1
© Kari Alanne
Micro-Cogeneration – I
Introduction
Kari Alanne
University Lecturer, D.Sc (Tech.)
© Kari Alanne
Session outline
1. Background
2. What is micro-cogeneration?
3. Micro-cogeneration technologies
4. Domestic micro-cogeneration
5. Micro-cogeneration system
6. Operational strategies
7. Energy excess, shortage and storage
8. Future trends
2
© Kari Alanne
Background –
Key phrases of sustainable development
• Scarcity of natural resources
• Efficiency in terms of the use of energy and raw materials
• Utilization of local resources
• Decentralization – ”not all the eggs in the same basket”
• Networking
• Flexibility and scalability
© Kari Alanne
Background – Different energy supplies
In the past
• Furnace in every single house
• Wooden fuel from the surroundings
• No electrical devices – no demand of electricity
Now
• Large power plants
• District heating
• Increasing demand of
electricity
In the future (?)
• Every single house consumes
and produces its own thermal and
electrical energy
• Thermal demand
minimized, strong dependency on electricity
3
© Kari Alanne
Definitions – what is micro-cogeneration?
• Also known as micro-CHP: Combined Heat and Power
• ”Simultaneous production of electricity and thermal energy in small units close to consumers”
• ”A direct replacement for a boiler in a hydronic heating system, which simultaneously produces heat & electrical power”
© Kari Alanne
Definitions – technical
• EU Directive on micro-cogeneration:– electrical power less than 50 kWe
– ”Mini-CHP”: electrical power > 50 kWe
• European Committee for Standardization (EN50438):– 16 A per phase in three phase (25 A single phase)
• Domestic scale micro-cogeneration (DCHP):– “one unit per home”
– practically: less than 5 kWe
4
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP technologies
• Fuel cells
• Stirling engines
• Internal Combustion engines
• Microturbines
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP technologies – fuel cells (FC)
• Operational principle: – inverse electrolysis (details on separate slide)
– operational temperatures 60…100ºC (Poly-Electrolyte Membrane, PEM), 600…1000ºC (Solid-Oxide Fuel Cells, SOFC)
• Fuel:– hydrogen, reformed natural gas
• Efficiency:– electrical efficiency 40 % – overall efficiency 65-75 %
– electrical power / heat flow ~ 1.0 (PEM)
• Market status: – emerging technology
• Estimated installed costs: – 2700…4200 EUR/kWe (10…100 kWe plants, full market)
5
© Kari Alanne
Fuel Cells – operational principle
Source: Center for Fuel Cell &
Hydrogen Research
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP technologies – Stirling engines (SE)
• Operational principle:
– reciprocating engine, combustion outside the cylinder
– operational temperature 60…80ºC
• Fuel:
– natural or biogas, gasoline, diesel, LPG, various liquid or solid fuels
• Efficiency:
– electrical efficiency 20-30 %
– overall efficiency 80-90 %
– electrical power / heat flow ~ 0.3
• Market status:
– emerging technology
• Estimated installed costs:
– 1100…2500 EUR/kWe (5…10 kWe plants, full market)
6
© Kari Alanne
Stirling engines – operational principle
• 2 cylinders (expansion and compression) containing the working gas combined with a passage
• a high temperature is maintained in the expansion cylinder (red) and the compression cylinder (blue) is cooled
• classified into i) alpha, ii) beta and iii) gamma types according to how the pistons are arranged
Alpha type Stirling engine
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP technologies – internal
combustion engines (ICE)• Operational principle:
