8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
1/67
Commodities Market in India
1
1. Executive Summary
Commodities form an essential part of daily lives of all individuals. Changes in
commodity prices have a direct impact on households as they can lead to a fall or
rise in their cost of living. Commodities are the raw materials which form the basic
input to manufacturing industry. Thus even these industries are affected by the
commodity fluctuations.
With the establishment of online markets,commodities now offer investment
opportunities. Any person can now trade for commodities just like shares and bond
market.
Historical events show that India is one the most ancient countries to trade
commodities and derivatives market. Agricultural commodities, Oil, Gold and silver
form an integral part of Indian society.
The futures commodity market has shown a constant growth ever since its restart
early 2000s. The gap between the equity markets and the commodity markets in
India is closing down, but still the volumes traded are less as compared to the
international exchanges.Since the period recession in 2008 the growth of commodity markets outperformed
the equity markets. With some further reforms in the derivatives markets, there is
tremendous potential for growth of this market in the country.
This project focuses on the commodities exchanges in India with respect to different
exchanges and commodities for trading, available trading mechanisms, regulations,
comparison on Indian commodity derivative market vis--vis equity market and
future prospects.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
2/67
Commodities Market in India
2
2. Introduction
A market is described as a platform where buyers and sellers are allowed to trade,exchange goods, services, and information. Any type of trade can take place in a
market. The two major dependent factors by which a market can operate are
buyers and sellers.
2.1 Types of Market in India
Currency Markets - Currency markets are among the largest traded markets in the
globe, on a continual basis. Money flows are continuous around the globe -
governments, banks, investors and consumers - all of them are involved in buying
and selling currency round the clock.
Stock Markets - Stock markets seem to be the backbone of any economy allowing
investors to buy and sell shares of various companies. Majority of the Indian stock
markets are operating on an electronic network.
Commodity Markets - In India, the commodity markets are starting to gain
attention as the prices of the essential commodities steer the economy to a desired
level. Commodity markets deal in energy, soft commodities and grains, meat etc.
Debt Markets
There are three main segments in the debt markets in India,
(1)Government Securities
(2) Public Sector Units (PSU) bonds and
(3)Corporate securities.
Debt market is predominantly a wholesale market, with dominant institutional
investor participation. The investors in the debt markets are mainly banks, financial
institutions, mutual funds, provident funds, insurance companies and corporates.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
3/67
Commodities Market in India
3
2.2 Commodity and Commodity Trading
A commodity is a product that has commercial value, which can be produced,
bought, sold, and consumed.
India commodity market consists of both the retail and the wholesale market in the
country. The wholesale market is the one where the commodities are bought from
the producers and sold to the retailers by the wholesalers while in retail markets,
retailers sell the goods bought from the wholesalers are sold to the end consumers.
Commodities can also be traded on different exchanges which help in discovering
the price of the commodity and mitigate risks.
Earlier commodity trading was much more an unorganized one as all traders were
required to a common place and call out bids.
In those days the buyer would study the quantity of annual produce of the
commodities and the sellers would calculate the approximate demands. There was
speculation and dictating of terms. This was primarily because there was no
research and techniques of trading speculation.
However, commodity trading has seen a radical change with it shifting to an
organized set up in the form of the commodity exchanges. Actually futures
commodity trading was banned for over forty years in this country because of varied
reasons. And when this ban was lifted, no one could imagine the volume of trading
it has invited.
Commodity markets are similar to equity markets. The commodity market basically
two constituents i.e. spot market and derivative market. In case of a spot market,
the commodities are bought and sold for immediate delivery. In case of a
commodities derivative market, various financial instruments having commodities
as underlying are traded on the exchanges.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
4/67
Commodities Market in India
4
2.3 History of Commodity Trading in India
The history of commodity markets have their roots way back to early civilizations
where people used to barter different goods as per their needs.
Commodity trading was initiated in India and gradually it became popular in the
other parts of the world. Long years of foreign rule, natural disasters and calamities,
lack of sound government policies caused the commodity trading gradually lose it
sheen in the Indian subcontinent.
Major breakthroughs have witnessed an early death due to political negligence and
lack of strong will.
The Bombay Cotton dealers Association was formed in 1855 marked the beginning
of process of formalizing cotton trade in India. Some important events that took
place in the commodity market are as follows:-
1875 - Bombay Cotton Trade Association Ltd. Set up the first organized futures
market.
1900 - Futures trading in oil started
1920 - Futures trading in bullion began in Bombay.
1939 - Cotton derivatives banned
1952 - Forward Contracts (Regulation) Act enacted.
1953 - Forwards Markets Commission (FMC) established .
1963 - Futures trading in commodities banned.
1994 Kabra Committee recommendations
2002 NMCE established
2003 MCX and NCDEX established
2003 - Futures trading in commodities allowed again.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
5/67
Commodities Market in India
5
2.4 Commodity Exchange
A commodity exchange is defined as an association that organizes trading in
commodities.
Due to speculative reasons commodity trading on exchanges was banned in India
for almost 40 years.
However in 2003 the ban was lifted and trading began on exchanges.
The traditional system of open market place was replaced by computerized system
with on-line trading facilities.
The national commodity exchanges in India are:
Multi Commodity Exchange of India Ltd, Mumbai (MCX).
National Commodity and Derivatives Exchange Limited, Mumbai (NCDEX)
National Multi Commodity Exchange of India Ltd , Ahemadabad (NMCE)
Indian Commodity Exchange Limited, New Delhi (ICEX)
Ace Derivatives and Commodity Exchange Limited, Mumbai
Some Regional Exchanges in India are:
NBOT (National Board of Trade), Indore
Bikaner Commodity Exchange Ltd., Bikaner
Bombay Commodity Exchange Ltd., Vashi
Chamber Of Commerce, Hapur
Central India Commercial Exchange Ltd., Gwalior
Cotton Association of India, Mumbai
East India Jute & Hessian Exchange Ltd., Kolkata
First Commodities Exchange of India Ltd., Kochi
Haryana Commodities Ltd., Sirsa
India Pepper & Spice Trade Association., Kochi
Meerut Agro Commodities Exchange Co. Ltd., Meerut
Rajkot Commodity Exchange Ltd., Rajkot
Rajdhani Oils and Oilseeds Exchange Ltd., Delhi
Surendranagar Cotton oil & Oilseeds Association Ltd., Surendranagar
Spices and Oilseeds Exchange Ltd. Sangli
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
6/67
Commodities Market in India
6
Vijay Beopar Chamber Ltd., Muzaffarnagar
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
7/67
Commodities Market in India
7
2.5 Multi Commodity Exchange
Headquartered in Mumbai, Multi Commodity Exchange of India Ltd (MCX) is
a state-of-the-art electronic commodity futures exchange.
Started operations in November 2003
MCX holds a market share of over 80%* (87.3% during the nine months
ended December 31, 2011 and 82.4% in FY2011) of the Indian commodity
futures market
MCX offers more than 40 commodities across various segments such as
bullion, ferrous and non-ferrous metals, energy, and a number of agri-
commodities on its platform. The Exchange introduces standardised
commodity futures contracts on its platform.
Some rankings of MCX
o The Exchange is the world's largest exchange in Silver
o The second largest in Gold, Copper and Natural Gas and
o The third largest in Crude Oil futures, based on the comparison of
the trading volumes of our Exchange with those of the leading global
commodity futures exchanges in the world, for the calendar year
2010 and the six months ended June 30, 2011.
