8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
1/23
LABOR MIGRATION MANAGEMENT
IN TIMES OF RECESSION
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
Steffen AngenendtBosch Fellow, Transatlantic Academy
p a p e r s e r i e s
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
2/23
2009 ransatlantic Academy. All rights reserved.
No part o this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any orm or by any means without permission
in writing rom the ransatlantic Academy. Please direct inquiries to:
ransatlantic Academy
1744 R Street, NW
Washington, DC 20009
1 202 745 3886
F 1 202 265 1662
Tis publication can be downloaded or ree at http://www.transatlanticacademy.org.
Transatlantic Academy Paper Series
Te ransatlantic Academy Paper Series presents research on a variety o transatlantic topics by sta, ellows, and
partners o the ransatlantic Academy. Te views expressed here are those o the author and do not necessarily
represent the view o the ransatlantic Academy. Comments rom readers are welcome; reply to the mailing ad-
dress above or by e-mail to [email protected].
About the Transatlantic Academy
Founded by the German Marshall Fund o the United States (GMF), the ZEI-Stiung Ebelin und Gerd
Bucerius, the Robert Bosch Stiung, and the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation, the ransatlantic Academy
serves as a orum or a select group o scholars rom both sides o the Atlantic and rom dierent academic and
policy disciplines to examine a single set o issues. Working together rom a transatlantic and interdisciplinary
perspective, Academy ellows use research, publications, and ideas to make policy-relevant contributions to
policy debates acing the transatlantic community. In addition, the Academy has received early support rom
the ransatlantic Program o the Government o the Federal Republic o Germany through unds o the Euro-
pean Recovery Program (ERP) o the Federal Ministry o Economics and echnology. Te Compagnia di SanPaolo joined as a nancial partner in May 2009.
Chosen rom the elds o public policy, business administration, economics, journalism, and NGOs/civil
society, Bosch Public Policy Fellows are in residence at the ransatlantic Academy rom one to two months.
During their ellowship, they interact with the Academys long-term ellows, conduct their own research, write a
short paper or the Academy website, and make presentations to audiences o analysts and government ofcials
in the Washington area.
About Transatlantic Academy
Brussels Forum is an annual high-level meeting o the most inuential American and European political, corpo-
rate, and intellectual leaders to address pressing challenges currently acing both sides o the Atlantic. Partici-pants include heads o state, senior ofcials rom the European Union institutions and the member states, U.S.
Cabinet ofcials, Congressional representatives, Parliamentarians, academics, and media. For more inormation,
please visit www.brusselsorum.org.
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
3/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
Transatlantic Academy Paper Series
May 2009
S A*
Bh Fw, T A
I
Th I h C C L M 4
R M P T 6Th C P D C M 7
Ex wh C M Sh
P Ch 1
C F C M P 15
R 1
* S A h S Wh PkG I I S A (SWP) B Wh h G I h , h h h,, H h h xv G, E, Bj SWP 6, M A w h G C F A (DGAP) , h C Yearbook of International Politics H wk UNICEF, UNHCR, IOM, h G F Gv I C I R (Sh-K), h C A-E C- (CAEC), h Hh C M I(Zw) h G v M A h B h F Uv h H Uv H h PhD h F Uv B
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
4/23
Transatlantic Academy2
Th h k h
z v Rv
x ww
, wh
wh - A
w-q
w k
h h w h h
h,
h v w Ev
v -h
h h w k (P Tzz
), x h h wk h
, w
h
Nvh, h h
w -
F , z
hv
Ch w
v h
, z hv w h
h v
wh A h U N, 7,
13 h z
h ,
44 h
hh-k wk (UN DESA 8)
Th, hh h h v
wh, x h h
w w h (Sv
S ) I , hh
k h h w h
h h v
v x h
x w, whh
whv k
h - w
Mh h
h S
5, h h v
D h v, h
vh h E P
M I, v
h E U O 8 C
j
E , h EU hv
A h z
v h
w
Nvh, w, h h
, h h E
U wh M jv, ,
v,
q hv w: Sh h
h- , - -
v D
, v k
h Sh , h
Wh h v
h
Sh h (, ,
v ) vv, h h
w k
A, h h v q:
Wh h h v
Sh h h
k w-k wk, k hh-k wk
Th h j h v
v (hh
v Sh-Nh w) I
wh hw h
Introduction1
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
5/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
3
, , hw h j v hv j
h h ;
, v vvw h
(E) ; h,
v x wh
h; h, z h
h ;
, w
I hz h ,, Th
h k v
h w w-k, k,
hh-k , h
q v
v h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
6/23
Transatlantic Academy4
The repercussions
of the current
crisis are unclear,
but historical
experiences
provide some
insights.
