+
C+'
:0
066'2V
6.
+.5C(.60_.
02
C+. BC0(_. DC0 20 '/'+0 . 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+ H :0=0 20( 30+7*:. /.(. (0+:*(6. H ,.+.(60 C+. ,C0((. .
4C0(50 /'( 06 :'4*+*' :06 4C+:'R !+ 06 '5('V 0+ 7.4=*'V 0W*250 C+. *:0+5*:.: 0+5(0 6. ;C4.+*:.: H
6. +.5C(.60_.V 0+5(0 06 '(:0+ :0 6. 2'7*0:.: H 06 '(:0+ :06 7'24'2V /'( 6. 7C.6 6. 7*3*6*_.7*S+ 7'+2*250
0+ 20,C*( 6.2 0+20r.+_.2 2.,(.:.2 .7'4':b+:'+'2 . C+ /6.+ :*3*+' 7CH'2 (.25('2 +'2 ;.+ 2*:'
:0G.:'2 /'( :'DC*0( 0+ 6.2 4.(.3*66.2 :0 6. <(0.7*S+R -0(' 0+ .4=.2 30(2*'+02 /0(2*250 C+. 7'4q+
7'+3*77*S+ 0+ 6. 2C/0(*'(*:.: 4'(.6 :06 ;'4=(0 2'=(0 6'2 :04b2 20(02 3*3'2R !25. 7'+3*77*S+ 6'2
3'63c. 7*0,'2 .+50 .DC066. +.5C(.60_. DC0 BC+7*'+.=. /'( 2C 7C0+5. 7'+ C+. *+:*B0(0+50 H B.5.6
.C5'+'4c.R 8' DC0 DC0:.=. /'( BC0(. :0 6. S(=*5. :06 C2' ;C4.+' 20 3'63c. *+3*2*=60V H 06 C2'
;C4.+' 4b2 *+40:*.5' 0(. 06 ./('3*2*'+.4*0+5' :0 (07C(2'2R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 64/67
O`
?02:0 6.2 !25.7*'+02 9,(c7'6.2 !W/0(*40+5.602 0+ 6'2 .r'2 N^LM ;.25. 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6 0+
6'2 .r'2 N^eMV ;04'2 5(.5.:' :0 5(._.( 06 /0(*/6' :0 :'2 .75'(02 0+5(06._.:'2 0+ 6. 7'+25(C77*S+ :06
4.+0G' .4=*0+5.6 :06 !25.:' 07C.5'(*.+'R -'( C+ 6.:'V 6'2 .65'2 BC+7*'+.(*'2 /'6c5*7'2 DC0 0(.+
B'(4.640+50 6'2 G0B02 H (02/'+2.=602 :0 6.2 '(*0+5.7*'+02 :06 !25.:'R -'( '5(' 6.:'V 6'2 5i7+*7'2 H
BC+7*'+.(*'2 40:*'2 DC0 B'(4.640+50 :0=c.+ '=0:*0+7*. /0(' DC0 .20,C(.=.+ C+ 4c+*4' :0
7'+5*+C*:.: H 404'(*.
. 6.2
/'6c5*7.2
/q=6*7.2R
94='2
7'6.='(.=.+
5.+5'
7'4'
20
0+B(0+5.=.+a
7'*+7*:c.+ 5.+5' 7'4' 20 7'+5(.:07c.+R y +*+,C+' 0(. +* 2'=0(.+' +* *+:0/0+:*0+50R ?05(b2 :0 066'2
H . 5(.3i2 2CH'V 040(,c. 5.4=*i+ :0 5.+5' 0+ 5.+5' .6,' DC0 0250 0+2.H' +' ;. 0W/6'(.:'> 06 =.6.+70
*+025.=60 H BC,*5*3' :0 BC0(_.2 2'7*.602 DC0 :*2/C5.=.+ 06 /':0(V :02.B*.=.+ 6'2 20+5*:'2 .5(*=C*:'2 .6
/(',(02' H 4.(7.=.+ 7'+ 2C2 .77*'+02 7'5*:*.+.2 06 (C4=' :0 6. (06.7*S+ 0+5(0 6. +.5C(.60_. H 6.
