1
Fundamentals of Asset Management
Nat Coley, Economic Analysis Program FHWA Office Of Asset Management
2
Topics
• Definition and Understanding Asset Management– Importance of asset management and what it can do for us– Explain the role we play in implementing
asset management
• Methods and Tools– Apply the principles of asset management– Define steps that agencies can take to
improve asset management – Identify available tools that can assist in applying asset
management – Identify performance measures that are useful in an asset
management context
3
Transportation Asset Management
Asset management is a systematic process of maintaining, upgrading, and operating physical assets cost-effectively. It combines engineering principles with sound business practices and economic theory, and it provides tools to facilitate a more organized, logical approach to decision-making. Thus, asset management provides a framework for handling both short- and long-range planning.
4
Why Transportation Asset Management?
“As government providers and operators of transportation systems, we face an increasingly complex challenge of improving safety, mobility and the aesthetics of our highway system in an environment of constrained resources. Implementing an asset management approach is essential to ensure that we invest the public funding entrusted to us wisely, and that we minimize long-term costs in achieving our desired service level objectives.”
Neil J. Pedersen, Administrator, Maryland State Highway Administration and Vice-Chair, AASHTO Subcommittee on Asset Management
Transportation Asset Management
5
Why is it Important?
•Increasing congestion – between 1993 and 2002
–24% increase in passenger car VMT–32% increase in single-unit trucks VMT–39% increase in combination trucks VMT –Only a 2% increase in lane miles
•In the next 20 years–VMT will increase by 50%–Freight tonnage will nearly double
•All of this is occurring on an aging network and in a fiscally constrained environment
6
What Can we do about our situation?
• Aging Infrastructure Networks Need to make what we have work better for us and lastlonger
• Growing Congestion What can we do to reduce the inconvenience of congested roadways?
• Growing Traffic VolumeWhat can we do to curb the increasing levels of traffic?
• Increasing Legislative Oversight Need to respond to pressure to be more transparent andaccountable
7
Asset Management Principles
4 DECISIONS BASED ON QUALITY INFORMATION – management systems and tools are used
2 PERFORMANCE BASED – clear measures of performance and target service levels are established
1 POLICY DRIVEN – decisions reflect policy goals and objectives that define desired system condition and service levels
3 OPTIONS EVALUATED – comprehensive choices and tradeoffs are examined at each level of decision-making
5 CLEAR ACCOUNTABILITY – performance results are monitored and reported
8
Focus of Asset Management
At its Core, Asset Management Focuses on Resource Allocation and Utilization
At its Core, Asset Management Focuses on Resource Allocation and Utilization
9
Transportation Asset Management
PreservationCapital Improvement
Operations
RESOURCES
Safety Other
10
A Resource Allocation and Utilization Process
Policy Goals and Objectives
Analysis of Options and Tradeoffs
Resource Allocation Decisions
Financial Staff Equipment Other
Program and Service Delivery
System Condition and Service Levels
Funding Levels
Customer Input
PreservationPreservation OperationsOperationsCapacity
ExpansionCapacity
Expansion
11
Benefits of Asset Management
•Extend resources–Make our assets last longer–Make your dollars do more for you
•Get more money–Make the case for funding and have the executives and legislature understand the needs–Have your partners support you and communicate the case
•Communication, accountability, and credibility–Improved communication and collaboration within agency, across agencies, and with customers–Improved credibility and accountability for decisions
12
Asset Management Can Support Financial Performance
Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB)- Statement 34
• provides a comprehensive framework for financial reporting with the objective of making annual reports easier to understand and more useful to the people who rely on the financial information contained therein.
13
Asset Management Can Support Financial Performance
Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB)- Statement 34–the government manages the eligible infrastructure assets using an asset management system that has the characteristics set below:■ Provides an up-to-date inventory of eligible infrastructure assets;■ Performs condition assessments of the eligible infrastructure assets and summarizes the results using a measurable scale; and■ Estimates each year the annual amount to maintain and preserve the eligible infrastructure assets at the condition level established and disclosed by thegovernment.
