8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 1/25
1
A new orientalism?
The Anglo-Gothic imagination in East London by Phil Cohen
Some reflections on the Gothic Revival in East End Literature
Introduction: an everyday story of the Barbaresque
At the beginning of 1995, the London Evening Standard ran a series of special reports on the
condition of East London, under the title ‘The Betrayed’. The declared aim was to ‘reveal how so
many of its citizens live an underprivileged existence in the shadow of the success of this great
capital’. The series rehearsed many of the key themes of a journalistic campaign run over a
century earlier by WT Snead in the Pall Mall Gazette—in a series of articles on juvenile crime,
female prostitution and urban decay under the title ‘the Maiden Tribute of Modern Babylon’
which did much to set the terms of public debate and intervention into the life of the East End
from the 1880s until the First World War and beyond.
The Standard report examined what it called ‘the blood-stained face of race relations in East
London, exacerbated by poverty and disease’. The front page showed a picture of white youth,
under the caption: ‘Cannon Street Whitechapel and the random victim of an Asian gang stumble
to safety, his head pouring with blood. ‘
This picture is used to introduce and in a sense anchor the main theme of the report, which is that
Bangladeshi gangs are on the rampage, picking on innocent white people in a form of reverse
racism, committing gratuitous acts of revenge for the harassment they have suffered over the
years at the hands of white East Enders. This message is underlined on the inside cover, where
there is a photograph of a group of Bangladeshi boys lined up across a street, in a gangsta-style
‘they shall not pass’ pose.
Of course, this graphic realism is no less constructed than the meaning of the picture itself. But
what seems so peculiar about the text that is supposed to authenticate it, is that it is couched in
such florid sensationalist terms, as if it were a piece of popular fiction, rather than a
demonstration of sociological fact.
The introductory paragraph gives the flavour, and is worth quoting in full:
By the time we reached the street there was blood everywhere. The muffled crash we heard while
we were talking in the Golden Lion Social Club must have been the bottle breaking on his head.
Under the streetlights, the bloodied glass was being ground into the pavement by the boots that came again and again, pounding at the stranger’s body. They were about 20 of them a nd they all
ran off together, melting into the night. Their victim looked like he had blundered out of a
Tarantino movie. He was spitting out the blood trickling into his mouth. His companion, although
unharmed, was clearly in shock. We were just walking back from the pub. It sounded like a pathetic
bleat of protest. Why us? Such a question on a dark night in Cannon Street Whitechapel can only
be rhetorical. He knew why and so did we. His friend, gathering his wits, dabbed at the blood in his
eyes. He was i n no doubt. It’s because we’re white, mate.
We are back in the torrid world of Victorian melodrama and slum fiction, now remade into a
Tarantino movie. As readers we are deliberately turned into the spectators of a piece of cinema or
street theatre, which has been staged for our benefit. The dramatic quality of the mise en scene isenhanced by not revealing the colour of victim and assailant until the last sentence. The holding
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 2/25
2
back of the key racial descriptor (‘it’s because we’re white, mate’) and its sudden revelation
functions as a kind of denouement, a shock tactic designed to encapsulate the main point of the
argument:
Attacks, assaults, hatred —there is a mood of gothic barbarity amongst the poor and the angry
encapsulated in this warning by the 21-year-old posse leader in the Golden Lion Social Club. ‘We
are the majority, we are strong. If anyone gives us trouble we will hurt them.’ Yes, that much isknown. We have the picture that proves it.
The reference to the gothic has a double meaning in this context. It certainly evokes a return to a
new dark ages brought about by the advent of an alien, uncivilized anti-Christian power in our
midst. Islamaphobia rules OK!
This, too, is a well-rehearsed theme. The Victorian urban explorers frequently used racial imagery
to define the ‘natives’ of the East End as primitives; with the settlement of colonies of Chinese,
Malays, and Africans in Docklands areas, and then the advent of Jewish immigrants from Eastern
Europe, the non-Christian, non-occidental character of the area became a topic of increasing
public concern. Just as the West End was sharpening its image as the cosmopolitan hub of a
worldwide Empire, so it was felt to be increasingly menaced by the East End as a kind of Internal
Orient, a dark mysterious continent whose dense localisms formed the heart of That Other
England, where the Empire was already preparing to strike back.
Its first cartographer was Thomas De Quincey. In The Confessions of an English Opium Eater he
discusses his experiences with the ‘oriental drug’ and his explorations as an East End flaneur in
almost identical terms. His dreams are crowded with turbulent processions of Chinese and Malays,
in street bazaars where he is forever lost and wandering in search of forbidden pleasures, pursued
by the monstrous fauna and flora of the Ganges and the Nile. Then he describes himself walking in
an East End ‘surrounded on all sides with a sea of myriad shapes in which everything fluctuates as I
seek to find an individual human face ‘within the indistinguishable mass of this surplus population
so reminiscent of the swarming continent of Asia’.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 3/25
3
De Quincey also observes in the language and gestures of this East Enders ‘the subtle signs of
subversion, the Jacobin influence’. He is both fascinated by the promiscuity of the urban crowd
and fears its powers of social contagion and combination, and he locates both in an imaginary
geography where the East represents what he calls the barbaresque: the negation of everything
that the West stands for.
As John Barrell shows in his important study, De Quincey’s fear of being ‘contaminated’ byphysical or social contact was also an important theme in his anti-Semitism. In one notorious
passage he writes of ‘men’s natural abhorrence of the Jewish taint, as once in Jerusalem they had
hated the leprosy and cholera (oriental diseases), because even while they raved against it the
secret proofs of it could be detected amongst their own kindred’.
In the portrayal of the East End as a centre of foreign immigration, anti-Semitism and orientalism
increasingly converged in constructing an alien threat which is both global in scope and intensely
local in effect. In the process, Jews are increasingly confused with ‘Orientals’. For example one of
the witnesses from a local community settlement cross-examined during the police enquiry into
the Jack the Ripper murders described living conditions in the Jewish quarters in the following
terms:
There is something of the Oriental bazaar about the Jewish market, the swarms of unkempt
children running hither and thither on countless errands, the women haggling with each other,
shouting to make themselves heard over the general hubbub, the men scurrying in and out of dark
alleyways, the whole effect is one of labyrinthine confusion which can scarcely fail to make a
fearful impression on the casual visitor.
In the sober deliberations from the House of Commons Select Committee on Housing in 1901 we
find the following exchange:
Lord Robert Cecil: What do you say about the inhabitants?
Lord Lupton: Most of the inhabitants are Jews and their habits are said to be clean so far as their
persons go, but certainly the courts outside their houses are…
Lord Robert Cecil: Eastern in character.