Trade Timings at MCX
Normal Session:
Days Time CommodifiesTraded
Monday to Friday 10.00am to 5.00pm
Monday to Friday 5.00 pm to 11.30pm /11.55
pm
All commodities except Agri
commodities
Saturday 10.00 am to 2.00pm All commodities
Special Session: Monday to Saturday: 9:45 a.m. to 9:59 a.m. Special Session
(order cancellation session) is held to cancel the pending orders prior to opening of
market.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
8/67
Commodities Market in India
8
The Commodities traded on MCX are
Bullions Metals Energy Oil&OilSeeds Others
Gold Aluminium ATF Crude Palm Oil AlmondGold guinea Aluminium
Mini
Brent Crude
Oil
Refined Soya
Oil
Guar Seed
Gold M Copper Crude Oil Kapasia Khalli Melted
Menthol
Flakes
Gold Petal Copper Mini Electricity
Monthly &
Weekly
Soya Bean Mentha Oil
Gold petal Iron Ore Gasoline Cereals Potato (Agra)
(New delhi) Lead Heating Oil Barley Potato
(Tarkeshwar)
Platinum Lead Mini Imported
Thermal Coal
Maize-Feed /
Industrial
Grade
Sugar M
Silver Mild Steel
Ingot,Billets
Natural Gas Wheat Spices
Silver M Nickel Cardamom
Silver Micro Nickel Mini Coriander
Tin Turmeric
Zinc
Plantations Zinc Mini Weather Fiber Pulses
Rubber Carbon(CER) Kapas ChanaCarbon(CFI) Cotton (29mm)
Trading System and margin calculation at MCX
The best five buy and sell orders for every contract available for trading are visible
to the market and orders are matched based on price time priority logic. For the
purpose of computing and levying the margins, MCX uses SPAN (Standard
Portfolio Analysis of Risk) system which follows a risk-based and portfolio-based
approach.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
9/67
Commodities Market in India
9
Trading Window at MCX
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
10/67
Commodities Market in India
10
2.6 NCDEX
National Commodity & Derivatives Exchange Limited (NCDEX), a national
level online multi commodity exchange, commenced operations on
December 15, 2003.
The Exchange has received a permanent recognition from the Ministry of
Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution, Government of India as a
national level exchange.
In just over two years of operations it posted an average daily turnover of
around Rs 4500- 5000 crore a day (over USD 1 billion).
The major share of the volumes come from agricultural commodities and the
balance from bullion, metals, energy and other products. Trading is
facilitated through over 850 Members located across around 700 centers
(having ~20000 trading terminals) across the country.
Most of these terminals are located in the semi-urban and rural regions of
the country. Trading is facilitated through VSATs, leased lines and the
Internet.
Trade Timings
Monday to Friday 10.00 a.m.to 5.00 p.m. for agricultural products.
Monday to Friday 10.00 a.m.to 11.30 p.m for metal and energy products.
On Saturdays trade in all commodities takes place from 10.00 a.m. to 2.00 p.m
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
11/67
Commodities Market in India
11
Commodities traded on NCDEX
Metals Precious Metals Energy OthersSteel Gold Crude Oil CER
Copper Gold (100 gms) Thermal Coal
Zinc Gold International Brent Crude Oil
Aluminium Silver Natural Gas Polymers
Nickel Silver (5kg) Gasoline CER
Polypropylene
Lead Silver International Heating Oil Linear Low density
Polyethylene
Platinum Polyvinyl Chloride
Spices Oil and Oilseeds Others agri Plantation
Products
Pepper Castor Seed Guar Seeds Rubber
Chilli Sesame Seeds Potato Coffee-Robusta
Cherry AB
Jeera Cotton Seed Oilcake Mentha Oil Cashew
Turmeric Soya Bean Guar Gum
Coriander Refined Soya Oil Gur
Cereals Soybean meal Almond Pulses
Wheat Mustard Seed Chana
Barley Kachhi Ghani Mustard
Oil
Masoor
Maize(Yellow/Red)
Rapeseed Yellow Peas
Crude Palm Oil
RBD Palmolein
Groundnut in shell
Groundnut Expeller Oil
.
Trading Window at NCDEX
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
12/67
Commodities Market in India
12
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
13/67
Commodities Market in India
13
2.7 Performance of different commodities market
Turnover market Turnover market Turnover market
million share million share million share
MCX 98,415,030 82.4 63,933,025 82.3 45,880,946 87.4
NCDEX 14,106,022 11.8 9,175,847 11.8 5,357,070 10.2
NMCE 2,184,109 1.8 2,279,015 2.9 614,566 1.2
ICEX 3,777,299 3.2 1,364,254 1.8 - -
ACE 300,596 0.3 59,794 0.1 87,810 0.2
Others 706,368 0.6 835,610 1.1 549,176 1
TOTAL 119,489,425 100 77,647,545 100 52,489,568 100
India has over 7,000 regulated agricultural markets, or mandis, and the majority of
the nations agricultural production is consumed domestically, according to the
Agricultural Marketing Information Network.
India is the worlds leading producer of several agricultural commodities. There are
currently 21 commodity exchanges recognised by FMC in India offering trading in
over 60 commodity futures with the approval of FMC.
In the fiscals 2009, 2010 and 2011, the total value of commodities traded oncommodity futures exchanges in India was Rs 52,489.57 billion, Rs 77,647.54
billion and ` 119,489.42 billion, respectively.
The total value of commodities traded on commodity futures exchanges in India for
the first nine months ended December 31, 2011 was Rs.137,228.55 billion
2.8 Background of some commodities
2.8.1 Agricultural Commodity Markets
India has a predominantly agrarian economy and its commodity markets have a
long history. Indias agricultural commodity markets were initially formed when
producers and buyers met at designated locations to trade in their produces. Indias
wholesale spot markets for agricultural commodities have remained relatively
unchanged.
Agricultural commodities are predominantly traded in government-regulated
wholesale markets or mandis. Mandis are often located in or near important towns
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
14/67
Commodities Market in India
14
or centres of production, consumption or shipping where sellers, buyers and
intermediaries converge to buy and sell goods.
Since almost all orders flow through the mandis, they are a source of dailyinformation about the quantity of agricultural commodities and the price at which
agricultural commodities trade for the respective geographic areas in which the
mandis are located.
2.8.2 Non-Agricultural Commodity Industry in India
Energy products, precious metals like gold and silver and non-ferrous metals play a
significant and vital role in the growth of the Indian economy. Some of the
commodities which most actively traded on the exchanges (mostly MCX) are
Gold:
Nations have embraced gold as a store of wealth and a medium of international
exchange, and individuals buy gold as insurance against the day-to-day
uncertainties of paper money.
Gold is also a vital industrial metal, used in electronics and other high-tech
applications. Gold occupies an important role in India. Apart from being a symbol of
wealth, many social and cultural elements of Indian culture are associated with
gold.
However, despite being the largest consumer of gold, the Indian market has limited
influence on the price of gold bullion in the world markets as it is heavily dependent
on imports and its markets are scattered across the country.
Crude oil:
Many markets are related with the global crude oil market in various ways. Crude oil
is used for the production of a wide range of products from petrol, diesel, kerosene
and from liquefied petroleum gas to naphtha and other petrochemicals products.
According to provisional data from the oil industry statistics for fiscal 2011 and eight
months ended November 30, 2011 as published by the Petroleum Planning and
Analysis Cell of the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas, a total of 163.13 MMT
and 112.12 million metric tonnes (MMT), respectively, of crude oil, valued at Rs
4,536.34 billion and 4,152.38 billion respectively, was imported into India.
Crude oil production in the country was 37.95 MMT and 25.53 MMT during fiscal
2011 and eight months ended November 30, 2011, respectively. (Source: Official
website of Petroleum Planning and Analysis Cell, Ministry of Petroleum & NaturalGas).
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
15/67
Commodities Market in India
15
India imported 81.1% and 81.5% of its crude oil requirements during this fiscal 2011
and eight months ended November 30, 2011, respectively, and was highly exposed
to global crude oil price movements.Silver:
Silver is sought as a valuable and practical industrial commodity, and as an
appealing investment. The largest industrial users of silver in India are in the
photographic, jewellery, and electronic industries.
Copper:
Copper is the worlds third most widely used metal, after iron and aluminium, and is
primarily used in highly cyclical manufacturing industries. In India, copper is the
second most consumed non-ferrous metal, after aluminium.
At present, the demand for copper minerals for primary copper production is met
through two sources, namely copper ore mined from indigenous mines, and
imported concentrates.
