Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study Dominik Quantius German Aerospace Center (DLR) Institute of Space Systems Department of System Analysis Space Segment Bremen, Germany Telephone: +49 421 24420-1109 Telefax: +49 421 24420-1120 E-Mail: [email protected] Bremen, 28. March 2017
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 28.03.2017 DLR.de โข Chart 1
โข SolmeX CE Study โข What is SolmeX? โข Concurrent Engineering at DLR โข Integrated design model
โข โMain Parametersโ โข โImplicit Parametersโ
โข Parameter Graphs
โข Design Structure Matrix โข Impacts / Relations
โข Discussion
โข Meaning for MDO
Content
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 2
SolmeX CE Study What is SolmeX?
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 3
Umbra
Penumbra
โข Solar Magnetism Explorer proposal under lead of the Max Planck Institute for Solar System Research, answering 2010 Cosmic Vision call for M-class mission opportunity in ESAโs Science Programme:
โข fully equipped science satellite: Coronagraph Spacecraft (CS) โข second minimalistic spacecraft flying in formation:
Occulter Spacecraft (OC)
CS OS
SolmeX CE Study What is SolmeX: Solar Magnetism Explorer
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 4
SolmeX CE Study What is SolmeX: Solar Magnetism Explorer
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 5
Sequential Engineering (with iterations):
SolmeX CE Study Concurrent Engineering โฆis notโฆ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 6
โข Conventional Design / Engineering Processes
Centralized Engineering:
Configuration Thermal Power
iteration
Power
AOCS
Configuration
Thermal
Project Manager/ Systems Engineer
SolmeX CE Study โฆbut Concurrent Engineering isโฆ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 7
โข Concurrent Design / Engineering Process
โข The five key elements:
โข Interdisciplinary expert team โข Moderated CE - process โข Integrated design model โข Facility / infrastructure โข Tools (e.g. S/W; multi-media)
Project Manager/ Systems Engineer
Configuration Power
AOCS Thermal
SolmeX CE Study - Schedule
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 8
SolmeX CE Study - Domains
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 9
SolmeX CE Study Subsystem Mass Budget of the CS
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 10
Session #1 Session #2 Session #3
SolmeX CE Study โฆbut Concurrent Engineering isโฆ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 11
โข Concurrent Design / Engineering Process
โข The five key elements:
โข Interdisciplinary expert team โข Moderated CE - process โข Integrated design model โข Facility / infrastructure โข Tools (e.g. S/W; multi-media)
Project Manager/ Systems Engineer
Configuration Power
AOCS Thermal
โข At date of study (2010) we used ESAโs CDF Integrated Design Model (IDM):
Collection of domain specific MS Excel workbooks linked via data exchange and data parking macros
SolmeX CE Study Integrated Design Model
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 12
Output-Sheet
Calculation
(Sheets),
e.g. Power Budget
Input-Sheet
EQ Summary (manual input)
SWITCH (Manual/Linked) D
ATA EXC
HAN
GE.xls
Directly linked
DATA
EXCH
ANG
E.xls
SWITCH (Manual/Linked)
โข Explicitly entered to the data model:
โข Mass โข Dimension โข Temperature โข Power
โข Summed up to
systems level: โข Total Mass โข Total Power
demand (dependent on mode/duty cycle)
โMain Parametersโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 13
e.g. Propulsion Subsystem EQ Summary:
โImplicit Parametersโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 14
Calculation
(Sheets),
e.g. Power Budget
โข Domain specific parameters: โข Calculated outside the data model โข Or via โself-madeโ calculation sheets
โข e.g. Propulsion Subsystem: โข Components:
โข Thruster โข Tank โข Heater โข Valve
โMain vs. Implicit Parametersโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 15
Main Parameters: Tank Mass, Dimensions, Temperature
This sheet calculates mass for a spherical COPV (composite over wrapped pressure vessel) tank.
STA 6Al-4V Ti
Input ValuesVolume [m 3ฬ] 0,09326235Pressure [bar] 16,2Safety factor for pressure [-] 2Tensile strenght of composite [N/mm 2ฬ] 923,897477Safety factor for tensile stress [-] 2Wall thickness of liner [m] 0Density of composite material [kg/m 3ฬ] 4428,784Density of liner material [kg/m 3ฬ] 0Factor "spars & bolts" [-] 1,2Margin [%] 20
Output valuesR [m] 0,28132343Max. permitted tensile stress [N/mm 2ฬ] 461,948739Layout pressure [bar] 32,4Composite thickness [m] 0,00098657Composite material mass [kg] 4,34543567 NOTES:Liner material mass [kg] 0 It is assumed that the pressure loads will be carried by the composite material alone;Pure tank mass [kg] 4,34543567 the liner serves only for sealing purposes.(without margin and spars & bolts factor) The margin will be applied, when the spars and bolts factor has already been added.