Lord Lupton: Yes that is so exactly.
The Jews referred to were of course Ashkenazes from the shetls of Eastern Europe, not Sephardis
from North Africa or the Middle East, but this conflation is entirely characteristic of both popular
and official perceptions of the period. At the same time, moral panics around drugs and sexuality
that focused on the Chinese community of Limehouse in the late Victorian and Edwardian period
included many features borrowed from anti-Semitism. As Marek Kohn has shown, the theme of a
criminal underworld organized by a secret oriental conspiracy, which was popularized by Sax
Rohmer in his Fu Manchu novels, owed much of its logic to the Protocols of the Elders of Zion.
Another point of convergence was the white slave trade. If opium was a medium of seduction of
white women by ‘men of colour’, their induction into oriental perversity was supposed to lead
inexorably to their final fall into the hands of Jewish pimps who shipped them out to the brothels
of the Middle East. Finally, the Asian and Jewish communities were accused of a common
duplicity; the outward appearance of respectability and even prosperity was only a cloak for
hidden cruelty or corruption undermining both family and nation. Jewish money allied to Oriental
vice was a channel linking East End with West End, directly injecting moral infection into the
civilized heart of the metropolis.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 4/25
4
This close articulation of Orientalism and Anti-Semitism has been an important element in both
literary and journalistic representations of the East End over the past century. But it is important
to stress that the idea of the East End as an internal orient was not confined in its application to
Jews. The Irish and English working class were also recruited—cockney urchins, for example, were
routinely redescribed as street Arabs.
What this form of Orientalism drew upon and radicalized was a certain more general way of thinking and feeling about the city, and in particular its ‘spectral geographies’, its ‘other scenes’ in
which the gothic has played a central role. This tradition has been powerfully renewed in much
recent writing and painting which takes London’s post-industrial development to the east of the
City as its subject. In the second part of this study I will be looking at this body of work in some
detail, in order to analyse its relation to the cultural turn in regeneration. In this first part of the
study I want to trace and situate its provenance in a broader historical perspective.
Bare ruined choirs
‘High Towers, faire temples, goodly theatres
strong walls, rich porches, princely palaces
large streets, brave houses, sacred sepulchres
All those ( o pitie) now are turned to dust
and overgrown by black oblivion’s dirt.‘
Edmund Spenser, The Ruins of Time
‘It is often our mightiest projects that betray the degree of our insecurity. We gaze at them in
wonder —a kind of wonder which is itself a form of dawning horror, for we know somehow by
instinct that outsize buildings cast the shadow of their own destruction before them and are
designated from the first with an eye t o their later existence as ruins.‘
WG Sebald, Austerlitz
In an essay on the peculiarities of English modernism, Eric Hobsbawm has argued that its roots
were paradoxically gothic: ‘In the smoky workshop of the world, a society of egoism and aesthetic
vandals, where the small craftsman so visible elsewhere in Europe could no longer be seen in the
fog generated by the factories, the medievalism of peasants and artisans had long seemed a
model of a society both socially and artistically more satisfactory.‘
The argument skilfully points up the possible continuities, as well as the tension between the anti-
industrial, anti-urban bias of many English socialists and social reformers, such as John Ruskin and
Ebenezer Howard, and the aristocratic taste for the gothic and its revival in late Victorian literature
and the arts. If the Gothic imagination provided a privileged medium for the English encounter
with modernism, it was because it provided both a language and a landscape in which the ghostsin the machinery of industrial capitalism—the hidden hands who kept its engines of growth in
motion—could first be called up and then, if not laid to rest, at least usefully employed in the
historical task of accomplishing its downfall and final ruin.
The typical mise en scene of the gothic novel features half-destroyed structures, often ancient, or
mediaeval (and more recently modern) buildings which have either fallen into decay or disrepair,
or been subject to attack, through vandalism or bombardment. These buildings contain secret
chambers, subterranean passages, trapdoors, underground vaults, putrefying corpses, all of which
have an important narrative function in evoking a past that has been forgotten or ignored, rather
than cultivated or celebrated as a living heritage and which returns as a threatening or disruptive
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 5/25
5
force. The gothic thus represents what has been repressed or made unrepresentable by modernity
but which returns to haunt it.
According to this line of thinking, if capitalism established itself as the great civilization of
modernity by destroying the modes of production that preceded it, it was only to give birth to a
force that would one day just as violently supersede it; the mission of the Anglo-Gothic
imagination was to give this process a local habitation and a name: William Blake called it Los;those who followed in his footsteps spoke of Babylon: an outcast London whose grandest
architectures remain overshadowed by sepulchral ruins, and whose brightest thoroughfares are
haunted by an afflicted populace, bodies and minds ravaged by what capital had made of them.
Blake sets the scene:
I wandered through each chartered street
Near where the chartered Thames does flow
And marked in every face I meet
marks of weakness, marks of woe
I also stood in Satans bosom and beheld its desolations:
A ruined man, a ruin’d building of God, not made with hands
Its mountains of marble terrible
Its pits and declivities flowing with molten ore and fountains
Of pitch and nitre; its ruin’d palaces &d cities & mighty works
Its furnaces of affliction in which his Angels and Emanations
Labour with blackened visages among its stupendous ruins
Arches, & pyramids and porches, colonnades and domes,
In which dwells Mystery, Babylon
Those who followed in his footsteps as explorers of ‘London Babylon’ were not always as anxious
as Blake to resist the assimilation of ruin sentiment to the picturesque. His apocalyptic vision of
history, in which the dreadful has already happened, his evocations of the Uncanny, that twilight
world in which the living and the dead, the animate and inanimate, become strangely confused,
has, however provided a major resource for writers and painters attracted to what might be called
the metropolitan sublime. They have given us a city whose traffic with the world follows
mysterious lines of desire not to be found on any planners’ map: itineraries and encounters with
London’s ‘other scene’, which the long march of municipal improvement has tried in vain to sweep
from the streets. Anywhere the urban underclass and the bohemian demi-monde mingle and
trade, under whatever name—the slum, the rookery, the red light district, the immigrant quarter,
the zone of transition—generates its own hidden economy whose highly social but nevertheless
largely immaterial forms of productivity point to the limits of the fully rationalized city. It is in and
through these sites, at any rate, that the Anglo-Gothic imagination has made itself fully at home in
the idioms of metropolitan modernity.