The production of refined copper in India has increased considerably since the
fiscal 1999 after private sector manufacturers started production of refined copper,
and now a considerable portion of consumption is met through domestic production.
According to the estimates of the Indian Copper Development Centre, in the fiscal
2010, refined copper usage in India was approximately 550,000 MT. (Source:
Annual Report of the Ministry of Mines 2010-11).
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
16/67
Commodities Market in India
16
2.9 Exchange industry Growth in India
Commodity futures trading in India has grown since the Government of India issued
a notification on April 1, 2003 permitting futures trading in commodities.
The total value of commodities futures traded in India in the fiscal 2011 was
Rs.119,489.42 billion, representing growth of approximately 90-fold from the value
of commodity futures contracts traded in the fiscal 2004, which was Rs.1,293.67
billion. Commodity futures trading volumes have risen at a compound annual
growth rate of 90.9% between fiscal 2004 and fiscal 2011.
There are currently over 60 commodities futures that have been approved by the
FMC for trading during the calendar year 2011 with gold, silver, crude oil, copper,
zinc, nickel and natural gas comprising the majority of the trading turnover for the
fiscal 2011.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
17/67
Commodities Market in India
17
2.10 Global Commodity Derivatives Exchanges
Some of the global commodity market and the commodities traded are as follows
NYMEX Crude oil, Natural Gas, Gold
CBOT Corn, Soybean, Wheat, Soyabean oil
ICE US Sugar, Coffee, Cotton, Cocoa
CME Live Cattle, Lean Hogs, Feeder Cattle
Shanghai Futures
ExchangeCopper, Rubber, Fuel oil, Zinc, Aluminium
Dalian Commodity
Exchange
Soy Meal, Soy oil, Polyethylene, Soybeans no 1,
Palm oil
Zhengzhou
Commodity
Exchange
Sugar, Pure Terephthalic acid (PTA), Rapeseed oil,
Wheat, Cotton
ICE Futures UK Brent Crude oil, WTI Crude, Gasoil, Natural Gas
LME UK Aluminium, Copper, Zinc, Nickel, Lead
Tokyo Commodity
ExchangeGold, Platinum, Rubber, Gasoline
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
18/67
Commodities Market in India
18
2.11 Objectives
To study the commodity derivative market of India. To find differences between equity and commodity market.
To compare the performance of commodity derivative market vis--vis
equity market.
2.12 Methodology
The information was collected through secondary data sources during the
project.
Real time futures market values from websites like MCX, NCDEX were used
as examples to explain the theoretical concepts.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
19/67
Commodities Market in India
19
3. Trading in Commodity Derivatives Market
3.1 Derivatives
Derivatives are contracts which derive their value from an underlying. The most
commonly traded derivative instruments are forwards, futures, swaps and options.
Forward Contracts: It is a simple derivative. These are promises to buy or sell an
asset at a pre-determined date in future at a predetermined price. The contracts are
traded over the counter (i.e. outside the stock exchanges, directly between the two
parties) and are customized according to the needs of the parties. Since these
contracts do not fall under the purview of rules and regulations of an exchange,they generally suffer from counterparty risk i.e. the risk that one of the parties to the
contract may not fulfill his or her obligation.
Futures Contracts: A futures contract is an agreement between two parties to buy
or sell an underlying at a certain time in future at a certain price. These are basically
exchange traded, standardized contracts. The exchange stands guarantee to all
transactions and counterparty risk is largely eliminated. The buyers of futures
contracts are considered having a long position whereas the sellers are considered
to be having a short position. Futures contracts are available on variety ofcommodities, currencies, interest rates, stocks and other tradable assets.
Options Contracts: Options give the buyer (holder) a right but not an obligation to
buy or sell an underlying in future. Options are of two types - calls and puts.
Summary of options is as follows:
Options Call Put
Buyer Right to buy Right to sell
Seller Obligation to sell Obligation to buy
In forwards and futures both the parties (buyer and seller) have an obligation i.e.
the buyer needs to pay for the underlying to the seller and the seller needs to
deliver the underlying to the buyer on the settlement date. In case of options only
the seller (also called option writer) is under an obligation and not the buyer. Incase
the buyer of the option does exercise his right, the seller of the option must fulfill
whatever is his obligation.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
20/67
Commodities Market in India
20
Swaps: Swaps are private agreements between two parties to exchange cash flows
in the future according to a prearranged formula. They can be regarded as
portfolios of forward contracts. The two commonly used swaps are: Interest rate swaps: These entail swapping only the interest related cash
flows between the parties in the same currency.
Currency swaps: These entail swapping both principal and interest between
the parties, with the cash flows in one direction being in a different currency
than those in the opposite direction.
3.2 Commodity Derivatives in India
Commodity derivatives are the products where the underlying is any commodity. As
in case of equity market, the price of derivative is driven by the spot price of the
underlying commodity. The exchange provides the physical facilities and exercises
surveillance on trading practices.
At present trading in permitted only in futures, options are not traded on any of the
commodity exchange in India.
Futures are standardized contract settled on predetermined fixed future date with a
standard quantity and quality of the underlying (commodity). A futures contract maybe offset prior to maturity by entering into an equal and opposite transaction.
The main standardized items in a futures contract are:
Quantity of the underlying
Quality of the underlying
The date and the month of delivery
The units of price quotation and minimum price change ie. Tick size
Delivery center
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
21/67
Commodities Market in India
21
3.3 Futures Contracts: Terminology
3.3.1 Long Position :
It basically means
Buying of a futures
contract.
eg. A person has a
bullish view for gold ,
then he may enter into a
long position by buying
futures contract.
The payoff for such
person is as shown in
Figure1. The Strike
price(K) is at 27500, if at
the end of the contract
the spot price(S) is more
than the strike price the
person will be in profit of
amount that equals S
minus K (S K).
However if the prices
reduce and at the end of
the contract the spot
price is lower than the
strike price ie. (K > S)
than he suffers losses of
strike minus spot (K
S).
Profit
Loss
27500
Gold price
Figure 1: Long Position on gold at 27500 per 10gm
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
22/67
Commodities Market in India
22
3.3.2 Short Position :
It basically means Selling of a
futures contract.
eg. A person has a bearish view
for chana, then he may enter into
a short position by selling futures
contract.
The payoff for such person is as
shown in Figure 2.
The Strike price (K) for 20th
March 2012 is at 3700 per
quintal, if at the end of the contract the spot price(S) is less than the strike price the
person will be in profit of amount that equals K minus S (K S)
However if the prices increase and at the end of the contract the spot price is higher
than the strike price ie. (K > S) than he suffers losses of strike minus spot (K S).
Profit
Loss
3700
Chana price/quintal
Figure 2 Short position on Chana
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
23/67
Commodities Market in India
23
3.4 Pricing of Commodity Futures
Investment Assets Versus Consumption Assets
When considering forward and futures contracts, it is important to distinguish
between investment assets and consumption assets. An investment asset is an
asset that is held for investment purposes by significant numbers of investors.
Stocks, bonds gold and silver are some of the examples of investment assets.
A consumption asset is an asset that is held primarily for consumption. It is not
usually held for investment. Examples of consumption assets are commodities such
as copper, oil, and pork bellies. It is not usually held for investment. Examples of
consumption assets are commodities such as copper, oil, and pork bellies.
For pricing futures we use The Cost Of Carry Model which is as follows
F = S*er T where
F = Futures price
S = Spot price
r = Risk free interest rate or cost of financing
T = Time till expiration
Commodities however may involve storage cost as the exchanges have to hold the
commodity till the end of the contract. In absence of any cost the above equation is
used to calculate the future price of the underlying commodity.
If there is any storage cost involved then,
F = (S + U) * er T where
U = Present value of all the storage cost involved
Eg. For silver
Spot price = 55000 / kgDays to expiration T = 30 days
Risk free rate = 7%
Cost of storage = Rs 300 for 30 days paid in advance
Hence the futures price will be
F = (55000 + 300 ) * e0.07 * 30/365
F = Rs. 55619
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
24/67
Commodities Market in India
24
Scenario 1: (Cash and Carry arbitrage)
If the price of the futures contract is more than 55619 then theoretically, the futuresare said to over priced and thus it creates an arbitrage opportunity.
