2013/6/272013/6/27 11
2013/6/272013/6/27
Koshiro Suzuki (Canon Inc.)Koshiro Suzuki (Canon Inc.)
Hisao Hayakawa (YITP)Hisao Hayakawa (YITP)
A rheological study of A rheological study of sheared granular flows by sheared granular flows by the Mode-Coupling Theorythe Mode-Coupling Theory
2013/6/272013/6/27
Introduction Steady-state of the sheared granular flowSteady-state of the sheared granular flow
SettingSetting monodisperse monodisperse hard inelastic smooth hard inelastic smooth spheres spheres
(3D)(3D) uniform steadyuniform steady shear flow (bulk shearing) shear flow (bulk shearing)
Energy balance equation Energy balance equation (energy/volume/time)(energy/volume/time)
22
y
vx
Control parameters volume fraction shear rate restitution coefficient
x
y
d
Granular temperatureT is determined
m
volume V
2013/6/272013/6/27
Introduction Kinetic theoryKinetic theory
Shear stressShear stress
Energy dissipation rateEnergy dissipation rate
Consequence of the energy balanceConsequence of the energy balance
Bagnold scalingBagnold scaling
33
[Garzo and Dufty, PRE 59, 5895 (1999)]
2013/6/272013/6/27
Introduction Limitation of the kinetic theoryLimitation of the kinetic theory
It is known that kinetic theory works well up toIt is known that kinetic theory works well up to However, there is a large deviation from However, there is a large deviation from
simulationsimulationfor for
44
Granular temperature Energy dissipation rate Shear stress
[Mitarai and Nakanishi, PRE 75, 031305 (2007)]
2013/6/272013/6/27
Our work We aim to construct a theory viable for dense We aim to construct a theory viable for dense
sheared granular flows, sheared granular flows,
We attempt to apply the Mode-Coupling Theory We attempt to apply the Mode-Coupling Theory (MCT) :(MCT) : It is known that MCT captures the glass It is known that MCT captures the glass
transition,transition,
It incorporates It incorporates memory kernelsmemory kernels, which is , which is neglected in the kinetic theory.neglected in the kinetic theory.
We expect that the memory kernels play We expect that the memory kernels play significant roles.significant roles.
55
2013/6/272013/6/27
Previous related works Driven granular fluids Driven granular fluids
Kranz, Sperl, Zippelius, PRL 104, 225701 (2010)Kranz, Sperl, Zippelius, PRL 104, 225701 (2010) Sperl, Kranz, Zippelius, EPL 98, 28001 (2012)Sperl, Kranz, Zippelius, EPL 98, 28001 (2012) Kranz, Sperl, Zippelius, PRE 87, 022207 (2013)Kranz, Sperl, Zippelius, PRE 87, 022207 (2013)
Sheared granular fluidsSheared granular fluids Hayakawa, Otsuki, PTP 119, 381 (2008)Hayakawa, Otsuki, PTP 119, 381 (2008) Suzuki, Hayakawa, AIP Conf. Proc., to be Suzuki, Hayakawa, AIP Conf. Proc., to be
published (2013) [arXiv:1301.0866]published (2013) [arXiv:1301.0866]
No work has been done for the rheology of sheared No work has been done for the rheology of sheared granular fluidsgranular fluids
66
2013/6/272013/6/27
Results MCT shows better compatibility than to simulation MCT shows better compatibility than to simulation
than the kinetic theory for the than the kinetic theory for the shear stressshear stress.. However, MCT fails to obtain the However, MCT fails to obtain the energy dissipation energy dissipation
raterate, as is the case for the kinetic theory., as is the case for the kinetic theory.
77
Shear stress
2013/6/272013/6/27
A short review of MCT MCT describes (for MCT describes (for thermalthermal glassy systems) : glassy systems) :
two-step relaxation of the density time-two-step relaxation of the density time-correlation function (“cage effect”).correlation function (“cage effect”).
the nonlinear rheology (constitutive relation of the nonlinear rheology (constitutive relation of shear stress and shear rate).shear stress and shear rate).
88
Newtonian
yield stress
high density
low density
[Suzuki and Hayakawa, PRE 87, 012304 (2013)]
2013/6/272013/6/27
A short review of MCT
99
Schematic pictureSchematic picture The red particle is “caged” by the surrounding The red particle is “caged” by the surrounding
particles above the critical density until the cage particles above the critical density until the cage is broken by shearing.is broken by shearing.
This picture does not hold for granular particles !This picture does not hold for granular particles !