14
Asset Management Can Support Financial Performance
Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB)- Statement 34
– the government documents that the eligible infrastructure assets are being preserved approximately at (or above) a condition level established and disclosed by the government. Determining what constitutes adequate documentary evidence to meet the second requirement involves professional judgment because of variations among government asset management systems and condition assessment methods.
15
Examples of Application
•Policy Development
•Tradeoff Analysis
•Economic Analysis and Life Cycle Cost Analysis
16
Policy Development
Proactive Role in Policy Formulation
•Asset Management provides an opportunity to connect POLICY to ACTION•Agencies need to engage policy makers during their decision-making process
–Have an impact on external bodies that shape policies
–Frame and inform policy options
•Communicate implications of funding decisions •Reinforce accountability•Same principles can be applied to long-range planning
17
Proactive Role in Policy Formulation
Example – MassHighwayGovernor initiated a “Fix It First” program focused on reducing structurally deficient (SD) bridges. Initially, resources would be allocated to fix current SD bridges
Current SD Bridges
Number of SD Bridges
18
Proactive Role in Policy Formulation
Example – MassHighway (continued)Further analysis indicated that the number of SD bridges would increase over time with focus only on fixing current SD bridges
Current SD BridgesSD Bridges in Future Due to Deterioration
Total Number of SD Bridges
Number of SD Bridges
19
Policy Goals and Objectives
Analysis of Options and Tradeoffs
Resource Allocation Decisions
Financial Staff Equipment Other
Program and Service Delivery
System Condition and Service Levels
Funding Levels
Customer Input
PreservationPreservation OperationsOperationsCapacity
ExpansionCapacity
Expansion
Proactive Role in Policy Formulation
20
Proactive Role in Policy Formulation
Example – MassHighway (continued)
New policy balances preservation and replacement needs. New budget includes increased bridge funding to address current SD bridges and manage deterioration
Manage deterioration
Reduce the number of current SD
bridges
Number of SD Bridges
21
Tradeoff Analysis
What is a Program Tradeoff?
How many resources should we allocate to Structurally Deficient versus healthy?
Question is –
Tradeoff issue is–What are the consequences of a particular
funding allocation to pavements & bridges?
The final choice is– The allocation and set of consequences that the decision-maker prefers
22
Tradeoff Analysis Example
23
Economic Analysis and Asset Management
•Mechanism for evaluating and comparing long-term costs and benefits of alternatives
•Economic analysis results
– Help structure project-level tradeoffs
–Quantify & Qualify costs and benefits to the agency and to customers
–Support repeatable and transparent project justification and prioritization
•Management systems can help with economic analysis
Adam Smith
24
Economic Fundamentals
•Life-Cycle Comparisons
•Inflation
•Time Value of Resources
25
Life-Cycle Comparisons
16 17 18 19 20
Initial Capital
Cost
Year
Dollars
Benefits
Costs
1514131211109876543210
Typical Life-Cycle Profile
26
Economic Analysis Tools
FHWA Office of Asset Management offers multiple tools to assist organizations with economic analysis•HERS-ST: uses engineering standards to identify highway deficiencies, applies economic criteria to select the most cost-effective mix of improvements for system-wide implementation•STEAM: facilitates detailed corridor and system-wide economic analysis for large transportation projects•BCA.NET: web-based benefit-cost analysis tool to support the highway project decision-making •Life Cycle Cost Analysis Process & RealCost Software: performs a project alternative analysis