Suppose Futures are trading at 55700 then one can earn riskless profit as follows:
1) Borrow an amount of S+U at risk free interest rate and Buy in spot market
2) Sell the futures
If contract closes at 55650
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 Profit in spot = 350
Futures = 55700 Profit in futures = 50
Net profit = Rs. 400
Sell in spot at 55650 and return the borrowed amount
If contract closes at 55800
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 Profit in spot = 500
Futures = 55700 Loss in futures = 100
Net profit = Rs. 400
Sell in spot at 55800 and return the borrowed amount
If contract closes at 55100
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 Loss in spot = 200
Futures = 55700 Profit in futures = 600
Net profit = Rs. 400
Sell in spot at 55100 and return the borrowed amount
Scenario 2: (Reverse Cash and Carry arbitrage)
If the price of the futures contract is less than 55619 then theoretically, the futures
are said to under priced and it creates an arbitrage opportunity.
Suppose Futures are trading at 55200 then one can earn riskless profit as follows:
1) Sell in spot market saving storage cost and invest the amount in risk free
asset
2) Buy the futures
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
25/67
Commodities Market in India
25
If contract closes at 55550
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 loss in spot = 250
Futures = 55200 Profit in futures = 350Net profit = Rs. 100
Buy in spot at 55550 if required.
If contract closes at 56000
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 Loss in spot = 700
Futures = 55200 Profit in futures = 800
Net profit = Rs. 100
Buy in spot at 56000 if required.
If contract closes at 49500
Cost = 55000 + 300 = 55300 Profit in spot = 5800
Futures = 55200 Loss in futures = 5700
Net profit = Rs. 100
Buy in spot at 49500 if required.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
26/67
Commodities Market in India
26
3.5 Pricing Futures Contracts on Consumption Commodities
We used the arbitrage argument to price futures on investment commodities. For
commodities that are consumption commodities rather than investment assets, the
arbitrage arguments used to determine futures prices need to be reviewed carefully.
Suppose we have
F > (S + U) * erT
To take advantage of this opportunity, an arbitrager can implement the following
strategy:
1. Borrow an amount S+U at the risk-free interest rate and use it to purchase one
unit of
the commodity and pay storage costs.
2. Short a forward contract on one unit of the commodity.
If we regard the futures contract as a forward contract, this strategy leads to a profit
of F-(S+U) * erT at the expiration of the futures contract. As arbitragers exploit this
opportunity, the spot price will increase and the futures price will decrease until the
equation does not hold good.
Suppose next that
F < (S + U) * erT
In case of investment assets such as gold and silver, many investors hold the
commodity purely for investment. When they observe the inequality , they will find it
profitable to trade in the following manner:
1. Sell the commodity, save the storage costs, and invest the proceeds at the risk-
free interest rate.
2. Take a long position in a forward contract.
This would result in a profit at maturity of (S + U) * erT - F relative to the position
that the
investors would have been in had they held the underlying commodity. As
arbitragers exploit this opportunity, the spot price will decrease and the futures price
will increase until equation does not hold good. This means that for investment
assets, equation holds good.
However, for commodities like cotton or wheat that are held for consumption
purpose, this argument cannot be used. Individuals and companies, who keep such
a commodity in inventory, do so, because of its consumption value - not because of
its value as an investment. They are reluctant to sell these commodities and buy
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
27/67
Commodities Market in India
27
forward or futures contracts because these contracts cannot be consumed.
Therefore, there is unlikely to be arbitrage when equation holds good. In short, for a
consumption commodity therefore,F
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
28/67
Commodities Market in India
28
On the other hand, low inventories tend to lead to high convenience yields.
The Futures BasisThe cost-of-carry model defines the relationship between the futures price and the
related spot price.
The difference between the spot price and the futures price is called the basis. As a
futures contract nears expiration, the basis reduces to zero. This means that there
is a convergence of the futures price to the price of the underlying asset.
If the futures price is above the spot price during the delivery period it gives
rise to a clear arbitrage opportunity for traders.
This will lead to a profit equal to the difference between the futures price and
spot price. Traders start using this arbitrage opportunity, demand for the
contract in spot will increase ie. Spot price will increase & he will short
futures and prices will fall leading to the convergence of the future price with
the spot price.
If the futures price is below the spot price during the delivery period all
parties interested in buying the asset will take a long position.
The trader would buy the contract and sell the asset in the spot market
making a profit equal to the difference between the future price and the spot
price. As more traders take a long position the demand for the particular
asset would increase and the futures price would rise nullifying the arbitrage
opportunity.
Contango refers to a situation where the future price of a commodity is higher than
the spot price. A contango is normal for investment asset which has cost of carry. A
contango should equal the cost of carry because the producers and consumers
compare the futures price against the spot price plus storage cost.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
29/67
Commodities Market in India
29
3.7 Participants in Futures market
There are 3 types of participants in futures markets namely
1) Hedgers.
2) Speculators
3) Arbitragers
3.7.1 Hedgers
These are people with a present or anticipated exposure to a commodity which is
subject to price risks. Hedgers use the derivatives markets primarily for price risk
management .
Hedger tries to avert the unfavorable risk he may face in the future.
A hedger buys or sells in the futures market to secure the future price of a
commodity intended to be sold at a later date in the cash market. This helps protect
against price risks.
The holders of the long position in futures contracts (buyers of the commodity), are
trying to secure as low a price as possible eg. A manufacturer who might need raw
materials after 3 months finds them trading at a low price will enter into a longposition. This is called as long hedge.
Cotton in spot market is trading at Rs.782 per 20 kg cotton
April 2012 Futures is trading at Rs.857 per 20 kg cotton
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
30/67
Commodities Market in India
30
Company will require cotton in April and fears prices will rise further. Hence it can
lock the buy price.
The company buys 1 future contract of 1 lot @ 857*200 = Rs.171400.
Case1:
Spot on the last day is 860.
Futures will the same ie. Company closes contract at 860.
Company buys in spot at 860 .
Total Cost =Rs.172000 and receives profits from futures of Rs. 3 (860-857).
Total receipt =Rs 600.
Net Cost = Rs.171400
Case2: Spot on the last day is 840. Futures will the same ie. Company closes
contract at 840.
Company buys in spot at 840 .Total Cost =Rs.168000 and suffers losses from
futures of Rs. 17 (840-857).
Losses = Rs 3400.
Net Cost = Rs.171400
Profit
Loss
857
Cotton price
Long in
futures
Short position to close long
position
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
31/67
Commodities Market in India
31
The short holders of the contract (sellers of the commodity) will want to secure as
high a price as possible. eg. A farmer who produces a crop that is currently tradingat a higher price and has a view that in coming months due to increased supply of
the crop , the prices might
reduce will enter into a
short hedge.
Pepper in spot market is
trading at Rs.37610 per
quintal
June 2012 Futures is
trading at Rs.37835 per
quintal
The farmer fears prices
might fall further. Hence he
short hedges.
Short 1 Futures contract @ 37835
Profit
Loss
37835
Pepper price
Long position to close
short position
Short position
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
32/67
Commodities Market in India
32
Case1: Spot on the last day is 37800. Futures will the same ie. farmer closes
contract at 37835.Farmer sells in spot at 37800 .Total sell value = Rs.378000 and receives profits
from futures of Rs. 35 (37835 - 37800).
Total receipt =Rs 350.
Net receipt = Rs.378350
Case2:
Spot on the last day is 38840. Futures will the same ie. Farmer closes contract at
38840.
Farmer sells in spot at 38840 .Total sell value =Rs.388400 and suffers losses from
futures of Rs. 1005 (37835 - 38840).
Losses = Rs 10050.
Net receipt = Rs.378350
The commodity contract, however, provides a definite price certainty for both
parties, which reduces the risks associated with price volatility. By means of futures
contracts, Hedging can also be used as a means to lock in an acceptable price
margin between the cost of the raw material and the retail cost of the final product
sold.