2'7*0:.:R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 65/67
Od
!"0*"#$%&9S&
9((*,;*V #*'3.++* N^^^ lN^^dnR ?2 2#1$* -%$2* jjD 0%&'1* Y >*('1 '& 2*- *1/$'&'- (' &+'-,1# <>*8#R <R
-(*05' :06 <.4/' I5(.:RQR Y.:(*:> 9~98R <C025*'+02 :0 .+5.,'+*24' `R
93*6i2 9,C*((0V h0(S+*4' N^`LR !&:*1"' b+' '2 @%&%-,1* (' 461#- =U62%8#-; C$1%8+2,+1# Y 7*"'&,*
>1'-'&,#
#
2#
H#8%\&
NOWN‐
NOWPR
[C*5'R
X4/(0+5.
".7*'+.6R
9H.6.V 1R JR N^`PR @%&%-,'1%* (' 461#- =U62%8#-; @%&#- Y )*"+&%8#8%*&'-D !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\& NOWZ‐
NOWl R [C*5'R K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 :0 !:C7.7*S+R
Z.6.+70 N^dOR ?2 PV (' @#Y*D M#2#&8' (' +&# E'3*2+8%\& =*>+2#1D 0*8+"'&,*- >#1# 2# S%-,*1%#D
[C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2R
Z.+7' YC+:*.6 N^^PR ?2 ?-,#(* '& +& "+&(* '& ,1#&-:*1"#8%\&D !&:*1"' -*61' '2 ('-#11*22* "+&(%#2 R
&.2;*+,5'+> Z.+7' YC+:*.6R
Z.DC0(*_' Y'(0+'V E':'6B' N^`dR @%&%-,1* (' X*6%'1&* Y =1'3%-%\& G*8%#2; !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\&; NOWW‐
NOWRR [C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R
Z.('+.V 9(+.6:' N^``R !&:*1"' X'&'1#2 (' .#6*1'- ('2 0'>#1,#"'&,* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; F#-,# '2 WQ ('
i+&%* ('
NOWWR
[C*5'R
Y*+*250(*'
:0
$=(.2
-q=6*7.2V
9,(*7C65C(.V
057R
K.660(02
K*/',(bB*7'2
".7*'+.602R
Z.('+.V 9(+.6:' N^`dD !&:*1"' X'&'1#2 (' .#6*1'- ('2 0'>#1,#"'&,* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; F#-,# '2 WQ ('
i+&%* (' NOWRR [C*5'R Y*+*250(*' :0 $=(.2 -q=6*7.2V 9,(*7C65C(.V 057R K.660(02 #(bB*7'2
".7*'+.602R
M*2',/& ?82'-%k-,%8*D E'3%-,# *:%8%#2 (' 2# C1b+%(%\8'-%- (' m+%,*R 9r' z8X "'R `R Y.(_' :0 N^`dR
Z'6'r.V @(.+7*27' hR N^`MR !&:*1"' ('2 @%&%-,1* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; =1'3%-%\& G*8%#2; ',8D # 2# H#8%\&; NOPO
‐ NOWQR [C*5'R K.660(02 K*/',(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R hC6*'R
<.25'(*.:*2V <'(+06*C2 N^PeD .n!&-,%,+,%*& %"#$%&#%1' (' 2# -*8%<,<R -.(c2> !:*5*'+2 :C 10C*6R
<;*(*=',.V Y.+C06 N^\MR i*1'1*- Y $1#& >1*>%',#1%*- '& NWZ #T*- (' 'a>*1,#8%\& 8#8#*,'1#R [C*5'>
<'+20G' -('3*+7*.6 :0 -*7;*+7;.R
