Digital Healthcare In A Subscription-Based Economy
Ravi Ganesan
CEO
Core Solutions, Inc.
Outline
• Lessons from History
• Healthcare Today
• The Subscription Economy
• Digital Transformation Strategy
• Q&A
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
History Of The Industrial WorldLooking back before we look forward
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
History of Industrial Revolutions
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Empowering Corporations
Empowering Individuals
1.0 – Mechanical (1784) 2.0 – Electrical (1870) 3.0 – Internet (1969) 4.0 - Data
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“Scalability and growth are critical for survival and success”
“Change is happening faster than any other time in history”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“Great nations (and great companies) rise and fall because of human decisions, not anonymous social or economic forces.”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“We do not learn from history and the consequences of this failure are tragic.”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Healthcare Today
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
• Consumer Choice
• Consumer Engagement
• Consumer Experience
Birth Of The Healthcare Consumer
Value Based Purchasing
Is Real
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
• What this means?• Provider payments tied to
outcomes instead of encounters• Being proactive with services• Keeping consumers healthy at-
home and out of emergency rooms
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“Health inequalities and the social determinants of health are not a footnote to the determinants of health. They are the main issue.”
Michael Marmot
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Five Things We Know About (Social) Determinants of Health in Health Care
• As a determinant of health, medical care is insufficient for ensuring better health outcomes.
• SDoH Are Influenced by Policies and Programs, and Associated with Better Health Outcomes.
• New Payment Models Are Prompting Interest in the SDoH.
• Frameworks for Integrating SDoH Are Emerging.
• Experiments Are Occurring at the Local and Federal Level.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.https://nam.edu/social-determinants-of-health-101-for-health-care-five-plus-five/
Behavioral Healthcare Today
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2016/05/19/guess-what-medical-condition-is-the-costliest-its-not-heart-disease-cancer-or-diabetes/?utm_term=.5978aaca6b3c
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://store.samhsa.gov/shin/content/SMA14-4883/SMA14-4883.pdf
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://store.samhsa.gov/shin/content/SMA14-4883/SMA14-4883.pdf
Exercise # 1What % of your business is from private insurance and self pay?
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
http://www.aha.org/research/rc/stat-studies/fast-facts.shtml#community
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://psychcentral.com/lib/mental-health-professionals-us-statistics/
https://www.kff.org/other/state-indicator/total-active-physicians/
“Behavioral healthcare lags other specialty providers on several key business metrics”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“Behavioral health remains a highly fragmented market with no one company that can exert enough influence to move the industry in a particular direction.”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
“Increased demand for services combined with complex market conditions require organizations to scale up rapidly with experts suggesting revenue targets of $250M+ as ideal for behavioral health organizations”
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Consolidation Trends
Fragmentation Shakeout Maturity Decline
Time
Sale
s V
olu
me
Providers: 6,000+Revenue: $370B
Providers: 15,000Revenue: $260B
X
7-10 years
The Subscription Economy
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
The Subscription Economy
At the heart of the Subscription Economy® is the idea that customers are happier subscribing to the outcomes they want, when they want them, rather than purchasing a product with the burden of ownership.
Tien Tzuo, Zuora
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Subscription Economy By The Numbers
• The subscription e-commerce market has grown by more than 100% percent a year over the past five years, with the largest retailers generating more than $2.6B in sales in 2016, up from $57.0M in 2011.
• E-commerce subscribers are most likely to be 25 to 44 years old, to have incomes from $50,000 to $100,000, and live in urban environments in the Northeastern U.S.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://www.forbes.com/sites/louiscolumbus/2018/03/04/the-state-of-the-subscription-economy-2018/#4a226d3153ef
General Categories
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Why Drive The Same Porsche Every Day?
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
The New Automobile Experience
• Cadillac BOOK - $1800/month you get to switch vehicles whenever you like.
• Volvo Care - You stay in one car, but everything is included, even insurance. XC40 -$600 per month.