27
Benefit and Cost Elements
Agency Cost/BenefitDesign and Engineering
Land Acquisition
Construction
Reconstruction/Rehabilitation
Preservation/Maintenance
User Cost/Benefit
Delay/Time Saving
Crashes/Avoided Crashes
Vehicle Operating Costs
Externalities
Remaining Asset Value
28
Performance Measures Basics
• Performance measurement is … – A way to link strategy to action– A process of gathering information to make well-informed decisions– A way of monitoring progress toward a result or goal (accountability is another dimension of this aspect)
• Goal of performance measurement is to align metrics to focused strategies that are achievable
– Having measures that state that one has to be good at everything is not helpful– Good measures strengthen link between strategies, actions, and results– Useful as a filter for how to respond to new initiative
29
Policy Goals and Objectives
Analysis of Options and Tradeoffs
Resource Allocation Decisions
Financial Staff Equipment Other
Program and Service Delivery
System Condition and Service Levels
Funding Levels
Customer Input
PreservationPreservation OperationsOperationsCapacity
ExpansionCapacity
Expansion
Performance Measures are Critical
30
VDOT Dashboard Performance Measures Example
•2002 – Program delivery was not good – late and over
budget•Commissioner - “Change the culture”•Develop and adhere to strict definition of on-time, on-budget•Measuring on-time, on-budget required data on outputs
–Work accomplishments–Project schedule–Cost of work to date–Contract award amount
31
Performance Results
From FY 2001 to FYTD 2007…
Construction
345% improvement in on-time delivery
74% improvement in on-budget delivery
Maintenance
110% improvement in on-time delivery
51% improvement in on-budget delivery
2001 2002 2003Performance Measure FYE FYE FYE FYE FYE FYE YTD1
Construction On-time 20% 30% 27% 36% 75% 84% 90%Construction On-budget 51% 61% 65% 73% 78% 86% 89%
Maintenance On-time 38% 43% 38% 51% 74% 79% 80%Maintenance On-budget 59% 71% 80% 81% 80% 88% 89%
1 As of January 08, 2007
2005 2006
VDOT On-Time and On-Budget Reported Results
20072004
32
Establish Performance Targets
Example – Analyze Resource Allocation Scenarios
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time (Years)
Percent Pavement in Good Condition
$25M/year
$5M/year
Do Nothing
33
Establish Performance Targets
Example – Analyze Resource Allocation Scenarios
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 5 10 15 20 25
Relative Budget, $Millions/Year
Percent Pavement in Good Condition in 10 Years $25M/year
$5M/year
Do nothing
34
Role of Preservation
•Preservation of existing assets is fundamental in any asset management approach•Doing the right thing at the right time to the right asset•Benefits
–Make existing capital investments last longer–Stretching available funding further–Reducing the frequency of costly, time consuming, traffic disrupting rehab, and reconstruction projects
•North Carolina DOT (described in the FHWA Comprehensive Asset Management Case Study) added “preservation” as an explicit budget line item to their budget
35
Example
Pavement Preservation
Time
Pav
emen
t C
on
dit
ion
PreventiveTrigger
RehabilitationTrigger
Optimal Timing
Original Pavement
36
Applying
Asset Management to Operations
•Operations broadens asset management beyond a preservation focus
– Can an ITS project achieve the same objective as a proposed capital project?– Should we “trade” a decline in pavement condition for improved capacity on an existing highway?