– conventional reciprocating engine, combustion inside the cylinder– operational temperature 85…100ºC
• Fuel:– natural or biogas, diesel, gasoline
• Efficiency:– electrical efficiency 25-30 % – overall efficiency 75-85 %– electrical power / heat flow ~ 0.5
• Market status: – on the market
• Installed costs: – 847…1020 EUR/kWe (5.5-30 kWe plants)
7
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP technologies – microturbines (MT)
• Operational principle: – conventional gas turbine process– operational temperature 85…100ºC
• Fuel:– natural or biogas, diesel, gasoline, alcohols
• Efficiency:– electrical efficiency 25-30 % – overall efficiency 60-70 %– electrical power / heat flow ~ 0.5
• Market status: – on the market
• Installed costs: – 800…1000 EUR/kWe (> 25 kWe plant)
© Kari Alanne
Images of micro-CHP products - I
Honda Ecowill ICE Whispergen SE
8
© Kari Alanne
Images of micro-CHP products - II
Acumentrics AHEAD SOFC Turbec T100 MT
© Kari Alanne
Domestic micro-CHP (DCHP) concept
micro
CHP
plantFuel
100%
ELECTRICITY
IMPORT/EXPORT
EXHAUST
5-15%
Heat
70%
ELECTRICITY
15-25%
• lighting
• appliances
• building services
• space heating
• domestic hot water
(DHW)
9
© Kari Alanne
Micro-CHP plant
Pre-handling of fuel and air
Fuel Air
Energy conversion module
Power conditioning module
Electricity
output (AC)
Electricity
(AC) for
ancillaries
Auxiliary burner
Heat
recovery
Exhaust gasExhaust
gas out
Water out Water
in
Mechanical power
or electricity (DC)
© Kari Alanne
Integration of micro-CHP plant into
building services
Buffer
storage
60…80ºC*
µCHP
plant
>80ºC
Hydronic
radiators
network or
floor
heating
40…70/
20…40ºC
Controller Circulating
pumpElectricity to
HVAC,
lighting and
appliancesElectricity to
grid
Fuel
and
air
Exhaust
gasesDomestic
hot water
55ºC
Cold
water* The storage temperature is
controlled using heat sink and
auxiliary burner, when needed.
10
© Kari Alanne
Operational strategies
• Aim:– to find optimal match between electrical
and thermal demand and supply
• Methods:– power control
– load management
– electrical and thermal storages
© Kari Alanne
Power control
1. Electrical load following mode, thermal excess is stored or dumped, thermal shortage generated by auxiliary burner and/or discharging the thermal storage
2. Thermal load following mode, electrical excess is stored or fed into the grid, electrical shortage satisfied by grid electricity or by discharging the storage
3. Operation at constant power (base load), the employment of thermal and electrical storages, heat sink, auxiliary burner and grid, when needed
11
© Kari Alanne
Temperature control of buffer storage
• The purpose of the buffer storage:
– to deliver heat to the hydronic heating system
– to shave the peak thermal demands
• Preset threshold values for storage
temperatures determine the on/off-
operation of the micro-CHP plant.
• The temperature of supply water to
the radiator network is controlled by
mixing supply and return water
according to the outdoor
temperature.
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
16
12 8 4 0 -4 -8
-12
-16
-20
-24
-28
Outdoor temperature [C]
Su
pp
ly w
ate
r te
mp
era
ture
[C
]
© Kari Alanne
Power control - challenges
• Only on/off operation available the usual present day micro-cogeneration technologies
• Long start-up and shutdown periods may be required (Stirling engines)
• Substantial fuel demand at start-up phase• Limited dP/dt (Solid-Oxide Fuel Cells)
• Low part-load efficiency
The above challenges are technology-specific.
In general: steady demand close to specific power output is preferable in the sense of micro-cogeneration.