• Flexdrive - vehicle subscription service that offers the car you want, when you want it. Just select a car and drive it for a week, month or as long as you need.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
The Subscription Experience
• Ongoing Value
• OnDemand Fulfillment
• Anywhere, Anytime
• Personalized
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Benefits
• For Companies:• Recurring, predictable cash flow
• Higher lifetime value of customers
• More valuable, long-term relationship
• Capital intensive
• For Customers:• Simplicity
• Convenience
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Key Metrics and Terminology
• MRR = Monthly Recurring Revenue
• ARR = Annual Recurring Revenue
• LTV = Long Term Customer Value
• CAC = Cost of Customer Acquisition
• Months To Recover CAC
• Churn
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Case Study # 1 - Peleton
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
# 1
-P
ELO
TON
How Peloton is Marketing a $2,000 Bike Beyond the Rich
• Initial business model• $1,995 stationary bike with an attached tablet and a $39-a-month subscription
service for access to live and on-demand classes.
• New Model• Immersive, indoor cycling experience
• $97 per month for 39 months for both the bike and subscription service
• Partnering with Westin Hotels & Resorts to get its bikes and classes in front of more of its target audience, as well as expanding its showroom footprint across the country.
• Results:• $170 million in revenue in 2016, up from $60 million in revenue in 2015
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Case Study # 2 - Adobe
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
How Adobe Pivoted Its Business Model
• In 2011 - Adobe’s Creative Suite generated $3.4B in revenue with a gross margin of 97%.
• In April 2012, Adobe announced the release of Creative Cloud, while continuting to see its CS6 product on a perpetual license basis
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
How Adobe Pivoted Its Business Model
https://blog.chartmogul.com/adobe-saas-pivot-strategy/
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
• FY 2016: CC revenue was up 44% year-on-year to $733 million
• FY 2016: Over 30% of CC total subscribers were new to Adobe
• Q1 2017: $4.25B ARR, a quarter-over-quarter increase of $265M
How Adobe Pivoted Its Business Model
Case Study # 3 - Microsoft
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Microsoft’s Move To The Cloud
• Microsoft Office – Estimated 1.2 billion users use some kind of office product
• Office 365 introduced in 2011
• Has over 120 million business users
• Expects 75% of all business customers to move to Office 365 by 2019
• Over 28 million Office 365 consumer users (1 million users added in 12 months)
• Future product direction towards cloud based products/services
Lessons Learned
• Experiment with side-by-side models to understand potential traction of the full scale
• Revenue growth through raising prices is not sustainable in the long term
• Stakeholder management and goal-setting is key to success
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Is Healthcare Ready For A Subscription Model?
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Subscription Models In Healthcare
• Software
• Medical devices
• Concierge care, Direct Primary Care
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
IORA Health – Business Model
• Venture funded – Raised over $200M in funding; 25+ locations
• Team approach – Provider, Nurse, Health coach
• Health Coach servers as the primary liaison with the client
• Fully integrated behavioral health
• Technology powered
• No transaction fees – Flat fee between $60-$200
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Qliance Story
• Founded in 2007 with over $30M In venture investments
• Financial model: Membership fees ($54-$89/month), no insurance
• Unlimited primary care services
• Growth – Over 25,000 members, including Medicaid members
• Customers – Corporate, Unions, Individuals
• Company closed doors in June 2017
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Qliance – Lessons Learned
• “Cash is king,” particularly in health care
• Having the right leadership at the right time matters.
• Even with perfect leadership and funding, DPC is a round peg in the square hole of health care.
• More on the changing nature of primary care
https://stateofreform.com/featured/2017/05/lessons-qliance-closing-doors/
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Direct Primary Care?
• Direct Primary Care (DPC) is an innovative alternative payment model improving access to high functioning healthcare with a simple, flat, affordable membership fee. No fee-for-service payments. No third party billing. The defining element of DPC is an enduring and trusting relationship between a patient and his or her primary care provider.
