7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 1/18
Kleistgoethe and WalsermannAuthor(s): VICTORIA NELSONSource: Salmagundi, No. 123 (SUMMER 1999), pp. 110-126Published by: Skidmore College
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/40549153 .
Accessed: 25/06/2013 17:17
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Skidmore College is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Salmagundi.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 2/18
KleistgoethendWalsermannBY VICTORIA NELSON
[Jekels]sof he pinionhat hakespearerequentlyplits pcharacternto wo ersonages,achofwhom henppearsnot
altogetheromprehensiblentil nce more onjoinedwith heother.
- Freud, SomeCharacter-TypesEncounterednPsycho-Analyticork"1
Who reyouto thinkou'renothing?- Germanaying
A fewyears ago, peeringnto therusticwoodenmaquetteconstructedyTim ndSteveQuay ntheir outh ank tudio or then-
planned uppet ilm fJakob onGuntenitwould atermetamorphoseintoheir irst uman-actoreatureilm,henstituteenjamenta),found
myself hinkingwhat completelyympatheticharacterts authorRobertWalser s, at least to a certainegmentfthepopulationhatincludesmyself howust ikeWalser' hapless haracter enzel ,too,couldhave bjectlyubmitted,id ubmit,he JobApplication"o omemartinetf bureaucrat"Large nddifficultasks cannot erform,nd
obligations f a far-rangingort re too strenuous ormymind . .
Assuredlyhere xistsnyournstitution,hich imagineobe overflow-
ingwithmain nd ubsidiaryunctionsndoffices, ork fthekind hat
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 3/18
KleistgoethendWalsermann 111
onecan do as in a dream?"), ow ife o the ess than irelesslymbitiousoften eems ike an endless oursenservanthoodt the nstitute., towhich ne's tuitions always narrears.2
Thinkingf Walser lwaysremindsmeoftheterriblehoto-graphsfhisdeath takennsitu ythe nvestigatingagistrateot arfromhe sylumn whichWalserhad penthe ast wenty-threeears fhis ife,where ecollapsed rom heart ttackwhile aking walkon
Christmasay, 1956.A German-editionollectionfWalsermemora-bilia everentlyeproducesourolice hots a set ffootprintsn he now
(foreground);woviews,head andfoot,of theungainlyprawled ody(background);inally closeup f he orpse's ace, rozenmouth aping
open.3 hinkingfthis iolationfthedead'sprivacynthename f art
triggered yNewWorldnegativeudgmentnthefetishisticuropeancult f thegenius-artistall those usts nd artifactsndwritingesks
turnednto ltars,eityworshipvery it svulgars a roadsidehrine oElvis. like o hinkhe rospectf deathmask, orxample, ouldhave
horrified alser, s much rom isownexaggeratedenseof unworthi-ness sfrom henotiontself,nways twouldnothavehorrifiedomeofhisprominentontemporaries,oreikelyoregardhis izarre ccoladeoffamesnothingess han heirue.But f oursen hose hotosWalser
got he wentieth-centuryquivalentnyway.What feuilletone could
havemadeoutof that.Most of all, thinkingf RobertWalsermakesme think f
ThomasMann. By virtue f their xtreme ifferencesithin lmostidenticalifespans stretchingromhe 1880sto the1950s,the ct of
readingneofthese uthorsnvariablyriggerseflexivehoughtsftheother: heworld-renownediteraryigure rapedn awards nd honorsversusthe forgottensylum nmate, epic vision versusmannered
miniaturism,r theultimateiterarypitaph)major" ersusminor."I submithat his erversessociations no fluke.t s, rather,
law of Hegeliannature hat wo suchdiametricallypposed iterarysensibilitiesnd lives mustbe symbioticallyinked, e moreweirdlynecessaryoeach otherhan oanyone lsein theworldfonlybecauseartisticnflation,ike sunny ayonthePacific oast, nexorablyraws
aftert hemarineayer f rtisticeflation.t satfirstlancewhatmightbe calledthe President'srother"yndromeJimmyndBillyCarter,
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 4/18
112 VICTORIA NELSON
FranzJosef ndMaximilian,tc. thenotuncommonpectacle f a
dignifiedndaccomplishedamousmangenetically oked o his darkcourtester,hatmbarrassinguffoon hodances nd avorts round is
legs, ven inraremoments)ausing he reatnetotrip. owevermuchthe minencewould iketo shake ffhisannoyinghadow, e remainsforeveround o t,giant odwarf,nternationallynown igurenexpli-cably ttachednour maginationso theneurotic/psychotichose ife
ends in squalidisolation. Like the wretched artleby,withwhomMelville'sprosperousmanoftheworld inds imself o mysteriouslyobsessed, hewasalways here."
