High Rate 60 GHz PHY, MAC and HDMI PAL StandardInvitation to ETSI BRAN, WiMedia and JTC 1/SC 06
open review
For Ecma’s comments and dispositions to DISs in ISO/IEC JTC 1’s fast track procedure
Ruud van BokhorstChairman TC48
Ecma/TC48/2008/131
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 2
60 GHz standardreview procedure overview
60 GHzcontributions
Final Draft 60 GHz
October 2008
ISO/IEC 22xx
Ecma’s Technical Comments +
Proposed Dispositions
ETSI BRAN review
Open-60GHz@Ecma-
International.org
ECMA-xxx 1st edition Dec. 08
ISO/IEC JTC 1Fast track procedure
TC48Drafting
TC48 review
TC48 finalisation
Ecma General Ass.vote 4 Dec08
JTC 1/SC 06 review
Wimedia review
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 3
60 GHz standard review procedure
Invitation to help: • Review 60 GHz standard; Solicit technical comments; • Draft, review and compile dispositions until xxJune 2009 (1-month before JTC 1’s end-of-ballot).Thereafter:
Ecma will issue technical comments and dispositions to the ISO/IEC JTC1 fast track to be addressed in the Ballot Resolution Meeting.
How to comment:
Send (ISO/IEC formatted) comments to mailto:[email protected].
Who:
Experts from WiMedia, ETSI BRAN and ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 06 who register at http://www.Ecma-International.org/memento/TC48-M.htm; The International Editor coordinates.
Planning of activities for TC48
0. Invite SC 06 (WG1) in Montreux for advance comments
a. Submission GA approved 60GHz standard
• by Ecma secretariat on 7 December
b. Propose International editor and Subcommittee
• At submission to SC 06
c. Action after 30-day review period
• Ecma might receive “perceived” contradictions, if so, TC48 helps with the Ecma dispositions thereto
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 4
Planning of activities for TC48
d. Create Ecma’s technical comments and proposed dispositions
• for input to ISO/IEC JTC 1
• and resulting from the Open-60GHz review
• Planned for May/June 2009
e. Comment resolution (part of 5-month letter ballot)
• We will receive comments in June 2009 and needs to make proposed dispositions for negotiation/confirmation in the Ballot Resolution Meeting in September 2009
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 5
Backup slides
JTC 1 Fast-Track Procedure
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 6
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 7
JTC 1 Fast-Track Procedure Submitter
Submitter:
• is a JTC 1 P-member or JTC 1 Class A-liaison holder
• is the only party that decides to submit to JTC 1’s Fast-Track; not a JTC 1 decision.
• may submit a published standard, amendment or Technical Report
• may solicit advance informal comments from SC’s
• either directly or via the JTC 1 Secretariat
• recommends assignment of the publication to an SC
• identifies an International editor
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 8
JTC 1 Fast-Track ProcedureITTF
ITTF:
• Settles copyright and trademark situation;
• Registers the Fast-Track proposal;
• Includes DIS number allocation
• Helps assignment to an SC or JTC 1 itself;
• JTC 1 Secretariat assigns
• Starts the 30-day review period;
• May result in perceived contradictions that ITTF settles
• Starts the 5-month letter ballot;
• Publishes Final DIS text as ISO/IEC publication.
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 9
JTC 1 Fast-Track ProcedureSC
Upon assignment to an SC:
• The SC administers the new project in its work programme and maintenance list;
SC Secretariat:
• Distributes ballot results to the SC’s NBs and all voters
• Within two months after ballot closure
• Calls the ballot resolution meeting, appoints the Convener
• Required in case of “disapprove” votes and/or contentious technical comments, but not earlier than 2,5 months after ballot closure
• Appoints the international Editor
• Who drafts the (proposed and) final DIS text and (proposed and) final Disposition of Comments report within 1 month after ballot resolution meeting
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 10
JTC 1 Fast-Track Procedure Voting and Voters
Two-staged:
• 30-day review period, to determine perceived contradictions;
• 5-month letter ballot (DIS or DAM), which is a combined voting process.
Voters, one per country:
• all NBs of ISO may vote;
• all NCs of IEC may vote;
• all P-members JTC 1’s shall vote.
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 11
JTC 1 Fast-Track Procedure Ballot criteria
Ballot pass criteria:
• ½ of JTC 1’s P-members voted (approved, disapproved or abstained) and
• 2/3 of JTC 1’s P-members “approved” and
• ¼ “disapproves” from all NB’s and NC’s that voted.
Disapproval:
• On technical grounds only;
• Must include justification;
• Should include proposed fix for identified technical problem;
• Requires attendance of ballot resolution meeting.
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 12
JTC 1 Fast-Track ProcedureBallot resolution meeting
Ballot resolution meeting:
• SC shall call a ballot resolution meeting in case of negative votes or contentious technical comments;
• NO-voters must attend;
• To turn NO-votes into YES-votes.
• By approving disposition of comments; Preferably by consensus, otherwise by majority vote.
• NB or NC shall confirm their vote change to “approve” to ITTF in writing.
Within one month following the meeting, the International Editor drafts:
• the final DIS text; and Disposition of Comments report from proposal versions (as modified and approved in the meeting).
Rue du Rhône 114 - CH-1204 Geneva - T: +41 22 849 6000 - F: +41 22 849 6001 - www.ecma-international.org 13
Rue du Rhône 114CH-1204 GenevaT: +41 22 849 6000 F: +41 22 849 6001
www.Ecma-international.org