https://www.dpcare.org
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
How To Complete Against Well Funded Competitors
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
3 Things People Get Wrong About David vs. Goliath
1. Goliath can't see.
2. Goliath is powerless.
3. David is deadly.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://www.inc.com/bill-murphy-jr/3-things-people-get-wrong-about-david-vs-goliath.html
Strategies To Complete
• Identify your “secret sauce”
• Reconstruct market boundaries
• Embrace a “digital first” strategy
• Develop strong partnerships
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Digital TransformationReimagine and Reset Your Organization For A Digital World
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Digital Transformation
Digital transformation is the profound and accelerating transformation of business activities, processes, competencies and models to fully leverage the changes and opportunities of
digital technologies and their impact across society in a strategic and prioritized way, with present and future shifts in
mind.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Risk For Digital Disruption
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
60%+ of Healthcare Organizations Expect Their Business To Be Disrupted By Digital Technology
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Digital Transformation Framework
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
VISION TACTICS Customer Experience
Create a compelling vision that will allow everyone
to reimagine your organization as a
technology focused, data driven startup.
• Help customers to get to their desired outcomes
• Digitize end to end customer experience
• Provide better, faster, cost effective customer experience
• Cloud Infrastructure
• Data Systems
• Mobility
• Tele Health
• Data Analytics
• IoT
Importance Of Healthy Margins
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Growth Strategies For Services Organizations
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
COST
PROFITCOST
PROFIT
COST
PROFIT
Growth Through M&ACurrent Profitability Through Cost Reduction
Profitability Margins Across Industries
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://www.sageworksanalyst.com/p
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
https://www.sageworksanalyst.com/
Financial Performance - All Industries
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc. https://www.sageworksanalyst.com/
Health Care and Social Assistance
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Maintained bed occupancy 64.3%
Operating margin 3.4%
Excess margin 6.1 %
Operating cash flow margin: 10.3 %
Three-year operating revenue CAGR 5.8 %
Three-year operating expense CAGR 5.5 %
Days cash on hand 211.8 days
Annual operating revenue growth rate 7.5 %
Annual operating expense growth rate 6.6 %
Current ratio 2.0x
Debt-to-cash flow 2.7x
Capital spending ratio 1.1x
Accounts receivable 48.4 days
Financial Ratios At NFP Hospitals
Source: Moody's Investors Service, "U.S. Not-for-Profit Hospital 2015 Medians" report, September 2016.
Do You Feel This Way?
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Most Profitable Companies (2016)
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Profits Margin (% Revenue)
Apple $45.7 billion 21%
J.P. Morgan Chase $24.7 billion 23%
Berkshire Hathaway $24.1 billion 11%
Wells Fargo $21.9 billion 23%
Alphabet $19.5 billion 22%
http://fortune.com/fortune500/list/filtered?sortBy=profits&first500
Importance Of Productizing Your Service
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Embedding Products Into Services
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Discover Potential Products
Developing Scalable
Technology Driven
Products
Profitable Revenue Model
Discover Potential Products
• Define a market segment ie., MAT, Autism etc.
• What aspects of the client experience can be automated?
• Case Study – EXL• EXL is a operations management and analytics company that helps businesses
enhance revenue growth and improve profitability.
• Original Process: EXL employees would examine medical claims for incorrect coding, subrogation, payment errors, nonbeneficial services, and other causes of overpayment.
• Developed a tool to scan, analyze and score claims thereby eliminating a lot of the manual work.
• Result – Increased efficiency and reduced costs for processing claims
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Developing Scale
• Developing scale starts with thinking big.
• Integrate technology across the board• Technology to automate all client interactions – registration, scheduling,
requests
• Integrate tele health into the mix
• Spend time in developing a unique experience and identity
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Financial Modeling Best Practices
1. Be clear on the purpose of the model:
Making a business decision?
Funding?
2. Create a story/timeline for the model
What is the timeline for the idea to move from startup, revenue generation, growth
3. Develop a Plan vs. Actual model to track progress and refine the model based on lessons learned
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Develop A Profitable Model
• Outline for a good financial model• Assumptions and drivers
• Income statement
• Balance sheet
• Cash flow statement
• Supporting schedules
• Valuation
• Sensitivity analysis
• Charts and graphs
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.
Summary
• Healthcare is changing rapidly
• Digital strategy can be a valuable
tool to cope with this change
• The decisions we make today will
determine the ultimate future of
your organization
• Start small…but let’s start today!
Thank You
Copyright (c) Core Solutions, Inc.