2013/6/272013/6/27
Microscopic dynamics of grains SLLOD equation (Newtonian eq. for uniform shear)SLLOD equation (Newtonian eq. for uniform shear)
No external noisesNo external noises Viscous dissipation of Viscous dissipation of softsoft, , smoothsmooth grains grains
1010
ζ : viscous coefficient(mass/time)
t=0Equilibrium Relaxation
to a steady state
steady shear &dissipation
hard-core limitis taken later
k
2013/6/272013/6/27
Liouville equation (1) Time evolution of physical quantities A(q(t),p(t))
1111
Formal solution
2013/6/272013/6/27
Liouville equation (1) Physical quantities of interestPhysical quantities of interest
Shear stressShear stress
Energy dissipation rateEnergy dissipation rate
1212
2013/6/272013/6/27
Liouville equation (2) Time evolution of distribution function
1313
Formal solution
: Phase volume contraction
(non-Hermitian)
2013/6/272013/6/27
Formula (MCT) : shear stress
It is written in terms of It is written in terms of time/wavenumbertime/wavenumber integration of integration of time-correlation functionstime-correlation functions , ,
Dissipative vertex functionDissipative vertex function
1414
dominantterm
(functions of equilibrium RDF at contact)
(hard-core limit)
2013/6/272013/6/27
Formula (MCT) : energy dissipation rate
The first term coincides with the kinetic theoryThe first term coincides with the kinetic theory⇒⇒ Maxwellian contributionMaxwellian contribution
1515
n.b. kinetic theory result
non-Maxwelliancontribution
2013/6/272013/6/27
Time correlation functions
1616
Slow modesSlow modes
Time correlation functionsTime correlation functions
Isotropic approximationIsotropic approximation
current density fluctuation
density fluctuation
scalar functions ,
2013/6/272013/6/27
MCT equations Isotropic, weak-shear approximationIsotropic, weak-shear approximation
Effective friction coefficientsEffective friction coefficients
1717
g(d) : equilibrium RDF at contact
2013/6/272013/6/27
Memory kernels for Density-Density correlation function for Density-Density correlation function ΦΦ
Dissipative kernels are Dissipative kernels are negativenegative
⇒⇒ They can cancel the glassy kernelThey can cancel the glassy kernel
1818
glassy kernel
dissipative
2013/6/272013/6/27
Disappearance of the plateau Parametrical study (varying Parametrical study (varying ee))
Glassy plateau of the density-density correlation Glassy plateau of the density-density correlation function disappears due to dissipative memory function disappears due to dissipative memory kernels.kernels.
Plateau appears complementarily in the density-Plateau appears complementarily in the density-current correlation function.current correlation function.
1919
Density-Density correlation
= 0.521 = 1.0e-2 T = 1.0 qd = 7.0
conditions
Density-Current correlation
2013/6/272013/6/27
Disappearance of the plateau
2020
Schematic pictureSchematic picture The red particle loses its kinetic energy due to
inelastic collisions ⇒ density correlations disappear.
Eventually the cage is destructed by the shear.
2013/6/272013/6/27
Scheme of the analysis Temperature is not well predicted neither for MCT Temperature is not well predicted neither for MCT
nor kinetic theorynor kinetic theory ⇒ ⇒ adopt the result of the simulation for adopt the result of the simulation for T T ((energy energy balance equation isbalance equation is not not solvedsolved))..
Compare the values of and Compare the values of and separatelyseparately for for given sets of (given sets of (T, , eT, , e);); is chosen as the unit of timeis chosen as the unit of time
5 conditions for 5 conditions for (0.55, 0.57, 0.58, 0.59, 0.60) (0.55, 0.57, 0.58, 0.59, 0.60) 3 conditions for 3 conditions for ee (0.98, 0.92, 0.70) (0.98, 0.92, 0.70)
2121
2013/6/272013/6/27
Inputs Static structure factor (Static structure factor (equilibriumequilibrium))
FactFact : : MCTMCT = 0.516 corresponds to = 0.516 corresponds to gg ~~ 0.60.6
⇒⇒ we adopt the following *, we adopt the following *, * = – * = – gg + + MCTMCT,, gg =0.595, =0.595, MCTMCT = 0.516. = 0.516.
Radial distribution function (Radial distribution function (equilibriumequilibrium, at contact), at contact)
2222
Interpolation formula (Torquato)
volume fraction 0.55 0.57 0.58 0.59 0.60g(r) at contact 9.486 12.196 14.229 17.075 21.344
ν: volume fraction
2013/6/272013/6/27
Result : shear stress e=0.98/0.92/0.70e=0.98/0.92/0.70
aa
Kinetic theory under-(over-)estimates for Kinetic theory under-(over-)estimates for e=0.98(0.70)e=0.98(0.70)
MCT works well for e=0.98, 0.92, 0.70MCT works well for e=0.98, 0.92, 0.70
2323
Why does MCT work well ? ⇒ time-correlation function
2013/6/272013/6/27
Result : time-correlation function e=0.98e=0.98
Dissipation is weak; glassy plateau appears in the density-density correlation.
The plateau is crucial for the evaluation of the The plateau is crucial for the evaluation of the stress.stress.
2424
Density-Density correlation Density-Current correlation
・ ・
・
qd = 7.0
qd = 7.0
2013/6/272013/6/27
Result : time-correlation function e=0.92e=0.92
No clear plateau appears in the density-density correlation.