12
© Kari Alanne
Load management
• A procedure to adjust electrical demands rather than the output of the plant
• Examples:
– Forced switch-off of ”power-eaters” such as sauna stoves and ovens
– Limited simultaneous use of electrical appliances
© Kari Alanne
Seasonal (long-term) thermal storages
• Thermal surplus during warm season commonly occurs in the case of micro-CHP, when the plant can be operated close to constant power only and shutdowns are not preferred (e.g. SOFC plant)
�Significant thermal losses, poor annual efficiency
�Solution: seasonal thermal storage
13
© Kari Alanne
Thermal storage technologies
• Mass storages
• Phase change materials (PCM)
• Thermo chemical energy storage
© Kari Alanne
Applicability of seasonal thermal storages
• Operational environment:
– climatic conditions, e.g. ground temperature, snow-covered ground
– geological structure of the building site
• Inlet temperatures of the heating system:
– 40ºC (low temperature heating system)
– 70ºC (conventional radiator heating in Finland)
• Trade-off between storage capacity and storage
losses must be found!
14
© Kari Alanne
Integration of seasonal thermal storage
into residential micro-CHP plant
Seasonal heat storage (5…45ºC)
Heat pump
Buffer storage
(45…50ºC)
Floor heating system (25…30ºC)
µCHP plant
(>100ºC)
Heat exchanger
© Kari Alanne
About electrical storages for micro-CHP
• Basic requirements:
– large charge-discharge
quantities
– must tolerate high discharge
power
– minor service requirements
– safety
– longevity
– high energy density
• Selected alternatives– Lead-acid- battery
• good availability at low price (4-6 Wh/€)
• low energy density 60-75 Wh/L
– NiMH- battery
• in the market, high price (1 Wh/€)
• high energy density 140-300 Wh/L
• high self-discharge
– LiFePO4- battery
• emerging, high price (< 1Wh/€)
• high energy density 170 Wh/L
• low service requirement
15
© Kari Alanne
Electricity to the grid?
• Monetary compensation for the electricity fed into the grid may
be based on:
– Feed-in tariffs
• the utilities are obliged to buy electricity from small producers at rates set by the government (buyback rate)
• a two-directional electricity metering required
• applied in many European countries
– Net-metering
• the deduction of energy outflows from metered energy inflows and compensated through a retail credit by a utility
– Time-of use metering
• Two-directional metering strategy that allows rate schedule depending on the peak demand hours
• The stability of the grid limits the amount of grid-connected
small-scale producers
© Kari Alanne
Energy saving houses – challenge for the future
• Thermal demand decreases significantly due to forthcoming low energy and passive construction standards.
• Electrical demand may decrease, remain the same or even increase in the future
� Electrical demand increases vis-à-vis thermal
demand, whereas the electricity/heat ratio of micro-
cogeneration plants (excluding fuel cells) is small.
• Zero energy / plus energy houses / autonomous houses aim at meeting the electrical demand by local generation.
16
© Kari Alanne
Example: demand profiles
Standard house, Helsinki
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000
8000
9000
10000
1 652 1303 1954 2605 3256 3907 4558 5209 5860 6511 7162 7813 8464
Time [h]
Ele
ctr
icit
y/h
eat
[W]
Electricity [W] Heat (standard house) [W]
Passive house, Helsinki
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
1 639 1277 1915 2553 3191 3829 4467 5105 5743 6381 7019 7657 8295
Time [h]
Ele
ctr
icit
y/h
eat
[W]
Electricity [W] Heat (standard house) [W]
© Kari Alanne
Trends of development
• Polygeneration– simultaneous production of electricity, heat
and cooling energy (at various enthalpy levels), fuel synthesis (e.g. hydrogen)
• Hybrid systems– micro-cogeneration +
• solar and micro-wind
• heat pump
• energy storage
17
© Kari Alanne
Micro-Cogeneration – II
Research on micro-cogeneration at Aalto University
Kari Alanne
University Lecturer, D.Sc (Tech.)