Moreover, if the dynamism of the modern city, driven by the ‘monstrous’ productivity of capital
was to be its own downfall, then at least its proletarian gravediggers had to be trained up as future
keepers of the ruins. This was the ‘pedagogic’ task which the artists and poets of the Romantic
Movement assigned to themselves, and which marked out their ambivalent identification, as a
self-conscious Bohemian intelligentsia, with the liberation struggles of the oppressed urban
masses.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 6/25
6
Rejecting the picturesque rural scene in favour of the sublime terrors of the metropolitan abyss, it
was not difficult for a Poe, a Baudelaire, or an ETA Hoffman, even, nearer home, for a James
Thompson or Arthur Machen, to discover the labyrinth, the secret passage, the dungeon, and all
the other characteristic devices of the gothic mise en scene in the ‘wastelands’ of the working-
class city with its maze of courtyards and alleyways, its cellars and dead ends. In their hands the
eighteenth-century gothic ruin with its ‘tottring battlements dressed with rampant ivy’s
unchecked growth’ is relocated in the dilapidated tenements and ‘dark Satanic mills’ where the‘dangerous, perishing and labouring classes’ were confined. In urbanizing and modernizing the
ruin, their aim was purely cartographic; as good Bohemians they wanted to map the territory, to
conserve its danger and its difference, not to reform or translate it into some approximation of the
‘bourgeois thing’.
James Thompson in The City of Dreadful Night (1874) made the link between the ancient and the
modern in these terms:
The city is ruinous, although
Great ruins of an unremembered past
With others of a few short years agoMore sad and found within its precincts vast.
This promiscuous intermingling of ruins created a spectral geography in which distinctions of
wealth and poverty were magically erased. These connoisseurs of urban dereliction were too
invested in ‘ruin sentiment’ and what might still be excavated imaginatively from it—the evidence
of a long and continuous national history, in which ruptures and breaks, even the devastations of
war, could be recuperated as part of an organic (albeit entirely invented) tradition—to want to see
the slums of the Victorian city demolished altogether.
Their plan view of London Babylon thus had little concern with such mundane matters as street
lighting, sanitation and new model dwellings, let alone the Clean Air Act. Such improvements
would only have the effect of destroying the city as an aesthetic resource. The capital city
envisioned by the Fabians and other municipal reformers who were to found the London County
Council was neither mysterious, awesome, terrifying or sublime; their modest programme of
public works and parks, their hygienic vision of Suburbia, was as useless for entertaining the
prospect of revolution as for contemplating the retrospect of civilizational decay and decline. But
it was the Bourgeois Fabians not the Bohemian Conservationists who won the day.
In the 1860s and 70s more of London was rebuilt that at any time since the Great Fire of 1666. As
Lynda Nead has shown, large parts of the central and inner city were turned into a vast building
site, as the Metropolitan board of works and the railway companies undertook the widening and
straightening of roads, creating new thoroughfares levelling and tunnelling wherever they went. In
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 7/25
7
a novel of the period that saw the upheaval of modernization in frankly apocalyptic terms, the
hero remarks:
I was astounded in coming again into the busy city to observe great changes wrought in its
appearance. Some of the bridges over the river that I had left intact were nearly demolished and
others were springing up supplant them. Market place hotel and houses were in ruins or had put
on a new aspect. Arches had risen over many thoroughfares and trains swept above and betweenhouses to the jeopardy of upper tenements and tenants. What with the digging and pulling down,
building and improving I could scarcely recognize the old streets
But these improvements were unevenly distributed. The main effect was to clear large areas of
Holborn and Westminster of its residual rookeries and drive ‘outcast London’ eastwards. The Mile
End Road and the Peoples Palace also exemplified the new municipalism, but as for the rest,
London became an increasingly visible tale of two cities: The West End as the glittering home to
the conspicuous consumption of a new leisure class; and the East End, where home-grown
workshop industries joined hands with international trade and commerce to support a large,
almost exclusively working-class population and a hidden economy which provided a major
additional resource for the area’s diverse immigrant communities.
There were two responses to this new spatial alignment of leisure and labour, wealth and poverty.
The first, focused on East London itself, we have already briefly characterized as a form of internal
Orientalism, drawing on the tropes, and characterology of popular gothic literature to construct
the area as wholly Other, and its denizens as members of a ‘race apart’. WT Snead in the The
Maiden Tribute) already referred to, drew on the imagery of the Book of Revelation, with its vision
of the apocalyptic destruction of cities, to explore ‘that strange inverted world that is the London
labyrinth’ and portrays the dreadful consequences of allowing a great part of the capital to
become ‘a den of iniquity’.
Although Mayhew and Booth eschewed such overt religious imagery, their accounts of East
London’s life and labour, for all their claims to ethnographic authenticity or scientific objectivity
were not averse to taking a leaf or two out of Dickens’ books (especially Oliver Twist and Dombey
and Son) to graft some kind of realism onto material that all too readily lent itself to the
sensational emplotments of the gothic novel.
Through these various narrative devices the East End was sealed off as a site of urban dereliction:
either rendered into a mysterious underworld entirely enclosed within its own densely
impenetrable meanings, or else shown as a capillary power structure surreptitiously infiltrating the
‘over world’ through the traffic in dangerous drugs, sex, and ideas.
The docks and their immediate hinterlands became central to this new iconography because they
could be made to represent both versions of the story: an intensely local, almost closed
community which nevertheless controlled a key artery of international trade; a potent force in the
organized labour movement and the new unionism but an equally significant presence in the East
End’s hidden economy.
Little wonder that the Dockers themselves played such an important role in what the East End was
made to represent about the state of the nation as a whole: at once the backbone of the nation
and a race apart, patriotic cockneys and congenital crooks, heroic boxers and athletes, as well as
sexual rough trade; the figure of the docker in its very duplicity came to focus all the ambivalent
identifications which both bourgeois and bohemian entertained towards the East End and its
diversely dangerous classes.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 8/25
8
The second response to the modernizing process was to focus on the West End and the City and
apply the devices of romantic ruinology to the task of deconstructing its pretensions of power as
exemplified in its great public buildings.