2525
Density-Density correlation Density-Current correlation
・ ・
・
qd = 7.0 qd = 7.0
2013/6/272013/6/27
Result : time-correlation function e=0.70e=0.70
Dependence on density decreases as eDependence on density decreases as e↓↓ The origin of the density dependence resides in The origin of the density dependence resides in
the memory kernel, which dissapears as ethe memory kernel, which dissapears as e↓↓
2626
Density-Density correlation Density-Current correlation
・ ・
・
qd = 7.0
qd = 7.0
2013/6/272013/6/27
Significance of the plateau e=0.98e=0.98
The result of the kinetic theory is close to the The result of the kinetic theory is close to the MCT without the memory kernelMCT without the memory kernel..
Precise evaluation of the relaxation of the time-Precise evaluation of the relaxation of the time-correlation function is crucial for the shear stress.correlation function is crucial for the shear stress.
2727
・
Density-Density correlation
qd = 7.0
Shear stress
e=0.70e=0.70
The result of MCT is coincident to The result of MCT is coincident to MCT without MCT without memory kernelsmemory kernels..
2013/6/272013/6/27
Significance of the plateau
2828
・
Density-Density correlation
qd = 7.0
Shear stress
2013/6/272013/6/27
Summary of the results MCT shows better compatibility with the simulation MCT shows better compatibility with the simulation
than the kinetic theory for the than the kinetic theory for the shear stressshear stress.. Precise evaluation of the Precise evaluation of the relaxation timerelaxation time of the of the
time-correlation functiontime-correlation function is crucial. is crucial. The relaxation of the time-correlation function is The relaxation of the time-correlation function is
determined by the determined by the dissipative memory kerneldissipative memory kernel..
However, MCT fails to explain the However, MCT fails to explain the energy energy dissipation ratedissipation rate⇒⇒ we will retry !we will retry !
2929
2013/6/272013/6/27
Discussions Nonlinear rheologyNonlinear rheology
In MCT, deviation from the Bagnold scaling In MCT, deviation from the Bagnold scaling is is notnot observed. observed.
This is due to the hard-core limit.This is due to the hard-core limit. Proper treatment of the soft spheres is Proper treatment of the soft spheres is
necessary.necessary.
3030
[Hatano, Otsuki, Sasa, JPSJ 76, 023001 (2007)]
2013/6/272013/6/27
Discussions Jamming transitionJamming transition
Precise evaluation of the Precise evaluation of the vibrational frequency of vibrational frequency of the contact networksthe contact networks (instead of the collision (instead of the collision frequency) is necessary.frequency) is necessary.
The replica theory might be of help for this issue.The replica theory might be of help for this issue.
3131
3232
Appendix
2013/6/272013/6/27
2013/6/272013/6/27
Hard-core limit Relation of ζ and eRelation of ζ and e
Collision frequencyCollision frequency
It is difficult to derive in MCT.It is difficult to derive in MCT. We adopt its expression for the kinetic theory.We adopt its expression for the kinetic theory.
3333
(contact duration time)
k : linear spring coefficient(1)
hard-core limit
effective collision frequency(1)
[Otsuki, Hayakawa, Luding, PTP Suppl. 184, 110 (2010)]
2013/6/272013/6/27
Hard-core limit Collision frequency (kinetic theory)Collision frequency (kinetic theory)
3434
g(φ, d) : equilibrium RDF at contact
The step function is formally replaced by the delta function.
viscous coefficient(hard-core limit)
2013/6/272013/6/27
Interpretation of the granular temperature Normalization of current projectionNormalization of current projection
Requirement 1 : Requirement 1 : TT should be treated as constant should be treated as constant TT is not included as a basis of the projected space is not included as a basis of the projected space
Requirement 2 : Requirement 2 : TT should satisfy the energy balance should satisfy the energy balance eq.eq.
3535
T : granular temperature
We simply assume T = TSS in this work.
2013/6/272013/6/27
Projection operator formalism Basis of the projected spaceBasis of the projected space
Projection operatorsProjection operators Mori equationMori equation
Mode-Coupling ApproximationMode-Coupling Approximation
3636
density fluctuation
current density fluctuation
specific for shearedgranular systems
: static structure factor
2013/6/272013/6/27
Time correlation functions
Additional functions are required from Additional functions are required from Initial conditionsInitial conditions
3737
additional correlation functionsfor granular systems
translational invariance in the sheared frame
2013/6/272013/6/27
Mori equation
ExactExact equation for the time correlation functions equation for the time correlation functions Coefficients , are Coefficients , are equilibriumequilibrium quantities quantities
(n.b. (n.b. TT is exceptional) is exceptional)
3838
2013/6/272013/6/27
Approximations Isotropic approximation
Dissipation is almost isotropic For reducing the load of calculation ( 3D⇒1D )
Weak-shear approximationWeak-shear approximation Second (and higher) order terms in and/or Second (and higher) order terms in and/or
are neglected. are neglected. e.g. , , , etc.e.g. , , , etc.
3939
e.g.
reduces to two scalar functions ,