Thisodd-couple airingfWalserwithMann snotwithoutts
strongmirrorcho nGermaniterature. e cannot ullyppreciateheduowithoutteppingack o aken full uaternityhatncludes einrichvonKleist ndWolfgangonGoethe centurynd half arlier: oethethe ane, ife-embracingensibility,leist he euroticuicide;Goethe he
center, leist hemargin. oethewasa culturalcon, hemost enerated
literaryigurenEurope;his ontemporaryleist ookhisown ife tagethirty-five,eneratingsilence omparableoWalser' when e enteredthe sylumtage forty-sevennd ffectivelynded ll humanommuni-cation. neknowsntuitivelyhat oethe ad deathmask ndKleist idnot.ThomasMannhadnodeathmask 1955reallywas a bit atefor hatsort ftribute buthe did have a "lastportrait,"ketchedytheDutch
painteraulCitroen.)It sthe opular iew hat achage's major rtistsiveout heir
days n he unlightfpublic cclaimwhile tsminorrtists uddlen heir
monumentalhadows,butterfliesn the liff fgreatrt,"s Walser utit. nthis iew hemajor, eservedly,s someone veryoneasheard f;theminor,qually eservedly,elongs othe pecialistsnd cholars.Atthe ame ime henaggingense ingershat he entermightctually,nsome ubterraneanay, e nferioro nddependentn themarginatherthan he therway round. here s a spiritfthemarginhatsserts, sWalter enjamin id ofWalser' work,Thisnothingnesssweighty."4Cynthia zickmaintainshat tobeable tosaywhat minorwritersif t could be done at all wouldbring s a little earer odefining
culture,"houghhehastens o dd lest, ne uspects,he ound sifshewere dvancinghe ereticalotion hatminorsbetter):There anbe no
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 5/18
Kleistoethe nd Walsermann 113
majorwork, nfact,without he creen, rground, f esser artistsgainstwhom themajor figures illuminated.Orput t thatminorwriters re the
armature ntowhich theclay ofgreatness s thrown, ressed,prodded."5But Ozick's firstbold statement s more interestinghan her
qualification justasminor rtistshemselves, erversely,end obe. And
her mageof thereverse mprints much ike thatRilke used to describe
his own quirkyfiction, heNotebooksofMalte Laurids Brigge:
I myself ometimesthought f it as a hollow form, negative
mold,all thegrooves nd ndentationsnd mostpainful nsights,but hecastingfromwhich,were tpossibletomake one (as with
a bronze thepositive figureone would get out of it), would
perhapsbe happiness,assent mostperfect nd most certain
bliss.6
All this magery fmolding ndcasting, nfact, srather eminiscentf
deathmasks.And Rilke's metaphor, oubtless drawnfrom bservationsofhishero theepic sculptorAugusteRodin, ironically ummonsRobert
Walser's ownuncharacteristicallylat estheticpronouncement:God is
theoppositeofRodin."7
God is theoppositeofRodin.This is theromanceofthemargin,
marginchauvinism,and we speak now in its language, marginolalia.
