Views expressed are those of the presenter and are not necessarily those of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco or the Board of Governors.
INDUSTRY CONDITIONS & CONCERNS:
What Keeps Regulators Up at Night?
Regional Bankers’ Forum San Francisco, California
November 7, 2013
Wallace Young Director, Risk Coordination Unit
Risk Monitoring and Analysis Group Banking Supervision and Regulation
Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
12TH DISTRICT BANKING
CONDITIONS
2 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Bank Profitability Continues to Recover
3 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
ROAA has Improved in Most States
* NV: excludes credit card and zero-loan banks
4 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
NIM Pressure Continues
5 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Loan Loss Provisions are at 20+ Year Low
6 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Overhead Expense Trends are Mixed
7 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Average Core Profitability Edges Higher
8 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
9
Non-Performing Assets Continue to Decline
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Average Noncurrent Loan Rates are Declining
Noncurrent loans include all loans on non-accrual status, plus loans that are 90-days or more past due and still accruing interest.
10 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Net Charge-Offs Approach Pre-Recession Levels
11 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Loan Growth Slowly Returns
12 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
District Loan Growth Varies by Bank Size
13 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
C&LD Concentrations Decline to 20+ Year Low Relative to Capital
60% 40%
143%
26% 10%
60%
26%
0.0
25.0
50.0
75.0
100.0
125.0
1992
1993
1994
1995
1996
1997
1998
1999
2000
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
Mar
-13
12th District Banks Nation
14
Note: Data as of 1Q13
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Liquidity Build-Up Appears Over
15 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
16
Liquidity Build-Up Appears Over
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Total Risk-Based Capital Ratios Inch Lower
17 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Tier 1 Common Equity Ratios have Peaked
18 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
12th District CAMELS Upgrades Continue to Outpace Downgrades
19 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Average CAMELS Component Ratings for 12th District Banks (1: strong; 2: satisfactory; 3-5: less than satisfactory)
CAMELS Rating Components Improve
20 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Economic Political
Competitive Regulatory
Headwinds
21 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
SUPERVISORY HOT TOPICS
22 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Earnings Challenges • Core earnings under pressure • Low interest rate environment narrowing margins and increased extension risk • Intense competition for quality borrowers • Limited opportunities to grow fee income, especially for smaller banks • Overhead expense headwinds
2005
2005
2008
2008
2010
2010
2012
2012
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
<5Y >5Y
Assets < $10 Billion
2005
2005
2008
2008
2010
2010
2012
2012
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
<5Y >5Y
Assets > $10 Billion
Total Securities & Loans by Maturity (% composition)
23 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
24
Small and mid-sized banks (in particular) are taking on
more interest rate risk.
As longer-term interest rates increase, market value of
investment portfolios decline.
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Liquidity & Sensitivity Challenges • Recent deposit inflows may exhibit more volatility than expected when rates rise • Recent changes in deposit mix, such as increases in nonmaturing deposits (NMD), may not be
sustainable • Historical models may not capture depositor behavior following prolonged period of low rates • Will banks that have extended duration on the asset side be able to reprice quickly on the
liability side?
25 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Expansion into New or Unfamiliar Lending Areas • Banks are seeing rapid loan growth in some lending areas
o C&I: large banks; 1-4 family residential: mid-sized/small banks; multifamily: mid-sized banks • Concerns:
o Expertise in new lending areas may be lacking o Competition/pricing pressures are leading to some easing of underwriting criteria/terms o Historical loss rates on C&I are higher than most other loan types o Management must maintain robust risk management processes around all products
26 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
* Based on a panel of 341 District commercial banks without significant mergers, loan sales or loan purchases over the period. Each bar above is based on banks with at least 4% of loans in the particular loan type; prelim. 6/30/13 data
Cyber-Security • Banks are having to spend more money and devote more attention to making sure corporate and
customer information is secure. • A big issue for larger banks, but even smaller banks need to be concerned….particularly
serviced institutions.
Vendor Management • This is more than an IT (Information Technology) issue. • Banks are increasingly more reliant on 3rd party vendors and service providers. • Require comprehensive, risk based due diligence, monitoring, and reporting processes. • New regulatory guidance will be issued very soon.
Bank Secrecy Act/Anti Money Laundering • Increasing regulatory attention on BSA/AML compliance. • Banks that are engaged in foreign wire transfer activities are most vulnerable. • Several recent high-profile cases resulted in significant fines and penalties.
27 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
http://www.philadelphiafed.org/bank-resources/publications/consumer-compliance-outlook/ http://www.communitybankingconnections.org/
http://www.frbsf.org/banking-supervision/publications/first-glance-12l/
28 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
DODD-FRANK ACT UPDATE
29 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Comments/Opinions on Specific Dodd-Frank Matters
To help ensure that the rule-writing process is conducted in a fair, open, and transparent manner….
Federal Reserve Board policy requires documentation of
substantive comments or recommendations on matters related to Federal Reserve rulemaking.
Comments are summarized on the Board’s public web site.
Formal written comments are invited via the Board’s web site. http://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/reform_proposals.htm
30 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Major Dodd-Frank Act Provisions To address… DFA created / requires
31
• Enhanced regulatory standards for large banks
• FDIC orderly liquidation authority (OLA)
Too Big To Fail
• Volcker rule (proprietary trading, hedge funds)
• Incentive compensation rules • Risk retention for mortgages sold
Excess Risk Taking
• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)
• Simplified products and disclosures
Abusive Lending
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
Recently Completed DFA Initiatives
32
September 2013 • Stress Testing Requirements BASEL III Application and Transition Period (Interim Final Rules)
August 2013 • Supervisory Assessment Fees (Final Rule) July 2013 • Integrated Regulatory Capital Framework (Final
Rule) June 2013 • Swaps Push Out Provision Applicability to Uninsured
U.S. Branches and Agencies of FBOs (Interim Final Rule)
April 2013 • Retail Foreign Exchange Futures and Options (Final Rule)
• “Financial Company” Definition for SIFI Designation (Final Rule)
February 2013 • Federal Reserve Accounts and Services for Financial Market Utilities (Proposed Rule)
January 2013 • Appraisals for Higher-Priced Mortgages (Final Rule)
November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
For additional information and resources related to new capital rules, see:
http://www.federalreserve.gov/bankinforeg/basel/
USImplementation.htm
33 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
New Capital Rule
• What is the effective date? – For most institutions subject to the advanced
approaches rule: 1/1/14 – For all other banking organizations (including
community banks): 1/1/15 – Some elements phase-in over time. All aspects of
New Capital Rule to be fully effective 1/1/19.
34 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
• Who does it apply to? – All Banks – Top-tier BHCs (not subject to the Board’s small
BHC Policy Statement) – Savings Associations – Top-tier SLHCs that are not substantially engaged
in insurance or commercial activities.
35 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
New Capital Rule
• Key Changes from the June 2012 Proposal – Residential Mortgage Exposures – Accumulated Other Comprehensive Income
(AOCI) – Non-Qualifying Capital Instruments and Tier 1
Capital – SLHCs
36 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
New Capital Rule
• Significant Changes from Current Capital Rule – Revisions to the Minimum Capital Requirements – Adjustments to Prompt Corrective Action Thresholds – Additional Improvements to the Quality of Regulatory
Capital – Capital Conservation Buffer – Credit Ratings – MSAs and DTAs – Revised Risk Weights
37 November 7, 2013 Regional Bankers' Forum
New Capital Rule
Questions?
November 7, 2013 38 Regional Bankers' Forum
Thank you!
Wallace Young Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco
101 Market Street San Francisco, CA 94521 [email protected]
(415) 974-3166