Analysis of Options and Tradeoffs
Preservation
OperationsCapacity
Expansion
37
Management Systems
All state DOTs have some form of pavement and bridge management systemsSelected agencies have other management systems and analytic tools – tunnels, safety hardware, traffic signals, culverts, etc.Management system uses:
Manage an inventory of assetsMonitor condition and performancePerform engineering and economic analysisDetermine budget needs and expendituresDetermine what is working well and where work is neededMajor challenge – tying management systems to the decision-making process
38
Pavement Management Systems
Invest in strong bases and preventive maintenance to maximize pavement life at lowest life cycle cost, and rehabilitate pavements well before they become noticeably rough.Many Pavement Management Systems exist in the market
39
Bridge Management Systems
A tool for managing a bridge portfolio for optimal resultsQuantification of the benefits of addressing bridge needs and the increased cost of deferring needed workDetermine the most cost-effective way to maintain the bridge inventory
40
Other Management Systems
Maintenance Management SystemsCombines asset inventories, work planning, and work ordersMany products exist in the market
Culvert Management SystemsAlabama, Maryland, Minnesota, and Shelby County case study
Many adapt their BMS for use with culvertsAdapt maintenance management systemsHome-grown systems exist
Other states have custom developed systems (NJDOT) Operations Asset Management
Tools operations asset management systems are beginning to be published and made available
Traffic Operations Asset Management System (NCHRP)
Identification of operations assets (FHWA document)Signals, lighting, safety hardware, signs, others (NCHRP)
41
Data and Data Management
Many agencies view themselves as data rich, but information poor Existing tools are largely under-utilized in most DOTs for asset management decision-making, especially predictive modelsAs a general rule, the most
successful man in life is the man who has the best information.
Benjamin Disraeli
When you cannot measure, when you cannot express in numbers, your knowledge is of a meager and unsatisfactory kind: you have scarcely, in your thoughts, advanced to the stage of a science.
Lord KelvinData is a lot like humans: It is born. Matures. Gets married to other data, divorced. Gets old. One thing that it doesn't do is die. It has to be killed.
Arthur Miller
A computer cannot turn bad data into good data.
John R Pierce
42
Forces Driving Data Business Planning in Transportation
Fragmentation, lack of integration
Need for greater accountability
Data Business Plans
Support for data programs
Maximize use of existing data
Data quality issues
Shrinking resources, growing needs
Data Rich, Information Poor Syndrome
Increase understanding of data
value
Better payoff from IT investments
Technology Advances
43
Data Plans: Delivering Value
Design
Validate
Store
Access
Use
Collect
Document
Integrate
Established need, sound measurement methods, precise definition, fit with other data
Efficient and sustainable methods using current technologies
Process to ensure accuracy
Provide metadata for users and integrators
Protect data security and integrity, enable access
Link to other data sets
Provide access to meet user needs: downloads, reports, maps
Use to support decisions, meet reporting requirements, etc.
44
Moving Forward with Asset Management
There is no one right way Most important ingredient is an organizational support structure
Identify a champion Clearly define responsibilities
The scale of the effort can be big or small; agency-wide, division centric, or unit focused; involved hundreds of people or a small groupThe Self Assessment in Chapter 3 of the Asset Management Guide can help identify greatest opportunities for improvement
45
Developing a Plan
Step 4 Implement actions and periodically revisit plan
Step 3Develop an asset management plan with clear set of prioritized actions
Step 2 Define gaps, needs, and opportunities
No single “correct” approach to getting started
Step 1 Establish vision and objectives
46
FHWA Office of Asset Management
Mission•“provide leadership and expertise in the systematic management of highway infrastructure assets.”
•“serves as an advocate for asset management, system preservation, pavement management and analysis, bridge management and inspection, and construction and maintenance activities, as well as technology development, outreach, and partnering initiatives.”
47
FHWA Office of Asset Management
Three TeamsConstruction and System Preservation responsible for construction and maintenance program policy, technical support, and national outreach. Specific areasof responsibility include accelerated construction,transportation systempreservation, and continuous quality improvement initiatives such as system preservation.
48
FHWA Office of Asset Management
The System Management and Monitoring Team: responsible for developing & promoting systematic approaches to the management of highway assets. This work includes refiningand advancing the use of pavementand bridge management systems and developing systems where theypresently do not exist, such as for tunnels and roadway hardware. Theteam is made up of a Pavement Management Group and a Bridge Management Group.
49
FHWA Office of Asset Management
Evaluation and Economic Investment Team development and promotion of an array of procedures for inclusion in an engineering economic analysis toolbox, identification and dissemination of alternatives for developing data systems to support asset management, and providing assistance with implementation of relevantstandards issued by the Governmental Accounting Standards Board (GASB).