1
COMMERCIAL LAWLAW 243
Introduction
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
2
WHAT IS COMMERCIAL LAW?
Commercial law (also known as business law) provides a comprehensive coverage of the law relating to business.
Source: Wu Min Aun & Beatrix Vohrah, Commercial law of Malaysia, Longman Publisher, 2008.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
3
OBJECTIVE OF THE SUBJECT
• Understand the basic principles of law and regulations affecting business transactions.
• Understand the term used in the legal environment of business.
• Apply conceptual knowledge to real problems.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
4
CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Malaysian legal systemChapter 2: Law of contractChapter 3: Negotiable instrumentsChapter 4: Law of agencyChapter 5: Law on hire purchaseChapter 6: Law of partnership
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
5
COMMERCIAL LAW
Chapter 1:
Malaysian legal system
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
6
LEARNING OBJECTIVE
• By the end of this chapter, students should be able to define the word “law” and understand the concept of law in Malaysia.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
7
SUBTOPICS
1. What is law?2. Classification of law3. Sources of Malaysian law4. Judicial system in Malaysia
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
8
CHAPTER 1:MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM
Subtopic 1:
What is law?
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
9
1. WHAT IS LAW?
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
Activity:Brainstorm What comes
toyour mind when you heard the
wordLaw?
10
Cont.
> Oxford Dictionary:
The system of rules which a particular country or community recognizes as regulating the actions of its members and which it may enforce by the imposition penalties.
Source: Oxford dictionary. Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul
Ghani
11
Cont.
> Sir John Salmond
(1862-1924):
The body of principles recognized and applied by the state in the administration of justice.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
12
CHAPTER 1:MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM
Subtopic 2:
Classification of law
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
13
2. CLASSIFICATION OF LAW
LAW
Public law(individual+state)
International law(state+state)
Private law(individual+individual)
Constitutional law
Criminal law
Public international
law
Private International
law
e.g. Law of contract
e.g. LawOf trust
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
14
Cont.
Public law: • The law which governs the relationship between
individuals and the state. • Public law may be further subdivided into two categories
i.e. constitutional law and criminal law. • Constitutional law lays down the rights of individuals in
the state. It deals with questions such as supremacy of Parliament and rights of citizens. It also covers areas dealing with state and federal powers.
• Criminal law codifies the various offences committed by individuals against the state. A crime is a wrong against the state for which punishment is inflicted by the state.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
15
Cont.
International law:• The law which governs the relationship between state
and state.• It may be subdivided into two categories:
1. Public international law
2. Private international law.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011. Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
16
Cont.
Private law:• Private law concerned with matters that affect the rights
and duties of individuals amongst themselves.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011. Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
17
CHAPTER 1:MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM
Subtopic 3:
Sources of Malaysian law
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
18
3. SOURCES OF MALAYSIAN LAW
> The main sources of Malaysian law are:
A. Written law (also referred to as statute law):
1. Federal Constitution
2. State Constitution
3. Legislation
4. Subsidiary legislation
B. Unwritten law:
1. English law
2. Judicial decision
3. Customary law
C. Islamic law
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
19
A. WRITTEN LAW
1. Federal Constitution:- Supreme law of
Malaysia- Provides the powers of
the Federal & State Governments- Provides fundamental
rights of individual
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
20
Cont.
2. State Constitution:
- Regulates State Governments
- Contains provisions derived from 8th schedule of the Federal Constitution
3. Legislation:
- enacted by Parliament and the state assemblies• Act: laws made after 1957• Ordinances: - laws made 1946-1957
- laws in Sarawak
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
21
Cont.
4. Subsidiary legislation:- Laws made under any Acts, Enactments or Ordinances - Very important because specify the laws in more
detail and for everyday matters- Example:
Parent Act (main law) : Hire-Purchase Act 1957Subsidiary Legislation : Hire-Purchase (Repossession)
Regulation- Subsidiary legislation made in contravention of either
a parent Act or the Constitution is void.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
22
B. UNWRITTEN LAW
1. English law:- Applicable in the absence of local laws- Suitable to local circumstances
English Commercial Law?
• Section 5(2) of the Civil Law Act 1956, English commercial law applies to Penang, Malacca, Sabah & Sarawak
• If no local laws applicable• Today, many local laws dealing with commercial matters
e.g. Contracts Act 1950, Partnership Act 1961, Companies Act 1965
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
23
Cont.
2. Judicial decisions:
- Judge’s decision
- Doctrine of binding precedent : Not decide cases arbitrarily- must follow precedents (previous
decisions of similar situations). Each court is bound by the decisions of courts of the same level or higher than it in the same hierarchy of courts, whether or not it believes a decision is correct.
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
24
Cont.
3. Customary law:
- Customs practiced by local people
- Generally, customs relating to family law are given legal force by courts in Malaysia-marriage,
divorce, inheritance
- Sabah and Sarawak: native customary laws apply
- Peninsular Malaysia:
Adat Perpatih - Malays in NS & Naning in Melaka - land, lineage, election of rulers
Adat Temenggung - many states - from Palembang, Sumatra
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
25
C. ISLAMIC LAW
- applicable to Muslims only, does not apply to non Muslims
- family matters (marriage and divorce)- estate matters (inheritance, wasiat)
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
26
CHAPTER 1:MALAYSIAN LEGAL SYSTEM
Subtopic 4:
Judicial system in Malaysia
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
27
4. JUDICIAL SYSTEM IN MALAYSIA
FEDERAL COURTFEDERAL COURT
COURT OF APPEALCOURT OF APPEAL
High Court in MalayaHigh Court in Malaya High Court in High Court in Sabah & S’wakSabah & S’wak
Sessions CourtSessions Court
Magistrates’ CourtMagistrates’ Court
Penghulu’s CourtPenghulu’s Court
Syariah CourtSyariah Court
Session CourtSession Court
Native CourtNative Court Syariah CourtSyariah Court
Magistrates’ CourtMagistrates’ Court
Juvenile Court Juvenile Court
Source: Lee Mei Pheng & Ivan Jeron Detta, Commercial law, Oxford Fajar, 2011.Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
Assignment
28
QUESTIONS
1. The main sources of Malaysian law comprise: statute law, unwritten law and Islamic law (True / False)
2. The following are written law except:
a. Legislation enacted by Parliament and State Assemblies
b. Judicial decisions of the superior courts
c. Subsidiary legislation
d. State Constitutions
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
29
Cont.
3. Unwritten law also referred to as statute law (True / False)
4. In Perak, Malacca, Sabah and Sarawak, English commercial law at the date on which the matter has to be decided is applicable in the absence of local legislation (True / False)
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
30
Cont.
5. Judge decides cases arbitrarily without refer to decided cases (True / False)
6. The following statements are true except:
a. Federal Constitution provides fundamental rights of individual
b. Judge must follow precedents (previous decisions of similar situations)
c. English law applicable in the absence of local laws eventhough not suitable with local circumstances
d. State Constitutions contains provisions derived from 8th schedule of the Federal Constitution
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
31
Cont.
7. Subsidiary legislation made in contravention of either a parent Act or the Constitution is voidable (True / False)
8. Private law is the law which governs the relationship between individuals and state (True / False)
• Define the word ‘law’?______________________________________________________________________________________
10. What is meant by ‘judicial precedent’?______________________________________________________________________________________
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani
32
THANK YOU!
Copyright lecture notes prepared by Miss Fadhilah binti Abdul Ghani