Hubert Robert had first popularized the genre by imagining the Louvre in ruins—sacked by a
victorious proletariat, a visual polemic made by a disgruntled aristocrat shortly after the fall of the
Bastille. In similar fashion Joseph Gandy depicted the newly built Bank of England as a classical
Piranesi ruin and the Compte de Volney in his classic account of Revolution and Empire producednumerous imaginary pictures of the great cities of the world in ruins to illustrate his pessimistic
thesis about the rise and fall of civilizations, in an argument which bears closely on Marx’s
observations about ‘the mutual ruin of the contending classes’.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 9/25
9
In 1872 the French engraver Gustave Dore teamed up with travel writer Blanchard Jerrold to
produce London: A Pilgrimage, a guided tour of the city based on a geography of contrasts
between high society and lowlife, West End and East. Dore had a profound fascination with the
grotesque; he illustrated Grimm’s Fairy Tales, Poe’s short stories, Dante’s Divine Comedy. In what
was ostensibly a travel book, he uses his skill with chiaroscuro effects to depict the tale of two
cities—one of glittering light and the other of murky depths, associated here not so much withcapital and labour as with the worlds of the rentier and the criminal. His pictures of slum housing
have been endlessly reproduced and, for example, provided the visual inspiration for the Crown
Film Unit’s classic inter-war documentary on the subject, which in turn had an important influence
of post war urban planning. But for all that he was not after documentary realism, but its gothic
equivalent.
We can see this is an etching captioned ‘a New Zealander contemplating the ruins of a once great
and powerful city’. It shows an artist seated on a broken arch of London Bridge sketching a
cathedral like ruin. On closer inspection this building turns out not to be a church but the brand
new Cannon Street Station (completed in 1873) here imagined with the cast iron piers of the
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 10/25
10
bridge rusting away in the tidal ooze. The railway whose coming had done so much to transform
London into a modern metropolis is thus rendered into a piece of obsolete industrial archaeology.
This conceit gives a new twist to an old tale. The figure of the native from the new world
contemplating the ruins of London was already well established by the time Dore came to depict
his version of the scene. It was mentioned by Gibbon in his study of the Decline and Fall of the
Roman Empire and also in a throwaway comment by Macauley. In Archimago, a gothic ruin novelpublished in 1864, the scene is vividly described:
I sit upon the last crumbling stones of that bridge, erst the famous London Bridge Pavement,
footway, parapet abutment pillar, pier all are gone… and I on the last few mouldering stones
survey the ruin’d and desolate city.
Subsequently, Dore’s picture, with its theme of the artist triumphantly surveying (and surviving)
the destruction of modern technology has been taken up by Michael Moorcock, one of the key
figures in the contemporary renaissance of urban ruin fiction. In ‘Mother London’ and in a series of
science fiction stories written from the vantage point of the late twenty-first century Moorcock
has been concerned to construct an archaeology of the present in the form of a counterfactual
history in which ‘modernity’ is just a blip on the screen. And true to Hobsbawm’s formula, he
imagines the future as a regression to a mediaeval world of villages and primitive agriculture:
We reached the ancient village of Suthuk which is on the edge of the river bed of the Thames, most
of which is reclaimed land planted with cabbages, the export of which form the principle staple of
the country.
Our first destination was the vestiges of the once famous Lun-dun Bridge mentioned in many
ancient accounts and in one folk lore ballad which has come down to us beginning ‘Lun-Dun bridge
is falling down’ Several arches of this structure now span the intervening space between the village
of Suthuk and the extremely picturesque ruins which are visible on the summit of an opposite
eminence.
These ruins are all that is left of the once famous Cockni cathedral of St Pauls. Several benighted
peasants we are told claim to be the last survivors of the tribe of the Cocknies now began to gather
round us and to offer for barter certain objects they had dug up-many of which possessed a certain
archaeological interest.
Altogether the impression made on us was one of admiration mingled with awe and wonder at
these monuments of a past civilization. No doubt it seemed to the inhabitants of ancient Angleland
and their mighty city of Lun-dun that they would escape the fate that had overtaken Assyria, Egypt
Greece and Rome, that the solidity of their structures would escape the tooth of time, But although
they have thus passed away and left nothing but these relics to attest to their former glory yet theEnglish people played their part in the hastening the ultimate civilisation of the world and its
adjacent planets which we today witness.
Indeed there are few places which promise a great attract for a summer holiday that the ruins of
ancient Lun-dun.
All that is solid melts into fog and marsh
‘I watched the sun
On lurid morns on monstrous afternoons
Push out through fog with his dilated disk
And startle the slant roofs and chimney potsWith splashes of fierce colour. or I saw
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 11/25
11
Fog only, the great tawny weltering fog
Involve the passive city, strangle it
Alive, and draw it into the void
Spires, bridges, streets, and squares, as if a sponge
Had wiped out London—or as noon and night
Had clapped together and utterly struck out
The intermediate time, undoing themselves
In the act.. Your city poets see such things.
But sit in London at the days decline
And view the city perish in the mist
Like Pharaoh’s armaments in the deep red sea
Then surprised
By a sudden sense of vision and of tune
You feel as conquerors though you did not fight…’
Elisabeth Barrett Browning, Aurora Leigh, 1857
‘Picture a land of mist and mud… London as an immense, sprawling rain drenched metropolis
stinking of soot and hot iron and wrapped in a perpetual mantle of smoke and fog… ceaseless
activity in warehouses and on wharves washed by the dark slimy waters of an imaginary Thames in
the midst of the forest of masts, a tangle of beams and girders piercing the pale lowering clouds.
Up above trains raced by at full speed and down in the underground sewers others rumbled along
occasionally emitting ghastly screams or vomiting floods of smoke through the gaping mouths of
airshafts’
Huysmans A Rebours (1884)
‘Unreal city
Under the brown fog of a winter dawn A crowd flowed over London Bridge, so many
I had not thought death had undone so many.‘
TS Eliot, The Wasteland
At night, while he was working on the ‘London Pilgrimage’, Dore, accompanied by a minder,
wandered the streets of Limehouse and Cable street with sketch pad in hand, part flaneur , part
slummer, part artist in residence. But his days were spent at the Café Royal, mixing in what was
then known as the ‘haute boheme‘ Oscar Wilde was a member of the circle and so too was James
McNeill Whistler and Claude Monet while they were in town to paint the Thames red, yellow,
vermillion and green. Both artists has been attracted to London by a phenomenon which served toblur the outlines of its distinctive and divided social geography—it famous fogs.
The smoke was Victorian and Edwardian London’s second name. ‘Peasoupers’ turned day into
night, rendered the most modern parts of the metropolis once more mysterious, and terrifying;
under the brown fog of a winter dawn even the most brightly lit and open thoroughfares suddenly
became spectral and unreal places, traffic ground to a halt, and thousands of Londoners, especially
the very young and the old, suffered and died prematurely of respiratory illness.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 12/25
12
The Thames was the prime attractor of fogs, whose cause, of course, lay principally elsewhere, in
the large scale domestic and industrial burning of coal throughout the city. But this association
between metropolitan miasma and an increasingly polluted river (the Thames was in effect an
open sewer carrying both industrial and human waste leading to the Great Stink of 1851)enhanced the scandal that was Babylon; Ruskin in ‘Storm, cloud of the 19th century’ portrayed fog
as a physical sign not just of industrialism but of its morally polluting effect on the human
condition while Huysmans elaborated a whole cartography of special landscape effects predicated
on the spectral gloom.