<(.AB'(: :0 E'=0(52V 8'*2 N^\MR ?2 ?8+#(*1 '& 2# <>*8# 8#8#*,'1#` 1'->+'-,#- 2*8#2'- #2 #+$' Y
8*2#>-* '& '2 8%82* "*&*'a>*1,#(*1 R ER [C*+50(' H !R 1H63. I5(.:2RQR [C*5'> !:*5'(*.6 F+*30(2*5.(*.R
<(02/' $(:Sr0_V E*7.(:' N^dLR !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\&D @%&%-,'1%* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; !&(+-,1%#-; @%&#- Y
[+1%-"* NORPR [C*5'R K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 :06 <'60,*' Y*6*5.(R
<C3*V "*7'6b2 LMMeR 8. *+25*5C7*'+.6*_.7*S+ :06 7'+20(3.7*'+*24' 0+ 06 !7C.:'( IN^d^‐N^e`Q> Y*2.06
97'25. 1'6c2 H 06 ?0/.(5.40+5' @'(025.6R !+ =1*8'-*-D E'3%-,# '8+#,*1%#&# (' F%-,*1%#R "'R LLR X ]
XX 104025(02R [C*5'R
<C3*V "*7'6b2 LMMe.R jY*2.06 97'25. 1'6c2 H 06 7'+20(3.7*'+*24' 0+ 06 !7C.:'( IN^`O‐N^e`QkR ?*/6'4.
:0
025C:*'2
.3.+_.:'2V
<0+5(0
:ƒ!25C:*2
:ƒJ*25S(*.
:0
602
<*i+7*02R
Z.(706'+.V
F+*30(2*:.:
9C5S+'4. :0 Z.(706'+.R
<C3*V "*7'6b2 LMM^R 8.2 204*66.2 :06 *4/0(*.6*24' .,(c7'6. 025.:'C+*:0+20 0+ 06 !7C.:'(R !+ =1*8'-*-D
E'3%-,# '8+#,*1%#&# (' F%-,*1%#R "'R `MR XX 104025(0R [C*5'R
?06 J*0(('V E*7.(:' N^`^R !&:*1"' b+' '2 @%&%-,1* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; !&(+-,1%#-; @%&#-; )*"'18%* Y
[+1%-"*; >1'-'&,# # 2# H#8%\& NOWOR [C*5'R K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 :06 <'60,*' Y*6*5.(R
?(.H5'+V E*7;.(: J.((H LMMMR H#,+1'o- X*3'1&"'&,` G8%'&8'; !">'1%#2 M1%,#%&; #&( ,F' o!">1*3'"'&,o
*: ,F' f*12(D "0A J.30+ .+: 8'+:'+> y.60 F+*30(2*5H -(022R
?C(b+ Z.660+ ERV 1R!R N^`MR !&:*1"' b+' '2 @%&%-,1* (' S#8%'&(#; )1<(%,* =U62%8*; M#&8*-; @%&#-;
)*"'18%* Y @#18#- (' 7k61%8# >1'-'&,# # 2# H#8%\&D i+2%* NQ (' NOWQR [C*5'R K.660(02 #(bB*7'2
".7*'+.602R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 66/67
Oe
!,|0_ Z.DC0(*_'V -0:(' -.=6' N^L\R !&:*1"' b+' >1'-'&,# # 2# H#8%\&; '2 @%&%-,1* (' =1'3%-%\& G*8%#2
Y [1#6#A* NOPZ‐NOPVR [C*5'R X4/(0+5. ".7*'+.6R `M :0 20/5*04=(0R
!27'=.(V 9(5C(' N^^OR .# %&3'&8%\& ('2 ['18'1 @+&(*; 8*&-,1+88%\& Y ('8*&-,1+88%\& ('2 ('-#11*22*R
Z','5b> !:*5'(*.6 "'(4.R
!2/*+'2. -RV 9R N^dMR !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\& @%&%-,'1%* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; !&(+-,1%#-; @%&#- Y [+1%-"* NORQR
[C*5'R X4/(0+5.
