4
3/24/2019 1 Evaluating swimmers for sport readiness: What measures are important? Kathy Wayman, PT, DPT, SCS Co-authors: Pintar JA, Briggs MS, Schlueter KR Swimming is complicated! Musculoskeletal injuries in swimmers are often multifactorial o Mobility Joint ROM Muscle extensibility o Strength/endurance o Static/dynamic movement Unique training environment o Anti-gravity o Water as a barrier visibility auditory o High training volume Injuries in Swimming Increased injury risk in freestyle swimmers have been associated with asymmetries in: o Upper extremity (UE) strength (Butler 2017; Tate 2012; Batalha 2013) o Shoulder range of motion (ROM) (Ozcaldiran 2002; Su 2004; Thomas 2009; Walker 2012) o Thoracic rotation (Feijen 2018; Micheli 2016) o Body roll (Psycharakis 2011; Psycharakis 2010; Payton 1999) Injury incidence in swimmers: o Shoulder injury 41-91% out of 80 young swimmers (13- 25 years old) reported episodes of pain (Tate 2012; Wanivenhaus 2012; Pink 2000) o Knee injury most prevalent in breaststroke swimmers (5x more likely) (Wanivenhaus 2012; Rodeo 1999) o Back injury 68% of elite swimmers 29% of recreational swimmers (Capaci 2002; Wanivenhaus 2012) 1 2 3

What measures are important?Evaluating swimmers for sport ......restoration Use: swimmer has been removed for

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: What measures are important?Evaluating swimmers for sport ......restoration Use: swimmer has been removed for

3/24/20191

Ev

alu

atin

g s

wim

me

rs

for

sp

or

t rea

din

es

s:

Wh

at m

ea

su

res

are

imp

or

tan

t?K

ath

y W

ay

ma

n, P

T, D

PT

, SC

SC

o-a

uth

ors: P

inta

rJA

, B

rigg

s MS

, Sch

lue

ter

KR

Sw

imm

ing

is c

om

plic

ate

d!

M

uscu

losk

ele

tal in

jurie

s in sw

imm

ers a

re o

ften

mu

ltifacto

rial

oM

ob

ility

•Jo

int R

OM

•M

uscle

exte

nsib

ility

oS

tren

gth

/e

nd

ura

nce

oS

tatic/

dy

na

mic m

ov

em

en

t

U

niq

ue

train

ing

en

viro

nm

en

to

An

ti-grav

ityo

Wa

ter a

s a b

arrie

r•

visib

ility•

au

dito

ry

oH

igh

train

ing

vo

lum

e

Inju

rie

s in

Sw

imm

ing

In

crea

sed

inju

ry risk

in fre

esty

le

swim

me

rs ha

ve

be

en

asso

ciate

d w

ith

asy

mm

etrie

sin

:o

Up

pe

r extre

mity

(UE

) stren

gth

(Bu

tler 2

01

7; T

ate

20

12

; Ba

talh

a2

01

3)

oS

ho

uld

er ra

ng

e o

f mo

tion

(RO

M)

(Oz

cald

iran

20

02

; Su

20

04

; Th

om

as 2

00

9; W

alk

er 2

01

2)

oT

ho

racic ro

tatio

n(F

eije

n2

01

8; M

iche

li2

01

6)

oB

od

y ro

ll(P

sych

ara

kis 2

01

1; P

sych

ara

kis 2

01

0; P

ay

ton

19

99

)

In

jury

incid

en

ce in

swim

me

rs:o

Sh

ou

lde

r inju

ry

•4

1-9

1%

ou

t of 8

0 y

ou

ng

swim

me

rs (13

-

25

ye

ars o

ld) re

po

rted

ep

isod

es o

f pa

in(T

ate

20

12

; Wa

niv

en

ha

us

20

12

; Pin

k 2

00

0)

oK

ne

e in

jury

•m

ost p

rev

ale

nt in

bre

aststro

ke

swim

me

rs

(5x

mo

re lik

ely

)•

(Wa

niv

en

ha

us

20

12

; Ro

de

o 1

99

9)

oB

ack

inju

ry•

68

% o

f elite

swim

me

rs

•2

9%

of re

crea

tion

al sw

imm

ers

(Ca

pa

ci2

00

2; W

an

ive

nh

au

s2

01

2)

123

Page 2: What measures are important?Evaluating swimmers for sport ......restoration Use: swimmer has been removed for

3/24/20192

Inju

ry

Sc

ree

nin

gE

va

lua

tion

Re

lev

an

t Fin

din

gs

Stre

ng

thS

ho

uld

er IR

/E

R m

uscle

imb

ala

nce

w

atch

pa

rticula

rly m

id a

nd

po

st sea

son

cha

ng

es (B

ata

lha

20

13

)