A Hedger can be Farmers, manufacturers, importers and exporter.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
33/67
Commodities Market in India
33
3.7.2 Speculator
These persons are basically high risk takers.
They have a view on the direction of the market and buy or sell in futures / optionmarket to try and make profits of the market movement.
Speculation of commodities is different from that of speculation of equity
speculation. A person can speculate a direction of companys movement , buy the
shares and keep it with him as long as wants. But commodities involve various
storage costs associated with them.
With availability of derivatives any person can speculate the prices of commodities,
even if he doesnot hold the commodity as some derivatives are available with
option of cash settlement rather than physical delivery.
Entry into the futures market will only involve the person to deposit margin money
with corresponding exchange.
The speculation logic may be of demand supply logic of the commodities.
Eg1. Due to political tensions between the western world and Iran, one can
speculate Crude oil prices can move up in near future. A speculator thus being
bullish on Crude oil can buy the futures contract. This strategy is Bullish security,
buy futures.
Spot price of Crude oil on MCX 5266 / barrel
March Futures Trading at 5321 / barrel
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
34/67
Commodities Market in India
34
The speculator buys one contract ie. 100 barrels of crude oil, he pays an initial
margin for entering into the contract.
At the end of contract the
spot and futures close at
5355 / barrel.
Speculators profit =
5355 * 100 - 5321 * 100
Speculators profit =
Rs 3400
This profit is exclusive of other transaction costs involved in carrying out the trade.
Eg2
If a speculator feels that that due excessive production or reduction in demand of a
particular commodity , the prices may fall in the near future than he can sell the
future contract of the commodity and earn profits
Spot price of gur = 1031
March futures trading at 1066
Speculator belives that due to excessive supply the prices may fall in the near
future.
Even though he does produce Gur, because of futures market availability he can
just sell the futures trading at 1066.
Profit
Loss
5321
Crude price
Long futures
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
35/67
Commodities Market in India
35
The speculator sell 1 futures contract worth of Rs.266500 (1066*10000/40).
In futures market he
only has to pay an initial
margin to enter into a
futures contract.
If he gets his bet correct
and the value of gur
falls to 1050, the profit
he earns will be =
(1066-1050) *
(10000/40) = Rs. 4000
Profit
Loss
1066
Gur price
Short futures
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
36/67
Commodities Market in India
36
3.7.3 Arbitrageurs
They take positions in markets to earn riskless profits.The arbitrageurs take short and long positions in the same or different contracts at
the same time to create a position which can generate a riskless profit.
The arbitrage condition is possible if:-
1) If the price of the same commodity is different in two markets, there will be
operators who will buy in the market where the asset sells cheap and sell in
the market where it is costly.
2) The futures price of a commodity is theoretically different from the calculated
spot price plus the carry cost compounded using risk free interest rate.
This activity termed as arbitrage, involves the simultaneous purchase and sale of
the same or essentially similar security in two different markets for advantageously
different prices.
The buying cheap and selling expensive continues till prices in the two markets
reach an equilibrium. Hence, arbitrage helps to equalize prices and restore market
efficiency.
The arbitrageur can make the use of cash and carry arbitrage and reverse
cash and carry arbitrage explained earlier in pricing of futures, to earn riskless
profits. The summary of them is as follows:
Cash and carry 1)Borrow an amount at risk free interest rate and Buy in spot
market
2)Sell the futures
Reverse Cash
and carry
1)Sell in spot market saving storage cost and invest the amount
in risk free asset
2)Buy the futures
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
37/67
Commodities Market in India
37
3.8 Trading in Futures
3.8.1 Trading methods
Trading on exchange takes place in following manner
1) Open out cry
2) Electronic trading
Open Out Cry system
While most exchanges the world over are moving towards the electronic form of
trading, some still follow the open outcry
method.
Open outcry trading is a face-to-face and highly
activate form of trading used on the floors of the
exchanges. In open outcry system the futures
contracts are traded in pits.
A pit is a raised platform in octagonal shape
with descending steps on the inside that permit
buyers and sellers to see each other. Normally only one type of contract is traded in
each pit like a Eurodollar pit, Live Cattle pit etc. Each side of the octagon forms a pie
slice in the pit. All the traders dealing
with a certain delivery month trade in
the same slice.
The brokers, who work for institutions
or the general public stand on the
edges of the pit so that they can easily
see other traders and have easy
access to their runners who bring orders.
Chicago Mercentile Exchange follows open cry system as well as electronic trading
system.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
38/67
Commodities Market in India
38
Electronic Trading
Electronic trading offers significant advantages like:
a) Easy accessibility to remote investors in real time.b) Improved efficiency.
c) Low transaction cost.
d) Greater transparency.
e) Automated transaction.
The orders are placed in the system by the broker. The host computer matches
bids with offers according to the pre-determined rules. In a simplest case if a trader
places a buy order equal to or higher than the sell order matching occurs and the
host computer automatically executes the order.
Trading at MCX
The Trader Work Station (TWS) is the application through which members access
the trading platform, place orders and execute trades. The TWS offers a multitude
of user friendly trading features which include commodity price ticker, market watch
screen displaying best buy, best sell, last traded price, volume for the day, open
interest etc,top gainer and loser contracts, net position, on-line back up facility etc
Trading System
The best five buy and sell orders for every contract available for trading are visible
to the market and orders are matched based on price time priority logic. Orders can
be placed with time conditions and/ or price conditions
Trading at NCDEX
The trading system on the NCDEX, provides a fully automated screen-based
trading for futures on commodities on a nationwide basis as well as an online
monitoring and surveillance mechanism.
It supports an order driven market and provides complete transparency of trading
operations.
The NCDEX system supports an order driven market, where orders match
automatically. Order matching is essentially on the basis of commodity, its price,
time and quantity.
All quantity fields are in units and price in rupees.
The Exchange specifies the unit of trading and the delivery unit for futures contracts
on various commodities.
The Exchange notifies the regular lot size and tick size for each of the contracts
traded from time to time.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
39/67
Commodities Market in India
39
When any order enters the trading system, it is an active order. It tries to find a
match on the other side of the book.
If it finds a match, a trade is generated. If it does not find a match, the orderbecomes passive and gets queued in the respective outstanding order book in the
system.
Time stamping is done for each trade and provides the possibility for a complete
audit trail if required.
3.9 Orders in Futures Market
Customers can place different type of orders with brokers. The instructions given by
the clients should be clearly specified in terms of
a) Buy or sell
b) Number of contracts.
c) Type of commodity
d) Month of contract.
e) Price.
f) Period of validity.
g) Validity of order.
Some important orders used in futures market are
1) Market Order
2) Limit Order
3) Stop - loss order
4) Time Order
5) Spread order
6) Exchange for physicals
Orders used at MCX1) Time related Conditions
a. DAY order
b. GTC - A Good Till Cancelled (GTC) order
c. GTD - A Good Till Date (GTD) order
d. IOC - An Immediate or Cancel (IOC)
2) Price Conditions
a. Limit Orderb. Market Order
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
40/67
Commodities Market in India
40
Orders used at NCDEX
1) Time conditions
a. Good till day orderb. Good till cancelled (GTC):
c. Good till date (GTD)
d. Immediate or Cancel (IOC)
e. All or none order
2) Price conditions
a. Limit order
b. Stop-loss
3) Other conditions
a. Market price
b. Trigger price
c. Spread order
Note : Meanings of all the orders are mentioned in appendix
3.10 Margin requirement for futures.
To enter in to a futures contract every member has to deposit a particular amount.This amount is called as margin. It has to be deposited by both buyer and sellers of
futures contract. Margin in futures is not a complete down payment value as in
securities spot market but it is kind of bond. The margin varies from one contract to
another and they are set by the respective exchanges depending on the volatility of
the commodity.
Kinds of margin in general:
1) Initial margin: This amount is deposited by the customer while entering into
a contract. Initial margin is collected by the clearing agency forallowing members to take positions on their own behalf or on behalf of their
clients. In a rough sense, a clearing agency assumes that everyone in the
market is going to default on his/ her position at the end of the day.