If Dore was concerned to depict the grotesque effect of London’s fogs on the lungs of its people,
Whistler and Monet were more interested in its aesthetic properties. Monet was intrigued by the
way fog transformed light and colour, and in his London river paintings he uses broken masses of
colour to create smudged surfaces and blurred outlines which give the canvas its layered painterly
texture and organize the composition. No wonder he was on record as saying that what he adored
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 13/25
13
most about London was the fog, since in his eyes it made the city look ever more like one of his
own impressionist paintings: Nature imitating art imitating the environment.
In contrast, Whistler’s etchings of the Thames (the famous nocturne series) tried to made
dockland look not picturesque but sublime; using a range of diffused tints to envelop each scene,
he paints the river as if it were the further shore of some industrial Byzantium, so effectively
vaporising the squalor which Dore invested with such fine graphic detail.The indeterminacy of form, the uncanny reversals of figure and ground which fog gives to a
landscape, was for Whistler, as for many urban Romantic poets, an incitement to imagine another
world—the Isle of Dogs as the Isle of Doges. As Whistler put it in his diary:
And when the evening most clothes the riverside with poetry as with a veil and the poor buildings
lose themselves in the dim sky and the tall chimneys become campanili and the warehouses were
palaces in the night and the whole city hangs in the heavens and fairy land is before us.
Elisabeth Browning (see quote above) castigates the city poets for their moral passivity in the face
of urban degradation and the all too easy victories achieved by their aesthetic resolution of it into
a metropolitan sublime; but the kind of subtle alchemy wrought by dusk or the painterly palette,the cosmetic makeover achieved by fog, the consoling melancholy of ruins, these devices of
imaginative transformation offered a powerful symbolic substitute for the kinds of material
change associated with social and political struggle—struggles in which, I have argued, the
bohemian subculture inhabited by painters and writers had little real interest or stake.
The apocalyptic vision of the capital’s ruin had one further resource: its cemeteries. Cities of the
dead, abandoned cities where only the undead roam, generalised the topos of the gothic novel to
the modern urban condition. Eliot’s vision of office worker-zombies streaming across London
Bridge (‘so many, I had not thought death had undone so many’) feeds upon a vein of poetic
imagery that, as we have seen, has a long provenance. But in giving urban gothic a
characteristically modern twist, he points it in a direction whose more radical implications he istemperamentally, and ideologically, reluctant to pursue. For Necropolis is where the power of
living labour gives way to dead labour, and where the Holy Church of Capital gets finally to rule
OK.
London had always relied on a large reserve army of labour to service its economy, many of them
East End immigrants. But one effect of the rising organic composition of capital in the drive for
profit was to replace the combinatory powers of labour with new technologies as the key driver of
productivity and growth. The long, uneven (and never fully completed) transition from small
workshop production to the Fordist machine age meant that dead labour (the value of labour
power embodied in machines) rather than living labour (the trade skills of manual workers) was
now widely regarded as the animating force of London’s economic vitality.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 14/25
14
In consequence a growing population of casual or intermittent workers, whose mobility was
governed by both seasonal and cyclical fluctuations in demand was added to the ranks of the
urban underclass, as were the hidden hands who serviced the new metropolitan consumer
culture. The ratio of ghosts in the machine—those whom dead labour had undone—to those who
continued to embody the meaning of work as the living creation of value, shifted decisively in
favour of zombiedom.
In the age of machinofacture, the bodily metaphors which had hitherto described—and
naturalised—the process of London’s de and re/generation were in any case bei ng made
increasingly redundant. In their place mechanistic metaphors of reproduction—of function and
dysfunction modelled the city’s spatial divisions of labour as the basis for organising them into
distinctive zones of regulation. Those places, populations and practices which fell through the
rationalising grid found themselves confined to a new form of urban liminality —a twilight zone in
the interstices of metropolitan modernity, where they morphed easily into figures of an existing
gothic landscape.
The vast cemeteries that were built to provide a last resting place for London’s growing population
were often built in the East, where land was cheap and, just as important unfitted for any otherpurpose. This necropolis was Victorian London’s edge city drawing around itself a whole nexus of
social, cultural and economic activity; in the twentieth century, as the city sprawled ever further
eastwards into the Essex marshlands turning them into the suburban bad lands of Chingford,
Romford, and Dagenham, the romantic ruinologists used the movement of both the living and the
dead to good effect to create a whole new space of representation for the urban uncanny.
Marshes had long been a part of the gothic vocabulary—the home of pestilential fogs, and solitary
rumination, belonging neither to land nor sea, but where these elements enter into their most
intimate dialogue. The vast muddy indistinction of sky, water and shore that is the Thames Estuarywas host to a endless speculations about the porousness or permeabi lity of the nation’s
boundaries—as well as to doubts about the loyalties and residential status of those who lived
there. Cockneys kids might be happy as mud larks playing on the holiday ‘beaches’ of Canvey, but
anyone quite so at home in the tidal ooze was at the very least an anthropological curiosity, and
not to be regarded as a fully-fledged member of the ‘island race’ unless otherwise specified.
For the ruinologist the very indeterminacy of the marshy habitat provided an ideal setting for the
telling of cautionary tales about the transience of human existence and/or the vanity of the
grandiose monuments to Industry and Empire which now dominated the capital’s skyline. In After
London, Richard Jeffries draws on one of the original uses of the gothic ruin, as a site for
contemplating the triumph of nature over the follies of man to paint a powerful picture of this
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 15/25
15
new Babylon, a megalopolis strangled by its own monstrously destructive forces of production and
reverting to the organic vegetative condition of marshland. Mud, slime and ooze become the
symptomatic medium of destruction, carrying the trace elements of the ruined civilisation to a
watery grave.
‘When the wind collects the miasma and as it were presses it together it becomes visible as a low
cloud which hangs over the place. They say the sun is sometimes hidden when the vapour isthickest —it is plain there are no fishes in the water all the rottenness of a thousand years is there
festering under the water.