Total tank mass [kg] 6,25742736(including margin and spars & bolts factor)
R
343ฯVr =
101
2โ
โ โ
=ฯrpt
compcompcomp trm ฯฯ โ โ โ โ = 24
linlinlin trm ฯฯ โ โ โ โ = 24
โMain vs. Implicit Parametersโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 16
๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก = 4 ๐๐ ๐๐2 ๐ก๐ก ๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
๐ก๐ก =1
10โ๐๐ ๐๐2 ๐๐
๐๐ =3 ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
4 ๐๐
13๏ฟฝ
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก =๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก = ๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ 1 โ1
๐๐ โ๐ฃ๐ฃ ๐๐๏ฟฝ
=3
20โ
๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก ๐๐
โ ๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ 1 โ1
๐๐ โ๐ฃ๐ฃ ๐๐๏ฟฝ
โMain vs. Implicit Parametersโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 17
๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก = 4 ๐๐ ๐๐2 ๐ก๐ก ๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก =3
20โ
๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก ๐๐
โ ๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ 1 โ1
๐๐ โ๐ฃ๐ฃ ๐๐๏ฟฝ
Main Parameter Input
Main Parameter Output
Implicit Parameters
Systems Launch Mass: ๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐ก๐ก๐๐๐
Mission Analysis โ๐ฃ๐ฃ
Propulsion Tank Mass: ๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
tank pressure ๐๐
density of tank material ๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
tensile strength of tank material ๐๐
thruster exhaust velocity ๐๐
density of propellant ๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก๐ก
10 parameters for tank design + temperature parameters
Propulsion Tank Radius: ๐๐
Propulsion Thickness of Tank Wall: ๐ก๐ก
* Untersuchung des Parameterraums
einer Concurrent-Engineering-Studie FH Aachen, DLR-Bremen, 2011
Parameter Graphs - Collection of Study Parameters
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 18
Parameter Graphs - Formulary
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 19
Parameter Graphs โ Relations per Parameter per Component
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 20
mass
housekeeping data width
density
shape
height
length
surface max
tank
Component Subsystem Parameter Relations
propulsion
Parameter Graphs โ Design Structure Matrix(Adjacency Matrix)
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 21
Subs
yste
mM
A
INT
Com
pone
nt
CUSP
Para
met
er
mis
sion
dur
atio
n
orbi
t per
iod
sem
i-maj
or a
xis
ecce
ntric
ity
incl
inat
ion
rigth
asc
ensi
on
argu
men
t of p
erig
ee
mea
n an
omal
y
ecce
ntric
ano
mal
y
angu
lar v
eloc
ity
sola
r con
stan
t
true
ano
mal
y
posi
tion
vect
or
orbi
tal p
ertu
batio
n
mas
s
hous
ekee
ping
dat
a
wid
th
shap
e
heig
th
leng
th
surf
ace
max
Subsystem Component ParameterMA 14
mission duration 6;7 6;8 6;9 6;13 6;14 6;17 6;19
orbit period 7;6 7;8 7;9 7;13 7;14 7;17
semi-major axiseccentricityinclinationrigth ascensionargument of perigeemean anomaly 13;7 13;8 13;9 13;14 13;15 13;17
eccentric anomaly 14;8 14;9 14;13 14;17
angular velocity 15;8
solar constant 16;8 16;9 16;10 16;11 16;12 16;13 16;14 16;17
true anomalyposition vector 18;8 18;9 18;10 18;11 18;12 18;13 18;14 18;17
orbital pertubation 19;7 19;8 19;9 19;10 19;11 19;12 19;13 19;14 19;16 19;17 19;21 19;23 19;24 19;25 19;26 19;27
โdepends onโ
โhas
an
impa
ct o
nโ
Parameter Graphs โ Design Structure Matrix (Adjacency Matrix)
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 22
Mission Analysis
Configuration
Domain- specific
parameters
Data Handling &
Communication
406 x 406 parameters 9513 dependencies
Parameter Graphs โ DSM: Impacts
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 23
0 50
10
0 15
0 20
0 25
0 no
. of i
nflu
ence
d pa
ram
eter
s
parameters 435 1
Parameter Graphs โ DSM: Dependencies
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 24
para
met
ers
0 40 80 120 200 160 no. of influencing parameters
20 60 100 140 180
435
1
Parameter Graphs
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 25
โhas an impact onโ โhas
an
impa
ct o
nโ
Depth-First Search Breadth-First Search
Graph Data Structure 1 2 3 4 Depth: 1 2 Depth:
Parameter Graphs โ Impacts on Parameters
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 26
(Breadth-First Search)
Dep
th
Hits
Tota
l
Max
Min
Ratio
to 1
. dep
th
occu
rren
ce
Occ
urre
nce
1 6 2 1 1.2 5
2 6 2 1 1.2 4
3 2 2 2 0.4 2
4 0 0 0 0 0
ร2 ร3.5 5 2 one parameter; all depths
1
2 Depth:
3 Depth:
Depth:
E1 E2 E4 E3