© Kari Alanne
Session outline
1. Baselines for the micro-CHP research at Aalto
2. Current research efforts
– SOFC micro-cogeneration
• economic assessment (break-even costs)
• seasonal thermal storages
• cost-optimized operation
– Combustion engines
• calibration and validation of SE simulation model
• performance assessment of SE-micro-cogeneration in single buildings and communitites
3. Future research
4. Discussion
18
© Kari Alanne
General baselines
• Computational study by IDA-ICE whole-building
simulation program
• Target building: single-family house (131 m2, 4
occupants) located in Helsinki area
• Annual electricity consumption: 6100 kWh/a
• Annual thermal energy consumption: 11200
kWh/a
• Reference system: hydronic heating system with
condensing gas boiler (η=93 %)
© Kari AlanneIDA Simulation Environment
• Simulation environment with different applications– IDA Indoor Climate and Energy (ICE)– IDA Road Tunnel Ventilation (RTV)– IDA Tunnel
• Developed at the Swedish Institute of applied mathematics and at KTH• Owned by Equa Simulation, www.equa.se
• Features– Possibility to write user defined models – Support of either NMF or Modelica models– Adaptive time step– Very flexible data input possibilities– Easy data export (to Excel, Matlab, etc)– Unique 3D visualization and animation of inputs and results for quality
control and presentation capabilities– A model version handling system for easy comparison between different
runs– Plenty of result presentation possibilities– Location and climate downloads– Internet and email support
19
© Kari Alanne
Economic premises for SOFC micro-
cogeneration in Finnish households
Presented in Clima 2007 conference in Helsinki
© Kari Alanne
Objective and methods
• Objective:– To evaluate the financial viability of SOFC-based micro-
cogeneration for residential applications in terms of
• break-even prices for plant investment and buyback prices of electricity
• sensitivity of break-even prices to electrical power, operational strategy and overall efficiency
• Methods:– Computational study by IDA-Indoor Climate and Energy (IDA-ICE)
– Estimation of hourly energy consumptions
– SOFC-”blackbox” model developed by VTT on the basis of the model specification by Beausoleil-Morrison et al. (2005)
– Estimation of SOFC operation
– Post-processing of simulation results
• financial analysis
20
© Kari Alanne
Results
What should the buyback price be to
create annual savings when SOFC is
compared with the reference system?
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0,5 0,6 0,7 0,8 0,9 1
Overall efficiency
Bre
ak-e
ven
bu
yb
ack
pri
ce (
sn
t/kW
h)
1 kWe 2 kWe 3 kWe
Overall efficiency 80 %,
2 % escalation of electricity price
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
5 7 9
Buyback price snt/kWhP
ayb
ack p
rice (
EU
R)
5 a 10 a 15 a 20 a
How much may an SOFC plant cost
in order to be feasible within
payback periods of 5-20 years?
© Kari Alanne
Conclusions
• Preferred operation: constant run of 1 kWe
SOFC (efficient heat recovery necessary)
• Investment support is required to make SOFC micro-cogeneration financially viable.
• Computational results cannot be generalized.
21
© Kari Alanne
Seasonal heat storages and residential
micro-cogeneration
Presented in MICRO-COGEN 2008 conference in Ottawa
© Kari Alanne
Objective and methods
• Objective:
– to find the optimal shape and size of a seasonal mass thermal
storage in a simulated residential SOFC plant located in
Finland
– to find break-even price for storage investment
• Methods:
– IDA-Indoor Climate and Energy (IDA-ICE) – estimation of
hourly energy consumptions
– Post-processing the simulation results in a spreadsheet
application
• polynomial expression to predict the thermal production of an SOFC plant
• financial analysis to find out the economic value of accumulated energy savings and the break-even price
22
© Kari Alanne
Results and conclusions
• Optimal storage size: 150 m3, semi-spherical shape
• Optimum operational conditions:
– constant operation of 3 kWe
– annual fuel savings of 5342 kWh a-1
– annual cost savings of 194 EUR a-1
– total savings of 2483 EUR (20 a)
• Computational results cannot be generalized (e.g. optimal storage size).
• The financial viability of the storage was not evaluated in the computational study, but on the basis of experience the present configuration is hardly feasible.
