6
Written Task 1: Short Reflection, 250 words (5%) Due: 5pm Thursday, 8 August Foley, Dennis. “Too White to be Black, Too Black to be White.” Social Alternatives 19, no. 4 (2000): 44-9. a. What do you understand by the term ‘social racism’? (50 words) I understand the term ‘social racism’ as all aspects of racism where there are negative stereotypes against a particular group of individuals on an ethnic or cultural basis. This also includes the notion that a person’s behavior, skin color or genetic make up influences their racial classification. b. According to Dennis Foley, why is physical appearance not a reasonable way of determining whether or not somebody is Aboriginal? (50 words) Physical appearance is not a reasonable way of determining whether somebody is Aboriginal, as Aboriginality is not based on the color of your skin or facial features. Reasonably, being Aboriginal is a mystical distinctiveness, which is within your identity that can only be felt by an individual born in an Aboriginal family (Foley, 2000, p. 2). c. Why is it important for people to understand the negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity? (150 words) It is important for people to understand the negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity as stereotyping stipulates a view that is commonly limited and biased. The outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity – including labels based on physical appearance or biological make up, hurt Aboriginal people in a genuine way subsequently leaving them at a shortcoming. Even after many attempts of removing themselves from detrimental situations, Aboriginal people are still faced with this burden that harmfully impacts their lives. The article highlighted that a student refused to willingly acknowledge their Aboriginality. Even after the student leaves the situation where they are faced with negative stereotypes, the effects of managing with that situation remains and has a lingering inimical impact. The negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity does not allow for individual differences and consequently damages groups of people, therefore stopping us from learning the real truth about real Aboriginal people.

Written Task 1.pdf

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • Written Task 1: Short Reflection, 250 words (5%) Due: 5pm Thursday, 8 August Foley, Dennis. Too White to be Black, Too Black to be White. Social Alternatives 19, no. 4 (2000): 44-9.

    a. What do you understand by the term social racism? (50 words) I understand the term social racism as all aspects of racism where there are negative stereotypes against a particular group of individuals on an ethnic or cultural basis. This also includes the notion that a persons behavior, skin color or genetic make up influences their racial classification.

    b. According to Dennis Foley, why is physical appearance not a reasonable way

    of determining whether or not somebody is Aboriginal? (50 words) Physical appearance is not a reasonable way of determining whether somebody is Aboriginal, as Aboriginality is not based on the color of your skin or facial features. Reasonably, being Aboriginal is a mystical distinctiveness, which is within your identity that can only be felt by an individual born in an Aboriginal family (Foley, 2000, p. 2).

    c. Why is it important for people to understand the negative impacts of

    stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity? (150 words) It is important for people to understand the negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity as stereotyping stipulates a view that is commonly limited and biased. The outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity including labels based on physical appearance or biological make up, hurt Aboriginal people in a genuine way subsequently leaving them at a shortcoming. Even after many attempts of removing themselves from detrimental situations, Aboriginal people are still faced with this burden that harmfully impacts their lives. The article highlighted that a student refused to willingly acknowledge their Aboriginality. Even after the student leaves the situation where they are faced with negative stereotypes, the effects of managing with that situation remains and has a lingering inimical impact. The negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity does not allow for individual differences and consequently damages groups of people, therefore stopping us from learning the real truth about real Aboriginal people.

  • Written Task 3: Using Written Sources as Evidence, 500 words (10%)

    Due: 5pm Thursday, 5 September

    Broome, Chapter 9, Controlled by Boards and Caste Barriers

    Media articles on LEO

    This task requires you to use evidence and examples from the Week 6 set materials to

    write 500 words (1-2 paragraphs) answering the question: How did assimilation

    policies suppress Aboriginal culture and autonomy, and how are the 21st century

    Aboriginal people striving to reverse the impacts of assimilation?

    During the twentieth century, Aboriginal people in areas of Australia were controlled

    in two modes. The first, a caste barrier. These individuals were against those who

    were regarded as Aboriginal by the color of their skin. The second, the Aboriginal

    Boards, who operated under special legislation allowing them power to detain

    individuals on reserves and coordinated what they did daily including their work life.

    They also broke families and deprived them of any respectful rights (Broome, 2010, p.

    172).

    Assimilation policies greatly overpowered the Aboriginal culture and independence

    of Aboriginal people. Public servants ran the Aboriginal Boards thus had great power

    over the Aboriginal people. After the 1920s, the board overlooked Aboriginal people

    as Indigenous unless they dwelled at the Lake Tyres reserve. By not appreciating the

    Indigenous uniqueness of those residing in other reserves it subsequently rejected

    Aboriginality (Broome, 2010, p. 173).

    Aboriginal recollections of Moore River were adverse during assimilation. Conditions

    were pitiable, rations were deprived and people were only adequate for low-skilled

    rural laboring (Broome, 2010, p. 174). The Aboriginal Board employed young girls into

    domestic services, where they experienced exploitation for being an Aboriginal

    female. Like any servant, they were overworked and underpaid and suffered much

    misery (Broome, 2010, p. 177). Many girls who had returned from inland services came

    back pregnant to the men there.

    Since Aboriginality was denied, this led to broken bonds within Aboriginal

    communities in the years of assimilation, which at the time citizenship certificates

    were being offered. Few individuals applied because it was essential for them to

    agree to the European culture consequently discarding Aboriginality. Nevertheless,

  • the few that did apply were left feeling lonely and further withdrawn. Following, the

    European Australians still recognized the individuals as Aboriginal and the Aboriginal

    people believed these citizens were being untrue to themselves by changing into the

    mainstream Australian (Broome, 2010, p. 188).

