11/23/2020
1
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Advances and Challenges over the Past 50 years
Jerry A. DiMaggio, PE, D.GE
Senior Principal Engineer-Associate
Applied Research Associates, Inc.
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA ProprietaryDate: November 12, 2020
1
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Advances and Challenges over the past 50 years
Key Messages
- Why this topic?
- 1970 to 2020 Recommended Processes and Procedures
- 2020 Challenges (Save the BEST for LAST!)
2
11/23/2020
2
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Advances and Challenges over the Past 50 Years
Why this topic?
- It is important to know where we have been, where we are presently and where we are headed.
- A LOT has changed in 50 years mostly good BUT some not.
- Geotechnical science and engineering is critical and provides a significant contribution to Infrastructure, Mankind and the Earth.
- Poor processes and practices significantly affect the quality of life, economic well being and safety.
3
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Features
A. Shallow Foundations (spread footings and mats)B. Deep Foundations (drilled shafts, driven piles,
auger-cast and micropiles)C. Earth Retaining Structures (permanent and temporary)
D. Engineered soil fills and cutsE. Engineered rock cuts and fillsF. PavementsG. Drainage elements
Guidance provided in this presentation is based on my highway and rail experience but is applicable to all infrastructure facilities (buildings, energy, transportation, etc.)
4
11/23/2020
3
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Example of CHANGES Deep Foundation Practice 1970 - 2020
● Load demand, performance requirements/ constraints have increased significantly. Foundation designs have become more complex and become more “optimized”.
● Pile material strengths and sizes (L and D) have increased significantly.
● Frequency, types and importance of load and integrity tests have increased significantly.
● Load Resistance Factor Design platform “requires” a close relationship between the design and construction disciplines (reliability based design).
● Construction equipment, specifications and plan details have become very complex. Project financing and delivery methods have changed.
CONSTRUCTION IS MORE IMPORTANT AND CRITICAL MUST TO SUCCESS
5
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Overall Objective
Failure Overly Conservative Design
6
11/23/2020
4
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
7
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Rock Characteristics
• Strength• Regional geomaterials,
qu = 50-1500 psi
N160 (or N60)> 50
• Hard rock, qu > 1500 psi
• Rock mass properties
8
11/23/2020
5
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
AASHTO LRFD Bridge Design Specs. Section 10.4 Soil and Rock Properties
4.1 Informational Needs
4.2 Subsurface Exploration
4.3 Laboratory Tests
4.4 Insitu Tests
4.5 Geophysical Tests
4.6 Selection of Design and Construction Parameters
9
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Standard Penetration Test
6 blows for 6”6 blows for 6”6 blows for 6”6 blows for 6”6 blows for 6”6 blows for 6”
SPT Resistance(N-value) =6 + 6 = 12
140 lb Hammer dropping 30”
10
Typical Values’f = 25o - 45o
11/23/2020
6
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
11
Correlation: SPT N160 to Drained Friction Angle
AASHTO Table 10.4.6.2.4-1
N160
Drained FrictionAngle
< 4 25 – 30
4 27 – 32
10 30 – 35
30 35 – 40
50 38 – 43
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Other In-situ Exploration Tests
SPT CPT DMT PMT VST
12
11/23/2020
7
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Selection of Soil Shear Strength
• Rate of construction loading to soil conductivity
• Effect of Applied Load Direction on measured shear strength
• Effects of expected levels of deformation on the structure
• Influence of Construction Sequence
13
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
EVALUATION OF SOIL SHEAR STRENGTH
14
• SPT• CPT • Pressuremeter• Dilatometer • Field Vane Shear
11/23/2020
8
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Measured or interpreted parameter value Coefficient of Variation, V
(%)
Unit weight, 3 to 7 %
Buoyant unit weight, b 0 to 10 %
Effective stress friction angle, 2 to 13 %
Undrained shear strength, su 13 to 40 %
Undrained strength ratio (su/po) 5 to 15 %
Compression index, Cc 10 to 37 %
Preconsolidation pressure, pc 10 to 35 %
Hydraulic conductivity of saturated clay, k 68 to 90 %
Hydraulic conductivity of partially-saturated clay, k 130 to 240 %
Coefficient of consolidation, cv 33 to 68 %
Standard penetration blow count, N 15 to 45 %
Electric cone penetration test, qc 5 to 15 %
Mechanical cone penetration test, qc 15 to 37 %
Vane shear test undrained strength, suVST 10 to 20 %
15Duncan (2000), FHWA (2006)
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Link between Site Characterization and Risk
Improved Site Characterization reduces risks in design, construction, and performance by:
o Reducing likelihood of encountering a differing site condition (dispute) during design and construction
o Increasing reliability of estimated geomaterial properties
o Decreasing uncertainty of subsurface conditions during construction
o Increasing the confidence in understanding the role and variability of groundwater
16
11/23/2020
9
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Pile Types
17
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
iiQi ≤ Rr = Rn
i =
i =
Qi =
Rr =
=
Rn =
Load modifier (eta)Load factor (gamma)Force effectFactored resistanceResistance factor (phi)Nominal resistance
18
11/23/2020
10
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Available Nominal Resistance Verification Methods
19
Static Load TestDynamic Measurements Wave Equation Analysis
Static Analysis
Where:
= nominal driving resistance (kips).