Th h wh h
34 v
GDP v h 3 (IMF ) Wh
, k A L A, hv
x w h ,
h x h
k wh Th
wh ( v
) h h h
h w
, Nh A,
h G S, E I h U S, x, h -
h 18 (G 8),
S h q 17 (OECD 8),
h U K h h 1
w 4 7
(ONS ) D h wh
h k x wh
,
hw h w
F h , x
h
h w O h v wh h x
I , h z
hv x w j : h
- h 17,
h A h 1 Th
w h v
w (Sw ; M ) Th
h h
E A w
5- wk
E, w w A D h
, h w k wk
h Sh Sh h E
h h -W W II Wirtschaftswunder
Nh W
E O h h q
wk w h
h h
v , A,
w v h w
z Ah w
B h -
w hh v A
Sh E
h w h E
C M Tk Nh
A, x, w h w hv
, h v h
h w H,
v
I , A
h h 171 A h
w Ahh
h w h w
, h v
h O , J Sw () h , w h
v (, ,
, ) w hv
w-k h
v
Th, h w,
,
wk , h h v
Gv hh x,
h
- h I , x h k
w-k , h
v v , w
h x w -,
h v w h
(ILO ) I,
The Impact of the Current Crisis on
Labor Migration2
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
7/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
5
Due to the
global character
of the crisis,
many potential
re-migrants will
hesitate to return
UK , w hv (UK H O )
Phv
B
hh k h v wh hv w
h k
h w hv
v Th v k h
h
h h
w v v
w h (C ; W
Bk )
Th, v h v
j h v
Nvh, v
w hh
w h h A
h
, v
hv v k h j q
I , h z
h ( hk) w v
w, h
v h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
8/23
Transatlantic Academy6
Many
governments will
try to substitute
permanent
through
temporary flows.
Recent Migration Policy Trends3B h , v h vw h
v w (OECD 8) Nw
hv, hh v
w , h h ,
q , w h wh
I
w z w
E Nh A hw
k h hw hh-
k (Dk,
Kwk, Thh )
F hh-k , h z
w h--
h (k h h
U K) w w
h Wh k
, h k w x (
C, F, Nw h k
), h -v
w x (A, Nw Z,
C) S hh-
k k w-k ,
w h h
(, S, I, G, P, K), wh
h
( wk h, j, ) w
(S, A, Nw Z) I ,
h EU h
k h w
h EU , whh
k w-k (Ch
L )
Nw, h , v
h I , h
wh v I x h v w v
h v
h , , q, h qv
, w ,
h j -v
h
wh (L )
Nvh, v h w
v k
hh-k , k h
h w
v Fh, h
h x
h, w h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
9/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
7
The current
debate is
characterised
by substantially
different concept
of circular
migration.
C w O h h
A, A,
L A (Vv 7; A
Nw 7), h
z w z
wk I w
h
,
z h h I Oz
M (IOM), h W Bk, h
G C I M
(GCIM) Th GCIM ,Migrationin an Interconnected World: New Directions for
Action (GCIM 5), h
h w
, v
,
Th E w
O 6 G-Fh
v h-I M W
Sh G N Skz
F (A 8) A
wh h h x EU (G6), h G-Fh
Iv Nw E M P
Th, x
w E, h
hk h E
Th h
P I C (
v O 8 h EU h
E P I A)
h , ,
Th
hhh wh w : h h
, v , ,
I h , h
h k
F h E , h w w B h
v v E
h E C S
5 q v
I h , h C
h w w
k h w
w
I h C vw, h v h k
v h kw w
, whh
h v Fh,
h h
v h h
S h ,
h C h
q
, h h q M
7
Th E P h wh h
h G-Fh
v w, h C
h j I h vw, h
h h
h ,
h h h E U
h
Nvh, h h
E k
h v wh
h Wh h C P
w
v, h J
I M h (J
H A C, JHA) w hz
I h
v, Sh Skz h
The Current Political Debate on
Circular Migration4
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
10/23
Transatlantic Academy8
Circular migration:
A tool to improve
labor migration
management,
promote
development, or
reduce irregular
migration?