Marginchauvinists elievethat ll worthy,ivelyartderivesnotfrom he
sanctioned, ewardedmainstream, utfrom ts eastregarded ributaries
andrivulets.Recovering ndvalorizing hemarginhas beenan important
criticalundertaking f the last twenty-five ears. Gilles Deleuze hasproclaimed:"There s nothingmajororrevolutionaryxcepttheminor."8
This preference the same sensibility hatmaintains,as the Polish
maverickWitold Gombrowicz did, "The imperfects superiorto the
perfectbecause it s moreconstructive)"9 exerts tself tevery urn nd
can be said, in some quarters,to have overturnedthe center and
mainstreamedtself.By thisvery ct,however, uchartmaybe negated,since the ow status fthemarginal s primarily hatdefines t;a margin
demarginalized s a marginno longer.Deleuze again:
How many stylesor genresor literarymovements, ven verysmall ones, have only one single dream: to assume a major
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 6/18
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 7/18
KleistgoethendWalsermann 115
Shakespeare's lays, nd it is stillhighly isible n themetaphoricaldistinctionse makebetween he efinedcenter) ersus he nstinctual
(edge),high ultureersusowculture,nd oon.13 hesedays, f ourse,whenwe ook t theGothicmanuscripts,urKleistian erspectiveicksin.Marginhauvinismssertstselfndour ecular yemoves traightothemargin,lottinguttheholy enter:Wherewouldwe rathere,we
think,rappedike a fly n amber nside stiff,ormalapital ettern
Corinthiansrrevelingn thefree paceout n themargins dancing,eating, ornicating,ilkingows ormysteriously,s inonemanuscript,presentingplate fturds o a lover)?
Asmembersf n nformalentraluropeanine fdescenthat
Benjaminthe rchetypal arginommentator)ubbed he legacy f he
fool,"14 alser ndKleistbelong o this pecialmarginfdrôleriesn
Europeanulture.Within heboundariesfthe ldHolyRoman mpirea latter-dayenealogyfthemarginaliteraryrotesquean betraced n
which escentoesnot oconventionallyrom athero onbut vuncularly
fromnestrikingoguemaleorMelvilleansolateto nother.hiskleineProsa sensibility, hich lso foreswearshegrand nd epic forthe
deliberatelyiminishedndcompressed, uns n a single hread rom
Kleist ndGeorgBüchnerhrough alser, ranzKafka, runo chulz,andothers. The blackholeof Germaniterature,"label appliedto
Büchner,ould qually escribellmembersf he loodline and ttests
totheuneasy ensethat hemargins not afely eripheralutrather
seductive,hreateningortexhatmightasily wallow pthe enter ere
it o inclined.
Whetherrnot the ink mong hem onsitutesoincidence,overtnfluence,raffinityrising romncubationn the ame cultural
crucible, these "uniques" show a kind of Kierkegaardian
symparaneckromenoi,"fellowshipfburiedives."Their irstommon
featuresan nherentversion,n ife s in iterary atters,othe oleof
patriarch.nd ince llwereverymuch ons n real ife with prepon-derance fdomineeringathersn thepicture), t thus eemsfittingo
describeheiriteraryloodrelationships much ikethat ftheBreton
folk eroKingArthurndhisknights,onless ll,whose ower escended
frommaternalncle onephew. ythe ame oken,ontemporariesuchasWalser ndSchulz ndKafka ouldnotbedescribeds "brothers,"
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 8/18
116 VICTORIA NELSON
connectionar oo hargednd ntimateor uch iteraryoners,ut ather
"cousins," xchanging arybut notunfriendlylances t each other
across he ormal,inen-cloakedinnerable tyearlyamily atherings.(There reno aunts nd nieces ntheKleist-Walser lood ine.15)
The genetic athers fthese mbattledons had theiriterary
counterpartsho endedobehaventhe amebullying ays the meek
son" tance,ike ny thern ife, ctings amagneto ttractuch ypes).
