Women and Gender Studies

Nicole

Dayna

Danny

Katie

Discussion Topics of Day 1(Katie)

Women and Gender Studies Discourse Community

Author’s Background Article Discussion

1.The Meaning Behind the title 2.‘Thesis’

3. Rhetorical Devices4.Article Prevalent to Today (Sarah Haskin Skit)

Women and Gender Studies Discourse Community (Nicole)

The Diversity Many scholars that write in the Women

and Gender study field usually have degrees in other fields.

For example W.G.S Professor Ann Brigham has a masters in English but

works in W.G.S field 

The Issues Gender roles Sexuality in men and women Politics Maculate and Femine models Sexism

http://athome.harvard.edu/food/6.html

An inside about why the wait has took so long and still today is discussed more in books than articles.

Food in the Discourse Language Food is usually defined and

studied in W.G.S communities as gender associated, body images, nutrition values, and/or relations to sexuality.

Susan Bordo (Danny)

Author Background: Susan Bordo is Professor of Philosophy and holds the Otis A. Singletary

Chair in the Humanities at the University of Kentucky. In the words of Susan Squier, professor of literature at Penn State University, Bordo's writings "can be said to have catalyzed the birth of the new interdisciplinary field of work known as 'body studies'." Bordo's best known book, Unbearable Weight, is widely cited and discussed in scholarly writing and used in courses throughout the disciplines. Named a Notable Book of 1993 by the New York Times, it was nominated for a Pulitzer Prize and received a Distinguished Publication Award from the Association for Women In Psychology. Columnist Kathy Pollitt named it one of the five best books in Women's Studies of 1993. Bordo describes her forthcoming book as "a personal/cultural exploration of the male body from a woman's point of view." She lives in the countryside of Kentucky with pianist and professor of Russian literature Edward Lee, along with their pet dogs and cats

Assumed Main Thesis of Hunger as Ideology (Dayna) It is clear that the audience is asked to question the ‘body images’ with food advisement. In the

article Bordo dissects popular food items and the way they target women and male consumers. Women are meant to think consciously of food choices especially those seen ‘unhealthy

portioned’; while men are asked to look more at the ‘heartiness of the meal’ then the portion size.

Bordo wants her audience to be aware of the ‘gender ideology’ in a sense sexism that lays within today’s ideology of hunger. That America society still unconsciously uses Victorian era etiquette in advertisement and social thoughts.

Victorian Era etiquette: women were taught to be reserved, controlled, and discipline in food and sex

Hunger as Ideology Gender Ideology Man Controller and

Women are Controlled

Defining Key Terms In Hunger as Ideology (Katie)

Gender Ideology: Gender: sex of a person(s) female or male clasifications Gender ideology: Bordo’s in-text descriptions seems to

define gender ideology as the gender differences among needs and ideas based upon the America culture standards and advertisement.

Usage of the word is seen

“specifically (consciously or unconsciously) servicing the cultural reproduction of gender difference and gender inequality, quite independent, or […] marketing concerns.” (Bordo 110).

Hunger as Ideology:

Hunger: a strong desire or craving for food Ideology: the body of ideas reflecting the social needs and aspirations of an individual; group, class, or culture.

Hunger as Ideology: Bordo has turned hunger into ideology. Title being ‘Hunger as Ideology’ instead of ‘Hunger as an Ideology’ turns hunger from ‘a’ ideology to ‘the’ ideology of American culture. Hunger has become the aspirations and ideas of American culture in advertisement.

Rhetorical Devices (Nicole) Essay Language

Switches between third person and first Assured Intention: Bordo’s opinion is valued and

respected, she always includes the audience so there are connections made. However Bordo also switches because too much first person can deter the audience. In respect to this observation she has left the supposedly left the audience to make their own opinion. However the audience is being guided consist images and general knowledge.

‘BIAS’ Images The Ads used show the differences between

female ‘hunger cravings’ and male’s Assured Intention: Bordo’s opinion may be

highly backed by her degrees and background; the images however SHOW her audience that the conclusions are constructed by obvious messages within the Ads ‘clever’ marketing.

Repetition Bordo repeated usage of words such as

ideology, hunger, we, us, our, gender, Victorian.

Assumed Intention: The words relate back to the assumed thesis.

Audience * This essay is from her book Unbearable

Weight. Her targeted audience seems to be America specifically the women consumers, mothers, and working class women that deal with these sexism Ads.

Connections from Sections

“The Woman Who Does Eat Much” Danny Bradley

Discussion on sections Rhetorical devices Bias

“Man Eat and Women Prepare” Nicole Lee

Discussion on Sections Rhetorical devices Bias

“Psyching Out The Female Consumer” Danny Bradley

Disscussion on sections Rhetorical devices Bias

“Food, Sexuality, And Desire” Nicole Lee

Discussion on Sections Rhetorical devices Bias

Connection From Sections

“Food and Love” Katie De La Torre

Rhetorical devices Bias

“Destabilizing Images” Dayna Ross-Garnes

Rhetorical devices Bias

“Food as Transgression” Katie De La Torre

Rhetorical devices Bias

Each sections discusses how food and hunger are used to create ‘gender ideology’ in America Culture

Sarah Haskins ‘Women Know How to Eat Right’ It was in 90’s why should we still care about the

Article?The information is still a prevalent issue of today.Not much within the United States has been

published about Food, Advertising, in the Women and Gender Realm. Most of the articles related to Food advertisements is discussion of past historical issues and not that relevant to current conditions.

Sources

http://athome.harvard.edu/food/6.html

http://www.cddc.vt.edu/feminism/bordo.html

Questions and/or Comments for Thursday Discussion Thursday Game:

Battle of the Sexes (Chalkboard Style) Game Host and Hostess

Danny Macho Man Bradley Katie Pretty in Pink Da La Torre

Game Scorers Dayna Giving Him Something He can Eat Ross-Garnes Nicole Chocolate is a Girl’s Best Chance Lee