w: W w k F h,
h w
h q
Th q h
h E v, h
wh wh
h A h , h
k wh
h E U w h
x qk
h ,
q Nvh, h x h q v
h C, whh w h h
wh h h
Th k h , h
G-Fh v w
hh
B h , h
w h
Ahh h v , h w Th
h w v
h v
( h )
h h
S h h v, h
w h JHA h
E C Nvh, v
h , wh w :
F, h JHA h wh
k w-v v h
wk
h 15 EU G
F, x v h-
k h A
h , h h h h
w v
h h wk
x v v h
S, h h h
v
h
wh whh h h
I whh
whh
kw x
, whh h
h
Th q v h v q v A, h
h h E,
h Th
h h
k h v
x wh
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
11/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
9
Many
industrialized
countries have
substantial
experience with
low-skilled labor
migration, but
less experience
with other circula
migration types.
Nw (8) h ww ,
h h w Th
, , wk, x,
W A w Mx h U
S h 1, w -
v
k h E U, h N ,
w A Nw Z I , h
w,
(1) w-k wk, () -w-k wk, (3)
Wh h , h
h h wh whh
v v hv h
x w-k wk
D , v (h U
S, C, Nw Z) w -
(G, h
U K, S) hv hv
h , h , , v
G, x, h k w 3,
35, wk h
, h 173
, whh Th
h
-x , v h hh v,
wh hh G
h U K ,
w S
S hv x z- w-k -k
Th G S E A hv
hh h
(IOM 8), ,
h hv h
wk
w, h h v
I , h wk
E hv
h
, v h x wh
w Nvh,
h ,
wh h x, S
h U Kh w
- w-k -
k
A h
h h :
, , A
v, z
h , hv v wh
h h
hh-k wk I, Nw
(8) , h v
wh wh h , wh
w
,
h
Th, v ,
h h h w
v Th v h hh-k
w, h h h hw v v
Experiences with Circular Migration
Schemes5
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
12/23
Transatlantic Academy10
Gaining public
support is
extremely
important for
any circular
migration policy.
Gv h q , w h hh v (
h) - x
wh , v h
h w
h, wh (1)
, () ,
(3) h
1. Public acceptance
Ahv
vwh
, x
v h v
h
I x,
h, hv v
Th,
h w
,
h
k
Ov,
z S h hv h E U, wh h
w wh h
, , h
x S E hv
(hh -kw) h
(, F, h U K,
G, h Nh), wh h w
hv
(I,
S, P) F h , h
w EU E E h
x h , wh
B v
h hv wh
, h w
h h v h w , h
h -W W II (B 3)
Policy Challenges6I W E, v v hv
-wk
h I h -
h z
h h v
, h
h h h
wk h
h h hv
(B I ), h
A v
h v v w (HWWI
)h
Cq, E, h w
hh-k I
, -
hv , h 1 I
G, x, h R-G
(SPD-G) v j
h S Ch 1
zh h S H, , h
j I ,
- h-w
hv h h
, , h 1 F (L P
F N), I (U B L N)
Dk (P Kj Dk Fk)
Ev h w , h
h h h
I, h,
hv
I, E , h
w h
wh w w
h v h
, whh k E h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
13/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
11
Paradox: Societie
remain hostile
to immigration
despite their
increasing
depency on
inflows.
w I E, hv
k wh h h
h z Wh
x (F I), E
, h Sh E
E , w wh
hk (A
A ) Th
( : hk
h v h v )hv
w E ,
j , x k ,
( h
, x wk ,
, -v
) Nvh, w,
v v h
h h
Th xh h
wh
w v h
h h v v h
A
w v v
v h h, ,
Wh hh-
q , h h k
w-k A , h
hh-k , w w
v h w-
k , h v
hh-k v h
h
T z h z
, w z
,
, O
h (, , , hh,
, NGO) h
G S D/G v
/1 I C M
R k h
Hwv, h x
h hw h h
w
P w ,
h h w
h k
k h hh v, h
- w w w
(A, K, O 3) Th,
h
k
h h
h v h
2. Policy implementation and compliance
A h
: Hw
, hw
Wh , h
vv h q
S
h ,
wh k v (
), wh h h (
j ), hw
h ( h, v,
) A , h
-
U, h
w h q A E
, x, I,
G B, Shv
h ,
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
14/23
Transatlantic Academy12
Compliance seems
to be higher if
programs foresee
subsequent
back-and-forth
movements.
