A Webinar on Learning: From Cognitive Development to Identity Development
Jenna CondieUniversity of Salford
@jennacondie
This session is about making the connections:
Technology Globalisation
E-Learning Multiculturalism
Developmental Theory Educational Practice
Learning
Identity Development
Cognitive Development
Unpicking theory
Developing theory
Theory as underpinning your practice
Flickr: ogimogi Flickr: wallyg
During the webinar, consider the benefits and limitations of learning online.
Can this approachbe applied to yourassignments?
An Opportunity to Reflect & ApplyFlickr: London College of Fashion short courses
What can you rememberabout Jean Piaget’s theory of cognitive development from last year (this year)?
Image from Wikipedia
Piaget’s stages of cognitive development
• Sensorimotor stage (birth to two years)
• Preoperational stage (two to seven years)
• Concrete operations stage (seven to eleven years)
• Formal operations stage (from about eleven years)
6Flickr: geonandoFlickr : Lee CourseyFlickr babypixel eyesFlickr: ecohen
Does the theory stand up to examination?
Consensus: Further theoretical development needed
• Formal operations– Children think differently, they are not mini-adults
(Mitchell & Ziegler, 2013)• ‘Naughty teddy’ (Donaldson et al., 1978)– Young children can conserve. – Must have misunderstood what Piaget was asking
them. Flickr: AndyNor
Misrepresentations of Piagetian theory?“First, the simple fact that during his productive lifetime – well over 60 years – he wrote more than any one person could keep up with; and his ideas, of course, developed, interacted, and changed in more and less subtle ways.” (von Glasersfeld, 1982)
Important to readoriginal work & makeyour own interpretations
Re-interpret Flickr: adesigna
von Glasersfeld (1982) An Interpretation of Piaget's Constructivism Link: http://elearnmap.ipgkti.edu.my/resource/dpli_r/index_htm_files/InterpretationPiagetConstructivism.pdf
Interpreting Piaget: The difference between development and learning?
Piaget (1964) – Development and Learning: http://www.psy.cmu.edu/~siegler/35piaget64.pdf
Linking cognitive development to learning to read
Link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hJCa_0iZd0Q
Uta Frith (1985): A theory of reading acquisition
Logographic
stage
• Instant recognition of familiar words• Word order largely ignored• Phonological factors secondary• Willing to have a guess, no response if word unknown
Alphabetic stage
• Reading systematically decoding phonemes and graphemes
• Enables pronunciation of unfamiliar & novel words• Letter order and phonological factors now key
Orthograp
hic stage
• Written words as a whole• Fully systematic approach to reading that is non-visual• Internally representing letter-by-letter strings
Frith, U. (1985). Beneath the surface of developmental dyslexia. In K.E. Patterson, J. C. Marshall, & M. Coltheart (Eds.), Surface dyslexia , London: Erlbaum. Available here
Could you combine aspects of Piaget’s theory with aspects of Frith’s theory to develop your own theoretical approach for learning to read?
Flickr: ellajphillips
concept
have
goa
mappingat
The problem with stage theory explanations of learning…
Can you jump a stage? Can you be in more than one stage at a time?
Are these theories universal? How might learning to read differ across
languages? What about the style of teaching?Role of others? Role of culture?
Role of identity? Flickr: followtheseinstructions
14
Piaget’s constructivism: an epistemology that knowledge is actively constructed by the individual
(Mitchell & Ziegler, 2013, p. 14)
Flickr 4nitsirkFlickr IMLS DCC
Piaget’s constructivist theory and the classroom
Epistemology: a theory of knowledge, how can we know (Willig, 2001)
Lev Vygotsky: taking constructivism furtherPiaget Cognitive constructivism
Learning as assimilating and accommodating information (revisit Slater & Bremner, 2011)
Vygotsky Social Constructivism Can not separate learning from the social context“Every function in the child's cultural development appears twice: first, on the social level and, later on, on the individual level; first, between people (interpsychological) and then inside the child (intrapsychological). This applies equally to voluntary attention, to logical memory, and to the formation of concepts. All the higher functions originate as actual relationships between individuals.” (Vygotsky, 1978, p. 57)
16
Social Constructionism*• What we experience or perceive is not a direct
reflection of objective environmental conditions. It is constructed in talk and interaction (Willig, 2001).
• Social Constructionist research identifies the ways in which people construct their social realities by taking into account the specific linguistic, cultural and historical influences (Burr, 2003).