:06
Y*+*250(*'
:0
9,(*7C65C(.R
@6'(V Y.+C06 !6*7*' N^`LR j@*6'2'Bc. 7(*25*.+. :0 6. /('/*0:.: /(*3.:.kR !+ ?2 0'6#,'D 0%#1%* (' 2#
"#T#&#V LM :0 4.(_' :0 N^`LR
#.6.(_. w.3.6.V h.*40 N^P`R =%1#,#- '& '2 X*2:*R [C*5'> !:*5'(*.6 1'6*5*0((.R
#(0+*0(V <;(*25'/;0 LMMP lLMMMnR )*&-'13#8%\& 8*&,1# &#,+1#D .#- %-2#- X#2k>#$*-R [C*5'> X@!9 p
!4=.G.:. :0 @(.+7*. 0+ !7C.:'( p XE? p F91Z p 9=H. ] y.6.R
#C0((0('V %*(,*6*' N^`PR !&:*1"' ('2 @%&%-,1* (' =1'3%-%\& G*8%#2; C-%-,'&8%# =U62%8#; [1#6#A*;
C$1%8+2,+1#; !&(+-,1%#- Y )*2*&%L#8%\&R [C*5'R K.660(02 K*/',(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R NM :0 .,'25'R
#C0((0('V 9+:(i2 N^\MR .*- *2%$#18#- ('2 8#8#*D ?&-#Y* -*61' 2# #8+"+2#8%\& *1%$%%# '& ?8+#(*1c
F#8%'&(#-; 8#8#*,'1*-; 6#&b+'1*- 'a>*1,#(*1'- Y 8*"'18%#&,'- '& X+#Y#b+%2; NVOQ p NONQR
[C*5'> !:*5'(*.6
!6
<'+0G'R
#C0((0('V 9+:(i2 LMNMR C("%&%-,1#8%\& (' >*62#8%*&'-; 3'&,1%2*b+%# Y ,1#&-'-81%,+1#D C&k2%-%-
F%-,\1%8*-` '-,+(%*- ,'\1%8*-R 8*4.> @89<1$‐!7C.:'( ] X+25*5C5' :0 !25C:*'2 -0(C.+'2R 10(*0
!25C:*'2 J*25S(*7'2V e`V 95(*'R
X+25*5C5' :0 @'40+5' N^eMR !&:*1"' (' 2# i+&,# 0%1'8,%3# ('2 !&-,%,+,* (' 7*"'&,* (' 2# =1*(+88%\& #2
SD )*&$1'-* H#8%* NOZQR [C*5'R !:*5'(*.6 <'6S+R
h.6*6 Y'+502:0'7.V h'2i N^eLR @%&%-,1* (' ?8*&*"/#D !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\&; NOZN‐NOZPR [C*5'> K.660(02
#(bB*7'2 Y*+0(3.R
~*+,4.+ #.(7i2V !:C.(:' LMMOR .# 8%+(#( Y 2*- *,1*-D m+%,* NVhQ‐NORQD S%$%'&%-"*; *1&#,* Y >*2%8/#R
[C*5'> @89<1$ 10:0 !7C.:'( ‐ F+*30(2*:.: E'3*(. 0 %*(,*6*V <'6077*S+ 95(*'R
80 #'BBV h.7DC02 N^\eR .n!"#$%&#%1' "<(%<3#2D ?--#%-R -.(c2> #.66*4.(:R <'66075*'+ Z*=6*'5;„DC0 :02
J*25'*(02R
804'2V YR<R .+: 9,(.A.6V 9R LMMOR !+3*('+40+5.6 ,'30(+.+70R !+ C&&+#2 E'3%'^ *: ?&3%1*&"'&,
#&( E'-*+18'-R %'6R `NV //R L^P‐`LeR
Y.(WV ~.(6 N^P\ lN\eP‐N\e\nR ?2'"'&,*- :+&(#"'&,#2'- >#1# 2# 81/,%8# (' 2# '8*&*"/# >*2/,%8#D
M*11#(*1 NVZl p NVZV dX1+&(1%--'BR %'6 NR -R 17.('+ I5(.:RQR NM 4. 0:*7*S+R YiW*7'> 1*,6' zzXR