RO

M

SH

OU

LD

ER

•P

ec m

uscle

len

gth

: ≥9

.8cm

rest; ≥

11

.9cm

stretch

(Ha

rring

ton

20

14

)

•F

orw

ard

sho

uld

er p

ostu

re (H

ibb

erd

20

16

)

•S

ho

uld

er p

ain

hig

he

r with

join

t hy

pe

rmo

bility

(Oz

cald

iran

20

02

)

•S

cap

ulo

hu

me

ral

rhy

thm

55

°o

f scap

rota

tion

at 1

35

°h

um

era

l ele

va

tion

(Su

20

04

)

•S

ho

uld

er E

R R

OM

93

°o

r ≥1

00

°(W

alk

er 2

01

2)

•D

ecre

ase

d sh

ou

lde

r IR/

ER

AR

OM

mid

sea

son

an

d/

or in

crea

sed

scap

ula

r up

wa

rd ro

tatio

n a

t 90

°a

bd

uctio

n

(Th

om

as 2

00

9)

KN

EE

•D

ecre

ase

d h

ip IR

37

°(b

ette

r if ≤4

6°) (R

ov

ere

19

85

)

•K

ick in

itiatio

n h

ip a

bd

uctio

n a

ng

le

≤3

or ≤

41

°(V

izso

lyi

19

87

)

SP

INE

•H

igh

er risk

(by

2.5

x) if fe

ma

le; k

yp

ho

sis plu

mb

line

≥9

0m

m; lo

rdo

sis plu

mb

line

≥6

0m

m (Z

ain

a2

01

5)

Sta

bility

Up

pe

r Ex

trem

ityY

-Ba

lan

ce T

est (U

E Y

BT

–p

icture

be

low

)(B

utle

r 20

17

)

Tre

atm

en

t Op

tion

s

W

all a

ng

els

T

urk

ish g

et u

p

U

E ro

lling

Re

tur

n to

Sp

or

t

Ph

ase

1:

Re

intro

du

ctio

n to

wa

ter

GO

AL

-n

or

ma

lizin

g s

trok

e

me

ch

an

ics

Use

: swim

me

r ha

s be

en

rem

ov

ed

for ≥

6 w

ee

ks

•A

vo

id p

articip

atio

n in

form

alize

d p

ractice

fo

cus o

n te

chn

iqu

e

•F

ree

style

on

ly

it com

prise

s mo

re th

an

ha

lf of n

orm

al tra

inin

g v

olu

me

•R

est in

vo

lve

d b

od

y p

art:

•N

eck

, up

pe

r ex

trem

ity in

jurie

s: swim

on

ba

ck in

strea

mlin

e p

ositio

n a

nd

kick

•L

ow

ba

ck, lo

we

r ex

trem

ity in

jurie

s: use

the

pu

ll bu

oy

Ph

ase

2:

Em

ph

as

is o

n te

ch

niq

ue

res

tora

tion

Use

: swim

me

r ha

s be

en

rem

ov

ed

for <

6 w

ee

ks O

R h

as a

lrea

dy

com

ple

ted

Ph

ase

1

•R

etu

rn to

org

an

ized

swim

pra

ctice w

ith te

am

•Y

ard

ag

e a

nd

pa

cing

restrictio

ns o

utlin

ed

by

PT

/co

ach

for sa

fe p

rog

ressio

n

Ph

ase

3:

Mu

ltiple

pra

ctic

es

in 1

da

y

GO

AL

–g

rad

ua

lre

tur

n to

sp

or

t (RT

S)

Use

: Re

turn

to S

po

rt–

hig

hv

olu

me

•F

ollo

w p

ractice

gu

ide

line

s no

rma

lly d

urin

g first p

ractice

of d

ay

•R

estrict 2

nd

pra

ctice o

f day

to fo

llow

the

gu

ide

line

s ou

tline

d in

Ph

ase

2

•D

urin

g 2

nd

pra

ctice, a

llow

for re

lativ

e re

st of in

vo

lve

d b

od

y p

art:

•N

eck

, up

pe

r ex

trem

ity in

jurie

s: no

pu

ll bu

oy

or p

ad

dle

use

•L

ow

ba

ck, lo

we

r ex

trem

ity in

jurie

s: no

use

of k

ickb

oa

rd o

r fins

WK

1

456

Page 3: What measures are important?Evaluating swimmers for sport ......restoration Use: swimmer has been removed for

Slid

e 6

WK

1

Waym

an

, Kath

erin

e, 3

/21/2

019

Page 4: What measures are important?Evaluating swimmers for sport ......restoration Use: swimmer has been removed for

3/24/20193

Resources

1.