Flickr: Leonard John Matthews
* Note the different and interchangeable terms (for further reading see Burr, V. (2003) Social Constructionism, Hove: Routledge)
Identity Development and Learning
Social constructionist view – identities as constructed in dialogue in the classroom.
Flickr : USAG-Humphreys
Learning Identities
Talk
Thought
Identity as socially constructed
• Identities seen as something which requires “ongoing negotiations within a complex web of relationships and practices” (Gough & McFadden, 2001, p. 89).
• Identities as negotiated in interactions and the “telling” of “stories” (Seaton, 2009, p. 304).
• Identities as relational to others (Mason, 2004)
Developing dialogues for learning• Mercer (2008) social constructionist research, ‘learning
talk’ & construction of identities. • Vygotskian influence, relationship between language and
thinking
“One of the strengths of bringing a sociocultural perspective to bear on education, I believe, is that it encourages us to
recognize that the quality of education cannot be explained in terms of 'learning' or 'teaching' as separate processes, but rather in terms of the interactive process of 'teaching-and-
learning” (p. 18, in press version)
Mercer (2008) Developing Dialogues, Link: http://people.ucsc.edu/~gwells/Files/Courses_Folder/documents/Mercer.DevelopingDialoguepdf.pdf
20
Where is The Self?
“When you ask people to localize their self, they will point to their body and tell you that it is somewhere inside.” (Hermans, 2004, p. 298)
Flickr: hanspetermeyer.ca
21
Constructing identities
“The choosing, deciding, shaping human being who aspires to be the author of his or her own life, the creator of an individual identity” as “the central character of our time”
(Beck & Beck-Gernsheim, 2001, p 22–23)
Flickr: AhmadH
amm
oud
Teaching as dialogical
“Teaching involves communication; whether its purpose is to enable students to gain access to inalienable truths, or to promote intellectual or social exploration for its own
sake.” (Stables, 2003, p. 1)
Vygotskian influence: learning through dialogue with a more learned other in a ‘zone of proximal development’
Classroom dialogue can impact positively or negatively on children’s identities and sense of self.
Stables, A. (2003) Learning, Identity and Classroom Dialogue, Journal of Educational Enquiry, 4 (1) Available here: http://www.ojs.unisa.edu.au/index.php/EDEQ/article/viewFile/528/398
Learning through blogging
• Remember quadblogging? • Blogging and development of writing skills (McGrail & Davis, 2011)• Ownership creativity, expression, experiment, exploration, audience, self-directed (Ducate & Lomicka, 2008)• Learning identities?
Flickr: kpwerker
Link: http://zororomubaya.wordpress.com/2012/11/14/reflection-my-unique-experience/
Link: http://www.doubleblind.org/
Teachers as learners too
Link: http://hub.salford.ac.uk/salfordpsych/2012/11/07/labels-hurt/
Need ideas & inspiration for your seminar?
Check out Salford PGCAP Website
Narratives in the classroom: Interrogating practice (Karen Gallas)
• ‘Sharing time’ in a socio-economic and racially diverse classroom in city suburb.
• “Discourses of power”, dialogical approach• Jiana – six year old African American girl, lives in shelter – Said to Gallas “my mother must not have gone to the
same kind of school as you” – Initial assessment (pre-kindergarten level)– Wait and see approach – Jiana enjoyed ‘sharing time’
Screenshot from Riessman, C. (2008) Narrative Methods for the Human Sciences, London: Sage
Screenshot from Riessman, C. (2008) Narrative Methods for the Human Sciences, London: Sage
Narratives for development and learning
• Stories became part of the “fabric” of the classroom. Stories as “power” (Gallas, 2003)
• “Identities were formed and transformed in group performance” (Riessman, 2008, p. 136)
• The role of classroom dialogue in enhancing the student learning experience (Stables, 2003)
• Teaching-and-learning interaction (Mercer, 2008)
Flic
kr:
umja
nedo
an
During the webinar, consider the benefits and limitations of learning online.
Can this approachbe applied to yourassignments?
An Opportunity to Reflect & ApplyFlickr: London College of Fashion short courses
Conclusions
What is your stance on learning and development? Same, different, fence?
What’s your theoretical position on learning?Cognitivist, constructivist?
What has influenced your learning identity? How does your identity link to your learning?
Underpin your work with theory. Take a stance!
Flickr: derekbruff
A Webinar on Learning: From Cognitive Development to Identity Development
Jenna CondieUniversity of Salford
@jennacondie
A Webinar on Learning: From Cognitive Development to Identity Development
Jenna CondieUniversity of Salford
@jennacondie