And liffslsoenvy utterflies,ecause majors" ave nannoyingabitofnegativelyefininghe ccomplishmentsfminorsoprotectheir wn
positions. fKleist, oethepronounced:With he estwill n heworldtoward hispoet, havealwaysbeen moved o horror nddisgust ysomethingn hisworks, s though erewerea body well-plannedynature,ainted ith n incurable isease."16 s directorf theWeimar
theater,oetheeems ohave uined leist' TheBroken ug ndnot nly
rejected enthesileaut urned hemanuscriptnthe tovewhile onde-
scendinglynnouncingisownpreferenceor something ore rom he
heart."17Evermore living nstitution,ndfrequenthampion f thesafely hird-rate,"otesone commentator,hewithholdingather f
Kleist, ölderlinnd therswas trikinglyonsistentnrejectinghe est
ofthenext eneration."18ThomasMann, aving erventlyodeled imselfike good on
after oethe,till efendedleist s "one f he reatest,oldest,ndmostambitiousoetsGermanyasproduced;playwrightnd torytellerf he
very irstrder; manunique nevery espect." ut he could not esist
makinghefatal ualificationhat einforcedis iteraryather's ege-
mony andbyextension isown): "Kleist' ambitionwas in itsveryessencedamagedbyhubris,ealousyandenvy, lwaysoverreachingitself,he assion f nepretendingo crownhats not ightfullyis ndwhichmust etorn rom heheadof ts rue wner,nthis asethemost
great,most ichly lestGoethe."19Is t urprising,hen,hat he ephews,ringingnder hese eath
raysfrom heir arsh nd udgmental ather/brothers,urned o theircousins nduncles or upportnd validation? ever o haveflesh-and-blood ons nddaughtersf theirwn, hesemen selected heiriterary
forebearsndprogenyike fairiessubstitutinghangelingsorhumanbabies.Walseriked nd dentified ith leist, afka iked nd dentified
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 9/18
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 10/18
1 18 VICTORIANELSON
But henephewslsoactively oughtack,ntheirelf-effacingway, gainst hefather/brothers,ndmarginhauvinism as a crucial
weapon n thisbattle. or whenmarginnd center radeplaces,the
"imperial"rtistinWalser' condescendingerm) ecomesminor,he
marginalizedrtistmajor. rom he mperial erspective,artlebymaylook ikeRilke' negativemold;fromhe utterfly'serspective,God sthe ppositefRodin." nthis anny eversal fvalues,Kafka efines is
literaryousinRobertWalser y omparinghe acehorsehatumpswiththe nethat oesn't.Afterxtollinghe ision f essence" nd unity"rider erives rom he ormer,ethen onsiders heviewfrom he atter:
But fmyhorse urns ack ndwon't ake heump nd huns hehurdle r runs ff nddisportsnside he rena, r eventhrows
me,naturallyhe otal iewwill eeminglyavegained greatdeal. There regaps mong he pectators;omefly, thersall,handsweave back and forth s though espondingo every
possiblewind, rain ffleetingnterrelationshipsalls ponme,and t squite ossible hat ome pectatorseel t nd oncur ithme while lie on thegrass ike worm.22
Neatlyunderminingheauthorityf theunifyingmperial iew,this
impeccablyelf-effacingistinctionerives,n way, romvery udeo-Christianision f he pset freceivedower: hosewho re ast hall efirst.
Fromthe owerperspective,urthermore,he"greatman" s
revealeds a vampireevouringis ntimatesnd iteraryompetitorsnsinglemindedursuitfhonor ndglorymasked s devotionohis rt. hisworm's yeview of theunderbellyfgenius s brilliantlyepictednChild'sPlay, a novella y heAustralian riter avidMalouf,nwhicha youngtalian errorist,na ratheriteralcting utofHaroldBloom's
anxietyf nfluence,lots he eath f hemost enowned riterfhisday.About he iteraryminence ehopes oassassinateMalouf terrorist-narratorsks nexasperation:
Cangenius eseparatedromgotism? isego smonstrous;etit s n he roteanransformationndmasqueradesf his go, ts
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 11/18
KleistgoethendWalsermann 119
capacity oslip nandout of other orms,therives, hathediscovershat eelingor he neness f hingshat othustifieshisvision fhimselfs aphenomenonfnaturend onvincessof ts ruth.23
This novella s profitablyead in conjunction ithThomas Mann's
Diaries,which mply eflectMann's sense of his owngreatnessnd
entitlement:
Onmy fternoonalk houghtnce gainhowgood twould eif were o die now.Thenfeelingf ove for he ittle ne[his
