1. Collateral Damage in Cyberwarfare Mike Chapple mchapple@nd.edu @mchapple

2. What is Collateral Damage? Unintentional damageaffecting facilities, equipment or personnel -USAF Targeting Guide

3. Cyberwar Targeting Issues I. Unintended Effects on Intended Targets II. Unintended Targets III. Intended Effects on Inappropriate Targets

4. Cyberwar Targeting Issues I. Unintended Effects on Intended Targets II. Unintended Targets III. Intended Effects on Inappropriate Targets

5. Stuxnet 12 Source: Symantec

6. Inside an Iranian Nuclear Facility Source: Vitaly Shmatikov 13

7. Another View Source: Vitaly Shmatikov 14

8. Cyberwar Targeting Issues I. Unintended Effects on Intended Targets II. Unintended Targets III. Intended Effects on Inappropriate Targets

9. I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States

10. Collection of [intelligence] is a priority objective and will be pursuedconsistent with the Constitution

11. Telephone Metadata

12. Judge Richard Leon Ruling Almost Orwellian technology To be reasonable under the Fourth Amendment, a search ordinarily must be based upon individualized suspicion of wrongdoing I cannot imagine a more indiscriminate and arbitrary invasion

13. What would you do?

14. Thank You Mike Chapple mchapple@nd.edu @mchapple