v h I , h C M E A
(COMECON), h z
, h G wk
h h x wh
Nvh, h
h h ,
h v
A , h x wh h-
wk E
wh v h h wh h
q h
-- Th
h ; E ,
v, hv v
h h w
wh I
, h -
Mx h U S
w wh h US v
h 1 (Nw
8) Ov, , h k k h h
I w, h, v x
h
A h , w
hw vw
h H,
hv v
h x h
A
v w h
x wh h hv v B h v
h v
, -- , h
j w T
,
w h v
z h h h
w
q S h
q wh
whh h
hh h
vv h
Ah q
whh
hh Th , h
- w h q; , j
I v h v wh w
v
h w hv h
h h h ,
wh wh h w
k Th v
h v
Nh W A h M
h E U Ah
h wh k h
h
h z
Bh , , h
hh h v
Th h
w
Hwv, h h v
wk h h
h h h h h x,
v h h h v I
D , h v
w q
h q
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
15/23
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
16/23
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
17/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
15
Realistic,
transparent, and
clearly defined
policy goals are
indispensable.
Wh w h h x wh
B,
v
1. Generally, circular migration programs
should be realistic and transparent
L , ,
w Th
h M
v w h
, ,
h
h, ,
h I , h
v h h
z w h h
, whh w
w h k, xv
, q wk
v hh h
h v v,
v h, v
I , h
h w hv h w
Th w
w w h v h
x, wh k
h
h h w B h
h
T h , v z
hk , v hv
h v
w, h
h
v,
x h v h
Wh , k h
h w h ,
h Th,
v
hw wh
h Gv h v
z w hz
wh h
h h h
N h w
h I , , , h
w sine qua non hv
k hv
G, h
z Th EU x
v EU z v
2. A circular migration policy should contain
clear policy goals
Ov,
v k h
h v First,
k v,
k h v
wh x wh
v k Second, h h
w v h
(hh h
v h h ),
h , whh j v
I , x h h
wh h h
w
h, h v
Third,
Conclusions for Future Circular
Migration Policies7
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
18/23
Transatlantic Academy16
Circular migration
programs should
be tailored to
skill levels.
( ) w
v , h
h
h v h
v h v
v h vv
C, h v
B h
h wk h
k E h ( x,
,
) h
h h v
3. Circular migration programs must be
tailored to skill levels
Ov, h -z--
h w
C w
v v, h
h v Th,
h j h
k v,
Asfarasunskilled and low-skilled migrants
,
k w
Th,
h h
k h hv h
, h h h
Th h
xv -v A h
z
h
h h
wk Eh v
h h,
, h-, wh
w
h
Fh,
, , h wh
h, h
h v
hw ( v
) Th, k
w-k h j
, ,
Incontrast,receivingcountriesshouldabstain
v- h highly-
skilled migrants Gv h w
h ,
h h
- Th h
-v, h
h j
Gv wh
h hh k
, , x
S h
v h
k, h h
h k, v
h h h
Rv h
, , h
A , v
h h h
, wh vh h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
19/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
17
Circular migratio
programs are
not a cheap
way out of labor
shortages; they
require substant
governance.
Sh v ( )
v z
O
h wh, h hh-
k ,
h
Afarmorechallengingissueisthatofcircular
skilled migrants Ahh
z
h
w, w w
Th v
x k
v h
h wk O h h,
hv v
h hv
h wh w
O h h h,
v, k h
k v h
h k, h v wh v
h
v
Nvh, h x h
k w h hv
hv h v h ,
h h
v, h hv q
h Th,
k h
z v h j whh h vq h
v , h
h, xv
k h,
v wh
L , k h h w hh
h ,
k
h v h
()
h I , h
z
h h h (E)
wk h v,
h h
,
O , h w h h h
h , v
A x v-v
xv
, h v h v
x h q
h G, v h
z
h
I , v
h h
4. Finally, circular migration schemes require
substantial governance efforts
Th h w
h E k ,
h w h
j B h
h k ,
, whh
vw Th h
h v h h v
wh h hh k
w-k k
I h v ( k
, x, ) h h
w h v k h
h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
20/23
Transatlantic Academy18
I , , h
, v, ,
k
I h , hh k
h h w
hv , v
, :
v k
h h
w-k k ;
k v z h
v h - v h
w
z ;
wh
h
8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
21/23
Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession:
Is Circular Migration a Solution?