daughterlizabeth],ndbegan xperimentingnmymindwiththe hexameteroem.But also saw thethematicelationshipbetweenmyfuture orks nd thedomain fmyreading: heromanticismf deathplus affirmationf life n TheMagicMountain,he rotestantismfTheConfidence an.A sense f
reaffirmation.24
These rethe ecuremusingsffame,which llowthewriter he uxuryof ontemplatingis euvrend alibratinghe extppropriatedditionsto t.Againsthem,s if onstructingnalgebraicquation,ne mmedi-
atelywants o et he emark alser iveshis ltergo, he spiringervantJakob onGunten,nhisownfictionalagebuch: In aterife willbeanutterlyharming,phericalero."25
It is not imply ttitudeowardwork nd other rtists hat s
affectedy iterarytatus. ltimately,hework tself analso reflectfalse xaltation,he ollownessf he sixty-year-oldmilingublicman"as shrewdlyescribedyElias Canetti:
Everywriter hohasmade nameforhimselfnd assertshatname nowsuitewell hat orhis eason e sno ongerwriter,for e administersositionsike nyburgher.uthe hasknown
peoplewho were so utterlyndpurelywritershat hey ustcouldn't e successfult t The writer ho sserts imself,
whoknows heywerepurerhan e,can'tendure aving hemaround orong, uthe squite reparedo veneratehemn the
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 12/18
120 VICTORIA NELSON
asylum. They are his split-offwounds and keep vegetating s
such. t s exalting ocontemplatendgettoknow thewoundsso
longas one does not have to feel them noneselfanymore I
wonderwhether here s, amongthosewhobuild theireisurely,secure, inear cademic lives on the ifeofa writerwhodwelled
inpoverty nddespair,even one who is ashamed.26
Witold Gombrowicz,writhing ompetitivelyn the giant shadow thatMann cast overeveryotherEuropeanwriter f his generation, eclared
that greatness s always inauthenticity"nd thatMann's vaunted "har-
nessingofopposites" "greatness oillness,geniustodecadence,superi-
ority odegradation")became overtime meretactic, one morewayof
forcing under heguiseofhonesty evenhumility others o acknowl-
edge his own right oglory."27Yes, yes andyet. Marginchauvinism side,uncles-and-neph-
ews is not theonly story. Becoming-minor"s one step n the now,but
it s notthe ast,nor s itby anymeans the best.Let us look atthematterof persona first, orself-presentations the cornerstone f all artistic
illusion.In Gombrowicz' voice can be heardthesame envythatMann
identifiednKleist,theenvyand bitternesshatwarpthe udgment f the
disenfranchiseds surely s the sense of entitlement arpsthe udgmentof thoseat thetop. n theend,does anything istinguish he mperial goonone hand from hepathological elf-effacement,he orgiesof belittle-
ment,"as MartinWalser described the earlier Walser' s characteristic
posture,on the other?28 Both personas are equally narcissistic. The
omnipotentbasement fKafka'shungerrtist ardens nto kind fbodydeathmask, nd meregreatnesss drowned utbythegrandiose choes of
Walser' s "sphericalzero."
The real secret,the important ruth,ies outside questions of
literaryrpersonalsuperiority,nd t s this: hePresident nd hisbrother,Mann and Walser, Goethe and Kleist, are more alike than they are
different. ome,mostnotablyChristopherMiddleton,have observedthis
basic underlyingdentity.n describingRobert Walser as a "liminoid,"
marginal rtist,Middleton acknowledgesthatMann,"withhis antitheses
andtensions, ndhisantagonisms,"might e a liminoid rtist,oo,thoughhe qualifiesthecomparison:
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 13/18
KleistoethendWalsermann 121
WithMann there s an immensely ntricate ntellectual
superstructureothenarrative;massive ultures enshrinedthere.Perhapsthat mass serves to cushionthe authorial
imagination.ithWalsert sobviouslytherwise.e sfootlooseandbarefoot,ndhe dances atherhan lods.His dance s thatof an autodidactalbeithe read widely), xposed,boyish,
defenseless, holly ependentn a spontaneityhat ludes, smuch s itchallenges,he equential eterminacyf deas.29
Middletonlsosees deep ffinityetweenWalser ndGoethes "eternal
youths,"eter ans whonever rew p.The usualfate fthese ypesaswasthe aseformost f theuncles ndnephews)s early eath r other
formsfself-extermination,reativerpsychological.But, sMiddletonoints ut:
Once na bluemoon . uer eternusemainsntact ndreachesan advanced gewith is reativeowers otmuch iminished.