    The 21st century Aboriginal people are determined to reverse the impacts of

    assimilation. Reconciliation of the Indigenous culture is allowing Aboriginal people to

    preserve the relationship between their inherited language, culture and with their

    land (Pearson, 2013, p. 16). A Murwillumbah dance group is helping young individuals

    to reconnect with the Aboriginal culture. The groups instructor, Dennis Walker Jnr

    states, were giving the kids whats rightfully theirs, their identity. Back in the old days

    it was frown upon to do cultureits like a jigsaw puzzle thats been smashed into

    pieces and has been lost forever and you cant get it back. So we need to keep

    what weve got and hold onto it (Burin, 2013). Dennis main goal is to support young

    Aboriginal people to learn about culture through dance and ultimately find

    themselves.

    The lack of respect disadvantaged Aboriginal people of their potential embrace of

    modernism. The Aboriginal people have become sentient that education is a vital

    key into the future of their children. Three primary schools within the Cape York

    Australian Aboriginal Academy have been established. Three domains of learning

    are being taught including one on culture where students concentrate on traditional

    language and cultural knowledge. There is also a mainstream class domain allowing

    students to be equipped for the global economy while the culture domain

    encourages students to learn about their identity and language. These types of

    schools support and help Aboriginal people and their culture to grow and show in

    Australia once again (Pearson, 2013, p. 16).

  • Written Task 5: Critical Response, 500 words (10%)

    Due: 5pm Thursday, 10 October

    Re-read: Foley, Dennis. Too White to be Black, Too Black to be White. Social

    Alternatives 19, no. 4 (2000): 44-9.

    Review: The short answers to the questions you gave in Written Task 1 access this via

    LEO.

    Use the reading to answer questions a, b and c; use your submission for Written Task 1

    to respond to question d:

    a) What do you understand by the term social racism? (100 words)

    Negative stereotypes against a group of individuals on an ethnic basis, is social

    racism. Including the notion that an individuals behavior, skin color or genetics

    influences their racial category. There are many forms of social racism involving

    verbal abuse, harassment or interpretations in the media that provokes enmity

    concerning a group of individuals. Social racism can intensify through physical abuse

    and violence and also arise at an influential level through policies that detriment

    certain groups.

    Social racism expresses through prejudice for example, Aboriginal characters

    commonly lowered to insignificant or stereotypical roles and are continually

    overlooked by white characters (Warren, 2011, p. 2).

    b) According to Dennis Foley, why is physical appearance not a reasonable way of

    determining whether or not somebody is Aboriginal? (100 words)

    According to Foley, physical appearance is not a way of determining Aboriginality,

    as Aboriginality is not centered on the color of your skin, facial features, the size of

    your brain nor your biological make up. Realistically, being Aboriginal is a mystical

    distinctiveness that is felt inside yourself; it is within your identity. This exclusive

    sentiment is difficult for an individual not born in an Aboriginal family to understand

    (Foley, 2000, p. 2). Foley (2000, p. 2) also explains that Aboriginality is as much to do

    with culture and life understandings, as it is to do with ancestry.

  • c) Why is it important for people to understand the negative impacts of stereotyping

    and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity? (200 words)

    For people to confidently say who they are, they must openly express their

    uniqueness and relate to their history. Aboriginal people are victims of untrue images

    created by non-Aboriginal Australians. Its important for people to understand the

    negative impacts of stereotyping and outdated ideas about Aboriginal identity as

    stereotyping stipulates a view that is limited.

    Stereotyping about Aboriginal identity includes labels based on appearance or

    biological make up. For example, Warren (2011) stating that, Aboriginal men were

    used as guidesexploiting their survival skills and knowledge of the country (p. 2).

    Also the label black tracker (Warren, 2011, p. 2) used as a belittling insult to

    Aboriginal people.

    People need to realize that stereotyping hurt Aboriginal people in a genuine way. It

    not only affects the process of finding their true identity but how they question it

    consequently Aboriginal people may feel they are on the bridge between two

    creations black and white. These impressions and ideas stop us from learning the

    real truth about real Aboriginal people.

    d) Now look back at how you answered these questions in Written Task 1. Have your

    ideas changed since you answered these questions in week 2? Why do you think

    this may be? (100-200 words)

    My ideas have not changed since week 2, though I now had the opportunity to learn

    about real Aboriginal people.

    Social racism today reminds me of the discrimination towards Indian people. Like

    Indigenous people, Indian people are differentiated on the basis of their behavior,

    employment, skin color and accent. It is sad to see that this type of judgment is still

    occurring today. Social racism and negative stereotypes cannot be abolished until

    individuals learn about the many different cultures in the world and about the real

    people.

    I still agree with Foley that physical appearance is not a way of determining

    Aboriginality. It was odd to discover how people longed to obliterate physical

    characteristics in-order to be less Aboriginal, but in reality Aboriginality is within you.

  • It is similar to being homosexual. There are no physical characteristics rather it is

    something that is only felt by you regardless of how you look or your genetic make-

    up.

    I never realized how important it was for a person to find their identity until I re-

    answered question C. There are many Aboriginal people that still do not know their

    story or history and by hearing about negative stereotypes and outdated ideas

    about Aboriginal people, it can greatly affect their community and the development

    of their identity.