= developed hammer energy (ft-lbs) in the form
of ram weight, W, (lbs) times stroke height, h
(ft).
= pile penetration resistance (blows/inch).
1.75 log 10 100
Dynamic Formula
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Pile Testing Methods
Analysis MethodResistance Factor
()(AASHTO 2014)
Est. Measure
Capacity
Stress
Energy
Capacity
Stress
Energy
Dynamic formula 0.10 (EOD) or 0.40 (EOD) X
Wave equation 0.50 (w field confirmation of hammer) X X X
Dynamic testing* 0.65 (2%) or 0.75 (100%) (0.5 uplift) X X X
Static load test** 0.75 to 0.80(wo/w dynamic) (0.6 UPLIFT)
X
20
* Dynamic Test requires signal matching**Static Test requires one test pile per site
11/23/2020
11
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Advances in Computer Analysis and Application Tools
21
FLAC: FS=0.98
FD
LE
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Service Limit State Checks
Global Stability Vertical, Horizontal Rotational
Deformations
22
11/23/2020
12
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
23
Extreme Event Loading: Seismic, Ice, Vehicle, Vessel, Scour, Blast
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Assets and Asset Management (performance in post construction and long-term)
24
11/23/2020
13
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Drilled Shafts
25
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Large Diameter Open Ended Pipe
26
11/23/2020
14
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
We have the learned the meaningof the word “drivability”
27
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Bi-directional O-cell Test
-1
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000
Load, kips
Move
men
t, inch
es
28
11/23/2020
15
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Statnamic Load Tests
29
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
1-28.jpg
Geosynthetics
30
11/23/2020
16
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Functions of Ground Improvement
• Increase bearing capacity
• Increase density
• Control deformations
• Accelerate consolidation
• Decrease imposed loads
• Provide lateral stability
• Increase resistance to liquefaction
• Transfer embankment loads to more competent soil layers
31
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
GEOTECH TOOLSwww.GeoTechTools.org
• Main product: Web based information and guidance system• Within the system, for each of @ 60 technologies:
– Technology Fact Sheets– Photographs– Design Procedures– Quality Control/Quality Assurance Procedures– Cost Estimating– Specifications– Bibliography– Case Histories
32
11/23/2020
17
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
What aboutEarth Retaining Structures?
A structure used to hold back earth and maintain a difference in the elevation of the ground surface. Often called:
– Retaining Wall or
– Earth Retaining System
33
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Groundwater Measurements
• Groundwater level and pore water pressure measurements are extremely important for geotechnical analysis
• Sources of Informationo Existing wells
o Open borings
o Observation wells
o Piezometers
34
11/23/2020
18
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
Geotechnical Reports
• Field Investigation Logs
• Geotechnical Data Reports
• Geotechnical Design Reports
• Geotechnical Baseline Reports
35
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
CURRENT Challenges: Better to Consider as GREAT OPPORTUNITES
• Poor understanding of tolerable deformations
• Mainstream application of soil/ structure interaction
• Marginal quality of construction and quality assurance
• Quality/use of lab and field subsurface information
• Definition of recommended soil/ rock parameters
• Demonstrating value added service to clients
• Communications oral and written
• OTHERS? Certainly there are many.
36
11/23/2020
19
www.ara.com© 2019 Applied Research Associates, Inc. ARA Proprietary
INNOVATIVE SOLUTIONS TO COMPLEX PROBLEMS
• Contracting methods used by state agencies are:
37
Q & A
Jerry A. [email protected]