Goethedid so. The grandmaturityf his mind, ested nd
seasonedby a multitudef externalnterestsnd profound
experiences,ncluding esponsivenesso theradiance f the
eroticwhichdoes not seemtohavefiguredn thescript f
Walser' fortune),rainednd ransformed,ndwasnotmpeded
by,hisunquenchableusto, isabilityo be almost onstantly
emergent,ariouslyorefreshimself.30
Thepoint otake s not henevitableowtoGoethe ut he act hat oth
GoethendMann tartedutmuchmore ikeKleist ndWalser han ither
culturalehemothelt omfortablecknowledgingn ater ears, ide he
instinctiveevulsionan emotion ften tronger hendirectedgainsttraits ne recognizesn oneself) xpressed yGoethetowardKleist.
Perhapsikewiseeeingmore fTonioKrogernhimselfhan ecared o,ThomasMannmade deliberatend elf-consciousgodecisionomarry,
havinginthewords f onebiographer)fallenn ovewith he dea of
living representativeife, ikea prince."31notherritic awMann'sliteraryurnromisuncle chillero veryalculatedmitatio oethe s
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 14/18
122 VICTORIANELSON
a "growingsmosis ftwopersonalubstanceso that,na way,GoethebecomesnThomas annwhat homasMann ecomesnGoethe."32es,Goethemannthatwas thiswriter'sesiredmarriage oal,but he ecretidentificationith heminorontinuedocast shadow n hiseffortsoconsummatehis nflatederemonial nion.
Suchattemptsy climber fthe iteraryliffo fuse dentitieswith "giant" fthepast like thenephews' essflagrantttemptso
mergewith heir ncles contain he seed of a betterynthesis,heprovocativeuggestionhat heremight e anothererritory,eitherhe
imperialeathmasknor tsnegativemold, hat n rtistanoccupy. iventhe ntrinsicimilarities,ouldnot writer ovefromhemarginowardthe enterorfromhe enter ack to themargin)till arryinghebest
qualities fboth as,Middletonmplies, oethe troveodo,outgrowinghisdeflationnly ofall ictim o nflationncehehad rossed o he thersideof he iteraryhadowine?Andwouldn't heminors ehappier,nealmostwants osay, f heyllowed hemselvesull ccess to ife, ove,
seaton the acehorsehatumps?Who,Walserncludedanddespite isprotestations,hich ssified ntohis final dentity),eallywants o beEdward cissorhands?
Another ootnoterom hehistoryfbooksmaybeuseful ere.
During he ixteenthentury,eforewidespreaddoptionfthe rintingpress, riotousnion fgraphicrt nd alligraphyascelebratedn uchworks s theMiraCalligraphiaeMonumenta,handwritingodel ookin whichJorisHöfnagel, rtistn thecourt fRudolph I ofPrague,launchedhimself rom hemargins fGeorgBocskay'scalligraphy.