© Kari Alanne
Cost-Optimized Operation of a Residential
SOFC Plant
Presented in MICRO-COGEN 2008 conference in Ottawa
23
© Kari AlanneObjective, methods and results
• Objective:
– to evaluate the potential to improve the energy efficiency of a simulated residential SOFC plant located in Finland applying a simple cost-optimization algorithm
• Methods:
– IDA-Indoor Climate and Energy (IDA-ICE) – estimation of hourly energy consumptions
– Post-processing the simulation results in a spreadsheet application
• polynomial expression to depict the thermal production of an SOFC plant
• optimization algorithm to find out the control parameter (20%…100% of the specific power) that results in minimum costs at given time step
• Results:
– Annual savings of 65 EUR compared to constant operation of 1 kWe were obtained using the optimization algorithm � feasible in all probability
© Kari Alanne
Implementation and Validation of
Combustion Engine Micro-cogeneration
Routine for the Simulation Program IDA-ICE
Presented in Building Simulation 2009 in Glasgow
24
© Kari Alanne
Background
• The original combustion engine model
– was developed in the IEA/ECBCS Annex 42 for whole-
building simulation programs
– is a ”grey-box” model that circumvents the exact
thermochemical modelling of combustion process
– addresses the dynamic effects of micro-CHP devices
– had been so far implemented in ESP-r, TRNSYS and
EnergyPlus
• The novelty of the IDA-ICE implentation:
– thermal exhaust gas heat recovery
© Kari Alanne
Model validation
• Method:
– inter-program comparison with ESP-r, TRNSYS and EnergyPlus
– Annex 42 test program entailing 9 test series and total 44 separate cases
• An excellent agreement was obtained
25
© Kari Alanne
SE micro-CHP in a single-family house –
performance assessment
• 3 – 5 % cut to primary energy consumption and CO2
emission compared to hydronic heating based on
natural gas boiler and grid electricity depending on
building type (standard vs. passive) and climate
(Helsinki, Jyväskylä)
• The effect of exhaust heat recovery ~ 1 %
• Cumulative savings €3000-4000 (10 years, interest rate 2 %, electricity price 5-15 c)
© Kari Alanne
SE micro-CHP in small communities –
performance assessment
• ”District micro-cogeneration”: 9.5 kWe pellet burning SE micro-cogeneration plant
• 70 % of annual electricity consumption can be covered by local micro-cogeneration, when the
number of houses < 10
• Annual primary energy consumption curbed by 25 % and CO2 emission by 19 % in comparison with pellet-
fuelled district heating without CHP
26
© Kari Alanne
Research trends at Aalto university
• Commercialization of a Rotary Steam Engine (RSE)
micro-polygeneration (electricity + heat +
desalination) system (technical development and
experimental research)
• Hybrid systems (solar + micro-cogeneration)
• Zero and plus energy buildings, autonomous buildings
• The application of micro-co-/polygeneration in small communities
• Contribution to IEA/ECBCS Annex 54
© Kari AlanneRotary Steam Engine (RSE)
• Ongoing pilot project for a 4 kWe / 30 kWth pellet-fuelled Novoro2, funded by Tekes
• Novoro Inc. collaboration with Applied thermodynamics research group since 2006 (-2010)
• Good applicability to biofuels, solar energy and thermal energy in desalination processes
• Estimated installed cost of a similar magnitude as for micro-CHP plants based on internal combustion engines
4 kWe / 30 kWth NOVO2 - RSEExample: RSE and solar-powered desalination
Source : Novoro Inc. / Heikki Pohjola and Aalto University / Applied Thermodynamics
27
RSE micro-cogeneration plant
© Kari Alanne
Evaporator
RSE Generator
Condenser
Water container
Source : Novoro Inc. / Heikki Pohjola
© Kari Alanne
Collaboration opportunities?
Current research themes:
• Micro co-/polygeneration
• Zero and plus energy buildings, autonomous buildings– Definitions – connection to life-cycle economy
– Applicability to• various building types
• climates
– Simulation / optimization studies
Recommended