GMO AMENDMENT BILL 2005 GMO AMENDMENT BILL 2005
2
PRESENTERSPRESENTERS
Julian Jaftha DoA
Ben Durham DST
Leseho Sello DEAT
Modiegi Selematsela DoH
Ndivhou Rabuli DoA
Mbudzeni Sibara Advisory Committee Chairperson
3
ORDER OF PRESENTATIONSORDER OF PRESENTATIONS
Some general concerns • Precautionary Approach• Protection of indigenous seeds• Biotechnology in South Africa• Scientific safety assessments
GMO Amendment Bill• Environmental Impact Assessments• Labeling Regulations• Liability and Redress• Sections of the Amendment Bill
4
PRECAUTIONARY APPROACH?PRECAUTIONARY APPROACH?
Principle 15 of Rio Declaration in 1992–
In order to protect the environment, the precautionary approach shall be widely applied by States according to their capabilities. Where there are threats of serious or irreversible damage, lack of full scientific certainty shall not be used as a reason for postponing cost effective measures to prevent environmental degradation
Lack of consensus on the status as a principle of law GMO Act: Implemented through risk assessment and
risk management Protocol: – Annex III
5
PRECAUTIONARY APPROACH contPRECAUTIONARY APPROACH cont
Where decision is necessary, measures based on the precautionary approach should be:
• Proportional to risk• Non-discrimination • Consistent• Based on cost-benefit assessment• Subject to review• Capable of assigning responsibility for producing scientific
evidence
6
Protection of the indigenous seedsProtection of the indigenous seeds
Farm saved seeds
Seed vigour
Not limited to GMO’s
Plant Breeders’ Rights Act
International Treaty on Plant Genetic Resources for Food and Agriculture
Policy on indigenous crops
Conservation
Collection, characterisation and storage of indigenous seeds
National Gene Bank
Seed diversity fairs
7
BIOTECHNOLOGY IN SOUTH AFRICABIOTECHNOLOGY IN SOUTH AFRICA
DEPARTMENT OF SCIENCE AND
TECHNOLOGY
8
SCIENTIFIC SAFETY ASSESSMENTSSCIENTIFIC SAFETY ASSESSMENTS
CHAIRPERSON
ADVISORY COMMITTEE
9
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENTENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT
DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTAL AFFAIRS AND TOURISM
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
LABELING REGULATIONSLABELING REGULATIONS
DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH
23
Foodstuffs, Cosmetics, Disinfectants ActFoodstuffs, Cosmetics, Disinfectants Act
Any person shall be guilty of an offence if he sells, manufactures, or imports for sale any foodstuffs, which is harmful or injurious to human health
Empowers the Minister to make regulations prescribing the manner in which foodstuffs shall be labelled.
24
GM Food Labelling RegulationsGM Food Labelling Regulations
Regulations relating to the labelling of foodstuffs obtained through certain techniques of gene modification were published in 2004
Based on Codex Alimentarius principles for labelling, definitions and concepts
25
Codex Alimentarius CommissionCodex Alimentarius Commission
“Food rules”was established in 1962, protect consumer health and facilitate trading practices
Codex Committee on Food Labelling developing guidelines on GM food labelling since 1995
26
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
Mandatory Requirements• A GM food differs significantly in composition, nutritional
value, storage, preparation
• The presence of allergen from crustaceans, eggs, fish, groundnuts, molluscs, soy beans, tree nuts and Triticum species
27
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
Voluntary claim
• Genetically improved or enhanced characteristics– Validated and Certified by a body accredited to SANAS– Name of certifying body has to appear next to the claim
– Regulations governing the labelling and advertising of foodstuffs published under GN No. R2034 of October 1993
28
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
Labelling of GM foods is not mandatory• Require product differentiation between GM and GM raw
materials prior to use in processing• Need for a certification system for monitoring and
verification• Threshold level of tolerance for commingling
29
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
Australian study • 8-18% cost increase• Canada• 35-41% of the producer prices• The Philipines?
30
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
No provision for non-GM claims Identity Preservation System
• Identity of a non-GM and products is preserved by segregating the handling and processing thereof from those of a GMO and its products
• SABS, Health, and Agriculture developing guidelines to provide for grains, fruit and vegetables, meat and fish and products thereof
31
GM Food LabellingGM Food Labelling
Current regulations can be regarded as interim measure pending the following
• Finalization of an Identity Preservation System• Progress at the Codex Committee on food labelling
32
LIABILITY AND REDRESSLIABILITY AND REDRESS
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
33
LIABILITY AND REDRESSLIABILITY AND REDRESS
Existing liability regime• Common law• Gaps
Channeling of liability Type of liability
• Strict • Fault-based
34
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE
35
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Insert cartoon
36
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 1 – Definitions
Transboundary movement• cross border vs across boundaries
Contained use• Movement & storage
User • Consumer & end-user
Activity• Use
Commodity clearance• Relation to definition of release
37
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 5 – Powers and duties of the Council
Discretionary power• Different activities• Environmental release
– Public input, EIA, socio-economic impact– Regulations
Science based risk assessment• Convention on Biodiversity• Cartagena Protocol • Separate assessment for socio-economic impact
38
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 5 – Powers and duties of the Council
Public input• Conflict in time periods – GMO Act & PAIA• Access to information - What information is confidential?
– Provisions of the Protocol– PAIA as basis– Section 18
• Transparency– Feedback on decisions made– National Biosafety Clearing House
39
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 7 – Meetings of the Council
Consensus decision• Members present vs all members• Different sectors / policies / legislation• Effective decision-making
– Prior consideration– Meeting
40
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 9 – Functions of the Registrar
Too much power? Most functions subject to Council instruction Without instruction
• Maintain register – facilities & trial releases
• Routine inspections
• Suspects possible contraventions
– Cessation / dispose / repatriate
• Submit application & documents to Council
• Communicate Council decisions to Biosafety Clearing House
• Extension permits
– Subject to terms & conditions of Council
– Already previously approved
– Reporting to Council
41
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 10 – Composition of the Advisory Committee
Why specific requirement for ecologist?• Reason – Protocol
– Protection of the environment– Including human (and animal) health
• 1st level assessment - assess environmental, human and animal health concerns
Other experts less important?• Co-opting knowledgeable persons• Appointment of sub-committees
42
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 15 – Appointment of inspectors
Self regulation?• No independent review of assessments
– Advisory Committee function• No monitoring of compliance with permit conditions
– Routine inspections – section 16
43
GMO AMENDMENT BILLGMO AMENDMENT BILL
Section 19 – Appeal
Time periods?• Convening of Board• Taking decision• Communicating further action by Minister
The type of information to be considered in an appeal• Limited to “scientifically proven information”