Höfnagel' spreadingudzu ine fwild rnamentationanimals,hells,plantsndfruitscrupulouslyrawn rom aturenthenewRenaissance
emphasisnnatural istory beautifullyugmentshe extwithoutver-
whelmingt.33 marginalistyprofession,öfnagelived uthisurge oinhabithe ull pace nanadmirablyemocraticashion, ithoutsurp-ing rupsettinghe alance.With nityf ext nd llustrationshisgoal,Höf agel urnedheseopybookmodelsnto omethingxtraordinarythe
butterflies,normousnes, erchmajesticallys full qualson the liffftext.Bythe imeHöfnagel adfinishedhework nthe1590s,however,
bothlluminationnd alligraphyeredyingrafts. hemachine-printedbook restoredheprimacy f textover a clearlydefined order f
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 15/18
Kleistgoethend Walsermann 123
unviolatedwhite pace, and center esumed ts dominanceovermargin.Occasional examplesoftheHöfnagelmodel that f transform-
ing a minor-majorymbiosis nto a synthesis do appear in the iteraryrecord.We might ee itoperatingndirectlynthePolish writer lexander
Wat,whospentmost fhis ife nthemarginfirstrtistically,s a Dadaist/
Futurist, nd thenin real life, in Stalin's labor camps) yet lived his
emotional ifesquarely nthecenter,n a deep relationshipwithhis wife
and son. In his greatmemoirMy CenturyWat eloquentlydescribes hisconversion rom margin ensibilitynLuby nkaprison,wherehe osthis
taste for the avant garde, to a wider vision of life. "In prison," he
commented,
the aestheticsensibilitys purgedof various fashions, ll that
experimentalvolatility.Everythingvolatile seems somehow
illusory, lmostnonexistent. nd what's eft rethings hat xist
in themselves ndderive fromwhat s stable.34
A life ived in themargins aveWatgreaterccess to thecenter fthings,tothetruly uman, hanmostpeople ever achieve. That he expressedhis
conversionn a dictatedmemoir ather han work f maginative rt akes
nothing romtspower.Thiskindofunifyingxperience,however, ccursall toorarely
in a single mortal, nd oftenonly underthe most special and difficult
conditions.The randomforcesoflife,fame andpersonalcharacter wist
artistsnexorablynonedirection r theother, enter rmargin,warping
their ensibilities ccordingly. or the rueunionofopposites,we have tolook higher or lower;inthiscontextbothdirections re thesame) to the
metalevel,where he tory f themargin lood clan is fulfilled nlywhen
we combine itwith the storiesof theirmajoralteregos. For surelythe
worksof each member f thesetwopairs GoetheandKleist,Mann and
Walser stand ndesperateneedof theother'scharacters nd storiesfor
satisfactoryompletion.A Borgesianfusionof identitywould bring he
high ow andthe owhigh, bliteratingmajorandminor, ext ndmargin,and allowingthefullstory thegenuine ife-embracingensibility to
emerge from the harmoniousconflationof theirdisparatebut oddlycomplementarymaginings.The Marquise of Ο bringsFaust's child to
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 16/18
124 VICTORIANELSON
term, rounding issoaring mbitionnthe tabilityf a happyfamilyife.
SiegmundandSiegelindemateenthusiastically ith heTannersiblings,thereby reakingboth sets of incestuousbondsand liberating ll. JakobvonGuntengains employments thefootmanntheBuddenbrookshome
and, n a Pinteresque eversal ffortune,eizespower?No, that' not uiteright too muchmajoryangand notenoughminoryin.Better:Jakob's
humility xerts a transformativeffect n themembers of thisrigidly
hierarchicalhousehold,withgratifyinglynarchicresults.Hans Castorp, takinga strolloutside the SanatoriumBerghof
nearDavos, discovers a set of footprintsn thesnow . . . and so his lifecontinues.
Kleistgoethe nd Walsermann.A consummation evoutly o be
wished,though pparently otbythefour arties hemselves,whoinreallife turned heirheads firmlyway from heir ecret harers.Marrythe
shadow,not hegod?For all ofus thats easiersaidthandone.We pickoursides at birth nd decide there's no turning ack.
Notes
1Sigmund reud, ompletesychologicalWorks,tandardd.,vol. 14,trans.James tracheyLondon:TheHogarthress, 957),p.323.
2RobertWalser,TheJobApplication,"electedtoriesfRobertWalser,rans.ChristopheriddletonNewYork:Farrartraus Giroux, 982).
3 Elio FröhlichndPeterHamm, obertWalser: ebenundWerknDatenundBildernFrankfurt:nsel,1980).
4Walter enjamin,RobertWalser,"rans. arkHarman,nMarkHarman,d.,RediscoveringobertWalserHanoverndLondon:Universityress fNewHampshire,1985),p. 144.This xcellent nduseful ook ontains numberf ssays boutWalser yotherwriters.
5Cynthia zick,"Alfredhester'sWig,"nFame ndFollyNewYork: arrarStraus Giroux, 996),p. 87.