2) Maintenance margin: Maintenance margin is lower than initial margin and is
minimum amount that must be present in the account of the customer who
has entered into a futures contract .If the balance in the margin account falls
below the maintenance margin, the investor receives a margin call and is
expected to top up the margin account to the initial margin level.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
41/67
Commodities Market in India
41
3) Additional margin: It is a precautionary step taken by the exchange if it
fears that market has become very volatile and there might payment crisis.
4) Mark-to-Market margin:At the end of each trading day, the margin accountis adjusted to reflect the trader's gain or loss. This is known as marking to
market the account of each trader.
All futures contracts are settled daily reducing the credit exposure to one
day's movement. Based on the settlement price, the value of all positions is
marked-to-market each day after the official close. i.e. the accounts are
either debited or credited based on how well the positions fared in that day's
trading session.
If the account falls below the required margin level the clearing member
needs to replenish the account by giving additional funds or closing
positions either partially/ fully.
On the other hand, if the position generates a gain, the funds can be
withdrawn (those funds above the required initial margin) or can be used to
fund additional trades.
5) Margin for Calendar Spread positions: Calendar spread is defined as the
purchase of one delivery month of a given futures contract and
simultaneous sale of another delivery month of the same commodity by a
client/ member. Since price moves across contract months do not generally
exhibit perfect correlation, calendar spread margin is imposed to cover the
calendar basis risk that may exist for portfolios containing contracts with
different expirations.
These margins and some other margins are levied by both MCX and
NCDEX.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
42/67
Commodities Market in India
42
3.11 Clearing and Settlement of futures contract
3.11.1 ClearingClearing of trades that take place on an Exchange happens through the Exchange
clearing house. A clearing house is a system by which Exchanges guarantee the
faithful compliance of all trade commitments undertaken on the trading floor or
electronically over the electronic trading systems.
The main task of the clearing house is to keep track of all the transactions that take
place during a day so that the net position of each of its members can becalculated.
It guarantees the performance of the parties to each transaction. Typically it is
responsible for the following:
1. Effecting timely settlement.
2. Trade registration and follow up.
3. Control of the open interest.
4. Financial clearing of the payment flow.
5. Physical settlement or financial settlement of contracts.
6. Administration of financial guarantees demanded by the participants.
The clearing house is a guarantor for all transactions that take place in the
exchange and it stipulates margins to manage the default risk.
Depending on a day's transactions and price movement, the members either need
to add funds or can withdraw funds from their margin accounts at the end of the day
as calculated by the clearing house. Thus clearing house will never have any open
position in the market.
National Commodity Clearing Limited (NCCL) undertakes clearing of tradesexecuted on the NCDEX. After the trading hours on the expiry date, based on the
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
43/67
Commodities Market in India
43
available information, the matching for deliveries takes place firstly, on the basis of
locations and men randomly, keeping in view the factors such as available capacity
of the vault/ warehouse, commodities already deposited and dematerialized andoffered for delivery etc.
Matching done by this process is binding on the clearing members. After completion
of the matching process, clearing members are informed of the deliverable/
receivable positions and the unmatched positions. Unmatched positions have to be
settled in cash. The cash settlement is only for the incremental gain/ loss as
determined on the basis of f inal settlement price.
MCX has an in house clearing house which monitors and performs all activities
relating to delivery, fund settlement, margining and managing the settlement
guarantee funds. It operates a well-defined settlement cycle to ensure no deviations
or deferments from this cycle.
3.11.2 Settlement
Futures contracts have two types of settlement, the MTM settlement which happenson a continuous basis at the end of each day, and the final settlement which
happens on the last trading day of the futures contract. On the NCDEX daily mtm
settlement and final MTM settlement in respect of admitted deals in futures
contracts are cash settled by debiting/ crediting the clearing accounts of CMs with
the respecting clearing bank. All position of a CM, either brought forward, created
during the day or closed out during the day, are market to market at the daily
settlement price or the final settlement price at the close of trading hours on a day.
On the date of expiry, the final settlement price is the spot price on the expiry day.
The responsibility of settlement is on a trading cum clearing members for all the
trades done on own account and his clients trades. A professional clearing member
is responsible for settling all the participant trades which he has confirmed to the
exchange. On the expiry date of a futures contract, member submits delivery
information through delivery request window on the trader workstations provided by
NCDEX for all open positions for a commodity for all constituents individually.
NCDEX on receipt of such information and arrives at a delivery position for amember for a commodity.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
44/67
Commodities Market in India
44
The seller intending to make delivery takes the commodity to the designated
warehouse. These commodities have to be assayed by the exchange specified
assayer. The commodities have to meet the contracts specification with allowedvariances. If the commodities meet the specifications, the warehouse accepts them.
Warehouse ensures that the recipes get updated in the depository system giving a
credit in the depositors electronic account. The seller then gives the invoice to his
clearing member, who would courier the same to the buyers clearing member. On
an appointed date, the buyer goes to the warehouse and takes physical possession
of the commodities.
3.11.2.1 Settlement Mechanism
Settlement of commodity futures contracts is a little different from settlement of
financial future which are mostly cash settled. The possibility of physical settlement
makes the process a little more complicated.
Daily mark to market settlement
Example of calculation of mark to market
Spot Price of Sugar = Rs.2903 / 100 kg
Futures price for 15/03/2012 contract = Rs. 2855 /100 kg
Trading unit = 10 metric tonne
long 2855 MTM
10-Mar-12 2857 +2
11-Mar-12 2858 +1
12-Mar-12 2864 +6
13-Mar-12 2861 -3
14-Mar-12 2866 +5
15-Mar-12 2859 -7
Total +4
Total profit = 4 * 100 = Rs 400
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
45/67
Commodities Market in India
45
short 2855 MTM
10-Feb-12 2852 +3
11-Feb-12 2857 -5
12-Feb-12 2860 -3
13-Feb-12 2855 +5
14-Feb-12 2856 -1
15-Feb-12 2850 +6
Total +5
Total profit = 5 * 100 = 500
Final settlement
On the date of expiry, the final settlement price is the spot price on the expiry day. It
is final price at which the contract is closed down. All open positions in a futures
contract cease to exist after its expiration day. The settlement price may be varied
by the exchange if it finds the trading of commodity was volatile in the last trading
days.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
46/67
Commodities Market in India
46
3.11.2.2 Settlement MethodsSettlement of futures contracts can be done in three ways:
1) Physical delivery of the underlying commodity
For open position on the expiry date of the contract, the buyer and the seller can
announce intention for delivery. Deliveries take place in the electronic form. All the
other position are settled in cash.
When a contract comes to settlement, the exchange provides alternatives
like delivery place, month and quality specifications. Trading period, delivery
date etc. are all defined as per the settlement calendar. A member is bound
to provide delivery information. If he fails to give information, it is closed out
with penalty as decided by the exchange.
The delivery place is very important for commodities with significant
transportation costs. The exchange also specifies the precise period (date
and time) during which the delivery can be made.
For many commodities, the delivery period may be an entire month. The
party in the short position (seller) gets the opportunity to make choices from
the above alternatives.
The exchange collects delivery information. Then the exchange selects a
party with an outstanding long position to accept delivery.
After the trading hours on the expiry date, based on the available
information, the matching for deliveries is done, firstly, on the basis of
locations and then randomly keeping in view factors such as available
capacity of the vault/ warehouse, commodities already deposited anddematerialized and offered for delivery and any other factor as may be
specified by the exchange from time to time.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
47/67
Commodities Market in India
47
2) Closing out by offsetting positions
Most of the contracts are settled by closing out open position. In closing out, the
opposite transaction is effected to close out the original future position. A buy
contract is closed out by a sale and a sale contract is closed out by a buy. For
example, Spot for almond is Rs.365 an investor who takes a long position in one
almond futures contract for 30/4/2012 at 364.5, can close his position by selling one
almond futures contracts on 27/04/2012 suppose that Rs.370 is the futures price on
that date. Trading unit for almond at MCX is 500 kg.