Z*=6*'507. Zb2*7. :06 -0+2.4*0+5' 1'7*.6*25.R
Y7<'')V 15C.(5 LMMMR G,#,'- *: H#,+1'` G8%'&8'; C$1%8+2,+1' #&( ?&3%1*&"'&, %& ,F' G>#&%-F
)#1%66'#&; NlhQ‐NORQD 9C25*+> F+*30(2*5H 'B K0W.2 -(022R
Y7<'')V
15C.(5
LMMLR
8.2
0/*:04*.2
6*=0(.602R
9,(*7C65C(.V
.4=*0+50
H
,6'=.6*_.7*S+
0+
!7C.:'(
INP^M ] N^`MQR !+ ZR Y.(5c+0_ H YR ER -(*05' I7'4/2RQR ?-,+(%*- -*61' F%-,*1%# Y #"6%'&,' '&
C"<1%8#R %'6R LR H*1,'#"<1%8#; G+(#"<1%8# Y '2 =#8/:%8*R YiW*7'> X-#J p !6 <'60,*' :0 YiW*7'R
Y*660++*C4 !7'2H2504 92202240+5 LMMeR ?8*-Y-,'"- #&( S+"#& f'22 ‐6'%&$` GY&,F'-%-R &.2;*+,5'+
?<> X26.+: -(022R
Y*660(V -0:(' %R N^`ND !&:*1"' b+' '2 @%&%-,1* (' 461#- =U62%8#-; C$1%8+2,+1# Y 7*"'&,* >1'-'&,# # 2#
H#8%\& NOWQ‐NOWNR [C*5'R X4/(0+5. ".7*'+.6R NM :0 GC6*'R
Y'6025*+.V !(+025' N^`LR !&:*1"' X'&'1#2 (' .#6*1'- ('2 0'>#1,#"'&,* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; F#-,# '2 WQ
(' i+&%* (' NOWPR [C*5'R K.660(02 K*/',(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R
7/23/2019 R04 BAUD (2013) Ideologies of Progress and Expansion
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/r04-baud-2013-ideologies-of-progress-and-expansion 67/67
YC(.5'(*'V Z6.+7.R N^^dR ".7*S+V X:0+5*:.: H !5+*7*:.:> 6'2 *+:*'2 07C.5'(*.+'2 H 2C2 *4.,*+0('2 .
B*+02 :06 2*,6' zXzR !+ ZR YC(.5'(*' I0:RQR !"k$'&'- ' %"#$%&'1*-D E'>1'-'&,#8%*&'- (' 2*-
%&(/$'&#- '8+#,*1%#&*-; -%$2*- j!j Y jj R [C*5'> @89<1$R
"0='5 %06.27'V h.*40 N^edR @%&%-,1* (' ?8*&*"/#D !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\&; NOZW‐NOZRR [C*5'> !:*5'(*.6
8.2.660R
"'(5;V
?'C,6.22
N^^MR !&-,%,+,%*&-;
!&-,%,+,%*
)F#&$'
#&(
?8*&*"%8
='1:*1"#&8'R
<.4=(*:,0
F+*30(2*5H -(022R
$2='(+0V Y*7;.06 LMMNR 9776*4.5*_*+, 5;0 &'(6:> 9 J*25'(H 'B 5;0 -.(.:*,4.5*7 <'6'+*.6 17*0+70R !+
4-%1%-R %'6R NeR
-6._. 8.22'V #.6' N^d^R ?8*&*"/# Y >1*(+88%\& '& '2 ?8+#(*1D ?a>*-%8%\& ('2 =1'-%('&,'
)*&-,%,+8%* (' 2# E'>U62%8#; 'a8"*D -'T*1 X#2* =2#L#; 1#(%#(# '& X+#Y#b+%2 "#Y* (' NOROD
[C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 +.7*'+.602R