19
A, Dv Rv, Kh Nw(7) C M Dv:
T, P R, W Fw,
M P I P B, A
7
A, S (8) C M A
S C M P SWP
C 7/C 11, J
A, S, Ik K, H O
(3) Th F I R
G German Politics, N 3, 1-145
A, S Rk Pk (8)
S L M h EU
Pv, SWP C 8/C 1, M
A, Wk S A ()
Demographie und MigrationEinfluss auf
die Sicherheit, in: Bundesakademie fuer
Sicherheitspolitik (), Shhk
D (h)
Ch, Jh G L ()
Managing Highly-Skilled Labour Migration: AComparative Analysis of Migration Policies and
Challenges in OECD Countries OECD P,
Mh 18,
Dk, J R Kwk, Dh
Thh () The Battle for the
Brains: Do Point Systems Make the Difference?
Wh, DC: Th G Mh F
h U S, Mh
Ek, W (167) C M h
Gwh Tw E A International
Labour Review, 6 (6), 581-5
E C (7) I P
C M B, J 6, 7
GCIM (5) M IW: Nw D A G
C I M
G, Ezh M (8) D I
M h F-B P
h US C B P
M P I, Wh, DC,
O 16, 8
Hh Lv G (4) F h Ch:
Th L S Gwh
E R h Hh Lv
G h W Kk, B
I L Oz, ILO
() The Financial and Economic Crisis: A
Decent Work Response. I L
Oz, Gv
I L Oz, ILO ()
Migration and the Financial Crisis: How Will
the Economic Downturn Affect Migrants.
Gv: I L Oz,
Dv Rh C M,
G Pv, B N 17,F
I Oz M, IOM
(5) International Migration Management
through Inter-State Consultation Mechanisms.
Gv: I Oz
M, 5
I Oz M, IOM
(8) World Migration 2008: Managing
Migration in the Evolving Global Economy.
Gv: I Oz
M, 8
IMF () World Economic Outlook Database.
Wh, DC: I M F
Rv : h://www/x//
x=
References8
http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=29http://www/imf.org/external/ns/cs.aspx?id=298/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
22/23
Transatlantic Academy20
L, G () Recent Developments,the Crisis and Beyond. Wh, DC:
I L M, P
OECD, Mh 1, 8
M, Ph () The Recession and Migration:
Alternative Scenarios Ox: I
M I, WP 13-
Nw, Kh, Dv Rv A,
A Tz (8) L D:
Ex C MMPI-Insight,
S 8
O E C-
Dv, OECD (8) International
Migration Outlook 2008. P: O
E C- Dv, 8
O E C-
Dv, OECD () Economic
Outlook Interim Report. P: O
E C- Dv,
Mh
O N S, ONS () UKR P C Bh O
N S: Population Trends, N
135, S
P, D G A Tz
() Immigrants and the Current Economic
Crisis: Research Evidence, Policy Challenges, and
Implications. Wh, DC: M P
I, J
Sv, W M S ()Immigration and the Labour Market: Theory,
Evidence and Policy. L: M P
I Eq H Rh
C, Mh
Sh C () M h
G F C: A V S
U 1, F Rv : h://
www--///
/1
Sw, J () M h F
C: Hw w h E Dw
A M Sx C M
Rh B, N 17, F
UK B A ()Accession Monitoring
Report, May 2004December 2008, L
Vv, Sv (7) C M: h
w w Uv
Ox IMI Wk P, N 4
UN DESA (8) World Population Policies 2007.
Nw Yk: UN D E S A, 8
W Bk (6) Global Economic Prospects
2006: Economic Implications of Remittances and
Migration. Wh, DC: W Bk, 6
W Bk () Global Economic Prospects
2009 F U, DEC P G,
Mh 3,
http://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdfhttp://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdfhttp://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdfhttp://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdfhttp://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdfhttp://www.age-of-migration.com/ns/financialcrisis/updates/1a.pdf8/8/2019 Labor Migration Management in Times of Recession: Is Circular Migration a Solution?
23/23
1744 R STReeT, NW
WAShiNgToN, DC 20009
T: 1 202 745 3886
F: 1 202 265 1662
WWW.TRANSATlANTiCACADemy.oRg