Parameter Graphs โ Impacts on Parameters
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 27
Depth Hits Total Max Min Ratio to 1. depth occurrence Occurrence
1 9513 249 1 25.23 377 2 29583 246 1 78.47 377 3 30691 204 2 81.41 367 4 6699 162 1 17.77 360 5 7689 137 1 20.40 349 6 9778 137 1 25.94 211 7 8334 137 9 22.11 131 8 5045 137 9 13.38 113 9 1149 137 9 3.05 73
10 292 13 7 0.77 32 11 27 9 9 0.07 3 12 0 0 0 0.00 0
ร6.35 ร288.59 299 2 (one parameter; all depths)
Parameter Graphs โ Parameter Impacts/Dependencies for โLaunch Massโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 28
Depth Impact on Dependent on
1 28 112 2 59 111 3 183 26 4 15 40 5 11 41 6 31 7 3 8
Parameter Graphs โ Impacts on Directed Edges
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 29
height
length area volume
area volume volume length length area
P3 P2
P1
E9 E8 E7 E6 E5 E4
E3 E2
E1
Parameter Graphs โ Impacts on Directed Edges
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 30
Depth Hits Total Max Min Ratio to 1. depth occurrence Occurrence
1 9513 249 1 25.23 377 2 188047 6088 1 498.80 377 3 634509 5831 1 1683.05 376 4 684090 5213 36 1814.56 369 5 182442 3567 24 483.93 362 6 238397 3135 24 632.35 351 7 254914 3127 24 676.16 211 8 207088 3127 228 549.31 131 9 134584 3127 450 356.99 112
10 44021 3123 445 116.77 73 11 16445 528 445 43.62 32 12 1584 528 528 4.20 3
ร7.36 ร6884.97 7273 3 (one parameter)
Parameter Graphs โ Edges Impacts/Dependencies for โLaunch Massโ
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 31
Depth Impact on Dependent on
1 28 115 2 553 2752 3 1115 2975 4 4248 112 5 516 518 6 564 1089 7 959 8 49
โข Assumption regarding the Data Model:
โข So far: only fixed values for input/output parameters โข What if it would be possible to e.g. declare all dependent
parameters as variables within a specific interval ?! (generic / each study started from scratch)
Discussion โ Meaning for MDO
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 32
Multidisciplinary Design Optimization task โข 377 variables out of 406 parameters โข 9513 dependencies in the first depth โข 108,800 parameter relations โข 2,595,634 edges
Min. Launch Mass / Cost Max. Mission Lifetime
Max. downloaded Science Data
โข Which kind of functions?
โข Linear, exponential, logarithmic, trigonometric
โข Non-convex design space, discontinuous (e.g. different
thruster types of fixed thrust: 3 x 10N vs. 1 x 30N)
โข Not always differentiable (no Jacobi/Hesse)
โข Loops between parameters
Discussion โ Meaning for MDO
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 33
โข Domain specific blocks could be used as a problem
decomposition and be simplified via curve fitting techniques
โข Exclude Configuration parameters since they are more dependent than having impacts on others
โข Sensitivity analysis upstream the optimization in order to neglect variables which have low influence on the total system or objective function
โข Interval arithmetic for knowing the feasible solution interval
Discussion โ Meaning for MDO
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 34
Thank you and enjoy the coffee break!
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 35
Backup Slides
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 36
SolmeX CE Study
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 37
CE Process at DLR Bremen Star
t
End Initiation & Preparation Phase Study Phase Post Processing Phase
Scientific background
Trade-off
Studies Requirements
Mission Objectives
Requirement Changes
Domain Reports Different Budgets
MoM
Presentations
CEF Core Team Customer Domain
Experts CEF Core
Team
Customer
Session 1 Session 2 Session 3 Session n
Final Report
Simulations (S/W)
Lessons learned
โข What is the magnetic structure of the outer solar atmosphere?
โข What is the nature of the changes of the magnetic field over the solar cycle?
โข What drives large-scale coronal disruptions such as flares and coronal mass
ejections?
โข How do magnetic processes drive the dynamics and heating of the outer solar atmosphere?
โข How does the magnetic field couple the solar atmosphere from the photosphere to the corona?
SolmeX CE Study What is SolmeX? - Science Background -
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 38
SolmeX CE Study What is SolmeX: Solar Magnetism Explorer
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 39
Parameter Graphs โ Launch Mass
> D. Quantius > Parameter Analysis of a Concurrent Engineering Satellite Study โข OSE4, Bremen, Germany > 2017 DLR.de โข Chart 40