Vast marshes now cover the site of ancient London; through there is no doubt that in the days of
old there flowed the River Thames. The river had become partially choked from the cloaca of the
ancient city which poured into it through enormous subterranean aqueducts and drains... When
this had been going on for some time the river unable to find a channel began to overflow into the
deserted streets and especially to fill the underground passages and drains of which the number
and extent was beyond all power of words to describe. The waters underneath built up and burst
in, the houses fell in and the huge metropolis was overthrown. All those parts which were built on
low ground are become marches and swamps. There was nothing visible but trees and hawthornson the upper lands, willows reeds and rushes on the lower. These crumbling ruins still more choked
the river and almost but not quite turned it back —there is no channel through to the salt ocean—it
is a vast stagnant swamp which no man dare enter since death would be his inevitable fate.‘
The theme of the deluge clearly links to contemporary anxieties created by the great public
works—and in particular the renewal of the sewers taking place in London at this time. The
metaphor of flood is also closely associated to the fear of uncontrolled flow of populations, just as
the crumbling tenement is used to evoke the dissolution of Empire from within. This whole
network of associations stabilised a certain apocalyptic vision of London’s future as its long
imperial and industrial decline gathered pace. But then history intervened to produce a ruination
whose catastrophic scope and scale created a new and more dreadful city of the dead beyond thewildest nightmares of the Anglo-gothic imagination.
And then came the Blitz
‘A generation that had gone to school of a horse drawn streetcar now stood under the sky in a
countryside in which nothing remained unchanged but the clouds and beneath those clouds, in a
field of force of destructive torrents and explosions, was the tiny fragile human body.‘
Walter Benjamin
‘Blitzkrieg has come to London in all its fury and brutality and filth.. Death drops from the skies. It
falls on the just and the unjust. It strikes against the weak, the humble, the unoffending. Fire, ruin,explosion, murder stalk through our streets and work their will, not without impediment, but
without any single restraint which humanity normally imposes on the devilry of man... How can
human frames parry such b lows of metal? How can human brains withstand such endless
pounding? The mighty machine rattles on and obliterates flesh and blood in its giant cogs and
pincers
Something flowers among the ruins, something so fine and noble that not all the powers of hell can
destroy it —t he courage of our people.’
London Evening Standard editorial, September 1940
‘The world of the blitz was a world in which the everyday and the unthinkable existed side by sidewith the two continuing changing place. To those living through the Blitz it often seemed as if life
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 16/25
16
was divided by the clock, factory, office or domestic routine by day —hell and devastation let loose
when darkness fell. The courage of so called ordinary people was shown by the way they passed
from one world to the other without br eaking down or cracking up.’
Charles Madge
‘If Wrens most beautiful churches and some of the Cities most noble and historic buildings are
damaged irreparably they have taken with them in their passing some of the dreariest and meanest stretches of Victorian office building. The hun is giving us a priceless opportunity to
reconceive the city on a more rational and liveable plan…’
McDonald Hastings, London Calling, December 1940
The advent of aerial warfare, and in particular the bombardment of cities from the air, was
perhaps the single greatest instigator of twentieth-century urbanism. Since Booth’s great Survey
of London Life and Labour, the search for panoptic strategies of urban planning and governance
aimed to create standpoints from which it was possible not only to map the city’s physical
geography street by street, but to comprehend its social patterns and economic prospects as a
meaningful whole. It was never going to be easy to connect the local ethnographies produced bythe urban explorers to a wider framework of conceptual and political control; the very complexity
and scale of the territory also resisted assimilation to some omniscient, all embracing mental map.
But this project, which some think is nothing but that of modernity itself, also has its other scene,
its own gothic tale of shock and awe to impart.
Once the scope of the bird’s eye view narrows to that of a bombers gun sight, once whole
neighbourhoods can be devastated, and their populations all but annihilated in a single bombing
mission, the creation of a rational urban grid through the imposition of zoning regulations does no
more than provide a template for the more efficient application of terror from the sky. Moreover
once the explosive power and accuracy of the bomb makes total destruction of the target
possible, all that is left behind to mark the moment of impact may be a heap of rubble and dust.
Carpet-bombing destroys the ruin. The ruin works its metonymic magic by evoking the complete
edifice of which it was once a part. Its role in the urban fabric is to celebrate the triumphant
survival of form over the annihilation of function. But once reduced to formless rubble, the scene
of devastation can no longer function as a lieu de memoire. It signifies only the obliteration of all
distinction between the human world and inorganic waste, an objective correlate of the state of
numb no-thingness which overwhelms the sense of loss in cases of post-traumatic stress.
The blitzing of London, and in particular the docks, was the single most traumatic event on the
home front during the Second World War. Not because it was unexpected, or even because of the
extent of damage and suffering it caused but because it upset the official calculus of risk and itsgeographical coding. The main target of German carpet-bombing was not the heavily protected
centres of wealth and power in the West End, but the dense concentration of working class
population adjacent to main industrial arteries of trade and commerce clustered around the
docks.
The Thames Estuary lived up to its reputation for letting the enemy in through the back door by
providing a clearly visible fix for German pilots to navigate by on their way in to bomb the docks.
Fog however changed sides; no longer a treacherous dissembler of appearances, it provided a
comfort blanket protecting people whose faith in bomb shelters, let along barrage balloons and
anti-aircraft batteries was quickly dispelled by the Blitz. But ‘nature’ could not be relied upon
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 17/25
17
either, and when the skies cleared, the fog was replaced by the smoke and flames of the burning
docks.
The second Great Fire of London posed as great a challenge to the resolution of the war artist as it
did to be the fire fighter, the air raid warden and the Dockers themselves. And they responded in a
remarkably similar way—by carrying on as usual, by denying the full impact of the horror, and yet,
at the same time being awestruck by the scale of the devastation all around.As far as English war artists were concerned business as usual meant trying to assimilate the
landscapes of the Blitz to the pictorial conventions of the gothic ruin or the picturesque landscape
as a way of asserting a sense of historical continuity with the nation’s cultural heritage.
The National Gallery may have been bombed but the aesthetic code of Turner and Constable,
many of whose paintings it housed, was indestructible—that was the message. Kenneth Clarke,
the doyen of English art critics indeed described the bombing of the East End as Picturesque. His
protégé John Piper painted the remnants of Coventry Cathedral as if it were a replica of Tintern
Abbey; his sketches of blitzed East End houses would not look out of place next to Constable’s
Hadleigh Castle.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 18/25
18
In contrast the blitz landscapes painted by his contemporary Graham Sutherland explored the
register of the sublime. His Devastation Series shows the twisted girders of bombed buildings
transformed into writhing organic forms as if to celebrate nature’s final redemption of the terrible
damage inflicted on the world by the hand of man.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 19/25
19
War photographers adopted similar conventions in their artfully composed images of the Blitz. The
famous photograph of St Paul’s standing defiantly alone and undefeated amidst a sea of flames,
offers a view of the Cathedral’s place in the national imaginary which is in a direct line of descent
from William Blake’s vision of Los.