-'+70 !+(cDC0_V <.4*6' N^ePR ?2 71'&,' !&,'1&* (' 2# =#,1%#` '2 "'A*1 $*6%'1&* &* '- '2 $*6%'1&*
>'1:'8,* -%&* '2 $*6%'1&* >*-%62'D [C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R
-(*05'V Y0(70:02 LMMdR .%6'1#2%-"* Y ,'"*1` %"#$%&#&(* 2*- -+A',*- %&(/$'&#- '& '2 ?8+#(*1
>*-,8*2*&%#2; NVOZ
‐NOZQR
[C*5'>
@89<1$
]
!7C.:'(R
-('.r' 9(.+:*V @(.+7*27' LMNLR !+5(.r.=602 H :020+5(.r.=602 0+ 06 0+2.H' 6*50(.(*' :0 9,C25c+
<C03.R !+ C$+-,/& )+'3#` 3'%&,' #T*- ('->+<-R [C*5'> <.4/.r. ".7*'+.6 !C,0+*' !2/0G' /'( 06
8*=(' H 6. 8075C(. p F+*30(2*:.: 9+:*+. 1*4S+ Z'6c3.(R
E'7. <.(='V <.(6'2 N^d`R !&:*1"' ('2 -'T*1 @%&%-,1* (' C$1%8+2,+1#; !&(+-,1%#-; @%&#- Y [+1%-"* #2 SD
)*&$1'-* H#8%* NORWR [C*5'R X4/(0+5. :06 Y*+*250(*' :0 J.7*0+:.R
10*2 40202 N^e`D h "'-'- (' C("%&%-,1#8%\&; +& >#-* '& :%1"'R [C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 ".7*'+.602R
1'6C(*V h';+ LMMOR M#&#&# )+2,+1'-` C$1%8+2,+1'; )*&-+">,%*&; #&( ?&3%1*&"'&,#2 )F#&$' %&
S*&(+1#- #&( ,F' _&%,'( G,#,'-R 9C25*+> F+*30(2*5H 'B K0W.2 -(022R
15'60(V Y*7;0660 LMNLR j!6 GC25' 2.='( :06 7.7.'> ?02.Bc'2 H 30+5.G.2 :06 7'40(7*' GC25' :06 7.7.'kR
K02*2 :0 6. -(',(.4. :0 Y.025(c. :0 !25C:*'2 8.5*+'.40(*7.+'2V Y0+7*S+ 0+ E06.7*'+02
X+50(+.7*'+.602 :0 6. F+*30(2*:.: 9+:*+. 1*4S+ Z'6c3.(R [C*5'R X+i:*5'R
1Cb(0_ %0*+5*4*66.V Y.(*.+' N^ddR @%&%-,'1%* (' C$1%8+2,+1#D !&:*1"' b+' '2 @%&%-,1* (' C$1%8+2,+1#;
!&(+-,1%#-; @%&#-; ',8D; >1'-'&,# # 2# S*&*1#62' C-#"62'# )*&-,%,+Y'&,' NORRR [C*5'> X4/(0+5.
:06 Y*+*250(*' :06 K02'('R 9,'25'R
K'=.( ?'+'2'V hC6*' N^^LR ?2 %&(%* '& '2 ?8+#(*1 %&('>'&(%'&,'R [C*5'> -'+5*B*7*. F+*30(2*:.: <.5S6*7.
:06 !7C.:'(R
F(,066i2 <..4.r'V h'(,0 8C*2 N^eMR @%&%-,1* (' ?8*&*"/#D !&:*1"' # 2# H#8%\&; NORO‐NOZQR [C*5'>
X4/(0+5. @0(+b+:0_R
%'+ J.,0+V
%c75'(
N^\\R
0#1^%&
Y 2#-
%-2#-
'&8#&,#(#-R
EV
[C*G.+'
ER
I5(.:RQR
YiW*7'>
!:*5'(*.6
?*.+.R
wqr*,.V "0/5.6c N^dMR 7'&\"'&*- (' 2# 1'#2%(#( '8+#,*1%#&#D [C*5'> K.660(02 #(bB*7'2 :0 6.
!:C7.7*S+R