Futures contract value = 364.5 * 500 = 182250
Close out price = 370 * 500 = 185000
Profit = 2750
This profit will be credited in his margin account by way of MTM at the end of each
day, and finally at the price that he closes his position, that is Rs.370 in this case.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
48/67
Commodities Market in India
48
3) Cash settlement
Contracts held till the last day of trading can be cash settled. When a contract is
settled in cash, it is marked to market at the end of the last trading day and all
positions are declared closed. The settlement price on the last trading day is the
price closing spot price of the underlying commodity ensuring the convergence of
future prices and the spot prices.
For example On MCX Spot price of Cardamom = Rs.845 and an investor takes a
short position in one cardamom futures contracts expiring on 15/03/2012 at Rs.968
/ kg.
On 15/03/12 the last trading day of the contract, suppose the spot price is Rs.970/
kg.
This is the settlement price for his contract. Trading unit for cardamom is 100 kg.
As a holder of a short position on cardamom, he does not have to actually deliver
the same, but he suffers a loss of Rs.200 (968 * 100 970 *100).This amount is
debited from his account
Settlement dates at MCX and NCDEX
Daily Mark to Market settlement where 'T' is the trading day
Mark to Market Pay-in (Payment): T+1 working day.
Mark to Market Pay-out (Receipt): T+1 working day.
Final settlement for Futures Contracts
The settlement schedule for Final settlement for futures contracts is given by theExchange in detail for each commodity.
Timings for Funds settlement:
Pay-in: On Scheduled day as per settlement calendars.
Pay-out: On Scheduled day as per settlement calendars.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
49/67
Commodities Market in India
49
3.12 Regulation of commodity exchanges
The Forward Contracts (Regulation) Act, 1952 (FCRA) is the principal legislation
for the commodity futures market in India.
The FCRA and the Forward Contracts (Regulation) Rules, 1954 (FCRR) provide
for the regulation of commodity futures trading under a three-tier system, which
consists of the following governing bodies:
the Department of Consumer Affairs, Ministry of Consumer Affairs Food and
Public Distribution
FMC and
an Exchange or Association recognised by the Central Government on the
recommendation of FMC.
FCRA exercises overall regulatory supervision over the commodity exchanges, and
also has the authority to grant or withdraw recognition of any commodity exchange.
The FMC (Forwards Market Commission) was set up in 1953. Most of the
regulatory powers of the Central Government were delegated to the FMC.
The FCRA categorizes commodities into 3 categories for purposes of regulation:
commodities in which forward trading can be undertaken through a
recognized association
commodities in which forward trading is prohibited and
commodities which have neither been regulated for being traded under the
recognized association nor prohibited. Such commodities are referred to as
free commodities and the associations dealing in such free commodities
are required to obtain a certificate of registration from the FMC for trading
thereof.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
50/67
Commodities Market in India
50
3.12.1 Forward Markets Commission
Establishment of the FMC
The FMC has its headquarters at Mumbai and a regional office at Kolkata.
Under the FCRA, it is stipulated that the FMC shall consist of
A Chairman
Two members from amongst the officials of the Ministries or Departments of
the Central Government dealing with Consumer Affairs, Commodity
Derivatives, Food and Public Distribution, Agriculture or Finance
One member from amongst the officials of the Reserve Bank,
Five other members of whom at least three shall be the whole- time
members
Functions of the FMC:
To advise the Central Government in respect of matters arising out of the
administration of the FCRA
To grant or withdraw recognition of any association
To keep forward markets under observation and to take such action in
relation to them as it may consider necessary, in exercise of the powers
assigned to it by or under the FCRA
To collect and publish information regarding the trading conditions in respect
of goods including information regarding supply, demand and prices,etc
To make recommendations generally with a view to improving the
organisation and working of forward markets
Impose circuit filters on commodities and keep a watch on volatility
To regulate the functioning of members of the associations, clearing houses,warehouses and intermediaries
To levy fees for carrying out the purposes of the FCRA
To conduct research for the purpose of development and regulation of
commodity derivatives market
To protect the interests of the market participants in commodity derivatives
markets
To prohibit fraudulent and unfair trade practices relating to commodity
derivatives markets
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
51/67
Commodities Market in India
51
To prohibit insider trading in commodity derivative
SupervisionThe FMC has powers to conduct inspection of accounts of the exchanges and their
members and to inquire into the affairs of the exchanges.
In addition, the FMC shall have the power to suspend member of recognised
association or to prohibit him from trading; supercede governing body of recognised
association and power to suspend business of recognised associations.
Penal Provisions
The FCRA provides for penal provisions in relation to offences involving
contravention of the FCRA and most offences under the FCRA constitute
cognizable offences. The powers of search, seizure and investigation are with the
respective state police authorities.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
52/67
Commodities Market in India
52
3.13 Difference Between Commodity And Financial
Derivatives
There are some features which are very peculiar to commodity derivative markets.
Those are as follows
Physical Settlement
Financial derivatives are cash settled but commodity derivative may be cash settled
or may involve a physical settlement.
The seller will have to deliver the goods to the warehouse and the buyer has to
collect it from the there.
This may sound simple, but the physical settlement of commodities is a complex
process. The issues faced in physical settlement are enormous. There are limits on
storage facilities in different states.
There are restrictions on interstate movement of commodities. Besides state level
octroi and duties have an impact on the cost of movement of goods across
locations.
Warehousing
As the case of physical settlement arises, the exchange requires to make anarrangement with warehouses to handle the settlements.
Such warehouses must have requisite infrastructure and take all precautionary
measures for storing the commodities.
Quality of Underlying Assets
When the underlying asset is a commodity, the quality of the underlying asset is of
prime importance. There may be quite some variation in the quality of what is
available in the marketplace.When the asset is specified, it is therefore important that the Exchange stipulate the
grade or grades of the commodity that are acceptable.
Trading in commodity derivatives also requires quality assurance and certifications
from specialized agencies. In India, for example, the Bureau of Indian Standards
(BIS) under the Department of Consumer Affairs specifies standards for processed
agricultural commodities.
AGMARK, another certifying body under the Department of Agriculture and
Cooperation, specifies standards for basic agricultural commodities.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
53/67
Commodities Market in India
53
Importance of offsetting positions
In equity derivatives if the member has open positions at the end of the contract,
the difference will be settled in cash. But in commodity futures contract if thecontract is of compulsory delivery type and the member does not reverse his
position before the end of the contract than he will have to deliver or collect the
goods.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
54/67
Commodities Market in India
54
3.14 Commodity v/s Equity derivatives
Ever since the first national level commodity exchange was introduced in 2003,commodity exchanges have seen an exponential growth. In the last fiscal, that is,
2010-11 the total turnover of the Indian commodity markets was approximately
Rs.112.52 trillion, an increase of more than 50% as compared to the year 2009-10.
Following the sharp surge in turnover and trade volumes in recent years, the stakes
in commodity trading are higher than ever before. Investment and trading in
commodities is now considered a good alternative investment in the country.
Growth in the commodity market as compared to the equity market
The Indian commodity futures volumes have grown 5.5 times from Rs.20.53 trillion
in 2005-06 to Rs.112.52 trillion in 2010-11. Currently, the average monthly volume
on the Indian commodity exchanges is Rs.6 trillion.
MCX leads the industry, followed by NCDEX. MCX is not only number one in Indiabut has achieved some global milestones too. It was the largest exchange in silver
(in terms of number of futures contracts traded in 2010), number two in gold, copper
and natural gas and number three in crude oil. When we say India is the largest
exchange in silver, it is a great achievement for the Multi Commodity Exchange.
The Indian agricultural commodities market has futures contracts of commodities
such as black pepper, cumin seed, mentha oil and many more which are
internationally traded but only listed in India, internationally traders tend to considerthese as benchmark rates.