Through the prismatic lens of romantic ruinology it was thus possible to see the war torn city interms of a familiar Anglo-gothic mise en scene and hence provide a link with its past. H. V Morton
noted at the time ‘by an ironic twist of History, the destruction of war has created ancient ruins
which dead generations could only see in dreams’. In this view the night terror s of the Blitz, these
‘furnaces of afflication’ which Charles Madge and his colleagues at Mass Observation reported as
part of the diurnal rhythm of Londoners lives was, at a deeper level, nothing but the recurrent
nightmare of a history from which there was no awakening except through the uncanny
realisation of Desolation’s ‘déjà vu’.
However most observers of the Blitz, then and now, have settled for less complicated ways of
exploiting its aesthetic possibilities; the aim has been to convey impressionistically enough, the
shock and the awe evoked by the spectacle of massive incendiary and cluster bombing. In order torender what might otherwise be unpalatable to the reader into a palette of pleasurable sense
impressions, it was enough to paint a word picture after Monet and Whistler with a nod or two at
the penny dreadful. Consider this piece of purple prose penned at the time by Mrs Gwendolyn Cox
viewing the blitzing of the docks from the safe prospect of her flat in Cholmley Gardens
Hampstead:
It was a dark and moonless night, volumes of rose pink smoke and many coloured flashes from
explosions pierced again and again the blood red cloud which, brooding and angry hung over the
city.
Fifty years later David Johnstone in the ‘City Ablaze’ recreates the scene like this:
A rainbow of shades some almost delicately radiant transfixed onlookers, deep crimson flecked
with scarlet, blue tinted with yellowy green. Vermilion edged with orange and gold —all tossing in
the north easterly gale. Each district was floodlit by its own distinct tincture. Everything seemed
grotesque and unearthly —the overall effect was another worldly nightmare, a carnival night in
hell.
He cannot, unfortunately, resist recruiting other people, supposedly there at the time to bear
witness to his prosaic flights of gothic fancy:
To 15 year old Dorothy Haring the whole scene was like a dream, the fire and the smoke, the noise
of the fire pumps and anti-aircraft guns seemed too loud to be real. More than one fireman staringout at the daylight brilliant wall of flame suffered a sensory breakdown, some were literally
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 20/25
20
hypnotised, and others experienced mild hallucinations seeing weird forms and unreal faces in the
windblown fires. Even other firemen when seen in that light looked like strange creatures from
another world.
In contrast the Evening Standard Editorial ( see quote above) grounds its immediate response to
the Blitz in the theme first enunciated by Walter Benjamin twenty years before, of the frailty of
the human form pitted against the monstrous new war machine.Mervyn Peake, the future author of the first great post war gothic novel Gormenghast also
reinstates the body as a measure of the city’s pain, imagining Blitzed London as ravaged women:
‘Half masonry, half pain: her head
From which the plaster breaks away
Like flesh from the rough bone, is turned
Upon a neck of stones; her eyes
Are lidless windows of smashed glass,
Each star shaped pupil
Giving upon a vault so vast
How can the head contain it?’
Shapes and Sounds, 1941
This re-inscription of the organic metaphor as a central unifying image of community, nation and
state runs like a red white and blue thread through war time propaganda narratives. Divested of
terror laded imagery, this appeal to the body politic could evoke magical powers of reparation
capable of assimilating the traumatic experience of the Blitz to a quasi-natural cycle of urban
decay and renewal, which in turn is seen to be integral to a thriving city. The war ruin is thus
integrated into the harmonising compositional structures of the landscape picturesque: just
another tumbledown building overgrown with ivy.
This is the burden of Eliot’s response to the Blitz in East Coker:
‘In succession
Houses rise and fall, crumble, are extended
Are removed, destroyed, restored, or in their place
Is an open field, or a factory, or a by pass
Old stone to new building, old timber to new fires
Houses live and die: there is a time for building
And a time for living and for generation’
In fact his raid on the inarticulate discovers a principle of eternal recurrence in London’s wartime
travails which owes more to the cosmology of Eastern religions than to any Western spiritual oraesthetic discipline. Nevertheless it was to furnish a decidedly profane principle of hope for post
war reconstruction.
It was a short step from accepting the air raids as part of a higher purpose, to seeing them as a
godsend to all those who wanted to rebuild London according to a more rational plan. The view
that Hitler’s bombers were clearing the East End of its slums more cheaply and efficiently than any
municipal bulldozer was first enunciated by MacDonald Hastings in his famous war time broadcast
on the theme (see quote above).
Even if the planners at the LCC who were put in charge of London’s post war reconstruction did
not dare to publicly voice such sentiments, it is clear from their memoirs that privately they moreor less shared this view.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 21/25
21
The Abercrombie Report published in 1943 was the first attempt at a comprehensive master plan
for the whole of London. Perhaps its most significant feature was that it abandoned the piecemeal
development which had hitherto characterised London’s growth and went back to Ebenezer
Howard’s model of organic growth onto which it attempted to graft a functionalist gr id. The result
was to turn London into a distributed series of self-contained improvement zones, little islands of
urban redevelopment—an unconscious mapping perhaps of the ‘stand-alone’ island story so
central to Britain’s wartime image of itself, onto its post war urban geography.
The clearing of the bomb sites not only deprived the blitz kids of their favourite haunts, it put an
end, for the moment, to the gothic revival. As Rose Macauley put it, the British have had enough
of German ruin lust to last several life times. But not everyone was happy with the result. John
Betjeman, the poet laureate of late Victorian Gothic, especially in so far as it had influenced the
vernacular architecture of London’s middle class suburbs, saw in the new developments nothing
but an act of vandalism which was completing the destruction already wrought on the capital by
the Luftwaffe. As in his famously vitriolic poem about Slough:
‘Come, friendly bombs, and fall on Slough
It isn’t fit for humans now, There isn’t grass to graze a cow
Swarm over, Death!
Come, bombs, and blow to smithereens
Those air-conditioned, bright canteens,
Tinned fruit, tinned meat, tinned milk, tinned beans
Tinned minds, tinned breath.
Mess up the mess they call a town—
A house for ninety-seven down
And once a week for half-a-crownFor twenty years.’
The new public housing estates, both low and high rise, brought the principles of modernist design
to bear for the first time on everyday working class life on a large scale. The application of Parker
Morris standards ensured that for the inhabitants of these new model dwellings indoors offered as
much space for relaxed conviviality as out, in addition to providing a new locale for leisure
pursuits, TV and, of course, D-I-Y.