6 RainerMarieRilke, etters,ol.2,trans. ane annard reenndM. D. Herter
NortonNewYork:Norton,947-48), . 147.
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 17/18
Kleistgoethend Walsermann 1 5
7 Christopheriddleton,ntroduction,akob onGuntenNewYork:VintageBooks,1983),p. 11.
8 Gilles Deleuze and FelixGuattari,oward MinorLiterature,rans. ana
Polan,TheoryndHistory fLiterature,ol. 30 (Minneapolis: niversityf Minnesota
Press, 986),p. 26.
9 WitoldGombrowicz,Dominique eRoux," d.,AKind fTestament,rans.MauriceNadeau London:Calder& Boyars, 973),p.63.
10 Deleuze andGuattari, inor iterature,. 27.
11 Michael amille,magesn heMarginCambridge, A:Harvard niversityPress, 992).
12MichaelCamille, The FleshMade Word:Originsnd Functions f Gothic
Marginal rt,"ecture, niversityfCaliforniatBerkeley,eptember1, 1990.
13 Ibid.
14 Benjamin, RobertWalser," , 145. MartinWalser,however, hought
Benjaminwas taken nbyWalser*consciouslyonstructedholynaif*pose. See his"unrelentingtyle,"nRediscoveringobertWalser, p. 153-168.
15With heBlueFlower, fictionboutNovalis haracterizedy Lenz'Mike
understatementndflatnessfaffect,he nglish ovelist enelope itzgerald as madebidfor iece tatus,ut tspositionnthebody f herwork s anomalous.
16 Goethe uoted yThomasMann n hisforewordo HeinrichonKleist,he
MarquiseofΟ and Other tories, rans.MartinGreenburgNew York:New American
Library,960),xvi.
17 Goetheuoted
nPhilip
B. Miller, d. andtrans., nAbyss eep Enough:LettersfHeinrich onKleistwith SelectionfEssays ndAnecdotesNewYork:E. P.
Dutton, 982),p. 177.
18 bid.
19Mann,Marquise onO,ix,xiv. havefound odiscussionfRobertWalserin Mann'sworks.
20 RobertWalser, p.cit.
21 GuyDavenport, aVinci'sBicycleBaltimore, D: The Johns opkins
Press, 979),pp. 149-185.
This content downloaded from 190.136.119.216 on Tue, 25 Jun 2013 17:17:26 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
7/28/2019 Nelson Kleistgoethe and Walsermann
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/nelson-kleistgoethe-and-walsermann 18/18
126 VICTORIANELSON
22 FranzKafka, LetteroDirectorisner/*nRobertWalser ediscovered,p.139-140.
23 DavidMalouf, hild'sPlay Harmondsworth,K: Penguin, 983),p.60.
24 ThomasMann, iaries1918-1939, d.Hermann esten,rans. ichardnd
ClaraWinstonNewYork:Abrams, 982),p.4 [Saturday,eptember4,1918].
25 RobertWalser, akob onGunten,rans. hristopheriddletonNewYork:
Vintage ooks,1983),p. 24.
26 EliasCanetti,RobertWalser,"n RobertWalser ediscovered,p. 1 1 1 2.
27 WitoldGombrowicz,iaries,vol.2, trans. illian Vallée (Evanston,L:
Northwesternniversityress, 989),p. 125.
28 MartinWalser,RobertWalser,"nRediscoveringobertWalser, . 161.
29 Christopheriddleton,A Parenthesiso heDiscussion fRobertWalser'
Schizophrenia,"nRediscoveringobertWalser, . 193.
30 Ibid.p. 191.
31 RonaldHayman, homasMann:ABiographyNewYork, cribner,998),
p.616.
32 FritzKaufman, homasMann: The World s Will nd Representation(Boston:BeaconPress, 957),p. 170.
33 Joris ofnagel, iraCalligraphiaeMonumentaMalibu,CA: J.PaulGettyMuseum, 992);seealsoPhilip . Meggs, MiraCalligraphiaeMonumenta,in Print 7,no. 1 JanVFeb.993):94-104,144.
34 Aleksander at,MyCentury,rans. ichard ourieBerkeley: niversityf
Californiaress, 988).