Ba

talh

a, N

., Ra

imu

nd

o, A

., To

ma

s-Ca

rus, P

., Ba

rbo

sa, T

. an

d S

ilva

, A. S

ho

uld

er ro

tato

r cuff b

ala

nce

, stren

gth

, an

d e

nd

ura

nce

in y

ou

ng

swim

me

rs du

ring

a co

mp

etitiv

ese

aso

n.J S

treng

th C

on

d R

es2

01

3;

27

(9), p

p.2

56

2-2

56

8.

2.

Bu

tler R

, Arm

s J, Re

ima

nM

, Plisk

yP

, Kie

selK

, Ta

ylo

r D, Q

ue

en

R. S

ex

Diffe

ren

ces in

Dy

na

mic C

lose

d K

ine

tic Ch

ain

Up

pe

r Qu

arte

r Fu

nctio

n in

Co

lleg

iate

Sw

imm

ers. Jo

urn

al o

fAth

letic T

rain

ing

20

14

;49

(4):4

42

-44

6.

3.

Bu

tler R

J, Bu

llock

GS

, Bro

ok

reso

nN

, Kn

ab

AM

. Ex

am

inin

g fu

nd

am

en

tal m

ov

em

en

t com

pe

ten

cy a

nd

close

d-ch

ain

up

pe

r-ex

trem

ity d

yn

am

ic ba

lan

ce in

swim

me

rs.J Stren

gth

Co

nd

Res

20

17

; 31

(6):1

54

4-

15

51

.

4.

Ca

pa

ciK, O

zcald

iran

B, D

urm

az

B. M

uscu

losk

ele

tal p

ain

in e

lite co

mp

etitiv

e m

ale

swim

me

rs. Th

e Pa

in C

linic 2

00

2; 1

4(3

):22

9-2

34

.

5.

Fe

ijen

, S., K

up

pe

ns, K

., Ta

te, A

., Ba

ert, I., S

truy

f, T. a

nd

Stru

yf, F

. Intra

-a

nd

inte

rrate

r relia

bility

of th

e ‘lu

mb

ar-lo

cke

d th

ora

cic rota

tion

test’ in

com

pe

titive

swim

me

rs ag

es 1

0 th

rou

gh

18

ye

ars.P

hys

Th

er

Sp

ort

20

18

; 32

, pp

.14

0-1

44

.

6.

Go

rma

n P

P, B

utle

r RJ, P

lisky

PJ, K

iese

lKB

. Up

pe

r qu

arte

r y b

ala

nce

test: re

liab

ility a

nd

pe

rform

an

ce co

mp

ariso

n b

etw

ee

n g

en

de

r in a

ctive

ad

ults. J S

tren

gth

Co

nd

Re

s2

01

2;2

6(1

1):3

04

3-3

04

8.

7.

Ha

rring

ton

, S., M

eise

l, C. a

nd

Ta

te, A

. A cro

ss-sectio

na

l stud

y e

xa

min

ing

sho

uld

er p

ain

an

d d

isab

ility in

div

ision

ife

ma

le sw

imm

ers.J S

po

rt Reh

ab

il20

14

; 23

(1), p

p.6

5-7

5.

8.

Hib

be

rd, E

., La

ud

ne

r, K., K

uce

ra, K

., Be

rko

ff, D., Y

u, B

. an

d M

ye

rs, J. Effe

ct of sw

im tra

inin

g o

n th

e p

hy

sical ch

ara

cteristics o

f com

pe

titive

ad

ole

scen

t swim

me

rs.Am

J Sp

orts M

ed2

01

6; 4

4(1

1), p

p.2

81

3-

28

19

.

9.

Mich

eliL

, Ste

in C

, O'B

rien

M, d

'He

me

cou

rtP

. Sp

ina

l inju

ries a

nd

con

ditio

ns in

yo

un

g a

thle

tes. S

prin

ge

r, Ne

w Y

ork

, US

A (2

01

6).

10

.M

cMa

ster, W

., Ro

be

rts, A. a

nd

Sto

dd

ard

, T. A

corre

latio

n b

etw

ee

n sh

ou

lde

r lax

ity a

nd

inte

rferin

g p

ain

in co

mp

etitiv

e sw

imm

ers.A

m J S

po

rts Med

19

98

; 26

(1), p

p.8

3-8

6.

11

.O

zcald

iran

, B. A

rela

tion

be

twe

en

static fle

xib

ility a

nd

sho

uld

er p

ain

in co

mp

etitiv

e a

ge

-gro

up

swim

me

rs.Th

e Pa

in C

linic

20

02

; 14

(2), p

p.1

59

-16

3.

12

.P

ay

ton

CJ, B

artle

tt RM

, Ba

ltzop

olo

sV

, Co

om

bs R

. Up

pe

r ex

trem

ity k

ine

ma

tics an

d b

od

y ro

ll du

ring

pre

ferre

d-sid

e b

rea

thin

g a

nd

bre

ath

-ho

ldin

g fro

nt cra

wl sw

imm

ing

. J Sp

orts S

ci. 19

99

; 17

:68

9-9

6.