In the East End the streets were increasingly abandoned to children and the territorial rivalries of
male gangs. There was little room in the new urban order for the kind of spectral geography which
had made ‘The Smoke’ with its ‘holes and corners hidden from the honest and the well to do’
(Mayhew) such a popular haunt of the uncanny, not to mention the down and out. The post Clean
Air Act finally killed off the pea soup fogs, leaving the blackened faces of London’s public buildings
and monuments to be given a wash and brush up by municipal cleansing departments. Yet even if
the material signs of war damage could be removed, or built over, the memory traces left by the
Blitz, the hidden wounds of war could not be so easily erased. Disavowal always leaves space for
re-inscription.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 22/25
22
One of the more interesting examples of this was in the design for Peterlee —a new town built in
the heart of the Durham coal fields, as the North East’s answer to Milton Keynes. On the designconsultants for this project was Victor Pasmore. He started out as a lyrical landscape painter but
evolved into England’s foremost abstract painter, who applied the same formal compositional
principles of what he called ‘synthetic constructionism’ to the the layout of houses and roads in
the south western quadrant of the town. Indeed from the air the flat roofs and prefabricated
timber panels look exactly like one of his paintings; similarly the orthogonal blocks and painted
black lines of his reliefs are modelled in the pedestrian routes which cut through the housing
blocks. The centrepiece of the whole design—an ‘abstract concrete bridge over a lake—now
known as the Pasmore Pavilion—was described by him in the following terms: an architecture and
sculpture through which to walk, in which to linger and play, which can lift the activity and
psychology of an urban housing community onto a universal plane’.
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 23/25
23
Pasmore explicitly saw town planning and abstract art as equivalent instances of a modernist
aesthetic which rejected the pictorial conventions that had hitherto dominated English landscape
painting—including much of its war time art. There was nothing picturesque or sublime about
Pasmore’s work—it invoked a cool, hard edged, architectonic form of spatiality—a kind of abstract
impressionism in that it sought to give formal precision to the otherwise chaotic sensorium of
environmental perception. Interestingly enough, even before his Peterlee adventure, much of
Pasmore’s work looked compositionally very like a plan view of the bunkers, emplacements and
other military installations which British and German architects, inspired by Bauhaus principles,
had built to defend the coasts of their respective countries from invasion during the war.
This may be coincidence—a family resemblance between different instances of the same Bauhaus
aesthetic. But this project may also bear the unconscious imprint of the trauma induced by thedestruction of the ruin as a place where loss could be mourned. For here was an art that
celebrated the indestructability of pure form, its ability to distil from the detritus of everyday life a
universal sensibility of an enduring beauty than no bomb could destroy. As if to say: we can design
and build new towns and cities that can never again be reduced to rubble —or even ruin, that are
vandal proof and will survive everything that history can throw at them.
In fact the history of Peterlee, and in particular the Pasmore Pavilion, was to prove quite
otherwise. Over the years the radical rooftop and brickwork designs have been all but been
effaced by their D-I-Y conversion into a more vernacular style—all pitched roofs and PVC windows.
If people from the housing estates did linger and play in his Pavilion it was not to ascend to the
universal but to mark the structure with the particularisms of their presence. The building quicklybecame a public ‘canvas’ for graffiti, and a meeting place for local gangs of disaffected youth; it’s
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 24/25
24
condition has deteriorated to the point where local residents have begun to press for its
demolition as an eyesore.
So what if these post war New Jerusalem were to harbour, in the very sterility of their conception,
the seeds of their own undoing, the return of the traumatic conflicts they had repressed? How far
would this upset the confident geometry of the post war settlement between capital and labour?
Would it create the conditions for an alternative way of implementing Blake’s Vision of Los? And if so who are to be the keepers of the new ruins of modernity?
In the second part of this study, to be published in the next issue of Rising East On Line, I will
consider how a significant body of work produced by a group of contemporary writers, painters
and film makers—including Iain Sinclair, Patrick Wright, Peter Akroyd, Patrick Keiller, Jock
McFadyen and John Virtue—struggles with these questions as it seeks renew the Anglo-gothic
imagination and its capacity to address what is at stake in London’s eastwards turn.
Acknowledgement
The author would like to thank the staff at the Borough Archive of Peterlee for their help with the
picture research related to Victor Pasmore and for permission to reproduce the related visualmaterial.
Select Bibliography
Readers who want to explore some of the issues raised in this article in greater depth might like to
consult the following:
Peter Akroyd London a biography (London 2000)
John Barrel The Infections of Thomas de Quincey (London 1991)
Christine Boyer The City and collective memory (Cambridge 1996)
Paul Brimicombe The Big Smoke (London 1987)
Gesualdo Bufalino The Keeper of ruins (London 1994)
Glenis Byron and David Punter Spectral readings—towards a gothic geography (London 2002)
Kenneth Clarke The Gothic Revival—an essay in the history of taste (London 1962)
Alain Corbin The Foul and the Fragrant (leamington 1986)
Deborah Epstein Walking the Victorian Streets (London1995)
Robert Ginsberg The Aesthetic of ruin (Oxford 2004)
G Stedman Jones Outcast London (Oxford 1971)Anne Janowitz England’s ruins (Oxford 1990)
Patrick Keillor Robinson in Space (London 1999)
Marek Kohn Dope Girls (London 1992)
Seth Koven Slumming (London 2004) (London 2001)
Eric de Mare Victorian London revealed (London 2001)
Alan Mayne The Imagined Slum (Leicester 1993)
Thomas MacFarland Romanticism and the form of ruin (Oxford 1998)
Michael Moorcock Mother London (London 1988)
8/3/2019 A New Oriental Ism - The Anglo-Gothic Imagination in the East London
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/a-new-oriental-ism-the-anglo-gothic-imagination-in-the-east-london 25/25
Linda Nead Victorian Babylon (New Haven 2000)
Shaun O’Boyle Modern Ruins—photographic essays http: //oboylephoto. com
Susana Orega and John Stotesbury London in Literature—visionary mappings of the metropolis
(Heidelberg 2002)
Ian Sinclair Lights out for the Territory(London 1997)
Tate Modern Turner, Whistler Monet catalogue (especially the essay by Jonathon Ribner) (London
2005)
Anthony Vidler The Architectural uncanny (Massachusetts 1996)
Judith Walkovitz City of Dreadful delight (London 1992)
Patrick Wright Journey through the Ruins (London 1991)
Alexandra Warwick Lost cities: London’s Apocalypse London 2001)
Paul Zucke The Fascination of Decay (London 1968)