For example, exporters from Vietnam, the largest producer of black pepper, are
keeping a close watch on Indian pepper futures. Slowly but steadily the Indian
commodity market is laying a strong foundation for a takeoff in the near future.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
55/67
Commodities Market in India
55
Turnover Growth of Indian commodity Exchanges in Rs Trillions
From Rs.20 trillion, the volumes have reached Rs.112.52 trillion in FY10-11and it
has been a futures market, without Options.
Foreign institutional investors, domestic institutions, banks and insurance
companies are not allowed to trade on the Indian commodity bourses and a
majority of volumes come from jobbers, arbitrageurs, retail traders and small scale
enterprises and corporates (for hedging). Even portfolio management services are
not permitted.
Globally, commodity derivatives volumes are 35x-40x of the physical market but in
India it is just 4x. As the number of participants is increasing by the day and the
overall interest in commodity futures market among traders and investors is
increasing rapidly, the growth potential of this market is immense.
20.53
34.639.01
52.21
73.3
112.52
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
56/67
Commodities Market in India
56
Turnover Growth of Indian Equity Exchanges in Rs Trillions
Comparison of equity and commodity markets.
While the turnover in the equity derivatives segment has grown at a CAGR of
21.70% since FY08, the turnover in the commodity futures market has grown at a
CAGR of 30.32% in the same period.
Over the last few years, the equity market has seen turbulent times due to themeltdown in the global financial markets. In FY09, the equity derivatives turnover
48.24
74.15
133.52
110.22
176.63
292.48
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
-40.00%
-20.00%
0.00%
20.00%
40.00%
60.00%
80.00%
100.00%
2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11
Commodity
Equity
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
57/67
Commodities Market in India
57
had fallen from Rs.133.32 trillion in 2007-08 to Rs.110.22 trillion in 2008-09, a fall of
21%.
On the other hand, the commodities market has seen a steady growth rate over the
years. Being in a nascent stage, the commodities futures market is catching up
rapidly with equities and in the coming years, it has the potential to equal or surpass
the equity turnover.
Reasons for growth of commodities volumes
The reason for the rising trade volumes on the Indian commodity futures exchanges
are:
They provide an efficient platform for hedging against price uncertainty and
global volatility.
The exchanges provide transparent price discovery and hedging platform for
trading futures contracts of different commodities.
On these exchanges, the fair value prices are determined through active
participation of a large number of stakeholders of the commodity value
chain, who have access to information on the demand and supply
conditions.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
58/67
Commodities Market in India
58
3.15 Future Prospects of Indian Commodity exchange.
Introduction of option contracts: Option contracts are currently notallowed on the Indian exchanges. If these contracts are introduced, the
trading volumes will definitely increase.
Allowing for institutional investors participation:FIIs are not allowed to
participate in commodity exchanges, with their participation there will be
benefits like more liquidity, better practices, global experiences etc. But they
also have some risks involved like concentration and control over crucial
commodities, withdrawal from markets etc.
Mutual funds in the market: With commodities like gold providing
interesting returns, the mutual funds can invest in such commodities like
they do in equity market and thus indirectly the retail investors in mutual
funds will get the benefit.
Index Trading: This will give small investors a diversified investment option
that can be easily tracked with an overall knowledge of the commodity
market.
Amendment in Banking Regulations Act: According to the Banking
Regulations Act, banks are not allowed to trade in the commodity
derivatives. But banks have a big role to play in the development of the
commodity market. As they have exposure to agriculture, they would be
better off in case they were able to hedge their positions.
Imposition of Commodity transaction tax: There is a buzz around the
market that the Finance Minster might introduce a Commodity Transaction
Tax(CTT) in the union budget of 2012-13. A CTT of 0.017 per cent, or Rs 17
for every lakh of transactions, on commodity derivatives was announced in
the 2008-09 Budget. However, it was never put to practice, as there were
apprehensions from then the Prime Ministers Economic Advisory Council
(PMEAC).
Impact of CTT
The commodity markets are relatively new and the tax would impact the
volume and liquidity of commodity exchanges.
Though the Agricultural Produce Marketing Committee (APMC) Act has a
provision that says no tax, cess or mandi fee is payable by the farmers, theywill have to pay CTT as it is proposed to be levied on sellers.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
59/67
Commodities Market in India
59
It implies that a farmer, who sells a futures contract to protect himself
against price risk, will be required to pay CTT.
Due to higher volume requirements, exchange charges etc. the participationof farmers is lower and with this kind of tax, the participation will reduce
further.
The commodity, before it comes for trading on the exchange platforms, is
already taxed to the tune of almost 12%, with taxes such as mandi tax,
cess, handling costs and warehousing charges, hence the prices will
increase futher if CTT is introduced.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
60/67
Commodities Market in India
60
4. Conclusion
Due to increasing demand from the developing countries like India and China the
period from 2000 has been a boom for the commodities market. With India being
susceptible to oil prices which drives the overall inflation, investing in commodities
helps in hedging against it and also diversify the investors portfolio.
Since the restart of futures market, the commodity has not seen a backward step
and there is a lot of scope for growth. The government now has to play an active
role to get the farmers educated about the market so that they receive the worth of
their efforts. Banks and NGOs which have their presence in rural India can provide
a helping hand for this purpose.
The infrastructure facilities like warehouses, transportation etc. should be improved
so that the genuine buyers can take physical delivery of goods instead of settling
transaction in cash.
Amendments of FCRA to make FMC autonomous and permitting new derivative
products like options are the need of the future.This introduction will further help
deepen the market & would help in increasing the popularity of such exchanges and
lead to a wider investor base & lesser power in the hands of ruthless traders &
speculators.
With these kinds of reforms there is no doubt that Indian commodity market will
outperform the Indian equity markets.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
61/67
Commodities Market in India
61
5. Bibliography
John C Hull, Options Futures and other derivatives 8th Edition, TMH
publications.
IIBF. Commodity Derivatives Published in 2007. MACMILLAN Publications.
Madhoo Pavaskar, Readings in Commodity Derivative Markets,2010.
Takshashila Academia of Economic Research Publishers.
Magazines Articles-
o Commodity as Asset Class - Commodity Vision, Aug 2011 Edition
Websites
www.mcxindia.com
www.ncdex.com
www.fmc.gov.in
www.business.mapsofindia.com
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
62/67
Commodities Market in India
62
6. Appendix
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
63/67
Commodities Market in India
63
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
64/67
Commodities Market in India
64
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
65/67
Commodities Market in India
65
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
66/67
Commodities Market in India
66
DAY order- A Day order is valid for the day on which it is entered. If the order is not
matched during the day, the order gets cancelled automatically at the end of the
trading day.
GTC - A Good Till Cancelled (GTC) order is an order that remains in the system
until the expiry of the respective contract in which it is entered or until when the
same is cancelled by the member.
GTD - A Good Till Date (GTD) order is valid till the date specified by the member.
After the specified date the unexecuted orders get automatically cancelled by the
system.
IOC - An Immediate or Cancel (IOC) order allows a member to execute the orders
as soon as the same is placed in the market, failing which the order will get
cancelled immediately
Limit Order The order wherein the price is to be specified while placing the
same.
Market Order The order at the best available price at the time of placing the
same.
All or none order - All or none order (AON) is a limit order, which is to be executed
in its entirety, or not at all.
Market price: Market orders are orders for which no price is specified at the time
the order is entered (i.e. price is market price). For such orders, the system
determines the price. Only the position to be taken long/ short is stated. When this
kind of order is placed, it gets executed irrespective of the current market price of
that particular commodity.
Trigger price: Price at which an order gets triggered from the stop-loss book.
8/2/2019 Commodity Market Word
67/67
Commodities Market in India
Spread order: A simple spread order involves two positions, one long and one
short.
They are taken in the same commodity with different months (calendar spread) or inclosely related commodities. Prices of the two futures contract therefore tend to go
up and down together, and gains on one side of the spread are offset by losses on
the other. The spreaders goal is to profit from a change in the difference between
the two futures prices. The trader is virtually unconcerned whether the entire price
structure moves up or down, just so long as the futures contract he bought goes up
more (or down less) than the futures contract he sold.