13

.P

ink

MM

, Tib

on

eJE

. Th

e p

ain

ful sh

ou

lde

r in th

e sw

imm

ing

ath

lete

, Orth

op

Clin

No

rth A

m 2

00

0. 3

1(2

):24

8.

14

.P

sych

ara

kis S

G, M

cCa

be

C. S

ho

uld

er a

nd

hip

roll d

iffere

nce

s be

twe

en

bre

ath

ing

an

d n

on

-bre

ath

ing

con

ditio

ns in

fron

t craw

l swim

min

g. J B

iom

ech

. 20

11

Jun

3;4

4(9

):17

52

-6.

15

.P

sych

ara

kis S

G, S

an

de

rs RH

. Bo

dy

roll in

swim

min

g: a

rev

iew

. J Sp

orts S

ci. 20

10

Fe

b;2

8(3

):22

9-3

6.

16

.R

iem

an

n B

L, W

itt J, Da

vie

s GJ. G

len

oh

um

era

ljoin

t rota

tion

ran

ge

of m

otio

n in

com

pe

titive

swim

me

rs. J Sp

orts S

ci20

11

;29

(11

):11

91

-9.

17

.R

od

eo

SA

. Kn

ee

pa

in in

com

pe

titive

swim

min

g. C

linS

po

rts Me

d. 1

99

9 A

pr;1

8(2

):37

9-8

7

18

.R

ov

ere

, G. a

nd

Nich

ols, A

. Fre

qu

en

cy, a

ssocia

ted

facto

rs, an

d tre

atm

en

t of b

rea

ststrok

er's k

ne

e in

com

pe

titive

swim

me

rs.Am

J Sp

orts M

ed1

98

5; 1

3(2

), pp

.99

-10

4.

19

.S

u, K

., Joh

nso

n, M

., Gra

cely

, E., a

nd

Ka

rdu

na

, A. S

cap

ula

r rota

tion

in sw

imm

ers w

ith a

nd

with

ou

t imp

ing

em

en

t syn

dro

me

: Pra

ctice e

ffects.M

ed S

ciSp

orts E

xerc2

00

4; 3

6(7

), pp

.11

17

-11

23

.

20

.T

ate

A, T

urn

er G

N, K

na

bS

E, Jo

rge

nse

n C

, Strittm

atte

rA

, Mich

en

er L

A. R

isk F

acto

rs Asso

ciate

d W

ith S

ho

uld

er P

ain

an

d D

isab

ility A

cross th

e L

ifesp

an

of C

om

pe

titive

Sw

imm

ers. Jo

urn

al o

f Ath

letic

Tra

inin

g 2

01

2;4

7(2

):14

9-1

58

.

21

.T

ho

ma

s, S., S

wa

nik

, K., S

wa

nik

, C. a

nd

Hu

xe

l, K. G

len

oh

um

era

lrota

tion

an

d sca

pu

lar p

ositio

n a

da

pta

tion

s afte

r a sin

gle

hig

h sch

oo

l fem

ale

spo

rts sea

son

.J Ath

lTra

in2

00

9; 4

4(3

), pp

.23

0-2

37

.

22

.W

alk

er H

, Ga

bb

eB

, Wa

jswe

lne

rH

, Bla

nch

P, B

en

ne

llK

. Sh

ou

lde

r pa

in in

swim

me

rs: A 1

2-m

on

th p

rosp

ectiv

e co

ho

rt stud

y o

f incid

en

ce a

nd

risk fa

ctors. P

hy

sical T

he

rap

y in

Sp

ort 2

01

2;1

3:2

43

-24

9.

23

.W

an

ive

nh

au

sF

, Fo

x A

J, Ch

au

dh

ury

S, R

od

eo

SA

. Ep

ide

mio

log

y o

f Inju

ries a

nd

Pre

ve

ntio

n S

trate

gie

s in C

om

pe

titive

Sw

imm

ers. S

po

rts He

alth

: A M

ultid

isciplin

ary

Ap

pro

ach

20

12

;4:2

46

-25

1.

24

.V

izsoly

i, P., T

au

nto

n, J., R

ob

ertso

n, G

., Filsin

ge

r, L., S

ha

nn

on

, H., W

hittin

gh

am

, D. a

nd

Gle

av

e, M

. Bre

aststro

ke

r's kn

ee

.Am

J Sp

orts M

ed1

98

7; 1

5(1

), pp

.63

-71

.

25

.Z

ain

a, F

, Do

nze

lli, S., L

usin

i, M., M

inn

ella

, S. a

nd

Ne

grin

i, S. S

wim

min

g a

nd

spin

al d

efo

rmitie

s: A cro

ss-sectio

na

l stud

y.J P

edia

tr2

01

5; 1

66

(1), p

p.1

63

-16

7.

7