The Science Behind Emails that Persuade
Nancy HarhutChief Creative OfficerWilde Agency
@nharhut
Today You Will Learn
• How successful marketers get their emails opened, read and responded to
• Which of psychology’s “decision-making shortcuts” work best
• Easy ways you can use them now
2
@nharhut
Agenda
1. Words that work best in subject lines
2. Two ways to position your message for fast response
3. The ripple effect of the Consistency Principle
4. Why you’ll sell more using Social Proof
5. When “negative” can deliver positive results
6. How Availability Bias turns doubters into buyers
7. What instantly makes you look better than the competition
8. The one thing to say to increase response
9. The journalist’s secret that boosts email readership
10. Which days are best for success
3
@nharhut
The Biggest Secret?
Everyone relies on decision - making shortcuts
4
@nharhut
Words that work best in subject lines
5
@nharhut
• Drive opening rates
• About 35 characters
• Use “eye magnet words”
6
@nharhut 7
@nharhut 8
@nharhut 9
@nharhut 10
@nharhut 11
@nharhut
Two ways to position your message for fast response
12
@nharhut
The Principle of Scarcity
• Urgency
• Exclusivity
13
@nharhut 14
@nharhut 15
@nharhut 16
@nharhut 17
@nharhut 18
@nharhut 19
@nharhut 20
@nharhut 21
@nharhut 22
@nharhut
The ripple effect of The Consistency Principle
23
@nharhut
• Once people commit, they remain consistent
• First small yes leads to subsequent larger ones
24
@nharhut 25
@nharhut 26
@nharhut 27
@nharhut 28
@nharhut
Why you’ll sell more using Social Proof
29
@nharhut
• We do what other people do
• Especially if they’re like us
30
@nharhut 31
@nharhut 32
@nharhut 33
@nharhut 34
@nharhut 35
@nharhut
When “negative” can deliver positive results
36
@nharhut
Loss Aversion
• 2x more motivated to avoid pain than achieve gain
37
@nharhut 38
@nharhut 39
@nharhut 40
@nharhut 41
@nharhut 42
@nharhut 43
@nharhut 44
@nharhut
How Availability Bias turns doubters into buyers
45
@nharhut
• Personal relevance
• If it can be recalled/ imagined, it’s “more likely to happen”
46
@nharhut 47
@nharhut 48
@nharhut 49
@nharhut 50
@nharhut
What instantly makes you look better than the competition
51
@nharhut
The Authority Principle
• People recognize and respect authority
• Assume they’ve done the work for us
52
@nharhut 53
@nharhut 54
@nharhut 55
@nharhut 56
57@nharhut
The one thing to say to increase response
58@nharhut
• Give the reason why
• Because = compliance trigger
59@nharhut
60@nharhut
61@nharhut
62@nharhut
63@nharhut
64@nharhut
65@nharhut
The journalist’s secret that boosts email readership
66@nharhut
• 5 Ws + 1 H
• Use numbers and lists
67@nharhut
68@nharhut
69@nharhut
70@nharhut
71@nharhut
72@nharhut
73@nharhut
74@nharhut
75@nharhut
76@nharhut
77@nharhut
Which days are the best for success
78@nharhut
• Holidays
• Special celebrations
79@nharhut
80@nharhut
81@nharhut
82@nharhut
83@nharhut
84@nharhut
85@nharhut
@nharhut
Key Takeaways
1. Certain words automatically attract readership
2. People find urgency and exclusivity almost impossible to ignore
3. You can make a small “yes” lead to larger ones
4. People naturally trust your customers more than you
5. Avoiding anything negative is a big mistake
6. It’s easier to make a sale using Availability Bias
7. Trusting an authority is a common mental shortcut
8. People more readily do what they’re asked when told why
9. Helpful info – especially with numbers – entices readership
10. Special occasions create special interest
86
87@nharhut
Email by the numbers
• Limit your marketing pre-header to 85 characters
• Use short, scannable copy because online reading takes 25% longer
• Put key message upfront – up to 80% of people read only preview panes
• 1- Column layouts are best for mobile
• 2 more layout tips: People read in an F pattern; Use a contrasting color for buttons
• Pad your CTAs by 15 pixels to combat “fat fingering”
• Use the same primary visual in your email and landing page for 18% higher conversions